The features we are voting for seem to be recreating the 2007 Blog Cabin. I guess that is to be expected, since the people that voted for it last year are the ones doing the voting again this year. The stone surround woodburning fireplace, the metal roof, the arts and crafts kitchen cabinets...they are all natural selections for a cabin. And the power shower is another natural addition, who wouldn't want one? But I hope that we get a little more exotic, or maybe a little more practical? East Tennessee gets snow, so making the outdoor patio enclosable would be a nice addition. But I hope that radiant floor heat is offered as an option. And it would be nice if recyclable materials were being used more extensivly throughout the cabin. Maybe that would make an interesting challenge, a cabin made completely of recycled materials, and as eco-friendly as possible. Manufactured logs, manufactured floors, composite materials throughout, to show that a high-end cabin can be made using nothing new?
Anyway, when do we get to start entering to win the cabin? I live in Michigan now, but all of my family are in northern Alabama. This cabin would allow me to move closer to my family, and help get me out of the economic cesspool that is Michigan now. We are planning on moving once my youngest daughter finishes high school in three years. This cabin would be a wonderful place to be moving too.
Keep up the great work.

What is the square footage of the floorplan?

It would be nice if some info was given about some of the choices. For instance the countertops, what are the differing characteristics of each choice and the showerheads, what are the eco pros and cons. In an age where energy use is a concern and recycling is the name of the game standard choices might not be the best but without some info I feel like my vote is a shot in the dark. Thank you for your consideration.

Hello Barry,

Thank you for asking - this square footage question has been popping up. The answer is: we don't know yet. The Blog Cabin team (builders, producers, consultants) are still considering all the suggestions that have been made concerning the floor plan. When their decisions are final, we'll know - but if I had to take a guess, I would say in the neighborhood of 2600 square feet (I think you are right, Susan) - but don't quote me.

Watson, DIYnetwork.com Manager

Great, new things to vote and blog on. So far so good. I especially like the wood fire decision. In keeping with 'greener', more eco-friendly choices like wood fire I voted for the eco-friendly low flow shower. The region is in a serious drought and with water demand rising this may be a permanent state of affairs. Reducing water use will become more important in the future so let's build for the future today. Recycling/re-using 'grey' water and installing smart flushing toilets also would be a step in the right direction. Conserving rainwater in cisterns could work for yard irrigation. I know the land is on a lake but often in these circumstances lake water is not permitted to be pumped onto the land.
Stone fireplace surround is a must.
Quartz counters are a bit less maintenance than granite which needs annual cleaning, re-sealing and is becoming a bit dated. The same goes for soapstone and others which have varying degrees of maintenance.
It has to be a metal roof. All the other options, although looking quaint, simply don't hold a candle to metal roofing for durability, low maintenance and no oil based product (unless an oil based coating is chosen) in the production.
I went with traditional cabinets because they are in keeping with the cabin theme but are less prone to dust collecting compared with the English cottage or the arts & crafts which have a lot of open spaces. Constantly having to dust dishes etc. is a chore and no fun.
I have an additional comment/question on the lake. This is a man-made lake used to provide water for electricity generating. There is a nuclear plant at the Watts Bar Dam and hydro too I believe. Does anyone know what the seasonal draw-down is on this lake? Similar lakes to this, such as Lake Norman in NC where my folks live, have a big annual draw-down to prevent spring flooding of the nuclear plant. The water level drops up to 10ft or more for several months in the winter. Boat docks have to be a fair way out into the lake to compensate for this and all docks need a boat lift. What are the local regs. for docks?

Seems kinda weird that the other day there was a glitch in the voting and you could already see these new items to vote on (but you couldnt vote yet) and there were already winners and low and behold there are already run away winners. Seems pretty fishy to me. Like the bulders already know what they are going to build so its up to us to vote on something differant. I am really really dishearted over this issue. Our voting may all be in vain.

I love most of the selections for the cabin this round. I'm happy the hanging light won and Dlogs won , I had a hard time with the woodburning fireplace though. I would definitely dread having to haul & store or pay for wood, & clean smoke and ash up! But I wouldn't let that stop me from having a gorgeous fire sometimes. And this would most definitely be the best in case of electricity failure, right. Now as for the new choices I never heard of the paper countertops, very interesting choice. I'd like to know more about them. My personal choice would definitely be the quartz or granite c-tops they are beautiful in any type of home or style. The Arts and crafts cabinets and stone fireplace,tin roof, were so georgeous! I want exactly what is pictured. Gorgous!!!! They are perfect for the cabin in my opinion. The power and rain shower are also my favorite, hard to decide between the two but I do worry about the fact that they do use a huge amount of water and Tn was definitely dry last year and behind in rainfall totals last I remember, so that makes me somewhat conscienctience about the importance of saving as much water as possible. I would love to know: Do the rain and power showers come in water saving power flows? That could be helpful in determining that choice better! I am having alot of fun on the blog and Mr Watson You be a good blog host now! Scolding Us! Well I never! You are doing a great job and looking forward to hearing from Ahmed Soon!

Hi Watson,

Thanks for the sq ft comment. It helps but didn't I see that Lakeview Estates states in it's literature that all homes should be a minimum of 2600sq ft? Is this not so for this cabin?

Sue

Hi everyone. My name is Grace and I am the show runner of Blog Cabin. I echo the sentiments of one blogger who feels we are repeating Blog Cabin 2007. I urge you to consider new building materials and not vote for the standard or expected choices. Of course we felt we needed to offer these up but had hoped for a whole new feel for this cabin! Please keep in mind, we are only offering up solid choices that will look good in this floor plan. For instance, granite, while a very solid choice, is starting to feel a bit overdone in the eyes of many designers and they are opting for sustainable products or other solid surfaces with equal or longer life expectancies. Soapstone would be my choice as it feels at home in rustic, cozy homes and it is easy to clean, gorgeous, and nonporous. Now, for the metal roof! Take a look at the composite cedar and the slate options. They are quite beautiful, environmentally friendly, and frankly will look darn good with the log and shake design of the San Jacinto house plan. I urge you to take a look at the choices, perhaps read up on their strong points and look forward to an even better cabin this year!

Quartz counters rock! (pun intended) Think the look of granite but with none of the work. My quartz countertops are beautiful and they require no maintenance. In fact I sometimes scrape my counters clean with a straight edged razor blade. Try that with a granite countertop! Also, I don't have to remove every item on my counters so they can be sealed every six months. Not necessary with quartz. The hardest thing about getting my quartz countertops was choosing the color. They were all so beautiful.

I have a question about the fireplace surround. There is a tile choice, but I don't see any actual tile in the photo. What am I missing?

And I second the comment left by Teri above. It would be nice to have some info about the various choices so we have something to base our decisions on. I know which shingle look I like best, but if I were putting them on my own house, I'd certainly go by more than looks! And what exactly is a power shower head?

I love all of the voting choices we have this time compared with last year! Everything I have voted for so far has come out on top, but I am somewhat concerned about the English cottage cabinets. There are a lot of open cabinets, which like a previous blogger stated, will collect a lot of dust on your dishes. But, also, I think they look a tad Hansel and Gretelish. Ok, so that is just my opinion, I actually voted for the European Country cabinets, as they look clean and modern, yet suitable for a log cabin. I had such a hard time deciding between the power shower and the rain shower. Maybe the power shower could have a huge rain shower at the top? Just a thought. I am hoping, if the stone fireplace surround wins, that they will do one similar to last years. Last years fireplace was absolutely beautiful, but this years, because it is the focal point of the room has the potential to be absolutely grand! I can't wait to see the final product!

I forgot to mention in my previous post about the stone fireplace. D-logs are smaller than massive round logs, and I think a huge stone fireplace would totally overpower the logs and it would look out of place. If stones do win over the other choices, you'll definitely have to go with smaller stones and make a much smaller fireplace surround with them, as opposed to the massive floor to ceiling stone fireplace in the 2007 cabin.

Hi Guys and Gals,
My family and I love to vacation in the smoky mountains. One thing we like to do is invite friends and other family members to come with us. I would like to see a basement apartment or extended family space in the cabin.The lay of the land usually easily accomodates this and the space gained is priceless.It is also a great place to house laundry areas,hvac,plumbing, and electrical.Thanks for your time...Amy devers rocks!!!

Oooh, kitchen options! I love white cabinets with a earth tone counter top, made of something neat like IceStone (icestone.com). Then a darker floor, like cherry wood. Of course, it all depends on what the walls in the kitchen look like (are they logs, or do they have sheet rock), if they are logs then I would have to pick something totally different.

Well, it looks as though none of my choices are going to win this time either.

The slate composite tiles are beautiful...and many have a high re-cycled plastic level, which makes them green as well. Additionally, they are very sympathetic, visually, to the home chosen. Here is an article that discusses slate composite tiles:
http://www.oldhousejournal.com/magazine/2002/july/slate.shtml

Paperstone countertops are fabulous. Richlite is an amazing product...but it won't win. Not enough people know about it. For those who'd like to educate themselves...
http://www.richlite.com/countertop/

I DO think the fact that we are asked to vote, before folks have really had a chance to research, is one reason the cabins are shaping up similarly. Perhaps if the powers-that-be made it easier for people to educate themselves, we might get different results. I'd suggest posting the facts about stuff for a week BEFORE we begin voting. Then we could make an informed choice.
Additionally--I think people react to the color of the proposed choices...even though that may not be the color SELECTED for the cabin. If you showed the paperstone possibility in the "slate" or "sage" colors, rather than "baguette" or "hemp" you might get completely different responses.

I'm going to keep tilting at windmills...and if I win the place I'll just pull the granite out and replace it with Richlite! (Well, probably not...but I'll WISH I could.)

- Metal Roof -- If this ends up winning, please do this with recycled metal. The appearance can look like any of the other options or many other things.

- For the shower heads, please ensure that whatever is selected has the energy conserving options in it. Power showers & waterfall show heads can be adjusted to reduce water consumption to the same the "eco friendly" version.

On all of them, try to get locally produced items or, at least, within 500 miles.

One reason I like the metail roof is that it is easier to rainwater collection with it -- so, we also need a cistern. But, hopefully we can also have some greywater reuse too.

And, radiant heating in the floors, please.

I think the metal roof is great since it will last for years and does not use trees or other natural resources to make it. I think the stone fireplace would look great after all this is a log cabin and what better look to have in the Great Room. I like the suggestion on the faucets for the shower - you are right that we should be looking at conservation when voting! And the comments on the coutertops are extremely helpful in making a decision - thank you all for the information!

It looks like people are voting for the same materials as the 2007 Blog Cabin. Come on folks you can have a log cabin without the Tin roof. Folks go for adventure try something new for change you may like it. Let's not just reproduce the same thing over and over dare to be different. Review the material strengths before deciding. You may be surprised at some of the new material coices.

Thank you for listening

Clive, you are a "well" of information. Glad you are along for the ride....kind of like having a roll of duct tape in the glove box, but better;

You give us thought provoking questions and send us searching for answers.

Thanks for the input.

In some ways this blog gives a good feel for reality.....we really want our comfort, and if it is convenient...the eco friendly too. We are a spoiled lot.

I had never seen recycled paper countertops or heard about them until today. I had a look online and it was really an eye-opener. If we are trying for a more eco-friendly/'green' cabin they must be serious contenders. They do require some maintenance as they appear to be more like a cross between solid wood and laminate in the quality of the surface. Trivets are necessary for very hot things and they do need periodic refinishing, polishing etc. but they are 100% recycled waste paper, wood and bamboo fiber with non-toxic epoxy resins binding them (no vapors or chemical releases as there are from some woods and other composite surfaces). If we're trying to be a bit different and more eco-friendly they should be considered as an alternative to the 'Oh so predictable' granite, quartz and soapstone options.

Flooring, backsplash, window treatments, plus 27+ unspecified votes to go. Such fun! :)

Backsplash -- I'll delay commenting on type until we know more about cabinets & countertops in the Kitchen. But, please give us some recycled materials from which to choose.

Love wood floors, but in the Entry, Mud Room, Laundry (whether it is moved or not) & Baths, suggest something that can take water more. Perhaps consider linoleum for green purposes. Or reuse tiles from another site (same for the wood). Or, at the least, use material with a lot of recycled in it. For the wood, please have bamboo and cork as options -- unless one can get wood from a torn down building or railroad ties or similar. If carpet is used, please ensure that it is from recycled fibres & that it includes removal & recycling when it is replaced. (Some companies already have that as a set package.)

Window treatments -- lots of windows on the lake side (with few panes) would be nice. But, please ensure they are super energy efficient.

Radiant floor heating, please. With some strategic ceiling fans to send heat back down when needed, such as from the wood fireplace.

I think perhaps the metal roof is out pacing the others in the vote because it is the only one actually shown on a cabin. The others are a little harder to picture what the results would look like combined with the D-log exterior.
I voted for a concrete counter top because there are so many things you can do with it as far as shape, color, possibly even tile inlays! It could really be fabulous if done right.
Last buty not least, I hope the fireplace surround will have a built in storage area for the logs, as it just looks neater and it's easier to keep the surrounding area clean.

I think that Granite in the kitchen might be too fancy for a cabin and hard to take care of. Quartz or soapstone would be a better choice. Please consider adding another bedroom on the first floor with roll in shower and a ramp somewhere to get into the cabin! You never know when you might need the convenience. This cabin looks like it is going to be a great place to live.

I was torn between all the choices of shower heads since I was pushing the new walk in shower and tub, finally chose the rain shower.

I chose the metal roof, most of the houses here near the lake I live real near 30ft from have metal roofs.

I chose the stone fireplace, but agree the stones need to be smaller than last year.

I love the european cabinets, the arts and crafts are to open.

Thank you Melanie after reading your post I read up on Richlite and wish I had been more informed before I voted for concrete. I voted concrete because I have seen them used on both DIY and HGTV and they seemed wonderful, but I would rather pick something that uses recyling.

I love the input all the bloggers have, keep it up!!!

Mary from Texas

It's great to see products like the slate composite roofing, paperstone and concrete counters and the low-flow shower heads.

I am new to this blog. I assume the design team decides which items to vote on? If so, I would like to see options like; heat, forced air or radient? Heat pump or furnace? Tank or tankless water heater, with/without solar? Duel flush toilets or designer? FSC certified wood? Type and R rating of insulation(fiberglass, spray foam, ridgid foam, celeous, etc.)? Sky lights, solar tubes, extra windows?

Maybe next year bloggers could pick the options to vote on. I would be glad to give up the more expensive tiles or cabinets in exchange for solar panels or a gray water system.
What do you all think?

I'm going metal roof, too. It just makes sense - 30-50 trouble-free years, and then maybe a paint job. I like that. Re: shower...do we want there to BE a lake next to the cabin in, say, 20-30 years? Might want to go lo-flo shower, then. AND add a grey water reclamation system (I don't hug trees, but I have been known to plant them LOL). I like the stone surround for a cabin fireplace - and this gives the brothers another long chance to weigh in :-). But, granite counter tops - no. Soapstone is a much better choice a) can be recycled from architechtural yards, b) is a more care-free option (mineral oil 3-4 times a year), c) hot pots go RIGHT ON with no discoloration for low care easy use, d) can be worked with common tools - no power wasting fine honing AND can be sent to site in workable pieces AND can be re-worked on site (low care installation). Oh, did I say LOW CARE .

Jim Roberts

It's good to see my comments did get posted even though they are now cut off from the current conversation and no one will be likely to see them. I hope the designers saw them and could use some of my suggestions, it looks as though the posting names were off by one blog entry also. OOPS!

Anyway, love the new choices!

Grace, not to worry, eventhough some of the choices are the same, the varieties of the stone surround for the fireplace are probably in the thousands with different color and stone variations. My preference is the flat flag stone appearance or large rough textured squares. The granite possiblities are endless as well.

If the metal roof wins, deep red/maroon or eggplant would be beautiful on a log home (the green is getting old). I absolutely love the cedar shake look but having wood on wood is not going to give an interesting appearance to the cabin as the coloring will all blend together.

Shower head.....don't think the "power shower" fits with the rustic log cabin theme but who wouldn't want it anyway, try to make it blend in.

Modern cabinets? Design team, what's up with that? This is a cabin right? Great job everybody! Keep blogging!

All the choices had my head spinning until I read some of the other blogs. I agree with Aimee that there should be a little more info so we can make wiser selections. (I don't know anything about roofing!), but I absolutely love the rain shower. Thanks.

Where to begin...my concerns about metal roofs are these (previously owned a home with one): they are noisy when it rains (can be good or bad), we had issues with bats making homes in the channels, (also know someone where bats were such a problem the roof was destroyed from excrement), and also seemed to be prone to ice damming. Perhaps newer roofing techniques and design have improved these pitfalls. With that said, I think the composite shake would be a "good look" for this design.

I would suggest a nongloss finish for the countertops whichever is the winner (warmer, more cabin-like feel). More info about product selection would make a huge difference when voting as the pictures can be very misleading! My guess is most don't have time to research all these options. Now that I am aware of the drought issues in the area, I will change my vote to a simple watersaver shower if we don't have more info about the other options by tomorrow. Speaking of green-please limit the amount of lawn in the landscaping to keep fertilizer out of the lake from runoff.

Has anyone mentioned a dog washing station might be nice after a dip in the lake. Lots of people own pets and this would be helpful in keeping the home clean. Pet & people friendly options are good to keep in mind. I am all for graywater and rainfall recycling. Just makes sense with the drought concerns in the area.

Thanks for letting me share my 2-cents.

I missed the previous selections: hanging pendant, wood-burning fireplace and D-log system. I like all the selection choosen so far. The wood fireplace in the cabin I feel is a must and don't mind cutting and/or carrying the wood to make a nice warm fire. I don't know much about the benefits of the D log construction but will investigate it. As for the new choices I have heard of all the countertop types. I personnally didn't like the paper or concrete for use in this type of home. My personal choice was between the ganite and quartz. An from a maintaince point of view I felt the quartz was better and even though the style of choice these days is granite. The Arts and Crafts cabinets and stone fireplace where more suited for the cabin. The tin roof definitely looked better even though I voted for another type. Again, another building material I'd have to look into to make a more informed decision. When it came to selecting the shower heads while the power and rain shower were my favorites, I chose the rain shower as I felt it would have given the cabin that natural feeling. Others opinions on eco friendly materials are important and should be always be considered when building a new home especially if the region had little rainfall. Its fun reading everyone's input and the different ideas everyone is having gives me a chance to learn new things and makes one stop and think of all the little things that go into making a new construction a home. Dr. Watson your doing great!!

Hello Watson, thanks for all of these great choices. Welcome Grace!! You have some pretty big shoes to fill but I bet you'll do great.

Most of my choices are coming out ahead but I'm rethinking granite. I didn't realize the regular maintenance involved. Quartz seems to be a good alternative. Will we be able to conserve water with a power shower?

I agree with an earlier post. We need info on what we are voting on. How about a link next to each choice that will take us to a page explaining the pros and cons? What's green, what isn't? I think we would all make different choices, at least one or two different choices, if we had more info.

Once again, thanks for all the great choices! ~Betty~

Count me in the group looking for a bit of conservation when showering or counters in the kitchen. Recycled stuff can look just as great and soooo very helpful to the eco systems (ecology & economics). I'd rather spend a few bucks less when possible to have the money to spend on the activities around the lake (fishing for one) instead of sitting and looking at the expensive stuff. Of course I COMPLETELY understand that others want amenities they may never be able to get without winning this cabin (count me in THAT group too, ha). So I did go for stone surround and a real fireplace to balance out my modest choices or vice versa. ***cheesy grin***

We agree that the cabin should be luxurious and eco-friendly as possible. Yet if you have spent anytime in the Tenn. mountains in the winter then you would know that there are times when you are stuck at home. If you put in some type of eco-friendly yet luxurious items then the time you spend in the cabin, on the snow covered winters day, wouldn't be so difficult. We are newlyweds and would love to enter for a chance to win the cabin. We love the choices that have been offered so far, but would like to see more of a change in the plan from the 2007 blog cabin. It appears that they are coming up alot alike.

I agree with Glen, let's not make this cabin look like the last one. Let's create a different look.
It's a cabin, yes, but everything doesn't have to be cabiny. I lived in Florida for a while, but the inside of my house didn't have pastels and flamingos. It was very Tuscany. To that end, I would like to see a European kitchen. Nothing wrong with that.

Good Morning Cabenthusists....

In reading through the 28 pages of THE COVENANTS And RESTRICTIONS for LAKEFRONT ESTATES SUBDIVISION, I discovered much to ponder.

Here are just a few of the entries I found interesting ...

1. Multi-level houses will be considered on an individual basis by the Architectural Control Committee (A.C.C.), but shall have a minimum of 2600 square feet heated living area, not including the basement area. >>>

2. All houses Must Have a minimum two-car garage that will accommodate at least two LARGE SIZE automobiles. Garages shall open toward the side or rear of the house unless otherwise approved by the A.C.C.. Detached garages will only be permittd with the prior written approval of the A.C.C.. All garage doors must be located at the side or rear of the dwelling (or detached buidings if allowed and approved) and emphasis will be given to insure that garage doors will not face streets. No trailer, trailer house, boat , or recreational vehicle shall be parked on any Lot, except within the enclosed garages erected in accordance with the plans and specifications submitted to and approved by the A.C.C.. Garage doors shall be kept in working order and shall be kept closed when not in use. >>

3. No plumbing vent or heating vent shall be placed on the front side of any roof of any Lot dwelling or accessory structure. >>

4. Exterior Lighting of buildings for security and/or decoration shall be limited to concealed uplighting or down lighting. >>

Hope this information proves enlightening for all those who are taking this adventure to heart and breathing life into our little cabin by the lake building extravaganza!

p.s. The Covenants and Restrictions I read were marked as the final version and were recorded on November 1,2007.

I love the metal roof, arts and crafts cabinets, quartz countertops, power shower and stone fireplace... These would definitely be my choices in the home (vacation home) of my dreams. Our family enjoys the family get aways to the Smokies and would so get so much use of this home. We live in Kentucky and find long weekends and any opportunity we have to get away for a few days, we land in the Smokies... Keep up the great work and I'm so looking forward to each and all the choices along the way.

well...i don't know about the rest of you but i am voting differently this time than on the last cabin! I'm voting for something entirely different and that is the butcher block counter tops and the brick around the fireplace...something new! i have worked alot with this type of counter top and they clean up so nice...and as they age certainly add character! i did vote for rock around the fireplace on the '07 cabin but for some reason, this place is different. seems bigger, a little more like a house rather than a cabin. i would like some info on the pro's and con's of the roof selections...and here's my question about the metal roof: clearly my favorite but what about if there is a fire; are the firemen able to get through a metal roof? it seems like metal would be best and least flammable but if there ever is one then is it still the best choice?
i LOVE the idea of radiant heating for the floor and i'm sticking to MY suggestion of a safe room (this is tennessee) and for a reading area, possibly in connection with the master bedroom!!
thanks diy,
brenda

THREE WISHES ...

1. Zoned Heating and Air Conditioning, with a door at the loft landing to promote energy efficiency. (Plus the added bonus of noise control and privacy on the second floor)

2. A laundry shoot that deposits linens and such from the second floor onto the work station table in the laundry room, or better still, installed so that items are deposited in one of the storage cabinets above the washer area. Think suspended laudry hamper. Bonus: It would keep the multi-functional room off the kitchen (if that is where the washer and dryer will be installed) tidy and user friendly between wash days.

3. A dumb waiter .... now, wait, before you roll on the floor laughing, just think of all the possibilities that having a method of getting things from the kitchen or laudry room upstairs without carrying them would create. It really is a splendid wish.

I don't see why major changes should be made to the floor plan. Everyone had the chance to look at all three and pick the one they liked the best.
Unless there is a reason for you to make any changes(like last year they switched a few things in the kitchen) But the people have made "their" choice.
That would be like the winning vote from the people being a wood fireplace and because so many people requested after the voting for gas, that you would change it to gas.
Doesn't make sense for you guys to have to re-design the floor plan that everyone picked. You can use those ideas in next years cabin. Please let's keep our eye on the main focus and that this is to be a green/eco-friendly cabin. Like how about concrete counters.

Hello Folks,
I am a first time blogger, but I have enjoyed reading the comments. I am reminded of my childhood, and open house at school. Teachers allowed us to make the choices of how to decorate for our parents. This is nostalgic! How often do we get the opportunity to vote for our own desires? Forced to make a decision on what styles I actually like for my own home, which is and always has been eclectic. I truly love the floor plan, and the all my choices have coincided with the other voters. There was one exception, the wood burning fireplace. I remember cleaning ours out when I was a child. The metal roof is wonderful; I plan to replace ours with the same. Thank You for allowing us to share ideas with you and each other. Please consider flexible rubber pavers for the walks, they are safe, attractive, and WONDERFUL! Talk with you all later………..

Well, I am getting very excited about this cabin! I am gonna feel like i am right there with you guys when you start to build! I love all the choices and i have picked my favorites! I have Arthritis, and i would love to see a Hot tub installed somewhere in that beautiful cabin!

I think the concrete cabinet tops are a great choice, I also like the painted cabinets. I would want the kitchen most maintence free and I love the painted cabinets.

I missed voting on the log style (just didn't get in and do it - my own fault) but I can't help making a Horace Greeley kind of comment. ANY rounded log is totally inappropriate for this area of the country. Flattened, hewn logs only, with dove-tail corners. Anything else will look ridiculous. If you don't think so, come to Denver where I can show you so many log cabins in the middle of all kinds of modern homes, and they look absurd.

If you want to build round log cabins, that will look appropriate to their environment, "Go west, young man!"

Please no metal roof. Not everyone finding them soothing when it rains they are noisey. i know I have a friend that lives next to one and it drives me nutty whrn I go to visit and it is raining. It has kept me awake many a night. Plus last years cabin had a metal roof. Let's try to make this one a little different. With the floor plan and outside sketches I think that maybe the cedar roofing would make a very eye pleasing statement and blend into the natural background. Something to think about.

There is a community close to us that the homes are built to reflect the 1800's era homes. They require the composite cedar style roofing. I would like to see something different than what every other log homes has....metal, especially green or red.

Thanks Melanie and Grace for your informative posts. Checking out the possiblities on the internet has been great. For those that do not know what some of the products are about, just google them and I promise you will find your information. I agree. Lets do something different and interesting. I already voted today, but will change my votes tomorrow based on Melanie's and Grace's comments.
Thanks again! It's gonna be beautiful and effecient everyone, come on!!! It's DIY!!!
Patty

My husband and I spend several weeks each year in the Smoky Mountains renting cabins, and we have looked at several to purchase. We have a list of things we would like in the cabin we buy or win and those are the things are voting for, the metal roof, granite counter tops, stone fireplace and arts and crafts cabinets.
The 2007 Blog Cabin is beautiful, we had a chance to see it on one of our trips down south, so it makes sense that people are voting for the same things. To each his own.

I agree with many comments already posted The cabin should not be a repeat of the 2007 Blog Cabin. The use of eco. or recycled products shoudl take center stage. It's a DREAM CABIN remember! Slate roof, water miser shower heads, low flow tolets, radiant and /or zonal heat. Cabinets should reflect lake front rural with usable knock around cabinet tops, as much natural log wood walls as possible, flooring should be slate and wood mix all easy to clean. A place easy to keep up and clean up after a visit to the CABIN. Cisterns if possible to catch winter rain for use in the summer, intagrated solar heat and solar electric roof pannels and many ideas yet to come. Keep up the good work but be brave earth friendly and different!!!

Thanks Melanie See for the info on the paper based countertop, it's definitely a thought provoking material isn't it. I wish there was a bigger picture of it so I could see more detail of it.

Hi Mr Watson I would love to request that you allow us to be able to see the material choices that we are voting on at all times. It is frustrating for me when I want to see them later on so I can find info and realize I can't look again or remember the name. You can't even show someone else, because I voted for the day! And I agree with others if you put a little more product info up or a website for the different materials available: People might get more confident and vote for something different if they knew more about it. If I was too excited and you already had the info please forgive me. Really voters another cookie cutter home everytime is gonna get boring after a few seasons. I do Have another request for the master bath: how about one of the modern free standing deeper clawfoot type whirlpool or jacuzzi deeper soaking tubs? And a small electric fireplace nearby it on the wall at eyelevel.

This is awesome!! We've gotten Log Home Living for over 10 years and Barna is our favorite builder. So far everything that we have voted for has come in first place. It's almost as if we are there watching the cabin be built.
By the way, we've had granite counters for years and we wouldn't have it any other way. Also, d-logs allow you to hang various items on the walls without worring about about spacing. Thanks for the experience. This is the perfect way to end a day after a long day of teaching!

I enjoyed having all the choices. When I look at the location and the potential views of the water, I see more natural materials for the interior, the Arts and Craft cabinets with butcher block tops, contrasting wood floors, stone fireplace to bring the outside to the inside. Metal roofs are nice, however they can be noisy during rain and storms. The simulated slate roof would provide a nice contrast and years of durability.
I hope you are also going to include a dock to match the house and increase the enjoyment of the property.

Looking forward to watching the building process.
Pat
Leesburg, VA

Hellow Everyone !
I just wanted to say that the new cabin is our chance to do something "new and different". So dont forget to vote out side the box , BE CREATIVE with your choices !!
I also like the idea of radiant floor heat. It can realy take the bite out of a cool room in the morning. I might also suggest using solar hot water from a roof top collector. once installed by our friends from DYI can give the new owners a low cost energy source .
Have some fun, and be CREATIVE in your choices.
Joeb

Yes we do need to really think about our choices. Eastern Tennessee, North Carolina and South Carolina are in a SEVERE DROUGHT and we all should be conscious of what we use. I voted for the low water usage shower heads and they should be used in all bathrooms along with low water usage toilets. Our drought here is bad and being on usage restrictions is difficult. We have reduced our usage considerably and they are looking at restricting usage to 25 gallons per per a day. Think about how much water you do use and consider reducing your usage. Rain barrels are a good idea so it could be used for all your yard watering. I heard 1" of rain can create 800 gallons on an average roof. Don't know if true or not, but since if we get rain that is the amount we have been getting lately. Sounds like a lot but when you don't have it it is a drop in a bucket. 119 days left in our lake where water is drawn is a little over three months and that is with what restrictions we already have. We are over 9 inches below our average rainfall, so PLEASE think conservation....

I would like to know more about the composite roofing materials as well. Too bad you are not informing us prior to our voting. I would rather know something about the product before voting. AND how come we had no warning that the voting had changed. Has it been what 1 week, 2 weeks? And BAM! We are voting on counter tops, bathrooms and roof materials.

Yes, stone is the thing for a cabin. You think about building a cabin with the resources around you and stone is everywhere...

Now the stone counter tops are nice and I even think the Concrete has it purpose, but how much maintenance does it require. If it is YEARLY sealant, like granite, that is not bad. Soap stone sounds good too. Now cabinets, Traditional is always nice, but something different would be nice in this cabin. We did traditional last time and the Arts and Crafts have a simplicity that should go with a log cabin/home and still have some character. Natural finish please.....

Guess I better go look up what I can find on composite roofing materials.

After looking at all the great choices wehave to choose from I decided to vote for the metal roof (like a lot of other bloggers). I also voted for the stone surround. The master bath shower should be a rain shower. I personnaly believe that the cabinets should be the Arts & Craft design and finally the countertops should be the butcher block. I know these are almost all the standard that everyone will choose but for a log cabin, I just cannot fathom going with Mediteranean cabinets as I think they would be out of place. I'll keep researching on all my choices and se if my decisions can be swayed by other bloggers and manufacturers.

Wow, it is amazing that I voted then suddenly I am overwhelmed by the thought of my hasty decisions. Melanie should get a job as consultant she did the research that should have came with the voting. Love the green metal roofs but is probably dated like my countertop choice.

Hey Melanie can you look up some more info for us...Thanks.

Maybe next year you can add an eco-blog cabin with a hose running to a dollar store water saver head behind a fence. Just kidding lets not push our views so harshly. Thanks

I am glad to know what the latest voting options are. Now I can do a search for the different options, and try to make a more informed choice. I figure the first vote is on a quick gut response, and every vote after will be an informed choice.

Keep up the good work DIY!!!!

Hi Watson & everyone,

I do have to say I am disappointed that everyone seems to be voting for the same old thing. Metal roof, granite counter tops. I feel the slate roof and the soapstone counter tops would be a wonderful change from the same old thing. Soapstone is very easy to take care of and is more durable than granite.

I do have to say though that it has to be a stone fireplace in a log cabin otherwise it would look totally out of place. I prefer the traditional cabinets in the kithcen but my second choice would be the arts and crafts, so that's not so bad.

I feel that we should be given links for more information about the items we are voting on, then maybe people would not vote for the same old standard. Thanks to Melanie for posting the links above.

Here's one for the soapstone.

http://www.soapstone-co.com

Hopefully this will help some people.

I agree with Teri, it would be nice if you could provide additional information regarding the choices available.

Personal observations: I've had granite countertops, but never, ever again. Quartz or soapstone is the only way to go.

There have been a lot of great suggestions for consideration: rainwater collection (cistern), radiant floor heating, and screened porches, etc. to start.

Great job DIY. Someone's going to be a very "happy camper".

Folks, READ the Blog from Grace, she's the Blog Cabin show runner 1/29 11:41am. (For the computerly impaired - top left Edit drop down,then select Find, enter Grace or 11:41 in the pop-up box).

Picture this cabin with the COMPOSITE cedar (no maint) or slate shingle. The tin, ah metal roof is so oh last year...REALY, take a look at 2007 Blog Cabin. Plus this is being built in a higher end area. The CEDAR (or slate) would fit in MUCH nicer. This isn't a one room hunting cabin in the mountains, it's a deluxe log home in a gated type community. Again, I state, look at the exterior drawings of the San J., check the dormers (and gable ends?), there's cedar shakes. That type COMPOSITE shingle, which is what is being offered, or the COMPOSITE slate would look much more tastful with this home, IMHO. The metal roof would be OK with the San Jacinto roof line, but it was done LAST YEAR! Let's have some imagination.

I'd voted for granite, but Grace has me rethinking. Think soapstone, quartz or marble is were I'm heading in future voting. Perhaps the rest of us need to unite, pick one of these and BEAT DOWN the dreaded GRANITE CLAN! United we stand! Well, we could at least. Same goes to STOP the METALHEADS! We must UNITE behind the CEDAR or SLATE! WHAT SAY YE ALL?

Good fellow bloggers; Please, some of you should read the Blogs before commenting. I've read every one, it appears some haven't.

Some really great ideas! That outside wood furnace might be a great secondary/supplemental heat source. The radiant floor heat sounds nice, as long as it's not visable. I see others have mentioned collecting rain (and gray water) too. Fans in and out, to ciculate air. I like the idea of the waterfall element that had been mentioned, I'd one-up that and ask Ahmed to do a long flowing creek/waterfall/Koi pond element along the edge of the lot - should be 'easy' due to the slope of the lot. Nice little solar/battery/ac (if exists) pump unit to recirculate.

Passive heat can be scavenged from the fireplace. I've seen some that blend well, not ugly, yet add heat to the room.

Now, for MY brief ;^) footer:

BASEMENT -walkout/roughed in, GAS LOG STARTER -elec. ign., STRECH FLOOR PLAN -lgr MstBdrm, closets, Kitchen/Island, CHIMNEY/FIREPLACE in BSMT, CLEANOUTs in chimny, TILE FLUE in chimny, BOATHOSE/DOCK, STONE PATIO(S) -behind wkout bsmt and at shore/dock, HARDWOOD & TILE FLRS, 40" FRONT DOOR w/SIDELIGHTs -NO DBL DR, AWESOME LANDSCAPING -Dazzle us, AHMED! GARAGE -2 1/2 or 3

BLLOGERS - READ MY LAST POST (above?) LET'S UNITE BEHIND SOMETHING OTHER THAN A METAL ROOF (COMPOSITE CEDAR, my 1st or COMPOSITE SLATE)

LET'S STOP THE GRANITE MOVEMENT! UNITE BEHIND SOAPSTONE, QUARTZ or MARBLE! Who are these granite people? It must be a conspiracy from New Hampshire!

READ THE POST FROM GRACE January 29, 11:41 AM

LET'S GET CREATIVE FOLKS! WE'RE BUILDING THE SAME CABIN AS LAST YEAR!

I agree with Grace. Think outside the box! Let's make some different choices and not have the same identical cabin as the one they built last year. With that in mind, here's what I chose and why.
I voted for the composite cedar roof. I think it will look great on a log cabin. I love the sound of rain on a metal roof, but I think this cabin needs something a little bit different to make it stand out. I bet most of the other cabins in this development have metal roofs--let's make this one unique!
I also voted for the brick fireplace. What I really think should happen is that the interior fireplace should be brick and the outside fireplace should be stone. My parents have a stone surround and talk about collecting dust! However, I have a brick surround and love it. I think it would blend nicely with the interior of the D-logs (thank goodness they won).
I voted for the power shower. Yeah, yeah, I know I said make this one different from the 2007 cabin, but that definitely needs to make a return appearance.
For the kitchen cabinets, I chose the European Country cabinets. They're gorgeous. They're classic and beautifully detailed. They would look great painted, stained or glazed. Why not do all three?
As for the counter surface, I think granite is totally overused. Let's do something totally out there--like cement! That's my vote. I think the juxtaposition of cement which is urban vs. classic styled cabinets would be awesome. But even if you don't like cement countertops, pick something besides granite. Soapstone would be an interesting choice--anything but granite.
This may be jumping the gun a little, but I hope one of the choices for the kitchen flooring is cork. This is a wonderful, "green" product with ergonomic benefits. And it looks good.
Come on, fellow cabin bloggers--listen to Grace (and me) and make some innovative design choices!

ok the options this time are a little harder to chose. i really like the metal roof but does it have to be green or are you gonna pick the color?
the counter tops what about soapstone people? granite is tooooooo over done this is a log home.

stone and wood i thought this was a home from the outdoors? that is the way to go stone!!!!!

i still have one question though what is that spot by the closet in the master bedroom behind the powder room ? is it another fireplace? if thats the case i would make the indoor ones gas and the outdoor one wood.

This is my first time voting on the blog cabin,so to me the choices are all new.that is why I have favored the metal roof,the granite cabinets,stone surround. These may be like lst years cabin but these are the items I would be pleased with. As for size I am not picky,its a cabin to enjoy.I would love it no matter the size. Right now I live in a 30 year old mobile home where Ive fallin through my kitchen floor 3 times.I,d be happy with anything new.thanks for giving us a chance to win such a beautiful home.

I found an example of a log cabin with a composite cedar shake roof. Looks great. Take a look and change your vote from metal!

http://www.davinciroofscapes.com/davinci-for-homeowners/davinci-shake/gallery_autumn.htm

HEY, I just one of those light bulbs go on!
I bet lot's of folks are voting on OUR (Bloggers)
Log Cabin and don't bother to read any of the BLOG or make any informed votes. Probably too late to do it this time, but...........

Before ya can vote, the VOTE LINK should direct you to the BLOG, maybe even require you post BEFORE you vote. At least, some might read a bit.

What do you BLOGGERS and DIY Administartors think?

P.S. Build 2009 in NW IL/SW WI - Door Cnty, WI - Some Scenic/Hilly/Bluffs area of WI, Nort Woods, WI. Hey Der, listen up, Eh?

I hope my choices for the 2008 bloq cabin win out.
So far so good,I looked at the voting result
charts.I especially like the artsy craftsy cabs
because they look so log cabiness,and I chose granite for the counters cause it compliments
the colr scheme.I've wanted a log cabin for a home
for thirty years and now that I'm 52 it looks hopeless but I get to help to plan this one for someone and I find it fun and interesting.Thank you for this show I'm quite enjoying putting in my input Happy bloq cabinnning Susan Whitney
Belmont Mass.

OK... I like the metal roof.. there are other colors than green tho... and different styles.. to change it up... love the houses in my parents old neighborhood that have changed over to them...
also they last longer (protection from fires in the woods) and since I read that you have to treat the outside of the logs every 2-3 years... that is enough maintance to deal with... this is a weekend (vacation) home...
I wouldn't want to spend all my time on upkeep and not enjoy the lake..

Concrete countertops... less maintance... any color...durable... and a change...

agree with stone for the fireplace to fit a log home..

Master Shower... big enough for 2 (could also be used by someone with special needs) no step up..but the Power shower would help older bones ...

Cabinets... just not open.. and some character...

Still on my Wish List :
1. a dock...
2. a garage (large enough for storage of toys & lawn equip. & the cars) with some connection to the house to stay out of the rain to bring in grocries.. (how about one of those new lifts to be able to use the attic of the garage to get things up into it http://www.bpghome.com/index.htm ).....
3. the larger patio over by the kitchen.. agree that a retractable screen would be nice... leave the porch area by the lake with nothing....for the view... and one large stairway down to the lake off the back..(you could use it for seating on the steps when everyone is over)
4. at least one reg tub upstairs..
5. still wishing that the bed in the master bedroom could be put on the closet wall so you wake up to a view of the lake (pull the windows together like the dinning room)... how wonderful that view would be before going to bed & to wake up too..
6. like the idea to flip the L shape counter in the kitchen for easier flow to the great room or better yet an island (love mine for prep. work and it has a pull out to put a large trashcan on that can be replaced easier (plus less cost to build) & a plug for using the mixer,etc.... make the kitchen large enough for mult. people to work in...
7. Also a seperate closet for the broom, vac. & floor cleaners so they don't have to be stored in the front closet (which was made for guest coats) or the garage ... we all have them and no place to put them...

Just my thoughts... love that we can put them out there for others to see and love reading everyone elses...
And we all have changes that we wish we could have made in our house. after thoughts.. for
storage... light switches.. plugs... etc..
at least we have a chance this time... with so many people looking to catch some of them... in design .. rather than in after cost to re-do or to have to live with...

I'm excited about the new choices and think the cabin is coming along beautifully. I would also like the see the cabin "more green" and voted for the recycled countertops. I voted for the gas logs as we need our trees. But then they have come up with recycled "logs" by companies like DuraFlame.I read the comment by someone who is suspicious about the voting and would like to see a response. Can't wait for the next phase.

I love the metal roof. it would look great in red and if the front door was also red. the arts and crafts cabinets are beautiful I hope they go with the lighter color, I also love the granite counter tops, but wish I knew more about the quartz, they are beautiful. not that it matters, as its not my money but what is the cost difference between quartz and granite? when do we get to enter to win this cabin? I can hardly wait to move in.

I agree with Grace on soapstone! So warm and natural. I'm in the construction business & feel that granite has peaked. Also, we really need to look into these environmentally friendly products such as the composite shakes or the faux slate. I'll look it up, but I think it is not only made of recycled materials, it even performs better under acid rain conditions than natural slate (which is just GORGEOUS on high-end homes.)
Love the opportunity to Blog.

I like the voting choices offered. This is great fun. Quartz counter tops are great because they do not need to be sealed, are hard enough to compare to granite and come in an antibacterial type that kills germs. There is an infinite number of colors and style to choose from. I would like to know more about the tile for the foreplace surround. I love the idea of the power shower as long as it reduces water usage. I checked out the web sites Melanie had and that was helpful. I also liked her idea for posting some information about the choices offered before we vote on them. I changed over to the D-logs because of comments I read here in the blog, but can not spend lots of time researching stuff for this because I'm supposed to be working ;-).

Hello fellow bloggers,
I agree with the concerns expressed earlier about voting for the "same old, same old" in building materials. I voted for a brick fireplace, which may seem an old style to many, but offers plenty of options as far as the layout of the bricks, color, etc. It could also be painted at a later date if so desired.

I voted for soapstone counters for the look. They are really mellow! I will do a lot to maintain something when I am in love with the look.

What I find hard about voting for design items piecemeal is that people may not concern themselves with the total look and style, but rather select items on an individual basis.

Looking forward to seeing more!

It all sounds great, however, I am interested about the type of cedar shingles material they are considering using. The cedar is my choice. Are these shingles 20, 30, or 40 year life span. With the metal roof, the life span is long, but then you need to consider the loud sound of rain on your house, unless they plan to sound proof the metal roof. The spring time rains are beautiful to hear, however when you really want to sleep and a downpour of rain is on your metal roof, trust me, it will be hard to fall asleep. I also have not heard any discussion about the radiant heat system for all the floors in the house. Radiant heat is clean, you have no registers showing, no heat borders, no blowing of heat into the air of the house. In my opinion radiant heat system is the way to go. I think the wood buring fireplace is absolutely a poor choice. Gas would be cleaner and again as I said before, if you have a power outage in the area during the winter months, you can still heat your living area with the gas fireplace. They have their own starter. Perhaps they can insert the gas piping in the fireplace for those who wish to go the gas route verses the wood. For me, gas is the only way to go. As for the kitchen cabinets, I hope they choose white cabinets with alot of lighting to brighten the interior of the house. I would love to see a dark hunter green granite for the counter top. Along with a nice white oblong under counter sink which has a beautiful clean look to it. A nice high and tall Moen faucet in the sink would be wonderful. I so enjoyed Blog Cabin 2007. I think this one sounds like a up scale to the one in 2007 which I thought was great. Thank you DIY for making this such a great adventure.

I agree with several of the above blogs. The 2008 cabin is going to look like the 2007 cabin. I believe this is because (as one blogger said) people are not educated with what is available. I believe the other reason may be because they totally believe the choices they made are what they would REALLY want in their cabin. I personally would like a description (benefits) listed what you are offering as choices for the 2008 cabin.
Connie

Dear Watson,

Can we please have more info on all of the ROOFING and COUNTERTOP choices?

Thanks,
CabinScraps

For the countertops, I think you just can't beat the beauty and easy maintainance of the soapstone.
I know everyone likes the marble, and it is beautiful, but it also is very easily chipped, scratched and cracked by heat transfer. (Not to mention extremely expensive to repair or replace).

I have to say I agree with some of the other bloggers. If we are to vote on options, more information about the differenecs and characteristics would be helpful. I know each of us on our own could research each product, but really that is not likely to happen. If you guys could at least post links where info can be read, even that would be better than nothing. After all if we were building a house with a builder we wouldn't just choose what looked good, we would want to know about durability and maintanence, as well for some who would want to know how "green" the product is. Think about it please, especially if you really hope people might vote differently from last year.

I don't understand why everyone chooses Granite, all the time. I understand it's appeal in some settings, but really, let's think about what is being built here. Have you all seen the fantastic, lovely and durable, wood coutertops that can be made? Or what about the recyclable material of paper? I just get the feeling that not everyone is thinking outside of the box. Perhaps we all are thinking of what we'd like in our home, as opposed to the best thing for a log cabin home and setting? I am not saying that I am not guilty of that also!! I agree wholeheartedly with the person who said what about trying to build a eco-friendly lob cabin, or one using alternative energy sources. That sounds like a great idea!

I think it's interesting to read the blogs about people wanting DIY to go 'green' on this cabin...yet look at the choices people are making. Now that's what you might call ironic!

I make no pretense. I want the cabin to look like a proper lake house with a metal roof (LOVE the sound of rain on a roof), a stone fireplace, and craftsman style cabinetry. Personally, I would love soapstone counter tops in the kitchen but that doesn't look like it's going to happen so no biggie. I have granite at home and love them so I can't fault the choice.

While it is true that there are similarities between the 2007 and 2008 Blog Cabin, some of these are to be expected since the locations have a similar feel. If DIY decides to build a 2009 Blog Cabin, it might be fun and different to locate it near an ocean beach (there goes the budget!)and theme the choices accordingly.

Could we have some metal roofing options. There are so many styles available with metal roofing. It doesn't even have to look like it's metal. Check out http://www.metalroofing.com/

P.S. I'm not a roofing contractor just an enthusiast.

Sorry Kim and Grace but yelling at us because we are not voting the way you want us to is usless! Being from CT - Northeast I look at durability of the products and ease of taking care of them (maintanence). Metal roofs last and though at first they maybe noisy you get use to it and over time you don't even hear them! I prefer a color that will blend in with the surronding woods so for me red would be out since it would stick out like a sore thumb - what about brown or black???

I like the idea of a laundry shoot from the 2nd floor to the laundry room - beats throwing clothes down the stairs! lol The dumbwaiter idea is great - no lugging clothes us and down stairs for guests or family!

I am disappointed that once again there is a shower in the Master Bedroom and not a jacuzzi. After a hard day of playing it is so nice to relax in a jacuzzi rather than a shower. Are you planning on doing what you did last year and put a jacuzzi in the guest bathroom? Too bad you don't change this and have one in both bathrooms.

What about a hot tub on the deck outside the Master Bedroom???

A barbecue/patio area out back would be terrific with that great lake so why not enjoy it by spending some time outside with friends and family barbecuing? I for one enjoy cooking out whenever possible. The porches are nice but come on would you really want to barbecue on them? It would be nice if the porches were screened in during the nice months and glassed in for the colder months it would be a nice area to read year round or extra sleeping areas during the summer!

I like the idea of stairs going off the back of the cabin it would give more places to sit especially if you put a patio with a barbecue area there - what about a hammock?

I also like wood floors but please give me tiles in the entry way, bathrooms, and laundry room, etc they are so much easier to take care of and wear so much better then linoleum - and don't get me going about how easy to clean - the last thing I want to do if I win is spend a lot of time cleaning when you have that gorgeous lake to enjoy!

OH! And the fireplace glad everyone seems to like the stone!

Hey guys,

One more thing that this log cabin needs - a back-up generator so when you lose power you still have power to keep the food cold and keep the cabin warm!

I really love the log home as I once had one. It is fun to watch the choices made. One thing that I think might enhance or make extra special, if the stone front on the fireplace is chosen, is a mosaic of the fish in the lake. It would consist of a border of similar stones surrounding a depiction of a fish. This piece of art would be central above the mantle. Just a thought.

DyI has giving us great choices! Keep up the great work !!!

I would love to see a steam bath or sauna added to the log home. After the sauna, a nice dip in the lake would be great.
I recently moved to Tennessee from Florida and lived in Minnesota and having a steam bath or sauna is a great memory from my childhood and plan on adding one to my lake front home in Tennessee.

need some help....has the new voting items been posted cause u cant bring them up for somw reason...first time ive had a problem and ive soooo looked forward to the new voting.
thanks
margaret

I also think it is being re-created into last years. wheni voted this time i went for more eco friendly items and a different look, altho some of the ways a log cabin should look have to be done the same or else it wouldn't be a log cabin..

I have enjoyed reading all the blogs. I agree with many of the other bloggers about this log cabinis starting to be an exact replica of the 2007 Blog Cabin.

Folks let's start thinking outside of the traditional materials for the 2008 Blog cabin. If you are blogging that means that you have already voted on your choices. It is not too late to research the other materials. You may like some of the different materials. Like the cedar composite roofing or asphalt shinlges for the roof.

Also I was watching HGTV last night they did the counter tops in a cooper material looked fantastic.

Just a thought to look outaide the normal you never know what you may find and like. Let's not just repeat the 2007 Cabin although it was great looking.

Is it Silestone quartz? Their antibacterial (Microban Antimicrobial) feature is great for a kitchen.

http://www.microban.com/asia/about_us/news/?lang=en&releaseid=2004112812

I went for the metal roof because there is a wide range of color choices for these roofs now days and they last forever. Also, as written before, this roof type can be set up to collect rain water. I like the look of stone around a log cabin's fireplace. I agree with others that the stone does need to be smaller. Being eco minded, I would prefer that the fireplace be an insert that can burn corn or wood pellets and have a heat-a-lator (sp?) type function that can be used to heat the room. I like the ideas I've read using radiant heat flooring systems, low flow water/shower systems & gray water if possible. The number of people here who are environmentally concious and responsible is great. I hope their ideas are taken into consideration.

The blogs have provided some very good info on some of the choices. Would still like to have easy access to more specifics on each choice. One question - what about fire danger in regards to roofing choices? Considering the remote location and drought conditions what is the better choice? I think I might be more concerned with that aspect than other maintenance issues.

love the metal roof. it would look great in Blue Not Green Thats Showing. Also love the stone Fire place..

I'm a first-timer and would like to see a skylight in the upstairs loft if possible. Thanks DIY!!

Reading through the entries, I think Aimee is right about most of us not being informed about the choices to vote on. I didn't really know that much about paperstone until I researched it. Still not a big fan so I vote for concrete. Not really eco-friendly but I don't like to worry about moving pots off the stove. So maybe concrete next to the stove and paperstone by prep and wash areas. Also, a friend had concrete put in and he was able to get a trim design fabricated into the concrete which looks really cool.

As far as the shower, I like my full body shower. I had an Insta-Heat tank installed with it so I don't waste water waiting for it to come to the right temperature. True when my daughter is using it, I can feel the water level at the dam lowering but thats a learning issue. When I am at hotels with low flow shower heads I tend to stay in longer trying to get a clean feeling. So it equals out to the same as a regular head.

So glad a two-storey designe was chosen. My suggestions are:
- Make Bath #2 accessible from the Loft & Bedroom #2 (don't want to have to disturb one of the bedrooms to use the bath upstairs)
- I agree that the porch should wrap all around to the front of the house and have stairs down to the lake.
- The Patio off the Master Bedroom should be screened in for use during the Summer. I would flip it to the other side of the cabin so that it is next to the Kitchen for outside dining, the Rear Foyer & easily accessible to all users of the cabin. This would leave the deck outside the Master Bedroom as a private area if desired.

Thx for letting us give our input, PasadenaChuck

Many blogs agree that we should be building something a little different from last year’s cabin. The problem is that if the same choices that were such overwhelming winners last year are options again they will win. It's inevitable. The vast majority of voters don't read the blogs so they never change their views. Like fans of a particular sport team they will remain loyal despite their team not performing well. It's too late to change what has been voted on or is in this round of voting, however, I would urge the design team to consider dropping some of last years options in favor of different, modern, exciting, eco-friendly alternatives for the remaining votes. Sure, this is driving the design a bit but it's probably the only way to get some diversity from last year's design.

PS. Thanks to the blogger who had researched Lakefront Estates regs. Some eye openers there especially regarding garages, watercraft and siting of lights. Maybe he could post a URL or something similar so we can all get an idea of the local building regulations. It may save a lot of blogging on ideas that simply will never be considered in this sub-division. It's certainly going to make the choice of any driveway covering very important.

it would be nice to try some copper on the counters or an island it's something new to try

Thank you Grace for your comments. I feel that we need to have something different from the 2007 house. After all DIY is doing this for a series, it would be a boring program if the 2008 house was just like the 2007 house. Please, Bloggers lets reconsider our choices.

I think the slate roof would be charming. The red traditional cabinets would be a gorgeous contrast to the wood logs. I thought the big round shower head fit the theme of the cabin nicely.

Thank you everyone.

Linda

What Grace said!
SteveL

HEY ERIN! Just kiddin'. I know CAPS are/can be taken as shouting. I didn't mean it that way. I just did caps so the post(s) would stick out.

I don't think Grace was yelling either. I just wanted to point out her post, as she's involved with the show, I gathered, and had some good point, I thought. Also, I was just pointing out that the cedar and slate shingles are composite, not natural, as it appears some folks missed that part. Hence, low maintenance, and I assume longer life. I saw some links for those products. I'm going to check it out. I was serious about seeing if others were interested in uniting on a common product other than granite and metal roofing, but I wasn't intending to yell, just organize! The granite thing was in reference to New Hampshire - Granite State ;)

I don't take this, or myself, that seriously to SHOUT. Part of it might be you missed part of what I consider humor, distorted it may be. Mmm, like Yoda did that sound?

Clive Wells, I agree. Kudos to the Blogger that found the ACC Guidelines...very informative!

Now for MY (new) standard tagline/propaganda:

BASEMENT -walkout/roughed in, GAS LOG STARTER -elec. ign., STRECH FLOOR PLAN -lgr MstBdrm, closets, Kitchen/Island, CHIMNEY/FIREPLACE in BSMT, CLEANOUTs in chimney, TILE FLUE in chimney, BOATHOSE/DOCK, STONE PATIO(S) -behind wkout bsmt and at shore/dock, HARDWOOD & TILE FLRS, 40" FRONT DOOR w/SIDELIGHTs -NO DBL DOOR

Climbing onto my soapbox today....

Just finished reading through the newest entries and would like to put my vote in for "more informed choices" ... because, simply stated,not all of us have a building background (or a grasp of basic searching the internet techniques for that matter...smile).

If more detailed information was provided, prior to arriving at the voting page, it is very possible that many voters would step away from the "that's familiar box" when making their decisions for 2008.

It would be great if product choice information, or the link to that information, was provided before the vote screen process appeared.

Blogger comments/experiences are so essential, of course. And (or but), because we are all so vested in this project, Website product info. would offer the less emotional presentation of the product's qualities. The contributions from both sources would enable voters in the process of casting their vote For or Against a feature.

And, to those of you who feel there is no need to invest time in learning about other options for the home, I understand. The runaway choices of recent voting will produce a great home, BUT, are we really taking advantage of our voting power, if we end up voting to construct a cookie cutter adaption of 2007? Case in point...

The 2008 home location seems to be very upscale. Of the 67 lots offered in the first area, two are sold and two are reserved. The remaining lot prices, (which reflect a cost of just buying the dirt, not the final cost once a home is constructed), range from $129,000.00 (One lot/not on the water) to $499,900.00 (10 of the remaining 64). Lot 4 is priced at $299,900.00 and Lot 6 at $379,900.

Maybe, before the voting process and blueprint revisions go any farther, a "do-over" should be considered. A moment of reflection into the process could prove to be very enlightening. Maybe no choices would be changed. Maybe there would be a few surprises.

The bottom line is: A simple revision to the voting procedure is needed... Give us the tools to help us make informed choices ... so that this labor of love for DIY and its Bloggers can produce a dwelling on the Watts Barr Lake, that represents the look, feel, and WOW factor befitting its unique surroundings and the love that went into producing it.

Climbing down off my soapbox, now. Thank You!

NO NO NO NO Soapstone is awesome. Also not that metal roof. what about the composite type roofs. any info?
I think obviously have to have the power shower but maybe some "green" choices also. I guess if you take a poll the most popular will prevail, I am surprised that traditional for the cabinets isn't coming out first. If I win I won't complain.

Bloggers and Watson, please take the time to look at these links they are very informative.

www.coolmetalroofing.com

www.concretenetwork.com

Thanks, Kathy Seals

I agree carbon copy of last year, lets get creativ, no more tin, eco freindly quartz ect.

I posted a link to composite roofs...scroll back up. I'm going to switch my vote from composite recycled paper countertops to soapstone. I'm going to keep voting for contemporary cabinets...contemporary styling can work quite well with cabins...and the clean lines are nice.

Perhaps NEXT year they won't even OFFER granite and country cabinets!

I lied. I posted a link to the slate shingles. Here is a link to one brand of cedar composite shingles:

http://www.enviroshake.com/about.php

One wonders why WE are having to educate one another? Come on DIY--you could do a better job than we can!

Melanie See

Ok, I'll agree with the "dumb waiter" to transfer laundry, toys, etc from up stairs to down stairs. This would be something you don't see much of and would be useful. Going back to my previous statement, whatever can make our lives easier is great!

I think I have been pursuaded, I have GRANITE COUNTERS and I love them. ---BUT--- you do have to treat them every 6 months and they do absorb moisture....even when treated properly. The non-porous quartz that someone else was discussing may be a better option. Again, less work = makes life easier!!! Thanks for the oppurtunity! :-)

Has anyone figured out the sq ft size of the house?

I love the location and what has won so far. The idea of something other an a metal roof is great. The ceder or slate would be work with the plan or a metal roof that looks like ceder or slate also. Then you have what so want in metal but the look of ceder or slate.
I think granite is alright but is way over used. For what ever that is worth.
Power or Ring shower for sure.
This log cabin is not and should not be like last years. It is bigger and the location is up scale has you can see. There are guide lines that must be followed.
I would love to see a rain water collection system for watering and ect.

Happy Blogging
Joyce

THANKS FOR PUTTING ON A GREAT SHOW LAST SEASON. LOOKING FORWARD TO THIS YEARS BLOG CABIN SHOW!!

I like Arts & Crafts style but I don't think the pale oak color fits this room. How about Craftsman style with cherry finish? And I love the copper suggestion! Wow! How more craftsman can you be? I hear all the anti-metal roof talk, but I have enough Scotch-Irish in me to see the durability as a real plus. Sprayed in insulation will cut down on the noise, and will the cabin really be close enough where the noise will bother neighbors?

Hello Blog Cabin Creaters! I try to vote every day and i am soooo excited! I love everything so far!! I do have a suggestion RE: the Porch side with the Fire Place. I would like to see this side of the porch screened in, to make it more enjoyable in the evening hours. It will help keep out the pesty bugs! Thanks Phyllis H.

I am in TOTAL agreement with the "more informed choices." I posted something similar previously. I am not a builder, never have been and probably never will be but if I am going to vote on a home that I have a chance to live in I would definitely like to be a bit more knowledgable about the materials/products, uses, pros/cons, etc. I do know that when someone builds a home, they speak with the builder and/or home planner to discuss the different possibilities during the process, much the same as we are doign here. It would be wonderful to have that information provided to those of us who are "constructionally challenged" so we can make good decisions about our possible home.

Like the idea of keeping it as green as possible. Also some what old fashioned. Nothing better than rain beating on a metal roof too put you right to sleep; the rain shower is impressive also. Brick fireplace Possibly easier to maintain and repair is necassary. Can't wait to see it all come together with the final votes.

I can't seem to find the page to log in to the voting for the cabin. Cam someone e-mail the info to me?

Hey Guys & Gals, I have and will continue to vote for composite cedar, however if metal wins...please not green or red. A friend just built a "vacation log home" using a 6x12 dovetail with an chink channel, they were also tired of seeing the same color metal roofs...so their solution is really very nice looking. Gray stain on the logs with a light gray chink, barn red door and a black metal roof.
Very nice looking home and different!

...soapstone would be nice. I am sure DIY or suggestions from fellow bloggers will find a way to make this cabin unique despite some of the leading "typical" choices. Just interesting to see different options come together.
Exciting to imagine you are choosing for a cabin that is "your own" without the headaches of really building.
This is a process that is positive and fun. Thanks for the interesting process.

You know I really have to agree with Grace, I'm afraid with the current voting trend that we will end up with a repeat of Blog Cabin 2007. I love the tin roof on a log cabin but I really wanted to see something different go up this year, I went with the simulated slate. However I had to go with the power shower, "green" or not, what's wrong with a little self indulgence.

Glad to see some of my choices are ahead. I still feel that the butcher block countertop is the best for the log cabin. I originally voted for the Arts & Craft cabinets as I believe they would look a lot better in the log cabin than European or contemporary. As for the value of the property, I don't think that should have any bearing on the choices as this is a log home and will fit in with the best of homes.

Thanks Grace, for that comment on voting. I've never been quite sure how they chose the winner for the cabin, and was thinking that maybe it's the one who had the most "winning" votes? From now on I'm voting for what I would like if the cabin were mine, and not what I think will be the winning choice.
When I was in Whistler, BC, I was able to tour some of the log homes there....Talking about INCREDIBLE. One think I noticed, however, was the lack of light in some of them. Here's my plug for lots of windows, big and small, and skylights that open electronically, please. :) Thanks!

Thanks for posting the link www.metalroofing.com.
I love the choices of metal roofs. They don't have to look like last year's roof at all. I'm so tired of the green metal. hooo huuum

I like the metal shake roofing and the metal slate roofing. They look just like shake and slate...lol.

I voted for quartz countertops because granite is soooo used now. Quartz is trouble-free and beautiful.

When the contractors get around to planting the lawn, I hope they take into consideration the drought conditions in Tennessee and plant huge flower beds with plants that do not require watering every day.

Our Dream Green Team that some of us might be familiar with has some information on the different products we are voting on. Paste and copy the link into your address bar. Also search their site for information on other stuff we have to vote on. Good Luck. Kathy Seals

http://www.greenhomeguide.com/index.php/knowhow/entry/641/C219/

I think since you have a lake in front of cabin,It would only be right to install GEOTHERMAL Loops in lake and make use of the energy under your feet, Let me know I may be able to install and supply products.

I have a suggestion for the roof. If metal is the winner, maybe choose the metal roof that looks like the runner up. For example there are metal roofs that look like slate. This way maybe it will please 2 groups of people. Plus, this would give it a much different look fom the 2007 Blog Cabin.

I also suggest a different color than green. I feel a burgundy, maroon or purple would be gorgeous.

For the shower I had to go with the power shower. I seem to spend half my time making sure my hair is wet enough to shampoo, getting the shampoo out of my hair, and getting the soap off. From what I hear, and read, power showers tend to be much quicker since these things happen quickly. Also, someone mentioned some kind of quick heat system. This would be fabulous since in the winter it takes me running the shower for 5-10 minutes until it is warm enough to even think about getting in.

I also like the idea of a barbeque patio under the deck. Add one of those fancy barbecues for my husband, and he would be in heaven.

As to counters, I love the color variations in each piece of granite, but there are some wonderful options in quartz also. The Richlite someone metioned has a lot options that would also be a beatiful choice. I also looked into the concrete countertops, and was amazed at how beatiful they could be. I was visualizing a counter looking like a driveway, but boy was I wrong! It is definately worth looking in to! My husband even switched his voting after seeing some of the ones shown, and he has always been dead set at granite even after reviewing all choices for our new counter tops. Here is one of the sites I checked out.

http://www.absoluteconcreteworks.com/index.html

I personally don't like the options that usually come in in one solid color, such as the recycled paper countertops. After looking at soapstone, it appears that it has a similar look to marble, and I wouldn't want something as large as counters in either.

Designer's may not want granite, but my opinion is that they have used it so much (since it is beatiful) that they want a change. When you work on designing kitchens everyday, I am sure the same choices over and over would get old, but it doesn't mean a homeowner would not love a granite countertop for years to come.

I was so happy that someone posted the developments requirements and restrictions. I was very happy to know that a 2 car garage is required. After having my car in a garage for years, I would hate to have to go back to scrapping windows in the winter. Plus, there are so many storage options for garages.

For the fireplace, I have always been a sucker for stone fireplaces. Brick is nice, but the stone just makes me want to curl up with a good book in front of the fire, or snuggle with my sweetie.

Time to step onto my soapbox for a minute:

For those bloggers that are unhappy with the way the voting is going, and stating that too many people are making uninformed decisions, I STRONGLY DISAGREE. You talk like most of the voters and bloggers are idiots! Just because people don't vote for your choices does not mean we have not researched the different options. It just means that our likes, dislikes, and choices are different from yours. Please keep this in mind next time you critisize other peoples choices, and maybe state your opinions, and reasons for them, without being so rude and demeaning to others.

To all the other bloggers who have expressed their opinions and ideas in postive ways ... THANK YOU! Keep up the great work!

Now I am stepping off my soapbox. At least for the time being.

This is my first time seeing this page, and I have to say I am impressed with Blog Cabin. However, I would have preferred to see a round-cut log winning the vote. Is there a feature available to see why people prefer the D-cut log to a structurally engineered round-cut sweedish-cope log? It is more of a natural look. We see hundred of home here in Alaska made with this type. It is worth checking out.

I just read Grace's post, overlooked it for awhile. She's so right...we ARE building the 2007 cabin over. After taking another look at the cabinet options I've changed my favorite to European country and my roof choice to cedar composite. My favorite countertop is soapstone so that won't change...but I just don't like brick fireplaces. The slate time could look gorgeous and different.

I do wish that the choices had not included some obvious stones like granite....I am saddened that it's such a runaway favorite now. There are SO many other great materials available but I would be a hypocrite to say I don't like it since my laptop is sitting on my own granite counter as I type this.

DIY Show Team...In the choices still to come please give us different choices to vote on so we don't have a complete repeat this season. We really don't want to mess this up. If we can't see it then we can't get carried away and vote for it, right? As another blogger said, many people don't read the blogs and just vote for the same things each time without considering the consequences. Variety is the spice of life, as they say, so let's do this right!

I think reading the blogs is very interesting. I am wondering what Regs this community has after I read Clive's blog and I was unable to find any reference to the regs on the web from here.
I would also like to see a skylight over the loft, and maybe a "mud room" opposite the washer/dryer area for the sandy,lake water to be washed off prior to entering the main house, also for beach towel and other beach paraphernalia storage.
This is fun to watch come together.

The notion of addional light from outside is great, but skylights are not the best answer. Sola-tubes (brand name) provide a very high level of light input with a much lower probability of leaks and have minimal maintenance requirements.

I have read a lot on granite and quartz countertops and it seems like quartz is easier to maintain, so I voted for that, but I see most voters prefer granite!!!
Stone fireplace would be terrific. It looks great, and creates its own atmosphere, not to mention, it stands out against the walls [logs].
A composite cedar roof is preferable, especially when considering the sound of the rain. I would also love the power shower option.

Good Morning ...

and a tip of the hat and a wink of the eye to Clive Wells (it's She not he, Clive)and to Kim Mc, for their kind words about the value of the information in my post (Keight at January 29, 2008 4:19 PM) concerning the Covenants and Restrictions and the A.C.C.

Unfortunately, I do not have a URL to offer ... I have a copy of the original document.

Later today, I will post more of the document's content that relates to current ideas being discussed. (ie: boat dock, landscaping, solar panels, etc.).

If anyone has a specific area/question/topic that they would like me to research, just ask in a post .... I read all the entries each day and will be happy to share any guidelines that are contained in the C & R document.

This is my first experience with the Blog Cabin. I definetly agreed that some links should be provided with the choices for voting for the not as well informed. Also, living through the current severe drought in NC in a town with year-round water restrictions, I would like to make several suggestions for the cabin. Let me say: Low impact (drought) landscaping. A lake cabin should have trees and landscaping that does not require a lot of upkeep or watering. Now, having grown up in the mountains in upstate NY and lived through quite a few ice storms in NC, a back up generator is an absolute necessity. I hope additional "green" options are offered, such as solar panels and rainwater collection systems. I really am torn about the shower systems. Are there water conservation options on the power shower or rain shower? Do all of the bathrooms have roll-in shower configuration or do they have tubs too? I would like to see either a "modernized" claw foot tub or large spa tub option. But only if they are of a good size. My sister and I shared a house for a while that was listed as having a "luxury garden tub." We actually never used it, because at 5'11" & 5'10", we were too tall to stretch out and relax in the tub. Thanks for listening, Nicola

I'm sure DIY images for the voting are representative only, not necessarily the exact version that will end up in/on the house. So please voters don't pick the "red" cabinets because the colors go with other design features, etc., you are choosing the STYLE.

Let's not just build the same cabin as last year. My preferences are for the slate or cedar shingles, a combo power shower AND rainshower (bummer that you can only vote for one), Arts & Crafts cabinetry (as long as it stays the natural wood finish, as A&C is all about not painting wood), quartz or soapstone countertops (Unite against those granite voters) and as for the fireplace, use brick inside and then stone outside. I guess I'm leaning more towards a polished, yet casual feel, not too rustic. I would also love to see the outdoor fireplace be located off a main living area as it appears the master bedroom has a fireplace in the room.

Kim Mc has some great ideas to consider. "GAS LOG STARTER -elec. ign., STRETCH FLOOR PLAN -lgr MstBdrm, closets, Kitchen/Island, CHIMNEY/FIREPLACE in BSMT, CLEANOUTs in chimney, TILE FLUE in chimney, BOATHOSE/DOCK, STONE PATIO(S) -behind wkout bsmt and at shore/dock, HARDWOOD & TILE FLRS, 40" FRONT DOOR w/SIDELIGHTs -NO DBL DOOR." All are great ideas to work into the design (my favorite being the front door with sidelights, the next being the gas log starter for the wood burning fireplace), I'd also like to see more environmental concerns addressed, i.e. rainwater collection and the like.

Does anyone know what the space across from the washer and dryer is intended for? Office maybe? I'm new to the blogs and don't know if I might have missed something. I think that the space, combined with the rear foyer and hall, would be great for a laundry area/mud room rather than having the washer and dryer in a hallway and then the area would be more open, less segmented.

WOW! I have just spent a couple of hours pouring over the blogs. I must admit, I voted without knowing about some of the things offered. I WILL BE DOING MY HOMEWORK from now on! I have to agree that maybe some informed information on the choices is needed. I also agree & felt this way weeks ago that people are voting on what they are seeing. I bet lots of people voted on the pendant lighting for the outside based on the one shown. I don't think that will be the one used (maybe I am wrong, correct me if I am)but just an example of what a pendant light is. I really feel that in this day & age of water droughts that the power shower & rain shower could lead to a lot of wasted water! However I really think that the metal roof is the way to go as rain could be collected into a cistern & used for watering the plants or even used to wash up after a swim in the lake before coming inside. At our place in the Smoky Mountains we ONLY have a cistern with filtration system since there has not been a lot of success with wells on the mountain. Even though it is our get away place, you have no idea how much water you use until it is very limited!

Definately agree radian heat in the floor is needed!

Can't wait to see what's next. You all are doing a great job!

See you soon,

NINETTE

well I for one would really love to see a true green cabin..... but unlike so many who believe what they have been told. why not strawbale,timber frame,rammed earth, cob, adobe, it is traditional....... very earth friendly and you can use so many earth friendly ideas to make it a great cabin.... how about a masonry wood stove? solar hydronic floor heating? there are so many ways to do it its unreal and here we are being so non-traditional building a traditional cabin.

This is my 1st Blog!
I just want to comment on Keight's comments about the bylaws of the "SITE"! If the garage has to be put "out of sight" from the street then the way you look at the house will make a BIG difference. Do not take it for granted people that it will be placed on the lot just as it is shown in the picture!! If the house is placed just like the picture then the logical place to put the garage would be to put it on the side of the kitchen (I personally would not like to enter through the Master Bed) maybe attaching a "breezeway" from the rear door of the kitchen to the garage and then move the washer and dryer to the side of what I think is the pantry and flip the pantry to where the washer and dryer are now (to me that makes more sense).

As for Grace, she has some very good ideas but like alot of people have said WE need to be more informed about these choices and it would be a GREAT help if DIY explained what each item is made of, eco friendly, etc.

Something else that should be discussed is if the home is accessible for Disabled People? I AM a Disabled person and I would like to see some ramps, wider doorways, accessible shower, lowered countertops (or some with mixed heights) in areas like bathrooms and kitchens, lightswitches lower(dimmer switches) and maybe even an elevator!! I have seen these really cool looking screen doors that can be folded in like a pocket door so that you can have it open when needed or closed and they wouldn't take away from the beauty of the door.

I think that this is enough for my first Blog and I truly hope that Watson, Grace, Ahmed and all other BIG WIGS read this information. I will be voting and checking in again.
Thank You!
Paula Smith
from the Beautiful Oregon Coast

Hi,

Can't help being a bit disappointed in the choice of METAL ROOF.

The San Jacinto floor plan is better suited for the Cedar shingle. Alas, it's my thought on the matter.

Regardless, I LOVE the stone fireplace! So very lovely!

My previous post about the new choices wasn't posted. Hope I'm not one of the people that needs to stand in the hall. Anyway, I think we need to rethink our choices for this log cabin and not go with the "usual". Although I love a metal roof, the composite cedar shingles are interesting and certainly give the cabin a more upscale look that fits to this community. Soapstone a beautiful surface for a kitchen. My friend just reconstructed her kitchen and used this material. She loves it and finds it easy. The fireplace choices are difficult. The pictures posted aren't very good. Maybe using an interesting brick, possibly handmade by a local craftsman, would fit in this house. I'm not sure tile is appropriate, although tiles made by a local craftsman would be interesting too. And as for cabinets...arts and crafts.

How's about...
- a larger master bedroom and dining area; you could move the lakeside wall out even with the great room and extend the porch out even across the front.
- widen the dormers across the full width of the bedrooms; so you lose a little closet space, there's still room for bureaus and dressers.
- move the outdoor fireplace to the other side of the house off of the dining room; that would make it beter for entertaining purposes.

Even tho I am not as informed on the building choices I voted what I thought would look or function the best. Some of my choices made the cut and some did not. The cabin still looks like it will be terrific.

Well...
I've spent the morning reading all previous blogs and all I can say is WOW!
This is my first visit to the blog (not from lack of trying), I just couldn't figure out how to get here. I can imagine how many other people there are that have just given up on finding the blog, voted and went away.I wish I could have found the Blog sooner. I probably would have changed my vote on things like soapstone instead of granite and cedar shingles instead of tin.
I'm feeling a lot more informed now.
Thanks to the bloggers that offered up information on regulations, the weather, the area in general and product information.
This is great fun! Belinda

I am really liking the choices in materials overall but would really like for people to consider that sure a "Power Shower" is great but lets start thinking a little more conservation as we continue to use up our nations water supply at an astounding rate. Laundry and Showering are the number one source for wasted water in the world... come on... lets get a little more conscious and do the right thing when building this one. I have to agree that the folks at DIY need to really start offering more details on the products and giving more "Green" choices for us to choose from.

However, once again... great job all...

I agree with the comments concerning voting for more "eco friendly" features and including them in the design. Alot of people vote for what they know and are used to; they need to be more informed on the newer choices.
I would also like to see features that would transcend time, such as thinking about people as they get older; making a home more easily assecible for the elderly and handicapped.
All in all, I think the Blog Cabin is a wonderful idea.

Another thing that they might want to begin looking into is recycled water systems and even perhaps grey water reuse in landscaped areas. I don't know that they should go as far as the new composting toilets (however, they are especially green), but beginning to look at ways to improve our mark on the world would be a step in the right direction. Who wouldn't want to own a newer technology, greener log cabin?

Hello, everyone! I've enjoyed the light-hearted banter regarding the different choices and suggestions. I've read quite a few of the entries, but something I haven't seen is anyone asking WHY IS THE LARGE OUTDOOR LIVING AREA OFF OF THE MASTER SUITE INSTEAD OF THE KITCHEN SIDE? The cabin is very symmetrical so I guess it could be switched easily (if construction hasn't already begun). I'm just thinking of entertainment purposes. If my kids have friends over and are out there til midnight - am I gonna be able to go on to bed???

Roofing - I voted for the metal roof, but only because it was the only one with an image of what it looks like on a log cabin. I really tried to envision the others, but just couldn't.

I like the idea of placing the fireplace on the foyer side, however it would take the focus away from the view of the lake (unless the room is big enough to have 2 focal points). Plus, with the door to the powder room opening to the foyer and not the great room, the issue of privacy is really not an issue...

Countertops - I know granite is the most popular option in the Nation these days, but in a log cabin, I feel Soapstone is a much nicer choice. It is more rustic, yet it has a very sophisticated appeal! Therefore, it can suit the style of the cabin while bringing a classy element into the picture.

I would also like to echo the sentiment regarding more info prior to voting. Maybe for next year's Blog Cabin you could overhaul the site to make it easier to envision the choices. With technology as advanced as it is, there's no reason why you couldn't have a rendering of the different rooms and the product options available for specific areas. Lowe's and Home Depot can show you what YOUR kitchen would look like with different countertops. Why can't the DIY website do it? Then, the voters would be able to "see" what the products would look like in that particular setting. (You can always have a disclaimer noting that the actual product may vary...)

Well, I've had fun sharing my views and reading all of y'all's! Hope y'all have a great day and that you get a chance to come visit me in my new Lakefront cabin sometime in the next year... ;o) (wink, wink, smile!)

When do we get to start trying to win it???

As a first time blogger for the cabin, I was amazed to see all the input. I was thrilled to read up a little more on the recycled paper counter top. Honestly, if I won this cabin, I can't see that I would really be unhappy with any choice. I am really interested in some of the information on the water issues that seem to be of great concern for the area, this could really effect the new owner. I agree with the dumb waiter, the sky light idea for the loft, as well as the radiant heat on the floors. I also liked the idea of the dogwash outside. I know the roof is a highly debated issue, but I would really like to see the metal roof. I know they can be noisy, but if this is a place you can't be at all the time, I think peace of mind to know that a hail storm hasn't caused roof leaks, and damages inside is something to think about. I guess I haven't seen the ice and snow problems with the metal roof. This will obviously be a discussion till one is chosen.
Guess I need to do a little more research on the products offered before I vote again. Keight has made some valid points too about revising.
Thanks for letting us all give our input into this new cabin.

Just wanted to add a comment regarding the basement. I think that would be a FANTASTIC addition! It doesn't have to be completely finished out as long as it's roughed for a bath, kitchenette and other options. The technical closet could be down there - very beneficial since it does get pretty cold there in winter. Plus, some people may want to add another bedroom - 3 bedroom homes are only ROOMY for 4-person families. If you use it for a vacation home, you might want to be able to invite others to join you. If you plan to live in it (my first choice), then you'd probably want room for visitors and not have to impose on anyone's regular schedule (I have 2 older boys and a 20-month old girl).

Just a note about the Blogger's comment on placing the Master bed to optimize views. The Master looks large enough that you could place the bed in the middle of the room with a bank of bookshelves or something at the head to separate a small reading nook by the bath door. The bookshelves could be open cubicles so you don't totally block the light from the windows... Just an idea if you should win...

I agree that the laundry should be moved across to the larger room. The closet where it is currently located could be used for storage and a large pantry...

I disagree about flipping the L in the kitchen. I think the open bar links the rooms enough yet still lends some separation to the area.

Thanks for letting me share my thoughts... K

The fact that posts on the blog can take 24 hours+ to appear isn't helping matters, either. We can't even educate one another in a timely fashion. You know, in many other blogs, once a poster has been verified, said poster's contributions get added without delay. If a "verified" poster crosses the line of good taste/internet etiquette their posts get held for review.

Just a thought! It's your sandbox...but if you want us to make different choices/influence one another...you have to make that possible. If not...perhaps you shouldn't complain when things go the way of "safe."

I have been convinced that QUARTZ is a better option. I DO have granite and love it BUT I did some research. A helpful website is www.cambriausa.com , I found alot of facts that I wasn't aware of. Quartz is non-porous which makes it safer for food prep and clean up. It doesn't need treated and naturally prevents harmful bacteria from absorbing. It also won't absorb tea, coffee, kool aid stains! Again, anything that makes life easier is the best!!! Thanks for the oppurtunity! :-)

Carrisa

I must admit that I voted for the metal roof but after reading most of the blogs I agree that the composite slate or shingles would be better. I thought they looked better but wanted to go with something that had low upkeep. I stand corrected!

I love the idea of a walkout basement. I come from a large family and the extra space would be just what I need. A screened in porch that can be enclosed in the winter is also a good idea. I lived in the northeast for awhile and spent many pleasent evenings on the porch.

I see a lot of posts that mention lasts year blog cabin. I didn't really know about it until the end but I wouldn't want this one to look the same so I will make a point of reading the blog first before I vote next time.

Let's face facts, we want a log cabin with all the modern amenities! I love the metal roofing, the stone surrounding the fireplace, granite countertops and the power shower!

I love that soapstone countertop with the little veins of white in it. The granite and quartz are nice materials but they're just not as pretty.
So how about some other color options?

With the growing population of retiring baby-boomers and the trend for "Universal" designs with accessibility, will (should?) this log home incorporate these common sense ideas into its design?

In looking at the winning floor plan, it doesn't look clear if doorways of the closets, bathrooms, powder room, etc. are wide enough for a wheelchair to pass through. Will the master bath toilet really be accessible with what appears to be a narrow access? Will the shower accommodate a seat or will one be built in, and will it have appropriate infrastructure support to add railings, if necessary? Or how about the usability of the kitchen…the utility rooms beyond the kitchen…the powder room (maybe the door needs to swing outward), and etc.?

I know from my experiences it is a lot easier, considerably cheaper and more aesthetic looking to build these designs into the home at the beginning than through remodeling endeavors.

It would be great if Blog Home could carry their forward thinking of their product choices into a future thinking, universal home

Thanks Mary checked out that metalroof web page and liked what I saw. Maybe everyone should,lots of styles that look great and it's still metal. Let's just keep voting and maybe one of our choices will win. Thanks DYI for our little bit of input.

Please excuse my laspe in wordsmithing, I meant Blog Cabin...not Blog Home.

Kim Mc -- If you were using caps so that your post would stick out, then that is shouting. (People verbally shout so they will be heard/noticed.)

ok i haven't voted yet today but...
i think that there are many choices that we NEED more info on. going by looks is great butif someone haden't read the RULES for the site and posted them we (the bloggers) that haven't found them would never have known. and as far as the choices i think that someone from diy should be on here daily to answer some of our questions.

we are all excited about this home and making more informed choices and not remaking the same cabins over and over would be nice.

as far as the choices go granite is over done and if we keep on using it we have depleted it all. so what about soapstone ?

the fireplace surround... i live in pennsylvania and we have stone called pocono stone that i think would be awesome. it ranges in color from tans and browns to reds and purples and orange.
if you get the mix it comes together great.

the roof metal is great for the length of time it will last and that there is no maintainence to it. since there is maintainence to the logs every couple of years but please go with a color other than green or red. eggplant is nice.

the cabinets... the arts and crafts style is more cabiny i think and you could even do a wash of color on them for extra pazazz.

so since i have said all that i can think of right now i'm gonna go vote.

thanks everyone for the info you all have taking the time to find out that i couldn't find and i can't wait for the building to begin.

randee w.

I have been following Blog Cabin since the airing of the 2007 home. I LOVE the concept, and have been happily reading & voting since the beginning on this years house.

I too would love to see more information about the different choices. Before voting each time, I find myself going online to read up on different options, and it would be SO helpful if there was information or even just a few links provided for each choice.

One other thought... I would like to echo the others who have requested green choices. With the cost of living rising and environmental impact becoming more & more of an issue, I think it would be great to see DIY act as role models in environmentally-friendly building technique/products.

just a thought that i just realized. the pictures that you used for voting... the top choices are the ones that are of log homes. the choices that are failing are of more traditional homes could you change the pics so that they are all of log homes?

randee w.

First time blogger and I'll try not to create any controversy. I like the metal roof - low maintenance, the butcherblock countertop - more in keeping with a cabin, stone fireplace surround and power shower. I'd also like to know more about a garage. Radiant heated floors and a generator would be a real plus.

Thanks!

The choices are great. However, can the power shower and rain shower be "greened" so that not so much water is used? So far, with the exception of the countertops and cabinets, I'm on point. Love the floor plan but would push out the back porch another 5-6 feet to really make it another "room", possibly with a pergola at one end and a fireplace to gather around on cool TN nights.

Love the idea of possibly adding a link with more info next to the products we're voting on. I think we would be more apt to doing some research on the one's we're not familliar with, if we don't have to google everything.

Am also definately for making the indoor fireplace gas and the outdoor one wood. After going through an ice storm with no power for 3 days, our gas fireplace kept us warm the entire time. Sure, our gas bill rose a little, but it was a lot cheaper than "trying" to get a hotel room somewhere. And I like the idea of radient heat.

Also, I have a question....is it me, or did I not even see a plan for a garage? Per the covenants for the development, there has to be one. Where is it going?

And....I love the idea of the interal intaheat tank for the bathrooms. This alone would save so much water. Then we could all really enjoy the power shower or rain shower without guilt. :)

Keep up the good work DIY. This is fun!

Regular showerhead!

Getting to vote/help design is both exciting and frustrating, especially when you seem to be in the minority on some of the choices. I believe you provide an enormous amount of choices, all that are fairly current, except the butcher block countertops-I thought the trend was pulling away from that and to more durable surfaces such as concrete-hint, hint...start kicking up that vote!Do you think its a possibility someone from a horribly hot and treeless state could win such a wonderful cabin on the wooded lake? Thank goodness we can all dream.
Enjoy,
Babette

why does the majority seem to want granite or quartz counters IN A LOG CABIN? I just don't get it. I've always thought of log cabins as being more rustic, not fancy with top-of-the-line finishes. Am I the only one?

A special note to Watson, Grace, Ahmed, and the many other people (sorry your names may never be known, but I know you must surely exist!) working so diligently on behalf of the 2008 Blog Cabin.

Many of us realize that there is so much that goes on "behind the scenes" when it comes to building a home. From pulling permits, to endless meetings with the "powers that be", every final decision is reached only after layers of time and energy have been invested.

So.... Thank you and Best Wishes .... to all of you at DIY that are working so hard to meet the requirments of the developers of Lakefront Estates, while, still, remaining cognizant of, and incorporating many of the "Wishes" that are submitted by your faithful, albeit, opinionated "off-site" blogger crew.

Lively exchanges and the occasional "come on guys, you need to improve this" are what makes this such a remarkable experience. Knowing you are the ones ... entrusted with this huge task ... who listen to the wit, wisdom, sense and nonsense that is thrown at you on a daily basis and still continue on ... I just wanted to say hip hip hooray!

And, on a final note, as caught up in the project as I have become, I really do realize that everything I comment on is not exigent, and that you will deal with it if/when the time is right.
It's just that somedays it seems the October 2008 Season Opener cannot arrive too soon!

to Keight at January 31
Apologies for the gender switch. Many thanks for the info so far. It helps. Do you have any idea how the drought is really impacting this development and the surrounding area. I read in the Spring City 'Echo' about the possibility of the Watts Bar nuke plant having to close due to low water in the lake and the possibility of a 10-fold increase in local power costs. If the area is so sensitive to environmental impacts then we should definitely be very conscious of this when deciding water usage and appliances.

I'm taken back by the majority vote on the power shower. Having the Colorado and Mississippi River running over you during one shower (OK that's a bit of exaggeration) when the government has mandated all new toilets have a maximum flush of 1.85 gallons and the populace is preaching conserving the environment I find the power shower a little too much. Hey, I love showers as much as any one...

There are so many new and more eco-friendly choices out there for products to use. I challenge the builders and decision makers to NOT put in the same old choices for each section. You may end up with run-away voting, and the same cabin every year. Classic choices in a different material, or classic material in a stylish pattern, would be wonderful to see. I do love many of the choices already made, while questioning the practicality of some others.

Let's all try to think outside the box. We have a golden opportunity to create something extraordinary. I'd hate to see it become a beautiful, but slightly boring, carbon-copy.

I am grateful for the opportunity to participate in Blog Cabin. I can't wait to see it all come together. I think all the choices are wonderful options. I am surprised I a have not seen silestone or corian coutnertops, which are not as expensive, but they are relatively easy to maintain. It has to be a stone fire place. Can you make the seating area wider and deeper on and around the stone fire place or are there buidling codes that prevent that? For the cabinets, a light or natural stain would be nice too. Is it too late or early to comment on landscaping?

Hello Bloggers and Watson,
Question I went to the blog cabin web site on Jan 27, and there was already voting on the new choices. But Watson you never even posted about new choices until the Jan 29. And on the 27th the choices of roof,(metal) cabs,(arts &craft) countertops (granite), shower (power)and fire place (stone) was already in the lead by the thousands of votes and that was on the 27th of Jan? who did all that voting so fast?
I'm so confused I thought we had a chance to choose but I do not see it. I wanted different things this year but looks like it doesn't matter.
I have read the blogs and I see everyone was wanting different choice than what is winning how can that be?
Just a question
Susan from Florida

Awesome cabin! Can you add an outdoor shower? They are great for coming in off the lake. Love the voting!

Hey Bloggers - GREAT comments . . BUT did anyone REALLY look at the neighborhood when they voted a 'metal roof'? Yes the metal is low maintenance (although noisy unless extra insulation applied) but the synthetic slate is much more becoming to the area and does look nice on a log facade, more befitting a lakeside home. As far as the shower -if you want to waste water & electricity - you have a much larger budget than most, or if you want a rain shower - go outside. Whoever wins this cabin will be outside enjoying the area and lake and a GOOD firm shower on the back & shoulders cannot be replaced by a 'rain shower'. I agree with alot of the bloggers (and the designers) that Granite is 'high maintenance' - really not practical for an active family. Quartz is the lowest maintenance, takes the heat(set a hot pan on it) and beating (dropping a pan/bowl) if no one has done that then they are not 'using' their kitchen (ha ha). As far as cabinets Arts & Crafts just didn't seem to fit the eastern US, lakefront area. It was OK for Blog Cabin 2007 but there again bloggers - let's put ourselves IN the home IN the location and environment and DESIGN a true beautiful cabin! Traditional or European designs are lower maintenace(cleaning) yet feel warm and comfortable. BLOGG ON !

Here are some other points to ponder that I've discovered while reading through the Covenants and Restrictions for Lakefront Estates Subdivision:

1. Roofs: Roofing materials shall be "architectural dimensional shingles" of at least a twenty-five (25) year expected life manufactured by a company or companies approved in advance by the A.C.C. in a color approved in advance by the A.C.C.. Other roofing materials, to the extent three dimensional or higher quality, may also be utilized with the prior approval of the A.C.C.. The majority of the roof pitch must be 10/12 or steeper on one-story dwellings and at least 8/10 or steeper on one and one-half story and two-story dwellings, except as otherwise approved by the A.C.C..

2. Section 8 Docks: All docks must be permitted by TVA and be approved by the A.C.C.. The following criteria must by (sic) met: the dock must be one of three styles: a single slip dock with a 6x12 pitch roof (it can have extra overhang), a sundeck dock or a 4-way hip roof dock with a copula. A dock may contain up to 1,000 sq.feet: all roofs must be the approved forest green or burnished slate metal unless specifically approved otherwise by the A.C.C.. The A.C.C. shall allow cedar shake roofs to match the primary dwelling. All dock plans must by (sic) approved by TVA.

3. No exposed, above ground tanks for the storage of fuel or water or any other substance shall be located on any Lot: provided, however, that this prohibition is inapplicable to exposed or unexposed above or under-ground tanks for the storage of sewage for the entirely of Lakefront Estates Subdivsion.

4. No living tree having a diameter greater thatn 4 inches, breast high, may be cut on any said lot without first obtaining written consent from the A.C.C..

My comments are not getting posted and they are not being returned.

What am I doing incorrectly?

Anyone figured out the size (sq ft) of the cabin?

Leanna, there are lots of different granite tops, mine is similar to Giallo Napoleon or Venitian Gold and I would not call it formal or fancy in any way, it would go fine in a log cabin with the right cabinets. The edge also makes a difference in the tops formal or informal apperance. I've seen lots of comments on sealing the top and I can't believe that people think sealing the top once or twice a year is such a big deal. It's a log cabin, there's going to be lots of yard work that will need to be done here, and the logs on the cabin & the deck that need to be sealed and fire wood that will need to be cut. Maybe some folks should reconsider log cabin living as it is probably not a good option for them. Although I do like the Granite, almost any of the countertops could be beautiful if done correctly. I've seen some concrete that wasn't so great and one recently on DIY or HGTV that they stained with a copper color that was awesome. I personally do think the paper is awful.

Liked the metal roof site www.metalroofing.com. Stlll like burgandy or eggplant.

I'm happy all my choices are in the lead at the moment (part of the boring majority I guess).
Some "green" in the home is fine but really, I would choose what I liked rather that what was "green", no matter what. I propose the next cabin/home be for all the "green" beans out there, allowing only "green" choices and more infomation on the choices before voting. It is ironic that I saw several "greenies" wanting a large tub in the bath which I thought went against idea of conserving water (unless they intend to use it a couple of times Ha! Ha!), collecting the water run off is a great idea though! Keep Bloging Everyone!

To those I may have offended with my plea that we better inform ourselves...my apologies. I did not mean to imply that anyone who voted for a metal roof or granite countertops was uninformed. That stated, if you read through the posts, you will see that once folks clicked through some of the informational links we bloggers provided, they wished they'd voted otherwise. That would seem to indicate that some people weren't informed about those other choices.

I am never sarcastic in my posts (on this site at any rate!) because sarcasm seldom "reads" in blogging...unless one "knows" the poster. I work under the assumption that others are genuine in their postings... So to whomever it was (joe?) that suggested I be a consultant next time...Thank You! I can think of nothing I'd enjoy more!

I do hope we can have a cistern or rain barrels as part of this house...the drought is no joke here in the SE. I'm in NC and currently on "hiatus" from work because I had foot surgery...but if they do an outright ban on watering I'll probably be laid off. Not much call for Garden Center employees if no one can water the shrubs they plant.

Melanie See

I don't know if anyone has suggested it yet but could you please consider building a dock on the lake to go with the cabin. I can't imagine anything more peaceful than sitting on your own dock looking out over the peaceful waters of the lake. What a way to end the day!!!

LDM

Well it is so hard to choose from the styles on some of the choices because they are all great. But I asume these are supposed to be a personal opinion and then putting the most voted on the list. I think so far so good.
Thanks again for giving us something to put our dream version on and in.
Tammie

(((Kathy)))I think the space across from the w/d is a nice size pantry. Also would you be kind enough when posting to put your last name or at least the first three letters of it so this will distinguish all of the Kathy's out here. Thanks:) Kathy Seals

Trying to get a head start on the Flooring issue. Other things can be found there too. It's our Green Dream Team's website you can access:

www.greenhomeguide.com

Direct Flooring info. head to:

www.greenhomeguide.com/index.php/Knowhow/entry/803/C220

Good Luck! Kathy Seals

Hi, I am a first time blogger so forgive me if the style is wrong.

I love medal roofs because I have one here in Maine and we love it. No problems like snow accumulation and weight, or ice dams for that matter. Though I would pick maroon as the color for the cabin not green. I agree also on having a garage, radient floor heating with a ceiling fan for circulation. I like the idea of a skylight in the loaf and access to a bathroom(with tub) upstairs. Maybe a daybed/murphy here for a guest also.

The kitchen if it were to have an island I would like an electrical outlet hidden in a cabinet under the island. That way it isn't just a hole on the top of the counter. I don't like butcher block have had it and it is gone. I really have not researched enough but marble and granite are my choises.

I believe the deck should have the ability to be closed/screened in for bugs. Maybe a retractable netting like a Sunsetter would work. We had to do that up here for the black flys and mosquitoes. I also would like another stair off the deck in the back.

I'd like to see a basement for storage, extra freezer, shelfs for food stuffs and mechanical needs.

Since we had an ice storm up here and did lose our power for 27 days I think the generator is a must with an auto start, propane I think.

I'll keep reading the blogs and thinking what would be a nice addition or extra. Many of the items which won I voted for also but I few I didn't like the hanging light.

I'm enjoying this and can't wait to see the results.

I love the choices so far. I think natural looking granite or quartz would be beautiful in a log cabin. Stone, wood, quartz are all natural products. Log cabins do not have to look "fancy" just because you have some updated choices. With the great designers of the log cabin, I think we can look forward to everything tying in nicely. Last one was gorgeous!

OK, OK!! After reading all of the blogs I realize that granite is not necessarily the correct choice for the kitchen. Can we really start voting in time to change it? I did vote for the cedar roof since the pounding of rain on a metal roof is not conducive to sleeping.
Any news on solar heat, heated floors, gas/electric/heat-pump? How about insulation? Basement or no basement? I agree about giving us some time to research the options before voting. I can't get on line until at least 7pm.
Debbie - I had the same problem you had in regards to blogging. I voted but it took me a few days to finally get here.

Melanie See, thanks for the composite cedar link.

http://www.enviroshake.com/index.php

I enclosed the HOME link. GREAT PRODUCT! That's what I'm going to keep voting for.
Made from recycled products - GREEN
Fifty Year Life Expectancy - THRIFY
(See Warranty section)
Maintenance Free - MORE PLAY TIME

I'm voting for quartz today. I like the soapstone too.
I saw links for quartz, soapstone and concrete.
I'll check them out, and see which helps lock me in. I saw a lot of posts on the advantages of quartz though.

If stone for the fireplace wins, there are many choices other than just the large river rock. I saw Owens-Corning manufactored stone that looked like flag or sandstone. I'll try to find a link and post it. I someone else mentioned a stone they saw up Nor'East.

Now for my standard advertisement:

BASEMENT -walkout/roughed in, GAS LOG STARTER -elec. ign., STRECH FLOOR PLAN -lgr MstBdrm, closets, Kitchen/Island, CHIMNEY/FIREPLACE in BSMT, CLEANOUTs in chimney, TILE FLUE in chimney, BOATHOSE/DOCK, STONE PATIO(S) -behind wkout bsmt and at shore/dock, HARDWOOD & TILE FLRS, 40" FRONT DOOR w/SIDELIGHTs -NO DBL DOOR

P.S. Remember folks, and new bloggers you can vote every day! You can change your vote choice too. I did. I voted for granite at first, then read Grace's post.

I am the one that wants the Master bedroom's windows put together and the closet wall so that you can put the bed against it .... so you can enjoy the view of the lake...
KaVee Wils .... the room is only 13'6" X 13'5" and you can't put a bookcase behind the bed to have a walkway between the closet door and the bookcase... it won't work.... so I am still going to ask for the closet door moved to the side by the sink.. and in the closet on the wall next to the sink you could put a built in chest...

Laura M. .... understand the Ice Storm and being glad to have a gas fireplace to stay warm with no Electicity... we were lucky .. and only had to deal with it for 12 hours... but others here in the OKC area had to deal with it for a week..
so I too voted for gas...

Also for you against the metal roof.. go look at the site that someone posted above... you can have a metal roof look like a slate or cedar shingles... & there is also a wood look color...

so I am staying with Metal for the low maintance...

I would love a larger kitchen and room for more than one person in the kitchen... even if you don't want help there are times when you need help if there is a group over.

And typing in caps is not always yellin'
we are saying a greener cabin... how about
being kind to our fellow bloggers....too
we come from all over the US.. and backgrounds
and knowledge of blogging on the internet...
I have learned so much for other bloggers here
on products and likes & dislikes...

My concern about a metal roof is the noise factor.
Does anyone know if a metal roof is louder
than the regular shingle roofs in rain and hail?

Almost all of my family lives in Tennessee and we live in Florida. Don't get me wrong but I would rather live in Tennessee because It's home to me and I would like to have the change of seasons. I long for change, it's a wonderful part life and I hate "LOVE BUGS"

I love these new choices, especially to see how the stone around the fireplace is leading in votes. I really like bringing the outside in.
I like the metal roof, but as one other blogger commented on the DIY message board, does it have to be green? Will there be other color choices? Also, as I've seen mentioned, it would be nice to know the different qualities, i.e. wear and tear, that the countertops can hold up to. I have, I guess laminate, and would love to know how soapstone and concrete hold up to cutting and hot pots.
Also, as mentioned above that I spied, radiant heat floors, oh yea!!! If I ever get to build again that is how we are doing it.
Thanks for all the input you let us do DIY!

With all the worry about fires, which are likely to become more and more of a problem as the planet heats up and water becomes more scarce, it seems to me any house built in any area where there are lots of trees and shrubs need to keep fire resistance at the top of the list of building materials. Any roofing material that does not provide maximum fire resistance should actually not even be allowed.

As for the shower: yeah, that power shower is beautiful, but what is the water usage with such units?

And about those wood burning fires: What could all of you who voted for it be thinking? Do you have any idea how much choking smoke spews out of a chimney from wood burning fires? All that lovely country air you'd be going to the lake to breath would be full of particulat matter and benzopropylene, both powerful carcinogens, not to mention ashtma producers, and pollutants to the surrounding trees. And think of this: We should be planting trees, not cutting them down for firewood. Gas fires may not be nearly as romantic as wood burning fires, but they are a lot more responsible.

A lot of people are asking to make the cabin more wheelchair accessable. Friends of mine just built their own home and the first thing I noticed were the wider doorways. It just made the house seem more open, and I loved it. I would have never guessed what a huge difference it made, but if I ever build my own home, it will definately have the wider doors and doorways.

Well, let's face it everyone, we are not building a cabin, we are building a dream home. With all the changes here and there we are all planning on living in this log HOUSE, when we win. I know I would be, when we finally retire.

Yes, I am a baby boomer hoping I can be the winner and have been voting with the expectation that whoever wins might be in the same position I am in. I would want to live there in retirement.

I would hope that you all might listen to some words of wisdom and realize that our planet is in danger and we are to blame. We need to really think about choices here. I blogged during 2007 and most of my choices were selected and the first cabin was a mass of selections that some bloggers could not imagine coming together and it did.

I think those of you are new to the 2008 blog have just watched all the segments of 2007 Blog Cabin and may be thinking I liked that lets vote for it, hopefully not. But the selections this year are so much more than the first Bog Cabin. To have the roof materials like we have this time are to select from, is a learning experience and a somewhat hard choice. I am all for longer lasting and different from Blog Cabin 2007. The metal was a nice selection for a cabin. I noticed in my travels and property search in Tennessee that every other cabin/home had a green or red metal roof. Oh to see another color would have been nice. Asphalt is something that is so everyhome, that it would be really nice to do something really different. I think that the cedar or slate composites would both really be nice on a log home and I like both. They are made from recycled material and to me, much more the right choices.

Just know that you can change your votes, if you are checking into these materials, so do it before it is too late. I like metal too, but is it the best environmental choice.

A power shower is great but is it the best environmental choice. If you don't think about water consumption now, there may be little water for your children or grandchildren. The right choice now can help the future and save in the long run. I can atest that knowing that our area has only 100 days of water left is a bit scary. Yeah, I can buy water, but you use it for drinking. The faucet and showers are among the top water useage in the home just below your toilet(#1) and washing machine(#2).

I would hope that when the bathrooms are done they are installing low flush toilets and the low flow shower head and faucets that has reduce the amount of water coming out, like I have seen on some home show. A bit of reserve should be taken with the POWER shower and do the low flow shower head. If the shower takes 13+ gallons per household per day thats can be 92 gallons for a week just for a shower. The toilet averages 19+ gallons per day 135 gallons a week for flushing. Think of the water we will save if we could put in low flow toilets(1.6 gal per flush) and showers(2.5 gal. per minute) we could save over 11 gallons per day.

Here in NC they are thinking of limiting us to 25 gal a day per person as a water restriction to help keep our supply as lakes get gets lower. But that includes your washing machine and dishwasher etc. Not outdoor watering or car washing etc., we stopped that last summer. Lawns went dry, plants died and it was hotter than Hades this summer. So please, please, PLEASE think of conservation.

Enough for today. Lets keep blogging......

Wow !! This is going to be a great cabin for some lucky winner. I have to agree with some of the others in this Blob, and that is some of the choices that are being made. I notice that most of the picks are similar to the last Blob cabin. I actually loved the look of the composite slate roof and the European cabinets with a quarts counter top. It would be nice that once we see the cabin being built to include a small bay window over the sink or somewhere in the kitchen area for plants or and herb garden.

Sincerely Looking forward to seeing the show and watching the building of the magnificent cabin.

Blessings

I don't understand why people are having such a dificult time investigating the items that are in each voting section. All you have to do is open a new window on your computer and go to your search engine to find the information you need. I did that on each category and looked up all the choices before I voted - except for the roofing. It really isn't that difficult if you want to put in the time and work to make an informed decission.

The roof - METAL. Not because it is always used, but for the fact that, unless a tree falls on your house, there is virtually NO repairs needed on it. For those of you wondering about the "noise of rain", there is none. It also comes in alot of colors and you could use one of the lighter ones to reflect the sun to actually make it cooler inside during the summer. Now-a-days, most metal roofs have a plywood or composite board underlay otherwise the metal sweats. Metal roofs are the best for snow slide-off because the snow won't pull any of the other roofing material down with it and they are great in aiding in the gathering rain water.

Fireplace - Stone. Sorry, I just like stone.

Cabinets - Arts & Crafts. After viewing the other choices, this just seemed more "homey".

Countertop - Soapstone. No maintenance, looks great, durable and long lasting.

Shower - This was the hard one. Low flow, or "do I want to get cleaner, faster"? Face it, on a low flow you have to spend more time in the shower which, in turn, actually wastes water. The Power-Shower sets your water temp and the water pressure and you're in and out which actually conserves water so that's what I voted for.

If we're talking laundry rooms, leave it where it is. You just may need that larger room for a larder or pantry or canning foods. I know how some winters can be because right now, we can't get out with all the snow we've received (2 feet on the ground and 2 new storms coming in.) Luckily my wife does her own canning and she buys "Emergency Essentials" - just a little every month. We now have 2 - 7'x3' cabinets filled with the stuff! You may think it's silly, but if there's ever an emergency, we'll be prepared...remember Katrina????

I liked the idea about the floor heating. We have friends here that have recycled hot water that runs through pipes under their floors. Very efficient and economical. Also, I liked the idea about the fireplace insert for pellet usage. You could also have an JUCA air tight insert installed - http://mb-soft.com/juca/jucal.html which have an 80,000 btu/hr rating. It even comes with an automatic blower that is more powerful than most. Just an idea...

It seems like the most traditional choices for the cabin are winning in the polls. I voted for the low-flow shower since I work in water conservation and in my experienc a good low-flow showerhead provides a great shower experience. The high power and rain tiles use too much water. Plus a lot of homeowners put in more than one which is a "luxury" but it comes with a cost and is extremely wasteful.
My other picks were for the cedar roof and the soapstone countertops, however, if I had known the recycled paper countertops came in additional colors before I voted, I would have changed my vote. When I did a bit of research, the recycled countertops won me over. My pick would be for the black recycled countertops and the craftman style cabinets. I believe it would give them cabin an earthy, organic feel. For the fireplace, I admit I chose the stone but I would have gone for flagstone had it been offered as a choice.

Another great "green" product not listed are recycled glass countertops, they are absolutely beautiful and come in a variety of colors. I also would like to see more green choices for the floor and even for the cabinets. Bamboo and Eucalyptus are durable and lovely.

The dining room should be larger than shown in the floor plan. Dining rooms are NEVER large enough. Also an outdoor kitchen would be nice at the dining room/kitchen side of the house. Include a built in gas grill, a mini frig or frig drawer, and a sink. A sink area would be helpful when it comes time to clean all those fish.

For all of you wondering what the "power-shower is all about, you can check it out at:
http://www.us.kohler.com/performanceshowers/dtv.jsp?section=2&nsection=2&nsubsection=3&category=12&nitem=cat12

The DTV I not only sets your temperature and spray intensity, it also sets the angle of water delivery. If it's the DTV II, you get mood lighting, personalized music, and steam.

Forgot one thing...how about some Class 5 Technology toilets? These alone would save 2,000 to 3,200 gallons of water per year for each one installed.

butcher, euro, stone, metal, power

Three More Wishes...

1. Moving the MasterBath Tub away from the big front window onto another wall so that taking a nice long soak in the tub would not be so darn chilly (or so revealing to the neighbors coming up the front walkway). OK... window treatments may solve that one major problem, but it still gets mighty cold sitting in a bathtub next to a huge window!

2. A covered deck on the second floor with access from the loft (and, perhaps the bedrooms) to take full advantage of the fantastic views of the lake and landscape. Just picture yourself cupping a mug of steaming hot (fill in the blank) and watching the sun rise over the lake. Glorious!

3. Screening in the upper covered deck (created by my second wish).... Think of the days to come, reading a book or taking a little nap up there, with a gentle breeze swinging the hammock ever so gently, the sounds of the water lapping up on the shore and No annoying buzzing of mosquitos in your ear. A little bit of heaven right there on Watts Barr Lake.

Leanna said: why does the majority seem to want granite or quartz counters IN A LOG CABIN? I just don't get it. I've always thought of log cabins as being more rustic, not fancy with top-of-the-line finishes.

Leanna, I have quartz counters and they are not fancy looking. I chose a plain squared edge, not the complicated layered edge they show in the voting photo. My counters have a simpler, almost shaker-like look to them. I think its natural to want to fill a wood home with other organic surfaces. We're voting to put stone around the fireplace, why not stone on the countertops? (Well personally, I'm voting for brick, but everyone else seems to be voting for stone around the fireplace!)

Leanna,I'm with you girl.Rustic is the theme here.Why not a tile fireplace? Because its a log cabin people.So why not stone or concrete in the Kitchen as well? I'm so confused.Let's keep it real,thats the bottom line.

Help! I just found out that people are voting for things like bathroom tile, etc. I have no idea where this voting is taking place! I am still voting on the roof, countertops, etc., and downstairs right now on DIY they are already working on installing these things. Does someone have the address to the new vote? Also, it's a relief to see the new blogs! Watson, could you help me here? Thank you and may the most worthy blogger win!

Melanie and Margo: Thanks for those links to composite/synthetic shingles.
Both product are maintenance free - MORE FREE TIME
Are made with recycled stuff - GREEN
50 Year warranty/Life Expectancy - THRIFY
Those DaVinci shingles look REALLY nice, their slate is awesome too. I could live with that look too.
(Looks like our 'little humble cabin' is going to have a metal roof though. I saw a link for metal roofs too, didn't go there yet. Maybe we can a least get a metal roof with a different look, at least. Still gonna be noisy, I'd bet.

Keight: Interesting about just the price of the 'dirt'. So 'our' lot is probably somewhere between $300 -$380K, with the structure(s) what do you figure, $450 - $650 range? Wow! How's property tax in Tennessee? Wonder what Uncle Sugar will hit up the winner for? Sorry about that dose of reality bloggers.
P.S. Do the ACC Reg's mandate any particular home attributes? Like, I hope they allow log homes! (Do they allow metal roofs? He, he he!)

Folk that put those links for countertops, thanks much! I checked 'em all(the 4 w/links), very though provoking. Looks like the 'cabin' is going to get granite, though I see QUARTZ making a slight move. Go QUARTZ, GO!!! I'm going to be doing my own DIY 1st floor powder room remodel. The four products I looked at all in the running. My 1st choice would be quartz, but that's with CINC HOUSEHOLD approval. They all have interesting features though.

Paper Composite: Nice, but a bit bland. Limited choices, less durable than some, stain -maintenance - care issues. Probably reasonable price and GREEN.

Concrete: I was highly impressed! I was thinking 'sidewalk', not so. Great variety in pattern/style/color. Downside for me, maintenance issues - staining, heat, 'cracking'. Probably still moderate price, they had sq ft pricing on site. GREEN.

Soapstone: This stuff looks to be really tough. Vitually stain proof, or easily cleaned/repaired. Down side, for me - not a lot of styles/colors - though you can use mineral oil to alter look, but must do that every 4 -8 weeks, or can use certain sealers that last much longer.

Quartz: Ahhh, you quartz fan bloggers made a believer outta me! I went to the Microban link listed then to the actual countertop place, Silestone. Here's the link.

http://www.silestoneusa.com

Wow! Non-porous, practically stain proof. No maintenance. VERY HARD, so you'd have to work to scratch it. Four times more 'flexible' than granite, to harder to chip than granite. HUGE choice of colors/patterns, etc. Nice stuff!
We might still be able to get this one to win! Remember, be like good Chicago Democrats - vote early, and often!

I learned a lot looking at these sites. Thanks again folks.

Standard advertisement follows:

BASEMENT -walkout/roughed in, GAS LOG STARTER -elec. ign., STRECH FLOOR PLAN -lgr MstBdrm, closets, Kitchen/Island, CHIMNEY/FIREPLACE in BSMT, CLEANOUTs in chimney, TILE FLUE in chimney, BOATHOSE/DOCK, STONE PATIO(S) -behind wkout bsmt and at shore/dock, HARDWOOD & TILE FLRS, 40" FRONT DOOR w/SIDELIGHTs -NO DBL DOOR, AWESOME LANDSCAPING -Dazzle us, AHMED!

Hello all!
This is my first blog about the blog cabin and after the show that I watched today, the choices seem to me to be a repeat of the same things that I saw being built, for the 2007 cabin.
One thing that would be awesome is to have the option to use green friendly things like low emissions varnishes on the cabinets and stuff, or even, if possible repurposing some old cabinets so cut down completely on the emissions that new cabinets can put into your air. Being from a rural area, many things, except in the rich folk's cabins, are repurposed from either family or community. Such recycling can be hard to do, but if it is in an area in which there is a community, sometimes just asking can open the door to such possibilities. Well, that's my two cents... thanks for the opportunity to air them. Have a good night all, Mydnight

When it's on DIY's dime why not go all out!! GO GREEN, show me the money!

I agree with the folks that are asking for more eco-friendly choices.
We voted for the metal roof because we have one and it has lasted through many storms.
The generator is a great idea too.
Thanks for letting us vote and share our opinions.

Hello again,
Someone else may have already addressed this; if so, let me add my two cents worth.

Could we possibly have a combination of counter top materials? I vote for soapstone, but think that a section of butcher block would be a great compliment to it. I can't believe that this would add to the cost significantly or make construction any more difficult. Also, many new custom homes offer a combination of different cabinet styles, ie., materials, colors, etc. For example, painted lowers and wood uppers - or a painted island. I think this contributes to a custom look.

Thanks for listening.

Unless I am missing something I would like to enter the contest or are we entered automatically when we vote, enjoyed the last cabin and will enjoy this one.

Natural Quartz on the counter tops would be ideal, as they do not collect germs and bacteria like other surfaces. They are equal in beauty to granite, but much more family friendly. A non porous counter is definitely a biggie in my opinion.

hi everyone,
what wonderful choices there are...the metal roof is always a plus..i live maine and there the best when it comes to snow!also contains the coolness in the summer.had a hard time choosing betweenj the granite and the marble both would look lovely in the arts and crafts kitchen which i think is awsomely perfect but a nice pice of butcher block would complete it.as for the shower couldnt the rain shower be combined with the power shower ?that cobble stone [as i would call it] fireplace is the bomb ! ive always been partail to them my gandmother had one in her home many years ago and they always seemed homey,oldfashion and cozy for a family get together.looking forward to the next choices....keep up th good work diy....i love your show....always gives me GREAT ideas and cures for my mistakes....have a good day bloggers !

You will never need to put me in the "hallway" for I am happy as can be with any of the choices! I do think it is great we get to vote and we are part of the decision making, and we get to learn the pros and cons about the choices through the blogs. Bravo to it all. I would be so honored to win this cabin regardless if something was chosen that I didn't prefer. It is a life long dream of mine and one of these days (hopefully sooner than later) I will be living in one!! How do you register to "win"??? Thank you

I had a few questions and comments.

1. You are putting that "cresent looking" window over the other front window and is that window being changed to match the set of all the other front views? It looks a little funny and off balance.

2. I would like to see a sink in the area across from the washer and dryer (to clean all the fish we are going to catch). Also some storage options for poles, life jackets and such things.

3.Would like to see access to the porch from the great room area (french doors w/the blinds in the glass and retractable screens-so no need for curtains and no taking away from the view-instead of windows).

4.Would like to see more than one window over the kitchen sink area.

5.Do not like the idea of carrying all the "dirty" clothes through the kitchen...maybe a laundry chute for the 2nd floor bedroom area.

6.Would like to "beef up" the front porch with maybe stone around the lower part of the columns.

Thanks for listening...Maria

HI Everyone,
I'm new at this,I just found the site the other day and have spent a lot of time looking at both the 2007 house and the current choices for this one. I see that some of the choices that people have voted on are the same as last year and I wondered about that. However, when I voted and then looked at the scores, I found that I was consistantly voting for the second choice compared to overall voting. My biggest disappointment there is that I have had soapstone counters and find that the texture and colors are so much better than what one gets with granite...Hey, but that's me.

I just found this site and the log cabin. I surely wish I had read the blog before I voted as I would have voted differently on the counters had I known more about the products. When does the contest to win the cabin start?

Hi Everyone,

Love the ideas that are coming out. And just so you know - many of us are researching the different materials being voted on since there are so many different sites that offer advice on all these choices as well as going green.

I like the suggestion of radient heat and the rain collection system both I think should be added. I also like the idea of plantings that can withstand draught conditions since you are going to see and hear about this more and more.

Remember that you can lose power and not only do you want heat, which the fireplaces can provide you need to keep food cold so a back-up generator is a must. Having a place to barbecue can help in a power outage since you still can cook - all things that you have to consider.

Maybe instead of having a fireplace on the Master Bedroom or Kitchen side of the house move this to out back instead adding a patio for an area to cook and entertain - this still could be covered! Just a suggestion.

Still want a hot tub though! This would be great on the deck outside the Master Bedroom. They are great in the winter months and for loosening those tight muscles after carrying wood for those fireplaces.

Having stairs off the back porch leading to the back area and waterfront would be nice. If the garage is on the side of the Kitchen than having steps in the middle of the porch would make it accessible to both the Kitchen and the Master Bedroom. Just another idea to throw out.

Like the idea of a finished basement. The last cabin ended up with a dirt floor - thought that with all the work and money at least the basement could have a cement floor.

Keep the ideas coming love reading them!

i have to agree about the idea of giving more info about the choices and letting people know and discuss the pluses and minuses of the choices before we are able to vote.

and i am not just saying this because all my choices are losing. :-)

no, it is because i feel people are losing site that this is a log cabin...ok, a very BIG cabin..at a lake and not just their 'dream' suburban house. all this laundry room talk. oh, for heavens sake! i am not going to the lake (in my dream, ok) to do laundry. yes, it will have to be done but it will not be my priorty. and these fancy cabinets and granite counters...how 'been there, done that'....another over sized McMansion in the making if we are not careful.

imho... ;-)

Hello Everyone,
This is my first time "blogging" and I didn't even know about the 2007 Blog Cabin. And no, I haven't been living in a cave, but I just recently got DIY network for the first time. It's my new favorite channel!!
So, I will give my 2 cents worth about home-building in general. First off, there is no need to be snippy with anyone here about there opinions on building materials. I am quite sure that the vast majority of people on here know what they are voting for when they vote. And besides, everyone is entitled to have an opinion.
Sorry, I just had to get that off my chest.
I love quartz countertops! They are beatiful and absolutely maintenance free and about the same cost as granite. Standing seam steel roofs are my choice. They are great looking on any type of home and last so much longer than any other roofing material and you don't kave to worry about snow buildup problems. I drill water wells and install water systems, so my natural choice for shower heads is the power shower. I would also like to see the an option at this cabin for a "Constant Pressure" water system. Here is a link for everyone to learn more about it.http://www.constantpressure.com/
Some solar PV panels would be nice too and a geothermal heat pump system for heating and cooling. And the geothermal system could be used to supply hot water to the radiant floor system. Here is a link for an excellent heat pump(I have one in my home)http://econar.com/
I have so many more ideas, but I will let you guys take a rest for now. If anyone has any questions about wells or water systems, you can contact me at maurer-drilling@centurytel.net

I too Think That the Pepole are missing it. CABIN Are RUSTIC Not top of the line finshes.
And as for the shower same thing.. not power shower.... just adding $$$$$ to the CABIN! the Cabin needs tobe low cost down to earth place. Just Think About Pepole....It's A CABIN NOT TOP OF THE LINE HOUSE>>>>>

I was hoping to see the recycled glass counter tops as an option as well. Unfortunately the paper composite option did not win out:( I am wondering when granite will fade out? Here in San Diego it seems like this is the norm in counter top upgrades. I am bored with this option for counter tops and would have liked to have seen more eco-friendly options. I think it would have complemented the log home near the lake. Thanks for the opportunity to blog it out:)

Granite is boring, metal roof is loud.... people have such boring taste in things these days. I'm sick of it. UPGRADE!

I only saw some of the episodes of the 2007 blog cabin, but I can imagine that there are some characteristics that are unique to log cabin building. While I agree with other bloggers that I would love to see some more exotic or maybe unconventional attributes, I would like this project to retain an overall, log cabin quality.
I would also like to echo others' comments about wanting to have an "eco friendly" home. I would like this project to stand out for more than just being a DIY house. I really would love to see this house pick up some of the local flavor of the region, and still be a showpiece for a "greener" home.
Can't wait to see more.

Hi DIY Bloggers:

Wow so many great comments you have made.

Metal roofs last for years and the noise is not as bad as some say. The sound of rain is relaxing. Last for years.

I was hoping that the voters would see that the recycled paper counter tops would be eco friendly and look good in the cabin. Granite YUK way to fancy. All the other counters you have to dig in the earth or cut down wood. Recyled paper is at least using the paper that came from trees.

I picked the rain shower because being disabled I might be able to use it.

Cabinets well I think all of them would be nice as long as they aren't real dark.

The ston around fireplace would be nice, but please keep stones smaller than last year.

I agree with Paula and Dwight, I know not everyone is disabled, but the disabled seem to be left out. A home or cabin in this case can be built friendly to both.

Okay enough ranting, chances or 1 in a million I would win.

Mary from Texas

Watson,

Thanks so much for answering my question about the square footage of the cabin. 2,600 square feet certainly qualifies as a BIG cabin.

Where are the other posters getting the information about the covenants etc. for the development?

if you do actually go so far as to centralize the fireplace to as to make a hearth access to the loft, consider adding a balcony off of the loft. well consider that anyway. something about a second story view over a lake that is also quite nice. of course, i would like this also to be screened.

In the world today, I think networks that highlight new hone construction of any kind are in a very powerful position to educate the public about the necessity of building homes as green as possible. Especially a cabin that's purpose is to offer people an opportunity to enjoy nature. Options like fireplace surrounds should be replaced by high efficiency wood burning stove options, for example. Please use your media power to influence builders and buyers in a more positive, eco-frindly way. Just because people are more familiar with features such as granite countertops and hardwood floors does not mean those are the best options out there for the world and consumers today. Many people have not ever seen Paperstone countertops, so they cannot be fairly represented as an option here.

Thanks for the opportunity to voice my opinion!
The future us green!!!!

I really enjoyed the two series of Blog Cabin 2008 last night. It was fun watching them install the power shower, and watching them try to see if a tub would fit in the upstairs bath (it wouldn't). The roof looks fantastic, as does everything else that's been done. I was glad that the home inspector gave them three stars because they don't have four stars!!! In other words, they are doing a spectacular job as usual. Is there a new address where we can go vote on the new items that aren't already installed (like the roof, logs and Power Shower, etc.?) I can't wait until this weekend when I get to see them working on the kitchen cabinets!!!! This is just so fun, my main reason for living right now! And as usual, may the most worthy blogger win! Good luck to us all. Cabincraver2008.

IT'S THE ROOF. I AGREE THAT METAL LASTS LONGER BUT WHY GREEN? DOES IT COME IN ANY OTHER COLOR? AND WHAT ABOUT WHEN IT RAINS. IS IT LOUD? I STILL THINK THE CEDAR SHAKES ARE NICER.

Hey Concrete and Soapstone fans, join the Quartz Qlub! And then VOTE, VOTE, VOTE! C'mon, we can steal this from the Granite Group!

BASEMENT -walkout/roughed in, GAS LOG STARTER -elec. ign., STRECH FLOOR PLAN -lgr MstBdrm, closets, Kitchen/Island, CHIMNEY/FIREPLACE in BSMT, CLEANOUTs in chimny, TILE FLUE in chimny, BOATHOSE/DOCK, STONE PATIO(S) -behind wkout bsmt and at shore/dock, HARDWOOD & TILE FLRS, 40" FRONT DOOR w/SIDELIGHTs -NO DBL DR, AWESOME LANDSCAPING -Dazzle us, AHMED! GARAGE -2 1/2 or 3

QUARTZ - COUNTRY - COMPOSITE CEDAR

I love all the great comments people are making. I would also like to see some more eco friendly options in this cabin. As nice as the 2007 cabin is, it would be nice to see more environementally friendly options. In particular, it would be greate to see some alternative power and heating and cooling options. I am just not sure what would be the most effective in that climate.

Thanks, Melanie, for the posted information on the paper countertops, that site (Richlite) was very informative. Also thanks for the posts for the composite roofing choices - note to Watson; maybe links to these sites can be added to the Blog Cabin web page? I agree with others that access to information makes for a more informed vote. I think I'll change my vote to quartz countertops next time - I don't want to have to refinish anything , ever (like granite) - the paper counters are OK, but I would be concerned about staining.
Dark metal roofs in the summertime are HOT - especially a black one as one person suggested - did y'all hear - they are HOT; and NOT in a good way. There is tremendous heat transfer, especially in a house plan like San Jacinto, where the ceiling of your great room IS the inside (bottom) of the roof - you can't get enough insulation to make it bearable - thus running up your air conditioning bills (and energy use...). My parents re-roofed their house from cedar shakes (real ones) to dark brown metal propanel, doubled the insulation, yet the house still heats up 20 degrees more than it did before in the summer - and they don't have air conditioning (they're in Colorado). It'll be 90 degrees or more in the house - you have to go outside to cool off. Composite cedar shakes would be the way to go, environmentally responsible, visually enhancing, cost effective, maintenance-free, and usually fire resistant.

I would recommend a walk-out (maybe unfinished) basement, since the lot is on a slope. Also, that will give you someplace for the garage to go (drive around the side and under).

For the fireplace, I recommend a metal "insert", that reflects heat, as well as upper and lower side vents in the stonework, that allow for maximum heat gain with a fire. This is something I have seen work very well, you could actually burn yourself on the heat coming out of the upper vent opening. The heat is retained by the metal insert, allowing for heat gain even after the fire burns down. And as you are using only room air, you don't lose heat up the chimney. Also, glass doors are needed on the fireplace so that you can close them after the fire burns down, and you can go to bed without all the heat in the house going up the chimney overnight (since you have to leave the damper open with smoldering embers in the fireplace). Also, place an ash clean-out trap door in the floor of the fireplace, so that you just sweep ashes into it, and they fall down inside the empty lower chimney structure. A swing clean-out door below (inside or outside the basement - although inside is better!) is necessary, although, in 30 years of use, we still can't see the level of our ashes in the chimney; it's not even anywhere near the level of the clean-out access.

I like the others' suggestions about cisterns for rainwater collection for yard watering (although you would have gotten damn all this year!). Gray-water recycling is also a great environmentally conscious idea, but you may be too close to the lake to be able to use it (there are usually restrictions about how close to streams and lakes that you can use recycled water).

Keep up the great posts! Oh, and for the last person who asked the square footage of the cabin, it was estimated in a previous post to be around 2600 sf.

Take care everyone.

I hope more people give their attention to the blogs on the difference between quartz and granite, I switched to quartz due to those blogs.

Metal roofs need a cistern for the run-off. It should be a simple addition.

I agree with many of the bloggers above...this home should be as green as can be! Recycled materials when possible, alternate power sources, a flash water heater, rain water collection for plant watering...etc.

You guys can use this cabin to showcase some of the awesome items available to consumers when it comes to building green.

thanks and keep up the great work!

Its always been a dream of mine to design and build a log cabin on a lake so this is the best! I only wish I could physically help build it. The choices being made seem to take advantage of the best features and modern touches. I agree with them since a modern cabin isn't just a rustic getaway anymore, its a full time convenient destination for an entire family. I can't wait to see what happens next!

Hi all,
I agree with other bloggers. Let's leave all the
2007 blog cabin options off and make a lakeside cabin. I can't wait to see all the options available and the majority of my choices came in second or third place so far. But I not giving up. This could be a great cabin.
A dock would be great with a solar charger for the lights and to charge the batteries for the boat.

This is my first post. Actually, only the second time I've ever "blogged". Anyway, I am still trying to think through all the options. So far, I think it is absolutely wonderful.

I love the idea of soapstone countertops with the arts n craft style cabinets!!!! I am very concerned about water conservation is one reason I chose the metal roof, makes it easier and cleaner to collect rain water and also helps the snow slide off easier! I have friends that have the power shower and it (theirs) does have a conservation style control on it. I also love the idea of a walk out basement, teenagers could have a game room down there and maybe I could manage a workshop space either there or in the garage!
I love reading all the blog entries so many good ideas, keep up the good work!!!!!
Marianne

I would also like to know about the paper counter tops, any information would be great. Has any thought been given to having solar panals? I have a friend with solar panels the is selling the excess.

8:14 PM EST on February 1st...and the most recent Blog posting showing is from 2:56 PM on January 31st.

Just sayin'.

After fighting with kids and hot water shortages. What about a hot water tank for the master bath? A frind of mine had their house built and it is beautiful! They had a 2nd tank put in for the master bathroom. That was so cool. The rest of the house runs off the main tank.

It's fun to vote for various features of this beautiful cabin, but I'm confused about something. How do you actually enter to win?????? Any input, anyone??? Thx!

Metal roof is a great plus, but I still would like to see a foot print of the house on the property!

I love the arts & crafts style, but other selections go better with "traditional" I think. Who decides if we slect compnents or styles that don't really go together? I was sorry to see the gas firplace also. I have had both and the natural is great for the first year, then it became too much work. Nothing beats flicking a switch and having a fire. Anyway, I enjoy voting and appreciate the opportunity to vote and comment. Thanks!

my daughter and i just lost our dog of 11 years. he was a dalmatian, named Nero. he protected, loved, and took care of us. we are trying so hard to find a place to live...a place to call our own. god willing we will soon find somewhere to call our own. i'm not a proud person if you can help please e-mail us at kimstown@yahoo.com. i have my daughter in theraphy. her father is a sob. kim

QUARTZ...QUARTZ...QUARTZ

There is no Maintenance on this material and it looks every bit as good as granite. Why is everyone so obsessed with granite??? QUARTZ is 100x better. Granite has varied veins and patterns but I don't want to have to worry about sealing it every 6 months or worry about discolorations over time.

This may be a "log cabin" but its no ordinary log cabin! I think we can stray a little from the "traditional" cabin makings and experiment. Thank you all for the great education - lot of brilliant bloggers here. So this has to be a minimum of 2600 sq ft - not exactly tiny. There is a lot of room to do something different. Composite slate shingles, soapstone or paper countertops (I don't know much about concrete but am very interested in it). Cabinets that don't need so much dusting - that was why I voted for the d-log to begin with!! Currently I have really different cabinets and love them. We couldn't afford to replace them so my husband & I sanded, primed, painted, applied 1 tiny stencil on each door then antiqued and sealed the whole shabang. We love them! I love imaginative details & I hope we take advantage of that opportunity. The power shower has lots of features - there must be a water saver built in one of its options - but really, w/all the opulence it offers who would really go for conservation! Why is there no hand held option for a shower head? Just a thought. And what about that garage? Did DIY get special permission to not have one?

I agree that before voting one should be able to review the differances in the choices on a preview page.

DIY, Thank you for your censorship. You have succeeded in driving away some good bloggers. I am sure you will sucker in a bunch of folks, as for me and some others we are tired of the censorship. Enjoy and happy people reading what you want them to read. Can you put mirrors on the ceiling?

Does everyone know that all the items that have been voted on and are still being voted on are already in a stage of installation from delivery to completion? Why are we still voting on work that is in the works? Where/what will the next vote be for? I can't wait to see it! The Power Shower is in, the green tin roof is on, the kitchen cabinets will be shown today at about 4:30 CST, I saw the granite being delivered but got interrupted because I had to fix dinner (I'm the only person who can cook apparently!) so I am really excited to see what our next choices are. It's so fun watching them put everything in! Also, they went to some local artisans and got stained glass covers for a window, and home made lye soap, and all of these fantastic craftspeople will soon be some of our neighbors! Won't that be FUN! We can maybe learn to do some of these things ourselves! If anyone has any news please update us! May the worthiest blogger win!

Love all the choices so far, but agree that a garage would be nice....also, will there be any storage areas?

Hi!
I lived in a log cabin in NJ while I raised my 3 children. The one thing I remember and this may be a moot point at this time, was the dust that accumulated on the ledges of the interior logs. If the logs in this home are all standard on the inside, this would not be a concern, however, if they are in their rustic state, it's rather like having to vacuum the walls of your home constantly, especially when there's a wood-burning stove (of which we had 3). Even though we had skylights and french doors in the home, lighter colors were superior in most choices as the homes can tend to be dark (we were surrounded by trees and it was a 'cabin', only 2 bedrooms and 1 bath). Our kitchen cabinets were oak which seemed to blend with the pine floors and ceilings; that worked fine because cherry or other materials seemed too ostentatious in a log home. Lighter countertop materials and tile in the kitchen helped immensely. Just my thoughts.

Judy

Pam WHO said capital letters are SHOUTING?

JUST WHO CAME UP WITH THAT NONSENSE!

A POLITICALY CORRECT SOMEONE?

GIVE ME A BREAK!

WHO GIVES A RIP?
THE WORLD WILL NOT COME TO AN END JUST BECAUSE I OR ANYONE USES CAPITAL LETTERS!

NO I AM NOT SHOUTING! I AM USING CAPITAL LETTERS! DUH!

IT IS VERY SAD & TIRING TO HEAR PEOPLE WHO CRITICIZE OTHERS FOR THE LEAST LITTLE THING!

I actually thought that this was supposed to be at least semi-green. I can't believe so many people voted for the power shower. I'd hate to pay their water bills. I voted for the low flow & the paper countertops. Since it is a log cabin I voted for the fake shakes. Now that I think of it the metal roof is great also.

The stone fire place has the rustic look for inside the cabin. How about the same look outside on the back porch. A stone Grill that can be used from the porch,if it rains or from the yard on nice days. Matching the two ideas would bring the inside out, and the outside in

I agree, Leanna. It certainly would be nice if we were to "switch it up" a bit. Deja vu, perhaps? Having lived in a log home for the past 15 years, there are certain "cookie-cutter" choices we shy from, such as the proverbial granite countertops, green roof and earth tones-abound!!
LIVE A LITTLE, BLOGGERS!!

If you want more information about the development go to the Lakefront Estates website (link on the blog cabin page). You can see pictures of every lot in the development. For more info send them a request and they will give you access to their "sales kit" containing prices and the covenants & restrictions document (parts in a previous post)

From reading the restrictions and the price list my opinion is this is planned as a high-end development. My guess is our blog cabin will stick out like a sore thumb, esp if red, purple, etc metal roofs are chosen (assuming the developer will even allow them).

There are 62 lots available. 35 are priced $300,000 -$500,000 (I round amounts up $100). 15 are $200k - $300k. The remaining 12 are $120k-$160k.

Someone spending that much for the "dirt" is going to put up a very NICE home. Not that I don't think our cabin isn't going to be very nice. I just think it may be a little "rustic" for this development. It will be interesting to see what the neighbors build.

I love the lake setting and this will be a beautiful home for some lucky winner. You bet I'll enter.

If metal roof wins out, I hope the design team looks hard at the products that look like a shake roof. I've changed my original vote from metal to composite shakes after reading some of the other blogs.

I agree with the post about putting the garage on the kitchen side of the house.

Walk out basement is great (homeowner can finish it out later). We have one in Ohio. Some of the lot pictures show rock outcroppings so excavation might be costly.

Tankless water heaters are a great idea. Someone mentioned unsightly propane tanks, I'll bet the homeowners assn requires it underground.

Deja-vu

Seems like last year all over again.

Metal Roof, Two Stories, Granite Kitchen Counter, Power Shower, Stone Surround on the fire place, wood burning...

Not that I mind at all, since I vote for most of the options myself.

I can't help but wonder, couldn't next year (and I hope that there is a next year) include things like:

1. Energy source: Wind and Solar or Grid Only or Subterranean Heat Exchange

2. Recycled counter tops only: Recycled Paper and Concrete, Recycled Glass and Concrete, or Recycled Hard Wood.

3. Wood Finishing for door jams and maybe even floor: New cut, Recycled from Anywhere USA, Local Recycled

4. Water Saving Feature: Low Flow Toilet, Low Flow Shower, Water Reclamation Tank, Hot water recycle pump (select two)

You get the idea, move main stream love of features into eco friendly choices. It can still be the blog cabin.

Leanna, I agree a log cabin at the lake should be comfortable, homey, and to a certain extent rustic. Think about the total package. The soapstone counters fit with the natural feel of a cabin.
I've been wondering about the garage myself, where can all the fishing equipment be stored??

I think some elements belong in a log home. I hate looking at some log homes that have a contemporary style. It just doesn't belong. The metal roof is noisy, but if you insulate well that problem should be diminished. The color choices of the metal roof should be given as an option for later (since it looks like this choice is going to win). A stone fireplace belongs in a log home and should be the focal point in the great room. Granite countertops are beautiful, but they don't belong in a log home. A rain shower would be a nice inclusion to the master suite. A basement gives you shelter from storms and extra room to hide all of the mechanicals as well as extra storage and entertaining area. A mud room in the back foyer area is a must for a cabin at the lake. Putting the basement stairs near the mud room gives you an area to put your fishing poles and other outdoor recreation items for easy clean up and storage.
Building 'green' also can enhance the value of the cabin; there are many new materials being developed for building new homes. This is a home made of logs and should reflect nature and respect for mother nature as much as possible.
Yes, this is an upscale community but please don't use that to diminish the 'cabin by the lake' that it really is. Natural materials and eco friendly materials really belong in this home. Modern conveniences should also play a factor, but they should be downplayed as to not take away from that 'cozy' cabin by the lake feeling. A tankless water heater, a built in generator system, a hot tub in the master suite area, a office area by the kitchen are all convenience features that should be incorporated. This cabin should have the best of both worlds.
Just a few thoughts to consider...

Hi Everyone,

Love the ideas that are coming from everyone. I like the idea of having the basement roughed out as far as a cement floor the last cabin had a dirt floor and didn't understand why a cement floor wasn't put in. This way you can add a family/game room or more sleeping areas. I have a problem though with the suggestion to have hook-ups for a bathroom in the basement. Basement bathrooms are more problems - back-up from sever lines, freezing pipes, etc., headaches - headaches - headaches galore! Anyone from the northern states will tell you what that is like in the winter when the sever pipes back up into the basement! Get exercise walk up the stairs to the bathroom instead.

After seeing the tips on the countertops have switched my vote to quartz instead of marble. I like butcherblock but will always have a problem with having these in a house because of germs - just like having a wooden chopping block!

Would still like to see a hot tub off the Master Bedroom on the deck. Seems everyone is having a problem with the fireplace on that side of the house - how about moving the fireplace to the back of the house (not attached) as part of a patio instead - just a suggestion/idea - like to see what others are thinking for suggestions on this since many seem to have a problem keeping it on the Master Bedroom side of the house. It may not be able to be placed on the kitchen side if that is where the garage is going. Think of a set of stairs going off the back porch right in the middle or by the kitchen with a nice patio area there - could be covered for protection like a mini pavalion area!

The cabin needs a back-up generator. That would solve the problem with power outages for heat and storing food. You can always barbecue for cooking. I don't like the idea of gas for the fireplace otherwise I would have voted for it in the first round - still don't want it especially for an outside fireplace unless propane for barbecuing. The main fireplace in the Living Room/Great Room would throw a lot heat if needed for heat as well.

Like the ideas of water retention systems and solar panels for energy - keep thinking green. Recyling water anyway we can is terrific. Maybe we could recycle the water for radient heat floors???

Would like to see a patio outback with a barbecue area instead of having a barbecue area on the porch area. Would like to see the porches screened in this would enable the winner to have guests expecially children sleep on the porch during those hot summer months if they wanted or furniture so you can enjoy those wonder days/nights during the spring, summer and early fall! A hammock would also be nice to have.

Love all the suggestions and ideas coming from everyone - keep them coming. I also agree that DIY should be responding to some of the questions being posted by bloggers

Don't know if this will help everyone but on the DIY website are a list of who the vendors were for the 2007 Blog Cabin - this may help or give you some ideas from what they did last year.

Here is the site: http://www.diynetwork.com/diy/pac_ctnt_988_leader/text/0,2829,DIY_26336_64007,00.html

One more thing - we need a tankless water heater for this cabin - this is a must if we want to save water and cut down on the utility bill!

I like the Arts & Crafts with the wood beams. It would be cool if there could be the European Country with the beams :)

Hi Everyone,

I found this information on "About.Com" on countertops. I thought it might be useful for those that had questions. Might help everyone determine what type of countertop to vote for in this Cabin.

Granite Counters
Granite is the countertop material of choice when there are no other things to think about - like money. It defines elegance in a kitchen. As the use of granite becomes more widespread, the price comes down. The beauty of the stone contributes to the beauty of even the most modest kitchen.
Pros: holds up to heat; comes in a range of beautiful colors; looks permanent and substantial; will last a lifetime; has a high value to home buyers.
Cons: very expensive but it's becoming more affordable as it becomes more widely used; requires considerable maintenance, including periodic sealing; absorbs stains; can crack if stressed; somewhat limited range of colors available, though again, more become available all the time.

Engineered Stone
Engineered stone is composed of 93% quartz particles. It is available in a larger range of colors than granite and has a nonporous surface that resists scratches. It's easy to maintain, without the annual sealing required by natural stone. Some brands on the market include DuPont Zodiaq®, LG Viatera®, Cambria Quartz, and Silestone®.
Pros: Resistant to stain and acid; easy care.
Cons: Expensive.
More Info

Solid Surface
Because solid surface counters are just what they're called, solid, any scratches can be sanded out. The countertops are custom-made to your specifications by companies such as Avonite, Corian, and Swanstone.
Pros: comes in a rainbow of colors and patterns; seamless; stain resistant.
Cons vulnerable to hot pans and stains which can damage the surface; can be moderately expensive.
More Info

Wood or Butcher Block
Wood countertops offer a beautiful warm look and are available in a wide range of colors and finishes. Hardwoods such as maple and oak are most often used as countertop woods.
Pros: easy to clean; smooth; can be sanded and resealed as needed.
Cons: can be damaged by water and stains over time; scratches must be oiled or sealed according to manufacturer's instructions.
More Info

Soapstone Counters
Soapstone is generally dark gray in color and has a smooth feel. It is often seen in historic homes but is also used in modern homes as both a countertop and sink material.
Pros: rich, deep color; smooth feel; somewhat stain resistant.
Cons: requires regular maintenance with applications of mineral oil; may crack and darken over time.
More Info

Marble
Because of it's extremely high price tag, marble is not often seen on the countertops of whole kitchens. To get the luxurious look, use it on an island or inset at a baking center. Marble requires constant maintenance, as it easily stains. Some new sealers retard staining.
Pros: waterproof; heatproof; beautiful.
Cons: expensive; porous; stains easily unless professionally sealed; can scratch; may need resealing periodically as per manufacturer.

Concrete Counters
If you have countertops in unusual shapes, concrete may be a good choice, as they're often cast right in your kitchen. The high price tag may be beyond most people's budget.
Pros: heat and scratch resistant; can be color-tinted; looks exotic and unusual; new treatments eliminate cracking; additives reduce porosity; new finishes are more decorative.
Cons: mid to high range on cost due to custom work; cracking is possible; can look somewhat industrial; porous but can be sealed.

Good luck!

I haven't voted in a few days and was excited to see how things were going. Unfortunately some of my choices are not doing so well. I like the style of the European Country cabinets. My second choice would be the Arts & Crafts cabinets. However, are the pictures shown the colors that will be in the cabin? And for the countertops are these the colors that will be used? I have seen several questions in the different blogs regarding information such as this but I have not seen any answers. Have I overlooked them? The other bloggers give great info but of course there is no way for them to know the specifics that will actually be used in building the cabin.

My husband and I definitely would love to own this log cabin or any log cabin for that matter. The San Jacinto plans are very similar to ones we picked out if we ever build one. Of course we preferred the porch go all the way around the house; with a screened in part off the kitchen area.

It's exciting to see the cabin begin to take shape. I didn't know about the voting in time last year to vote but am enjoying having an input in this one. When does the actual construction on the cabin begin and when will the show air on DIY?

Although I'd love to win this cabin, I'd have to agree with whawkins that this seems to be a repeat from last year. Same plan, same roof, etc. I think the choices need to be more in reference/relation to the surrounding area with emphasis on being Green. Otherwise, why bother voting?

Wow you have provided great choices to vote on this round. I would suggest for those wanting more info on these choices to do some research yourself, after all if you are voting you have the internet at your disposal. I roofed a house in '77 with cedar shakes that are still turning the water today, although they have weathered considerably and look grey now. About any roof will last 30 years with today's technology, provided it is installed right. But if you really want durability go with metal or slate in my opinion. Can't wait until we get to see this years show. Looks like the cabin is coming along nicely on "paper" Blog Cabin Rocks!

Grace, thank you for the helpful information. I hope more people educate themselves on options for countertops, roof, etc. before voting. There are so many new materials out there that may be better than what we've used for years.
Ultimately, whether it's granite countertops or soapstone, it's gearing up to be a fabulous cabin in an exceptional area.

Can I chime too? The kitchen, (Sorry it's what I do, I design and sell kitchens, so I guess I know a bit more then the average blogger here.) Counters - Quartz all the way, (Yes, it should be Silestone) low care and look great! Not only do you not need to seal them (ever!) they clean up with normal house hold cleaners. Unlike granite, or concrete for that matter, they are heat AND cold tolerant. Yes, you can put a bag of ice on it and then a hot pot in the same spot with out fearing the counter will crack. There are also lots of great color choices.
Cabinets - while the A&C look nice it could end up looking like a regular shaker cabinet if the cabinet doors are too small, the cabinet companies will only add the center rail on doors larger then 18". I'm not sure what the size of the kitchen is on "our" floor plan, but I went with the "traditional" (shaker) door, again there are tons of color and wood choices here. There are also a number of different doors that would fall into this choice. One cabinet company I work with has four doors in Maple alone (birch, oak, hickory, and cherry too but not all the same).
Will the flooring in the kitchen "flow" in from the dinning area? or will it be a distinct change?
My choices for some of the other picks this time out... Brick for the fireplace, I do like the idea of rock outside.....
slate for the roof, come on we did metal last time and this is a bit more upscale this year.

Looking forward to the next set of choices and one heck of a log cabin when this is all said and done.

Well getting to vote on someone elses log home is great. After building one from scratch myself, you learn a few things. Like changing your mind on what you used for roofing,fireplace and heat up here in New York.

I would like to see a slate roof as they look great and last almost forever. Fireplace stone is a must, Square and rectangle stone would look better than the round field stone everyone likes to see. Heat, I think ya gotta go with radiant floor with boiler/wood back up.

Look forward to seeing what others vote for and how the place turns out. Keep up the good work.

I think the idea of giving us the info on the items we are voting on a week in advance is head on. I'm sure a lot of folks don't know what the difference is between items. I've never heard of a power shower & would like info on it. The items we are voting on sure are making this cabin look like last year. It would help if we knew what the color choices were going to be before voting on an item.

Dear Bloggers,

I really do not think that anyone is reading the blog before voting. Looking at the results of the votes it appears that people are voting for the same old thing.

Please keep in mind that this is a up scale neighborhood. There are options other than the traditional for this log cabin. I have voted for the ceadr composite roof. I have had first hand experience with a tin roof. It is not one of my most pleasant memories. Tin roofs are loud when it rains or heaven forbid it should sleet or hail. Tin roofs are loud they do not soothe.

As for the cabinets I voted for the European country something different but will go with the log cabin interior just fine. Along with quartz countertops.

I wish that everyone would stop and think before voting. Research the options.

I hope we have the choice of radiant heat on the floors.
Thanks for listening.

Debbie G.

Yikes! With the lot at about $200,000 (or more) and the house approximately 2600 sq ft..cost of construction $175 -$200 per sq ft(?) ...seems as though we are gettng to the point it might be a challenge for the lucky winner to be able to keep the cabin. That would be a heartbreaker!

Please No granite countertops. They may look good and be so exclusive and expensive but, if you need repairs it's costly. And they chip so easily. Please no "tile pieces". There is only one functional great product and that is the QUARTZ countertop. Its cost effective, easy to maintain and virtually break and chip proof. For the cabinets being selected these fit really well and granite does NOT! I expect a back-up generator unit is going to be installed to accommodate the "power shower", hope so. That would be interesting to see and set a specific temperature. The metal roof being the best for the environment. They have added drainage and insulating qualities if done right. Good job Blog cabin team.

I Love the soapstone countertop option. Easy to maintaine and ages so beautifully. As long as we have water saving options on the shower lets go for the power. We do love our creature comforts but we can be planet friendly too. The area is beautiful. We are planning our retirement within the next ten years and hopeing to build our own log home. We're taking notes just in case we aren't the lucky winners lol. I agree with a previous blogger that a portion of the porch should be screened or glassed in. The mild seasons must be enjoyed and there is no better place for a morning or evening cup of coffee than a porch over looking the water.

Is there any way to place the tub in the master bath inside a bay window instead of just the square box?

Regardless of all the negitive comments I have read I believe this house is what I would love to call my own... Both my wife and agree with most, but not all, of the choices, but we would still love to watch this house become a home to someone (like us of course).
We would like to see a two car garage and have the second fireplace either glassed in or made usable in could weather...
We really liked the outdoor fireplace at the first house in addition to what you have designed so far...

Me again, even though I didn't see my other comment posted...not for sure if doing this correctly.

I just wanted to add that INFO on the choices would be so much appreciated and helpful. I believe you then wouldn't see as many votes for the "common" choices then.

Also, how to register to win?

OMG I am watching the cabinets go in and the making of the table! I LOVE IT~!! that table is awesome!

Denise

Hi Watson,

AWESOME! I got to VOTE again. THANK YOU!!! I'm so excited! I only wish I could hammer a nail or cut a piece of wood or something. But since I can't Voting will do...

Soapstone was my choice for the countertops and European Country cabinets would look great, lets get some style in that kitchen. The other cabinet choices are to plain.

Loved the Power Shower and Stone has to be the best choice for the fire place, it's so rustic but yet sooo inviting...

I had a really hard time choosing the roof material though. Before I even saw the choices I thought of the Cedar Shakes but thought that the color of the roof and the house itself would be to similar and maybe look washed out. I'm not a big fan of Metal Roofs, but I do like the idea of color that stands out. If any of the other choices can be done in a color other than a Grey or Brown Tone I would change my vote. But as far as the house plan goes, IT'S GREAT! No complaining here. Keep up the good work.

And I know that whatever the choices will be for this Cabin, that you will do the best job in its construction and that the end result will be a safe and inviting HOME!

Whatelse can I say...BLOG CABIN IS AWESOME!

I am a first timer, and not exactly sure how everything works. I was wondering who picks out the colors of countertops, roof, cabinets, etc. Do we get a vote on this or only the style? There are some great alternatives to the green standard metal roof. My personal favorite is a pre rusted metal roof that gives a very rustic look.

We agree with the few rebels posting here, we have voted for the soapstone counters, synthetic slate shingles, and the rain shower... How great would that be... to play in the rain when the sun is shining? We are a bit worried about the water consumption though, we reside in NC and know well what a drought can do.

Ok guys it seems like the metal roof is winning! so, how about a different style of metal roofing instead of just the regular same o stuff....... I've seen many different styles: haven't you?

What if.... Some of the suggestions offered by the Bloggers were offered as the Options for the next round of voting!

I have been amazed by the number of outstanding, well thought out and researched suggestions/features/products/ideas for the 2008 cabin that have been contained in the Blog.

I, for one, would like to have a way to see some of them come to fruition in the 2008 Blog Cabin.

What do you say.... Is there a chance that We As A Group could suggest to the DIY Cabin Team to offer some of those items (that meet the development's requirements) as the Options to be Voted On next time around?

I can think of a least a half dozen items that, once posted, generated a lot of interest and were considered as great ideas. It would be a shame if nothing ever comes of them.

You probably have your favorites, too. Wouldn't it be great to see them have a chance to become a Vote Option for the 2008 Blog Cabin!

They have metal roofs in shake styles, slate styles, clay looking roof tiles, regular looking shingles and etc, etc. Many different colors & styles! Same energy efficiency, with the soothing rain rhythm, I personally love, Easy rain collections, snow melts off tin better than real shingles too, and the tax breaks.

If someone is planning on building a home for themselves to enjoy with family and friends for years to come, some research and speaking with different contractors would be the first thing they would do. The home builder has been picked along with the house plan. As the process proceeds, options are presented. Anyone building a home would pick the options available based on ease and comfort, not value and bling. Unless a person is planning on selling the home if they win, they will research the options available and vote, not vote for the most expensive option presented. Is everyone who voted for granite counter tops ready to pay every six months for the maintainance involved? Are you prepared for the water bill and power bill that will come with a power shower and all that hot water? Are you prepared to cut, bust and stack wood for the wood burning stove, or buy wood? I would never vote on something that would cause someone else a hardship as this home may be a second home and all the upkeep will wear a person out. Sure we all want nice things and bling, but once presented with all the facts involved with really nice things, would we end up choosing the nicest or most expensive? Nope, that's just not realistic, only the hope of extra equity.

Thank you Dyi for letting me vote, it's been alot of fun. No complaints here, actually feels like I have had a little part in the building process. The Cabin is turning out great!!! better then great!!! Just think somebodies going to be a very lucky winner in the future. Good luck to everyone and Thank you DYI...

I hope the deck goes all around the house. Make it with a wide place to put a hot tub outside the Master Bedroom.
This house should have lots of big windows and sliders to get good views of the scenery.
I had a problem making up my mind on the Kitchen. Looked like way to different floor plan. But it is nice to have some of the Butcher Block in a work area. All Butcher Block would be an over kill I think after looking it over. Maybe a sky light in the kitchen.
A nice built in tub upstairs next to the shower.
Also French Style windows upstairs.
Just my thoughts.

Hey everyone,

I live across the lake and a bit down the shoreline from this years blog cabin location. BEAUTIFUL area! Someone asked earlier about the water levels. Not sure if this has been answered or not, but the answer is, it varies. Some places along the shoreline are year round deep water, others are not and the water level of the lake drops about 6 feet in the winter. In the winter months, our dock is completely out of the water, but we don't mind. We're not going to spend time on the lake in the winter anyway.

We actually don't get much snow here, so an open outdoor patio would be great. We just have a couple of weeks worth of really cold weather here. For instance, we were in the 30's last week, but it was over 50 here today and will be 68 on Tuesday. I would LOVE to win this, as I know so many others would. My husband and I have been looking for land to build on around here for so long. We want to sell our place on the lake in exchange for life in the woods, but this would be great with a wooded lot AND on the lake and so close to home to boot. Best wishes and good luck to everyone.

Blessings,
Lisa

OK now I'm sorry I voted for the metal roof ! It was a knee jerk reaction to a log cabin, and I did take into consideration the location - where you dont expect snow. Snow and metal roofing dont mix well without snow arresters installed. Yes I agree that the choices seem the same....... BUT ! It IS a log cabin, and how different is one log cabin from another? The blogger who said flat sided logs with chinking is absolutely right ! Although this was not offered as a choice. That looks so much more authentic than the neatly manicured log kit type homes.
I did vote for soapstone and I stand by it. Granite is SO LAST WEEK ! Sick and tired of it already. Use materials that show a little grit, a little wear, some Chutzpah ! I hope none of the floors will be carpeted - and YES YES YES to radiant floor heating ! Think "allergies" so many have them - radiant flooring is great for that. As is the stringent use of carpeting.
I hope Slate Tile will be a choice for tiled areas. Please NO TRAVERTINE ! Save that for Malibu.
The location of the washer and dryer is AWFUL. My own home had that for a location and I made a change immediately ! Who wants people stepping thru piles of laundry on their way in or out? I sure dont.
At least one of the porches should be screened - my first thought is the extended one with the outside fireplace. Tennessee isn't immune to bugs !
I think I would eliminate the counter eating peninsula entirely. It disrupts the traffic flow, the view is to the kitchen, not the lake, and the dining area doesnt seem that large anyway. Let there be more space in the actual dining area.
Maybe a small round table at counter height in the kitchen, where the cook could sit to peel potatoes etc while feasting on the view.
It would be wonderful if the Master Bedroom layout could be adjusted so that the (KING!) bed could face the lake view as other bloggers have suggested. Isn't that part of the package when you live somewhere with a view? Reconfigure the closets and the bath to enable this. I wonder if anyone would really use the front of the house bump out for a soaking tub. Perhaps a compromise could be reached for a combo tub/shower unit, partially recessed into the floor with some sort of safe and secure way to get into it.
As another blogger said - one of my own core beliefs - is that a new home should be built for one story living with openings wide enough for a wheelchair. Enabling us to live in our own home for as long as possible, not to mention the possibility of a short term injury or surgery where we need help maneuvering.
The style of the arts and crafts cabinets is "ok" but it just gets to be TOO MUCH WOOD ! That's why I chose the painted cabinets to break up the textures and colors.
Offer sinks in wall hung vintage styles, and also offer vintage bronze finishes. THINK RUSTIC
Ill be back !

I agree with many of you that this is looking to be a repeat of 2007. I would like to see something a little different. The metal or slate roof seem a bit more practical. I like the brick fireplace. You just don't see them that often anymore. There are a lot of places to get recycled bricks. I think the soapstone would make a more appealing countertop to me, the marbling of the stone is wonderful.

I think for future voting options they shouldn't include the ones that were picked for the 2007 cabin.

So far all the choices have been great, but I'm still interested in the idea of a full basement. I know not many homes in TN have basements but that added feature adds space, storage, and a good place to chase the grandkids off to play when the weather gets nasty. Does anyone else thinks a basement would be a good idea?

Sa 9:32 CST 2/02
Think we need Sherlock Holmes to track down Watson. No blogs posts since Th afternoon 1/31 2:56

Watson, I just recently found this thread thanks to a blogger at the other site (Clive), and I'm glad I did! I like your "tude", and I'm looking forward to what Ahmed has to say also.

I have been watching repeats of last years cabin thinking that they were this year's. See, at the beginning of the contest I was diagnosed with an illness that kept me tied up for quite some time with surgeries, hospitals, weekly treatments, etc., so I think I got to watch about the time they were building the outdoor fireplace! So ignore everything I've said about items already being installed; however, items have already been voted for and have obviously won the vote, so bickering over things is really moot at this point! I just can't wait to see the next voting round, and I can't wait to hear from Ahmed and start watching the new cabin come together! I love Amy and she is great; but Ahmed is funny and smart and I think will make a great host for this years little cabin in the woods! Again, may the worthiest blogger win and have a lovely Sunday.

Cabincraver2008

Hello family.
I have thought about the noisy roof and thought about some re roofs that i have seen. They could put insulating foam under the metal to deaden the sound. But I have changed my opinion to the shake roof style because I too saw the log cabin under the roof, oooops. The green team is really turning up the heat wow.

I think diy is in a learning position right now and we should let them digest all of our changes to their blog, not their blog home. I am sure that the cost of a power web publisher could cost as much as our changes. Maybe that is why they dont have all of the choices shown on a log home.

If I won this it would be a rental/vacation home for me because the only way it would pay for the property tax's and electricity, food gas cloths etc. etc. would be for me to continue working. When I framed houses for a living I always joked that they told me I could build as many as I wanted but just dont try to live in a nice house. The Pay is not very good for the hard manual labor, w/ weather days off/no pay, sick days /no pay, take your kids to doctor/no pay, no health insurance(most of the time not even offered). Then you see a realtor in his mercedes benz even though he couldn't build a dog house. One time i was working on a large multi-story commercial building, we went to the banks break room to buy some snacks before returning to our floor. This office lady said "those nasty filthy construction workers need to stay away from us". I thought what if she didnt have us filthy construction workers and she had to put her desk under a tree outside with no heat or air, and an extension cord for her computer if she would appreciate us more. sorry I was on a roll, this is my God given talent but very few appreciate us.

Watson, I just recently found this thread thanks to a blogger at the other site (Clive), and I'm glad I did! I like your "tude", and I'm looking forward to what Ahmed has to say also.

I have been watching repeats of last years cabin thinking that they were this year's. See, at the beginning of the contest I was diagnosed with an illness that kept me tied up for quite some time with surgeries, hospitals, weekly treatments, etc., so I think I got to watch about the time they were building the outdoor fireplace! So ignore everything I've said about items already being installed; however, items have already been voted for and have obviously won the vote, so bickering over things is really moot at this point! I just can't wait to see the next voting round, and I can't wait to hear from Ahmed and start watching the new cabin come together! I love Amy and she is great; but Ahmed is funny and smart and I think will make a great host for this years little cabin in the woods! Again, may the worthiest blogger win and have a lovely Sunday.

Cabincraver2008

I am confused AGAIN! Lakeview Estates Lake is a reservoir lake. It is not a development where they are building, so if the cabin is on Lakeview Estates Lake, where on the lake is it? I have been researching Lakefront Estates on Watts Bar Lake near Spring City. This lake is huge, deep, and Lakefront Estates has 55 lakefront lots, 10 interior lakview lots that use the multi-boat dock. There are two houses built there right now. One is a one story and the other is a one story but has a walk-out basement. Could someone please let me know which place is correct? Because on the page of photos I saw a heading that reads: Lakefront Estates Photo Gallery. I have been talking to Marty at Lakefront Estates and she says Watts Bar is a huge, deep lake and personal boat docks are allowed. I did not ask for the minimal square footage but she mailed me a package and I will review it and pass on any pertinent information to any blogger that is interested. I have a feeling that they are not building at the reservoir, but are building in Lakefront Estates on Watts Bar Lake, Spring, TN which is close to Knoxville, and a bit further to Nashville or Georgia. Here is the address if anyone wants to take a look. Happy blogging and goodnight for now! Cabincraver2008

http://www.lakefrontestates.net/

some things are the same as 2007 but thoses were the best things so i can see why everyone is voting for them but i was surprised that they voted for the metal roofs instead if cedar. it really surprised me! it will all look great though i know what a great job you did last time and all the love amnd team work i can't wait until it's done :)

Most of my votes have been for things that are low maintenance or allow isolated survival in emergencies. For example I voted for the wood-burning fireplace. You wouldn't want your only source or heat to be reliant on the power grid or gas lines.

I like the idea someone posted above for a cistern to collect rain water from the roof. Even if it's normally only used to water the landscape it would help reduce water usage and make the cabin more "green" as well as serving as an emergency water source. I'd personally like to see the house on a well rather than city water.

How about solar panels to supplement grid power or heat water? There also is such a thing as a solar pre-heater for the hot water which uses solar energy to warm the water before it goes into the heating system, thus requiring less power to heat it to usable temperature. At night or during bad weather of course the regular system has to shoulder the whole load, but the pre-heater can significantly reduce power usage for water heating when the sun is up. Combined with a tankless water heater the savings should be substantial.

Lastly, I agree we should try different things than the last cabin. It was great but I don't think we want an exact duplicate. I voted for soap stone because I thought the butcher-block counter tops would be too much wood but that we needed something different than granite. Soap stone seemed to fit the bill.

I know I said goodnight, but something about this cabin has me "hooked" (pardon the pun!). I just thought everyone would enjoy this:

Lot Number: 5

Address: Shoreline Drive

Lot Size: .72 acres

Lot Description: A gently sloping, beautifully wooded home site with a great view across the lake towards a small island.

Information provided is general in nature. Lot purchaser must review final plat and engineering drawings for specific detailed information regarding each plot.

For more information, including a property price list, please contact Lakefront Estates.

Also, I checked out the photo tour, and very plainly on the front gate and all the signs and in the copy it says Lakefront Estates, Watts Bar Lake, Spring, TN. It is gorgeous and we are so lucky to have DIY do this for one of us!!! Also, I am very relieved that it isn't a reservoir since we have a reservoir where I live and you can't swim or fish and what's the point??? Really, truly, goodnight fellow bloggers!

If you build it for me, The cabin should have
a rustic quality, Not that I don't like the best.
But here's what I suggest. It should blend
to the surrounding area, It should be inviting
with simplicity and modern upgrades. And when
comparing one to another, cost vers beauty will
always matter. living in relaxed comfort with nature.
And user friendly,
With a loft you can find some extra space.
If that suits your taste.

Something else just occurred to me, based on the Covenants and Restrictions:

Each house in this development MUST have a large 2-car garage, and the floor plan doesn't show a garage.

Detached garages must be pre-approved by the HOA.

What sort of garage are they going to build to meet the CC&Rs?

i guess the more i see the fireplace in the plans and pictures and so-forth the better of a idea it becomes

I was born and raised in NY state and have spent many, many weekends in the Adirondack region enjoying the outdoors. For those who have never visited the Adirondack area much of the scenery is similar to that of the site chosen for this years cabin.

After visiting my first Adirondack Great Camp I was in awe. I've had the pleasure of seeing several others since that first visit. They were inspiring for me as it relates to voting on what the 2008 cabin could look like with a roof other than metal.

For those who have never visited a great camp you might want to visit this link: http://www.aarch.org/santanoni/santanoni.html OR http://www.greatcamps.com/tourslides/great_camps_tour_1.htm

If you have further interest you could also do a basic search for Adirondack Great Camps and find much more information.

The inside of these camps have wooden counter tops that still look incredible. If you look at some of the cabins in the links I included in this blog these cabins have stair and porch railings, molding around the windows, as well as designs on the doors made out of branches. These branches came off the trees that were cut down to build the cabin. Burls were also used when designing these cabins.

After being built the 2008 cabin would become somewhat of a modern day great camp with all the wonderful features selected by the general public. It would be nice to see the new cabin include some of the features of those old magnificent great camps.

I'm quite sure there are many magnificent cabins in the woods all around the country. Those old cabins in the woods, regardless of what part of the country they are found, is where it all began.

Thanks DIY for giving us the opportunity to dream and to offer our opinions.
I can't wait to see the cabin finished.

Please Please re-think the Roof Guys and Gals! Why a Metal Loud Noisy and easy damaged Roof(when it rains, sleets, hails, snows, etc.! I plan on winning this Cabin and I really would like A Cedar Roof!
Please, all you experts on building, say something! We really gotta change this!

I just discovered the Blog Cabin, it is awesome, and they picked a beautiful area to build 2008 cabin. But now I have an obvious question ( to most of you) how the hell do I enter to win the 2008 cabin? Thanks, Solent

The rain shower option has a hand held sprayer - thats what I want! I would like to see something different in this cabin from the last one. I agree with all of you who are thinking creatively. Currently I have granite counter tops & I love them - show me something new in the new cabin! How about concrete? I have to admit I love a stone fireplace - but why can't it be river rock? Well, I hope this has some impact. I have to admit that its frustrating at times but it'll be up to Ahmed and the builders to pull it all off. Good luck!

Well I think alot of us are rethinking our choices. I know I have. I am now voting for quartz counter top instead of granite. The fact that it is nonporous is the reason. With germs and virus in this day and age, it is a very important factor for me. I've been checking the results of the voting and it looks like quartz is trying to catch up to win. So lets keeps voting and hope for the best. One think that I would love to see is larger dormers and larger windows. It would be really nice to see book shelves on each sides of the windows with a window bench to store things. Happy Blogging!!! :-)

You should add a detached matching garage. Where else would you store the kayaks, canoes, jet skis, yard equipment, and all the other stuff you would use on a lakeside property?

Hi, It's wonderful to be apart of blog cabin, I look forward to voting on all the choices. When we start thinking about the outside of the cabin maybe we could consider a fence around the cabin with lots of gates for easy access. I have three puppy dogs that would love to run around the property. Also, a fence would keep small children from wandering to close to the lake.
Thanks for listening,
Mary

I've read comments regarding the washer and dryer location and wanted to know, what is the room across from the washer and dryer, a pantry? It would be nice if the wall was bumped out into the deck are, allowing the interior kitchen area to be made larger and still have a really nice pantry area and a room for the washer and dryer, rather than it being in a closet. I also agree that adding windows to the great room area on the 2nd floor area would make for an impressive look from the back of the house, and also allow for a lot of additional light.

I am also surprised that they did not provide links to research the various choices. After all the links may help sell the products to those of us not lucky enough to win the cabin.

I will be buying a house in the next six month. It would be nice to be able to have a link to look more closely at the various choices.

Wouldn't it be fun if they got Bobby Flay, Emeril, Mario, or one of the chefs from their sister network discussed the advantages/disadvantages of each counter and kitchen style? As someone who likes to pretend she can cook, it would be great to hear from the experts. Of course links on where to buy, how to get the most (longevitywise) out of each would also be nice.

they could do somethng similar for the other choices as well.

Okay, This comment is more the the website people than about the cabin. WHY are none of my posts being posted. If I am doing something wrong then please let me know. I did notice since last time I tried to post that there is another Jeanette. Is that the problem????? I realize new posters are held until approved, but at this rate the thing will be built before I get my thoughts heard. Please let me know. Loving the cabin, and very much want to be a part of all of it.

I'm new here today and just got done voting. I certainly hope there will be a design coordinator- as the house "built by committee" will be a mish-mosh of competing elements. Certainly doesn't seem to have anything like a theme so far...

But it does show something about "us", the "democratic designers":
We certainly seem to embrace "earthy friendliness" until it comes to something that touches us personally- ergo the power shower. We all seem to know what we should do (or what everyone else should do) but we won't do it ourselves. Especially if "power" is part of its name.
Hard to believe ANYONE would choose the arts & crafts kitchen- though the style name is good- it does look like something that would end up being sold at a flea market.
...a mild lesson- wood goes with stone which goes with slate which can go with traditional or contemporary...just an opinion.

I am not sure if it might be included but it would be really nice if there were a bonus cash prize with this Cabin to balance to help zero out the taxes so who ever won it was free and clear to keep it if they so decided.

Have you ever thought to move the washer and dryer into the room behind the kitchen and stack them on the wall by back porch. This would leave room next to them for a hanging rack and shelf. On the opposite wall there would be what looks to be at least 6 to 8 feet for shelving for large pantry. Remembering this is a cabin and with weather and location, dry and can food storage would be a great benefit.
This frees up the laundry space to be a computer desk area and storage cabinets above. There is never a thing as to much storage. I see where several mention a dumb waiter and this might be a good use of some of the space for the dumb waiter to be installed.

First, let me say that I have read all the previous blogs. My "informed" choices, and reasoning for the choice, are listed below.

1. Love the floorplan. Would not want to change it except for a garage that seems to be mandatory.
2. The D-log system works for me. I like to occasionally decorate my walls.
3. I wanted the sconce light because I just liked it better. However, I am not upset if the majority like the hanging pendant.
4. The wood burning fireplace is really nice. I have had one for 35 years in the 7 homes I have owned. It's not that big of a hassle and it does use a renewable fuel.
5. The metal roof is definitely preferred over the other types offered. Lasts longer, many different styles and colors to choose from, and insurance should be lower. Thanks Dave for the very informative link at http://www.metalroofing.com/.
6. My vote goes for a stone fireplace surround. Stone just works better for me. All my fireplaces have been stone and yet each one had a different appeal.
7. I like the idea of coming out of my shower clean. Soap on the body tends to itch. Also, I believe a power shower takes less time to complete than a low-flow one.
8. The look of the arts and craft kitchen cabinet style really appeals to me. If I were building a home right now I would choose a similar style. Like it!
9. Quartz countertops are my choice. There are many different colors to choose from as well as designs of edging.

There is one thing I would like to ask of the DIY team. Could you build the cabin on a basement foundation? There are tornadoes in Tennesee and it would be prudent to have a hidey-hole to run to.

Thanks for listening DIY and thanks for giving us the opportunity to be involved in this venture.

Lynn from KY

How hardy are the granite counter tops in comparison to the quartz? Isn't quartz one of the hardest substances on the planet. Also, I do agree that a log cabin should have some rustic qualities, but having lived in Colorado my whole life I do know what true rustic can be and it isn't a vacation home.

This cabin is awesome. And the area that was chosen is also out of this world. I have placed my votes and so far it seems that I am right in line with what most of the other voters like. One thing that I would like to see is a security and fire alarm system installed. I am not sure that this issue has been addressed in any of the previous plans, but given the type of structure this is, it would be difficult to add these after the fact. I live in Tennessee and although we would like to envision our ideal paradise as being a safe place, looks can be deceiving. If these systems have been slated for installation, please let the public know.
Thanks. Can't wait to start entering the sweeps!

Does anyone know the semi annual TAXES of other houses in this area?

Wonderful project and wonderful ideas. A thought that comes to mind is the entertainability of this home. Loving to cook and share times with family & friends the location of the kitchen and lake view is paramount. Isn't is were everyone gathers waiting for the first morsel to be served? A kitchen looking at the lake and watching our grandchildren enjoying the water is my vision for our next home. Everyone is doing a great job designing my home just remember that while I am preparing meals with family & friends we all want to see the lake.

I agree with Leanna. Log cabins should be rustic. As a child my family owned some cabins in the foothills west of Denver. The main house was solid log, about 900 sq ft. A second cabin was clapboard and had three trees growing out of it. The third cabin was a 12 x 16 bunkhouse. Sometimes there were as many as 30 family members spending the night. When the cabins came into the family in 1949 there was no electricity and only running water in the Summer and an outhouse, the main house had a fireplace and wood burning stove, the other two cabins had woodburning stoves, it gets cold in the Rocky Mountains. Now that was a cabin. But I would love to own the fancy estate that we are desgining

I vote for garage or walkout basement!

hey while I'm dreaming, both.

Good Luck on the cabin.

That property just screams for dogs! I like the idea of a pooch/person shower to rinse off after a day of outside fun. Surely we'll have a dock being located on the lake. I still say soapstone is the only way to go with the counters. It ages well,looks rustic at the same time upscale and it will be sooo easy to maintain. Will the garage be attached or detached? How about a workshop area in the garage? I didn't see any plans for outside amenities. A brick bar-b-q and a firepit would be great additions. This is so much fun! It makes me ready to build again!lol (ALMOST)

How about a tankless water heater to go with the shower? see http://www.foreverhotwater.com/for more details about the energy effiency.

I really love the idea of the steel roof but does it make for more moisture in the wood underneath it?

Right on to Grace and those who are disappointed in the 2007 repeats. I voted for soapstone countertops, it wasn't even a question. As for the metal roof...........the only way a metal roof will ever look good on anything other than a barn is if it is something similar to a Decra Metal roof that looks like anything but metal. I would absolutely want my home to look vintage and very different from the thousands of other log homes across the nation.
Regardless, when you leave the decisions to the masses you have to expect there will be some made that you don't like. Its still a fun project to follow.

Here are some other thoughts.
1) With such a large porch area, maybe a wood looking environmental friendly and maintenance free material should be used. No warping, no staining, no rotting.
2) The master bath seems to have a jet tub, but how about adding a steam unit unit with a seat. This would really cap off a master bathroom.
3) There are, what look to be half circule windows abobe the master bath window and over the window of the 2nd floor lounger area. Why not also put one over the window on the in the unmarked room on the other end. All 3 of these windows could also be stained glass fixed windows
and would add cenitry to the front view.

Voting is coming along nicely. Most of my choices are winning so far. I guess I'm partial to the metal roof because of the many happy times I spent at my grandma's house in KY. When it rained we either played on the porch or in the attic and the rain on the roof was a pleasant background. Falling asleep to that sound had a tremendously calming effect too. I remember Christmases spent around the stone fireplace at home singing carols and making popcorn strings for the Christmas tree. And my very favorite great grandmother lived in a REAL log cabin with a dirt floor that she actually swept. (I'm NOT championing that however) LOL Happy childhood memories play a great part in some of our later choices in life. Just wanted to share some of mine.
Belinda

I saw your link on your sister site HGTV while checking out the dream home. Wow, two totally different living environments but both outstanding! Thanks for the opportunity to be part of choosing the components that the cabin will consist of as well as giving everyone hope of winning such a fantastic home.

Why no garage?

Watching the last season made me wonder about that.

My husband and I have always loved log cabins and to come across this Blog Cabin idea was exciting for us. I just wish I had found this site sooner. I don't really like the green roof, it seems like people are trying duplicate the 2007 blog cabin. It would be nice to see how a log cabin looks with a different type of roof. Also, the power shower and rain shower...HOT!!! I do love all of the other selections, too. Look forward to seeing the finished product and even better it would be nice to be the Winner!!! : )

I love the way the voting is going for the cabin. I would also love to see a walkout basement and a screened porch. Whatever is chosen, it will be great. Thank you for giving us the chance to vote!

I like how we're able to make comments here. Wish I had been more aware of this.

I did not choose Cedar shingles for the hindsight experience. While living in a home WITH cedar shingles, we experienced many silverfish. It was on an HGTV episode where we discovered that the Cedar shingles may have been the culprit for the problem. I've been opposed to them ever since...Love the appearance just don't like the silverfish (insects).

I'm not opposed to the placement of the laundry room towards the back. I'd rather have the main living areas having views of the lake than a weekly/occasional laundry duty day.

I mentioned on another board that the FLAT cabinets make for easier cleaning. I use my steamer to get in the crevices where we are living now, but it would be nice not to.

Hot tub...oooooh! NICE!

Why do the countertops need to be all the same? While I think too much butcher block can be too much, it sure is handy. I would love to see a combination of butcher block and soapstone. Also, what do you think about moving the covered deck to the kitchen side of the house? I also agree, radiant floor heating is a must.

I am sure this place will be so beautiful when it is done, I'd want to move in pronto :o)

After reading all the blogs once again, I am in agreement with Jack, that the butcher block countertop would be the best. I still like the metal roof even though this time I voted for the composite slate as I believe that it would be another outstanding roof. All of my other choices are ahead except for the shower and I personnaly like the rain shower. Oh well, no matter what wins for accessories, it will be great.

On the shower, definitely a Power Shower, but incorporating the Rain Shower in it.

I love being able to choose from different designs and styles. I echo some of the comments to try something different. Some choices are obvious like the stone fireplace, but I am making my votes count for building green.

If you have chosen a wood burning fireplace please add a gas line with valve to the fireplace to get the logs started. There also should be an easy way to clean out the ashes. A pellet stove in some other part of the house would decrease the propane bill considerably. Keep up the good work!!!!!!!!!

Im with Margie, butcher block needs to retire. The other choices are all within reason for modern cabin lifestyles.

While I like the look of folk art style cabins, that does not equate to leaving out modern accents which seperate this home from being a weekend hunting cabin in the rual woods setting to a rustic cabin in the modern ages that belong in a modern development.

If you like the old cabin butcher block styles to keep with the traditional style, then leave out all modern amenites like Dishwashers, refrigerators, and toilets!

I have to say, where I live, there are alot of stucco-style homes being built everywhere. I just cant stand them. How can you not love a house of wood, stone, and glass..It doesnt necessarily have to be rustic, but open areas for the outdoor views of trees, sky, and garden areas. Windows, should be just like storm-windows, where you dont feel chills from them. I like the metal roof, being close to the water, and then the weather, it would last and not warp like other roofs. In a cabin, you really dont want a high electric bill, so having more windows/glass then walls, you can warm your house during the day..maybe lovely curtains to close during the night. A stone fireplace of river rocks, or rose quartz would be nice.

How come no update for a few days?

Dear Watson,

I think DYI should replace you since we have not seen any new blogs since Thursday, January 31st after KaBee stated "The fact that posts on the blog can take 24 hours+ to appear isn't helping matters."

Even though this was Super Bowl Sunday if that is the reason for not posting or if by chance you were sick, I would think that DIY has someone who can fill-in for you.

So if you are not going to do your job, resign and let DIY get someone who will post the blogs daily if not sooner and maybe answer some questions that are being asked in the posted blogs rather than wait until new items are up for vote!

Today, the snow and freezing rain in Iowa makes this cabin look better and better regardless of whether all of my preferences are voted down.

Everybody, just relax and enjoy the beauty of the cabin and Lakefront Estates, Watts Bar Lake.

It would be nice to have a rinse off shower/tub for bathing dogs in the laundry room. It could also be used to rinse off shoes/boots etc.

Well it looks like the power shower is the winner how about incorporating the rain shower into it and then moving the shower to were the bath is located and making it a rock shower with a built in binch.
Then putting a spa next to the master bedroom to soak in.
a spa is a lot cheeper to fill every 6 months then trying to fill a large tub everyday!
then you could turn the old shower location into a large linen closet.

Today was the first time I have hada look at this years cabin. With what I am seeing from voting it will be as beautiful as last year. Looking forward to see what will be coming to vote on.

I didn't get to vote on the fireplace, but would've voted for gas. They are much cleaner, don't smell and easier to use. I share the recommendation for gas on the indoor fireplace and wood on the outside.

Unfortunately you probably have to go with the majority, so may I suggest a very marketable compromise. Stub out the indoor fireplace for gas, maybe even putting in a gas starter. That way the winner can convert easily and quickly to gas logs.

I really like the winning plan, though I must admit I might reverse the porches putting the outdoor fireplace on the public side of the house near the kitchen. Since that will probably become the outdoor eating area it makes a lot of sense to have it close to the kitchen.

Is there a chance for a full (unfinished) basement for the cabin? They seem to add so much potential to any house at a relatively low price(though admittedly not free).

This cabin will be awesome. It won't hurt my feelings if I won it. I love granite because it's durable. First time blogger here, but it won't be my last.

Jeanette, the pattern seems to have changed since the last time it was noted. in general the previous days posts are released en masse once a day (this was around 2p, tho i noticed it was closer to 10:30a today). You may have a shot at same day posting if you post between now and COB (5p. tho johnny-on-the-spot seems to have taken an early fri. this past wknd).

Now that a pattern is apparent, we will likely see a change once again. (a change to more frequent posting, we can hope.)

my personal preference would be towards automatic posting with user reporting for abuse/spam.

and by the way

METAL, STONE, EURO, BUTCHER BLOCK, POWER SHOWER

We love the smokey mountains. My husband and I will be retiring soon and are considering tennessee as our retirement we have been therer to check things out.We are even considering building our own log cabin home we have always said that when we retire we are going to have a log cabin. We currently have log furniture in our family room. I think it is great that you let us viewers select the design and features throught the home

Hi Bloggers and DIY team,

Well it took me over 30 mins. to read they blog today since no update all weekend, why is that?

Thank you Lynn from KY for the great link about metal roof, hope more voters go to it, so many different metal roof designs and colors.

Seems the voters didn't go to the recycled paper countertop link they still voting on the yukky hard to maintain granite.

I will keep blogging and voting even if I win could not afford the prize taxes, muchless property since the site of cabin is so expensive and the building requirements make the cabin worth way more than a vacation cabin.

Have a good day bloggers

Mary from Texas

Love reading the blogs. My thoughts on some of the suggestions-
A basement near a body of water may not be a good idea....occassional flooding.
Kitchen cabinets do NOT all have to be the same. Certainly style should be the same but not necessarily the color.
Hot Tubs can be lots of maintenance.
Countertops- While some of the materials offered do require some care, it isn't that big of deal. No surface is perfect. All have some challenges just because of constant use. Probably butcher block and marble are the most difficult to take care of but even that isn't much.
I love the idea suggested that something "fish" be used in the mantel of the fireplace. Actually, any artisan touches would be a real plus to the overall design.
Last, I do think some sort of storage for cars, boats, etc is necessary. If not a garage then a shed type of building that has a storage room or something that can be locked.

Is there a way on the voting page or results page to post some of the most common suggestions the bloggers have made and add to them as they come in? I've been reading these blogs for about three weeks and I'm seeing the same suggestions over and over because people aren't reading the previous blogs. The fact that the blogs from the last round of voting are separated from the current voting blogs doesn't help. Also on the same page post some of the subdivision by-laws with the other suggestions, indicating what the square footage, garage & dock requirements are as these questions are being asked daily and the by-laws discussed in the previous blogs have already determined some of what will have to be built. Stating your arguments for one product or the other should maybe also have it's own place as someone suggested several weeks ago. A page to just weed thru the b.s. and input NEW suggestions would be great.

After reading some of the nasty comments that some bloggers have posted, I have to say that DIY might think twice about doing another Blog Build.

I think it's important to remember who's doing what for whom here, people. We have a chance to have FUN participating in the cabin design and we all will get a chance to WIN it after it's built...so maybe people should try to be a little nicer. Let's not bite the hand that feeds us, okay??

I agree with Annetta, Feb. 3, 12:22. We lived in Colorado in a cabin on the side of Pikes Peak, which was a cross between upscale hippie and posh. However, the heat surround at the wall bottom just didn't do the trick and we spent a fortune on at least 3 reams of wood in two short months! The first cabin we rented had luxuries such as running water; it ran down the hill in front of the house! The Outhouse had no roof, so an umbrella was very important. No. 3 washtubs aren't very comfortable, either! I think if the cabin is comfortable and has some of the finer things in life the winner won't complain. I know I won't! When is the next vote coming up, anyone know? Thanks, and may the worthiest blogger win!!! Cabncraver2008

I would love to see a small mudroom. A place where you could clean off all of the 'outside' before heading into your beautiful clean cabin.

Yo, Cabincraver2008 - just an FYI. The DIY Blog Cabin show you're watching is last year's (2007) cabin, not the one we're voting on ;)

This is my first time...but I liked what I saw and what was voted on. I've read a few of the comments and agreed that if it snowed alot, then shouldn't there be radiant heating in the floorplan? It would also be nice to include recycled materials and energy saving systems, as well. It's still a beautiful house, no matter what...

No posts appeared between 1/31 and the morning of 2/4...then they all appeared in a lump. I e-mailed DIY's comment team...one hopes that they will take care of this issue.

DIY Blog Cabin - Watson,

Any comments on what Keight has found?
See:
Posted by: Keight at January 31, 2008 4:56 PM
and prior posts re: ACC.
As I suspected, this type of community might have resrictions to make sure homes, and this really is a log 'home' more than cabin, conform with the desired look. Looks like a garage is a must, the dock 'must' be a sort of boat house, the metal roof might NOT conform (that'd break me up, NOT ;). Also, as I'd mentioned before, I hope they allow log homes - Keight?

Also, something he posted might look like a pendant light might not meet ACC rules, or it can't be 'visable'.

I wonder if anyone besides me is looking for an outside fireplace. Those are so wonderful and yet it will provide a cozy atmosphere for the wonderful fall, winter, and spring months.

Note to Clive..

Concerning Water Levels: Someone's post stated: Watts Bar Lake is part of the TVA system, and in the autumn water is released from the Watts Bar Dam, but not all waterfronts are exposed. The let out varies between 8-12 feet, so it depends on the water level and slope at the property. "Seasonal" waterfront means you will have little lake left when the dam is opened, "year-round" means you will have boat access to the lake year round.
I do not have any other information about water levels to share at this time, however, LISA @ Feb 2, 2008 9:35 pm., offers some insight on the topic.

Also.... Another post offered the suggestion to request a "Sales Kit" from the LakeFront Estates Website so that you can receive a sign-in and password to use at the website to view more detailed information about the development. All Lot Dimensions, sinkhole site location, lot prices, etc., will be viewable, with a bit of navigation. Also, I found that a copy of the Cov. and Restrictions can also be downloaded from a "protected area" within the website, once you have the tools needed to unlock the area. Hope this information proves helpful.

P.S.... Apology accepted!

Not to be a scrooge but, it would be nice to have answers to the following questions:
What about the apparently mandatory garage?
What about property taxes?
Is the sales tax still on everything except medical and calculated at TN + County + City about 10%?
What do the covenants and deed resrtictions cover?
How much is the HOA fee for the privilege of living in this upscale community?
When the house is situated on the 0.72 acre lot will there still be room for outbuildings? How much room, and what are the building set-backs?

Wow, what a lot of input and thought!

I'm concerned though. I did a comment last week, yet the blog my name is attached to is NOT my comment! Who can check into this for me?
Watson are you out there? I did not see any "boxes" to click if you were having difficulties.

Happy Blogging!

I do agree that the choices for materials are the same as the 1st cabin. That may be because they are very good choices. Let's give some credit to the staff and hosts and thier imaginations to make sure the cabins don't look the same. Maybe they will impress us even more than they did the 1st time.

Note to Kim Mc...
In regards to your question: A few were answered in entries I submitted in the last few days but, like so many other "held for review" blog entries, they were among the one big lump released today (Monday).

It appears to me that you (and Clive and his wife, and Erin, and Grace,and KateByTheLake, and etc., etc.etc.) are among the "read everyone's comments bloggers' group", so you will most probably already know the answers by the time you read this comment.

But....Here's a brief summary for you and any of those interested who may have missed the info because of the sheer number of posts released today....
1. All building plans must be submitted to the A.C.C. for approval. No construction can commence without the written approval of the A.C.C..
2. The roof material requirements are quite detailed in the Covenents and Restrictions. When I posted that section information it was in full (as written) for review and enlightenment.
That said, I have read on one of the metal roof websites that metal roofing material can be manufactured in many different patterns and weights, so, perhaps, metal roofing material does meet the A.C.C. roofing standards. Guess we will find out sooner or later. (Surely, it would not have been offered as an option choice, if it did not fall into the outlined standards, right???)

Just a comment now: It would be a pity if the DIY Blog Cabin building team had not read the Covenents and Restrictions long before I started posting various sections of the document. I am hopeful that the on-site team is as aware of the requirements as we as the "off-site Blog Cabin Builders" are educating ourselves and each other to be about the project).

Hello I just love the cabin and the look of the land. the last cabin was sooo nice. And a great job the builders did so quickly. Can't wait for the new cabin to start. Enjoy watching it being built.

Well it looks like the power shower is the winner how about incorporating the rain shower into it and then moving the shower to were the bath is located and making it a rock shower with a built in binch.
Then putting a spa next to the master bedroom to soak in.
a spa is a lot cheeper to fill every 6 months then trying to fill a large tub everyday!
then you could turn the old shower location into a large linen closet.

Here's a thought a little off track. Perhaps next time we could vote on the house, its design and ammenities, then get a winner and build it where they want it built.

Hi first time at this,Love the cabin and being able to vote on the planning of how it turn's out. What ever the out come some lucky soul will have a nice place to live.thanks keep up the good work Ellen .M.

Hello All,

WOW finally got the blog back up and running again I see! I came every day sense the 31st of Jan. and could not see any new posting's. I wrote an email to the webmaster never heard back but happy to see it is working again.

Well I'm happy with this log cabin I feel I would be so lucky if I could win this and thankful for any of the up grades that are of the highest quality. When you are stuck in the city in hot and tired high rise with crime all around that you are in fear for your life to go out after dark. This win would be a miracle from God for me. So you see, there will be no complaint's from me, I would just be so thankful to win and get out of this city so That me and my children could have a real life. We would be the ones hitting the ground when even a car back fires because that's what our life is like here. Always in fear and ever so thankful we made it home another day to be with each other for one more day. This isn't any way to live. If only our prayers could be answered and we could win this!

So no complaint's from me!

Thanks Diy for the blog and a chance to dream

Susan from the city

I don't know if anyone else shares my concern regarding the new host for 2008, but I have to say it. What is a landscaper doing in this role? How is he going to be able to articulate the fine points of custom construction? It'll be like having a dog groomer explaining aircraft assembly. I don't know how I'm going to enjoy the show, while constantly evaluating if my trust is being earned. I want Amy back.

Hi Everyone,

Glas to see that Watson is finally posting the blogs again - took some time to read them all and WOW some great information.

If you are interested in some ideas or information on building green go to this website, which is also a sister site of DIY. HGTVPro is a website for building professionals that is fantastic! So check it out.

I also saw on HGTV another DIY sister site about fireplaces that can be vented to provide heat what a great idea especially if there is a power outage.

Love to see tile at the entrance, kitchen, laudry and bathrooms - so much easier to clean. Love the idea of having a sink in the area of the laundry room for cleaning fish - great idea and suggestion!

Also like the idea of having fans for circulation in the cabin!

Great ideas and great feedback from everyone! Spending more and more time just reading all the feedback from everyone and visiting the different websites that are being suggested! Thanks Everyone!!!!!

I have enjoyed reading the blog comments. I wish I had thought to read them before I voted, as many of the comments made me think a little more seriously about alternatives.
I selected the metal roof as it just says cabin for me. The others seemed a little more formal to me but that may have just been the influence of the picture that was chosen to display the choice.

I agree that the 2008 cabin should explore alternatives other than the 2007 choices but since I just joined this thing I was not totally clued into last years choices.

I liked the informal feel of the arts and crafts but do agree that choices of color and finish on any of the other choices would have made any one of the options fit a cabin.

I did select what appears to be a trailing option of cement counters. I was thinking along the lines of different, informal, and new. Though I guess cement counters have been around for awhile they seem to be coming more popular of late. For a cabin I think the look would be perfect.

I went for the luxury of the power shower though it was hard to choose between luxury and the environmentally friendly choice. But I thought what a pleasure the power shower would be after a long jog around the lake or a day rowing on the lake.

If this is on a reservoir is there a limitation on the boating???

I selected the brick because the only show I did see on the 2007 house was the one where they put in the facing on the fireplace with stone. I thought the tile option was a little too formal for the cabin. The brick would be different and could be informal with a rustic mantle. I hope a fire box enclosure will be considered for additional heat and cooling efficiency.

I also agree with the suggestion that a patio with barbeque and fireplace would fit the cabin espically for more enjoyment of the lake view.

I am great fan of wrap around porches also. And enclosing part for year round usage and view of the lake would get my vote.

laundry shoot and dumb waiter may be considered decadant but what a splendid idea.

This is fun.

Great talking to you all.

I would like to see us vote on colors for roof,walls,tile etc. We also need more info on some of the choices.

Granite counter tops are beautiful but I really think that concrete countertops would be awesome. Everyone has granite. Time for a change.
It would also be nice to incorporate solar energy into the home.

Hi Bloggers,
It's been a long weekend, espically with the snow storm. It took friends 12 hours to drive from Chicago to Detroit. Sandy - I have the same situation as you. I'm still voting on counters and roof and watching installation on the tv. Maybe it's my computer or reruns from the last cabin. I'm so exhausted by the time I get home I just automatically turn on DYI to unwind and relax. If anyone can let us know how to "catch up" with the voting that would be great.
Be nice to Watson, maybe he was caught in the stormy weather this weekend too.

Hi Grace....
You may have already addressed this question, and I just somehow overlooked your response, but could you tell us what your job description is as: "show runner of blog cabin"?

And Watson....
Will you be taking part in some way in the construction of the Blog Cabin 2008, or is your primary function related to the DIY network website?

I think I am not alone in wondering about the answers to these questions. Thanks for addressing these questions in a timely manner.

I have been reading and haven't noticed any discussion obout the landscaping. I might be a little early. The interior seems a little familiar to last year. I think this cabin should sport some interesting exterior ideas. One is a private pier if allowed by the homeowners association. The other is a pavilion near the pier for outdoor family entertaining. Gas piped to it for the barbque and a fire pit. The property looks like it can handle a lot of entertaining.

When ordering the countertops for installation in the kitchen, would it be possible to have the manufacturer put in the grooves that allow for drainage into the sink of the run-off from rinsed dishes, washed vegetables, etc.?

For anyone who is unfamiliar with this countertop treatment and would like to see an example of this application....

A picture of a grooved countertop can be viewed on the landing page at www.soapstone-co.com

(I realize that soapstone is not the winner in the voting for the kitchen countertops, but a kitchen designer explained that the grooving can be done in granite,too. He also stated that bacterial build-up in the grooves from food preparation has not proven to be a cause for concern because of the way the area is finished, and has actually been proven to help eliminate the accumulation of bacteria on wet areas near sinks on countertops. Spray Methods used to keep the countertops sanitary is all that is needed on the grooved area for cleaning purposes.)

Any thoughts and comments on this idea, bloggers?

Wow, we sure aren't short on emotions! It is so easy to take offense by some of the strong (borderline rude) comments, but that is not what this is about, now is it. Reality check? Time to vote on some new options? This phase is getting old and the winners are apparent.

Whatever perceived "mismatched" choices appear, I'm sure the very creative DIY team will make it work beautifully.

When this year's 2008 cabin voting began (didn't have the channel last year), I was also confused at first, and didn't realize the old 2007 programming was running (gave me a brain-cramp). Hopefully the bloggers didn't get frustrated and give up...

It is time to hear and see more from the "powers that be" at DIY please.

A carport please! Covered parking is so important.

OK, we can vote everyday.....so let's go quartz! Let's push granite out!! Granite is porous and more work to maintain. For a kitchen you need a clean surface, you are not suppose to use bleach on granite or any harsh chemicals!! And it absorbs everything!! Come on Quartz!!! Thanks for the opportunity! :-)

8:46 AM 2/5/2008...last post showing is from 10:04 AM on 2/4/2008.

May I suggest a plan for the next round of voting?

I intend to research all the choices BEFORE I cast my first vote. I'll attempt to post my thoughts with links on this blog...but we see how that is going! Ah well, regardless, it'll be a lovely cabin.

To those who are confused about how we enter to win...we don't until the voting is complete. One checks the site periodically.

Whoops! Hit "post" instead of "preview"--I intended to add...while I'll post links of my research...everyone should probably do their own...because things aren't posting in a timely manner. Didn't mean to imply that anyone should take my choices/research for gospel...it's just that I'm home waiting for my foot to heal from bunion surgery and have WAY too much time on my hands...so I'm happy to do the research.

Melanie

This would be a dream come true but don't know if we could afford to keep it. These subdivision communities always have dues and it is a racket. Why not build these cabins on privately owned lots.....I guess because developers are buying up all the land.
About the cabin, it would be nice if the out door fire place were on the kitchen and dining side of the cabin instead of the master bedroom side (private side). Thinking of summer and swimming in the lake and kids and family entering the house and needing to run in to use the restroom, it would be nice if the rear foyer were a mud room with shower and toilet and sink but still need laundry and a pantry. There doesn't need to be two baths upstairs, one would do. If the roof is noisy when it rains it would drive me nuts so not sure the metal roof is a good idea. I don't understand why folks aren't voting for the water saving shower. Where I live, NC, we are in a drought and we have 100 days of water left and we are trying to conserve as much as we can. I read recently an article on the Great Lakes, and they have been dropping for the last few years. So much so that ships can now get stranded on the bottom in places. We all need to wake up.
It would be nice if the cabin were more energy efficient, more "Green".
I know there is a lot of hard work going into this project and here’s a pat on the back and a slice of my pecan pie, (you'll just have to imagine the pie, sorry, it works for the Gecko :) ) for all the folks working on the cabin.
Good luck to every one and God bless!

I,m greatful for the opportunity to vote on all the features.I always wanted a log cabin so I really enjoy seeing this built and being able to
to take part in the building of it. All the features that have been chosen are absolutely
great.

Hi Folks,
New to the forum...can you tell me how one enters the sweeps for the log cabin. Would love to win it! I Like that we have the chance to vote for options on the cabin, as if we were building it ourselves. Really like the lot, and the floorplan seems nice too. Didn't get a chance to view the others. How many square feet is the home? Is there a virtual way of seeing the plan put together to make any changes in it before it is finished. I have to agree with Glen Cannon about closing in the porch for the winter months when there is too much snow. He also had a lot of other good ideas as well...must be in the building industry... Am very happy there is something like this to get excited about. I've already entered the dream home for hgtv, now I have another type of home to enter for. More chances to win something, Isn't life grand! All I need now is to figure out how to enter? LOL. Will look forward to seeing what developes over the next few weeks. Until then, many blessings!

I am glad to see all the discussion.

I wish the voting would start a week or so after the new choices were posted. That would give everyone time to really think about and research each of the possibilities.

Any way it turns out will be fantastic, and I for one would be thrilled to call it home.(Not just for vacation)

It's not fair they give us so many wonderful choices! I have a hard time deciding. Just kidding. I think the bigger porch and the stairs to the water were great ideas. But my thing is the laundry. I think that since it is a job no one likes to do that it should be put somewhere bright and sunny with a good view. That would make this place perfect in my opinion.

Where will the outside vent to the dryer be? I hope it's not up through the roof. The longer the vent hose, the harder it is on the dryer and electricity. I've had two homes w/ the vents this way and it's awful !! Hopefully the contractors will put the vent vertical to the dryer, and through the wall/log.

Hey guys, what is up with this posts here? Jim and my comment was posted with another gent's name as follows...

"Posted by: Dustin Ragle at February 2, 2008 7:27 PM

We agree with the few rebels posting here, we have voted for the soapstone counters, synthetic slate shingles, and the rain shower... How great would that be... to play in the rain when the sun is shining? We are a bit worried about the water consumption though, we reside in NC and know well what a drought can do."

The comment just below that has our name attached even though it is not ours.

RE: Posted by: Tingoat at February 4, 2008 7:30 AM

Wow, I don't know who you are however the above referenced post, in my humble opinion, was harsh and uncalled for. There are always many behind the scenes actions taking place in this type of endeavor, listening to the thoughts which you have carefully placed in writing matters and I am certain they are being read by those individuals who hold the greatest ability to impact the outcome here. Just what is so devastating about your post not making the board for a few extra days?

Life is meant to be experiential, why not go out and live a bit? Have a little fun, lighten up and help a soul or two... You might just find the joy one finds when not chained to a desk.

Hello All.... Here is some Information found on the LakeFront Estates Website for your enlightenment:
.....Construction completed on community clubhouse
The 2,000 square-foot clubhouse near the gated property entrance to Lakefront Estates has been completed. The building features a “rustic elegance” design and includes a fitness center, kitchen, and great room with a high-definition TV that’s perfect for watching football games in the fall. The clubhouse is great for family gatherings or other homeowner activities and is ready for use. We’re also finishing the landscaping throughout the property and installing the sprinkler system.

Community boat dock ready for home owners
Construction is finished on the 10-slip community boat dock at Lakefront Estates. This attractive, covered dock is for use by owners of the off-the-water home sites and includes a spacious boat ramp for launching or retrieving watercraft. The dock also has tie-on spots for any visiting boats.

The difference between proposed and reality
One thing we’ve noticed in the marketplace for waterfront property in East Tennessee is the great number of “proposed” amenities at various communities. A developer will tout his “proposed” marina or a “proposed” clubhouse or “proposed” tennis courts. At Lakefront Estates, we like being what we say we are. We say we’re a true lakefront community because the overwhelming majority of our home sites are on the water. Likewise, when we say we have a lovely gated entrance, paved roads, clubhouse and community boat dock, we mean it. We think you’ll like our reality better than their proposals. Lakefront Estates is truly “ready to live in.”......

Looks great so far! Great job in the kitchen.

Just recalling what Freddie wrote about the future of the 2008 Blog Cabin Experience ....
And wondering if all the "innovative green" is yet to come as Voting Options or Construction Method News .....

September 27, 2007
Blog Cabin 2008: A quick update
Hi everyone! It's never too soon to start thinking about Blog Cabin 2008. Just yesterday, we had a wonderful meeting with a log home company. In the coming days, we'll be sharing more details about them and our partnership. The exciting news is that they have some amazing innovations and opportunities for our cabin next year. Building green is a very important part of their philosophy. We're anxious to hear more about their ideas and share some of your green ideas with them. That also means we'll be able to let you vote and decide on even more features for our cabin next year.

So far I am very impressed with all of the choices given to America to vote out the next Blog Cabin. I am happy to partake in the voting, and so far everything I have voted for has been chosen.

I am excited about this round of voting. I voted for the soapstone countertops. Granite would normally be my first choice, but I think the soapstone looks more rugged and would match the rest of the rugged feel most seem to want the cabin to have. I do like the formal touches like french doors...however there are so many door choices out there it won't have to look too formal. I was also torn by the roofing choices. I voted for the cedar, but was sorely tempted to vote metal because I can just close my eyes and imagine what it would sound like when it rains. Brings back memories of vacationing at my great-grandparents in Kentucky. However, I think it would be nice if this cabin wasn't a carbon copy of the 1st Blog Cabin. Different setting, different location. Needs a look all it's own.

And the fireplace...I LOVE stone fireplaces. They are a must when living in the country. I'm very excited for the fireplace on the deck off the master suite. What a great idea to give the owners their own little romantic oasis.

Keep up the good work voters! We're voting a beautiful home into someone's future!

Ugh...I'm almost bored of this just because of the way people vote. There is obviousley a lack of imagination and an inability to stray from the norm. It kind of makes me gag. I hope your not all voting like this in the presidential primarys...or we're all in for another W.

I was concerned about the choise of a pendant light fixture. I live on a lake,and the winds that come up are a danger to anything hanging outside! Please be carefull about the length of the pendant and how close it is to anything that could destroy it.

Okay so now it is feb 5 but no posting to day the last postings I see is for feb 4 at 10:04 am

What's up with that?

For the metal roof color, can we have a tan to light brown instead of the business shed green. It would blend and look better residentually.
Looks like Granite won over the sensible cost effective Quartz. Since the Arts and Crafts is shown in light oakwood [?] does that mean the countertop is light or dark? If I had to choose a color I would prefer the SAME color of stone used on the fireplace [medium Grey color]. For the fireplace stone [Grey lights and darks mixed]. Someone suggested a Tankless water heater which sounds good too. Since we are looking at going green and conservative the toliet water reuse system too. Anything to make this house self sufficient is great with me especially is there is a built-in full house generator. I guess if you use a blue water tablet it would suffice to offset any water discoloration in the bowl, if any, but what kind of sewer container/filter system is it? I am really not up on this system but something to consider. Also on the wiring, can there be an area dedicated for a computer system. I just want to thank DIY and the Blog Cabin Teams for an opportunity to voice in and possibly win. Thank you.

Just watching the news today here in KY we have to be weather aware today/ tonight and lately we all are seeing how harsh the weather can be. With all the tornadoes and straight line winds etc. that are happening more and more in the tn area and all across America. I suggest that if you are not going to build in a basement in this home. That at least: PLEASE consider putting in a SAFE sheltered room. You could place it under the cabin in a small safely sectioned area, tall enough for a very small room or just several people standing side by side in or sitting space comfortable enough or in a safe room location on the main living floor of the cabin. A room that could be constructed toward the center of the place with extra & closer placed wall studs and harder wall coverings or even concrete walls & ceiling. I do encourage you to please consider doing putting a safe place in all of the diy, hgtv, and green homes if possible. It would be great for some storage; with easily moved out of the way rolling cabinets and don't forget a Noaa weather radio and a very secured locking door, that locks and unlocks from inside and outside of it. For "kid" safety, "It scares me to think about it, but we don't want our homes to blow off foundations or burst apart in case a tornado "wind devil" did coming knocking and blowing your house down". You know this safe room could be constructed as a little office/sitting area and it would not be looking any different from the other rooms: but you would know it's the safe place to go to in case of storm emergencies: Just think it could also save lives and educate your (DIY)etc. viewers about ways to protect their families "the most important gift of all". When building or remodeling their existing homes. Thanks for all the things you have brought into our lives. Building, remodeling, beautiful homes: the knowledge and courage to try "do it yourself" and to conquer making them so. It's fun doing it yourself and it's sure is nice seeing the results. And it's even more fun to be a part of Blog Cabin. Thanks have a great day diyers!

It looks like it's going to be a beautiful house, but I would like to make a comment on the choice of a roof material, since the metal seems to be winning. I have heard a few comments on the metal roofing with the painted surface not being installed very long at all and it was peeling and chipping off. I don't know if this was one particular brand, but it makes me leery of choosing this material for a longtime roof. The old roofing of years ago was galvanized and rusted and was painted. I don't think people now want this look.

Hello again everyone i am new at this Blogging. i have looked at the new cabin everyone has voted for. It is really nice. I think it would be perfect for the land that has been choosen. The materials that are being picked at great. It will make the cabin look even richer looking and easy to take care of. Less up keep for those of us that are older. love watching your program DIY..:)

I was just reading a comment on the quartz countertops, that is what I voted for, it is a shame the people are choosing granite since it has to be repeatedly "sealed", which I didn't know, and it will scratch! Why not quartz? It is a 7 on the scale of hardness, and the most common mineral in the earths' crust, so it is plentiful!

Can we please talk about garage? We must have one and I have not heard any discussion about it. A workshop would be great! And a fire pit is almost a must. Add a nice brick bar-b-q and I can already see the fourth of July fireworks from my deck chair on the SCREENED IN porch!

Yawn! Wake me up if the keepers of the blog ever return to work. I wish I could get a job like theirs. Turn up to check the blog once in a long while; post a few messages so late they have little meaning then back to whatever I was doing for a few more days of ignoring the blog. Not really the way it's done on a 'proper' blog is it?

wow i thought the round logs would win =(

I finally got caught up again since the last posting on the 31st. Almost two hundred new entries since Thursday. A little more frequent posting would be much appreciated. When you only have the evening to catch up, it can get a little overwhelming.

Someone mentioned the small size of the master bedroom. I pulled up the floor plan again, and was amazed to realize that the master bedroom is smaller than the master bath. Granted I love a large master bath, but it would be nice to have a little larger master bedroom. Maybe it can be extended either into part of the large patio on the side, or to the back.

Others have mentioned radiant floor heating. This sounds fabulous! Not just in a bathroom this time.

Generators are a must if power is lost frequently there. We just got one since we were losing power at least 6 times a year. It is amazing how nice it is to have reliable power now. I never minded too much, but it drove my husband and daughter nuts. Everything is dark everywhere, and we have power, heat, internet and cable (as long as cable doesn't go out too!). Plus you still have the use of your refridgerator, and freezer, and you don't have to go replace all your supplies after the power comes back.

Maybe a hose off area before getting to the foyer. Kind of like you find at the beach.

One other thing I was thinking about is a nice relaxing spot set up with a hammock. This could be on the deck, or out in the trees, or both. I have always loved hammocks!

A recap of my past change requests are:

1) At least one bathtub upstairs (necessity for younger children).

2) Loft access to one of the upstairs bathrooms (I would hate to wake up someone in a bedroom to use the bathroom).

3) Basement for storage! At least as much as was in the 2007 Blog Cabin, but hopefully, much much more. Maybe an unfinished basement that could be finished at a later date, by the winner, into whatever would work best for them. Gym, office, 4th bedroom, or whatever fills a need for them.

I enjoy the people who are still holding strong for the brick fire place, and the Cedar shingles. If you get enough new people to vote, you might have a chance. ROCK THE VOTE!!

My heart goes out to all of you who have been affected by today's storm outbreaks. I pray the Lord be with you all.

Everyone seems to keep talking about this log home as if it is a small cabin. From what I can tell it is not. This could be a home that you live in year round if you wish. It is larger than last years, the location could not be more different and the style of the home does not make one just think of a weekend get away. This all makes me vote and think differently than last year.
The metal roof is okay and there are metal designs that don't even look like a metal roof. I myself like the composite cedar or slate for the roof. Quartz or soapstone for the counter tops are great, granite over used. Stone for the fireplace and heated floors are so nice.
Just my two cents worth plus my husband and I would love to retire there enjoy Watts Bar Lake and Lakefront Estates.
Happy Blogging

Hellllooooooo!!! Waaaatsssssoooonnnn??????
You folks working part-time these days?
Also, what about the ACC info from Keight?

Hey Concrete and Soapstone fans, join the Quartz Qlub! And then VOTE, VOTE, VOTE! C'mon, we can steal this from the Granite Group!

QUARTZ - COUNTRY - COMPOSITE CEDAR

BASEMENT -walkout/roughed in, GAS LOG STARTER -elec. ign., STRECH FLOOR PLAN -lgr MstBdrm, closets, Kitchen/Island, CHIMNEY/FIREPLACE in BSMT, CLEANOUTs in chimny, TILE FLUE in chimny, BOATHOSE/DOCK, STONE PATIO(S) -behind wkout bsmt and at shore/dock, HARDWOOD & TILE FLRS, 40" FRONT DOOR w/SIDELIGHTs -NO DBL DR, AWESOME LANDSCAPING -Dazzle us, AHMED! GARAGE -2 1/2 or 3

QUARTZ - COUNTRY - COMPOSITE CEDAR

2/05 10:28 PM CST
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

i noticed there is a single door from the masters bedroom onto the porch,,,id like to see french doors there.it would allow more light in and a flair for the romantic ones out there ,young and old...
you guys are doing a great job anyway you do it, even addin a little balcony on one of the bedrooms upstairs too......get up in the morning..go downstairs when its nice a quiet...go back upstairs with a cup of coffee and the paer or a book and sit out on a balcony before anyone elses rises....now dont that sound inviting ?
keep up the good work!

Heading South, go quartz go!!! I have liked quartz from the beginning. A concern I have is that people are still complaining about the roof being noisy. The roof has several websites that explain that due to past problems with noise they now offer several ways of layering under the tin to help with insulation and to cut the noise facter to 0%! I really enjoyed reading about the real log cabin with the dirt floor, and the popcorn being strung by the fireplace. These are the kind of memories we can create for our families if we win, leaving out the dirt floor, of course! (LOL!) Being mainly a designer and not a contractor or builder, all I can do is investigate the different materials on the internet. I like quartz, RIVER rock surrounds (nice, big, smooth stones) but in TN you are going to find flat, sandstone like rock, flat and exactly the way it looks in the picture. Having rock hauled in from Colorado or some other large river state would not be cost effective at all! I wish it were, I love those stones. I want light too, the big windows. Even the power shower is now energy efficient, but people aren't reading about that. I think we should all educate ourselves as much as possible by listening to the bloggers who obviously have experience or by looking items up online. And about Watson and not answering blogs from Jan. 31st for a couple of days...does he get a weekend? Could he have been sick? Do you have any concenpt how many of these he has to read and approve before posting first-timers, and I'm sure he reads several of those being posted by those of us who are consistant bloggers! Give the guy a break!

May the worthiest blogger win, and you guys keep the info coming.

Hellloooo DIY!

I've been reading the blogs and have seen skylights mentioned a few times. I would still like to see this as a rustic, homey cabin without skylights. If the cabin has high windows and several french doors, skylights would not be necessary. Additionally, no matter how well the skylights are installed, they eventually leak.

In any event, this will be a gorgeous home for a very lucky family!

Happy Logging!

I guess I'm not like many of the bloggers on this
website...I did not grow up w/a silver spoon in
my mouth. So, with all the comments, (and I know
I'll get a lot of flak here)about how this or that should be changed, & so many people aren't
happy because this cabin is similar to 2007 cabin
just makes me want to say: whoever wins it,and is
not satisfied that all the amenities is not built
into it as you wanted for your 'dream cabin', then spend your big bucks adding to what you may
win, should you be the winner. Everyone had an
option to vote for what they liked, so please be
glad if you are the winner, it didn't cost you a
cent to purchase...all you got to do is pay taxes
,insurance & utilities. Myself,If I won, I'd be
so happy in winning that I would feel really fulfilled. Everyone knows that the winner can
always add more amenities as money comes in, if
they aren't satisfied with the cabin when it's
completed. Thank you DIY for the opportunity to
be able to vote & if voting wasn't as I wanted, (which, it sounds like it is) I'd still feel blessed if I won. Whoever wins it will have more
than they had before, so quit complaining and go
with the flow. If the price of the lot is as
expensive as I read in someone's blog, I'd say
taxes will be skyhigh, and the more amenities that's added just makes the taxes that much higher!! I liked last yr's cabin, and would have
been so thankful had I been chosen the winner, so
if this yr's cabin was the exact replica, I'd be
pleased as punch!

Wow, Love This! Voting on the Bath and kitchen, and everything, It Is Awesome, This cabin is going to be GREAT! What a blessing it would be to win this one. GREAT JOB EVERYONE!

WATSON,
LET MY BLOGGERS GO!!! 72 hours of uncensored blogging. Think about it; you and I might learn something.

I agree with the many requests for a garage.
I will need a place for all my power tools.
For those of us that Love and Live DIY - a garage, workshop, or basement is a must.

fellow bloggers have changed my vote to quartz. I am all about less maintenance. I think the idea of a tankless hot water heater is great, why heat water your not using. sure would save money. and radiant floor heating is awsome. especially in the bathrooms. or under any tiled area. I still think the roof and front door should be red. and a mud room off the back porch with a sink and toilet, keeps you from tracking in mud and dirt when you have to GO, and then want to return outside. I love reading all the great ideas, & can't wait to incorporate them when we build our cabin in the next few years, unless of course I win this cabin, speaking of how do we enter to win???

Whe we went to the smokys and rented a cabin it had a hottub and it was awsome.YOU NEED A HOTTUB!Can you please use solar lighting???I think you should add steps to the deck.You could also add more to the porch and add a basement.It would be nice to add more windows to the top of the Great room.You need to covert coffe tables with game tables painted on.What kind of wood are you using???

Not voting for Metal Roof...Just want to see something different. However...PLEEEEAAASSSEE not green or red, like every other log home you see. Shake it up a little..be different. Enough said about that, the truth is, I'm sure I could adjust to anything picked for this home....when I (hopefully) move in! :-)

hi everyone,
trish,i have to go with you...i wrote in ,in an earlier blog that a nice piece of butcher block would be great....not only to break it up but you have one place to cut up all your foods on...if you think about it there isnt a person i know that dont have a cutting board...that would be eliminated by adding the butcher block.
have a great day everyone
keep on blogging

The lack of timely updates is becoming frustrating! What is the problem?

Also, is there any chance you can archive some of the earlier posts? It is very time consuming to page through everything on your way to the most recent questions and comments.

Thanks.

I have read the blogs and it looks like the metal roof is aclear winner.My question I went to the metalroofing web page and checked it out again. Question: Will you use Natural Metalr Painted Finishes? Also Vertical Panel or Style? Whatever you choose though no complaint.

Why vote for a relatively high maintenanhce countertop like granite?
Radiant heat in the floor is not the best idea for the cabin, especially if it is primarily for vacation/weekend use. It takes too long to get the air in the cabin and thus everything else warm just for a cold morning.

First time blogging on the blog cabin. I voted today and noticed that alot of what I liked was in the last blog cabin, which I never saw until after I voted today. I think I will check out a bit more of the site and read more of your comments so I can put a more unique picture in my mind for the cabin.

From winter wonderland in Wisconsin, where today's snowfall is shutting down the world, hello everyone! I agree with the idea of granite countertops, but the larger point is, don't we really want to keep life simple and easy? In everything we do here, we should consider the maintenance issues, and upkeep. Also, keeping the place clean should be an easy task, so lets take a moment to consider this in every choice we make. Chiao!

What's up with the blog? Has everyone gone to a place that I don't know about?

Hello Everyone,

Just wanted to apologize to you for the delay. I attended an off-site training seminar yesterday and had plenty of tasks queued up when I returned. So sorry for the long pause. I'll refresh again first thing in the morning and stay vigilant from here.

Best,
Watson, DIYnetwork.com Manager

I am in total agreement with most of the winning choices except one, (to which I protested in a former blog), the wood burning fireplace! Perhaps you can clarify this issue for me. Because burning anything levies environmental consequences—there are no exceptions! Burning wood obviously produces smoke and destroys trees. Trees are a renewable resource when managed sustainably, but without strong legal oversight, they usually aren’t. If you want a glimpse of what uncontrolled forestry practices can produce, just take a look at China, Iceland, or Ireland—countries that were once heavily forested. And anyone who lives in an area where burning wood for heat is common can attest to the air pollution it can produce! Even if everyone used EPA-certified woodstoves, the pollution would be vastly reduced, but nonetheless present. I would greatly appreciate information on the "Green & Eco" standards you will use on the construction of the wood-burning fireplace being used in this cabin. Thanks.....

Cabin on the lake is a dream - who cares if something is the same as the last cabin - I would have loved the last cabin too! This is too fun not to enjoy! Can't wait to win it! hehehehe

Ooh...I love the idea of bigger dormers with bookshelves on either side. Great Idea! And window seats too!!

Watson... a thought.. why don't you put the newest post in a different color print so that we could just go to the color blogs and start reading.. then when you add the next day the old blogs change to black print??? just a thought

Everyone if Watson has to do this alone with no help then we should all say Thank You for having to read all the blogs...

Do wish we could get some answers to questions ??
Basement, Garage size, Changes we have sugguested
But I understand they are STILL being worked out by the DIY TEAM.. I realize these things will come to us in time...

And to the person who said we all had silver spoons at birth... that isn't true... we have been educated by watching DIY and her sister stations.... and were taught we could DREAM BIG..
so that is what we are doing..
If we could build this Log Home what would we want in it.... so we vote on our wishes..
so lets let everyone have their Dream...
Have FUN !!!

my wishes are flip the outdoor patio (screens that can be pulled down), small patio on bedroom side with hot tub, main stairs to the lake (use as extra seating), Wall for the bed in the master bedroom to look out on the lake, tub upstairs in 1 bedroom, Large pantry and storage for vacs,etc.

Keep on Dreaming everyone !!!

Watson, I KNEW there was a good reason you didn't respond and post blogs every single day. Even a super human such as yourself needs a break, but you didn't even get one of those! Still working, no matter what! Let's give Watson a hand (left or right, he won't mind) and thank him for seeing to it that we get heard! No more grouches!

Still cabin dreaming, still can't wait till you start building, even though the voting is so much fun. I really enjoyed the person that told everyone with a silver spoon in their mouths where to put it. The money, I mean, not the spoons!

May the worthiest blogger win, and everyone have a great evening!

I'm not fussy - I just love log homes! And I would truly LOVE to launch my kayak off that property and explore the area!!! I can't wait to see the building start on this home in August! I caught the tail end of last year's Blog Cabin and was very sorry to have missed so much. I haven't a clue what to do to actually have a chance of winning.

First time blogger here. I just couldn't resist it any longer. I think the location and floor plan for the cabin is awesome! The layout will work well for young and old in my opinion. As for the voter turn-out, I think the opinions of everyone are clear. You got to have a stone fireplace, metal roof, and arts & craft cabinets. The fireplace is a great focal point and can bring the family together on cold winter nights. Everyone needs a place to discuss whats going on in each others lives. The metal roof is very durable and will look good throughout the years to come. However, I would like to know the gauge of steel and the warranty info. of the metal. I think the cabinets will look great in the kitchen no matter what the countertop material.

Our Dear Watson, glad to see 'the game's afoot' again. All's forgiven, since you've been honing your skills.

But, back to business...any replies from the DIY folks regarding the ACC that Keight found for us?

Is is safe to assume (we know what that does thought ;) DIY was/is fully aware of the ACC rules and is is synch with Lakefront Estates, or did something 'slip thru the cracks'....or is it NUNYA at this time?

Thanks for your hard work BTW.

I have read several comments concerning water shortage. In the interest of supporting "green" technologies, one advantage with a metal roof is you can capture rain water from the roof and then inexpensively sanitize it and use it for much of your daily water needs. Just an inch or so of monthly rain can provide several thousand gallons of fresh water, which means that same amount is not removed from the deep acquifers. Some states such as Texas, Washington and others used to and may still give homeowners financial assistance and/or tax breaks for installing a rain water capture system.

Another 'old' technology that can save energy is to preheat the water with solar energy. I recently saw a PBS program about all of the innovations some engineering colleges used to build into their entry for the 'green' housing contest in Washington DC.

I just want to say to you all who voted for the stone hearth fireplace...YUK! Come take mine out of my house, PLEASE. I don't care which of the other two would have won, but I sure wish it hadn't been that dang stone.
Oh well - I am pretty sure we won't win the cabin anyway, so it really doesn't matter!! LOL! I really enjoy the chance to vote and pick out things that I like.
LOVE the "power shower"!
I am with the people who think it needs a hottub!

Hi Bloggers & Watson,
Watson relax some of these bloggers need to take a chill pill! this is for fun. isn't it ?
First off I love Edwards grooves in the granite by the sink and i want them on the left side for food prep. I think we need litegreen granite (casta saraldo). all so an outdoor spa tub in a screened in gazebo (BUGS)on the side of the house. I hope the landscape will be native plants and more trees on the road side of the home.
later you all

Everyone has impecable taste. I'm voting for all of the current winners, except for counter top. I think the quartz would add more light in the kitchen.

Since some blogger have brought up the issue of drought in Tennessee, I thought I would proffer the idea of including an underground cistern. It would catch rain water from the metal roof, and could be used for watering the lawn and plants around the house. It would be a great environmentally friendly addition for little investment.

With energy prices skyrocketing, it would be great if part of the cabins energy could come from solar panels. You cant get much more eco friendly

I'm glad to see others are thinking like me,lets use some recycled materials in the house. Maybe we could find an old barn and use some of the wood from it on the floors or the ceilings. although I did vote for the Arts and Craft Kitchen people are right,a lot of dusting and I'm not into dusting.
Could we have a walkout basement? I did like the ideal of having the basement set up for the out of town guest you could be having.

Possible countertop compromise...

--Having once walked through a granite yard, my husband and I were stunned by the beauty and uniqueness of stone from all over the world, which helps explain its continued appeal in spite of the sealing issue. How about a custom-made dining room table using a beautiful, uniquely patterned granite top (not marble, due to its susceptibility to stains)? The soapstone or quartz would then be excellent options for the countertops as their subtlety would not compete w/the vibrancy of the Arts & Crafts cabinets (should they be chosen). From the photos, it appears they may be of hickory, the grain of which varies considerably.

a couple of other items...

--If they go with a walkout basement, how about supporting the deck w/"shallow" arches and sheathing these and the rest of the foundation w/the stone used for the fireplace (assuming that stone is the choice)? Then, how about a patio beneath the deck?

--Speaking of stone, how about a drystack, ledge style look? Would be a sophisticated choice for this beautiful home, different from last year, and is consistent w/log construction. Would also look great under the kitchen peninsula/bar (as I suggested in a previous post).

--Overhead fans throughout are great! That slight breeze often negates the need for air conditioning and makes the a/c more effective when it is needed.

--Having lived in the Mid-Atlantic my entire life (not to mention being a mosquito magnet), a screened in area is essential for comfortable summertime outdoor living.

--Still love the metal roof. Great for durability, and the ambience of the rain. However, hope that it would still be in an earth color--have seen blue on a log home, and seems inconsistent.

Enjoying reading all of the ideas! kim h

the best way to vote!!
when I win the blogcabin i dont want to be forced to change alot of stuff.
this is the options you SHOULD vote for.
to make MY life easier.
counters:granite
cabinets:contemporary
M.shower:power
F.P. surround:stone
roofing:metal

With the new design of the San Jacinto in the kitchen close off one of the doors leading out to the porch and put in double windows and place that door or double door on the other side in the living room that leads out onto the porch so you will not have to go such a long ways if you were haveing a picnic under the overhang on the other side of the porch. Love the design and great work.

Greetings all..
It looks like there are numerous posts asking the same thing about square footage, lot size, will there be a garage, etc, etc. All of these questions have been answered previously (see Keight at January 29, 2008 4:19 PM...this covers house size, garage requirements, etc.), and a few others knowledgeable about the area of this years cabin.

There's a multitude of excellent ideas and suggestions thus far. It seems like a lot of us were "spoiled" by Amy's attentiveness with last years Blog Cabin, but even then we underwent a certain "learning curve" with her, so let's cut Ahmed some slack. I'm sure the powers that be at DIY are taking all of our suggestions into consideration.

I agree with the previous suggestion about DIY posting the next block of items to be voted upon a week ahead of voting being opened, so we can research the upcoming items, and weigh the pros and cons before committing our vote.

My suggestion for next year's Blog Cabin...how about building it here in the Black Hills of South Dakota?

Just my $0.02 for today.

My thoughts and prayers go out to those who were affected by the tornadoes last night (06 Feb).

I have a great feeling that this next cabin will be amazing! Here's a wish list item for ya.... I think central vaccuming would be an awesome addition. It keeps dust and alergins to a minimum inside the home, and is sooooooo convenient.

Hi Ahmed/Build Team/Blog Line
I have been reading and researching roofing materials. I agree with Ross of Jan. 30. that said metal roofs are ok provided we use a product that looks like standard roofing.
There are several options available that look similar to standard shingles, give the life expectancy of the metal, have build in sound deadening, and help to insulate the heat, hopefully we select one of them.
.
Everyone is talking about using "GREEN" and keeping the cabin "Green" yet few by contrast are voting that way, I have little room to talk as I too have gone contrary to my desires to go "Green" I voted for the Power Shower.

I have been thinking about lighting in every room and hope that the build team will consider using Hunter ceiling fans with the lights hanging down from the fans. I have them in every room in my home with exception of the bathroom of course, and use them the majority of the hot humid summers here in the Chicagoland area. When the temps get really bad I have been known to turn on the AC but not often as the ceiling fans seem to move enough air to keep one cool.

People need to keep in mind the temps that this cabin will be subjected to, its not the Northern Midwest, its Southern Midwest. The average temps in the Smokey’s is a considerably a more temperate climate and in most cases if a home is insulated properly will have little problem in keeping warm. Its heat one should concern themselves with, I was just in Bowling Green KY. on Tuesday and the temps were in the sixty's down there. In Chicago the temps were in the twenties and low thirties. The cabin will be subjected to heat and humidity three quarters of the year, and with that in mind we should concentrate on an exterior that will accommodate that climate. Metal attracts heat not reflects it, and will be hard to insulate and keep the cabin cool let alone sound deadening during the heavy rains. Most, not all, but most metals for roofing are now coming from off-shore and now we support Southeast Asia in the cabin build another story for another time. We need to “Buy America” as much as possible. Soon there won’t be a America product if we keep up our current foreign trade policies, lets keep our eye on the ball. Think “Green” “Buy American” and not just from American companies but American made where and if possible.

Ahmed, has a date been set for ground breaking yet, are you going to be presenting it on line as a video? I think that’s something we would all be interested in seeing.

I’m confident that you will do a great job as the Build Host Ahmed and I fore one am looking forward to your first show on TV for the build.

To all Blogers, keep up the good work; I love to read the interesting and not so interesting comments we all have. Many are right on, some well, everyone has a right to his/her opinion. All are very interesting to read, and some have even provided me with new ideas for things I may incorporate into my own home here in Chicago.

Great job Y’awl
Bob

Just started blogging and used the voting. pretty simply cabin with a great location. Just a few additional comments. The kitchen would be great if it was more connected to the great room. It seems a bit disconnected, considering its a vacation home. Also, there seems to only be room for one surface type for voting in the kitchen. I think a mixed surface would be a great idea (ex. Granite and butcher block in the same space). It would give a little more visual interest. The metal roof seems to be the logical choice with it's good insulation qualities. I can invision this cabin as an old world chalet. Deep rich tones and thoughtful details.

Good Morning fellow bloggers! Very sad morning seeing the devastation in Tenn. and surrounding states. Our prayers are with all affected by the terrible tornadoes. Thank you Carrie Miracle for sharing your thoughts on a basement "bunker" room. I was thinking the same thing. I don't think it would add much to the pricing of the cabin, and would save lives. DIY, PLEASE install a bunker in the basement. I think everyone will agree that it would not be an option, but a serious must in the contruction. Thank you DIY for considering all view and comments. Cabincraver, even though I changed my mind on the counter tops to quartz, I don't think we are going to win as far as the counter tops. Also, I didn't know that cedar shingles invites silver fish. I certainly do not want to deal with that. With all the information on the roofing, countertops ect. I feel that a "redo" on the voting should be done. I am wondering if anyone knows if Blog Cabin 2007 was hit by the tornadoes? What about the community where 2008 is going to be built? Just wondering. With all the excitment of Blog Cabin 2008, and 2007, lets pause and think of the people in the area. We wish them God's grace to take them through this time. Watson, nice to hear from you again. We are all excited about this project....Oh! by the way, everyone is welcome to visit us....we will be moving soon to "Lot 5" at Lakefront Estates! :-) Happy Blogging!

OK one more observation/question...... The screened porch w/ the fireplace..... what will the floor be? Hopefully the Stone guys will do something there. Wood floors would seem dangerous especially when the embers pop out!! ( I know a firescreen is supposed to deter that...but hey,a stone or hard surface floor would be beautiful!)

Hi Everyone, I know the voting for the fireplace is over, and there was lots of discussion about which was more eco-friendly..wood burning or gas. I just came across an article which might give more insight to the issue. (notice, I said "might") :)Please check out the link. Thanks, velvet

www.thegreenguide.com/doc/ask/stove

I have been voting on a regular basis and some of the things I picked are winning while others are not. But, even if none of my picks came through I would be thrilled to win the cabin as my dream has always been to live on a lake. My husband and I both enjoy fishing and this would be great and provide an early retirement opportunity for us! It's fun to vote and dream, but "beggars can't be choosers"!
Cathy

Good Morning to all,
First time bloger! I am very excited about the chance to win a beautiful cabin. I wish that it was made as eco friendly as possible, with the least amount of upkeep. Who wants to be thinking about what needs to be done, when you have a beautiful lake to enjoy! I like being able to vote and would like more info on the choices. I also feel a garage and basement are a must.. PLEASE take in to concideration the weather in your choices. I am from IOWA and this is a factor that cannot be overlooked reguardless of where you live....

I've been readiing with interest the various blogs and the apparant disregard for some of the information provided by Keight and others. Since this is seemingly a gated subdivision and somewhat upscale, those hoping for a "cabin in the woods" look may be a little disappointed. The A.C.C. probably won't approve anything too rustic in an attempt to maintain a style more in line with their intended market. Things like the metal roof will probably be dictated to be something other than the one shown in our choices. It can be metal, but as I understand, must be made of a dimensional product, that is, look more like conventional shingles or roofing tiles.

Since it appears the garage question has been answered, the question is where are they going to put it? Judging by the lot shape and size, it would seem the lot is somewhere around 100' in width and the house appears to be close to 80' including the decks and porches. Soooo, if the garage is not supposed to be situated with its opening toward the street, where do you put it without it setting behind the house blocking the view of the lake? If there is little more than 10' on either side of the house, that leaves little more than enough room for a driveway. We may find that the covered deck with fireplace finds its way to the rear of the house which probably isn't such a bad idea anyway.

Whatever the actual layout turns out to be, it will be a super place for someone to win and hopefully live. I doubt if any of us would turn it down if our name gets pulled just because we didn't vote for the kind of countertop that was decided upon. Watson has lots of patience listening to all of us rail on about our passions and prejudices. Vote on fellow bloggers!

1st time to blog this site. The cabin is beautiful. I vote for quartz countertops. Simplicity is required at a cabin in the mountains. Metal Roof reminds me of days long gone. A trip to the Smolky Mountains is about relaxing, dreaming of a life in the quiet, peaceful countryside and enjoying the natural sites and animals. I think more windows for lighting would be better than solar lighting. Tankless water heater would be a great way to conserve energy. I enjoy reading the blogs and the opinions of others. When I win, I will allow others to visit for extremely reasonable rates.

The tax rate for RHEA CO. (where Blog Cabin 2008 will be located) is: $2.00 per $100.00 of the assessed value of the property. The assessed value is 25% (percent) of the appraised value. WHEW! That was explained to me to translate into everyday thinking as: Let's say the 2008 Blog Cabin lists as a $600,000.00 valued home....A $600,000.00 valued home would be taxed at $3000.00 per year.

Good Morning Watson....
So glad to know you were just attending an off-site training seminar (was that you, at SUPER CON?)
Since the blogs were not "refreshed" for what seemed like an extreme amount of time, tension seemed to be rising with concern that you had lost interest in the project. It was actually a relief to finally realize you were just otherwise involved, and not harmed by the fierce weather in Tenn. and the surrounding area.
But, come on... now that you know you 'worried' some of us.... could you just remember to post a comment saying you will be "off to deal with other parts of your job" and that you have no assistant who can release comments when you are away. (Would you like an assistant who could help with that???)

Hi Guys from us Guys,
We are so excited over the locations you pick, the choices you give us to pick from and the Awesome fun in knowing it matters! We would love to be the winners but know Joyce is enjoying her new cabin as well from 2007, and since my name is Joyce too, well...why not another Joyce> :))
We think the roof of metal is great, the fire place should be stone, and granite in the kitchen, with the Euopean kitchen cabinets is nice but I see others are winning over that...all are great.
We love the Hanging light, the styles of bathroom fixtures and all are super/which ever wins will be tremendous to use. The rain was nice but it would sure do hair styles in - and I like the ideas of having a tub also. Soaking is good for resting and peaceful leisure. One of the Old 4 legged ones would seem lovely. We had one we named "Matilda" in our kids classroom and the kids used it filled with pillows to read in.
Matilda was painted Forest Green. But also a hot tub for couples to enjoy would be nice also.
Will there be a Library wall with assorted shelving. I really do love my books! I paint and love lots of lighting and I also believe a cookout fireplace on the back would be super near the water. No fires please?
Thanks for all you are doing for this great adventure to give away!
Your Super People!
We loved it Amy last year and this is so great too. Will there be room in the Great Room for a Pool table? Just asking? We are in ministry so it would be good to use for Ministers to use for a Getaway...they all need one now and then. It would be used for His Glory!
Blessings and thanks for all you are creating "US GUYS"...whoever us guys are...
Joyce and Clifford Guy in Texas

Hello DIY bloggers.

First thanks Watson for telling us why the blog is not up to date. Hard to convince voters why not to vote for certain things if blog is way behind, Keep up the good work.

My heart goes out to all the people that were affected by the storms, your in my prayers.

Granite countertops are not going green vote recycled paper.

power shower is the biggest water waster, and you worry about drought.

There are metal roofs that look like cedar shingles.

Keep blogging and good luck

Mary from Texas

Love the site. Remember to keep the Kitchen as user friendly as possible as much time is spent there.

HI.... Did anyone else catch the post about suggesting the addition of grooves in the kitchen/utility countertop? What a great idea!

If you missed reading about grooving, The post was submitted by Keight at February 5, 2008 12:05 AM.

Anyone else interested in boosting the awareness of this application so that it might be considered for use in the 2008 Blog Cabin by DIY?????

I have included some of the information from the post, in case you think you may be interested in promoting it's use, but don't want to try and locate the original post....here goes:

...would it be possible to have the manufacturer put in the grooves that allow for drainage into the sink of the run-off from rinsed dishes, washed vegetables, etc.? For anyone who is unfamiliar with this countertop treatment... A picture of a grooved countertop can be viewed on the landing page at www.soapstone-co.com....(realize that soapstone is not the winner in the voting for the kitchen countertops, but a kitchen designer explained that the grooving can be done in granite,too. (it)... has actually been proven to help eliminate the accumulation of bacteria on wet areas near sinks on countertops. Spray Methods used to keep the countertops sanitary is all that is needed on the grooved area for cleaning purposes.).....
Any thoughts and comments on this idea, bloggers?

It seems every area of the our country is getting hit with some sort of tragedy. Every place has its weather disasters. I wish every one the very best in putting their lives back together after the recent tornados. but like other bloggers have mentioned - a safe room in the basement would be brilliant. I've lived through tornados & hurricanes and its so very scary. I don't want to be maudlin - but a safe room would bring peace of mind.

On another note - I just can't get over how beautiful that lake view is! I haven't the foggiest idea how a garage is going to fit on the lot or how DIY is going to get around it but I've enjoyed watching how they've solved problems before. Maybe next year the cabin design choices will have garages! I think that a walk out basement with a garage under the house could work. Just a thought - the 2009 cabin could be somewhere more west, maybe on a river or stream - just to even things out a bit! I am so looking forward to the start of the build in August & am glad that the twins are going to be back! What about river rock for the fireplaces?

For those who have mentioned that a dock would be nice .... Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) owns from the lake up to the 750 foot contour of the land on the lots in this development. The lot sizes do NOT include that land which is owned by the TVA. All lakefront lots are dockable, but the specific dock config. (there seems to be three choices at this time) are spelled out in the Covenants and Restrictions of the community. It is my understanding, that if a dock is to be built, the chosen style blueprint plans must be submitted to, and approved in writing, by the A.C.C., who will take into consideration many factors, including, but not limited to, the lay of the land of the lot. If approved, and built on the property, the 'ownership' of the dock structure will be the lot owner (you build it, you own it) and the lot owner will be responsible for the upkeep, maintenance, and such of the dock.

I agree that a tornado shelter of some sort would make a great addition. I am not sure of the cost of this, but it seems to me in light of the recent devastation that there would be no cost too high?

Comment on the power shower, with the recent water shortages, I would really like to see a standard shower head installed. The power shower is great but depending on how many heads are installed, each head using 2.5 gallons per minute, it would be very possible to use 15 gallons per minute. You have a lake in front of you if you want all that water!

I agree with the comment on the quartz counter tops, great look and a lot less maintenance. I also like the soapstone. You don't see that used very often, another great material for counter tops, and its so rich looking, gets even better with time, love it.

Watson--I'd no idea you were doing this by yourself. Other blogs I participate in have more than one moderator. Perhaps you need to designate a couple of interns! Or delegate when you know you will be away. Or, at the very least--give us a "heads up."
I doubt you'd have gotten chastised if we'd know what was happening. Just some thoughts!

Such devastation wrought by the tornados on Tuesday night in the East of Tennessee should remind us all of how fickle and powerful weather patterns can be. My thoughts are with the people in the regions affected and also with the design of this cabin. I was opposed to a basement originally but this reminded me that without it there really is nowhere to hide. Carrie Miracle and others have made a case for at least a 'refuge' room and a basement is the only realistic place so I add my name to the list of those asking for this to be considered.

Thinking about the community that is planned (but not yet in existence) in this development, I'm struck by the difference from last years Blog Cabin. That was in a long established community. Here the cabin is one of the first (about the 4th by the look of it) sites to be sold and developed in this community. There is, as yet, no community but a lot of plans and ideas. This being so it's a wonderful opportunity to set some standards and design a truly unique cabin. With this in mind I would urge people to look beyond the granite, metal roof, power shower and other cookie-cutter things or at least research them to suggest modern, green and efficient versions and not just the same-old things. Remember, if everything is top-of-the range or the most expensive the eventual winner will be saddled with a very hefty tax bill and probably forced to sell in a very depressed market. Sometimes the most expensive isn't the best way to go.

Every time I look at the cabin and all the features that have been chosen I want to cry. It to me, is the most beautiful sight I have ever seen. It amazes me how many of you have voted the same as I have. My heart melts and will be envious of the family that wins this home. Heaven on earth!!
Keep up the great work!

My thoughts and prayers go out to those pummeled by the devastating tornadoes. Living in "tornado alley", I have been in 3 natural disasters. A shelter is a must in such an area, and sometimes those don't help! God bless and keep you all.

I keep trying to get quartz to catch up, but the more I vote the behinder it gets! I was really hoping people would research it and see it's beauty and qualities.

Can't we give DIY the benefit of the doubt and know that if something is required it will be taken care of, and quit worrying about things that are required by the rules of the housing committee? Shouldn't we spend our time learning from each other, watching our cabin being built, and packing???? May the worthiest blogger win, and God bless you all.

Hi Watson and DIY gang
After much research I voted more wisely this time. I still wish that Watson, Ahmed and DIY Exec's would consider DISABLED PEOPLE in their plans when the cabin is FINALLY built! I would like to suggest a Tankless water heater for energy purposes, and a back up propane generator! In the kitchen should be a farm-style sink and a skylight like i said in my last Blog move the washer/dryer to the rear and flip the pantry to the other side and this would give room for a "mudroom" and a larger area for a sink and folding table and room for a freezer and shelves for canning! In the upstairs flip on or both of the bedrooms and make at lest one accesible to the loft and definately put in a bathtub preferably near the window and also put sky tubes in both upstair baths. I also still think a elevator would be a good idea especially for DISABLED PEOPLE. Ceiling fans throughout the cabin would help conserve energy as well. People read the Blog from Lisa who lives in the area to get an idea of the year-round weather!! Well that's enough from me today, until the next vote
Paula Smith
from the Beautiful Oregon Coast!!

This is a beautiful place, but I hope to one day see you here in Utah. There are many spectacular views here and I would love for everyone to see my state as I see it. I love the cabin, I did notice that there were a few ideas for add-ons. Each one of us has had an idea in their heads for their entire lives as to what their dream cabin will look like. I know I do, each month I get a magazine of log cabins, and I dream. I wont ever quit dreaming. I will someday have my own home, one in which my children and grandchildren will be proud to come to. Never quit dreaming, its what keeps some of us going at times. Bless you all and good luck!

to Sherry, February 6

There are many postings quoting facts and figures supporting wood as the most green fuel option. However, there are certain caveats. Open wood fires (in fact any open fire with any fuel) are very wasteful of fuel and heat. Wood and other solid fuels are also significant sources of particulate matter pollution (indoors and out). This being the case and the choice of fuel for a fire being wood it's a good idea to push for a modern, efficient, closed wood or wood pellet fueled fire. Then all the green positives of wood as the only renewable fuel source (solar excepted) can be realized. The wood or pellets must come from sustainably managed plantations. In the case of this cabin that's easy as there are numerous state, national and local forests nearby with well managed plantations of local hardwoods. Pellets have the additional advantage of utilizing sawmill waste and not requiring additional tree felling. They cost about $3.50 for 45lb bags and are clean and almost dust free. The newest versions of these fireplaces consume very small amounts of fuel (3 x 18inch split logs or about 2 lbs of pellets per hour to heat a house bigger than the proposed cabin). With their re-burn of gases etc the total particulate matter pollutants (smoke) can be as little as a 1/60 oz per hour. This is less than the weight of potentially allergy-producing pollen released over a similar time by one medium sized oak or dogwood tree. With a properly constructed chimney there will be no visible smoke and virtually none smelled either. Add tho this thermostat control for the heating, electric timer with battery back-up for igniting the fire and electronic ignition and the system works as well as any central air system.

I don't think anyone is considering heating the cabin with imported wood seriously, at least I hope not.

If I am reading the information provided by Lakefront Estates correctly, there is no natural gas piped into the development. Any gas fuelled fire will have to be propane. The tank must be underground, per the Regs. & Covenants of the Development, and the cost of heating the house will be considerably higher and will continue to increase significantly over the next few years. Also, LPG produces more than twice the amounts of gaseous pollutants than wood and isn't renewable.

I hope this helps. If you are interested in worked practical examples of wood and other fuel heating and their environmental impacts check-out "The Zero-Emissions Challenge, Part 3: Heating" at http://asymptoticlife.com/2007/09/05/the-monbiot-challenger-part-3-heating.aspx

Hi Bloggers,
First- my prayers and thoughts are with every family that has been affected by the terrible weather the past few days. Lets try to remember the 50+ recorded thus far.
After reading the blogs, I too would love a basement for storage and possibly a screened porch since I dislike bugs and they seem to enjoy me.I was unaware of the water problem since I'm from Michigan. It sounds like it would really be wise to have the underground cistern and some solar panels.
Take care Watson.

I love the plan and the site is paradise! I hope that the choices made this time around are a little different than those made on the last cabin
since the setting is so different -- not as rustic.

I think an enclosed porch would be a nice addition, making it usable year round. I went with slate for the roof, tile for the fireplace and european for the cabinets. I think it adds a little elegance to the cabin, while still keeping that cozy feel.

No matter what the final choices, this is going to a lovely place to live.

Knowledge is power. If I need more information, I research it. I'm amazed that anyone would think that granite is a "green" product. Does anyone think about the hole that is left in the ground after the slabs are quarried? How about the caustic solutions required to try to keep the tops from soaking up spills? Granite is NOT food safe!

Quartz is an option, but please don't think that it is perfect. Bleach can permanently fog the surface and yes, you CAN cut the surface. Guess what, you now have a counter top that is scratched for life without the ability to repair it. It stays cold and never warms up and if you want a real treat, read the fine print of the warranty! You will be surprised by how little is covered.

Concrete? Sure, let's go with something you walk on outside as your top. Oh, don't like the color? Let's spill coffee grounds and see what new swirls you can get. It isn't a matter of if your top will crack, but when. What a waste as you will be replacing the tops in a matter of years. Make sure you seal them with the same caustic stuff you use on the granite too.

People need to realize that no product is perfect and you do need to treat each product according to the instructions. Think you can put anything hot on Quartz? Think again. The manufacturer suggests using a trivet, so please don't do whatever you think you can because ill-informed folks tell you they "think" it is the best. You'll end up damaging your tops and being really unhappy because you thought you knew it all.

Concerning repetitive questions being previously answered- with over 400 comments on this blog alone, does anyone believe someone new to this would be able to read and remember all the information given. It would be really nice, and very helpful, if DIY would make a page for responses to help everyone keep up and keep track. This would avoid most of the repetitive questions. Just my 2-cents again. Thanks.

CabinCraver2008,

I would just like to point out that I did buy watson a virtual cup of coffee back when we were voting on DLOGS. I think a round of applause may be distracting to his task. So tomorrow, your job is to buy him a virtual latte:P.

terri,

when we're all done voting and the cabin is (or is almost) done. we shall get the chance to enter and win.

mr bailey,

you will most likely win and get

counters:BUTCHER BLOCK
cabinets:EURO
M.shower:standard
F.P. surround:brick
roofing:SHINGLE

and if i win all the choices will likely be the opposite of my choices. such is life.

Betty,

i was born with a silver spoon in my mouth, only because my mother wanted me to appreciate the good things in life. so be nice. and let us enjoy the fun (that includes griping) this is supposed to be.

I have had quartz counters for the past two years and love them. No sealing, no worries from hot pans, great for baking - they stay cool like marble.

I'd love to have a metal roof on our wooden house (cedar siding.) We had a mini-shear tornado through here and tree branches put 3 holes in our roof.

One thing I can't see from the pictures is how steep the bank is from the lot. Some of those Tennessee lakes have very steep sides. Will there be steps to the lake?

Please no full basement, it is not needed.
However, it would be nice to have a small
underground emergency shelter preferably
near the fireplace since they are usually
the only thing standing after a twister
or even a fire. As for the metal roof,
any type is great just change the color.
No green or red instead select a brown.
Would like to see a landscape plan with
walk down steps to the water's edge. Maybe
some raised beds along the way with walls
and non-corrosive rails. When are we moving
onward to vote new items?

I just want to say THANK YOU. I read some of the comments and most are very nice and informative. But some are negative for no reason at all. After all...diy doesn't have to give away a cabin. Let alone allow us to help design it. I hope to win the cabin just like everyone else. But even if I don't, it's been fun helping in the design. And yes...maybe even dreaming a little. So I would just like to say THANK YOU to diy and all of the people that have dedicated so much time and effort into building the beautiful cabins. I love voting and I agree whole heartedly about the screened in porch. I was born and raised in the Ohio Valley not far from TN and the bugs at night around the lakes can get pretty pesky :). I live in California at the moment because of my husbands job. But would love to have a chance to move back to my home area. So good luck to us all and God Bless. And please...let's remember to count our blessings instead of biting the hand that feeds:)

I too have been thinking a lot about those who were devastated by the tornadoes and hope the best for everyone in those areas. Someone mentioned above that the DIY team should include a basement bunker in the cabin. Having never lived in a tornado prone area (just hurricane prone here in Miami) I feel pretty stupid to ask this question but here goes any way! What happens if you have a basement bunker and there is so much debris piled on top of the entrance after the tornado passes that you can't get out? Do two way radios work from basements? Cell phones? I assume most phone lines would also be down so a landline phone would not be practical. How do you communicate with the outside world if you are trapped?

I think that many of you are being too mean "rude" to Mr. Watson. If you read all these blogs you would know it takes a while to read these things. He must read all of them kept and refused. Then consider this: This blog could be an extra responsibility over his normal job duties. And patience: should be a virtue, right! come on have some patience!! Good news comes to those who wait kindly & patiently!!!

It's difficult at first to understand why, in a region of the country so sensitive to drought and where there are already water supply problems, the power shower is leading so emphatically if people are at all environmentally conscious. However, if one looks at the blogs on the matter it's clear that voters prefer to feel clean and believe they will get cleaner using more water which they believe the power shower will deliver. Other shower types have much more boring descriptions ('regular', 'low flow' & 'rain'). They all sound like a comment on prostate problems and all infer less water, less power in the shower and, therefore, by inference but with no proof, less ability to cleanse. This is not necessarily so. If, as I suspect from the picture, the low flow shower is the "Ecofficient showerhead" from Kohler it can save up to 20% water while delivering just the same powerful spray as the most efficient power shower. I have 3 in my home and they are just as good as the ‘power’ heads they replaced. My brother-in-law has installed them in his new lake house in NC and is completely satisfied with the power and the look.

It’s hard for many people to bother to investigate the options being offered. However, if products are given labels that imply something they may not be then the urge to discover new products and technologies is further discouraged. Surely this is the opposite of what the DIY-Network is all about?

The concept of the Blog Cabin is great but a little more thought should go into the captions of the choices people are being asked to make. If captions are boring or unexciting there is little chance the items will be voted for. Can the design team try to level the paying field and give slightly less prejudiced descriptions of items or a little more information that will encourage bloggers to become better informed?

Even if the votes still go for the less eco-friendly options, the blog, which is a separate entity from the vote, can be a very useful forum for interested and engaged people to share ideas and concepts and to help inform each other. This could be a better and longer-lasting legacy of this endeavor than the cabins themselves.

There seems to be a big disagreement on the types of counter tops. What about a synthetic counter top that is made to look like quartz or marble? Wouldn't you have a bigger range of options with the new types of synthetic counter tops available and no digging in the Earth involved and they don't chip. Which seems to be the biggest complaints. Just something to thing about maybe.

Hello again my fellow bloggers. Just a few ideas I've been kicking around today. With the talk of energy and heating & cooling, I would recommend that a return air duct be positioned in the ceiling so as the heated air rises it can be recirculated back into the house. Also, a geothermic heating system is a good idea for this area.
As Tim posted earlier today, we must start supporting American made products. The steel mills in this country are on their last legs. Most have been bought by overseas companies while the rest are fighting hard to survive. Without the industrial and manufacturing jobs, our country will continue to go down hill. We already see this impacting our economy. If we continue to by the "cheaper" made products of our competitors instead of supporting our american based companies and workers everyone will suffer in the end. I cannot speak for all bloggers, but as for me, try to use as much American products as you can in this beautiful cabin.

How GREAT it would be to win a cabin on the lake!!! I love the choices that are offered for the cabin. And I agree vote different this time. Be different, go outside the box. You will be surprised what you get when you explore and try new things. Not the same old, same old.

I am glad the vote goes with the metal roof. This is a low maintenance choice. We are replacing the roof with a metal roof on my cabin here in Alaska. I like the stone fire place and the power shower. What kind of primary heat source is planned for this cabin? Radiating floor heat works well at -40 below, is cost effective and environmentally friendly. How about using bamboo flooring? It looks good, is very tough and can take a beating (Think mud, water, kids-dogs running in and out). Are there any plans for collecting and using rainwater, or using gray water for toilet flushing etc.?

Heading South, et al: I don't think the silverfish would be associated with these cedar shingles, since they're composite (AND have a 50yr life - like metal), I believe they'd only be possible with real, gen-u-wine cedar.

AND, the Quartz Qrew CAN DO IT! VOTE EVERY DAY, reruit freinds, family - get our soapstone and concrete brethren and sisthren to get on board and vote quartz every day too!

Standard Propaganda follows..........

QUARTZ - COUNTRY - COMPOSITE CEDAR

BASEMENT -walkout/roughed in, GAS LOG STARTER -elec. ign., STRECH FLOOR PLAN -lgr MstBdrm, closets, Kitchen/Island, CHIMNEY/FIREPLACE in BSMT, CLEANOUTs in chimny, TILE FLUE in chimny, BOATHOSE/DOCK, STONE PATIO(S) -behind wkout bsmt and at shore/dock, HARDWOOD & TILE FLRS, 40" FRONT DOOR w/SIDELIGHTs -NO DBL DR, AWESOME LANDSCAPING -Dazzle us, AHMED! GARAGE -2 1/2 or 3

QUARTZ - COUNTRY - COMPOSITE CEDAR
^^^^^
2/07 11:25 PM CST { 0 0 }
:^O> ;^)> (:^()> -uuu-| |-uuu-
"""""

I think that the tornadoes were more out in the western side of tennessee memphis and jackson tn and I think that the 08 blog cabin land is located mostly toward the north eastern side of tn. We are 3 hrs or so north from watts barr lake and I have been to townsend many times (07 blog cabin) about the same distance. I'm not sure how that area faired weatherwise. I am located in south central ky and we had us a couple of tornado warnings, several tornadic storms hit in close by cities and counties: but we were spared here. Thank God! It was scary knowing that all the tornadic storms were heading our way, as many of you know first hand as well, especially that it was in the dark and around midnight, we were up all night literally storm after storm. We heard the tornado sirenes and the police driving by warning everyone. Thank God for the emergency workers and meteroligists out there. They definitely don't get enough recognition. They have tough jobs. WE don't have a basement and had to go to my husbands families house, where they have one. My prayers are with you all out there recovering from the storms aftermaths.

Oh My Goodness! I found this site through the hgtv dream house site. I am going to stop entering on the "Dream House" THIS would be my dream house!!!
I live and grew up in AZ. I am so sick and tired of the desert! I hate that my children and I do not know how the seasons changing look and feel!
We vacationed just this last summer in the Smokey Mts. It is so unbelievably beautiful there! So green! I felt like I died and went to heaven! And this was during a drought!!!
To win this cabin would mean everything to me. As I'm sure it would to all of you. And to live on the lake! Oh my, the dream of all dreams!
Thank you for giving us the chance to win this gorgeous home and to dream the American dream!

Cathy blogged: but "beggars can't be choosers"!
on: Posted by: Cathy at February 7, 2008 9:52 AM

Cathy, in this case I beg to differ. That's exactly what we're doing, choosing - with a pinch, dash or heapin' helpin' of begging thrown in! ;^)

Sparing all from my shameless 'begging' this time.

It is fun to learn from all the research we are
all doing into the choices isn't it?
I changed my mind to soapstone counters because
of what I read from other bloggers....also
agree that radiant floor heating and a laundry
chute would be nice. How about at least partially screening some of the porch space for
pet owners who want their pets to enjoy being
outside without wandering...(or little children)?
and is there a donwstairs den planned?
Thanks, enjoy.

BLOGGERS,
Blowing your horn for a page and a half is not going to increase your chances of winning. How much did the winner blog last year? Look it up. Let's get to the point without draining my will to blog. Thank you, Vote for mirrors.

Watson,
Don't hide behind the screen; come out and blog. I know that is what you get paid a rediculous amount for, but now it's time to earn the bucks, same goes for Ahmed; Ahmed who? Come out!!

Hello again all,
This may be a given but I hope construction will include some preventive treatment for termites and other crawling critters. Here in SC, we have a huge fire ant problem and I think Tenn has them, too. Please keep in mind when landscaping.

Also, this lakeside setting with pine trees is sure to draw bats. How about using one or more bat houses to keep them around to eat mosquitoes but NOT in the house?
Keep smiling!

Ok, I know this is a little off track, but, if HGTV's Dream Home includes a vhicle, why can't the waterfront Blog Cabin have a boat as part of the package? So that the winner can enjoy the lake. Let's say a Bass Boat or something like that.

Hi Ahmed, Build Team, Fellow Bloggers,

First I would like to ask all the DIY Team and bloggers alike to keep the people in both TN. And KY. In our prayers these coming days and weeks ahead after the devastating tornados they were hit with. I was down in Bowling Green KY. on Tuesday getting home late Tuesday night. I drove in a rainstorm all the way back to Chicago and I can tell you it was nothing short of nasty. The people I meet with in Bowling Green just narrowly missed being one of the victims of the tornado’s that hit that area by about 100 yds. A home just down the block from these was completely gone nothing let but the foundation. These people are without power and heat, food and shelter.

After the devastating storms that ravaged the TN. Valley/KY. area this past week, we need to consider more now the safety of the people that will be living in this new cabin. I feel the same as another blogger that a storm cellar should be created as a place for these people to go in the case of sever weather condition’s. It’s an area of the country that sees more then its share of very back storms.

I suggested once, and will again, that we have only two (2) comment areas. One for the old comments, and one for new comments. New comments become old comments after a certain amount of time i.e. one day then are moved to the old comment area. As it stands right now I have come across a few areas where comments reside Again we need to read many comments several times in an effort not to miss any, and by doing it the way I have suggested, you have the old comment area, and the new comment area, with little back reading to catch up if you miss a day or so in several comment areas.

I read a comment from a Mary in Texas; she must have metal roofing on her home as she said it’s not that noisy. We spec out and put metal flashing with layers of insulation and tar on top of metal for industrial applications yet in a rain it’s very noisy with very poor insulation properties. Hot in the summer and cold in the winter. It’s used because it’s cost effective.

Ahmed, I’m looking forward to your fist show on the cabin build, it should be a very interesting show.

Guys remember “Green” and “Buy American” soon there won’t be anything left “Made in America” if our politicians in Washington have anything to say about it, and I don’t mean Bush, he’s a puppet for the true politician.

Bob

I don't know if we'll be voting on alternate building products, but I'm a big fan of composite materials for the decking and handrails. I may be one of the only cabins in Murphy NC to have composite, but trust me, it's terrific. Murphy NC has very similar weather to the blog cabin site so I would think what works for me would work for the blog cabin.

The Smoky Mountains are "SMOKY" because of the humidity. Using pressure treated or some other "natural" material will mean sealing/staining/cleaning on a fairly regular basis. This is going to be a 2600 + sq ft home. Anything to reduce the upkeep is a must. Composite decking & railing has been easy to live with. Hose it off or a light pressure wash and you're good to go!

Hopefully if everyone hollers about the screen porch needing to be on the kitchen side, we may be heard. If I win, this cabin will be closer to my husband's work !! I'll just catch our supper for us while he's at work. Is the master bedroom large enough for a kingsize bed?

There are shingles now available with built in solar panels, no more unsightly raised flat structures. Perhaps this should be looked at to see if styles are available to match cabin decor.

Tankless water heaters are good (to echo a few other bloggers)!

If relief of land supports it, a garage under the cabin so that entrance is from rear to support ACC requirements and to add basement space and a place to duck into in case of bad weather.

Hey all,

There's so many comments here that I haven't read through, so I'm not sure if this has been brought up already . . . I feel like most of the choices are heavily influenced by the pictures. For instance, the roof--the only one pictured on a log cabin-style home is the metal; the fireplace--only the stone surround is featured in a log cabin-style home. I suppose these examples are fairly obvious--you don't see many log cabins with tile-surround fireplaces or slate-shingled roofs or modern kitchen cabinetry--but there are others that are subtle, for instance the shower choices--I think the power shower is winning in part because its picture has a fireplace in the background, evoking that log cabin feel.

Don't get me wrong, I'd still be voting for the metal roof and stone surround even if there weren't any pictures to look at. But I think some of the voting results would be different had the choices been comparably showcased in the pictures.

What an amazing home this will be. The scenic setting is ideal for vacation or all around living. Will there be a dock for a boat? The choices of building materials is outstanding. Someone will really enjoy living there. Thanks so much for allowing our input.

I loved voting last time for the many features of the log home that actually did get the high marks from everyone...I 'm trying again to vote on the other things but am having a problem veiwing the enter key to register the vote! HELP.....
I only get the roof option (question #5) and thats it.....

WOW! I think this will be the most beautiful blog cabin for many years to come!I love the floor plan and the location is just plain awesome.I would rather have seen a heated slate foor in the kitchen,and having 5 kids more bedrooms but hey all things considered just beautiful guys.I love watching your show it makes me feel good to think that somebody might win their dream home!I just hope its not someone that already has two or three you know.Any way I too enjoy home improvement and I also love building anything out of wood. So far I have built a wonderful coffe, and end tables for my wife,along with some adirondack chairs and a few shelving units. I really enjoy diong it so if you guys need any help whatsoever please contact me and i live in union co. so i can be there yesterday lol

I am very excited about this cabin. How many bedrooms and bathrooms will there be? Will this be a home someone can live in or vacation? Keep that in mind when building.

Good morning everyone - I've been reading the blog comments & it seems to me that a lot of you out there must think the Blog Cabin team is inept. I'm sure before they started listing the items to vote on that they were aware of all the restrictions & covenants that this place has. Like most contractors, they would have had to get in touch with the people at Lakefront Estates. Let's give them a benefit of a doubt & assume they know what they are doing & for us out here in bloggerland to enjoy dreaming of owning this cabin. I agree that we should not bite the hand that feeds us. No one is making us to enter for a chance at winning this home. Let's all be nice & dream of owning this home. Thanks.

Okay now why isn't the blogg update last post I see is the early Feb 7.

Why blog and express our opinions whe soo it will be to late to change others votes.

Also some of the questions ask all throught the blog have not been answered few examples:

Does the area required a garage?
What about helping the disabled?

Hello fellow bloggers. It appears that it is going to be metal roof and granite counter tops at this point. I agree with Doug that it will need to be a design that look like tiles or shingles to fit in with the requirements of the development. Which is the look I would prefer. I have said it many times so one more will not hurt, I guess. There is too much granite used and the up keep is too much. I prefer quartz for what it is worth.
Lots of bloggers keep asking about a garage and the question has been answered. The development requires a garage we just have not be told where it will be located.
If our name is chosen we will be happy beyond words and love making wonderful memories there.
Happy Blogging

hi fellow bloggers and diy,
i was wondering the graniet thet everyone is choosing , do we get to pick the color or design too.i went looking at counter tops for my kitchen and noticed they come in different colors to which i was unaware of. ive raised a hair or two in here....but realized ,hay this is suppose to be fun and informative...its not a debate like the president(haha)come on guys some of your ideas are awsome
you can learn alot here.
margaret

Hello, Fellow Bloggers!

This is my first time commenting on this blog site so please be kind to me.

The choices in the lead seem to be eco-friendly - or can be with the correct equipment. The woodburning fireplace IS more eco-friendly than gas if done correctly (See "Kina's" blog and link: www.thegreenguide.com/doc/ask/stove

As for a basement - PLEASE include a basement in this cabin. Until a couple of months ago, I lived at Lake Cumberland in Kentucky - 2 hours away from the Blog Cabin site. There are many tornado watches and warnings in the area, just as there were deadly tornadoes this past week. It is very important to have a basement in this area, for safety reasons. If you have to make a choice between a basement or garage, please make it a basement. The winner (hopefully, me!)can always add on a garage if s/he wants one.

HELPFUL HINT:

First Comes: The Blog Post

THEN: A BLACK LINE running beneath the Post
_________________________________________________
Posted BY: Blogger's Name, Date Time Line*
*The info BELOW THE BLACK LINE Indicates the person who submitted the Post Directly Above the black line.

It is so great to note that many bloggers are reading each other's comments and then, referencing back to them to help other fellow CabinHuggers make informed choices. Just take a minute to be aware of the way the posts are formatted. Providing the tools needed to find the original post quickly and easily among the huge number that are posted is really important.

Watson did mention this black line confusion/situation when a blogger referenced Watson as author of a comment he did not make, but mamy may have missed his post.

GOOD MORNING CABINHUGGERS!

Below is a post containing all of The Covenants and Restrictions for Lakefront Estates Subdivision that I have included in several previous posts. There are more Covenants and Restrictions yet to post, but I just thought putting the ones already posted into one entry might be helpful.

Please note: The Caps. in the greeting above represent youthful, gleeful, enthusiasm!... and, oh yes, to get your attention - (Smile)

THE COVENANTS And RESTRICTIONS for LAKEFRONT ESTATES SUBDIVISION,
1. Multi-level houses will be considered on an individual basis by the Architectural Control Committee (A.C.C.), but shall have a minimum of 2600 square feet heated living area, not including the basement area. >>>
2. All houses Must Have a minimum two-car garage that will accommodate at least two LARGE SIZE automobiles. Garages shall open toward the side or rear of the house unless otherwise approved by the A.C.C.. Detached garages will only be permitted with the prior written approval of the A.C.C.. All garage doors must be located at the side or rear of the dwelling (or detached buildings if allowed and approved) and emphasis will be given to insure that garage doors will not face streets. No trailer, trailer house, boat , or recreational vehicle shall be parked on any Lot, except within the enclosed garages erected in accordance with the plans and specifications submitted to and approved by the A.C.C.. Garage doors shall be kept in working order and shall be kept closed when not in use. >>
3. No plumbing vent or heating vent shall be placed on the front side of any roof of any Lot dwelling or accessory structure. >>
4. Exterior Lighting of buildings for security and/or decoration shall be limited to concealed up lighting or down lighting. >>
1. Roofs: Roofing materials shall be "architectural dimensional shingles" of at least a twenty-five (25) year expected life manufactured by a company or companies approved in advance by the A.C.C. in a color approved in advance by the A.C.C.. Other roofing materials, to the extent three dimensional or higher quality, may also be utilized with the prior approval of the A.C.C.. The majority of the roof pitch must be 10/12 or steeper on one-story dwellings and at least 8/10 or steeper on one and one-half story and two-story dwellings, except as otherwise approved by the A.C.C..
2. Section 8 Docks: All docks must be permitted by TVA and be approved by the A.C.C.. The following criteria must by (sic) met: the dock must be one of three styles: a single slip dock with a 6x12 pitch roof (it can have extra overhang), a sundeck dock or a 4-way hip roof dock with a copula. A dock may contain up to 1,000 sq.feet: all roofs must be the approved forest green or burnished slate metal unless specifically approved otherwise by the A.C.C.. The A.C.C. shall allow cedar shake roofs to match the primary dwelling. All dock plans must by (sic) approved by TVA.
3. No exposed, above ground tanks for the storage of fuel or water or any other substance shall be located on any Lot: provided, however, that this prohibition is inapplicable to exposed or unexposed above or under-ground tanks for the storage of sewage for the entirely of Lakefront Estates Subdivision.
4. No living tree having a diameter greater than 4 inches, breast high, may be cut on any said lot without first obtaining written consent from the A.C.C..

Hope this information proves enlightening for all those who are taking this adventure to heart and breathing life into our little cabin by the lake building extravaganza!

p.s. The Covenants and Restrictions referenced were marked as the final version and were recorded on November 1,2007.

You know, One thing that I have noticed on both log the cabins so far. The interior doors are not wide enough. I am confined to a wheelchair, would love to win, but I would have to modify the floorplan before I could move in. It looks like the interior doors are in the 28-30 inch wide range. I would like to suggest 36 inch wode interior doors. I don't know what would have to be modified to make this work, but even for people not in wheelchairs, it would make moving furniture, etc. much easier. Just a suggestion. Another suggestion is LET ME AND MY WIFE WIN PLEASE!!!

This information is for everyone that is interested in a complete "green home!" Well check out the "green home" give away being built on www.hgtv.com the home is being built near hilton head in SC. a place called Traditions and it comes with a hybrid yukon when the sweeps starts....

I've read everything I can find on the cabin, but just cannot find the location. Where is it going to be built? I know the fireplace has been chosen but please consider an insert with a fan that will blow the heat into the room. I live in Alaska and it is a huge energy saveer. Also, let me know where it is?

my word people have gotten snarky!! this is not passion but bad manners geez. who would turn this down ?
i vote for stone fireplace just cause its cooler looking but i have a very efficient wood stove, 2 cords of wood will get me thru this winter . and i know what drought is we're in the mountains of no az, this year got lots of snow but its a first for us, so i voted for the rain shower. counters i really like the soapstone altho i have the butcher block got to admit its pretty cool easy to clean. my cabinets are hickory craftsman style very rustic geez this is a cabin not a penthouse. so i guess some things are a given. i like the whole green recycle thing, like cork bamboo ect would be cool to have radient heat . and as far as roofing i like the metal it seems to tolerate the wind better we keep finding our shingles in the forest. im concerned that so many are not being practical.

One thing I would like to see is that every room,
including the master bath, is prewired for CATV/SAT, and Telephone for any tech updating and
home networking

I was wondering if you could put a big sceen lcd tv in the cabin.I wanted to put a fan by the fireplace so the heat can surround the great room.What part of Tenn. is it in???How many acres does the cabin come with.Does the cabin have a storm shelter,tornadoes are commen here.I heard about them on the news.Mabey you can make a genarter to make elcetricty from the lakes current, to power the house.Add a basement.What kind of wood are you useing???PLEASE LISTEN!!!!!!!

Mabey you can add a indoor pool and a mancave!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!And a 3 car garge!!

Carrie Miracle...

I couldn't find a green home sweeps at hgtv.com..can you post a link?

Thanks!

Melanie

I love the spot that was chosen for the next cabin. I think it's important to keep in mind that people staying in a cabin like to live a casual life. The countertops need to really, really easy to keep up. If we use something that takes time to take care of, it will not be kept up. I like the look that money has been spent on the room, but maintenance is an issue for whomever is doing the cleaning.

Never mind...I found it. HGTV Greenhome giveaway is coming "spring of 2008."

Looks pretty interesting!
Here's a link:
http://www.hgtv.com/hgtv/green_home/

Melanie

I voted for the roof out of metal because we have to worry about fires as much as being eco-friendly. If you can find a shake-shingle-look roof that is made of something recycled and fire-retardant I would vote for that. When deciding on what to put inside the cabin, please think of maintenance. The "mom" (male or female - the one that does the cleaning) of the group, does not want to spend all their time cleaning when on vacation. Bamboo used for wood products is a very wise choice (floors, cabinets, furniture, etc.) since it's a renewable resource. Yes, you should look at ways to "slow the flow" of water where it is possible, but don't you just love a great shower???

I have read most of the comments made and one of the best I saw was written by Kim P suggesting a tankless hot water heater. I've seen these installed and they take up less room, are a lot more efficient as they don't have to keep all the water up to temp. and therefore use less power. I'm sticking with the metal roof but I think the power shower would be great.

Hello Out There In Blogville USA,

A couple of comments;

(1) I think the reason that so many of the choices are the same as last years cabin is simple. Many of us did not participate in last years blog for a variety of reasons. Also, when you think of the word "Cabin" certain things naturally come to mind such as metal roofing, lots of wood detailing, etc. Nothing wrong with that, it's just some of us voted based on our "Dream Getaway Place" without giving it much additional thought or insight into the realities of this build. 2,600 SqFt Wow that is really more like a dream home than cabin.

(2) I definately voted without really thinking about all the options and their weightiness in the long term. For example, I voted granite because I would love to have granite counter tops they are gorgeous (I thank the Lord for my current laminate but would love to upgrade to something nicer like most people). However, after reading this blog and doing some research on my own I agree that the Quartz is probably the way to go (I'll do better on future votes I promise). I do still think that the metal roofing is the way to go as far as fire protection, length of life, and well I really just think it looks great on everything from 400 sqft minicabins to million dollar log mansions. I think that the European Country Cabinets have a nice detail that would be "AWESOME" in a Maple Hardwood with a medium colored coffee type stain and rubbed wax instead of urethane (I've seen and felt such, Man They Were SWEEEETTTTTT!). I voted for the power shower also. Okay, I know that we are in a severe water shortage. So, I will try to vote more conseratively in the future (But, honestly I could just about kill for one long shower right about now). I really like the rock and would definately stick with that over brick and tile. However, I think a stack stone type layout would give a nice country aesthetic while still having some upper class appeal for the high end neighborhood. ($300,000 for the lot, REALLY... Holy Cow Batman I am so not in this tax bracket)

Also, I submitted a post yesterday that does not seem to have made the cut. So I will again add my request for a quilt to be made to go in this cabin. You know maybe a simple patchwork with each designers signature stiched in. Anyway, I hadn't heard anything like that yet and EVERY CABIN NEEDS A QUILT!!!

You guys and gals have really put a lot of thought into this process. The people participating for the second year are definately at an advantage for researching the choices, I never even really thought about it until after I had voted and then read all the blogs. I do agree it would be nice if DIY would provide some more information prior to opening the voting or maybe even a preview page of what you will be voting on so that you can do your research before you are in the middle of voting.

Keep up the GREAT WORK!!! I think I am hooked, bring on the next set of choices, bathroom and kitchen fixtures? doors and windows? door knobs and hardware? paint or stain colors?

I'll keep voting... Down with Granite... LOL :0)

This is turning into Blog Cabin 2007. While it was nice, we don't need a repeat of it. Can you say boring.

Hi, I don't know if this has beed posted yet but someone asked in which city the cabin is located.
Go to http://www.lakefrontestates.net/location.html

That page has lots of details about the area.

It's in Spring City in Rhea County TN

so, when can we actually enter??

So far this looks to be as nice a cabin as the one that was built last year. You go!!
Is there a deck planned and if so will it have a built in BBQ grill? How about a boat and fishing dock?

I am voting for lots of unpopular things this year. I am all for change. Let's not repeat last year's Blog Cabin. However, coming from California (originally) where fire storms rage I will always go for the metal roofing. And since Tennessee is currently experiencing a drought we should consider being prepared for this. I would love to see the cement countertops. Normally I love the Arts & Crafts cabinets in a home, (especially my own) but how about a more traditional look. Remember this is a cabin. This building should not be too refined in its decor. Showers I can live with whatever, but a "power shower" is something I have never encountered. Again, let us remember the drought situation. I really appreciated last year's cabin where Amy & her crew brought in local artisans. Since I live in the Watts Bar Lake neighborhood I am interested in seeing what special details are brought to the 2008 cabin. So sad to see Amy replaced. Can we still have the twins building the cabin? Isn't this a lake side lot? How about a fabulous dock with a BBQ, refrigerator, and lots of storage. As I mentioned in a previous blog....wide open space in the interior and lots of beds for guests.

The bunker that I suggested would actually be below the basement level. It would hold up to eight people, lined with a bench to sit down, supplies such as batteries, flashlights, water ect. are important. The hatch door on top would be steel. This would not be costly at all to install, and with lives, we just cannot put a price on it. For the question referring to who would know you were there with all the house on top of you. I am sure family and friends would be aware that you had a bunker in your house and alert the authorities where to look. On a lighter note, I was thinking about the rear mud room, the kitchen area, and all the bathrooms would be nice to have ceramic floor instead of hard wood. I think with all the mud coming in, it would be easier to keep clean. I am hoping for alot of lighting inside the kitchen, and I feel that both exterior and interior doors should be wider than the Blog Cabin 2007. As for the master bedroom, I was thinking that it should be able to have a king size bed in it, with plently of extra room to walk around. The Blog Cabin 2007 master bedroom looked rather small. At any rate, I am sure this one will also be wonderful. I am still voting on quartz, but I don't think we are going to catch up with the granite. The taxes are relatively low for the property and I am please for that. When is contruction going to start? Thanks again to DIY for all their hard work in putting this project together....

My suggestion has to be to eliminate the large windows on either side of the fireplace and in their place install two sets of french doors with transoms. It will open the space to the outdoors and create a larger entertaining area, while still giving the space the light and views intended in the original design. Anyway that my two cents....Mike

Hello fellow bloggers ,
I have noticed that alot of you have mentioned the fact , that this is a repeat of the same old..same old... My comment is to remove or not include the most popular choices and put in those that can be eco friendly or a good project to learn from . Also the home needs a basement w/ a renforced storm area within it. The decks facing the lake needs to be enlargened to get the most of the view and entertaining , and the area where the outdoor fireplace is , needs to be screened in . Please DIY don't remove the trees . There's nothing worse than no shade .

I have been reading the many blogs, agree with the screened in porch. I live on a lake in the GREAT Mississippi Delta where the mosquitos are terrible in the spring and summer months. A screen in porch would allow the winner to utilize the porch year round. Another suggestion is to make the fireplace inside gas burning and to put a wood burning fireplace on the screened in porch. This is a much cleaner option for inside the home.

Looking GREAT - good job America !!! Having had a mountain cabin previously, would suggest a wide porch. MANY times we had guests for dinner and served on the porch; wider (12 or + feet) provide additional comfort for dinner guests and for other activities such as card or board game playing.

the POWER shower does actually seem more eco friendly than the other choices. for two reasons.

1. it's programable. if you just have to have a low pressure shower i'm sure that can be accomplished via the programming. this would likely be my choice on a day to day basis.

2. but let's be practical. life is tough and full of many stressors. the POWER shower would be an excellent and therapeutic way to unwind. and we all know that stress leads to poor health which leads to trips to the doctor which leads to medical wasted. so throw me a bone folks. if 20 minutes in a massaging shower can help prevent medical waste.

Dear Watson,

It was so nice that another blogger had to tell us that the blog site had been moved. Could you correct the problem for the next round of voting so that we can just hit the blog button next to the vote button so that we are directed to this address rather than going into the old website. (Just in case you forgot or didn't realize that this was happening here is the website that you are directed to when you hit the blog button when you go into vote: http://blogs.scrippsnetworks.com/diy/blogcabin/) There are still blogs being posted to the old blog website. Afraid that you have lost individuals who had been blogging and did not catch that there was now a new website for posting/reading the blogs! Or maybe that was what you wanted in the first place when you changed the website.

For those who would like the next Blog Cabin in the West - HGTV has built "Dream Homes" in the west so how about putting one in the Northeast - we really are friendly up here and have many areas in all New England states with beautiful scenery and of course we have gorgeous mountains -Western MA has some beautiful mountains along with Vermont, New Hampshire and Maine. We also have beautiful coastlines as well! So my vote is to have the next Blog Cabin built in New England!

Great ideas from everyone. Thanks Clive for the great information you have provided. Kim, Keight, Grace, and all the others thanks for the time you have spent researching options! It will be interesting to see what the next round of voting will bring.

Does having a tin roof cause a lot of noise during a rain storm?

The choices are good, but I would like to pick the details... that is what makes a place have character. Like when you are entertaining is the person in the kitchen able to be involved while still being in the kitchen? I think that a seating area in the kitchen that is not at a counter would encourge people to linger while you clean-up or prepare. I can remeber a couple of vaction areas that we visted that did that and it has stayed in my memory. Also, what is going to set this cabin apart from all the others? We all know that you can build a beautiful cabin, but what options are out there that we might not know about yet that might be good choice? We all know that you are going to "market" and getting previews of up and coming materials and ideas! Looking forward to the process...

agree that a tornado shelter of some sort would make a great addition. Just thinking of safety.
As for the roof i know that can come lots of colors.But Stander is blue, green, red. Can Have what at higer cost. Oh Still think that the cabin needs place to park. carport or out bulding garage.

thats 2cents Tracy G. Smith
Ceres,Ca.

A family member built a cabin in the Lookout Mountain area and they started having problems with a low amount of rain fall, but one of the things that they did to help there situation was to create a rain barrel system them captures water and then filters it so that it is used in the house and takes some of the pressure off of the well. Maybe that might be an options that would be of use to this house as it is in somewhat of the same area.

Watson, It sure doesn't seem to me like you censor these blogs! I think we should all be able to get along and vote our choices respectfully - and, if not . . . get censored while we are standing out in the hallway. Then, when all is said and done, we should be happy with any choice made by the majority votes and be very happy for the person/family who is blessed enough to win this cabin/home. I'm sorry, but I was amazed at some of the things I've read, and I just feel like we should all be able to blog like adults. :) I'm not talking about those bloggers who nicely try to persuade us to change to their choice - I think we learn by listening to why they feel their choice is best-but the downright mean blogging directed at individuals. Can you censor it?

I am so sorry to hear about those dastardly tornadoes. It does give rise and credibility to those blogs asking for a basement and/or a "safe room". I would request a safe room in a basement, as my family hails from tornado alley and I have seen first hand the destruction tornadoes cause. I'd even be willing to give up certain other luxuries I have dreamed of adding - (mud room, hot tub, sky lights, and I loved the idea of the screened-in loft balcony!!!) - to have the security of safety.

Also a HUGE THANK YOU to Keight and the others who have provided so much information on the C & R. I still am wondering where that garage will be, or if whomever wins the cabin will have to build one themselves? Watson? You seem like the perfect person to answer this question. . . Do you know? Or is there a reason to keep us in suspense?;)

Another HUGE THANKS to DIY and Watson, and everyone else for this blog cabin opportunity!

Happy NICE Blogging! Micbeth

I love the idea of this cabin, but I don't understand why anyone would want a metal roof. Coming from a farming community, this will make the house look like a barn! Shaker would fit right in w/the wooded area. Love the stone fireplace, but would immediately add the gas logs. Also the quartz countertop and Euro cabinets are my picks! Can't wait for the next decisions! Please add an attached garage. Thanks.

Hello Bloggers,

My thoughts and prayers go out to those pummeled by the devastating tornadoes. A safe room is a must! Please!

Wow, A cabin on a lake! The plans show it is going to be beautiful and so roomy! I can't wait win this and set by the lake and watch the stars at night.

Well I'm happy with this log cabin just the way it is. I feel I would be so lucky if I could win this and thankful for any of the up grades. When you are stuck in the city in a high rise with crime all around, and you are in fear for your life to go out anytime. This win would be a miracle from God for me. So you see, there will be no complaint's from me, I would just be so thankful to win and get out of this city so That me and my children could have a real life with out fear of being shot. No freedom here to play or even be outside at anytime. We would be the ones hitting the ground when even a car back fires because that's what our life is like here. Always in fear and ever so thankful we made it home another day to be with each other for one more day. This isn't any way to live. If only our prayers could be answered and we could win this!

So no complaint's from me!

Thanks Diy and Watson for the chance to win the blogcabin and a chance to dream!

Susan from the city

I have entered several times but have yet to see a post I have made. Are post screened for selection and does it count as an entry if it is not posted?

Everything is coming together quite well, I like the original layout and hope that no changes are made!
Vince

Carrie...the location is in Tennesee, one hours drive from knoxville.
I love that DIY listened to us and built the childrens room upstairs. Children have no business being on the ground floor. I also love that the Master Bedroom is downstairs. I believe if you build a log cabin, it should have a little resemblence to your great-grandparents place. I guess I'm just old-fashioned.

Yesterday I posted a comment but it didn't show up but my comment was about a post by Kim P which suggested using a tankless water heater. These heaters are very thrifty on use of the electricity and get hot almost instantly. I think it was a very good suggestion. I also mentioned in an earlier blog that I think solar panels on the roof would be great idea, especially with all the bad storms out that way.

Hi Everyone!
I would also like to know what happens to my blogs since they don't seem to make the page. I see the same people's comments over and over. Yet I've sent in 3 comments and have not seen any. I'm going to try one more time, hopefully I'll make it through. So here goes..one more time. First of all a basement is definitly important in the KY-TN area. Tornados are a way of life there and all that live in the area know it's always best to have shelter from the storms. I also am second guessing my opinion about the counter tops and would like to know what the DIY experts think would be the cleanest and most enviromently friendly way to go on this subject. I also think a compost area would be good since the person that gets the log cabin will be dealing with a lot of leaves and waste from the yard. I agree as well with the person that mentioned the fence, since the area will have it's share of wildlife and if you want to grow flowers or a garden in the area you will need to fence them out. A garage/work shop would also be nice since the winters can be very cold and sometimes snowy. Well that's all for now. Be well fellow bloggers and God Bless

For those still asking about location: beautiful Watts Bar Lake near Knoxville, TN. Still really would like to see a walkout basement w/ parking and DIY workshop. The floorplan is so-o-o adaptable to that. And the large portion of porch ought to be flipped to dining side and screened. And triangular or trapezoidal windows flanking the upper wall of fireplace. And the electronic bells & whistles so you could check on the cabin from your laptop at work, etc., would be a fun addition. Widening doors on main level now for accessibility would not be hard to do, (as well as ramping the side entrance) and would be a gracious gesture for those with physical limitations now or in future. One could even adapt the plan for an elevator with little fuss for an additional $20-30 K (especially helpful if you put that third level with parking in the basement.) Love granite but would still like to see a little quartz or soapstone. How about an island instead of a peninsula and placing a contrasting countertop on it?

Hello Bloggers,

I wrote earlier that I live in the area and thought I could possibly help answer a few more questions. I see a lot of you asking about property taxes in the area. Of course, this will differ even in the same area. There are many things to take into consideration, but my house is on the same lake. It's 2100 square feet and our lot is almost 1 acre. Our property taxes are $1100.00 per year. I used to live in MN and the property taxes here are way lower.

Also, I've seen comments about a garage. We may live in a warmer climate here, but let me tell you, we have a carport and I HATE it. Every time it rains or storms, the vehicles are covered with debris blown off of trees. In the spring when the pollen is a problem, there's always a thin film of yellow pollen all over everything and it doesn't blow off as you drive down the road. The vehicles are ALWAYS dirty. You have to be careful what you store in a carport because of critters and they also try and get in your garbage cans. Everything in the carport is ALWAYS dirty. My next house WILL have a garage whether it's attached or not. If DIY offers a garage, believe me, you will want it.

In regards to a basement, I have lived in many different houses in my lifetime. I have always had a basement, whether finished or unfinished, with 2 levels above until this house. This house is a rancher with a finished basement, but no third level, so to speak. I totally miss the storage and again, my next house WILL have a basement. I also cannot tell you how many times, whether in MN or TN, we have headed to the basement because of bad weather. I'm sure you know yourselves, no matter where you live, there's never enough storage. If DIY can put a full unfinished basement under this cabin, you will be happy you have it if you win.

I haven't read the covenants for this subdivision, but if there is no garage provided, can the new owner put one up later? What about storage sheds, etc. If there's no garage, the new owner will be trying to build one or at least bring in storage sheds. Where will you store your lawnmowers, garden tools, leaf blowers, etc? Storage is of the utmost importance in any home and there is never enough.

Blessings,
Lisa

Hello! My first blog. The cabin is amazing. Couple of things - being a newbie - will there/has there been a sweepstake for the 2008 cabin? Also, shouldn't a lake cabin have a sauna? Well - love the design anyway! Truly wondering about the noise though from a metal roof!

I have no idea whether or not the location where this it being built has drought problems or not. On our side of the Smokies & Blue Ridge Mountains (NC), we have been having one for the past two years. As such, I was wondering if there was a way (besides installing a water saving showerhead, which appears to be losing big-time to the power shower) to either build in a grey water system or, at the very least, put in a water catchment system on the gutters (like a "rain barrel" that the downspout could run into, a rollout rain distributer or way to run the downspout into a soaker hose that can then water the flowerbed or the bushes, etc.

My husband and I, while putting together for that dream home we want to finally get when we retire in 15+ years, have been trying to come up with as many efficient plans as possible. One of his coworkers trumped our grey water plans with an additional plan: rather than just have the greywater and gutter runoff water go to an outdoor holding tank, Stuart suggested the idea that the greywater's primary use could be to the toilet tank. (stay with me here).

Basically, a toilet stores water in a tank (cavetette) and then when you flush, it empties the bowl & refills the bowl from the cavetette after the wastewater has gone down the drains to the sewer or septic tank. This being the case, the primary feed for the greywater system could be sent to (at least one) toilet's cavetette or to the incoming supply for the toilets. Instead of being filled with the potable water, this nonpotable water could serve a second purpose before going down the drain.

Of course, if we go with a nonwater system, such as an incinolette, the grey water system can go back to the initial irrigation plan.

Okay, question number two: I understnd that the Blog Cabin would probably end up WAAAAY over budget (provided, of course, there is a slated budget for this), but if this is on the side of a lake, is there any reason we can't take advantage of the sunlght to place a solar collector for on the grid energy or for a solar water heater? Heck, if you set it up right, part if the outdoor "feature" could include a solar heated rinse off shower. If you've ever spent time with kids anywhere near a beach or potential mud source, you will understand how useful an outdoor shower is. If you have a built in solar-heated water tank, you can, again, make a water catchment (rain catching system) the main source of water. The shed that will house the unit can also have a water feature on the outside (sort of a water fountain, birdbath)that could keep the water circulated/aerated AND the shed could hold grilling items, fold up lawn chairs, etc. put it next to a nicely designed flagstone patio and it won't even look too much like a shed. If you'd rather, you could pitch the water feature idea in favor a of potting shed. It would be just as convenient to have water available for that....

Last item: natural light. The one, main, problem with a log cabin is that you generally end up with less windows than you might have in a conventional (stick or brick) house. The "not as many windows/less sunlight" issue can be best resolved at the time of construction by installing Solatubes. (No, i don't have any association with or income coming from the product--more's the pity.) Seriously, I have seen these installed in friends' houses. Bathrooms that have no exterior walls are brightly lit even on cloudy days. They can be routed to ANY floor, including basements and they cost a heck of a lot less than skylights. I know that we'll be installing them in that "one day" dream house we want to build.

What would really make the cabin feel like home is a outdoor or indoor pool with a heater.I am all for adding a gas fire place upstairs it adds heat up stairs and it can be turned on and off.You can also add a second set of stairs to the upper part of the house.And it would really help if you added stairs and a gate to the deck[the gate is for secirty and to keep pets and small children from falling down the steps.And add rubber under the roof if metal is picked.For safety!!!!!!

So it seems a garage is needed and a lot of people (including myself) would like to see a basement. could the garage be placed under the house? Have the garage door set back with a 3 foot overhang from the main house. The door should be insulated and able to be bolted from inside. That way it could be used for storing vehicles and be a place for bunkering down when needed.

Michael posted about making the doorways wheelchair friendly. Though I don't need this feature, I urge the designers to follow the suggestion. We put the wider hallways and doors in my parents retirement home and it makes the house feel more open. It did cut into other areas of the home but makes moving from one room to another not feel like moving down an airplane aisle.

It seems most of my choices will not win but thats ok. In the end I am sure the cabin will be fantastic.

Wow this is so great. I found this when all the voting was done on the last cabin. I do believe so many are traditional in their choices of style for a log home. My husband and I are in the process of building a 2600 sq ft 2 story log home here in Middle Tennessee. We planned for 15 years for this house. Now that it is erected I wish that we had not picked all the traditional styles. My husband had the plans for 10 years and was set on the green metal roof. Now that I see different styles I just wish that we were a little more adventuresome in our choices. I love the soapstone counters and the cedar roof. There is so much variety that can be done with log homes. Its great to read everyones ideas.

I think the cabin is going to be great - - can't wait for the first day in "our" new home. The metal roof -- stone fireplace - the plan - etc will be fantastic - - I did vote for quartz counters due to somethings I've heard about grantie giving off radon.

One thing I have noticed is that a lot of bloggers are campaigning for a much larger house, wanting to add here, enlarge the plan with a basement etc.etc.etc. If your not careful the house will be out of range for an average family when you start to consider taxes, maintenance etc.

In going through some of the comments (and I mean some as there are so many), i've noticed the lack of taking aadvantage of the waterfront view from the waterline. How about a matching Boathouse or enclosed dock that folks could sit on in the evenings to enjoy the sounds of nature.

I agree too the doors need to be wider, especially with the size of some of todays furniture and electronics.

See Y'all

What a perfect place! Let's get as much "Green" into this cabin as possible. I would have liked to have seen a different choice on countertops but the granite will be beautiful. Radient heat would be a fantastic idea especially in the bathrooms. Tankless water heater - wouldn't that be great? This is the area my husband and I are looking to move to when we retire and to have a vacation home . So this is exciting!

When you get the number of people discussing something like this, eventually some folks will get on others nerves. But this is a pretty much the largest 'place nice' area I've seen on the net.

The metal roof seems to be the popular choice; but one question I have is the noise amount in rain or or other weather.

Putting the garage in the basement could be done if grade, cost, and covenants allow. This could be done fairly easy depending on the type of foundation that is put in. If its poured concrete, then a poured wall between the garage the rest the basement. This will work as a storm shelter and as an emergency egress from the basement.

**************

I absolutely LOVE recycled glass countertops

They are beautiful. Perhaps a future home will offer it.

For a sampling, look at www.vetrazzo.com

Ewwww! Bugs? I didn't even think of that.
Living in AZ we really do not have much of a bug problem like I've heard of out there.
If I win this cabin I would really appreciate screened in porches. :o)

I changed my vote to the rain shower. My sister used one and says it is marvelous! I also go with the quartz counter tops. They are beautiful and much more practical than the granite.

so where are all the green people?? bamboo floors its harder than wood and renewable. also zen master bath and ornate guest bath ??? when was last time a guest ever cleaned the bath before they left ??? yes thats the bathroom i want to clean when family leaves , so switch them out. altho i actually like the rustic bath

Things are sure coming together. Can't wait to see what is chosen next.

This would definately be an amazing place to live, my family is from the nearby area, Rockwood/kingston. I too would suggest that options should be explained as best they could, knowing that the design team has the opportunity to tweak the design as necessary. I do believe, however that the master bathroom should be a combination between country and modern, same with the rest of the house. Sleek lines everywhere would be a bit much, but so are rounded wood railings everywhere you turn. Try to factor in Stainless Steel or Iron rails somewhere in the build.

Just a quick comment on the floor choices, bamboo is the one I picked. I have read many articles and heard on DIY that it is becoming more popular because bamboo regrows quicker than other wood choices. I have a small home and I am in the process of doing a total remodel, (one area at a time), and plan on using the bamboo flooring in the kitchen and dinning area. My home was built in the early 80's, has been to the point of total neglect before I got it, so reading the blogs and checking out the sites provided has really opened my eyes to different ideas about counter tops and roofing choices for my small home. My next project is to tear out a bathtub and replace it with a walk in shower and chair height toilet, which would be a good choice in the blog cabin. Keep up the great blogs!
Marianne

Just a quick comment on the floor choices, bamboo is the one I picked. I have read many articles and heard on DIY that it is becoming more popular because bamboo regrows quicker than other wood choices. I have a small home and I am in the process of doing a total remodel, (one area at a time), and plan on using the bamboo flooring in the kitchen and dinning area. My home was built in the early 80's, has been to the point of total neglect before I got it, so reading the blogs and checking out the sites provided has really opened my eyes to different ideas about counter tops and roofing choices for my small home. My next project is to tear out a bathtub and replace it with a walk in shower and chair height toilet, which would be a good choice in the blog cabin. Keep up the great blogs!
Marianne

It looks like they confused the bathrooms in this vote, and said the Master is the Guest bathroom and vise versa. If not, that's a pretty elegant guest bathroom.

good afternoon fellow bloggers, I am excited to have new choices to vote on but, am disappointed in the choices for the bathrooms, how about something that looks like it belongs in a cabin. maybe an old fashioned flush box that mounts up on the wall. with granite counter tops on a vanity made of logs. the choices seems to frilly for a log cabin. I still am a huge fan of radiant heat flooring in the bathrooms. also maybe a claw foot bathtub would add character. the floor should be slate or something that looks like stone, tile seeems to formal.

I'm very surprised at the choices because many of them are not green!
I realize that this is a "dream" cabin...but all choices should & could be of green products used throughout the cabin.
I'd like to save resources for generations to come.

Great, new things to vote on and blog about. I'm not too bothered about color and a few of the other things. Not sure why anyone would choose a high maintenance ornate bath over simple, easy to clean and easy to maintain options. Maybe some people just love to spend their time cleaning all those nooks, crannies and little coving shelves?

For me the biggest disappointment is that there are no really adventurous and (dare I say it again) few Green alternatives on the flooring.

If we have to go with wood why not 'Lyptus' or reclaimed and recycled flooring such as Californian Olive wood? Both are much more eco-friendly than the options offered here. They are harder, better to work and better for the environment. 'Lyptus' is a hybrid eucalyptus wood mainly from Brazil. It's only plantation grown (absolutely no more deforestation) much harder than most domestic flooring, expands less than almost all others (especially bamboo) and is almost as fast growing as bamboo. It's a renewable hardwood that preserves remaining forest and looks great too.

There are so many other flooring options it's sad to see three very similar options and one a bit different. Do be wary of bamboo. It has all the hype but also has the greatest ability to alter shape with drier or damper atmospheric conditions (up to 7% or more for some types). It also dinks and dents too easily for my liking. Friends did their kitchen, hall, living and dining room in bamboo a few years back. Initially, it looked great but last year they replaced it with a recycled wood because of the constant problems of the bamboo shrinking, expanding and warping in our upper Mid-West climate.

With those wonderful views...PLEASE consider casement windows. I have them at my house...and I love them. They open WIDE to let in cool breezes, and no horizontal sash to interupt the view. I voted for casement windows, bamboo floors (everyone I know with bamboo adores it) and butternut stain. Oh, and the zen bath and the "clean and simple" guest bath. I just like the "less is more clutter-free look."

Melanie

For those with some spare time and wishing to become better informed about the true costs and eco positives and negatives of bamboo flooring there is a very good article “Bamboo Flooring- Environmental Silver Bullet of Faux Savior?” (March 15th 2005) by Dr Jim Bowyer and others. (http://www.dovetailinc.org/documents/DovetailBamboo0305.pdf)
Bowyer is a professor in the University of Minnesota's Department of Bio-based Products; Chairman of the Tropical Forest Foundation & Chairman of the Minnesota Bio-fiber Council.

Also, bamboo isn’t subject to the same rigorous standards as hardwood floors because it isn’t a wood. JANKA measurements are almost meaningless for bamboo too. Generally, it’s considered to be about the same hardness as Black Walnut which is a ‘soft’ hardwood. There are no ‘Fair Trade’ agreements covering its production and processing either so environmental impact and the welfare of workers in China where the bulk is produced are not protected. Bamboo requires gluing together to make boards and the glues used are usually formaldehyde based. These can leech formaldehyde for years which is an environmental hazard in any home.

One thought. If trees are to be felled to clear the ground for the cabin why can’t they be planked, properly dried and used for the flooring. This is surely one of the best and most environmentally neutral options?

Casement windows definitely a ‘must’ here with the view. Say no to cookie-cutter little panes and inserts. Go with the view.

My first question, Watson, is how did the drought affect last year's cabin? Are there any foundation problems, etc.?

Secondly, is this a House or a Cabin. It is not a matter of semantics, but of aesthetics! If this is a Log House, and 2,600 sq, ft. is a "house", then according to several decorating mags I take, the interior design and decorating can be any style the owner wants. Not just Early Rustic :-) The interior doesn't have to carry on the period style of the exterior. If you, design team & Watson, agree, then please change the interior to offer several style choices to us, i.e., modern, French country, Art Deco.

Keight, you ruined my dream; this is an exercise in futility, as is HGTV's Dream House, with those levels of taxes. A lot of baby boomers have had their pension funds raided, been defrauded by employers (Exxon), and now gas prices, layoffs, and a recession. I guess that leaves y'all youngsters! These contests need to find benefactors to chip in (see "Extreme Home Makeover").

I'll open a B&B or a "conference center"!

The ideas for an emergency closet and a water catchment system are very timely.

The next house needs to be in the Northwest, New England, or the Midwest.

Since I am retired, I'm off to research to my heart's content ....

BTW, "yes" to handicap accessibility!

Leslie in Texas

New to the blogging thing but thought I would join in the fray! I haven't read all the previous comments tho, so please forgive me if I'm repeating ideas.

Overall I've been really pleased with the winners (especially the floorplan, yay!) except in the roof and countertop areas. Was hoping for quartz or concrete. Granite is just too fancy. Voted for the slate roof. The metal has it's benefits, but not much character.

I love the wood-burning fireplace and rock surround. But do the rocks have to be round? Couldn't they be flat, like sandstone? I know I'm not explaining this well, but here's a link to what I mean. http://www.bouldercreekstone.com/stone/SEL . It can be staggered on the front when laid providing a lot of texture and color. Hey, it's still stone, right?? Especially if local product could be used, bringing the colors of the area into the home.

The flooring choices are interesting. I too would like to have seen some more green choices and info about each type. My favs were the bamboo and the teak. Teak won out for me only because of the color and grain and questions about the long-term durability of bamboo. The bamboo color was so dark you lost the grain. But the sustainability factor of the bamboo is a huge draw. I loved the butternut stain for the exterior. Warm but not too yellow... I hope.

The casement windows let in the view. Why live on a lake and peer thru little teeny panes? The paned windows are very traditional, but the light, the passive solar benefits (green!)and the wow factor can't be ignored. Just picture yourself standing in front of them in the morning, with a cup of something hot, watching the fog lift and the sunrise. Ahhhhhhhhhh

Bath styles - the zen bath is stunning, but not over done, imho. I love all the slate, the open tub, and the sheer peace of it. I didn't particularly care for either guest bath style. The clean and simple was too clean and simple. Really stark, hospital like, even if they don't go all white. The orate was enough to rival the master bath and overdone. Isn't there a middle ground? Something to marry the two choices? Something that while simple, maybe adds some arts & crafts details to help make it pop? A great cabinet, a few decorative tiles to add some design elements. The simple was just flat and the ornate not flat enough.

Things I'm hoping to see: tankless hot water system - heats fast, uses less water, easier on the bills! I'd love to see the fireplace area outside the MB turned into a sunroom (good use for the big paneless windows!!) and the fireplace moved to a beautiful patio and attached to an outdoor BBQ. An outdoor dining area should be a must have with such a gorgeous setting, especially as the kitchen inside appears a bit tucked away. A hot tub - tucked away at the other end of the patio where you can relax and watch the moon come up over the water. A rainwater system - something to catch it and hook it up to a drip system for the landscaping and/or a graywater system. Covered gutters - there's a lot of leaves on those wonderful trees. A compost area to re-use the leaves. A landscaped, lighted pathway to the lakeshore and boat slip. My husband has just one wish: a big garage of course! Enough for two cars, his shop, and storage.

It's a beautiful cabin DIY, can't wait to see it when it's finished!

I have been reading the post, and see a number of you have re-thought on the roof! What are the chances of a re-vote on the roof?

Ok, I HAVE to add my 3 cents to this one. The bathroom choice that is winning, absolutely baffles me. This is a LOG CABIN!!!! The "Zen" bathroom is totally out of place and I think will stick out like a sore thumb. Thanks-I just had to vent.

Watson, here I am bragging and defending you, but you didn't post by blogs from yesterday! Did I speak too soon? I think not, and look forward to being able to play with the other bloggers as before!

Leslie Thompson made some extremely good points, Yeah Leslie! 77000.00 in taxes is going to kill just about everyone regarding the HGTV Dream House, and that was the minimum my accountant stated, not including the vehicle or other aesthethics we would have to pay taxes on, plus the percentage you pay over a winning of $35,000.00!!! Very few people could afford those taxes and those that could really don't need to win a dream house or a blog cabin! They probably already have a house in the Hamptons, one in the Caymans, and who knows where else? The Catskills or the Adirondacks? So Leslie made some really valid points!

May the worthiest and neediest blogger win!

Keep the great advice and comments coming! I love the new voting choices, but agree that the interior needn't match the exterior, and would like some more design choices. Then the voting would take forever, though, and probably be all over the boatd. I'll just assume DIY know what it's D'ing. Cabincraver2008

Hi, This message is for Melanie See and others interested in a green home: Directions to the hgtv's GREEN home blog website future give away: GO to www.HGTV.com then go over to the (dream home) heading (in the dark blue lined headings). The greenhome link is on the same link as dreamhome, just below it.. You will see the(green home)link pop up, as soon as you touch the dream home go down to green home and click it. It should take you there. I hope I explained this correctly! I'm not the greatest with computer talk.....But it is very interesting, exciting and it will be given away too soon. They haven't started the sweeps for it just the blog. But the dream home give away sweeps in the florida keys is up for voting, but not much time left on that opportunity. For those of you who love the Keys... Me I'm all for the lake blog cabin in Tn. That's the right bait for me and my family... Just thought I'd pass along the info.. Have a great day everyone! Melanie let me know if this works for you ok...

Love most of the choices so far. But I would really love to see the wraparound porch with steps down to the property. Having lived in the TN mountains the breezes are great but it would be nice to have a portion of the porch screened as the bugs can get pretty fierce.

An outside shower would be great after working in the yard or being in the lake.

I think the baths are just a little too fancy for a cabin. I would prefer a deep jetted soaking tub in the master with a steam shower. The "spa" bath shown is beautiful but really does not fit into my vision of a cabin.

The teak floors are a wonderful choice for a humid environment and will work perfectly with damp footprints from the lake.

This setting is beautiful and I can hardly wait for the entry period to begin.

I think the tin roof is very becoming of the house and the stone fireplace is beautiful. With the rustic look for the home decor would really set it off.
And the counter tops should be butcher block that would go with the logs.

Deborah in pa.

I absolutely love choosing the different styles for the log home. This is my dream home, I receive log home magazine every month and I dream. You can see why I get such a kick out of participating in the process. Even if the things I voted on don't win, I am excited to see the finished product. I will sit here and dream, and wait for the next set of things to vote on. Best of luck to you all. God Bless

I love the choices for the interior of the cabin, except for the double hung windows. I voted for casement windows because there is nothing on the window to impede the view.
I can't wait to see the finished product!

I'd vote for a masonry heater as the fireplace. We just put a soapstone one in our new home. Awesome. Very little wood. Excellent draw. Soapstone retains and radiates the heat for hours after the fire is out. Green Mountain Soapstone makes them. Tulikivi is a big name. Rod Zander does customs. These are high efficiency for fireplaces.

I have been involved in the cabin voting and entering the contest for a couple of years now. First let me say that I have read some of the comments that people have made and I see some criticism but I guess thats why we blog. I personally like to see the choices that are being considered for the cabin whether my favorite choice is picked or not. We all enjoy dreaming that someday, maybe we will be the one to win this beautiful cabin that is being built. I just think that it is great that some ordinary, everyday person will win this cabin and have a memory to last a lifetime. Also, the winner will be able to enjoy the weather, view, beauty, etc... I think this is a great thing that you are doing and it truly gives people something positive to think and dream about.

This isn't a cabin...it's a not even a house...it's a luxurious mansion. The choices that are being made are just too rich and extravagant. Good luck to the winner.

This cabin seems to be a pricey prize for the winner, just as the Dream Home will be. I am not too sure that any of us could afford the taxes and such... Please build something that the plain "Joe" or "Jane" can afford and grow old in. However, the choices that people are making are great, it is nice to have a say in what the place will look like when finished. How do we enter to win this home??

Hi, last years cabin was outstanding and I'm sure this years cabin will be outstanding too. I just wanted to say that your chooses of the wooden floors are to dark, maybe something a little lighter would be nice. Just thinking outloud, ed.

Hello everyone,
This is my first time blogging, but have been reading everyone's comments for some time, and have learned a lot! I am moved to speak up because the choices this time seem like "apples and oranges". For the guest bath, it is hard to really see the differences between the fixtures, and especially hard to see past the contrast of 'economy class v.s.luxury'. The country bath example doesn't show us the fixtures. While the Zen style is extremely cold-looking, at least you could dress it up with accessories, and bend it to your own design tastes - you could put anything in there, from country to French Provincial. None of those flooring choices are appealing - I'm looking forward to seeing some input from you "researchers". I thought I liked bamboo (renewable resource) until I saw posts about personal experience with it - shrinkage is scary! I also think the sample shown is much too dark - I've seen store samples with richer color, and more interesting variations in it. I voted for teak for durability and appearance, but wonder about environmental impact. We do not need to strip rainforests to floor our houses! Last, what is the difference between oak and cedar stain? I couldn't detect any.

Regarding the wood stain options; they were all very similar in color, and I think the trees from the pictures have a more grey bark look to then; therefore the home would be a part of the wilderness around it instead of sticking out with a stain color that doesn't match it's surroundings unless it's Fall and the leaves are changing to orange and brown. Thanks for allowing me to offer my opinion. Sheri

I am new to this blogging, I,m having touble voting, I can vote for the wood floors, than it will take me to the stain, today I was able to get to the windows; than a message comes up that I can only vote once a day; and I didn't even get to see the bathrooms. Am I doing something wrong? Could it be my lap-top? Thank you, I really think this populas of people watching and learning how and what different products and so many ideas from so many talented people is fabulous. Sheri

Will the cabin be accessable for an active
paraplegic wheelchair person?

371184

I love log cabins, but have a "classic" personality so the "country" log cabin, paired with the classic styles; ie: winning bathrooms and granite countertops, just win me over big time! It's great that those of us that like it both ways CAN have our cake and eat it, too! Hopefully one of us can WIN it, also. He He He!

are the logs and brzilyen flowers sastanebly grone
used and re planted all green like

hi,
really hope I can win this cabin...near to retirement and empty nest so would be a blessing to move into OUR own place. Love the look so far!
cindy

It may already be too late for this year's blog
cabin but what is a good idea is to have a wood
box built into a wall close to the fireplace with
an outside door that can be opened from the inside and outside and locked from the inside. If the area is cold in the winter you can also
insulate the door. It is handier to open the door and load the wood from the outside. Once
full you can shut and lock the door from the inside and there is no mess on the floor from carrying the wood through the front or back door, etc.