Be the first to comment! Enter your comment in the form below.

I am not one to watch TV... but this series has had me glued to the tube every Sunday night. Clive has such a quick wit and the individuals chosen to compete had such a diverse and unique chemistry. I look forward to next year (I HOPE they do it again!)oh.. and Vern.. lighten up a bit!.... grin

Posted by Kelly – September 11, 2006 4:14 PM

This show was incredible! I was so afraid that the television public would not pick the true talent -- but they did! David is an incredible designer and I want to use his skills. I'm looking forward to his design show. Congratulations David and congratulations, HGTV.

Posted by Brenda – September 11, 2006 12:18 PM

Caught the final segment. But, missed the comparison between Alice and David. Rest of my family both wanted David to win.

Posted by Jon Bond – September 10, 2006 11:50 PM

I am glad David won. He really deserves it. His design has been very consistent with creativity. All of his designs were very impressive. Even though there were a lot of emotions involved, he had been very focused. He really stole the show in the last design which he designed a great bedroom in a glass box. Every one would love to lay on that bed, feeling very peaceful. That's the core product of what a great designer should come up with --- viewer wants to live there! That was a real test for both of David and Alice. In my opinion, Alice blew the last one because of limitation of her creativity in comparison to David.

Posted by Julia B Land – September 10, 2006 11:29 PM

Absolutely loved the show! Of course I was a fan of ALL the design shows but this was quite interesting to see the different design styles and personalities emerging. Loved Alice's personality and her style but David's rooms were so consistently my favorites. His pet store room blew me away. That was a quirky show but some of the rooms were quite inventive considering the materials available. Can't wait till the finale tonight...but guess I have to. Know I won't miss it or the show if it is repeated next season. Thanks for the wonderful entertainment. Wish you could both win.

Posted by Paulette – September 10, 2006 9:55 PM

I have enjoyed some aspects of the program but I hope, if you do it again, you will not focus as much on the drama as you did during this series. I think that's what made Trading Spaces jump the proverbial shark.

While I love the idea of a contest with the winner getting his/her own show, I think far too much focus was placed on the drama, ie: Ramona from that trading spouses reality show, and Donna & Temple's silly cat fights. (How many women cringed at seeing women portrayed in that light?)

I suspect most HGTV viewers watch the programs for the design rather than the drama. There are dozens and dozens of reality programs on tv already. Give us more design and less drama next year.

Also, the guy that was elminated prematurely should be brought back again next season. Joseph?Can't remember his name but he's the one that was eliminated the week that chick with the glasses should have gone.

BTW, congratulations David and Alice.

Posted by candide – September 10, 2006 8:07 PM

I voted for david because of his dreamy pecs!

Posted by mike – September 10, 2006 7:57 PM

David is my design star whether he wins or not!!! Go DAvid!! You rock!!

Posted by Judy – September 10, 2006 5:47 PM

I love Alice's personality and talent. David is very good, too. Yes, a show for each of them!

Posted by Anne Grande – September 10, 2006 5:33 PM

Are you kidding? Dani's post above says "David's obviously trying to win votes by working with his shirt off. While he has a good physique, it's very unprofessional
I totally disagree, I loved him with his shirt off, he looked amazing, lets keep the eye candy coming :)

Posted by Dawn – September 10, 2006 4:49 PM

I absolutely love the show! It was well worth watching once Donna was eliminated. Although the vacuum lady was horrible, Donna should have been the first to go! She completely left the two gentlemen doing the patio area penniless the first day and they had to makeup for lost time due to her poor planning and time management. The only thing Donna was good at was shopping. I, like the judges, never got the feeling of her design style.

Looking forward to next season!

Hey Clivie, love you on Design to Sell:)

Thanks,

Dayna

Posted by Dayna – September 10, 2006 1:15 AM

Sorry I missed the last show. I think that although I believe David had the better design that week, I would chose Alice as Design Star/Host because her designs are more functional and she has the flair to make an audience very comfortable.

Posted by carole – September 9, 2006 11:50 PM

Why can't they both be on a show together? There is such good chemistry between them. Just like Matt and Sherri on Room by Room.

Posted by Cora Clampitt – September 9, 2006 7:23 PM

I love David. His final room was wonderful. I hope he wins.

Posted by KAREN – September 9, 2006 7:18 PM

I loved the show - and was anxious to see the new show each week. I am going to miss it on Sunday evenings. Both of the final designers are great. I was disappointed, however, that the judges who were not to judge the final design made such a presence on the final show and made comments. They seemed that they had an obvious choice that thay wanted to win.

Posted by Nancy – September 9, 2006 6:44 PM

I know everyone loves David, but my favorite is Alice. I like how she uses practicality in her designs and doesn't just focus on how good it looks. I think David is a great designer, and his rooms usually turn out nice, but they got predictable after a while. Modern/contemporary artwork, clean lines, only a couple of colors, in like EVERY room!!!!!. I think that Alice dishes out different styles each time and is so comfortable in front of the camera. I didn't like Alice's "mancave" though bc all the furniture was crowded onto the back wall. Over all, I think that David is the better designer, but I would MUCH rather watch a show with Alice. I like her personality better. She is more humble, fun, and bubbly. A sure winner in my mind!!! As for the rest of the contestants, I wish them the best luck but I do think we have the right final two. That's what happens when the judges, NOT America, decides. ;) I hope Designstar continues next season. And alice, I will watch your show!!!!!! You are the BEST!!!

Posted by Ashley – September 9, 2006 5:32 PM

A request for next season: there are lots of us "wannabe" designers who have followed each challenge on the edge of our seats and wonder what we would have done with a similar space. PLEASE, give us the dimensions of the space/s, and floor plans from each episode! I could spend many happy hours putting my own creative touches on those spaces, using the judges' comments, just for the fun of learning.

Thanks for a great show!

Posted by Carrie – September 9, 2006 2:49 PM

With the glass houses, I would have like to have seen a greenhouse/garden room/porch theme done.

Posted by JB – September 9, 2006 11:03 AM

I was already to vote for Alice, but this last episode showed that David is brilliant. I don't know what posessed Alice to do a childs room and then use a white bedspread and those tacky hand drawn pictures. It ruined the look of the room.

Posted by Melody – September 9, 2006 11:02 AM

I really love HGTV, and I've been following the Design Star from the beginning. However, neither of the final 2, looking at the whole contest, seems worthy of their own design show. Those people are right about David, this isn't Porn Star, it's Design Star, and he seemed arrogant as Vanessa. Alice always seems so sweet, but just one step behind. Nothing she did (besides her hosting skills) "wowed" me. Because of this, I ended up not voting at all!

I couldn't choose who was the most worthy, I felt like neither deserved my vote. These people are right, they should allow these 2 to work together and co-host their own show. Alice is a great presenter and can balance out David's zen side, whereas David has that "wow" factor in his imagination. thanks for the show!

Posted by JAH – September 9, 2006 2:24 AM

David and Alice have such chemistry together. I hope whichever one gets their own show has the option of inviting the other one to be a guest on their show or even better a cohost. They compliment and balance each other beautifully. I have really enjoyed watching them progress through the competition because they were both such good sports as well as being talented and attractive. When I first saw the commercials for this new "reality show" called Design Star I rolled my eyes and decided I wouldn't watch. My curiosity and my appreciation of Clive's hosting abilities won me over. I hope the next season is as good if not better.

Posted by Liz – September 8, 2006 11:19 PM

Wow - a hard decision when you look back over all of the shows. However, for the last design challenge, David had a more polished and complete room.

How much more beautiful Alice's room would have been if her bedspreads had been colorful with polka-dots to carry out the theme from the chandelier...and if her artwork and inspirational words had been painted with translucent paints on the glass instead of on white boards and the "not-at-all-attractive headboards. Soft and Puffy, sculptured hot pink and/or lime green headboards would have been SO much better!

I think David will win and he has my vote from this last challenge, but BOTH would be great assets to any show. Possibly the "non-winner" could be a guest-designer for Designer's Challenge or another show....?

Posted by J.J. – September 8, 2006 11:00 PM

I think this is a great show and I have thoroughly enjoyed it. I have always thought David should be the final one. I do think that if you do it again that it would be great if we could see what it is like for the designer to interact with a client. I wish them all well. The design business can be trying sometime. Thank you for the great entertainment.

designer, SDG

Posted by SDG – September 8, 2006 10:52 PM

I think David should win because he is just great all around! He is a godly man a wonderful designer and he just deserves to have this show! I think he is a great role modle!

Posted by Autumn Joy Davis – September 8, 2006 8:45 PM

David got my votes for his incredible design talent; cannot WAIT to see his show.

And, I agree with everyone else; Alice is adorable and fresh, and HGTV should NOT let her go away. I would love to see her grow and mature with her own show as well, even if only on a consultancy basis.

Glad (DD?) addressed Temple; I totally agree. Temple's behavior was absolutely appalling and unacceptable, and I'm stunned she was allowed to publicly humiliate Donna in that way. In fact, I believe the HGTV audience may have been cheated out of truly fine work because Donna (with 20 years' experience!) really did not have the chance to express herself freely. Temple is not a nice person.

The first reality show I cared about. Overall, good job, HGTV. You're still the channel of choice for me!!

Posted by Susan1 – September 8, 2006 8:18 PM

I've watched the final challenge three times, and am still amazed at the wonderful work that David had done. The room he created was warm, inviting and relaxing. It was if you could almost forget that you were in the middle of a park, and lie on this beautiful bed and imagine you were in a moment of solitude. I was enthralled and impressed with all of his designs throughout the show. He is a true professional.

I was a bit disappointed in Alice's design. I expected more from her than that, and her work seemed childish, at best. While I agree with most people that her online presence is astounding, her work does not measure up to that of a "design star".

Posted by Melissa – September 8, 2006 6:50 PM

I only just came in to watch the last two episodes and I love both David and Alice. I think they both have talent.

I also can't vote as I would vote for both of them and also cancel out my vote.
Good luck to both of them!

Posted by Laura – September 8, 2006 6:36 PM

I am transfixed by this show, like a housewife hooked on soap operas! (neither of which applies to me). I do adore chic design and suspense thrillers – voila, Design Star has the winning combo! Suspense, action, stunning designs from David, so week after week I root for him. His designs are superior to anyone else’s – his vision, style, execution, equate a professional designer, whereas others conjure up pleasant designs of a hobbyist. Should America not vote for him, then it is obvious that people suffer from appalling taste and are in abject need of a dose of divine design !

Posted by lu yiu – September 8, 2006 6:25 PM

Loved the shows. David rocks in every way! Just a thought. I live in an older mobile home. Couldn't one of the challenges be to decorate/design a new room for someone who doesn't make $100K+ a year and lives in a mobile home? Now that's a challenge, believe me! Also, in the other shows they have "homework time" and things are done at night. Why these time constraints that include shopping time and getting supplies? Why is are not a carpenter and painter provided for every challenge as in real life and real shows?
And the couple that was promised new cabinets & granite countertops in their $10K makeover - did you give them new cabinets & countertops? Temple's kitchen makeover looked sick and I would have sued HGTV if it had been me.
Why allow all this bickering started by Temple? She should have been told to get along or eliminated immediately. How can a host of a show constantly fight with everyone and not listen to others? How totally unprofessional. I found her constantly playing the "I'm a single mother, tear, tear card" to be quite annoying. She should have been axed when she didn't deliver the kitchen. Maybe Donna would have done better without having to defend herself from attacks from Temple all the time.
That Joseph got a raw deal goes without saying. Vanessa was a total ego trip who never accepted responsibility for what she did but took responsibility for what others did if it was good. Ramona was a nightmare. I usually throw my old vacuum out, not put plaster on it and call it art! The twins were Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum. They couldn't function without the other - like Siamese Twins. Tym had great ideas and used common sense in his time limits but his designs were always half done and lacked something. Especially the walls. With $10K he could have done a much better job for the Katrina survivor. I thought his design for her apartment looked like he shopped for everything at the Salvation Army Store! The Tudor bedroom looked great but still unfinished.
In the end, the two best were picked. David & Alice. However, Alice is a decorator and not so much of a designer. In the "Man-Cave" she could have left the woodwork alone and spent her time designing a room that was more what the woman wanted for her husband, instead of the family room with a leather chair she received. It is David who is the Design Star! David Rocks!
As for the judges, I found them a little condecending at times.
I feel you should have different judges for EACH show and elimination. Then the designers are not trying to please the same three people every week.
Clive, I love, yes love, you and Lisa on Designed To Sell. That Chicago group are horrible. I was going to sign up but when I watched one show knew they were terrible. You have the best in Lisa, Bruce, Steve and yourself along with Donna & Shannon. You should travel around the country like they do in Antiques Roadshow.
Some have said it's terrible David showed so much skin. Well I think he's a hunk and loved it when he took his shirt off. Just wish Clive would have de-shirted himself too! Such a cuddly teddy-bear you are Clive! Just like that sexy Roger in that other show! Can't wait for the next season.

Posted by DD – September 8, 2006 5:14 PM

I think the FINAL 4 were the ones who worked well together- they ALL supported each other and seemed to be focused on the people they were there to benefit from their talents.....

Gosh- I wish David and Alice could both share a show.....I honestly could not favor one or the other......they both are super! ( and I think TYM and TEMPLE really enhanced that equation for your last shows....)

Thanks,

Vicki S in Tucson

Posted by Vicki Senter – September 8, 2006 3:38 PM

David came up with another winner! His room was so wonderful. Alice again just did ok....nothing spectacular.... She talks her way thru the room much better than her designing... Her wonderland story was cute but her room wasn't

Posted by Carole – September 8, 2006 2:32 PM

I agree with so many others, that David and
Alice would be a great show. They have great chemistry together and seem to genuinely like each other. a great combo. But alas,since there could be only one, then David is it!
D- Dynamite talent
A-Amazing art
V-Viewer friendly
I-Incredible work
D-Design star

Posted by cathy – September 8, 2006 2:25 PM

I LOVE ALICE! SHE HAS STYLE AND GRACE AND SEEMS TO HAVE A WONDERFUL ON AND OFF SCREEN PERSONALITY. I WOULD WATCH HER SHOW IN AN INSTANT. THE JUDGES CRITICIZED HER CURTAINS BUT ALSO CRITICIZED DAVID'S LACK OF COLOR, WHICH I AGREE WITH. DAVID'S BEST SHOW WAS THE PET STORE ROOM, HE BLEW ME AWAY BUT THEN AFTER THAT HE WAS PREDICTABLE WITH HIS ART, PRETTY MUCH THE SAME THING OVER AND OVER AGAIN WITH DIFFERENT COLORS. I VOTE FOR ALICE, BUT DON'T THINK ONE COULD GO WRONG WITH DAVID EITHER, JUST THOUGHT ALICE WAS THE BEST.

Posted by Carol Baxter – September 8, 2006 2:24 PM

I couldn't vote... if I had, I would have had to vote for both and would have cancelled out my votes.

I truly hope HGTV comes up with a way to give both of the two final contestants a show, better yet a show cohosted by them.

It is like comparing apples to oranges, you can't!

I have watched DesignStar since the beginning and many reruns of the shows, then got my daughter hooked on the show, it has been fun all the way thru! I would watch any show that these two end up on!

I hope to see another DesignStar season... it is fun to watch the upcoming designers. But, Clive must continue to host it!

Good luck to David & Alice - you guys are great!

Posted by Jennifer – September 8, 2006 2:11 PM

Both aspirants have great talent. However, it's disappointing to see the last of Alice's designs. I, as a designer, do not feel a designer's touch in the room. She's made better choices in previous challenges. I guess the pressure was on. She does have great presence on camera. David, on the other hand, has proven he can take any room and make us feel the design. But, can he work something other then contemporary? Is the design functional or only tasteful? David is at ease in front of the camera; we see it already in his audition tape. Great charisma. Any one of them win, HGTV has already won!

Posted by Nadine – September 8, 2006 12:56 PM

What a ride! I enjoyed the competition so much I hate to see it end! My vote is for Alice although it was very hard to decide after episode 7? If there could be a tie the exectives at HGTV should have them both have a show together like "Alice meets the Madhatter"! Or some reference to Alice in Wonderland...You can see they both enjoy each others company and
their mix of style with always compliment and
keep the viewers interested...Thanks HGTV for good and fun programming..Good Luck guys!

Posted by Roe – September 8, 2006 12:45 PM

I really think David has won the hearts of America with his very creative and unique talent, pleasant personality , and very superior sense of design . He has improved a lot in his hosting ability and I know he can learn this , but his innate , genius creativity is definitely a big plus . He would really attract droves of viewers to his own show ! I wish him the very best of luck and we hope he wins !

Thanks for the most pleasant show on HGTV - I have never enjoyed a show so much !

Posted by Angie Caculitan – September 8, 2006 11:49 AM

Apart from David's great looks, he's a terrific designer. He has consistently shown that he has what it takes and more to be HGTV's star.

David, you and your designs rock ! Awesome job, I got so inspired, i even went and got the stone thing that u did inside and out at the window. Those light fixtures, in a minimalist budget and u created terrific rooms.

Great work ! I thought Vern's the best on HGTV, now you'll be a valualbe addition to the team.

Posted by Tia – September 8, 2006 10:30 AM

When we got down to the final three, I knew that I was going to be sad no matter who was eliminated. I like Tym, too, but his work seems a little less finished, or polished, than either David's or Alice's.

Alice--what a sweetheart! I would love to have her as a neighbor or friend. Her sense of honesty, integrity, and compassion are admirable. However, there was something about each of her rooms that left me slightly unsatisfied--something missing. Try as hard as I might after the last episode, I couldn't understand Alice's theme (even after she explained it). The room, to me, lacked cohesiveness.

Each week, as the designers' rooms were rated on the website, David's rooms were consistently rated higher than Alice's. The Zen bedroom was his crowning glory! It was absolutely perfect to me. (In fact, I was rather hoping that I could convince HGTV to send me that room when they are finished with it in the park!) I am glad that he did not go with the judges' suggestion to add a splash of color on the bed. That would have ruined the look for me.

David has the advantage of being very versatile. Yes, he is an artist, but he is also a designer, a decorator, a carpenter, a space planner, an organizer, and a very good listener when it comes to what his clients want. I think that his presentation style is rather fun--although Alice's is, too. (No, I am not David's mother, nor do I know him personally, at all!)

I voted for David as often as I could, but good luck to both of them--and to Tym and Joseph (whom I thought got a really raw deal.)

Congratulations on a truly engaging show! I look forward to watching our next design star in action.

Posted by Judy B. – September 8, 2006 9:19 AM

I have thoroughly enjoyed the whole series. Alice and David were the clear choices for the finalists. I have to say though, Alice certainly disappointed me with the last room. To me it was very ordinary and predictable. I thought for her last challenge they would go all out. The only thing that I saw in Alice's room that "shined" was the chandalier. I feel she should have run with that. Instead everything else was ordinary. Even the bed placement was ordinary and predictable. David becomes more confident on camera each time. His designs are not always my taste but very classy and well thought out. He is also extremely nice eye candy. I have to agree with others the two of them on one show would be wonderful. They are both extremely talented. Her southern charm, his energy, their combined talent would be a top rated show.

Posted by Pam – September 8, 2006 7:45 AM

Dilemna!?! My gosh - this was a VIEWER'S dilemna. Both Alice and David had their strengths and weaknesses, but this is like trying to decide what to take off the dessert cart. Win or lose, I hope to see both of these talented and personable designers again on television. (Preferably together since they are so complimentary.) Clive - you are such a charming host. I hope will be there to wrangle the next set of designers on the next show!

Posted by Katy – September 8, 2006 6:23 AM

alice cute but lacking in creativity her designs did not stray far from the originals. which is of course why her last design felled she had nothing to reshape, add to, or change around. david on the other hand has true talent abd could keep a show alive. If america fells to see this lets hope hgtv doesn't. Go david! It takes more than cute to cut it.

Posted by mary – September 8, 2006 2:40 AM

I have been bothered for weeks that no one responded to Temple's malicious comment that Donna was "30 years older than me". Donna's age is listed as 49, and Temple's as 29. That's 20 years. Temple should have been eliminated right then for slander.

Posted by Cheryl – September 8, 2006 2:35 AM

I find it interesting that the former judges criticized Alice for using curtains but praised David. That pretty much says who they think should win. When they were talking among themselves they asked why she put them there to ruin the view, etc., yet when David used them around the bed and lining the walls they only praised him.

Posted by Anne – September 8, 2006 2:18 AM

My husband and I have enjoyed watching Design Star together, however my husband doesn't usually watch the reruns. Today, I had him watch again.
My husband is an engineer and is quick to notice things that escape my notice. Alice was told that she should have oriented her beds to take advantage of the fountain view. My husband noted that would have been impossible, due to how HGTV located the glass houses and where the doors were placed. (Interestingly, they did not make the same comment to David, who had his bed oriented in the very same direction.) He also noticed the headboard drawings that Alice gave to Tim. The headboards were not made in accordance with her drawings; the wording was not cut out; he did not use her whimsical lettering sample. It takes an engineer to notice these details! In any event, I feel that Alice has the best all-around talent, and does not limit herself to only one style. David seems to emulate Vern a great deal and he shows little variety in his style, which is nearly always lacking in adequate storage space, if any at all. Alice designs for real life. She is tasteful, practical, and really considers the purpose of the room. She should be the next Design Star! She is also a true lady and would represent HGTV very well!

Posted by E.T. – September 8, 2006 2:14 AM

I have to admit I think David won this round, but I want Alice to win! Her style and personality are great. David has a wonderful style as well, and has obviously worked on his hosting ability. I would like to say to HGTV to please make room for the "runner up" as well as the winner in your programming. I would also like to see Tym on a show. I can kind of see he and Alice together, actually. I think their stregnths would compliment one another, sort of a la Matt and Sherry. Anyway, this has been a wonderful show, and I have watched and re-watched it (unusual for me). Look forward to the next season of Design Star. Thanks

Posted by Elaine – September 8, 2006 1:43 AM

I LOVE THE SHOW ...
I VOTED FOR DAVID, BECAUSE I THINK THAT HE IS MORE CREATIVE, HIS DESINGS ARE VERY UNEXPECTED AND THATS WHAT KEEPS PEOPLE ATENTION...
AT THE SAME TIME HE BRINGS NEW IDEAS THAT WE CAN USE IN OUR HOMES...

Posted by Ana – September 7, 2006 11:56 PM

Can they both please have a show?

I have watched every episode from the beginning and think they are both completely fabulous in their own unique way! I think that David seems to be the favorite, but I think Alice should not be overlooked because she is so talented and endearing as well. Overall, its really hard to choose.

I LOVE them both and want them to come to my home!

Give them both a show HGTV, you did such a fantastic job with this one!

Posted by Shivann – September 7, 2006 11:40 PM

David rocks!!!

Posted by Laris – September 7, 2006 10:07 PM

I think both David and Alice are wonderful designers. I think it is true what has been written about David that the judges did not favor him, but just rewarded his talents with applicable comments on each show. David's talent was evident from the first show. He is an extremely talented artist and has a wonderful personality to go with his talent. I also like Alice. I personally voted for Alice and I will explain why. I think either one of these people would make a perfect host for a show on HGTV. I voted for Alice because I think she, like David, has a wonderful talent is a very gifted designer. But I think Alice is more well rounded. David is fabulous but he uses his personal style when he designs. I would like to see what he would do with a request that was not contemporary or modern. Alice on the other hand, has shown that she is versatile and can cater her designs to her clients desires and requests. I have enjoyed watching Alice on this show and I think she has remained professional, diplomatic and honest. She obviously has intergrity to go along with her talent. What it comes down to with me is that if I had to choose between the two of them - I would choose Alice to do my home and David to do my office. My home has to be a reflection of my personality not my the personality of the designer. I would like David to do my office because I love his work but it is not me, but it is beautiful. So I have voted for Alice but I think both of them are wonderful and either would be an outstanding winner. Great job David and Alice.

Posted by Amy – September 7, 2006 9:58 PM

i love love love ur show i wan to be a designer when i grow up im only 11 right now but still i LOVE it ........

Posted by shelby – September 7, 2006 9:37 PM

David and Alice are both worthy of having shows of their own. Compare them to the clowns who host the color show and Design on a Dime. David is the conceptual designer, although the criticisms of his concepts not being liveable are valid. Alice 's voice and laugh and class are enticing. I think HG is the winner for a concept brought forth at the right time. Other shows on HG (Like the above), I wonder how they got the job...Clive, you shine on this. Give both of these talents a show - and you can't lose. Build the program around each of them.

Posted by Jeanine – September 7, 2006 9:04 PM

I must admit--I wrote an email to HGTV early in the series slamming the silly, melodramatic aspects of this show. I still think a lot of the melodrama was ridiculous and annoying, but I was hooked by the contestants and the judges, and by the variety of design ideas. Next time, can you tone the silliness down a little??!! And bump up the time spent on showing the final designs and hearing more of the judges' reactions?

RE: the "final two": I absolutely LOVED all of David's designs--they were so bold and interesting--but, as another commentor said, not quite liveable (were there reading lamps by the bedside or night tables to put a cup of tea on?). And I thought his hosting greatly improved over time--he's hip and fun. Alice's designs were, I thought, a bit more pedestrian but much more practical, and she is so completely charming as a "host"--I could listen to her for hours. In the end, I favored David slightly more--I'd enjoy seeing his bold designs more.

Like many other commentors I agree that I'd love to see a show involving both of them. Kind of a She/He Designs--contrasting David's bold designs vs. Alice's softer designs. With both of them sharing the hosting. They clearly have a good relationship and would be great fun to watch.

Posted by Nancy E. – September 7, 2006 8:14 PM

Well I have been watching HGTV for years, and I have learned a lot from it, and I have watched every year, and I feel that Alice is great at what she does, but David is a true Designer, and he has a ton of idea's and he knows how to please who he is working for. It is a pleasure to see what he comes up... I hope he is the winner...

Posted by Connie D – September 7, 2006 7:44 PM

Actually Clive is my favorite and the reason I watched the show. But between the two designers I thought David's designs were the best. For the final challenge his design was far better than Alice's but I would have liked one splash of color somewhere. Alice is much more personable and would probably make a better host. Overall I thought this series was very enjoyable!

Posted by Stephanie – September 7, 2006 7:43 PM

DAVID, DAVID and DAVID. What's a talent! I think he, without a doubt, should be the Design Star and hosts his own show. He has such great personality, his designs were unmatched. I would love to have him designed my place. Good luck David. I count on seeing your shows in the near future.

Posted by Monique – September 7, 2006 7:22 PM

Wow! A remarkable show with so many talented designers. Although some of them left a whole lot to be desired, with some odd and off the wall designs, I am sure they relished their time in the sun and I give them credit for entering the contest. I believe those "your show has been cancelled" were terminated with just cause. David and Alice are, by far, the top designers of the whole and deserve royal treatment. I simple loved David's final design and his ability to shine with artistry, sets him above the run of the mill designer. So, he prances around in a T. LET HIM! He is pleasing to the eye. Alice, the charming southern gal, is also tops. Her southern drawl is right up my alley because I have the drawl too. Something about a southern drawl...it gets ya right in th' heart! I wish the two of them success and hope their careers soar to great heights. The only gripe, if you call it a gripe, is the judges should never have been allowed to comment on the final design, since the general public were judges. Clive, honey, you'da bomb. You can come in my house any day and tell me what you do to the young girl whose closet is a mess...but I certainly won't shut the door! Take care, Love, and have a good day, ya' hear?

Posted by Joyce from Arkansas – September 7, 2006 5:58 PM

I LOVE DAVID'S DESIGNS!!!!! I hope he wins!
also, I love Vern's designs and I wish he was doing his own show. HGTV!!!! We need shows about maximizing space in a studio. small spaces is not a good show and many of the spaces aren't really that small???

Posted by yasmin – September 7, 2006 5:57 PM

I LOVE DAVID!. Alice is ok, but if I had to choose someone to design a room in my home it would have to be DAVID. Eveyone of his designs were great. My favorite was where he had to shop at the pet store and come up with something for his room. He definitely stood out above everyone else. You can have great camera presence, but if you designs are not strong, you will not be able to keep the viewers interested. David can pick up with practice his hosting skills, but his designs are AWESOME. I will be watching Sunday and I hope he wins. As far as his shirt, he can take it off anytime. With a body like his, why hide his assets.

Posted by Leticia – September 7, 2006 5:32 PM

What a fun show this has been. I have enjoyed each episode and totally agree that the best two made it to the finals. They are both talented but I think that Alice is more well rounded and has the ability to pull off very attractive and functional rooms. David really is an artist and his room designs reflect that. But they all have his signature style all over them with little variety. And as far as function goes, they leave quite a bit to be desired. A well designed room is both beautiful and functional. As for who would make the most engaging host it is without a doubt, Alice! David is cute but seems a little anxious and does not draw you in like Alice does. She got all of my votes! I hope she wins. Whether she or David wins they are both winners. Thier success on this show will most likely have a very positive impact on thier careers and who knows, maybe another network would offer them a show. Best of luck to both of them.
Good job Clive!
Connie

Posted by Connie – September 7, 2006 4:10 PM

am an avid watcher of hgtv. love you clive. as far as a design star...i feel the same as some others, it would be great if dave and alice could co-host. i wonder though if there would be room for both of their personalities on the same show. i kind of got the feeling in the last design that alice was tired and was ready to say, "ok dave, you win, i'm ready to go home." i think she's tired of all his stuff, she has a lot of class, a real southern belle. one judge particularly thinks dave should win. it's clear he has talent and knows how to play to the judges, but the public is fickle. he needs to step it up and look outside the box or maybe push the walls out alittle. maybe this will develop if he doesn't let his success get in the way. he's like a kid in a room full of toys and that's great, now let it fly dave...best of luck.

Posted by Rhelda – September 7, 2006 4:07 PM

For the final challenge of the glass houses, it appeared to me that David spent his off time, before this final challenge, working on his hosting skills. He came across great when showing the audience his incredible asian bedroom design. He has my vote totally. I sure hope I get to see him on his own HGTV show.

Posted by Pat – September 7, 2006 3:37 PM

Finally had a chance to watch the last episode. Was slightly disappointed that David and Alice both chose to do bedrooms. There was a great opportunity to do "dining in the park" with a beautiful dining room. "Relaxing in the park" with a cozy living room. Or "sleeping in the park" which they both chose to do. Maybe because the budget was limited, (we were never told the budget)a bedroom was a cheaper way to go. If one had done a different room from the other, I don't think when the "judges" came they would have been able to compare the two rooms. They didn't influence me in any way. I already knew who I was going to vote for.

Why does it bother anyone whether or not David wears a shirt? Often times when my husband and I are working outside in the front of the house I wish I could take off my shirt as he does. But he works very hard and he works up more of a sweat than I do. I believe the same as David. He works physical harder than Alice.

Alice, while very sweet and extremely likable is not a designer. She is a decorator and unfortunately it showed in this episode. Her room confused me and lacked the designer quality. David, on the other hand, designed and decorated his space beautifully.

I was happy to see that Temple, with no one to argue with, was very helpful to both of them. Tym is a very good carpenter and designer, but not a good decorator. Both of them worked very hard for whoever they worked for that day. They both tried to help either David or Alice achieve their goal.

I sure hope in the next week that the judges will be able to explain to Joseph why as team leader, he was eliminated over Vanessa, but when Temple was team leader, Donna was eliminated over her. It still doesn't make sense to me. Did the judges somehow have second thoughts on eliminating the leader and not the person responible for the mistake?

Anyway, I'm sorry to see the show end and I look forward to the next one.

Posted by Julie – September 7, 2006 3:27 PM

David's sense of fun and energy is infectious. He has his own very creative, clean style which comes through in all of his designs. Alice tries to interpret what the client wants whether it is her taste or not. She's sweet and easy on the eyes. They seem to enjoy each other's company and have fun together. With David's shirt off, and Alice's good looks, having a show with both of them hosting would be a fantastic balance and appeal to a wide audience. While their styles are different, I think they could work well together, and the synergy of their passion, combined creativity and charm would make for a highly engaging show to watch.

Posted by Suzy – September 7, 2006 3:20 PM

Liked the unique challenge of the last episode. Thought Alice's product lacked cohesiveness and completeness. Theme appeared to be almost an afterthought. David's product clung together. But, neither really embraced the park environment thoroughly.

Posted by Bill – September 7, 2006 3:07 PM

I agree with the other comments about David and Alice having a good chemistry. I would love to see them both work together on a show. David's designs are great, but too severe. Alice could bring some femininity and softening and color.

Posted by Betty – September 7, 2006 2:05 PM

Alice has great tv presence, but David covers all bases. he got my vote. My only question about the whole series is where the hell did they get that idiot Ramona ( the 1st cancel) A dumpster diver who can't work with others. Maybe it was to give us someone to hate immediately, followed by Donna who could only shop. Great show.

Posted by Gordon – September 7, 2006 1:15 PM

Does anyone else think that Alice makes some very goofy faces when she's not in hosting mode, sure she can turn on for the moment but I think David is much more sincere and he is obviously the better designer.

Posted by Nina – September 7, 2006 11:25 AM

To me it would all come down to what kind of show they will be doing and also what the majority of people will watch. Both are great but I'd hire/watch Alice. David's designs are more unique but not my style. Alice seems to be able to make it work better in an existing room. Like I said, depends on the type of show they will be doing. Both are really great and I also would like to see them working together.

49 in Florida

Posted by Beverly – September 7, 2006 10:07 AM

Some have written that the judges favored David from the beginning. These judges were professionals and recognized a fellow professional. David's work in EVERY challenge was marvelous and the judges conveyed that in their critique.

Posted by Joy – September 7, 2006 9:23 AM

I WAS NEVER REALLY INTO REALITY SHOWS, UNTIL I HAPPENED TO TURN ON THIS ONE AND I LOVED IT. I HAVE WATCHED THE REPEATS ALL WEEK AND THAT IS SOMETHING THAT I NEVER DO.
ALICE, REMINDS ME OF GRACE ON THE THE TV SHOW WILL & GRACE. AND, I LIKE HER WORK, BUT IT JUST SEEMED LIKE IN MY OPINION THAT THE GLASS HOUSE JUST THROUGH HER FOR A LOOP AND SHE DIDN'T REALLY KNOW WHAT TO DO.
NOW, FOR DAVID'S HOUSE IT JUST ROCKED; AS MY OLDEST WOULD SAY. EVERYTIME HE WAS GIVEN AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO HIS OWN THING, I JUST FELL IN LOVE WITH IT. I KNOW THAT I VOTED FOR DAVID EVERYDAY THAT I COULD.

Posted by JAMIE – September 7, 2006 8:30 AM

I absolutely have loved David's designs from the get-go. Alice is good, too, however there isn't a "wow" factor in any of her designs. Design Star is the only reality show on TV that I have truly enjoyed from day 1. Good job!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by amy harris – September 7, 2006 8:11 AM

Just a quick post to comment on those that complain about David not keeping his shirt on....I know David personnally and I've been to his studio where he puts in long hard hours in the Miami heat with no air conditioning. Living in Miami and working in those conditions cater to working with minimal clothing. In fact living in Miami caters to wearing minimal clothing. It simply doesn't have anything to do with professionalism or sexism or any of the other criticisms that have been posted. He's simply more comfortable working in a hot environment without a shirt. If you noticed while he was doing the room in Washington state his shirt stayed on. With shirt on or off David's designs were simply and consistently superior to the others and he gets my vote.

Posted by jeff – September 7, 2006 2:43 AM

I have been on the egde of my seat through this whole show...All the people that I wanted voted off was voted off, and the ones I wanted to stay were there until the very end...I really like Alice's work but David blew me away everytime! Good Luck to them both!

Posted by Chasity – September 7, 2006 1:55 AM

I think David deserves to win personaly is a great designer I would love to have him sesign something for my home for he is really great shirt off or on I don't think that has anything to do with what he does and designs for I have watched it and he is reallyl good too.Sharon Zadra in colorado>>>> email is sharon_zadra@hotmail.com

Posted by Sharon – September 7, 2006 1:38 AM

We started watching the series sporadically on Sunday nights, caught the whole series on Labor Day and again today due to bad weather in the southwest. wow, we are building contractors, so we may look at things in a different light, but David just shined to the stars. We are a hubby and wife team, but we both agreed, he just stood so far above the rest, his designs are innovative and effortless and so right on target. While we both like Alice and Tym for design projects, David seems to have a natural feel for client needs, timing and a natural flair for asthetic appeal. Good heavens, a kitchen in 32 hours, yet he just went to work;.......can we hire him? We also agree here, his hosting is A ok, very effortless, natural and relaxed. We all would watch him any time, he is what the real world is needing. And a huge thank you to Tym for bringing in the element of timing and honesty to clients,we have a great respect for both these contestants. Best of luck to both of them. Alice was cute, but not so adorable to make us want to watch every episode, TWICE. Our best of luck to her as well, she is a great second choice. Barb

Posted by Barb – September 7, 2006 1:25 AM

Clive:
From one Brit to another-I LOVE YOU! The only reason I began watching "Design Star" was because I saw you on the advertisements! And please come back to "Designed to Sell"! I miss you!

Now about this episode. I must say my favourite to win is Alice. Her use of colour in every episode is great. I can always expect something new from her.

As for David... Blah. Always the same! He was my favourite after episode 3, but after that I turned towards Alice.

As for co-hosting? One word: NO! Alice is the clear choice to me.

Posted by Lily – September 7, 2006 1:14 AM

David is the clear talent here, he is so creative.

Posted by Mel – September 7, 2006 12:45 AM

What a classy show! Clive, as always, was funny, enchanting and kind. All three judges were professional and impressive with their evaluations of the work performed. And, after suffering through the necessary "conflicts" designed to get the viewer emotionally engaged in the competition, the top three contestants - David, Alice and Tym - showed themselves to be talented and engaging. I sense their fondness and admiration for each other is real.

This competition is about finding the DesignStar. In my view, David is the clear winner. Although I would want Alice to decorate my home, I was fascinated with David's ability to engage me with his design energy and there is something about Tym's intense physical energy that draws me in!

It would be a real shame if HGTV doesn't find a way to add all these individuals - David, Alice and Tym - to your outstanding talent pool. Together, separately, old shows, new shows - it doesn't matter. These are the type of "performers" who draw viewers to your shows. I would love to see more of all three of them.

Thanks, HGTV, for a classy product, everyday.

Posted by Leah – September 7, 2006 12:40 AM

I love watching David on camera, he is a little awkward (no one can deny that Alice is a natural), but his enthusiasm really draws me in. I think with some training and consistancy (to build him a comfort level) David will be able to control and manage the camera he is in front of. I love his originality and artistice talents that are so very original, but Alice has a way with the client, filling the needs they ask to have resolved. While David's designs are fantastic and original to the person, Alice's are very realistic and something I would be more likely to bring into my own home. I would absolutly love to have a show with the two of them together, I think they play off each perfectly, and where one is weak, the other will "pick up" the slack and the overall show will be fun, talented, and meet the needs of the client. I started this week certain I would vote for Alice, but I cast mine for David. GOOD LUCK to them both, they are truly winners.

Posted by Sarah – September 7, 2006 12:37 AM

I agree, THE best reality show. Alice is talented and charming. There is nothing about her that is not likeable, she just seems to be missing that one little "touch" that pulls everything together. However, David is an all inclusive package. While he is not the natural in front of the camera (when prompted), he has a dynamic and very likeable enthusiastic personality, especially when non-scripted. He should be the next DESIGN star. He has vision, talent, execution, imagination, and so much more. And, he is able to pull it all together with a WOW factor but his work is never over the top. I cannot believe his indoor/outdoor boxes were just grazed over in the final challenge. His work is, as one judge said, "genius." While I think David & Alice work well together, I truly think David is a one-man show. It would be nice to have Alice come on the show for guest appearances. On the remaining contestants...Donna is a decorator, Temple has some talent but it is overshadowed by her poor attitude. Vanessa, whoa, I hate to say this but she was the most self-absorbed person on the show. So unlikeable and limited in talent/creativity. Ramona, she just needs a thrift shop to run. I also think the judges were honest, professional, and compassionate. One could not argue with their choices nor their reasons. A well-fit panel for the show. Clive, I just love watching him. His personality complements everyone and every situation.

Posted by Cheryl – September 6, 2006 11:33 PM

Whenit comes to voting on who will win, sometimes you dont have to scratch a leg to think, because the genius always "shine".
david comes like a shining armour , destined
to win.his design ideas are hot, simple lines with a strong statement makes one person really at home, very cozy.He is able to reach out
to his clients by his clever design that fits beyond the imagination of his client.Bravo David!

Posted by sarah – September 6, 2006 11:06 PM

DAVID ROCKS.

I came late to the party, but I saw all episodes on re-runs, and agreed with the "cancellations" every time.

Now, down to the final challenge, I think David showed that he can create a harmonious room in ANY setting. His designs have all been vibrant and exciting, yet suited the space. For this very very difficult challenge, he reined in his trademark WOW factor to make the best room yet, perfect for the glass room in the park. Even with the crowds outside, I think I could peacefully drop off to sleep in that flawless zen room. More of a whispered "wow."

His presentation was a vast improvement. He is clearly trainable. There's no way HGTV is going to let him on the air without being able to fine-tune his hosting skills. As much as I liked Alice's personality and camera presence, I feel David will be her equal. His inner kindness and generosity will shine through, as we have come to know him "off-camera" (well, there was obviously a camera present, but you know what I mean).

Alice's room was disappointing, but I think she made a poor choice with a child's room then did the best she could. Loved the chandelier, but the rest was not inspiring. I hope she gets to guest on David's show, if he wins, because she is sweet and a natural on camera, and her ideas have been good.

Design talent like David's is innate and cannot be learned.

What a fun, involving show! I am surprised at how much I care about the outcome -- I've never gotten so much into a competition reality show before except for "Project Runway." I guess it's the excitement of seeing people unleash their creativity and grow along those lines.

It doesn't hurt to have such a fabulous host! Clive, you're the best!

Posted by Marsha – September 6, 2006 11:03 PM

While both contestants are very worthy of winning, and having their own style. I have yet to love all of Davids designs. (his red room was like office cubby turned living space.) Alice works outside the "box". I did like David glass house better, but overall liked all of Alice's designs. All the contestants showed talent, some more than others. Good luck to both!

Posted by Kathy – September 6, 2006 10:32 PM

Kudos, HGTV! What a fantastic show! To sit for four solid hours because you don't dare miss a moment speaks volumes for your specific goal to showcase designers' talents and unique challenges. No getting mired down in drawn out drama, which has little value. All the participants had value and talent, and even at the end of each segment, Clive's task of voicing the decision of the judges, was gentle and professional. Now we have David and Alice. David has the wonderful energy, talent and creative passion for his work! Alice has the beautiful, feminine side in her creativity and her compelling TV presence seems so natural and sweet. Whoever wins, we pray we will see both of you in the future in our homes for a long time and benefit from your fantastic gifts!

Producers, directors.....all of you, our undying gratitude for an awesome television experience!

Posted by N n J – September 6, 2006 10:29 PM

Just saw the next to last episode this afternoon... (too late to vote! )

David has great designs (absolutely beautiful!), but ALICE is the hostess. She's charming, friendly, warm, great hair, cute face, and soothing voice. And though David's designs are perfection for looking at, I could actually live in Alice's designs - comfortable, just spiced up a bit.

Posted by Lora – September 6, 2006 10:25 PM

I love them both. Both have outstanding design talent and tv presence. They have a cute chemistry together and will pull in the viewers. Put them together as co-hosts on a show.

Posted by Cliff – September 6, 2006 10:04 PM

How can you all be voting for DAVID? It doesn't make sense! Have any of you noticed that his designs are not functional or livable-imagine walking on a wood chip floor or whacking your ead on hose wicker "thingees" on the ceiling. UNFUNCTIONAL 100 PERCENT!!! His designs are predictable and lack warmth. His "ingenuity" makes me sick- the same "pet" room was sent to me by my sister in Idaho by e-mail (no kidding!). Alice, on the other hand, has a huge base of ideas. She wears APPROPRIATE CLOTHING! Sure, that shirt was a little low, but a low shirt is better than NO SHIRT AT ALL!!!

Alice is the clear choice. I will not watch a show hosted by David and will not accept a co-host show. Period Amen.

Posted by Meghan – September 6, 2006 9:42 PM

While I like Alice's designs I think she plays it too "safe." The children's bedroom was just a children's bedroom although a very nice one. David appears to have more imagination and the confidence to put his designs together. He also seems to be able to spark the imagination of the viewers, as I am considering using a few of his ideas.

Posted by Elaine – September 6, 2006 9:42 PM

My husband and I looked forward to Sunday nights all week! It was great to see Vern, again. We really enjoyed watching the talent and personalities of the contestants. The challenges were so interesting. We wish David had done more with his original art work. His designs were super!!
But...our hearts and votes belong to Alice. She'll make a Delightful Design Star.
Jane & Steve

Posted by Jane – September 6, 2006 9:38 PM

I like both designers work but David is the PERFECT choice for HGTV. He's more confident and skilled and a overall designer. David you rock!!

Alice is terrific and a great designer, but lacks the confidence to pull it together with her own, she needs advice too often. Go with you gut feeling lady and you'll do just fine. Making it to the second runner no matter who wins and the winner you both win.

Great job Alice and David and all the other designers that put theirselves in the spotlight to go for it and we love a good design show!

I vote for David as the designer.

I'm a southern and I like the southern drawl. Everyone has one :) And you can tell she's a very nice, talented designer. I think she'd work great like on design on a dime where they all work as a team weekly.

Cheers and good luck to both David and Alice now and in the future.

From KY

Posted by Ruth Wells – September 6, 2006 9:36 PM

I think Alice completely missed the purpose of the glass room. She should have adapted it to that wonderful chandelier she found and truly made it an "Alice thru the Looking Glass" room. How perfect would that be? Along with the dots on the ceiling, she could have added bead curtains, mirrored head board or a round bed smack in the middle of the room with polka dot spread, bead bag chair, soft pillows everywhere, etc, etc. Then = any child, teen, grandma would love it. She is so sweet however, I can't knock her too much. David on the other hand was always spectacular. I especially noticed that they were the only 2 who didn't complain about anyone else the whole time, no quarreling, no back biting, no fighting, just tears for winning and getting done!! Hurrah!!!. Good luck to you both, you will be fab whatever you do or wherever you go.

Posted by Jeanette D – September 6, 2006 9:13 PM

In the end, after re-watching and re-reading, I went for David for the sole reason that he seems more comfortable in front of the camera. This show has been great. As a reality show junkie, I really wondered how you were going to pull it off. Congratulations to everyone involved because it was definitely a winner! My favorites for some reason seemed to be all the men and I'd be happy to watch any of them in their own shows. Great job HGTV!

Posted by Karen E – September 6, 2006 8:45 PM

Even though I believe David will win this last challenge, I believe HGTV, its veiwers, and Alice and David will all benefit the most from Alice and David co-hosting. As stated by others, David has a more modern style while Alice is more conventional and traditional - what most people are. This compliment of styles and talent would truely bring balance to a show and add another creative demension. The key word today is diversity and you have it with these two. Also, I believe David would loosen up and slow down a bit working with someone as open as Alice. He does very well in conversation vs "reporting."

HGTV, do us all a favor and see if the winner is open to sharing the stage. We will still all know who won the contest, but we will still be able to enjoy a great team.

David, I think you may be the winner. You have excellent creative capacity. I have even seen your work in person. Congrats! Now, would you consider broaching the question with HGTV and Alice of having a co-host - it will be your show.......?

Alice - you have also done a fantastic job - and your designs would work great in my home - which is why I watch HGTV - to see how I could redesign my own living space. I have a feeling this will not be the last we see of you, and I'm looking forward to the next time!

Judges & HGTV: You did a great job throughout the series with your evaluations and guidance. I believe it was misplaced in this last show though. This was to be judged by the viewers and your comments I believe brought in a bias and did not leave the two designers to stand on their own merit. That is a loss. Take this as a learning opportunity for next time. Find something else to shoot if you need to fill the air time.

Also, I agree with someone else's comments that the designers should know in advance what their resources will be (help or no help). If you want to get tricky take away a resource or add a requirement midstream (i.e. they would have to incorporate a 5'x7' piece of cardborad into the design, a roll of tin foil, or a rock etc.) and make sure the change up is fair - doesn't favor one person's skill set ove another.

Thanks to all. Great Show!

Posted by Kimberly – September 6, 2006 8:32 PM

Believe Alice to be best to watch and learn from on a livable basis as well as design. Can't wait to buy David's coffee table book of design--great picture, but possibly not as livable. Re: kitchen how many man hours did it take to "finish" and how much more material purchased? Did the family keep the floor as done...Did some of the designers "throw" their designs to get cancelled early for some unknown reason...On the glass room how went the budget...noticed neither "purchased" additional labor/help.

Posted by Joanie – September 6, 2006 8:29 PM

I know some think they should co-host. I DON'T want them to have a show together at all. They have different style and for the most part appeal to different crowd too. David will do his contemporary and fantasy-art inspired rooms. Alice will do her traditional/southern living thing she wants to do. Personally I'm a fan of David's work and creative talent. I just want to watch him do his own show. If he wins maybe they can have a contestant appear on his show helping him out couple times. I'd rather Temple and Donna appear separately on his show (I think they both like him) And maybe Alice can appear with him once too, but that's all I can handle. Let them have their own separate shows if they want - but not together. I'M ONLY INTERESTED IN DAVID'S SHOW.

Posted by silvershadow – September 6, 2006 8:29 PM

It was so hard to vote - just about broke my heart - I want both to have a show. Or at least a show together. So I voted 4 times for David and 4 times for Alice

Q

Posted by Q – September 6, 2006 8:18 PM

The first show I watched was the pet store MASTERPIECE that David did!!! Unreal!! His work was absolutely lightyears ahead of the rest, and I think the judges were so blown away they actually contained themselves to not show favoritism. David's work has been awe-inspiring, and it is so hands-down obvious who the best designstar is!! I think Alice really went the wrong direction with the child's room, and it puzzles me why such bland posters were adequate over the beds, for such an important style and concept piece. they didn't fit. If she had take Alice in Wonderland and actually put that into the room with the looking glass, teapots, hats wilders colors and patterns etc.
David won this challenge so completely, and he is deserving of this show in every way including polishing up his presenting skills which even improved!

Posted by Lym – September 6, 2006 8:02 PM

Design Star is the best show ever! Period!

Posted by Paul – September 6, 2006 7:50 PM

I love them both, but David got my vote. I loved everything he did. It was nice to watch a contest show where people were kind to each other and not back-stabbing (except for drama queens Temple and Donna). Next time, though, I'd like to hear more comments from the judges or have them actually view the designers' work -- not just through the videos.

Posted by Lisa – September 6, 2006 7:45 PM

Alice is the one, y'all!!
David's brilliant...but his TV style is not as comfy and homey as Alice's....
And Alice is so cute!!
She's an excellent designer...and is able to give people what they want...and still show her talent....
Go Alice!!!!

Posted by Caty – September 6, 2006 7:33 PM

Hello Clive,
Well? Who shall be the next(make that the FIRST) design star?
David....no Alice......And what about Tym? He looked so nice coming back, he has such a great TV presence. And he walked right in and built David's design. These two work so well together.
I think David's room was the definite winner. I liked Alice's room but it did not come together like David's.
Again, the two of them looked great together! In the hotel suite giving each other 'courage'they seemed so sincere. And on onscreen these two just 'pop' together.
If I can ever get my computer to let me vote...I'll be voting for David. But it is really too close to call.

Posted by Guneet – September 6, 2006 7:16 PM

I loved both David and Alice. She is sweet but David's designs definitely had the "Wow" factor. He didn't just push furniture around but came up with a truly exquisite design each time. I could hardly wait for the finished room because I knew it would be such a delightful surprise. He got my votes.

Posted by anita – September 6, 2006 7:14 PM

I loved both Alice & David's personalty. I feel David has the ability to visualize a complete design in his mind and execute it. That to me is the true talent. I love David's clean lines and loved all of his designs on the show (the pet store room still amazes me). I loved Alice's "tiffany box blue" room, but in the final challenge I was disturbed by the plain writing on the poster boards mounted on the headboards and poster boards hanging on the walls. If a designer did that in my room I would not be happy. Therefore, I voted for David -

Posted by lisa – September 6, 2006 7:12 PM

I voted for david because I LOVE his desingns.

P.S.I am only 10 but I LOVE to desingn

Posted by Guneet – September 6, 2006 7:06 PM

I love em both! My only regret is that Tym isn't in the finals as well. How refreshing it has been to watch a reality show where we ended up watching talented people who actually seem like nice human beings as well. I'll be happy no matter which one wins - David's room was better this week, but Alice has done a fine job overall as well.
HIRE THEM BOTH!!

Posted by Ron – September 6, 2006 7:04 PM

i will start off by saying that i feel too many people focused on the "skin" issue. who cares? it never even caught my attention until 1029843747 of you pointed it out :)
thumbs up to hgtv for a wonderful job on the first season....clive was an awesome host, as usual.
i voted for david b/c he left me speechless everytime...
david,alice, and tym are all wonderful designers.my two favorites from the beginning were tym and david... but by the end alice had won me over too. (and alice your accent is adorable) i would absolutly looooooove to see ALL of them on a show.

Posted by melissa – September 6, 2006 6:50 PM

I really hope that david wins! I love all of his designs and art work. He truly should be the design star!! good luck David!!!!!!!!!

Posted by caitlin – September 6, 2006 6:37 PM

David's design was superior this time around, but I voted for Alice. I find the fact that he has to design and work shirtless REALLY annoying; yes, he has a great body, but the show is about DESIGN...But if wants people to look at his designs, he needs to remain fully clothed.

Posted by Paul – September 6, 2006 6:36 PM

"People in glass houses shouldn't throw stones."

Thank GOODNESS you picked Alice and David for the final challenge! HA HA HA!!!
They are the most collaborative of the all the designers from the original 10, so they were easy to work with, and easy to work for. It is no surprise that the 2 have such a good rapport.

I could easily see having either of them redesigning a room in my house. And I would give them more than 28 hours to complete it. ;)

Posted by MC – September 6, 2006 6:32 PM

I happened on the show in the middle of the season by accident. I hate I didn't get in on watching from the beginning and hope they will have another season of it.
I really like Alice and her personality. I liked her Tiffany Box Blue room she did in the first show I caught. But overall David's designs have been the best in my opinion and really shone. That is why my votes have gone to David!
ummm... Maybe they should co-host and make up for each other's weaknesses!

Posted by Kerri – September 6, 2006 5:56 PM

Even my husband, who always says "Don't you get tired of that channel?" said "Wow" to David's glass house.

I love the way David uses unusual materials, like his kooky rugs, and makes them a favorite point in a room. So many of his decorating choices are not what anyone else would decide on, but turn out so beautifully.

He has shown that he factors in all aspects of his designs, more than the obvious room itself. He looks at functionality, wants and needs of the client, how the room will really be used-and who will be using it. But what truly sets him apart is he can sense the emotions that are going to be felt in a room, and translate that into design.

I think HGTV has not just a design star, but a design ambassador in David.

Posted by Diane – September 6, 2006 5:37 PM

Why I voted for Alice... I love David's designs, but regardless of what the judges say (:) ) His style is very predictible. It has all be fantastic, but Alice has her own style, but she is not as predictable. She works with the space, adapting her style. I would love to see them both have a show... David a show like Kenneth's but Alice, I think she would work best in any circumstances.
PS-I think Tym was great too, and would be a great TV personality. :) Maybe a new Trading spaces, with the three of them as some of the designers? :)

Posted by Penny – September 6, 2006 5:20 PM

This is the first reality TV I have watched. It is an excellent show, the Host, the Judges, the Contestants, the Challenges, and most of all the TALENT, I predict the most talented will win and deservidly so but I agree with many of the other viewers and we all like Alice's style and personality as well. We would love to see them co-host or atleast have an Alice segment. Good Luck with second season, this one will be hard to top.

Posted by Robin – September 6, 2006 5:09 PM

I Love, Love all David's designs! The Pet Store, WOW! I have to say he reminds me a lot of Vern's clean lines.Love Vern too. And I met Clive at work, he is as nice in person as on TV. See you in Prada and vote for David.

Posted by Sherry – September 6, 2006 4:59 PM

I feel as a designer that David is more innovative and completes each project that he is given. It would have been nice to have seen some interaction between designer and client. However, it isn't my show. I feel that all of the designers accept Donna need a person to help them dress professionally. Maybe this will improve with their experience. Love the show.

Posted by SDG – September 6, 2006 4:20 PM

Ohhh I love Alice and previous to the final I would have given her the slight edge over David. But it was always ever so close and David's final design completely stole my vote. The space was zen like, and I loved the effect you got from viewing the raindrops through the gauzy fabric he draped over the bed. Truly inspired and inspiring. I felt like I could lie there and drift calmly to sleep. I loved his confidence in sticking to his vision and not adding colour as one judge suggested. It was completely unnecessary in the final design. He created such a unique space without requiring many obvious, ostentatious elements. He created a feeling, an atmosphere - in a glass house in the middle of a rainy park. In 26 hours? Now that's a design star. David, you won me over. Congratulations!

Posted by Dana – September 6, 2006 4:17 PM

I'd love to see both Alice and David with their own shows! They're both fun to watch, and definitely draw the viewer in. A show with both of them as a team would be fantastic! I could see them doing a Trading Spaces (sorry, diff't network!)kind of show.

Like the other viewers, I'm also really glad that this competition was fair and truly based on talent. The top designers of the bunch made it to the finals, and I was soooo worried at the beginning that some of the other, ahem, personalities would get to the finals without any talent to show for it.

The judges did a great job, and of course, Clive has been a wonderful host, as always.

Posted by Nora – September 6, 2006 4:15 PM

To HGTV - whichever "design star" wins this one - please don't forget the OTHER (and Tym, too!)! Looks to me like each of David, Alice, and Tym has come out of this with a fan base of his/her own! Your audience would LOVE to see all three of them again!

Oh, and one more thing - I've read several comments here about "Alice's annoying drawl" -- why do people think it's okay to say nasty things about Southerners, but it's never okay to say nasty things about the way other people talk? Her accent is her accent! We all have accents, people! Maybe somebody thinks YOUR accent is annoying!

In other words, if it doesn't pertain to someone's ACTIONS and CHOICES - then - BE NICE!

Posted by Kathy – September 6, 2006 4:14 PM

This was by far the best reality show I've ever watched. It really showed the true spirit of healthy competition and how it can bring out the best in everyone. I voted for David, but as with some many others here, I would absolutely love to watch a show co-hosted by David and Alice. David for the "Wow" factor, and Alice to reign things in a little when he gets out of control. Again, Congratulations HGTV!

Posted by Dave G – September 6, 2006 4:04 PM

I believe David can immediately see a vision in his mind,and it includes artwork, color, space utilization, materials , and also what needs to be done to complete the job. He can do this while working well with others. What a wonderful, rounded , talented individual! As others have mentioned, I think Alice is a TV natural, and I had a hard time giving her a negative vote of any kind, but you WERE looking for a new design talent, and he has it ALL.

Posted by Gail – September 6, 2006 3:59 PM

I think they should both win too! David and Alice are much better together than they are apart. But in the end if I have to choose it will be David. I loved his pet store room! His finished product was always great! Alice is more comfortable on camera, but that will come in time for David. He always talked great on camera he just got too rushed when talking about his rooms.
And as for Designed To Sell, Clive Pierce and Lisa LaPorter are the only design to sell show to watch. The chicago team has very little personality and do to may bargin basement finds. There houses never look as good as Lisa's and the other guy isn't fummy like Clive.

Posted by Michelle – September 6, 2006 3:51 PM

So I do agree with most when I say that this has truely been a great show! It seemed to have everything that one would need to keep your attention. I do love both Alice and David's styles and everything that they have put together. I ended up going with Alice though everyday! I really and truely did love the rooms that David did, but they were all the same. I think that i would much more enjoy a designer who stretches his or her own limits and trys to create something that the client would love and not just what they personaly like. Yes Alice's last project wasn't the best espically with the dorm room style bed's and the paintings in the middle of the glass. But look at the whole picture everything that they both have created.

Posted by Lindsie – September 6, 2006 3:48 PM

I have to say first that having the contest in glass houses is an ingenious test of David's and Alice's skills.

I think both contestants have plus and minuses and both are infectious likeable characters so I don't view this as a personality contest. Both are good on-camera.

This project program did lean toward David I'll admit it, but he did incorporate the glass house into the design of the room where I feel Alice might have used the glass as another type of wall. I think the rain helped, belive it or not, making David's design more visually appealing.

David's was simple but elegant, Alice's was complex but thoughtful.

I give the edge to David because I think it would be more interesting to see what David does to resolve design challenges in a new HGTV show.

I think whoever 'loses' it won't be the last we hear from them.

Posted by Dale – September 6, 2006 3:45 PM

The show doesn't have the name "Design" in it for nothing. David is the one person who continually came up with a design vs. decorating (pet store anyone?). He did both design and decor in the same space. I do agree there is great chemistry between David and Alice. But David is the clear winner here and I can't wait to see what he can do with time, funds, trademans, and pre-planning that his own show would provide. Alice would be a nice compliment to him doing her own little "short piece" of the program. But David should be the star. Period.

Posted by Sharon – September 6, 2006 3:33 PM

Clive...Your the greatest host...Also love you and Lisa on Design to Sell...

Great group of designers to start with a great mix of ideas and philosophy's...But the bottom line is getting to the end...Both David and Alice are talented with stage presence going to Alice and David not far behind (He has a great ability to learn fast)...Design wise it's close but David is a confident designer with a hot bag of skills and idea...He does one thing that separates the two--He creates from whats presented and his final product is always breath taking...Hopefully you will have alice as a guess on his show after he's established... It was exciting and can't wait for season #2...As always Clive your the man...

Posted by Johnnie – September 6, 2006 3:26 PM

David showed so much more creativity then Alice. He always had some personal art work and something he had built to add to the room. He didn't rely only on what he could purchase to put in the room, thus he was able to be more creative. I agree that it wasn't necessary to add a punch of color in his room. The calm you had when you saw it was what he wanted.

Posted by Sharon – September 6, 2006 3:10 PM

My daughter and I have been sitting on the edge of our seats watching Design Star. This is the only "reality" show that I've ever watched! I would have liked to have seen the contestants do individual spaces for the first 2 or 3 competitions so that we could get an idea what their style was. And then move on to group projects later on with only the more talented designers. The group projects in the beginning led to too much conflict and some designers "taking over" the rooms. I absolutely would love to see a show with David, Alice, and especially Tym together--something like Trading Spaces using all three of them. All three of them impress me. Individually they all have some weaknesses, but together they would be awesome!

Posted by Jane – September 6, 2006 3:04 PM

I became totally hooked on the show! David won me over from the beginning in every way - good looks, personality, smile, professionalism, and of course, talent. Alice is deserving of second place, but to be honest, her designs did not have the "wow" factor.

Posted by Judy – September 6, 2006 2:46 PM

Voting was SO hard!! I absolutely adore watching Alice, but David has some really nice designs. I would really like for BOTH to get their own shows. They were both my favorites since episode 1.

Posted by Elisabeth – September 6, 2006 2:43 PM

David's shirt off, Alice's cleavage, they are all the same. While it does bother me a bit, I still truly enjoy the tremendous talents and great personalities these two have. I can't tell you how much I appreciate the fact that this show does not encourage conniving and backstabbing behaviors so prevalent in almost all other reality shows. Design is about bringing out the beauty within and around each and everyone of us. Good job, Clive! Good job, HGTV!

Posted by C.Y. – September 6, 2006 2:33 PM

Fascinating show, from the first minute. I haven't been riveted to the TV like this for years.!! The cream has risen to the top and David and Alice both belong in the final voting process. We have voted for David as his design sense and style shine in all his work, and whatever space and materials available to him becomes something beautiful and interesting. The sequence where he was unable to assemble the chair, and in frustration finally handed it off to the carpenter who couldn't figure it out either, was "reality television" at it's best. Design Star indeed.

Posted by John & Sandie – September 6, 2006 2:23 PM

David clearly has the imagination and talent to do a type of design show that we haven't seen before . . . And I voted as much as I could to make sure he get's that opportunity. As far as the "no shirt controversy" goes . . . Get over it! It was clearly hot and muggy in New York, and no one should be faulted for trying to find some relief for goodness sakes!

Posted by Judi – September 6, 2006 1:43 PM

I agree - I have really enjoyed this show. Personally, I like both David and Alice. David created the best room with the final challenge but I also enjoy Alice's presence. They get along and are two great people who would be an amazing TEAM!

Posted by Sally – September 6, 2006 1:27 PM

What will the show be like that the Design Star will host? Can I put in my application now to have David (hopefully) come & design my bedroom? That would rock!

Posted by Linda – September 6, 2006 12:45 PM

I have a question for Clive.
I have been looking at the bios for the individual design star contestants. Three bill themselves as "interior designers", and of those three only Alice actually has an interior design degree. Both Vanessa and Donna boast of owning their own interior design firms, and Vanessa stated that she taught interior design; yet, Donna has no formal education and Vanessa is still a student. Legally, aren't Donna and Vanessa misrepresenting themselves--aren't they actually just interior decorators?

Posted by Linda – September 6, 2006 12:33 PM

What a refreshing reality show! The judges were not full of themselves and were genuinely interested and helpful! The contestants were all talented as well as entertaining. And absolutely the right two were competing in the last show! Very talented and very capable and very versatile. (I do have my favorite, but won't share it right now.)

Posted by Roberta – September 6, 2006 12:30 PM

NO! They should not co-host a show. Alice has a cute TV personality but that does not make up for her design abilities. All of David's designs have been Grade A, especially the final show. David has improved greatly in front of the camera and was confident in his design which said "WOW" (and from the voting, America loved it!), but Alice relied too much on the judges comments and ran out and tried to please them. Some of her elements were cute, but together they didn't quite make sense. The room looked cluttered and unfinished. Nothing about the room made me say "wow." All of David's designs have been spectacular!!
AS FOR THE JUDGES: they should have kept quiet. It seemed as though they were trying to sway the public's vote. If they wanted to make comments on the designs, it should have been on the next episode, after the public had voted.

Posted by Shelli – September 6, 2006 12:10 PM

I absolutelt loved the show. It's so hard to choose, but overall my favorite has been David. I really enjoy his personality, and the fact that he is comfortable with himself reflects through his work. Alice has done alot of great designs as well and to me her tiffany blue was pretty, but nothing else stands out for me. Tym had it tuff from the very start with Donna taking the money to the lazy carpenter. good luck to you both.

Posted by Ada – September 6, 2006 12:03 PM

Let me chime in with the many others -- make them a duo. They have fantastic chemistry together! I sure would watch!!!

Posted by Steve – September 6, 2006 12:00 PM

I love this show! David and Alice are rightfully the final contestants. I have always thought that they would be great sharing a show. They are the yin and yang - David has an artist's sophistication and Alice has a more earthy, endearing personality. They are attractive and friendly together. No matter who I voted for, I think HGTV would do well to keep these two together.

Posted by CJ – September 6, 2006 11:54 AM

We have less than a half hour to cast our votes and mine have been for Alice. Although I can't dispute David's design genius, I've realized he has a predictable, graphic bent and can't seem to deviate. In contrast, Alice has executed different styles each time. And, she's a quick study--she learns from her mistakes and takes advice to heart. Plus, she's comfortable with herself on camera, very welcoming and friendly. In contrast, David will need serious elocution coaching and counseling to overcome his lack of on-air confidence. He hasn't been open to design-advice thus far; would he be able to undergo a "communication-makeover"? My biggest fear is this: HGTV has an enormous female audience and David exudes sex-appeal. Will he garner more votes simply because we women can't help but admire a hunk?

Posted by Kaley – September 6, 2006 11:54 AM

I think David won the final challenge, but Alice's man's room was just spectacular. I agree with the previous commentor about the Designed to Sell show. The Lisa LaPorta designs are FAR superior to the Chicago designs.

Posted by Kathy – September 6, 2006 11:52 AM

I think David is the more talented of the two designers at the end. I enjoy his use of shapes and defining of space to create his rooms. He is simple, yet eloquent. Alice's designs seem commonplace - I've not been surprised by anything she's done, in fact I think I could do as well. David,on the other hand, is always surprising.

Posted by Candi – September 6, 2006 11:52 AM

I think David and Alice are both very talented. david turned me off as I think he was very calculating in the clothes he wore, (He was bare shirted most of the time so we could admire his manly physique). His shirts stretched to the utmost to show off his muscles. I don't need things to be spelled out so blatantly. I have 2 good eyes to see for myself. Alice was sexy without being pushy about it.

Posted by Bea – September 6, 2006 11:47 AM

Design Star has been very professional, especially compared to Project Runway. More about the designing, less about the silly arguing. I liked David's designs from the very beginning. Alice was more reserved and didn't shine until the end. Both are obviously very talented, and it was great to see the nice guys finishing last. I felt so bad for Tym and that awful carpenter he had to work with initially. And he didn't get any credit for his great decision to let him go and find another carpenter, who worked out great. Keep him in mind, HGTV! He is very talented. I was annoyed by Temple throughout the series, but she did work well with both David and Alice in the final challenge, so good for her. I have voted for David because I think his room is the best design, but I still like Alice. Maybe you could get rid of some of your worn-out shows, like Debbie Travis, and give them both a show! Both are professional and humble even! Great series! Loved it. I would watch Design Star Season 2!

Posted by Kathy – September 6, 2006 11:46 AM

I love this show! My sister got me hooked on HGTV and was the person who turned me onto Design Star - and now I can't stop watching!

I love David and Alice both. I think they're both good designers, both come off on screen as humble, kind, fun, and light-hearted. I do think, however, that since it needs to come down to one person, it will probably be David. Too bad, like so many others have mentioned, the show can't be co-hosted. I liked a lot of the elements in Alice's room (the ceiling thing was incredible! was that a lighting fixture? too bad we didn't get to see it all lit up at night in the middle of Manhattan!). I did think, however, that David's room was amazing. It was amazing the way he could bring such a calm and serene feeling to a glass room located right in the middle of New York City! I agreed with his decision to NOT add color, as I think it would have taken away from that serenity. And I also agreed with Alice's decision to not take the judge's advice to nix the curtains.

Both talented designers and both will make good hosts (Alice is a NATURAL! but I think David will have to work a little on letting his natural personality shine -- he seems like such a good guy in interviews -- he just needs to let that flow in his hosting).

I also think Tym would have made a fantastic host for a home improvement type show - with building things and stuff. Too bad we had to see him go. Of course, I'm especially on the edge of my seat waiting for the final episode so I can see Ramona and Vanessa again - NOT!

Can't wait for the results! Good luck to both!

Posted by Kathy – September 6, 2006 11:42 AM

This was the most fascinating show out of any on all the networks. My husband and I were both addicted. David was his choice from the beginning. I flip-flopped back and forth between David and Alice the entire time, so I was happy to see them end up as the finalists. I really thought I would choose Alice overall, but this last challenge really caused me to choose David. The way he incorporated the outdoor environment, the structure itself, the playing around with diffused lighting, etc. just was genius. I really want this room in my own house!!! Please send David to my house! And, FINALLY he seemed comfortable in front of the camera. I think that's what was causing me to lean towards Alice at first, but David really rocked this time.

They both have a ton of talent and should do well no matter what. I do hope David wins Design Star, but - like others have posted - I would love to see them both do something with HGTV. I hope we haven't seen the last of either one of them!

Congrats, David and Alice. You both have done outstanding jobs throughout the competition. We'd be happy seeing more of either of you!

Posted by Kimberley – September 6, 2006 11:41 AM

Although I think David is a great designer, his rooms all look too similar...modern, masculine, minimal.

Alice shows much more diversity in her designs and describes her rooms better to the audience. She seems much more comfortable in front of the camera.

My only change would be that they should be judged on the entire body of their work throughout the show and not just this one room.

Great concept for a show though! Keep up the good work HGTV and next time tell your contestants to remain fully clothed during the show.

Posted by Janice – September 6, 2006 11:38 AM

I have never seen a show so blatantly pimp one contestant over another. I really like both designers a lot and would love like many others to see these two host a show together. However, it was evident from the very beginning that the producers and judges were pushing for David. Not only did they kick off the show with him, they did everything they could to show him as strong and decisive while showing Alice as unsure of herself and her design. The judges gave him a complete pass while nit-picking Alice's room. I even predicted to my husband and daughter, who were watching with me, that they would turn it around at the end and make Alice got first. Sure enough, that's exactly what they did, thus giving David first and last exposure for the show. When Vern praised David by saying he could forget he was in Central Park when in his room after trashing Alice for not orienting her room to take full advantage of the park my husband about had a coronary. We have truly enjoyed this program and were completely heartbroken to see it ended in such a deliberately one-sided way. Good luck to both designers, they are BOTH stars in our books.

Posted by Julie Morris – September 6, 2006 11:36 AM

David and Alice are a terrific team, I enjoyed them throughout this whole design star. The judges were exceptional and honest.

Posted by Sharron Myers – September 6, 2006 11:31 AM

I missed the first episode where the woman was voted off, but have watched ever since. I think Alice is a good decorator and David is an awesome designer. I will be voting for David just because his room was more pulled together and he made and created some of the things in his room where as I think Alice bought too much. I wanted her to show us how she could create items for the room like she did in the challenge where they all had the same room to design. She went to her store and bought items then took the room and disassembled the bookcase and made it into other functional pieces. I was disappionted in the final challenge with her even though I do think she did a great job in the other challenges. I did not like her words on the headboard. Why didn't she put her artwork on the headboards instead of on a white board stuck on the frame of the house? I also didn't like the rocking horse. It was out of place because the room to me was for a child about 7 years old and older, but the horse was for a toddler. Just a thought. David's room was livable, airy, just AWESOME!! I loved the white sheers over the bed and his artwork is always great!! I could really relax in his room. I also want to say I am glad that Vanessa was voted off. She was too bossy and unwilling to work with others. She was overconfident in her room where she had to go to the beauty store. That was the most horrible room yet she was so confident and excited. The hairdryer had no purpose and she just placed knick-knacks all over the room. In the challenge where she and Alice and Joseph were a team redoing the living room, I don't think Joseph should of been voted off. I think he had alot of talent that we didn't get to see. It wasn't right for him to be voted off just because he was the team leader. Vanessa is the one who should of been voted off. She's the one who painted the heirloom. I would of liked to have seen what Joseph could do in a room of his own. I also think Temple should of been in the final 2 instead of Alice. While Temple did get on my nerves with her attitude some, I think it was because she's so passionate about her designing. Her room where she had to go to the automotive store was 2nd place to Davids! It was AWESOME, creative, and inventive, and a great design!! The judges talked harshly to her where she did the room at the apartment. The judges said it was too much of a doubles as this and that, but I think that's what DESIGN is about because people in small apartments and small houses NEED pieces in their homes that can be used differently. She had the color yellow and she did an AWESOME job and wasn't given credit for the room that she deserved. Temple you should of been in the final 2!! She's a hard worker and has great TV personality. The judges said she lacked personality, but I think she was great. Thanks

Posted by wendie – September 6, 2006 11:22 AM

I'm voting for David since he actually shows unique designs which are practical. His zen room gave good bones and as for the use of color, any client would be able to infuse specific tones via personal items. As for Alice, her body of work does not seem as original and takes of from whatever is available retail. The glass room curtains should have had more style in the hanging and the ribbo ties were too small. There should have been a puddle efect on the floor. They looked like something from Linens and Things just slopped up with some hair ribbons. There was no flow and it was Target decorating. Her projects often look cheap and are things you could do yourself. So why would I hire her instead of her competitor? Only if discounts to the trade more than made up for the cost I would otherwise pay.

Posted by life – September 6, 2006 11:21 AM

I am completely addicted to Design Star - and my kids love it too!!! It's so nice to have something that we can all enjoy watching together! I would like to commend both David and Alice on their professionalism and the support they have given to eachother and to the other contestants during the show. They both have shown a lot of class, a trait that is sorely lacking on TV today, especially in reality shows. I love them both and wish them both well regardless of who wins.

Posted by Debbie – September 6, 2006 11:21 AM

Alice is adorable and I have a great deal of respect for her. I wish she wouldn't play it quite so safe. She is very talented but, somewhat limited by not taking as many risks.

Since I vote on overall vision, I must vote for David. He has the daring creativity that I am looking for when I look for a designer, plus he has the ability to listen to the clients needs.

I really hope that whoever loses has the opportunity to make a few "guest" appearances on the winner's show. Plus we want Season #1 to come out on DVD!!!

Posted by Cosmo – September 6, 2006 11:20 AM

I love this show, its format and Clive! (I've been a huge fan of Designed to Sell.) From the beginning David has been in the lead. Ramona was a joke. The twins were sweet and talented but not a lot of common sense. Temple did drive the others mad and made it through as far as she did on instinct and just plain old drive. Donna was annoying. Tym was a great guy - with a greater body too - but seemed to be more of a carpenter than a designer. Both Alice and David are terrific and comfortable on camera but Alice's last room couldn't compete with David's spa like retreat. Maybe if she had replaced those white boards hanging in the glass windows with stained glass butterflies and bumble bees....so the light shines through them...and the headboards to the twin beds were weird. Even large, colorful plastic magnet letters that the kids could change out spelling different words would have been better. Is it safe to sleep with your brain near magnets? lol

All in all - despite his body ego - David is clearly the winner. I WISH ALICE ALL THE BEST..she's going to do great with her career, too

Posted by Arthur Wooten – September 6, 2006 11:11 AM

David's dezine was fantastic . He truly observes the space & goes from there . It was Beautiful The more I watched the reruns of the show I seen more details .How he incorporated the entrance with the stone rug & the boxes on either side & how it reflected on the inside . The three chairs ,the Canopy over the bed the headboard as a sogee screen. The bedding ect. it just seemed as though you were transported to that home . it was inviting JUST BEAUTIFUL.he has done this since the first show .
Alice let me down for the first time . I was disapointed in her room dezine. She was at loss with the empty space ,There was so much she could do from infancy,early childhood years to teenage years , boy or girl.in a children's room.
I loved her cooperation & team spirit& how she gave the people the dezine thy wanted.
she is just beautiful in her manor &ways . she short changed herself . she is a natural before the camera but you need both .She has showmanship.
David has our vote .
We love the show looke forward to the next show
God Bless , Ellen Krupp

Posted by Ellen Krupp – September 6, 2006 10:52 AM

Both Alice and David have strong design talents and a vibrant chemistry between them. Consider asking the winner if he or she would be willing to ask the other to co-host!

Posted by Joyce – September 6, 2006 10:51 AM

I loved the family room that Alice did last week but her children's room was not appealing to me at all. That yellow rug drained the room of energy and the white bed covers were boring, IMO. David's designs are intriguing and I always look forward to seeing what new design elements he is going to add to whatever he does. I think he is really the Design "Star."

Posted by Lynn – September 6, 2006 10:50 AM

I loved the show and wish HGTV would do this again maybe next year. How refreshing to watch David and Alice plan and carry out their designs. They are both talented, but I voted for David. It touches me to see a man cry and admit to praying!! Wow, nobody seems to do that much anymore. That's not the only reason I voted for him. I liked his room better. On another note, why shouldn't you work the coolest way possible...if you're hot take some clothes off!!! Way to go David!!!

Posted by Henrietta – September 6, 2006 10:45 AM

I wanted to make a comment...I do think this contest was weighted toward David. Due to the fact that neither designer knew they were going to get any "help" as they did from Tym/Temple, they had to design based on their own physical limitations. That is why I think we see Alice relying more on "store-bought" elements as opposed to David who is able to build things from "scratch". Most designers in the real world have tradespeople to work with to create custom designs...a key element that was missing in this competition. Still, I think the Alice in Wonderland scheme was more of a last minute gimmick for the presentation rather than a true inspiration for the design...otherwise, where were the "looking glass" elements, tea party, Mad Hatter and other references that could have been so cleverly implemented in the design? There could have been alot more whimsy without the room becoming too "theme-y". I love Alice and David, I think they are both darling! David however, I believe is the most versatile because he CAN design AND build one of a kind furnishings and artwork. He incorporates the entire environment into his designs. I believe a designer should have their own style which they do GREAT, as opposed to doing "every" style with mediocrity. Good luck to BOTH Alice & David... I have a feeling we haven't seen the last of either of them!

Posted by Lisa – September 6, 2006 10:42 AM

I really loved this Design star competition. The whole concept is truely engrossing. I think that the two best designers did shine through.
David;s designs were thought out, using all visual angles, he has fresh, creative, and bold ideas. My votes went to him..because of the wow factors.
Alice was disappointing with the kids room, The twin beds were blah, as was the bedcovers. The Alice in Wonderland theme was not carried out at all. I must say she is a natural in front of the camera, but her voise is annoying. However, David can learn to slow down, relax in front of the camera and explain his design ideas better.
Like so many others Can't they alternate a show?

Posted by Bonnie K – September 6, 2006 10:41 AM

Clive, I just want to say that you are an awesome Host !!!! Fun, up beat, kind, wonderful to watch, (Love you & Lisa on Design to sell-great combo). Design Stars has been really enjoyable. Very difficult to deside between David & Alice, they are both great personalities, and talent. David is our personal favorite, but I agree with others - a show hosting both of them, and throwing in Tym could only be good. Anxious for the out come on Sunday. Thanks again .......
Barb
(Idaho)-Not only do we have hot & cold running water up here - we have HGVT) ;-)

Posted by Barb J. – September 6, 2006 10:31 AM

I am glad to see that there are other viewers that feel the same way I do about David and Alice. Have the new show hosted by both of them!!!!!

They both bring alot to the table. David is very secure in his designs and thinks out of the box and Alice is very secure on camera and she really makes it fun to watch her (I loved her extra tip she gave to parents!). David needs polishing on camera and Alice's designs needs some pizazz but if the two worked together they would compliment each other greatly.
They look great together on camera and have such a great repoire with each other. They support each other. I love them both - it makes it hard to choose.

Posted by Jill – September 6, 2006 10:26 AM

David "got it", Alice "lost it"!

If you have co-hosts, make it the "David & Tym" show, have them work together on each design, and the results would be awesome.

I hate the Southern Twang in Alice's voice, it gets on my nerves very quickly. I would not be able to watch an entire show with her talking in it. Maybe if she didn't talk...

Posted by Jordan – September 6, 2006 10:22 AM

great job to all the designers but, david, of course because of his designs but i have a feeling that both of them will come out winners. hopefully david, his own show and maybe alice could co host with him as a "special designer" guest. now that would be a great show.
good job hgtv and to clive too

Posted by rose mary – September 6, 2006 10:20 AM

I voted for David, his room was more pulled together in my opinion. BUT, he and Alice worked together so well, I really think a show with the both of them would be so great. I would watch that show, no doubt.

My sister wasn't watching the show, cause we both hate reality shows and the initial commercials showed a lot of conflict. But after watching the second show I got hooked and got her hooked by the forth show. Not like the other reality shows at all. This show is really based on design skill, not who wins the fights. Kudos for the judges, they made some tough decisions toward the end.

I would really like to see Tim come into his own. He has a good feel to him. I hope being on this show, doesn't mean that HGTV will not keep him on call.

Posted by Janie – September 6, 2006 10:16 AM

I too thoroughly enjoyed the show. I voted for Alice. While I agree that David has great talent, I feel Alice has the whole package put together. Her designs are more functional and true to real life. (Which is where I live!) David's room could have been pulled from an asian furniature showroom. Whoever wins though, I'll keep watching!

Posted by amy – September 6, 2006 9:48 AM

?All I want to say is that HGTV would be nuts not to capitalize on these two.They are like pennut butter and jelly they go together.It would be fun to see what they could.I hope someone takes the time to hear all of who have said this.Clive loved the show what I saw of it and Im sorry I didnt give it a chance.But I thought it would be like the others just a lot of nasty people.Your Fan Chrissy

Posted by Chrissy – September 6, 2006 9:40 AM

The show exudes talent and class. I look forward to Sunday evenings and will miss the show. You have captured an audience that wants to improve their living space and I feel the show's ability to teach the homeowner to make intelligent choices is great. Watching the designers gain confidence is uplifting. I like that the judges are encouraging and truly want to advise the designers, rather than tear them down like many of the other reality shows. David and Alice have a tremendous presence that will appeal to all audiences! Clive, please DESIGN a way to have both Alice and David on their own show. YOU can make it happen !! Their show would be filled with talent galore and I love that they actually care about the clients. It shows in their faces, actions, etc. Clive, congratulations! You are a terrific host and the judges are first-class. Your Show will Never be Cancelled on my TV. Looking forward to next season, Deb
(PS .. .. I do hope that David will learn from this show he has TRUE talent and doesn't need to rely on anything else .. .. as he states in his earlier comments about being pretty, etc.)

Posted by Deb – September 6, 2006 9:32 AM

Both should have their own show or perhaps together. Both can offer a lot together. David thinks outside the box, but seems limited to contemporary, whereas Alice can work in any style with ease. I love her Southern accent. I am glad she doesn't have a Boston accent. Too many are from California or Northeast anyway. Let's have more from the real part of the US. I can't make up my mind. David was a great team player and Alice didn't fall into the jealousy or narcisstic trap like Donna, Temple and Vanessa. David has always stood out, too, throughout the competition. Love them both, HOPE IT'S A TIE!!!!!

Posted by Mo – September 6, 2006 9:26 AM

Can't tell you how much I enjoyed this program. I couldn't wait from one week until the next. I enjoyed each week, except for the bickering when contestants were working in teams. I really thought the two in the finals were the right two. I voted for David; I thought his work was exceptional...especially the week with the pet store products. Alice , also did a fantastic job. I appreciated her talent.I do hope to see something similar to this show soon. Sincerely, Jamey

Posted by Jamey Spence – September 6, 2006 9:24 AM

Something just occurred to me, something that I think could be a really important factor in deciding between Alice and David. During the series, there have been several comments on David's forte being designing for children. I think perhaps Alice decided to take on David at his strongest point and design a child's room that was more comfortable and less over-the-top!

David's audition tape showed a wild green jungle room with custom-built bunk beds (at least that's what it looked like) His design for the kids' end of the basement was the same over-the-top explosion of color -- and it didn't tie in to the rest of the room at all! It was as if an invisible line had been drawn between brown/beige/black minimalist adult area and riotous explosion of color kids' area.

Personally, I think Vern Yip and Martha McCully have been unreasonably critical of Alice -- even though she has won two of the challenges! They say things like "Your designs never surprise me." and something about not having a defined design style. I said it before! Alice works with her clients to satisfy THEIR needs. Her room are not cookie-cutter copies of each other. Each one stands on its own.

I think the unremitting pressure and publicity may have finally gotten to Alice -- and not being able to find pieces she wanted [she said those curtains were not what she wanted when she was shopping -- but she used them, dressed them up with brightly colored ribbons, and said not one word to the judges about not actually liking them herself.

Alice is a class act all the way! David would be great as the furniture builder for Alice's show, but between his too-consistent designs and his play for votes with his shirtless look, I don't really think he's a Design Star.

Kudos to both for their consistent up-beat moods, their willingness to work with anyone, their peace-keeping skills, and their honesty and compassion. Alice and David are both models of talented, highly competitive people who can and do work well with others. That quality stood out from the very first episode -- and I think, ultimately, it's what got them to the point where they were able to showcase their individual design skills.

Posted by Deanna – September 6, 2006 9:23 AM

I hope David wins! He is an awsome designer. Alice is a shopper...did she actually design anything...or just bought it all??? Also, I am from the South...but Alice's twang really bothers me. She does seem very sweet, though. I am sure that both David and Alice will end up on design shows. Congratulations to both of them! I cannot wait for the next "Design Star" show. I loved this season.

Posted by Donna – September 6, 2006 9:09 AM

I loved this type of show, very unique to show off the talents of different types of people. Through the shows it was obvious to me when their shows were cancelled. Although we never really got to know those voted off early.

I loved the two finalist, I really would like to see both of them on a show. They seemed to have become friends and it showed. Although I did have to cringe by the bare chested David on every show and the cleavage on Alice in one episode. They both are great looking young people. I thought David bought a shirt two sizes to small for him in the final episode to show off his muscles. :-)

Anyway I voted for Alice as I live not far from her in Texas. She has a warm and calming personality with a country flair that would wear well on TV. David has great ideas and his modern approach is good for this century. For us old folks since I am 81 I love the country look and love neutral colors of brown and beiges that David used. That is why it was hard to choose but since I had to, I went with Alice.

Hope they both win!!

Letta Meinen

Posted by Letta Meinen – September 6, 2006 8:39 AM

David and Alice are both very talented designers. Alice's design is very down to the earth, practical, very classic but plain. David's design is very creative and exciting with nice surprising. He gave us many "WOW"... David has quick mind, he dealt frustration better in the show. He was nervous, but his big smile always brought the audiences with pleasant feeling (rather than being stressed out when watching Alice). I voted him. I agree with another person on this board that David needs to improve his professional appearance.I wish if he will host shows, he needs to be more careful with his dress code. Taking off his shirt is not very professional on the national show. Also his tattoo distorted his public image. I'd cover it up.

Posted by Jade – September 6, 2006 8:32 AM

ALICE ALICE ALICE
Vote Alice. All of David's designs look alike. Yes he did a great job, but over and over and over it's the same. Alice is able to do different styles. She has a great personality, will listen to the customer's desires and not just go in the direction she wants. For the long haul her show would draw you in. It's Alice all the way!!!!
Rachel

Posted by Rachel – September 6, 2006 8:12 AM

I would like to see both David and Alice work on HGTV Alice, is by far, my favorite. I think if Alice could have found the twin beds she was looking for, the room would have been fabulous. I thought David's room the week before last was just plain ugly. David does not have the ability to maintain creative design. He would do well on a show like Design on a Dime but he does not have the talent to stand out on his own. Alice has the personality to host a design show.

Posted by Deana – September 6, 2006 7:52 AM

I thought I would have a difficult choice to make with the last show.

After watching Sunday and one of the reruns, the vote is an easy one. David created a fantastic design, I couldn't believe the intimacy he created in a cold glass box. I felt protected and comfortable imaging myself in the room, even though the whole world was around me.

I was so disappointed in what Alice created for a "CHILDREN'S" bedroom. I would not want my children in what felt like an unfinished dorm room. I liked some of the more adult furniture, but those cold metal lockers, even though colorful, were awful.

I really looked forward to seeing her vision, and thought it would be much more colorful and a lot softer.

This might have worked for a teen, but children need softness and warmth. There was none in the final room! The plain white institutional bedspreads left me with the feeling of being as cold as ice. No amount of throws on a lovely colorful chair could make up for not having soft, warm, colorful throws on those beds.

Thank you Clive for an interesting series. Best wishes to David!

Posted by Gwen – September 6, 2006 6:33 AM

I too, was fascinated with the show. I hold a degree in fine arts, and am married to an inovative Architect. It was apparent from the beginning, that David is schooled in the arts. His basic design principles are sophisticated. With knowledge and talent, one can design anything. It is all one principle, whether shoes, clothing, unbrellas, houses, or nose rings!

Alice is darling, and there is certainly a place for her. She is a decorator. Her work is pleasing, and charming. Her work will make many people happy. Her presentation is superb!

David, on the otherhand, is first and foremost a sculptor, thus, the ability to apply his talents in 3 dimensional setting. I think his weakness only exhibits in his one dimensional paintings. Color is not his forte, as with most architects.

I vote for David, as I believe he is really out there with the talent, education, desire, drive, and spirit, all which will enhance his contribution to whatever he may endeavor to accomplish.
Joan Stoyanoff

Posted by JOAN STOYANOFF – September 6, 2006 4:26 AM

Whoever made the comment about David being a designer and Alice being a decorator hit the nail on the head. Week after week I looked forward to what David was going to design, even if he didn't quite achieve the perfect outcome every time. Even though his design concepts are similar he has true vision and talent and ability to develop an original idea, whereas Alice decorates her rooms with whatever she finds on her shopping trips and always has a very safe predictable outcome (yawn).

Alice's hosting skills were more natural from the start but I think I would get tired of her syrupy sweetness and annoyed by her nasally, twangy voice. I don't think I could stand to watch her cry every time she was stressed or something went wrong. David's hosting improved dramatically and can only get better, especially without the pressure of having to be in a competition.

So - the question is who's show would we want to watch more? Personally I would look forward to watching a show where I didn't quite know what to expect, where the design would be really fun and innovative every time even if it wasn't totally practical. I might watch the first episode of Alice's show just out of curiosity but would not want to watch again - too predictable and boring. I think David should win (since it is called "Design Star" and not "Decorating Star") but I think he should decline and hand it over to Alice. Then someone at one of the major networks should develop a show for him and let him have the widespread exposure he deserves.

Posted by Beth – September 6, 2006 4:00 AM

David...ALL THE WAY! I adore Alice, how can you not, she's just the sweetest thing - maybe too sweet to watch week after week? All I know is this, I'm hiring David to design the house I'm buying my mom in Los Angeles. Ain't no one out there that can WOW us like him!! David, Alice - best of everything!!

Posted by Roberta – September 6, 2006 3:42 AM

I thought Alice's design pretty ordinary -- anyone could have come up with that child's room...other than the light and the dots, it was so-so.

David, on the other hand, showed originality, style and confidence once he decided on a design. It's clear to see that once he commits to that design, he works very hard to make it happen...and it does. He's much better than Alice. Don't get me wrong...she's ok, and certainly has a great stage presence. But if you want originality, true creativity and someone who will always wow you, David's the man! Ok, he shows off his great body, but who cares? It's his designs that count, and he's got it there, too! Can I vote again, please, Clive??

Posted by Annie – September 6, 2006 3:08 AM

I would like to see both of them on HGTV shows, maybe one for every other week in turns. I do like the originality of David's design all the way. he seems very comfortable with oriental style/accent and very artistic on painting and drawing for kids, and have the clean, simple style and great feeling for the space and color, I would love to be in one of the room he designs.

On the other hand, Alice has the clean style, and she has very good feelings about color and accent pieces. She finished big challenges to design a 'man room' and I do think a 'Alice's wonderland' is be a great theme and kids may love Alice's room for the final challenge too.

I think if HGTV is planing on a show, it needs different styles and variations, have two or a little more would be better than one style. maybe even invite a few of the competitors such as Temple and Tym back for one episode would be nice. Since all audience would like to see fresh idea and different styles to fit their needs. And designer's would be tired of design a new room every week.

Overall, some of the earlier round of team work does not work as well as individual challenges. we really like to see what every competitor can do on hisown, not wasting time arguing with teammates or struggling on money issues.

Alice's hosting TV is very natural, comfortable, and adorable. David's skill has been improved but still needs work, and please keep his words at the same pace as the camera, not ahead. I do agree with some comments here, taking his shirt off seems a little 'show off' to me.

Both of them will have great future and they deserve the title of 'design star'. Good luck!

Posted by Ling – September 6, 2006 2:39 AM

Alice needs to replace one of your other hosts.
If the show they are to get is design orientated then David.
Alice works with the client and so she's not as creative as David.
But Alice would be a great addition to your hosting staff hands down.

Posted by Janet – September 6, 2006 2:33 AM

I have kept track of the work of both designers. While David's designs are innovative and polished, they all seem basically the same and I'm not sure that they would be as practical or liveable as Alice's. She seems to be able to adapt to different client needs better. I feel like I could actually use her rooms. Your final show seemed a bit slanted towards one designer by the way. Either it wasn't fair or it was an attempt to sway viewer votes.

Posted by Erin E. – September 6, 2006 2:26 AM

Yes, David's audition tape is so annoying it makes you not want to vote for him, but he so clearly had the best design.

Posted by Gin – September 6, 2006 1:49 AM

I too agree that David, while talented, seems to show two dimensions: that he can paint and that he is contemporary, modern, minimalist designer.
While Alice seems to be a little underdeveloped, she seems to have a range of design ideas. She is the sort of designer whose clients would be mostly satisfied but not always blown away by her work. David on the other hand will find a niche in the moden world, and will almost always exceed expectations. A tight battle.
In the end it would be good if we knew what type of show HGTV had in mind for these stars. If it will be a niche show then David is the best choice. If it's more of a smorgasboard type show, Alice edges David out.

Posted by Carolyn – September 6, 2006 1:43 AM

Hope the producers are listening -- David and Alice are great TOGETHER!!! How about a show that features the two of them? Seems like a lot of viewers have had the same idea; maybe it's a good one. Just one suggestion: David needs to keep his shirt on. His eagerness to display his fine physique is a distraction. After all -- this is supposed to be a DESIGN show!

Posted by Connie S – September 6, 2006 1:32 AM

I voted for David. The rug he made from a pet store finds won me over then. I like his smile, tatoo and caring attitude. Alice is a winner too.Please find a show for her too. Guest spots on David's would be nice.

Posted by Jackie – September 6, 2006 1:28 AM

I loved both Alice and David! PLEASE make it a co-hosted show, using both of them. They work so well together and are so supportive of one another. I am very anxious to see the "final" episode!

Posted by Kris – September 6, 2006 1:24 AM

I honestly thought I'd hate the show when it first started, but I got hooked. I love it! I have agreed with every elimination so far. It's a tough one between David and Alice - they are both great! David seems to have a more 'one-trick' style, but he's very imaginative and creative. Alice is great on camera and so likeable! Give them each a show, or let them co-host!

Posted by Dennis – September 6, 2006 12:52 AM

I enjoyed all the shows. Have to agree the judges comments should have not been aired on the final show. David is more a sex symbol than a designer. Alice has my vote!!!!!! She is great. Her designs are more on track with homeowners who watch TV and do not hire designers to decorate their homes.

Posted by Janie – September 6, 2006 12:44 AM

I would love for HGTV to give them a show together. They compliment each other so well!

That's one show that would make my DVR list.

Please, Please HGTV consider it!!!!

Posted by Sherry – September 6, 2006 12:18 AM

I agree with previous sentiments that say David & Alice complement each other and that they should co-host a show. They do have great chemistry together and it would be a fun show to watch. They have very different styles and perspectives. I think their show would provide a great deal of insight into design by providing two different perspectives. Does there always need to be a winner and a loser? Can't they both win?

Posted by David – September 6, 2006 12:11 AM

Alice and David are both magnanimous. The whole package whom we know as Alice, with her diversity and her natural ability to interact with all from t.v. behind the sceenes crews to clients themselves, would offer up a T.V. show that would appeal to a wider range of the population who watches hgtv's productions. David grew from week to week and came through with flying colors. He, too, deserves to have a career in the television industry. It is my hope that both these people land careers within the industry. They worked so hard to reach the final two and they satisfied our appetites for entertainment and viewing pleasure.

Posted by Adrien – September 6, 2006 12:06 AM

I watched with much excitement on Sunday night, the final episode between Alice and David. When I saw the glass houses in the park, I just about came unglued. One word question: Why?
David, once again, spent way too much time shirtless. His approach to design has become too predictable. Being an HGTV addict I knew exactly where he would go-Zen-wow wasn't that a new concept.
Now Alice, that is a woman after my own heart. Step out of your comfort zone and really show what you can do with little direction. And the play on words, Alice's Wonderland, was quite smooth. Her room was fun but allowed for a child to move from the early years beyond with a few updates along the way. Loved the slight use of the silk drapes in the corners-at least she didn't cover up the view of the park.
Don't even get me started on the arrival of the judges. They were done last week and I thought they were not appropriate for the finale.
And Temple and Tym, please. At least Temple kept her comments to herself for a change.
Yes David and Alice are both talented but Alice walked into Wonderland to become the next Design Star.
Thanks Clive for your part-you rock!

Posted by Sally – September 6, 2006 12:02 AM

I was very pleased that David and Alice were the finalist. If It was up to me I would make them co-host. There is a very likable chemistry between them. I truly enjoyed the show. Not an avid TV watcher but Design Star got my attention. All through out I found Alice and David both very gracious. I do have a preference for David's work. But Alice shows so much talent a versatility.

Posted by Cuz – September 5, 2006 11:51 PM

I really enjoyed this program, especially since I don't "do" reality shows. The challenges were all interesting and really made the designers kick it up a notch!

David and Alice have been my favs the whole time, so I'll be glad with whoever wins. But like others have posted, I would LOVE to see both of them co-host a show.

Posted by Danielle – September 5, 2006 11:47 PM

My husband and I have thoroughy enjoyed the series and have agreed with the three judges. However, we both feel that instead of just one winner, that David and Alice would make a great team somehow, co-hosting a show. With their combined talents and personalities, they would be incredible together. Also, Clive was an inspiration and fabulous choice for host.

Posted by Jean Baird – September 5, 2006 11:45 PM

David is SMOKING HOT. I hope he hosts his new show with his shirt off.

Posted by Ken – September 5, 2006 11:35 PM

THEY WERE BOTH MY PICK FROM THE BEGINNING AND ARE BOTH GOOD DESIGNERS. I PICKED DAVID BECAUSE I LIKED ALL OF HIS DESIGNS AND HE JUST SEEMED LIKE AN AROUND PERSON. I WOULD THINK THAT WOULD MAKE THE HOMEOWNERS VERY COMFORTABLE TO RELAY THEIR WISHES AND DREAMS AND ALSO BE ABLE TO STAY IN THEIR BUDGET. GOOD LUCK, DAVID

Posted by ROYCE – September 5, 2006 11:35 PM

they were both great but david's designs always seemed right on the money. too bad they can't host a show together. alice is very sweet and i think she is genuine.

Posted by pat – September 5, 2006 11:10 PM

I voted for Alice; I think she has a lot of class; I wish David would wear a shirt. I think his designs are very cold; I don't care for that kind of decorating. He is also very nervous in front of a camera. Alice is very calm and friendly and if she were to do a show, I'm sure her decorating would be even better as she'd have some time to plan! She also dresses like a lady!
Clive is a great host! I always watch his show, Designed to Sell!

Posted by Jo – September 5, 2006 11:06 PM

I have really enjoyed the show! I was really glad to see Donna go! Alice and David were the best by far of the group. I agree with others that the two would be great together on a show, but alone, Alice isn't there yet. David definitely has his own style, but also seems to "get it" better at this point. I think they are both great personalities, even better than some of the show hosts HGTV has now! Clive, you are fantastic! I love Designed to Sell with you and Lisa! The new show just doesn't do it like you two do! I hope you are back on it soon! Best wishes to David and Alice! (PS, David, although the package looks nice, keep the shirt on. It is very unprofessional!)

Posted by Terri – September 5, 2006 11:05 PM

David's designs are so superior to Alice's. He can be groomed for tv. Alice may be "cuter" but her voice is grating and her designs are mediocre at best. I hope David wins for his originality and imagination.

Posted by Diane – September 5, 2006 11:02 PM

I'm hooked on this show. I thought the judges should not have been allowed to make any comments before Alice & David completed their designs. They obviously favored David. For several weeks now, I've thought David would win, and he's got my vote. Alice is a close second, but her children's room design seemed chaotic to me, and David's was more of a wow. Hope to see future design star competitions. I can live without hearing the grievances of the eliminated designers on the final episode.

Posted by Sonja – September 5, 2006 11:00 PM

I liked the concept, but I don't think I would be as interested if they do this same competition again. How many design shows can there be? Maybe if the next theme or search were different, it could work. This is my opinion, of course. Reality shows, a la "American Idol" get old really fast. I loved seeing all the talent and how each contestant faced each challenge. Maybe next time, a "team" search might be something to consider. Seeing Tym and Temple working with Alice and David added a great deal to this particular show. Whatever the production staff decides, I hope they keep Clive as the host. He is, as always, a joy to watch.

Posted by Jacki – September 5, 2006 10:56 PM

Why did the judges chstise Alice for not considering the park's fountain and then not mention that David didn't consider it either? How can one find zen in a glass room in the middle of a NY City park? Were the designers supposed to make practical use of the glass room in the park? When the judges reviewed Alice's room they appeared to think so but when they looked at David's where was that condsidered? I am obviously confused by these judges.

Posted by Sharon – September 5, 2006 10:55 PM

I have thoroughly enjoyed all the episodes of Design Star, but particularly thought the eispodes where the designers worked alone the most important. In reality, how many designers work in teams??

However, I was frustrated with the flaws in the show concept - I know very few designers who are carpenters, electricians, seamstresses or painters. Their training is in translating their customer's needs and wants into designs and concepts that can be executed by skilled tradespeople. David is an exception in that he does everything, but that also limits him to what he can do, whereas if a designer has a good rapport with skilled craftsmen, their design possibilities are expanded. Vern said a designer shouldn't offer a client something they couldn't do themselves. Really???? Is he a licensed plumber or electrician? Does he belong to the carpenter's union? If not, then according to his own words, he cannot design kitchens or bathrooms.

I think the creators of the show had a great concept, but they got a little confused as to what they wanted - an architect or designer, or an interior decorator?

I agree with others that the judges were very biased and I thought it very unfair to bring them into this episode at all.

After all of the above, I will vote for Alice because she showed grace under pressure, ability to listen to a client or have an understanding of their needs and, within the extreme constraints of the show, come up with lovely, liveable rooms with concepts that are easy to copy in real life. On the other hand, how many of us could recreate much of what David did, or in reality live in it?

Posted by Jan – September 5, 2006 10:45 PM

David has a great sence of houmor.Plus he took of his shirt in the first episode.

Posted by Alt – September 5, 2006 10:35 PM

DAVID ROCKS. I really hope he wins. His talent, not only with design, but with all the graphic & original art make him an all-around fabulous designer! (Alice is B.O.R.I.N.G & A.N.N.O.Y.I.N.G)

Posted by Lindsey Dino – September 5, 2006 10:22 PM

I trully enjoyed this show, i voted for David. In my mind if I am going to hire a designer is because I want the WOW factor and although I think Alice's personalaity is charming her design are no different than any ordinary person with good taste would do. If I am paying for a design, they better bring something that only a designer could do, otherwise i will do it myself and to me that is what sets David appart. I do think that Alice would make a good co-host and that Tym would contribute to the creativeness.Brendalee/Florida and Puerto Rico

Posted by BRENDALEE – September 5, 2006 10:20 PM

What a great show! How refreshing to see a "reality show" that requires talent instead of luck or looks! It was fun to watch each participant grow as the show progressed. In the end however, I really think David pulled it off. Alice is truly a natural on camera, but David is becoming more relaxed with each effort.

I hope there will be additional contests of this type on HGTV. Clive, you are a great host of this show and Designed to Sell.

Posted by Darlene – September 5, 2006 10:14 PM

I think both of them are great and should both have there own show David is creative and colorful and Alice is fun and great to be around they both are fantastic U GO GIRL!!! TEXAS IS AWESOME!!

Posted by Bonita – September 5, 2006 10:13 PM

I love both ALice and David but David definately has the design talent that would make a great show. His ability to make art out of almost anything to complement a design is remarkable. He can build things as well. Alice did a nice room but I think it was one that almost anyone could have done with a little talent. She has good taste but not that much creativity.

Posted by Carol – September 5, 2006 10:09 PM

I'm still torn between Alice and David, even though I've already voted a couple of times! But the show was meant to entertain and it did that. This was a very compelling competition. The winner has certainly earned the title.

A few comments:
1. We saw too many designs that were done for the camera - a creative surface treatment of a given space. We did not see designs that were meant to be lived in as a long-term solution to space/design problems. Examples: the famous kitchen floor, a bedroom with no storage space, and little attention paid to lighting.
2. This was not design "reality". No designer would ever have to complete a job in such a ridiculously short amount of time. Nor would a designer be allowed to just go his or her own way, without input and approval from a client. And no designer would have to do construction. That's what craftsmen/women do...and with a considerable amount of advanced planning and consultation with both the designer and the client. (As an aside, I know of no experienced "carpenters" who would paint for a client. My dad was a union carpenter, and while I could trust him implicitly with building materials and power tools, he was no painter, nor would the union allow him to be.)
3. We HGTV fans are used to seeing a completed project in a half hour. But most of the shows we love are taped over several weeks, not several hours. Decorating with quality materials requires expertise, good taste, shopping...and time.
4. In the future - Keep all contestants on for at least two weeks before asking anyone to leave. Have them work with real clients sooner in the competition. Show more of the design process, and fewer tears. Certainly creativity does not begin and end at Ikea...I know many people who would never want their style to include cheap comtemporary furniture. Show me a designer who must deal with a sentimental client, one who simply must have Aunt Milly's china cabinet or Uncle Ted's hall tree as part of the design.

And finally, edit these shows to highlight true design content - NOT the catfights, the skin, or the innuendo regarding contestants' personal lives. Both the contestants and the audience deserve better than that.

All that being said, I really do love HGTV. And I wish for the winning designer an exciting and successful adventure as the first Design Star!

Posted by KK – September 5, 2006 10:08 PM

This show has really gotten and kept my attention. I think it's because the 10 potential design stars each have memorable personalities--or at least the editing has allowed them to develop a viewable personna. An excellent and compelling show--even more so because we now have a part in it!

Posted by Virginia – September 5, 2006 10:05 PM

Alice and David were great. They should co-host a show. I voted for David.

Posted by Elouise – September 5, 2006 10:05 PM

I think both David & Alice are fantastic & I would like to see them on a show together. Their designs show two totally different styles. David's is more "artsy" and minimalistic, while Alice's is more comfortable and real. That said, I can picture David's work in a magazine, while Alice is the one I would want to do a redesign of my own house.Also, Alice has the very best TV presence, while David can be a bit full of himself.I have to vote for Alice-I can relate to her more.

Posted by Laureen – September 5, 2006 10:02 PM

After having watched each of the shows with great interest, I DO conclude that David is the clear winner in terms of his abilities. Having also had the benefit of watching most of these shows with a dear friend (who owns his own design firm), I came to appreciate the clear vision that David projects in his creations. He believes in himself wholeheartedly, which is not always the case with others...on this show or not.
I was afraid that since the majority of design decisions are done by the female in the home, I am glad that the majority of comments here have recongnized the talent of a man to create spaces that transcend all ages and styles. David can go calm, he can go kinetic. Whatever the variable, he adapts. Vote for him and let's anticipate his future work.

Posted by Steve – September 5, 2006 10:02 PM

I feel that David is more creative and able to
work with his hands making and assembling ideas
for his designs. His design using a pet store
as his assignment was very cleaver! Alice also
has a different type of talent. She uses store
bought items instead of creating them herself,
but she is definitely a charming personality.
Even though I voted for David for his originality, I also believe a show with both
hosting would definitely have me as a viewer.
Good luck to both of you! I have enjoyed the
challenge. It was great!

Posted by Diane – September 5, 2006 10:00 PM

I really like them both. David has great artistic talent and his Asian inspired bedroom was fantastic. He really showed his creativity! Alice's room, while very bright and cheery, seemed to be average. I do feel she has an exceptional t.v. presence and is very charming and perky! She would make a perfect t.v. host. I am torn! They are both great and I think they'll do equally well in their field!

Posted by Nancy – September 5, 2006 9:53 PM

I enjoyed the show very much. I think both designers have design styles miles apart. I think it's going to be tough choosing one style. Alice is traditional almost always. And that has its place, and David has a clean contemporary style. Both pull it off. I voted for David though, he always surprised me with completeness of design. Maybe they should cohost a show, they seem well suited for that.

Posted by Kathy – September 5, 2006 9:39 PM

Dani(Sept 3) is right.I also think it would be great if David and Alice had a show together! They DO seem to have great chemistry.

Posted by Kim – September 5, 2006 9:39 PM

I loved this show! I voted for David - he is a real designer. I liked Alice - but I think I could have done what she did; nothing exciting. Can't wait for the next season!

Posted by Alison – September 5, 2006 9:34 PM

I have sooo enjoyed this series! The two that deserve to be here certainly are. I think both designers bring such talent from two totally different perspectives. Why not have a co-host show? I think the pair of Alice and David would be fabulous! David would bring the 'wow' factor and Alice the 'elegant simplicity'. Such a dynamic duo! Think about it HGTV... I think David edged Alice out on the glass house project. Why in the world were the judges there to offer any opinion? I think we saw David stand fast on his design and Alice shuffle which was too bad.
Cannot wait for the next group!

Posted by kristin – September 5, 2006 9:31 PM

David is a designer in every sense of the word. Alice is a decorator..she purchases, fixes, and fusses...David deals with space, spatial, color, texture and balance...He is the natural winner..and if it goes the other way...then, something is wrong with the show.

Posted by jan – September 5, 2006 9:30 PM

Go Alice! I hope so much she gets her own show. I appreciate her professionalism, her talent and ideas! She did a great job with her room. I was surprised the judges said as much as they did to Alice, especially knowing how very little time she had. I enjoyed seeing Tym again.

Posted by Teresa R. – September 5, 2006 9:29 PM

I have enjoyed the show so much that I've actually watched the weekly reruns as well. I agree with the large number of people that both David and Alice should have their own shows, or co-host together. They are a great team, and balance each other so well!

Hope you do the show again!!

I LOVE HGTV!!!!!!!

Posted by Sharon – September 5, 2006 9:29 PM

Alice all the way! She has great style and a fabulous TV presence. I really like her - she's genuine and honest. David has great talent, but I hated watching him with his shirt off all the time. Alice is a class act!

Posted by Stacy – September 5, 2006 9:28 PM

I've found that responses from your viewers mirrored my own impressions. I like the idea of David and Alice co-hosting a show, but the design trio of David, Temple and Tim for a Design on the Dime team might be a great "consolation" gift. Guess that says where my votes went. :-)

I also appreciated the lack of "drama" on Design Star, that seems to be a staple on similar reality based shows. I know there was some early on, but those people found themselves off the show. In the real world, no one wants to deal with a prima-dona, much less hire them to design their home. In the end you were left with people who respected each other's talent, and skill and that was a much better "reality" to watch.

Posted by Mary Ann – September 5, 2006 9:22 PM

David is a designer, Alice is a decorator. David has a great body but I could do with a little less of it on camera. The judges seemed to lean toward Alice because of her Cutesy little girl squeal but I could not watch 30 minutes of that high annoying almost scream. She seems a little too immature to host a show IMO. I voted for David and hope he wins. He is creative and would have an interesting show.

Posted by A.J – September 5, 2006 9:21 PM

WOW, what a wonderfull show. I have so enjoyed the entire process. Clive you are a great host. I think the judges were very fair in there comments, and decision's. I wish both could win! David, Alice I have been pulling for the two of you since the begining. I had such a hard time making a decision. GOOD LUCK TO BOTH OF YOU.

Posted by jerry – September 5, 2006 9:19 PM

I have enjoyed this show tremendously and love both Alice and David. I went into the final viewing really wanting to decide who should be the next design star because in my mind they both are wonderful. However, I was so disappointed with the way the judges obviously leaned toward David and I believe this will sway the audience. For instance, they both did bedrooms -- but the judges chose to lie down on David's bed and view the sky and commented on how he took that into consideration. Really! If they had lain on Alice's bed, they would have seen the same view!!! I am disappointed in the judges. I cast my vote for Alice because not only does she design for real people who live in real homes (not glass houses), but because she has been treated unfairly.

Posted by Barbara -- – September 5, 2006 9:18 PM

Both of these young people have gained so much experience by doing this very interesting and creative show, so I don't think either of them walk away a loser in any way. They both are talented, enjoyable, creative, fun and will offer all of their clients in the future a job well done from what the have gained from this show.

This was a show worth watching!

Posted by Debbie – September 5, 2006 9:05 PM

Put clothes on David? What about Alice? At times I wasn't sure if we were watching "Design Star" or a remake of "Valley of the Dolls".

Posted by Fran – September 5, 2006 9:00 PM

All David's designs were minial and more asian influence, which was the safeway to go as everyone who watches home shows, know that is Vern'style. Alice took some risks. Both are good butAliceshouldwin as she is more versitle in her design.

Posted by barb – September 5, 2006 8:50 PM

David is cool when he's designing, except when his shirt is off. He needs to wear a shirt. I like his design, and if I needed either Alice or David to redesign my room, I'd pick David's style, but Alice is good, too, and she's really nice. Pity they both couldn't win together and work as a team, which they'd be good at.

Posted by rebekah – September 5, 2006 8:47 PM

As I've said before, Alice has a wonderful demeanor, but other than that, she just buys furniture. Some have said that it was a disadvantage to her to not have Tym on her team on the first day, but even when she had a carpenter at her disposal in the past, she did not use him to build. Also, has no one noticed that she had to stoop under the light fixture? It may have been pretty, but she obviously did not think in terms of the height of the room.

Lastly, some have said that David tried to collect votes by not wearing a shirt. Has no one noticed the cleavage?

Now I feel like dirt, because I really like Alice. However, the people at HGTV are way too smart to let Alice get away without giving her a spot on another show, and I'll be watching it.

P.S. Several have asked about the light fixture in Alice's room. In Alaska they sell it at the Lighting Gallery by Browns. If Alaska has it -- it should be about everywhere. Trust me on this one.

Posted by M in Alaska – September 5, 2006 8:47 PM

I voted for David, but it was a hard choice to make. My one concern about David is that if you look back at his work each week it is all a little bit the same. Alice shows more ability to change the design style she uses in each situation. They both have great hosting potential. Like many others who have posted here I would recommend giving David and Alice a show together. But I would go even farther and beg you to also get Tym and Joseph on the payroll in some capacity. They have more charm than a few hosts I can think of on HGTV. (Calm down, Clive--you and Lisa are great! I'm talking about some of the others who just don't have the spark to totally sell their show.) I look forward to seeing what the show will be that the winner (winners?) will be hosting. Have loved Design Star and hope to see it back next season!

Posted by Deb – September 5, 2006 8:38 PM

I taped Sunday's show, and just got around to watching it. Although it is obviously a difficult decision, I feel that Alice is the one who deserves her own show. As much as I like David's designs, I feel that they are all very similar in style, and that I would tire of his ideas and color schemes very quickly. Alice, on the other hand, always has a new idea to fit the space. And honestly, who ever designs a glass house in the middle of a park? Although David can 'wow' you, it is too trendy, and eventually the variations on the same theme would get old.

Posted by Alexis – September 5, 2006 8:35 PM

First of all, Alice's room was not a mess. The judges who really had no right to give an opinion since it is the public who will be voting, failed to reallize that David covered up his view, Alice's was much more open. What happened to good old Americana design? I think David and Alice are both winner, but since we have to vote, I vote Alice.

Posted by Janet – September 5, 2006 8:34 PM

This has been a delightful and inspiring HGTV series. This last competition was wonderful. David's Zen to create a sophisticated tranquil room for rest and relaxation was....utterly, Divine!!! And, Alice through the looking glass created a sense of heightened anticipation for any child in this Wonderful-land. Clearly both of these designers are complementary to each others personality. They both would make a great Host's for a Ying/Yang Design Show. David has a bit of an edge on design talent but Alice has a camera personality that complements both of their unique talents. What would YING be with out YANG ? Be BOLD and go for both.

Posted by Julie – September 5, 2006 8:23 PM

Love the show! It's tough to decide between David and Alice. I'm leaning toward David because his designs are always so great and he clearly worked on his presentation during the break.

On another note, I'd love to see an individual challenge right away in the next season so that we can clearly see the designers styles right away.

Posted by Leigh Anne McIntyre – September 5, 2006 8:17 PM

David - WOW, I could not wait to see the final product that was produced it was SO HOT and SO NOW. Alice, that design has been done to death. I felt many of the pieces did not work well together, and what were you thinking with the hanging light fixture.Although you are nice David is the true design star this season.

Posted by Laurie – September 5, 2006 8:08 PM

I have voted for both David AND Alice! (On separate days, of course.) I just can't decide. I love them both, and I think they'd both host a great show.

Please, please, PLEASE let us have both of them . . . with guest visits from Clive on a regular basis.

And Tym can be their carpenter/helper! :D

Posted by DJD – September 5, 2006 8:07 PM

Alice was the most consistent with her designs throughout the show. From her contributions in the team competitions to her own rooms she showed professionalism and talent. Although the artist comes out in David I believe he lacks the versatility Alice has in design.
Go Alice

Posted by Victoria – September 5, 2006 8:06 PM

I watched this episode twice & still cant decide!

I love the way Alice "designs for the client" every room she does shows a different personality. This room was designed for a child to grow into it. I could see a child of almost any age feeling comfortable there, from toddler to teenager. My only complaint was the white spreads! I know Alice said she couldnt find some of the things she really wanted & had to settle for what she could find in the short time they had but NEVER put white on a childs bed!!! For that matter I wouldnt trust most adults with white spreads.

David's room was awesome looking but could anyone live in it? There was NO storage at all. It would make a great guest room. While I think David's style has great artistic impact, it's not very livable to me - I have too much stuff!

Still cant make up my mind - may have to vote for both - how about a tie! Co-hosts?

Posted by KC – September 5, 2006 8:01 PM

I love Alice! She is a natural on camera and her obvious delight in each new challenge is beautifully paired with her spirit of fellowship she shares with David and the past challengers.

As with all her designs, Alice remembers to design with the client in mind and always ends with a livable final designspace. David's room(s) look cool and sleek - but really if you don't make the bed - the entire design on the final challenge is nothing but messy linens!

Alice kept the (possible) child's use of the room foremost - and the "judges" although obviously enamored of David with their comments that they wished Alice had addressed the location more - PLEASE it's a glass box in a park in New York! (this is not reality folks) seem to be biased towards David.

In the real world, we want designs that work in our everyday life - not something one dimensional that only looks good on camera. I think Alice has that concept hands down!

Go Alice!

Posted by Trisha – September 5, 2006 7:54 PM

Just wanted to thank everyone for a very enjoyable smart reality show! David showed his talent from the very first show, glad to see someone of his talent get the chance to live his dream! Good luck to both, David, let your star shine!

Posted by gregg – September 5, 2006 7:51 PM

If I have to choose only one, it is Alice. However, the two of them co-hosting a show is a great idea. Actually they both deserve their own show. You could definitely get rid of "Get Color". PLEASE LISTEN TO YOUR VIEWERS AND GIVE THEM BOTH A SHOW!!!

Posted by Colleen – September 5, 2006 7:45 PM

Clive is the best, and the judges were great all the way through. I learned a lot from their comments to the contestants.

David? Alice? What a fun show they could do together! But as far as out-of-the-box thinking that still takes into consideration the practicalities of daily living: it's David all the way.

I wondered why Alice didn't choose a dining room. The NYC night sky would have been a no-brainer for that.

A glass box isn't the first environment that springs to mind as something parents would choose for their children unless it was an open a sleeping porch at the family cabin in Minnesota or Maine.

Thanks, Clive! You made this show the success that it was--your comments, the way you decide to host it, everything. Also, it was great to follow a show where both finalists deserved to be there!

Posted by willowbarcelona – September 5, 2006 7:37 PM

I have seen enough "global" and "Asian" decor! Do we really need another "David" to show us how to shop at Ikea? Enough. Not being from the south, I enjoy seeing Alice's PERSONALITY and design sense because it's fresh. I think if David wins, you might as well call the show "Another Guy That Shops At Ikea". It has been funny to watch the judges ooh and ahh over what "is done to death" modernisim.

Posted by mila – September 5, 2006 7:34 PM

I loved this show!! I wish it had lasted longer. Next time they need to have a thrift shop as one of the stores to shop from. And I agree with one of the other people who posted on here, it would be nice to keep the original ten people around a little longer and see what they are capable of.

Posted by Sharon – September 5, 2006 7:32 PM

Clive: I was so bored with HGTV that I had quit watching except for a few shows. You and Design Star brought me back. I hope you do more of this type of programing as it is so refreshing. I was very disappointed with Cynthia Rawley as a choice for judge. Although she is a remarkable fashion designer I often felt she missed the mark on interior design. The fighting between Donna and Temple was not pleasant to watch, but I felt Temple did a great job of trying to be a lady while Donna appeared to be a lazy immature child. Clive, you are a wonderful host and I hope we see much more of you. Thanks so much for a great time each week.

Posted by Phyllis in Louisiana – September 5, 2006 7:28 PM

Really enjoyed the show, and there were plenty of nice design ideas. But there is no question who has the design chops here-David hands down! He is the only one who displayed real innovative design talent. Alice is a reallllllly nice person, but I fail to see anything innovative with ther rooms, pleasant as they were. David's screen presence is a little bumpy, but nothing that a little experience and practice cant handle. Alice's screen presense is great, but honestly I find her accent and voice pitch shrill-I could not listen to a full 30 minutes of her. PS Really enjoyed Tym too-Id like to hear/see more from him in the future. Thanks again for a great show!

Posted by chris – September 5, 2006 7:25 PM

I voted for David not because of him walking around shirtless most of the time but because he completely stunned me in every show. If the boy wants to flash some skin let him, and even if he was bundled up each show...he still delivered each time. The "pet" room was incredible. I wish him the best of luck. I did like Alice as well and thought her designs were nice, she doesn't seem to have the flair that David provides to a room but sure is darn cute on camera. Good Luck to both!!

Posted by Robin – September 5, 2006 7:18 PM

What a nailbitter this one was! What really surprised me was that they both chose to do a bedroom. I would think that with such a expanse of glass a dining room would have fit the bill better. Just think - dining in the park. Can't you just picture it? A beautiful dining table set on a rich-toned rug with a credenza against one wall and a beautiful light fixture above the table that is set with beautiful china and elegant candles. Or is that too expensive for the budget? Then, how about a living room with a pair of love seats facing the fountain, warm lighting, rug, etc. The possibilities are endless.

That said, since bedrooms were chosen, David's room is the one that I would love to fall asleep in. It was quiet and serene and it really showcased David's talents and design abilities.

Although I love Alice (not her voice), I don't feel that she can take a blank canvas and envision a finished product. When you entered her room, your eye went everywhere at once. The room looked like it was done by someone who was just learning how to design. When you saw a spot of color in her room, it didn't lead you to another place that could make the room come together.

Was completely surprised by Temple. Without someone to bicker with, she came through as a hard worker that knows something about design. Happy to see Tym return. He truly is talented and will go far in his career.

The judges appearing on the show didn't influence me in anyway. Even if they hadn't shown up, it was obvious to me which room I liked. Do they ever regret cancelling Joseph so early in the game? Really think Joseph would have given the contestents a run for the money.

I wish Alice good luck in her career as I am pretty sure the winner will be David.

Sad to see the show end.

Posted by Julie – September 5, 2006 7:13 PM

This was a very hard decision! I have enjoyed watching both Alice and David from the first as I felt that they both stood out from the crowd. I, too, wish that they could both have a show or one show together. They certainly have good chemistry on the show. David has been such a gentleman throughout the whole show.

It took me two days to decide who I wanted to vote for and I am fighting the urge to vote for the other one by cell phone!

Good luck to you both!

Posted by Karen – September 5, 2006 7:11 PM

I adored David's room. I think having the judges there may have intimidated Alice a bit. Alice and David have great personalities and both are good designers in my opinion, I just love the clean lines of the Asian Influence that David used. I also liked Katherine's suggestion about using the Dollar Store as a challenge sometime. And Vern Yip, one of the judges, is my absolute favorite designer, was glad to see him as a judge.

Posted by Kathy – September 5, 2006 7:06 PM

Sometimes it's not about the decor but how it's presented. Alice is a great hostess, giving detail to so many things, making a guest feel comfortable at all times. She has such a way with words and that sparkle in her eyes just makes you want to stay in whatever she's describing, no matter if it was a cardboard box.

At first David was a bit camera shy, but he's now very comfortable in front of the camera and it's become his best friend. I voted for David, simply because I think his "glass house" design was the BEST. I feel he actually had a theme and adhered to it, bringing the outside in and taking the inside out... true ZEN form. His neutral colors blended together, giving it that earthy down to earth tone and made me want to climb through the screen on my TV and lay down on that gorgeous bed, to gaze at the stars.

Both David & Alice have the ability to work well with others, unlike a few contestants that obviously had their show canceled, because their design didn't measure up or possibly because they bickered so much among themselves they ruined the whole thing.

I'm rooting for David, but I agree with someone who said that if David wins he should give Alice a guest spot on his show and I think vice-versa too.

May the best designer win. Good luck to David & Alice! :)

Posted by CJ – September 5, 2006 7:03 PM

I wish we had a third choice on the voting - both David and Alice as a team. I would like to see David and Alice co-host a show. They each have different strengths and good chemistry together. It would be much more interesting than either one individually and appeal to a wider audience.

Posted by Tami – September 5, 2006 7:01 PM

I regularly watch HGTV and watched every episode of Design Star! If the powers that be at HGTV don't create a show with both David and Alice as co-hosts they are going to miss out on a great thing! These two are meant to be together! How about a show with an audience? Do anything but please keep them together. I love them both!

Posted by Miss Carol – September 5, 2006 6:58 PM

I enjoyed this series and decided to vote for David, but it was a difficult decision, as he and Alice are both wonderfully creative and talented. I hope HGTV will seriously give thought to developing a prgram they can host together (maybe an hour long?) Now that would truly be a hit show!

Posted by ida McClendon – September 5, 2006 6:53 PM

I loved this show... Totally addicted! Can't wait for the next series. It was disappointing to lose two people on an episode though. And wish it was still going on. I missed only the first one. (saw it later in repeats)

I loved the lessons the judges taught... working together, over all design, leadership, budget and so forth.

I love Alice, and most of her designs and her charm. She would be a great host. She was willing to go out on a limb and try new things. She is a great designer.

David's vision for the whole room was much better than Alice's... though he wasn't much in the hosting department... He sees the whole picture but the words are missing. His designs are very strong.

These two rightfully belonged in the final competition. Awesome show! Can't wait for the next run! (No more double elimination rounds and please... give them a little more time.)

Thanks for great entertainment!!!

D~

Posted by Diane B – September 5, 2006 6:47 PM

We're really at sixes and sevens here. David had a gorgeous room, but no functionality. Alice remembered that children have "stuff" but does every family have TWO children to share space?

Vern Yip, whom we have not always appreciated, told Alice she was not utilizing the view with her curtains and bed placement. However, David covered his windows with vellum and that was o.k. Again, the double standard. Mr. Yip never seems to want to call David to task.

I enjoyed the lightness and airiness of Alice's room, just not the two beds and, unless David's "client" had a separate and extremely large dressing room, I can't feel comfortable voting for him either.

Are you absolutely certain there is no way that they can both win -- their styles do compliment each other and they can certainly learn from each other. I don't feel David can "carry" an entire show on his own. Of course, when you say "their own show" you do not indicate whether it is a one shot deal or a series.

Really have enjoyed watching but as we say, we're a bit disappointed in the (nearly) final episode. Backing out of voting seems the only fair option.

Appreciated that both Temple and Tym were on board and very supportive of both challengees.

Posted by Frank & Beckie – September 5, 2006 6:45 PM

The winner should have the runner-up on one of their shows! They're both quite talented and genuinely kind individuals. I believe they would complement each other by having a segment together.

Posted by Nancy – September 5, 2006 6:44 PM

David is my pick. Can't wait to see how it all ends, or is it just a beginning?

Posted by Dawn Roberson – September 5, 2006 6:34 PM

My son (age 12)and I really loved this show and we normally hate reality shows. We have been glued to the TV every Sunday night. Our overwhelming choice from the first episode has been David. We wish Alice all the best as well. She was charming, but David's style was fantastic. We are still talking about the rug he made out of wood chips (how clever was that). Anyway, David should win. We also love Clive as a host.

Posted by Cheryl – September 5, 2006 6:11 PM

I was unimpressed with David's shirt constantly off;could there PLEASE be a show that doesn't have sex tied to it?! I was disappointed in how low Alice's shirt had gotten towards the end of the competition.While I really liked David's style and over all personality; I thought Alice's wholesome,light-hearted and sweet personality was more charming.Both David's and Alice's talent definitely showed through;I felt Alice was a better choice.

Posted by Julie – September 5, 2006 6:07 PM

David and Alice are both very talented. It seems to me that no matter what the outcome the experience of being on the show will be very beneficial for both of them. I hope they would be able to get some pointers from TV professionals in whatever areas they need to improve or change. I would be fun to see them in a show as co-hosts. I won't reveal who I'm voting for here but I wish them both the very best and pray for the highest blessings for them in all their endeavors.

Posted by Sophia – September 5, 2006 6:01 PM

I have watched the show from the first, and I love it. My request for the next season would be to reveal the budget used. They each had "x" amount of dollars - how much did they use? Sometimes a tie-breaker room could depend on how much they did or did not spend. I know that I am on a budget, and it would make a difference to me regarding who to hire. Just a thought, but I think it is a good one.

Again, love the show. Clive - you're the best!!

Posted by Andrea – September 5, 2006 5:56 PM

I want a show that features both David and Alice. I think they would make a fabulous team!

Posted by Kathy – September 5, 2006 5:52 PM

In reading the letters here, I find that the majority of your viewers would like to see David and Alice share a show as co-hosts. We already know that works, as you have proven with Matt and Shari in "Room by Room". They are a delightful team, as are David and Alice. I truly think a show with the two co-hosting and sharing their definite chemistry with the nation would be awesome, and I don't think anyone would care if the original idea got changed at the end, looking at the rest of the responses in here. How about a try, or offering it as a voting option after next weeks show?

Posted by Lucinda E Freeman – September 5, 2006 5:46 PM

WHO is Alice related to?..WHY is she still even in the running?

That children's room stunk. We all could have done that well with an expensive chandelier and a bunch of furniture from IKEA!!! Ribbons for tiebacks...is she still in college!!?!? Come on.

Her rooms are consistently average, while David's actually look "designed". That "man cave" she did (in episode 6) hardly looked any different from before to after. Poor Tym had to do an entire apartment with the same amount of money.

She always flies just under the radar..not the worst of the week to get kicked off, but never is she really execptional. A agree she is cute, but stick her on some other show, scrapbooking or something.

If David doesn't win, I'll know it was rigged. She shouldn't have gotten this far.

I will never watch her show if she wins.

Posted by ChiccaD – September 5, 2006 5:44 PM

I liked both designers equally and thought they both did a great job on all challenges. I voted for David, however, because I hope he will share his VISION in creating his rooms, which is his very strong point. I'd like to see the show focus on that creative aspect, more than how he brings it together: "Okay, here's a room, here's my design, here's how I met challenges to put it together." Everyone does that. What they don't do is share the design aspect. Clearly, David is fabulous at that aspect and that would make a different, fresh type of programming. This is the show I'd like David to do.

Posted by Ann S. – September 5, 2006 5:39 PM

This week I liked David's design the best, but, once again, Alice did a better job of presenting. The major problem I had with Alice's design was that it seemed to be an adult design imposed on a child's room. I don't know how many kids would like words on their headboards. But she really sold the room when she described it. David's room was exquisite, but he's still a bit nervous in front of the camera. I now don't know which one to pick. But being a Tym fan, I felt it was a shame that he wasn't able to participate in this challenge because his outdoor-influenced desing would have shone in a glass room in a park.

Posted by Debbie – September 5, 2006 5:30 PM

If David has his own show, will he always be topless? He has a rockin' bod, but it gets a bit disconcerting after a while.

Posted by Christina – September 5, 2006 5:24 PM

I think David is creative but I would never let him touch my house. Alice would provide a great design, great personality to work with or watch and given time to fulfill her task definitely be the best candidate for my viewing. I watch HGTV for design ideas not for men without their shirts also...

Posted by Freda – September 5, 2006 5:16 PM

No no no do not put them together. How unfair is that? David won hands down. Alice was great but just not as talented.

Posted by Bonnie – September 5, 2006 5:15 PM

GREAT SHOW! Loved the challenges each week.
For me, David thinks "outside the box". He is able to conceptualize, organize, and pull all the elements of his designs together. Throughout the episodes he has had a sweet charm in working with others...a big plus!
Alice is very talented but I'm guessing that the kids room wasn't her, at her best. It didn't hold any surprises for me and was a bit disjointed.
I wonder what each of them would do if given the chance to redo elements of their final room. Good things are to come in their futures.

Posted by Patty – September 5, 2006 5:13 PM

I disagree with Alice and David co-hosting a show together. Give David his own show! He's got vision! His style is quite refreshing, innovative, and all-together together! Something to appeal to everyone's sense of style.

I think Alice and Tym should team up for a design show - together I believe they could have a perspective that would appeal to a large audience.

Thanks for letting me gab!

Posted by mouse – September 5, 2006 5:12 PM

Why can't y'all make a show with TWO hosts.
David AND Alice. They are the perfect pair!!!

Posted by Rachel – September 5, 2006 5:10 PM

I TOTALLY LOVED THIS SHOW!!! I don't normally care for reality TV, but this one sure got me hooked! I LOVE HGTV, and enjoyed watching every weekend! I was a little hurt when i missed it one Sunday (we were in Vegas), but we made sure we had it recorded & watched it as soon as we got back!!! David's room was TERRIFIC, but i don't understand what happened to Alice w/this room??? The rug should've been a brighter color, the...i could go on, and on...but i won't...she's tooo darn sweet! But i must say that i loved her Tiffany Box Blue inspired room, i even considered it for my room. If her last challenge would've been that great, she could've had a chance...SORRY ALICE! i agree though, that if they could be on a show together, THEY'D BE GREAT! FANTASTIC! SUPERB!
GOOD JOB HGTV...YOU'VE CREATED A WONDERFUL SHOW THAT EVEN GOT MY HUSBAND HOOKED!! (as did my 5 and 7 year old daughters)
and Clive....YOUR GREAT!
I LOVE DESIGN TO SELL!!!! OH MY GOSH....I LOVE HGTV!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [was this long enough??]

Posted by Monica – September 5, 2006 5:09 PM

Yes..Yes..Yes, Please have a show with both David and Alice together. That was my thought after the 3rd show. David's designs are very good and remind me of Vern Yip's style. I'm sure evertone has noticed that. Love HGTV.

Posted by Lorraine Arnold – September 5, 2006 5:08 PM

I really think that David and Alice should have a show TOGETHER. They'd make a great team! So hard to vote for one or the other.

Posted by Cynthia Jones – September 5, 2006 5:05 PM

Go David! Your design sense rocks. Alice is a lovely woman with a good TV presence, but is not as nearly spot-on as David insofar as design goes.

Posted by Maureen baranov – September 5, 2006 5:04 PM

The best thing the judges ever did was get "Miss Pris" off the show...Temple that is. She was soooo immature and unteachable. Both Alice and David would do well as hosts...maybe you could just use both of them!

Posted by Paul Chaney – September 5, 2006 4:57 PM

I think both David and Alice should have a show together because they really work well. For a moment, I was wondering if they were about to hookup. In judging one, David would have to be my choice because I love chic and elegant both of which were shown in his design choice.

Posted by Deborah – September 5, 2006 4:46 PM

A blurb about the finalists: I'm glad that David and Alice are the two finialists. I am sad to see Tym go, but given his bad luck with time, money and carpenters, he just wasn't able to show his true colours. Perhaps without such a short leash in regards to time and resources, he could really do a wonderful room. I agree with the Judges that David's outdoor room needed colour. ANY colour, SOMEWHERE. The room was completely starved of colour, almost to the point of being irritatingly void of it. I mean even a single stripe of green on one pillow would have made all the difference, perhaps a stroke of red beaded fringe lining the canopy. It would have made the room a little more feminine and warm without going over the top. It seemed a little on the masculine/cold side. Alice's room was a great idea, I loved the polka dots she found. I think that's a marvelous idea, but at the same time, it is a choking hazard if one should fall, like another commenter said. I loved the transitional pieces like the dresser that could easily grow up with the kids. I agree with Vern when he said he didn't really lik the traditional layout of the twin beds, and how he wishes they would have been set up to take advantage of the view on the opposite side. Perhaps lining the bed up in a 90 degree angle or, if the dimensions of the room allowed, on opposite walls. That would have been a little more creative. Overall I love Alice's room. Everything was fun, brightly coloured, but still, not the typical pastels or the overly bright primary colours.

I love Alice's work, especially the blue room she had when it was down to the last four. However, Ultimately, I choose David for the next Design Star. His work has been executed nearly perfectly throughout the entire series. He has a lot he could learn, but he IS young, he will soon develop his skills and talents even moreso. Good luck, David!

A quick blurb about the judges and HGTV: I love watching HGTV, you have a high reputation for quality and creativity that I've come to expect in every show aired. I believe a show for Vern would be a smart idea. I love his inputs for every aspect of the show. He displays a working knowledge of pyschology which, when working with people's personal tastes, is the key to your success. He didn't berate the designers when they did somthing he obviously didn't like, but he rather constructed his criticism professionally and as painlessly as possible. (Is it possible to vote for Vern for Design Star?!)

A blurb about the others:

I was totally blown away at how different Temple acted in this episode! Before, she was simply childish and didn't seem to be able to work with anyone. Her arguing to no end with Donna, and for thinking that cabinets are a quick 1-2-3 installation, was just aggravating. I suppose her attitude changed enormously when she wasn't in the running anymore! Her unbiased, full attention and support of both Alice and David turned my view of her around! Good job, Temple.

I have nothing new to add about Vanessa, Donna or Ramona that hasn't been said reduntantly already. Just know that I agree with the lot of commenters here. (Vaccum cleaners, no matter what you do with them are NOT art... nor is the three-colour-mural if it can be uplifted to be called such.) There is a lot to say for a designer with a solid sense of finance. The clients you work for aren't always going to give you thousands of dollars to spend away like petty cash. You may somtimes have only a couple hundred to redo the whole house. It is a part of your ingenuity and your JOB to make it work no matter the number of zero's at the end of the check they give you. (And Vanessa, don't get me started on your ego.. you're worse than most men)

The twins could go into business together and do ok that way, but they're obviously not so wonderful on their own.

Joseph really didn't get much of a chance to shine during all this, but with the total destruction of someone's furniture... I think in all fairness the judges were right on removing him from the line up. No amount of talent can sway a homeowner into allowing you to finish "decorating" their house if all you do is destroy their stuff and make it worse than it was before.

Posted by Milisa – September 5, 2006 4:40 PM

I looked forward to David's designs with great anticipation.

Alice impressed me when she obviously listened to the judges and made changes in her designs each week. They are the experts and had lots of great suggestions. The judges were right to offer suggestions on the last two designs while the contestants were in progress, but their comments on the final designs should have been saved for next week's show, if at all.

Posted by Jane – September 5, 2006 4:39 PM

Loved the show and the final two challenges. David and Alice are both winners in my book.

Posted by Linda – September 5, 2006 4:36 PM

I loved Alice's room----all the bright colors & the cool dots on all the glass. Beautiful and clever--Please, someone put some clothes on David. The show is suppose to be about "Designs". He is over the top and full of himself. Has anyone seen his audition tape? Take a look---annoying.....Alice is the whole package, professional, poised and able to actually follow through on what the client asks. She would make a great host with credibility.

Posted by Katherine – September 5, 2006 4:33 PM

I REALLY like both of these people. Alice because her designs are good, but her personality and hosting are the best. I also liked her bio where she introduced herself as a newlywed and believed in a strong moral code and value system. She is endearing, natural, and someone I'd be comfortable working with in my own home. David because his designs are terrific and he seems genuine. He really has a wonderful design sense and showed it week after week. But, in his bio, he mentioned he had no problem using "cute" to win, if that's what it took. I was sorry to hear that. (so come on you two, cut the no shirt/low cut top to gain votes. It's a turn off and so obvious.) I did vote for Alice, mostly for the personality issues and because I felt she would listen to me as the homeowner/client. As a decorative painter, I have to do that, too.

Bottom line, I'd love to see them work together. As a long time HGTV viewer, I still miss Michael Payne. Why not bring back a version of "Designing for the Sexes" and put Alice and David together to work with the couples!! I'd watch that show everytime!

Posted by Ginny – September 5, 2006 4:31 PM

They need to co-host. What he lacks, she has and what she lacks, he has. Is that what you've been planning to do all along? Something tells me you already know they'd do far better as a team than either one will do alone.

Other than that, they've both shown a bit more skin than is professional, and I'm no prude.

Posted by Bonnie – September 5, 2006 4:25 PM

Outstanding...David ...has consistantly shown he can pull it together and be creative. If I wanted a designer it would be him. If i wanted to watch a designer it would be him. I couldnt wait each episode to see what he would create.

Alice was very disappointing on many levels. Her rooms and colors I would never have wanted in my rooms. She as a host, I could not watch. I find her voice..perhaps the southern type accent, annoying. She is sweet and likeable, but this doesnt make a reason to make her a design star. I honestly don't think there was anything she did that I liked at all.

Posted by Anna – September 5, 2006 4:25 PM

From all the comments it seems inevitable that David will win and I can't help being disappointed. David is a good artist and has shown many creative ideas, but many are impractical and they all look the same. In the individual room challenge, I thought the room was supposed to actually be livable--who could walk on a rug of wood shavings? In the color apartment challenge, though David did a good job of his color use, the space planning was atrocious--who would want an already small space to be chopped up and walled off? You have to sit in a cubicle box to watch TV and can't see it from the kitchen, the bed or the table--terrible. The long family room was good in parts, but the children's area and the adult sitting area were totally disconnected and unrelatated--no effort to bring the colors of the children's area into the other part. The zen bedroom was very nice, but seemed like just more of the same style--sparse, linear, IKEA modern like so much else on quick make-over shows and all David's and Vern's designs.

Alice's rooms showed more versatility and connection with the client-real or imagined--though they didn't always stand out as David's did. Her last room was not up to the caliber I would expect, but she did a great job of hosting and selling it--to bad it didn't have more fantasy and color.

Alice's personality is charming and friendly--David may be nice, but he comes off as conceited, in love with himself and his body and insincere when he acts humble. I watched his audition tape and all he could talk about was his looks and how cute he was (hey-you're not THAT cute). I am totally turned off by his wife-beater/sleeveless/ or no shirt act. I don't know if I could even watch his show if I have to look at that hideous tattoo in every shot. His whole manner of dress may be artsy and cool in his mind, but is TOTALLY unprofessional. Alice seemed to be much more professional in her demeanor until that last few episodes, when she started showing cleavage and wearing tank tops (even when it's raining?) I hope this sex appeal thing is not HGTV's idea--if so you may pick up a few new viewers, but lose the demographic that made you what you are.

All in all an interesting show that I look forward to--just make it more professional HGTV, More time for projects, start with individual ones, more information about the rooms and the challenges, the budgets, the construction, and less about the interactions and fights. I want to see design, not Alice and David having champagne in their bathrobes--this was in such poor taste I couldn't believe it. Was this a prelude to setting up a co-hosted show for them--setting them up as friends and partners instead of competitors. Why were they sharing a room and discussing their ideas with each other and shopping together? This made no sense for a competition.

I would check out a co-hosted show as long as David keeps a sleeved shirt on. Perhaps Alice could drag David out of his minimalist, large graphic on the wall rut. I hope the kinks will be worked out of this show before HGTV rushs another one on.

Posted by Diana – September 5, 2006 4:25 PM

This glass house design challenge seems to have worked to David's strengths, but not to Alice's. I kept wishing Alice would go all the way with the idea of colored glass that would use the light of the glass room, which was, of course, its main design element. Swirling patterns inspired by Art Nouveau backed up with wrought iron might have worked well.An adult space would have probably lent itself a bit more to this than a children's room. She is, however, very charming and more confident and at ease on camera than David. \\ David's design was gorgeous. I was particularly struck with how quickly he thought of bringing the outdoor space inside with his Zen window rock box. It was so lovely. \\ I have watched this show from the beginning. As a genuine "hater of reality tv", I am surprised to find myself captivated by Design Star. \\ It was annoying to me as a viewer to watch what seemed to be Temple's viciousness toward Donna. I couldn't see that Donna had done anything to deserve such ire. I found myself wondering if the obvious attraction Temple has for David made Donna feel it was "inappropriate"(I don't, incidentally). Donna seemed quite reseved and private and a bit out of place in the communal living setting--and I don't think that had anything at all to do with age, just personality--I wondered if she might have said something to Temple off camera, and that that might have been the spark that set Temple off? It made me feel that Temple, with all her talent, was sabotaging herself as a team leader. \\ I do agree that Donna did not ever seem to get a chance to really show her stuff. I was impressed by the table she chose for Temple's kitchen design. From the glance the camera gave us of it, it seemed to work beautifully in the space. \\ Tym is absolutley wonderful on camera. His designs remained masculine and too stripped down for my taste, but I loved watching him when he "hosted". He really is so good at this. I hope HGTV or some other network will notice this and pick him up. \\ Temple is a natural talent. I have a feeling we'll be seeing a lot more of her too. Her design chops are really impressive. With so much drive and ambition backing her up, I know she will go far if she gets the right kind of mentoring. \\ I think all the designers deserve a lot of credit for having the courage to let themselves be so exposed and vulnerable in a setting that was intensely difficult and competitive. \\ Thanks to HGTV for making our summer Sunday evenings so compelling.

Posted by Theo White – September 5, 2006 4:23 PM

We thought David had it all - great design skills and great TV personality. We're looking forward to his new show on HGTV.

Posted by Libby – September 5, 2006 4:18 PM

Great Show----I voted for David. I loved his room and by the way, there was COLOR in both the pillows--It looked like dark brown......That is a color,right? Please have BOTH of them do a show together, (I'm not the only one that thinks that) Love the Show.

Posted by Rosellen – September 5, 2006 4:15 PM

Clive you're awesome as usual. Perfect choice for hosting this show. HGTV has made several good decisions with this series. It has held so many of us glued to our TV's. Now HGTV has another opportunity on making good a decision by David and Alice co hosting. The chemistry between them is electric both personality as well is talent. The new show would be so much better with them bringing their ideas together and watching them work together in carrying them out. It is a disappointing end if only one wins. The premice of the show was finding the undiscovered talent. You have found it in the pair as a team.

Posted by Roxanne – September 5, 2006 4:07 PM

I really liked Alice's room the best. The light fixture was awesome. Two children of different ages could easily occupy that space. David's room was too monotone and sterile. Who lives in a room like that?

Posted by billie – September 5, 2006 4:05 PM

I agree with others who want David and Alice to cohost. David did better on the final challenge but their chemistry is great.

Posted by Oregon mom – September 5, 2006 4:04 PM

My vote goes to David without any doubts. His was a truly Beautiful and well designed room with professional signature. Alice's room? Blah. I would not want anything like that in my house. By the way, this is the second time that her space planning isn't up to par. A large couch blocked the window in the den she designed for a military man in a previous episode. Now, again she did not take advantage of the view to place the beds. Blah...

Posted by jt9 – September 5, 2006 3:55 PM

I voted for David; I was so disappointed in Alice's last room. I hated the giant headboards with the words--especially that they were so tall and so white and the printing was so big and uninspired. What was she thinking? The chandelier and the dots were great, the drapes were okay but nothing outstanding. What age was that room appropriate for? Pristine white bedspreads for grubby little kids? I just couldn't figure out what she was thinking with that room.

David's room was wonderful and organic. I think it could have used one spot of color--perhaps a vase with a single flower--but I liked that he didn't take the advice and went with his own vision.

In terms of a future show, I wonder if I might get tired of David's style--he definitely returns to the same rectangular shapes again and again. It's not clear what else he can do.

I also think that if I were hiring a designer for my own home, I'd probably prefer Alice--David's rooms are beautiful but not my personal style. Alice seems more like someone who has less of a clear style but possibly a greater ability to translate the client's wishes into a design.

What I like best is that the two finalists were people who, throughout the series, seemed most able to get along, did little complaining and criticizing of others. They seemed like nice people, above all, and so, whoever wins, I'll be happy to watch the winner's new show.

Posted by Eleanor – September 5, 2006 3:48 PM

It seems "HG" got to the judges and had them say nothing but good things about David's room to sway the voters. I thought his design was boring and unimaginative (except for the "indoor/outdoor" rock boxes). Ofcourse Vern loved it. Vern is the king of stripes and squares (guess what- there's more to design than geometry). David's sheers on the ceiling was so obvious. And candles setting on rocks- give me a break. I could by that set up at Bed, Bath and Beyond!
David is a wonderful artist- that's what has carried his rooms in the past (his art made that big, obnoxious brown wall in his studio space almost bearable!). And any one can fill a room with red chotchkies and line up 5 of the same red candles on a countertop. Sorry David, I'm sure you're a wonderful guy in person, but your TV personality can be ANNOYING (shirt on or off). We need another Debbie Travis or Candice Olsen on HGTV. Which brings me to Alice...
Given the confines of past challenges, I thought Alice did an excellent job. I can tell from her design that when she has some TIME and MONEY, she can really pull a room together. Even if she isn't the best designer, she will be able to pull off a great design show because...she's cute as a button, has a great TV personality, she comes off as sincere, she's beautiful and gracious. What's not to love?
Even if she can't design at 100%- that's what staff is for. She's got all the ingredients to make a great design show host. Let's not short ourselves this great chance for a wonderful new design show.

Posted by jbug – September 5, 2006 3:46 PM

LOVE THIS SHOW AS MUCH AS CHOCOLATE! I can't say that enough. I am going to have DS withdrawal.
Each challenge has been based on an HGTV show. These shows average a two day shoot to several months worth of shooting. These challenges showed the strengths of the designers based on a certain amount of time that could fit into a 1/2 hour time frame. David has shown over the weeks that he's a great designer but not a great design leader, nor can he verbalize his design vision well. Alice has shown she was a design leader. She could always verbalize her design vision, and a good designer. Ultimately this is what a design show is all about. I have to go with so many of my fellow DS viewers, together they are stronger than alone. I wonder if that doesn't say something. Ultimately my vote is Alice.
Please Clive bring the show back very soon! Love ya!

Posted by a.d. volpe – September 5, 2006 3:42 PM

I have to agree with the person who advised to scrap the voting and just put David and Alice together on a show. They obviously have chemistry, and their personalities are not so ego-centric as to be threatened by each other. I believe they are equally talented, though in different ways. Together, they would make a runaway hit!

Posted by DeeDee – September 5, 2006 3:33 PM

At the beginning of the final challenge I knew I wanted to vote for Alice. I like her look and her hosting style, but, alas, David proved again that he has the better talent. Alice thinks within the box (or glass house) and David clearly thinks outside the box. His room was beautiful from every angle. I would have loved to be able to take a nap in that beautiful room while it was raining.

In every competition, there has to be a winner and a non-winner. David's design talent is truly the winner.

Posted by LINDA – September 5, 2006 3:33 PM

I think that Alice is by far the best! Although David's room this week was well-planned and executed, his rooms each week look essentially the same. A rectangular geometric motif, neutrals of brown and taupe, with either red or orange accents. He knows what he likes and he does it well, but I would never hire him as my designer because everything he does looks the same. I have the same feelings about his potential show -- it would be very repetitive week to week. Alice, on the other hand, does something different each week. I think that she is very creative and versatile, and is someone that I would definitely want to design in my home. Moreover, she has a better television presence and I think would make a great hostess on a tv show!

And what was with the judges' complaints about Alice's choice to use twin beds? Twin beds are very practical for a children's room. Ultimately, this contest isn't about who can make the best magazine spread. It's about who can design something both creative and useful.

Go Alice!!!

Posted by lauralee – September 5, 2006 3:31 PM

David is a designer, Alice is a decorator.

David wins hands-down. His bedroom was inspired, while hers was not.

Posted by Finn – September 5, 2006 3:27 PM

David has shown since very early in the season that he is by far the most talented designer of the group. While I like Alice a lot as a person her designs seem ordinary to me.

Give David the show and let him keep his shirt off as much as possible! Actually, he and Alice should get married and make beautiful children.

Posted by Jan – September 5, 2006 3:25 PM

Clive, I adore this show, love both David and Alice, but I feel that David really won this last competition hands down, and he'll get my votes. I agree with all the other people who think both David and Alice should have a show, preferably together, and I'm thinking of something like "Designing for the Sexes", where they get to integrate their very individual styles to suit everyone in a family. How about it HGTV??? I'm looking forward to the next season. I must say too, that I enjoy reading the opinions of the other posters -- I'd really like to get to know some of you! Jan in Port Townsend, Washington

Posted by Jan – September 5, 2006 3:23 PM

I think HGTV nailed it with this Summer-time slot filler. From somebody who cringes everytime they announce ANOTHER TV reality show - this one was a keeper (once you got passed the bickering episodes and focused on design, that is.)
The judges were refreshing...their comments were constructive and to the point, although I didn't ALWAYS agree with them.
The last challenge was innovative and truly a test of design capabilities. GLASS ROOMS!
Although I had a favorite...both rooms gave me an idea or two I felt I would be comfortable implementing (in my own way) in my home.
And that's what HGTV is all about!
So...good luck to David and Alice, you both have showed integrity, strength of design and have given me ideas to recreate in my space.
Thanks!

Posted by Pret – September 5, 2006 3:23 PM

David is great! Alice is wonderful! I would love to see them hosting their own show, together...what a team it would be! I'm sure it would be my "new" favorite HGTV show. I haven't been this excited to watch a TV show in a long time.

Posted by Kim – September 5, 2006 3:21 PM

David has been the winner from the 1st show. And keeps growning better each week. I would have loved to see a bathroom redo, as they are the hardest. I love Kenneth, and to follow the way his design works with the homeowners input, is the best.But I will watch whoever wins for ideas. Please let me the next makeover for bedroom and master bath. I really need the help and have a very large area to work with....Thanks Judy

Posted by Judy – September 5, 2006 3:18 PM

What a great show!! I too could not help but think that BOTH David and Alice deserve their own show. Both are entertaining, pleasant, vibrant and terrific at what they do. I also loved Tym who should be able to do the "assist" on both of their shows.
Thank you to all who participated in the show - from the judges (bravo to all of them), Clive for being a wonderful host, and for the many varied participants... this show was a breakout hit. I loved each show thoroughly and even in repeats!
Please heed your "Design Star" faithful viewers wishes... and give both David and Alice a shot... with my particular favorite, Tym also.
Thank you for a truly entertaining summer show! Bravo.
Larraine, Albuquerque

Posted by Larraine – September 5, 2006 3:17 PM

I absolutely loved this summer and watching Design Star. I'm glad Alice and David made it to the end. They, along with Temple, seemed to have the most design talent. I would like to see both David and Alice co-host a design series on HGTV. Alice is a natural in front of the camera and David has such fantastic designs. My house is ready for a major makeover, I'd hire either or both together!!!

Posted by Linda – September 5, 2006 3:12 PM

Alice and David are both terrific designers... Alice is polite, unassuming, and truly projects the design over the personality. David, PLEASE this is a DESIGN show not a 'SEE MY GREAT BODY' show! Keep your shirt on for heavens sake!!!

Although I think David's designs are perfect in scale, theme, and complete projection...he tends to lean way on the contemporary side...I would love to see him really get into some more traditional, ecclectic, and whimsical designs. Alice is more "everyday", something that is completely "doable" and design that someone could easily impliment in their own homes.

I think Alice and David should be a design team because they would complement each other, where one is weak the other is strong, I vote "TEAM DESIGNSTAR"!

Posted by Kim – September 5, 2006 3:08 PM

David wore me out flexing his muscles and pulling off his shirt every chance he got. I think he & Alice would compliment each other with their talents and both deserve the show. I wasn't impressed with the childs room and wish she would have done a garden room with the beautiful space provided..

Posted by ruth bernhard – September 5, 2006 3:03 PM

I've been for Alice since the very first show, and then David eased himself into the mix. I feel like so many others do....Let them co-host a show! It's a win win situation...HGTV wins with a new show format and both designers win with a co-hosting job together! Of course the rest of us viewers win because we get to see both David and Alice.

Posted by Maryellen – September 5, 2006 2:56 PM

Great shows every week! Enjoyed them tremendously! David and Alice are both great but I think David won out this week. It would be fantastic if there would be a way to incorporate both of them somehow in a new show. It would be great to bring Tym back as well. I enjoyed seeing Tym and Temple come back to help.

Clive does such a great job of hosting as well. I enjoy watching him with Lisa LaPorta.

My only complaint about the design shows lately is that there is too much "skin" being shown. I watch those shows mainly for the design ideas. I prefer not to see the guys with their shirts off and the women with their cleavage and bellies showing.

I appreciated too the fact that the judges didn't pick the contestants apart in a rude way. Keeping the comments as more of a "suggestion" than a "criticism" was certainly easier to watch and listen to each week.

Congratulations to HGTV for a great show! I hope to see more of the same!

Posted by Nancy – September 5, 2006 2:56 PM

David is amazing! He's human too, those tears told me how much heart he put into his design. I can't wait to see his show and how he will continue to impress us all. Good luck David!

Posted by Carmen – September 5, 2006 2:42 PM

i think they both have complementary strong points - David's yin to Alice's yang. pls give them a show together!!

Posted by nancy – September 5, 2006 2:41 PM

I'm voting for Alice !!. She has the style and
flair to keep you watching. She also has the
mature angle and common sense that David will reach
someday. Great show!!

Posted by Peg F – September 5, 2006 2:21 PM

I love Design Star it is the only show I watch all week.Our whole family loves to sit together on Sunday evening & watch this fabulous show.After reading alot of the previous comments I can see that we are all pretty much in agreement.David is HOT & he rocks our socks in designing,but we also love Alice's sweet charming "mary ann from giligan's island" ish style & presence.I think putting them together ona show would definately be a win win all around.Great job Clive we all love you,you crazy Brit! Cant wait for next season.

Posted by Jme~ – September 5, 2006 2:19 PM

Do you have the guts to do it???!!! Do what EVERYONE is asking you to do.....let them share a show!!!! It would be terrific!

Posted by pp – September 5, 2006 2:13 PM

They are both good designers, but time after time, something was lacking from Alice's work. I cannot fault her sceen presense though. David's designs deliver. They are more unique then the othes. He is a bit weak when it comes to presenting his work, but he has improved.

Posted by Bill – September 5, 2006 2:09 PM

David did a much better job of pulling together a design concept from scratch in a limited amount of time. Alice seemed to get stuck at the 'concept' stage and it plagued her from the start. She seemed to be piecing the room together as she shopped, picking out cute things that she liked as she came across them. Nothing really fit together as the end results showed.

For anyone who accuses David of trying to get votes by taking his shirt off (a highlight of the show if you ask me), go back to the replays and take a look at just how tight Alice wore her shirts. Seems like they were both utilizing their best 'assets' to their advantage.

One more point - I could see myself tuning into watch David on a weekly basis. His voice is very soothing. On the other hand, Alice's accent has already started to wear on my. I don't think I could watch another show featuring just her. (And I live in the South, so I am pretty used to accents.)

Posted by Debra – September 5, 2006 1:51 PM

Clive et al,

You cannot expect us to vote for David or Alice! They are both very worthy of HGTV. PLEASE hire both of them to either work together or separately but we can't chose between them!

Posted by Kim R – September 5, 2006 1:51 PM

I really love them both & would be thrilled to see an "Alice and David Show". They would both bring so much talent and personality to a new format. It could be similar to the "Design for the Sexes" show where they both could design for couples who can't make up their minds. It was truly refreshing to watch the two most likable and talented designers finish on top. The only thing that could make it better is to add Tym to the mix. It would be a top-rated show with tons of fans!

Posted by Cathy – September 5, 2006 1:50 PM

Great show and hope to see more. I love David's and Alice's work but David out shines Alice. She is so cute and camera but so is David. I voted for David and would like to see them both on a show together.If not she will still have a sucessful life.The best, Sally

Posted by SALLY BYE – September 5, 2006 1:47 PM

I was impressed with David's work from the very beginning. It always has a finished look to it. Very soothing. Alice is O.K., but to me, her work always looks pretty much the same except for the last episode. It looked tacky and cluttered. I like her, and she does have a cute t.v. personality, but that is not what people are paying for when they hire a designer. Sorry Alice. Itis David for me.

Posted by Mary – September 5, 2006 1:42 PM

I loved both of the rooms. David and Alice are both incredible in their own ways. I guess I have a question. What is more improtant in design? The overall look, or overall look and functionality? If it is about the overall look the David wins, hands down. If it is about overall look and finctionality, the Alice must win. david's room was absolutely gorgeous, but what about a dresser? Chairs someone might really relax in? Read a book in? Storage space? These are the things real people in real homes need. It was easier for David's room to be "clean" because he didn't worry with practical issues. Alice used furniture with practical purpose, in a fun, colorful and playful way. I think they should co-host because they both bring so much to the table. In the end, Alice is the design star. She has balance and diversity of style.

Posted by maxie'smom – September 5, 2006 1:41 PM

WOW, I have been watching the show from the beginning and have enjoyed everything that Alice and David have created. And Tym...he was talented as well! I loved watching and hearing from both Alice and David and wish they could have a show together. Now that would be so groovy! This is truly one of my favorite shows!!

YEA HGTV...now can someone help me out with a very small bathroom re-do in Kansas....there's no place like home...there's no place like home!

Posted by Margi – September 5, 2006 1:33 PM

David and Alice would make a great co-host team. They clearly have a warm, comfortable rapport with each other, they're likeable and look good together. Whaddaya say, Clive?

Posted by KPeterson – September 5, 2006 1:33 PM

Great show! Clive is the best host ever and keeps the show moving in the right direction. David is the winner!!! There is no way I could endure listening to Alice throughtout an entire program. In addition I really miss seeing Vern Yip on Trading Spaces!

Posted by Ila – September 5, 2006 1:25 PM

Vote "A" for David. Vote "B" for Alice. Vote "C" for "A" & "B". My vote is "C". I agree with many of the others that David and Alice would make a great team. Add in Tym and you have complete symmetry.

Posted by Tammye – September 5, 2006 1:23 PM

note to HGTV for future shows-
PLEASE give the designers at least one chance to work alone before making them work in a group!! We have no way of knowing what their design vision is when they have to work with a group right out of the gate. Also it's not fair how the dynamics play out - it's not fair that everyone didn't get enough money to work with on the first challenge and Joseph was booted off when Vanessa should have gone - notice she gave us a terrible design in the next challenge - maybe Joseph would have won that next challenge but we'll never know! I realize you want drama and to make it interesting but please ALSO give the designers a fair shot at it!!!!! We would also like to hear more of the judges comments - not just those little snippets.
Thanks!!!

Posted by AnnK. – September 5, 2006 1:18 PM

David's designs are amazing and have been from the beginning. His hosting skills continue to improve and will only get better over time.

Alice is quite charming, but her designs are extremely predictable and somewhat characterless.

I'm really hoping David wins, as his designs really inspire me, and that's one of the reasons I watch HGTV in the first place.

Posted by Steffen – September 5, 2006 1:14 PM

I really enjoyed the show, Clive being my favorite host. I think he has class, kindness and he can be funny too!

I like both D & A, they seem like truly beautiful people, inside and out, and seem to genuinely like each other. I do prefer David's designs and style, but I think a show with the two of them would be very entertaining. I was sorry to see Tim go, I think he is very talented, but I understand that someone had to go.

I love the judges, and although I appreciated the fact that they were not out to truly humiliate the contestants--as in other shows--they need to be more consistent with their comments.

Thanks HGTV for such an entertaining show, I smile the whole time during that last challenge!

Posted by Marisa – September 5, 2006 1:13 PM

Boy did you hold my interest. Alice is like a young Natalie Wood come back to life. David's dimples just make you want to smile. Both designers just missed a bit though. I was really disappointed that they did not use the glass house as a solarium. This is a very popular room for Americans today and your audience wants to see some creative designs for this glass room. It is called house and GARDEN TV isn't it? Where was the garden? Glass entension rooms are the marriage point of interior design and exterior design. It was an interesting challenge.

Posted by mona – September 5, 2006 1:08 PM

It has been exciting to watch. I have voted for David because of his creativity, his art talent, his construction abilities and his upbeat, enthusiastic personality. I love Alice so very much for her designs, her southern personality, and, like many, wish they could have a show together. They are so fantistic together! Tym is very good and would enjoy him on HGTV also, but since you make me choose, then I have to choose David. Can't wait for Sunday next.

Posted by Joanie – September 5, 2006 1:04 PM

Clive,

This is a no-brainer . . .HGTV has to create a new show around both David and Alice. The chemistry is good. Also, as another poster mentioned, I would like to see Temple, Tym, and Joseph make some appearances as well. These were all good designers! This series has been awesome.

For traditional style and vision, Alice is the winner. For the raw artistic talent and vision, it's David. How can you choose only one of these elements!

Posted by Kay – September 5, 2006 1:03 PM

Congratulations to both -- great jobs. I vote for David.

I wish both could be 'co-hosts' along with Tym.

The judges shouldn't have commented as they were NOT judging--the public is, and, possibly, be swayed.

Posted by kathy – September 5, 2006 1:02 PM

Hi Clive 1st, I enjoy watching you interact with all of the D2S folks as well as the DS cast. You are a hoot! David and Alice are so different, but compliment each other so well. Co-host them! David, handsome lad you are, put your shirt on! Alice, don't let anyone tone down your accent; be proud of your Texas roots! A very upscale Design on a Dime would rock! Tym is a good worker and would make an excellent 3rd. However, if I NEVER see Temple, Donna or Romona again I will be happy.
Alice-I could tell you what I wanted done, and know that it would be perfect. When can you come visit? (I've got a kitchen needing attention!)
David-love ya darlin', but I would never ask you to do my make-over! But you can still come for dinner!
I choose BOTH!!!!!!!!!
Keep up the good work HGTV!
Sincerely, Shirley Rex, Plano, Texas

Posted by Shirley Rex – September 5, 2006 12:59 PM

Honestly, I was completely ready to vote for Alice. She is genuine and true to herself, which is invaluable. David's style seems to be more contemporary, which I'm not a big fan of. The deal with him always taking his shirt off is sort of tacky as well. But his design's are just incredible. I would like to see Alice on HGTV, I like her. But David is the better designer. Just keep your clothes on already!!

Posted by kristie – September 5, 2006 12:58 PM

I'm glad it has come down to David and Alice. David is great, but the rooms alway are predictable, they are all modern and have his design stamp. I feel that Alice is well rounded and more able to suit the person she is designing for, not showing her design style only. I feel that either or both would do well with a show of their own, but Alice would show more variety.
Alice gets my vote!

Posted by Leslie Graham – September 5, 2006 12:58 PM

Alice is a natural and does a good job. However, most of her designs are things I could and have done myself. David however is a true artist. He has shown his creativity and ability on every design. I agree with Vern, I would love to have seen a pop of red or burst of burnt orange in a pillow, a vase or a flower somewhere. Still, I loved the Asian inspired room. It was so tranquil. I wish it were my own. Congratulations David, you are the winner in my book!

Posted by Connie – September 5, 2006 12:53 PM

Voted for David, but David and Alice belong together. What a winning combination!

Posted by Marilyn Couture – September 5, 2006 12:45 PM

What a grand idea- to allow viewers to "catch up" on any missed episodes! Thanks for a fun and inspiring show!! While I personally hope that David wins (just a tad tired of the wildly waving hands during Alice's presentations), I am already wondering what to watch in the hiatus between this one and the next Design Star.

Posted by kjmcadoo – September 5, 2006 12:42 PM

I have enjoyed the show. Everyone was great! Alice was wonderful but David always had the perfect design. AT the end David improved his presentation and is truely the STAR!

Posted by karen – September 5, 2006 12:42 PM

My wife and I (I work in Network Television) have wondered about: who prompts Dave to always take off his shirt? and, why aren't the women prompted to remove their's?; will the winner have a show where they will actually use their design talent or just host? (if just hosting, the winner will be who's best on camera); designers don't do their own construction (they hire the contractors) so the work looks pretty weak, how much after production work has to be done off camera after assignment? will the winners show be buried at some oh-dark:30 timeslot? (like at Food Network did with the winners of their cooking contest? Just wondering.

Posted by Edward – September 5, 2006 12:34 PM

I think that both Alice and David did wonderful work throughout the episodes. David is a great artist and Alice is very creative. I am having a tough time choosing one of them. I will be happy either way it goes. And I'm glad to see that I'm not alone in wishing that Alice and David could co-host a show. They have great chemistry and seem to truly enjoy working together. What one may lack the other compensates for. HGTV won't you reconsider???

Posted by Jan – September 5, 2006 12:34 PM

Loved watching the shows all in a row even after seeing them one by one.
On the last show David's room was more appropriate for the glass house, but was it really planned with the sky views that it turned out to have?? Alice's room would be better with painted walls.On all the shows I feel the designer's lacked the time they really needed to design and transform. I really do feel any of the designs could have been done by any "creative"
person, mostly because of the time constraints and sometimes they had to use the same resources for their designs, at times making the rooms look more like dormitories than city homes.
I feel David has more appeal on screen and is "different" than was is on TV, but would like to see him pull together a very classic traditional livingroom, instead of his more contemporary flavor. My husband found Alice more appealing, but her designs were much more traditional in vision. Give david the time , staff and money and I feel he could truly create any space that one desires.

Posted by Annette – September 5, 2006 12:33 PM

I think I am in Love with David. Everything he does is sooo exciting. He is beautiful and his designs are way above the rest.

Posted by S. Lee – September 5, 2006 12:26 PM

My husband and I both felt that David's completed room lacked some basic necessities. There was no bedside table, let alone one on each side. There was no chest of drawers for clothing storage. We
noted the missing items in David's studio apartment, as well. His headboard was very large and wouldn't be likely to make it through most hallways in a home; we've had double doors leading to a master bedroom, but even then we don't think that both open doors would be large
enough to accomodate his headboard. These are
very practical comments, but should be considered
by HGTV. Your viewers want design ideas that they can actually utilize in their own homes.
On the other hand, Alice has always provided good storage and people could implement her creativity.

Posted by sara – September 5, 2006 12:22 PM

Alice's work is strong, and her hosting style is natural, and I reaaaaalllly like her but - we've already got that on TV. Sadly, she brings very little that is new to the small screen. And the oh so strong southern accent is a bit overwhelming. I wanted to vote for her, but felt compelled to go with David despite my resistance to yet one more metrosexual "contemporary designer guy".

Here's why - David's audition tape showed someone totally confident and very amusing on camera. David is very confident in his designs, and HGTV can work with him to get the confidence back when working with him on camera. I know its in him - check out David's audition tape on the website and even if you're an Alice fan like me, you'll see how much fun it will be to watch David. But he still needs to keep the shirt on :).
Great job HGTV, excellent work all around.

Posted by Jeannie – September 5, 2006 12:19 PM

Wow! What an exciting show! Reeeealy loved it! The challange was on!

2 cents from the peanut gallery ---

Alice, love how you can adapt, your rooms have been my favorite to date... This one however; fell short. As a mom (4 gifts from God) while your interview talked about "wonderland" you did not give us one :( No, on the white bedspreads -- you needed color! Where was the function? You should have had a least a desk, perhaps a table with chair for art work, homework. Really couldn't tell if this was a girls or a boys bedroom, perhaps it was a childs since it had a rocking horse... You still rock and I love your personality.

David, you are wild!! While I personally don't run to Asian themes, had to say I loved how your room imbraced the inside with the outdoors. How calm, serene and comforting it would be to sleep in a glass house in the park. On this episode you are clearly the winner!

Clive -- have them work together. They could be a team like you and Lisa LaPorta. Ditch the Chicago team -- they don't have what the two of you clearly do!

Overall,

Posted by Patricia – September 5, 2006 12:14 PM

I absolutely love your show and I agree that both David and Alice are very talented and deserving! No matter who wins, I hope the other continues to pursue their dream. Both have won the hearts of America and will carry fans where ever they go. It was a hard decision, but I ended up voting for Alice. I think she is more diverse in her designs. She isn't quite as creative as David, but she is growing. David does great work, but most times his designs end up looking very modern and have the asian influence. I wonder how he would do if he was asked to design a French Country or Traditional room?

Posted by Annette – September 5, 2006 12:10 PM

You can pick Alice's designs out of any home decor magazine. She's entirely predictable and lacks imagination. That Texas drawl and giddy grin get on my nerves too.

David ROCKS in design. You never know what to expect from him and his designs are unique and truly inspired. He can learn tv presentation and doesn't have that giddy grin and drawl to irritate people.

Posted by nacheivo – September 5, 2006 12:08 PM

I honestly believe that the judges put through the two most deserving designers into the final competition--both as designers and genuinely nice people (although I will say that Tym also was deserving to go at least as far in the competition as he did).
Although both Alice and David are good designers and good people, my vote has to go to David as being more reflective of the style that I prefer.
And, admittedly, part of me would like to see David get his own show with the promise that, at least once an episode, he appears with his shirt off. Logical to believe that such an occurance would happen as David appeared shirtless, at some point, on all the competition episodes and other design shows feature hunks as carpenters. Even David, in his submission video, said that he used his 'cuteness' to help further his career (without letting it substitute for talent). And, what keeps it from being cheesey and keeps me from being just as cheesey giving in to it, is the fact that I think David is an incredible and flawless designer (I think back to the first episode of designing the townhouse and wonder just how much of the bedrooms' design was Vanessa's, that she immediately took total credit for, and how much of it was David's design, considering how much the bedrooms reflected his later designs). Cuteness backed by an enormous design talent--what more could you want for a design show. (And yes, Alice is adorable on camera as well--just my preferences go to David).

Posted by S. Lee – September 5, 2006 12:05 PM

I think both David and Alice are strong designers; however, I want David to win. I think watching a one-hour show hosted by Alice would, in the end, be like being trapped in a closed room with an ambulance siren. She's cute, she's smart, and she's talented--but that shrill voice when she gets excited or is introduced to someone is just too much.
I loved David's Asian room.
Alice's children's bedroom had some features I would have certainly done differently: the white headboards with the black lettering was too boring--why not use color? And the graphic images on the white made the design look hurried: why not do the graphics on plexiglass instead, to give it a more mirrored effect?

Good luck, David! I sincerely hope you win, and I will watch your show! Alice, I wish you luck also, because I think you are a talented designer and can go on doing what you do on your own.

Posted by Linda – September 5, 2006 12:04 PM

This whole concept on HGTV ROCKS!!! HGTV is my favorite channel to watch on tv.. Clive is truly a great presense on the shows (Designstar and D2S). He has my votes hands down. Vern is one of favorite designers, I also do the simplistic designs in my own home. I am inspired by his designs and try to use his inspired designs in my own home.

Now for my choice!!!! David gets my vote every day,(not because of the shirt on/shirt off), its because he has such inspired design skills. I always look forward to seeing what he is going to create next. I enjoy watching watching David struggle to get his concept from paper to actual on the show. He puts a lot of heart into each and every design. I think his "Quirky" presense is just FANTASTIC!!!! How much more natural can you get? Isn't it wonderful to see a "real" person on the air? But I also think a little nervousness is natural, he seems to have improved a lot since the first time he had to "host" the first time..After watching the show Sunday night I felt that his design was truly a beautiful and relaxing room. Just really loved the Zen inspired room, very,very relaxing. I feel confident that it is a room I coud do in my own home and be extremely relaxed in. Thank You David!!!

Alice, you are also truly amazing! Love the designs too. But sometimes you should go by your own instincts. Follow your own "gut" instincts, on what you want to do in your rooms. Too much "stuff" going on in this space. Love to watch your "on-air" presence, you are a natural in front of the camera. Did absolutely love the lighting you chose!

The shows have been a lot of fun to watch, I look forward to seeing much more in the future. Perhaps the winner will partner with the other "winner" and have a new and exciting program..Who says they can't become partners?? Cant't wait until the finale on Sunday night, Good Luck to both of you. YOU BOTH ROCK!!!!!

Posted by Sue Mitchell – September 5, 2006 11:54 AM

David's design is spectacular this week. Alice did impress me on all the episodes except this one. Guess she made all the wrong choices in the room. Anyway, her tv hosting skills are good and David's too this week. Hope he wins.

Posted by Raje – September 5, 2006 11:48 AM

Oh yes, one thing more--was the "artist/sculpturer" a plant? She was just too rediculous. How did she make the cut?
Paul

Posted by Paul – September 5, 2006 11:45 AM

Why not put them on the same show and show America how to compromise when tastes and design ideas run in different directions? That would be a show worth watching!

Posted by Lucy – September 5, 2006 11:44 AM

David was the clear winner of the last challenge. There was no clear theme in Alice's room. I felt Temple and Tym would have been better choices in the final two over Alice. I really was pulled into the show, it was great. However, I feel the designers did not have enough time or help, (i.e. carpenters, electricians, etc) to show their true design talent. They were too busy doing all the work themselves...

Posted by Saronda – September 5, 2006 11:42 AM

*sigh* David *sigh*

yummmmy

Posted by Deb – September 5, 2006 11:37 AM

I think Dani has the right idea. Beautiful Alice and grand-standing David would work well together. I must admit though, I prefer David's work to Alice's. Her glass house child's room didn't do it for me at all, while David's Japanese themed bedroom was striking and restful at the same time. Some of us wouldn't mind if he came along with the bed.

Posted by Paul – September 5, 2006 11:35 AM

I love the show. The final two contestants are great and make is a hard decision. I really enjoy the judges. What professionals they are! Other reality show judges seem to be so much of the "action" of the show that they seem to take an equal part in the program and overpower the actual people on the show. Not so with the Design Star judges. They are calm, reserved, and professional. They are definitely a positive part of the program with just the right amount of praise and criticism. Can't wait until Sunday. It is a hard decision, but I do have my favorite and can't wait to see the outcome. With either person as a winner the Design Star's show should be great. Thanks!!!!

Posted by Gloria – September 5, 2006 11:22 AM

Alice has a wonderful presence in front of the camera. But the final challenge decided me -- David is a designer and Alice is a decorator.

The Man Cave that Alice designed addressed the color, texture, comfort of the task, but it lacked design. I could have lined the furniture against one wall and added the armoire and the frig (I have one). I expected something more.

Can't both of these designers win? The would make a great team!

Posted by Carolyn – September 5, 2006 11:18 AM

It would have been great to see them work on a room together. It would have been amazing!!!! Alice's femine touch added with David's clean design. Wow!!!

Posted by Lori – September 5, 2006 11:12 AM

Both of the final designers are awesome. I like David's room best, but I don't know if it was a better room or if it is because he chose one of my favorite looks. Alice gives the appearance that she can work with any client's taste -traditional or modern - but I am not sure if David could do a good job on a non-modern style room - it just wasn't shown in this competition.

I wholeheartedly agree that the should both get a show !

Posted by TK – September 5, 2006 11:12 AM

Wow...what a tuff choice. They are both so good! I just wish that David would keep his shirt on! It looks as though he is tring to play the sexy card. And its a bit to ovious.

Posted by Lori – September 5, 2006 11:05 AM

Both David and Alice are great in design. The one thing I would like to see Alice do is wear a little more in the way of top coverage. My personal choice is David, he has inspired me to work on my rather large living room. He has great talent and will be a great asset to HGTV and to the public that watches his show. Thanks David and Thanks Clive for bringing this show to us.
I vote David
Mary Ann
Dunn, North Carolina

Posted by Mary Ann – September 5, 2006 11:05 AM

David and Alice, You both did a great job on your rooms. You've made it a hard choice. I do wish you both well whatever the outcome. Each of you are STARS. Thank you Clive for the show.
Your TV watching friend.

Posted by Stephanie Crawford – September 5, 2006 11:02 AM

I hate to have to choose, David and Alice are both so talented and versatile. They both exude confidence and both have such a strong on-camera presence. I've casted my vote, but boy was it tough!

Posted by LMT Boston – September 5, 2006 11:01 AM

I think both David and Alice are gifted designers and probably deserve thier own shows but having to choose just one, I vote for David. In the final challenge he made it appear that the "glass house" was designed around his room and not the opposite! His choice to incorporate the outside with the inside was brilliant.

While Alice's room was very nice it was also very ordinary and seemed to be designed in spite of the space rather than to complement the space - as the judges pointed out the beds did not even take advantage of the view.

Posted by DJ – September 5, 2006 11:00 AM

I love this show my husband gets worried when I watch this show. Laughing. I think David is the best. Lillian from upstate New York

Posted by Lillian – September 5, 2006 10:58 AM

I think David and Alice are both very talented. But reviewing David's designs from all the rooms he did, there were square boxes or grid patterns on the wall in every room. That gets boring after a while. All his rooms were basically alike - neutral brown colors with boxes on the walls. Alice on the other hand, worked with many colors, each room was an adventure unto itself. She showed that she can work with whatever room she has been given and each room looks completely different when she's finished.
I was put off by the fact that David seemed to think he had to take his shirt of when he worked. Any workman who disrobed while working in my home would be immediately sent packing! A more professional demeanor should be presented for a real star. Alice was always professional, courteous and always seemed to do her very best with what she had to work with. Way to go Alice.

Posted by Linda – September 5, 2006 10:40 AM

Alice had a great presentation as usuall and her design was great! she really thought out what she needed to do with the time she had. David, put your shirt back on! its obvious you are trying to win with the male and female vote. Do you think this looks professional for a designer to go around with their shirt off? By the way, this was suppose to be a vote from the public but you could tell that the judges and host were already guiding the people to vote for David. Was David's bed facing the correct way? Also when you decorate a kids room it is not going to be used with soft colors such as brown, beige, orange and earth tones which gives it a more warmer feel. The kids room is suppose to be bright and poppy. The one thing I noticed about Davids room was that every week the same color family was used and lots and lots of circles. Did he pick out some pictures from some magazines before he started this show. He seemed to always be doing the same room from the same color family. Way to go Alice, you nailed it! you are truly a great decorator even though David was picked at the very start of the show by the judges. I think the judges should have stayed out of the final show, they just steered the voters in the direction toward David so he could win. Maybe he will ask one of them out. Go Alice, you should be the next star!!!!!!

Posted by Sandy Clayton – September 5, 2006 10:38 AM

HGTV is the winner not only with a great show format but with two new faces creating the best designs...what's so nice they execute designs the lay person can understand...and they are working within my budget!
Clive is a natural for this job, because even when he has them "exit the studio" I still love him, his voice can soothe my nerves everytime.
Alice is good but David has the fresh absolute JOY doing this work...he got my vote...good job HGTV, you are the only channel that is on my tv 24 hours a day!

Posted by Stephanie – September 5, 2006 10:38 AM

THEY MUST CO-HOST THE DESIGN SHOW. THEY ARE A DYNAMIC DUO AND PLAY OFF ONE ANOTHER'S TALENTS AMAZINGLY.

DAVID'S INTO "ZEN" AND ALICE IS INTO "PRETTY" AND TOGETHER THEY'RE GREAT!

Posted by Cynthia Klein – September 5, 2006 10:34 AM

Thank you for an entertaining & educational show.

Everyone keeps saying that Alice is a natural in front of the camera but, although she is obviously sweet and kind, I didn't notice a huge difference between her and the others. She is photogenic, that is for sure. And her style, while beautiful, can be found in most local show rooms.

David is easy to watch...not because he is cute...but because he is genuine and ONE OF A KIND.

I'd like to see him dress a little more professionally WHEN he gets his own show. As every woman knows, you can dress well without clothes being too tight or too revealing...but perhaps the producers and editors emphasized that part of his wardrobe.

David was a children's decorator and has now shown that he can do sleek contemporary. I'll bet he can do anything he sets his mind to....

Posted by Eileen – September 5, 2006 10:30 AM

David: excellent clean and creative designs. Alice: her forte is decoration but with her accent I could watch a show for hours. HGTV: guys the buzz is everywhere, subways, restaurants, work... America has fallen in love with both David & Alice, they compliment each other- let us have them both!!!

Posted by Andrea – September 5, 2006 10:30 AM

I would love to see a show co-hosted by these two. I think Alice can benefit from Dave and vice versa. Dave's design was interesting and clean, but ultimately I think not comfortable--especially those chairs. And also a bit boring--easy to fall into when aiming for restful. C'mon this is a bedroom. And I agree with Vern--what about some color? Alice's room was good, but had a bit too much stuff in it. Loved the fixture, and the red chair, hated the other chair--it actually would have gone better in Dave's room. I think if she had stenciled the head board words and the insects on the windows and left off the white it would have been great. Or, how about the headboards being shades of the red chair? Anyhow Alice I know Vern talked about placing the beds differently but from where I was sitting(in front of my TV) I don't know where else you could have put them.

And an aside here to Vern, I've watched you with interest since I first heard about you and saw you on Trading Spaces. Love some of your designs, but thought several were too dark and too cluttered too--so there!! I still have a crush on you and for the most part loved what you did; not that you care :-).

I think these two should each have their own show or cohost or alternate.

Denise

Posted by Denise – September 5, 2006 10:27 AM

I love what David and Alice did. They would make a GREAT team. I think David has the edge though. I wish them both the best as they are great designers.

Posted by michael – September 5, 2006 10:26 AM

What a great show. My husband and I have enjoyed all the episodes and make sure we watch or record each of them so we can see them again! I think both Alice and David are fabulous designers. I really liked both final rooms, though I think Alice's would translate much better into an actual in-home space. David's, on the other hand, could be placed into the middle of anywhere and still be fabulous! Both my husband and I favor traditional design, but agree that we could live in any of David's designs with complete comfort. He is so talented. I was impressed with him in that he considered the whole picture inside and out and from every angle as he executed his design. We can hardly wait until next Sunday. David wins hands down, in my estimation!!! BTW....both having a show together would be wonderful too!

Posted by Sharon Tognetti – September 5, 2006 10:23 AM

I loved watching the show. I think that both David and Alice would be a great addition to the HGTV channel. I wish them both good luck. However,in my opinion, David is much more gifted than Alice. Alice's room in the park was a nice children's room but it lacked creativity. David's room however, was outstanding. He incorporated the views into his design, He brought the outdoors in, and the indoors out.

Posted by sam – September 5, 2006 10:19 AM

Such a great show. What a hard decision! They are both such talented people. This week I must admit I liked David's room better, but still believe Alice is the better host. They appeared to have so much concern and encouragement for eachother which really was quite refreshing. [I get so tired of "I'm so great and the other's aren't" attitudes seen on other shows.] I'd love to see them host a show together!

Clive!! I've loved you since I started watching Designed to Sell. Great show, great work!

Blessings,
Di

Posted by Diane – September 5, 2006 10:17 AM

David has done a fantastic job! I love his art work and his creative designs!! I do have to say that Alice has done a nice job and they are the only two that deserve to be on the last show. Through it all David has had my vote!

Posted by Rachella – September 5, 2006 10:14 AM

Really enjoyed the series! David's final room was very well thought out and he definately stayed within his comfort zone (neutral colors, clean lines, etc)to create a peaceful space in the middle of NYC. Alice seemed a little scattered in the planning stages and I think her room reflected that. We were trying to decide during the show what age child would inhabit that room and really couldn't tell. The "rocking bear" indicated a baby or toddler, while the twins beds were suited to older kids and the hot pink chair to teens. That being said, Alice has a lot of talent and a great personality. Her blue room was beautiful and showed what she can do!

Posted by Dawn – September 5, 2006 10:13 AM

Hi Clive,
It was nice to see both Temple and Tym coming back to help out! It was nice to see David more relaxed when it came to revealing his room and Alice has always been a delight to watch. Although his room was very stylish and relaxing he could have used a little color. I had the same reaction to the rug Alice had, it was a tad boring for a kids room. Too bad she couldn't find a colorful rug with the colors that were in the really cool ceiling fixture. It sure has been hard chosing, but I hope Alice wins!

Posted by Leni – September 5, 2006 10:07 AM

This was definately the best reality show ever. I am a true fan of David. I love his simple bold lines. He really came into his own when he began doing his own spaces. I will ALWAYS love the 'Pet Store' room. Amazing ...

The one trait that I admired in David was that he always had a kind word to say about his competitors. Most of these shows can get so ugly, but he was always supportive of the others. It truly shows that you can compete and still treat individuals with respect.

David will get my vote ... and I know that Alice will succeed as well.

My hats off to HGTV ... I hope you continue with this series, it's awesome! Thanks.

Posted by Linda – September 5, 2006 10:03 AM

Is it too late to declare a tie and agree with the significant number of people who are saying what a great team David and Alice would make? I know the concept (taken from a number of other "reality" competition shows) is for only one winner--$1 million; the winner's own restaurant; huge prizes, etc.--but who would have thought the final two would be so complementary? David seems to have the creative edge, but Alice seems to have the presentation edge. However, David has been getting better and better on camera and Alice has always had the client's needs and desires uppermost.
Give them BOTH their own show!

Posted by G B Leatherwood – September 5, 2006 10:02 AM

While both are good, David has superior creative skills and design skills. I most appreciate that he did NOT take the suggestion of adding more color to his room, I think it would have been a distraction from the overall design. I personally do not think Alice did that much in the way of design but rather just filled the room with furniture. The fact that Alice keeps taking the advice of the judges gives the impression that she is not confident in her own decisions and most of her rooms have been a rehash of what was previously there (i.e. - The Man Cave!) or based on someone elses ideas.

Winner, hands down, David. If he does not win, this thing has been a farse!

Posted by Ken – September 5, 2006 9:56 AM

I don't understand why everyone keeps missing that a designer designs for clients, not themselves. As we all know, people are very different in their tastes. With that in mind, although I think that David is an excellent designer, his designs only appeal to the "clean lines, contempary, minimalist person. His designs all look the same whereas Alice is very versitile, listens and responds to the client's needs, wants, and style. Therefore, she is the perfect "Design Star" and exactly what HGTV should be looking for. All of their current design show hosts and current shows aired, mix-up their designs to suit the client's needs. I would have loved to have seen what David would have done when asked to design a very traditional room. On the other hand, Alice has shown what she can do with more that just a traditional design - The "tiffany box blue room" was a fantastic demonstration of clean, airy, minimalist style.

David, I would still watch your show but I wouldn't be upset if I missed it since it would be the same as the week before. Furthermore, if I wanted to completly change my style to the "clean line style", I would seek you out because you defintely are awesome in your comfort zone.

Alice, I would not miss an episode of your show if you are chosen. I think you are great.

Good Luck To Both Of You!!!!!!

Posted by Ann Hendrix – September 5, 2006 9:56 AM

DAVID - He has that innate talent and a creative mind - that's why its easy for him to see inspiration as soon as he saw the glass house. I see how that structure would make him think of Japanese vibe too. I love the layout and the big head board that he designed. And the bedding and pillows are tasteful and sophisticated. And since he didn't add any bright and bold colors - its not necessary because it would have taken away from the serene/Japanese vibe, and the beddings has the stripes and pillows has textures that already adds interest and catches the eyes. Love the way he had the white cloth as canopy too. And those lamps are captivating. I hope if he gets his own show he'll do an episode with Asian/south pacific theme (I love Asian sculptures and wall carvings) Yes, David's Design was the best to me. It just makes me wanna sleep in that room for the night - I would sleep peacefully too even if its in the middle of a park. He really capture the effect he was going for in this design. He did a wonderful job. He's improved on his presentation too. I've been rooting for him all along. I hope he wins.

ALICE - I saw things in her design clashing and didn't see the "Alice in wonderland" vibe. Its like a color riot with the bold color pillows. And the material of the green curtains seem too luxurious for the room compared to the casual beddings and the child-like drawings on cardboards and those cheap stacked storage boxes. And the chandelier is nice but it seems more fitting for a contemporary living room than a kid's bedroom. And that metal chair with the animal prints seem out of place too (it matches her top at the reveal though - but the issue is the room) Some of those things just looked like they didn't fit right together. David's design on the other hand fits the idea he's going for. She was just average and made obvious mistakes with her design. I don't think she should win. But she got exposure from this show plus her "Tiffany blue" room will be featured in "In Style" magazine and that should help her private business.

I liked seeing Jay from "project runway" season one. He and Kara were my favorites.

Temple and Tym were helpful. She looked like she lost some weight to me. At first I didn't like Tym's new hair cut but I got used to it. You know next week's episode is gonna bring the drama when they all come back for sure. Its gonna be amusing to see Ramona again.

Posted by Silvershadow – September 5, 2006 9:50 AM

I would love to see David host a show and Alice and Tym be his Assistance. What a great team and the Chemistry is awewsome. You would have one amazing show. They also seem to desining homeconcepts in the average price range. To be honest most people can't afford a $55,00, unless they are planning on assisting you with the construction of the kitchen rennovation. If, they can. They'll use an experienced desighner and leave it to her to get his list in. And Gladly pay designer. If, your on a limited budget, as I am, I want the similar function at a lower price, so we would have to look at redesining my home.

I am the type of person who who never apply.
So, I use your books and other and the help from HGTV and friends.I cut out lots of pictres, my friends and I disect your shows and styles. Maybe you could give families sketches how to improve their other rooms. If, they do that withing 3-6 months the paint and painting supplies are free. Maybe we would get other stores to donate computer desk,computer,Tv's. but the room has to be completed. "Give a Man A Book,You open,The world" Oprah might help???
I hope this makes since. It's early and maybe, I should walk first.

Posted by Barbara – September 5, 2006 9:48 AM

David is clearly a designer/decorator, while Alice is a decorator. David's final design used the structure's interior & exterior to determine his direction. Alice simply decorated a room. Is it his choice to go shirtless - or the producer's?

Posted by LM – September 5, 2006 9:47 AM

I really like both these guys and although David is the best designer, Alice does bring a feminine, traditional touch that David doesn't have. I agree that they BOTH should be in the new show. They are a good team!

Posted by Kathy – September 5, 2006 9:46 AM

Great show. Love the fact that the fighting is not the focus. Please let design continue to be the reason for the show. David should keep his shirt on and buttoned. We can tell he lifts weights without seeing his chest. I agree that co-hosting would be a great concept.

Posted by Missie – September 5, 2006 9:44 AM

Some have complained that David worked with his shirt off. SO WHAT! This is a show about design and style and that is what he has proven to excel in. If you let that influence you in your voing then that's a sad statement on what your priorities are. Stop complaining and vote for the most talented.

Posted by Sara – September 5, 2006 9:40 AM

I'm not alone, I see, in wishing that David and Alice could host a show together. I love the fact that they are so supportive of one another and really seem to care for the other.

Hard choice - but I went with David. I think great screen presence can be learned, but his design skills are just a natural!

Posted by Karen – September 5, 2006 9:39 AM

I agree, David should have kept his clothes on, unprofessional, for sure, but I have to say his room was beautiful. Alice tried, but her design was uninspired. I don't know any kid who would have liked that room. Alice, you are very personable and cute. You'd make a great tv personality, just not for this show.

Posted by Ann – September 5, 2006 9:36 AM

I felt it was unfair to have Alice as B. It was much easier to remember A for Alice. Obviously, I am for Alice. She is so sweet. David is nice, but I'm sick of looking at that tatoo. That is all I can see. I would have a hard time tuning in to a show hosted by him unless he had a long-sleeved shirt on.

Posted by Pat – September 5, 2006 9:28 AM

Go David!! I've been pulling for you since the beginning and so glad you made it to the final round. I do think both designers are very talented. But David has an 'edge'. He is definitely superior and deserves to win this one.

Posted by Rhonda Fiorella – September 5, 2006 9:24 AM

A great final episode! I agree with a comment I read last week; I would like to see them co-host a show. That not being possible, I vote for Alice because I think I would enjoy continuing to tune in each week and because her designs seem more useful to us "do it yourselfers" which I would think would be your target audience. The show isn't just aimed at other designers, is it? Also, I think she relates more to the real needs and wants of her clients. David is very talented, but also quite extreme, and most of his designs just wouldn't work in everyday life.

Posted by Millie – September 5, 2006 9:16 AM

Clive, I loved this show! I hope Design Star will become a staple in the HGTV annual schedule.
If you want to know, my choice for the next design star is David. I loved his work and he seems to have all of the design/artistic skills a design star should have. As far as his hosting skills, I really think that winning will give him that little something extra he needs to become as confident in his presentation skills as he in his designs. He'll be a master in no time. I know I'll watch his show. I'm not happy with Alice. Her designs are uninspired and routine...even I could do what she did. Her presentations get a bit cloying and annoying very quickly. I don't expect to watch her show on a regular basis. I won't have to, it will be the same week after week.

Posted by Kathy L – September 5, 2006 9:16 AM

What are you going to do with the rooms in the glass houses. Maybe have a drawing, so I could win David's!!! Or Alice's.

Then as the winners first project, they can install their glass house makeovers into a real live house!!!!

email when they'll be arriving with the camera crew!!!!

Enjoyed the show, and these two really are who should be in the challenge.

Hopefully you can have a spot for both of them on the upcoming new show. Would love to see a where-are-they now of the entire contestant panel as well !!! Definitely hope thats in the works.

Posted by thrift decorator – September 5, 2006 9:06 AM

I think that both of these designers should have a show together. How great would this be!!!! Both have distinct styles, both seem to get along and work well together. I think it would make an excellent show. But this is only my opinion.

Posted by lorrie – September 5, 2006 9:05 AM

As a woman, it's time we start getting more eye candy to watch while we learn how to do things. David encompasses all that is needed to accomplish that! Since Vern isn't seen much on TV anymore, I say hand the reigns over to the cutest up and coming and give him plenty of air time!!!!!!

Posted by Cindy – September 5, 2006 9:02 AM

I love both David and Alice. It is such a hard decision on who to vote for. Alice has such a great personality with talent to match. David is a hunk with exceptional design skills. Good luck to the both of you. Maybe they both could have his own show.

Posted by Kathy – September 5, 2006 9:02 AM

I like Alice but was dissapointed in her room. The gel stickers are a choking hazard when they fall onto the floor. The storage lockers are not practical, how is a child suppose to access them? There is no step stool in the room, they can topple over onto a child also toys can topple from them. There is nothing in this room to spark a child's imgination or creativity, there is no lego table, no chalk board, nothing for a child to put thier hands on. It may be a nice childs room in the eyes of an adult without chilren but it is not a good children's room in the eyes of a child and certainly not in the eyes of a mom in terms of safety.

Posted by Dawn – September 5, 2006 9:01 AM

I love both - David and Alice - and prior to the final challenge I was not a fan of both of the designers being a pair - HOWEVER - because DAVID is so - single color palette insistent and ALICE is so - can't think out of the box - they would be a GREAT DESIGN TEAM !!! Since - HGTV Enjoys throwing hooks at it's audience - now would be a good time!!! although we want it - we would not expect you to do it (pairing them as a design duo. I find David's designs to be extremely boring and Alice's beginning to lack originality.
Although I love the show - I watch religiously and enjoy the personalities....Love Clive and the panel!! Keep up the Great Work HGTV!!!

Posted by Julie – September 5, 2006 8:52 AM

Hi Clive,

As a former Real Estate Agent and aspiring designer, I find this competition to be quite intrigueing. What a great concept! Making a room out of a glass house must be one of the most difficult dilema's possible. My first instinct would have been to make a japanese tea house. It had those distinctive lines and the sun filled the room, perfect for a shogi screen or two. I agree with the judges that David's design could have used a splash of color. Red would have been my choice. Just a bold statement. Nothing overwhelming. I love your show by the way (designed to sell). I watch it religiously. You have proven yourself to be quite good at what you do. Congratulations on your show and a great career.

Jeannie

Posted by Jeannie – September 5, 2006 8:44 AM

Really enjoy the show. Both of the finalists are great and either one will make a great host or hostess. I watch HGTV the great part of each day just for the variety of good shows that you have. We are looking forward to the new show with one of these young persons as the host.

DG

Posted by David H Groll – September 5, 2006 8:42 AM

Clive, you are the perfect host for both Design Star & Designed to Sell. I thought this show was loads of fun to watch and I really liked that David and Alice were two people who genuinely liked each other. They would make great co-hosts! My 11 year old son has been so motivated by David that he has drawn up quite professional looking plans for the remodel of his bedroom. I guess you know who we'll be voting for. Can't wait to see the final outcome.

Posted by Karen – September 5, 2006 8:37 AM

HAVE ENJOYED YOUR HOSTING, CLIVE; AND, THE PROFESSIONALISM OF THE JUDGES.

Posted by EVELYN – September 5, 2006 8:28 AM

I have watched this show from the beginning and have enjoyed seeing the participants grow and change. I am THRILLED that David and Alice are the 2 finalists! David is VERY innovative and Alice is so sincere! It was a difficult decision when I cast my vote - I would love for them to each have a show!

Posted by Kay C in MN – September 5, 2006 8:16 AM

David and Alice make such a great onscreen couple and would work well together, find away to have them co-host a later show, maybe alternating between the design and the presenting/commenting roles?

Posted by Peter Davis – September 5, 2006 8:10 AM

Dear Clive,
What a personality. What real designs. Alice is the Design Star.

Posted by Mark – September 5, 2006 7:57 AM

It was really tough to decide who to vote for. Both my husband and I love them both - their designs and personalies. In the end we felt that the few times that the designers had to respond to a client's needs that David's designs were more respond to the style and functional need.

Future design star challenges should include more off-the-street clients. Everyday design is not just for design sake it must respond to real people living in the spaces everyday.

Posted by judy – September 5, 2006 7:53 AM

I love Davids work, he doesn't stick to the same old design like Alice. Her work is nice but it seems to be a variation on the same design each week.

Posted by Pat – September 5, 2006 7:37 AM

I watched every show and even some reruns. The
entire series was well done by all. I hope
there will be more such shows in the future.

Thanks to HGTV (some of my favorite viewing)
for some great entertainment. My favorites are
"The Painted House", "Devine Design" and of course designed to sell"

Posted by Janice Zittle – September 5, 2006 7:18 AM

I was sure I would be voting for Alice but after this episode I have to say "David is GREAT." He consistantly did great designs. Alice, putting those white pictures and bedspread in that room just turned me off. Both, hpwever, seem to be very nice people and I'm sure they will do well.

Posted by Melody Kiley – September 5, 2006 7:00 AM

There is only one clear winner here and it is David!!! Alice failed with here "wonderland" child's bedroom...I had a much nicer bedroom growing up than what Alice threw together...what was she thinking!!!

Posted by davidfan – September 5, 2006 6:50 AM

I have an unusual slant to watching and enjoying the whole Design Star process. I am a victim of both Architectural and Interior Design curriculums at the college level. I've enjoyed designing environments for my friends, extended family and my wife and I. The odd slant is that my wife is a former TV news anchor and show host at the ABC and PBS levels. The exposure to all this tells me to hire both Alice and David to combine their talents into a vehicle that covers ALL the bases. You won't be sorry!

Posted by Pat – September 5, 2006 6:17 AM

PS In watching the program again, it really did seem the minute the judges walked in on Alice's glass room they were very negative. Condoning. The judges were suppose to notjudge, but they certainly let the whole world know that this was NOT a great design. Why three chairs in David's room? Were they for the three judges? Flopping on the beds, sitting in the chairs all looked staged. That act was too impartial, and unprofessional--clearly out of character, very biased. Lesson learned for next show: is that once the judges were through on episode five, they should not have returned. Period. Their presence totally blew Alice's chances. If no one saw any of the other five episodes they would have thought to judge Alice on her last room, and listening to the judges condon her, they would not have voted for her.

Posted by Wendy – September 5, 2006 6:16 AM

I think that David and Alice are both terrific designers. David, however, stands out with his talent and vision. They are both gracious and kind to each other which I have appreciated. My choice is David. I would watch his program definitely. Hope Design Star will have many more seasons. Thanks for providing such a great program.

Posted by Virginia – September 5, 2006 6:00 AM

David & Alice

The best of luck to you both and it could be interesting to have a show with both of you in it. I will say this that I do prefer the clean lines and content of Davids room over Alices

Posted by Charles T – September 5, 2006 5:45 AM

Good Morning Clive, we love Design Star so much...We love both the young designers, but our hearts and votes have to go to David,,,a graduate of our wonderful Ringling School of Art and Design...please tell David we need him to come back to Osprey and help us with our decorating dilemma...Thanks, Stanley and Ollie...(another fine mess he got me into)...

Posted by Ollie – September 5, 2006 5:23 AM

Hey Clive! I'm not a regular Tele viewer but got hooked by the Design* by way of enjoying the entertaining presentation of an HGTV programme saved from being a bore by you!. My room mate would yell out "Clive is on TV... come and hear what he has to say on this episode"... No I am NOT a 'groupie' luv,tis just refreshing to hear a bit o' wit every once in awhile. Thanks. Err I digress, so getting back to design star, consensus in the house is that David is definitely an amazing designer but Alice is a confident presenter so y'all (had to add that in deference to Alice's southern roots) do MAKE BOTH DAVID AND ALICE CO-HOSTS as they compelement each other rather well. OK, so I confess I have voted for David online, based on the superb job in the final episode.
Mayhaps you could plant this suggestion in the producers' ear/s ( I'd be surprised if this has not sprouted on it's own in some power-that-be's mind and is maturing as I write). Excuse the typos & do keep in mind that english is not my first language.

Posted by Bharti – September 5, 2006 3:21 AM

Aice and David are both so great can't you just give them both a show? Since I can only vote for one of them, it'll have to be Alice because of her talent and that it is also my mother's and granddaughter's names.

Posted by Linda Buffo – September 5, 2006 3:16 AM

I LOVE the show. I have "favored" Alice throughout. She does Texas proud, but I ultimately cast my vote for David because you have to give credit where it is due. The man is just simply Talented with a capital "T". He imagines it, creates it, and installs it like a Michealangelo. I would love to see BOTH of them have their own show, because having to choose one was difficult. She is equally adorable, and has a gift as well.

Posted by Donna – September 5, 2006 3:15 AM

I didn't start watching Design Star until the 5th show, but I took the opportunity to watch all of the episodes today (Labor Day)and realize that the "cream" did rise to the top. I was very impressed with David all along, yet Alice definitely grew on me. I think I will vote for Alice one day and David the next day because I feel that both of them are equally talented and would be so enjoyable to watch. I agree with other viewers who said they would love to see them co-host a show together.

Clive is one of my favorite personalities on HGTV and is an excellent host; I also liked the individuals chosen as judges. All in all this is a high class production and not the run-of-the-mill "reality show," which I do not like and will not waste my time watching.

I look forward to the announcement of the winner on Sunday and, in the future, the opportunities that have opened up for the other participants due to their appearance on Design Star.

Thank you for a well thought out show. It has been very interesting to actually see how the design process works.

Posted by Shar – September 5, 2006 3:10 AM

I felt Alice's childrens room was weak at best. I did not see any creativness to her idea at all. My daughter and I have done better things with less money than this young womens design. She does do well on camera though.
As for David's design, it appeared much more thought out and completed. I might have added a small punch of red somewhere, but that would be just a personal taste thing. His neutral color design can be much more soothing to many.
I would like to say I do enjoy this show almost as much as project runway. Keep up the good work.

Posted by Donna W. – September 5, 2006 3:09 AM

i think david should win loved id designs would not mind him to come and redue some of my home what a drip it wou be.
i thought alice was gret but i loved david designs

thank you
gaby lehman

Posted by gaby lehmann – September 5, 2006 2:51 AM

Excellent episode! I loved it. I believe it showed, hands-down, who the winner ought to be. Omg, i am looking forward to the finale.

Posted by Janet – September 5, 2006 2:48 AM

Hi Clive,

I love the program. I watch it with my adult daughter, and so far we agree with almost all of your choices. We are a little stumped about the final choice. Since David and Alice get along so well, how about co-hosts. Alice's voice alone for a whole show could grate a bit and David could use a little bit of Alice's color sense.

We hope you will do Season #2. Incidentally, except for the Donna/Temple personality clash, your show was about the design and not the intrigue ( as in Project Runway, which has allowed some aweful treatment toward one contestant's mother that should have been stopped, we think).

Those time constraints make for some real compromises in quality. Do they need to be so tight?

Keep up the good work!

Posted by Peg of Lancaster, PA – September 5, 2006 2:40 AM

Am I the only viewer who has noticed that David's room in the final challenge is essentially identical to the "pet store" room that wowed the judges in Episode 2? Same large-scale grid as a background, this time using soshi screen paper over glass instead of paint on a wall; same color and texture for the rug, this time using an actual rug instead of wood shavings and reptile bedding; same monochromatic color scheme from the same general corner of the color wheel, using white for contrast.

On one level he IS more artistic than Alice, but on another level--that of practicality and functionality, he is not. He reminds me most of Kenneth Brown, which is not a compliment. In his designs, as in Kenneth's, appearance continually trumps functionality. Building the bed low to the floor expands the visual volume of the space but is a pain in the backside when you try to make the bed.

In Episode 6, like other designers who don't live with children, he relied on murals and an artsy-fartsy room divider for the kid's corner. His use of space, furniture placement, and color choices were trite, having been done the same way jillions of times on other design shows. I like modern furniture, but I think I would be hard-pressed to actually live in one of his rooms.

Alice, on the other hand, usually turns out fairly livable rooms, although as one judge noted, they're "nothing surprising."

Which person wins the gig as design star? Doesn't that depend on HGTV's plans for the winner? What niche will either designer fill in the HGTV roster?

Posted by too young to be a curmudgeon – September 5, 2006 2:35 AM

Gosh Clive, why can't you make David and Alice both the new Design Star as a team??!! That would be something to see!

Posted by Charlene – September 5, 2006 2:31 AM

Though I think Clive does a commendable job on "Designed To Sell", I resent his droll, almost-ominous comedic attempts with the contestants. I seriously doubt that his comments come across as comforting to the contestants. Bottom line: Rather than immitating other reality-based shows with their doomsday dimissals, why not come up with some creative ideas that stress warmth rather than doom. Wouldn't that be a refreshing departure? Try it! You (more importantly the viewing audience) might like it.

Posted by Dr. Edward Daniel – September 5, 2006 2:23 AM

ONLY ALICE CREATED A TRULY LIVEABLE ROOM, not a
bed display. Alice provided clothing storage,
storage for toys and extras, and COMFORTABLE seating. Children would LIKE AND USE her room.
ALICE DESIGNS VERY CAREFULLY FOR THE WAY THAT PEOPLE REALLY LIVE.
DAVID CREATED A ROOM WITH NO BEDSIDE TABLE, NO
CLOTHING STORAGE OR ANY OTHER STORAGE. Rather,
David chose statuary! Statuary is nice, but far less of a necessity than storage. David's room had lamps in abundance, but no chair in which to curl up and comfortably read a book. David's profile said that he designed PROPS and children's rooms for model homes, BUT MODEL HOMES ARE NOT HOMES THAT ARE DESIGNED FOR REAL LIVING!
Alice was careful to provide storage, not only in this design but in her prior designs. David tends to habitually ignore storage issues. Even in his prior challenge, I found it strange that he didn't design toy storage at a level where the children could actually reach their toys. There was no toybox in the actual play area. [This is rather strange for someone whose specialty is said to be designing children's room.] There was no storage for arts and crafts supplies by David's craft table. David provided a microwave, but no cabinet to store the microwavable items! His rooms have some flash, but they are not grounded in reality. I am flabbergasted that the judges didn't notice that!
This time David provided three chairs. Did he anticipate that the judges would be coming and give them more consideration than actual room usage?
AT THIS POINT, ANYONE WHO STOPS TO REALLY STUDY THE ROOMS COULD ONLY VOTE FOR ALICE! After all,
This show is called "Design Star," not "Flashy But Impractical Star." Additionally, Alice always conducts herself like a lady and would excellently represent the best values of HGTV!

Posted by Eddie – September 5, 2006 2:21 AM

David's techniques of using a neutral palate simply shows that it does not take bold colors to make a bold statement. He also seems to be able to show off the features of any room by taking the individual room and designing around it, instead of taking a design and trying to make it fit a room!
As a Realtor in the Denver area, part of what I do is to make recommendations to sellers on the best way to prepare their home before it goes on the market. Sometimes this means recommending painting and usually using neutrals, since you never know what the next homeowners furnishings will look like.
I find that David's designs are simple, elegant and make a bold statement. Every room he has designed you simply go, "WOW"!
I will begin using his ideas as inspiration for recommendations to my sellers!

Posted by Keil Steck – September 5, 2006 2:13 AM

I love Alice. She is sweet, genuine and very charming. However, her approach throughout has been more that of a decorator than a designer. She doesn't work from strong concept, allowing every choice to be determined by that concept. She seems to go shopping to figure out what she is going to do. The result is that her work lacks the unifying power and magic that a strong, well thought out concept gives to a design. David is truly a designer! I look forward to seeing what he will do as the Design Star winner.

-A Retired Professor of Interior Design & Architecture

Posted by Alexa – September 5, 2006 2:10 AM

The two finalists display (to me) a passion for their work which I did not detect in those whose shows were cancelled. Though they're both good, not just at what they do, but at presenting themselves and their work for the audience, David presents such an open, its-just-me demeanor that he's most refreshing. And I like him....which is funny because I'm put off by tatoos and most people who have 'em. I was somewhat put off by David's shirtlessness and thought it a bid for female judges votes. (Kept wondering if Alice would be afforded, if she wanted it, the same latitude!

But, then, I"m still wondering how you let that other channel get away with Christopher Lowell.

Posted by Lenora Cobb – September 5, 2006 1:40 AM

Clive-
The show has been wonderful! I think it's very interesting that David and Alice are the two choices. It seemed evident right from the start that David was a very strong designer. He also seemed to be the one who was most able to put aside the conflicts or address them directly without drama. Alice was slower to shine, but by week three, she was the other obvious choice. The judges were a hoot (on Trading Spaces, Vern is the only designer I consistantly enjoy watching, as he doesn't insist on losing the ceiling fans...), and they were so fair for the most part. This was a great idea, and you, of course, were a fab host! I can't wait to see who America picked! I hope it was David, but I'll check out the new show reguardless of who hosts!
Ta Ta! Susan

Posted by Susan Brady – September 5, 2006 1:16 AM

This is one of the first times I have ever watched a television competition when I truly felt I would be satisfied with whoever won the competition.

I must say that I watched the auditions and some of the other information posted on the internet and found David somewhat less likeable because he seemed to be somewhat egotistical about his looks. Fortunately, that has not come through in aired episodes. David has appeared to be truly likeable and supportive of his competition.

The only other criticism I have of David, and in fact, I am surprised that the judges did not, is the fact that all of his rooms look alot the same. All of his rooms relied heavily on the color brown and all of them seemed to have a alot of repetition when it came to lining up a series of identical objects. In addition, his rooms all tended to have a repetitive theme of boxes or grids of some kind on the walls.

Don't get me wrong, all his designs were beautiful and well executed, all be it very similar. I think this might get old on a long running series.

Alice, is absolutely delightful, as both a person and a designer. I would want Alice as my best friend.

Alice is also a good designer. I think she seems better able or at least more willing to adjust her own personal style to fit the situation at hand. She is so likeable and so talented, that I can't invision a show featuring Alice that everyone wouldn't clamour to see.

In my opinion, the least likeable person on the entire show was Vanessa. She seems incredibly self centered, and very quick to take the credit for any thing that goes well, even if she is not responsible for it. She is equally likely to blame others when she is criticized. She is one of those throw them to the wolves type of people that I try to avoid. I think that it was fitting that she got eliminated during a challemge that she could not blame anyone for but herself; moreover, as a viewer I could see right off the bat that the room was something my 11 year old might have designed. She was so confident that her room was great, that I can only assume she has no design sense whatsoever.

I hate it that Joseph was eliminated so early, because I liked him and did not get a chance to see how good of a designer he was. The first challenge focused so little on the back court yard and they did not have time to do much because of the money situation.

With regard to Temple, she said that she did not want to be portrayed that way - Well, I guess then that she should not have acted that way!!!!

Posted by JULIE – September 5, 2006 12:52 AM

Loved both designs and have been in favor of Alice for awhile, but I think David is the one who really pulled this one out. And his presentation was much better than any before. I think he's the one!

Posted by Liz – September 5, 2006 12:47 AM

I liked Alice's idea of "through the lookinglass" but was disappointed at WHITE bedspreads in a children's room! As the mother of two boys, I can attest that those blankets would be a pale grey sooner rather than later. I agree that the focus of the room should have been turned to face the park. I loved that she used "real" furniture and really considered the way things would go together instead of buying a pre-fab children's suite from a store. She has been one of my favorites all along.

That said, I have saved all my votes for David. He truly DESIGNED the space, not just decorated it like Alice did. He created unusual pieces, like the indoor/outdoor rock garden and integrated the surroundings into his design. His fabrics were beautiful and perfect for his space; any more color or texture would have been overwhelming, in my opinion. Bravo!

Very interesting to see Temple invited back. I thought, uh-oh, but she absolutely surprised me with her ability to take direction. I hadn't seen that at all during the show. She proved to be a very adept worker on this last show, and that was a very nice surprise.

I'm glad Tym was invited back, too. I thought it might be hard for him to be assisting on the last challenge when he'd come so close himself, but he really was professional and helpful. He did an amazing job for David; I'm sure there's going to be a life-long friendship with those two!

Posted by SoCalPam – September 5, 2006 12:42 AM

This has been a great series all the way! Everything on TV (even HGTV) seems to be reruns and I basically quit watching. Then I saw an ad for the series. I missed the beginning of the first show but have been glued to it ever since. Of course, some of the message boards could make a TV drama also! HGTV has me back. I really like Alice, she is so sweet, her style is so much more what I would have in my home, but I voted for David. His personality is infectious, I liked the extra zing in his designs. I am re-decorating now and his designs make me think "Oh, I could try something like that!" Not the whole room but the extra little punches. Alice is so sweet but doesn't make me want to get up and try something. It is a tough call. Perfect solution - as so many are saying - they would work well together and you should be the host! What a show that would make!

Posted by Mary E – September 5, 2006 12:39 AM

David and Alice are so cute! Why not have them together on one show.

Posted by Clare – September 5, 2006 12:37 AM

REALLY enjoy the show. I think the final two designers are both great... It's very hard to vote!
Watching each epiosde from Southern California.
SB

Posted by Sally Brady – September 5, 2006 12:37 AM

I LOVE Alice - she has always been so genuine and natural - but i think that in this final challenge, David aced it. The clean lines- mimicking the structure, and those awesome inside/outside boxes. I want this bedroom. His "host" skills have definitely improved also!

Posted by Kat – September 5, 2006 12:36 AM

Hello, great show, I have enjoyed it all very much! I think a great idea would be to have the design star show have David and Alice as co-hosts, because he seems to be the strongest design talent and she seems to be a natural in front of the camera, and they adore each other and working together! They are both talented designers and would be greater than the sum of their collective parts as a design star team. That way they both win!

Posted by Karen Flynn – September 5, 2006 12:31 AM

I really feel that the best designers are in the finals but I'm very disappointed that Tym had such a difficult time with his carpenter. Did HGTV select him? Was Tym set up to fail? Nothing was even mentioned about what he had to overcome. Maybe there would have been some wall treatments if he hadn't had spend his time fighting with his "assistant". I would have liked a comment or two about what he had to overcome. Also, I didn't see much change in the room that Alice designed. She did change the furniture but the room didn't really change that much.

Posted by Patt Fairfield – September 5, 2006 12:29 AM

I think that David and Alice are good designers, but feel that Alice let us down in the finale. David did an execellent job,as usual.

Posted by Zina – September 5, 2006 12:29 AM

We absolutely love this show!!! Both Alice & David are incredible and can only imagine what they could do with more time and resources available to them. David's idea of the inside/outside flowing connection was so impressive, along with the rug outside shows his creative thinking. The kids room by Alice was adorable with the bright colors, and the light was the perfect touch. Both are outstanding & too hard to choose a favorite.

Posted by Cari – September 5, 2006 12:19 AM

I came late to this party -- just today! Watched the marathon from episode 3 on ... a long day doing housework made much more enjoyable by the fun on TV.

I agreed with every elimination, though it was a toss-up between Tym and Temple. I thought her strong personality served her well, but her lack of experience led her to make poor choices. Tym came across as charming on camera, but his true personality was negative and abrasive, his designs lacked spark, and he obviously has no idea what to do with walls. I felt sorry for the poor woman who was his last client. I hope she has an artistic friend to fill those sad walls with something lively. I would have liked to see what Temple did for her.

In any case, the correct designers were chosen for the last challenge. Both are loaded with charm, easy on the eyes, and have talent. But only one can create a TV-ready room, and that's David. Just judging from his previous designs before this last challenge, he had the most innovation and creativity. His designs are consistently interesting and come alive on TV.

Alice has more instinctive TV appeal as a host, but in this challenge, David more than rose to the task as a host, a skill that can be learned. No matter how much brushing up Alice does, her designs are ordinary, have no pizazz, and this last room displayed all her shortcomings: poor pre-planning, last-minute decisions, no clear story in the room, and bad execution. I really, really disliked the kid's room. She would do well as a host on Trading Spaces, or some other home show where others do the actual design. I agree with some other suggestions I've seen here that D & A share a show -- his designs and charm, her bubbly introductions and reveals.

David's room was magical and he met the design challenge's needs perfectly. I would love to live in that bedroom -- as long as it wasn't in the middle of Central Park with everyone watching!

GO DAVID!

Posted by Harriet – September 5, 2006 12:18 AM

These are obviously talented designers. However, I can't help but feel that they were also chosen for their blatant sex appeal. These are not designers with only their skills on display. I saw a lot of skin in cleavage and bare chest shots.

Posted by Lynne – September 5, 2006 12:13 AM

I think this was the most wonderful new show that HGTV could come up with. It is refreshing to see something new on the program guide. There has been WAY TOO MUCH of House Hunters. I think it would have been really interesting if the designers would all have had to do the exact same room. Maybe next season. Thanks for the great job in giving viewers something new and interesting to watch.

Posted by Martha Hansen – September 5, 2006 12:10 AM

Both David and Alice are talented designers, and deserve to win. HGTV should consider forming a partnership of these two designers, b/c they both bring so much talent to the network.

Posted by PMK – September 5, 2006 12:10 AM

Actually, I think Alice and David would make a GREAT TEAM! Their gifts complement each other. The judges did a great job narrowing down to these two talented and delightful designers. Thanks for a great show!

Sincerely,

Mary George

Posted by Mary George – September 5, 2006 12:08 AM

I can't believe I missed this episode, thank goodness you are re-running it a number of times. Looks like David rocked again!!!
He'll be such a fun TV show host. Please, please come to Wisconsin and paint my house, I love your artwork!!!

Posted by Kim – September 5, 2006 12:00 AM

Mon 9/4 - I watched most of today's review waiting for the final challange. It was so exciting - the judges were very fair in their comments and added greatly to the outcome of each design. I commend both David and Alice on their creativity, but my vote is with David for incorporating the use of the glass house as part of his design. His cool and calm interpretation of the room transported me from Bryant Park to Japan. Great work David!

Posted by Phyllis B – September 4, 2006 11:53 PM

I was unaware of the show's exsistence until today. However HGTV did a "Design Star Marathon" and I got to watch the entire series from start to the final judgement episode. I have to admit that I am not a fan of reality tv shows - something about the competition brings out the worst qualities in the contestants exhibited by the back biting and attitudes. This show however, had me hooked from the very beginning. I like interior design shows so that I might be able to get a great idea to work with on my house and the idea of watching the "Design Stars" develop and overcome obstacles along the way somehow intrigured me. I wound up watching all 7 episodes back to back - stuck to the tv as if I was personally part of the competition. I agreed with the judges throughout the competition and saw that they were very aware of what they were doing and while I was sorry to see some of the designers go I am totally gratified in the judges final choice of David and Alice. In the end I have to go with David as my choice only because I feel that he takes the time to work out his design and then executes it well. I also think his designs are just a LITTLE bit better than Alice's in that they are more organized around the main concept of the design. While I do admit that his talents in front of the camera may not be the best (he seems a little nervous) he can always get help becoming more comfortable in front of the camera. Whereas Alice is a natural in front of the camera but lacks a little in the design concept area. My best advice though would be to keep them BOTH and utilize the particular talents of each in a show and that would be the best of both worlds. However as this was a competition I still say that I believe that David did the best of the "Design Stars" throughout the competition and that he got more comfortable in the hosting part even as the competition progressed so I believe he will make an excellent host of his own show.

Posted by Rob – September 4, 2006 11:47 PM

The diverse designers, creative challenges, and elimination of a designer each week to produce a final winner has been instructive and entertaining. I have learned to expand my own thinking about spaces and credit your excellent program! I have especially enjoyed David because of his excellent conceptions, amazing execution and expert balance and color sense. Alice is wonderful and very gracious...however, her designs aren't as interesting to me. It's been a great experience and I wish them both the very best. I'm sure that they will both be wildly succesful regardless of the outcome next Sunday.

Posted by Sherry – September 4, 2006 11:45 PM

you made it hard to make an easy choice, I wanted to vote, but finding the voting spot was too time consuming. I loved every episode, but I thought you would make the voting much more simplistic. You didn't, so I had to keep hunting for the voting spot.

Posted by linda morgan – September 4, 2006 11:41 PM

Hearing the comments of the judges didn't effect the outcome of my choice, but I think it could have. If the voting was to be "America's" choice,I feel like we shouldn't have been given the judges opinions until AFTER the winner was picked. Loved following the competition! These
comments are just one person's observation.

Posted by B. Stuart – September 4, 2006 11:41 PM

I really enjoyed this show so much - I watch so much HGTV that I have redesigned almost every room in my house - next project will be the bathrooms - wish I could have a Design Star help me with that one. I must say that Design Star has been something great to watch and I had an awful time deciding who to vote for. But my vote is in and I hope HGTV will do another Design Star show in the future. Thanks so much.

Posted by Dee Lee – September 4, 2006 11:39 PM

Personally, I think they compliment each other and should have one show with both of them hosting it. It appears to me that they're getting to be alittle more then friends, so why not. I think like a couple they bring out the best in each other.
Wouldn't it be great it this ends in a tie?

Posted by Frann – September 4, 2006 11:34 PM

I loved the fact that both designers were given the same challenge and in a public way. Incorporating the outside along with your inner details was, I'm sure, a daunting task.
Alice did great with her polka-dot lighting and dots on the glass so the outside lighting would be brought into play in the room.
David's room was wonderful in incorporating the view from the bed but keeping the "Zen" feeling of uncluttered simplicity.
My pick is David nearly from the get-go in this designers show down!

Posted by Cathy – September 4, 2006 11:33 PM

I have found that David is consistently creative.His designs are clean,pleasing to the eye.Creative without becoming abstract.The designs pull you into the space easily.If I could afford a designer,he would have carte blanc at my home. Sincerly,and the best of luck to all who have participated in this adventure.Beverly Ann Weeks

Posted by Beverly Weeks – September 4, 2006 11:31 PM

My fiance and I watch HGTV often and we have enjoyed watching this first season of Design Star. We both think it would be great if it comes in as a TIE and Alice and David share a show! They have great chemistry and it would be a neat twist to all these Reality Shows to see a tie! But... since we HAVE to pick just one then based on tonights show only we think David is the winner. I love the Zen bedroom and that he does so much custom work in all his designs. Alice is a natural on TV and I doubt it's that last we'll see of her!

I also have a suggestion that has bothered me from the onset of all these "Reality" competition shows, why aren't they done as a cumulative point basis and the lowest score at the end of each episode is 'cancelled'. The judges seem to consider past challenges into their decisions so why not make it officially part of it, it's how the olympics and other competetions work. Yet some of the "Reality" competition shows it's obvious the producers make the decision, not the judges and that's just pathetic!

Keep up the good work, Clive! Love both of your shows!

Posted by Mitzi – September 4, 2006 11:23 PM

Are Alice and David an item? Do they date? They seem to really like each other. Anything more than that? How about a show with them as co anchors???
thanks
jackie
Delaware.

Posted by jackie koetz – September 4, 2006 11:22 PM

I love both designer's personality and passion for every task they take on. You can tell neither will have a problem in their chosen carreer. But man!, David is great. He is off the chart every time. I must say I think Alice is "cute as a bug in a rug" but even though I am southern, I find her voice irritating at times. I think it would be too much for an entire show.
We love you in Tennessee Clive, you are great to watch, anytime.

Posted by Terrie – September 4, 2006 11:20 PM

David is by far the more talented designer. His gift is natural and with refined results. Every single time his true artistic talents shine way above everyone else. He is also kind and gentle as well as very good looking. Go David!

Posted by margie maki – September 4, 2006 11:16 PM

I voted for David because I think he really thought about how the room would look inside and out. He really made the glass house work with his design. David always seems to have small touches to his designs that really add to the room and make it a complete package. The inside outside box was great and I loved the stone rug he had at the entrance to the glass house.

I think Alice lost the challenge the moment she decided to do a kid's room. She narrowed her audience down because not everyone has kids. I liked some of Alice's work but not everything in the room appealed to me.

Posted by Mary Cowin – September 4, 2006 11:13 PM

If only David and Alice could both win DesignStar. David has the raw design talent. Alice has design ability but also has a wonderful screen presence. Alice's openness, ability to work with others, and really listen makes her a refreshing candidate for having her own show.

If the new DesignStar's show is about designing a new space, David is my choice. If the new is show more of a hosting or Design to Sell show, Alice is my choice.

Showcasing scenes of Alice and David together in the final competition episode was brilliant. They appear to have a real rapport and great screen presence together. I hope HGTV has plans to pair from together in future.

Bringing back Tym and Temple worked well too. Alice and David needed the help and it give the audience some closure with Temple and Tym.

Bottom line, it is a tough voting decision to make - Alice or David - David or Alice. Just wish there could be two DesignStar winners instead of one.

Posted by Susie – September 4, 2006 11:12 PM

Hi Clive-met you earlier today actually, and just wanted to let you know I watched the show again tonight. They both are really great...the play on words and theme by Alice was a good choice for her, and I truly love the zen room David designed. This whole program concept was terrific, as I am not a usual fan of reality shows...it will come as a very big surprise to those who know me that I found this so entertaining.

Great show, and both final designers were so talented and likeable it made watching a sheer joy! Good luck to all!

Posted by Debbie D – September 4, 2006 11:10 PM

This final challenge was incredible! David's design and finished room blew me away with it's beauty and attention to detail. As a Japanese-American viewer,I wish I could have him re-do my entire house! The room was absolutely gorgeous and serene!
Alice's room was very whimisical and cute, but not very inovative. She is a fantastic hostess though! I could see both David and Alice hosting a design show together! They would make a fantastic team both in design and with their presence!

Posted by Sue – September 4, 2006 11:10 PM

I think there is such a great chemistry between David and Alice. Why choose one or the other. I say choose them both to host HGTV's newest show.

Posted by Sherri – September 4, 2006 11:08 PM

David has an incredible eye and sense of design. He definately won this competition in my opinion. I vote for David.

Posted by Kathy – September 4, 2006 11:07 PM

Clive!
This is too hard - I am voting for both.
I like the style of both but I especially like their attitudes toward one another and toward the other designers throughout the competition. Neither seems like a tempermental primadonna - the judges did a good job.
Design Star is a winner!!!
Linda

Posted by Linda Patterson – September 4, 2006 11:07 PM

I think David and Alice are equally talented, but
Alice seemed to be overwhelmed by so many options
available to her. That doesn't mean she wouldn't
do just as well under different circumstances.
Good luck to both!
Jan

Posted by Jan – September 4, 2006 11:02 PM

To start, I would like to say that I am so impressed with how Alice and David have conducted themselves. They seem to genuinely care about each other, and that has made this experience so much more enjoyable and so much less stressful for the viewers.

I have loved both Alice and David through the entire competition. They are the most talented of the original contenders. They both did a good job on their glass houses, but much as I was rooting for Alice, I did not care for the plain lettering above the beds in the room. A more whimsical font in lighter/brighter colors would have had more impact. I'm guessing that the strict time deadline restricted Alice from having many options. Having said that, though, as a woman I would be much more inclined to want Alice to design the spaces in my house. David does a GREAT job, but I think his future business will be restricted to those who like his modern designs, which might be more of a male audience(?). He's so good at what he does that he can most likely build up a great business wherever he lives and he'll most likely be busy all the time. The same goes for Alice. I hope HGTV does not let a good one get away with either of these two. They are both very likeable, talented and viewable.

Posted by Mary Jo – September 4, 2006 11:00 PM

This was such a tough decision. I finally decided on David because I think his design talent was better than Alice's, but she is also an excellent designer. I also think Alice was the better host, but I had to go with "whose rooms impressed me the most?" David's rooms were consistently amazing!

Posted by Linda Bond – September 4, 2006 10:55 PM

Thank you again for your comments and hosting skill. I liked this program especially well although I thought the challange was strange.
Bringing back Temple and Tym was both helpful and very nice for two talented people, especially Tym.

Like many others, I have noticed how well Alice and David compliment each other. While only can win this particular prize, it seems that somewhere in the future, they should have the opportunity to do somehting together. They look nice together and they play off each other very well.

Posted by deba dietz – September 4, 2006 10:51 PM

It is truly a shame that we have to make a choice between these two. They are both great designers and I really consider both of them winners anyday.

Posted by mike – September 4, 2006 10:48 PM

I really enjoyed this challenge. I believe that both David and Alice are outstanding and the two of them together have wonderful energy and design ideas. I would like to see them share a show together. It wouldn't be the first time that you have taken a team approach. They are very watchable, engaging and talented, why stick with one star?
Marsha

Posted by Marsha – September 4, 2006 10:46 PM

I think hgtv will be making a big mistake and america will be losing too, if both of these terrific talents don't get to continue on television. It's really been so great watching the design star show (is was not intending on getting so attached) and making a choice between Alice and David seems so unfair. If I vote for one I feel like I'm cheating on the other. Please, won't you make both of them stars???

Posted by sherrihill – September 4, 2006 10:43 PM

David's personality shows such confidence with his knowledge of design elements, color usage, his ability to think quickly on his feet to plan and organize and then to implement his plan into a wonderful finished "work of art" on a time deadline. He has a great deal of charisma on camera which reveals a genuineness to him that is pleasing. David also has a quick wit about him. He truly shows the ability to become a GREAT design name in the industry. His completed work has been very appealing to the (spelling?) ying and yang of calmness, quality of design knowledge, a naturalness toward design, and shows his knowledge of design while providing marvelous appeal with his design elements in each room he has completed. His work reminds me of the clean lines used by the famous architect, Frank Lloyd Wright. David's work certainly would be appropriate on

Alice, on the other hand, shows good decorating sense; however, I do not see any real "design talent implementation" in her rooms. She just is a good decorator with a tremendously great personality to fit into employment such as a great show host! Just do not think her decorating skills do not compare with David's talents and abilities used to complete their rooms. I do not think Alice has the natural talent to be the Design Star. David's work is more like that of Picasso. His talents shine!!!!

Posted by Joyce Johnston – September 4, 2006 10:37 PM

If there is a tie will you have them as a team show?

Posted by peggy – September 4, 2006 10:37 PM

Hi, Dave -

I'm so excited to see you sharing your talent and awesome smile with the world! I'm rooting for you and spreading the word! Congratulations on all of your successes!

Hugs,
Cari Johnson from Minnesota
Jeremy and Jessica's cousin)

Posted by Cari – September 4, 2006 10:36 PM

Allice is adorable, but David is Design. Good, consistent, interesting design. Another level above the rest. Can't wait to watch his show!

Posted by mmmurals – September 4, 2006 10:29 PM

Clive -- I voted for David, but would really like for both of them to be together on a show. Their personalities are both so upbeat. They remind me of the couple on Romm-by-room ... totally creative, totally pleasant. But I must say that I enjoyed the whole contest .... including the judges. Thanks

Posted by Barb Vickroy – September 4, 2006 10:29 PM

I loved both David & Alice on all their designs but have to vote for Alice. I think she has a natural talent. Thank you J. Ahhlgrim

Posted by Jeannette Ahlgrim – September 4, 2006 10:25 PM

I think the show is great but I think that design has nothing to do with sex appeal. Clearly the best designer is David and it is
sad that he had to take off his shirt to compete with Alice's cleavage shots.I think the designer
should win on the merits.

Posted by ccw – September 4, 2006 10:16 PM

I have enjoyed this show very much. It will be interesting who America choses. Both have design flair and personalities that are warm and caring which comes across to audiences. I'm always looking for ways to solve my own design dilemas and these kids seem to have endless ideas. Whoever is chosen will be a great addition to an already great programming channel! Clive Pearse was an excellent choice for the MC.

Posted by Ann Nortman – September 4, 2006 10:10 PM

WHY DID YOU HAVE TO BRING TEMPLE BACK? TO HAVE ANY HELP FOR THE DESIGNERS REGULAR CARPENTERS WOULD HAVE BEEN THE CALL.JUST THE SIGHT OF TEMPLE ACTING LIKE SHE IS SO GLAD TO BE ONE OF THE HELPERS JUST GAGS ME, SHE IS SUCH A PUT ON.

I THINK THE WRONG THING ALICE DID IS CHOSE THE WRONG TYPE OF ROOM.SHE HAS BEEN SO MUCH BETTER IN OTHER TYPES OF ROOMS IN EARLIER EPISODES.

AS MUCH AS I LIKE ALICE WHEN SHE TALKS TO THE CAMERA I REALLY THINK DAVID IS THE ONE TO BE CHOSEN. HE HAS GOOD IDEAS AND HE KNOWS HOW TO CARRY THROUGH WITH HIS IDEAS WITH A BANG FACTOR.HIS PRESENTATION WAS SO MUCH BETTER THIS TIME SO HE IS ABOUT TOGET THE WHOLE BALL OF WAX.

Posted by SANDRA – September 4, 2006 10:09 PM

I WOULD LOVE THE BOTH OF THEM DO A SHOW TOGETHER!!! GOOD THOUGHT? IT WOULD BE GREAT FOR YOUR RATINGS!!!!!!!!!! THANK YOU AGAIN, FOR A "JOB WELL DONE"

Posted by Claudia – September 4, 2006 10:04 PM

my vote is for David, i love his design style, i would love to see David win. Great job David. yours truely David Mills

Posted by david mills – September 4, 2006 10:03 PM

Go David. I love your design!

Posted by Marie – September 4, 2006 10:02 PM

We very much enjoyed the show and all of the episodes. We beleived you really challenged your "contestants". We are looking forward to seeing who is the winner and to their new show. Thanks.

Posted by J. Bowen – September 4, 2006 9:57 PM

This was the best show yet. Both had great designs. but, David was my pick. His design was over the top. He used the fact that the house was made of glass. He designed inside as well as outside.

Posted by Jacquie – September 4, 2006 9:54 PM

Like the show also like Design to Sell with Lisa.

Posted by sherry lafollette – September 4, 2006 9:48 PM

I think David and Alice look so good together that HGTV would be wise to keep them together as a design team!

Posted by Laura – September 4, 2006 9:46 PM

This is a great show... I have enjoyed it immensely! I would love for David and Alice to be on a show together. They have great chemistry! They both have sweet spirits with different things to offer the audience. David is the best designer while Alice the most natural on camera. Hopefully this will be a spring board for the second place win. Can't wait see the show next season!

Posted by Steph – September 4, 2006 9:43 PM

We were so impressed with Davids' work. He had very clean,interesting lines. Very soft appealing and soothing rooms. We wish him well

Posted by Marian Hauck – September 4, 2006 9:40 PM

David's room was aesthetically very pleasing. But what about function? Where would I put my clothes? Was there a dresser or closet that I missed? Alice's room was more functional. Both did a great job given the nebulous instructions -- (e.g. were they told to consider the view of the park???) and high pressure timelines. David seems to be a bit stronger in creating a room with the WOW factor. Great to look at. But who wants to walk on a carpet made of rabbit bedding -- or whatever looked so great on TV a few weeks ago? And Alice seems more practical and more polished in front of the camera. Seems a shame that one must lose, yes?

Posted by REB – September 4, 2006 9:39 PM

i feel like David showed the abilities to always come through, make snap judgements and carry his design to completion no matter what the challenge. his designs always looked complete. the ability not to have to spend so much time making decisions is a plus especially when in a time crunch. even when it came to deciding who to choose as helper he put his choice into perspective and made the best choice. i would definitely watch any shows he were to be on.

alice was good but she seemed to lack the ability to make good decisions and have her project seem complete.

i have enjoyed watching even the reruns of shows. it taught me a lot about what i do.

thank you for such a well thought out show. hope to see more in the future

Posted by Rebecca Pittman – September 4, 2006 9:37 PM

This episode underscored my impressions of these two designers all along.===Alice: she is adorable and very relaxed to watch. I like the style of her portfolio rooms as they are more feminine and deviate from contemporary (I'm not a big fan of contemporary). During the show though, her rooms were too mainstream and fell short of creativity. She missed the mark in several important areas like furniture placement and artwork. For instance, the TV was far too small for the man-cave lounge. The room was overfurnished with large scale pieces. Plus, all the furniture faced the wall, which did not take advantage of the lovely view outside. In this final challenge, I would have loved to have seen a fun, round bed, and more colorful artwork, a bold color or print on the bedspreads (instead of white - kids are dirty). The bee design could have been made out of colored window film from Home Depot instead of drawn on white canvas - and those words were boring in black block letters on a white background. I loved the lighting fixture and the curtains though. I would watch her show if it happened to be on but wouldn't make a point to tune in.====David: I love, love, love his creativity and imagination. His rooms are intriguing and masterful. His hosting skills have certainly improved and I believe will continue to do so. I would definitely watch his show just to see what new, imaginative things he came up with and would make a point to tune in for it. If he does win, I'd like to see him stretch himself beyond contemporary though as there are already several men designers doing contemporary on TV.=====Because of the creativity factor, my vote goes to David.

Posted by Keylagh – September 4, 2006 9:25 PM

I cannot believe anybody would put white bedspreads in a child's bedroom. Certainly nobody I know would ever consider it. Alice's room was just devoid of life...the children I know have far more life energy coming out of every pore of their body than her room showed. I am a huge believer in using adult furniture for children's rooms, but please use the right adult furniture. David's room had much more life and interest in it...a peaciful, restful life, but a reinvigorating force is just as important as any other sort. I loved his room.

Posted by Donna Hunt – September 4, 2006 9:25 PM

I have enjoyed the competition immensly.

What I truly wish would happen is David and Alice would both co-host the new design show. Together their talents would really rock.

Posted by Lana – September 4, 2006 9:21 PM

I truly believe that the two finalists are the best picks from the pack of ten. My applause to the judges!! I do have a bad time voting for just one fialist, but if I must I will do it. I think that the two together would be a great team for a design show together to bring their talents together to enhance each others work. It is obvious they like each other and could do a marvelous job together and complement their ideas and styles even though sometimes they are Mars and Venus. thanks for reading my comments.

Posted by nedra goodwin – September 4, 2006 9:19 PM

Both David and Alice seem like wonderful people and are very talented designers. I wish they could co-host a show because they would both add so much. While Alice has such a charming on-camera presence, I think David has an extraordinary design talent.I was very torn, but I voted for David.

Posted by joan allen – September 4, 2006 9:16 PM

I thoroughly enjoy your show. It is most exciting. All in my opinion are very talented individuals. Some do better under stress than others and are highly creative. I look foward to more exciting shows in the future.
Best of luck to the challengers.

Posted by Angela Garthright – September 4, 2006 9:15 PM

I absolutely loved the room David designed,,the room had a very calming and tranquil affect on the mind,,the colors were perfect! Almost forgot it was sitting in the center of Manhattan,,,,this is the kind of room I would love to be able to come home from a busy, hectic day to relax in. Great Job David!! You in my mind should be the one who gets to have their own show,,,also,, Thank you HGTV I love watching your shows.

Posted by Josie – September 4, 2006 9:15 PM

David's design is awesome. It is really hard to find a person with that capability. Highly innovative, creative, patience, great leader and motivator. He is the best in this field and am sure he will win.

Posted by Cesar Pogi – September 4, 2006 9:12 PM

I voted for David, I know many people have said to me that there are already so many men in this field that it would be nice for Alice to win, but I have liked David's work since the first challenge. I really hope he wins and has a wonderful career in the field of design. Many years of happiness to him. There are to many people who do not get to work at the job of their choice. I send him wishes and blessings for his future. AnneMarie

Posted by AnneMarie – September 4, 2006 9:11 PM

There is no doubt that, although Alice is a lovely woman and enjoys her work, David is the winner. Week after week, he shows a focused, sophisticated approach to designing a space that is right on target and yet "outside the box".
His use of the glass house to become part of the solution was inspired. Alice tried to deny the house, and although her room was "cute" it did not compare to David's. Good luck to them both!

Posted by Celia – September 4, 2006 9:10 PM

I think David and Alice both should win, and let the judges determine how it can be done. Both designers have consistently proven that the talents they possess are excellent, in their own, individual, way.

Posted by Glenda Hawkins – September 4, 2006 9:09 PM

I saw the show on Sunday night and found that althoiugh David is more confident about his designs up front..he is much more conceited. His explanation was all about.." I did that and I did this.." Alice was all about what the viewer could gain by the designs..not about herself. Also..his designs are very similar..very clean lines and minimalistic. Alice, I believe, can adjust to the people she is working with. Her style infuses color always. I think she has a more likeable presence on tv. I would tune in to see what would be new that week.

Posted by lovehomedecor – September 4, 2006 9:04 PM

I can't understand why the judges think Alice's presentations were so great. She's easy on the eyes and seems at ease in front of the camera but her voice is irritating and sounds a bit immature and lacks authority.

Posted by Robert Stein – September 4, 2006 9:04 PM

We think that David and Alice would make a good team like in Room by Room.

Posted by Suzanne Roberts – September 4, 2006 9:04 PM

My wife and I would like to thank you and your program producers for the presentation of "Design Star." We have always appreciated the abilities of others to be creative,unfortuanately through the years have lost those passions we once enjoyed. Your program revitilized and invigorated our artistic sub-conciousnesses to the beauty and inventiveness of the human spirit.
Kudos to all and once again we offer you our sincerest thank you.

Ted McCade

Posted by Ted McCade – September 4, 2006 8:58 PM

First, I am very pleased by the civility that the two finalists have shown toward each other. Clearly, both David and Alice have exquisite taste, but I think that David is the more inventive and original of the two; his aesthetic and his adaptability to his "clients" and his tasks/challenges are pretty remarkable. And he has developed a more easy relationship with the camera and the audience he can't see. These qualities I associate with Vern, too.

Posted by Jeanella Vennekotter – September 4, 2006 8:54 PM

I think David and Alice would be great on a show together. They could complement one another's strengths and weaknesses. And they seem to work well together!

Posted by Leann – September 4, 2006 8:53 PM

I love your show. All of the contestants were talented but David stands out in the crowd! Would love to see him with his own show.

Posted by Elise – September 4, 2006 8:48 PM

They both are great! Couldn't HG make them both Design Stars??? Alice and David working together? I can't really decide on who is more talented. I think David's designs are better but Alice has so much more of a presence and her charisma shines through. If HG is looking for a designer then David is the winner but if HG is looking for a host, then the answer is obvious- Alice.

Posted by Laura – September 4, 2006 8:47 PM

I'm so excited to see David and Alice as the last two designers standing. I think they are both so talented and creative! It is hard to choose which one should win, because I think they are both equally talented. I would rather see a show using both of them as a design team, because I think they would work really well together and they would complement each other as designers.

Posted by Deborah Olivieri – September 4, 2006 8:44 PM

David is clearly the winner!!! His designs, especially the basement and final episodes, were excellent and showed a cohesiveness that made you want to be in his spaces. Alice's designs seem to lack imagination. When designing the room for the Iraq soldier, she did nothing to change the room layout and take advantage of the view. The final episode did not demonstrate her stated theme of a looking glass type of room.
This series has been delightful to watch.
HGTV continues to remain our favorite channel.

Posted by Susan Meade – September 4, 2006 8:43 PM

If the producers were smart both of them would be together on their own show. They have alot of chemistry together and very different design styles- which could make for interesting TV.

Posted by Sheri – September 4, 2006 8:43 PM

I agree with the judges regarding David's designs. It's nice to see someone who uses the
contemporary feel in his designs. I'm from Florida too and I feel this state is extrememly
contemporary challenged. In Tampa their are only
"2" good contemporary stores and finding accessiories is a nightmare. Make me want to go
back to the West Coast. I do a lot of on-line ordering, but the shipping is a killer. No choice.

Posted by Bubey – September 4, 2006 8:42 PM

I think both David and Alice should both win and cohost a new show together. I mean not only are they both talented, they have such good chemistry together. One can't help but think " are they or are they not together?".

Posted by Maria Aggari – September 4, 2006 8:40 PM

I thought David's room was much better, but I think Alice is a better host. Tough Decision! Room or Host???

Posted by Leslie – September 4, 2006 8:38 PM

I have enjoyed these weekly shows so very much. I truly wish David & Alice could BOTH win and have a show together. Why not? They compliment each other's work. Alice loves color and a challenge, but at the same time did a wonderful job on the "Man Cave." David uses a more serene approach but he did a super job on the combined adult and children's basement family room. Together they could create dynamite rooms and a GREAT SHOW!
Thanks for listening. Linda Winkelman

Posted by Linda Winkelman – September 4, 2006 8:38 PM

David's design is wonderful- he is able to create not just display. While Alice is awesome in front of the camera David has a greater amount of talent!

Posted by Design Star Addict – September 4, 2006 8:37 PM

I have really enjoyed this show (in spite of Donna and Temple fighting). I think David has the most design talent and he should win but I would like to see Alice do something also on hgtv since she has such a talent for communication. Maybe they could work together since they really seem to get along.

Posted by Vicki – September 4, 2006 8:36 PM

David is constantly thinking and creating "outside the box". He is truly inventive and creative and has done some spectacular installations. Given time and coaching, his "on air" personality and smoothness will continue to develop and he will have a spectacular show. He has demonstrated the ability to work with others and supervise crews well.

David's design space, both last week and this final week, have been spectacular! I also loved his use of color when he had to design from the pet store. This guy is truly talented!

While Alice is really quite good, she does more traditional designs but barely deviates something from the norm. However, she is precious!

I think David will give Candace Olsen a run for her money as the best HGTV designer. While Candace does not seem to have a budget for her shows, David has demonstrated his ability to design within a budget affordable by most.

Posted by georgene – September 4, 2006 8:36 PM

After viewing a second time, I still think David can only continue to grow in his profession. This is one designer's opinion to another professional.

Posted by Suzanne – September 4, 2006 8:35 PM

Two designers, only one choice. Alice had a wonderful presentation, but the bees and dragon flies did not work on a white canvas. Maybe a mirror effect with those elements draw on would have been more effective. Something to see through. I did not like the look of the white bed spreads either. Other elements such as the lighting and colored dots were inspired. The polor bear rocker and pink chair along with the large orange alarm clock were wonderful. I liked the way she tied off the curtains too.
David gave a good presentaion too. I loved his choice of flooring and his attention to detail, which made his space look well designed. He did create an in-door out-door feeling to the room. I did not think I would vote for him, because of his dedication to cuteness and open shirts, but his talent has won me over. I guess when you got it, flaunt it.

Posted by bonnie – September 4, 2006 8:34 PM

I've thoroughly enjoyed this series! As someone who loves design myself, I watch each episode sketching what I would do with the space--and wishing for more information. Next time, could you post more details on the website--dimensioned floor plans and elevations, photos that include what's overhead--so we can design along with the contestants? For that matter, how about an online "design this room" contest, with scanned and uploaded proposals? Oh I know, you'd be inundated--but we'd have a great time!

It's been fun watching the contestants grow personally as the series progressed. I'm glad to see the final four, especially, taking on more of the graciousness and generosity toward others that Alice has shown from the beginning. Imagine our world if we were all more like that? Thanks, Alice.

Posted by Sue – September 4, 2006 8:33 PM

well, it seems to me that David is the clear winner. To borrow a term of Vern's, he "rocked" it. I was impressed. I liked Alice's idea, but the idea was better than the execution. All in all though, what has been heart warming to me is their kindness, and the warm feeling they share for eachother. Never caddy, never mean spirited, always wishing the other well. They both seem like decent human beings and that's just lovely. Either one of them will continue to do well in their lives, I'm sure. I've really enjoyed this show...I can't believe how nervous I got for both of them! Best, Ron

Posted by Ron – September 4, 2006 8:27 PM

This is such a hard decision. David is the best designer but Alice has such a great personality and is better in front of the camera and easy to watch. I only wished I knew what kind of show we were voting them to host. Since the decision is so close this might have made a differnce in voting.

Great show - Ilove it!!

Posted by Janet – September 4, 2006 8:26 PM

dear Clive,
I would like to see the next set of designers win a nice dream vacation as well. i would also like you to tell us for each challenge how much money the designers have to spend. that way we have a better idea if they spent their money wisely.
ps. go back and do the design to sell shows the other guy is not funny as you.
t

Posted by gillian – September 4, 2006 8:25 PM

David's design is soooo exciting! I love his sensibilities and vison! I want him to have the opportuinity to show the world his concepts of LIVING ART! He is the future! Not only is his personality adorable, his presence is strong and bold. In 10 years, I see a powerhouse beyond anything we know now! David is CLEARLY "THE" design star! If only I could get him to come to Atlanta!!!!!

Posted by Mary Wells – September 4, 2006 8:23 PM

What a great way to spend a lazy holiday! Today, I watched most of the episodes back to back. I don't know if I could have stood the anticipation between shows if I had seen them once per week.

Great concept, judges, host and designers. Your choice of mixing it up with seasoned designers, artists and design enthusiasts with no training was very savvy. Very fun show, very captivating.

I hope you continue with this concept. Looking forward to seeing David on his own show. Maybe Alice can co-host occassionally?

Cheers,
Katrina

Posted by Katrina – September 4, 2006 8:23 PM

This show was extremely enjoyable and entertaining. It was unique to see everyone's creativity displayed in such different ways.
I will be voting for David - his work has been original and striking in so many ways. He is truely an artist. His natural instincts certainly shine and his genuine approach and attitude make him a joy to watch.
HGTV - Thank you for more of your great programming!

Posted by Carol Hopkey – September 4, 2006 8:22 PM

It's so very hard to pick. They are both brilliant designers. I have watched since the very beginning and I knew Alice would end up in the final, but it was a toss up between Tym and David (both great). Well, David is in and I'm glad. Their designs in their little glass houses were amazing. David I thought was very strong with his creation. The room looked amazing considering he didn't have much time to put it together. Alice's concept was really adorable, with the Alice in Wonderland concept of the looking glass. Although, I was just a little bit disappointed in the outcome. But I have to say that the light fixture was awesome, and she mirrored the colored stickers on the windows to the colored globes on the fixture.
Well, good luck to you both and I know who ever wins or loses, you both have a great future ahead of you both.

Posted by Annette – September 4, 2006 8:20 PM

I just wanted to say that this is my favorite show on hgtv!!! I truly believe that David and Alice were definitely the two designers who deserved to make to this point. David is so funny, and so talented. Some of his designs actually made me speechless. He's very creative. Alice seems like one of those people who are truly beatiful on the inside and out. She seems like a wonderful person to work with, and very easy to watch on television. I noticed such a change with her throughout the show. In the beginning I think she stayed pretty quiet, and didin't really show us what she could do until later. However, once she showed everyone what she was capable of, she blossomed. In the end, I voted for David because there were so many rooms that I was just absolutley speechless...they were great! He seemed consistent with great designs throughout the challenge. I can't wait to watch the next season. By the way, I also love Clive!!!!!

Posted by Nioaka – September 4, 2006 8:20 PM

My sister and I are huge fans of HGTV, as well as DIY. We are freelance designers and artists; we live together here in Las Vegas and have been watching the show since the premier. We both agree that the two of them are incredibly talented, so ultimately we had to split up the voting process because we love them both equally. We would love to see David and Alice working together on the same show and we would watch it religiously. they have totally different design styles and work very well together. We believe it would be a hit!
Thanks for listening Julie and Janna

Posted by Julie – September 4, 2006 8:20 PM

I have really enjoyed this show. Please ask Alice to stand up straight and pull her shoulders back! She is a beautiful woman be proud and show it in the way you present your body.

I hope that I do not sound like your mother! Good luck to both!!

Posted by ann – September 4, 2006 8:19 PM

It is a shame that there had to be an elimination at 3. Tym is great, Great, GREAT and so real. All 3 are so good. After Temple's elimination I wanted to sing "Ding Dong the witch is dead! She was on there far too long!!
Perhaps, whoever wins could invite the other 2 of the final 3 as a "Guest Designer" The final 3 are terrific as a team. I still vote for David if I have to choose one.

Posted by Roberta Peterson – September 4, 2006 8:19 PM

I have enjoyed this show so much and I would love to see David and Alice win this show together but if that can't happen I do hope to see some of the designers on the show that is being created for the winner.

I love HGTV, keep up the great programing.

Thanks.
Carol

Posted by Carol – September 4, 2006 8:18 PM

Dear Clive;

I felt the judges were fair but a little too hard on Alice in the end which seemed to understandbly shake her up. I have voted for David and the reason... he is a true artist and I look forward to watching his talent unfold. Each week, his original art work has been amazing.

The only thing missing that would really please many voters... to be able to see Alice co~ host with him.She is adorable.

Excellent show!

Thank you for reading my comments,
Debera

Posted by Debera Bashaw – September 4, 2006 8:16 PM

Alice is great, but David is fantastic! So innovative w/just the right touch of drama, all pulled together into very comfortable, livable rooms. So nice to see a real personality, not the polished perfect host/hosteess.

Have the greatest respect/admiration for all of the designers - great show! Thanks. Ginna Jordan, ASID

Posted by Ginna Jordan, ASID – September 4, 2006 8:15 PM

Alice did a design that looked like a great room designed by an amature. David's room was awsome and looked like the very best that the creative mind of a professional designer could produce. I like Alice on camera but she seems a little child-like and didn't grow over the weeks of the show. David has gotten stronger with each presentation and has turned into a pro with heart, spirit and a commanding presence.

Posted by marsha – September 4, 2006 8:15 PM

I think HGTV should partner David and Alice on a show. They compliment each other very much. I absolutely adore David's designs - he is definitely a much more talented designer with a unique style and passion for his work. Alice is more run of the mill (Frankly, I could do better and have, being a set and theatre director)but she is an absolute doll and terrific on camera. If HGTV truly wants the combination of great designer and TV presence, have the David and Alice show! It's only fair!!

Posted by Judy – September 4, 2006 8:14 PM

How disturbing! I thought the viewers would vote for the winner of your challenge...instead it was quite shocking how biased this show turned out to be!! Who needed those 3 judges back? They should have kept there mouths shut and not "swayed" the audience by praising everything David did! We as viewers are not stupid...we can see what was going on.

Posted by june – September 4, 2006 8:14 PM

I love both of them. I can't decide which I like the best. They make a cute couple. Please give them a show together. One is not better then the other. They each have their best qualities.

Posted by Carolyn Speeckaert – September 4, 2006 8:14 PM

Enjoyed the Design Star show. Each episode helped to clearly determine the final two, and David and Alice are both winners. Would like to see a show with both of them, as they have such different styles.

Posted by Kathy Brown – September 4, 2006 8:13 PM

Once again, David has dominated in the design competition. I think Alice's design was just average whereas David's design made me wish I could afford to have him do some work in my home. This young man has impressed me throughout the entire show!

Posted by barb haynes – September 4, 2006 8:13 PM

my only comment is that i know that you have to have time limits, but if i were to have someone come ina and take charge of my place, i would not want it done in a 24 hour period, give them a few days to think and make the right choice for all those concerned. i thought this show would be like the others, but i quite enjoyed myself watching, and anticipating to see who would shine the brightess,. love alice and david both, they are both truly talented in their rights and was extremley happy to see them both in the final 2!!!!!!!! congrats and good luck. p.s. clive you to were a wonderful host to watch an listen to....

susan

Posted by SUSAN HOUSEHOLDER – September 4, 2006 8:13 PM

David's work is amazing. He was by far the most sophisticated designer in the group. He took every challenge to another level by being an inventor and a creator;not a follower of design. His presence on camera is strong and likable -- I think he's truly fits the bill to be your design star!

Posted by Carl – September 4, 2006 8:13 PM

Alice is a decorator, David is a designer. David should win.

Posted by Jacquie – September 4, 2006 8:13 PM

I love David! He doesn't just decorate a room. He designs a room taking into consideration his clients wishes and expanding upon them. The basement was wonderful. I could see the parents playing there with their kids.
David truly has an "artists eye"! He designs a room from every aspect of the room as well as its relationship to the adjoining "rooms"; as in this case, Bryant Park.
Love you too Clive.

Posted by Madeline Fair – September 4, 2006 8:11 PM

I just loved the show and all the designers. However, David really has a sense of bringing you into a tranquil, relaxing space that I love. Good Luck David and Alice!

Posted by Lynn – September 4, 2006 8:11 PM

I would use both--it was funny watching them together!

Posted by Julia – September 4, 2006 8:09 PM

I thoroughly enjoyed this season. I just love Alice's personality and she is just so natural on screen. I would love to watch her in her own show. But David's design talent won me over completely. He is extremely talented and his designs were clearly head and shoulders over all his competition right from the start.

Posted by molly malone – September 4, 2006 8:08 PM

This was a great show/series. At first I wasn't going to watch it but I got hooked after watching just the last 10 minutes of the first episodes. I liked the fact that the two best personalities/designers are competing. Both of them deserved to be the final 2. Can't wait to see the results.

Posted by rose – September 4, 2006 8:07 PM

I enjoyed the show very much and have voted for 2 consecutive days. The only comment I have about the show, which irritated me every time, is that the lipstick on Vern Yip and David is so obviously pink and shony. I know that they need to wear make-up for tv but theirs was just too much.

Posted by Gina Zagors – September 4, 2006 8:07 PM

There was absolutely no design competition between David and Alice. David's design was cohesive and well planned and executed. Alice's design looked like there wasn't a plan. If Alice's final design was the only one I ever saw, I would wonder why she was one of the final two!!! David wins...hands down.

Posted by Joan – September 4, 2006 8:05 PM

The two complement each other and would be a great TEAM.

Posted by Ray – September 4, 2006 8:05 PM

Both designers are inventive and original, I love both works. I voted for David simpy because the last challenge he nailed and came across well on television. I think they both should have a show. Alice is so people friendly and talented, David has talent. wow. thanks for the show, mimi

Posted by mimi – September 4, 2006 8:03 PM

Absolutely Marvelous!! The show is great. I do not typically vote for people on t.v. but couldn't resist this one! Thanks for an AWESOME show! I'm anxiously awaiting the results!! Good luck to both finalists... they truly deserve it!!

Valerie

Posted by Valerie – September 4, 2006 8:03 PM

I thought this was the most fascinating show on HGTV
all season. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I hope that you are going to do it again.

Posted by Marie O'Brien – September 4, 2006 8:02 PM

David has the natural design talent and Alice has great camera presence. They would make a fantastic duo, together as co-hosts of a new show.

Posted by lori – September 4, 2006 8:02 PM

I don't think the judges should've been aloud to "judge" the final challenge on camera. They should've only been aloud to say what they liked about the space. The reason being is some viewers will still listen to what the judges had to say instead of just going by the final product. It wasn't up to the judges anymore to decide who won so I don't feel it was right to have their opinions on camera for the final challenge.

Posted by Lorie – September 4, 2006 8:02 PM

David you are an awsome designer

Posted by Pat Carhart – September 4, 2006 8:01 PM

I certainly have enjoyed this series. David and Alice are both extremely passionate about their work and very capable. Either of them will make a great HGTV Design Star!

Posted by Terry Tate – September 4, 2006 8:00 PM

First of all....I love the show! My big area of contension is the judges voting Tym off! Tym is driven, great on camera, a fantastic decorator, good communicator and secure with who he is.
Im in shock the judges voted him off!!

Posted by Traci – September 4, 2006 7:59 PM

I like Alice a lot and although her room did not have the sophistication of david's I think regular America wold relate to her room. She has a "stage presence" and comfortable on the camera. That is a large consideration in hosting their own show. David shold have dressed better for his time on tv showing his room.

Posted by Susan Lynch – September 4, 2006 7:58 PM

I liked both contestants, but I think Davids was the most intriguing design of them. It was just what I sould want if I could live in a dream world.

Posted by Phyllis Tatman – September 4, 2006 7:57 PM

I'm voting for Alice. I love her work.

Posted by Diana Beard – September 4, 2006 7:57 PM

Both rooms were good, but David's was the best. It was totally relaxing and everything was pulled together. I disagree about the judge's suggestion that he add a "shot of color"; it would have disrupted the serene feeling of the room. (besides, it looked like there was brown trim on the pillows, and brown is a color!) Alice's room looked mis-matched and unfinished, but I loved the pieces that she chose. The light fixture was cool, and so was the storage. They just didn't go with the artwork or the headboards.

Posted by Cathy A – September 4, 2006 7:56 PM

I have watched the final reveals on this episode THREE times and I still can't decide! And for once I agree with all the judges. Helphelphelphelp!

Posted by MC – September 4, 2006 7:56 PM

I agree with many of your viewers that a show co-hosted by Alice and David would be great.

Posted by Mary – September 4, 2006 7:54 PM

I consider myself to be a very competitive person and I believe that one shouldn't even attempt to play the game unless one truly does feel that he/she has a greater chance than all others to WIN. And in this case, both, David and Alice have proven to have an equal amount of confidence, individual design ability and certainly enough charm for both of them to have their very own show. C'mon HGTV, why not be fair by getting rid of some of those 'Design on a Dime' shows and give them both their own designer show? Seriously, .. Sandy

Posted by Sandy – September 4, 2006 7:52 PM

I really thought Alice's work looked less than that of a pro! The headboard's messages looked so cheap, the bedspreads lacked TOTALLY of interest for a child's room! I was really disappointed! I'm not impressed with her presentations, either!
On the other hand--David's room looked absolutely pulled together! David has shown to be pretty level-headed, knowing his direction--and solidly following thru with the plans.
Both have alot of ego--but I feel that David's is not as irritating as Alice's!
Thanks--for a very unique program! I've enjoyed following each one--and watching some repeated on our tv programming.

Posted by Nancy Bartlett – September 4, 2006 7:52 PM

Great show! David rocked it! Hands down the winner, especially since he kicked the on camera bit up a notch! Can't wait to see the finale and the upcoming show!

Posted by Jean-o – September 4, 2006 7:44 PM

I think that Alice could host a GREAT program showcasing designers from around the cournty/world. We have enough of similar shows where one host and team redo a room. Let's try highlighting many ideas from all over the country. Alice will make a delightful host.

Posted by Crae – September 4, 2006 7:43 PM

loved the new show. David has such wonderful ideas. i also really enjoy design to sell, it's given me a lot of helpful hints i will need when i put my house on the market next year.

Posted by sharon beck – September 4, 2006 7:41 PM

These too are so talented and have such chemistry together, why no have them co-host a show?

Posted by Jeanne – September 4, 2006 7:40 PM

David definitely won this one, but I find myself still wanting to vote for Alice, I can't figure out why. I still think it would have been nice to give them a project with more time to develop their ideas, just because someone can't throw something together in 3 days doesn't mean they aren't creative and talented. Some of the judges criticsms are unfair, too because they complain that certain pieces lack originality, with the time constraints, they can't really produce custom pieces.

Posted by Mary – September 4, 2006 7:39 PM

David's design was beautifully done and his style was simple but quite effective use of the cube space.The Asian influence with the tent/canopy gave a sanctuary feel to the room which is what a bedroom does at days end. Chairs for reading, candles for mood, and style to set the mood for a secluded evening to unwind.

I have enjoyed Alice during this series, however she missed the mark for a children's room. Many choices could have been made to make it a haven for little minds and bodies to have fun and grow in their own "Space". Lack of bursting color, kid friendly fabric, few play items, no electronic toys, and void of theme made the space "blaugh"."Alice in Wonderland" could have made a fairy tale or "Land of Adventure" to excite kids through teens. Alice is wonderful with color and design normally but this time she missed the mark totally.

Posted by mary – September 4, 2006 7:38 PM

I am sure that David will win...not only are his designs incredible, he seems very honest and likable. I think the job he did on the glass house was awesome...when he said that he drew his inspiration from the house itself, I thought - WOW that is impressive...that is a designer! Alice is sweet as well, but almost too sickningly sweet. They would both be good hosts, but I think David has staying power!

Posted by Robin – September 4, 2006 7:37 PM

I feel both designers are very talented and have worked very hard to get where they are. David is the better designer. I love his space that he designed it is very peaceful amd I wish that it was my bedroom. I wish Alice the best.

Posted by Polly – September 4, 2006 7:37 PM

I love blogs about reality shows but I want more gossip, details who was fighting with whom. Clive you are just too darn polite. Still I love David's work and hope he wins, It is really nice to see a designer skilled enough to work with his hands and well as his mind. Still, did the producers tell him to keep taking his shirt off??? not that I don't mind a little eye candy but still I thought it was a tad out of character.

Posted by Maria – September 4, 2006 7:35 PM

Love the shows, the judges were superb, fair everytime, the host, as usual, favulous, the designers, incredible and David just magnificent! Have no ways to express how much I've enjoyed, suffered, cried and laugh with every show. I've watched them over and over with the same joy!
Love you all!
ThankS!!!!!!!

Posted by Iris Archer – September 4, 2006 7:34 PM

This is going to be a hard decision. Personally, I think David's design is better, but Alice's personality is better suited for television. Is there a way to do "Design Duo"?

Posted by Maureen – September 4, 2006 7:34 PM

Hello Clive

I think both of the final contestants are great! Although David is my favorite, please relay the message to the "powers that be" at hgtv that we would love to see David and Alice hosting the new show (with Tym stopping by sometimes to help out). They are so talented, down-to-earth, and have such good chemistry which results in people who are simply enjoyable to watch.

Thanks for an awesome show - have a nice day!!!

Posted by terri – September 4, 2006 7:33 PM

I was very disappointed with the judges for last evenings show. They were so obviously pulling for David. You must know that David has only one style and I have seen it several times already. This was a repeat of many things he has done before. Alice has done several styles, including creating a "smoking room" for a male. I don't think she is appreciated for her outstanding abilities. Everyone seems to be concentrating on David's "artistic" abilities. That is fine, however, if I remember correctly, this show was titled "Design Star", not "Artist Star." I hope others feel the same and give Alice the credit she deserves. I like both of them, however, when it comes down to the wire, I want to see many different designs, not just contemporary repeated in different ways. You need to remember that your fans are not all lovers of contemporary. The judges really critized Alice last night and were overly harsh. Shame on them. This was supposed to be America's choice, not theirs and they slanted it so much, if anyone is gullible, they will now vote for David rather than Alice......The editing of the show/episode does deeply concern me as a great and loyal fan of HGTV. Let's give America ALL design styles, not just comtemporary reinvented. You already have many, many shows with contempoary design. Let's find something different to view......

Posted by Jan Keener – September 4, 2006 7:30 PM

David is so talented. I absolutely will vote for him. I think their works are still shown in
Bryant Park... I gonna go to have a look ^_^

Posted by Cissy – September 4, 2006 7:29 PM

The two finalists were my favorites. I was convinced that I would vote for Alice because she has such a presence and is so likeable. After the design in Bryant Park, David just blew me away with his design. I think they would be a good designer twosome together.

Posted by Marcia – September 4, 2006 7:29 PM

Hi!
Just thought you might like another opinion. David and Alice work so well together. You should put them on a show together!
By the way, I don't normally watch any "series", but you all hooked me on this one! Great idea!
Thanks for those enjoyable episodes.
Georgia Baird
Waco, TX

Posted by Georgia Baird – September 4, 2006 7:28 PM

I am so disappointed!! I have been rooting for Alice from the 1st episode, but this seemed more like one of Tym's rooms - not quite finished. The idea was great, but it just didn't gel. The artwork would have had more impact if she did it directly on the glass with glass paint.

On the other hand - David's design just floored me. I am not into minimalism, but I would love to have my bedroom look like that.

I cant decide who to vote for....I love Alice, but David's design was clearly better. Maybe I'll vote for both!

Posted by KC – September 4, 2006 7:26 PM

It would be great to have a tie!
Alice and David are both awesome, but what one
Designer lacks the other one makes up for.
As a team .... they would rock it, as Vern would say.
I can't decide because I like both of their designs and I find each one lacks some detail that the other one is very talented at.
David isn't as relaxed on camera as Alice, but Alice isn't as dramatic as David.
Just call it Design Star(s) and give it to both of them.

Posted by Anjeanique – September 4, 2006 7:25 PM

Well I couldn't vote last night after the episode because the site was over whelmed so I voted today. I have my definite favorite, but I get the strong impression that person will not win. I really feel that the judges unfairly influenced the audience towards one than the other.

David is a great artist and is not afraid to put his style out there. But, for the most part they are not designs that make me feel like I could live in that space for a long time. On my limited budget I would not be able to change a style that often. I also feel like there is already a show that does the same as his would do.

Alice does rooms that are comfortable and livable for families. They are usually in a style that would last a long time and not become outdated in the next 2 to 3 years. Let's face it the majority of people can not plunk down big design dollors every 4-5 years. Most of us need something that will last and transition with us for the next 8-10 years. I would love to have Alice come do rooms for me. I really feel like she gives a home owner what they are looking for.

I would watch a show with either of these two as host, but I definetely would gravitate towards Alice. Wish they could both have a show. Hers geared more towards families on tight budgets!!!!!

Posted by Leanne – September 4, 2006 7:23 PM

Clive, You are cool and I watch you on Design to Sell. You have got to think about putting David and Alice together on a show. David is truely a marvelous designer, I love his stuff; Alice is so comfortable in front of the camera but most of all THEY HAVE CHEMISTRY!!!

Posted by Connie – September 4, 2006 7:18 PM

Good show (again). I think David had the edge, and nailed the presentation. I thought Alice did very well throughout the whole competition and was just a little short of David's final effort. Hands down, I think David is more popular among the viewers, and although I would've liked to have seen a little more masculinity with his personality (not so much the physical body) but acting, talking like a man I think he would've put more distance between himself, and the competition. But then again, as a male designer I guess this is about as masculine as one could ask for.

Alice is cute, and I like looking at her, but I think I would get tired of watching her after the bloom were a little off the rose for me.

Go David!!

Posted by Edward – September 4, 2006 7:15 PM

One more little comment, Alice's drawl is a natural part of her. Having one myself, doesn't bother me a bit. Lots of y'all need to realize a good portion of the country speaks with one "dem der drawls". Trust me, hers isn't that bad. Some places you go you can't understand what the population is saying unless you "speak the language yourself". Reminds me of an episode of an older sitcom where the female lead takes a friend down home with her. They stop at a restaurant and the friend can't understand the waitress when she talks. Then he orders "a grit". ROFLMAO Don't hear y'all complaining about Clive's accent. Of course his is very "Americanized" and I'm sure if he did "speak the Queen's English" y'all would be complaining too.

Posted by Reese – September 4, 2006 7:15 PM

Why Not have David and Alice be the stars of one show. Co-Hosts I guess. Since they are both so talented and they said they have become great friends and created such a bond. It only makes sense!!!

Posted by Mark Dodd – September 4, 2006 7:11 PM

Hello Clive,
Well? Who shall be the next(make that the FIRST) design star?
David....no Alice......And what about Tym? He looked so nice coming back, he has such a great TV presence. And he walked right in and built David's design. These two work so well together.
I think David's room was the definite winner. I liked Alice's room but it did not come together like David's.
Again, the two of them looked great together! In the hotel suite giving each other 'courage'they seemed so sincere. And on onscreen these two just 'pop' together.
If I can ever get my computer to let me vote...I'll be voting for David. But it is really too close to call.
Rena Hamrick

Posted by Rena Hamricck – September 4, 2006 7:10 PM

David is a design genius. His "glassed" bedroom was brilliant. Cannot get into the voting page; hope others can and vote unanimously for David!!

Posted by Dean Bergman – September 4, 2006 7:09 PM

I have so enjoyed watching this series. I have gotten so many ideas along the way and seen how people can work together and do wonderful things or be discordant and not get things done. I'm not good at all at design but I just love to study it. I'm taking another course this fall. After one teaches all day, one has to do something for one's self and this show has really given me a lot of pleasure. I thought from the very beginning that David was the strongest of all of them and Alice grew each week as the challenges got more difficult. She is so good "on her feet" in front of the camera. There is a place for her on HGTV, that's for sure. But I've got to go with David, he has such talent. I've been surprised by some of the items he has used (remember the rug that wasn't a rug) but it worked. It was so cool!!! I would watch him, like I watch Candice, Ken and you Clive: every time I get the chance!!! Who needs to sleep anyway?

Posted by Barbara Black – September 4, 2006 7:08 PM

I think that David was right in not putting bold colors in his room. A bedroom is supposed to help relax you. A bold color might be appealing to the eye however it is not as comforting as the nuetrals that David used.
Alice's room needed the bright colors due to the fact it is a childs room. The colorful discs radiating cheeerful colors throughout is what is needed for children to help them enjoy their environment.
I would like to know how much each designer spent on their individual projects. When I need to have someone come in to help me, I am always interested in what the cost is to have the profeesional's help.

Posted by Ralph – September 4, 2006 7:06 PM

Wow, what an exciting night. Hate to say it but think David designed the best room this round. Alice's design was great on paper but lacked the pizazz and livability of her previous efforts. Really believe the comments by the judges threw Alice off her stride resulting in a room which had bright spots (the lighting, the cubbies, rocking horse etc.) but lacked luster. Painting on the headboards would have been so much better than tacking paper to them. Perchance Alice will read the comments eventually, therefore I say, "Believe in Yourself".

David, great job! Only thing potentially missing was the one splash of bright color which was suggested. Don't think so much on the bed but one iris blossom or stalk of bright red flowers in a vase would have added just a touch of color which all seemed to be looking for.

Have seen many comments here denigrating the D2S Chicago team. Folks, let's remember they have a hard act to follow. Clive, Lisa and the guys do great work and have developed their personalities on air. Noticing more and more the Chicago folks are getting more comfortable. Do agree the Chicago real estate expert could learn to turn her negative remarks into a bit of humor via Donna Freeman's manner. Sorry Shannon Freeman but your mom? just has a way with her. All in all great job by everyone!

Posted by Reese – September 4, 2006 7:05 PM

This has been a great show and I have loved every minute of it! Like others I would love a show with the last three, even just David and Alice working together. But the name of the game is "Star", so I must choose.
I am having a really hard time doing just that; choosing. I love David's designs and his combination of design and art skills. The glass room was just perfect from every angle. That was what really got me..you could look from outside, sinside, up down and every time you saw how perfect it was.
Alice is great on TV. I love the way she describes her work, sometimes even better than the work itself. I think she listens to her client and I find that refreshing. Her designs are nice but not WOW!
Who to choose? I must make up my mind...

Posted by J.M. Combest – September 4, 2006 7:05 PM

I would love to see Alice and David co-host a show, but barring that I would like to see Alice win. She's so COLORFUL, and very at ease with the camera.

Posted by Rebekah – September 4, 2006 7:03 PM

Terrific Program! My wife and I were thoroughly entrenched as each episode was well done. Shows up well against ordinary series shows. Bravo!!!

Posted by George Humes – September 4, 2006 7:00 PM

This will be a close one. My preference is David because his design offers more than the usual paint, fix-up and buy new furniture. He actually constructs a custom furniture that brings out the "wow" factor in his work that is truly a one-of-a-kind design that no one else will have. I love his designs and wish it was my house that he was making over. I hope he wins. I like Alice's designs too, but they don't offer the same pleasant supprise.

Posted by Ms. D – September 4, 2006 6:59 PM

I played the video of episode 7 and David was in the frame 90 percent of the time 2 percent showing a crown with someone holding a sign "vote for David" and no Alice except with the group of ten tv screens. This seem grossly unfair. I was going to vote for David but felt Alice was shafted so voted for her. She has an excellent presents and does not do the same look every time. David would have to change or give us some surprises for a weekly tv show Want to see another Design Star show.

Posted by Gloria – September 4, 2006 6:59 PM

I think David and Alice have equal talent, and I really like both of them, and the way they like each other. Why not a show with two hosts? I think they'd be fabulous together!

Posted by Rebecca – September 4, 2006 6:58 PM

Such a great series and two really great people as finalists.

Posted by Jean – September 4, 2006 6:55 PM

I have thoroughly enjoyed your whole process of Design Star. Meeting all ten of your contestants was a lot of fun. You all did a great job. Keep up the good work.

Posted by Judy – September 4, 2006 6:46 PM

I also noticed how Alice can be unsure of herself but always seems to pull it together. I agree that David's hosting skills are improving. I'm surely voting! I do, however, miss Temple.

Posted by Chelle – September 4, 2006 6:39 PM

I enjoyed watching Design Star and think it was a great idea to have the judges choosing who went home each week until the final two, then letting the viewers choose.

Posted by Denise – September 4, 2006 6:39 PM

I voted for David for this challenged. I think he did a superb job compare to Alice's room. I think Alice did a good job too, but it doesn't stand out like David's room did.

Overall, I felt that David had better plan and control throughout this challenge. On the first working day, David used his Tym wisely on the first day by letting him work on his plan while he's out shopping vs. Alice took Temple along on the shopping trip while she could be carrying out some of her ideas by building or working on stuff (which in my opinion wasted a lot of time). Then when the judges came to see their room, Alice panic on the feedback provided by them vs. David continued with his plan (which should have included the suggestions provided).

I felt that Alice's design is a very cute but not striking. She could have used the space a lot better. I really liked her room, but ABSOLUTELY LOVED David's. The thing I like about David's design is that he's put a lot of thoughts into it, and a lot of original ideas. You get a fantastic view from every point.

Before seeing David on camera in this episode, I was a little concern about him being infront of the camera because in the past few episodes, I think he wasn't as impressive on camera as Alice, but he really surprised me this week. I thought that he was a lot more relaxed, and came acrossed charming vs. a little nervous like previous weeks. I've always felt that Alice was better infront of the camera and David was a better designer in the past, but this week, David was equally as good as Alice on camera.

Way to go, David!!!

Posted by Angela – September 4, 2006 6:36 PM

I've already commented, but wanted to say one other thing.

What's the deal with having the judges critique the projects while they were still in the middle of them?

We were supposed to see David and Alice's own ability, so why would they want to "coach" them?

Also, how discouraging for Alice to hear such criticism in the midst of trying to get everything done!

It was a bad bad idea and it seemed unneccesarily cruel the way they ambushed and bombarded her. And did you see the way they all looked at each other when she explained her plan? They reeked disapproval.

Bad judges. Bad judges. Now go sit in the corner and take a time out.