Be the first to comment! Enter your comment in the form below.

I love dave's work. he is such a genius---I have been watching every single night..I feel that dave is very confident in his works and calm..I wish you good luck and hope you can run your own show..Maybe alice can be your partner...

Posted by sharon ng. – September 8, 2006 12:51 PM

I loved every show - wow!!

A few suggestions for next season.

1. Give the designers more professional help. Who knows, maybe they don't know how to work with them, and we/you could see this.

2. Have us vote each week, show the ones that got the least votes (say the bottom 3) and then the judges get to pick which one leaves.

3. Give the designers more time to explain there work.

4. Give the designers more time, I'm sure in TV land, you get more that 16 hrs to find out what the project is, plan, shop, build, install and fine tune.

5. Show portfolio's of there work before the shop, or at least info on why they got choicen.

6. Finally link the voting to emails, not the computor, I share a computor with alot of people and we could only vote from it once a day. We had to have a vote on who got to vote!!

Posted by Becky – September 7, 2006 11:24 PM

great show,there were some real egos on the show ...speaking of temple and donna,but glad were down to the final two,hope david wins...good luck!

Posted by sassy – September 6, 2006 7:28 PM

Clive, First off, well done! You kept this contest fair, objective and entertaining. I was happy to see the bold challenges set before each of the challengers. I have to say that I am torn between David and Alice. I love David's contemporary designs, his brilliant compositions and his eye for art. I also love Alice's ease with people, her flexibility and her openness to other's opinions. She is so talented and humble. They are both so very very talented that I would be happy to see either one win! Good luck to both!

Posted by Angie M – September 5, 2006 11:56 AM

Thank God Temple is gone. She seemed fake and used her tears to make people feel sorry for her. Donna was protrayed as her foe but I think Donna was very classy in the way she handled Temple's attacks. Temple is inmature and caused a lot of grief on the show. She should have been kicked out on the second show.

Posted by constance – September 4, 2006 11:43 PM

Love the show - Love Clive! DTS is one of my favorite HGTV shows (imagine my surprise when I found out that Lisa LaPorta was the design coordinator on Michael Paine's Designing for the Sexes) - and when I win the lotto I'm hiring Vern and Candace Olson to decorate my new home :)

As for Design Star - I unfortunately missed the first episode - so I didn't see Ramona...I've got to try and catch it in re-runs, and I missed the kitchen debacle. I really liked Temple - I liked the apartment she did in yellow and I always root for the underdog. The fact that she wasn't "trained" made me like her all the more. I am glad that David and Alice are the final two even though it makes it extremely difficult to choose - both have great presence and style and even though in h beginning I didn't think that I would like David - he has definately grown on me. I think the best idea I have seen in all of the blogs has been a joint show with both of them, because they work so well together.

Anyway - keep up the good work. I love all the shows on HGTV.

Posted by DeAnna – September 4, 2006 10:28 PM

I agree with so many others, that the two remaining "stars" should have a show together. They are great. I will miss whoever does not win.

Posted by Laura Love – September 4, 2006 2:23 PM

David's designs show alot of originality, Alice's people skills show a lot of heart! It will be difficult to decide between the two. I would love to have David work on my outdoor Tiki Bar!

Posted by Rob – September 3, 2006 12:45 AM

I am just glad Temple is gone.

Posted by DavidK – September 1, 2006 3:21 PM

In response to "Gloria" who posted the question about who was right (Temple or Tym) regarding hanging cabinets. Tym was right. Temple has no idea what is involved in hanging -even 'ready made' kitchen cabinets! even if they are ready to hang , there is a process for getting them to hang properly and "match" up. it may sound like it's nothing but ask any kitchen cabinet installer and they will tell you it doesn't take "just a second" to do it. Tym was correct on this one.

Posted by Jkarrow – August 30, 2006 11:54 AM

YES, David AND Alice co-hosting would be a great idea!

I also feel that the contestants were not able to shine when they had to work in a team so soon. I think individual rooms for at least the first challenge would have been better. Its hard to see someones style when they are forced to work with a team that may or may not share their vision. Obviously they will have to work in a team later, but for the competiton we need to first see what their individual vision is.

I liked Tym but hated his hair. I hope he gets a makeover.

I have to say also that while I like David overall, I felt that it was wrong to not "mark him down" for doing a "rug" from animal bedding. it may have looked good (it did look good) but it is NOT useable!! so in "real life" it would not have been a good design.

Posted by Kay – August 29, 2006 1:20 PM

I propose a twist ending: David and Alice get to co-host their show!
They are both talented and adorable, and something about each complements the other. I'd just hate to see either one of these two lose.
HGTV, you've already found your TWO new Design Stars!

Posted by Nina – August 28, 2006 4:05 AM

I have ben watching all week, and"Alice" has shown me the best of designs. She works well with others and she has such a charming personality I would love to watch a show in which she was the host and designer,I would welcome her to come and design my kitchen any day.David needs to try different approches twards implementing his designs, they all look alike, and I wouldn't watch his show because it would remind me of re runs all the time, and the "Hippi" remark "Peace"!
Alice is it in my book, show them Alice.
best of luck to Alice, the next; "Design Star"

Posted by linda – August 27, 2006 11:17 PM

I love Vern Yip and wish he was still Trading Spaces. He produced some marvelous designs that I would have liked to have in my own home if I had the same types of rooms. He made an interesting comment, though, about the use of red in regards to David's studio design. He applauded David's use of red in the room and he said that if you really tried to exist in a red room, 24/7, it would drive you up a wall. I distinctly remember two of Vern's early Trading Spaces rooms that were red or a derivative of it in design. One was a living room...the ceiling and walls were a glossy lipstick red, which exposed flaws in this older home's surfaces. The space was also dark and oppressive, even under the scrutiny of TV lighting. In this case, the homeowner did not seem to be too happy with the space. The other was a kitchen...the top half of the cabinetry was done in deep orange and the bottom half of the cabinetry was done in lipstick red; the walls were lipstick red as well. In this case, the wife loved it but she said she loved contemporary design and lots of color so the design fit her personality to a tee. The husband seemed less pleased but not unhappy. I think red has its place such as in David's focal point design, in a room with little wall space or in a powder room for drama. I think Vern's early experiences have probably shaped his opinions of today. I've seen pictures of his own space in a magazine layout and he has wonderful taste. I just read that there will be another designstar challenge in the future and I hope Vern will be on board once again.

Posted by Denise – August 27, 2006 11:10 PM

I loved Temple's idea of the bed/sofa, and I liked her design. Just wish she had used more colors in addition to yellow.
I really liked David's colors, did not like way he had segregated tv area from the rest of the space. Think David is really good designer.
Why didn't anyone use drapes to hide bed? Tym was close to that.
Loved Alice, Tym and David presentation.

Posted by Nanette – August 27, 2006 9:19 PM

Of all 10 of the designers, I really only like Temples and Davids designs. I would never be able to get along with Donna, she thinks she is the only one that knows anything. Ramona only wanted to design with trash, I did not anything she had to design, I was glad she was taken out on the first show. The only ones I would have to design for me would be Temple or David, I believe that either one of them deserve to get their own show on tv. I would watch it all the time. Thank you for letting me express myself, about you tv show.

Posted by Donya – August 27, 2006 8:28 PM

Clive,

A few thoughts for future shows:

1). I would love to see the designers get more time (and technical help) for their projects. Sleep is a good thing.

2). I would love to see the contrast between the viewers' votes and the judges' votes for each project. Perhaps unable to be viewed during the actual episode, it would still be fascinating to see as a follow-up. Viewer participation is a good thing.

3). I'd love to see a small portfolio presentation from each designer before the competition begins. Exposition is a good thing.

4). Clive, you are a good thing. Keep smiling! If you want to re-do a mess of a small galley NYC kitchen on any of your venues, I am up for the challenge!! Working kitchens are a good thing.

Posted by Patti – August 27, 2006 6:45 PM

I have to say that even though I really like Alice, I did lose some respect for her when she implied that if Joe went, the whole team would have to go, and then minutes later, she did not keep her word. That said, I still think she could get the job done if she wins. Tym presents well, but I would not chose his designs for my home. David has an creative eye, but he's not very practical and doesn't present very well. Although I know a lot of people didn't like Temple, I really liked her. I thought she was an extremely hard worker, put things together in a livable and attractive way, and I found her quite likable. I did not feel put off or threatened by her looks, and I could definitely feel for her since she is a parent who was separated from her children.

Posted by babyhudson – August 27, 2006 6:33 PM

p.s. Clive, you are hilarious and I wish you were a designer (or maybe you are?) because I would love to watch *your* show too!

Posted by SUsan – August 27, 2006 5:13 PM

Love the show, lots of personalities lots of ideas. David is too stuck on himself. Alice is like a breath of fresh air. I would watch any show Alice hosted.

Posted by BETTY – August 27, 2006 5:13 PM

Thanks so much for a great reality tv show! I can't stand the genre usually, but I'm a total HGTV and interior design nut. I'm also learning a lot about interpersonal skills and how to give critical feedback - useful in my own life! And thankfully I won't have to learn the lessons on national TV! Your judges are stupendous, especially doing it with the cameras rolling. Each has his or her own style. I appreciate their honesty and frankness. They are doing the designers a favor by being truthful with them. That's something they can take with them even if they don't become the next HGTV Design Star.

I am happy the three finalists are who they are. I really like them all. David has a strong design talent and seems to be a natural on camera (moreso in the interviews than his overly speedy presentation last week). I do wonder if he will be successful in executing a design style not his own. Could he pull off a traditional room? Or country? I would think that kind of flexibility would be helpful. He would be fun to watch.

Alice seems the most well rounded. She clearly is a pleasant person to work with, and knows how much of the success of her final outcome is based on the work of her team. (Good for you, Alice!) In that respect she reminds me of Candice Olson (love her!). However, Alice would need some voice coaching to even out her pitch. The comfort level would come with practice, I'm sure. She has a very good eye, flexible design style, and good business sense. I wish she had more confidence. She is really good!

I really like Tym too. He is bold, if a little rough around the edges. I think he would grow well into the position, once he got used to the flow of the work. He's got all the raw materials - great eye, skills, seems nice, comfortable on camera, interesting quirky look (thank goodess they got rid of the snotty beauty queen). His experience led him to understand that sometimes time is more of an issue than budget - he astutely caught the "catch" in that week's assignment. He also generously shared that knowledge with others, which I think is to his credit. A cut-throat type person wouldn't have done that.

Can't wait for tonight's show! Regardless of who wins, I think they will deserve it and I am looking forward to adding it to my HGTV repertoire!

Thanks for the summer fun, HGTV!

Susan

Posted by Susan – August 27, 2006 5:12 PM

Clive: My family is on notice: Sunday nights from 9-10 are mine!! I look forward to each episode every week. I generally hate ALL reality shows and their much heralded back-biting animality. To me, they symbolize how low the American mind-set has sunk. But this show is different. I see true human compassion amongst the players, the judges, and [you Clive] the host. Please keep that aspect of the show alive--at all costs!

Clive, it is heartbreaking to watch you inform each candidate, "Your show has been cancelled." I see the sorrow in your eyes and hear it in your voice. The judges are kind as well. I appreciate how they always discuss each candidate's strengths before anything else. Good for all of you! I wouldn't mind seeing more of that humanity. Human kindness is something rarely modeled in today's world.

I also agree with a past writer: I would love to see Dave and Alice co-host a show. I cannot decide between them. They are both extremely talented and their strengths would complement each other.

I hope you keep this show going, but how will that work? Will each "Design Star" get his/her own show for one year? I think that could work very nicely and launch careers for many talented people.

Posted by Patti – August 27, 2006 4:40 PM

I think David's designs are sooooooooooo superior to the other contestants. His talent shines through each week. I really hope he wins the competition.

Posted by Amyre – August 27, 2006 4:02 PM

You are a positive comrade to these souls, they are doubting themselves, under stress and not in their comfort zones but they can count on you to be a fair and kind friend-mentor.

I am writing to say that and this:
When Tym and Temple had a difference of thought pertaining to the hanging of the kitchen cabinets
in the couple´s kitchen, I still wonder who ia accurate?
Temple said the cabinets were one piece and it was like hanging a shelf only it had to be secure on the wall because it would be heavy.
(As I think when seeing premade cabinets that areone piece)
Tym said it was much more complicated -like he was going to fabircate them from scratch.

The latter would have been asking the team too much but not the first-buying and hanging a ready made cabinet.

Why didn´t the panel address this logistical question -not only for the participants learning but for ours. I would have liked an experts opinion on this for all to hear.

BTW This show is lots of fun and I enjoy it!!!!
From a non-TV viewing person that is quite a compliment!

Posted by gloria – August 27, 2006 2:52 PM

Don't think Temple should be gone. I do understand the judges have more experience than myself, but I just think she could have been the Next Star. She had natural talent and with the judges helping her she would have continued to shine. I like you because you seem natural, I seen that in Temple. Well, look forward to tonight. Good luck to all.
Diana

Posted by Diana – August 27, 2006 2:27 PM

I was truly amazed that none of the designers thought to construct a platform bed, especially with a skilled carpenter at their disposal! They could have used the space beneath for a desk area and had much more room for the living/dining area. Don't they watch HGTV?

Posted by Barbara Jean – August 27, 2006 11:43 AM

Hi All, A very exciting show! I honestly would never watch the remaining three on a show of their own, but has been mentioned earlier in the blog that David & Alice would be good as co-hosting. I felt that way also except I at this point it would be more exciting to being Tym into the picture. The three of them are all so much fun in their very special ways! Their diversity, in design and wonderful personalities is key to a very exciting and fun program on HGTV. As one, not interesting but united they totally stand!!! This is one great program! Keep up the good work HGTV!! Sincerely, Dianne in the beautiful Carmel by the Sea, CA

Posted by Dianne – August 27, 2006 1:17 AM

While I am not a "Temple fan", I just cannot see what the judges and everyone else see in Tym - I must be missing something. I know one thing I missed was the show Sunday night, so I watched it tonight instead. I noticed that the judges were verbally most critical of Tym and much more positive with Temple. Even knowing she was out, I was surprised to see that she was eliminated after listening to the comments by the judges. ( I would have eliminated Tym solely on the basis of the sickening green bed comforter he choose, and I don't care what color was in his paint can!) Plus, I'm still upset by last week's show. Temple had a lovely plan, which the homeowner's chose. Tym and Donna just plain refused to go along with her plan, and kept arguing it "couldn't be done". They were reluctant to be part of the team. My husband and I do a LOT of home improvement stuff, including cabinetry. While the team probably couldn't have gotten the cabinetry scribed and leveled properly in the time alotted with their skill level, they could certainly have installed them. It certainly is easier to install new cabinets than to PAINT them if there are time constraints!! If the team had worked together instead of working against Temple, they would have done better. With the budget they had, there was plenty of money and time to carry off Temple's plan with 7 supposedly competent adults. I didn't think Temple was treated fairly on that show, nor on this one. Plus, Tym is always bragging up his building skills, except in that show, where he kept saying, "this can't be done, etc." It's always interesting to see what part sexism plays in shows like this, because, intuitively, most men and women have trouble following a woman's lead unless there's a long-developed relationship and trust. (Designed to Sell is a great example of this - except who knows if the ideas are really Lisa LaPorta's or someone else's- I assume they're hers because I've been following her since her stints on "Designing for the Sexes"?) Then, of course, it's the woman's "fault" when her lead isn't followed. I thought the kitchen make-over show was a great example of that dynamic. I also think if Tym had done Temple's room and Temple had done Tym's room, the judges would have dismissed Temple anyway. I thought personality came into play. I guess, though, that's fair, since whomever is chosen will be hosting a show. This show is worth watching, though. It's the first "reality" show I've ever watched. It doesn't begin to compare to Designed to Sell, or Redesign, my two favorite HGTV shows. Design Star is more in the line of Designer Finals, which I usually don't watch because the outside parameters are so silly. (Let's give some new designers a final assignment to give them a taste of the "real world": you have 50 bucks and 4 hours to make major improvements in a home after being allowed to look at it for 3 minutes. That's realistic!! Every designer I've ever known certainly works that way!)

Posted by Ann – August 27, 2006 12:37 AM

I love the show! I can't wait for Sunday evenings - I will hate to see the program conclude! There was never a single room that Vern designed on Trading Spaces that I didn't love so his critiques are so credible!

Clive, you're sweet - you have a streak of mischief! Your humor is welcomed!

I was so glad to see Temple go! Wow! Was she in love with herself or WHAT? She was so arrogant with a superiority complex! Alice is my favorite - she has such a sweet spirit with no backbiting, sniping when Temple was having it out with almost everyone but Alice!

Tym seems to miss the mark just a tad and David is good but I agree with other viewers . . . he is so generally similar with his designs, he's rather a one-trick pony!

My choice? Alice in Wonderland in her Tiffany Blue Box!

Posted by marilyn – August 27, 2006 12:06 AM

I thought it was unfair of the judges to knock Tym and Temple for applying their color all over the walls in their apartment, when Alice did exactly the same thing. I was surprised that David put up that horrible little wall around the livingroom area. It reminded me of an office cubicle. Temple's space looked more relaxing to me, but the dual purpose "full size" bed/sofa doesn't work for me. I don't understand Tym's work at all, regardless of his camera presence. Alice is the best in my book.

Posted by Connie – August 26, 2006 11:46 PM

hgtv love love love the show i am addidcted to hgtv.
clyve you are great to watch and you have 2 of the best shows airing. love your humour and to hear you speak.
I have totally agreed with the dismissals.(Joseph was sad) Donna you got lazy on your last.(was rooting for you because of name) Temple yeah from utah, me too. I saw your addition tape while I watching episode 5. So when you got booted i was not sad. I was dissapointed in your style. Your decorating not selling sex!!?

I like Tym because he is able to do all and love the family. But Alice and David are great also. Cant wait to see next weeks

Posted by Donna – August 26, 2006 11:37 PM

I read a bunch of the comments below, and hope I'm not repeating anyone since I couldn't read them all. My questions/thoughts:

I know that to make the show interesting and fast-paced, editing is going on...so I try not to put too much into everyone's facial expressions before the breaks (or anytime during the show for that matter)!

I would be interested to know how much time the judges and anyone else (Clive and the producers perhaps) take to come up with their decision. Is it truly done by just the 3 on-screen judges?

Do the judges look at clips/outtakes other than the "before and after" shots? I guess it would help them gain greater insight about individuals caught on camera, but again editing could harm or help.

How much time do the designer interviews take (in the blue room with the painted squares on the wall)? Does it bug the designers that they have to be taken away from their work to do those, or just know that it's part of the process?

I agree that the final three have done the best job overall. Will be interesting to see who's chosen, and what format his/her show will be.

Posted by Jim – August 26, 2006 11:18 PM

I love HGTV channel!. I'm a person who likes to dream about interior design,and HGTV gives me that.Though I think the essence of Design star is missing something; even the production seems to lack some professionalism.
Clive the host is great but, the direction and content of his lines sometimes seem to be cut or missing something.
The judges, who I have heard little about them,(excuss my ignorance) seem like they are not the right choice for the job. Cynthia has been the only one to show not to be personally emotional about some of the contestants.
I like the competitions, but I think who ever is in charge of choosing these challenges, how and when they need to be done is not been realistic. Twelve or Twenty four hours, the use of only one color and the lack of help even to an experience interior designer would not be enough to perform a well put together project.
I don't know much about all these things. but I do see a lack of something. I look forward to see the rest of the episodes and see who wins.
Good luck to all!

Posted by Jeanie – August 26, 2006 10:03 PM

David's use of color and space was head and shoulder above anyone else's. Temple's and Alices were average and Tyms -- that was just a plain nightmare.

I'm routing for David!!!!!

Posted by Tracy – August 26, 2006 9:36 PM

My only question is why it took so long to get rid of the truly arrogant, devoid-of-interpersonal-skills Temple?

Alice should have this, hands-down. She's talented and, most importantly, likeable.

Posted by Jack – August 26, 2006 7:28 PM

It seems to me that these contestants are all designing out of the same school - sleek, modern, clean lnes. Honestly these apts all looked pretty much the same to me. I really did not see much personality in any of them. They all did a good job but they were all the same and all lacking warmth and upon first stepping into their apts I was not feeling "hey, can I come in? It looks really inviting and homey in there!" Well, I guess it's easy to judge. But I'd love to see some more diverse and unique designs.

Posted by Karen – August 26, 2006 7:13 PM

I. LOVE. THIS. SHOW!!!

Posted by MilkMaid – August 26, 2006 6:30 PM

I have watched parts of three of the episodes and I have to say that I am embarrassed for all involved. The "contestants" may have talent but none have the experience necesaary to be a "design star." Furthermore, I cannot believe that the judges would want to be a part of this nonsense. Would Mr. Yip accept a design project that had these kinds of constraints? Or a kitchen makeover in 32 hours? Not likely. Then why would he participate in judging projects like this?

One last comment. Critique but do not insult!

Posted by Robert – August 26, 2006 2:53 PM

I think this show is great, I watch HGTV all of the time, and I love this reality design star idea. It has been fun to see all of the talent and I really learn a lot myself by listening to the judges. I am disappointed however in the audition video's on this site to watch, I thought Temple's was completely out of line! How in the world did she even get chosen to be on the show? I hope it wasn't because of her "throw"! If that is the reason she was chosen to be on the show, I'm really glad she is gone, she used her body to get on the show, or at least that is what it looked like. I think the design talent is great in Alice and David, I think ALice has what it takes to be a "Design Star" Go Alice!!! The whole mess with Temple and Donna was rediculous, honestly, women, grow up! I was embarrassed by their actions and the way they treated each other. Looking forward to another episode tomorrow night!

Posted by LKremin – August 26, 2006 1:50 PM

Yea!! ... Sunday is almost here! You'd think I don't have a life (I DO!) wishing away my week until the next Design Star episode ... it's just so exciting! I agree with one of the postings below ... I am hoping the next challenge will impose a specific style instead of just a color on the designers. They all are leaning toward contemporary/IKEA tpye of rooms as they are the quickest and easiest to "manufacture". Let's face it ... a room full of white furniture, a can of paint and a few color-coordinated accessories and most of us could do just about as well. I think all the remaining designers have their own strengths and weaknesses ... David will no doubt work his on-camera persona up-to-speed with a little practice (look at all his show commentary to date ... natural, witty and love the facial expressions ... they speak volumes!!) Yes, I was really turned off by his cocky, "I'm pretty" attitude at first too, but now it kind of works with his personality (only certain men can get away with this!!) He certainly has the edge when it comes to vision, utilizing color and creating artwork ... again ... I'd love to see something traditional, rustic, etc., that would be a stretch for him! Tym is a very earthy, creative designer. His style is a bit spartin currently, but I think given a little bit more time with challenges ... we'll see him offer a more finished look ... always a little more eclectic than the others for sure, but more finished. His personality is a little intense, but he was soooo comfortable on camera. He would be a very different host than what we see on HGTV currently and that could be a terrific option????? Alice ... OK, I AM an "Alice" so I can relate to everything she has done so far and her personality. She is extremely charming, compassionate, considerate of others feelings without being sappy (I loved her comments re: Temples floor with the extra-twangy "We're not contractors!" She would blend in very well with the Joan Steffand, Michelle Torres types. We really didn't know what her abilities were in first few team efforts as she was more of a support person it seemed in that setting. I think we'll see more of her "range" in the individual challenges! SHOULD BE VERY INTERESTING!! ... and I hope all the talented designers get a great deal of exposure and work from their participation on the show. I could design a great room with a decent budget, resources and time frame, but in the circumstances these folks have worked ... I'm not so sure!?! Best of Luck Designers!

Posted by HugeFan – August 26, 2006 12:56 PM

never thought I would get hooked on a reality show....but I did thanks to the marathon you did
with all the shows. Very interesting.

Posted by Brigitte – August 26, 2006 12:37 PM

Yes..I could watch HGTV 24/7...I give all the designers so much credit to get on national TV and do what they do...it's very exciting to watch the challenges and see what the reaminding designers do...David annoyed me at first but I was impressed at every challenge with him, I love his style and would love for him to help me out with some design challenges in my home...I think Tym cries a lot and is suprised he's still here...Alice is good...think it'll be between her and David...Davind winning in the end. Can't wait.

Posted by Karl – August 26, 2006 12:16 PM

I can only say one thing and that is I am glad to see Temple go.

Posted by DavidK – August 26, 2006 11:21 AM

I am very disappointed in the last decision. The judges need to get off their high horses and realize the contestants are not the "design for the rich and famous" type of people. They are normal every day type designers. Tym's designs have been horrible from the beginning, yet he stays on. I feel some consideration should be given for natural talent. Guess you have lost another viewer. Really don't like your version of "reality TV". I'm disappointed in HGTV as a whole. By the way, you need to take the "G" out of HGTV. We're not seeing it.

Posted by Kris – August 26, 2006 9:04 AM

David's has been most consistent in doing good designs in challenges. I like his work the most. I hope he wins. I want to see his show on HGTV! Alice's work are just ok, and she'd be boring to watch.

Posted by sandra – August 26, 2006 7:15 AM

Clive - really enjoy the show - now down to this idea of "Design Star" - don't think that is what you have here - I think what you have is a "Design Star Team". I think the show would be much more exciting and entertaining with Alice, Tym AND David - what a great bunch of creative voices for our homes. There's Alice that you can trust any room in the house to - just leave for the day and you can bet she will delivery something you will be happy with. Tym will delivery a creative thoughtfully planned space with the homeowner in mind - if you want outdoors - you'll get it - you get the idea. Then our cute David - I call him "circles" - he's great but can you image him decorating the average American's home? I can see Tym doing this over David. Anyway, they are all great - so give them all a run! They deserve it. By the way, I think all the designers deserve a BIG design star award - despite all the problems they survived. Gee, just surviving reading some of these comments is enough to anyone want to cry! Give them a break....could you do what they did?

Posted by Cindy Dowis – August 25, 2006 10:56 PM

I'm not surprised that Temple finally got the boot. She had an unrealistic idea of what it takes to redesign a room in the past and would not listen to anyone. It wouldn't have surprised me if she had asked Tym to remove a loadbearing wall on her kitchen project and for her to want it done in "a minute" because she has no experience. A pretty face does not a designer make. I like David's work.....his pet store room was wonderful.I think Alice needs to let go and just run with color and fabric. Tym is very intriging to me and I'm looking forward to seeing more from him I have not picked my winner yet.

Posted by Kathy – August 25, 2006 10:55 PM

Would most of us question or care if it turns out that "the vote was determined to be SO CLOSE that it was declared a TIE"?

I vote...for a tie vote!

Carol D.

Posted by Carol D. – August 25, 2006 8:08 PM

Well I am in total agreement with most of you, the final decision will be a tough one. I am concerned, however, that Tym might be let go completly. I feel that would be a mistake. Although I am not convinced he is great design star material he certainly IS a powerful on-screen personality. You have many shows that the host or narrator is not necessarily a design genius but the shows are very successful. Clive himself is a great example of this. I think America could fall in love with Tym given the opportunity. Charisma is something that can't be taught.

I do believe that either of the other two would make decent candidates, but my final vote would have to be for Alice as I believe she is someone that almost anyone would be comfortable with having in thier home. She oozes with southern hospitality and refined interpersonal skills. Traits that David has not honed to as fine of an art.

Posted by Penny – August 25, 2006 7:42 PM

Watched a rerun last night - amazing how you see things that you missed before...

...like the mirror tiles on the back wall of Alice's apartment with the top one at a strange angle, and a shelf above the bed at the perfect height to do some serious cranial damage - WHAT was she THINKING?!?!

Temple's effort has actually grown on me - particularly since her apartment sadly had only one window down on the floor in the alcove off the kitchen! There was only so much the poor thing could do with that. It was clean and coordinated, which is much more than I could say for...

...Tym's apartment: It really was the worst - first for the clashing shades of green, the blue rug that didn't associate with anything else, and that framework that he built around the bed that served no purpose whatsoever: no fabric hangings or beads to break up the space, nothin. His furniture material choices were cold and uninspiring and his layout was drab and disjointed. A room from a prison, I think one of the judges called it.

David may seem like a one hit wonder, but think about this: You wouldnt call Kenneth Brown if you wanted an English Garden room w/ lots of chintz and florals, and you wouldn't call Mario Buatta if you wanted a sleek loft - so what's wrong w/ David having his certain style that he's known for? He was creative with the space planning - even if the result didn't work so well, at least he tried something original.

He's creative, fun loving and nice to look at: David is our Design Star.

(Where do I sign up for the next competition???)

Posted by BEP – August 25, 2006 7:34 PM

I must say between Design Star and Hell's Kitchen, these are more drawing (and to say the least fun) than Survivor or and other reality based show. I find the remaining 3 good choices and deserve their places. I hope Tym can pull it together at crunch time.

Posted by Nancy – August 25, 2006 7:23 PM

Clive is the star of this show. I only started watching because of Clive. However, the contestants have my interest now to the point that I watched the show twice this week, it was so good.

I really like all three finalists. I'm not sure who should win yet but I have a feeling it is between Alice and David.

I like Tym the best for on screen because I think his body language is relaxed and comes across really well for me. He is good at verbally communicating his design ideas even though I don't think they translate as well in the room. -I haven't liked his designs so far. They come across very cold and sterile to me. -On the other hand I did like the shades of green he used for the walls. The bedspread was not my color or taste.

I won't even guess at what's going to happen this week because the previews are so deceiving. But I will be glued to the T.V. this Sunday night again. Thanks Clive, you are the best.

Posted by Oblina – August 25, 2006 6:42 PM

Bravo to this show. I'm another who doesn't care for most reality shows, but this one is an exception. I was very pleased when the annoyingly egotistical Vanessa got the boot early on.

I love David's artistic sensibilities and vision. To my mind, he "brings it" every time. I agree that the wall in the most recent challenge (#5) was a bit too blocky. If he had lowered it about a foot and a half it might have worked better. But I've loved everything else about his work. I hope he keeps his shirt on from now on so that his talent is not overshadowed by his physique.

Alice is cute, and her designs are not bad, but they don't usually stand out as much to me as David's. I worry about her ability to lead a design team, since being an agressive leader is not her forte. I think she needs to improve in that area if she gets the show.

Cheers to the remaining contestants, and kudoes to everyone at HGTV. I am currently in the process of "Designing to Sell" my own house. I have learned a tonne of great things from your various programs. Can't wait to use them in my new house and yard as well!

Debz

Posted by Debz – August 25, 2006 6:03 PM

David is really the only one that has any taste or talent. Tym is too off-beat; and Alice? Well, Alice needs to work on her people skills. A design school refresher wouldn't hurt either

Posted by Marker – August 25, 2006 4:24 PM

I truly believe that at the end of the day the judges know what their doing. The three that are left are truly the best all round designers. I hate to see any of these three leave. They all bring alot to the work. I really wish there was a second and third prize fitting these three gifted and personable designers.

Posted by Margaret Wilson – August 25, 2006 3:46 PM

I believe the judges are unrealistic and catty. I thought Temple's design was clean, fresh and very inviting. Of course, I love yellow. It certainly ranked above Tym's sea of green.

Posted by Cherl – August 25, 2006 2:00 PM

This is the only reality show I will watch, and since it is on my favorite channel, it's easy to catch. I have alreay picked my favorite for the star, and wish I could just vote now. Alice is great. She works with class and handles the interpersonal areas in a mature classy style. David is talented, but all of his designs kind of look the same. He would be OK as a design star, but he would need to prove that he can do different types of design. After all, in the real world, everyone doesn't want paintings with red circles all over the walls. I can't figure Tym out yet. I'm not even sure he has much talent. His designs never seem to have that "pulled together" look. So, I'll vote for charming, talented Alice, and hope that if David wins, you will pull him aside and make him learn some different styles of design, or I simply won't bother to watch his show much!

Posted by Lucinda E Freeman – August 25, 2006 1:44 PM

Does anyone know what the process is to becoming a host of a hgtv tv show? I'm up for the challenge!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by rick – August 25, 2006 1:38 PM

Where and how in the world did these people get on this show? Too think that anyone of them has what it takes to be a host on hgtv is a insult to all in the design world! Tell me where and when,I will show up and go head to head with anyone! HGTV give me a chance! I am the one that can bring tv design land back to the real reality of interior design!

Posted by rick – August 25, 2006 12:29 PM

I remember when it was announced that HGTV was about to be born; I was so excited! I don't watch much except for the weather channel and your channel because I consider my time as a gift to be wisely and profitablt invested. I love Designed to Sell and House Hunters and anything with Clive or Joan Steffend or Kenneth Brown.
I think Temple had a lot of talent but poor interpersonal skills. A little classwork and she could become great. I enjoyed the twins but could see they didn'r measure up. I loved David's red challenge; he seemed to know how to use color for accents and highlights. I think Alice & Tym have learned a lot during the weeks of the show. I can't wait to find out who wins.
If I were going to hire one of them it would be David, beccause he isn't afraid of strong colors and doesn't slather the challenge color all over but uses it to make sparkle and exciting exclamation points in the story that is a design space.
You experts were great. Who couldn't love Vern?
Clive, you are a real class act. I love your concern for those who have to leave; I see it in your face every week. I also love your tads of sarcasm from time to time; a little vinegar actually sweetens up the show.
Great job all!

Posted by Budge – August 25, 2006 11:30 AM

Great show last week. All the weak designers have been weeded out and the best are left. I really hate to see anyone lose at this point as I think all three have great ideas/talent. I do have to say, Alice and David are the top two and if they could cohost a show, that would be the best. A show together, next one with Alice and then one with David, then start over. The only thing I didn't like about David's room was that wall around the couch. To separate the bed area from the TV/couch area would be good, but the then curving the wall around behind the TV did make such a small space seem smaller.

Great job everyone. Eagerly awaiting Sunday's show.

Posted by Suzanne – August 25, 2006 11:11 AM

It is down to my three favorite; I am so glad. I would place them as Alice, first, Tym, then David. Alice is darling and confident. Tym is realistic and sure of himself and just appeals to me over David. David is talented, but he seems to be a one-hit wonder with colored circles.
Summing it up and thinking of my home, I would trust Alice or Tym.
Oh, and I, too, noticed that Temple's presentation was slightly different from Sunday's viewing. Why is that?

Posted by tennbeekeeper – August 25, 2006 9:32 AM

I'd really like the designers to be given a style to work with rather than to incorporate their own. I like David a great deal but am unsure I would want to watch his show because all of his designs resemble one another. What else can he do?

Posted by Peg – August 25, 2006 3:30 AM

Can't wait to see this Sunday's competition! It is getting tougher on both the contestants and the judges!

I feel that David's talent is still the strongest of the 3 remaining contestants remaining... but I would be very interested to see if he can do something outside of his comfort zone...like traditional or cottage! He is wonderful at contemporary and transitional. I would think that versatility would a must in interior design show. His TV personality was a bit hurried, but he could easily be "taught" camera presentation... he has natural personality to draw from.

Alice has finally shown some of her talents. Like she stated in her profile, she isn't one to take charge in a group situation so I don't think she really had shown her talent until this last episode. Her camera persona is good and again she has a personality that would be very easy to develop for TV cameras!

Tym has lots of camera presence. You can tell he has spent some time in front of one! However, his design talents aren't as strong as the other two. His concepts are good but they just don't materialize visually. I think Ft. Wayne, Indiana is lucky to have a talented person available to them! This national exposure should give him loads of business!!!!

If it comes down to David and Alice for the final episode... America will have a really tough choice. I'm sure the judges will be glad that THEY aren't the ones to make the final decision!!!! I know I haven't made my final choice as of yet.

Good luck to all!

Posted by Pat – August 25, 2006 2:59 AM

Clive,
My wife Cheryl and I are huge fans and have followed the show since the beginning. We are in the middle of our own move (Hawaii to California) and our first priority was to get cable so we could catch DS the next night, we were glad we did. We came into the final four with three favorites (Dave, Tym, and Alice). We too seem to be following the crowd and are leaning strongly towards David's spot-on talent. Though I must admit, the remaining three all could host a show, we think Dave is the strongest candidate in this first season. Regardless of the final outcome, PLEASE record our vote to repeat this show many more seasons - it is our must see TV. Regards,
Erik

Posted by Erik – August 25, 2006 1:46 AM

Unfortunately I don't get to see Design Star until the rerun on Thursdays so I have to stay away from the HGTV site in order to remain surprised. It was definitely a surprise this week. I thought for sure Tym was out. I thought his design was way to cold. Maybe the judges are seeing something in him that I just haven't noticed yet.

Loved Alice's fabric, color usuage and her presentation was really the best. David's designs so far have been my favorite with the exception of this week. I think he's a consistently strong designer and the presentation will come with experience.

Temple's room was certainly livable but I agreed with the judges that it was a little bland--even though I liked her room better than Tym's.

So far David's my next "Design Star". Alice still has a shot. Tym lost my vote after the leash thing a couple weeks ago!

Posted by Elizabeth – August 25, 2006 1:13 AM

I am really glad that Alice is still in.
I was sorry, in a way, to see Temple go.
As someone said, she went with grace &
dignity & no whimpering or crying, etc.

Maybe it is just because it is my name too,
but Alice has been my choice to be the next
designstar from the get go.

Alice Craig
alice1127@yahoo.com

Posted by Alice Craig – August 25, 2006 12:47 AM

David is showing us his very creative artist talent and is my current favorite to win Design Star. To quote him "I dont do good, I do great!" That really sticks with me...and I can see how that is becoming evident in his work each week. I wasnt sure I would like him due to his quote, but after watching him in action these past weeks, I tend to agree with him.

Alice is my second choice to win Design Star. I hope she comes up to the plate this week and wows us all with something fantastic. I would change my mind about her in flash if that happened! So far, her work has been good, but nothing that particularly stands out to me. Come on Alice, WOW US!

Posted by Dawn – August 25, 2006 12:41 AM

Alice... David. David....Alice. Not sure which is my favorite. I like Alice's designs, I liked the open, airy feel of her blue room. Besides, she's just as cute as a bug in a rug, and she's from Texas, y'all.

I also liked David's assertive use of red in his room, and his artwork, but not too keen on that wall/divider. But, he's a fellow leftie! As for the negative comments about him going shirtless too often, I never noticed it until I read all the comments about it here on this blog. Gotta admit, though, his bare chest is much easier on the eye than seeing my husband's every day (he never wears a shirt in the house!)

Yes, call me shallow.

I think Alice has the edge. In my book, anyway.

Posted by Jade – August 24, 2006 11:03 PM

First of all, I loathe reality shows of all kind (and everyone's obsession of them)!!!!! I did enjoy the first couple of episodes of Survivor though. However, my 15 y/o and I absolutely love this show. Imagine a teenager screeching with excitement, "Is that a new episode mom?" She seems to be more (if possible) enthralled than I am. You have produced a hit HGTV!!!!!!!!!! I would like to say that I enjoyed Temple's designs and I believe that the others (especially Donna and the Trash Lady) felt intimidated by her. I believe that she was not a natural leader, and she found it hard to get through to people. Yes, indeed, she needs more experience to become a star, but I liked her personality.

One of the twins always threw design genres around, but I'm not convinced that he really knew his stuff (I hope it wasn't the Harvard grad). Vanessa is good, but she lacks pizzazz. Tym is cool, but he lacks personality.

David, David, David...............................
I love his cockiness, expressions, looks, and most of all his refreshing and mesmerizing designs. His pet store design blew me away. I did not like the restrictive feel of his apartment though, but it was still magnificent if you agreed with the style. He's a genuine charmer that knows his stuff. I would love to meet him. Loooooveeee...

Posted by Tracey – August 24, 2006 10:48 PM

this is the only reality show i watch. i missed it sunday nite so i had to make sure i saw it tonite. very interesting challenge. my tastes run very much to what david designs, so he has been a favorite. however, i have found that alice has grown on me. partly because of her personality, but partly because i think that she has grown a lot since the competition began. i also feel that david and alice were not whiners or complainers, but just got down to doing what they needed to do. that is a great quality. so i am torn between the two of them. i continue to be impressed though with the quality of the comments from the judges. one can learn a lot by listening to that!!

Posted by diane – August 24, 2006 10:39 PM

This is going to be difficult! I love ALL three of the finalists. Okay, let us vote, but how about giving all of them a position with HGTV. They each have special talents...just different. This show has been so much fun to watch!

Posted by Nancy – August 24, 2006 9:57 PM

Give me a break! Was Temple's hosting bit re-edited? I distinctly remember her inviting us into her "crib." She used the word twice and I cringed both times. This evening she was saying "house" instead! What gives?

Posted by MaryFaith – August 24, 2006 9:52 PM

Clive,
If I didn't have to work I would watch HGTV 24/7. I thought you did great with design to sell but this has everything beat!! I am not areality show enthusist but will not miss this for anything on Sunday evening. I think judges have done well with eliminations thus far. Although I enjoy and appreciate Alice, David by far is my favorite. Not only does he have an appealing design style,he has handled each situation with an easy grace considering the different personalities as well as he is easy on even the older eyes with a charm to match He would definitly bring your ratings even higher. David all the way!!!!

Posted by Deb Haws – August 24, 2006 9:44 PM

The remaining three contestants have shown some talents, however, I believe Tym is the obvious choice for an overall star. He is extremely creative and thinks out of the box, manages his projects, accomplishes any task, and is by far the most alive presenter. He gives detailed explanations of his projects. His audition tape was wildly creative and he showed his gifts on soooooo many levels. Tym's life looks exciting and artsy. This contest is looking for a "designer" not macho eye candy or the sweet decorator girl next door. Tym is the solid choice for the "Design Star" and looks pretty darn good too!

Posted by Lisa – August 24, 2006 9:40 PM

Love the show, can't wait to see it each week, and I watch the weekly "reruns" to catch things I've missed. (Should I get a life, or what?) How can we vote for a "Design StarS show" with David & Alice? David's contemporary design needs Alice's cozy style. Both of their personalities are winsome and real.

Posted by Nancy – August 24, 2006 9:36 PM

Okay, everyone, the show is so much fun to watch. Even my husband is now hooked. I agree with everyone's comments about Temple... she just doesn't have what it takes. I'm still having problems with David and his macho'ism. Tym isn't right for decorating, and Alice is just plain sweet. So, what will next week bring?

Posted by Paula – August 24, 2006 9:25 PM

Watched the first 4 shows in a marathon session and am totally hooked! David is my prediction for the winner, but I'd love to see a co-hosting with Alice. He projects professionalism, but Alice projects an empathy in what a homeowner might be interested in.

Posted by Kathy – August 24, 2006 9:15 PM

I believe in Alice for her true personality and positive design appeal. She is true America. She is honest and you would love her to come to your home and work her magic. You trust her and believe in her. Alice is your new Design Star.

Posted by lynn – August 24, 2006 9:10 PM

I loved Temple's room. I think she has such natural talent. It might not have been her best work, according tothe judges, but I think she has proved herself over and over in the past. It was a shame to see her go. If she was a designer in my vicinity, I would definity use her to remodel any part of my house. I also think she has a wonderful personality and was definitely intentionally portrayed as a b----- on purpose to stir up the pot. David and Alice are wonderful too, but I believe the judges were totally wrong this episode. Thanks bunches. And I look forward to seeing who wins. How about giving Alice and David a show together? They are both so cute and talented. :)

Posted by Laura – August 24, 2006 9:09 PM

I thought Tym was the clear winner of the hosting part of the competition, and I liked his design the best. But I think that my tastes and Tym's taste aren't universal. He seems to like metal a lot, and people can see that as cold and stark. Personally, I'd like to take some metal ceiling tile and use it on the wall underneath my stairway, but my parents own the house, and they would kill me if I did that.

I thought David made the best use of his color, but I disagree with the way he divided up the room. I didn't think Temple's use of color was that bad, but the overall design seemed somewhat similar in tone to the kitchen she designed.

One would think that blue would be a soothing color, but the amount that Alice used seemed intense. I have to admit I speak from experience. I painted my living room a somewhat darker shade of blue than Alice used, and it's hard to find any furniture that goes well with the color. The other minor problem I had with her design was the shelves over the bed. I would be afraid I would hit one with my head if I woke up from a bad dream. But Alice is sincere, sweet and hard-working. I wish I were more like her.

But I'm more like Tym, and I'm sticking with him to be the next Design Star.

Posted by Debbie – August 24, 2006 6:34 PM

My Sunday nights totally revolve around this show! David is by far my choice. He's obviously quite talented and artistic, but what I like most about him is his personality. He's confident but not arrogant and is very laid back - perfect TV host if you ask me! Alice is my second pick. I was very happy to see Donna go a couple weeks ago! HGTV - this is the best reality show on television - hope to see many, many more seasons!

Posted by Angela – August 24, 2006 6:21 PM

Hey Clive, I am not at all fond of reality shows except for those on HGTV. Design Star & Designed to Sell are 2 of my favorites. Alice has the personality & David has the best & most consistent designs, they ought to have a show together!

Posted by Judy – August 24, 2006 6:10 PM

Clive, you are so charming! Let's get together for coffee! I am a realtor and redesign/redecorate/ basically fluff my client's homes for a quicker more profitable sale. Thanks for D2S, we all learn wonderful ideas and techniques. Design Star is fantastic! Congrats on another hit! It is creative, innovative, and dramatic! I believe Alice is sweet, cute and country nice but we have all seen that show. David brings a twist - he is unique and innovative. I believe his show would be full of fresh, new ideas, constantly changing as he would bring in the art world along with the design world. Fresh, creative, innovative - isn't that what HGTV is all about... HGTV needs David Bromstad - he has vision and creativity beyond any one of the other designers. He is a DESIGNARTIST. Each show his creations and designs stand out, the others just seemed to move things, paint things, and make them "pretty". I truly believe there are several other hundred designers out here and we can do the same things - isn't that why we watch HGTV! I believe David's nervousness from the last show proves that he is sweet and he is not arrogant. We've already seen that he is not afraid of the camera and the camera loves him! David is your next star!! Now about that cup of coffee??? What's good for you?

Posted by Lara – August 24, 2006 6:08 PM

David has so much talent it is amazing. He looks at a challenge with such a unique and fresh perspective. He is head and shoulders above the rest.

Alice has the personality. She seems approachable and comfortable however, eventually, the easy confortable feeling will subside if her designs don't have that unique punch.

Tym has talent but, really seems as though he would make a better assistant than a lead. Not particularly unique or noteworthy. Sorry.

So my vote is obviously with David. It has been since the second show.

Now talent (David) with personality (Alice) together may be an interesting alternative....

Posted by Roseann – August 24, 2006 5:52 PM

LOVE this show! LOVE Clive. Cannot get enough of Design Star, Clive,and Design to Sell, which is why it makes me so mad that I can't find any Design Star shows ON DEMAND. (Especially because I missed the first one.) The trailers say that they are there, alas, they are not. And there are only one or two Design to Sell episodes ON DEMAND, which is frustrating for a junkie like me. Back to Design Star, Please don't wait til next year, do one in the Fall, and the Spring ok, you get it. As for final three, the absolute right choices-- I like all for different reasons, although I felt Tym was definetely the most comfortable in front of the camera talking about DESIGN not himself. I like his construction cum designer angle, it's different and refreshing. I think I really would tune in. And yes Alice is sweet (too?) and I am ambivalent about her accent, is that a reason to tune in? Don't know if her designs are unique enough for me... And David, I do love his designs but boy was he nervous, but you gotta give them all a break as they were working like dogs and had this sprung on them at the last minute nearly. I like a previous poster's idea of teaming Alice and David together.
Regardless, they are all winners in my book, head and shoulders above the rest.

Posted by Anne – August 24, 2006 3:09 PM

Posted by Carol W.

I love this show! I feel that David is overall the most impressive of the designers, the most creative and very much a person who can get along well with others without losing his own sense of integrity or back-stabbing (which was one of the problems with some of the others who are now gone). I really see his rooms having an overall cohesiveness that is very much what I would like to see in future shows and I can imagine that he will develop and grow as a true "design star" with a strong following for his own show. Alice's "Tiffany Box Blue" was lovely and her hosting stint was delightful, but otherwise she has not shown the consistency that David has week after week. He's my definite choice! Thank you Clive and the Judges for being straightforward but not killing the spirit of past contestants.

Posted by Carol Worthey – August 24, 2006 1:35 PM

I am not usually attracted to reality TV. In fact, I avoid it like the plague... Except this show. I LOVE IT! I can't wait until Sunday evenings. I think the competition is really between David and Alice. I really like David a lot and hope he becomes the Next Design Star. I like Alice, but I don't think that she could really hold my attention in a TV show. I was Soooo glad to see Temple go. I think that Donna really didn't help in Episode 4, but she should have stayed and Temple should have been booted then! The Episode 5 challenge really would have given us the opportunity to see what Donna could do. Someone mentioned that Tym has great construction and design ideas. I think that is totally true. He should be supervising sites, and have others do the follow through. He should not be the Next Design Star.

My vote is for David!!!!

Posted by LBee – August 24, 2006 10:27 AM

David, David, David.....need I say more?

Posted by TZ – August 24, 2006 9:22 AM

Wow ... love the show! Can't wait each week for the new episode and watch the reruns to see what I missed the first time around! I try to remind myself that television editing can really depict a person in a particular light by only showing the "dramatic". You can tell this is being done somewhat (OK ... I know drama sells "tickets"), but thankfully, it seems to be in moderation. I am soooo glad this is being taken as a serious competition and the comments and decisions from the judges have been professional and very straight forward and yes, even compassionate ... YEA! Clive ... I love your sense of humor and progress checks. Just goes to show that a host can be witty AND YET still supportive of the competitors ... good for you! We didn't need another "Simon!" That is what is setting this show apart from other sensationalistic realty shows ... this one IS for real. Forthright commentary is fine, but please continue to remember that these are educated, talented individuals really putting themselves out there and they deserve respect for their efforts. These are not the bimbos and gigolos from Tempation Island! So proud of HGTV for finding an entertaining AND integrity based middle ground! You've won the respect and attention of your viewers!

Posted by hugefan – August 24, 2006 8:58 AM

Just SOOOOO thrilled Temple is gone!!!

Posted by Melissa – August 24, 2006 2:27 AM

I am enjoying Design Star so much that whoever wins, I think it will be a letdown after watching the race to get there! The fun is really in the contest, and I wonder just how many shows the winner will actually host. Has this been mentioned at all? One show? Three shows? Ten shows? Or just 'wait and see how it goes!'
Of course, the producers will be foolish if they don't do another Design Star selection again next year! This show is a winner and it is the suspense that has everyone captivated!

Posted by Barbara -- – August 23, 2006 11:37 PM

I think David is rising head and shoulders above the other designers. I waited this long to write about last Sunday's episode to see what lingered in my mind. I had a difficult time recalling just what Alice had done with her robin's egg blue color, and remembered many details of David's work. I feel David has what "can't be taught" and anything he's lacking in presentation skills can be quickly learned. In addition, I think his design skills equal those of the other designers on HGTV and complements those program offerings. I'm not sure Alice has the design experience needed to enhance the channel.

Posted by Mary – August 23, 2006 11:12 PM

Ok, So where do we vote!

I think it is between David and Alice. Tym, I think he can do alot but his taste is still very strong on the construction/contractor side of things. Maybe he can stick with helping some friends and relatives for a good price to make a little extera money. It just seems like he picked up design as a side issue and we all know that what you give yourself totally to you become and he has not given himself to design so how can he really be a designer. He is a contractor in the construction with a little bit of design talent that's all.

Anita

Posted by Anita – August 23, 2006 10:33 PM

This is the best show on TV. I'm relieved to be rid of Temple. I could not have watched that spoiled brat who made excuses for every negative. I'd like to see a design team made up of Alyce & David. Tym is adorable but looks and talks like he is always frustrated. Is is too late to switch gears and do a "design star team". They look good together.

Posted by Barbara Brooks – August 23, 2006 9:46 PM

Hi, Clive:

I think the red room of David was the best. He has to have his own show. All the desings he all ready did it's just incredible. Good job for all of you with this show and Designed to Sell and the new show I love HGTV channel I learned a lot. Go, David Go!

Posted by Griselly – August 23, 2006 9:25 PM

I think you Clive are doing an outstanding job and its NOT an easy one. Tough to tell them their show is cancelled.

I am glad to see Temple gone and I really hope she reads some of these comments and realizes she needs to work hard on how she treats others. Her current way will never work and will not be good for the client.

I think David and Alice have styles that compliment each other and might be very good to cohost a show.

I do think that if HGTV decides to do this again that you might consider a new procedure. Give the designers a look at what their challenge will be, then segregate them (like a jury) where they cannot bouce ideas off each other. This might be better to bring out their talents.

The current format is shoot from the hip which is not what happens when they obtain a client in real life.

Just a suggestion.

I REALLY LIKE the show and I rarely like any type of reality show as most are foolish. This one definitely is NOT foolish.

Posted by Sandra Beene – August 23, 2006 8:45 PM

This show is great. What took HGTV so long to come up with this idea? I would much rather watch designers compete than below average entertainers do their thing on national t.v.

Posted by Kay – August 23, 2006 8:38 PM

I would like to say I'm not overly fond of reality shows, they seem to me to be lacking on the reality side and I've found myself wondering how much I'am being played. With that being said, I have watched all of the episodes. I really think that the remaining 3 are right where they should be. I do think that David stands out as the all around best designer, but can he relax in his skin and host a show? That is the question. Still, when I compare him and the others to lets say Candace Olson wow do they compare? Would I tune in weekly? mmm

Posted by Dee – August 23, 2006 6:52 PM

I am so glad that Temple, Donna, and Vanessa are gone. It makes the show more enjoyable to watch now that they are no longer on it. I think that David has talent but still do not care for his cockiness. Tym work is O.K., but Alice is the one that should be the next "Design Star".

Posted by Ellen – August 23, 2006 6:43 PM

I like Alice's work and her sweet personality. I think David is very gifted as an artist but his personality doesn't win me over. Tym is also talented but I see him as being the next one to go. It makes sense that the audience will have 2 different designers with different personalities to choose from. Alice is like the Paula Dean of design. I do miss Temple, she is a hottie!

Posted by Felix – August 23, 2006 6:31 PM

Alice has class, charm and so talented. Her accent and her design sense is so refreshing. She would make a great host.
David would be my second choice. His work looks good visually, but he hasn't shown that he is a designer. Who would want to live in a small so chopped up. He does seem to be stuck on the bold designs on canvas. He is stuck on himself, but not as much as Temple was. Thank God she is gone! Trouble with a capital "T."

Posted by Sarah – August 23, 2006 6:20 PM

I love the show! Can't wait for Sunday nights! Clive - you are a fantastic host on this and Designed to Sell! It was great fun this past week getting to see the "designers" on camera presenting their products...any one of the remaining three would be welcome on my TV!

Posted by Carol – August 23, 2006 6:15 PM

Wassup Clive?
I've read the other blogs and we all agree on one thing and that is Design Star is a great show! I'm a HGTV Queen and I must say Design Star is one of my favorite along with D2S. You are a great host and might I add handsome!
I can never wait until the following Sunday to see the next show I always look forward to doing so.
And now for my prediction...Drum Roll please, Ladies and Gentleman the host of their own design show is DAVID!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Because not only is he extremely talanted but because he's a piece of "eye candy" well, besides you of course Clive. ;-))
I sincerely hope that this show will continue on forever.

Posted by Ms. C – August 23, 2006 6:10 PM

Red is not easy to work with, but David made it work in this challenge. He didn't over-use or abuse the color assigned to him like the others did - if you have the right touch you know when less is more. Also I think over all David has shown the most creative ability and talent in the challenges and deserving of a title "design star." His work on the show has been very good and his official website shows designs that are star quality (Alice's official website shows plain and average designs - nothing special) HGTV can do an interesting show with David's style that sometimes fuses fantasy Art with designs and does carvings and sculpture too. And David has a likable personality and should be easy to work with. What Alice will bring to a show has already been done to death. David should win because his show and creations will be creative and inspiring - that's what HGTV needs to keep viewers and bring in new ones.

Posted by silvershadow – August 23, 2006 6:02 PM

It's interesting to observe the four players that remain. David still presents himself as a professional both in the quality and execution of his designs and in the way that he handles himself as a representative of the interior design community. Unfortunately many people are not aware that the Interior Design profession holds it's members to high standards, and that every member of the interior design community needs to try and uphold those standards for the good of the profession. The constant bickering between Tym and Temple was simply annoying to watch. I am happy to see the nastiness between the contestants disappearing. This competition should be about the quality of the designer's work, not about how nasty they can be in order to beat one another out of the competition.

Posted by Audrey Dalton – August 23, 2006 5:57 PM

Hi Clive! I'm hooked on this show. I want David to win, but think it's going to be Alice. I think Tym is a little too 'out there' for mainstream America. David has a great eye, but I just don't think he's got what it takes to make it with HGTV's style.

I could not stand Temple. And while I can't recall the name of the one young girl (she did the beauty suppy room)...I'm sooo glad she's gone. I got really tired of her eye rolling and face making. Alice needs to watch that...I think that that is something people catch, and if she's going to show immaturity that way, it might not come across too well with the judges.

P.S....Clive, my husbie won't watch D2S anymore because I once told him he reminded me of you, and now he's jealous cuz he's figured out my little crush!

Posted by Anita – August 23, 2006 4:02 PM

So very glad Vern quit supporting Temple and her "so called" raw talent(s). She has been truly obnoxious and deceptive thru out all the episodes.

My pick would be David.... His designs are eye-catching. Alice would be second but I can see me watching her show....too bland. Tim should go home.... He hasn't been very good at all.

Love the show.... Hope there will be more seasons to come.

Posted by Carole – August 23, 2006 3:58 PM

I just want to echo EVERY WORD said by the poster above (identified as "Cindy"). She articulated well everything I have been thinking and feeling about the show and the designers. I've waited to see how the designers met the various challenges before choosing to put in my two cents, but now, well, HERE I AM! ;)

I'd have to add that while David's initial cockiness turned me off, he has consistently shown that he has the design sense and the ability to back up his sense of self. I can appreciate that. And as the challenges progress, an appropriate nervessness has started to peep through, and I can appreciate that, too.

As likeable as both Alice and Tym are, I don't think they have strong enough personalities to be solo design show hosts. I think they would each be great additions to THE RIGHT team mix (i.e., definitely NOT together).

Obviously, David is my current choice as the next Design Star, and I look forward to the final challenges.

Posted by Miss Dee G – August 23, 2006 2:10 PM

Hi Clive,

I am glad that Temple is no longer a part of the group. She seemed to think it was all about her. It was quite easy for her to cover up with lies which was good at trying to cover herself. She spent too much time and energy being bossy and glamorous. She does not have the talent or knowledge to be a designer. Temple would not have had the total interests of the homeowner at heart.

Posted by RG – August 23, 2006 2:06 PM

This was a great show!
I am so happy Alice won this week!
In terms of the challenges, I really think Temple was thrown off by the color. Personally I would have wanted a darker version on the walls and done a Parisian pied-a-terre look; but if she's never seen this done on her favorite TV shows, maybe she couldn't visualize it.
Where is Tym going with his designs? I still don't get it. I appreciated his use of two tones to designate space use, but he didn't use his space. It looked like a college student lived there. I'm sorry, people have more stuff than that.
I loved David's use of an accent wall. I loved his brown wall and the reference to the cabinets in the kitchen. I hated his "living room area". It was cramped and claustrophobic looking. The furniture was too big for the space. It didn't strike me as a completed space for some reason. Generally great looking, but not complete.
Alice the room was fabulous. I loved how you took the doors from the cabinets and created framed pictures for the accessories. I felt like I was looking at a finished room. I only wish you and the others would have considered how to use the window spaces next to the columns. Perhaps a hidden closet? It was dead space in every room. In N.Y. city where you are charged by the inch for living, dead space is a commodity no one can afford. Nonetheless, my vote is with you Alice.
Again, Clive, I love this show. I am so glad to see new Design 2 Sell shows on the air too. Looking forward to next week and the countdown to voting. HOOOORRRAAAAYYY!!!

Posted by a.d. volpe – August 23, 2006 2:05 PM

Wanted to say this show is awesome and I look forward to watching it every week. I wish that they had not had two eliminations 2 weeks in a row because it would have been nice to see how the other designers would have done the studio apts...the format as it stood allowed for no mistakes and everyone, no matter how good they are make mistakes...it would have been nice to see some recover in the studio apt setting and made for a more interesting competition not to mention, a longer series ;)

With that said David is incredible. I even liked his design this week that got so much criticism. Overall it rocked. I think he should have made the wall in the livingroom that held the tv a movable wall so that it could close off the bedroom when entertaining but still be moved to the living area when the occupant wanted to watch tv. I love his personality and think he is a talented artist. I think he is much like Kenneth Brown in style and a show could be made where his own designs were featured. I love that his artist background makes for great sculpture and each room is a true work of art.

Alice has the all around look, personality and likability that would work with a tv show although I think she needs to work on her shyness. She is modest which is appealing. I think her designs are okay but nothing that really wowed me. Still I think she has great potential for her own show. I don't think she would be good at a show that featured her own designs rather hosting a show like country style where she showcases other peoples talents. I think her hosting ability outweighs her individual talent as a designer.

I am one that finds Tym's work very interesting. I like that he thinks outside of the box and takes more risk then any of the other designers. I look forward each week to his work because I know it will NOT be your run of the mill design which is exciting. I really likes this week because his personality showed through for the first time. He is a likable guy and it would be fun to watch a show he hosted. I could see Tym doing a freestyle show where he used his unique creativity to use what the homeowner already had to make a room rock. That is the type of show that appeals to me the most because anyone with any talent can design a room with a monetary budget but few can do so with a minimal budget or no budget at all. One has to be able to think outside the box to pull that off and Tym could do that one with great ease.

So basically I think all three have a place on HGTV but in different venues where their strengths could shine through.

PS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO glad Donna is gone. She was a pain in the butt and whiney. Temple? I could not think of a more obnoxious host for a show. She is a legend in her own mind. Yes, there is some talent there but NOT enough to compensate for her OBNOXIOUS presence.

Lastly, Vanessa too was immature and obnoxious but I would have loved to see how she would have taken on the studio. I think underneath her awful personality there was some talent.

Posted by Cindy – August 23, 2006 10:55 AM

So glad that Temple is gone. All that whining and arguing. Very immature and makes you wonder how she is with clients and contractors. She seemed to have a distinct inability to hear anyone's ideas or suggestions other than her own. Then, all the talk about being a single mom, etc. The client and the viewers don't want to hear about that. They want to hear about the design and how it meets the needs expressed. She may have had raw talent but organization, diplomacy and teamwork are not traits than can be taught. You either learned them growing up or you didn't.

Posted by Nikki – August 23, 2006 10:21 AM

Great show! I approved of the judges' choice this week and also their comments seemed accurate. Personally, I don't choose what I LIKE best, but rather who does the thing that works that I never would have thought of. In that case, I voted for David to win this week, even though his design did have some obvious flaws. The other three created rooms that I would have been able to come up with, given the money and carpentry services. Just because you shop at IKEA doesn't mean your room has to look like a page from their catalog. The fact that Alice seems to understand how rooms FUNCTION is her great talent. Her comment about Temple's kitchen floor design was brilliant. Good luck to all three of them when they work with real homes and real families. And P.S. to Clive: love the new Designed to Sell promos!

Posted by jukesgrrl – August 23, 2006 5:31 AM

One word: "David"

Better -- Three words: "David and Alice."

Going on vacation tomorrow and trying to figure out how I can manage to get back to the hotel in time to see the show on Sunday. Even called the hotel to make sure they have HGTV. Is that sick or what?

Posted by M from Alaska – August 23, 2006 4:26 AM

I neglected to tell you Clive that I really enjoy your work on this show and on D2S. You have a refreshing way with your delivery and I really enjoy it. As predicted, Temple went back to Utah and her kids. No more do we have to hear her contradictory statements about being a single mother, and about her children's father. YUCK!
Alice did a great job on both counts, Tym was so-so in design and great in delivery, and David was off for some reason; I too agree that the bed area should have been the one to be more enclosed. But, everyone is entitled to a so-so week. I think we will be saying good-bye to Tym this week, after that it's anybody's guess.

(ps, I have never written to ablog before in my life until I wrote to you. Says something about how I feel about your shows

Posted by ric – August 23, 2006 2:07 AM

I've been a faithful viewer from the first show and surely enjoy reading the varied comments from others. I'm an HGTV junkie, watching or, more likely, listening, all day long as I work from home. I even see reruns multiple times but learn something new each time. I have a BS degree in Interior Design and although I'm not working now in the field, I'm still always learning.

From the first episode, I thought Alice was the most professional, most tactful and most knowledgeable in your field of ten.

My questions are regarding what you are planning to do with the Design Star and whether this programming will be continued each year. I imagine you were trying to get a variety of personalities and experiences - 10 experienced practicing interior designers obviously was not your goal, but selecting Ramona as one of the top ten made me feel negative on the show from the start. What could you have been thinking of? If you want a design idea show, you need someone, male or female, like Candice Olson of Divine Design who thinks out of the box, can do all kinds of themes, has a team of craftsmen to support her and has a professionalism and quirkiness that is most appealing. I know of NO designer who is asked to paint, build furniture, lay floors and lay tile as you have expected your ten to do. Nor do they work with a team concept. Each is used to thinking on their own and coming up with real life solutions for their clients, not a team of judges. They've been asked to be creative with talents they have never tried, and their response to the challenges has been most telling.

If your goal is to develop a show like D2S (which I adore and where Lisa gets her hands in there,) Re-Mix, Design on a Dime, etc., which start with a very different premise, then your selection of artists, furniture designers, architects, etc., might be more appropriate. Interior Designers design and project manage; Design Craftsmen are a different animal.

I hope that if you continue this each year, your selections of finalists are more appropriate using professionalism, education and experience as a firm base.

Posted by Jill – August 23, 2006 1:29 AM

Hi Clive,

Love D2S and DesignStar!

I'm very glad that Temple is gone. She should have left much sooner, whining is not an attractive trait for a potential TV show host. She was really good at passing the blame and not listening to her cohorts, espescially in the kitchen remodel. Tym, well Tym ain't my mug of beer. His designs are bOOOooooring! David and Alice both got it going on, so it's going to be tough for me to pick one as the winner.

I love the fact that Vern Yip is one of the judges. I've always enjoyed his designs, when he was on that other home show. He's knowledgeable,up front and is a rockin' designer....Hi Vern!!!

Posted by LC – August 23, 2006 12:39 AM

Alice won something from InStyle magazine in this epeisode. Does anyone remember what? And where can we see the results?

M. McCulley did write about Alice in her blog at instyle.com . Was that it?

Posted by MC – August 23, 2006 12:11 AM

Hi Clive,

I just wanted to comment on the fact that of all the designers that have left the show, Joseph and Temple did so in a more gracious way than some of the others. The twins also left graciously. I was not wild about
Temple, but when she left she didn't cry and make a scene. I wish her well and hope that her dreams as a designstar will one day come true for her.

I really think Alice should be the next designstar, but as one of the other posters said the last three would make a great Design on a Dime team. They seem to all get along quite well.

I look forward to next season for a new group of designers to show America their styles. I would also like to see different judges for a change, such as Joan Steffen (Decorating Cents), Michelle Torres (Country Style), Kenneth Brown (reDesign), Candice Olsen (Divine Design), Sarah Richardson (Room Service).

Thanks for reading.

Posted by Janet – August 23, 2006 12:07 AM

Sooo glad that Temple is gone!!! I thought her design in this challenge lacked any imagination. Actually a little disappointed over all the designer's rooms. Lots of options but almost everybody chose to just slap paint over the walls to introduce color? David's was different. Had a little more vision. Liked Alice's Tiffany Blue box look. Tym's wasn't horrible. It just lacked something-not sure what. I always think of NYC as being really hip and maybe on the cutting edge. I was hoping to see more of that.

Hope things heat up now that it is down to the final 3.

Thanks goodness Temple is gone.

Posted by zandraa – August 22, 2006 11:35 PM

This week's challenge made sense, the playing field was level and fair. I loved seeing the presentations and room outcomes for a more whole picture of each designer's talent. I must add my voice to the chorus of people who were sorry to see Joseph leave. I thought his departure was weakly supported and each week I wonder what he would have done with the challenges. I am curious as to the format of the winning design star's show--or is it dependent on who wins? Clive, thanks for the blog--are you going to host an episode with your shirt off?

Posted by ww – August 22, 2006 11:27 PM

Still love the show! I have never watched "reality TV" but I can't wait for each episode.

I was surprised that the judges dumped Temple. I liked her room much better that Tym's.

Everything that Tym has done has been bizarre. I wish that we had been told why the judges decided to keep him. Temple's presentation was okay and her room at least wasn't obnoxious.

Still like Alice. She seems like a really nice person and that's certainly refreshing. Her rooms haven't wowed me, but they have been pleasant enough.

David is inventive. I don't think I'd have him design my house now, but I probably would have loved his designs when I was in my 20's. Someone should have shown David the tape, so he could see he was going faster than the camera could follow and maybe he would have gotten a better take.

Just one word about Donna. I think that she might have really shown if she had made it to this last challenge. Most designers are probably not great carpenters. I don't see Lisa Laporte being nearly as successfully without the contractors & carpenters. Lisa does pitch in on painting and scaping wall paper, but she really shines in design and shopping for the right furnishings to give a room a finished look. Don't underestimate the ability to shop!

Posted by Jane – August 22, 2006 11:27 PM

Hi Clive! I am in total agreement with everyone that was glad that Temple got the ax!! She got on my last nerve from day one, good riddance! I think it will be between David and Alice, I will root for both of them, but I do like Alice's personality the best. I am looking forward to Sundays episode, it's a very fun show! You are terrific, Clive, as always! Love you on Designed to Sell, another one of my fav shows!

Posted by Lorie – August 22, 2006 11:12 PM

I'm glad to see Temple gone. Her room wasn't horrible--none of them were, really--but it definitely wasn't the best. She really should have added a complementary color or two to the mix, such as red or blue pillows, curtains (with a pattern of colors other than yellow), a different colored bedspread, that kind of thing. The judges are looking at all the contestants "cumulatively"; couple her non-extraordinary effort here with the kitchen fiasco, that would explain why the judges booted Temple rather than Tym.

I'm from Tym's home state, so I have been rooting for him. However, I didn't care for his room, either. Vern had commented that something was "missing." To me, the room was missing more than just one thing. I love where Tym placed the bed, but I would expect a moveable screen or a curtain separating it from the living area, rather than that skinny post. The room also would have benefitted from art on the walls, perhaps of various outdoor scenes. Also, the room needed more plants, and a rustic wooden headboard instead of that bicycle rack. His presentation definitely saved him this week. I worry that he'll be cancelled next week, however.

David's room had several fantastic ideas, but the wall (as everyone seems to agree) wasn't one of them. Definitely claustrophobic! Again, why not a screen instead? But I loved his restrained use of red; he's the only designer who didn't coat the walls with the designated color (which makes sense, as red would be overwhelming). His presentation skills can be developed, since he already has the design skills in place.

Alice's room was pretty, although I didn't find it (or any of them, for that matter) particularly outstanding. The walls looked turquoise blue to me. (Does Tiffany include turquoise pieces in its collection?) However, hers was the most liveable of the four, and I loved her presentation. I also appreciated that for the appearance before the judges, she wore a tasteful black dress with pearls. What did Temple wear? Blue jeans and a tight-fitting shirt?

Although I'm glad to see Temple gone, I really felt for the judges. This really was a hard decision to make.

Posted by Susan – August 22, 2006 9:59 PM

Hello Clive...

I have enjoyed all of the episodes of The Next Design Star, but I believe that this was my favorite. Temple is history! I just couldn't imagine myself watching a show with her on it. I was having trouble watching her on Design Star. The trouble was not her visions... but her attitude. I really think she should have gone instead of Donna. But, that's just my opinion. Enough about that! On a more positive note... I love Alice and David. They both have obvious talents and have shown them on different episodes. This is going to be a tough choice for the judges. I would really like to hear more about how they make their final decision. It's really the only thing that I feel is lacking in the show. We only hear their initial remarks, not how they do the voting when cancelling a contestant's show. It seems like their criteria changes from week to week and kind of leaves the audience hanging. Otherwise... I Love it!

I watch HGTV all the time. I love Designed to Sell, Sensible Chic, Double Take, Design on a Dime, and reDesign, just to name a few.

Keep up the good work... I LOVE HGTV!

Posted by Debbie – August 22, 2006 8:41 PM

I do believe the top 3 the judges narrowed it down to are truly the best choices. I hope the number 3 and number 2 candidates will get a shot at a TV/Design career somehow, much like how the runner-ups of American Idol get record contracts. The top 3 remaining display integrity, professionalism, maturity and a seriousness about design. This show is hot! Will there be a season 2? Clive--you are great on this and on Designed to Sell. Lisa is a great designer on that show! Much success to you in the future.

Posted by Julie – August 22, 2006 7:13 PM

As usual, loved the show and can't wait for next week. The decision was tough this week. I really thought Tym was going to go, until he saved himself with his presentation. I like him, but I have to say, I really hated that room.

I still love Alice, and would love to see her win it all. Still, I would love to see her really take some chances. Actually, could we have one challenge that gives the designers the time and budget to go all out - maybe just a presentation(?), so they could get super creative and really go over the top and show what they could do? It just seems like the time limitations kill them in the creativity a bit. I think Tym might shine a bit more with a little more time, too. Of course, David always manages to get creative, doesn't he?

Whatever, it's all good fun, and I'll be watching next week!

Posted by DJ – August 22, 2006 7:03 PM

I have scoffed at reality TV since it's inception, but Design Star has me hooked. Watching it is my new guilty secret (almost as good as eating Milky Ways)...and now I'm commenting on a blog....YIKES! What is happening to me??? No wonder I need a bag over my head :)

My prediction is that in the end it will all come down to Alice and David. Two very talented folks, albeit in a different vein and with quite distinct personalities.

An observation.....
as the design challenges became increasingly challenging, I think that the amount of time given over to executing the designs should have increased as well. Although I was no fan of Temple (she of the cantilevered physique) I think her response as to why the rugs were askew in her yellow room was symptomatic of many of the mistakes we've seen the designers make over the last few weeks. They simply did not have time to do all that needed to be done. The time constraints are unrealistic and have caused some to be penalized because they needed more time to hatch their ideas. One suggestion would be to separate shopping time from working time - i.e. 10 hours to design, shop, and gather materials and then 24 hours to complete the work.

I am hoping that the upcoming challenge will provide the designers with the opportunity to have more time to fully realize their conceptualization.

Posted by Bag Over My Head – August 22, 2006 6:24 PM

Alice was great. She was also a very good presenter. I agree with most of the folks, however.... David and Alice should cohost their show. They both have talent which compliments each other.

Posted by Peggy – August 22, 2006 6:07 PM

Hey Clive, I have to say that you and Lisa are my favorites on HGTV. I only watch "Designed to sell" when you are hosting. You are cute, witty and have a nice accent.

My choice for Design Star would be Alice with David as second. I really got tired of Temple's whining and Donna's attitude, glad they're gone!!!!!!!

So happy to hear DtoS will be on 5 nights a week.
It and design on a dime are my favorite shows plus design star.

Posted by Ruth – August 22, 2006 5:23 PM

Clive, you rock. I love you on D2S and on Designstar. An actor with a hammer, or a ham with an act. Let me know if Lisa LaPorta available to design my humble hovel.

I don't quite understand how the judges do their thing. It seems that they say one thing and do another. I really don't know how Temple got axed this week. Her room was not the worst nor was her hosting at all bad. On the other hand David's room was a disaster and his screening was the worst. I think his designs might look nice maybe in a museum or art gallery not a home.

Someone should have told Tym that comforter really sucked, yeah it was green alright.

I live a sheltered life, so I have never seen Tiffany Box Blue. I hope it is the last time, but the room overall was nice.

I look forward to next week and hope to hear you say "David, your show has been cancelled." Maybe he and Ramona can do a show called the "Odd rooms and other Oddities"

Posted by Michael Anzelmo – August 22, 2006 5:09 PM

Hi Clive! This show and Designed to Sell are 2 of my very favorite shows on HGTV. I love the ideas that you can get from them. As for the winner, I like all 3 that are left. The decision is definitely going to be hard but I tend to lean toward Alice or David. Out of those 2, I think Alice would be great as a host for a design show. Sure you can't have a 2 designer show for them? I'll be watching again Sunday! Good luck to all of them.

Posted by Agnes – August 22, 2006 4:57 PM

Glad to see Temple is gone - she was catty and not able to translate vision into reality. She blamed everyone but herself for this - so I'm sure if she got her own show it would be the homeowner's fault that the design didn't work. The designers who are left are very talented and very likeable - all three of them. Personally, I'm rooting for Alice, but all three have charm and character. And Hooray for Clive and Vern - they make the show fun to watch.

Posted by Teresa – August 22, 2006 4:42 PM

I am addicted to HGTV and especially Design to Sell -the Clive and Lisa version. Not too sure about the Chicago bunch yet. Now not only do I get Design to Sell but DesignStars on Sundays. Great shows. I am so glad Vanessa got the boot. She was arrogant and I was tired of her bragging. Temple did not work well as a team member, it is obvious that she likes to be in control. Donna had experience but liked everyone else to do the work. She must be use to having contractors to do the work.My favorite designer on HGTV is Lisa LaPorta - she is creative but not over the top, of course that doesn't mean she can't be dramatic or formal. Can't wait for Sundays.....

Posted by Ellen – August 22, 2006 4:25 PM

LOVE THIS SHOW! I usually don't watch reality TV either but this show involves some brain power and hard work so its really interesting.

I wish I weren't renting and had a house to sell so I could meet Clive. I'm glad HGTV has figured out who is really popular on that channel and is putting Designed to Sell on more often. And I LOVE the commercial where the teen girl slams her bedroom door in Clive's face. She's rude, but he's as witty and charming as ever.

I am liking the Designed to Sell idea with the remaining three more and more. They are the best of the bunch idea wise and they all must have gotten excellent grades in kindergarden because they can work and play with others well.

Can't wait until Sunday!

Posted by Motown Girl – August 22, 2006 3:01 PM

Hi Clive,

I'm a big fan of yours! Glad to see you on this show.

I couldn't believe that Temple went. She is one of the best designers of the four left. The top two would be Temple and David.

And I can't believe Tym stayed. Remember the dog food bags?????? I couldn't stand to be in the rooms that Tym and Alice designed, let alone look at them on tv. There must have been something that didn't come across on tv, because both of their designed made me nauseated.

Now there is no secret as to who will win. David. Not much interest to tune in anymore.

Posted by Anastasia – August 22, 2006 2:59 PM

Both Alice and David are great! I'll be happy with either one hosting a show, which I will definitely watch! I love Alice's accent!! It is so cute!! I am sure that the final voting will be very tough, as reading the messages, both contestants are equally liked! Guess what? I wish I was a designer, and I wished I could have study that, but now it is impossible.

Posted by Sonia – August 22, 2006 2:49 PM

Well let's see: long dark hair, perky girl next door attitude, KNOWLEGEABLE of her business, able to pull off a big order with cool ease, and the ability to take direction. Rachel Ray? NO the next design star ALICE!!!!
I'm sorry to point out that the difference between a designer and a wanna be is the ability to take what "is in your head" and MAKE IT WORK!

Posted by Jean – August 22, 2006 2:42 PM

Just want to say how much I enjoy the show. Just wish it were longer (two hours?)!!

Posted by Toni – August 22, 2006 1:38 PM

Hi Clive

Well, this week was interesting. It was great to see how the designers would work in a real life setting.

How ever as a designer my self I had a problem with the fact that every one left the bed next to the front door. It is embarrassing and uncomfortable your for guest to walk directly into your sleeping area. Personally I would have moved the bed to the other side of the room. I was born and raised in New York. Noise does not effect native New Yorkers. It's actually the thing that I miss at night since moving to
Atlanta. As far as light goes, there is a little invention known as room darkening shades. Me personally, I love seeing the night lights from my bed at night.

Temple had the best idea, to use the bed as a couch as well as abed. However, anyone who has lived in a studio will tell you sleeping in the same area that you entertain becomes tiresome after a while. If you have the space create two separate areas.

David's idea of building a wall to separate the space was great, but, he should have made the bedroom more private and not the living room. I did notice that he stated that the wall looked good in his mind but he was not sure if it would work in reality. This is not a good sign. How is he going to work as a designer if he has no confidence in what he visualises? I was happy to see that he kept his shirt on for the last two episodes.
As usual Tym's room was just plain ugly, explanation or no explanation. I would not put any student I know in it. I don't even think there is crime great enough to be subject to that penalty. I think the judges should have let him go a long time ago. He should have left this week and not Temple. I still saw raw talent in her that would work on a show intended to help the average person design their space.

Alice just is not my cup of tea. Her style is predictable. Her voice is annoying. I found her room to be boring and plain. Her choice of Tiffany Blue was the only good thing in the room.

I wish we could see more of how the judges make their determination. I really could not understand why they chose to let Temple go and not Tym. Or even, why Alice was the winner.

I would watch next season if you did this again. I would suggest some changes, more time viewing the final design results and individual designs sooner in the show.

Posted by Jacquie – August 22, 2006 11:42 AM

From the judges comments it appears there may have been more than one "hung jury" on a few of the episodes. I've come to respect the opinions of Cynthia and Vern the most. Kudos to Vern, who in a move of poetic justice, told Temple "honestly, you rocked it!" As a novice she produced more creative designs than Donna and Alice who have had 24 cummultive years in the business. I hope David wins because I actually look forward to seeing what he comes up with, and if Alice wins I probably just won't tune in due to boredom. Clive I love your deadpan deliveries..YOU rock!!

Posted by Donna – August 22, 2006 11:28 AM

Dear Clive,
Big fan of you from Designed to sell. Love the new show!!!
Alice is fantastic. Her designes are livable which after all is what real people do in their homes.She is so adorable and perky. I would definitely tune in to her show. I wold also hir her to work in my home. Texas ain't too far.
David has BIG ideas but no one could possibly live in that red horror.Until this episode I thought he had it all going on but his presentation was weak and the construction of the wall was hisd downfall.

Tym is not MACHO... his designed FAILED and he should hsve been the one to go insttead of Temple. His room was not Central Park I don't get him at all. He is surly and quite bizarre.

Temple is gone... It should have happened weeks earlier. No talent and no I wouldn't hire her to do a dog house.

Given a little more leeway and time I'm sure David or Alice would do a great job.

Alice is definitely the next Design Star!!!

Posted by Mark in Thibodaux,La. – August 22, 2006 11:10 AM

The show is great. I'm very happy with the 3 designers left. Very glad Temple is gone! Tym is probably the least ready of the remaining group overall (though I can't help and admire him for standing up to Temple).

Alice is great. She is warm and appealing and her designs are nice, however, she may need a bit more flare to pull off a show of her own. She may play it a bit too safe.

My vote for the best overall designer is definitely David. He needs to present himself better as an on-camera host, but, since we've been watching him for several weeks and we see how he comes across on camera in the contests, we already know that he has charismatic enough for his own show. He is the most creative and energetic of the bunch and he can do about everything including building his own furniture...Must admit that watching his biceps when he works is a guilty-pleasure bonus.

One last thing. Is HGTV planning on releasing Season #1 on DVD? I hope so and I hope it will include extra bonuses.

Posted by Cosmo – August 22, 2006 11:03 AM

Well, we're down to three who work well together, and I'm almost sorry they must go their separate ways, not even able to drop in and assess one anothers' progress. If "resourceful" needs to describe our finalist, the upcoming travelin' show with its mystery clientele should make that adjective stick. Of course, we mustn't forget the importance of being "timely." For even if personal space-time seems warped or enhanced, the judges have only one clock.

"Just a second, Tym, justascondItonlytakesasecond."

I like the way Clive seems to enjoy visiting the projects. I think his job is more fun than that of the other judges. Would love to see a reunion with Tym, Alice & David doing the judging, Joseph designing a project, and our able judges doing the work. Clive, of course, as host. Let's not fool ourselves...it's not reality, but it's really fun.

Posted by Gen – August 22, 2006 10:53 AM

I have to say that I "watched" the final verdict of this week's show with my eyes squeezed shut. I almost couldn't bear the thought of seeing one of the last four challengers getting the ax. I thought the judges had a supremely difficult decision to make. In the end, of course, they made the right decision. Temple's design and camera presence were OK but not stellar. Her poor execution on the kitchen task caught up with her.
I've watched DesignStar from the beginning. After reading the participants' bios online, I began to cheer for Tym. I believe we may have "gone to different schools together;" and if he went to football games in college, then we were in the same place at the same time at least once. So first and foremost, I support Tym. Then when David showed his strength, his creativity, I began to silently cheer for him. Now I can see that Alice has great potential as well. She might represent the whole package: good design, and good presence in front of a camera.
From this point on, I can accept any one of the remaining three as the winner. But at the same time, I will be solely disappointed when the others have to leave. I like them all. And if they're taking the time to read this message, I need to say: I enjoyed sharing in your experience, even remotely through the TV cable. And I wish you all the best in your future endeavors. ALL of you will be winners in your field from now on.

Posted by Corinne Smith – August 22, 2006 9:56 AM

Really love the show - very watchable and entertaining. This episode really allowed the individual's to shine on their own and show something of themselves. In my opinion it will boil down to David and Alice - a tough decision! However,David and Alice have one thing to overcome in their designs - an elementof predictability. David is bold and inventive but is relying a bit too much on the "same" type of "tricks"and Alice is a bit too constrained. One may do many things on a television show but never bore. They both have talent but I believe it will boil down to presentation and Alice has the edge there. She is confident and assured in front of the camera. No one will feel comfortable with a host who is tense and edgy I don't care how innovative they are. It is going to be a tough decision to make. I love David and Alice both,but I am leaning a little more for David because I think he is more exciting. Tym is a true craftsman and a really good presenter - but not the best designer - and the show IS called "Design Star" and I believe will be eliminated next for that reason.
A few other comments. I was so happy when Donna was FINALLY asked to leave. She was really getting on my last nerve! She WAS on my last nerve when she when on the Kitchen Episode she stood around berating and being the least productive after being gone all day shopping for something that should have taken a couple of hours and then coming back with other items that were not correct. She was just good at flitting around and leaving the work to others and I don't understand how she lasted so long. She obviously "loved" the "glamor" of being a designer and forgot that it took work and originality and not just relying on the same "stale" tricks like placing furniture on an angle because a couple of decades ago it was in vogue. Because of that she did it for that reason alone and not because it was appropriate.
I love the show and and hope it continues. I truly love HGTV and a large amount of my viewing time is spent with HGTV. Clive, loosen up a bit and let your natural charm and enthusiasm show through more instead of trying to imitate other "stiffer" personalities and hosts. You are ,by far, better than that. Keep up the good work, everyone,and I can't wait to see to see what happens.

Posted by Steve – August 22, 2006 9:47 AM

How hard it must be to come up with any decent designs at all in such a short time frame! I applaud the 4 who are left and actually enjoyed each of the rooms created, though I am pulling for David to win! He's wonderfully creative and suprising, something I'd look for in a designer of my home.

PS: Clyve, you rock!

Posted by Storm – August 22, 2006 9:18 AM

What a great show!
I am glad Temple is gone. I think she may someday be a good designer, but she needs to check her ego at the door. She had a terrific color this week. I just wish she would have used a deep rich gold. It would have given the space a classy look. And why the white rugs?? She could have really added some style with a different color there.
Tym had a great color too, but what he chose did not remind me of Central Park. He has a wonderful on-camera personality. He really needs to get his design plan to come across better in reality.
David was probably the most disappointing. He worked the color red well, but what was up with the partition. It made that room close in on itself.
Alice's use of blue was great. It was a breath of fresh air. Her personality really showed in her on-camera presentation.
Unless Tym can pull off his design this week, he is gone. Between David and Alice, well that will be a toss-up. I hope there will be a real challenge in the remaining episodes to help the viewers make an informed decision.
Margaret

Posted by Margaret – August 22, 2006 7:37 AM

I absolutely adore this show! I am also terribly glad that Temple is gone, the water works were getting very old, no one will want to watch that on TV if she doesn't get her way every day.

But luckily the judges let her go finally, and we're left with true talent to view. I am eager to see how this week goes, although I really hope that Alice and David are the two left for the final vote. Tym has pretty good designs, but I hate to admit she is right in this, but Temple did underscore his negativity, he has quite a lot of that overall. I do think he does not believe in himself as much as he should and it does hinder him, and the viewers as well.

When the show first started, I was not at all impressed with David's audition or comment section. I don't believe trading in on your own good looks is a selling point for this competition. I also would not have chosen any kitchen design where the dishwasher was on the other side of the room, that is highly impractical. It might have made sense in a space aspect, but he should have also looked at this as how the home owners would use the space.

I really like Alice's personality and her designs so far. I am really curious how she will do for this next contest.

So once again, thank you Clive for writing this blog and giving us the chance to add our own two cents. My mother and I keep reiterating the same things to each other each time we watch it, so it's nice to have another place to 'chat'.

Posted by Luriena – August 22, 2006 6:02 AM

Is it Sunday yet????

Posted by Beki Burton – August 22, 2006 4:03 AM

Hi Clive,

I too have become addicted to this and I'm as anti-reality TV as anyone on the planet.

With that said, this show is very enjoyable. My only critique would be I would like to get more of the Judges discussions, and get them a little more continuous (but that's apparently what editing has to be in our ADD dominated society - so I do understand it)

This weeks episode was really quite revealing of the four finalists, and I didn't envy the judges their task. My breakdown would be as follows:

Tym: Really seems to have a great design mind and will work "outside the box". But it's frustrating to watch him week after week come up short on execution. I was ready to bid him adeau until his "on air" performance - which I think he nailed.

David: Is overflowing with creativity and talent, and I'm rooting for him for the win. He does need to loosen up on camera, though (and he does he have to run without a shirt ALL the time).

Alice: I think is pretty good but a bit bland in both design ideas and personality. At this point i wouldn't be upset if she won, but she's not my first choice.

And finally the correct choice for "being cancelled" Temple: She's rubbed me the wrong way each and every episode. True she was eye-candy which wouldn't hurt ratings, but I won't miss her.
The Automotive room to her credit was very well done.

Keep up the good work.

Ciao,
Ziggy

Posted by Ziggy – August 22, 2006 2:59 AM

Alice- has a nice personality, good attitude, can work with others, very personable, practical, and has had strong like-able designs that people can actually live and feel comfortable in. I would tune in to her show. (not crazy about the shade of blue she had used this week, but she made it work, very classy)
David- seems like his styles are more contemporary, like his artwork, but maybe he focuses too much on that, he has good use of color, but the wall thing? not sure what he was thinking this time. I would have preferred the sleeping area be more separated instead, think that would be a better use of space. He seemed a little rushed in his presenting, but that can be improved. He has a nice presence, but needs to be more personable, and I don't need to see his tatoo each week. I would like to see him do something more traditional to see if he could pull it off. Maybe he and Alice could do something together.
Tym- a little too far out there for me, the nature idea sounded good, but didn't see it, in what he presented. Seems down to earth as a presenter, but not sure about his design outlook.
Temple- was glad to see her go. She was a troublemaker, although her room was bland, I liked it better than Tym's this time. She could go to school for design, but still needs to be able to work with people and get along in order to be successful.
I think that Joseph left too soon, would liked to have seen more of what he could have done up to this point.
Clive-As always, it's a pleasure. I love listening to you. I'm hooked on Design to Sell. You and Lisa make a great team.
I am already looking forward to next week's show, where they will hopefully focus more on the designs, before and after, and how they will work out for the families involved.

Posted by Krista – August 22, 2006 2:51 AM

I looked at the website photos before voting. Looking at the actual photos, rather than relying on memory, Alice's blue room could be the only
winner. Alice also has very good support from the
bloggers. So I'm mystified as to how Tim is scoring so many favorable votes, in excess of Alice and David. He is receiving minimal support from bloggers. Perhaps his fans have a way to use multiple websites at work, etc. There is obiously something wrong with the posted voting scores.
I hope that this will not be the way that viewers
will determine the final winner.

Posted by Eddie – August 22, 2006 2:43 AM

Clive,

Can't wait til next week. I think about this show all week. I loved the challenge that brought out each persons talent. I think it will be Alice or David who will win. Both are professional and really able to bring the design to life. Both would do excellent though I do favor Alice in her energy and accent. She is studious and really good.

Brenda

Posted by Brenda – August 22, 2006 2:18 AM

This episode was fantastic, epecially when Temple was put out to pasture. I thought her behavior in the previous episodes was terrible, especially her lack of respect for Donna. Good luck to Alice, Tym, and David.

Posted by Tiki – August 22, 2006 1:51 AM

First time on a blog, but here goes -- I can't add alot to what has been said. I agree with most comments. --- In spite of David's comments early on about his "good looks", I had him as a clear winner. Then Alice had a chance to shine.
I think they should co-host, or alternate episodes. Each of the two have what the other lacks. David's strength is in color, architecture, and art, but seems to be best with Contemporary or Zen style. Alice's strength seems to be fabrics, accessories, alternate uses for objects, and probably her charm and her dealing with co-workers and future clients. Her expertise would seem to be in Cottage living, Traditional or eclectic style...all of which are PROBABLY the styles of MOST of the DIY'ers and regular viewers. I have to agree with her comment about efficiencies/small spaces in the "South" (being a Southerner myself). Most are decorated in "Early Poverty/Early Marriage" style or by "Divorces-R-Us", with no money for a re-do.
I was surprised with comments about using more unique furniture or accessories, and less use of IKEA. They don't have the time or budget to shop for unique things. I can spend hours in a fabric store (and spend more money than I should) and if the IKEA stores are the size of Houston's, it still takes at least a half-day to shop and check out (but the least expensive). As with my other favorite design show, PROJECT RUNWAY (on Bravo), I am AMAZED at how much all of these designers can design, buy, and complete their projects with all of the time and money restraints! -- As for Temple, talented or not, I had enough of her comments about missing her children and being a beauty queen. (She managed to mention both on her way OUT the door!) She lost my vote when she said Tym misrepresented his talents (although he said repeatedly that he/they could not accomplish what she expected. And instead of thanking her hardworking carpenter, Temple was quick to lay blame about rug placement on having "no one but HER" to do things in the last minutes. --- I
will suffer WITHDRAWAL when Design Star has ended. I pray that it returns again, and again. But I still have all of the other great HGTV shows to watch in the meantime. (P.S. Clive, I think you are the PERFECT choice to host Design Star!) ----- Carol D.

Posted by Carol D. – August 22, 2006 1:31 AM

Hi Clive,
Love your show and Design Star. I agree that the last three contestants are the most talented ones of the group except maybe Joseph. Alice has been my favorite from the beginning and she seems to have the talent and maturity to be a Design Star. I won't say anything about Temple because I'm pretty sure almost everyone is glad the drama is finally over, except maybe her sister and friends who heated up the message boards daily.

Posted by Cindy – August 22, 2006 1:17 AM

This was the best episode yet. Temple wasn't distracted by Donna, and everyone had a chance to show their stuff.

I have to thank Roxana, another poster, for suggesting that all 3 of the remaining designers would make a great show together. I could see them as a Design on a Dime team; they seem to have compatible personalities and talents.

I think Temple was gun-shy this week after trying to do too much last week. Or maybe she just doesn't like yellow. She may have had the most functional design - I really liked her desk and breakfast bar - but overall the room never reflected the theme color. If I had walked in without any intro, I would have thought the theme was white or bamboo. The only place she let the yellow come out was on the bed pillows. I thought she could have added yellow to the kitchen hardware, and incorporated in the kitchen drape either with stripes or as a trim. Same for the rugs. The pale yellow she used through out was very washed out, and while the room was relaxing, it wasn't special and certainly not yellow.

I enjoyed Alice's room, and it certainly was soothing, but there is something missing. It needs some oomph, and may be that was a time thing. Her bookshelves also needed -BOOKS!!!! These are HER words - check her profile on this site.

Tym's room could have been just what he wanted, but the bed was a big problem. First of all, that SPREAD!!!!!! If I was striving to bring nature indoors, I would never use a color that nature never intended. At least on my TV, that vibrating green spread looked like a bad chemistry experiment. And that headboard, while minimalist, was also outside the theme. I would have picked something more organic.

I disagree with Vern about the placement of the bed in David's room. I think it belongs away from the window, so that it is easier to sleep - less light and noise from outside, very important in Manhattan. He was the only one who used large graphics on the walls, and while I wasn't crazy about what he painted, I thought this was missing in the other rooms. I think he might have been able to use furniture as dividers instead of walls, and that would have made the room less claustrophobic.

The only thing that could have improved this episode was interviews with the carpenters, discussing how organized or realistic the designers were. Otherwise, I really felt I had a much better idea of what these people could really do this week.

Posted by MC – August 22, 2006 1:02 AM

Love this show! Would love to see David and Alice co-host a show - they are the most talented and the most watchable. Temple's ego got the best of her, too bad. Clive, your wit livens up the night! Can't wait for Sunday night!

Posted by jinny brannon – August 22, 2006 12:36 AM

Finally this show is exciting. No more cat fights (It was getting old.). Now nothing but raw talent and creativity and professional carpenters to help them achieve their designs. For the past few weeks, I have gone back and forth between David and Alice, but this week I was disappointed in both of them. I kept saying to the television, :Come on Alice, show us your personality." This week she did and I found it irratating and squeaky. If she wins, they will really need to tone her voice down a bit. As for David, I love what he did with the color red, and I feel that the brown he chose went well with it; but, when I saw that brown wall, I felt trapped in that room. The wall was too high, too thick and closed off the wrong room. I like Tym, but I really didn't like what he did with his green color. Did not like Temple's room too much.

I always watch this show twice. First by myself (which I tape) and then another time with my husband. I mentioned to him how many comments there were about David's body and we agreed to watch the show and focus on David's body. But to be honest, we are interested in design and not other people's bodies, so most of the time we hardly noticed whether he had a shirt on or off.

Clive, how do you do it? How do you stand up in front on the designer's and with a deadpan face, say "You're show has been cancelled!"? How many takes does it take before it is the one that we see? You are fantastic and make a great host for this competition. Can't wait until next week.

Love your new commerical!

Posted by Julie – August 22, 2006 12:26 AM

I vote for David! I vote for Alice! A show with both of them would just be so awesome, or how about a format like Designed to Sell with David on the East Coast and Alice on the West. Would love to see how they would design in homes of each state but that may be too much.

David does great work and nothing wrong with him saying it. Alice is a sweetheart, inside and out, and also does great work. So, I'm going to have to vote for both of them. Can I do that?

Posted by Liz – August 21, 2006 11:44 PM

Great show! The judges really hit it this time. Alice is a little jewel. David's room looked good except for the wall partition, which really took away from the excitment of the red, in my humble opinion. Tym really surprised me. He was great on camera doing the room tour. He possesses the most showmanship of the group. --- And, I was ready to cast him aside! Imagine!

Posted by Fran – August 21, 2006 11:34 PM

I am glad that my TV wasn't the only one that didn't pick up the blue in Alice's room. It was more of a green for me.

I thought it was tacky of Temple to mention being a beauty queen when she was being interviewed outside the studio, (had to get it in one last time, didn't she?) I am so glad she is gone.

Tym has great ideas and needs to be polished more and he will do great in his future.

Alice showed appreciation for her carpenter and if given her own show, it will be a group effort and she will give credit where credit is due. Alice has the personality to carry a show.

I don't like the color red on a wall and didn't like the brown with the red or the design. I felt David showed a weakness this time.

I think Alice and David will be the final ones.

I'm jealous, Lisa LaPorter gets to work with Clive, what more of a dream job could a woman ask for?

Of course, who can forget Clive, the host with the most. I watch HGTV all the time and now I am hearing that I get to watch Clive 5 times a week. Have I died and gone to HGTV heaven?

Posted by Brenda – August 21, 2006 11:33 PM

This has become my favorite show each week! I usually don't make public remarks about T.V.shows, but since remarks were asked for, I will respond.

The voting has gone pretty much the way I would have voted. This week was exciting. I was ready to vote for David because I think he is so talented and would fit the part of a design star, however I was a bit disappointed in his room. It was a little disjointed with the room divider. Also he has been so overly confident throughout, that I was so surprised when that stage presence didn't come through. I am sure he was very nervous. I voted for Alice, whom I think has a lot of talent also. Her presentation was terrific! I wish them both luck along with Tym.
I have really missed Vern, so it has been so good to hear his comments.

Posted by Mary R. – August 21, 2006 11:07 PM

I absolutely loved last night's show! Alice was a star! I loved her choice of blue, and how she incorperated it into her design.
I was surprised by David's choice of space. Red is a favorite color of mine. It just seemed too heavy with the brown.
I llked Tym's room. It wasn't "special" though.

Posted by Teresa R. – August 21, 2006 11:05 PM

Clive you are so cute, and your personality shines. I can see why they picked you to do this show and others.

I have enjoyed all the episodes, thus far. But, I like it when each person works individually. It shows their ability more than when in a group project.

I felt this episode Alice definitely won hands down. I thought Temple's work wasn't bad, she has a true natural ability for design, but her attitude had to go.

Alice has charm, sweetness,and it shows on camera. I think David has good design ideas, but lacks something, maybe he just needs to work on his confidence level.

The other guy just needs to go, he cannot design a thing, sorry. Plus his attitude is not where it needs to be.

I know it has to be hard, I can remember taping my submission sent in, and it was a little nerve racking for me. But I love Interior Design, and creating new spaces.

I wish all the design finalist that are left, much luck.

But Alice would be my pick. Without a doubt.
She is different and she seems real.

Thanks WH

Posted by Wanda Hudgins – August 21, 2006 10:41 PM

Clive I am so glad you are on this show. You are good at hosting the HGTV shows they let you on, and I think (you) could probably host almost any of the HGTV shows. I still watch all of the Design to Sell show reruns over and over. The new Design "Star"! Well David where is Great? Haven't seen it yet , oh maybe with the Pet store room, yes that was as the judge said "Rock star effort". I really did expect more from David's use of the Red room, we just did are living room in our apt.- RED, the ole man picked the color. I was worried but now I love the way we used it. I wondered why no one put the bedroom separate like David did the living room. It would have been so much better to separate the bed than the couch. In an efficency apt.It could have looked like a better apt. with the bed behind the half wall and the couch out front where you first enter the apt. I think that is just common sence. Isn't it? Alice and Tym's rooms were very good, and like others have said, I would have had a hard time trying to pick a winner of those three. Temple was just so completely out of her league here. She can think of what a good room looks like, so can a lot of people, but, designer she is not. I am so glad that Vannessa is gone gone gone, she was not even a nice person. Did anyone else mind how totally irritating she was every week? She drove me nuts. Good luck to the three who are left, you are doing fine. I wouldn't want to do what you are all trying. Clive you keep up the good work too, it seems they like to have you around. Thanks for having this blog, it was great to write in. Sincerely, S. Bateson

Posted by Sandy Bateson – August 21, 2006 10:09 PM

I never watch any real time reality type shows....but this designer challenge is a clear cut above the rest. To see their native talent come through and how that is affected by each personality.

Temple really needs some medical help on listening to others and her cutting personality. Getting along with others is critical. Cring when she has backed herself into a corner gets very old very fast.

All the others seemed to have no problem working together without barbs. Those who remain now have that "touch" of style and will be a success even if they do not get their own show.

Just to be on the program is quite a feather in their caps.

Posted by Sandra Beene – August 21, 2006 10:08 PM

For someone that does not like reality shows I have been counting the days each week to the next show. I was disappointed that Temple's room was taken in the persepective that it was. Her room was the only one that I would have considered being stuck in for any length of time. While I have felt Alice and Tym were really good choices for designers, I think Tym needs to work with someone like Alice, I think his true talen with design is in building the design elements and letting someone dress them. (I absolutely abhorred that green bedspread, "ug-leee". The blue Alice chose would have worked in a smaller dose for me, but it was overdone. I would have liked to have seen them do a "real theme" -- yellow - makes me think of the sun, sunflowers, daisy's, Arizona, orange/yellow -- yellow/white/sage green -- they all used too much of their color on walls. I did not like David's room because of the choice for the enclosed wall, the dark color made the space there feel smaller and while I understood the concept behind it, I would have thought enclosing the kitchen area as Temple did with the curtain to have been a better choice for a wall. I was also perplexed that none of them (except Temple's curtain), utilized any type of material (plants, wicker, bamboo, lattice, or a screened frame (painting the screen) or papered screen) to divide the areas. As far as an upstyle design for New York, I believe Temple's and Alice's stood out more, Tym's idea was good, his bedspread though just killed it for me, as did the enclosed wall color in David's room. As far as artwork, I was not impressed with David's artwork, it was very bland, the artwork design actually made the space look smaller -- a better choice would have been an elongated or triangular design to give an impression of depth instead of drawing it into the center.

I was not impressed with the use of the carpenter - hello, they are not "painters", they are builders... hopefully Tym will show his true style this coming week and Alice will continue to have good designs (& hopefully stay away from the blue). David is my least favorite in this although I did like the fish bowls, very creative and unique, but that's the only time I saw him doing anything that really impressed me. I was also surprised that no one except Alice gave credit to their carpenters, shame on all of you for that, if they hadn't been doing the painting and clearing none of you would have finished!!! One more note, all of them need to give "clear directions and "more direction" when providing their instructions, David was the worst at that!

Posted by Bre – August 21, 2006 10:02 PM

Hi Clive,

YOU are doing a great job with this show. You have such a pleasant and positive attitude, even when you are delivering barbs! You have been very nice and professional with all the contestants and very professional.

Please consider this idea: Most of us really like the remaining three candidates and they are all very talented with their unique strengths and perspectives. Can't we just keep the remaining three? Think of the variety of programming that could be done: Rotate them. Each one would have their own show each week of a month; Tym one week, Alice the next, David the third week of a month. Then, on the final show of the month, give them all an identical project and show us what each of them did with it. As innovative as your DesignStar show has been, you could top it off with innovative design in TV programming.

What do the rest of you think? Would you watch every week to see what the others are doing?

This program has been fun and the bog is the icing!

Posted by Trish – August 21, 2006 9:53 PM

David is by far the best... and the only one of the last three I would look forward to tuning in to see.

Posted by CA – August 21, 2006 9:50 PM

Clive, I do love the way you don't dwell on the negative and stay so upbeat. During the first episode, I was seriously disappointed in all the backbiting and contentiousness (can you tell I don't really like 'reality' shows?) but I kept watching for the before-and-after designs that I tune in to HGTV for.

I really liked Joseph and Alice from day one, and was sad to see Joseph take the fall for Vanessa.

Now that its down to the final three, I'm looking foward to seeing more design and less angst. Oh, and less of David's tattoo, as well. What a turnoff! That is something I would never want to see in my livingroom.

Any show that Alice is on, either as designer or as host, is one that I'll definitely watch. She exhibits true class in her actions and designs. I think I could take smaller doses of Tym and David as well, but only if they keep their shirts on and their egos in check.

Will you be explaining what TYPE of design show is planned for the winner? I hope it is not one that surprises the clients with a 'reveal' or races the clock with artificial time constraints. Real designers don't work like that. It is time for HGTV to get serious about design again.

I do like Design to Sell and Re-Mix because they help homeowners re-think what they have and use time and resources to their best advantage. Great hosting, too! (Ditto on your new fun advertisement!)

Posted by Staci – August 21, 2006 9:38 PM

To the Entire Team at "Design Star" -- Absolutely LOVE the show idea. I've watched it every week and sometimes a rerun during the week. My only criticism is that there's way too much drama allowed to play itself out. We want to see good, inspiring design -- not a soap opera. That's NOT something I'd want to tune in to every week on HGTV; you're better than that.

There should be higher standards clearly established and the contestants should be held accountable to those boundaries. Please don't allow such a great idea to turn into a circus act.

Personnaly, I've seen DAVID as the clear favorite from the very first episode. I think with a little coaching he can be taught how to slow his delivery for his audience. The overall appeal he exudes cannot be taught -- one either has it or they don't! He's got the "IT" that it takes to captivate viewers week after week.

Posted by Karen – August 21, 2006 9:32 PM

I love this show. Designed to Sell is my absolute favorite, but this one is a close second. The first time I saw the group before any designing had begun, I picked out David as the one who has the "look." He has shown that he is also very talented. I took like Alice a lot and think they would be great co-hosts. I'd definitely watch that show. I really enjoy you Clive on Designed to Sell but like that more of your personality and humor get to come out on Design Star. There's a little bite in that niceness and it's fun to see. Thank you.

Posted by Priscilla – August 21, 2006 8:55 PM

I think the wrong person went home this time, Vern said it he appreciated it more after Tym's explanation, BUT a good design is like a good joke - if it needs explaining you've already lost your audience... Tym's lost me a few times... Temple's room had alot more substance to it even if it was "bland"

David does dramatic very well, Alice does quirky but livable design... it's apples vs oranges now...

Posted by Sam – August 21, 2006 8:55 PM

I won't mourn the loss of Temple, but I actually thought her studio turned out the best. David's was great except for that awful half wall, closing in the sofa area. Vern was right, if he was going to partition something, it should have been the bed area. I thought Tym's studio was a green nightmare and I can't believe he wasn't cancelled. I like him but I don't think he's a design star. Alice is great, even though I cringed at her Tiffany Blue selection.

Posted by Mike – August 21, 2006 8:36 PM

Great show, keeps me coming back every Sunday and watching the rerun during the week. Alice's design fit my personality -- but was impressed with how David uses color. Temple although tries very hard her personality and lack of experience hindered her the whole time. I think Tym's presentation was super but he has a hard time portraying what he sees in his head. Can't wait to see what happens next week.
Clive you are stupendous and the judges are all great and everyone of them are willing to tell it like they see it.

Posted by Judy – August 21, 2006 8:32 PM

Although I'm dying to read everyone else's comments, I have to put in my own two cents without being swayed by others.

THEN I'll read. I can't believe it's only the day after the show aired and there's already over 200 comments!

When this show ended Sunday night, I wanted to shout "At last!!!"

This is what I have been waiting for. This is why I started watching it in the first place. No more fighting, just pure design.

I thought Alice nailed it in every way - colors, arrangement, and hosting abilities. I really loved the way her room flowed in it's traffic pattern.

David's room was good. The main thing I didn't like was the military precision of the red elements. It was too "graphic arts" in feeling for me. I don't find that relaxing.

Temple's room was also good, but her traffic flow didn't flow as well as Alice's.

Tym's room. I just hate to say I didn't like his room, because I love his personality. It was too spartan and the shade of green on the bed didn't sit well with the green on the walls. I did like the way he painted his kitchen cabinets green though - that was inspired.

At the end of the show, I agreed with placing Alice and David ahead of the others, but I didn't understand the criteria used to decide between Temple and Tym.

Although I didn't like Temple's personality, I think she was more of an eye for design than Tym does. I think she should pursue the field.

Tym is innovative, but doesn't seem to have the greatest visual sense.

Can't wait for next week.

Oh, and Clive? I saw Lisa on Designed To Sell last night and her hair looks fab!!! In fact, she looked the best I've ever seen all around. Let her know, please.

;)

Posted by Lori – August 21, 2006 8:30 PM

My vote for the best "color" on Episode 5 was for David, and then Alice. We were happy to see Temple go!!! It seems that everyone was putting the blame on Donna for the friction between her and Temple, but it looks like Temple had her stinger out for Donna from the get-go.

Posted by Atha Martin – August 21, 2006 8:24 PM

Boy, that was quite different than I expected.
If Tym hadn't presented so well on camera, it would have been good riddance. His room was so . .. green! Temple blew it big time too though. Expecting her to be a good on camera host, but she wasn't. She also didn't live up to previous design performances. Alice, well, Alice - can we see a different room - just once? It was nice, but nothing I couldn't do myself. No special inspiration. David as usual was very punchy and fun. I think the judges are just getting used to expecting flash from him. They are also too used the the Frank Lloyd Wright great room - obviously. I always split my livingroom off from my work and sleep areas. David my have better used screens, but the lower wall kept the space from feeling divided. But, at least you can sit and watch a show without watching your dishes!

Looking forward to next week. Wish we could have a couple weeks of the final three to see them in different challenges. This weeks would have been a great one for the twins I think - much more freedom.

Posted by Ann – August 21, 2006 8:22 PM

What a great show. Glad to see Temple go finally. I think this next week will be the tale of the tape.....on thier own and totally dependent on themselves. Since David is a "one man show", my vote goes for him for the next show winner. Go David !!!!

Posted by Dean – August 21, 2006 6:36 PM

Just one more thing: the designers really should get more time to work. Even Lisa has more than two days!

Posted by ChiChi – August 21, 2006 6:30 PM

OMG!! I am totally hooked on design star- HGTV, you are amazing! I really think Tym should have gone...his room felt so COLD!(despite it being green)that bedspread was horrible-totally stopped your observational flow. David and Alice were FANTASTIC as always! ;-) I honestly can't decide between the two who should be the next Design Star!

Posted by ChiChi – August 21, 2006 6:28 PM

I have been reading the comments and agree that it would be great to have both David and Alice share the top honors. I am assuming that the Design Star will have a weekly show. It might be nice if they alternated the lead some weeks. For other shows, they could team like the Design on a Dime teams do. There are so many things you could do with two stars. Since these are basically new designers (at least for television), a weekly show might be too much for one to handle.

I am really looking forward to next week's show. I will hate to wait until mid-September for the final show.

Patricia

Posted by Patricia – August 21, 2006 6:25 PM

Clive, I LOVED your newest commercial. Having that teenage girl slam the door in your face is just hilarious! I am torn between David and Alice. I can hardly stand the wait for the next episode. Any hope HGTV will have a season two?

Posted by Dana – August 21, 2006 5:39 PM

Alice has everthing a Design Star needs. She has all the talent and skills in addition to her awesome personality and warmth. If I were in a position to hire a designer it would be her. She has the temperament for the job and is the type to work with someone, not condescending or know-it-all. I hope she wins. This girl from Texas will sure be watching !

Posted by Judy – August 21, 2006 5:34 PM

This show is driving me nuts! I have had trouble sleeping every Sunday night since it started. I just lay there and think - this is so fun, what would I have done differently? Last night I made the mistake of getting out of bed and going downstairs in the middle of the night only to catch the re-run of last night's episode. I am so frustrated I am thinking about challenging my husband to some sort of design contest!

Posted by Suzanne – August 21, 2006 5:23 PM

I loved this particular episode because there was such a nice, adult camaraderie among the remaining designers. I guess the bickering was turning me off more than I realized. I think the judges made the correct choice, and I really can't decide which of the remaining three I like best!

(Was Temple really barefoot during her presentation?)

Posted by LA – August 21, 2006 5:12 PM

I am so glad temperamental Temple is GONE! I was disappointed with Tym's design and felt the judges hit it right on. Alice's was nice but somewhat bland. I just loved David's room. His treatment of the color red was masterful. It would have been so easy to over-do it but his approach was dead on. I look forward to seeing David as the next "Design Star" ! ! !

Posted by GiGi – August 21, 2006 5:06 PM

Clive. You crack me up. You're like David Niven, only a little funnier and a little cuter. ;-)

This episode was quite the white-knuckle ride. The ones who are still left standing truly deserve to be there. I was extremely impressed by Tym's hosting. Except for the bed area, his room was really quite nice. And Alice and David were their usual excellent selves.

- Frances

Posted by Frances – August 21, 2006 5:05 PM

This competition was a real tough one to judge, as I don't feel that any of the competitors really nailed it:

David - Whassup w/ that wall??? Everything else was fab (did anyone else notice the Red Fire extinguisher hanging on the wall by the kitchen - Clever!) but please, please point these things out to us? If the layout didn't work for the cameraman, it's not gonna work for a viewer.

Tym - Ever see a guy wearing green pants and a green shirt? It NEVER works! Easily the least comfortable space.

Temple - Yawn.

Alice - I know you SAY "Tiffany Blue", but that color was reading as "Caribbean Teal" on screen - Ugh. And you Said "Light and Gauzy", but where's the gauze? I was expecting massive billowing fabric panels separating the sleeping & kitchen areas...

In use of color: David wins.
In use of space: Temple wins.
In use of the camera: Alice wins.
In use of adjectives: Tym wins.

Nobody wins on space planning - Nothing innovative here at all. If you're gonna build a wall, why not separate the alcove from the kitchen and make that into a sleeping-pod? How about getting a couple of twin beds arranged in an L w/ lots of pillows to make a Lounge-y sectional sofa/guest sleeping area?

And what's up w/ the overuse of IKEA on these shows? To paraphrase one of the judges: If I see one more of those tired plain white IKEA Klippan sofas I'm gonna scream!!! (or at least get a Red Leather one, DAVID) Can't they ever source a few pieces from West Elm or even some groovy/unique/repurposed things from Craigslist? They clearly had enough of a budget - I don't think any of them used their entire budget.

Clive--

Love your shows & enjoyed meeting you in Palm Springs a couple X-mases ago Keep up the good work and give Lisa a hug for us!

Posted by BEP – August 21, 2006 4:56 PM

I really enjoyed this week's show. Having each designer take on a studio apartment is a good test of skills. I agree with others who have written that having a bed double as a couch is a bad idea (especially a big bed), and I also agree that the bed should be enclosed instead of the living area. Who wants to see a bed when they walk into a main living area? I was surprised that screens weren't an option. Having the contestants "host" the walk-through was an excellent idea. After all, someone will be hosting his/her own show, so let's see what each can do. Although I have never liked Temple, she did exit the show gracefully, so went out on a positive note. I have always thought Alice was sort of bland, so her presentation was a welcome surprise. I'm glad she told us the name of her blue color, because it looked more green to me! I have always liked Tym because he seems down to earth and likable. His presentation was good. I did think David did the best job on the room, but that's just my personal taste. I wish that all three of the remaining contestants could have their own shows or be on a show. Depending on what you have in mind for the winner, each has his/her own strengths and would be a good addition to HGTV.

Posted by Louise – August 21, 2006 4:17 PM

OMG! this episode was awesome!! i am totally siked for the next episode. i personally think that tym will be the next designer who clive has to say "youre show has been cancelled".
i LOVED alices design! at first i thought the blue had a bit too much green, but with all the accents, it looked really good. i am in for alice to win. at first it was because of her carefree design, but after watching her present in front of the camera, i think she has what it takes! cant wait till the next show!!!!

Posted by leo – August 21, 2006 4:01 PM

This is the first time I have ever written to any blog or chat room of any kind so I must be a FAN of this show. I am very pleased to see that my choise from the first episode is in the top three. I believe that Alice has the talent, the looks, the integrity and the genuineness to be the first "Design Star". I was particulary impressed with her integrity when told Joseph that the team whould stand or fall together which Vanessa agreed with until it was time to fall. When Alice called her on the agreement and Vanessa said "whatever" I completely lost any respect I might have had for her. I am puzzled by the comments that people are just jealous of Temple's beauty as I find Alice just as beautiful just not as aware of it and certainly not as affected by it. Her personality and respect for others really showed this episode when she not only was the only one to mention her carpenter but gave him great cudoo's for being so important to her success.
Anyone who takes the time to look at the audition tapes has to wonder if Temple was using her "believed" sex appeal to be somewhere she shouldn't have been. While I think she has some raw talent she needs training to sharpen her skills and finishing school to remind her that the world is not a beauty pageant alone. I also believe that she needs to learn to deal with others in a grown up manner instead of saying things like "you need to grow up" to settle a conflict.
I believe Alice has the poise, talent and beauty to handle a design show of her own and I certainly will be voting for her if I get the chance.

Posted by Dea – August 21, 2006 3:25 PM

Clive -

What a show! I was on the edge of my seat the entire hour. My heart can't take much more of this suspense. I love the show, I love you and I am impressed with the designers and their individual styles.

All that being said, how on earth can I choose between Alice and David? I agree with others that they would be dynamic and fun together. Can HGTV "think outside the box" and give them a show together? I know we are out for a "design star" and not two, but these two people compliment each other in some special ways. I also think the relationship between them would be dynamic - sort of like 2 good friends having a blast doing what they do so well. I would watch that show every week!

I am glad that carpenters were provided this week - but did anyone else notice that they were not of the "stud muffin" quality that appears on Design to Sell?

I really like Tym but have some compassion for him in this competition. He is a perfectionist and I think that the unrealistic time constraints are taking up his energy and he can't let his creativity surface. Only makes you wonder what he could do with a regular schedule. I do believe he will be gone next week, but it makes me sad. So I am now back to the original thought - how can I choose between David and Alice? I can't - so I just hope for a tie and then HGTV will have to give them both a show! That would be a perfect world, Clive. Be a good chap and pass it along, please!

Posted by Barb – August 21, 2006 3:15 PM

I loved last night's show - such drama. I was on tenterhooks the whole time. I agree with the judges that Temple's design was the least creative. I also disliked her presentation - she actually said "or whatever" at one point.
Alice's room was the best and I'm rooting for her to be Design Star. She has the personality, talent and professionalism and would fit right in at HGTV.
Tym's room did nothing for me and I agree that his ideas do not translate visually. A room with a nature theme should have been much softer and less "steely" in my opinion.
David is obviously very talented but I'm starting to find his designs predictable. I'm glad he kept his shirt on this week.
One final comment - I was a tad disappointed to see the literal interpretation of the colour that each design projected. I'm no designer but just from watching HGTV I understand that using colour doesn't have to mean just painting the walls and choosing matching accents. What about the feeling of the colour? Blue, for instance, reminds me of the sea, the sky even the beach. So maybe with a blue theme I would have gone for a summer beach cottage design, incorporating the colours of sand, white clouds, sea foam and of course blue water. The blue could have been used with other colours and textures as a running theme to unify the space. Perhaps even a large blue piece of artwork could have been a focal point. I thought the designers were too "safe" with their interpretations - I would have liked to have seen someone be innovative and take a risk.

Posted by Dana – August 21, 2006 3:13 PM

This is such a great show! Love to see it every new season! Although, there's just one thing -- I really wish Design Star directors would spend more time showing us the actual room space before and the designs afterward. As Elvis would say, "a little less talk and a little more action."

And now some advice from someone who couldn't put a room together if she had a million dollars and an exact photograph to duplicate(!!):

David - a) Find a way to deal with your nerves and you'll do well hosting, and b) stretch your artistic abilities as far as you KNOW they'll go;

Tym: Less isn't ALWAYS more (YOU may like minimalist, but I don't see it winning this competition);

And -

Alice: Three words - BOLD BOLD BOLD!!

IN OTHER WORDS, DESIGN STARS - THROW CAUTION TO THE WIND!! THERE IS NO OTHER COMPETITION -- THIS IS THE COMPETITION!!

Posted by Kathy – August 21, 2006 3:09 PM

I loved the show last night and was on pins and needles. Temple's room had no real color. She should have mixed it up a bit, using oranges or greens as accents or anything but white and yellow. Although she does not have what it takes to be the Design Star, I have no doubt she will soon start her own design business where she lives. Tym's room was good, although too much green and I did get it; he had the branches or long stems in cointainers as accents, bringinh the eye up and looking around. His Host ability was what saved him and it was good. David should have eliminated the one wall and just left the one at the end of the bed so the "relaxing area" was not so small and one could not watch tv in bed, but his sense of color is outstanding. Nervous on the presentation, but he defenitely has the minimalistic clean lines style that Vern likes. Alice was great. The choice to leave the doors off the upper cabinet gives one a chance to show off good dishes or anything else. I loved the color choice, but not the bed spread; too busy. Her presentation was fresh and came across as someone that honestly knows their stuff and how to put it together. I loved it when they announced she had won! She was and is so honest in her attitude and responses. She even jumped a bit! I think she would go far and has come far in this show already. Its too bad it cannot be a "Design Team" of 2. Cannot wait until next week, but the person that has to venture into unknown territory for shopping, etc, and whoever loses the carpenter is in deep trouble.
I want them all to win, but if it comes to one, Alice is my choice.
Although, Clive could win on character alone. I love his sense of humor!

Posted by Adrianna – August 21, 2006 2:55 PM

Down to the final 3! I think from the overall group, the right 3 are still in. I still think David has the "lead" right now. His designs have been exciting and colorful. However, I didn't like how the bedroom was open, and the living room closed. I feel it should've been reversed, but I loved his color scheme. Alice also continues to come up with bright colorful ideas and as this episode showed us, she really seems comfortable in front of the camera. I liked Tym's idea, but his room didn't seem real comfortable. His chairs kind of seemed like they wouldn't be fun to sit on for too long, and his room was a little minimilistic. I agree with the judges that his room was lacking something. He has great ideas and can explain them well, but in my opinion, you shouldn't have to explain too much. The room should be able to speak for itself.
I really liked the idea another blogger put out about having David and Alice on a show together, create their own designs for a space and have people vote on which they liked best. Both of those two are my favorites and I'll hate to have one of them lose. I would choose David first though, just because he keeps taking his shirt off. I would watch a show hosted by any one of these 3. Looking forward to the finish!

Posted by Collin – August 21, 2006 2:51 PM

I like David's ideas all the time. Every time he has something new. Alice is ok. I know from the begining that it will be Alice and David. But winner should be David.

Posted by Saba – August 21, 2006 2:50 PM

Clive,
I loved this show the best. I am sooooo glad Temple is gone. One of the things a host needs to do is to get along and work with other people and be realistic as to what can be accomplished. She is a prom queen/diva and should have been let go a long time ago. I could care less about her winning a beauty contest. When I hear a blonde joke I think of her. Her room looked like a room for a 6 yr old girl. Perhaps instead of yellow she should have opted for gold to give the room some class. The best thing about Tym's room was the kitchen but the rest was a hodge podge and the bed a nightmare. Do you think you could tell him he's not 16 anymore and get a haircut? David was his usual awesome self but I too found that his design was backwards and perhaps a credenza separating the living/bedroom areas with the TV on top would have been better. Or a curtain. He has great ideas and budgets his time well. Alice's room was primo and I could definately see living there. It was inviting, classy and roomy. She did a fantastic job. I think it will be ultimately come down to Alice and David. Alice reminds me of Laurie of Trading Spaces and David more of Doug Wilson. Both are great but have different styles. Why don't you have Lisa LaPorta make a special guest appearance when you check up on the designers in the future? Would be interesting to see what she thinks. I think your hosting is great but wonder why you do a Regis Philbin impersonation when you are letting someone go. I am expecting you to say: Is that your final answer to the judges sometimes! This is a great series and I hope it is NOT a one time deal. Sure beats watching the other reality shows where you have diva brides, ladies cleaning up a slob's home or people eating worms or jumping off cliffs. Keep up the good work. Many thanks to you, the numerous behind the scenes staff and your sponsors for making it possible.

Posted by Dave – August 21, 2006 2:48 PM

I have to admit that I've just gotten hooked on watching the competition because the previews with all that contention just totally turned me off -- and I am a real HGTV junkie!!! I did like Alice's room the best by far. Did not like the partition in David's at all - too small for that. Wasn't impressed with way he left his "helper" without enough work -- needed to use time better. As for Tym's, his greens clashed and weren't what I'd call outdoors -- ugly bedspread! As I said, I watch many, many hours of HGTV (repeats included) and I think Alice could make a good moderator.

Posted by Diane – August 21, 2006 2:40 PM

All the final four had their strengths.
Temple had great design style, but lacked in practical knowledge of how long things would take to do. She also had trouble taking advice and working with other colaborately. The Kitchen show was a prime example.But I think she would do well working for herself in the design field.
Tim's designs were hit or miss for me, but I admire his knowledge of building and time management:good old common sense.
Alice is sweet and has nice design style, but she never stood out to me.I don't remember any of her work.
I loved David's consistently good work.I always seem to remember something he has design from one week to the next. And I always look forward to see what he does next.
I think either David or Alice could be groomed into a wonderful Design Star.

Posted by michele – August 21, 2006 2:36 PM

Wow. Fun episdode. Sorry to see Temple go, only in that it was fun to see what someone with zero experience would do in those situations. Her work this week was okay. The problem that the professionals had with her work, and as a designer myself also had, is that her work looked like a room put together by someone with nice enough taste, but no skill. Anyone could have done what she did by going to a local home decor store. It was nice if you're doing your own apartment, but nothing a client would want. And the rugs on an angle.. ugh. The angled furniture and rugs thing screams amateur. On the practical side, her seating and furniture layout choices were bad. Temple is pretty, and has obviously spent $$ on her appearance, but her tv personna was unimpressive.

Tim's place. Loved his use of blue areas with the green paint. His miscalculation was the bedding. I understand what he was going for, but the color just fought with everything else. A bit too cold for my taste. His presentation was good, and much better than the room, actually. Having a TV personality is very important as.. well.. this is TV.

David. Loved his use of color. I loved the brown and red together. When I saw him putting the living room into the cubicle I wanted to reach into the tv and smack him before it was too late ;). I think most of us agree that was a miscalculation. He could have created a great open/great room space around the eating area.. putting the tv where he had the couch.. and then used some type of divider.. shoji panels perhaps?.. to make the bed more private. Gorgeous design, other than that. I like his personality.. but why does he take his shirt off all the time?

Alice. She has always been my favorite in this. She's stayed out of the catfights, and stayed on task. Her work is similar to my tastes. I loved her apartment this week. The Tiffany box idea was great, and nicely done. Her work is very clean and sophisticated. She seems to understand, more than any other conestant, what a real design job is. It's about getting along with everyone.. contractors, clients, co-workers, everyone. You are only as good as the people you surround yourself with. If you treat them badly, your design will suffer, and so will your clients. She's level headed. I think that it would be great to see a show with Alice and David togther. Can there be a co-winner thing?

BTW, if I was given the color theme, I would have used a nice neutral on the walls, and used the color as wonderful accents. but that's just me.. ;)

Posted by Diana – August 21, 2006 2:28 PM

Joel Daggert wrote:... I've had a feeling that it would come down to David and Alice in the end. It will be hard to choose--I really like them both. Maybe the runner up could get a spot working with a team (like Design on a Dime). Just a suggestion...

Can I support that idea I think David's very bold and masculine designs would be well set off by Alice's soft touches

Q

Posted by Q – August 21, 2006 2:27 PM

I really enjoyed this last episode Clive. I think it showed the Designers at their best. I also think like the theme store show that it gave you a better chance to banter with them and I very much enjoyed watching that. You have such a poker face - I don't know how you didn't burst out laughing at Alice's expressiona and big gulp when you told her that there was a twist and still managed to hold it together and not laugh at her trepidation/relief that all she had to do was give a walk through and not something worse. I think she was afraid you were going to take away her carpenter.

Which reminds me - thank goodness they had professional help for a change. I think it was interesting to note that Alice and David were both grateful for the help. Tym was as well but Temple hardly said anything about him

I love David's room. So practical and functional. Very masculine (which is to be expected) though perhaps a bit claustrophobic in the living area. He was the only one who understands people watch TV far more often then they have parties and a guests over. His TV was the only one in a reasonable watching zone. I like Alice's Design next best very pretty. I agree with Judge's Temple's Design was very washed out and have you ever tried to use a bed as a couch? Unless it is a Twin which this was either a double or queen - it is very uncomfortable and difficult to get in and out of easily. But Tym - he may be innovative but why do all his designs look so very uncomfortable? Folding chairs - ick ickity ick His design was so uncomforatble feeling and stark.

I must say I HATE! HATE! HATE! white furniture and rugs. They are so hard to live with - one drop of soda or heaven forbid Wine and the item looks like crud. Do any of these high falutin' designers live in the real world. And I am not just talking about the Design Star wannabes. At least Lisa Laporter doesn't stick her families with white couches and chairs (well at least not too often)

Q

Posted by Q – August 21, 2006 2:20 PM

I love your show. Each week I come away with more exciting ideas. I wish each participant could do a room in my house. They are ALL wonderful. I agree with most of the bloggers that it will be between David and Alice. Alice has my heart, but David runs with my head. They are both Awesome. I would have complete confidence with either of them totally decorating my home as well as yard. I truly could not choose. The judges have a huge task ahead of them. Keep you heads held high Alice and David. I am as proud of both of you as if you where my own children. You both have talent and class!!!!!

Posted by Pamela – August 21, 2006 2:18 PM

Alice - you just proved my point that you're the one! Your design was simple, sophisticated and livable! And you made it look so easy! The presentation came off as if you were inviting me into your own home - very nice. I loved the room even though I absolutely hate tiffany blue.

David - loved your design and the way you used red as accents rather than overall color. However, have you ever lived in a studio? That wall took up too much of the room and actually put too much focus on the bed. In a small space, you need to be able to use ALL of the space, but the bed shouldn't be the focal point.

Tym - what happened? I loved the idea you presented, but your design was way off! Your color values clashed and made the room look choppy. I didn't get any sense of the outdoors, I got institutional drab. so disappointed.

I am soooo glad to see Temple go! Her abrasive personality & manipulative ways have driven me crazy from day one. Unfortunately, I actually liked her room better than Tym's this week. Bland is better than uncoordinated.

Posted by KC – August 21, 2006 2:16 PM

Just a few comments. I have been very disturbed by so many of the contestants and their in fighting and back biting. I have to say David is the only one I think stood up and did whatever he was assigned to do without attempting to overrun anyone else. He is also an impressive designer with an excellent grasp on his use of color.

I think Alice is the cute, sweet, innocent (except behind your back) little southern gal. Her room this episode was interesing. I am not a big fan of the blue she chose and would have gone with a bit less, however it seemed to impress others and I agree she did well.

Tym is a strong individual who wants to push his ideas. I really did not like his use of the green in this episode but thought his idea was a good one. He just didn't pull it off. He has been so intense in each episode that we do not have a true grasp of his personality. I wonder what lurks beneath the surface?

I hated to see Temple go because she has shown her true talent, inspite of having to work with others who were negative and disruptive. Her grasp of design seemed to be firm until this episode. I don't know what happened but her use of yellow was very disappointing. Maybe she really was homesick for her children and just not as into it however it was a real let down.

I am sure she will do well in her future if she chooses to continue with design.

As for the judges, Vern is the one designer I would feel comfortable in giving complete freedom to design my home. He is incredible and well able to articulate exceptional design. I was so disappointed when he left Trading Spaces, so it was wonderful to catch him on Design Star.

I love the show but would have watched it, even if I hated it. Just for Vern.

As for you Clive, I love listening to you talk. You do a great job. You and Lisa LaPorta make a great team.

Posted by Joyce – August 21, 2006 2:11 PM

I can't belive it took so long to get rid of Donna! But at least you got rid of Vanessa. Tym may think out of the box but he has yet to put together anything interesting in my book. For some reason everyone was down on Temple, who was very talented and just happened to also be a past beauty gueen (so they held that against her)? If this is the best we've got for design talent in this country were in trouble. Not that there is anything wrong with Alice and David, I'm just not sure they are STAR material.

Posted by Karen – August 21, 2006 2:07 PM

Hello Clive,
Good job! I thought this episode was nicely done. I loved that they had to present thier room to the camera! Alice is really standing out. I loved how she used brown, black and white accents with her tiffany blue color scheme. And her presentation was well done. She seems very "real". I really liked David's use of the red, limiting it's use on the walls and bringing it in with accessories, pillows and artwork (although I do not understand why he lined up the red glasses on the counter and turned a bowl over on top of another bowl). The cubicle was a bit crowded and although I like David's artwork it was a little to reminiscent of his artwork in episode one and again in three (I think); it could get a little tiresome if he continues to do the same type of art every time.
Tym's green was OK but a bit much to do the cabinets in the same color. The green bedspread was terrible (too joltingly bright), it did not seem to fit in and I thought the navy blue rug was out of place. If he was trying to do a nature theme I wonder why he did not use some brown and off white tones along with the green. So glad Temple is gone. I am sure her kids must have missed her more than we will.

Posted by Connie – August 21, 2006 2:03 PM

Oh WOW!! What an exciting episode!! I cannot express how glad I am that Temple is GONE!!! The last remaining three are all good in there own ways, but I think that David has hit the nail on the head in this challange. Alice's room was pretty and serene, but I don't think that I liked the Tiffany Box Blue that she chose. Tym's design was okay, he lay out wasn't very good, but he did okay. I cannot figure out that green bedspread. Yuck. Temple's room was alright, but more than a little bland and I don't think that I could of put up with her attitude one more week. David's room was AWESOME, but I do agree that the bedroom should of been the secluded area, not the living space. Alice and Tym spoke on camera better than David, but we all need practice with some things. Clive, you rock as the host of this show, without you there would be no Design Star. :) Best wishes to all the contestants, but I'm rootin' for David!!!

Posted by Kirsten – August 21, 2006 2:00 PM

Personally I wasn't overly excited about any of the rooms. I thought that they were nice...but none of them really wowed me this week. They each had good components to them but the finished rooms seemed to be lacking something.

I am a big fan of the show and agree with many of you that the 3 best are left. Would love to see what they could do with a little more time and $$ a la Kenneth Brown or Candice Olsen.

Posted by Laura – August 21, 2006 1:59 PM

Wonderful show!! Alice did a great job and I hope she is the next DESIGN STAR. She has it all ...the talent, personality, team work, and attitude to have her own show. David has lots of talent, but not the tv presents and variety of design to win.

Posted by Marcy – August 21, 2006 1:48 PM

David is my favorite, although I was not fully inpired with the half wall between the bedroom & office space. He needs to be careful with those types of design at this stage. I will be surprised if Tym moves on and Temple is just
ok with me.

Posted by Ronna – August 21, 2006 1:47 PM

I wish that we could have 2 winners who would co-host the show. Alice and Tym would make a great team. They are both realists and appreciate the amount of work it takes to execute the design. I think they would complement each other well during the presentations. While I love David and his talent, I don't know if he can carry a long-term show.

Posted by jada – August 21, 2006 1:46 PM

It was a pleasure to see the contestants be
positive with one another, for the most part. As
I recall, however, David was not pleasant with
Temple when they were working at their
design boards. I believe that he said something about her being at the bottom of the class. Thank goodness that Alice quickly diffused a situation that could have become unpleasant.
This skill cannot be taught, but will be very important in creating a future television program.
I agree that Temple's work was not outstanding, but Tym's selections bordered on the
jarring and, as the judges noted, would seem like
a penalty.
David had an advantage, in that he lives in
a studio apartment, himself. That makes it more
difficult to understand his choice to CONFINE
the "living room" section, LIMITING ability to
expand it when company arrives. It would make
more sense to have increased the privacy in the
"bedroom" area.
In the end, Alice was clearly the winner!
Her choices were easy on the eyes and would be
easy to live with, for a client. She increased
storage, which is very necessary for New Yorkers.
Her room did have the feeling of a light and
breezy refuge, so important in New York or in any large, urban location. It was cheerful, but serene. Standing the test of time is more important than creating a quick, dramatic impact that the client will quickly find confining or
tiring. She was the unequivocal leader in hosting skills, as well; the camera just loves her and she is very, very pleasant. Her personality is one that people would want to invite into their homes.

Posted by Sara – August 21, 2006 1:37 PM

I can't believe they let Tym stay over Temple! I did not like his room this week at all. Would absolutely not want to live in that space. Temple's room was soft, warm, clean, and inviting. She actually put thought into some of her space-saving ideas since this was a small studio apt. I just don't get what Tym was trying to do, even after his explanation.
I think most people are too hard on Temple because she is pretty. It is very hard for a beautiful woman to be taken seriously and professionally, especially by egotistical men and jealous women. They make it look like she cannot lead a group, when in fact it is the group that cannot take orders. Temple, if you end up reading this, I feel for you and have liked all your ideas and spaces. Keep going and learning as much as you can because even though you have a good eye for creating a nice space, I think you could do even better by learning to be a little more creative. I bet your own house is beautiful!

Posted by Cheryl – August 21, 2006 1:33 PM

It comes down to David & Alice...Tym's rooms seem to always require "explanations" while David's & Alice's rooms speak for themselves. David was a little nervous with his presentation, but once he has a show he'll be completely scripted and won't be fumbling for words. I like Alice's designs well enough, but I think David's designs push the envelope and show the most creativity (as did Vern Yip's when he was on TS). Can't say that I'm disappointed by the departure of Temple the dreckorator. Her work was consistently mediocre and it would have been a shame if HGTV allowed her to continue just for the "drama" her "character" provided to the show. Thanks, Clive, for not allowing the producers to turn this show into a personality contest as other reality shows about design have done.

Posted by Greg – August 21, 2006 1:24 PM

I am a huge fan of HGTV and a retired designer. My assessment thus far isas follows: Tym-creative but can't pull it together to produce a comprehensive and well-integrated space.Alice -lovely and a competent designer but lacks the creativity that gives a room that extra punch.David -hugely talented.His use of color is wonderful-combining red with brown and pink is very creative and something everyone can learn from.Also his bundling of sticks (or branches)on the wall of his bedroom to create a kind of sculpture was fabulous . It shows that a very inexpensive solution to a blank space can be the best one .Even though I was trained and worked in the field , David can still show me a thing or two and I think the rest of your viewers too.

Posted by joanne martin – August 21, 2006 1:14 PM

Alice has been my favorite since Week 1. She has common sense, a great sense of color and style. She is also able to get along with others, even the most difficult. What struck me was last week, even when it was evident that Temple's kitchen would be somewhat unfinished, Alice was working like crazy on that floor and just commented: "Let's just keep going, guys." She's got the whole package, in my opinion. She has the looks, the style, the personality, and HGTV needs a Southern girl for a show! (No, I am not a Southern girl, myself). I just think it would be a fresh idea.
I see Tym as being more of a home-improvement "Bob Vila" type.
David has some great artistic flare, but like many artists, seems a little more into "his art" than he would be in his clients.

Posted by Darcie – August 21, 2006 1:10 PM

THANK GOD TEMPLE IS GONE! Her room last night was really a "nothing" Everything blended into everything else--you might as well have been inside a cardboard box as inside her room. Alice's room came together nicely, though I didn't much like it during the process, nor did I like her color. I thought Tym's room was great when finished, though I did not like the eating area at all. It was the one area that I thought was underdone. David's room did seem claustrophobic, and I didn't understand the bedroom being open to the door and hallway while the living room was closed off. I also did not like the red and brown together, though the original artwork he did was great, as was his decision to sprinkle the red around rather than spread it. It would be great if these remaining 3 could all share a show together, as in "Design on a Dime" What a great team they would make.

Posted by Eva – August 21, 2006 1:09 PM

How about a new design show with BOTH David and Alice called "Uptown Boy Meets Down Home Girl"? They could be given the same parameters (bedroom, color, etc.) and each do a design in their own unique style then let the viewers vote on their favorite and announce a winner each week.

Posted by Klyla – August 21, 2006 1:01 PM

I'm sorry, but I disagreed with the judges and most of the comments so far. I think Temple's room was way better then Tym's. His room did nothing for me, I agree with Vern that it looked like a college dorm, and looks are what counts, not explanations. If you have to explain it for someone to see your idea, then you missed the boat. Temple's room may not have had the color pop that the other's had, but she also had the hardest color to work with. I thought that Temple downplaying the yellow, allowed the yellow that she did use -- pop. Using the bed to double as a couch was both innovative and allowed the space to appear larger. Both David (with the wall, which I thought was too high) and Alice (with removing the cabinet doors) were also innovative. I saw nothing innovative with Tym's design at all, someone feel free to correct me if I missed it. I think that some of the judges were biased against Temple especially the "in-style editor". She really lets it show which I think is preudicial to the other two judges. Temple, especially considering how well she has done on the one to one challenges and her lack of experience should have gotten a place on the final three. It is about design, correct. Looking at it from a cummulative point, she still deserved to stay over Tym. Tym has shown me nothing, but again, to be fair his presentation wasn't bad, but his design skills are not there. Poor, poor choice. I will keep watching, but HGTV might consider giving both Temple and Joseph a second chance somewhere down the road without the "in style" judge. Just my opinion. Clive, you are still the best part of the show. And Alice, I really like you too. Good Luck!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Sharon – August 21, 2006 12:53 PM

I am a design show junkie(Divine Design, Designed To Sell, Sensible Chic, etc.). I love it when I am able to take something from a show and apply it to my home.
David is an extremely talented artist, but I think his art is his design. While I think his designs would be appealing for urban loft style areas, can he do mainstream?
I have to say, I am leaning towards Alice. She makes you feel like she is someone you would invite into your home. I loved her room. It was just as she presented it, calm and serene.
Tym, you are just toooo out there for me!!!
Clive, love you and Lisa on Designed To Sell!!

Posted by Barbara – August 21, 2006 12:45 PM

I'm looking forward to seeing a head-head competition between Alice and David. David possesses confidence and skill. Alice has ideas. My understanding is that it will be viewers that determine the ultimate victor. Coming in with the Silver Medal in this competition will be nothing that can be shrugged off. Alas, poor Tym has spent much of the challanges whining about various aspects like time, material and others. In the real world, he has to deal with these every day to please customers. Tym, loosen up.

Posted by Lyle – August 21, 2006 12:42 PM

Again, last night was a real thriller! Keep it up and hope that you decide do to do this again next year with new contestants.
I imagine that Alice is quite thrilled to have an opportunity to be in the magazine, more exposure on her talents. Her room and her personality really showed in her work.
Tym is good and has some great ideas, that I won't deny, but the execution is lacking.
David is excellant in many ways. The judges did give him some great cretiquing that should slow himself down a little on his feelings about how he great he is and thus be able to really blossom on the next show.

Posted by Ann/Texas – August 21, 2006 12:32 PM

I enjoyed the fact that the challenge was "color". This means more than what's on a pallet. It means what "color" is each designer's own personality. And clearly you could see that smooth & sleek Alice and David made the grade. The other two, Tym and Temple didn't bring their "color" to the table. I really do enjoy watching this show, and hope, personally, that David wins because he's a hometown boy, from my part of the world. You Go BOY!!

Posted by Jay Roehrig – August 21, 2006 12:31 PM

Hurray! Temple is gone. That was my goal for this week and now with her departure, it really is a horserace. I believe Tym will probably be gone next week and then it will be between David and Alice. From what I have heard, the viewing audience is going to make the final decision. NO!!!!!!!!! Don't make me have to decide. Up until this time I thought David was a shoo-in but now I realize that Alice is a formidable opponent. I can't possibly choose and I don't know how anyone else could either. I look forward to each episode with anticipation! Next Sunday can't come too soon for me.

Posted by Paula B – August 21, 2006 12:24 PM

David Loved it, Alice good, Tym not so sure, Will miss Temple, She's fun to watch. David should be the winner!

Posted by Joanne – August 21, 2006 12:18 PM

This was the best show by far, and it can only get better. I was so glad the judges agreed that Alice's design was the best and that her presentation was the most natural. Alice has been low key during the first episodes, but in a host situation, her personality shines. It was also interesting that Alice was the only one of the four designers to give credit to her carpenter during her presentation. She also acknowledged that she spent a considerable amount of time shopping and would not have been able to complete her design idea without the assistance of the carpenter. My guess is that she is very easy to work with and open to suggestions. These are important qualities since the next Design Star will be working with craftsmen, clients, producers, television crews, vendors, etc.

David's design would have been better if he had sectioned off the bedroom area instead of the living room area. Keeping the living room, kitchen, and eating areas connected would have made the space appear larger. I would have thought David would have understood that since he said he also lives in a loft appartment. His presentation was a bit wooden.

Tym had a good concept, but he just couldn't quite execute it. I expect that Tym will be eliminated on the next show.

Temple needed to go. Her ego exceeds her talent, and it showed in this episode. When Clive told her about the presentation challenge, she said that she felt very comfortable before a camera. Her presentation was disappointing.

I can't wait for the next challenge. This one should be the best yet!

Posted by Patricia – August 21, 2006 12:14 PM

Great show. I loved the fact they all were on there own this week.It shows what they can do. I did think Temple's design was the worst, but not bad, just those rugs being placed on a diagnal, otherwise her room was o.k. Alice's room to me was the best of everyones and I loved her presentation...She is like a fresh breath of air to watch. I thought they all did a good job. It would have been a hard choice to make of letting one go and next week's show is even going to be harder...The stakes are very high now. No mistakes can be made. Keep up the good work Alice.

Posted by Glenda – August 21, 2006 12:10 PM

Loved this week's show. So much more interesting to see their individual talents. I realize the other shows allow for judging their interpersonal skills and are thus necessary. David's designs are great and well executed. Alice is equally terrific. Tym is also good but since I HAVE to choose next week, I will vote David or Alice. I vote for having two winners - David and Alice. As always, love Clive on this show and Designed to Sell with Lisa.

Posted by Joan – August 21, 2006 12:05 PM

I keep telling the wife it will be Dave or Alice. I think she sees this now . Alice could have used a slightly darker color blue as that blue was almost not seen but it did work for her.Unless Dave or Alice fall on thier face , Tym will probably go home next week.Tym lacks " punch" in the end result of his designs.When the new show airs with Dave or Alice as host , I know I will be watching.......

Posted by Dave – August 21, 2006 12:03 PM

I really love this show and really look forward to each week. I think the judges made a good choice in getting rid of Temple this week. I didn't think her hosting talent was all that great. She kept saying "um", that drives me crazy. I really think Alice is wonderful. I think she has what it takes to be the next design star. David and Tym are okay too, but I think Alice is the whole package.

I hope there will be a season two!

Posted by Connie – August 21, 2006 11:55 AM

Phew! The judges finally woke up and axed Temple!
Alice has consistantly shown she has the ability
to work with what ever is handed her. David
seems to have a spare talent that goes in a single style. Tym? his talents seem limited to me.
Alice is clearly outstanding.
Sue

Posted by Sue – August 21, 2006 11:49 AM

Alice has my vote. David is good, but always a bit too contemporary for me. Alice's designs, like her personality, seem very warm and inviting. GO ALICE!!

Posted by diane – August 21, 2006 11:46 AM

Hi Clive

Another great episode-I think the best so far. I think Alice did well in her design and I loved her host presentation. David's room was great and his presentation was fine, although I agree with the judges that he talked too fast. No doubt that was nerves. Tym's room was ok but he makes too many mistakes. If he makes one next week, my guess is he will go. His host presentation was great and I think that's what saved him. Temple, well Temple needed to go before this. That's all I have to say about that. At this point I would be inclined to watch any HGTV show Alice hosted. She is a sweetie and I love her personality. I would probably watch David, too, because I am an HGTV addict. As always, I loved seeing you Clive-- I am a big fan. and best of all, I heard last night that Designed to Sell is going to be on every night beginning 9/11. Really look forward to that. I can hardly wait til next Sunday.

Posted by JACQUIE – August 21, 2006 11:44 AM

I just have to ask, if Tym was going for "nature," why did he use that awful shade of green?? I would agree with the other post that said his room was just not comfortable. David and Alice will have to battle it out. They would sure make a great pair on a tv show!!

Posted by JLD – August 21, 2006 11:36 AM

Love the show! 1st reality series I've ever gotten 'in to'! I love HGTV!!!
I really liked Temple's room, it was crisp, clean, and cheerful. I was sorry to see her go, she was very professional.
Alice is great, a very sweet personality, hope if she is the next design star, her country, country accent will be worked on, she sounds like she's from the deep woods of Texas!
Tym, like the judge said, has great ideas, but does not follow through on execution. And I think he just has this air about him, that he is better than anyone, in every way.
David, very handsome and sexy, and knows it. Fantastic artist, great ideas, good use of 'splashes' of color.
I'm voting for Alice or David!

Posted by Debbie – August 21, 2006 11:21 AM

Well, Temple is gone. My favorite color is yellow but I felt her room was very bland and I never got the couch/bed thing. It still looked like a couch to me. I think David needed a bit more organization and I hated that tiny Tym cubbyhole for a living room. For the first time Alice seemed to shine and I really enjoyed her. It was nice to see her win without stepping all over anyone else.
Keep it up Clive. I've developed into a real fan and appreciate the dignity you bring to the tough job of ousting people each week.

Posted by Terry Lord – August 21, 2006 11:21 AM

Finally! The judges made a good decision about letting Temple go. Her design was okay, but I thought her hosting skills lacked severely. I didn't know "ummm..." was such a popular word to describe your vision. It seemed too scripted with her forgetting her own script. I loved Alices color, it was a beautiful choice. Tym impressed me, and david was cute because he was so nervous, but I agree that Alice should be the one. I would have never watched anything Temple ever put out. Clive, I love your new commercial- I literally laughed out loud at that one!

Posted by Janice – August 21, 2006 11:17 AM

Finally! A reality show I can get my teeth into! Regardless of whether I agree or disagree with the outcome, I'm there every week to see who gets voted off the kitchen island.

Posted by Gina – August 21, 2006 11:10 AM

Wanted to say first, Clive, that I've enjoyed watching you on "Designed to Sell" from day one, and that I think you're without doubt the best possible host for "Design Star." Like the greatest of TV "character" actors, yours is a personality and manner very welcome in our homes. *** "Design Star" is the first reality/competitive show I've watched, and I'm hooked. Plan to continue watching this season and next.

Also happy to note that the designer I picked in the first show is still in the running!

Posted by Kay Hooper – August 21, 2006 11:05 AM

Clive, I loved Alice's room and I thought David's was very different and unique. Temple's was a little bland, but I thought Tym's was downright awful. I have watched every week and I am amazed Tym is still around. Yes, he is handy, but as far as decorating goes, I don't see any potential there. He just doesn't seem to have the eye for it in my opinion. I guess the question is, do you want someone who can decorate or someone who can do the handy work by himself? My other thought is why did you take one (Temple) amateur and put her in with all professionals. If you wanted a pro. why not just accept them for the show. It seems everyone was out to get Temple from the beginning because she was not a pro. She was constantly having to defend herself against everyone. This made for exciting TV, and she handled it well, but it doesn't seem quite right. Love the show and am hoping Alice wins, she's got the personality and the talent! Tiffany

Posted by Tiffany – August 21, 2006 11:03 AM

I loved the color of blue that Alice picked for the studio apartment. I liked David's room too. For Tym's and Temple's, it was okay, but it did not impress me like Alice's and David's did. No wonder everyone was nervous about hosting. Since Clive is a wonderful host already, they had big shoes to fill. But Alice's personality really showed this week. I think she will be the next Design Star. I wasn't sad to see Temple go. I think it will be Tym next week if he doesn't step up to the plate. I am definitely looking forward to next week's episode. As always, Love ya Clive.
You are a wonderful host.

Posted by Michelle – August 21, 2006 11:00 AM

This is one of the best competitive shows on television. I thought Clive was great on design to sell, but he out does himself on design star!!!
I like Davids ideas, his use of color, and he works well under pressure. I think he will win the competition. Alice is wonderful and deserves a chance on WYWO, or trading spaces as a new designer.

Posted by Gina – August 21, 2006 11:00 AM

Hi! I'm new to this fun design show...I love the "American Idol", "Apprentice" and HGTV (my favorite network!)all rolled into one great show. I love Alice and David. They have personality and skill...they could be good together. Glad Temple is gone now. She was grating, and her work had NO sophistication. Going to the "American Idol" concert next Sunday night, so I'll have to TIVO you! Good luck, have fun...I'll be waiting to see your expert designs for the families.

Posted by Kitty – August 21, 2006 11:00 AM

Enjoyed the show, tho I would have like to see a little more of the space beforehand to get a real feel of what they had to work with. A little too much conversation and not enough focus on the design task, imo.

Temple's room was blah, especially for having what could have been a dynamic color. Vern's comment about it being 'picked up at the showroom and plunked down' certainly fit.

Tym is great with design concept and reconfiguring the spaces and elements, but frankly I am not sure he has it when it comes to the interior decorating part. His color was nice, his concepts good, but he had no 'soft touches' like art, and where the heck he found that bedspread? Yikes! His presentation was good - but I don't think he will survive the next challenge.

Alice's room looked like all of Alice's rooms - simple, clean liveable - but not interesting or exciting. She reminds me very much of designer Sarah Richardson. Kind of a one trick pony - every room has the same feel. NIce, but predictable. I thought she was 'cute and perky' when she did her tour, and of course some of that was nervousness, but I am not sure her personality is strong enough either on design or presentation, to take the final prize.

David has great concepts, and most of the time I really like what he does. This time I think he missed the boat by walling off the seating area, instead of the sleeping area. I would like to see him have to do a room in a very formal or traditional style, tho. His comfort zone is clean and modern, and I think he needs the challenge of a different style. I think his presentation reflected his nervousness, which could dissipate with more practice and experience.

I hope next week when they descend on these homeowners they will have at least a carpenter to help them out. I also hope we see more about their designs and decisions, and less talk - except with Clive, of course!

Posted by Les917 – August 21, 2006 10:57 AM

Okay I'm hooked!

Here is my 2 cents worth.

Temple should be given scholarship money to a design school to hone her raw talent. I think she has the ability to become a professional designer, but maybe not a show host. May need to work on her people skills a little, but in this high stress situation that may be an unfair analysis.

Tym has talent and I am sure he does a great job for his clients. Would want a little more from him though.

David has bold ideas. Is brave enough to try them and seems to execute them well. I agree with Vern that it is the bed area which should have been seperated. Tired of seeing his tattoo, but that is just personal preference. Think he could be a good host if he toned down his ego a mite. Needs to get more comfortable in front of camera.

Wish the twins could have shown what they are really capabale of. Really would have watched a show with both of them hosting.

Wish Joseph hadn't been eliminated quite so soon. I think he probably is a great designer just never had the chance to show it in this format.

Donna, eh.

Ramona was the comic relief.

ALICE, I really have liked your attitude during all of this process. I would definitely watch a show you hosted. Seems to me you have a real feel for design and have been able to think throug and execute your ideas. You were also able to convey your ideas simply and comfortably in front of the camera. I hope the next challenge was successful for you.

Wouldn't mind seeing this show again next year. Just stop with the camera bouncing and quick cuts. I want a good look not a quick glance.

Posted by Leanne – August 21, 2006 10:54 AM

You aint kiddin' - "now we're talking"!! I am soooo glad to see Temper - ahem - TEMPLE gone. Her room wasn't the worst, BUT her "hosting" was awful. She wasn't warm at all! I'd say unless she either showed the best of herself - or had a personality transplant (if this is as good as it gets), then I'd never watch her show, anyway.

Tym's presentation was fantastic! A NATURAL in front of that camera. The room, though, was, I thought, pretty bad. (Who the heck wants to sleep on a COT in New York - unless they're at Rikers Island?)It wasn't at all up to what I truly believe the Tymster can do. I KNOW THIS BOY HAS TALENT! For some reason, though, he just doesn't bring it through to the end. When he said, "Central Park," and then I saw his room, I thought, "does he mean the Central Park bathrooms?" Come on, Tym, old chap, step it up, or you'll be gone!

David's room was very good (as always) EXCEPT - the second I saw it I thought, "whooaaa! New Yorkers LIVE on top of each other, they WORK on top of each other, they want their own little spaces to be open and breathable!" The partition thing made that open studio feel like a cubicle. There are other ways of making, say, a bedroom (probably the only "room" he should have sectioned off) separate without making it feel closed off. He's still extremely talented, though. Presentation was, yes, too hurried, but I think he'll put it out of the fire for next week. David, you come off as a kind, warm, and humble guy in the interviews -- show that warmth in your hosting, and you'll be a force to be reckoned with!

Excellent job, Alice! What a wonderful room! I LOVED the colors, loved the theme, and that was an apartment I would have killed for when I lived in NYC! Bravo, girl!

So, the truth, I think, at this point is that America loves all three of you! To take liberties with Vern's words, "I'd totally watch the Tym/Alice/David show!" Hey, how about a show with all three of them?

Posted by Kathy – August 21, 2006 10:54 AM

It seems to me that David and Alice would make an awesome design team. Maybe the next season it could be changed to that. Several shows have a team of designers.
I like David he has some great ideas that can be made into reality. Alice is awesome as well and has a simple plan and gets it done. It is going ot be a rough choice!

Posted by Starla – August 21, 2006 10:53 AM

Great show. Glad to see Temple gone, I think you should just take the three remaining and use them all in a show. They could replace Brice and his team on Design on a Dime. Think about it.

Posted by Lynn – August 21, 2006 10:51 AM

I absolutely love this show... I have an idea for the "new" show - "Thinking inside and outside the box" with Alice and David. Alice is super and does things that appeal to homeowners as well as judges. David can't do it alone, but his artistic talent is wonderful.

Posted by Gayle – August 21, 2006 10:40 AM

Alice just has to win this competition. She has a very appealing personality and her designs are great. I would definately tune in to see her each week to let her help inspire me.

Posted by cindy – August 21, 2006 10:33 AM

I really enjoyed this week's show. It seemed a reasonable, though still difficult challenge. It was also good to see the designers demonstrating their hosting skills for the first time.

The judging seemed correct to me, and I appreciated the lively discussion that the judges had in choosing the winner and loser for this week.

And as always, Clive is great fun to watch.

Posted by Love HGTV – August 21, 2006 10:30 AM

Clive,
What were the judges thinking???? I didn't think Alice's room was anything very outstanding. And Temple and Tim's had no appeal to me. But, DAVID is a master of design. The others painted "all" of their walls and decorated with furniture and accessories. David created a "new" space with walls, ORIGINAL ART, and accessories that completed the design; with the same amount of money and time as the others. On every project he has an immediate design plan and executes it flawlessly within the time/money constraints. HE is the next DESIGN STAR!!!!!

Posted by Carol Barras – August 21, 2006 10:29 AM

All I have to say is "finally" Temple is gone....she was as phony as you could get. It was a big mistake when she placed the area rugs at an angle when that was one of the things they mentioned when Donna did that in her own room and in the entry hall...Angling irritated the judges.

One thing I really hate is when you use a bed as a sofa, either you have no back support or your feet don't hit the ground. There was plenty of room, as the others showed, for a separate living and bedroom, so don't combine them. The 2 chairs weren't something you could cozy up in, they were attractive but not comfortable looking.

I really thought they were all pretty good. One thing on David's room was that with such a dark deep color, why close in the sofa and TV into such a small space? Maybe just the one side to separate it from the bedroom and/or half a wall where he placed the TV, but otherwise it was good.

I think Tym has gotten a raw deal in some of the judging. I don't see him a negative at all. Of course I think the editing of the show has led the audience to certain beliefs on all the contestants (other than Ramona, who I think was just for viewer shock value). I don't think Tym was always negative or hiding his talent nor do I think Donna shopped the entire time during all of the work hours, but editing made you think so. The contestants were chosen for some reason, Ramona - strangeness and off the wall ideas, Temple - no formal education and big chest, Donna - age, need to get someone out of their 20's etc. There had to be better candidates than those 3.

I think the best 3 are left but I like Alice the best for a show. David is a little too conceited and Tym needs a hair stylist. Maybe they could share a show like Design on a Dime.

Posted by jas – August 21, 2006 10:26 AM

Even though Temple's design was bland, it was still very good. But I am so glad to see her go. She was grating on my nerves with the "poor single mom with lots of raw talent" act. I am glad Alice got a chance to shine in this challenge. I really think it will be down to David and Alice in the end. Frankly, they could work together in a show. Neither one is a prima donna and both have different styles that could play off the other.

Alice has a sweet traditional style with a modern twist; David has the edgy modern style. I would like to see David use something other then geometrics. I'd like to see him use something other then circles and bold color.

Tym - I'm not sure I'd watch his show. I'd like his explanation of his studio but I still don't know what his style is? Industrial?

I would have like to see Joseph stay on longer, but the rest were right to go.

Vanessa - Too full of herself. Glamorlistic? That says it all!

Donna - I think most people could design a room if you have someone else's money and all you have to do is shop. Obviously she is used to her clients calling the design shots. They tell her what they want, how much to spend and she shops for it. That is not design.

The twins - I know I should give them the benefit of being separate, but I think they probably work best together. They should stick to architecture, not interior design. Maybe if they had looked at the individual room challange from an architectural point of view they would have done better.

Temple - Considering who watches more HGTV, a host with more sex appeal then talent is not going to draw me to her show. P.S. I know David trades on his sex appeal too, but he has talent)

Ramona - Vacuum cleaner sculpture, broken bottle vase and mural. Enough said.

Posted by Janie – August 21, 2006 10:25 AM

I thought Temple handled leaving well. I was sort of sad to see her go. I did not like her at first, but since Donna was gone, she was more likeable. I understand that her design was sort of flat, although not unappealing. I would like to see what Tym can really do. So far I have not been too impressed with his designs, although his previous TV hosting experience showed in his final take of hosting his flat. He seemed very natural.

I love what David does with artwork and am surprised the others didn't do things similar. It doesn't take much artistic expertise to paint a canvas avant-garde repeating the rooms colors, and it adds so much more than just a nicely painted wall. He seems to have a great personality that I think would translate well to an audience on a weekly show.

Once again, very impressed with Alice's room. She has a bit of Laurie Smith with that accent, it's appealing. She seems genuine. I think she'd make a great host, so far. Let's see what next week has to offer....

Posted by KELLY – August 21, 2006 10:18 AM

This show has been so much fun!! I just want it to go on and on! I think David might be the next design star. I sure did not feel this way until now. His attitude totally turned me off, but, I have to say I love his creativity, and his ability to get the job done. It also really helps that he is an artist. The original pieces he has created have been awesome. I love Alice's work also but I am not particularly fond of her stage presence. I have had trouble with Tym since Temple's kitchen. He could have been the positive energy needed to complete that project, instead he chose to be the pessimist. I believe a design star definitely needs to have a "can do" attitude, and I have not seen that in Tym!! I would love to see a recurring show, where the "design star" perhaps ends up working with other "design stars" on their own show. I could see rotating hosts each week, I would love to see a "traveling" design star that actually does go to those out-of-the-way places. I see so much that can come of this show!! GREAT WORK EVERYONE!!!

Posted by Willow – August 21, 2006 10:15 AM

Hi Clive,

I love this show! It gives me something to look forward to watching on Sunday night TV (after watching Designed to Sell, of course!) David seems to be a natural, but I was surprised that he was so nervous when showing his room. However, that is a skill he can fine tune over time. Tym impressed me with his room reveal. He appeared to be quite confident and did an awesome job explaining his design concept. I like Alice a lot and I loved her color choice. She has been flying under the radar through past shows, and I am glad she is still on the show. She works hard and has such a warm positive attitude. I think she handles herself very well and I like that she doesn't bad mouth the other designers, as Temple and Donna did. I can't wait to see what happens next!

Posted by Susan – August 21, 2006 10:14 AM

What a great show last night. Good riddance to Temple, need I say more! What an incredible color of blue Alice chose to use. The room was soothing and functional and completely finished down to all the decorative details. She is professional, down to earth and has extreme talent. I would watch a show hosted by her any day. David also has a lot of talent, but he thinks way too much of himself. For that reason alone I would never watch his show. He thinks enough of himself already, he doesn't need an audience. Tym has great design ideas, but they never seem to quite turn out right. I think he does have a great personality, just the right combination of cute and quirky to make an interesting host. I think that with the right show on HGTV he could also do a great job. I hope it comes down to Alice and Tym and I'm still not quite sure which way I would vote. At least now we're down to design talent and done with the cat fights. The next few weeks should be interesting.

Posted by Carol – August 21, 2006 10:07 AM

Now that the contest is narrowing down everyone is really going to have to step up to the plate.
Alice did well both in design,color and her presentation was very good. She has the natural cheery girl way of coming across. Very relaxed and explained her room excellently and flawless. Love the use of the tiffany box.

Temple had much to be desired her color was not carried off well she eliminated seating had much unused space and was very blan with her decorating. The reason for the rugs being as they were was lame and showed a more noncholant attiude, like good enough. She should have done some creative thnking to get the rugs placed properly. Temple did do well with her presentation but then she has had some camera experince. I really expected more from her.

Tym did well with his use of colors maybe a bit over board with all of the different shades. I understand his clean lines modren rooms. However
he needs to find that punch just a bit more to pull it off.One look should tell the story of what it is he is trying to say. But I must say he did excellent on his presentation and really did explain the room well bringing it to life, also he looked relaxed and buff in his presentation. I could see me tuning in to watch him on his own show.

David excels in his room design. He used the red excellently and it had the right amount of punch. I agree it did get to feel a bit tight and I would have used the extra wall on the bedroom incoperating the TV space with the bed and sitting area he could of had it on the wall between the rooms on a swivel actually the entire wall could have been on a large lazy susan type fixture allowing the media space to be shared with either living space. But I still think for time and budget he did excellent. Now all David has to do is relax in front of the camera. He has the ability for the design area. David relax I say relax. If he can find his ability to be in front of the camera in a much more relaxed manner I feel he will go far.

Posted by Joel L. Daggett – August 21, 2006 9:57 AM

Now this is getting fun. I enjoyed all the designs, but I did think Temple's fell flat. I wasn't crazy about Tym's, and was kind of surprised that he was the one they kept on--although I didn't care for Temple's personality and was hoping she'd get booted. I've had a feeling that it would come down to David and Alice in the end. It will be hard to choose--I really like them both. Maybe the runner up could get a spot working with a team (like Design on a Dime). Just a suggestion...

Posted by Jennifer – August 21, 2006 9:49 AM

David's design was stunning, but completely impractical--what was he thinking with that heavy wall in a studio? Temple had a good idea, shielding the kitchen with a curtain; he should have done something similar if he wanted to separate the space. Her design was "pretty," but nothing special. She normally seems so energetic and vivaciousness--even to a fault--but came across flat during her presentation.

I felt Tym's design was weak, but agree he has a great presence. Nothing he has produced, other than the bedroom with the twins, has felt cohesive. The judges nailed it by selecting Alyce, definitely the best combination of design + presentation. I was not yet convinced she deserved to make the final four, but she delivered with this design.

Posted by JKaT – August 21, 2006 9:37 AM

Temple's hosting skills didn't impress me at all. She used too many "ums" and said "tons" several times...very annoying. Plus, she never really looked into the camera to make eye contact with the audience while showing her room.
Surprisingly, I didn't care for David's room divider. Maybe the brown color was too stark for a wall situated in the midddle of a small space?? Perhaps with more time and $ he could have accessorized it with artwork or painted bands of accent colors, or designed it with built-in shelves. I agree with Vern that he should have wrapped it around the bedroom area instead of the living room area, or made it from soft/moveable materials for maximum flexibility.
If Tym had chosen different bedding and more plush-looking cozy furniture, his room would have been great. His hosting debut was really good, though. I found him likeable in a knowledgeable yet low-key kind of way.
The color of Alice's room looked more green than blue on my TV, but I loved everything about her design and presentation.

Posted by Melissa – August 21, 2006 9:29 AM

I have never watched a reality show before and I have to tell you, I'm totally hooked on this one. I even watch the reruns knowing what has already happened. I've been sad to see some go and glad to see others go - haven't we all? This is a wonderful show and I sincerely hope HGTV will continue this format. It would be wonderful if you could do a follow up of the last four designers 6mo to a year down the road. Eager to see what happens now.

Note to David: Keep taking that shirt off, Darlin'. Your talent is awesome.

Note to Alice: Such a talented designer and very loving to every one - how nice to see

Great job Clive, judges and design contestants.

Posted by Suzanne – August 21, 2006 9:25 AM

I think the show was terrific! I agree with one of the judges that Temple should have come up with other ideas to ifuse yellow into the apartment rather than just painting the walls. She chould have had one wall in a more vibrant yellow and done the rest in white and then brought in yellow with storage pieces, accents, any number of other places. Yellow is a hard color to have on every wall in a room. She should be proud that she, the one with NO experience made it this far.

Alice was a delight once again, as she has been throughout the show.

David's red was OK, but I agree with Vern Yip, that the wall placement would have been better in a different section of the apartment. It DID look claustrophobic.

Tym needs to really pull it together this next episode or he'll be OUT!

I can't wait for next weeks episode.

Posted by Sally – August 21, 2006 9:22 AM

I didn't understand if they chose the color or if it was assigned to specific people!
I liked Alice's blue and Tim's green "walls" but I sure didn't like the green bedspread!
Alice and David would probably work well together!

Posted by Lucy – August 21, 2006 9:20 AM

I love Verns work. I have ben admireing his work for a long time. I was surprised, and happy to see you hosting this show. Tim needs to unwind. Tim needs to trust his ability. Alice really has her finger on it.David as my Grandchildren say is off the chain. He displays smooth, relaxing, vibrant etc. One day I can see him being a Vern #2 in his own rite. I am enjoying this show.

Posted by Solomon – August 21, 2006 9:20 AM

Love this show but never ventured to write before. Loved Alice's color and room and she's a doll and pretty to boot.
Love Tym but didn't get his room or the color..maybe it was the color on my TV ..didn't show well at all. Was surprised that he stayed and Temple left.
David's room was super except for the wall that should have been in the bedroom to close it off.
Sorry to see Temple go...since yellow is my favorite color I loved that room and really like the curtain blocking off the kitchen. She has great ideas but needs some training.
On all the rooms I thought about how I would like to live in them or not!
I favor Alice as the design star because I like watching her but bet David will win it as he seems to be the judges favorite. I predict Tym will leave next.

Posted by Jazz – August 21, 2006 9:14 AM

Temple has design talent, but feels that her looks gets her to where she is going.
Alice is like a breath of fresh air, she is soooo
real. Nothing about her is fake. She needs to go just a little farther with her ideas. I like that she stands for what she believes, and I am glad that she didn't leave the show when Joseph was terminated, I was sure that she was walking also.
Tim seems to be stressed by all the Donna-Temple riff-raff and has to overcome that, which may happen now that they are gone. He need to push to the limit next week to stay.
David's art talent shows through, he has the personality, but needs practice in front of the camera. I admire his honestly when asked about who should be voted off, he is definitely the peacekeeper of the group.

Posted by patricia white – August 21, 2006 9:12 AM

Even though I am not a big fan of the color yellow,Temple's room was fresh and clean. David's room with the partitions,looked like a maze.He should have put arrows on them to show which way to go.Tym's room looked like army barracks. Alice's room was just there. I think David is the best of them all but I really think Temple should have stayed. Love You, Clive.

Posted by Lynne DeMarco – August 21, 2006 9:11 AM

I loved the rooms that were done this week. I think that everyone did a good job. I personally liked Temple's room, but I understand that someone had to go. I love David's work and hope that he is the design star!!

Posted by Tammy – August 21, 2006 8:57 AM

This week it was nice to see the contestants get some real help instead of having to rely on each other. The challenge seemed to be a good one, but I was as disappointed as the judges with the interpretation by Temple, Alice and Tym - too literal.

I thought Alice's color was green not blue, and retro - same color has been in my mother-in-laws kitchen since the 70's at least! It's way to cool for a living space for me. There were ten of us watching last night and we all thought it was reminiscent of her camping room. And I remembered the blue pillows of the first show. Alice needs to go ORANGE!

I thought Tym fell short of bringing the outdoors in. A little more plant and natural accessories, maybe a bedspread that didn't look so dormy (natural colors to offset the green walls). I didn't catch the two tone either. Everything was just GREEN. His presentation was the BEST of them though. I was impressed with his comfort on camera.

Temple could have picked more varying yellows and done something really fun, but she fell flat. I expected a lot more with the last few designs she came up with, and was disappointed she didn't do better in the presentation. Though I liked Tym's room less, I can see why Temple went. Unless Tym pulls up his roots and starts moving, I'm sure he'll go next week.

David's apartment was excellent. It was the only one I thought of as more than just a room. I think this time the judges fell flat and showed how much they were stuck in a box. (Especially after the comment to Tym about how they had all poorly interpreted the use of color in this challenge.) David's separate living area was so understandable. When you want to relax, you want to get away. You don't want to be stuck in your kitchen and bedroom. David left the top of the wall open, so it didn't close off the space, and used his color as a theme not a room wash. He fell on his face talking so fast on his tour, but that can be fixed.

I'm liking Alice less as an equal contender each week, and am hoping people will choose David for his unique and innovative ideas. I don't want another same-old-same-old HGTV show. I want something more fun. I think David could be what Debbie Travis should be, someone who can show us some fun and innovative ways to add color and spice to our living. I also think he's got a lot of ideas in his head that are new to HGTV and the modern design mainline. He makes me see something in a space that I never imagined.

Love the new commercial about the cluttered closet Clive!! Keep up the awesome work.

Posted by Linda – August 21, 2006 8:57 AM

I was glad this week that each of the designers had a carpenter. I believe Alice's apartment was the winner. It was cool and refreshing - just what you need after a busy day in New York. Dave's was a close 2nd, but I really didn't care for the wall he had built. Tym just had too much green (and I love green), but he at least threw in some blue. Temple's was just too bland. She could have helped herself by injecting other colors. I believe Temple would be a good designer if she would go to school and get some formal training. Her only downfall is her people skills. She doesn't seem to listen to others that have more experience.

Can't wait for the next show!

Posted by Lin – August 21, 2006 8:43 AM

GO ALICE...GO ALICE...GO ALICE. Gang, let's all vote for Alice. Wouldn't her show be great?

Posted by Judy – August 21, 2006 8:41 AM

The judges raally rock! Good elimation of Temple! My favorite is still David but Tym might be a dark horse, waiting to explode!!!!

Posted by Elizabeth Orbison – August 21, 2006 8:39 AM

A star is born! Alice is the complete package. Great designer, charming personality, cheerful, would certainly watrch her show. Tym is also very interesting.

Posted by Mario – August 21, 2006 8:34 AM

HI, THE PROBLEM I HAVE WITH ALICE IS TWO FOLD 1.) I REALLY DON'T WANT TO SEE A WOMAN OR A MAN FOR THAT MATTER IN EMOTIONAL UPHEAVEL AND TEARY EYED HAVE A PLACE IN MY LIVING ROOM. 2.) I HAVE NOT SEEN HER EVER THINK OUT SIDE THE BOX. HER DESIGNS ARE THOSE THAT ARE REGULAR ALBEIT (HO-HUM) PRETTY. I WOULDN'T WATCH A SHOW SHE HOSTED FOR THOSE REASONS. TYM I THINK IS BRILLIANT, HE STANDS OUT AS MANY REBELS OF DESIGN HAVE FOR HIS OWN VIEWS. HE COULD DO ANYTHING BUT CHOOSES HIS OWN PATH. DAVID, HE IS A STAR! HE HAS ALREADY CAPTIVATED MANY OF US VIEWERS, AND WE WATCH JUST TO SEE HIS NEXT DESIGN. ALL OF HIS DESIGNS ARE POWERFUL STATEMENTS AND WORKS OF ART. IF GIVEN A SHOW, HIS SHOW WOULD MAKE IT. HE HAS ALREADY SUCCEEDED. HE HAS ALREADY MADE AN AUDIENCE. TEMPLE'S PERSONALITY WOULD HAVE AXED ANY SHOW, AND I BELIEVE ALICE'S WILL DO THE SAME. IT HAS ALREADY TURNED ME OFF. THANKS

Posted by sara gindin – August 21, 2006 8:07 AM

First off, Clive, it's nice to know you actually read our comments. Sometimes you wonder with these celebrity/TV show blogs if that's the case. I'm glued to the set each and every week and usually watch at least one of the re-broadcasts; so this program is definitely a hit with me. (But what do I know? Usually they end up cancelling the shows I like... *grin*)

I liked this week's challenge since it gave everyone a chance to stand on their own. I really haven't been as impressed with David as the judges are. What was with the 5 foot wall separating the living area from the rest of the apartment? I could see if he'd constructed it so that it enclosed the bedroom area... but it didn't make any sense to close off the living room from the rest of the flat. As it was, the bed was the first thing you saw as you entered, and then you had to go around that wall to get to the main seating area. Just what kind of entertaining does that guy do...? His performance on camera was sad.

Temple's room -- though a cheery color -- was quite bland and cold in feeling. As the judges noted, she was simply displaying items she bought, rather than designing the space. She had virtually no USAEBLE storage space; for example, the shelf over the table/desk area...? How could you reach it if you were sitting at the desk working? The whole point of design is to facilitate proper use of the space, and Temple doesn't seem to get that. Finally, her presentation was just awful. If she'd said "cool" one more time... And talk about mechanical and "fake." So glad to see her go!

I can't understand why the judges are so hard on Tym when they routinely lavish David with undeserved praise. I thought Tym's building project was much more succesful than David's. Thought his color scheme was nice and clean... okay, sure, if he wanted the sense of bringing the outdoors in, he might've added some plants to the space; but it's not like anyone else hasn't overlooked plants... If anyone's room looked like a prison, it was David's, not Tym's... Certainly Tym's presentation was far superior to David's.

I love Alice, and I'm glad she won. She's so bubbly and sweet! Though I wasn't a fan of the "Tiffany Box Blue" shade she used, it was something a little out of the ordinary, and thus made her design more interesting and unique. Her room was calm without being cold, like Temple's. And her presentation was just so natural... sure, she could work on her posture, but it was nice to see her come into her own, finally.

Posted by elaine – August 21, 2006 8:02 AM

Alice is good. Tym is good. David is great. Temple is gone, finally. . .

Posted by Julie – August 21, 2006 7:58 AM

I was so happy to see Alice get noticed this week. She has been doing well all along, but apparently until there were less people to look at she seemed almost invisible. Not only did she have the best room, attitude and hosting ability, but she also won something extra from InStyle I believe. That had to be exciting for her.

I think we all know that the face off will be between David and Alice. Tym would probably be a good host, but as your previous poster said he seems to hang on by the skin of his teeth every single week. What was up with that blue rug? Everything was green and then 'bam' there is this dark blue rug in the middle of everything. I didn't get that. If more blue had been there I could have seen it, but most of his room was green.

David has GREAT talent, but I think in this one he kind of over did it. He has been praised for his vision and everything so much that he thinks he has to keep impressing them that way, but I do believe he can use the artwork of others and not always have to do everything on his own.

Anyway, I can't wait to see next weeks episode.

Posted by Sheryl – August 21, 2006 7:58 AM

I agreed with the judges this week and am glad to see Temple go. She certainly did have raw talent and I even liked her room (but agreed with Martha that those rugs being off-kilter were wreaking havoc with my eyes!), though I thought it was too too much in such a small space. I would have been hard pressed to vote on which of the remaining three was my favorite. I loved them all and even agreed with David on the breaking the rooms up a bit. I did have to agree with Vern though on that living room area being too small closed off...

Tym's style is not my style, but I think he does great work as well. He is very modern and minimalistic. I like the minimalistic clean lines, but I'm not too into that modern look. I wish all three of them well and if I had to pick now...well...personality wise it would be Alice or Tym. Design style wise, it would be Alice or David...

Good luck you last three standing! You do deserve to be where you are now! Good job judges!

Posted by AutumnLeaves – August 21, 2006 7:43 AM

Hi Clive & Everyone,

I was tossing & turning last night 'til 11:30 thinking how I would have handled the color yellow. What a great show!

So far, Tim's color sense & ability to handle the decorating details does not match up to Alice or David. David is definitely the strongest designer, but they all have great screen presence. Can't wait to see what happens next week. Bye for now...

Posted by Catherine – August 21, 2006 7:33 AM

I think it will come down to Alice and David. I don't think you could consider one necessarily "better" than the other, but I think all of David's designs have been AWESOME...Can't wait till Sunday :)

Posted by Missi Thigpen – August 21, 2006 7:23 AM

This is such a great series, Clive.
Both Alice and David are very appealing, each in his own way. David is so strong when it comes to design ideas and I like the way he approaches each challenge. Alice has a great personality although her design ideas are nowhere near as brilliant as David's.
Tym has never quite risen to the challenge as far as I can see - he always seems to be apologetic for what he didn't quite accomplish.

Posted by Claire – August 21, 2006 7:21 AM

Clive,
Was really disappointed in David, as he has been so consistently superior. Thrilled that Alice gets the exposure at INSTYLE,she deserves the recognition. All three of the finalists are nice and worthy of winning. Tym finally was able to show off his personality---but I think David will recover from his stumble and win overall.

Posted by CG – August 21, 2006 7:02 AM

Very encouraging direction with this challenge and the handling of the two layered judging criteria. Would have been nice to have had this earlier in the process. I think there might have been a different final 3 designers. At this point - I would give any of the remaining contestants a shot and would watch a few episodes of a show and then decide. Alice has the best style but David shows strong creativity and is the best risk taker.

Posted by KL – August 21, 2006 6:18 AM

Okay! We finally have some real designing going on here! Loved pretty Alice and her pretty Tiffany blue room. So fresh and charming, like a summer sky. David's use of red was judicious but he blew it on space planning -- that tiny cubicle around the couch was a mistake. However, his use of the color throughout the space and in the art work was inspired. Liked Tym's use of green plants; as we have seen before, he had a good concept, but fell short on execution. His presentation for the camera pulled it out, as he obviously realized. Temple had a good concept, too; liked what she did with the bed -- it opened up the space. She just should have gone bolder with color and pattern, which she might have done, if she had liked the color more herself. A restrained, timid Temple -- who knew? Anyway, it can't have been easy for the judges to choose between her rather bland room and Tym's "upscale prison room". At least we finally got to see more of what each person could do as an individual, both as a designer and as a presenter. My money's still on Alice as the eventual winner and that is how I will vote when the time comes. With some professional hair, makeup and wardrobe advice, that girl is going to scorch earth on TV!

Posted by Karen R – August 21, 2006 6:05 AM

clive great show this week I really thought davids room was the best this week.when using red remember moderation,sorry alice I really didn't care for your choice of blue, maybe in a bathroom.see you next week and keep up the great job.

Posted by dawn – August 21, 2006 5:12 AM

I agreed with the judges this week. I am looking forward to next week to see what happens. This is my first reality show to watch and I am enjoying it.

Posted by sbgausa – August 21, 2006 4:58 AM

Clive --

Thanks so much for adding your personality, charm, and patient wit to this show, and to Designed to Sell.

All four of the remaining designers deserve kudos for being talented, professional, and courageous.

That said, I found Temple's and Tym's designs to be less than inspirational. I'm not sure I can even say why, I just know my response was, "That's nice....".

David's is design at its finest, artistic and energizing. Straight from a magazine, with balance, "pop", and motion. Well done.

I found Alice's to be the most interesting and intriguing, though, and the most "livable". The color is relaxing but not boring, and it's used in a balanced, but not rigidly symmetrical, way. She seems able to take design and translate it into a home, rather than a photo shoot.

Which is best? I think that might depend on what kind of a show is being proposed....

Posted by Beth – August 21, 2006 4:28 AM

Love the show except the fighting, Thank god all the fighters are gone, now let's see some great design and creativity and ability to carry out concept. HGTV please have Vern host a show of his own by showing us the projects he has done, letting him go to a home a critique it improve it, he is the TRUE DESIGNER STAR. He is been gone way too long from the TV design world.

Posted by Jean of San Deigo – August 21, 2006 4:21 AM

I have been leaning toward David winning this competition until tonight's episode. I thought Alice's use of the blue and her presentation really stood out. Of course, David's color scheme stood out also. It is going to be very hard to pick one over the other. I'm not a fan of reality shows but I can see where people get addicted to watching them week after week as I am doing with this one.

For tonight's challenge, I'm thinking that 3 out of the 4 contestants were under the impression they had to use their colors exclusively for their rooms. Only David thought "outside the box" and I congratulate him on that.

I'm certainly not a fan of yellow, however, used sparingly, or in different shades, it could have worked for Temple.

Tym's green room was way too much. It didn't bring the outside in IMO.

Alice's blue room was nicely done. I think the bed covering looked almost jewel like (blue diamond)? It did remind me of opening a jewelry box and seeing a pretty inside.

David's room was more to my liking, other than the wall he built. Loved his use of color other than red. I believe he was the only one who "got it".

All in all, I agree with the judges that Alice's was the best room tonight. And her presentation was right on.

Posted by J.R. – August 21, 2006 4:09 AM

I was truly afraid Tym was on his way out. I think I would have done something varied with the color instead of using it everywhere. The mattress color seemed to clash a little to me with the wall. That was my initial response. Maybe my TV needs adjustments in the color area. I was afraid Dave wasn't going to make it, but actually I was worried about time for each contestant. I can't wait to see next week.

Posted by Susan Barthelow – August 21, 2006 4:08 AM

I think the key to winning this competition is for each of the designers to really expand their designs beyond what is expected. In my opinion Tym saw his color as green and so did we. He didn't go beyond the paintcan. Temple too saw only the word "yellow" and didn't think out of the box on this one. She could have picked a deep gold or mustard shade and made this space really look regal. She also made a big mistake painting the cabinets in the kitchen, it would have warmed up the space considerably if she had left them be. I thought Alice picked a terrific color scheme and carried the execution of it well. However, I would have liked a little more creative space planning ideas. David, however could easily be the next Design Star with his creativity and ability to see items out of context and incorporate them into the design(i.e. the fishbowls from last week). He continually thinks outside of the box on every turn. Maybe his space planning wasn't your taste, but at least he used a creative idea for defining the spaces unlike the other contestants. Tym put up a column and it was bearly noticably when you look at the before and after photos. I hope next week Tym can execute his designs like he expresses them and is not a big disappointment.It should be very interesting what happens, I can't what to see!

Posted by dahtdah – August 21, 2006 3:54 AM

I really enjoyed getting to see Alice's personality this episode! She's been so quiet up 'til now... She always comes across as a consumate professional, and her combo of design and presentation was well worthy of her "win" this week!

I'd love to see Tym step his design ability up just a notch next week! He has what it takes to give David and Alice a run for their money, to be sure.

David obviously LOVES what he's doing... His designs are executed with pure exuberance! If he can relax more on camera, it will be almost too close to call in the end.

I've watched each episode at least twice (including tonight's)... Can't get enough!!!

Posted by Jinx – August 21, 2006 3:40 AM

Clive:
It was great to see the designers get to shine on their own, or fail on their own. I loved Alice's room and the Tiffany Blue idea. I work in an office building where Tiffany is on the ground floor and I was feeling her all the way! I also loved what David did with his room, he is just great at seeing an idea and bringing it to life. I was sorry to see he was so nervous on his first tape to the viewers though. Hang in there David it will get better. Tym is starting to come into his own and I am pulling he can put his designs out there and bring them forward. I am sorry to be so callous, but I was glad to see Ms. Temple go, it was time. I love the idea that we, the viewers, will get a say in picking the winner. Hallelujah, I was hoping the show would let us have a say. Love it, love it, love it!! Can't wait until next Sunday.
Take care.

Posted by Carolyn – August 21, 2006 3:38 AM

What an interesting show. The whole series so far has kept my interest. I do watch the repeats trying to see the little things that I missed from an original weekly airing. Hindsight is always 20/20, so I can't be upset with the judges. They're learning as they go along, too.
Other than Joseph(who seemed such a passive fella and might not have gone a lot further anyway)I think the designers who have been cut are on target.

Clive and Vern are both perfect choices for this show. I don't know who the other 2 judges are or what they are really about. (don't really care either as they seem too personally emotional about this. Just seems odd for judges).

While I feel that the entire group really didn't seem to know how to act like a 'team' in any of the group challenges, I am enjoying the individual projects.

My kids were never allowed to get as out of hand with the bickering as these designer "adults" did. Jealousy, envy, ego, and insecurities were obvious and annoying. But just maybe I'm too used to seeing a finished, polished episodes of shows like Design on a Dime, Decorating Cents, Changing Rooms, Trading Spaces that all have time crunches with budget concerns AND other people to deal with. This is more like Designer Finals without the excuse of being a student about to graduate.

As we are now down to 3, this next episode should be interesting more to see how the judges make their decisions. Hope its based more on the realities than the emotional.
My choice for the top 2 are Alice and David. I'd be happy with either for their own show.

(please don't ever bring back Vanessa! I didn't care for her just from the promos before the show ever aired.)

Posted by Ann – August 21, 2006 3:37 AM

Hey Clive,

I love you... on Design Star & especially Designed to Sell. Can't wait to see more of you every day of the week this season.
Now for the youngun's...
David is it. He's enthusiastic, upbeat, & has a daring design sense. He will be a sponge learner & if he can keep his swish in check, he'll be a fabulous, funny & fun to watch rising Design Star.

I think Alice is adorable & also a happy, ethusiastic person but she is more traditional in her approach & we want design excitement.

I also think Tym is an edgier designer but he lacks the enthusiasm & joy the other 2 have on air. He certainly was cooler on the presentation but I think that's due to his age & rock star experience. And Tym, maybe because you have the life experience & you know how important a break this would be you're coming across more intense... if so lighten up & let's see the joy man!

So right here in black & white I declare David the next "Design Star" but Clive you're still the man of my dreams!

Posted by Sue Kay – August 21, 2006 3:26 AM

Clive,
I am really enjoying this show! I know I wouldn't want to be one of thejudges at this point - oh, wait I am! Well, I will keep an open mind until next episode, but for right now, I would hate to see either David OR Alice go! I see such good over-all stregnths in both of them, design wise and as television personalities. David is such a cutie when he doesn't realize he is "performing on camera", and I know he will get better at hosting, and Alice is just a natural, comfortable person! Can't wait to see next week.

Posted by Elaine – August 21, 2006 3:03 AM

Clive,
I have not been "hooked" by any of the "reality" TV shows that have ever aired. I watched a little of episode 2 of "Design Star" and I was instantly hooked. My friends are kidding me now because I have critisized them for years about watching the reality shows that they watch saying: "I watch reality TV...the News." I never undedrstood the draw of this genre of TV, but now I get it. I have had the pleasure of watching these strangers meet, fight, make-up, work together, and work individually. They have been talented, competitive, supportive, critical, helpful and selfish in turns. As the designers are eliminated, those who remain continue to grow and progress. These people have improved as designers and grown as people. I feel as if I know the contestants and I will know the final remaining designer in a different way than how I know Debbie Travis, Kennith Brown, Candice Olsen, Lisa Laporter, and you Clive. Thanks for the SUPER FUN show.
David

Posted by David Hone – August 21, 2006 2:48 AM

I Love Alice. Her work is very good AND she makes everyone smile. She seems so real. It is easy to imagine living in her space. She also leaves a little space. In the 'Tiffany Box' it was near the window. Empty is good. Plants, a fish tank, a birdcage, a tiny bistro set would all work there. Room for an idea or not. Vern Yip does not leave that kind of space in his designs. He answers ALL questions. Mastery but not mystery.
David designs are innovative without being weird or uncomfortable. Very cool.
Tym! Pay attention! Anyone able enough to make it this far in this contest should not be getting the wrong kind of primer. I do not want to watch anyone shoot himself in the foot every week.

Posted by Martie – August 21, 2006 2:45 AM

Great job by Alice, great color choice, organization, execution,and presentation. David's room seemed dark and smaller with his choices and fell short on presentation. Tym and Temple were only fair.
I hope Alice is the next design star, but David has been very creative, but does not have the tv presents needed.

Posted by Marcy – August 21, 2006 2:45 AM

Is it me or is it my television set... but I only saw a turquoise green in Alice's room - not anything to what I consider 'blue'...

I felt David's room was very well designed - my thing with him is his artwork. Does he do more than just circles and/or ovals? I want to see more creativity from here on out.

And although Alice's presentation was better than David's, I did not think she deserved to be given first place.

Let the competition continue! Lov'in it!!!

Posted by Beth Elkassih – August 21, 2006 2:41 AM

Alice is sweet, lovely lady with great screen prescence. She is always supportive of her competitors with never a bad or negative word. The one time I heard her question someone's work she whispered to the camera. She should definately be the last one standing.

Posted by Mark J – August 21, 2006 2:34 AM

I loved it when Alice referred to the "blue box" color - thought it was great. Everything about her and her designs have made me smile each week. Her design ability is unquestionable. She's beautiful and her personality, excitement and presence is so real and contagious; all attributes to make Alice the well deserving next HGTV Design Star.

Posted by Wanda Garrett – August 21, 2006 2:29 AM

Hi Clive, great show. I'm sorry too see Temple go because she did a good job...I don't think I would have have made a comment on how the rugs were in an angle, but her presentation did need a little work..Oh Well. Alice did a great job, just loved it. David had a hard color to work with and pulled it off...Kudos. Tym also did a good job, just too much green, he needed more accent colors. I hated the color of the comforter and he needed more pillows. Overall I think this was the best show....Keep up the good work.

Posted by Elizabeth Walker – August 21, 2006 2:27 AM

Clive, I enjoy your personable hosting abilities whether with Lisa La Porta or on Design Star. I also like to read your comments about the show.
Of course all the designers are talented, but both David and Alice seem to have more of a total package of personality and ability. I watch a lot of HGTV, as do many of my aqauaintances, and I know we would watch a program featuring either of them. They seem to have a way of drawing you in. I also think that although the challanges seem equal on the surface, I am pretty familar with both the mountain west and the southwest.
Such activities as redesigning a studio apartment would be more unusual for Temple or Alice, than they might for designers who hale from huge urban areas or from either coast. On the other hand, a disorienting challange, such as purchasing items from a pet shop or camping store, actually puts them all on more equal footing, although it is certainly not "real world".

Posted by deba – August 21, 2006 2:26 AM

Clive:

Love the show. Love your wit! But please tell the judges to smile more. I like seeing Vern smile! I agree with Dee. Alice has such a refreshing personality, and her use of color is spot on. Plus, she seems very kind and has a wonderful accent. But, then again, I'm a "Carolina Girl," southern through-and-through, so I'm prejudiced. Alice is my choice for the next "Design Star." I'd faithfully watch her show. David and Tym also give off genuine and professional vibes. Good jobs all around!

Posted by Heather – August 21, 2006 2:16 AM

I'm glad to see Temple go. Her room this week was very bland, nothing stood out and it looked unfinished. Last week's room was a nightmare; she didn't deliver on anything that she promised and the cabinets were as far from Tuscan as you can get.
Tym's personality really showed through when he presented his space, but what was with that metal bed in a room that was supposed to be about nature?
I thought Alice and David's rooms were the best. The color of Alice's room was calming, there were touches of other shades of blue, and it flowed well. David's wall was a mistake, it made the living area too cramped. His bedroom area was the best though, and was the one part of the show that looked like it had been created by a true designer.

Posted by Cathy – August 21, 2006 2:10 AM

Though Tym does have some interesting art-related ideas, I think it's pretty obvious that the most talented *designers* are Alice and David. Looking at various messages boards and the HGTV website, it looks like America is pretty much tied, too, between Alice-supporters and David-supporters. It will be interesting to see who wins (and WHY).

Personally, as much as I respect David's vision and aesthetic, I think his personality would wear thin after a few shows full of just him, while Alice would remain refreshing and an attaction to the network for season after season.

Maybe we'll be lucky and they'll BOTH win! Actually, if both Alice and David get their own shows, then I guess it's really we viewers who would win! Why not?

Posted by Erin – August 21, 2006 2:07 AM

Wow! This show just keeps getting better and better. I was so nervous during the judging, for all of them. I have a feeling it will be David and Alice at the end and what a dilemma that will be. Can they host a show together? They have such great personalities and actually seem quite comfortable and supportive of each other. Well, a girl can dream. ;o)

Posted by Michele – August 21, 2006 2:05 AM

I love what David does with a room. Everything he touches is fabulous and in my humble opinion, he should be the next design star!

Posted by Jeani Johnson – August 21, 2006 1:58 AM

I agree I loved Alice's room and the color was truly a girls dream. I also loved David's use of the shades of red.. I do believe it's going to come down to Alice and David.. Best of luck to final three..,

Posted by Annie J. – August 21, 2006 1:53 AM

Clive; it is us that should be thanking you for doing this blog. :D What a wonderful show, getting to see design, execution and personality all in one. Mom and I watched the show together trying to decide which designer comments matched what room. Liked all of the rooms, but probably David's a little more and I don't even like the color red that much. Can't wait until next week.

Posted by Klancie – August 21, 2006 1:50 AM

It's rather refreshing for a completely NON-REALITY show watcher to have stumbled upon DesignStar and actually have enjoyed all of the episodes up to this point. Nothing is overly "produced" (see Contender) nothing is so unrealistic as to be questioned to fit in the genre (see Fear Factor). Thanks for the realness in your reality show.

Posted by James – August 21, 2006 1:47 AM

I appreciated this challenge because this really brought out the contestants' potential when it came to designing AND hosting. Was surprised at David's nervousness since he has the talent to back it up. Liked his room as well except for the slightly "claustrophobic" TV room. Tym's room looked refreshing color-wise but i would've like to see some art hanging on those bare walls. Loved Alice's tiffany box blue room hands down. Temple... well... her departure is way overdue. Would've liked to see someone else in her place on the final four.

Loved this episode. Can't wait for the next one. Thank you Clive for keeping us posted and for doing a fantastic job.

Posted by JD E. – August 21, 2006 1:39 AM

Clive: So far Alice is my fave to win. Her "camping" room was stylish without being pretentious. It looked relaxed and real, as was her room tonight. Also, she hasn't been catty at all. She is real sweet.

Though not a huge fan of Temple's personality she does have a raw talent that she should explore by going to school to get the basics. Her room tonight wasn't exciting but it was heaps better than Tym's. His was just butt ugly.

Tym and David (who is really stuck on himself) are a bit uppity. Though I loved David's "pet" room -- awesome, they need to remember the clients are real people and may not "get" their vision. They need to be a little less artsy and more realistic and functional in their designs.

Go Alice!

Posted by Susan – August 21, 2006 1:30 AM

Clive,
I must say I did not envy the judges this week. I love all the remaining designers. They each have a unique style that is very 21st century... sleek and innovotive. I'd be delighted to have any of them disign my home. That said, Temple's design was the least impressive of the four. I feel the judges have been spot on at each elimination. Thanks for a "reality/ competition" show that is actually fun and mature. Cheers!

Posted by Drew Agler – August 21, 2006 1:27 AM

Clive

Thanks for giving me a chance to share how much I'm enjoying the show. I really like David's style and believe he has had the best designs and is always consistantly impressive. Can you tell who I'm hoping will be come the new DensignSstar.

I think you do a great job and have great comic timing.

Keep up the good work,
Sharon

Posted by Sharon – August 21, 2006 1:21 AM

The show is getting intense. I am so excited that Temple is GONE! Alice was deserving of winning but her confidence is still lagging behind. I hope she finds a way to accept that she really is good. Glad to see David dressed for a change but his inflated ego needs to come down a notch. I predict Tym the next to go as he seems too cautious to be creative. I count the hours until the next show!

Posted by LeAnn – August 21, 2006 1:17 AM

I just wanted to let HGTV Design Star know what a fantastic job they are doing. I have never written anything up here before, but I do check out what's going on. I really do love this show! This show can inspire up and coming designer's (like myself) in the world to achieve the unimaginable. Thank you Design Star.

P.S.
Clive, I think you are so hot!!!

Posted by Marquita L. Riddick – August 21, 2006 1:13 AM

At this point I have to say that the race between David and Alice. David has the a way of using color,a way to see the potential of a room that is outside the box. Alice reminds me that working within the box is not always bad. Both would be perfect host of shows and both could inspire a whole new look that is both refreshing and artistic.

I don't see Tym as a challange right now and so far I think he has survived not by his designs and ideas, but rather because he was not the worst of each challange. And his presense does nothing for me. His is a show I would not watch. And I am so tired of him saying what can not be done. Dude, just get in there and do it.

I hate reality shows, and yet this one has captured me. My vote will always be for David, I think he has what it takes.

Posted by Nathan Cieszynski – August 21, 2006 1:12 AM

I'm so glad that Temple went home this week. I just always felt that she was more about selling herself to America than actually beginning a career as a designer who would help the rest of us improve our own living spaces. Maybe she'll get a job in television in some other venue, but I won't be tuning in.

I would be happy to see any of the three remaining designers on their own TV show. Each is likeable and they all seem to really love the work of designing, in addition to having talent for it.

I was a little surprised that none of the four finalists attempted to build a loft bed in the studio spaces -- HGTV has had a lot of shows lately with creative use of tiny apartments and almost always they put the bed up high and use the space underneath for either a closet or additional living space. Maybe I've been watching too much HGTV...

Clive is a terrific host for this program. He holds it all together. I can't wait to see who wins!

Posted by Emily – August 21, 2006 1:12 AM

I have been fans of Alice and David since the beginning. They seem to be the only ones with truly mature minds. I loved the blue room, it achieved exactly what I expected by the challenge, David's red room appealed to me because although Vern thought the TV could have been viewed from the bedroom, was just opposite of what you want in a bedroom. Its to sleep in, and I thought he executed the wall to make it a sleeping room. I only thought that maybe the wall was somewhat too thick and maybe an oriental type screen wall would have perhaps fit the red color scheme better. Great show!! I would never miss an episode.

Posted by Jann Buchholz – August 21, 2006 1:09 AM

i really like the design of Alice the color and the way she did on the color and design of the bedcoverings clean and very refreshing

Posted by sonia – August 21, 2006 1:07 AM

Wow! These contestants are amazing. What they can do with so little money in such a short time! David was a real standout as usual. The remaining three all did a great job on their hosting tapes. I am hooked and can't wait to see next weeks show. I think the new Design Star will be David!

Posted by Terry C – August 21, 2006 12:55 AM

Clive,
Our family watches the show together and tries to guess who did the best, who won't make it, etc. We really enjoy YOU, and hope you have more shows in the future! You bring so much charm to every show in which we have seen you!

Posted by Connie – August 21, 2006 12:47 AM

Wow, I can't believe Design Star only has a couple of weeks left!!! Alice is so good, she's been way too overshadowed by the other LOUD females-Donna, Temple and Vanessa, but no more. I think it could go either way--David or Alice. Love them both, and I will MISS whichever one doesn't win...I wish Design Star could stay on longer so we wouldn't lose either one!!!!

Posted by De-beauvoir – August 21, 2006 12:40 AM

I love this show. And am glad Temple was cancelled. The remaining three have TALENT and they show it. I would watch any of their shows but thought David was not as personable hosting as Tym and Alice were. I can hardly wait until next Sunday!

Posted by Sharon – August 21, 2006 12:32 AM

Clive
I am really surprised Temple and Tym have made it this far. The true designers in thes competition are Alice and David. At this point, anyone who can use red as effectively as David cannot be overlooked. Besides, the guy has been cooperative and willing to follow directions on team projects yet his efforts really shine when he works alone. If he is not the next DESING STAR, surely his future is bright as a much sought-after designer. JER.

Posted by JR Thompson – August 21, 2006 12:31 AM

Love the show! Did not envy the judges tonight. Tough choices. I think overall, Tym's room was the biggest disappointment for me. I like the way David used color, but I'm seeing a pattern in his execution ... very modern. Always. Is that because abstract (as in his wall art tonight) is easier? I'd be very interested in seeing episodes that challenged the contestant's creativity in a theme, i.e. Mission-style, Country French, Southwestern or any other definite look with their own personal twist. After all, interior designers have to please clients, not just themselves. I liked Alice's room, but none of them really wowed me.

Looking forward to next week! Think right now it's a toss-up between David and Alice.

Posted by Dianne DeBorde – August 21, 2006 12:16 AM

Ahhhh . . . finally the Episode Five blog.

I loved seeing what each of the designers could do with his own money and space. And it was great to get a mini-glimpse of how they would host a show. I think Alice is just getting better and better as time goes on. She seems so polished and capable, but still friendly and natural and welcoming -- someone you'd want to "come stay a spell." :D

Tym surprised me with how good a host he was, too. He's my second choice for Design Star.

David didn't finish as strongly as I had expected he would, but he still has a good chance.

And, once again, I'm THRILLED that Miss Prom Queen was finally sent home. To tell the truth, for the most part her rooms weren't bad, but they weren't exceptional either. And she seems like she would be a nightmare to work with.

Clive, as always, is a delight to watch. I love his wicked sense of humor. I think he likes seeing these design hopefuls squirm. ;)

Posted by DJD – August 21, 2006 12:11 AM

I'm shocked after watching tonights episode that Temple was bounced instead of Tym.I just did not get Tym's room.Temple's design surpassed his in appeal. I do love David & he is my favorite choice to be HGTV's new host.

Posted by Lori – August 21, 2006 12:11 AM

As a fellow Texan, I really appreciated Alice's charm and hospitality shining tonight. I usually don't watch reality shows, but since my TV rarely ever changes from this channel (well,I did have to watch the weather channel when Hurricane Rita blew through my city),I'm hooked!! I agreed with Vern about David's room. I would have secluded the bed and not the living space. Alice's room actually looked like she wanted it to feel ... you could see her vision without explaination. I'm glad she did well, and I'm sure she will give David a run for his money. Tym is a little too basic and abstract for my tastes. It would be interesting to see what David would come up with if a client didn't feel his linear , pop art style was for them. I know you are sending finalists across country for the next challenge ..... send Alice to may house so she can put the finishing touches on my "Rita" repairs. Can't wait for the next show!!! And Clive ... you're awesome as always ..

Posted by Beki Burton – August 21, 2006 12:10 AM

Tonights show really kept me on the edge of the couch, because it was really hard to tell who would be asked to leave. Blue is one of my favorite colors and I am so glad that Alice got to do blue in her apartment. She didn't use it in an overpowering way. I think her room design was very cozy and a place I wouldn't mind having if I were single. I have blues in my living room but on as fabric on my couch.

David had a pretty good design, except for the way he divided the room, I think it should have been left a little more open. He could have perhaps divided the bedroom area off with curtains, not such a dark wall. But he still did rather good.

Tym's was okay. Green is also a favorite color of mind, but I didn't care to much for his room design.

I like the color yellow and I think Temple really tried to do a good room, but as far as being a designstar I don't think she would make a good one and it is best that she is gone from the competion.

Clive, I agree that you are a great host, you just add something very special to the show. When will the next season begin for the design star show?

Thanks for letting me tell my opinion.

Posted by Janet – August 21, 2006 12:04 AM

Clive,
I just cannot be anywhere but in front of our TV at
9PM on Sundays! While I loved Alice giving her tour, David seems to have ideas that I have not thought of! I wish he had used only one 5' wall to separate the bedroom and had included a revolving shelf for the TV so it could be viewed from both rooms. His artistic skills comes through in all his rooms! At this point he my "star".

Posted by Julie Kalbrunner – August 20, 2006 11:58 PM

i adore hgtv, i watch it obsessively. i so love to watch the creative process. these last three designers truly shine. their creativity and hard work under such stringent time constraints is truly admirable. i have loved all of alice's designs. they feel so fresh. i love how she pulls colors together, her rooms are inviting and intimate. she also comes across as very, very authentic. she is my favorite. love david's work as well. he is so good with shapes. his designs are sculptural. he, too, comes across as very genuine. i liked what tym did with the sky blue accents inside the windows. can't seem to make a connection with him. i don't think he connects on screen. it appears that he sees the glass as half empty instead of half full. also, if i was watching him on a show i would be wondering if he whined through the whole project. wish you could give alice and david their own individual show. i would hire either of them to design a room in my home.

Posted by michele – August 20, 2006 11:58 PM

I'm impressed with how all of the contestants are working together it is very refreshing.

Posted by Carol – August 20, 2006 11:39 PM

i like David desingS ,he is the# one in the show
and he is goin to be the "Desingstar".
Gracias.

Posted by Roxana – August 20, 2006 11:37 PM

Greetings Clive, I think I was almost as anxious as the four contestants tonight. These four were the best of the ten. I agree that Temple should have been eliminated this week although I preferred her room over Tym's. I agree with Vern, Tym's room did look stark like a college dorm room or worse, a prison! Until he explained it, it didn't have a lot going for it but it should not have needed such an explanation to understand where he was going with his design. From about week three I felt Alice, David, and Tym had the most to offer as design stars. Actually I thought a show with all three would be dynamic since they each have significant strengths that would blend well together. Alice is definitely a standout when it comes to working with fabrics and colors, while David does great art pieces that fit so well with that program's theme. He too, handles color extremely well. And Tym seems to have an exceptional grasp of what is doable when it comes to remodeling and construction. Together these three would be a powerhouse and the best part is they GET ALONG WITH EACH OTHER. They were also appreciative of the workers (and the work they did) assigned to them this week. It's a tough choice between these three but my vote would go to you Clive to be the winner's host.

Posted by Nancy Ottati – August 20, 2006 11:36 PM

All in all I think Alice's room was the best, although David's had the most perspective. I justwouldn't want to live in that kind of a dark chocolate masculine space- however Temple's alternative too cheerful buttercup'n'cream room would make me sick day in and day out (like eating too much birthday cake). Tym's room was cold and boring and since I am not a nature lover the 'earthy park thing' just didn't appeal to me.
I think David should win because he has done the best overall since day one. Alice is sweet but I think she will find other opportunities- host doesn't seem to be her true calling.

Posted by Chani – August 20, 2006 11:32 PM

I LOVE ALICE! She is my favorite "person" of the group. I think the men are both really great, too. Temple...well, if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all...so I won't say anything!

And Clive is just so cute!

Posted by Pam Franklin – August 20, 2006 11:32 PM

Yesss. I have to agree with the judges 100% this week. Temple's design was unexciting and her presentation showed a lack of personality (she even stuck an "or whatever" in there). She sounded disinterested to me.
I think Alice should be the next Design Star. Her design skills have been consistently great and her warmth really came through during the presentation. She outshone David this week in my opinion, and proved she has the personality to carry her own show.

Posted by Dana – August 20, 2006 11:26 PM

I had a really difficult time deciding which one I would have sent home. They were all pretty good although I feel a little dissapointed that Temple didn't use more color in her design. There are many different shades of yellow that she could have incorporated to give her room a little bit of punch. David's designs are persistantly good, Tym really shined through, but Alice just blew me away on this weeks design. Kudos to Alice! Not only did I love her design and use of the shade of blue she chose I enjoyed her presentation to the audiance. I can't wait until next Sunday. I have to admit that I'm a little scared now because all the designers I liked in the beginning are all on the chopping block now and I would hate to see any of the last three go. I'm putting my cards on Alice.

Posted by Greta – August 20, 2006 11:22 PM

YES I THINK ALICE IS THE ONE. DAVID IS TO COCKY, BUT HE IS GOOD, AS IS TYM.....

Posted by DOREEN COLLINS – August 20, 2006 11:11 PM

I really did love Alice's apartment. It was so refreshing; probably because she seems to know how to put a room together. She not only designs well with color; she seems to know exactl;y how to arrange the furniture and accessaries. I so wish she could design my bathrooms. I will be making settlement on the 28th of this month at my newly constructed home. I must say that David is gonna give her a serious fight. He has a unique talent. I think he has this way of putting things together in a way that draws you to particular areas of the room and he has you thinking wow, this room is my own, it allows you to have many areas to gravitate to and has many areas to enjoy and it fills like it's many spaces to admire and and use rather than just your every day boring decor.

Posted by Cheryl Smalley – August 20, 2006 11:11 PM

Alice nailed it with her design tonight! She has so much class and talent! David did a nice job with my favorite color, red, but what was with the bedroom area being open just inside the door and the sitting area isolated? Seemed that he had them backwards. I did not like the green room at all. And honestly, I cheered when Temple left. I'd had about enough of her. It's gonna be a long week waiting for next Sunday night!

Posted by Lisa – August 20, 2006 11:09 PM

YEAH,YEAH,YEAH,TEMPLE IS GONE.THE LAST THREE ARE THE BEST IN THE ORDER OF ALICE,DAVID AND TYM. THESE THREE HAVE SHOWN WHAT THEY ARE MADE OF EVERY SHOW BUT THEY REALLY LITE UP THE SCREEN TONIGHT.

Posted by SANDRA – August 20, 2006 11:07 PM

I LOVE this show. I can't wait to see the winner in a few weeks. I'm really glad that the elimination tonight revealed the real talents and people who were easier to get along with. Temple is pretty but not very good at executing or orchestrating the BIG picture.

Posted by michele – August 20, 2006 11:06 PM

Clive,

I've been watching you on numerous shows on HGTV. In a show like this, I'd love to know how you manage to keep your own feelings so hidden from everyone, including the TV audience. It's got to be hard. The candidates in this Design Star show are all such interesting personalities, and yet you treat them all with the same good and kind grace, with know hint of what you are thinking. You are a real pro, and wow, I sure wouldn't want to play poker with you! I think YOU are one of the biggest Stars on the program!

You Rock, Clive!

Amanda

Posted by Amanda Nelson – August 20, 2006 11:05 PM

Clive, I'm hooked on Design Star! Great concept and I really like that the challenges change every week. Tonite the show was exciting to watch and yet a little sad because these folks all seem to have alot of talent and I'm sure it's very hard to lose now. I agree with the judges, Alice was the clear winner and has been my favorite for the past few episodes. Can't wait until next week, thanks again! Cindy

Posted by Cindy – August 20, 2006 11:03 PM

Well, thank goodness Temple is gone. Last week Donna now her younger version.
I think the final three are the most creative of the entire bunch.
I think Tym's choice of color hues were great, but his room didn't seem finished. It was stark and cold just like the judges said. Not cozy like a bringing the outside in room would be.
Temple's room was okay, but way too bland. I feel she could've kicked it up a lot.
Alice, well now, I actually like her final product but her color choice just didn't do it for me. I applaud the fact that she didn't go with simple plain blue, but pastelly colors are not my thing. I think she could've mixed it up a little more and brought in some other hues of the blue in a treatment for the walls.
David, I liked his design better than any of them, but I also agreeed with the judges that the wall closed the space in. A floaty fabric curtain would have delineated the space and still kept the open feeling much better than a wall. Even if he would've shortened the wall I think it would have made a better impact on openess.
I also agree with the judges on the paint thing. I get that paint is the best way to get color into a room, but mix it up a little. I've seen designers use fabric and ribbons to cover a wall. Heck even Hilde on Trading Spaces used hay and plastic flowers on the wall for color. Not my thing, but we need more creativity in the color department.
As for the presentations, I feel that Tym won that deal. Sorry, but he was more relaxed and open than any of the others. Alice ran a close second to me, but remember this is my opinion.
I really feel the two strongest candidates are Alice and David. Tym has some great ideas, but he lacks the end result that has to be there. His concepts are good, but as evident tonight he lacks the warmth factor as I call it or the finishing stages to make a room done and feel welcoming.

Clive you rock. I love your show and I look forward to a new one every week. I just happened to see a commercial that said you'll be on five times a week starting in September. Man am I in heaven. I can't wait till next month.

Posted by Sienna – August 20, 2006 11:00 PM

Yea! for the fact you brought in a carpenter assistant for each contestent this time around. It really allowed the designers to concentrate on the looks of their rooms.
It was somewhat of a surprise that everyone came up with pleasing designs for their rooms over all.
My favorite room was Alices, and the prize went to the right person, and her presentation was also the best. She made you feel like she was welcoming her into her own home with charm and grace. She has star quality in all areas, and I am glad she got to show what she is really capable of.
The next best room was Davids. Kind of hep urban and warm. I do agree with Vern that his room felt a little confining with that divider. He was the weakest on presentation and I wanted him to slow down. He shows a lot of what he can do by thinking outside the box with creativity. I just hope his stage presence isn't going to be his down fall when it comes to talking to the camera.
Tym's room was good but lacking, in that the first thing I noticed, was that there did not seem to be any art on the walls. I did not like his snack table area at all. I have to wonder if he either didn't think of art, or ran out of time and money to get some. He did well in his presentation...not the best, but very well.
He believes in himself and has talent, but needs to step it up a notch.
Temple's room was pretty, but lacked any personality. All yellow and white could have stood a splash of accent color somewhere....anywhere in that room. She presented well, but over all seemed to lack imagination to put her over the edge. The right decision was made by the judges on this episode.

I honestly was thinking that if Tym hasn't used his color as well as he did, and if Temple had use hers a little better, she could have been the one ending up staying, and Tym could have been the one going tonight. He is hanging on by a thread at this point. Unless David and Alice make big mistakes next week, I see Tym being the next one to go.
The best three are left, and the more I see of Alice, the better I like her as the next design star.
David is a strong second at this point.
Next week should prove to be even more interesting.
This weeks show was what it should have been about all along. Although I must admit the bickering and drama were entertaining along with some weird personalities, it was beginning to be a bit much.
I will chime in to say good job Clive. I catch your Design to Sell show whenever I can...even the repeats. The judges have done a good job, with the exception of Joseph, so far.

Posted by Barb – August 20, 2006 10:58 PM

Alice hit the nail on the head. Light, breezy, calming,and restful. All the things that a studio apartment in New York City needs. David's was exciting, but a little closed in. I would think that you would get very tired of the design very quickly. Temple's I felt had no depth, could have used the yellow more creatively. She has great natural talent and should persue her dream, DON'T give up Temple. I didn't get Tym's at all. I think maybe Tym's negativity hold's him back. Maybe he's not a team player! When designing you work with a team, whether it is painters, carpenter's, seamster's etc... and you have to be able to play the game and work together or you will be there by yourself!

Posted by Amelia Killingsworth – August 20, 2006 10:58 PM

Clive -
Nice to see Alice come through with "flying colors" this time! She is very personable and was most at ease with the hosting style.

However, I've been most blown away by David's eye for original designs and uses of color. It looks like he was a little unprepared for the on camera part, but...I think he's a winner. David's unique ideas, realistic planning, easy-going style along with his ability to get people to pull together make him a great candidate for hosting a new show!

Posted by M White – August 20, 2006 10:55 PM

Clive,
I have to agree with Dee Nelson that Alice is my preference for next Design Star. From the very beginning, her unaffected attitude and mannerly appreciation of her competitors' work impressed me. Then, on the first challenge she was so considerate of Ramona's odd ideas and comments, all the while moving ahead to make her part of the room as good as she could. In the ensuing challenges, she has produced a fresh, uncomplicated but comfortable feel in each space. She uses color well, not tritely or in a boring manner. I think it was ingenious that she cut up a bookcase to construct accessory boxes for camping equipment behind the sofa. I would welcome her to work on my spaces.
Temple has real innate talent as has been said so often by the judges, but she needs education to refine and develop her raw ability. Beauty queen or not, a pretty face will not always last while education can always be a benefit.
Tym is a bit strange - putting dog cages on the wall was a creative idea, but not at all inviting. His latest effort creating the green efficiency did not feel like he was "bringing the outdoors in"; Vern's comment about summer camp was right on.
David is awesome, but although his designs are creative and well-executed, I would not ask him to work on my spaces. His taste is too edgy and
sleek for a home where my family lives. On the plus side, I must applaud his self-confidence plus good sense which aids his design process without permitting him to become arrogant or insufferable toward the other designers.
Couldn't we choose TWO? Alice and David?

Posted by J.G. Singer – August 20, 2006 10:55 PM

I *knew* it would come down to these three-David, Tym, and Alice.

David has wonderful vision and each week I can't wait to see what he has designed. The judges were right this week--his studio seemed a little claustrophobic!

Alice is so bubbly and warm--a fantastic personality! I love the way her studio turned out--very tranquil and serene.

Tym seems to fall just short of the mark. When he explains his vision it seems wonderful but it always seems to be just a touch off.

Temple? Bland, bland, bland! There was so much she could have done--yellow prints on the furniture or a textured wall. All I kept thinking of when I saw her studio was "bread and butter".

I think the judges will have a tough time from this point on!

My first reality show and I'm loving it!

Posted by terann – August 20, 2006 10:53 PM

Hi Clive,
So far I like David's designs best overall. I would love to see him become HGTV's Design Star. I hope next week he lets more of his personality out during his presentation because I think he's a great designer.

Posted by Vicki DeSerisy – August 20, 2006 10:53 PM

I love Alice's personality. She has such charm! Her designs so far have been okay, but nothing stellar. She has some great ideas.

Tym's design was lacking. I do love how he describes things, however.

David is the one I'd hire to come to my house. I loved the brown with the red. He didn't go overboard on the red. David, I need your help. Will you come to my house?

Posted by Reg – August 20, 2006 10:51 PM

David rocks!!

I'm only watching this for him. He knows how to execute under pressure like the rest of the gang, but he has an edge. His pieces are always finished to the tee and it's honest. It really wouldn't be fair if he didn't win. Team David all the way.

Posted by Caroline – August 20, 2006 10:48 PM

WOW! What a great show. Definitely Alice - she is not "full of herself" or "unsure of herself". She is confident yet not over-confident. She does not have to congratulate herself or berate herself. Go Alice!

Posted by Leigh – August 20, 2006 10:47 PM

you know you all said that temple would go this week and guess what you were all right. and then you all left tyn and why i dont know. he has no personality, he says he is going to do all this and has grand ideas but i havent seen any thing as yet. but hes still there. why the one that has the least experience you let go,but i least she tried. i think david has great style, ans alice too. i think this programe is unperticable and very unfair.

Posted by MFEMFEM MFEMFEM – August 20, 2006 10:45 PM

Clive -
Talk about personality - thats you!
I am so happy to see that you are hosting so many fun shows on HGTV. You are really giving HGTV a flare of wit and sarcasm - even my husband is watching now!
Keep up the good work.

On a side note... David and Alice will most certainly be the last 2 finalist. I wish they could fly to my house and do something fun here!!
GM

Posted by Giselle – August 20, 2006 10:45 PM

This show is the last one I watch before retiring to bed at night, intense enough that I can't just fall into a restful sleep. I just have to respond now to get my thoughts out of my head while they're still fresh in my memory. Compliments to the people who have made this show such a success. We love it and can't wait for each week to see the new use of our designers and their work... Clive you also make for some of the finishing touches of this program too!!!

This was a very unique experience to say the least, however, as a designer each one has to think quick, but not more than they can actually execute as we saw last week. I thought they all did very well with their room designs, but we all know that one had to be eliminated. I thought Temples's room was decorated very nicely, but as previously said, a little too much yellow & white. Her curtain to close off the kitchen area when entertaining... to give additional definition to the space, was excellent, but perhaps with a bit more color or imagery to really catch an eye or two. Also bringing in more contrasting colors & prints with more pillows on her daybed and on the walls would have given it more punch and pizazz. The desk/table and daybed ideas were really good. You did great Temple for not having had any formal education or training as a professional designer and you did excellent in this competition. Good luck with your future career in design. Alice's room was very well executed and decorated as I expected it would be. She definitely has a "gift" for being a designer and has a very good chance of winning this competition. She seemed very natural on her hosting skills with a very pleasant voice and graceful poise as well. She has really been on top with her design skills and works exceptionally hard at completely any of the tasks that she has had too and then some. She certainly was a very excited and deserving winner in today's competition!! Congrats to you Alice!!! Tym's room was way too green for my liking and the print bedspread was much too loud and gaudy. It seemed to draw the eye to the "bed" rather than more interesting places in the space or the space itself. To me, that is not what I would want people to focus on. I felt that either Temple or Tym were going to go tonight. Tym definitely has puzzled my husband & I as to what his thoughts are sometimes with his designs. Perhaps he needs to chill and stop worrying so much about wanting to win. Sometimes just that can make things worse rather than better. Good luck next week Tym. By the way, your hosting skills weren't bad at all!! Last, but not least, David's space was definitely defined, but maybe too defined. When I have someone come into my home, the last place I want people to see as they enter my home is the "bedroom". That's my private space and so why make that the focal point when entering the home. Alice and Tym did that same thing, but somehow because David's was walled in, it seemed much more prominent and less private. Perhaps that's my taste, but it just did not give me a real good feeling upon seeing his completed space. His color use did define his room, but did not overpower it nor did it make the space too bland as in 2 of the other rooms. He is gifted, but this apt. just seemed a little too boxed in for such a small space. Good luck to you too David next week. You are really a talented designer!!

Posted by Karen – August 20, 2006 10:40 PM

I thought the judges missed it this week...badly! While I agree that Alice is by far the "cutest", her color scheme was, in my opinion, pretty putrid. David was, again in my opinion, the outright winner. What a great use of the color red. His artwork is also the best each week.
I did agree with the judges to eliminate Temple. But honestly, she probably should have been eliminated much earlier as she is NOT a team player and in the "real world", you have to be a team player. You can't stomp your foot because you don't get your way.
Tym did a great job too. I believe you can not go wrong when you "bring the outdoors inside".
I'm thinking David will be the next "Design Star".

Posted by Sarah D – August 20, 2006 10:39 PM

Dear Clive and Cast Members,
I felt tonights show help me see the talent and style of each individual. I also believe Alice did extremely well in her presentation and you enjoy watching her. After all, we are the ones who will be watching or NOT watching your show in the future. That presentation was very important. We all have our favorite show and designer and Lisa La Porta is no. 1 in my book! You and she are a great team!

Posted by Debra Henson – August 20, 2006 10:39 PM

I agree with Clive that Temple did not expand the use of the color in an imaginative manner. And I agree with the judges assessment of Tym's talent, vision and results. I hope that he is able to bring all his designing assets together to create environments that knock us out. I'm not sure if Alice is the next design star. I've yet to be convinced that she can break space down and reinvent. Tym and David are going to give her a run for the money. Good Luck to all the designers. I'm crazy about this show.

Posted by alice adams – August 20, 2006 10:38 PM

There is only word to describe David - FABULOUS! His design and his vision is incredible. His shyness and nervousness in front of the camera just proves to me that he is not full of himself and is completely real. In due time, he will make a wonderful design host. He has it all - looks, smile and most of all TALENT! I'm rooting for you - Dave!

Posted by Catherine Barrera – August 20, 2006 10:36 PM

I am so glad Temple was booted off...I would not watch a show with her as the star. She is a trouble maker with no leadership or teamwork skills. While Donna had some issues, I thought she was just defending herself and I felt sorry for her because Temple was so condesending and mean. I thought that was mean saying she was thirty years her senior (I think she is 30 and Donna is 49...that is 19).

Glad Vanessa is gone; she was stuck up. Confidence is one thing but she thought she was a shoe in because of all her experience...the other contestents have experience too and they don't brag. Plus she was a liar and took all the credit for the group, no responsibility for mistakes.

I think David will win. Alice is good too but I think David has a slight edge with his designs.

Posted by Angie – August 20, 2006 10:34 PM

Hi Clive,

Wow, this week was stressful to watch!

Temple's space was not on the level of Alice and David. The training is beginning to set people apart. It was her time to go.
Tym's space probably was better in person. It was institutional via the television, not warm. Very minimal. His presentation was 'This Old House'.
David's space was vibrant and sophisticated. You have to wander through to catch sight of all details as they unfold in his spaces. This to me is a great example of thoughtful design. The dark colors are not my preference but he did a fab job. He was very nervous through his presentation. He has presented on camera so well until now in various conversations.
Alice was the package this week. The design space was creative, hip and livable. Her presentation was the best. Her space was very serene and soothing. Her space could easily be printed and value added to a magazine spread.
I appreciate the artistic touches of both Alice and David. I know David painted his and I am assuming Alice did the graphic black and white sketches as well.

Looking forward to next week. I predict Alice or David.

Posted by kcordiak – August 20, 2006 10:34 PM

I wish all three could win! What a great trio. I don't want to kick Temple when she's down and out, but I'm glad she's gone.

Posted by Nancy – August 20, 2006 10:33 PM

Clive,
I have enjoyed watching the "stars" each week and seeing each of them grow or not. I am so torn between David and Alice. I believe each of them is so unique in their own way. I love David's use of color and his creativity with "projects", yet Alice has a creative insight with both color and fabric. I would love to see her do something more challenging to see how she does. I will keep watching.

Posted by Julie – August 20, 2006 10:33 PM

This was the best show yet! The designers really shined in a more realistic situation. I was very happy to see that they each got some extra help.

Alice was wonderful! Her design was great and she was so CUTE (without overdoing it) in her presentation. Alice, as one Texan to another, can you come to my home and design my family room? You've got what it takes, gal!

Posted by Susan – August 20, 2006 10:28 PM

Hi Clive,

What a great show this week...it was wonderful to watch the designers have complete responsibility for their rooms....and then have the opportunity to present them. I don't care for blues, but I did like Alice's room - and it really came alive when she "hosted" it! Great personality on camera....I also thought Tim came across very well on camera, but I wasn't thrilled with his use of green - especially that bright green bed. I liked his potential Asian theme, but would've liked to see more sagey greens in play. Temple is so talented, but I wished she had used more rich colors instead of white to balance the yellow. She is adorable and I hoped she would make it all the way. David's use of color and his way of "changing" the room space was fantastic, as usual. But I thought his presentation was rushed and I wanted more from him regarding his interpretation of his room. The next few weeks are going to be very challenging because all the contenders are worthy of their own shows at this point! When does the next "Design Star" begin? Will this be a regular program? I hope so.....God bless....

Posted by Laura O. – August 20, 2006 10:27 PM

i have to say i was somewhat disappointed with david's design this week. i thought the space was too cut up and blocked off with the partitions, especially the 'living room'. alice won my vote and i'm happy she was picked as this week's winner.

Posted by sharon – August 20, 2006 10:27 PM

After last week's disaster challenge, this week was pure pleasure! We finally got to see what each designer was all about. Alice was the definite star this week. She deserved to be the winner. David was a disappointment. He did not show well in his presentation. I thought his room was too broken and confining, and entering directly into the bedroom area seemed strange. Even though I did not hate Temple's room, it was time for her to go. She just does not fit the picture of a design star. I am now anxious to see how all of this plays out. Good show!

Posted by Nancy – August 20, 2006 10:26 PM

Great show tonight. I was glad to see that the contestants were given carpenters to help out with things they would never have been able to do alone. I was quite impressed with all of them, it's amazing to me that anyone could work under such pressure. I sure wouldnt have wanted to be one of the judges this week. As much as I have thought in the past that Temple's attitude should cost her the win, I must admit I liked her room. It was bright and well put together. I dunno about the angles on the rugs either, but it didnt really have that negative of an effect for me as it did for the judges. I liked Tym's room as well, even though I have not been much of a fan of his either. I have to admit though that I dont really get his personal sense of design which is rather stark. I think David is extremely talented and his leaving clothes on this episode did not take away from that. My only negative about David's room was that his designs are so distinctive that they run the risk of all starting to look the same, which can get old very quickly. My vote goes to Alice! My 8yr old would like to vote for David, he thinks he rocks! I really loved Alice's before the camera bit. She expressed exactly what I imagined she would in front of the camera which was warmth, professionalism, and a comfort and knowledge about what she did and why she did it. I was quite surprised to see the others as nervous as they all appeared in comparison. GO ALICE!

Posted by Diane – August 20, 2006 10:24 PM

I absoultely LOVED this episode. It let the designers show their true colors so to speak (haha punn. im so lame) and it really showed again who has what it takes.

I did not like who was voted off though. i thought temple's design, though sort of bland, was stronger than tyms. what was up with that LIME GREEN sheet on the bed? it did not match anything in that room and it looked like a color you'd find a crayola coloring box. And the dark blue rug out of no-where confused me a bit.

At least temples was warm like she sought out to do, while tym's was cold and kind of hodge-podged.

All in all i believe that Alice was the best choice and I was happy to see her win. Shes so adorable and i loved her design.

umm and someone tell tym what a comb is..please?

Posted by Samwhiches – August 20, 2006 10:24 PM

I think all the designers did a great job. Even though Temple has driven me crazy week after week, she still did a wonderful job, considering she has no experience.

I agree with Dee that Tym seems to fall short each week, but definately has personality and enough of the "right stuff" to make it.

Alice is such a pure delight to watch and listen to.

Her designs are all very pretty at the end of the show and I would look forward to watching her, but
I still haven't seen anything "extra-special" from her work.

David......now....and wow! Although his presentation seemed to be lacking compared to the other designers, I felt that his designs are always well above the others. He seems to put that "extra" tweek in everything he does. I am sure that producers can help him get over the camera shyness.

Posted by cindy – August 20, 2006 10:23 PM

Just had to watch this week. All of the people took the color and went with it. I especially loved David's design with the touches of red. He is the only one that didn't take the color and paint it all over the walls. I hoped that he would have been better in his presentation because during the other parts of the filming of the show, I think he really shines. Hope he relaxes more next week.
Tym has good thoughts and does his best but gets all nerved up when he executes. I thought his presentation was better than I would have expected.
Alice's design was nifty too. I think she admitted that this was her third take. I wonder how many takes the other contestants had before they got to get their best take?
I'm pulling for one of the guys to win the DESIGN STAR. Possibly be the next Vern Yip with a little more hip in design and youthful qualities in presentation. I think David is the one I'd choose at this point.

Posted by Jackie Landon – August 20, 2006 10:22 PM

I enjoy this week with the designers working alone again. The good, bad and ugly rests solely in their laps. I thought each room has something that stood out, but I liked Alice's room the best. And unless Tym really steps up to the plate, I believe we'll be seeing Alice and David as the 2 finalists...

Posted by Tina – August 20, 2006 10:19 PM

What a relief! Finally a great challenge to showcase the talent. Sooooo glad Temple is gone - would not have liked to watch her prance around the camera on a weekly basis. All of the other designers did great work and had great camera presence. Happy to see they got help too. I couldn't agree with judges more regarding Alice's room and hope she has a wonderful time with Instyle. I would feel very comfortable watching Tym, Alice or David as a design star, best of luck to all three of them. Clive - you are a treat to watch - loved the new commercial tonight for Designed to Sell.

Posted by bd – August 20, 2006 10:18 PM

Clive:

I wish HGTV could pick two designers instead of one because I love Alice's design ideas and they way she handles herself speaking to the public on camera. I love David's design ideas, his execution of the color red was outstanding, and I love the way he paints his pictures and threw the color red, all the way around the room. As a judge, I would pick two designers instead of one. Because Alice and David would be my choice and I think they would work well with each other, I love them both. Its getting down to three great designers and the choice will be soooo difficult.

Posted by Shirley Harold – August 20, 2006 10:18 PM

Alice really was a shining star in this episode. What a beautiful use of color. She really "gets it." I'm hoping she'll keep coming through...

Posted by Caffery – August 20, 2006 10:17 PM

The In-Style Editor's bias againstTemple was evident again. I could see living in Temple's studio unit, and next choice would have been David's. Tym can't seem to execute. By the Judges' comments I was sure he was gone. I think the others thought so too. Alice did very well on the host aspect. I'm not sure she has the best ideas, however. The idea of competing designs and follow-thru has tremendous pull - I just think the limitations are too extreme.

Posted by Nancy Richmond – August 20, 2006 10:16 PM

Well I think it's safe to say who the next "Design Star" will be. David is just a genious when it comes to interior spaces. Without fail he can use limited materials and budget to create rooms that seem to cost tens of thousands more. Every one of his rooms are emotionally satisfying as well. Keep it up David and your going to be giving Candace Olson a run for her money!

Posted by Tiffany – August 20, 2006 10:16 PM

Well I think that David used RED sparingly enough and brown was a good choice as well...BUT, Vern was right in that he might've made it to where the roomspaces were not so permanently or highly divided so as not to see the whole place., all in all great job I think he or Alice will win!

Posted by delia medina – August 20, 2006 10:15 PM

I'm loving the show and anxious for the next episode, as always. I think Alice did a fantastic job on her television appearance and her peaceful, airy room. She has a quality that supports and appreciates those she works with. That basic character showed when she acknowledged her contractor in the T.V. appearance segment, the only one who did. At this point, I think Alice will win and should. I think David's design knowledge is excellent and he will probably be runner-up.

Posted by Kat Horton – August 20, 2006 10:14 PM

love this show; and how these designers grow (with the show). Love, Love Clive on this show and with Lisa on Design to sell. Keep up the great work. Love you all and God bless you all on your journeys. David loved your RED room. It was the best one on the eyes.

Posted by patty – August 20, 2006 10:13 PM

Great show! I really liked that they had to present their rooms -- it appeared to save Tym! I think the right person went home. Looking forward to next week!

Posted by PJ – August 20, 2006 10:13 PM

Now we're talking!! I loved Alice's design and presentation. I was also a little worried about David this week, but he pulled it off. Tym's presentation saved him and I really want to see him win a challenge. Glad to see Temple go, finally!!

I was also happy to see everyone assigned a carpenter. It made this challenge a little more realistic; however, thinking about the real shows on HGTV, there are so many people helping (on and off camera) that they make it possible to get a zealous design delivered. It seems each week the contestants are getting pinged for ambition, but once they get their own show, they should be able to make their ideas a reality on time and on budget.

Good show this week and can't wait for next Sunday!

Posted by dd – August 20, 2006 10:11 PM

David is the best hes probably gonna be the next design star. GO DAVID GO!!!

Posted by Sameer – August 20, 2006 10:11 PM

Judges were spot on this week. Best episode so far.

Posted by kate – August 20, 2006 10:08 PM

Have to say that Alice's room looked the most like it was done by a true designer. I especially liked that she took the cabinet doors off and did the inside backs with the black. It really made them look professional and different. I loved the pops of black and brown mixed with the blue. Temples room was way to bland. It was not awful except for the rugs on diagonal and I thought it was set up more for bedroom use than for a living room. She didn't add the extra little surprising pops that I see most designers on tv use. That's why I like all of these shows to see new things. Davids room was nice but the divider wall was way too heavy and obstructing in such a small space. Tym's design is not my taste but he does go against the traditional grain and seems to try and add some surprising touches to every room. He definitely has to lift it higher next week. As of now I'm for Alice.

Posted by paula – August 20, 2006 10:08 PM

I totally agree with the judges both David and Tym did okay with their rooms, although Tym's did need more explaining to understand all his ideas. But Alice shined in both her design and presentation! Temple's leaving was to be expected it was only a matter of when. Way to go Alice.

Posted by audrey – August 20, 2006 10:07 PM

I really enjoyed David's room -- it was nice the way he partitioned it off into living spaces and his creative use of color. Tym's room seemed a little depressing but I did like the way he made the bed "separate"

Temples room seemed a bit Ikea-ish but so did Alices. I'll be excited to see who the next design star is!

Posted by Tracy – August 20, 2006 10:07 PM

I think that Tym should have been the one to be cancelled. His design was stark and confusing. He tried his best to sabotage Temple's kitchen last week, spending precious man hours arguing with her about whether something could be done rather than trying to do it.

Temple's room this week may not have been the best one, but it was certainly more comfortable than Tym's.

Posted by Catherine – August 20, 2006 10:06 PM

Thankfully, Donna was let go. Her design sense was seriously lacking, it seemed that all she really was interested in was shopping!! Nothing wrong with that, she would be great as an assistant to a designer--she did find great deals
and that is a talent. But difficult to deal with.
Given the extreme time constraints, true creativity shines through...David is so sensitive to color and space. I just loved the red room, and I hate the color red and the very modern style he incorporated. BUT he made that space feel much larger....a folding screen at the end of the bedroom would have made him the winner hands down.

Posted by Hilarie – August 20, 2006 10:06 PM

Oh yeah! Temple's gone. Her room was mediocre at best. Tym does need to work more on bringing to more positive fruition his design visions but from here on out it is going to be a hard decision for the judges. These three have all got it going on. Good luck to them all!

Posted by Reese – August 20, 2006 10:05 PM

Clive
I just love the color that Alice used in her apartment. We all seem to be in a "basic" color, and going outside of the circle with that color was unique. She seems to have a way with color with her designs.
I wasn't too impressed with Temple's use of her color. Even though the color was cheerful, it still seem bland.
Tym just seem to have it with his designs. He "gets there, and then just falls short in his execution".
David, David, David! He has a personality that show in all his designs. He used his red in moderation.
I think Alice is the next "DESIGN STAR"!

Posted by Dee Nelson – August 20, 2006 9:53 PM