« Another Five Features for Your Consideration ... | Main | Kitchen Features, Flooring, plus a Surprise Category »

February 14, 2008

Darlene Branim Reports on Changes to Blog Cabin 2008

Allow me to introduce Darlene Branim, CEO of Barna Log Homes. She has graciously taken the time to note all the suggestions made by bloggers that were woven into the San Jacinto floor plan:

NEW San Jacinto images below!

Hello Everyone! Here's a list of the modifications so far:

  • Bathtub inserted into one of the upstairs bathrooms. We were able to make this work with out changing the size of the dormer which allowed us to keep the home symmetrical on the road elevation and without losing any closet space. Although a little tight, we were able to get a full size bathtub/shower combo in the room with the water closet and a pedestal sink. It worked out very nicely.
  • Since many people thought the out door living space off the master bedroom was going to be an outdoor kitchen instead of an owner’s private porch, we moved the porch to the lake side of the home coming off the great room and closer to the kitchen and dining room.
  • We then changed the fireplace to a dual fireplace (indoor and outdoor) on the log wall thus allowing for a full view of the lake for the new outdoor living area.
  • Because we needed to change access to the new outdoor living space, we made the fixed glass units on each side of the fireplace to operable swinger doors.
  • Now that we no longer needed a side entrance from the master bedroom to the private porch, we moved the two windows to the side wall of the master bedroom and added a double door to the deck/porch side of the master bedroom for access and to match the dining room wing.
  • Bloggers wanted to see more glass in the fireplace gable end of the home so we added fixed trapezoid on each side of the fireplace to allow more natural light and to open up a view of the lake from the loft upstairs.
  • For a little variety, we added garden window at the kitchen sink.
  • Most everyone wanted to see a larger pantry and laundry room, so we replaced the home office with the laundry room and made the old laundry closet into a nice size pantry.
  • Although not requested by the bloggers, we added a small arch window to the rear foyer wing and changed the window size from a single to a double to match the master bath wing. This really made things look balanced from the road elevation.

The original design was to have a detached two car garage connecting to the home with a breezeway at the rear foyer wing; however, the lot size just would not accommodate the length of the overall structure, so we planned for the driveway to be moved to the other side of the home (Master Bedroom side) and we have changed the home from a crawl space foundation to a full size walk-out basement. Now the garage will be in the basement of the home underneath the master bedroom.

The stairs are stacked so we have access from the basement coming up into the great room just outside the dining/kitchen wall. We would have normally flipped the master bedroom and kitchen wings, however with this particular design and since we have load bearing points instead of load bearing walls, we could not flip these wings as the staircase would then be in the way in the basement preventing us from driving into the garage as we now must do.

I believe that we have a very nice open flowing floor plan focusing on the lake with great entertainment and outdoor living spaces, yet accommodating a very narrow lot and working with the natural lay of the land so we do not disturb or take away from the beauty of the lot and the adjoining lots.

This has been fun and educational and I look forward to continuing to work with the bloggers as we design and build this house together.

Darlene Branim, CEO
Barna Log Homes

Left Elevation
Road Side Elevation
Right Elevation
Lakeside Elevation
1st Floor
2nd Floor

Note: If you are opening the images in Explorer, allow your cursor to hover at the bottom, right-hand corner of the image - this should enable the "expand" option providing you with a larger image view.


Posted by whawkins at February 14, 2008 3:58 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.scrippsnetworks.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1081

Comments

Super! Thanks!!!

We appreciate that you consider the comments made here.

Like the garden window in the Kitchen -- thanks.

Still hoping for radiant heat floors & tankless water heaters.

Any chance of steps from the back porch toward the lake?

Can some of the porches be screened please?

Posted by: adele at February 15, 2008 5:40 PM

Dear Ms. Branim, Thank you for taking suggestions into consideration. I know a lot of people wanted the larger laundry room. Personally I hate doing laundry!! I was hoping for an office, but plenty of room to carry a laptop around if someone really needed one! I guess it would be good for voting on the next blog cabin!! Hopefully, whoever wins this lovely home will be so busy enjoying the lake and their family and friends they won't miss an office!

I haven't asked for any changes, but its is a pleasure to see that everyone is taken seriously. I have enjoyed all the posts to the blog. Many bloggers have very good ideas and really seem to know their stuff
Thanks again for listening!
Patty from Virginia

Posted by: Patty at February 15, 2008 5:56 PM

What an awesome idea!! I've enjoyed reaing the comments from everyone and like that you are listening. Can't wait to see the finished project!!!

Posted by: Janet Leone at February 15, 2008 6:30 PM

Is there any way to get revised floorplans with the changes described for those of us who are have difficulty visualizing things? I agree with adding steps off the porches in the rear of the house.

Watson: I had difficulty uploading the modified floor plans to accompany Darlene's blog entry. Look for those on Monday.

Posted by: Mary from Virginia at February 15, 2008 6:31 PM

Great changes. Now things seem to be moving and bloggers can see their suggestions aren't falling on deaf ears (most of us knew that but some seemed no to).

My personal requests are: -
1. Some broad, shallow steps down to towards yard on the lake side from the back porch together with as few railings as possible. They really do get in the way of the view and are usually only for aesthetics. A handrail up from the grass to the deck is all that's really necessary plus a ramp for disabled access and moving bulky items (my wife's piano for example) onto the deck.
2. Tankless water heating (either LPG or electric - assuming there is no natural gas line to the house?).
3. 'Grey' water reclamation system.
4. Eco-flow toilets
5. As much LED lighting as possible.
6. Radiant heating in all bathrooms at the very least.
7. Housing and set-up for standby generator.
8. Porous drive covering to allow rainwater to pass through instead of running off.
9. Landscaping to include low water demand plants and some landscaping of part of the lakeside to encourage natural, indigenous water plant growth to attract insects, frogs and fireflies, all of which are indicators of a healthy environment.

There are more but this will do for today. Enjoy the weekend.

Posted by: Clive at February 15, 2008 6:38 PM

Sounds wonderful! Thanks for letting everyone know, and especially for listening to the bloggers. :) I can't wait to see photos.

Posted by: Aimee at February 15, 2008 6:39 PM

Thanks, Ms. Branim! I for one am delighted that you took so many of our suggestions into the finished product. Clearly this year's cabin is really going to blow last year's away! Can't wait to see how that basement works out. If you don't get enough sponsors for some whiz-bang storage and workshop gadgets, please at least provide adequate electrical for the do-it-yourselfer to be able to add them later.
Yahoo!!!

Posted by: Connie at February 15, 2008 6:55 PM

Has any one noticed that when you are getting out of your luxurious master bath you will be looking straight at anyone coming your front walk and they at you. can the plans be flipped to put the master bath in the back of the house

Posted by: Deb H at February 15, 2008 7:22 PM

wow im looking forward to seeing the revised floor plan, but sounds sooo cool . i was ok with the office/craft room but could be a laundry/ craft room.and im totally into the pantry! the garden window is a nice touch, i have one now and like it, will look great with the craftsman cabinets. i had voted on bamboo floors but after reading some of the blogs i went with the teak gosh its just beautiful!! like the double hung windows cause a 2 story home so much easier to clean. a screened porch might be nice. like the idea of the garage under the house tho. well everyone enjoy the weekend!!!

Posted by: colleen at February 15, 2008 7:33 PM

Yea! Thank you Darlene! The basement is a very much appreciated feature! I don't mind losing the office to "ugh!" laundry. . . because that's a great excuse to have an open office up on the loft! A "hidden office at home and the main office at the workplace works for me, and my husband prefers the kitchen table anyway.
Thanks for listening, and for the opportunity for us to put our 2 cents worth in!
Micki

Posted by: Micbeth at February 15, 2008 8:06 PM

Thank you for all the changes, and the update! It just makes blogging even more exciting seeing that it makes a difference. I can't wait to see the new floorplans when I get back from vacation.
Time to go somewhere warm!

Happy blogging!

Posted by: Sharon in WA at February 15, 2008 8:17 PM

Ditto to Clives most recent posting. Love every one of the suggestions. I am particularly enthusiastic about the natural landscaping - depending on the parameters of Lakeview Estates. I would like to add that some local artisan touches would be a wonderful addition to the beauty of this cabin. I hope I win.

Posted by: Jenny at February 15, 2008 8:23 PM

How/When will I get to enter the sweepstakes for this amazing cabin?

Posted by: Julie Smith at February 15, 2008 8:50 PM

Watched the last Blog Cabin and truly enjoyed watching it all come together. Haven't seen the new show yet but can't wait. I love log cabins and I can't wait to see this one finished.

Posted by: Diane at February 15, 2008 9:14 PM

I keep seeing fancy extras for the adults, but what about a child friendly cabin? I would love to see a little log fort for the kids to climb around in outside. And could we get a mini bunk-house in one of the bedrooms (or maybe in a loft) with built in bunkbeds so we could stack sleeping children like cord wood?

Posted by: Katie at February 15, 2008 9:14 PM

put the laundry in what is listed as 'rear foyer' and open up that laundry room to expand your kitchen and pantry.

Posted by: Katie at February 15, 2008 9:21 PM

Thank you for the update on revisions. I too look forward to the revised house plans since my left brain has not ever fully develped! I have a garden window in my kitchen and have enjoyed it so much. What a nice development.
Once again, good luck to all and thank you to all the DIY staffers who are working hard for the cabin and all of us.

Posted by: sandi, iowa at February 15, 2008 9:27 PM

The changes sound exciting. I'm looking forward to seeing the floor plans.

I am hoping to see some good storage options in the garage or basement area. Noting specific, unless a sponsor is giving something that demands a particular storage rack or system.

For the windows, I wish everyone would consider how much nicer a generally unobstructed view through casement windows is. They are easier to clean too.

I also want to know if you would consider building a sister cabin and auctioning it off for charity or to recover some of your expenses.

Posted by: Robbie Orlando at February 15, 2008 10:01 PM


Yeah, an update! Nice to finally hear about the design progress.

Wasn't aware the lot was so narrow. Personally, I am disappointed the garage in now under the master. Never been a fan of that. Sounds like it was either that or no garage. I'm sure extreme care will be taken when insulating to keep the exhaust gases out of the master bedroom. Ground water issues must not be a problem in this area?

When is groundbreaking??? Keep us moving on!

Posted by: Cathy P. at February 15, 2008 10:21 PM

Thank you Ms Branim - this sounds good! I like the changes - as far as I can visualize them. Watson - I'm looking forward to seeing the plans - thanks for all your efforts. Once I see the plans then I'll be better able to comment. I think the bloggers are being well taken care of!

Posted by: Therese at February 15, 2008 10:27 PM

Miss Darlene Branim, barna & diy crews etc.
Thank you all for being so kind in providing such a wonderful home and land for some blessed family to enjoy and for fairly and respectfully taking everyone's suggestions to heart in designing and changing it for the viewers. I am so thankful especially for the basement. Please don't forget the storm saferoom toward the deeper part of the basement.... I'm so happy to hear that the laundry room was switched over and a tub added upstairs, the only thing needed there now is a nice mirrored storage wall cabinet above the ped. sink. I really hated the thoughts of someone having to trip over the laundry in the hall.. We have a laundry closet and homeoffice combined in a very small room near our back entrance and you know how it is with laundry it's up to your knees before you can get back to it! We are always shifting it around to get in and out of here. Aggravating!! Someone or something is always in your way! Even with trying to keep it contained and a going! I would gladly be the maid in this home, We all have to do laundry anyway why not have a nice view while doing it, right and a nice place to put it when you are too busy to do it! I'm so happy about the double fireplace at the back and glad there is more access from the dining & living room and more windows also.... very nice for weather watching, sunset,sunrise and lakeviews. I really wanted that master porch to stay myself, and have 2nd screen room on dining side, but I'm more thankful for the basement & garage!!!! Maybe the winner can screen in a small porch section at the back of the house for a homeowners retreat. I can't wait to see the basement layout! Add some swings, a hammock & rock patio under the decks! And rocked trail to the lake. Can't wait to see that new floor plan soon. So I can get a better look at these changes..See you monday watson. Hopefully bright and early!!!! Great job everybody!!!! hi 555's all around!!!!!!! I'm very excited!!!! Can't wait!

Posted by: Carrie Miracle at February 15, 2008 11:04 PM

This sounds fantastic! Can't wait to see the new version of the floor plans. Absolutely love the basement with garage.

Posted by: Tawanda at February 15, 2008 11:20 PM

The changes sound wonderful, thank you!

Is it possible to create/add a ventilation point for the garage considering its placement?

Thanks,
Jim & Jeannie

Posted by: Jim & Jeannie Porter at February 15, 2008 11:36 PM

Darlene, you have really done great work on the cabin and listening to everyone suggestions. I was happy with the floor plan the way it was. I just wanted steps off the back going down to the lake and have some of them screened in. I love the glass on the sides of the fireplace to give more light! Gardening and light makes my heart warm so the garden window is such a bonus, thanks!
I am truly enjoying the voting, blogging and of course dreaming of my husband and I retiring there.
Thank you
Joyce

Posted by: Joyce at February 15, 2008 11:44 PM

blogcabin=LOG cabin=nature=earth tones=simplistic=rustic

leave 'fancy' to the dream home or the green home.
dont ruin this 'country' setting with a bunch of highend 'city' frills!

Posted by: ADAM bailey at February 16, 2008 12:51 AM

Thank you for getting us updated. I have always enjoyed being a part of building/remodeling in many ways and have always dreamed of living in a log cabin and so this is fun to be allowed to take part in this. It will be fun to read your updates and blogs...I had been wondering how to find out more info. Thank you for including us.

Posted by: Linda McLaughlin at February 16, 2008 1:35 AM

Considering the new flow of the cabin based upon the revised floorplans unveiled by Darlene Branim, CEO .....

Any chance a dumbwaiter could be installed at the basement level up to the kitchen area? It would serve a very useful purpose .... the 'delivery of groceries' from the underground garage area to the kitchen area would be much easier and safer. (Carrying bags up the stairs can be difficult for some individuals)

And, if the dumbwaiter system continued to the loft area, it could be used to carry items from the kitchen area or laundry area to the second floor.

In the same mindset --and, again, considering the safety issue of carrying linens,towels, and clothing up/down steps to/from the laundry room-- the addition of a laundry chute, from the upstairs bedroom or bathroom area that is above the new location of the laundry room, would be much appreciated.

Thanks


From Darlene's Message....
...The original design was to have a detached two car garage connecting to the home with a breezeway at the rear foyer wing; however, the lot size just would not accommodate the length of the overall structure, so we planned for the driveway to be moved to the other side of the home (Master Bedroom side) and we have changed the home from a crawl space foundation to a full size walk-out basement. Now the garage will be in the basement of the home underneath the master bedroom. Darlene Branim, CEO
Barna Log Homes
Posted by whawkins at February 14, 2008 3:58 PM

Posted by: KateByTheLake at February 16, 2008 1:49 AM

I think this is great. I can't wait to watch this unfold. The changes are good ones, especially having a basement garage. I liked the idea of a sitting porch for the master, I think the porch can wrap the whole house. A kitchen would have made no sense. The choice of the zen bathroom is good except it could use more wood elements in it to warm it up. I like the clean lines for 'spa retreating', but should reflect more natural elements in with the stone tiles. I love the granite, but make sure they get sealed well. The feel of the cabin should be upscale to reflect the commuity, but should be about friends/family because of the remoteness of the locale. I think an outdoor fire pit (covered with a screen) for marshmallows would be great, with log seats. A volleyball/badminton rectangle leveled out and marked. A small 2 person sitting gazebo right (with flagstones marking the way) next to the lake would be great to replace the master bedroom personal deck. I love the changes the CEO made. My dream home has always been a log cabin, I live in California where the cabins are more modern instead of homey. I think you can blend them, but you must be true to the nature of a cabin which is to be closer to natural elements in comfort.

Posted by: Kay Beeman at February 16, 2008 2:14 AM

Some of these changes sound great, some not but everyone has different needs so it's hard to please us all. The only things I still haven't seen happening is disabled access, as a matter of fact you seem to be going the opposite direction. By putting the garage in the basement with stairs coming up into the great room area I would not be able to get to/from my vehicle. I would have to have my wife bring the car around to an area that would be accessable but if she is not home, I'm kind of stuck. I keep hearing stairs, stairs, stairs. Come on people, not all of us were lucky enough to keep our lower extemities and some who are aging are not going to be stair masters much longer either. Please lets start hearing more about ramps and lifts. Thanks for listening anyway!

Posted by: Dave Dalton at February 16, 2008 2:53 AM

Clive -- wonderful ideas.

Outdoor shower (to be able to rinse off dirt at lest on feet & pets) -- with cutoff to drain in winter so doesn't freeze -- on side of back porch with mulched drainage to one of the plantings so water is reused

Rainwater catchment

Under the back porches (which are from the walk-out basement), put porous pavers so the area can be used but rainwater falling on the deck or porch has a place to infiltrate

Rainwater catchment (from roofs or any other non-porous, surfaces, but keep non-porous to the minimum please) with cisterns

Composting area

Segregate construction debris during construction

At least stub out basement for plumbing & electric

Posted by: adele at February 16, 2008 5:31 AM

I think the changes will increase the desirability of the cabin. I agree with the requests for radiant heating floors and tankless water heater. There also should be the heated towel bars/radiators in the bath rooms. Is there going to be a dock? In looking at the site there seems to be a good place to have a pier to dock a boat.

Posted by: Mary at February 16, 2008 6:50 AM

Hello all,
DIY, many thanks for listening to the thoughtful suggestions blogged here. I am espcially happy with all changes that provide more light and lake views inside the house. Why live in this beautiful area if you can't see and enjoy it every day? Even clouds,rain, snow are beautiful.

Clive, I echo your suggestions loud and clear.

Keep up the good work, DIY!

Posted by: Tingoat at February 16, 2008 7:35 AM

I thought this was to be a more environmentally-friendly "cabin". Now it seems to be a high end year round home that is using more resources than my almost 50 year old home!
I was disappointed to see that the power shower and wood burning fireplace won out, due to the fact that there is a water shortage AND hauling, cutting, stacking wood and ash and soot are not my idea of a clean, work-free vacation! When somebody has to scrub the roof, the windows, the finish on their car from the soot, these decisions will be regretted! I live where that is exactly what is done all the time.

The products are beautiful, some are extravagant for a "cabin", non-green, so I guess I thought that people would select green things when they had a chance to and they did not have to pay for it. Is there going to be a sprinkler system , alarm system? Whether this is going to be occupied year round or not, and it is in a "community" environment, are these issues being addressed? Seems like with all the other luxuries, fire and personal safety should be right up there with imported wood flooring and quartz countertops... just some personal opinions..

Posted by: lin castillo at February 16, 2008 8:05 AM

wow those changes sound great thank you!!!!

Posted by: Denise at February 16, 2008 8:08 AM

What wonderful changes!! A duel fireplace is amazing! The outdoor improvements and garage sound great. Can you tell I'm happy with this update? :-) Just one lil thing that may be there and I've overlooked it, could we please have part of the porch screened in? Thank you so much for listening and taking our thoughts into consideration. I'm enjoying this process so much. No work just log in and see the results. THIS is the way to build a home!
Linda

Posted by: Linda at February 16, 2008 9:12 AM

Love the ideas, very thoughtful. Beautiful style home on such a gorgeous lot!

1. I agree with the suggestion to remove barriers to the view on the deck, allowing for safety, and to have steps leading directly to the lake. I see a flagstone path headed that way....
2. Especially love the "green" ideas, too. I'd like to add no "gas emitting laminate" in the cabin. Keep the wood solid!
3. A couple of screened in porches would be awesome.

It's going to be a beautiful creation!
Suzanne

Posted by: Suzanne at February 16, 2008 9:24 AM

Great ideas on the changes. I would like to see more "green" as some of the blogs have mentioned before me. I just can wait to sit in the outside porch

Posted by: Jose at February 16, 2008 9:37 AM

i just wanted to wish watson and all my fellow bloggers a fantastic day. i'm going out to garden and imagine i'm working on my garden off the kitchen in my newly built and won blog cabin.

it is of things such as these that dreams are made.

Posted by: Trista at February 16, 2008 9:56 AM

THANK YOU ! THANK YOU ! THANK YOU!! YEEEEEEEEHAAAAAAAW

Posted by: Kina at February 16, 2008 10:09 AM

Thank you Darlene for taking in consideration the thoughts of those who are blogging . This is going to be a great project . My only comment is I thought the master bedroom needed to be larger and a screened in porch .... thank you for all your hard work. hagd
Linda H.

Posted by: Linda H. at February 16, 2008 11:00 AM

EXCELLENT! (I know that comes across as shouting...but that's what I said aloud as I read the post.)

LOVE the garage in the basement. And am thrilled that you worked a bathtub into the upstairs. (I know MY children weren't thrilled with showers when they were tiny. We had to make certain all our summer rentals had a bathtub.)

An additional thought-- As someone who is coping with serious drought in NC--I would love to see a cistern for watering the landscape. (Somehow the development doesn't seem like the sort of place that would be "rain barrel friendly.") Plus, a cistern with a pump is easier to use than the trusty rain barrel. A rain cistern would be easiest to place during construction. Here is one site that talks about the different kinds of cisterns...
http://www.soquelcreekwater.org/Rebate_Cisterns.htm

I know they are a CA company...but my quick google didn't turn anything up specific to TN. I did discover that Tractor Supply Company sells the water tanks. I know a number of people in KY and TN use cisterns as their potable water supply...so I'm certain there must be companies that put them in. Metal roofs are and EXCELLENT collection system.

Just wanted to throw the idea out there. Y'all are doing a wonderful job...and whoever wins this cabin is going to be VERY lucky.

Melanie

Posted by: Melanie See at February 16, 2008 11:21 AM

Sounds wondeful. I am looking forward to having a chance to see the completed project. I think tahe whoever wins this cabin will have nothing but pure enjoyment in ownership. Thanks for taking the voters seriously

Posted by: Catherine at February 16, 2008 11:43 AM

1). Any chance of impact resistant window glass and installation? Lot of storms and varmits in woods and mountain areas.
2). What about handicap ramps or an elevator to ensure access? An elevator may be too expensive but ramp's may be conceivable.

Thanks and you are doing a great job!

Posted by: stella at February 16, 2008 11:52 AM

I like the double hung windows. the pictue shown with the glass panel above the main window body looks great. Would like to see no grids in the window glass. The grids do obscure some visibility. Thanks for the basement and garage additions. These items would have been a great addition to the 2007 Blog Cabin.

Posted by: Dave Chatfield at February 16, 2008 11:53 AM

Hi Darlene,
Wow, you're doing great and so is Watson, thanks for listening to everyone's comments. To all the complainers, they can't please everyone and they are trying to make this home suitable for the majority. We don't want just a vacation place, this would be home for us, we'd also be near relatives and we loved this area so much we got married near there. I've been reading & collecting Log Home Living magazine for many years (over 10), a log home has always been my dream since childhood and I've been in Barna sample homes, they are beautiful. My suggestion is to make it handicap accessable so neighbors, friends, and myself could get around easier, there are so many homes I can't go in plus making the boat area with a ramp would enable me to go boating again, whoopee. Another suggestion is to build a tornado proof shelter under the stairs inside leading to the basement, great use for unused area. Thanks for listening and your changes are wonderful, thank you!

Posted by: Misty & Rich at February 16, 2008 12:04 PM

Thanks for telling us about the changes you are going to make. I didn't see the one I wanted to see but no complaints.

Posted by: clifton t wilder at February 16, 2008 12:14 PM

Can't wait to see the new plan!! Sounds great!!

A couple of thoughts...

--Please allow for extra insulation between the garage space below and the master living space above. Lived in such a configuration that was woefully underinsulated and was often uncomfortable as compared to the rest of the home.

--Will you be doing a floor plan for the basement? If so, a couple of ideas:
--Spot for lawn equipment, (mower, kayaks?), etc. adjacent to the garage. (Mini door, perhaps?)
--Possible home theatre area in a dark, unwindowed portion of basement.
--Kitchenette w/bar.
--Game room setting.
--Additional bedroom w/bathroom*
*Configure bathroom(s) for multiple access--from bedroom, other living areas as well as access from outdoor entrance/vestibule, garage. Perhaps extra dryer or mini laundry. All of which for convenience for outdoor activities/parties as well as cleanliness, preventing tracking, etc.
--Lots of windows/windowed doors for view.

kim h

Posted by: kim h at February 16, 2008 12:25 PM

Dear Ms. Branim,

Thank you for the updates can't wait to see the updated floor plans, they sound great.

Clive thank you for mentioning the ramp for the disabled again, I didn't see it mentioned in the new plan.

Still hoping for the new walk in showers and bath tubs, guess everyone can't be pleased.

Keep up the good work DIY team

Mary from Texas

Posted by: Mary at February 16, 2008 12:29 PM

Thank you Clive, I adopt your comments and I look forward to the modified floor plans this Monday.

Posted by: Jesse at February 16, 2008 1:56 PM

All these changes are perfect....very well thought out! I can't wait to see it all come together.

Posted by: jac at February 16, 2008 2:01 PM

I live in the country with dirt roads and dogs. This cabin is going to be lovely, but with a second home- keep it simple, low maintenance inside and out, and design it for outdoor living, dirt tracking and fun. I have seen too many second homes that do not transport you to a different place - which it should.

Erica

Posted by: Erica Tremblay at February 16, 2008 2:06 PM

In the 2007 cabin you screened the porch ,but what about the floor. Bugs can come up through the cracks.

Posted by: Charles Trimble at February 16, 2008 2:10 PM

Thanks for the changes. Outdoor kitchens are in and very useful. I know this is a cabin and is supposed to be rustic but consider everyone including the handicap access please.
Thanks

Posted by: Tammie at February 16, 2008 2:33 PM

i cant wait to see the new blog cabin go up. i enjoyed watching it in 2007 even thought i did not get a chance to vote on it. i have always wanted to build a log cabin to live in. I am a single father so my plans have been put on hold for now. I cant wait to see the new blog cabin thanks Diy.

Posted by: Robert Gleason at February 16, 2008 3:13 PM

would like to see some differint bath lay outs

Posted by: TONY WALLS at February 16, 2008 3:22 PM

This is all so very exciting - and I cant wait for all the new changes to come to life - I agree that we need to stick to more enviromental construction and ECO Friendly designs within in this Grand Lake house! :-) It is interesting to see how everyone is voting and I so cant wait for this to AIR!

Posted by: Merry at February 16, 2008 3:37 PM

SOUNDS AWSOME i LOVE THE WALK OUT BASEMENT . IT MAKES A GREAT PLACE FOR AN EXERCISE ROOM, COOLER AND QUIET . i CAN'T WAIT TO WATCH IT GO UP

Posted by: SHEREEN at February 16, 2008 3:48 PM

It's wonderful to see how you incorporated so many of the bloggers' suggestions into the plan. I can hardly wait to see the finished product!!!

Posted by: Ingrid at February 16, 2008 4:13 PM

Darlene
Many people including myself enjoy fishing. Could a dock be included for a boat or to just sit on fishing. Having that first cup of coffee in the morning before everyone wakes up, even before the fish get up, is a great way to start the day.


Mark

Posted by: Mark at February 16, 2008 5:22 PM

Everything sounds really great! I also like the ideal of heated floors and tankless water heaters. I would also rather have the guest bathroom design be the master bathroom design and have the zen design for the guest bathroom. I just think it's a much more beautiful design and would fit into the master suite much better (just my opinion) But whatever is desided on..it's all so beautiful. You guys are doing such a wonderful job. Just want to say thanks!

Posted by: Deb at February 16, 2008 5:57 PM

Where can I find pictures of the first 10 choices, I missed voting on them.
Thank you
Kat

Posted by: Kathy Knight at February 16, 2008 6:42 PM

you need a sky lite in the mane room and mane intrince and hard wood floring in the mountains of new mexico

Posted by: paris at February 16, 2008 6:44 PM

you need a sky lite in the mane room and mane intrince

Posted by: paris at February 16, 2008 6:46 PM

I love it so much if I live in a beautiful rustic cabin log by lake. It's so awesome. I can't wait to sign up and I always watch for it. Thank you.

Posted by: Kathleen Sedberry at February 16, 2008 7:08 PM

The cabin is looking great with all the choices so far. I too would love to see the radiant heat floors.

Posted by: Mary at February 16, 2008 7:51 PM

Thanks for the up-date. Every thing seems to be coming to together very nicely.We bloggers appreciate the latest info. Thank you Darlene.

Posted by: sammie at February 16, 2008 8:13 PM

I would love to see the revised plans. I agree that steps from the deck would provide easy access to the deck without having everyone walking through the house with wet feet etc. How about an outdoor shower to rinse off before heading inside?

Posted by: Teresa at February 16, 2008 8:15 PM

I love the floor plan. I like the idea of the porch being moved to the lake side. I also like having a little office somewhere on the main floor. Maybe just a little nook somewhere to house a small office. It seems we are all so dependant on our computers. Thanks.

Posted by: Sally Westover at February 16, 2008 9:13 PM

I have been voting on the bathrooms,but it seems to me the guest bathroom is much nicer than the master bath. There should be 2 sinks and the toliet should be surrounded better in the master bath.

Posted by: Sandra Walter at February 16, 2008 9:15 PM

thank you for listening.

is the rest of the basement going to be a finished one? can an office be put there? or as i would use it a craft room?

thanks randee w.

Posted by: randee w. at February 16, 2008 9:30 PM

I'm noticing people tend to be voting for wood flooring that is from the Amazon-- Peruvian and Brazilian hardwoods -- can you guarantee that all the wood is sustainably harvested?

I would like to see more green options -- it was great to see the bamboo flooring as an option, and I wonder if it might be helpful to provide information with the choices as to how environmentally friendly the different choices are,

Posted by: Stephnie at February 16, 2008 10:57 PM

Why are all the houses giving away by HGTV have very little amount of T.V.'s. Don't you want us to watch HGTV while we are enjoying these wonderful views. We also need computers so we can web cam all our friends are new home. Even though we are eco friendly we still need to be current on all the new technology. More Flat screen T.v.'s and computers oh and also heated bedroom , kitchen and bathroom floors. Thanks

Posted by: Terry at February 17, 2008 12:13 AM

The 2008 BLOG CABIN sounds so very wonderful! We all appreciate the time and talent it has taken thus far and will take to finish. I am so hopeful that the winner will be someone very deserving. I, personally, would absolutely LOVE to tell my husband that I had won this and I was giving it to him for all the sacrifices he has made. The BLOG CABIN would be a perfect THANK YOU for anyone! Congratulations, in advance, to the winner and a very large THANK YOU to all that will come together to make this a beautiful reality!

Posted by: BARB at February 17, 2008 1:17 AM

Some terrific changes! Focusing on the lake and the open floor plan are great. Too bad the lot is so very narrow.

I'm disappointed with the basement garage-noisy under a bedroom, stairs to climb (hassle with groceries, shopping items, children, etc.), and a full size walk-out basement is another area to have to maintain and heat/cool (also clutter). How does this change the outside elevation(s) we bloggers voted on?

Though a great idea for those of us who like to grow flowers, plants, and herbs-garden windows can be fraught with problems, which is why some window manufacturers no longer offer them.

Speaking of windows, will they be aluminum clad wood (no exterior maintenance)? Will the muntins/grilles be between the glass? With even more glass, I'm hoping it’s all insulated (doors, trapezoids, arches, etc.) and will be low E (at least)/argon gas filled (more energy efficient). I hope they will be a good quality and will operate easily, whether double-hung or casement, for a long time and will be extremely energy efficient.

Looking forward to seeing these changes on the floor plan and elevations.

Posted by: Debra Leake at February 17, 2008 1:18 AM

In the case of the garage it is unfortunate that a basic house plan was selected that would not fit the criteria of the development that it was to be built in. Had the full set of deed resrtictions been considered, only suitable floorplans would have been presented for voting and this change would not have been necessary. Putting the garage under the house, in a walk out basement, makes it a 3 story structure and meakes the trip to the lake or to the car down more stairs. It also adds steps for the trips to the grocery store. It also adds a hazard condition having the car under the house. Not a senior friendly design.

The rest of the changes did not really affect the functionality of the structure and will be appreciated.

Posted by: Frank at February 17, 2008 2:29 AM

YEA! A walkout basement with garages!!! Like it!! Could you possibly look into a Permanent Wood Foundation???? I know, from first hand experience, when installed properly, they are wonderful,warm, easy to install, and most important..DRY!. Just google permanent wood foundations and check them out.

Posted by: vickie at February 17, 2008 7:45 AM

So far I like everything about the cabin except that there seems to be no patio area. With such beautiful surroundings I could like to have a nice area to BBQ out next to the lake for entertaining.

Posted by: Mark Bradshaw at February 17, 2008 8:16 AM

As with the others sentiments, Thank you for listening and adjusting.

I love the garage idea. I just hate how they stick out on sides of houses normally like a sore thumb. I like them hidden away.

The Garden Window concerns me. Does it come out where there is a porch? I hope not. I have a daughter that has a nasty scar from a Garden window, because kids just don't watch where they are going. PLEASE, PLEASE, if it stays, make it kid friendly/non sharp if possible.

Keep up the good work!

Posted by: Noël B at February 17, 2008 9:36 AM

Darlene, Thank You for the walkout basement and changing the venue of the side porch . The additonal lighting in the main living area is also a completely awesome idea. Now that there is additional space that anyone can configure to their own desires in the basement. And placing the utilities room there will keep free a little addtional space upstairs. Also , and nice planning on the fireplace. I know a fireplace is not intended to heat an entire house. I hope the grounds/landscaping will be kept minimal. The natural landscape of the area is perfect as it is. I wouldn't want to be mowing a lawn. And it would save water for those water conscience folks to have natural drought tolerant plants if anything. As for a dock ? With the raising a lowering of lakes , a cabled or chained floating dock is about all you need. A permanent dock would serve no purpose when the water levels were dropped. It depends largely on the restrictions of the development. If there are privacy issues , I am sure the landscape team can provide suitable alternatives to meet most everyones needs.
Can't wait to see the new plans. You folks are absolutely incredible. Thank You for actually considering some of our thoughts.

Posted by: Bob at February 17, 2008 10:45 AM

My dreams came true.


A walkout basement with a garage on the side.

you have changed this house from really nice,

to spectacular. This is so cool.

Thanks Richard

Posted by: Richard Medynski at February 17, 2008 10:45 AM

Dear Ms. Branim,
Thank you for listening to what everyone has suggested for the 2008 Cabin. Your revisions sound absolutely PERFECT! Barna Homes has always been our favorite. We fell in love with your product from the first Log Home Show that we attended. As far as the office, you can always set something up in the large loft area. If you have family running in from the lake, a nice size laundry room would be convient to rinse off and drop off wet towels, etc.
Thank you again for being an active part of such a delightful and "fantasy" experience.

Posted by: Luci at February 17, 2008 10:48 AM

Could we get another bathroom in the basement for those playing outside?
I don't get these fancy spa retreat bathrooms, why not go for plain low maintenance bathrooms (toilet, tub with shower)? and lots of them. Why bother with a Jacuzzi/posh shower, if there are people waiting outside the door rushing you?

Of course, I am looking at this from the view of family vacations where the house is packed to capacity at all times. If it is for a quiet romantic get away, then eliminate the entire 2nd floor.

Posted by: Katie at February 17, 2008 11:19 AM

my wife and I have been looking for a floor plan that is suitable for just the two of us and room enough for when the kids come to visit. This is it.

Posted by: Mike at February 17, 2008 11:22 AM

Darlene thank you for the updates I just got home from the hospital and was glad to see your update rather then trying to read all the old blogs!
Will the master bedroom still have a small deck out side I sure hope so! that would be a perfict location for a spa retreat. I am sure you could get a spa manufacturer to donate a spa just for including them in the show!
I would still like to remove the master bath and put the shower in its place as long as we had a spa.
Thanks Richard

Posted by: Richard at February 17, 2008 11:48 AM

Absolutely lovely! I'm glad the bathrooms are open instead of compartmentalized. As we age, many of us may need to have handicap access and maneuverability, plus it is easier to aide a little one or senior.
A tankless water heater would be a great energy saver. I agree, too, that outdoor outlets are a good idea.

Posted by: Sharon at February 17, 2008 12:06 PM

So someone can really win this cabin, how does that work?? It will look beautiful from what I have seen people vote on... Where is it located and all???

Posted by: Catherine Moore at February 17, 2008 12:11 PM

I hadn't thought about the basement garage being an accessibility issue...but it certainly is. Good call Dave! I'm still learning to think about things like accessibility. The pro-accessibility group lost out (to a certain extent) when a two-story structure won...please figure out a way to make the basement garage work for those with limited mobility. If I win, I want my friend in an electric chair to be able to come visit!

Posted by: Melanie See at February 17, 2008 12:12 PM

I'm so glad to see a garage this time. It is the DIY network. Like to see a place to store all the cool tools, and crafting materials. A place to hang the old fishing rods. Someone is going to love this place. I really love watching the show and dreaming how great it would be to win! It's like Christmas and the Lottery rolled together with power tools. My thanks for the dreams to the DYI hosts and sponsors and for allowing the viewers to add their two cents. Good luck everyone

Posted by: Richard Barnett at February 17, 2008 1:01 PM

Hello

I been a cabin lover for many many years. The natural warm and feel of a cabin is unsurpass. I would suggest the following additions or key elements when designing a special place. Your location is beautiful therefore enspire the place with an outside area for family to enjoy such beauty. Bring the family back to times of yester years where they can enough the outdoor space and cabin together.

1. Outside swings by the lakeside to enjoy sunrise or sunsets. You can add a protective overhang to settle to provide for afternoon shade if needed - one that retracts for open starry nights.
2. Perhaps add a gas fireplace for great family evenings to relax, tell stories, roast marshmellos or hotdogs before retiring to the cabin. Build holders for tiki torches to light the way from the cabin to the area.
3. Outside BBQ pit with running water and small refrigerator
4. Build plenty of bird houses to attractive the local birds.
5. Make some outside benches / chairs out of tree bark to fit the surrundings.
6. Maybe evening a small fishing pier to sit with your feet dangling in water and enjoy a quiet sunny day with the family.
7. Or a detachable dock so the kids can row out and play in the lake.

Thanks for listening

Happy building,

Fred

Posted by: Fred Kimler at February 17, 2008 1:18 PM

Thanks for all the updates. I notice that "woodburning" fireplace won the vote, but lots of us are allergic to wood smoke. Any chance the fireplaces can be wood or gas?

Posted by: Nancy Russell at February 17, 2008 1:22 PM

I thought the 2007 Blog Cabin was fantastic, and would be hard to beat. But I think you guys can out do it with the 2008 Blog Cabin, which looks as though it will be beyond awesome. The lake view and your choice of Lot 5 looks like what dreams are made from. I would like to see a firepit toward the lake and maybe a dock for a boat if possible. This will allow the family to really enjoy making memories of a lifetime. Wow! nice job you guys, as always. Good luck.:)

Posted by: Connie Landreth at February 17, 2008 2:09 PM

If a reclamation system for rainwater is not possible, could you put in a pump from the lake to provide water for an irigation system to water the landscaping? This might be a more economical and simpler system to put in instead of a cistern.

Could there be some built in bookcases and a reading nook somewhere in the design of the great room or the upstairs?

Posted by: Mary at February 17, 2008 2:17 PM

I was thinking today that a stained glass window would be really nice for the window added in the entrance to the house. How about a window design inspired by the location of the cabin? Also add DIY initials somewhere. Love all the new changes.

Posted by: Jenny at February 17, 2008 2:21 PM

Forgot to add this to my last blog. I hope that Ahmed will be designing the landscape. I loved his apprectiation of the location of the 2007 cabin. As much as I love a beautiful formal garden, I hope local flora and fauna will be incorporated into the design. The landscape design is as exciting to me as the cabin. Can't wait to hear from Ahmed.

Posted by: Jenny at February 17, 2008 2:47 PM

The changes sound good, I am looking forward to seening the changed plans. From experience be sure to heat the floor of the Master Bedroom, as the open exposer that the garage will create will keep this room on the cool side.

Posted by: Triscia at February 17, 2008 2:55 PM

I think that the plans for this home are wonderful. I am thrilled about a real laundry room instead of a closet, I don't want to feel closterphobic doing laundry.
I think the master bath should have more of a roomy and elegant feel to it rather than the guest bath, not that the guest bath should not feel roomy and beautiful, Just not more than the master bath as it seems here.
I think the added windows will bring in more light which to me is a good thing. I like the idea that one can open the windows for a beautiful breeze coming from the lake.
I think the wood floor will be durable for those of us with kids and pets. I have wood floors now and find them quite easy to clean and keep up even with kids and pets.
I think this will be a beautiful home when finished. I'll keep watching.

Posted by: Leslie at February 17, 2008 3:41 PM

Wonderful updates. I think a tankless water heater is amust also. I love the office being changed out in lieu of a pantry. I love country sized kitchens with lots of storage capabilities!

Posted by: Cat at February 17, 2008 3:43 PM

Thanks Darlene for giving updates and explaining all the changes made to the cabin. I'm excited to know I have a say in the home. Must say I love what you are doing. Keep up the good work.

Posted by: shirin at February 17, 2008 4:01 PM

Hi guys;
Your doing a great job, i enjoy every minute of the shows of the Blog cabin on tv and the blogs. Keep up the great work, and don't worry you cant please everyone all of the time.
Sue

Posted by: Sue Williams at February 17, 2008 4:03 PM

Thanks for all the changes. Could someone give me more information about casement windows. Do they have screens on them? We have a lot of insects in this area. Screens are a must, especially on a lake. The cabin will be wonderful and thanks for thinking about handicap options. I'm looking forward to voting on other aspects of the cabin.

Posted by: Allison at February 17, 2008 4:19 PM

Watson, are you having trouble receiving my blogs again? Last time I decided they were in blog limbo, and since Clive and Cathy and others are making it, I know that the same problem must be happening with my blogs. Too bad. I wanted to tell everyone how much I will miss reading their input, that I have never learned so much in such a short time! I wanted to compliment Cathy on her idea and Clive on his for reclaimed water, Cathy for the questions about electronic/internet/cable access, and added a question about what cell phone company's tower are we going to be close to? (Major company, not Two Guys and a String). I love everything that Darlene Branim has incorporated into the revised floor plan, especially the INDOOR/OUTDOOR SEE THRU FIREPLACE!!!! That is going to be gorgeous and brilliant! What a great idea. My only sadness comes from the loney, small, no storage space pedastal sink in the Zen bathroom. But when you have no space, you have no space! Darlene mentioned the lot is very narrow. What is the lot size exactly? It is a great relief to have a walkout basement/garage, and a dumbwaiter from the basement under the kitchen to the kitchen for groceries, supplies, whatever is a very good idea. If it were possible perhaps if a person who is wheelchair bound could be given the option of adding electric stair tracks to all the stairs so that they have access to every part of the house without having to play musical cars and so on. Of course, the wheelchair would have to be moved by a walking person, or it could ride down in the dumbwaiter if it's large enough for a folded wheelchair.

I will be in surgery this next week and am going to miss reading all of you, and learning and being updated on what is going on with our cabin. My daughter will be voting for me having been given my choices and instructions to advise me if a new vote begins that I will need her to print out pics of each voting option and bring them up to my room. She is not only my daughter but my best friend, and I thank God for her and her willingness to help me, but our family is like that. We pitch in. I am very proud of her; she has a family, 3 children, keeps a spotless house, has a great husband, and suffers from a terminal illness that could claim her at any time, yet she has a calm, loving, caring and peaceful demeanor. You guys say HI to Erika next week, would you? I know she will sneak a peek at your blogs, and I've told her of many of you and how intelligent you are and how you have entertained and kept me occupied for the last however long.

Hopefully I will only be in hopital a week, even though my doc said possibly two I'm hoping for the best, and hope to be reading you all very soon! You will be missed. Have a great Sunday! And may the worthiest BLOGGER win!!!

Posted by: Cabincraver2008 at February 17, 2008 4:40 PM

Watson. Thanks for starting to post blogs at the weekend. Most of us don't get the time during the week to read every thing, digest information and blog too. The weekend is a long time to pass without updates, especially when things start to 'hot-up' as they are now. It’s certainly more fun to dream about this cabin than looking out of our windows and the ice and rain storm we are ‘enjoying’ this afternoon. Good work and keep it going.

PS. Any sign of the elusive Ahmed yet? I'm really looking forward to some comments from him on the geography of the plot and possible landscaping options.

PPS. I notice some of the voting is getting closer again. No harm in hoping for casement windows at least on the lakeside is there?

Posted by: Clive at February 17, 2008 4:42 PM

Will you post the altered floor plans on the website. please?

Posted by: Adale67 at February 17, 2008 5:09 PM

I love the idea about a dumb waiter. As a matter of fact, I've been looking for a simple plan for a manual dumb waiter and can't find any. Could you post one on DIY or direct me to where I might find a plan? The motorized ones for sale are cost prohibitive. I can't wait to win this cabin!

Posted by: Paula at February 17, 2008 5:35 PM

Am enjoying the new cabin the 2007 one was really great I agree you need to think about handicap access my husband uses a wheelchair and it can be difficult to add later

Posted by: Dottie at February 17, 2008 5:47 PM

Dear Darlene and DIY Family,
As an avid watcher of DIY and HGTV I want to thank all of you for choosing Watts Bar Lake and Spring City, Tennessee as the location for the 2008 BLOG Cabin. I grew up on the shores of Watts Bar Lake and have many fond memories of family and friends visiting and sharing in the wonderful amenities that nature has provided us there. My mother always wanted a log cabin on the lake, but was unable to fulfill that dream before passing. I am so excited that you guys are going to MAKE that dream happen for someone and only hope they can experience and enjoy the abundance of nature and the beauty of the beautiful home you are creating for them. Its with great pleasure that I read the viewers comments and suggestions about their individual tastes and desires, but with the fine family at DIY and the fantastic sponsors this will truly be one of the BEST homes on the shores of Watts Bar Lake. Thank you for allowing us all to be part of planning and watching a dream come true "reality" for someone.

Posted by: John Wilson at February 17, 2008 6:09 PM

Thanks Darlene, Given all the suggestions, you and the team are refining the cabins bone structure into a great plan that should thrill anyone fortunate enough to call it home one day! I think most people would look forward to adding some of the extras on their own. That's why we watch DIY- to get info and help on how to build things like a fire pit, a pond, patio or even screen in a porch! Personalizing a building is to me the joy of making it a home, however humble or grand! I've enjoyed seeing examples of the Barna Homes on the website, they are all beautiful. Extra thanks for the basement/ would be workshop!!!

Posted by: barb aboard penrhyn at February 17, 2008 6:30 PM

I think having a loft bedroom for the master with a stain glass would be great. A central fire place made of soap stone. I think a kitchen with a view of the mountain side would be awesome as well.

Posted by: Heather at February 17, 2008 6:31 PM

I think having a loft bedroom for the master with a stain glass would be great. A central fire place made of soap stone. I think a kitchen with a view of the mountain side would be awesome as well.

Posted by: Heather at February 17, 2008 6:31 PM


If you've ever walked down a wet hill side to a lake without some type of good under layment; you've probably picked up yourself up a few times. I recently visited a creek side cabin in WV that had some wonderful logs holding gravel. Made for a much easier traverse up and down the hill.
There's nothing quite like the buzz of misquito's in the good old summer time; especially if they are located on the outside of the screened in porches..........
A nice place to clean fish located right on the pier is a wonderful addition.
I still vote for a gas fireplace insert. Wet logs are never fun and alas, no cresote to worry about.
Found a wonderful craftsperson from Shannendoah Primatives. Makes beautiful handcrafted furniture from old barn board.
Any plans to add a satellite link to the area for internet options?
We live in an old farm house that is over 150 old. Humidity is a must in a wood/log home when heating is taken into consideration.
Keep up the great work. Can't wait to see the finsihed product

Posted by: Suzanne at February 17, 2008 6:56 PM

...just a green comment....much of the wood from
South America is obtained by destructive logging,
and endangering species of trees and animals that depend on them.
...on the bathrooms...wouldn't it be nice if
all four choices were available for the master
and the guest bathrooms.?..I really like the
ornate for the master(:

Posted by: ACM at February 17, 2008 7:24 PM

Ooh ooh : I got an idea for the basement/garage area: A FISHERMEN's ROOM: just for the fisherman of the blog cabin: a wall section in the garage or a small room in the basement living area, for all the fishing gear, with adjustable shelving with drawers & rod racks for the tackle boxes which the tackle boxes could slide in like a drawer, have hanging/drawer space for the life jackets, rain gear, a desk with a mounted working light and spooler and holders for spooling, storing and working on the reels, rods and lures. Even vehicle or boat motors. My husband would just go nuts for a place like this.....He's a real diyer. I agree and vote for the dumbwaiter or elevator idea, it will be much appreciated in this home. Young or old handicapped or not could use it for hauling in groceries, wood & luggage, baby & toddler gear and easily moving stuff from floor to floor. I agree with everyone having a handicapped access from and to the home & lake is important, so everyone can enjoy the home whether you are handicapped or not. Everyone should be able to walk and roll right on out from the home to the lake. I think it would be a nice addition to the home and in the backyard. Alot of people have health trouble or life changes in the future or even sooner than they think. So, why not, fix or build homes with future people problems in mind. So people can be happy where they are and keep on in their lifestyles in case of some sort of accident or nature takes hold.

Posted by: Carrie Miracle at February 17, 2008 7:27 PM

I agree, I would love to see some updated floor plans. The changes sound great! What a beautiful setting. Thank you for listening!

Posted by: Julie at February 17, 2008 9:14 PM

Thank you, Watson and Darlene and DIY. I am learning so much, I am going to bug one of my DILs for a mother-in-law cabin LOL

On the accessibility issue, the multiple stairways and stone pathways (w/o a railing??) are a hazard - for everyone.

Moss will grow on flagstones; and, dew/fog can make certain types of stone/concrete very slippery. If this area gets *any* icing in winter ... maybe the exterior stairs could have weatherproof-outdoor treads with at least one plain handrail? And I think there are stone materials that can be slipproofed.

We are talking, I hope, about a place used a lot, year after year, if not as a year-round home.

People have many types of "disabilites", not necessarily involving wheelchairs. Lots of younger people suffer from asthma, allergies, diabetes, and various heart ailments. Lung- and heart-related problems tax these peoples' ability to do stairs/steep walkways. I feel this is part of the general safety issue. How many of us have had a child chip a tooth falling down? Or, you're not paying attention, in a hurry, on your cell phone, and you stumble or fall?

As was pointed out, the basement (garage) definitely needs to be ventilated away from the above bedroom and the rest of the basement.

I'm not a fan of the master bdrm. over the basement. I can just hear teenagers shooting pool with music blaring or coming in from a late date and slamming the car door shut ....

On that line, do smoke detectors (at least in all bedrooms and in rooms with wood-burning fireplaces), CO2 detectors and, if an area issue, radon detectors come with the house?

Yes, an alarm system w/motion detector would be mandatory. Call me cynical, but one of my kids lives in a nice, new subdivision. Last weekend, four vehicles were broken into, some for the second time. Neighborhood teens are suspected.

Please designers, no FORMAL gardens. Keep it simple. No one wants to "get away" to pull weeds and do maintenance ... on anything.

Spring will be here soon(er) or late(r). Add some flower bulbs to your cabin dreams!

Regards,
Leslie


Posted by: Leslie Thompson at February 17, 2008 9:42 PM

hi, i'm out of the loop, When can we start voting for the cabin?

Posted by: Brett at February 17, 2008 10:21 PM

Love the plans so far. Like the ideas of other bloggers regarding bookcases, reading nook and stained glass window at the entrance. Can't wait to register for this one!

Posted by: Clark & Debbie at February 17, 2008 10:35 PM

Now it's getting really interesting and, amazingly enough, all of my choices are in the fore-running this time. Still hoping for a few of the really important possible alterations to be addressed before finalization. My pet peeve being the issue of the wood burning fireplace, as I have aforementioned in former blogs....Now I know they are gorgeous to look at and nestle in front of, BUT, they are NOT enviro-friendly, and as I, and others have mentioned, many people cannot tolerate the smoke due to allergy and respiratory issues! The cabin is sure to be a huge success, but Please...please rethink this one issue. Good Luck to one and all in the coming months....Thanks DIY!

Posted by: Sherry at February 17, 2008 10:37 PM

I love the modifications and can't wait to see what wins in this next round. I don't know if I missed it but it would be great to have solar energy both heating and electricity to make the house more efficienct.

Posted by: Cathy at February 17, 2008 11:53 PM

I wonder what the outdoor choices will be? I personally would like to see fencing around the property. I know that if I lived there I would like to have fencing up just for the sake that I have small animals. I would like to protect them as much as possible while still allowing them to run free on the property? Also, the guest bath choice... is that one particular bathroom upstairs or both? Because my understanding of the floorplan is that both bedrooms upstairs have their own bathrooms. (Which BTW I think rocks!!!)

Posted by: Melody at February 18, 2008 12:01 AM

I would like to see dissabled access.
Thnak you for listening to us!!!!!!

Posted by: patlyda at February 18, 2008 8:12 AM

The 2008 Blog Cabin plans look Great ! But the Master Bedroom needs doors to open up to the porch instead of just windows . You need a way to see the beautiful landscape from this bedroom or walk out to porch. I can't wait to see it being built.

Posted by: Madonna at February 18, 2008 9:15 AM

Glad everyone likes the changes noted by Darlene. Some sound good. I still have a concern about windows facing a neighbors house rather than the lake. Also double doors out of the master is fine IF YOU INCREASE THE WIDTH OF THE MASTER BEDROOM.
It is just too small to feel like a bedroom with all these windows and doors, Why have windows when you have the doors. Isn't there any privacy in the bedroom anymore. If I had to choose between doors and windows I say doors only. Now you have a wall to put your bed up against!! With a basement now, does this mean the laundry room is now in the basement/garage. Also no mention about moving back the 1/2 closer to the entryway and using that space to increase the right side size of the masterbedroom closet and using the left side closet instead as the water closet and linen. A larger pantry is good, so why do we need so many cabinets. Thanks

Posted by: Harry at February 18, 2008 9:29 AM

Two things concern me about the changes...

1)the garage under the bedroom. We just built a new home with a bedroom over the garage. Our home was built using 2"x6" construction and all floors and walls were insulated with sprayed in foam and cellulose. After all that, however, the bedroom over the garage is still cooler...and even with a belt driven motor, the noise from the garage door opening is very loud.

2)the garden window. I've had two and hated them both. The depth of the window makes it hard to reach for cleaning and opening. Both of my windows ended up leaking over time. I would never choose to have one again.

The house sounds lovely overall...although it's a cabin by no one's standards! And to be perfectly truthful, I'd be thrilled to own it even with a garden window and a noisy, cool bedroom!

Posted by: stl_mary at February 18, 2008 9:53 AM

On the next project please concider making any hallways wide enough for an ambulance cot to easily move through with an EMT at the side as well as on each end. Please have the local EMS work with you in designing a floor layout to ease their work in getting a possable patient out of any room or floor with the mindset that the oatient may need CPR.
Also design kitchen, bath, ane entrence for both handycap and non handycap people combined.
Place a fire suppression system into the home as it is being constructed.
As a firefighter and an Emergency Medical Tech I would like to see the above for a more safe and emergency friendly home for everyone.

Posted by: Kenneth Hout at February 18, 2008 10:39 AM

Darlene, Why take out the home office? Many people need to work and a lot of them work from home.

Posted by: Barry at February 18, 2008 10:39 AM

I have been watching and even though I know nothing about construction I am fasinated. Your ideas and solutions to problems are fun to watch. I am hoping some of your creations can go into my house. I own a large mobil home on a 1+acre lot. Finances are tight but no mortgage keeps my head above water. We (husband) keep going back and forth about whether we want to build a house or just remodel the mobil. Again the issue is money. We are afraid that if we build and take down the mobil the taxes will esculate out of our reach. Taxes are minimul with the mobil. Do you have an opinion? I have seen some very beautiful mobils homes. I just love all your ideas. GOOD JOB!!!!

Posted by: debra at February 18, 2008 10:51 AM

Thank you so much for listening to the ideas of the bloggers. There has been so many good ideas from them all. It does seem a little disappointing that not many people are thinking about accessability for the handicapped or seniors. I know stairs are becoming a problem for me, that is why I had voted for a one level floor plan, alas. I think a ramp going down to the lake would look just as pleasing as stairs and the dumb-waiter idea is wonderful. The folks at Barna Log Homes have been great to make any changes to their plans & I am sure they cannot please everyone so keep up the good work.

Posted by: Wanda at February 18, 2008 12:01 PM

Where are the new floor plans?
I thought we was going to be able to see them today. I don't want to complain but am sure that everyone else has waited all weekend to see them too.
Please try and post the new floor plans today.
Thanks
Joyce

Posted by: Joyce at February 18, 2008 12:20 PM

I hope DIY keeps a good eye on Barna Log Homes as changes are made. I recently finished a Barna Log home and had difficulty passing our CO, as Barna's engineers missed some crucial problems with the stairs and rise over run when 10 inches was added to the second floor for a sleeper floor and there was not enough room for the stairs. DIY have your own engineers double check any changes.

Posted by: Terri at February 18, 2008 12:20 PM

What a dream home this is going to be!
Don't forget, there are handi-capped people in most families. A handi-capped ramp would be nice!
I also agree that it should be "rustic" not too fancy. Takes away from the feel you want in a cabin by the lake.
I do agree with some kind of storm shelter area. Maybe built in the basement someway. Nothing big and fancy, just a safe place to go and sit when tornado warnings are in the area.
Well, just a couple of things I consider important.

Posted by: Mary Marso at February 18, 2008 12:43 PM

Wow! The excitment is sure building (no pun intended)!

One request I have...now that there is a basement, and with the recent extreme weather, would you consider building a storm shelter? ... concrete walls with a concrete ceiling (maybe build it under the stairwell....)??

Posted by: Sheila at February 18, 2008 12:57 PM

The changes sound great....all except the garage placement. How narrow is this lot? I think the addition of a full basement is awesome by itself, but the idea of having to hike up the stairs from the garage doesn't appeal to me. I say the garage should be attached to the kitchen side of the house. My request: Add the full basement regardless (hehe, more space the better), and somehow attach, or, have the garage adjacent to the kitchen side of the house. Thanks :)

Posted by: Tim G at February 18, 2008 1:09 PM

I am beyond amazed. One of my ideas (indoor/outdoor fireplace, which I wasn't even sure existed) has been accepted. That is really cool! This is just so much fun. I look forward to this everyday.

I am still trying to find how to upload the changed floorplan.

Posted by: Kathy at February 18, 2008 1:20 PM

Oh my. My parents use to own a lot on this lake. What a dream come true that would be for us. I was born in TN and my heart is still there. I was raised in the Cumberland Mountains between Cookeville and Knoxville. This could rate for one of the Priceless moments. The location is priceless.

Posted by: Linda at February 18, 2008 2:25 PM

Perhaps there should be some consideration and research need be given to the Garage door opener. I know there are certain openers that claim to be near to silent. And Perhaps the same consideration might be given to the type of door as well.
If fencing is even permitted it would be nice to have it in beforehand. Perhaps Our brilliant landscape man can provide some sort of natural division of local plants,trees, rocks and or bolders that won't infringe on views of this property or others and keep within any guidlines of the development. I personally would rather see that than a stark line of fencing. And it might be really nice if a chord or two of wood ends from Barna might come with the package for firewood. And perhaps if there is a wall or fence line, a stack of wood could be incorporated into it.
I am cetain hwowever it all comes together , that this is going to be and absolutely beautiful home. Thank You to all who make this so much fun.

Posted by: Jerri at February 18, 2008 2:41 PM

I was slightly upset that there was only two choices for the guest bath. I like the look of the clean and simple, but I would like to see it in more natural tones no plain white. This is a log cabin after all,and I don't feel that white would fit in. That may actually be the reason why more people are voting for the decorative and ornate.

Posted by: George at February 18, 2008 2:47 PM

Having worked with people with disabilities for more than 20 years; it's very difficult to accommodate everyone of them. For example, in order to build a ramp down to the lake would make it look like a Disney World Ride, when you take into consideration the ADA compliance issues for ramps. 36 inch doors, wheelchair accessable showers, lowered vanities, cabinets, light switches, etc., etc. I am the first to stand up for ADA compliance, when indeed you are blogging to build an ADA compliant Log Cabin. If not this one, perhaps next years Blog Cabin can be built specifically with ADA compliance in mind. Something for DIY to consider, especially as many of our bloggers are looking at this property as a retirement get-away and we aren't getting any older! Thanks!

S.

PS Check out Uwharrie for your deck pieces and outdoor pieces. They are made to withstand the elements and hold life time guarantees. I work in interior design and they are great!

Posted by: Suzanne at February 18, 2008 3:28 PM

Ms. Branim,

Thank you so much for listening, and incorporating, the ideas of the bloggers. I especially like the walk-out basement.

Would you please consider a screened-in patio/porch? There are many people who are allergic to stinging insects (myself, included) and if the area is screened-in then we could enjoy being outside, too.

Thanks! Great Job!!!!

Posted by: Cyndyas at February 18, 2008 3:53 PM

I know you do care about handycap people. Let see it!!!!!!!

Posted by: Michael at February 18, 2008 4:08 PM

I would like to see a cabin that the average american can afford,also using the products that are made locally.

Posted by: deanne at February 18, 2008 4:11 PM

I would like to see a cabin that the average american can afford,also using the products that are made locally.

Posted by: deanne at February 18, 2008 4:11 PM

I love so many of the ideas others are having for the cabin. I, too, would like to see radiant heat floors, possibly from a geothermal heat source (more ecofriendly). A grey water reclamation is almost a must in this day of draught (Perhaps even to planters on the porches or even within the home as well?). And there was mention form a blogger for a composting area; I really like that! I have been so busy with work and being a mom to a two and a half-year-old boy that I have been away from the BlogCabin for too long. Now I am back and anxious to see the new floorplan and some headway on the lot!
Thanks to everyone involved in the planning and execution of this fantastic home! I can't wait to move in!
Oh, can we please have a rustic playset built that perhaps has a similar feel to the cabin. Gabe really would love that! Mom, too!!!!! And, in the event that I don't win the cabin, I think it would be a nice addition for a "summer home" (though it would be my year-round residence, most likely) to have a place for the kids (or the relatives' kids) to play.

Posted by: behop31 at February 18, 2008 5:01 PM

Hey Watson, Where will the modified floor plans be posted here in the blogs or on the voting page with pictures?

Thanks
Susan

Watson: Hey Susan - the latest images of the modified San Jacinto floor plan will be here, in this entry. Technical difficulties however. I'll try again Tuesday during the day.

Posted by: Susan from Florida at February 18, 2008 5:31 PM

(Last post didn't make the cut hopfully this time it will.)

Hello bloggers, Watson, Ahmed and Darlene Branim,

Thank you Darlene Branim for the new updates even though I loved the design as it was except for the windows for the loft area was the only change I wanted. I loved the owner’s private porch maybe there is still away to to have this private area? ( a little private getaway for me and my husband )

I knew the only way to have a garage was to be a basement garage, hopefully this will be insulated so fumes and noise do not get into the master bedroom or the rest of the house. I'm sure it will be!

Windows, I feel no matter the style should be high-performance, triple-paned, gas-filled windows that can help to make the cabin be more energy-efficient and comfortable. Please!

We need an outdoor shower or at least one in the basement with bathroom for outdoor use.

Tank less Water Heaters are only ran by gas, sense there isn't any gas at the cabin site this will not work ( that's why the gas logs didn't win) I would love to have this in my home too but I guess we have to be a bit realistic here.
*** Couldn't we get a DIY Solar Hot Water Heater Put in here Please.***
That way we can have the Radiant heating which uses hot water without having to worry about the bill. Solar panels can be placed on their on stands like by the lake as an arbor and do not have to be placed on the roof!

You can read more about this here:
http://www.thedailygreen.com/green-homes/latest/6080

Rain source has an underground rain catching system that I would love to see installed here please!
You can read about this system at:
http://www.rainsourcewater.com/index.html

I agree with lots of you about installing a greywater irrigation system here also.

Ahmed Please have the Landscaping to include low water demand plants and a path made of recycled tires with flagstone color to the lake, you can even use as a patio by lake for star gazing. With solar lights alone the path to the lake. Beautiful! I also liked the ideal of a floating dock.

I liked the ideal one of you suggested about the dumbwaiter system, but from kitchen or laundry room to upper level will have to be placed in the above bedroom but I love the ideal and agree! This should work great from basement to kitchen/laundry area.

I feel for the handicap persons requesting proper access to this cabin. Maybe the next one will be more handicap friendly for wheel chairs etc. Maybe DIY can do a retirement cabin next year after all, us baby boomers are starting to retire!

So long for now
Susan

Posted by: Sue from Florida at February 18, 2008 6:10 PM

It would be great if the cabin can built so its 'off the grid". Consider the options at: http://www.hardysolar.com/shop/home.php?cat=61

Posted by: lconrad at February 18, 2008 6:19 PM

Note for Sue: Casements do have screens-they are on the inside. Most casements open so that you can clean them easily (after the screens are removed) when they are opened and you are on the inside of the home. Some have an integrated dual locking systems, substantial hardware, high wind load capacities and many more features. The architect/designer showed this home with double-hung windows that have a fairly small lite (grille/muntin) pattern-many patterns are available and are available in casements too. Hope this helps.


I too would love to see some stained glass (suggested it on an earler blog). Over the master tub would be a great place-beautiful curbside appeal and privacy for the tub area. The stained glass can be quite large and can be insulated (between two panes of clear glass), giving it more protection from being damaged as well as being more energy efficient.

Posted by: Debra Leake at February 18, 2008 6:37 PM

I agree with the suggetions about a dumbwaiter and handicap access. I was just Dx with MS, it is hard to get around with wheelchairs and walkers in a house that does not have wide enough spaces. I also wanted to ask when we will be able to entry for a chance to win the house?

Posted by: Shannon & Jerry at February 18, 2008 7:23 PM

I sure could enjoy this house as well as where it is located, because I am very tired and want to retire some place where it's warm yet cool. I watch the DYI NETWORK, EXTREME HOME MAKEOVER, DESIGN ON A DIME, FLIP THIS HOUSE, etc. I want a house very badly. I hope I will be the winner. I am claiming it as of today 2-18-2008.

Posted by: Peaches at February 18, 2008 7:58 PM

I personally love the house and want it no matter what comes out. But, I personally don't understand why the master bedroom & bath couldn't be switched to the other side of the home: The 2nd entry/ washroom/ pantry area could become the new master bath with outside access & bigger closets maybe could be placed where the former kitchen/ & now the basement stairs wall is, could be used for (his or hers closets) eliminating stair climbing noises or one closet located on each side of the centered m.bathroom door & possibly increase the master bedroom size out toward the back or side of the house: The existing kitchen side porch could become the homeowners private porch now. These areas of the floorplan seemed to be similar in size, to me, if I remember the floor plan correctly, unless construction has started and everything is piped/wired in already. This suggestion I think could give a better open kitchen floor plan. Instead of the kitchen wall being blocked by basement stairs wall. You now have the possibility to add a bigger eat at bar maybe L shaped, on the other side of house with beautiful rustic log post supports instead of a wall closing in the kitchen area. If structually possible that is. Therefore the master bedroom is not over the garage any longer. The 1/2 bath in main foyer could be removed from current location & placed under the stairs at the front entrance: you could also expand the front porch across the front and have a nice creative decorative extra guest parking area in front of the house, using both front and side entrances for grocery & guest unloading, thus making it easier for the elderly or handicapped to enter the home. The screened entertaining room could be flipped to the back of the cabin running from the left end of the cabin & past the doubled fireplace or run it the whole length of the back. Now that you have a full basement walk out. The space under the porches could be another porch or patio for the basement. Hanging porch swings or kids swings or a clothes line for drying the towels and swimclothes or a storage room for lake toys and lawn tools would also be nice. I love diy! You are giving me a chance to dream design and build a home, it's fun daydreaming this is my house! Because it really is my dream idea home on the lake...... I'm having alot of fun thanks for everything....Happy blogging everybody!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Carrie Miracle at February 18, 2008 8:10 PM

I'm think the best improvement is the full size walk-out basement. It would make a great game room!
A dumb waiter from the basement to the kitchen/ food pantry would be helpful in getting groceries up stairs.
Thank you Ms. Branim for thoughtfully considering everyones suggestions.

Posted by: Judy at February 18, 2008 8:51 PM

Did I miss it? I couldn't find the new floor plans - and Watson, you said they would be in Monday's blog. I guess you got President's day off. I didn't & might be a bit fried. Did anyone else find the plans? If so, where are they please! Thank you kindly.

Posted by: Therese at February 18, 2008 9:22 PM

Just a thought about dumbwaiter and elevator, all of the new beach house's here in florida have the handicap elevators in them for people with disabilities. How about checking with these manufacturers of these elevators to donate for advertising purposes. I am sure they can make a sale or two even if not disabled but just re-TIRED people can see how great they are. Thanks for the open mike.

Posted by: joe at February 18, 2008 11:06 PM

Susan, there are tank less water heaters for electric. My son just remodeled our first home and has a tank less electric hot water heater. The home has gas and electric but he has changed everything to electric because of the cost of gas now.
Just thought you would like to know. I know when our hot water tank has to be replaced we are going with a tank less ourselves.

Happy Blogging
Joyce

Posted by: Joyce at February 18, 2008 11:25 PM

I read the update changes for the cabin, and ,although i liked the idea of the office, the change is fine...you're right...just carry your laptop around, i do that already, and a huge pantry should be a welcome addition. As for me, i love it all and have always, always, always dreamed of living in a log home. I've been buying the log home magazines and drooling for at least 25 years! I hope every day spent working on the cabin is joyful and safe.

Posted by: Beverly Story at February 19, 2008 12:23 AM

Are you guys building a cabin or a mansion?? The point of a cabin is to be simplistic and almost rustic!!
Do you want me to tell you how this should be done?
If I sound angry, it's because I am!

GUEST BATH: clean and simple
MASTER BATH: lakeside zen
WINDOW STYLE: casement
EXTERIOR LOG STAIN:butternut
FLOORING:golden teak
KITCHEN COUNTERTOPS:granite
KITCHEN CABINETS:contemporary
MASTER SHOWER:power shower
FIREPLACE SURROUND:stone
PORCH LIGHT:hanging
FIREPLACE:gas logs
ROOFING:metal
LOG:d-log
FLOORPLAN:san jacinto

Watson: Note to all bloggers - blog comments of this type are subject to editing and probably won't make the cut in the future.

Posted by: ADAM bailey at February 19, 2008 12:41 AM

The now self contained garage should have doors at least 8x8 not the default shy 7x7. 8 wide by 10 high would be even better. Metal roller doors use up less people and ceiling space and can be colored to match the house.
I surely hope the HVAC will be geo-thermal for effeciency and green approach.

Posted by: Deralte at February 19, 2008 1:11 AM

The now self contained garage should have doors at least 8x8 not the default shy 7x7. 8 wide by 10 high would be even better. Metal roller doors use up less people and ceiling space and can be colored to match the house.
I surely hope the HVAC will be geo-thermal for effeciency and green approach.

Posted by: Deralte at February 19, 2008 1:11 AM

Hey Watson,
Thanks for the info on the floorplans I will be watching for them on Tuesday.

Susan

Posted by: Susan from Florida at February 19, 2008 2:11 AM

YAHOO!!! I am so glad to hear we are getting a garage.... Thank you so much.
Tim Qualls

Posted by: Tim Qualls at February 19, 2008 7:28 AM

WOW! I am so thrilled about the walk out basement! Thanks for listening! :-)

Posted by: CARRISA at February 19, 2008 8:30 AM

Darlene, I don't care how small the lot is,I think it's great.you build somthing so wonderful in front of everone. and then offer it as a prize for someone what more could you want?????

Posted by: Nancy&Mouse at February 19, 2008 8:34 AM

I tryed to comment sorry what happend

Posted by: Nancy&Mouse at February 19, 2008 8:40 AM

It is so interesting reading everybody's comments and wishes. One thing that comes to mind when I read some of the add-on comments is that if I am lucky enough to win the cabin I would like to personalize the cabin and property with some of my ideas. Items like outside showers, gazebo, play areas etc. can be done by the winner. I think that the DYI staff gives someone the opportunity to win a upscale cabin not necessarily everyone's dream cabin. That will be up to the winner to make it their "dream". Thanks for listening.

Posted by: sandi, iowa at February 19, 2008 9:19 AM

Helllloooo DIY!

First of all, as I have stated many times....WOW!!! What a beautiful cabin/home this will be for some very lucky family!

Second, I have to say, I am very greatful in this lifetime for having what I have or what I have acomplished. Thus being said, Watson... I am extremely greatful that I do not have your job....Honestly, after reading days upon days of blogs, shredding you to pieces, I am not quite sure way DIY builds marvelous homes to "give away".

Unfortunately, as the world grows older and faster, people expect everything yesterday...no patience. I have read your statements that you are having problems uploading or that you have been busy with other functions of your job to post the blogs on what the viewers may feel is a timely basis.

Additionally, expectations are extremely high, as well, as expected. People need to remember that hand outs should be viewed as a step up not in life...not an expectation.

Sometimes, I wonder how people function in their own jobs or how they handle difficult people or difficult situations. I wonder how they react when "clients" are attacking them for not completing the job promptly or to satisfaction. In other words, place yourself in Watson's position.

NEWS FLASH: Hey guys/gals, DIY does not have to poll the viewers to rate the "FREE" cabin to the public's likes/dislikes, they do not have to change the specifications of the "FREE" cabin to the viewers likes/dislikes, they do not have to build the "FREE" cabin, they do not have to "GIVE AWAY" the cabin, etc... They certainly do not have to take the harshness of some of the same people time and time again.

My last comment, people....simply, take a deep breath and then exhale. ;)

Happy Logging~

Posted by: UnspokenMiztie at February 19, 2008 9:56 AM

What about a linen closet?

Will there be one?

Storing linens very important

Panty would be used for food which is great!

A linen closet is a MUST have! lol

Posted by: Danna at February 19, 2008 9:57 AM

I think the wood floor choices are too dark. It will show too much dirt,especially since it is a lake house and there will be a lot of mud and water. A lighter color will not show as much dirt. I like the guest elegant bathroom better for a master bath than a guest bath. It is more luxurious and spacious than the master bath plans are.

Posted by: Judy at February 19, 2008 10:06 AM

A huge thank you to everyone involved, I loved reading the changes, I can tell you that I am as happy as a "Lark"
xxooxxoo

Posted by: Larkin at February 19, 2008 10:08 AM

The Watts Bar area is a great location. So much of what you have elected to do and change sounds absolutely perfect. Just to reiterate some points of change, I will list some things I hope you take into consideration:

1. Wheelchair access to the home, to make it possible for handicapped visitors. This can be attained by constructing a rustic path and ramp (log lined cobblestone?) from the driveway to the covered porch.

2. The Zen Master Bathroom is wonderful. I envision it with dark and light contrasts: light everything with the balance of dark and heavy wood trim from floor to ceiling. The bathroom should be easy access from the bedroom and main floor (no elevations); thereby, any visiting wheelchair friends can maneuver to this restroom with ease.

3. Pocket doors can be an asset in saving space in smaller rooms such as bathrooms, closets, pantry, laundry and storage areas. I wouldn't be opposed to the idea of all the interior doors be pockets. It is smartly efficient and can be tastefully done.

4. A screened in porch area is definitely a plus to any home. Think dining and bugs. They don't mix. I live in this area and the mosquito infestation isn't as bad as you might think, but still, consideration has to be given to any home that is near a body of water. A screened-in porch will then be an extension of living space for those that will be blessed to live in this wonderful cabin home.

5. Ceiling fans: I recommend that you make sure the covered porch has them. The summers in East TN are hot. In order to enjoy sitting at any of the porch locations during mid-summer, please create a balance of outdoor ceiling fans. I suggest, also, that the interior have fans critically located in the Great Room and bedrooms.
Wind has a way of dying down in the dead of night. In the mild seasons before and after AC is needed, a bedroom ceiling fan can be the means to a peaceful sleep when the room gets stuffy.

My heart leaps at the thought that this cabin. I will watch it blossom with enthusiasm!

Posted by: Jil at February 19, 2008 10:16 AM

I like everyone else have many ideas for this home. There seems to be a frenzy of ideas always, it's hard to know if some are taken seriously. I feel that these days everyone should think as green and echo friendly as possible not just big and luxurious. I think a foam form foundation,(such as echo block), should be considered. Tankless hot water, radiant heat both with help from solar water heating. How about grid tied solar electric. There are so many ways to help keep things as green as possible. I am just rambling and don't really expect to be heard anyway.

Posted by: Scott at February 19, 2008 10:19 AM

Darlene, thanks for the update. Larger laundry room and pantry is awesome! However I would like to know if there will be any "office" space available, maybe in the new basement? Also, will there be added storage space in the basement?

Thanks again,
Lynn

Posted by: Lynn Duvall at February 19, 2008 10:27 AM

Love the new modifications. I cannot wait to hear more. When is the target dates for completion? My anticipation is growing by the day.

Posted by: Laura Macke at February 19, 2008 10:33 AM

To Sue from Florida at February 18,

You make some good points some of which others have echoed previously and I totally agree with such as the rain water catching cistern and drought tolerant landscaping. However, you also say : - "Tank less Water Heaters are only run by gas, sense there isn't any gas at the cabin site this will not work ( that's why the gas logs didn't win) I would love to have this in my home too but I guess we have to be a bit realistic here."

Actually there are several makes of tankless electric water heaters available
http://www.tankless-water-heaters.com/ for example
They are a lot more expensive to purchase and install than the conventional tank but will ensure you only heat the water you use. The power usage is also much higher than the conventional tank (at least twice while they are in use) but the same applies on need only use. Gas tankless are probably about the same efficiency but it looks like the only gas available here is LPG so gas water heating would be subject to the same problems as for the fire, namely, high and rising cost of a non-renewable energy source, potential supply interruptions and the need for a large LPG tank to be buried somewhere on the plot to comply with the Lakeview Estates rules.

Solar may be OK but it's unclear whether again the local rules will preclude panels or even solar roofing shingles. Also the house will be quite well shaded which will hinder their efficiency too. The cost/return may not be good either. Most solar panels require replacement within 20 yrs or less which is not very sustainable or green. Presently to generate about 30% of the house energy needs would require panels or solar shingles costing maybe upwards of $50,000 which would be a huge burden to replace regularly over the life of the house and will give a ‘real’ cost of electricity many times higher than simply purchasing the fuel as needed from the grid. I'm sure that in the right setting solar is an excellent option but I'm not sure in a wooded mountain lot in Tennessee it will achieve all you hope from it. I could be wrong on this so if there is anyone out there who has done the math please let us know.

While on the subject of the fireplace I am disappointed in the redesign as it seems to preclude any chance of having a high efficiency wood or wood pellet burning insert for very efficient heating and no pollution inside or out. Remember that some 7.5% of American adults have some form of asthma or respiratory problems and the increases in childhood cases is rising at between 10 – 14% annually. These people will be affected by wood smoke. This means the likelihood of the winner having problems with the interior air quality is about 1 in 10 which is significantly higher than the chances of the eventual winner having a mobility problem.

I believe the redesign has missed out on an excellent opportunity to properly utilize the real potential of these fires which could heat the entire cabin easily on a very small amount of renewable fuel. I may be wrong but with a dual direction fireplace there seems no way top fit an insert and blower system. Also, is there going to be a big 'hole' for cold air in the winter months and vice versa in the summer? What safeguards are there to prevent bugs specially carpenter ants or possibly mice and other critters from getting into the home through the fireplace area? I'm sure the logs will be treated to repel ants etc. but that has its own environmental cost and there will always be some vulnerable parts of a mostly wooden home that will need extra preventative measures i.e. toxic chemicals. Personally, the mice don't bother me as our cats are superb mousers but ants and termites?

Posted by: Clive at February 19, 2008 10:48 AM

Hi Everyone,

Casement windows are nice if you have a one story house and Debra Leake is correct that the screens can be taken out so that you can clean the windows. But you still have to be outside to clean the outside of these windows unlike double-hung windows! And if you have a second story floor (like this floor plan) you cannot clean the outside of these windows from the outside as you can double-hung windows. I know I have casement windows.

Debra is also correct that you can get integrated dual locking systems, substantial hardware, high wind load capacities and many more features. But having both casement windows and double-hung windows I will take double hung any day of the week not only for ease of cleaning especially on the second floor but also for opening. I hate my casement windows because they are hard to clean on a second story home but most of all because after 10 years they are difficult to open. I would never put casement windows in another home that I live in ever! Sorry Clive glad the voting is going for Double-hung windows and not casement.

Watson - thank you for posting blogs on weekends - so much easier to keep up with these now.

Would love to see a dumb waiter especially with the garage in the basement. Would hate to have to lug all those grocery bags up stairs through the great room to the kitchen on a bad rainy day! It would also be nice to have a laundry shoot for the second floor going to the laundry room on the first floor.

Would love to see the porches screened in especially the one that will now be off the kitchen. I still would like to have a patio out back for entertaining with a firepit and barbecue area.

Posted by: Erin at February 19, 2008 10:51 AM

Sorry one more thing!

Cabincraver2008 good luck with your surgery look forward to seeing your comments via your daughter Erika.

Posted by: Erin at February 19, 2008 10:56 AM

Wonderful so far! I also heavily agree on the screened in porch. Also, a porch swing or two is a must. Ceiling fans on the porch to help circulate the humid air in July and August would make being outside more enjoyable. Having lived in TN throughout my life, I know what the humidity is like. Anything that moves the air is a blessing!

Posted by: Melissa P at February 19, 2008 11:05 AM

I like the changes you made to the outdoor porch area. Much more convenient for entertaining and also the more private area off the bedroom. The kitchen garden window is also a nice touch. I was also wanting a larger laundry so I am glad you chose to change it.

For the guest bathroom, I am torn between keeping it simple and having an elaborately decorated bath. I would try to go somewhere in the middle. Guest baths may also be for children.

Also, the master Zen bath is a good idea but don't go too far away from the cabin feel. Incorporate the views of the lake and the outdoors and make them compliment the bathroom features.

Thanks for considering our ideas.

Kathy

Posted by: Kathy Pruett at February 19, 2008 11:34 AM

Darlene, Absolutely love the description of the new plans. Thank You so much for actually taking into consideration our thoughts.
I do agree with the storm shelter as an excellent idea. It would only take a little additional cement and form construction to put in a storm shelter, perhaps/ food storage room in the basement. It is also always nice to have a cool space to store potatoes, apples, etc...that can be used in case of a disaster.
I so wish I could be there to help with the construction ,to see how it all comes together. I think that is the most fun. I am so looking forward to seeing the phases of construction when they are posted.
Thank You Watson for your diligent work and taking suggestions of the blog. Among taking other things. You are THE BEST !


Posted by: Jerri at February 19, 2008 12:35 PM

I love the way the cabin is coming together.You are doing a great job and I like getting to vote for all the different thing that the cabin is going to have .It is like building your own cabin and chosing the way you want it. It is wonderful .

Posted by: barbara gibson at February 19, 2008 12:52 PM

Regarding landscaping - Don't!
There is nothing more beautiful than what nature has already supplied to this lakeside setting and it needs no additional watering, feeding, pruning, etc., to always look its best.
John

Posted by: John at February 19, 2008 1:08 PM

The changes will be a great improvement in the design.

Posted by: Susan at February 19, 2008 1:44 PM

Hi everyone! I am Erika, Cabincraver 2008's favorite (lol) daughter, and while she is having surgery I promised her I would vote for her and keep track of all the intersted input you guys have to say. I left a blog on the other page, but this morning she told me I should leave one on the Branim comment page, because many of her favorite people are writing here now. So, yesterday I posted this blog, and unless she has something she wants me to say or ask, I wish you all the best of luck and ask that you please pray for my momma during this hard time. She is a great, loving and caring person. You guys would really like her, and I appreciate all of you keeping her so occupied since Dad travels so much and she spends a great amount of time alone. She has a 25 year background in space planning, design (interior and graphic), marketing and advertising, so occasionally she has some pretty good ideas. But she told me that you people are really up on current building ideas and techniques and she has learned a great deal from you.

This is the blog I posted on the previous site yesterday:

My mom would not rest if she knew someone signed in as a Texan in Okie Land! She calls us their Northern cousins, and Dallas of the blue and silver is the only game watched in their house! She seems to be doing alright, she is pretty out of it today. I haven't really talked to her about her blogging buddies today but as I put her votes in I will read what I can from you guys and let her know how everyone is and what great ideas you have passed along. She really enjoys this, since Dad travels so much and she's alone most of the time unless I have the energy to come over here and check on her and allow her to hug the grandbaby and kiss the older one's heads. She is a very special person, was a cancer survivor although it is rearing that ugly, disgusting head again, and I really appreciate you guys keeping her so interested in this. She has come up with so many ideas for our new home thanks to you that I don't know when we will have the time to do them all, but she really thinks the world of you all, bloggers and Watson (?). I think he is a manager at DIY? Pleaes keep her in your prayers, she is worth having around for a long time to come. Thank you so much. One thing I know I am supposed to say; MAY THE WORTHIEST BLOGGER WIN! Thank you. Daughter Erika of Cabincraver2008

Posted by: Cabincraver2008 at February 18, 2008 7:03 PM

It looks as if it's going to be closer to a ten day hospital stay, and there were a couple of problems during the surgery. Her right lung collapsed and they have what looks like a thin dryer vent hose going through a hole in her back right now, but her doctor assures me that when she is breathing fine on her own that will come out. During the surgery her temperature went up to 105 degrees, and apparently she had pneumonia! I know her oncologist and surgeon, and had this shown up before surgery they would have sent her home! She is still a bit out of it this morning, and she is in a great deal of pain, but she still asked me if I had entered her vote yet! She's a card!

You guys take care. I will let you know later on how things are going, and everyone out there stay healthy and happy. Thank you for listening. Sometimes it's easier to tell a stranger what's happening than it is to listen or talk to your family, because they are too close and emotional, and tempers flare, hearts ache, etc. I know Mom, she's a tough one, and she is going to pull through this!

Talk to you at the end of the week or next week.

Watson, she told me to tell you thank you for all your very hard work, and that she appreciates all you do for the bloggers. She calls you a superman!

Uh oh, almost forgot! Thank you for letting her join in, and I know if I don't say this I will get scolded, so 'MAY THE WORTHIEST BLOGGER WIN" and God bless.

Erika, Cabincraver2008's favorite daughter!

Posted by: Cabincraver2008 at February 19, 2008 2:03 PM

Great to see Sikkens stain being used. I think this is the absolute best product for finishing a log home. I refinished my log home using Sikkens and still four years later have not had to do any maintenance. Kudos to Barna Log Homes for using this quality product. The addition of a walkout basement is great.Can't wait to see the finished home!!!

Posted by: Nancy Bolin at February 19, 2008 2:10 PM

Excellent choice for windows. It is nice to see our suggestions taken seriously. Any thought to more "green" ideas?

Gil

Posted by: Gil Dheming at February 19, 2008 2:19 PM

Hello again All,

I still see no accomodations for DISABLED PEOPLE!!
Now that the garage is in the basement an elevator REALLY is needed!!Clive mentions Ramps for Disabled Persons and everyone seems to listen to him so: Watson, Darlene PLEASE address issues for the Disabled!

Posted by: Paula T. Smith at February 19, 2008 2:26 PM

An open letter to: Ms. Darlene Branim CEO of Barna Log Homes:

My Dear Ms. Branim:

Please know that, I do not have any background in Science of Dream Analysis, and the last thing I want to do is creep you out over this, but for the past several evenings you have been the central figure in a recurring Blog Cabin Dream I am having. Since the dream sequence is so vivid, I finally decided, at the risk of sounding weird, to pass on the information to you for careful consideration. And, the information I have supplied is posted to engage others and encourage the lively exchange of ideas.

The dream always opens the same way …. A lively group is gathered at the completed 2008 Blog Cabin. The place is filled with an eclectic mix …. The DIY Blog Cabin Team, as well as many of the “off-site builders” that had offered so many outstanding ideas through their Blog entries, had all accepted my invitation to the evening’s festivities. (Note to Self during Dream: Everyone really does look just as I’ve been picturing them, based exclusively upon their Blog posting style…… amazing! Hmmm…Everyone except Watson --- He, who shall always remain an enigma, it appears. (Hey, it’s my dream).

But I digress …

You had just arrived and all were thrilled that you had graciously accepted my invitation to be the Guest of Honor at the Housewarming Open House Gala. The bubbly was flowing freely, the conversation lively, and the oohs and ahhs were heard from every nook and cranny. After a few rounds of the room you made a quick dash into the Powder Room.

By this time, quite a few of the group had begun to gather around my Baby Grand Piano (yes… a Baby Grand can be delivered right through the double hung front doors…. No need to struggle up the rear porch, if both front doors open rather than one being fixed shut).

The great room was a buzz of laughter and good cheer as Grace, Keight, Clive, Kim Mc., Kathy, Melanie, Robert, Harry, and CabinCraver shared the moment with KateByTheLake, Ahmed, Robert, and Erin. In retrospection, I must admit I look quite radiant, due in part, I am certain, because the group had helped me coax Clive’s wife into playing something for us all! (Thank goodness, I had the foresight to have the piano tuned immediately after hearing back by e-mail that they would be attending).

So…. OK…. You’re the Guest of Honor and the main reason this post is being written, and you are stuck in the Powder Room ….. What gives, you may be thinking. Here comes the part of the dream that you need to pay close attention to (at least I think this is ‘the message’ in the dream for you) ….. It is a bit tricky to put into words, so please bear with me, as I will be as delicate as possible in presenting this part of the dream.

The room has become quiet ----- OK, in reality, there is still a bit of a buzz in the room. Remember the bubbly is flowing pretty freely ----- We are all anticipating the first tinkling (of the piano keys), when, from the powder room that sound actually emerges, followed by the whoosh of the eco friendly flush and then, the taps being turned on then off.

It was like we were all witness to a terrible accident ….. NOBODY wanted to turn around and look, but we just couldn’t help ourselves. And, as you emerged from the Powder Room, with all eyes on you, well, let's just say a deer caught in the headlights of an oncoming speeding car closely sums up your expression.

I actually ‘saw’ the moment you realized what had just transpired.

Luckily, someone shouted, “Speech, Speech! And, without missing a bit you rose to the occasion.
All in all, the evening was a huge success. And, please don’t worry …. No one wrote about you and the powder room incident on “Face Book”. Incidentally, no one used that bathroom the rest of the evening, but you can’t fault them for that, either!

Since I felt compelled to write about this recurring dream for your enlightenment, I only ask that you take a minute to consider the gift that this peek into the future affords you. Before submitting the final blueprints to the A.C.C., for the written approval, consider