Hi Amy, Love the idea and am interested in seeing your log home go up. We live in one now but would like to build our own to possibly overcome some of the short comings of this one. Addressing heating concerns for open spaces and high ceilings would be one. A basement would be another for storage, workshop and laundry. To enjoy the area a screened in porch and hot tub would be a must. One thing we would not change are our rough sawn hand made cupboards. We'll be watching. Greg & Candy

Hi Amy, Love this diy cabin site. I'm with you on the vote for a hot tub and I think a outdoor entertainment area with a grill & a view would be great. Have fun designing. Michelle

Definitely got to do the hot tub. I also like the outdoor entertainment idea. What about adding an outdoor fireplace? Chuck

We really think a screened in porch would be one of the things that we would enjoy the most. Also, we would opt for a different kitchen choice. Contemporary is the only one offered that gave you a natural wood. We did not like the other two at all. How about a natural wood cabinetry with stainless steel appliances?

I LOVE your ideas for building a green home in the mountains. Let me tell you a little about one of our projects. My husband, Tom, has been working on an innovative windmill design. We would love to incorporate that design into your cabin. It would help introduce the world to "wind power". Also, he knows about solar panels and inverters. We actually use some of this technology in our current home. He had a home in the past totally powered by wind. Please get in touch so I can tell you more. Maybe we can work something out (mutually beneficial). Thanks.

Hi Amy & DIY,
Great to see that you're building a log cabin and in the Smokies; it is one of my favorite places. I went to school in East Tennessee; go ETSU! My thoughts: I voted for the Trillum because it was the only one with a mud room/washer/dryer area, and I loved that there is an entry door there. The other two designs didn't address a washer/dryer area, and it's great to be on the living level in the Trillum plan - it's so useful, practical, and livable. Forget the basement, unless it's a walkout. A one story floorplan would be nice, since stairs don't suit everyone, but I suppose it's not available on this build, but it's offset somewhat by having a bedroom on the living level. I noticed that one of the designs didn't have an accessible bathroom unless you entered the bedroom; that's a real problem. I also didn't like the roofline on the first plan because of the sloped ceilings upstairs; lots of wasted space. I know it can be used for storage, but you cannot stand up and put things in those areas; it's hard on your back. Also, if there is a deck, the new material that doesn't rot or require maintenance would be wonderful. The outdoor fireplace is a terrific idea; that would be magical. I agree that the high ceilings will let the heat rise, so a fix for that issue would be great. Finally, an entry area set apart from the great room with room for coats would be very serviceable. AND, a garage would be wonderful and very practical for this geographical area; they can get lots of snow. Thanks for the opportunity to enter my thoughts!

Yes! A screened-in porch with a porch-swing and a pitcher of lemonade aid! Dreamy

Hello, Amy,
The cabin is great! The walk-in shower in the Master bedroom would be awesome along with a jacuzzi tub. As for the Great Room, a stone, wood burning fireplace would be great! As for the outdoors, HOT TUB, fireplace, and a water feature would be fantastic. All this with a beautiful view, would be heavenly! Can't wait to see the finished cabin!! Enjoy and have fun designing the cabin!!! Arinda in Michigan

Hi Ron,
You really don't want to hear all the ideas I have because this is the home (Greenbriar, mine is called the Homestead but look the same) I have wanted for the last several years and have designed several plans for it for the day I am finally able to do it!

I agree with you on the hot tub but it has to look out at a water feature. Mine was a pond with a waterfall, fountain, lots of plants and of course, fish.

Another thing I was going to customize on the home was adding a nice deck directly outside the master bedroom.

I'll stop there but I can't tell you how much I would love to win this home, it would be my dream come true. Thanks for doing this!

Terri

A screened porch is a must, and an outdoor spa would be nice. Vaulted ceilings and a wall of glass would be wonderful. A raised eating bar on an island between the kitchen and living room (great room) would be excellent.

A woodshed/gardening shed is a nice touch to go with a Log Cabin. Also, don't forget the garage!

Most Definitely a Hot Tub. That would make me more inclined to have the Stone Fireplace patio. I like all three options. What about all three plus the Hot Tub! LOL.

We definately think a hot tub and outdoor grill area are great ideas for outside entertainment. Inside, we think it should have a Jacuzzi for the master bedroom. We honeymooned in the Smokey Mountains and we have always wished for a cabin just like the one on our honeymoon. We think every cabin should have a loft area and of course a fireplace. Sandra and Rick

Hi everyone,

I am so excited to watch this project unfold. Especially that our input may be implimented in the construction is FANtastic (pun intended).

A hot tub/spa area would be VERY nice.

A basement would be a big one for me.

Screened porch (not even the whole but a section near a door) would be great too.

That is all I can think of for now but knowing my brain I'll come up with lots of ideas.

Mary Ann

Hi Amy:
A screened in porch is a must in the Smoky Mountain area. I truly think the cabin should have:
1. A screened in porch where, with a cup of coffee, I can look out over the magnificent scenery.
2. A water feature nearby to set the stage for crickets and other night creatures to make beautiful music.
3. What would life be without an outdoor fireplace to enjoy while entertaining family and friends?
And lastly,
4. A hot tub to relax in after spending those hard-won retirement days enjoying nature and my grandchildren.

One more thing - - a pair of rocking chairs for the front porch.

Heaven!

Virginia Birdsell

A small garden area would be nice...using rustic, outdoor furniture, maybe have a pergola and use plants, Laurel trees and flowers native to the area, surrounded by outdoor lighting for evenings.

My mother grew up in the Smokey Mountains in a log cabin my grandfather built. The cabin belongs to other relatives now, but I have so many wonderful memories of visiting their log cabin.

There's nothing like sitting outside and breathing in the mountain air...the smells are so incredible.

Hot tub and outdoor fireplace/grill area are great ideas. I'm sure the area is sure to inspire so how about adding two sheds - one for the gardener and one for the "DIY-er" in all of us (a work/craft shed). Hey, how about an outdoor shower? And a mud room to clean up after all those treks through the woods?

I definately agree with the hot tub in a screened in porch with a view! That would be the ultimate in relaxation. I love the outdoor fireplace and patio too but in the Great Smokey Mountains would'nt it be wonderful to walk outside and hear the sound of the water! I sure would call it a blessing to win the log cabin no matter what design features it has !. Thank you HGTV for letting us help with the design and dream of winning it . Love and peace, Jane

I love the hot tub, but I wish we didn't have to choose between the water feature and the out door patio with the fireplace. I it all.

Amy,
Has there been a suggestion yet for a skylight or suntube? I think that each natural element put into the house would be accentuated perfectly with as much natural light as possible. Wonderful progress on the house, it sounds like a dream!
Kim in Kentucky

Amy,

We like the Greenbrier except; there should be a way into a first floor bathroom without having to go through the bedroom. What do you think?

We are new to your website but watch the DIY gang on TV regularly.

Keep up the good work,
Dave & Karen

Hmmm! Cabin in the woods...well, let's keep it elegant but simple. Seems that 'green living' does not include all the bells and whistles, i.e., hot tubs, etc. Screened in side room or porch; fireplace indoor/outdoor wood boxes; an entry mudroom or such; solar; protected area for parking vehicles get my vote. Practicality still holds the best interests for living in a REAL cabin, so I vote for practicality using no artificials in construction.

I love all these ideas! Most agree with these:

Wish all 3 plans had mud / laundry rooms with exit.
Want BOTH - water feature and outdoor patio / grill area.
Screened porch a must in the Smokies.
And need another kitchen option, yes. Something that fits the eclectic in me.
Oh, and the wall finishes - how about "all the above"...? I like something different in each area, to fit the use and mood of the room and to fit my whims..

Looking forward to seeing how it turns out.

The idea for a screened porch is great. I would also add a fireplace for those chilly nights and wet bar.
A laundry area is a must.
So far, everything looks so comforting, and like a place anyone would love to live and enjoy being with family and friends.
Keep up the wonderful ideas.

The idea for a screened porch is great. I would also add a fireplace for those chilly nights and wet bar.
A laundry area is a must.
So far, everything looks so comforting and a place anyone would love to live to enjoy family and friends.
Keep up the wonderful ideas.

The cabin is a great idea, but let's be honest, hot tubs are not a very green building practice. Don't get me wrong, I love them also, but they use lots of water and they need to be heated. They have maintenance with chemicals that are not great for the environment. You should replace the water quarterly, which usually means dumping it onto the yard, with the chlorine/bromine in it. Wasting water, wasting heat energy and using chemicals are not very 'green' practices. Why not have a very large picture window near the tub in the bathroom? At least you will save some energy and not use the chemicals.

Since you are building in the mountains, why not take advantage of the (hopefully) low light pollution and add a dedicated telescope space? A small building with a removable roof that could also store gardening supplies should be feasible and much more in line with your theme. I also like the idea of the gazebo or an outdoor cooking kitchen.

I spent my honeymoon in the Smokies many many years ago. Love the idea of a cabin in the woods as I love nature and animals. I like the quaintness of a clawfoot tub, but combined with pipes for a shower, it would be even better. Or how about a sunken tub? A screened in porch is an excellent idea! I'm looking forward to see the finished project. It'd be a dream of a lifetime to win this cabin!

Radient heat! The screened in porch with hot tub!The outdoir living space is important. I love the idea of windows for heat and natural light. A few added touches would be the natural wood choice for a kitchen painted wood is such a crime. But I agree the contemporary isn't my favorite choice either. Love the ideas here.

I love this cabin. Just incorprate everyone great idea`s they have sent in.In my cabin , The Trillum all I want is the island w/ round bar & in the center a cooking top w/a grill & a sink .I`ts to cold in the winter for a fall w/ fish. I prayed a few years ago for this log cabin so I know God has heard my prayer & I claim this cabin as my`s in the name of JESUS. Mrs. Johnnie Love/Thanks

DEFINITELY EGO FRIENDLY... a sustainable home, which is easy to maintain... especially for us baby boomers who are retiring shortly. A mud room is important.. I suggest a washer dryer be in the bedroom closet... and the closet have built in drawers, to keep the space in the bedroom for intimacy and a deck off the bedroom with a screened in porch, matching rustic/log furniture, and a hot tub, a green house off that or close by is also a good idea. For those of us baby boomers who have an practical eye toward the future, handicap friendly, (wide door openings, lower light switches, grab bars), and one level is important... as is convenience, comfort and practicality. For instance... having the kitchen, near the parking area, for carrying in groceries. A built in vaciumn. Lots of areas for stocking up/storage. Having radiant heating... and NOT hard floors for comfort. Having an area for the main storage of the firewood in a place which can be easily off loaded, with a trap door, which will open for convenience near the wood stove itself. A place for everything and everything in it's place... is a good idea to keep in mind when building for practicality and convenience. NO wasted space... this includes a built in area for recycling/compost... a convenient place for outdoor trash cans which is hidden from view. A outdoor fireplace is a terrific idea. LOTS of light... a green house and workshop/studio closeby as a private getaway would be a added bonus. Also... if you have hardwood floors, a trap door which will have a disposable trash bag so the debris can be swept up and into the trap opening and emptied when full. Thanks for the opportunity to enter our suggestions.

One thing that would be great on snowy, rainy days would be a garage, either attached or with a walkway to the house... This could also solve the questions on where to put the washer dryer, water heater, etc. and just plain ol' mountain stuff, like hiking gear and sleds....

Amy I would love to see a game room area for a pool table and room for some exercise equipment. I'd love to have a computer/sewing room also. Sounds like we are all just a little spoiled,huh. I know that this cabin will be beautiful!

Hi, wow what fun to design a mountain home , i loved helping you , please use the tin roof so when you are sleeping at night you can hear the rain falling on the roof , thats the one thing i would like , also large kitchen drawers that pull out for storage instead of cupboards would be nice and some skylights in the bathroom and kitchen would give added light , also in the bedrooms i would build dresser drawers in the walls to save space. Thats about it for me , thanks Delores

Amy, I am very interested in this project as we are in the planning stages of building our own log cabin for our retirement. I also wish you had a 1 story option as this better suits growing older. I will follow your progress with great interest.

I was surprised at a couple of the choices on the poll page, namely the stainless-steel kitchen appliances and the walk-in shower. I wouldn't have thought of it before, but modern features such as those in a mostly rustic-looking home would be a defining departure from what we've seen around here. What a cool retreat that would be!

We live in Knoxville, TN, and have visited or stayed in many rental cabins (as well as owner-occupied homes), and most of them feature designs and accessories that are just too cheesy and pedestrian for my tastes.

I also vote for radiant heat and an outdoor shower.

I have to agree with the hot tub and closed in porch. I also agree with the skylights. The eggshell color was ok but why not go with more earth tones? When I think of a cabin in the mountains I see, furniture made of wood, a huge fireplace in the living room also in the master bedroom. I also see a small pond near by to go wading in on a hot day, I also see a small deck on the upstairs that has a great view of the sunset to where you can sit and relax with a cup of tea or cocoa, while later looking at the stars. Definitely bring the outdoors inside. Lots of windows that let the natural light in and keep the heat in and cold out. I know the cabin will look fantastic with what you put in and around it.

I would love to see all of the flooring in the rooms and the roofs on the cabins with the windows. I think it would be more fun if we could see what each one would look like. We could change them out with the floors and other things mentioned. We could have a lot of fun playing with the cabin interior or outside, landscaping projects as well.

I would love to see all of the flooring in the rooms and the roofs on the cabins with the windows. I think it would be more fun if we could see what each one would look like. We could change them out with the floors and other things mentioned. We could have a lot of fun playing with the cabin interior or outside, landscaping projects as well.

Hi Amy,

I love the idea of your Blog Cabin. It is nice to be able to give some input as to what type of design I’d like to see built. Will you be adding any additional finished detail choices?

At first glance, I like the look of the Smokeyview with its wrap around porch the best. Though after looking at the floor plans, the Trillum seems to have a bigger kitchen and a mud room/utility area. I’d like to see a coat closet somewhere in there too. If you don’t add a screen porch, I’d make one of the porches a three season porch if I won.

What kind of hot water heater will the cabin have? Several years ago, we put in a tankless hot water heater. It has saved us quite a bit on our utilities and we never run out of hot water! Any chance of radiant heat, especially in the bathroom? I’m sure that it is too late now, but if you do this type of project again, would it be possible to have photovoltaic shingles as an option. Add a windmill too and you could go off of the power grid☺

Thanks for having such a fun contest. I’ve enjoyed checking it out to see what type of feedback you’ve received.

Julie

I hope you consider the people who are handicapped and need a lot of handicap accessible feaatures, like ramps, walk in closets, wide doors for wheelchairs. What good would it do to win a beautiful cabin if you can't get into it or use it.

I would love to have cork in my kitchen and bamboo flooring for the rest of the house. The cabin designing is so much fun to do. Thank you for allowing an entry a day. Elodia

Hi Amy,I like the idea of a pellet stove too.They are cleaner and nice too.

I have just finished reading all the comments about the cabin !! We live in the smokies- in fact work for the Great Smoky Mts. Natl Park-- the area that you have selected is beautiful with wonderful views of the park and the smoky mountains- no matter what style cabin is selected it will have great views!! There are so many cabins built in this area, and so many amenities to chose from. And a tin roof is great---most of the cabins in the area go with tin simply cause there will be less damage to the roof over the years from all the trees etc. ( the discoloration that always comes with shingles ). Can't wait to see it started and would even like to know if we are allowed to go visit the site !!!!

So many people liked the granite counters for the kitchen. I wonder if anyone is really familiar with quartz? It is just a beautiful and you can pull a beer can opener across it and not leave a scratch mark. It is very forgiving and kid friendly, which would be a must for a log cabin.

Hi Amy,

Great idea to build a log cabin I have always dreamed of owning one. I have an idea you could do three tier deck on the back walking out and on the first level is the picnic area the second is a huge hammock and on the last one is a gazebo, all around is built in benches and pbuilt in potters for flowers.

Jaime from Alabama

i can't really get the floor plans to enlarge so i can read them clearly. also, an endless swimming pool would be very wonderful!
sarah

Hi Amy, I grew up in Ashville and love the mountains. I like the wrap around porch on the first design and the outdoor cooking area. The idea of a hot tub sounds great but is not practical in the mountains unless it is indoors.
It would be very expensive to keep heated all year
and unless the winner is going to live there year round would have to be drained and winterized if not used. A screened area would be great and a utility area with a washer and dryer a must, although cloths could be dried out doors. looking forward to seeing the finished design.

Hello there,

I would make it dog friendly, we have 3 golden retrievers and we made our house here, dog friendly with tile and wood flooring. How about a pond some on the property (doesn't have to be too large) where the dogs can hit the water? We love the idea of a screen porch and an outdoor patio with the fireplace is great. We have one here in Florida and we use it all the time.

Chip

In the bathrooms, I would prefer a cabinet/sink for storage and countertop space, rather than a pedestal sink. And, if you want to pick up an a "cabin" theme, just saw a bathroom fixture at a national DIY store that looks like an old-fashioned water pump (with the convenient single handle hot/cold). That option with a small vessel sink on a country-style cabinet would be perfect for the cabin theme.

Hey Amy, Remember now location, location, location this is important to say, Also I think it would be great if the exterior of the cabin had that old look appeal, but when you enter the home it's like WOW! what a Breathe taking view not only from the time you walk thru the front door but, by the time you exit the back door your in another world. Absulutely breathe taking, kind of know what I mean.

While I like the hot tube idea, I think a better choice would be a LARGE whirpool bath in addition to the shower in the master bath. Then put a large window in front of the tub. Also, I like all of the paint options. Why not have a little of each? I think with living in the mountains, a garages is kind of a must. Between the snow and the tree debris, you just need a garage. I love the kitchen shape in the trilium! Also, I love the stone hearth, but is this also wood burning? IF not, it should be...no artificial fire, it's just not the same. And finally, I think the outdoor fireplace is a must, but I think there does need to be some sort of a water feature as well.

My husband and I vacation (alone, we have 4 kids) in southern Ohio always in a cabin far far away!! Here's what we have found to be some of the things we would like in our dream cabin:

HOT TUB on the porch a must

Deck access from master bedroom

Rocking Chairs on porch and swing on/off porch

Screened in porch is good to keep bugs out but the open space is nice too, either or a little of both would be nice

Outdoor Fireplace/grill area is a must

Hammock in the woods for reading and dreaming

Small outdoor refridgerator for cold beverages near the hot tub and/or chairs

Shed or Garage, you will need someplace to store outdoor maintance items at least, even your hiking and mountian biking equip.

Vaulted ceilings/ and loft area with celing fans

Simple low maintainance kitchen is a must, I like the rustic look with stainless steel appliances

Room or basement for laundry and storage not to mention hvac, you will also need some indoor place to keep the garbage cans, too many animals to get into them!

A room for what ever pastimes/hobbies suit you: computer, sewing, reading/library, painting, gameroom etc.. A room with lots of large low windows and bench seats near the windows to relax on is great.

Skylights are nice too.

Oh and log cabin walls look beautiful unfinished!!

Rustic furnishings and simple decorating is a must, we've seen cabins decorated to look like a country home, it's just not right! It's just wrong.

That's all for now, can't wait to see it.

Would NOT want a hot tub. I am a pool owner and know of what I speak. Too much upkeep, would want this to be low-maintence cabin living. Would LOVE a screened porch.

Solar and wind off grid power. Creek or small stream running through property to build a dam for hydro power generator. Real logs, not log siding. Pellet furnace or boiler with heated floors like "dream home". Lots of windows and skylights to take advantage of the sun. Open lot with no trees to take advantage of the sun. Full basement with garage door for pellet deliveries. Open floor plan with no hall way. Two car heated detached garage with enclosed glass walkway. Small heated pool and hot tub. Solar shingles for more power generation. Built overlooking the Blue Ridge Parkway in North Carolina, Mike & Pat in Winston-Salem,NC

Definatley a hot tub...maybe something built in with a natural stone surround. The most important feature of a home is "flow", and this home should flow from the outside in...so "natural" is the key.

A mud room is very valuable. Also washer/dryer. There are many people who can not or have much difficulty climbing stairs. Also narrow spaces make it hard for them to navigate. Please keep this in mind. Everyone ages eventually, some
just faster than others.

As long as we are dreaming, here are some of my thoughts on making this home perfect for me:
- radiant heating works great, even in our current home with high ceilings
- solar for the power
- on demand hot water (also a green feature)
- I choose the bamboo floors because bamboo is very eco-friendly. We've had bamboo floors for 5 years and they are great.
- mosquito free screened porch
- agree with other posters that I'd choose a wood/stainless combo kitchen
- mud / laundry rooms with an exit
- 2 car garage
- workshop (with power and a utility sink)

Just would like to comment that the Trillium is the only floor plan that has a mud room/laundry room, as Vicky had stated in her note. also the bathrooms seemed bigger. I'm more attracted to the contemporary cabinets, the country ones just look fussy to me for some reason. Also the fireplace outside seems to me to be less upkeep than the gazebo and the waterfall feature. Having MS, I would also have liked seeing a one story home. Thanks for the opportunity to comment.

After reading some of the other comments, I agree with the following:
- VERY good chance it would be a retirement home (especially if WE win it), therefore;
- LAUNDRY ROOM/MUD ROOM! Definitely a must-have, and preferably with a sink/tub;
- SCREENED PORCH very necessary and would be much enjoyed.
- SKYLIGHT(s) great idea
- PANTRY and as much storage space as possible
- WIRED for computer/satellite
- GARAGE/SHOP wired for 110/220 for vehicles/storage and all us DIYers' projects!!!
- DECK off the master, YES!
Personally, I think the Trillium is by far the superior choice; it's larger, open to the loft for more light and outdoor viewing. LOVE the upstairs master with the big bath and closet area.
This is exciting! I think DIY has a winner letting us give our input and I can't wait to see the final results!
Thank you!
Baby Boomers Nearing Retirement

I voted for the Greenbriar because even though cathedral ceilings provide a beautiful view, and curb appeal, you loose a lot of upstairs floor space and heat. I would like to see you incorporate: 1) a mud room near an entryway, 2) washer/dryer area, 3) adequate closets for storage and 4) a basement under all or part of the home that would provide space for furnace, water heater, storage, hobbies and shelter from tornados. If built into a hillside, the basement and garage could be partial walkouts, but with a way to drive up to the ground level in the back for unloading groceries and other things. Make sure there is plenty of insulation at ground level and attic to help keep energy costs down. A heat pump would also help the eventual lucky owner use less carbon based fuel. Making the Greenbriar a green energy efficient home would be a model for others to emulate.

I agree a hot tub would be great, I would like to see the patio fireplace enclosed in a screen room if possible.

Eco friendly is a must today. Radiant heat under the floors along with those fireplace choices will keep the place nice and warm. A small one in the master bedroom might be nice. I too like the Trillum design for all of its practicality. I would add built in book shelves in the upstairs loft space. PLacing a water feature on the bedroom side would be most relaxing at night. I would go with a fire pit area totally surrounded by a stone floor and seating area for safety. Hot tub within a gazebo type enclosure but no roof. You'll want to look at the stars. Screens that roll up and out of the way for the porch area sounds good.
Can't wait to see the finished cabin.

Love the idea on the cabin. My wife has always wanted to retire to the mountains in a log cabin. I grew up in the foothills and have always enjoyed the Smokies. I think that a screened in porch would add a tremendous amount to the cabin. This would allow more enjoyable evenings enjoying the outdoors.

Hi Blog community
I like the ideal of having a place for firewood and a airseal door for bringing in the wood.

Another thought: may we please have a dishwasher?

Hi Amy!
I just discovered your site! You definately have my "Dream Job"!
I would love to see the floorplan ideas on these!

My thoughts:
*Going with the Hot Tub idea...an old-fashioned deep round wooden one...perhaps dual heat (wood/solar or wood/electric)?
*Ceiling fans in all or most rooms!
*A woodstove insert with fan/blower (perhaps even ducted to save on gas or eletric heat). *A "mudroom" area with an itegrated bench to hang coats, hats and store boots (perhaps with removable glass panels that leave screen panels for air circulation in the warmer months)...maybe designed like a breezeway...if large enough could double as a summertime sleeping porch with hammocks!
*Depending on the staircase design, a built-in bookcase would be nice...If the staircase is exposed on both sides, a closet on the other side.
*If there are dormers, the window seats with storage in either a "lift-up seat" style, drawer style, or open sections for baskets.
*An open loft area at the top of the stairs for quiet reading or games.
*A "broken stone" walkway/driveway.
*A pantry

Can't wait to see the finished results!
-Eileen

There is a way to enjoy a hot tub and be green also! Check out www.snorkle.com It is an all wood hot tub heated by an underwater wood stove. It can be placed anywhere and does not need any plumbing or electricity. A true cabin hot tub.

Have always dreamed of living in a cabin in the mountains. Thanks D.I.Y. for a chance to make that dream come true!

Wouldn't it be wonderful to see the sun rise and set? You've gotta keep the East-West thing in mind. Perhaps a breakfast room toward the East with lots of windows, and a huge bay window facing the West??

Where in NC in the Great Smokey Mtns are you building the cabin ? We used to go to my parents log cabin in Bryson City but they sold it & we miss it very much. My family likes all the sports available in that area. They go kayaking on the Nantahala River & enjoy it very much. They also go mountain biking at the Tsali biking trails.Sightseeing thru Cherokee, the Smokey Mtn national park,Dollywood,Pigeon Forge,Tennesee,
Ashville,etc,etc. We still go there for vacation every year. Can't wait to see the cabin.

I love the idea of the screened in porch, bugs can ruin even the most beautiful sunset. I think a screened in porch with skylights and ceiling fans. Nice.

Consider recycled carpet for all carpeting in the house - it's so lush - easy to obtain - and is truly a GREEN product!

I like the screen in porch ,A nice size family room would be nice ,A sun room to enjoy all of the great out doors.

Amy, With the aging population, could you consider making the doorways wider and as the minimum the lower floor bathroom & bedroom wheelchair accessible? A ramp to one of the exterior accesses would be very helpful. Since the 1970s, Northern European new buildings have been universally accessible. Surely we can be do as well or at least be visitable.

LOVE the screened in porch idea. It is buggy in the mountains. Also, when I think rustic, country... I think wrap around porch, with, of course, rocking chairs. Something to sit in, listen to the crickets at night, watch the sunset... then, since the porch is wrap around, the next morning you can grab a cuppa and watch the sun come up.

I would also think, practically speaking, a mudroom would be a good idea :)

Also, perhaps some skylights in the master so you (well, of course I'm really thinking "I"!!) can listen to rain while falling asleep.

I imagine many winter trips for snoeshoeing and the like. So perhaps radiant heating would be great.

I'm really excited about this project. What fun! Thanks for doing it :)

Amy
I love the building of a log home, something we are in the middle of planning. We are baby boomers who have, like many others, reverted back to the ranch style. Anytime you want to build a ranch style log home, we'd be happy to be part of that project!!

My wife and I like to cook together; we think a large kitchen and open to the living area is important to a log cabin.

I'm wondering what or if there will be any thoughts on landscaping? I always wanted a cabin that looked like a 'Christmas Tree Cottage'. the mountains are always a perfect location for that kind of landscaping whimsy.

Choosing the house plan is difficult.

I like the floor plan of the Trillium the best, but I like all the large windows in the Smokyview and the Greenbriar has the most curb appeal.

I'm glad majority rules.

I love the idea of having the cabin be in the Smoky Mountains which my sister and cousins used to visit with my Grandmother HUNDREDS of years ago, it seems now. It would be wonderful to have the country cabinets in the kitchen in a pale blue antique-y type of finish. I hope the cabin will be built of cedar rough hewn logs, since they are beautiful logs that reputedly last forever. The cabin must have a loft with a wooden ceiling, so the warmth of wood will be outside, inside, and above. I am excited to see the dream come to life and would invite everyone who participated to come and see me there -- tee hee. Thanks, Julia

I didn't notice anything in the plan that discussed either auto storage (a garage), or foundation.
Is the plan to put this cabin on a slab or will there be a basement?
It would be nice if there were a bit more utility space - room for a washer and dryer, a freezer, and a pantry.

Hi Amy, wow, you have a great fans with a whole bunch of ideas that are fantastic. I too love the log cabin look, just someday I hope to have one of my own. My husband and I did look at a few this past year and were really disappointed in most. The outsides were the logs, but when it came to the inside it was not at all "log cabin" rustic feel at all. If one has the idea of building log cabins the design should be carried throughout the inside as well. I like the country look kitchen, and would have loved it ven more if it was of the rough hewn, natural rustic look, not the white washed. The contempory had the color but not quite the log cabin effect.
Why have the log on the outside, work at keeping up the maintence and only to have sheetrock walls and modern look on the inside. Oh, my pick is right on the top that all was chosen so far.
Thanks for hearing me out, I feel good now.
Bye, Donna

I have always wanted a log cabin and I think the choices you have given are great. The only thing my husband and I couldn't agree on was he wants the shower and I want the claw foot tub. Maybe you could do a smaller shower in with the tub :-) Have fun building!!

How about a walk-in closet for the master bedroom? or for all bedrooms, even a small one would be better than nothing? Also, with so many good choices for bathroom fixtures, why not have the modern slate walk-in shower for the master bath, and choose another one for the other bathroom (perhaps steam shower combo)?

As a simple person who has never had much space for things I would love to see storage space. I think window seats in a bedroom where things could be stored. A closet made of cedar. Ceiling fans are always a nice touch. A beutiful walkway of stone and a nice garden would be a nice touch. Is there a thought on a garage of any sort? A tree in the yard to hang a hammock or put up a swing to sit on to reflect,dream or relax on.

may be a carport nothing enclosed .

Hi Amy,

I am wondering about the granite countertop that looks suspiciously like laminant and not granite. I am hoping that all the votes for granite really get what they believe they are voting for?

Denise - avid DIY and HGTV viewer

I love the basement it would be great and a carport something with a open plan that you can walk through.bennett

I love the idea of a hot tub (with a roof overhead and close enough to run to in the snow!) I love the idea of a water feature that is not deep enough for the grandkids to be in danger (other shows have shown streams running through the property and they look great!) Don't skimp on garage space - it needs to hold at least 3 cars and have room in the back for crafting or woodworking. Please leave as many trees in place that the "forest" feeling is still there. Plant bulbs and other flowers that appear year after year. Low maintenance is the key since it will be a place to retreat to and we don't want to have to do "yard work" every time we use it. Flowering trees with "fruit" on them attract birds and add to the "forest" feel. A bird bath and some bird houses would be nice. How close would it be to other sites so one could take in some sight-seeing if they would like?

Have fun building this cabin. This is a great idea!

Hi Amy a screened in half porch and open on the other end would be wonderfull,and you could still throw in the hot tub too!!!!!

Hi Amy i like the water feature may be it could be made big and tall so you could walk under the water fall and down a trail. Bennett

The outdoor fireplace is a great idea...there are great pictures of outdoor fireplaces on patios and screened rooms with outdoor fireplaces at www.firerock.us

wow so many things i love and hate about the options where do i start i love mixing and matching but why build a beautiful log cabin to make it sleek and modern on the inside would of liked more options that arent so country but not stainless still anyways thats my opnion for now and who uses vinly for a roof, omg and does someone come clean it off i cant climb up there and why arent there any one story plans what about a pook option for outback lol oh i will stop for now

I agree with others that floor plan design for handicapped and having more of rooms downstairs.
The loft/bedroom is great letting more light inside. I also agree with radiant floors, screened porch and gararge/workshop.
My husband and I wanted to build our own log home one day but too many days have passed. Having one ready to move in, especially in Tennessee, is my dream come true without the hard work. Thanks for having this great, great contest.
Mike and Linda

Smoky mountains would be a great place to retire to my grandchildren would love it we have been looking for a place like this would be great.my husband and I love going for walks .All the deign you gave us to pick from were great.Bennett

I vote for a mudroom/utility room. You could easily screen in any or parts of all of the porches on these cabins. I like the versatility of the Trillium -- I wanted the metal roof til I read from a fireman... How about those fireproof shingles that look like cedar shakes? If I win this -- it's actually something I could afford to keep - unless you keep adding stuff to it... Would like to know if it will be over a crawlspace/basement or slab ... I like the looks of all of them up on the posts.. but realize that every hibernating animal would love to move under for the winter.... or just skunks/coons for the summer...

I once had a client who said in designing his weekend cabin retreat, that a must was the entrance mudroom with large closets to hold everyone's duffle bags, boots, jackets, etc. for the groups of relatives that would come to the cabin. A brilliant idea. Then having a bench with boot/shoe storage underneath works well for not tracking in the cabin. Another idea in the kitchen is to have ample room for guests that always bring a bottle of wine, bag of groceries or whatever and there is usually not enough counterspace to hold the arrivals. Again, usually these cabins are retreats that invite lots of guests for those wonderful events that we all love. The more the merrier!

Wow! What a great idea for a home that is affordable and so full of loving features. I haven't been keeping up with my email since I lost my Husband in Sept and just noticed this one today. I wanted to take part in designing this cabin because it reminds me of the quiet times we spent in a cabin in the Dells of Wisconsin. Our friends had a lovely place there and this looks like a place where one can enjoy peace, nature at its best and a warm home to share with family and friends. I chose the Greenbriar because I liked the floorplan, Cedar shakes because they are natural,and the Country kitchen because it looks like it belongs in this house. I chose Clover Leaf savannah for the floors and the branch railings just to add a surprise to the decor. I love the claw foot tub but the whirlpool would feel so good. The water feature was appealing but the outdoor fireplace just made me want to entertain there and sit out nights and watch the fire glow. All this home needs is someone to love it and make it their own with their family momentos. I can see me sitting there on the couch with a warm afghan, glass of wine and a view too beautiful to discribe. Thank you for designing a house that real people could actually afford. Whoever the lucky winner is, may they find peace and happiness there.

Hi Amy;
I think you need a basement, And to help protect the environment, I'd like solar and maybe some geothermal just for the savings. I'd love to build the kitchen cabinets myself, out of wormy chestnut to match the front door!
Charles

My vote would be for NO hot tub, screened in porch for all season comfort (no bugs). Love the wrap-around porch on the first floorplan as well as bedrooms and bath downstairs.

A few other thoughts about the Cabin Design. I agree with other comments about a Hot Tub..a fan on the screen porch,Glider rockers and a really nice grill on a covered landing .. sorry I vote for no cable on the porch and shut off the cell phone too.
Maybe some skylights in the upstairs bedrooms.

Responding to others comments....I still want the metal roof...it will last a good long time, and to someone who mentioned slate (its just as noisy, trust me)

Complaint - We were not given enough choices for interior finish

Well there are already quite a few people saying basement, I'll add for crafting. I would also love it if there was at least a modest greenhouse.

Am adding another comment to my origanal response. A real wood burning fireplace in the great room would be wonderful and in keeping with the rustic surroundings.

Hi Amy,
What an interesting venture. All of the suggestions are wonderful ideas. My brother-in-law built a place in the mountains several years ago. While it is a beautiful,comfy home, it lacks the feel of a true mountain cabin. A mountain cabin should convey the look and feel of the rustic abodes of the old Smokies. How fortunate we are to live in a time where we can achive this look and feel without losing the creature comforts that we are so spoiled by. Why have a cabin that looks like state of the art, cookie cutter suburbia, when you can have something that honors the real essence of the mountains. So as you can guess my vote leans toward the Smokeyview with wormwood door, shakes, clawfoot, stone fireplace, handcrafted walls, natural branch bannisters, country kitchen (that I would open instead of the U shape),with waterfall, outdoor fireplace AND rustic gazebo. A tankless waterheater would be great to save energy. Add some bent twig hickory and oak rocking chairs and you have a cabin that IS a piece of the Great Smokies!!
Enjoy,
Shaun Forbes Davis

Since your asking ---the things I want in my cabin:
Walk in Tile shower two shower heads
A Pantry is a MUST,
A Laundry room with large counter area,
Breakfast room with plenty of windows that look out at a garden,
Walk in closets with plenty of shelves and storage,
Basement entertainment area,
Secluded master suite,
Master bedroom to have its own patio,
fireplace that is double sided viewed from master bedroom and master bathroom
Mudd room,
at least 4 bedrooms,
attached garage,
Office,
hottub,
outside entertainment area
Not asking for much am I

I live in the country and know all about what the lifestyle should represent. In addition, I am in the real esate business. A cabin in our Great Smoky Mountains wouldn't be complete without a porch swing. Country life wouldn't be country life without a quite setting, pretty views, and peace. To add a tv to the front porch would drown the sounds of nature.

Another consideration: The Great Smoky Mountains is full of cabins! What will be done to this cabin to make it superior in both style and appeal?

Kitchens and baths are what makes it or breaks it. Stainless appliances and granite countertops are popular. In addition, wouldn't a granite sink be nice?

A HOTTUB IS A MUST, Please! Please! Please! For those of us with kids it would be the perfect way to escape from our little monsters once we finnaly get them to bed. Also, if at all possible. I agree with the basement suggestion - I'm thinking Rec Room and pool table with a rustic finish - that would be awesome. We live in a little cabin that we are slowly fixing up - we have lives here with 3 kids and no kitchen for 3 months untill we could fix it up - just a finished cabin would be nice!

Hi Amy,

This is all such an exciting process. I am really for the screened in porch. Definitely wicker furniture to have a nice cozy spot to enjoy the beautiful landscape. A nice flower and vegetable garden to enjoy would also be very enjoyable. Will this have a basement? That would be a great added asset to this project.

Well, I too had hoped for the Smokeyview. My family would be outside or looking outside, were we to be fortunate enough to live in such a grand place!! The side porch would be terrific as a sunroom/office, etc. and the fireplace on that wall could have been doubled into the sunroom. We wouldn't be spending much time in the bathrooms, but it could be that a family of 6 sees bathrooms from a different perspective - serves a purpose, but on to better things... :) I sure will miss the open ceiling!!!!! Any chance the ceiling could be raised 10'-12' just to add a little drama?!
Guess I'll need to dream on the new concept a bit as you can't be too far off in a log cabin!

I just love the thought of being in a cabin in the middle of nowhere..I had a chance this Christmas to spend two weeks in one and I fell in love with the view, the hot tub and the wilderness.....

I live in a house which was built in 1720. As a result I am familiar with those 'creature' comforts that make a house warm and inviting. A log cabin floor plan should consider some of that old world charm while providing for some modern day comforts. As a result I was a little dissapointed with the outcome of the floor plan vote. The wraparound porch would have been really nice and it could have been screened in, or at least a part of it.

With regard to Ron's interest in comments to the outdoor patio I would definitely vote for the fireplace with BBQ grill nestled in with the trees which provide adequate shade and respite from the sun.

I agree with an earlier suggestion to expand the island in the Greenbriar kitchen and remove the extension next to the dining room. I think it can improve the flow in the area.
I love the waterfall and have seen such spectacular results in naturalized efforts on the gardening programs. I would prefer to lay the patio, bring in a large low profile firepit, and set up a grill msyelf so we can open the area to see the woods, stars, and animals drawn to the waterfall feature. (Just in case we can't have it all....) Maybe French Doors or massive windows of some type in the dining room would look out on the feature.
Wow! I think I'm hooked on this planning/blogging thing!

Hi Amy nice floor plan. As for the outdoors an outside fireplace would be perfect,gathering the family outside and enjoying qality time with one another instead of veggying infront of the tv,injoying the fresh air what could a person want.
melody inman

In my oppion, the water feature would be the best choice. It would make the cabin grounds seem more "woods'ey." My husband & I have a Gold Wing motorcycle. Every year in April we try to come down to Pigeon Forge for the Gold Wing Spring Fling. We have fallen in love with the area! One of our favorite bike rides is the Roaring Forks Nature Trail. Our bike is alot quieter than some of the other makes of bikes,so as we ride along we can hear the water moving. It calms us & truly makes it seem like we are one with nature.

I have many ideas of my own as to the best features, what would be best in the location, as well as add ons, but you know what, all I really want to say is, if I were to win this cabin, I would be perfectly happy with just the features I voted on.

Just rechecked the floor plan on the Greenbriar and there is nothing overhead on three sides. Perhaps this is why the gazebo option? I would love something on the order of the branch stair banister, but much more substantial. I like the bench concept on the one shown and a table would be good, but am not fond of the roof and the support logs might need random branches added to each. Comments? Maybe the drama for this cabin is supposed to be outside?!

First choice is still the waterfall!!

If there is a sunny orientation for a vegetable garden, the gardener in the family would be very a happy!

If I could add features to this cabin, I'd add handicapped accessible ones first, easy access to the cabin and to the grounds - an adapted kitchen to some degree and I'd design with having a dog around, so a dog door through one wall leading to a small outdoor kennel would make my day. Noone controls what happens to them in their lives whether that's accidents or aging. Why NOT design for a future that might include time when not-so-able. And include our dog friends (or in my case Service Dog).

Even those with disabilities enjoy the outdoors.

Hi Amy!
Looks like almost everyone wants a tin roof; no argument from me because the sound of rain on a tin roof is one of the most soothing sounds one can experience. Personally, I'd be glad to pay the additional premium for insurance.

There would be a similar concern with cedar shakes on the roof. Forest fires are not unheard of in the Appalachain Mountains and the cedar roof could be ignited by falling sparkes. Of course it might be possible to obtain cedar that has been treated to be fire retardent.

Another concern is available water in the event of fire; I'm assuming this wouldn't be an issue if the cabin is being constructed in a developed area.

The chosen exterior design seems perfect as do many of the interior options that seems to be popular. Sure is nice to contemplate the possibility of being lucky enough to move in! The "Blog Cabin" is looking so much like the sketch Hubby made of our dream home!

Hi Amy & Ron-

My husband is a retired Fire Chief. I presented your question about the tin roof and fighting fires. He said it might present more intense axing to cut a hole in the roof if needed; BUT, it is a excellent safety factor in any wooded area. The tin does not catch fire if there were to be a forest fire and there would be a greater chance of saving your home!

L. Beason

hi, i read what others said they would like in a log cabin and i see it in another light. a screened back porch area would be nice but definately a walk around porch for the rest and lots of large windows to see the views from every side. when you walk in it should be a romantic getaway for 2. a fireplace in the center of the room that can be seen on all 4 sides, and a built in fish aquarium that runs up the wall, if i was living there i would want plenty of storage and i would like plush carpeting in all the bedrooms and a nice mahogony wood floor in the main rooms.. i would love a walk out basement with room for a billiards table and seating for watching tv. since i am a short person my kitchen would have the cabinets lower with plenty of room at the top of them for collectables. laundry room is a plus. walls in the family room would be rustic and i don't agree with the tin roof, i would have a beautiful cedar roof. outside would be wild flowers and a flowing stream with a waterfall and plenty of bird houses mounted around the yard to attract nature to you. built in bookshelves would be nice as well and the only other thing that could make it perfect would be a window seat built for 2. also an open area plan so when you enter the house you would see lofts up above.

All the comments so far are great but,let's put some sort of order to it. Combine the storage shed and garbage corral into an out building near garbage pick up (is there pick up there?) also adding pumphouse to outbuilding equation. As for the popularity of granite countertops...no thanks. If I may; how about looking into the energy shingles that collect sun/motion energy and store it for house hold use and sale back to electric company? A green item from a renewable source that has a 15/20 year guarentee.Then the building and possibly the out buildings would be able to supply most of the household's needed electric usage.

As for the kitchen, storage is a major consideration and I think a pantry to be included. I would also like to see a "mud room." I also agree that stainless and wood wouldbe nice. I just think the idea of this is wonderful.

Hi Amy, I'm from the Philippines and there, most of the homes have tin roofs, they are the best, specially when you're in the forest or close to it besides you can put some sort of insulation and support to lessen the noice caused by rain. I have gone camping so many times in different parks in California and when I used to live in Alaska and cabins are the best. Also, carbonized bamboo floorings are so comfortable and durable and very easy to keep up during the winter. An open living room and kitchen are more warm and inviting for a small family as well as having guests. It would be convenient to have a parking garage with a tin roof to blend in with the cabin during rainy days. A mixture of stainless and wood in the kitchen with a quartz top island table would bring up more ambiance, elegance and would make it more exquisite. Thanks, Joy...

What about a swimming pool? I mean, if you're talking about this being a cabin, and it's in the Great Smokey Mountains well, there's not a lot of places to go swimming in the Smokey's now is there? I personally don't think of cabins without water nearby somewhere. A pool in the yard would really set this place off as being super special, and a screened in one would be tops!!!