Be the first to comment! Enter your comment in the form below.

I keep thinking I have seen Kim before .. was she on another show ? can anyone clue me in ?

Posted by MaryAnne – September 17, 2007 1:05 PM

The LAST CHALLENGE allowed Kim's brilliant design sense to shine with finesse, sophistication and timeless style. But, can you imagine the completed suite if that hideous carpet had not been removed? Kim faltered, at first... until she heard Will's soothing, assured voice telling her the carpet had to go and he knew exactly how to finish the floor. The final two should be Kim and Will. They make a talented team. In a perfect world, there whould be a tie; and HGTV would create a show for them. They are dynamic individuals who would make a fantastic design duo! Todd would be hired by Disney as Head Imagineer and Sparkle J would redesign the Las Vegas strip to be as glaringly dazzling during the day as it is at night. Oh, and Design on a Dime would be banished forever.

Posted by TriciaKIM – September 11, 2007 12:57 PM

I breathed a sign of relief when Robb was eliminated, unlike when most of the others were. They at least were gracious and mentioned what a great opportunity they had had. Robb was beyond abrasive, from the beginning - and any issues were always someone else's fault. At the end of 5 when Kim mentioned he was a challenge to work with his comment showed he had no idea of the difference of leading a team and being a partner. The guy had no clue. They made a mistake - no doubt about it, the only mistake they made was to keep him as long as they did. I wish they had more chances to shine individually, but I thought episode 5 for Wayne Newton was interesting. I loved that he noted that the kitchen was a much harder project - this was not an equal design project. Still Kim manages to shine every time. She deserves to win.

Posted by jm – September 11, 2007 11:34 AM

I disliked Robb from the beginning and I'm glad they finally got rid of him. I also didn't like elimating 2 people on each show and doing so many group challenges. I believe we would have a better idea of what people could do if they were doing more individual rooms with the same theme and same availability of materials, and with only one elimation per week. I LOVE HGTV and watch it almost all the time. I didn't see the kind of talent with this years crop that we saw last year with David and Alice. Disappointing!!!! I dearly loved sparkly Josh, but I'd never let him near my house. Few of us have his glitzy taste, but we'd certainly have fun watching him. If they do a show next year, the presenters really need to be vetted for real talent and ability. They can always be taught the hosting and presentation part. I think we're all interested in people who are genuinely talented and have something to offer other than car doors on the wall and hopefully some personality that doesn't involve a HUGELY inflated ego. Perhaps someone like David who actually wants to PLEASE the client and is thoughtful about how things work together. Let's hope for better next year.

Posted by Barbara – September 7, 2007 6:18 PM

What's going on with the Blog? Has HGTV realized that the viewing public is upset and doesn't want to face the fact that the made a BIG mistake? I have not seen an update since show # 6. Also no TV spots about next weeks show - what's going on?!?!?!?!

Posted by Rene – September 6, 2007 1:00 PM

This years show is rigged! How else do you explain all those talented designers, and someone who has no regard for anyone's feelings, being voted off?????? After this last show, I am SURE this was a setup! They are headed to Hawaii!!! Where else would they go to give Todd the edge? He will be in his realm - now he can really give us what he loves, and he can show off his bod - surfing! I am thinking that if there is no change in next year's show, I (along with a lot of others, I am sure) will NOT be watching. The whole idea, for this series, started out great and if they would have continued with the same format, it would be worth watching. This year it turned into another STUPID REALITY show - none of which I watch. Last year, I thought we had the choice - this year, my feeling is we do not!!! It has already been decided. IF in fact Kim does not win this; I for one, will not be watching again! And I WILL NOT be watching the "Todd Show". I do not want a ramp, or Tsunami in my living room. I also would like a living room I could move in - not jammed with furniture! And what was with the two red ("most comfortable") chairs??? If that is comfort, I don't want them. Can't imagine how you could carry on a conversation with family members while sitting, or should I say laying in them! That was a large family. How did they all get into the couch area? You didn't show any of them "moving" around in that room. I agree with others; Will's room was the best designed with the needs of the girl taken into consideration. Did you notice he was done on time, no hurrying around. He remained calm, and I love his line (when he was "Hosting"- which Miss Martha didn't think was good) "Where there's a Will there's a way" COOL idea for the name of his show. Where are you HGTV? This whole series was hard to watch from the beginning, never did I feel like I did last year. I cheered for my favorites and they got booted off, I watched personalities take over. Wake up HGTV!! Next year has to be better - is sure can't get worse!!! Sis

Posted by Sis – September 4, 2007 1:42 PM

Boy, am I glad Robb is gone. He thought only of himself & berated everyone else. Why did they wait sooooooooooo long? Todd is an overgrown teen.Will's design were clean,but remember his room & compare to the girl's room. Very similr. Kim needs more experience but she's great. I will vote for her. I do miss "Sparkle Josh". He felt for everyone. I would have cancelled Robb's show, not Josh. I couldn't believe the couple chose his design.

Posted by Dale – September 4, 2007 5:11 AM

Robb... you are an a*@! I was so glad to see you out. You were combative with everyone (except Todd - hmmmm.... maybe there is something in that?)and took every chance to throw someone else under the bus - never being able to admit you didn't know everything. That is not a personality trait that would drive me to watch your show. (As if you could get a crew to work with you after the unprofessional way you handled yourself. Hiding things from your competition in the 99 cent store?! If you are so good, why do you feel the neeed to sabotage your competition?

Kim - YOU ROCK! You go girl. Nothing against Todd but a little humility goes a long way. Kim's presentation skills are tight and smooth... she draws me to watch... and listen.

Posted by Bryan – September 3, 2007 8:28 PM

Do we need another naked design star? although todd's body is pretty hot it's too familiar to david's style.

Posted by patty – September 3, 2007 7:48 PM

I would just like to know why when Will's design was rated the top design didn't the judges look beyond his TV presence and just couched him the way they did David.Will wanted to know everything about that young girls disability so he could take it into consideration when he designed the room .He thought of everything and his colors were fantastic .I am upset with those two drooling judges. Todd is no designer and he has showed that in all his challenges ,,this last one was not functional for this family .The couch and chaises were way to far to one side of the room away from the TV and the longest part of the couch faced the wall not the TV .The chaise lounges were too close together and the print clashed with the prints on the pillows.That red and orange room screamed at you and the red beam sure didn't take away from the fact that it split up the room ,,instead it made it stand out like a sore thumb.I didn't see this room as functional at all for this family ,,just because you use a sectional doesn't mean you have to put all the pieces together and that rug on the floor I saw a blue one just like it on another design show on HGTV just the other night.
Now as for Kim .Give the girl a break,, she had the hardest challenge,, a double wide trailer in the coal mine country of West Virginia ,,where the stores she had to shop in were miles away and no doubt scant as far as choices.The family wanted a carpet and the store didn't have many choices ,,yes I would have done a wood floor and used rugs ,,but that wasn't what the family wanted ,,they wanted comfort its cold in West Virginia .Kim did the best she could with what she was given and I for one applaud her.Job well done.
This is the Todd show ,,heck he is even the one holding the star on the Design Stars main page,,when a great designer like Will is overlooked something is definately wrong.I will never watch a Todd show ,,hello Bravo chanel with real designers.C.C.R.C had it right Todd spilled the beans about the last two being ,,he or she,,.Now what will Todd do in Hawaii design a surf shop.
I am totally discusted with this years Design Star .They really should change the name of the show if their going to get rid of all the good designers.Call it The Spastic Show ! Todd is no designer folks he's a spastic egomanic and an idiot .Sounds harsh huh ,,well it should be when this show was not fair to the real designers by chosing someone from the start that they thought would pull in woman ,,well this woman won't watch this clown no matter what you do to promote him.

Posted by Linda – September 3, 2007 6:08 PM

This show is ripping us off by kicking two off at a time, not fair. Clive is a good host & judges are good for ideas of improvement but the end should have us voting for three: Will, Kim and Sparkle Josh. Scott was very good too. Us viewers should not be made to think the others were kicked off for bad design... it was for the sake of who they wanted to win. And sooo glad Rob is gone: rude rude rude guy!

Posted by fan – September 3, 2007 4:24 PM

My family likes Will's work a lot. Todd is not my idea of a T.V. host, and I don't believe his work can be of any value out of California!! He certainly has all the right looks, but talent perhaps not.

Posted by Barbara Jay – September 3, 2007 1:10 PM

It was a hard decision for the judges tonight, however one had to go and Will, with all his talent as a decorator, he just can't seem to be able to face the cameras.
Poor Kim, with all that mud, she should've put a plastic runner at the beginning or take the shoes off, which would've been hard.
I agree that the carpet needed to be of a color that would not show the dirt so much, and the furniture in leather, but probably too expensive.
Todd... what can you say about Todd? Send him surfing back to California he is still too immature for the job.
I will vote for Kim... she is another Lisa La Porta dynamo!

Posted by Ana – September 3, 2007 10:56 AM

Well, I almost cheered...no, I did cheer when the judges said goodbye to Robb. The man's attitude wasn't what I associated with this network.

Posted by Deniece – September 3, 2007 10:43 AM

Ok, Will got the shaft tonight for his hosting abilities? His room was very much put together nicely for the handicapped child...he didn't miss a beat. So get him a coach for hosting, he'd catch on. As for Kim, bad carpet and furniture choice for a mining family. She also didn't consider the mud walkway, the sooty wood burner, or that tacky ceiling. Then there's Todd who hated the beam in the center of the room, but draws more attention to it with red paint? Another ugly ceiling that didn't get addressed. Don't designers look up anymore? Duh!

Posted by Joanne – September 2, 2007 11:41 PM

With tears in my eyes I watched the end of tonights show. What class from Will! His comments about the young girl he designed for, show what kind of person he is! He is right he is a designer, he will continue to design and I am sure he will go far. WHY? was he voted off??? Because he doesn't talk "right". I was sure Todd would be left on when I heard Martha say "I just love to WATCH Todd" Girl - It is not about watching a hunk - it is about design! She picked on Will and Kim's room right away. I felt the Will had the best design and Kim had the best presentation. If Todd wins this competion I will NOT be watching his show! I read the comment that Kim put in a white carpet. In the store she said that she picked the color (it was not white) because it would hide dirt. I think she did that for warmth - remember that they heat their place with only the wood stove. That was more practical than a cold wood or tile floor. I am quite upset with this years show. It has been too much drama and not enough designing. I will be voting for Kim, and I pray that the other voters do the same. She had the most class and a sparkling personality, as well as being a darn hard worker!(did you see her holding her own bringing in the couch? I sure hope the producers read all these comments before they plan next year's show and make some changes. Rene

Posted by Rene – September 2, 2007 11:30 PM

I read here in the comments that Todd posted his URL; I tried finding through yahoo, google, etc. but couldn't locate it; anyone have a link?

Posted by Paul – September 2, 2007 10:41 PM

9/2/07
This reeks! Tonight was no surprise. When I read Todd’s 8/28/07 blog his own words clearly indicated he was one of the final two and Will would be gone remember “he or she”. Why else would he go about setting up a “design team”. I think HGTV was onboard with a Todd from the start to them he had “the look” and they expected viewers to go ga-ga over him.
People it takes months to plan a show. Like any idea for a movie /show you plan it write the script then cast the characters this series was no different! They had a specific character in mind and apparently Todd was their choice. Personally I think this whole series was a farce and Robb and Todd were a tag team. Robb’s reward, a member of Todd’s design team on his new show. Todd is HGTV’s choice now it’s up to the public [we hope] to choose between the two.
The naïve side of me wants to believe we actually have a choice but the “are you kidding” voice on my shoulder says; ”It’s in the bag HGTV has too much invested in this project to leave it to chance.” I’ll vote anyway and hope for the best. That said a Todd show I will not watch.

Posted by CCRC – September 2, 2007 10:18 PM

After tonight's show I am finished with Design Star. By eliminating Will, they eliminated the only person that had good design ideas. Will's designs reminded me alot of Vern's design style.

I don't care who wins at this point. Although I like Kim and her hosting abilities, she's no Will. That's not to put her down, because I think she is really sweet. I definately prefer her over Todd.

Todd just isn't a designer...period. And it shows in his work.

I'm disappointed to say the least. I really thought I was watching a design show that wanted to pick the best designer. I guess I was wrong!!!

Posted by georgia34 – September 2, 2007 10:16 PM

Was that typical or what? I love Wills work and I thought his hosting ablity was much improved from last week. Look at Todds work again not functional. Who would sit on a sofa and not face the TV? I thnk Wills room was the best. So why did he go? Remember we are looking for a design star. I would never put white carpet in any home not matter were the person lived. In a coal miners home I would have used hardwood or ceramic tile. Let's see the show is already done so we will see if we really get to vote. I think it's already decided. How about you?

Posted by Denise – September 2, 2007 10:12 PM

I am glad Kim is in the finals. I feel that she will be the perfect host for a show of her own. She doesn't try and act like someone that she isn't. She also seems to really try and use designs that are going to please the client, not just what she wants.

Posted by Bryan – September 2, 2007 10:09 PM

I can't believe the girl decided to put white carpet into a coal miner's house!!! I am from WV and see many of these people as a nurse and can't believe she didn't think about the lifestyle of these people and that the woman of the house said the coal dust was ruining their house and furniture. I would have put ceramic tile or hardwood on the floors, and probably leather furniture to minimize the appearance of black coal dust!!! Duh??

Posted by Pamela – September 2, 2007 9:35 PM

I am so excited for tonights show. I hope that it comes down to Todd and Will. They are definitely the best two! But, I actually think Todd would have an amazing show of his own. He has tons of talent and he'd make for a great, refreshing, new show. Todd's my pick to win! I will keep my fingers crossed!

Posted by Jen – September 2, 2007 9:12 PM

Say what you want about Rob, but he did do the kitchen and if that girl gets to the final it will be a big mistake!

Posted by Jerry KC – September 2, 2007 9:11 PM

Glad robb is back on a flight to Orlando. He probably justified and rationalized all the way home! I believe Todd is the best designer left, and his arrogance has lessend a bit. I hope the final show won't be like last years where Alice's room couldn't beging to compete with David's. It looked like the fix was in!

Posted by gwen applington – September 2, 2007 7:04 PM

I can't wait for tonight's episode! I am trying to get my daughter interested in watching it at her house so we can watch "together". I don't see how we can have any other outcome than Kim and Will being the only two left tonight. I do appreciate Todd's talents as I continued to watch him towards the end of the competition, but I think both Kim and Will have much more design talent. I think Will's hosting skills can be coaxed, but I do think he will come in second to Kim. She's a natural in front of the camera.

Posted by blestwoman – September 2, 2007 4:21 PM

Maybe I can now relax and watch the show, since Robb is gone. It made me uneasy to watch the previous shows due to his treatment of others. Robb please seek some professional help. You are OVERLY aggressive. I see people like this everyday. You need some help to change your life patterns. It would help you with relationship success and probably reduce your stress level.

I look forward to the show tonight and would like to wish the final contestants good luck. I think that all of them have good qualities, but none of them seem to be the "full package" YET. Maybe tonight one of them will shine!!!!

Posted by anita – September 2, 2007 3:58 PM

I think the show has already been taped, except for the final showdown. This blog wasn't HERE when the judges were deciding on who goes.

I think a great show would include BOTH Sparkle Josh and Adrianna. She could do the "manly" carpenter stuff, and he could do the decorating and accessorizing (sort of a reverse Matt and Shari) Of course I think David and Alice would have made a great team as well!

After watching the "hosting" last week, I think Will will be the one leaving tonight. Remember it's MORE than just design talent and these guys have to be able to speak to a TV audience. Will was horrible at it. My prediction is Todd and Kim will be the finalists. I agree that Josh would have been the ONE contestant who's show I would have watched.

Posted by Mel – September 2, 2007 11:52 AM

I've been reading the blogs here, and have been surprised by the number of people who believe that Robb was a good man. I suppose that demeaning behavior towards women, relegating them to subservient positions, swearing, calling names, being a bigot and other atrocious behavior is acceptable to some folks. What scares me is that most of the Robb lovers are women. I thought that wife- and girlfriend-beating were a thing of the past; I'm obviously wrong... I'm wondering why these women think that it's quite all right to put up with verbal (and, possibly physical abuse). HGTV has truly managed to sink to Survivor status...

Posted by LAP – September 2, 2007 10:18 AM

Ya know I was really upset that Todd, [while still a contestant], blogged here and posted his URL.
Then I decided to check it out. Boy, you can learn a lot about a person from their writings, especially when they write about themselves.
One can easily detect a great deal of self aggrandizement in Todd’s words. He reveals an okay somewhat immature guy who lives what one might consider a privileged life, more than a tad self absorbed and out of touch with how the other half live. I’m not implying it’s wrong to have a privileged life not at all, good for him. However a person owning a business targeted to meet the needs of high-end clients may have difficulty relating to the needs of average Jane/Joe? Time will tell!

Posted by CCRC – September 2, 2007 8:34 AM

DITTO, DITTO, DITTO...Good riddens ROBB. Just think before you speak. You are the fool for thinking you were BETTER than everybody. You tried to be cool with Todd. Todd's much cooler than you. I don't think any person would watch your show anyway. Every Vern, has more class than you. Worst of all for you. I and alot of other people, wouldn't hire you now. BAD ADITUTE....

Posted by stephanie arruda – September 2, 2007 1:55 AM

Saturday night and one more day until Design Star comes on again. I read some of the blogs and I agree that it's good that Robb is gone. Now we are down to three. Don't have much enthuasim about any of them. I hope HGTV will take a long look at the way they handled this and will get some new judges. They apparently haven't read our blogs or just don't give a rap about how the TV audiences feel.I am so sick of TV exec.and politicians not listening to their constitients I just feel like giving it all up.

Posted by edna wilson – September 1, 2007 10:30 PM

Thank you one and all! Rob the *** is gone! He was so stuck on himself that he should have gone before! He might be a good designer, or not, he thinks he is, but you cannot treat people the way he did and expect the people to take his side.Or to take him seriously. The design in the kitchen was kinda sad, The only good that was going on, was what Kim did to decorated it. The guys in the living room and dining room,well wouldn't have been my style, but it still looked good! At least the custumer(Wayne Newton) was happy.

Posted by Mary Coleman – September 1, 2007 9:51 PM

Kim set me up. I should have won..... booohoooo... you all are fools,,, I am the best designer star... I can drive a truck and I have done many kitchens..... truck stop kitchens...My eyes are hurting from crying.... booohoooo... Kim hurt my little feelings... why does Sparkle Josh get all the great fan mail.... Did I tell you that I drive a truck... I have done 1000's of kitchens.. boooohoooo..
Robb..

Posted by Robb – September 1, 2007 9:35 PM

RE: Guesthouse kitchen
The green tile backspash was the worst installation that I've seen. The green color wasn't reflected anywhere else in the kitchen/
breakfast area. At the very least, it could have been put on the kitchen table. The color is very popular now and is available at many, many stores.
The time-proven triangle of kitchen appliances
was not used properly.
Important time was wasted in conflict. This shouldn't have happened, as time was too limited
to begin with.

Posted by Ed – September 1, 2007 8:51 PM

I love DesignStar. This season has really been exciting. I believe Sparkle had SO Much personality and talent. I miss him but hope to see him as a personality on an future show regardless of his finish on DesignStar. I'm elated psycho Robb is gone. It did my heart good to see him CRYING when he got booted. As for who has the most talent of the remaing three -- WILL by far. He is honest and believable in his design and the only one left who can listen to his clients and give them what they want in a realistic manner. GO WILL!!

Posted by Evelyn – September 1, 2007 8:23 PM

The Phone Has BEEN Ringing Off THE Wall!!!!!Design Star has a following.From South Jersey,SARASOTA FLA.and NAVARRE FLA. WE Are a group of 68.These people are my friends and family.And yes we are in the 46 and up group.Our group all believes that KIM AND WILL MUST GO!!! AND SHOULD HAVE LEFT BEFORE. Observe all Aspects OF THEIR WORK on SUNDAY. SINCERELY,LETITIA THE 68

Posted by Letitia – September 1, 2007 7:43 PM

I stick with my original comment from when the show started. HGTV tried to spice up the formula and it is backfiring big time. Is this about design or about TV personalities? Yah, I know it is about creating a TV show but look at how great Color Splash is but it is still about design and David remains a real person. This last challenge would have been perfect for sparkle Josh - did you see Wayne's living room?? - come on...and they did middle america with spice orange & black and a wooden platform. Talk about not reading the clients! Now they are down to two normal acting people and one athlete (or carpenter on caffeine). Maybe HGTV is hoping to redeem itself at the end. I think it is too late and they dumped a couple of people who might have been real contestants but were judged in group projects. Also the TV viewing judging is lame. Can I be a judge? - I can watch TV and make comments.

Posted by Rose – September 1, 2007 7:33 PM

I think there has been 'nuff said about Robb. He said it all in the last episode - really? Tear? My comments have to do with this year's show in general. Prior to last year I had never watched a "reality" show. However after watching, I felt it was great (I picked David from the first show - beside the point). What I see this year is that HGTV or whoever, is trying to compete with "regular" TV shows (which is a big mistake!) What I watch the shows for is to get some GOOD design ideas, and to see what designers have to offer (whether trained or not). This year, we have seen kooks, jocks, who love to do somersalts (not in MY living room), and those with problems getting along with ANYONE (especially those who are FEMALE, GAY, BLACK, etc.!) If I want this kind of show I will watch "REGULAR TV. Well, I don't - that has been why I have watched HGTV all these years. My TV, and recorder, are programed to all my favorite HGTV shows and there are a lot.
My suggestions for next year (should there be one), is to give us some REAL people, not "personalities" (just to get some other kooks to watch). Give those contestants (with design experience or not) enough time to show us what they can do. Quit rushing through contestants - maybe less of them OR a two part system - with the first group being bigger, then go to the finalist. ENOUGH of all the team business (once is enough to see how beople work together). Also give them a short time - if not each week,at least twice - to present their design on "TV", so we can see their ablity to be before the camera. I will be watching the last shows and really hope the final three will have time to show their talent. My choice since the begining has been Kim. However, Will really knows his stuff - I really think he could design for US - "regular folk". If I wanted a ski jump or turn table in my living room, I would hire Todd - however it is unlikely that will be a wish for MY living room. Give us REAL design work/ideas for REAL Folk. Do you think we could have new judges next year? I think we need new ideas there, too. It seems we hear the same comments over and over. A fresh look, all right? Please keep Clive - he is SOOOOOO refreshing. Just have him keep his comments to himself and refrain from "leading" questions. How about the other "stars" from HGTV design shows? Thanks for the time to get all this off my chest. I am anxious to see this week and see each one REALLY show what they have. Rene

Posted by Rene – September 1, 2007 7:29 PM

It's too bad that Robb is like he is. He has talent, but his ego is much larger than any talent could ever possibly compensate for. Had he gone on and actually won, I would never have been able to watch his show. Just cannot stand his attitude. Good job judges!

Posted by Verna Mae – September 1, 2007 7:15 PM

"Drama, drama, and more drama." Well, that's right on the money. (What I hoped for was design, design, and more design. For drama I watch another channel.)

At this point last year there were the individual color challenges, which let me see what each person could do individually AND then hear the explanation of why s/he did so. But on this team challenge it was still unclear who was bringing what to the table, even with the Robb-Kim aggravation-fest.
I don't know whether it was the pool that HGTV had to pull from, or whether there was a format change to turn it up a notch on the personalities and personal drama, but this season has not been as enjoyable or informational on design as in why material or color choices were made or critiques by the judges. I could imagine any of last year's top 3 hosting a show, although David was clearly the front runner. David, Alice and Tym were all nice people, had good and diverse design ideas, has some real skills, and could articulate why they made design choices. This year...meh.
Robb was not a pleasant person, but I got an "oh dear" feeling when he started tearing up...like I do when one of my kids makes a bad choice and then tries to pull it together by blaming the other with a quivering lip and watering eyes. Guy is almost 40 and is really out of touch with how he comes across either with those he works with and on national TV. Not exactly great PR for future design work; I hope he can still find employment.
Short version: It'll be interesting to see who wins but, for me, not a great 2nd season.

Posted by RGCF – September 1, 2007 7:12 PM

I also believe Robb got robbed. He is much better than Kim. Kim was always quick to criticize, but was low on action. Robb is innovative and has good overall concepts of how something should be done. Which is greatly lacking with all of your other contestants, except Todd. Yes, Robb has a strong personality, but he gets things done. Apparently, Robb did get the Vegas Wedding done and had the ability to put a team together. Yet, Kim set up very basic design tables. What's with this gal? I am surprised that your judges didn't listen to her constant nagging.

Posted by Jeanette Lutz – September 1, 2007 7:02 PM

Rob I hope you read these comments. You give men a bad name. Pull up your "BIG BOY Panties" & grow up. It appears you don't know what the word respect means! I am glad you're gone - it should have been 2 episodes ago. Didn't even see the end of this one because knew the judges had to have axed you this time. Take some lessons from David. He is not only talented but has a fantastic personality & is most of all, kind to people. Mean people suck & you are nothing but a mean person.

Posted by Nancy – September 1, 2007 6:03 PM

(sung to the Witch is dead from Wizard of Oz) Ding dong Robb is gone!....Good riddence. I cheered when he was given the boot. The only fool there was him.
Truckers are loners, and Robb is a Trucker by trade....No surprise that he's not a team player.
Kim had him pegged. She's a smart cookie...I'm glad she made it to the final three.

Posted by Karen – September 1, 2007 5:27 PM

IMHO: Todd = "off broadway" set designer ...
Will = great colorist & clean urban chic, if only Sparkle Josh was there to add the sparkle of unexpected + personality...
Kim = sorry I only remember a crafty coffee table & paper plate wallpaper even though a likeable person. Was this whole season scripted for drama rather than design??? PS not 1 kitchen had any class or thought about
functionality. If time & budget were a contraint, consider doing a few things well rather than a hodge podge of faux I wouldn't want to clean ! lol Good luck to the losers...I think there was a winner or 2 among them!

Posted by wwwebduster – September 1, 2007 5:06 PM

This one's for Robb:
"Behind every successful man, one will find a 'good woman'. I don't think Kim was 'good enough' for you... I've been helping my man build his own dream home for the past year and he has taught me sooooo much, even through the screams and hollers and cussing! I'm not a weak woman, therefore, I cannot be 'offended'. Did anyone look at the measurements that Kim wrote down? It appeared to me that she was too busy TRYING to make you look bad and PROMOTE the 'non-team effort' to make her own self look good. Coming from a woman's viewpoint, frankly, she played an excellent game on pure emotion and won. Have you ever heard the saying ~ "men are like tiles?" She made you lay your emotions all over the place, but this fan was actually paying attention to your talent and looking beyond your personality traits and how you deal with other people. After watching her manipulation and 'throw it in your face that she's your partner', it was obvious to me that she was the one that was having the complex. If the other judges couldn't see it, they at least knew your personality would keep the viewers watching and you know how everyone loves a good fight. Before the final four began the Newton renovation I actually told my fiance that I thought you and Kim would be great as a team...meaning, you would have your own design show and she could assist and it would be known as 'The Robb & Kim Design Pursuit Special'. You could teach each other and blend your talents together and give each other credit where credit was due... and be a good influence WITH REALITY in reality t.v. But frankly, I wouldn't even let her cut my hair now!
Good luck to you Robb, and if you would like to do some probono work in Arizona, my fiance could use a good carpenter/designer to help complete his dream house for when he retires in 4 months. But he's too proud, like you sometimes, and doesn't want anyone's help. He's a loner but he's really doin' it all FOR US! It's VERY HARD to build your own home when you have to drive 4 hours roundtrip everyday to work. There's very little time left on the weekends to build. I've been joking with him since Design Star began and told him I would contact you if you lost. I don't think he believed me. He's pounding and drilling away right now in the area that will someday be my new office where I will be able to complete my first 'how to book': How To Build Your Own House (in less than 7 years) And Be Debt Free... or how 'bout this title: If There's A Robb, There's A Way. I seriously doubt there will be 'A Will' on the next Design Star so WHEN Todd wins, I hope he calls you to help him on his show. Not only would that be the RIGHT thing to do, it would be the FAIR thing to do... remember... All is Fair in Love and War, but NOT in Reality T.V.
Faith I Carry,
Robin

Posted by Robin – September 1, 2007 3:31 PM

I love love love Design Star but why does it appear to be going by so fast? Have we missed some shows? I feel like they have shortchanged us on the number of challenges. Not fair - we want more of Design Star - not less... Great group that they picked and this last episode was exciting with one group fighting and the other getting along so well. I still miss Sparkle Josh, Good bye Rob, and it will be interesting to watch what the last three will produce individualy. Good luck!! (but stop with shortchanging us the number of episodes)

Posted by jw – September 1, 2007 3:30 PM

I think HGTV was trying to broaden the appeal of the show. Hence, macho types like Robb and Todd and the setting in Las Vegas. I think this has backfired on them. The Vegas wedding while definitely a challenge was just tacky. The designers this year seemed less talented than last year. They have specialist talents and lack professional training. Not to speak of good taste. Robb should have been kicked off for painting faux bricks in his "Tuscan" kitchen. All the reality shows need somebody to hate. They kept Robb around for that reason, but he was both too hateful and lacking talent. And Scott didn't deserve to go although he did overdo his 99cent room. Too much taste is better than none.

Posted by Marianne – September 1, 2007 3:26 PM

As a florida girl I am happy that irritating robb is gone - poof the jerk is gone..
I wish he would do us a favor and reture to his own home state of wisconsin instead of my state of florida..
Most floridians have style and grace...we don't wear stupid bandanana's on our heads.
I hoped that sparkles and will would go to the finals together. That dream is gone now.
My hopes still lie with will..

Posted by floridachic – September 1, 2007 3:02 PM

Just sitting here in a morning fog w/ strong coffee asking myself why should I care who the next DS is? Or that Todd blogged on this site while still a contestant? Worse, posted his URL, trawling for votes. So what? Could it be because it is wrong, unfair and downright poor sportsmanship! No wonder he got along so well w/Robbie and asked him to join his team. BTW his competitor did not choose to blog here [and it isn’t because they don’t have websites]. Rather they chose to win or lose on their own merits. That’s class! Bravo Kim and Will.

On second thought perhaps his posting that URL was a good thing. After all you can learn a lot about a person from their writings, especially when they write about themselves. One can easily detect a great deal of self aggrandizement in Todd’s writings. He reveals an okay somewhat immature guy who lives what one might consider a privileged life, more than a tad self absorbed and out of touch with how the other half live. I’m not implying it’s wrong to have a privileged life not at all, good for him. However, how is a guy that just recently founded a business targeted to meet the needs of high-end clients going to connect/relate to the average Jane/Joe? Not that the next DS should be a carbon copy of David B. or anyone else for that matter, but it should someone who has won fairly. Have a great day all 

Posted by CCRC – September 1, 2007 9:24 AM

I have to admit, Robb's tears at the end threw me! I realized that he has so much passion for what he does but hey Robb! certain elements of your passion needs to be reexamined. Your passion for design is obvious but your negative passion for other people can and has proven to be detrimental. Part of your task in the Newton Kitchen design and previous designs have been to work as a team and that seems to be a stretch for you... why? Team members can prove to be very valuable for what they bring to the table. I realize that this was a competition and you were competing w/ 10 other designers but your design skills, management skills and tv host skills were not the only qualities that judges were looking for. I'm actually sorry your gone but hope you've learned something in this process Robb.. you can't go it alone! It's not only impossible but it's lonely!

Posted by Nancy Brown – September 1, 2007 8:36 AM

I have to agree with everyone - I'm glad Robb is finally gone. What a nasty individual! He should have been eliminated in the second episode.

I, too, think that this season is moving way too fast. I couldn't wait for the show to come back, and now it's already almost over - what a rip off. And, as many have said, there's not enough showcasing of individual talent. I have no idea what Kim can actually do on her own, except for the 99 cent store challenge. I THINK she's talented, but who can tell when all she's had to do was support someone else. She needs to assert her ideas more. Well, too late now. I guess we'll finally see her talents in this last challenge.

Also, I think Pam's comments have a lot of good ideas for the show. Top Design, on Bravo, has the right idea (I hope it comes back). Each week each designer gets to show what they can do in an individual room, and the judges look at each room in person, not on a TV screen, and then give their critiques. We get to see their talents and many times the judges comments point out things we may miss because we only see what the cameras show us. And we get to enjoy the show for longer than, what(?) 6 weeks. Also, everyone keeps their clothes on, no one does handsprings off the table, and there's still plenty of drama.

Although in the first episode I thought it was the right choice to let Lisa go, I thought it was rude of Vern to say her design was a failure. I didn't particularly care for it, but it did have SOME function. There was at least seating and it did have a quirky style of it's own. What function did Robb's door on the wall have??? It was ridiculous. The judges hated his and Organic Josh's thrown-together-at-the-last-minute space, but that apparently was not a "failure". As far as Neeraja's bar space, she did make some mistakes, she could have found a couple of bar stools, but what else could she have done besides "just decorate" it. The bar was already there. Was she supposed to tear it down and build another one? I thought in general it looked pretty good. It would also be interesting to hear more of what the judges talk about amongst themselves.

Another point: Are there any real designers out there who are insulted by the fact that untrained individuals are all referred to as "designers"? I'm a Certified Interior Decorator. I know I'm not a Designer. Designers go to school and get trained in various aspects of not only decorating, but also technical skills. They graduate with a degree and can do far more than a decorator can. Obviously Design Star or Top Design sounds better on TV than Decorating Star or Top Decorator, but let's call it what it is and not give amateurs more credit than they deserve.

Sorry I'm going on and on, but what's up with this online viewer's challenge thing, where we guess who will win or get voted off? Yeah, it's fun, but how can we guess BEFORE we see what they'll be doing on the show. You might as well put on a blindfold and just pick one. This would work much better if they didn't reveal the winner and loser until the following episode.

So listen up, producers. First, you need to give Sparkle Josh his own show. The, for next season, you need to give the "designers" more individual challenges. I believe they should be within the guidelines that would work for real people in real homes. (It CAN be possible to decorate from the 99 cents store, BUT, for example, no one would really use the flooring materials some of the contestants used). You need to have judges with open minds. You need to stop voting off 2 people at a time.

You need to KEEP YOUR VIEWERS INTERESTED!!!

Posted by CONNI – September 1, 2007 7:05 AM

Great programs...

This last show has turned my insides out. I never felt so uneasy as to see and hear what all Robb had to say. It doesn't seem like he would be a good co-worker. This show has really upset me and it's too bad. I know that Kim hasn't had the 'experience' that Robb had, but I bet she has been in more kitchens and know where everything should be placed. I feel that Robb would be the kind of person who would want any female to 'stay in the kitchen and barefooted'.

'Glitter' Josh will be missed. Josh, you can come and decorate my home. I would definatelly trust you

Posted by Jan Williamson – September 1, 2007 6:41 AM

About the Wedding,
When Todd was in the banquet room and was turning flips and turn a table over. As a former Banquet Manager,If he would have broken the table I would have made him pay for it Design Star or not. I believe when you are trying out for the next Design Star you should "grow up" not act like a big KID
Shirley

Posted by Shirley – September 1, 2007 1:46 AM

I have been reading for 3 hours on the old blogs as well as this one. It is gooing to be very hard to pick if it is Will and Kim. Todd may be good with a set of tools, and a good artist, but he does not have what I think is called for in design - to work with and for others to facilitate the design, execution and completion of a project so that the customer is not just satisfied, but finds it a rewarding experience and is excited to live with their new space.
As far as carpentry skills, etc, most of that is done by a hired crew, so why worry about that part of it? Can't have the host slice off a finger with a power saw! The Do-It-Yourself shows are for those types of projects. The Design on a Dime, Design reMix and Designed to Sell shows are the ones where the designer has to have some tool skills. If they need it, give them a course in saws, drills and nailguns before the show starts filming. I also found another comment which made me change my mind about the format of next year's show from a former comment I made. I just copied it to paste in, it was too good not to: Thanks, PAM!

Ok, that all said - since HGTV is wanting feed-back on the series, I would like to be a part of the solution to the Design Star problem and not just end up as another griper. So, I would like to ask the JUDGES AND DESIGN STAR PRODUCERS to at least read and consider the following suggestions for the next Design Star series:
1. The producers and judges should weed-out all of the nuts and fruit-cakes before the series competition even begins (we really don't want to see people who are on major ego trips, vacuum cleaner decorators, and people who are continually doing hand-springs).

2. All of the contestants should stay and participate throughout the entire competition series, so that they can fully demonstrate their true capabilities in every competition. (The exception would be the removal of anyone who quite obviously slipped through the initial screening process undetected - such as Robb.)
3. The contestants should be given a fair and realistic amount of time to design and execute the tasks that they have been given (which quite often has just not been the case).

4. The contestants should be given more opportunities to showcase their individual talents.
5. At the end of each show each contestant should be verbally critiqued by the judges for each and every catagory that is being evaluated for that specific show (concept, design, originality, attitude, execution, etc.).
6. At the end of the series the judges should then review all of the Design Star shows (not just the clips of the finished work) and all of the contestants should be re-assessed in the light of their growth and progress throughout the series. The over-all scores should then be tallied-up and the process of elimination should begin at that time.
7. The remaining two contestants should be evaluated verbally by the judges, and then the viewers may choose the winner.
Hope this feed-back helps.
Posted by Pam – August 27, 2007 2:30 AM

I. Mamsters, believe that this really should be taken up and studied by the producers and writers. And PLEASE - get rid of these judges! And figure out a better group of people to decide who the contestants will be. Will, Sparkle, Kim, Christina and Scott should have been the survivors of the early cuts. The others just did not have the personality, maturity or people skills to adapt to being a star and really designing, executing and completing a project.

My nerves are on edge - this will be a sad elimination, but I hope it's Todd. He reminds me of the character in the spoof mini-series Fresno who never said much but also never had a shirt on!

Posted by mamsters – September 1, 2007 1:32 AM

I wish this season was Better; It's a step down from last year. Seems tacky somehow. Of couse I guess that is Vegas! I thought Rob should have been the one to stay; far more talent...

Posted by Levi – September 1, 2007 1:18 AM

Why is everyone disappointed in this year's show as opposed to last year's? I think it's great...but we wasted WAY too much time watching the pathological jerk with no talent whatsoever. I think Todd is the shoe-in this year...not because Martha drools over him; he has the most talent. If some find him over the top...he can tone that down. It is easier to cut back on energy than to create energy where it is lacking. I'd like to see some design skills like those of Candace of Divine Design and the English host of Designing for the Sexes (who's name slips my mind right now). I miss his show. In any case, I wish all the contestants the best of luck! Show us your true design skills!

Posted by PAC – August 31, 2007 11:51 PM

Robb should hane been gone since the first episode!!!!!!!
I'm so glad he is gone, on the wedding episode he did good on the design, he is good but too bad he cant control his ugly attitude.

Love the show.

Posted by Judy – August 31, 2007 11:08 PM

Whew!!! You had me worried. One week tooooo long for Rob. OMG--"If she had half a brain" or the one "are you lame" I knew when Rob patted himself on the back the week before he liked himself a little tooo much. Final word should not have been "Fools" but "Thanks for putting up with me" Guess he does not have to worry about Todd the Surfer Dude anymore.
If he had not left the building I would have stopped watching the show.

Posted by Sandy – August 31, 2007 10:28 PM

I think that this upcoming episode will show what inner talents these three have since they will be going it solo and designing for a family.

Some good talent did leave the show early and it was the luck of the draw and who the judges were most attracted to at the eliminations.

Robb had some good designs but something was wrong with his overall approach. I am not sure if he works well with living things.

Todd is a great carpenter who thinks outside of the box but he is somewhat pretentious. Suggestion: Try to keep your clothes on and tone it down some. Your target audience is not who you think they are.

Will works well with others and is a good designer. Suggestion: Practice in front of a mirror so you can see how you appear on camera. You are almost there.

Kim portrays a good image; someone who is truly sincere. She has good taste in her design style.
Suggestion: show us what you got this upcoming week since I believe your true talent didn't come out last week when you were paired with Robb.

Good luck to all three of you.

Posted by Vicki – August 31, 2007 10:07 PM

I'm reading alot of negative comments about Vern lately...Well, I love ya Vern...Although I do think the producers are probably forcing Vern to give some of the comments he is making lately. I think they are trying to make him into Simon from American Idol. The bad /stern one.

Well Vern, please stick to your honest but tactful comments you started out with. We do value your opinion, but not when it is given arrogantly.

Vern, your great design along with your humble, polite spirit is what made us fall in love with you in the first place...don't change!!!

Posted by georgia34 – August 31, 2007 9:43 PM

LWATKINS, this blog is directed to you, but does concern everyone who has been leaving blogs, both here, as well as the HGTV "Rate This Space" site. I had been reading rumors, since Tuesday, 28 August, that Todd Davis had been hinting that he was in the final two, for Design Star 2007. Also, he was hinting that Kim was the other finalist, which would mean that Will had been eliminated from the competition. I finally found Todd Davis' website, www.epic-spaces.com and confirmed this for myself. I read every page, comment and blog in his website, to make sure that I was not hallucinating. I found more than a few things which were disconcerting, as well as disturbing (check out the description and thoughts behind his artwork). Todd does, indeed, intimate that he is in the final two, and that America will decide, through voting, that "he or she" will be the next Design Star. I posted a note on the Kitchen and Living Room "Rate My Space" sites, saying that I wanted to know how to contact HGTV directly, to protest this "bean spilling." doughj01 left the message: "For Leonply to contact HGTV call 865-694-7879 Monday through Friday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. ET, to speak with a Customer Services representative." LWATKINS, as you seem to have a direct line to HGTV, I am urging you, as well as the rest of the faithful HGTV and Design Star fans, to contact HGTV and protest Todd's blogging, which intimates that he and Kim are the final two in the competition. I would have thought that there would have been an agreement signed by all contestant/designers, which would prohibit them from posting any information prematurely. Thank you.

Posted by Leon – August 31, 2007 9:42 PM

Has anyone read Todd's blog on his website, www.epic-spaces.com ????? His last two blogs, from August 29 and 30 practically scream out that he's in the final two, and intimate that Kim is the other finalist. Doesn't HGTV have a gag order or something to keep the designer/contestants from spilling the beans??? It was bad enough having to endure Robb-noxious for five weeks, as well as seeing Todd "Tumblina" cavorting like a near-naked spastic gymnast, who was also a bit of a bully. Now the anticipation of Sunday evening has been ruined!! I am not a happy camper, and I am trying to find out how to contact HGTV directly, to complain. I hope that others will do the same.

Posted by Leon – August 31, 2007 7:47 PM

I honestly can't believe some of what I have read here .How can anyone think that rotating design of Todds was a good one when all the furniture looked so cramped on top of that platform and it was so high you could easily trip trying to get up on it not to mention there was hardly no room to get around it.It looked like a big blue elephant in the middle of the already narrow room,,not at all functional .If it wasn't for Will bringing to Todds attention that the chair he placed near the door and merry-go-round was blocking the door then the door wouldn't have even been accessible.

Now Noone Your statement about Ty and Todd being alike and how important Todds carpentry ablity was and that he could do the carpenter work and learn like TY did to design in time was just about as foolish as anyone voting for Todd just because of his looks and body :) Yes Laid Back Design is a good choice Noone ,,He can lay back and watch the others design.Picking a Design Star is suppose to be just that and the only two designers left are Kim and Will.Will has an eye for detail and coordinates colors perfectly ,,as far as his presentation he can work on that just as David did last year.
Come on you woman get past the physical and look at the designer.How many real people would want a pipe line in their living room or a skate board ramp or a merry-go-round.Real people want their home designed for them not Mc.Donalds.

Posted by Linda – August 31, 2007 6:45 PM

Thank God that Robb has hit the road and will not be up for Design Star! I now do not have to quit watching HGTV. He is a bully and a crybaby. Everyone loves to see people like him go down.

Posted by jill – August 31, 2007 4:15 PM

I read through Todd's Blog and saw nothing that gave away the show, except for the he/she thing. But I didn't actually see it the same way as CCRC. However, I have made the journey from thinking that Todd wouldn't last (as far back as the first show) to he SHOULD be the winner, expecially of the three remaining.
While I am not sure that he would win with 2 others (take your pick, I have two in mind), he should win out of these three (and I like all 3 of them as people, just looking for something new rather than the same old show).

Posted by noone – August 31, 2007 3:56 PM

It is a pity, that Robb's talent was overshadowed by his own "foot in mouth" disease. He could get his own design show if he worked behind the scenes and it was in his contract to just "SHADDUP!". I love the final three and to be honest with you, I think they should get their own show as a team ( I know they don't want that ). I have to say that Will surprised me. He thinks like a designer/architect and I think that, if he won and improved his word usage, he would give us all an education.Todd did not impress me much until he designed Wayne Newtons den. That was a cool idea. One that I would use if I ever had a room that big.Kim, is great. There is a song by guitarist Billy McCloughlin calle the bow and the arrow. The arrow is nothing without the bow and vice versa. Well, Kim is the bow. If you need her in your corner, she will do everything to make sure you hit your target. She will make a great leader now that she's away from the divas.

Posted by Mary Titus, Orange California – August 31, 2007 3:44 PM

In my opinion, good "design" can be totally ruined by bad "decorating." Those who have been critical about some of the challengers' decorating over designing are not being fair. Whoever wins this competition needs to be sensible, knowledgable, personable, and appealing to the target audience. Impractical or silly stuff will only appeal to a minority of quirky people, and let's face it, a new show is supposed to draw a broad audience, good sponsors, and, bottom-line, money.

Todd's crazy gimmicks like the skateboard ramp and the revolving platform may be innovative, but in most homes stuff like that are not only inapproriate, but downright tacky! Also, that platform is potentially very dangerous, not just to little kids. Did anyone else see how close to the edge that chair was sitting? One false move and the Newtons' guests would be suing for a broken shoulder, hip, or neck. Holy cow! What was he thinking? And Todd, for heavens sake, put on a shirt! I didn't much care for it when David took his shirt off either, but he was such a pleasant fellow that I overlooked it.

Will was absolutely solid. He makes good choices and knows his stuff. Also, he's a likeable guy. He just needs sprucing up a little and maybe some caffeine to help step up his hosting. However, it was nice to see him actually addressing the design and decorating elements of the room and not spazzing out or acting dorky like Todd or (choke) Robb.

Oh, yes, now to Robb. I have fired people for less than his kind of arrogance and nastiness! To him I'd say, "Grow up. You are NOT the center of the universe. Get over yourself and quit treating other people like dirt." Personally, I think he should have been eliminated early on. Totally unlikeable, irritating, rude, egotistical, the list could go on and on. His designs were so-so, and what was with that ridiculous car door on the wall in the first episode? He displayed poor sportsmanship after he was eliminated, too. Robb, deal with it and take it like a man!

Kim is amazing! She should get a Tony or Emmy or somthing for holding her temper and keeping her cool. I think she has some good ideas and makes good choices. I'm looking forward to seeing the individual challenges. She has a very professional manner and seems to be someone who would really listen to her clients and put them at ease. Her hosting was the best, she was enthusiastic, articulate, and let her personality shine. Thank you, Kim.

I was sad to see the Joshes go. I think both of them could have done much more than they did, given better opportunities. I hope HGTV will give each of them a chance to "go green" and "sparkle" in another venue.

This next comment is specifically directed to the "Design Star" producers. If you're going to do another season, please eliminate the silly stuff like the auto parts store and dollar store. It's unrealistic. Innovative use of regular household items would show individual ability and creativity much better. Thanks.

Good luck to the three remaining designers! We're all watching and waiting! :-)

Posted by Jean Potter – August 31, 2007 1:54 PM

I think some people have a misconception about Interor Designers' personal decorating verses professional decorating. For example...when I go to Sparkle Josh's web site, I believe that some of the pictures are from his personal residence and maybe from a wedding... as a client I do not expect him to decorate my house like any of those pictures... I expect him to listen to my wants and needs and design my space accordingly...just like he did in the challenges on the show. When I saw him design those spaces, I knew that he had to be a real good Interior Designer because there wasn't any "sparkle" in any of the two rooms (except for the personal challenge). The real gift of an Interior Designer is the ability to listen to the client and delivier. Josh and Will have those capabilities and I know they will receive multiple blessings in the future.

Posted by Donna – August 31, 2007 11:55 AM

If you read all about Todd [from his own words] there is no way he can relate to the average person. Example 8 /28/07; “A space that could be forever changing and transforming depending on your mood sound interesting? I have done proximity, large format, convex wall, digital slide shows choreographed with strategic aromas that are emitted while the room shakes and sways to the changing scenery”, Interesting yes but bizarre and costly. Even Todd admits that; 8/29/07..”Yet for a select few, these moments, creative ideas and options have been a dream for some time for some people” I thought HGTV wanted to appeal to average viewer not a “select few”. Nah I won’t watch a Todd show. This whole series has been a disappointment. 

Posted by CCRC – August 31, 2007 7:44 AM

Judging from Todd’s comments on his website blog he’s in the final two and very confident he’ll be chosen by America. Excerpt from 8/28/07;” I've been working to put a wonderful team of designers together, who have been cut from the show. These designers now have plenty of spare time to help all of us out. Would you want some of the other, world class, maverick designers, who may possibly be the most innovative individuals in the nation to help with your design needs? So far only "Robb" has agreed to help out, but I'll be working on the others”
Interesting the only one that agreed was Robb? I’m still hoping Will made the cut but judging from another comment Todd made 8/29/07 I don’t think so;” Stay tuned and vote for who is going to bring you Epic, functional, interactive ideas. He or she will deserve it”. Notice he also used part of the name of his company Epic!
Too bad I had hoped for a designer the average viewer could relate to.I hope I'm wrong and Will makes the cut.

Posted by CCRC – August 31, 2007 7:09 AM

Come on, judges! Todd is really tiresome! (And should be disqualified for blogging while he's still a contestant.) Now it's a clunky revolving platform in the middle of a guest house? All he's shown me is that he can do backflips and use a saw - half naked! Does anyone think Vern would be so unprofessional? (My sons outgrew playground merry-go-rounds at about age 7 - & had learned some public modesty by then, too!)

Will & Kim get stuck with all of the grunt work while the others grab & get all the credit for the good stuff. I hope we can finally see what they can do this week!

Robb? Tacky choices again. I hope he learns that an abraisive attitude is a detriment to success in any endeavor - and that most women do know a little something about kitchens! How many warnings was he given while the rest who were eliminated got none?

Josh - we needed you for this one! You would have loved it - & created a classy guest house that would have blended harmoniously with the rest of the Newton's fabulous estate. I miss you and thank you for thinking of us!

Posted by Ilene – August 31, 2007 3:11 AM

well this show just proved how much Kim and Will have lucked out. Get the right partner and you can get on the next show. Rob may have not been the easist person to get along with but he did have a point and had it not been for him. The kitchen would not have been finished. As for Will if not for Todd he would not have finished the living room. We have all seen who has done the work and who has tagged along. I was very disapointed to see Rob go. Although had Will been sent home last week when he proved all he knows how to do is complain about everyone else's style. I no longer have a choice to pick. Todd is the only design star left.

Posted by mccormicks – August 31, 2007 2:54 AM

Hello AGAIN!!!I I would just like to say....has anyone counted the negative comments regarding MR. ROBB??How popular he has become. Although, Negative everyone is giving Robb attention. Let us all move on to more important matters. All this talk about judges being bias!! I have watched reruns and I do not see it!!!! I guess thinking many of the contestants just do not cut it makes myself abias person. SEING WILL GO ON SUNDAY Will MAKE ME SMILE AND SING.I find his chip on his shoulder too hard to bare.

Posted by Letitia – August 30, 2007 10:32 PM

I have been having a problem with "decorating" vs. "designing". I have seen blogs saying that one design star hopeful is a "designer" and others are merely "decoraters". Well, okay...I'm sorry but I think a Design Star needs to be both - As I read in a recent "Design" article: Good Design does not require being "different", or using trendy materials but rather good home design creates aesthetic pleasure (decorating), enhances your lifestyle (makes my life easier) and satisfies functional needs (how will this space be used). Which to me means...I can live in this space long after the camera crews pack up and go home.
Yes, I am disappointed in the lack of individual challenges thus far. And although I was irritated with the "crap" of drama and tension within this season, I am okay with the remaining three (not as excited as last year's finale between Alice and David but okay with it).
My favorite: WILL!! Love your common sense...love your approach to design AND decorating!

Posted by Pret07 – August 30, 2007 10:17 PM

I just have to say I am sooooooooooooo glad Rob is gone. The way Vern was gushing over him last week I was afraid we were going to have the most unlikeable design star in the world on our hands. I have been a fan of the show since last season but I have to tell you I have been so upset with the judges this year, and is it me or has Vern just become plain old mean. I have been a fan of his for sometime, but I have to say this year his likeable factor has gone way down in my view. Last years winner David is great. While my style since is very different to his he has excellent taste and his use of color is awesome! I am not real fond of Todd. He has quite an ego and I am not sure why he feels the need to appear shirtless every episode (Cause David, he aint!) but then again neither am I, but I am not going shirtless every week on national TV. I think I just heard America breath a sigh of relief.hmmmm I do have a fear, however, if he does win every male that is in the competetion next season will feel the need to go shirtless all season long!lol My very favorites of this season are already gone but of the the three remaining I have to say our darling little Kim outshines the rest! And No Robb was not a favorite!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Gil – August 30, 2007 10:02 PM

Loved the comment made about giving Todd his own show and calling it "Over the top with Todd". It fits 'Dude'.

The show has been very entertaining and I watched all the reruns this week to see if I overlooked something the first time around.

Nope, Robb really was obnoxious and made several key design mistakes. Sparkle Josh really had a great personality and a good deal of talent.
Ultimately Josh and Will really did make a great design team as they complimented each others design style.

I don't really care to watch Todd with his shirt off all the time but I admit he really is creative. I would really like to see him design for real people in an individual design challenge.

Scott really should not have been sent home at the individual challenge. He really showed incredible talent - sending him home was a mistake. Christina should have been sent home instead.

I really like the thoughtfulness that Will puts into each design. The reception design was truly outstanding and his 99 cent room was a success too. I really do think he could learn to present himself better - it's a process. His color sense is superb and he has shown time and time again that he is an excellent designer.

Kim really has become my favorite. She finally stopped being strictly a team player, stood up for herself and kept her cool during a trying exchange with Robb. She showed a strong flair for urban design and plenty of creativity in her own designs. Kim's presentation was dynamite and I hope she becomes the next Design Star.

I really want to see Kim pull off a strong design during next weeks individual challenge episode. Good luck to you Kim!
Alas, good luck to all three - let's see what you can bring on your own.

Posted by Roswitha – August 30, 2007 9:20 PM

The competition is really between Will and Kim. They are both designers and that was proved in the piece. They were the only ones that gave design elements when explaining the room. Kim, hands down, projected better on camera in terms of energy, but Will also knew what he was talking about though his diction was not very good. Overall, neither winner will be speaking off the cuff, but from a teleprompter, in which they will teach them how to read. Overall, Will is my winner. I feel everyone is concentrating on his diction and dialect more than his skill. Besides, Sparkle Josh was just as southern and split a couple of verbs as well. Lastly, for those of you that say “Will’s grammer bothers you,” well, please let your grammar bother you because you keep spelling grammar wrong.

Posted by T Renee – August 30, 2007 9:19 PM

Some people may want to consider that perhaps the new design show on HGTV will not be a typical let's do a family's living room makover show. Perhaps HGTV will utilize Todd, (who will be the winner. I mean, who else could it be? Kim? Gag. Will? Grammar?) to do some really incredibe spaces other than living rooms. He has a great artistic eye and lots of creativity and energy. The cast of hopefuls this season was dismal.

Posted by Tabitha Katz – August 30, 2007 9:09 PM

Where...does HGTV find these people? None of them are outstanding at anything. Kim was my pick from the second show till now...just because. To all the Sparkle lovers, most anyone can take gold and silver and beads and glitter and do something with it but it would not be liveable for the average American family. Ultimately that is where we are going, to choose someone to design a room for a family to live in day and night. They won't want a sparkle room! As for Robb; did someone pay him to act that way? No fool would be crazy enough to talk as he did if he were trying to win a competition. Todd..get real, no family wants a skate board ramp or a moving platform, or a painted couch in their living room.

Posted by JC – August 30, 2007 6:53 PM

I was gone for the weekend(Sat- Tues eve). I recorded the show of course! I didn't get time to watch it 'til Wed. night, so worried about who would be elimitated I entered the sweepstakes but was careful not to look at any info on that page! Thank God he is gone.(Robb) I love watching Color Splash and adore David. I want to like the next design star, maybe now I can. I have been watching last years show and I did not see soooo much drama. So glad Kim and Will have made it this far. I am ok with Todd but.. Love to read these blogs! !

Posted by Duffandy – August 30, 2007 5:41 PM

EVERYONE....go to Todd's website!!! He has amazing artwork and has done amazing work...check out his lifestyle shots as well..you can tell he entertains and designs by the way he lives his life...He has talent and background for a sweet show for sure.

www.epic-spaces.com

Posted by Lenas – August 30, 2007 5:32 PM

I wanted to add something now that I have read so many comments. How can Robb say that he was edited to make him look bad? Perhaps he had his polite moments, but I think we can believe the evidence of our own eyes. He displayed again and again that he couldn't stand any kind of contrary opinions to his. He reminds me of kids who have never been told "no," or older people who have never been argued with and descend into tantrum throwing to get their way. Also, it was not just one of the contestants who had a problem with Robb--it was almost everyone he worked with. I don't think they couldn't have "edited" the other contestants' obvious reactions to Robb. I hope next season they can show the judges early on that some people would be too difficult to work with. It was left way too long. I also agree with those people who are saying that many of us don't watch this show to see a lot of Robb-type behavior. I was ready to stop watching the show if Robb hadn't been eliminated this time. Please, HGTV, have mercy and try to have people skills as an earlier elimination criterion and not so much team competition, which shows us nothing about the individuals. Season 1 really was better in that respect.

Posted by Louise – August 30, 2007 4:04 PM

Todd is a super talented, fantastic desinger/artist. He also will bring personality and pizzaz to a show. He has the educational background too and can do just about anything including fabricating, carpentry, drywall, mechanical skills.

Go Tood, HGTV's next design star!

BTW, if you go on Todd's website and read an article about him in a California newspaper, he is an ex-snowboardist who was good enough to get in the X gamesas one of America's athletes (I think he was in the Olympics too as one of America's athletes). He has experience as a TV host too. I am sure his not coming across perfedct as a TV host was because he was so tired. I still thought he was the best, with Robb a close second as a host. And, you will see that Todd is married (for 2 yeara). His home has a basketball court in it too. He was injured practicing for the X games snowboarding, hit by a wayward snowmobile that was not supposed to be in the athletes' area as he came down the mountain. HIs one arm was mangled. He came back though and went back into what he studied for in college, design and artistry. His story is very inspiring.

Posted by Lara – August 30, 2007 3:51 PM

What sadness to see the three best designers gone: Sparkle Josh, Scott and Robb. I hope out of the ones left that Will makes it. Todd is no designer even though Martha drools over him every episode. Kim has a few good ideas but is untrained. With some education she might do well. People rant about Robb but I think things were carefully edited to make him look much more villinous then he is. His tears were real when he left and the disappointment hurt him deeply. I htink he has a crusty exterior but a big heart inside. He must have been hurt in life and uses this as a defense mechanism. Personally I think it's a foregone conclusion that Todd will win because it's been preordained so by HGTV. I think this season has been a sham. Todd should have been gone before Lisa! In the first episode. But they obviously want some more eye candy and Todd will do for HGTV. I will not watch his show. I miss Scott, Sparkle Josh and Robb.

Posted by Dee Dee Cee – August 30, 2007 3:29 PM

Hi Everyone... WHAM BAM THANK YOU MAME!!! Well I guess I can start off by saying if there was ever a good time for a house to fall down on the EVIL witch thank the winds it fell on Robb. I just finished watching the last episode and oh my gosh did he act like a total A** I felt really bad for Kim who in my view should get some type of bonus just for being stuck with him. However, that being said she was without a doubt the most professional and patient person I have ever seen. She stuck to her guns and made him see what a real Design Star is all about. How funny guys was the scene when Kim said Robb's measurements were wrong and the carpenter had to fix his mess!!! I was on the floor laughing. WAY TO GO KIM! She not only had a really difficult partner the space they had was by far more challenging than Todd & Wills room. They did a wonderful job on the Living Room space and, found Todd's platform creative however, not to practical considering Wayne Newton and his wife age. I can't wait to see the next show. Also, you've got to check out my man David's Vlog. If only Robb was on Season One. David is a true Design Star! Not to mention how many would like to see David kick the BEJEEBES out of Robb!!! I don't know about you but, I'd pay big bucks to see that SHOW!!!

Posted by Kathie – August 30, 2007 1:54 PM

I did not see season 1, so this is my first journey into the DESIGN STAR series. So many of us bloggers dislike this year's show because of how last year's show was. But I do not bear that burden. (and I am not a HGTV staff person, but I LOVE conspiracy theories.)
Being a DESIGN STAR incorporates so many things, and all of those things should be on display this week, don't you think? As each one goes on their own, it will be great to see how they can make it happen for each of these families.
I believe that we will all see these three in a different light when the show is over. All of our questions should be answered and that will be fun to see.
I like the show and so does my family. We are hooked.
By the way, The turn-table design is do-able by anyone. While it may have been "off the wall", he definitely eliminated the "focal point" controversy that this room held. In fact, he made a "focal point" to view all the other focal points.
Whoever wins, I'll watch their show.

Posted by noone – August 30, 2007 1:30 PM

I've never been so glad to see a contestant go...good riddens Robb! He was so full of himself there was little room left for the real design stars! Good luck Kim & Will!

Posted by Karla – August 30, 2007 11:28 AM

well now there are three..... Todd has good appeal and is energetic and his off the wall ideas while fun might not be practical in most homes i do agree with everyone when i say leave your shirt on todd and stop backflipping around i dont watch HGTV to see that Kim is nice and we see her as a tough cookie after she and Robb got into it.... that was fun to watch Kim can decorate we have seen that ..... NOW maybe this week we will see if she can design as well and finally Will i like him he has been the rock in most situations he can decorate and choose colors with some taste again will be interesting to see how he designs this week will be interesting now the judges..... that one lady needs to take a cold shower jeeze can you slobber any more over Todd? Vern is a leader but im not sure i agree with some of his views the other judge seems to be the most down to earth.....now if David were a judge id believe and not question his thoughts enough said good luck this next challenge ! i do wish Sparkle was still around

Posted by countriboy – August 30, 2007 9:07 AM

Oh my...I just went to Todd's website...oh my...what a weird set of stuff. (In my opinion..) I would NOT vote for Todd...I am also someone who does NOT appreciate the thinking that we only like to watch "eye candy" as someone said it. Put your shirt back on Todd...you are NO David....I would like to watch someone with REAL talent and appeal to the masses....I think either Kim or Will fit the bill. As far as Martha slobbering over Todd...be professional Martha....it is not what you like to look at.

Posted by kelli – August 30, 2007 1:44 AM

Watched the original episode, then Vern's Tips, then watched a rerun. WILL WAS RIGHT ON THE MARK.
HE WAS SUGGESTING VERN'S PREFERRED FURNITURE ARRANGEMENT WHEN TODD INTERRUPTED WITH HIS IDEA ABOUT THE REVOLVING PLATFORM. If Will erred, it was to compromise with Todd on that matter.
WILL, YOU HAVE AN IMMEDIATE SENSE OF GOOD DESIGN WITHOUT HAVING TO RESORT TO A GIMMICK.

Posted by Eddie – August 30, 2007 12:47 AM

I made a point to read each post AND re-watch episode 5 in order to try to see what I may have missed as some posts confused me. I also re-watched all episodes so I could put all work by each contestant fresh into my mind. That said – the shows did move too fast with the double eliminations. Also having mostly team efforts make it difficult to see each contestants true design abilities. We were, however, able to see how each one works as a team player, which is important on a show when he/she will be working with others every show. The “Newton Show” should have been done earlier with the wedding show eliminated. The only good thing I saw, with the wedding show, was how well Will did with being able to make the colors really work together. This, sadly, was underappreciated by all. The judges should have been allowed to see all the project boards and be the ones to choose who would go home.

Enough said about the past. On this episode, I have to say I was pleased that it was Robb that had his show cancelled as out of the four he does have the worst attitude as well as consistently having design problems. Knowing how difficult it is to lay tile, he still chose it for the backsplash. If he hadn’t then the room would have been completely finished, as time would have been available for more placing of accessories and installing the fridge. I blame this on him since from the start he took over control delegating Kim to being the flunky and note-taker. How I wish she could’ve fought that, but I believe she put the Newton’s first and allowed Robb to “rule” so that the room could hopefully get finished. I also do not agree with his placements of the oven and dishwasher. The other side would’ve been a good place for them but time would not allow total re-wiring and plumbing for the dishwasher. He could’ve, however, put the range top and oven on the other side thereby allowing for a better space for the sink and dishwasher. I also personally didn’t care for the square light-colored wood on the rock face. Though I am neither a designer nor a decorator, I would’ve opted for a darker stained wood with some curvature. However, Kat Newton did express her desire for modern and clean and what was chosen for the frame was that.

That said – Kim DID purchase quite a bit more accessories but was unable to implement them in the space because of time being lost due to Robb’s tiling. I feel the table and chairs worked just fine in the room and would’ve looked great if the rest of the accessories could’ve been placed. In addition, this is a kitchen and did not need a dining table. That was already in the other room. Both Robb and Kim did fine hosting with Kim definitely the best – out of all of them. Her “bubbliness” is infectious and her “arm waving” keeps your eyes moving around the room. With her eye for decorating, her upbeat personality, and her fine hosting skills, she would work great with her own show. She could learn to use power tools. I feel she could design very well if only given the chance.

Sadly, Robb could not leave with dignity. I believe his tears were real. It’s too bad he can’t feel as much empathy for others as he can for himself. Being a Scorpio myself, I am disheartened to hear him say he is one. I am nothing like him. I believe his bravado and attitude comes from his insecurities, which Scorpios can be famous for having. I do hope he gets help for this so he does not end up alone in life – which can be a strong fear in a Scorpio.

Todd – ever the big child - did manage to tone it down a bit this week. However, all he really did was work on the platform. That could have been left mainly to the carpenter until the final laying and carpeting of it. He has shown us repeatedly that he can “think outside the box” and his designs are “over the top” but he has yet to incorporate all areas of design into his work. He could have a show – the best name being “Over the Top with Todd”. I look forward to seeing him really work this next week.

Ah – Will. Such a beautiful job with your wedding design. I am so sorry that it wasn’t chosen as I would have loved to see it implemented. If I ever get wealthy enough and if I decide I ever want to marry again, I think you would have to design my wedding reception – if not the whole wedding. Your design style is a bit too modern for me, but your color choices and concepts of cohesiveness and compatibility are outstanding. I think your hosting in this episode was okay – you need to put some pizzazz into it. I loved the way you entered the green room at the end. Put some of that into your hosting and be sure you enunciate. Some of us out here aren’t good with accents and need spoken words to be very clear. I am rooting for you, but I feel that Martha decided from the beginning that Todd was the one. Her attraction for him is palpable – one can actually FEEL it over the television. If the others prevail, however, you will have a chance as I think Vern does actually appreciate and like your work.

Good luck to you three. I look forward to next week.

Posted by Toni – August 29, 2007 11:36 PM

GLAD TO SEE ROBB GO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FINALLY SOMEONE OUT THERE IN HGTV LAND HAD SOME GUTS TO LET GO OF THAT LOSER!
HE HAS NO TALENT EXCEPT FOR HIS HUTZPAH!
NO IF THE WOULD SEE THAT THE ONLY LOGICAL CHOISES FOR THE NEXT DESIGN STAR ARE EITHER WILL OR KIM.
TODD IS ONLY THERE AS EYE CANDY...
OH AND MARTHA...GO TAKE A REALLY COLD SHOWER AND AS FOR THE OTHER TWO FLUNKIES ON THE PANEL...GET A CLUE! HE MAY BE A GREAT CARPENTER BUT HAS NO DESIGNER TALENT WHATSOEVER!!!! NEXT WEEK SHOULD BE INTERESTING TO WATCH!

Posted by Jorge Corchado – August 29, 2007 10:42 PM

I miss Sparkle Josh and still think that he would have made the best design star. I loved his dining room and he had a great, sparkling personality. My next choice is Will. He has very nice designs and he is well spoken. Let's all vote for Will or Kim, who ever makes it into the finals. I agree that Todd must have made it to the final two because he wrote in and wants us to lke him. Of course, my first and favorite is still Sparkle Jsh.

Posted by karen – August 29, 2007 9:49 PM

Noone said: “It seems as though everyone is missing what Todd brings to the table...He is the next TY... “

Todd is the next TY? Yup I agree with that. All the more reason not to vote for him I stopped watching Trading Spaces long ago and one of the reasons was TY. His immature childish behavior is too much.

Ty inspired me too. Inspired me to shut the TV off a Todd show would do the same. I watch HGTV because I like good design not to see an immature man posturing, leaping, doing back-flips bouncing and spinning.
Noone also said; “..Kim would be a carbon copy ” and “Will is too unpolished..”

Unfair! Kim hasn’t had the opportunity to show all she can do but she was terrific in her video. She has a vibrant personality any show she hosted would be far from “carbon copy”.

Will is not “unpolished” he’s REAL. Isn’t that what we want a real person with design talent.

Posted by CCRC – August 29, 2007 9:30 PM

Yippee!Hooray! Robb is gone! What took the judges soooo long to see what the rest of us saw a long time ago. It was time for Robb to take his blotted ego and leave weeks ago. You go Kim! You really stood up to Robb and had a great presentation. I would watch your show. Will, you always impress me with your eye for detail and figuring out the problems before they occur. Step up your presentation. I would watch your show. Todd, you constantly amaze me with your designs. I have to admit, in the beginning I thought you were too over the top. I would watch your show. 3 great designers, next week there will be 2. Unless something drastic happens, I don't think I will be able to vote. Too difficult. Can't wait for next Sunday.

Posted by Julie – August 29, 2007 9:27 PM

Judy wrote:
LWATKINS WHAT HAPPENED TO THE POSTS THROUH THE NIGHT FROM 1:34 A.M. THROUGH 7:57 A.M. AUG 29TH? WHO DECIDES WHAT IS POSTED? IT SEEMS ODD THAT NO ONE BLOGGED OVER SUCH A LARGE SPAN OF TIME. PLEASE REPLY, JUDY
-------------------------------------------------
Hi Judy! There were only three posts between 1:34 a.m. and 7:57 a.m. They were all under the "Josh has heard your cries, Superfans" blog. I guess people decided to sleep last night rather than blog! (Surely not!) :o) The trend has been, at least up to now, that a lot of people blog on Sunday and Monday. (and even on Tuesday) Then it seems to slow down considerably. So, it isn't unusual for "blogging traffic" to be light during the wee hours of a Wednesday morning.

And, to answer your second question...I am the fortunate, (yet sleepy), person who approves the posts. As I have said before, I post everything I possibly can as quickly as I possibly can! I promise! Remember...if you write under the "Anticipation..." blog, that is where your post will appear; if you write under the "Episode 5" blog, that is where your post will appear, etc. If you are unable to EVER find your post, then 1. It didn't make it to me for some reason. (i.e. entered the secret code at the bottom of your screen incorrectly) or 2. The language and/or the content were unacceptable for audiences of all ages. (This doesn't happen very often, but unfortunately, it does happen.) I hope, if you cannot find your posts, that you will try it again in a day or two!
Thanks for the great questions, Judy! I LOVE detail people! And, I can tell you are one! (I am too.) Take care and keep on blogging! :o)lwatkins

Posted by lwatkins – August 29, 2007 8:12 PM

Bye Rob!

While Rob was good for the ratings. He is definitely not the attitude/personality homeowners are looking for in a designer.

DOES ANYONE ON THIS FORUM THINK IT IS A GOOD IDEA TO A TILE JOB IN <2DAY TIME FRAME. MEASURING, CUTS, MEASURING, THIN SET, GROUT TIME. (Did this make sense during any of their challenges? Maybe this is possible if you can work through the night, but with someone calling time everyday, it is not a good use of your time.) AM I MISSING SOMETHING HERE?

As for the remaining challengers, like everyone else I am looking forward to their individual efforts. The remaining 3 have their attributes, but I feel Kim is most deserving of her own show. Todd has the popular vote, but this would be too much of the same look on the network. I would like to see Todd's work this week for an average family. What would Candace have thought of the revolving living space. Gorgeous wood floors covered with this platform. For the money, it would have been great in a loft. Also, could we get a remote to do this rotating. As someone else mentioned, this would be a disaster for kids. '

Will has great decorating ideas. The network team could help him with his presentation skills. They all have worked well in a team situation. The heat is on!

I cannot wait for this week's episode. It will be sad to see any one of them leave, but hopefully the exposure on this program will give any of the challengers who have been eliminated a chance to be successful in their individual endeavors.

GOOD LUCK KIM!!!!!

Posted by Ms. Tee – August 29, 2007 7:34 PM

Please, tell me that Rob was a plant? So what, if Josh happens to "look the part"!!!! He is very talented...................I also like Kim. She has nothing to proove. She has a great personality.

Posted by Goldie Morris – August 29, 2007 6:30 PM

Robb is gone...still not sure whether I regret it or not. The drama and comedy he brought to the show made me laugh, but I never thought he'd make it to the end. I know, the show is not supposed to be about the comedy and drama, but about design. And he was a decent designer despite his lack of people skills. The editors may of cast him in a bad light as I've heard him say during an interview, but he did in fact provide them with some spiteful material to use against him.

Well, now we're down to one designer and two decorators.

I've liked Will's contributions during each challenge and think he's a great color guy. And he's had a lot of valid, rational input in my view regarding other people's ideas. Despite being very likable, I haven't seen him offer up any design ideas of his own. Did I take a bio break during the show and miss them? Lastly, despite liking him alot, I am sure his urban manner of speach would get to me if I had to watch his show for any length of time.

The other decorator, Kim, I just can't make up my mind about. She seems very nice and well spoken, but I fear her actual design input must be on the cutting room floor. The only idea that I can recall even sort of liking was the use of masking tape and paint on her table during the 99 cent store challenge. Everything else seemed much to generic and the paper plates on the wall looked like, well, paper plates on a wall.

Todd, our last actual designer, may have his foibles, but has brought something new and innovative to almost every episode. I'd prefer his shirt on, but do understand that he's working in Las Vegas during the middle of summer where temps are generally over 100 degrees. He seems to be hamming it up for the cameras a great deal, but his energy and enthusiasm would be infectious on his own show providing he could learn when to put a stopper in it. Not sure i'd want a lazy susan in my living room, but it was assuredly a fresh idea I'd not seen attempted before. His wave room may not of been habitable, but as Clive said at the very start "it does not have to be functional" and he showed he has amazing artistic talent to go with his construction skills. The editors also finally showed that he's not all machismo when they displayed his more caring side during the wedding planning and his taking note of the fact that the families should be unified, they needed room for the bride's dress, and that the day belonged to her.

At this point, unless Todd trips and hurls a power tool thru his next client's grandmothers ashes on the mantle...we have our next design star. The one that I'd at least watch. I like Will's color usage, but I can pick that out myself. I like Kim's...well, I like Kim, but I've no idea what else.

Posted by Quijebo – August 29, 2007 6:25 PM

HIP HIP HURRAY ROB IS GONE WHAT TOOK U SO LONG WHAT A POMPUS ?!?@@#?$?. OK TODD GET BUSY AND WIN THIS KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK. I LIKE THIS SHOW AND GLAD TO SEE ALICE AROUND IT WAS HARD LAST YEAR SHE WAS IN MY RUNNING BUT DAVID WAS IT LOVE HIS SHOW THANKS.

Posted by nancy – August 29, 2007 4:51 PM

To Sunny and everyone else who thinks will had bad grammar:

I was actually very proud of Will's presentation when He was showcasing the living room he and Todd designed. Please review that video once more and notice that Will did not make one grammar mistake in it. This just says to me that Will is capable of switching to "proper" English when it matters most. (i.e. like when he is hosting a national TV show) Cut the guy some slack. He like all of us just does some things differently in private vs. in public. That thing for him is how he speaks. With videos around him 24/7 we are just seeing the real him, but I believe he knows and will use proper grammar when he is hosting his own show!!!

P.S. Why does it take so long for our comments to be posted even if we've posted to the blog before?

Posted by Bisi – August 29, 2007 4:19 PM

I finally checked out Todd's website and although he is an impressive artist, the "indoor spaces" on his website were not all that impressive. In fact, if you take a look at his blog you will see that the indoor photos are of his home. So far in the competition he has done nothing to prove that he can put together a useable, functional room. Yes, the "lazy Susan" was an inventive solution to the question of furniture placement in a room with various focal points, but as most people have stated, it's not very practical for the everyday home. Will did all the real work of making that room look as good as it did. I am anxious to see what he does in an individual challenge in an actual client's home. Next week will be his chance to prove himself. He's not my favorite at this point because he really turned me off in the beginning with his childish antics. He's no David! David has an infectious energy. Todd's is just a little over the top and kind of annoying. I think if he got his own show whether I'd watch or not would depend on what type of show it is because I wouldn't watch it just because he's hosting.

Posted by Mindy – August 29, 2007 3:58 PM

Of course there is probably some editing going on to make the show exciting but Robb sure gave them a lot to work with, didn't he!

Posted by Karen – August 29, 2007 3:26 PM

I understand Robb is gone. After being on the chopping block in the first TWO shows, he never should have made it into the final four anyway. Of course, DO NOT FORGET that TODD SHOULD HAVE BEEN on the chopping block for being the dynamic force behind that fake Tuscan kitchen – and, yet, his work was PRAISED in that one! Go figure! (By the way, Robb – why is it all right for you to blog and not others? Blogging once or even a few times a week on HGTV doesn’t mean people take no time to “go outside and breathe the air” – or however you put it. Regardless, good luck to you.)

In all fairness to every contestant on this show, I truly believe that the producers and editors CHOSE whom to make look bad, whom to make look good, and even others to do very little with. I mean, just imagine if YOU were followed around all day every day with a camera – don’t you think there would be BOTH POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE footage of you? Exactly. Yes, choices must be made about what to throw to the cutting room floor, BUT I’m CERTAIN that bias plays a pretty big role here. For instance, does anyone remember last year with Temple? Remember how many times she talked about her “kids’ father”? (Many MANY times!) WELL, with all the times she said this, we didn’t hear that she actually had been MARRIED to him until LONG AFTER she was eliminated (final show)! You see, regardless of political correctness, the fact remains that, good or bad, many people still think negatively about a woman who has children with a man she’s not married to. That’s reality. And I believe the producers/editors knew this, and that they CHOSE this direction for her image. This just didn’t seem like pure coincidence.

I’d also like to say that I looked again at Lisa’s garage. Remember the names spelled backwards? Maybe I’m kinda late to the party on this, but I realized that she (probably) wanted it to represent the contestants going into the door, as though we were seeing them from the back. I realized (again, late) that this was pretty cool. If she’s an artist, though, maybe it would have been a better, more impressive idea to do some sort of artist’s rendering of their outlines from behind or something. I think that really would have been cool. In any case, good luck to you, Lisa. I think you were eliminated waaaay too early. She seemed talented and personable.

But, alas, after all this, the truth is that I only watched about five minutes of Challenge 5. I barely even care about this show any longer. In fact, I'm convinced that many of the blogs here are coming straight from the HGTV employees. After the producers panicked from last week's show of anger, and not to mention threats from its audience to stop watching, I’m really thinking that they told their employees to blog to make it look like their ratings didn’t drop. (Come on – almost 400 comments by TUESDAY of this week (!), and from an audience that largely said it would no longer watch? They only had 600 all together last week! You guys really think your audience is stupid, don’t you?! And so many of those comments are positive! Hmm. Sudden change of heart from your audience … or manipulation?)

Okay, conspiracy theories aside, just like I wouldn't watch Jaws without Robert Shaw or Pirates of the Caribbean without Johnny Depp, I will not watch Design Star without Josh Johnson. He was the biggest source of life and light this show had, and now that he's gone, I couldn't care less. And, yes, I know that Josh, himself, graciously asked that we watch the rest of the season – BUT – just as the rest of us are held accountable for a job poorly done, Design Star producers and judges need to be held accountable, as well. If a show is bad, don’t watch. PERIOD. It’s the ONLY way things will change.

I do wish well to Will and Kim. I think they’re both good designers and good people. Todd MAY be a good person, but he’s largely come off as a tall baby, walking around doing and saying anything he felt like, just like a baby does. I will say, though, that if he did an exhibition of his ARTWORK, I’d love to see it – and I’d probably buy something!

However, as for a Todd show (which is what I believe HGTV has been gunning for all along) - judging by what your CORE audience (women and gay men) has been saying for five weeks now, the only way his show will make it is if it’s “The Todd’s Weekly Watch Me Design a Room for the Naked Antonio Banderas Show.”

And, finally, what I truly believe are wise words to any future contestants - I know you’ll be followed around with a camera for hours/days/weeks, BUT whatever you do, keep on your best behavior. Maybe the REST of the world likes nasty, but HGTV’s audience likes nice people.

Anyway, I’m still a big fan of HGTV; I just don’t like the way the producers of this show have approached it, and I hate what the judges did to it this year. Bad bad bad. See you in the finale.

Posted by Kathy Gardner – August 29, 2007 3:02 PM

I loved Design Star 1 so much! This season has seemed too rushed - with double eliminations everytime. A few got booted too soon. And, all the team challenges is really unfair. That shows who's bossy and who are the team players, but it doesn't show individual capability. I would have loved to see what Sparkle Josh would have done - along with a few others. Kim is a perfect example of allowing a little time and the true designer they are will be shown. Todd is creative, but not practical. I haven't seen him do anything that was really about function. Will has a nice personality and is likable, but I don't think he came across commanding enough as a host. Rob, I'm glad is gone - if he'd won, I would not be watching his show. So, that leaves Kim as the winner for me. She's likable, has good design taste, and she really popped when she hosted the room. Great surprise.

Posted by DD – August 29, 2007 2:43 PM

Watched the 5th episode with Robb doing the home for Wayne Newton. He is an egotistical, arrogant ba----- who doesn't deserve anymore chances with the show. He so obnoxious and overbearing. Glad he was voted off for his behavior and inability to get along with his peers.

Posted by jane – August 29, 2007 2:31 PM

This has been a disappointing year for this series. Unlike last year, we've seen little of the individual's abilities and they were given less time to work on the very important 'presentation' stage which David started very weak in.

Frankly none of the finalists are people I would hire to design anything in my home and the judges' apparent favorite, Todd, has yet to design anything PRACTICAL. His rotating seating area was a joke and likely wouldn't pass any safety inspections.

HGTV used to be about design the homeowner can USE. Ideas, approaches, information. Will and Kim far exceed Todd in this respect, though they are more excellent interior decorators than designers.

All said, a disappointing series falling far below our expectations. We flip back and forth with a PBS series that is on at the same time this year. Little interest in this format.

Posted by Bruce P – August 29, 2007 1:59 PM

The lazy susan concept is great. What they should have done is incorporated a simple lock brake system (which you can buy already installed on many caster sets) in order to keep susan still! Also it would have been more pleasing to the eye to have rounded it off vs. having the harsh lines and corners, also safer when children are present. And I'd be more concerned about a few adults who had a few too many than a couple of 8 yr old boys. HA!

Glad to see Rob go. He may have some great talent, but it is definitely overshadowed by his brashness. Even if he was UBER talented & won, I wouldn't watch his show b/c of his behavior. He makes some smart choices, but also some dumb mistakes. Wedding? Not doing a scaled drawing? Kitchen? Not measuring accurately for the appliances to fit? Seriously. He needs to step back and take a look at himself b/c this show made him look like a total jerk.

Posted by spagmc – August 29, 2007 1:21 PM

I really looked forward to this series after last year. I think the editors felt they needed to play up the negative interactions to have it be interesting television. However, that is not what people watch HGTV for. We want to see design ideas. We want to see what the contestants can do. Instead the editors chose to play close up shots of the judges reactions and the negative interchanges between the contestants....taking up too much of our valuable time with them. You are getting into negative reality TV mode for your viewers. It is evident as I read the comments that people want to get involved with the design process instead. Obviously HGTV will have to re- adjust how they "design" next year's show to keep us watching. Why did they eliminate so many so fast??? What is the trifecta of talent needed by the designers?

Posted by Vickie – August 29, 2007 1:02 PM

IWATKINS WHAT HAPPENED TO THE POSTS THROUH THE NIGHT FROM 1:34 A.M. THROUGH 7:57 A.M. AUG 29TH? WHO DECIDES WHAT IS POSTED? IT SEEMS ODD THAT NO ONE BLOGGED OVER SUCH A LARGE SPAN OF TIME. PLEASE REPLY, JUDY

Posted by judy – August 29, 2007 12:35 PM

What are you thinking when you say Will would not be a good host because of his grammar?? Let me see, would it not benefit HGTV to have an African American host that speaks graciously and calmly, without slandering others??? The demographics for the show would sore, not to say "normal" people would watch. What? Do we have a bunch of British snobs writing in to this blog????

Posted by ssam – August 29, 2007 12:28 PM

I believe that the producers of HGTV should look long and hard before they allow Todd to have a show. The people who watch their shows are more along the lines of 'common' folks. You know us, we are the ones who can't afford to hire designers so we turn to HGTV for ideas and how to's. Really, Todd's designs are so far out there!! Who would want to live with anything that Todd has done to this point? His designs are more befitting a restaurant or bar setting not someones home. And Kim, as nice as she is hasn't shown enough talent (except hosting) to warrant a full season of shows. Actually, I don't believe any of the so 'challenges 'have allowed the designers to demonstrate their talents on an individual basis. This season has been more like a spin-off of Jerry Springer than a design challenge show and last Sunday was my last episode for this season. Expected better from HGTV.

Posted by Debra – August 29, 2007 11:57 AM

Here’s a tally from the top-rated page (http://ratemywork.hgtv.com/) for the designers in Challenge 5.

NUMBER OF TOP RATED DESIGNS (score 4 - 5)

Will 3
Kim 2
Todd 2
Robb 0.

While Todd has 2 top-rated TEAM designs, I note that most viewers disliked Todd’s design contributions (the quarter pipe and the lazy susan). Those projects got a top rating despite Todd, not because of him.

Vern’s tips (http://www.hgtv.com/hgtv/design_star_vern/) soundly criticize Todd’s lazy susan. Yet Todd sat in the Green Room while Will, the only designer to have 3 top-rated rooms--the only remaining designer to get a top rating working alone, faced elimination again. Todd will not face elimination next week no matter how absurd and how tacky his next design is. Robb would still be in the competition today if Kim had not forced the judges to confront his childish inability to control himself.

Yes, judge bias is apparent, but it’s not affirmative action. It’s a pro white dude bias.

Posted by KDT – August 29, 2007 11:09 AM

I loved the show last season! Almost everyone put 110% into the show. I picked David and I still watch his show. I love the judges! This season has me a little confused. I agree with some of the other people. Who picked these people? You did not have a bunch of raging crazy people last season and it was so exciting to watch. I think people really could not wait to see the exciting designs that the last group produced. I feel this new group (not all) lacked respect for each other. It takes a few shows for the designers to relax and show their real personalities. WELL... I will continue to watch the show but I am not sure which one I would like to see win. Good luck to all of them!

Posted by karen – August 29, 2007 10:58 AM

It seems as though everyone is missing what Todd brings to the table...He is the next TY. When TY started, he was a carpenter, but he had personality and added to the show greatly. As the show (Trading Spaces) progressed, Ty started designing more and more.
Todd is like Ty and will do great things on his show. Building is an important feature, looking at a room and thinking out of the box makes him a winner.
There are many decorating shows and Kim would be a carbon copy of that. Will is too unpolished, but such a gentle soul that he is love-able. But he is not a STAR.
Ty inspired me years ago and Todd will do the same for the new viewers. Start thinking of names for his show...LAID BACK DESIGN....DESIGN SPIN....

Posted by noone – August 29, 2007 10:20 AM

Design Star, Season 2....same drama as last year...same lack of individual challenges....
BUT, HGTV knows they have an audience looking at all the blogs. And what else are we going to watch, the same reruns of House Hunters over and over?

Maybe next year ( if there is a Design Star 3) it might be nice to take it to a College Campus! I'm sure a lot of students would enjoy some Design Ideas for their dorms (talk about a design challenge!)...and maybe we would get to see an OUTDOOR design (refreshing).

Posted by Pret07 – August 29, 2007 9:57 AM

This has been the most confusing season and a mean season. Rob was out of control - absolutely obnoxious! So glad he's gone. I also loved Sparkle Josh. I hope Will wins and if he doesn't, I hope he and Sparkle Josh open a business together. They are what this show should be about!

Posted by Geri – August 29, 2007 8:57 AM

i think rob is an actor put on the show to make it more interesting-so ud get fired up about him.loved martha-shes so cute .id like to see todd dressed up and not so energetic/makes me feel like a slug

Posted by carole – August 29, 2007 8:51 AM

Ok here's a question for us. My husband wanted to know are all these people really designers? Or did the show put people on to see what the real designers would do with their personalities? For example Robb. He can't measure worth crap. If he did so many kitchens how did they turn out? Todd surfer boy high energy dare devil. What's up with swirling in the living room? So what do you think. Are they all real designers?

Posted by Denise – August 29, 2007 8:28 AM

Sigh.. I am getting a bit tired of watching Vern run the show. It seemed that way to me on the first Design Star.. Vern loved David's stuff right from the start, and even though David's hosting abilities weren't the best, it didn't cause him any trouble. Well, this time it's the same - does anyone remember Vern saying to Todd - "you're not a Design Star, your a
Rock Star (designer). And also. if any of the judges disagree, Vern's decision seems to hold sway over the whole thing. I could tell several weeks back that they were going to go along with
Vern and choose Todd the winner; I can't really picture people in general wanting quarter or half pipes in their living rooms. Wonder how long his show will last? I heard David say that his show just got picked up for another 26 episodes, but his show appeals to the viewers in general. Don't quite see Todd's show doing the same, does anyone else?

Posted by RenieBug – August 29, 2007 7:57 AM

Oh wow, what a show. Yes, I found myself wondering what "Sparkle" could have been added to Wayne Newton's house, but still... watching Robb dig his own grave on TV was worth every minute. I was so proud of Kim for how she handled the whole situation. I also appreciated the footage of Robb doing a horrific tile job. His line about not having the time to do it carefully was priceless.

I also get a kick out of how the "experts" boast about how much experience they have. First Neeraja with her "over 6000 sq feet of tiling" and now Robb with his "tens of thousands of dollars worth of kitchen rennovations." Isn't tens of thousands of dollars worth, oh, about ONE kitchen makeover? And the folks who have no professional design experience to boast of are the ones with the most practical design input! I hope someone handed Robb a bucketful of clues on his way out the door. He could use them, wherever he goes.

As for the ones left behind... I can foresee my heart being broken again over the next two weeks. Todd has seriously grown on me, in his off-the-wall shirtless surfer way. I may not love his designs or want them in my house, but I bet every episode of his show would have something really cool and fun-looking in it.

Kim and Will are my favorites, though. I absolutely love Will's down-to-earth practical analysis of a design, but I'm afraid he going to have a hard time out-hosting Kim. And Kim... Kim. Wow. You could not have a better partner or host (except Sparkle. *sniff*), but I still want a better idea of how she handles the next challenge. Heck, I want to see how they ALL do next week. They're each great unexpected-problem-solvers. I can't wait for more!

Posted by Karen Momorella – August 29, 2007 1:34 AM

I am very glad that Robb got out of the show. If he were a talented designer he should have also shown a better communication way; I mean, there were supposed to be two teams working "together" and everytime I saw him, he pretended to be the most knowledgeable, etc etc.

Here's my own prediction:

The blondie wins and the other two go bye bye. Wanna bet?

End of the story. HGTV wants people that are cute, sexy, and as far as not being 100% talented, well, do you actually think that all the designers who work on HGTV get no help?

Oh! wait, and who in the hell does Vern Yip think he is? Please! I have seeing his work and if he thinks he is talented, sorry, think again!

The judges should really learn from a real awesome interior designer, CANDICE OLSON from Devine Design. For next season, get her as a judge!

Posted by Dama_fina – August 29, 2007 1:16 AM

I am absolutely sickened by the fact that a good number of people keep commenting on Kim and Will's skin color in an attempt to say that they are not deserving of their final three status. What a gross and totally inappropriate thing to say! YUCK!!! Here's the truth, ALL of the eleven contestants were very talented or they would have never been chosen. Just because your favorite may have been voted off does not entitle you to spew hatred and racism. Take your poisonous thoughts elsewhere, please!

Posted by chular – August 29, 2007 12:41 AM

I am soo glad to see Robb go!!! I think he has always been a jerk. He may have some talent, but he has absolutely no people skills and no respect for anyone else. My favorite this season is Will, but after the past couple of episodes, I fear he will be gone soon. Shine Will shine!! Lastly, I don't think any of the contestants this year hold a candle to season one. There is not a designer in season two who could ever hope to be half as good as David B. He was my favorite from the beginning. He has everything it takes to succeed; talent, talent and more talent. I would love to have one of his paintings. One bit of advice for season two: WOW us!! Show us what you got!

Posted by jamey – August 29, 2007 12:31 AM

Everyone is so glad Robb is gone and I have to admit he's been tagged as an unsensitive, insensitve hot-head, however, I just watched an interview done by the Centinel and came away with a different perspective. Television is all about 'editing' and creation-much like what designers do. He opened my eyes with respect to just how hard all the designers work, the long sleepless hours combined with the pressure. I have a new found sympathy for all of them. Robb did elaborate about his 'sliver' of an argument he had with Kim in the car-providing a broader background as to what the 'real' story was. Not to mention that Kim has had no formal training with respect to design-such as laying out templates, measuring, or what type of screws, tools and such are needed for any type of job.
I really enjoy and look forward to this show, but it's becoming more of a 'survivor' type show and the players are, (as Robb stated) being edited to appear as to be playing a role. Such a shame for each and everyone of the designers. I think 24 hours to design/build a kitchen was way, way unfair. I wish the show would give more 'individual' challenges-the idea of team challenges just serves to pit individuals against one another, which in turn, makes for 'better TV' to those that count the beans at HGTV. Sparkle Josh? I went to his website and yes, there's definately a dyanmic there, however, he's better at designing himself, selling himself (what a killer personality-I love it!) than what he did on the show. I just can't stop comparing last season to this season. Last year was about 'bitchiness'...this year is more about being hostile. Or at least, the editors/producers of this show have made it seem that way. Robb's interview put a whole different spin on the show and me thinks I'll be watching it in a different light come next Sunday!
Robb says Todd will probably win. Kim doesn't have the base talent(s) (my opinion) and while I love Will's work, he should assert himself a bit more!

Posted by geemartin – August 28, 2007 11:51 PM

I am a huge Design Star fan. I thought that season 2 would never start. But season 2 is not captivating me the way season 1 did. It seems that this season is more about quirky personalities than design talent.

And while teamwork is an important part of the job, eliminating people (sometimes 2 at a shot) on group challenges that do not really allow all the members to significantly contribute, seems like a cop-out. Prime example, the Las Vegas wedding. How was anyone but Robb supposed to shine under the Robb-Nazi's leadership? It invites conflict and backstabbing.

If they need to eliminate multiple people in a challenge, I would prefer to see the challenges broken in two pieces (develop & present a design & execute their own design) and cancel one designer in each part. Group challenges should allow each designer to contribute significantly.

As for the last show, I have been hoping Robb would be cancelled for weeks. FINALLY!! Relief from the rants and raves. Kim deserves an Emmy, and possibility nomination to sainthood for her cool, calm, assertiveness. You go girl!

It is a very close call, but my favorite at this time is Todd. He is so outside the box that it is refreshing. Yes, a lazy susan livingroom is not particularly practical, but this was a guest house. As a guest, it would be real fun to stay there. A great design to visit, but I would not want to live there. Or maybe I would!

Can't wait to see the next two episodes! I think Kim, Will and Todd have some surprises in store for us.

Posted by JasLady – August 28, 2007 11:51 PM

I really think this season was ruined. As I and many others have mentioned too many double eliminations. We all had favorites that left too soon. Mine were Scott (mainly) and Christina. I was not that sad about Sparkle Josh (sorry).
For those who are left:
Todd - he will probably win. He has "the Look", the judges have gone all "gaga" over him. I have warmed up to him and he'll be fine. I still did not like his "picture" during the 99 cent challenge. It was art...not design.
Kim - she'll be ok. She has a degree in broadcasting and would make a nice ok show. I like her personality. She seems sweet and enduring.
Will- I think he is really talented and has not been given the shot he should. Robb lied about him. But if you listen to Will's explanation of things he knows what he is talking about. He does not have a chance of winning, which is sad. He will probably be eliminated Sunday. He would be a good addition to any show. He is not a "cookie cutter" designer, but a good designer just the same.

Posted by Teresa R – August 28, 2007 11:48 PM

Now that I'm on a roll, I'm going to Pontificate... (forgive me, God, Grandmapumpkin and Islandnomad!) I continually see comments about how Robb-noxious is a wonderful, talented, caring and competent designer. Are we watching the same program? I didn't know that shouting obscenities at everyone, hiding things from colleagues, lying to clients, blaming others for self-incompetency in not knowing how to take proper measurements and drawing to scale, and being a contentious person in general, would be considered positive personality traits. Also, people have been writing, in poorly spelled and syntaxed English, that Will needs to be taught how to speak in a correct manner. This is a small, easily remedied problem, folks; Will has a skill, as well as a gift, in being able to work with nearly everyone, in a quiet, efficient and positive manner. If Robb was as wonderful as he portrayed himself, he could have quietly sailed through every single phase, without any of the self-aggrandizements, and he would be the person to challenge! He is all bluster and no delivery, again and again. "I've done tens of thousands of dollars worth of kitchens!" Really? Then, old boy, why can't you figure out how to use a measuring tape correctly? And a WALL oven placed on the floor? How do you get the door to open fully? You didn't come through with your boasts in Challenge 1, for which you were in the bottom two. You destroyed the cabinets of the kitchen in Challenge 2, again finding yourself in the bottom two. You copied David Bromstad's style and re-used the tasteless design from your audition video in Challenge 3, knowing that your phony good manners would be fawned upon by the three judges. You bonded with a horrid bully in Bruno, who steamrolled over his fiancee in the design for the truly tacky reception (will they call on you to design the courtroom, when they divorce?), in challeng 4. You lied about the jukebox, didn't deliver on the poker chip pillars, you didn't measure anything and produced a terrible travesty of a wedding reception, and then you lied about Will. In Challenge 5, you attempted to bully Kim, again loudly swearing at her, when she stood up to you, and you didn't know what you were doing in that kitchen. You have proven yourself to be a bully with no taste. Period. Go in peace; the rant has ended... :o)

Posted by Leon – August 28, 2007 11:44 PM

I was devastated that Robb was booted off the show- of the four remaining he is the only real talent. Of course the producers manipulated the clips to portray Robb as the "villian" it makes good TV. He had a great personality for hosting and again appeared to be the only designer of the final four. What a shame Scott and Sparkle Josh were booted off. The final three should have been Josh, Scott and Robb. I agree with Robb- the judges have made a huge mistake. The remaining three are mediocre at best!

Posted by Dawn K – August 28, 2007 11:29 PM

Just one thing to say - can Todd not manage to find a shirt??? Seriously dude, you are not all that. It is just pathetic. We are sick of seeing your arm pit hair. Want to host a show? Try acting like an adult. If you won, there'd be a whole series full of your arm pit hair??? It is hard to take you seriously as a designer.

Posted by Chelle – August 28, 2007 11:09 PM

Well the judges proved a very important point--designers are business people and in order to get ahead in business you need to treat other people with respect and be capable of working as part of a team. Robb has real talent, but he was unable to execute his designs with diplomacy. To have made him the Design Star would have meant "to hell with the customer;" and, as everyone knows, in business the customer is King (or Queen).

Among the three contestents left, each has the potential to have his or her own show. Let's keep in mind that were not looking to replace or duplicate Color Splash (I hope not--David B. is so classy, talented and gracious). Rather, HGTV will have to use the talents of its next Design Star to educate and please the public in a new way. With the challenges in the real estate world, involving a decline in home sales and tightening of lending policies, its likely that a new Design Star show might focus more on making bold changes to a home on a limited budget. To that end, both Will and Kim have great decorating abilities, they are good shoppers and can give you big bang for your buck. They both are more decorator types than pure designers. Kim has better presentation skills which is essential to being a television show host; her style is more urban and would be best used in smaller spaces like apartments and condominiums where subtle changes make a big difference. Hey HGTV, have you thought about the fact that even renters need to learn how to design a space--renters are more than 1/2 of America! Will is more of an "I'll make over your single family house and make it look good!" kind of guy, and he would--but if he wants to be the Design Star, he will have to step up his presentation skills; forget grammer, who cares about that--he just needs to be able to cogently break down and explain his design choices with style. Now the sleeper is Todd. Yes he is "over the top" in his style, but that ability, if properly focused could make for an amazing Design Star program. I can see Todd taking crummy spaces and if he listens carefully to his clients making changes that are so revolutionary that the home dweller will feel like they just bought their dream house, when all they did was make-over the property that they already live in. Todd also has the charisma and the kindness that is needed to work with clients. I think the judges and America have some tough choices ahead. Among 3 stars, only 1 Design Star will emerge. Will that Design Star be a Decorator/Designer, an urban type, a house maker-over, or a dream styler. It could be any of the 3 of them!

Posted by Todd 'n LA – August 28, 2007 11:02 PM

I have to say, I loved hating Robb about as much as I hated loving him. He had the bad boy brashness about him that just made me go gaa-gaa for him. Did I think he'd win? No, but I am upset to see him go!

Posted by Ambyr K. – August 28, 2007 10:50 PM

After watching another episode of "Mr. Loudmouth Robb" being just a royal butt to Kim, I had to say this. Kim deserves a show of her own due to the fact that she handle a very bad situation in a great way. All Robb did was turn people all over watching his foolishness against him with his mouth. I don't know who the winner will be but Todd put your shirt back on because we already have a GREAT DAVID BROMSTAD!!!! :) I love HGTV and watch it a good deal of the time. I think my hubby thinks HGTV is costing him money...LOL Can't wait for the next DESIGN STAR show!!!!

Posted by GrannyGirl – August 28, 2007 10:42 PM

I agree with the person who said that season two has been a bad sequel to a great movie. I don't even think these finalists are as good as those who got eliminated early "last season". Nevertheless, I must pick my favorite and that would be Will. I think Todd is a wolf in sheeps clothing and that deep down he doesn't have any better of a personality that Robb. If he had built that monstrosity of a rotating platform for my home that first thing I would have said was "what the hell is that thing"? "Whatever it is, it has GOT TO GO". I know deep down Will had to think that thing was "stupid", but he is kind and went along with it. Thankfully Will's furniture and accessories he purchased made that ridiculous platform look better. I'm not too impressed with Kim either, she's very nice but I can't see her running her own show. So there you have it, Will is the man!! IMO.

Posted by lynn – August 28, 2007 10:32 PM

I only watched Sunday because Sparkle said to, but was glad - like everyone else - to see Robb go. I didn't see last season so I didn't have much to go on as far as how this was done vs last year, but it sure didn't seem to give any of the designers much of a chance to show what they could do on their own. And why do we have to get to episode 5 before we are talking about HOSTING talents? Isn't this about having your own SHOW? Shouldn't the other contestants have been given a chance to show THEIR hosting talents before being booted. Surely, hosting would have to be a large part of having a show. Maybe not, though - I've tried watching a couple of last year's winner, David, shows and what a yawn! He may be cute but he has zero personality and his paintings are awful.

And Vern. Where does he get off being so snotty - from Trading SPACES, for crying out loud. The tackiest show on HGTV. Of course he was much less snotty after he got Sparkle eliminated - must have sensed real competition there. It's going to be hard to swallow his supposed altruism on the new show after watching him in action on this one.

I don't think this show will go another season if this is how it's going to be - the shows weren't fun, everybody looked miserable..yuk
Can't you do something fun and happy? How about some Sparkle?

Posted by sandra – August 28, 2007 10:26 PM

OK. So we think Rob was a long time in going. I agree that he needed to go. After he called Kim a moron, and said, 'if she had half a brain'. WOW! If he made it to the finals, noone would have voted for him because he was such a punk.
But to say Sparkles was a better designer than Rob? No way. Look at the level of their work. Rob was a good designer. Granted, he couldnt measure accurately. But he could design.
I have agreed with the judges decisions to this point, except for our surfer boy builder. He can create, but design? Hmmm....
Will is hands down the best designer on the show. But he doesn't have much personality. I think this season will go to Kim.

Posted by Rebecca A – August 28, 2007 10:04 PM

Yes Rob is gone. What an egomaniac. He just doesn't get it does he? Todd will be next. The show is going way too fast. I agree last years show was better. Well, I for one am releived, and looking forward to the next show.

Posted by wendy – August 28, 2007 9:41 PM

I agree with Sunny’s comments. Will does make grammar errors (incidentally, Sunny misspelled grammar). He will need help if he gets to host a show but he nonetheless has talent and charm. I would hire him over the others to do my house. I love his sense of style in all the rooms he has done. He is my pick, poor grammar and all. Todd’s idea are just over the top. I would admire his creativity with form if the function was there…it is not. I would not want any of Todd’s design ideas in my house!

Posted by EFUENT – August 28, 2007 9:34 PM

Does anyone know the timing of the taping of these shows? HOw long ago did these episodes happen? Were they over a period of time or all done at once?
Love the show.

Posted by Terese – August 28, 2007 9:23 PM

Am I the only one who liked Robb? He may have been a bit arrogant, but he had fantastic design ideas. Kim is the one who started the whole fight thing anyway. Little miss innocent may not be as innocent as you all think. She knew exactly how to egg Robb on to make him look bad. I want a designer with style, pazzazz and enough arrogance to believe in his designs. The wedding couple had it right. He is the best designer - hands down. Bring Robb back.

Posted by Connie Matty – August 28, 2007 9:16 PM

Robb was "robbed". I just have one question... Why is Kim even still in the running? As far as I am concerned she was as responsible as was Neeraja for the tile disaster in the first kitchen and the paper plate cut-outs were pathetic. Were I a judge she would have been so fired at that point. Next, what is the deal with Will? No personality, presence or design skills. Is this "Design Star" or "Affirmative Action Design Star"? You have two really weak African American designers still in the running and two earlier prize winning designers (Robb and Josh Sparkle) booted off the show. What's up with that?

Posted by Sonia – August 28, 2007 9:13 PM

I love HGTV. Design Star I was great. This one is not. They really don't have much to pick from and I don't think I would watch any of these persons show. I love David Bromstad. I love Color Splash. Davod has class. That is something that is lacking this season.

Posted by CSpraul – August 28, 2007 9:05 PM

Doriank wrote;“ CLEARLY JUDGES ARE BASING DECISIONS ON WHO THEY LIKE.”
Boy do I agree with that!

Since Robb certainly wasn’t a favorite of HGTV fans why then did the judges keep him on so long?
He behaved like a little tyrant with a mean spirited divisive attitude and sharp tongue. His design skill/sense is nil to mediocre. Examples; a beat up Chevy door and plethora of cheap pillows, dreadful crackled cabinet doors, crooked horrible tiling job, amber walls with sea-foam green tile with black grout ugh, planning to put the dishwasher underneath the sink, and placing the oven practically on the island floor.
This coming from a person who boasts he’s done hundreds of $10,000 kitchens. Incidentally not many designers do $10,000 kitchens. That sounds more like contractors cabinets with laminate counter top and conventional appliances.

Robb should have been gone on day one. I don’t believe Robb is a real designer. Personally he struck me more as a rough carpenter who probably worked with some real designers and thought he could pull this off. Christina and Josh J. exhibited more design skill and they were booted?

As for the judges I think they have already decided they want juvenile Todd to win. That became more evident Sunday when Clive asked the judges after viewing Todd’s hosting video; ”would you watch a Todd show”? To which Martha gushed she would. She needs to take a cold shower! Notice Clive did not ask the judges if they’d watch a Will or Kim show.Hmmm!

Makes one wonder were they trying to keep psycho Robb to the final two? Then Todd would have been a shoo-in since the public would never select Robb.

Have to say this years Design Star pales in comparison to last year.
I enjoy watching David’s show Color Splash he has talent and real design skills conversely Todd’s off the wall innovative ideas are not functional for the average homeowner. Also with or without his shirt a leaping, twirling, tumbling Todd might be entertaining on Venice Beach or at a circus but that isn’t what the average HGTV viewer wants. Enough already! Put your shirt on Todd.

BTW I hated the revolving platform, putting that “lazy Susan” in the middle shrunk the room crowding the furniture in the middle of the platform. Also some serious safety issues like sharp corners, raised up quite a bit from the floor and no locks to stabilize the platform. It just didn’t fit the space at all. Poor space planning Todd!

A good designer needs to be able to appeal to a wide range of clients Todd is too one dimensional. As for me I’m rooting for Will and Kim to be the final two.

Posted by CCRC – August 28, 2007 9:05 PM

There is no 'e' in the word grammar. Guess we're all human 'eh???

Posted by Katie – August 28, 2007 8:55 PM

Doesn't surprise me to hear that Rob said the HGTV's producers edited things to make him appear as a villian.

Insecure, manipulative people make excuses and cast the blame to others for their behaviors. We heard the things he said and the tone of voice he used. We saw him hiding items in the 99 cent store. We saw the disrespect he showed the others. When he was around ANYONE, there was always drama. Not so with the others. I think he must enjoy being a difficult person. What a sad person he must be to want to make others around him feel bad. If he was a nice guy....there wouldn't have been any material to use to make him look like bad. It was easy to make him look like a villian because all the material was there and HE provided it!

Miss you so much Sparkle! I'm making a wish you will get your own show despite Design Star! You are the most fun to watch! I would never miss your show! I'm like everyone else in hoping Will wins so maybe he will pick you to do the Ebony and Ivory Show starring Will Smith and Josh Johnson!

Cindy

Posted by Cindy – August 28, 2007 8:55 PM

Bravo!!! I am so glad that the judges finally saw the real Robb. A "star" is more than a good designer! They must be a good person,too. I found Robb to be very rude and demeaning in his treatment of team mates, egotistical, and down right mean spirited. He is not a team player. This has been a growing trend with him throughout the whole program. Frankly, if he had won, I would not watch the show. TV already has enough rudeness and disfunctional programing. I watch HGTV to get away from that scene. What we need in the world of design TV is not only an exciting talent but a genuinely kind and engaging personality. The remaining three have those qualities.

Posted by Beth – August 28, 2007 8:41 PM

Why does Todd feel the need to take his shirt off?
Please leave it on.

Posted by Kay – August 28, 2007 8:33 PM

Was anyone else insulted by the t-shirt Todd wore in front of the judges? I am perhaps an old fogey, but there is a time and place to display one's machismo lunacy, and in front of the judges on national tv might not be the place. Sorry, but that one slip will keep me from voting for Todd no matter how well he does. I actually prefer Will's quiet wisdom or Kim's bubbling enthusiasm.

Posted by Tricia – August 28, 2007 8:30 PM

Oh My!!!!I wish I had a dime for all the negatives regarding Mr.ROBB.However,although,Robb has some manic issues,he still is talented.I believe if Rob gets help,He could have his own show.
Please allow me to express my opinion on the last three standing.Kim is a nice gal with patience of JOB.She would be great as an assistant on a show. Will has the same design over and over again.His showmanship is a 0. Tod is a great carpenter and artist.But he lacks class and showmanship.You can coach to a certain extant,but a person either has it or not.Most people would not want to hear Dude in conversation.And my thoughts on the winners are..Will will be gone!! Kim and Todd will move ahead,Todd will win. Hopefully,next season there will be contestants 45 and up.I still want to be a contestant.... Sincerely,Letitia

Posted by Letitia – August 28, 2007 8:03 PM

I am a true HGTV fan and I have watched Desing Star from the beggining and I just finished watching episode #5 and I am totally disgusted. From the beggining Rob and Todd have shown that they are the contestants that posses the talent and the creativity to be the next Desing Star. I think that by cancelling Rob's show, Todd will not have much competition! I was really looking forward to see the final competition between the two of them. I believe this episode should have been each designer competing by themselves, so that we can get to see what each of them can do. Right now I think that the judges killed the show and I no longer desire to watch this mess...

Posted by Rafael – August 28, 2007 7:57 PM

As I said before I am a huge HGTV fan. I love good design...(can I say it again- good design.) I am not just into a pretty or handsome face. HGTV needs to know and respect the fact that its viewers are actually watching their shows to watch DESIGN. If we want drama and fussing we can watch Big Brother, Survivor or any of the other one thousand reality tv shows out there.

HGTV please stay focused on bringing your viewers good quality design and you will have loyal fans for life. But if you get into all the drama, you will lose your real fan base only to gain temporary viewers that like that kind of tacky dialogue.

**HGTV Please stay loyal to your real fans!!!!!!

Posted by georgia34 – August 28, 2007 7:53 PM

HGTV Design Star/Contestants,

A design dabbler here, I found Todd Davis as the winner with his latest turn style, and keep up the good work Todd, Kim has the techniques to apply under constraints it seems most days, ending up with other design star contestants that do not keep up to speed. Congratulations Will, the color schemes from the rock in the fireplace were the elements of the warmth you both created with the design and style created. A sure winner! Kim, they say if you cannot stand the heat, get out of the kitchen! You proved them wrong again, congratulations on your winning design star style again you showed us how to get things done with class and style pulled together in such a difficult space. The last three contestants, wow! The last two are the winners in my book!

Hearts,

Queen of Hearts~

Posted by Queen of Hearts – August 28, 2007 7:49 PM

Have we noticed that Josh's picture is no longer cancelled? Yet Christina's is?????

Posted by mercedes – August 28, 2007 7:39 PM

Okay, I know this is late. I have pretty good design sense and thought Sparkle Josh did an excellent job on his individual room. Then, he endured the critique that said he hadn't done what he set out to do. Am I alone on that one? I thought he was both likeable and talented. What room were they seeing? Oh, and the housewife putting the fountain in the family's kitchen was beyond me. Way beyond me.

Posted by mommybutterfly – August 28, 2007 7:37 PM

I jumped up and clapped when Rob was cancelled. In hindsight, it wasn't very nice. I just couldn't stand the idea that he thought he was so talented. Must go with the belief that people who toot their own horns do so because no one else wants to toot it. I think Rob is talented but a bit warped. Kim endured that situation with so much more grace than she could have displayed. I don't think she has been able to shine much, despite a good display on camera. Todd is talented but seems to just build things. Has great presence and the reserve only an older man can show. Will is my pick, because he has great design skills. He's been the underdog...always working the background while others beat their chests. His problem is in the way he speaks. Perhaps they can really go out on a limb and just give him a show and let him run with it! I loved Sunday's show and can't wait until the next. Fools?

Posted by Mommybutterfly – August 28, 2007 7:22 PM

Bravo - Robb is gone!!! He was so egotistical and mean, it is amazing that he was selected for the show....but actually, I suspect that is why he was selected...he was a pompous idiot....not only did he fail to get along with anyone - (except Todd and I am sure he would turn on him soon enough, too!) then he could not even leave th eshow with grace. He is a mysoginist, he has an over-inflated ego and I did not even see his design talent.....what a relief!!! I had no plans to watch the show if he won and I was ready to stop watching the competition if they kept him any longer.....his disrepect of Kim was palpable! Who did he think he was? Because he supposedly had kitchen experience and she did not she was going to be his order taker?!? Well, she hsowed him and he got exactly what he deserved!!! Ding Dong - the jerk is dead!!!

Posted by ajspirit – August 28, 2007 6:47 PM

Lynn, you can find out everything about Clive Pearse on www.clivepearse.com You're right; Clive is, technically speaking, a professional host. Three major shows in the UK and Europe, before coming to the States. Remember, Americans tend to be gaga for anyone with a British accent, and we have lots of hosts here in the US because if it, regardless of actual talent. And before everyone jumps on me because they perceive that I'm bashing Clive, I AM NOT!!!! I admit that I'm disappointed that he's going to be hosting a new HGTV show in the near future called "The Duchess," where the show is a "Docu-Soap" (their term!), invading the private lives of David Manners, the 11th Duke of Rutland and his family, in their ancestral home, Belvoir Castle. I do not think that this will be an appropriate show for HGTV, but that's my opinion.....

Posted by Leon – August 28, 2007 6:30 PM

I was reading some articles online about Robb and he has said that the producers of the show have made him the villain through editing. Well, if he wasn't such an a-hole they wouldn't have had so much material! I can't believe his parting comment calling the judges fools. For the most part America can't stand him so even if he made it to the final two he would never get his own show. Would he be calling all of us fools then? You reap what you sow, Robb, and I hope you have read all these comments on here, although I doubt you'll take them to heart.

Posted by Mindy – August 28, 2007 6:19 PM

I make a point of watching the show at least 3 or four times so I can absorb all of the ideas these talented people bring to the table but week after week I have endured Rob and I just wanted to smack him silly - THANK GOD HE IS GONE! I would not allow him to design my dog's house.

Posted by Inez Ross – August 28, 2007 5:59 PM

I am late with my comments this week, but I still wanted to make some.

First of all, even though I am 100% in agreement that Robb had to go, isn't it sad that so many other talented designers were booted while he still remained. It is for this reason that I agree that HGTV has let its die hard fans down by creating so much drama in this show.

This could have been the dream of a lifetime for so many talented people and yet they never had a chance. I am also convinced that no one at HGTV reads these blogs or they would realize how in danger they are of loosing many a loyal fan.

As I stated in my first paragraph, great that Robb is finally gone, but what about the raw deal given to the others. Lisa deserved more of a chance than Robb did. He was almost 40 years old, if he hasn't seen his own faults by now (which obviously he has not) he never will.

Sparkle being booted still breaks my heart and lets not forget Scott, who really should have been given more of a chance.

I don't mind some double eliminations, but week after week is not fair to the "hopefuls" or the fans.

About Todd. I just don't know what to say about him. His hosting technique isn't bad. But, once again I have to say that he is a builder and not a designer. The ONLY time he was ever completely on his own was he created the Tsunammi room. As we all said after that show, it was great art (albeit a little tactless), but not design. Will did all his shopping and choosing for him. Maybe HGTV is looking for a person to host a building show, if so, maybe he is their guy, but not for design. About the "lazy susan". It is a novel idea, but I couldn't help wondering how easy that was to move. It looked like to me that they were having to put there backs into it to budge it. I could be wrong about that though as no one commented on it.

Although Will is a good designer. His grammer definitely needs work. Although I didn't think that he presented himself that badly when he did his commentary for the hosting part. But, I will admit I am a stickler for grammer and it does bother me. Enough, I think, that I'd have trouble watching.

My pick is Kim, so far. She has great presence, is a sweethart and does her darndest to get a long with even the worst. Let's give someone with no formal background a chance!! I think she is the best bet amoung them. At least when she designed on her own, it was usable.

Posted by sunny – August 28, 2007 5:57 PM

Love the fact that Rob or is it Robb or whatever is gone! But that doesn't make up for the loss of Christina and Sparkle.
However, out of the 3 left, two are decorators and one is a designer. That one is Todd.
He is fresh, out of the box and would have a show that would put a whole new "spin" on design.
I like all three and really do feel that Kim will win for reasons other than design or hosting ability, but Todd would have a show that moves design on to new realms.

Posted by noone – August 28, 2007 5:45 PM

I am a HUGE HGTV fan too. I watch it every chance I get. I so looked forward to the new season of Design Star, but, like many, have been sorely disappointed. I felt too many people have been voted off too quickly without us having seen their individual talents, and there just doesn't seem to be the same talent/charisma of last year's show. I will watch to the end, but am disappointed in the show this year. I am sure Todd will win, although Christine was my choice. I think it will be down to Kim and Todd. I only hope Todd can do "normal" designing for everyday people instead of broken tables/waves and lazy susans in living rooms! HGTV is still my favorite TV Station no matter what. We need more of Candace Olsen and Kevin Brown!

Posted by Ava – August 28, 2007 5:42 PM

My question is , what took the judges so long to boot the arrogant, egotistical, jacka## ,ROBB? He should have been gone after the first show. He would throw his own mother under a bus. The boy is a loser and a poor one at that...."fools made a mistake". Yep Robb I agree they mistakenly let you stay way past your time. Now go home and sulk and find someone else to bully. Kim won't be there!

Had Robb stayed and won, my remote would have cancelled his show and HGTV.

Posted by Ticker – August 28, 2007 5:16 PM

have read a lot of the comments and must agree ... when Robb was eliminated I sat here clapping (and I'm all by myself), 'cause I was so glad to see him go. I also think Sparkle Josh should have remained and Robb should have been sent home then. Why, why, why was he kept on so long? I was never going to watch again if he had remained after this episode.
I see that they will be doing individual design jobs this time amidst rain and whatever ... life
is really fair for Kim, don't you think? Partnered with Robb and then have her carpet
soaked in the next show (at least that's what it looked like in the coming attractions). She will really need all the good will she can get.
And Todd, tell that woman judge to get with the program .. it's not about you, honey, it's about design not some guys body! If I ever needed my house designed, (one of my daughters is a designer for a very large financial institution so I don't pay for help) and wanted to hire someone Todd would be the last person. I am not a 24 year old 'surfer dude' who wants whirling platforms and skateboard places in my home. Does anyone know the term, "I'm going to sue you for my injuries?", spoken by a former 'dear' friend after thay've been flung off your new design piece.

Posted by jed – August 28, 2007 5:06 PM

I was so happy to see Robb get his "wings clipped", couldn't happen to a nicer fellow. Poor guy, was that a tear I saw in your eye?

Posted by LPalmer – August 28, 2007 4:40 PM

What is the rush this season? There are way too many "team" challenges and we have not been able to see any of the designers shine. And what is with all the double eliminations? It is ridiculous how fast this season is going and seriously, I couldn't pick a designer to root for (Sparkle?) because you are pushing through the season so fast. Last year was much more enjoyable and nail biting. SLOW it down next year for goodness sakes.

Posted by LPalmer – August 28, 2007 4:38 PM

Thank god Robb is finally gone. What was HGTV thinking keeping him on the show. Why would I want to watch such a pompeous ass on television who does not know how to treat people or work in a team environment. It should have happened sooner.

Posted by Randi – August 28, 2007 4:25 PM

OK....so rumor has it that Robb had his "show" canceled this last episode. I was boycotting "Design Star" because "drama" is not what I watch HGTV for. I do however enjoy reading the blogs about the show. Some of you are just soooooo very, very, passionate! Kind of like Robb in a way. Since the next episode involves individual designs, I will be back to viewing for myself. Hopefully there will be some interesting, innovative, creative, inspirational work to see. If not, I will be working on my own projects instead of watching TV. You all can fill me in later!

Posted by vanalinda – August 28, 2007 4:08 PM

Like someone else said, I have changed my mind about Todd. His enthusiasm, creativeness, and ability to execute are awesome. However, I've not viewed his website so I may not know the whole story.

Will, I thought your presentation had some really great tips. Just polish it a little and you are there.

Kim, your presentation was great as well. I also like how you stood up he-who-shall-not-be-named. "Your supposed to be talkin' to me, not the carpenter". I see in the coming attractions you've restyled your hair - talk about some serious foreshadowing?

lwatkins - don't know how you do it girl, but you nailed it with the 8-year olds spinning grandma. LOL! And next time you talk to Sparkle, tell him that I said howdy!

Posted by ktsmom – August 28, 2007 3:58 PM

I completely agree with Dianne. Will is the Design Star! He has been my choice since the second episode. ROBB IS GONE! What an abrasive attitude he has. I can not believe he lasted this long.

Posted by Doerrtl – August 28, 2007 3:32 PM

One of my biggest pet peeves in the business world, regardless of the setting, is rudeness and insults. I find Vern Yip to possess those qualities. First, to characterize the group (and often I might add) as to "you guys" is unacceptable. They are ladies and gentlemen. Second, to say that he was "nauseous" was inappropriate. If something is unacceptable (ie, unfinished tile), say that it is unacceptable. The unfinished tile didn't make me "nauseous"--just very surprised.

Posted by Suzanne – August 28, 2007 3:03 PM

Two days later and I'm still doing the happy dance that Robb is gone! I will pause only long enough to PLEAD with HGTV to bring Sparkle Josh back. I miss watching him so much and would LOVE watching his show.

Posted by Tracy – August 28, 2007 2:51 PM

Design Star is the first reality show I have gotten "hooked" on and am thoroughly enjoying it. However, in the middle of Show #5 I knew I would not ever watch again if Robb didn't get voted off. His attitude is disgusting. Of the three left, Kim has the best hosting style, but any of the three could be groomed to be a great host. I hope HGTV, or Style, or someone will find a place for all of them. GO KIM!

Posted by Gina Fox – August 28, 2007 2:38 PM

Ok guys...we all know that Robb was not a good fit for this "team" show, but in his defense (as much as I dislike his manic behaviors) he, as well as the others were not given the opportunity to showcase their individuality! Why do you think Sparkle is gone! If we were able to see each designer's own design work, I think we may have seen a different Robb, an individual Robb! Don't get me wrong, the man needs some counseling on how to deal with people and get off his ego trip, but if we could see each designer "design", I honestly believe Sparkle would have walked away with this and Robb would have been one of the first ones gone. Remember, all we have seen are "team" designs.....Robb's teams have pulled him through. After all, reality TV these days are all about the drama...why should this show be any different? Perhaps Sparkle will be blessed with a show on FINE LIVING! Wouldn't that be SaWEEEEEEET!!!!????

Posted by OH BOY! – August 28, 2007 2:23 PM

Just think - if the judges had voted creepy Robb off eons ago, Sparkle would be up there with Kim, Will and Todd. What were the judges thinking? Robb can't even measure and other people had to come up with ideas for him. What about a Sparkle/Will hook up. I think they would complement each other and tame each others' work.

Posted by margaret – August 28, 2007 2:20 PM

Well, this season for Design Star is almost over thank God. What a fiasco! It was like a bad sequel to a great movie. I loved season one, and knew it would be David. He has what it takes to carry a show.
I think Kim should carry the next couple of weeks and become the new Design Star and in my opinion, as she has no formal design training a show for "common folk" like me would be great. It could be a "design primer". Kim could bring out experts/professional designers to discuss special projects each week, such as window treatments, floors, painting techniques, styles such as mimimalist, traditional, shabby sheek etc. She could learn with us about furniture placement, accessorising, lighting etc. To me, this would be educational and enlighting and interesting to the general viewer. I think more interesting than "Remix" and other shows that think using "junk" from the attic and garage makes for great design. Sometimes it works and sometimes it looks more than shabby sheek. But that is my hang-up. I am an avid garage sale shopper and auctions, flea markets etc. so I do know that there are worthwhile bargains to be found and used. Anytway, I digress, but this type of shopping could also be in Kim's show to teach what is a deal and what is not.
I think Will is great also, but is too toned down to carry a show, but has design knowledge. He should not have been the 11th choice, but the 10th if they had omitted Robb in the first place.
Todd is really a cool artist, but not a disign star. He should grow up and keep his shirt on. He is no David.
If there is to be a third season of Design Star, the judges and producers should concentrate on design talent and not controversial characters.
Really, I don't believe in the addage that bad publicity is "publicity". I still think Vern is great, but next year maybe some of the other professional designers could be chosen as judges.
Anyhow this is just one "old lady's" opinion.

Posted by Bea Juhn – August 28, 2007 1:57 PM

POOOOOOR Rob. He's just so misunderstood.The guy just dosen't have a clue. How can you go through life as a complete mental moron? You almost have to feel sorry for someone that ignorant.He should have been gone sooner. What were the judges thinking. Or did the producers just use him to keep people watching till he got bounced.Bye Rob, sure glad you're GONE.

Posted by Tom – August 28, 2007 1:48 PM

I just wanted to say that "Robb" had confrontations with everyone that he worked with except for his good buddy "Todd"-and if he had made it any further Todd would have been next on his hit list next. Robb was to arrogant for his own good and to be quite honest with you if he had won this competition I would have NEVER watched his show as I'm sure the rest of the faithful HGTV viewers. His attitude and the fact that the judges knew that his ratings would tank before they even got started was his ultimate undoing

Posted by Di Di – August 28, 2007 1:35 PM

From one New Yorker/Hair Stylist to another i think that Kim handled herself very well. she has class and didnt let Robb bring her down to his level. If it were me i would have told him where to get off in so many words. She was a lady at all time....Kim you rock. Robb grated my every nerve week after week. I cant believe he lasted this long with his attitude and Im glad he was eliminated. Personal message to Robb, If you want to get anywhere in life u have to learn to treat people as you would like to be treated. You say Scorpions are missunderstood? never met a scorpion that didnt sting.

Posted by Mary Millet – August 28, 2007 1:27 PM

After noting that a large number of posts on this blog are mostly ranting against Robb, I wonder: was he just kept on the show for so long despite his abrasive nature partly because it was recognized that he would be unpopular? A lot of the reality/competition types of shows thrive on having a villainous contestant who will be annoying to the majority of viewers (going all the way back to the first season of Survivor). And, Robb does have some talent, so that is part of the reason he was not booted right away -- it's just that, some other people who went earlier than he did also had a lot of talent. So why did he stay so long, especially when you think of the close-to-disastrous part of the apartment that he and "eco-Josh" designed in the first show? I think the "powers that be" who are producing this show wanted to infuse it with a little bit of dissension and antagonism, and they found the perfect person to do it!

Posted by JAM – August 28, 2007 1:18 PM

I was actually praying that Robb would be sent home.He was so HARD to watch. His attitude over rode his talent. I love the show and David is a truly class act to follow. Robb on the other hand gives abuse another definition.

Posted by Rita Stickell – August 28, 2007 12:50 PM

I have spent the past 5 minutes trying to read all of the blogs for the show on Sunday night! What a roller coaster ride!

The judges are racist? Come on..... Will and Kim wouldn't be where they are now if that was true. Someone is always looking for a political correct or incorrect reason for something not going their way.

I am a former hairdresser, whats wrong with that? It takes artistic talent to interpret peoples wishes, in designing and hair! And your dealing with peoples egos too!

I am now a professional florist and event planner and used my previous background as a launching pad!

Kim will do great as a host, because she is intelligent, bright, and has the drive. As far as her lack of accessories in the kitchen, I don't think any of us would be able to pull a perfect design together in that short time frame, or having to work with someone so abusive as Robb.

Will has nice designs, but his "urban" use of English puts me off. I find him hard to understand, he speaks a bit too softly. As far as his energy in his preview though, man I know their tired and would not want to have to perform right after all that work!

Todd is fun, the shirt needs to stay on! It's not going to help in design. Even David B. needs to keep his on! Todd has innovative idea's and he could do a show for younger people with their first place, or even for teenagers living at home, maybe a show on skate boarding and tree house living! :)

All that said, YEAH! Robb is gone!!!!!

Posted by Cheryl H – August 28, 2007 12:47 PM

The second season does not have the quality of the first...no one is as good as David Bromstad. Too bad. HGTV is my channel of choice so will continue to watch, however, hope we get better quality candidates next time. Glad that Robb is gone!!!!!!!

Posted by Vicki – August 28, 2007 12:09 PM

I'm also glad Robb is gone. However, even though others suffered his abuse, Robb staying on for so long has certainly done the job in keeping the blog active! We all love to hate the bad guy. Robb was definately that. I would have liked to see more of Josh Sparkle, but with double eliminations, someone had to go. I admire Will's style. He needs to work on his TV personality. He's so nice, but lacking in outgoing personality. Kim has outgoing personality, but seem to me to still need to prove herself in the design area. Todd is awsome, but needs to stop trying to think SO outside the box and get down-to-earth and think about the majority of the folks who would watch his show and be a bit more practical. - I like Todd for now.

Posted by DarcyFromKY – August 28, 2007 12:02 PM

Watched the re-run last night; on Sunday I kept getting interrupted and missed some of the “drama”. Like everyone else, I am relieved that Robb finally got cancelled. Having worked for a major corporation for many years, I have noticed that people like Robb usually get their come-uppance, although it frequently takes longer than it should. Unfortunately, I think that both designs were really weak. Wayne Newton and wife, I believe, were just being gracious for the cameras when they said they liked the results. The kitchen was unattractive; the turntable in the living area was just a gimmick. What both designs desperately needed was Sparkle Josh out finding the inspired furniture and wonderful accessories to make it work. Kim definitely won the hosting segment in my opinion; she was really cute. Will would be more of a “star package” if he would dress up a bit (someone has already noticed this). Isn’t there a Brooks Bros. somewhere in Vegas? (I can see a show with Will as the dapper one in Brooks Bros. blazer combined with over-the-top Sparkle Josh.) Will seems to be the more consistent designer, but I am afraid the deck is stacked against him (no pun intended). The judge from InSyle Magazine (Martha McCully) appears to be infatuated with the blonde surfer Adonis . . . seems like she smiles more broadly, leans more forward, and makes more eye contact when he is center stage. And I think she stated several episodes ago that she was most disappointed in Will. But we will know more later; wild horses couldn’t drag me away from this show. Maybe they should allow some write-in votes on the final Design Star selection.

This is only my second blog; the first one did not get posted. There was a blog a couple of weeks ago from ‘Jane’, but it was not mine. Is it possible to get text and signature mixed up?
Thanks for reading.
Jane Also

Posted by Jane Also – August 28, 2007 12:00 PM

I am so glad Rob is gone. He may have design talents, but his personality is so annoying. He is very self-centered and thinks he is better than everyone else. I don't believe any of the contestants have the quality of David from the first year.

Posted by Marsha – August 28, 2007 11:21 AM

Like everyone else, I'm glad Robb was eliminated. He was very unprofessional. I believe the remaining designers are good, but I like Will's designs most. Good luck to all!!

Posted by Tracy – August 28, 2007 11:17 AM

Allot of tension thats for sure, I give Kim allot of credit , she handled herself very well under the stress of working with Robb. It is sad to see someone with so much talent ruin it by having such a horrible attitude . Robb does have good design abilities but alas his cockiness and his lack of respect for others is what did him in.

Posted by Sandy – August 28, 2007 10:40 AM

I am so glad Robb is gone - as is everyone! I think Martha needs to take a cold shower before the judging and should be aware that her obvious lust for Todd is being broadcast across the country. Personally, I believe Martha has it in for Will and wants him gone - two weeks in a row she had derogatory comments about him, when there was really no substanial reason for them. Will's hosting skills need a little spice, but Todd's were not better! I am impressed with Todd in that even if he does share a somewhat common personality with Robb he has kept his feelings and comments to himself. But Todd, please keep your shirt on, this is not Design Stripper!!!!

Overall, this season has been somewhat of a disappointment with the lack of individual challenges - to me, to pick a design star, you have to see what they can do alone.

Sparkle Josh - you are awesome and I hope and pray that you get your own show very soon!

Posted by lstav – August 28, 2007 10:37 AM

Disappointed... compared with last season... this one is a failure.
Robb should've been never picked to compete in the first place. I assume the people doing the interviews can tell the bad traits of a prospect player, obviously not, shame.
I don't think there will be another David Bromstad
and that's where the let down comes from...
hard act to follow.
Laura, from Guam

Posted by Laura, Guam – August 28, 2007 10:21 AM

I enjoyed Robb's time on the show and I thought he made it much more interesting. His design style was well planned and executed. Todd was the only one that was a true competitor to Robb...the rest are quite ordinary. I work with *abrasive* personalities daily in health care, so I am not put off by his demeanor. Some people just need to toughen up.

currently in Queens, NY
raised in Wisconsin--MHS class of 1986

Posted by LJ – August 28, 2007 10:15 AM

I just can't let this go and I'm only going to talk about this once. I am really tired of the whiny "the judges are racist" comments. Must we always jump on that bandwagon when we don't like something that is said to a person of color or minority? Seriously, grow up people.

And, correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't Kim black? So, to me, your comments hold no water when you say they are racist towards Will; he would not have made it in the first place if that were the case. I imagine quite a bit of footage is edited here and so you are taking one question way too much out of context. I think that because Todd said that he came up with the idea for the rotating furniture and because in the last competition (the tacky wedding) Robb said Will did not contribute, that Martha just came out and asked him what he did so he could say what all he did. You are making drama out of nothing.

And, to K.C. who wrote on Aug 27 at 2:36 a.m., you aren't watching enough HGTV. They do have black designers. Have you seen Spice Up My Kitchen with Lauren Lake? I only saw one episode where she took one outdated kitchen and turned it into another one that will outdate quickly - a purple kitchen! Seriously. It was not good. Some of the other things she did were good, but that purple was not a good choice for the long haul, IMO. Also, Designed to Sell has Michael Johnson and Deus Scott (host and carpenter). Mission Organization has Gail O'Neill. Of course, there could be more black designers with their own shows, I agree, but there could stand to be more Asian, Hispanic, Indian, etc., designers as well. You're not the only minority in the world.

At the end of the day, I am looking for a good designer with practical tips, thank you very much. I don't care what ethnicity they are. I think you're being tremendously unfair.

Posted by Mandy – August 28, 2007 10:13 AM

Great Rob is gone. There must have been slim pickings, or it was a set up to have him as the controversy. I agree with comments of not really seeing the talent of each individual when they have to team up. Re the comment of Vern saying Will's tone was a little flat. I don't want to watch a show with the host being the star, I want the show and content being the star. Vern has a mild and informative personality which is what I like, not someone jumping all over the place. Is this show supposed to be about showing the host or are about educating us viewers about skills and what we can do ourselves?

Posted by mary – August 28, 2007 9:56 AM

How about a show with Will, Kim AND Sparkle Josh working together? Josh (adds good taste, class and worked wonderfully with Will on the bedroom - great design), Will with his good designs and calmness, and Kim with her bubbly personality. All 3 make a great team...alone there is a component missing.

Robb....you are an obnoxious ( ). You fill in the blank. Any pig-like animal will work. Oh, sorry to the animals.

Posted by Lynn – August 28, 2007 9:14 AM

As much I didn't have a good vibe for Rob, it wasn't because of his cocky attitude. I just had a preconceived notion that jock types have no clue about design, and Rob proved that he does. Vern and the ladies have always said, "You need to have a voice and an concept of you come through your design." Why punish Rob for it this time. KIM is a drama Queen and she is going to come from the blind side and just ram rod everyone. She is a mistake because she did more complaining no different than Rob to me. ROB IS BLAMED FOR TRYING TOO HARD AND AS SUCH, IT CAME OVER AS RUDE. He obviously puts up a front. Anyway, I hope the final two are Will and the Surf Dude.

Posted by Andre-Paul – August 28, 2007 7:01 AM

I AM SOOOO GLAD ROBB IS GONE!! HE SHOULD OF LEFT ABOUT 4 EPISODES AGO! IF ROBB BEAT EVERYONE, I WOULD NEVER WATCH HIS SHOW. HE WAS SUCH A JERK. WHEN THEY ANNOUNCED HE WAS GONE, I SAID 'THANK GOD, IT'S ABOUT TIME'. LITERALLY. IM HAPPY NOW.

Posted by jamie – August 28, 2007 6:00 AM

After reading all the posts,

I just had to post again. Are you people crazy? Rob designed a kitchen without a refrigerator...and the double oven was put at knee height (how back breaking for the cook) and...what happen to the triangle that a kitchen is suppose to have (sink, stove, refrigerator). Robb was an idiot. Kim couldn't suggest anything for kitchen placement because Robb had his NO DRAWING picture, with everything put in the wrong place. Has he ever really designed a kitchen before? I sincerely think not!! Who the hell wants a double oven at knee height and the refrigerator in the mudd room? Plus his tile work was so shabby. For christ-sake this was Wayne Newtons home... why didn't he use glass tiles and more stainless steel. Those cheap tiles he put on the wall was the worst thing I have ever seen!! Plus the counter-top was laminate (OMG)... and he had the gall to talk about Kim and the kitchen tiles in the earlier show...kim did not ruin the tiles...it was that idiot woman who refused to measure the counter so the correct amount could be used. I can't wait for the next show to begin because each designer will have to design a room on their own. If Todd puts a half pike or a revolving wood slab in someone's home OMG...what a mess!! That revolving slab made the room look smaller and you can only seat 4 people on that slab!! Plus, Todd keep your shirt on...you don't have muscles and your pale skin is horrible to look at. You're no David B. so keep your shirt on your fat body!! Also, I agree with some of the other posts that the female judge needs to be a little more professional!!! If she wants to sex Todd ...do it and get over it because he's not cute and he's not a HUNK...but she really looks unprofessional when she looks at him. Plus I too think she's prejudice against Will. David B had no TV skills and had to work really hard to improve his TV style...so stop hating and get up off of Will...you really look and sound prejudice!! By the way...I'm Asian.

Posted by A J Abbley – August 28, 2007 5:53 AM

I have always wondered exactly what Clive's bakcground is? Is he a professional TV host? I see him on all these shows but I have never once seen him design or decorate "anything" himself. Does he even know how? Could someone please tell me, I sincerely want to know.

Posted by lynn – August 28, 2007 5:17 AM

Thank God Robb is gone!!...what a fool!! Robb, you don't have people skills...you can't work with people. One day you will learn that. But the recovery for Kim, was when the kitchen units didn't fit (ha, ha, ha) What happen Robb to your designing of 10,000 kitchens?...the units didn't fit and Kim told you that...try listening next time...you are a total jerk!! Not only do your co-workers have to like you, but we the TV audience must like you also, or we won't support the new Design Star show by tuning in to watch.

I think Will is a great designer. It was his first time on the camera and of course he was a little nervous, but his design of the living space was right on...because right away he knew to select the color of the room from the fireplace rocks. How brilliant!! Todd is a little to "surf boy" for me. His designs are innovative, but really not practical for todays homes. And the way he was jumping around the wedding challenge space really left me turned off. Grow Up Already!! Knocking over the table and turning cartwheels all over the place was a true turnoff!!

I hope the last two standing is Kim and Will. Oh...and thank goodness the evil Robb is GONE!!!!

Posted by A J Abbley – August 28, 2007 4:23 AM

I ditto everyone's anti-Robb comments above as well as agree w/other's that the talent this year no way compares to last season's level. I also miss Josh sparkles and agree that the challenges so far except for one did not allow the designers to show what they can or cannot do. However, I cannot understand how some feel Robb had talent. Yes, difference of opinions makes the world go round, but I would love to know what you saw on the past shows this season that demonstrates any talent from Robb except his talent to annoy and degrade all others except for "Master Todd???"

First show he spent most of his time searching for a car door to hang as art and then found the worst colored pillows in all of Las Vegas. Second challenge he crackled kitchen cabinets and didn't even do that correctly. The .99 challenge he proved he could present a room that resembled an ugly wrapped present. In this last episode, as others pointed out, his measurements were incorrect, his choice of tile and it's application sucked, his appliance layout was a failure and down right ridiculous. His presentation was the worst. Oh and how could I forget the wedding reception room, w/the revolving dice, the poker chip columns that had to be covered, the epileptic seizure causing strobe lit martini glasses and what I would have given to see people dancing on his contact paper covered dance floor--can't you just imagine the law suits of all the women getting their heels stuck in the tears created by the dance movements. Some might say the young couple loved it so that proves Robb had talent--what do you expect the married couple who just got HGTV to pay for their reception to say???? Really, I love a good debate and am known to have my mind change w/good hard facts--so what exactly did he do to demonstrate that he had talent other then chewing leather on each episode?

Posted by Jayne – August 28, 2007 3:45 AM

Ugh, Robb was getting on my last nerve and I was glad to see his condescending ass go. I think it will be down between Will & Todd in the end. Both are likeable and really good designers and have been consistent throughout the show.

Posted by Margie – August 28, 2007 2:54 AM

Well, like everyone else, thank GOODNESS Robb is gone. I think that no one who is that arrogant or rude should be rewarded with a TV show! It was just so sad to see Robb and Kim arguing in the car whilst Todd and Will were enthusiastically talking about their design and plans for the following day!

I am not sure Kim can design on her own. She has a great personality and good ideas, but whether she could carry a show, I don't know.

Todd definitely has an interesting style. Very creative and out of the box. Is it practical and something one of us could implement in our home? I don't know. And isn't the purpose of most of the TV design shows for viewers to translate into their own homes? I think Todd has a strong place in the design world. On TV, not so sure.

That leaves us Will. Will is a great designer. He is calm and collected and sees the big picture. He listens to the clients and is able to translate their needs into a thing of beauty. Can he be a suitable host on TV? Hard to tell. His "test preview" was not at all good. He surely had the design descriptions down --- the man knows what he is talking about. But he comes across so wooden. Does HGTV help the winner to be more natural? Is there training or advice? If so, Will would be the one to go with --- his design talent certainly warrants a win.

But will TV presence win out over design ability? Gosh, I hope not! Actually when you think of it, this entire concept of finding a TV personality/designer is a pretty hard one to fill.

Good luck to all 3 of you! May the best one win!

Posted by Kati – August 28, 2007 2:54 AM

I watched the show again tonight Kim did nothing but degrade and make rude comments about Rob over and over from the beginning (so what if she took measurements that is working together) and was snotty and also like she was trying her best to eliminate him and make him look bad and try to make herself look good- she is guilty of a bad attitude and her work and her pick of kitchen furniture was very bland and boring. I am sorry but I do not like her or her atittude. Even though Rob may have bee strong willed, he had some good points, Todd is entertaining and I really liked Sparkle Josn and I agree he should co host on a show - he made me smile and he had a certain presence about him that was fun - I was so disappointed when he was let go. Rob did great work and worked very hard. If I had to choose at this point I say Todd

Posted by DJ – August 28, 2007 2:45 AM

Design Star this year has been disappointing. Where's the pizzazz and personality? How do they decide on the contestants? I think they need to screen them better, make them do a hosting segment and then discover the real potential design star. Candice Olson and Kenneth Brown have what it takes.

In the beginning, I wasn't impressed with Todd. However, as the weeks go by in the elimination, he is the most creative and inventive. As far as the comments regarding his "lazy susan" being dangerous - locks could be placed on the rotation so kids wouldn't spin it as a merry-go-round (I'm sure he's thought of it). It was actually quite subliminal - a platform - for a Vegas performer up on a platform!

I like Kim and Will. I think they all have a shot at the title. No point in commnenting on Robb- it has all been said. And we can't bring back Sparkle. So it will be interesting in the next couple of weeks.

Posted by gb – August 28, 2007 1:57 AM

HGTV design star is great. I am enjoying it to the fullest. I even watch the re-runs. Unfortunately, I am really disappointed with the judging this season. I subscribe to In Style magazine and I feel that I may have to end my subscription. The female judges are quite racist and it becomes more and more evident each episode. They bash Will every chance they get and constantly put him on the chopping block. His designs are really good. I believe that acting is a learned behavior, good design is a skill. Will has that skill. Todd is a good wholesome American boy. Girls will like him because he can take his shirt off. However, I don't watch HGTV for that, I can look at my husband for that. I want to see how to decorate my room and Will can show me how. I wish the two female judges will listen to Vern when he says a television show is at stake. Will has the skills and should be given a fair chance. Stop looking at the color of his skin and look at his talent. Will is talented. Stop being racist pigs. Vern you are awesome loved you. I look forward to watching you more on HGTV.
Good luck Todd, Will, and Kim. Todd you think outside the box but I need to see you complete a design that is pratical and appealing to your customer.
Will your designs are great. I hope you sock it to those judges next week and really give them something to talk about. Let them know that a nice boy can bring Southern hospitality to any space. In fact maybe in style can do a feature called Southern Hospitality using some of your designs. Don't let those two ladies get to you. Think positive.
Kim good luck. When you picked up for Robb last week I was pissed. However, this week you got a chance to experience what all the contestants experienced each week. You did not back down. Excellent.

Glad Robb is gone. I miss Sparkle Josh. Can't wait to see him in the final episode. Hope they bring some of the season contestants back for the final challenge.

Good luck future design stars.

Mimi

Posted by Mimi – August 28, 2007 1:44 AM

Thank goodness! Robbhole is gone. What a caustic person to work with. Kim, you rock! You had the difficult task of having to deal with a horrible partner and a kitchen; hands down you deserve to be the next Design Star.
If it were not for Will, the living room would have had just a lazy Susan. Don't get me wrong, I think Todd has talent. His out-of-the-box creativity probably will not appeal to the average Joe wanting tips for their home.
Looking forward to the individual challenges this weekend.

Posted by RussellBombay – August 28, 2007 1:41 AM

Rob has a class A abusive, arrogant, rude and disrespectful personality and definitely can't handle not getting his way, nor can he accept responsibility for his mistakes.He likes to intimidate and blame. Like most of the other commentors I am so, so, SO very glad to see him gone.

Robb was an irritating distraction all through this series and should have been cut just for his unethical behavior in hiding items at the dollar store from other competitors. He was neither entertaining nor instructive. I had to click to another channel until the bad parts were over on this show.

I think Will has the clearest, cleanest and most attractive design style. I would watch him design any time...and he is a genuine person. He can learn to be a host just like David Bromstadt did. Will's pleasing personality, authentic and honest approach are very appealing.

Todd has flair, is fun to watch and seems to be a nice guy, but his work so far seems too impractical for regular homes. Kim has been burdened with dealing with Robb far too much and she just seems to have been buried by him. It will be very interesting to see how she does on the individual design challenges.

And yes like most of you I miss Sparkle...his sense of design is superb, his personality unique and pleasant and he has a great turn of phrase...I liked his individual room and did NOT like Robb's---what was with the flag down the back wall?

Sometimes I wonder about the motivations behind the decisions made on the show...I think a few people in both seasons lingered too long because the producers like the conflict and overule the designers. I personally don't find conflict of that magnitude entertaining and I am sorry to see it get so generally prevalent on TV. I watch HGTV as an antidote to murder and mayhem going on on other channels and to learn something...If a third season makes it to the airwaves and continues in this unpleasant way I will not be watching it. And really what the contestants were expected to do in such small amounts of time sometimes seems too overwhelming and unfair and in the end the client gets the short stick.

Good Luck to the last three..

Posted by W.E. – August 28, 2007 1:29 AM

It is a reflection of how self-absorbed Robb is that he is not aware of the importance of the team dynamic on the successful design shows. We love good creative design, but we also like to see it being brought to fruition by a team that truly enjoys working together. We are drawn in by their interactions, their laughter and playfulness. I could not have erased from my mind the memory of how disrespectful he was to Kim. If Robb had ended up with his own show I cannot begin to imagine wanting to watch 5 minutes of him interacting with his assistant(s) and crew. I thought Kim spoke with dignity and restraint when she said she still admired his managerial ability, but (in this challenge) he was not her manager, he was supposed to be a team partner.
I do watch every episode of Color Splash. I enjoy seeing David blossom. He is a delightful human being as well as a talented designer. Both qualities are needed in a Design Star. Will this season deliver? I don't know. They need to let us have more insight into the 3 people who are left.

Posted by Natasha – August 28, 2007 1:25 AM

Yippee! Hooray! Robb's gone! What took the judges soooo long to see what we all saw? Who would want to work with a blotted ego like that. Wow! Kim really stepped up to the beast and pushed him back. (I am your partner, not someone who takes orders from you.) Way to go Kim!
Todd has really impressed me more and more with each show. His designs are always very creative.
Will is the quiet one with great design abilities. He always sees what the others seem to miss.
This is really tough. I don't want to see anyone eliminated next week. Who will I vote for? Maybe I won't vote. I can't imagine picking just one from these 3. Maybe next week will help me decide.

Posted by Julie – August 28, 2007 1:18 AM

Rob, I hope you read this. As an employer, I hire people not only for their talent, but for how they work with others. You have talent, but you believe your way is the only way and others are there to serve you. Good luck in the real world, I do not envy your co-workers. It looks like your "clipped wings" statement to Kim came right back at you!

Posted by Northjudi – August 28, 2007 1:13 AM

First of all I would LOVE TO SEE diversity on HGTV. BUT CLEARLY JUDGES ARE BASING DECISIONS ON WHO THEY LIKE. ALTHOUGH ROBB WAS OBVIOUSLY NO ONES FAVORITE, HE IS OR WAS THE STRONGEST CONTENDERS. HE HAD A GOOD SENSE OF DESIGN, STYLE AND ON TV CHARM.
OF ALL THE JUDGES I AM DISAPPOINTED THAT VERN WOULD ALLOW HIS BRASH BEHAVIOR TO CONTROL THE VOTE. UNLESS THE GUY WAS DANGEROUS OR IMMORAL, I TRULY BELIEVE DESIGN SKILLS SHOULD HAVE TRUMPED. FINALLY I AM CONCERNED THAT HGTV IS ATTEMPTING TO CORNER A PARTICULAR MARKET. AS A PROUD MEMBER OF THAT POSSIBLE MARKET I FEEL THEY ARE TRYING TO CORNER, I WOULD ACTUALLY VIEW THE STATION WITH LESS RESPECT IF THEY CHOOSE SOMEONE TO HOST A SHOW WHILE REALLY HAVING OTHERS DO THE DESIGN WORK.

Posted by doriank – August 28, 2007 1:03 AM

What we saw in the fifth episode was almost the opposite of the fourth one, in terms of respect and politeness. In the past episode it was a very touching moment seeing Sparkle Josh and Will, one beside the other, showing such respect and admiration. When they hugged, we all saw two human beings that could see the interior beauty and professionalism of each other without any discrimination or differentiation... the opposite happened during this last episode when Robb insulted Kim in every comment he did directly or indirectly. But do you know why this happened? Since the beginning Rob was defensive and attacking all the time; and this is probably because he has had no respect in his life or in his family, so he tried to bond with the stronger Todd thinking he could smash the ones he considered weaker.. the black, the women, the girlish.. and he was so wrong, because they all showed to be much stronger and mature, and they all got deep into our hearts. Rob was the one that should leave the program since the very first episode when he did nothing. Sorry Rob, nothing personal; is that you cannot mistreat the people, punto!
MariaJ.

Posted by Mariajuan – August 28, 2007 12:35 AM

A big sigh of relief when Robb went home. CeeCee below does not realize that personality can't be practiced for T.V. The vast majority of viewers disliked Robb. For all that Robb was pointing fingers at Kim for not finishing the tiling, Robb didn't finish the tiles. Did Kim point out that Robb was on the block for the horrid treatments he did to the cabinets? She should have. The room was not about Robb, Robb, Robb; it was about Kim and Robb, THE TEAM. Robb's fault for not getting that, or respecting Kim. I think I finally get where Todd could go with design in a "normal" home, but felt that Will really was the force that brought that room together. I'm really looking forward to next week!

Posted by advolpe – August 28, 2007 12:30 AM

Thank god Robb's show was canceled. I sincerely was going to stop watching this season if he went through to another episode. Why did it take these judges so long to realize that he was an evil, rude, disrespectful person from the beginning. I have really started to question their ability to judge who should be our next design star.

Posted by Leah – August 28, 2007 12:28 AM

I think most people forget that the judges don't see or hear what goes on out of the studio. I loathed Robb's personality from day 1, but I could see why the judges left him in based on his designs. Todd's designs are innovative, but not really based on reality. And I wish he'd leave his shirt on. Kim is a whiz at conceptualizing a design and has the personality. Will's designs are solid and I could use them in my house, but so far he lacks polish. Maybe a "Kim and Will Show?" Or better yet, a "Kim, Will, and Sparkle Show"!! Wowie!

Posted by Susannah – August 28, 2007 12:20 AM

I am pleased with the elimination choice. I think that although Robb may have some good design ideas, his overall execution of them and willingness to work with others failed. The tiled backsplash was terrible. There is such a thing as spacers and chalk lines. Also, why was it necessary to move the oven from it's original position? The stainless steel would have looked great in the rock wall! Not to mention the whole work triangle. Cramming everything together was not smart design! I think that Kim really showed great personal character and that dealing with this and having to come up with decent design ideas would be difficult. However, attention to detail is a must in interior design. The table and chairs didn't seem to fit the scale of the space. Possibly placing a rug to ground it would have helped and would have brought a little more warmth, texture and color to the space. Vern's suggestion of accessories would have really brought alot to the space. Plants and fruit would have added alot for a little $.

The living room was a little off to me. I thought the space with way too linear. It needed some softer lines. I wasn't too keen on the whole turn table; but then again I'm more practical. Personal taste, I guess. Wouldn't swivel chairs have worked just as well? I also would have liked to see more color. Artwork instead of rectangular mirrors. I really think that Todd has great carpenter skills, but interior design just doesn't seem to be his gig. His presentation clearly showed that. He didn't mention anything about interior design. I agree that the comment made earlier about some sort of lesson on how to host should come earlier in the season. Look at David Bromsted. He did not have any experience with hosting. He has definitely learned on the road and is still learning. I love his ideas and designs though. Keeps me watching.

My pick for Design Star is Will.

Posted by Jo – August 28, 2007 12:20 AM

To be honest -- if Robb would have won the whole thing, and everyone would have thought he had great talent (which would of course, have been wrong) there wouldn't one person out there that could have convinced me to watch any show that he would have been a part of. I can't imagine that he wasn't simply kept for the "drama" factor (you know how those tv execs are!). "Drama" was the only thing he contributed to the show...am glad they "finally" put us out of our misery!...It's sad that Robb thinks of the judges as 'fools'...am afraid he leads the pack on that title... sigh...

Posted by J – August 28, 2007 12:18 AM

I am really happy that Rob was voted off the show.
I thought he treated Kim terribly. He didn't even give her a chance to prove her abilities. He just assumed she had none. He was so disrespectful of her and others he's worked with.
I am kind of disappointed in this year's Design Star. I don't like the quick eliminations of the contestants and I think there have been too many team challenges. I'd like to see more individual ones and really see the best designers emerge & develop as each episode goes by. They're getting kicked off so quickly, it's hard to see that. I think there were some very good designers who left at the beginning.

Posted by Annie – August 28, 2007 12:17 AM

Robb is the fool - he needs to learn that he can not look down his nose at people and expect to go very far in this world. I personally am surprised that he lasted as long as he did. With his ego - I feel sorry for anyone he works for/with - unless he learns not to be rude and haughty. This show is much better off with the likes of him. I did not enjoy watching him - his ego was a big turn off. Better off without him ! ! !

Posted by Cecilia Ann – August 28, 2007 12:11 AM

my husband actually liked the lazy susan living room, coarse then being practical i asked him what an 8 yr old boy would do. hmmmm. i could just see vases flighing thru the air!!! he thought the big jerk shouldve gone earlier. wasnt it just a relief to have rob done ??? it was stressful watching him , gosh , hgtv was doing a jerry springer style. what were they thinking???

Posted by colleen – August 28, 2007 12:08 AM

Who's the "fool" now Rob:)? I doubt you'll ever come to realize it's you yourself-feel sorry for you man but you bring it upon yourself. You waste your talent with your personality. Wouldn't trust you in my house no matter how good your idea or how hard you might listen to what's ask for-you sneak. His extended blog used his Scorpio sign as an excuse! Yes Scorpio does run deep and are passionate but note: there are three kinds of Scorpions I've read about--1.The grey lizard who repeatedly turns situations upon him/herself abusing self when things go wrong. 2. The eagle who rises above almost any situation and sores. And then: 3. The scorpion who not only retaliates when things don't go to his/her way but continues to sting and retaliate over and over and over... Yes Rob you are the true scorpion! But this is not an astrological show is it?

My girl Kim sure did show some class and diplomacy tonight when drawn into conversation by Rob who couldn't stand to be ignored. I'm sure she regrets answering him at all-he didn't deserve the time of day. She also did not come right out in front of the judges to throw him under the bus--they were asked by the judges to elaborate on the team conduct and she should have said what she did because is was so true. Go Kim! Great great TV personality and will be interesting to see what individual designs she'll come up with now. Todd you are cute and have an "outside the box" way of thinking that pretty cool but can you design interiors? We'll see-hope so. Will does show class in his designs but let's see what can be done with his personality and speech-be professional but most of all be yourself. (David B. learned alot. Like his show and creative ideas and art but would like to see him shine a bit more naturally personality wise even now and be more comfortable with his team. He is a special soul.)

Agree this is not a reality show yet feels like it at times--and although it's not what I want at all for a design star show; it's about the ratings too I guess. Well they are getting rated alright--by us. We may not have the power about what's showed but we do have to power about whether to watch or not:) I do remember several scenes from the first show as well least we forget. Got most of us talking and coming back did it not? I, for one, will find it very interesting with the remaining contestents for I believe these three all deserve to be this far and will definately watch now you know who is gone. I do niss some of the fabulous talent that is gone and too would have wished for more individual talent shown earlier in the show. Maybe HGTV is just trying to find out how everyone handle ALL types of situations and being a team player is key. But Las Vegas pllllllllllleese! Variety I guess--who the heck really knows why some things are decided but those that make these decisions and are behind the scenes. Won't stop us from putting it out there though to let them know how the people who make them what they are think and feel will it now? Just my humble opinions that are mine to have like everyone else here. Love reading all of the different viewpoints.

Posted by Deb – August 28, 2007 12:08 AM

WILL IS MY DESIGN STAR! I WOULD HIRE HIM IN A MINUTE! THRU OUT THIS WHOLE COMPETITION HE HAS ALWAYS CARED ABOUT THE CLIENTS WISHES FIRST! WILL HAS A GREAT PERSONALITY & WITH A LITTLE TV HGTV TRAINING HE WILL BE A FINE AND DANDY HOST! HE IS ONE WHO CARES DEEPLY ABOUT HIS PROFESSION AND HIS MAIN GOAL,PLEASING HIS CLIENTS! FINAL WORDS HE IS STEALTH! HE IS A THOUGHTFUL SPECIAL PERSON WHO DESERVES THE BEST! GO WILL!!!

Posted by Dianne – August 28, 2007 12:03 AM

YEAH ROB IS GONE! what an arrogant ...... well you get the point! He was horrible to everyone! I did not like how he talked about Will or how he treated Kim. Kim isn't the greatest choice here if you're looking for carpenter skills but as much as I like Will I don't think he has a lot of carpenter skills either.

PLEASE STOP calling it a "lazy" Susan! arrggghhh it's a CAROUSEL (A circular conveyor on which objects are displayed or rotated)

I have and still enjoy Will's designs and color schemes........

"not" a lazy Susan

Posted by Mizz_Pennsylvania – August 27, 2007 11:44 PM

Ijust read Robb's my space entry for last night's episode. I did agree with a couple of things he said. Yes, the challenge was not fair, kitchen versus living room, but it could have been any of the four that got the kitchen as it was a blind draw. The other thing I agreed with was it should have been an individual challenge. Out of 8 or maybe 7 episodes, we will only see 3 individual challenges and I don't think less than 50% of the episodes is enough to judge individual talent.

The other comments he made about not believing everything you see on the screen as it is a reality show and edited for broadcast. D'oh! Of course it is a reality show and edited for content to make a more watchable show. The interesting thing, however, is they can't edit in comments that aren't made. If you are not rude, abrasive and arrogant on camera, then they can't edit those factors into the show, can they? If you are rude and call people names, then there is an excellent possibility those remarks will make it into the final cut.

Posted by Alexis – August 27, 2007 11:36 PM

It is sad for the viewers that this season's shows have been less than last year's...this year they have more money, more everything...even presents...but they can't seem to "shine in design". Not their fault...maybe the judges didn't have too many to pick from, I dont know. Anyway, Will you are very nice and you show some good examples of design and we enjoy your comments. You are well liked. Whether you have the "it" to host a show, I simply don't think so. Kim, you too, are a nice gal and you have proven more than once how good a team player you are and how capable you are...again, whether you can host a show, I don't think so. This leaves Todd...the vain, cart-wheeler who thinks he is tops...he isn't tops...he isn't even in view of the tops...he is a California young man who enjoys building things and enjoys "pectorating" for us and who enjoys jumping around a lot...but...he is all there is this year, unfortunately. Maybe HGTV will get him a really terrific co-host...suppose?

Posted by shi2shi – August 27, 2007 11:30 PM

I AM SOOOO GLAD THAT ROBB IS GONE!!! He was so arrogant, and mean. Kudos to Kim for standing up to him and for having the courage to speak her mind to the judges. Todd and Will did a nice job last night, but I want "Sparkle". Josh, my wife and I loved you, and thought that you were great. I've read your blogs and you are truly one of the nicest, most humble people. I wish you well in your career. Take care and know that you are appreciated as a designer.

Posted by chefjmb1822 – August 27, 2007 11:16 PM

I am soooo glad that Robb is gone! I was horrified to see how he treated Kim, that is is terrible way to treat anyone,but especially a lady,and that is not what I would want to see in
a Design Star. I really,REALLY liked Will and Todd design, and I loved the "lazy susan"!That is so creative and genious!Kim,you are sweet, and I liked your camera presence and how you stood up to Robb.I am dissapointed at how the judges are being with Will.I don't Think that the judges are see the whole picture and all that Will has done. Well I am still going to vote for Will and I hope that he is the winner!

Posted by ash – August 27, 2007 11:05 PM

About time Robb got the boot. But, he's is about the least of that show's problems. Some of you have already said it, but I'll say it again. Three things that made this series fail this year:

* The judges. Please, get off your asses and go see the designs in person. You can't just sit in a room and judge the design work from a TV screen. And while you’re up and at it, get yourselves some personalities. These are the crabbiest, most humorless reality show judges I have seen. Give me Paula and Simon bickering any day over these sourpusses.

* Double eliminations. The contestants were picked off so fast and with little logic that we're left with slim pickins. The show has been a blur. There needed to be more individual design exercises and presentation opportunities earlier on. That would have kept some of the talented designers on the show longer.

* Poor talent recruiting resulted in too much juvenile testosterone from the likes of Robb and the surfing dude. Uh Todd, you ain't no David Bromstad. Shirtless worked for him last year, but you should probably come up with your own vote-provoking gimmick. Sparkle Josh, Will, Christina, and Adriana, you all are right on! Kim you're cute and nice, but lucky to still be standing. Last night you did a lot of standing around complaining, you should have been doing a better job decorating, yes I said decorating, that kitchen.

Okay, I'll watch the rest of the show, but HGTV you need to take a step back after the show is over and come up with something better.

Posted by Duggie – August 27, 2007 11:05 PM

The judges made the right elimination and it looked like the remaining contestants were VERY happy with the decision. I have a problem with showing the predisposition of one judge in favor of Todd. It makes the audience feel as though the one judge has made up her mind before the competition is completed. Anyone can see that Todd has been given a lot of air time, showing him tumbling, skateboarding, etc. That has nothing to do with a design show. I don't get it.

I admire Kim's character and restraint when she
had to deal with Robb's unpleasant personality.
I think that she would do well in teaching an
assertiveness training course. She was also a perky hostess, but I don't see any outstanding design skills.

Todd's platform idea was impractical. Even Mrs. Newton had concerns about it the instant she saw it. The furniture could have been arranged to take advantage of focal points, without having
to destroy a wood floor and take up too much space.

I believe that the winner, of the remaining group, should be Will. He has solid design ability. Remember that even David B. did not do well in his first hosting trial. It just takes a little practice and a little help. Will did well in summarizing the important design tips. He's a genuinely nice person.

Since they partnered David B. with Danielle, I think that HGTV SHOULD PARTNER WILL WITH SPARKLE JOSH. THAT WOULD BE A GREAT SHOW.

Posted by Sara Anne – August 27, 2007 11:02 PM

24 hours later and I am still celebrating that wicked, evil and self absorbed puppetteer Robb is gone. Kim was definitely the winner this week because he would have suffered some horrible accident as my teammate. She has a wonderful amount of grace and tact. She is looking more and more like the design star. Will is still my favorite designer because he has been rocking them from night one. The guy is good!!! Todd:our shirtless studmuffin, do a serious design and keep your shirt one for once. I picking Will or Kim as the WINNERS!!! I am watching to see, if Iam right.

Posted by Rose – August 27, 2007 10:53 PM

I think Will is probably the best designer. I also thought his attempt at hosting was totally endearing--he has a very sweet quality to him. With a bit of polishing, he'd do well at hosting his own show. Kim actually did the best job at hosting, and she did well going solo on the previous episode. I just don't like Todd's designs--they are a bit too esoteric. I'm rooting for Will to win. Note that 2 of the final 3 are self-taught (Will and Kim).

Posted by christine – August 27, 2007 10:34 PM

I have Design Star and Color Splash programed into my Tivo. Sorry to say that this years Design Star winner will not be so lucky. HGTV hit "pay dirt" with David Bromstad. This years contestants do not have the "wow factor" to have their own design program much less hold viewers interest.

Posted by Vickie – August 27, 2007 10:22 PM

All I have to say for those who think Robb shouldn't have not gotten kicked out: You people are LOOSERS!! Just like Robb. I don't care how much design experience you have, if you don't treat people with professionalism and respect that they deserve sooner or later you won't succeed!

I am glad Kim let him do what he felt was the "right" thing, so much that their carpenter had to do the big FIXER!! How humiliating! The judges gave Robb too many opportunities, since day 1..what was that with that car door he got and hung up in their penthouse??? Anyhow...I am so relieved he is gone, cause even though I am a faithfull watcher, it was giving me ulcers just watching him! Now I can breathe!!

Posted by Melissa – August 27, 2007 10:17 PM

Hi

Rob's exit interview only shows how sad he really is. Calling the judges fools and saying that everyone made a mistake is truly a portraite into Rob's psyche.
I believe the judges did the right thing by voting him off. I just wish it was a couple of episodes ago instead of now.

I pray that someday Rob that you realize how caustic you can be when working with others and get some help.

Sparkle Josh,

I believe that you will transcend this set back and be a better person for it. Your grace and beauty really shined how you handled being voted off. I hope if it is God's will that HGTV will pick you up for a show anyways. Rest in God's love and peace for he will guide your path in all aspects of your life.

Thank you for bring grace and decency to such a competitive intense group of designers. It is good to see that positive descent people still exist today.

Posted by Ginger – August 27, 2007 10:03 PM

At last, the judges finally got it right!!! I just wish they had made better decisions earlier so we didn't suffer the loss of Josh Johnson.
We can only hope that some of our opinions will be seen as valuable and help to create a better show next year - assuming they intend to have one. I, too, want more individual competitions so we can truly judge them independently. It only takes one or two shows to determine how they work as a team. I am an HGTV fan all the way but it will take Will or Kim to have me tune in to the new Design Star. Still a big David Bromstad fan, however!! And I surely hope that Josh Johnson is picked up by someone for a show as I would definitely tune in to his creations!!

Posted by Joanie – August 27, 2007 9:55 PM

I was reading though some of these posts and couldn't believe someone who never watches HGTV thinks you should cut the quality of design for his viewership. HGTV has been my default chanel though all of the hateful reality shows on network TV. I seldom watch any network progaming anymore. Do you want to loose your loyal audience for the fickle new? For me design and function trumps everytime. The creativity of David Bromstad,Candice Olson,Lisa LaPorta,Kenneth Brown and Jane Lockhart keep me watching rerun after rerun --- the bad mannered antics of people like Robb cause me to hit the "off" button. I watch HGTV for "quality ideas" not some superficial egotistic loud mouth. Good ideas send me shopping --- Isn't that what your sponsers want?

Posted by sidneysand – August 27, 2007 9:54 PM

I AM SO GLAD THE ROBB IS GONE...I HAVE NOTHING ELSE TO SAY...THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO VENT THIS COMMENT...

Posted by Harold – August 27, 2007 9:38 PM

You know someone in the blog hit the nail on the head when they say that the fourth episode, Robb's design was tacky, and the taste of the couple was tacky. I believe that the show this time has hit a low, I love it still, and hope for the best for the three that will be completing. They have a tough act to follow with the high class of the first season's talent. I was totally in amazement for what they pulled off in the first season.
I feel now that some of those who where taken off the show, had a lot of talent, some had horrible personalities that I couldn't see being a TV host. Dave Bromstad has pulled way ahead again, flash and good taste. Robb showed what taste he had, TACKY and same type of personality. Bravo for getting him off the show, but bad taste on the judges part to get rid of Kristina and Josh

Posted by DJ – August 27, 2007 9:29 PM

THANK GOD ROB IS GONE!!! His arrogance was just too much to take. Last night I had a knot in my chest throughout the entire show because of his abusive, cocky and demeaning behavior. Kim was Grace Under Pressure and diplomatic to the end. Smooth sailing now!

Posted by Flo – August 27, 2007 8:49 PM

I agree with K.C. - I feel the judges are racist - and I'm white! I love Will's talent - and wonder consistantly why he is given such a hard time when he has had a part of the best rooms, whenever he was allowed input. Would I watch him with his bad grammar? YES - I want to pick up design clues - not graph sentences.

Posted by Cheryl – August 27, 2007 8:48 PM

THANK GOODNESS ROB IS GONE , HE SHOULD HAVE GONE LONG BEFORE . HE WAS SOOO VERY RUDE !!!
I WOULD NEVER BE ABLE TO USE HIM DECORATING MY HOME , YARD , GARAGE OR ANYTHING ELSE . THAT BOY NEEDS HELP IN THE WORST WAY IN SEVERAL AREA'S .
I AM SUSPRISED HE DOES NOT HAVE 2 BROKEN ARMS FROM PATTING HIMSELF ON THE BACK SO MUCH .
HATED TO SEE SPARKLE JOSH GO BUT LOOKING FORWARD TO TODD, WILL AND KIM , AS I THINK THEY ARE ALL GOOD WITH ALOT TO SHARE AND SHOW US ALL .
GERRI FROM TEXAS .

Posted by GERRI GOLDREYER – August 27, 2007 8:33 PM

YEA. Finally that cocky jerk is gone. How Robb's disasters from day one could have been swept under the rug to get him this far I have no idea. The harem pillow disaster I believe the comment was the pillows should have just been left off the seating. The Fake (not faux) Tuscan kitchen, the only classy part was the fountain and that wasn't Robb's idea. No one wanting him on their team and well everyone knows the rest. I still don't understand axing Sparkle Josh. His and Will's bedroom on the first show got great reviews from the judges. He may have "just shopped" on the kitchen makeover but he chose the appropriate style and budget and won an award for it. How could all that get forgotten so easily? As for those who are left, Kim you go girl!!!!!! Even "Color Splash" David said he wasn't a designer when he won the first Design Star. Your ability to work under pressure and adversity is amazing. Will love your color and style selections. Just need to hear you speak up and out a little better (you remind me of my boss, can never understand what he wants). Good Luck Guys

Posted by Yvonne – August 27, 2007 8:31 PM

WOW!!!!!!!!!!!! Good riddens to Rob! How did he ever get on that show??? He may have a portfolio of artistic designs, but it takes more than that to be a Design Star! He was rude and verbally abusive! I love David's, Color Splash. He is what America needed! I am not crazy about this season, but I say give Will a chance. He is so sincere and his designs are great! He has respect for people and that should count a lot!! Todd's designs are not for the average home. Who sits on furniture that pivots around the room?? Come on now! America wants to see what the average family can do and use. Get it right Design Star and stop all the arguing on the show. This is a a show for families to enjoy together and show case talent!

Posted by Donna – August 27, 2007 8:13 PM

Sorry to say, this years show is lacking what last years had! I have been watching, but it has not been easy. Robb should have been gone on the 2nd show! What is it with the same first personality to leave - a kooky artist!! The first time I saw Robb roll his eye at Josh "Sparkle" and put Will down - he was off the show for me. I picked Kim right off the first show (as I did with David). Will is a very good designer and I would not be unhappy if he won, but Kim is still my choice. Can't wait to see them all do their OWN designing. There has been too darn much drama and team work - still haven't seen enough of their personal work. PLEASE do better next time - IF there is a next time, after this year! Go KIM and WILL.
Rene

Posted by Rene – August 27, 2007 8:11 PM

I know I have brought this up before - but I think Sparkle and Will would make an excellent show. People complain Will is to "plain" and Sparkle is too "sparkley" - they worked together and came up with a fantastic room in the first episode - probably because both know how to compromise. Sparkle named the show himself - Ebony and Ivory.

Posted by Cheryl – August 27, 2007 8:05 PM

I will always love anything HGTV does. I definately love the Design Star series. I almost did not watch Sunday night because I could see Robb staying - UGH! He is nasty, hateful, and only loves himself. Good luck to the last three contestants. Keep your smile up Kim - you beat Robb. YEAH!!!!!

Posted by Donna Banks – August 27, 2007 7:56 PM

LOL. I think Todd could do a great den - a super-large skateboard sofa, with a rotating fireplace (the other side could be a giant hairball sculpture). Remote-controlled pulleys from the kitchen for pizza and energy drinks. A fireworks display on demand. Astroturf flooring. Video games in every corner. And don't forget the giant trampoline in the middle of the room. Awesome, dude. A 12-year-old boy's fantasy of a den!

Posted by Cheryl – August 27, 2007 7:50 PM

Judges are not consistent. They are supposed to judge what they see on the screen. Instead of picking up on the hideous tiles in the kitchen they decided to charge the designers' behavior. A bit late at this moment. It seems the producers got sick of Robb and passed that idea to judges. Anyway, I'm glad he's gone.

Posted by luzhok – August 27, 2007 7:43 PM

Thank you judges for getting rid of Robb! In order to have your own show and expect people to watch it - the host needs to be "likeable". Robb may be talented, but he has proven over & over again from the beginning of the season that he likes only one person... and that is Robb. His arrogance and cocky attitude has been a turn-off to me from day one and I'm glad he's gone. Like Mindy, I don't think I could endure another episode with him on it. The remaining 3 individuals are "in competition", yet all 3 have proven that they can work with others and seem to care about each other. Robb cares only about Robb. Still can't believe he called the judges fools! He's the fool!

Posted by Elaine – August 27, 2007 7:40 PM

Robb is gone! Yippeee!!!

Posted by Terry – August 27, 2007 7:38 PM

is it just me or does everyone notice how martha gets giggly and smiley when the judges are interviewing todd. so glad that robb is gone...his parting remarks were not surprising...so rude. kim's challenge wasn't really the kitchen makeover but how to deal with robb gracefully. will did a great job in the livingroom/diningroom...the furniture and details looked so nice. the lazy susan idea was interesting...todd has proven once again he can measure and construct things. but how many people want a lazy susan or half pipe in their home?

Posted by angi – August 27, 2007 7:38 PM

Could Robb be a performance artist who found a clever way to get "face time" nationally?
What designer: 1) Puts a wall oven under a counter! 2) Puts an oven between a sink and a dishwasher!
3) Tries to put a dishwasher under a sink!
His strategy worked--when the show is long gone, which of the "losers" will you remember?? QED

Posted by KHoward – August 27, 2007 7:28 PM

I like all the rest..glad he is gone..just wished it was sooner..However, Kim did an excellent job working with him..I really don't know who I like so far..but I will keep watching

Posted by Peggy – August 27, 2007 7:26 PM

Robb did have some great ideas and seemed to implement them well. But his personality! I did not notice that he got along with anyone. I am thrilled that Robb is gone. He was truly a piece of work. And not in a nice way.

Posted by Doerrtl – August 27, 2007 7:04 PM

I thoughly enjoyed the show last night, I'm glad Robb got the "Boot", man he had a bad attitude. Oh well!

Posted by June – August 27, 2007 7:02 PM

Oh joy- Robb is gone. should have been gone many shows ago. He is rude and should have been punched by will or kim but they were very controlled. Think Todd is a little gimmicky so the choice seems to be will or kim. It Doesn't matter - the only thing that matters is Robb is gone!
Find a show for Sparkle Josh - he really livened up the show and do not do two eliminations next year and more individual challenges.

Posted by Lovescolor – August 27, 2007 6:57 PM

I am in total agreement with hundreds(if not thousands) of others... hip hip horray, Robb is gone!!! Although Robb had some interesting ideas, he is not show biz material. He is so self centered and angry in life, that it made the show less enjoyable to watch. Furthermore, it was the contractor that really should have received kudos for this job! Todd is quite creative, but honestly, over the top creative. It takes a special show for him to design ...like, Designing for the Overgrown Kid or something. The person who will do the best on their own show, would be Kim. Hands down! She ranks up there in workmanship, creativity and personality. I like Will a lot, but gosh, he flopped in the preview show part. No spark. Good luck to the winner.

Posted by ttopbird – August 27, 2007 6:49 PM

Let's remember what they did....In the first show Robb's big contribution to a classy Las Vegas flat was to hang a rusted car door on the wall. He faux painted in a kitchen leaving the lower cabinets undone. He gave the wedding couple the tacky look they desired although it just didn't strike me as fantastic design...it ended up more of a jumble of different elements. In the kitchen he knew so much about, the oven was crammed unevenly next to the dishwasher and the green glass tiled backsplash didn't coordinate with the design colors. I believe he tried to make Will look bad because he was trying to eliminate his toughest competitor. Unfortunately, the only successful room was the one he did all by himself. In real life you have to work cooperatively with others in a positive way to be a complete designer. Robb lacked this ability. Todd built a skateboard ramp in the Vegas flat, used his construction skills in the kitchen remodel ( but nothing he did in that room was outstanding). He set up stuff for the wedding and flipped over a banquet table possibly damaging it with his antics. The turntable, while initially innovative, only leaves seating in that whole TV area for three people. Cute but not the best use of the space. The one thing he impressed me with was his painting in the single room he designed. I still see him as an overgrown kid, pleasant enough but never quite taking the lead in superlative design. Kim initially impressed me with the relaxing seating area in the Vegas flat. She could have rechecked the measurements to see if they had purchased enough tile for the kitchen. I did see that she picked up on the owners' like of a wine theme in that kitchen. I saw her as a team player. In the wedding show her design board lacked pizzazz. I also expected some kind of final element in her solo room that took it from yeah to OH Yeah! Yes, in the last show she needed to stop Robb from taking over, but after that she again didn't purchase enough design elements to make the room go "WOW, I want to hire that designer"! Her camera poise was good. Will seems to have the knack of working well with each designer on color selection and in work. Every job was completed on time. The colors and furniture layout in the Vegas flat were excellent. Can't remember what contribution he made in the kitchen segment. Was pleased to see he used different color combinations in the flat, his individual room and again the bride commented on his ability to combine black, red, and purple together in a classy way. His design board looked more classy and well thought out than any of the others too. For someone with a college degree, I expect better grammar and posture. The real test is this week. Can't wait to see the results. Thanks HGTV, I enjoy this series. Hope you can find something for Sparkle Josh like you did for Alice from the last Design Star.

Posted by Vickie – August 27, 2007 6:49 PM

Robb had talent, but he just didn't know how to actually direct or focus it into the kitchen that was decorated. I mean he did a good job but he was too hell bent on bothering Kim and bossing her around. I don't think that was professional or polite.

Posted by Ribcage – August 27, 2007 6:42 PM

With great interest I have been watching the 2nd season of Design Star, as last year, was totally awesome this one doesn't seem to have the same gusto. I loved Josh as he did SPARKLE, loved his attitude and how he was willing to work with others, and he worked hard at what he did. But last week sadly they let him go, which I thought was the wrong pick but what do I have to say, except they kept Robb over him, no way. Well now, Episode 5 we got to see how Robb worked with his team, NOT, he was rude to Kim, and felt that he was digging at her and not having her as part of the team (his true color comes out). Finally, judges release him thank heavens, but what ?? he thinks they are fools, come on Robb, you didn't finish the first kitchen and now you can't be a team player, and you call them "Fools". What a difference from Robb's release and Josh's. I hope when they bring someone back, I hope it is Josh, not Robb, for he is to full of himself and needs to learn how to work with others. I do have to say that the Star's haven't really hit me like last years, I remember Dave Bromstad's, individual room, truly awesome from the pet store..who could imagine but he did and now he is great at his show, so I am going to watch with interst this next shows, who will shine, will it be Todd, with some of the weird things he comes up with, not really would I want that platform in the room, but it showed imagination, but did hit me like last year's designers. Will is quiet man, and hope that he brings up some guns for the next show. And Kim, who has great personality, working the with Robb and patience she has, now it is time to get with it. Show your stuff girl.

Posted by DJ – August 27, 2007 6:41 PM

Rob was robbed. Who? or what are we looking for? Design Star is not supposed to train a hopeful designer. This season is a let down so far, I am a designer, and even I, in my short career of around 5 years have worked on a few kitchens. "Round white table with black Blah! "chairs" C'mon that was an awful choice. All Kim did was go shopping, two mirrors, two pieces of artwork and she's done. Wasn't she in charge of dressing the room. Even as a novice I know that is not talent or style. Maybe the show isn't getting the best response to adverts when HGTV- Design Star is looking for best and brightest. Rob got it done, and on time. Kim is out of her leage.

Tobie in PA

Posted by Tobie Ketterer – August 27, 2007 6:30 PM

I have never blogged before, but had to take the time to try it. WOW! What drama last night. I am soooooo glad to see Robb kicked off. I did not like his designs and he reminded me of a pompous, arrogant boss I once had. Robb showed his true colors at the end of the show when he called the designers fools. But who's the fool now?? He's not getting a show! The most talented person left is Will. His designs are great and he has a very good attitude. Todd needs to put his shirt on, we already have David. My son is a skateboarder, so I really do not want to see anymore spinning, half pikes, etc. on a design show. I'm getting dizzy. Kim what can I say, you're a NYC girl, but I have yet to see your real talent. I am glad you did not say what was probably going through a lot of peoples minds regarding the jerk, oh I mean Robb.

Posted by Susan – August 27, 2007 6:20 PM

Hi, I was very pleased that Robb was eliminated from the show last night. You can tell from his comments after he was cancelled that his ego is bigger than his talent. A part of being talented is also being gracious and a team member. A true leader is someone who helps others accomplish their goals. He could have been a winner if he was also interested in helping his team member shine. I was very impressed with Kim's ability to handle Robb. It was difficult for her to show her talent with Robb's constant praising of himself. I wish all of the remaining 3 the best of luck. Annette

Posted by Annette – August 27, 2007 6:11 PM

I think the double eliminations in three episodes were a major disservice to the fans, the contestants and the judges. Decisions were made based on WHAT? The projects, especially the wedding, were one man shows with everyone else playing support. How could the judges have possibly eliminated ANY of the supporting designers, based on that? So here we were, with only four people left, not really knowing what any of the four are personally capable of, other than one individual challenge that was IDENTICAL to a challenge from last season, and only showed us who paid attention to last season...and we get ANOTHER team project this week. We are going down to the final two challenges without ever seeing the capabilies of the contestants. What is the RUSH? We love the show, so why not give us more episodes? Drop the Las Vegas glitz and give us some good, practical challenges that show individual talents.

Posted by Kathleen – August 27, 2007 6:11 PM

Robb is a great designer but has some deep issues with his personality that need to be worked out. Todd is very good also but seems to have a surfer boy style. He needs to get rid of that before he can be a design star. His designs need to be more functional. He definitely has the wow factor going on. Kim and Will's talents remain to be seen in full.

Posted by CrystalN – August 27, 2007 6:03 PM

I'm happy to see Robb gone. I'd never watch a show with a host who has an ego as big as his!

It was nice to see the designers agree on a basic color scheme to unite both rooms.

Not sure who I want to win.

Will has been quiet, but, he can get help with that if he wins. I like his designs.

Kim is a good host, but, not sure if her work could carry a show week after week.

None of Todds designs seem practical to me. A lazy susan in the living room? Wayne Newtons wife was scared to get up on it. And the couch seemed too close to the TV to watch it comfortably for more than just a few minutes.

Posted by Donna – August 27, 2007 6:00 PM

HIP HIP HOORAY, ROBB WAS SENT AWAY!. What a rude, arrogant person he was. Maybe he had good ideas, but then again, given what the bridal couple asked to be done for their wedding, they deserved that mess. As for the kitchen, well, after being borderline abusive to Kim, and being so pompous, he left a REFRIGERATOR SITTING IN THE BACK YARD! Not to mention, he couldn't measure correctly. And apparently he doesn't use his own kitchen, he put the oven nearly on the floor and put the sink up against a wall. How is that good workflow. Not sad at all to see him leave.

Posted by Karen B. – August 27, 2007 5:57 PM

Finally Robb is gone! I think Todd should be the next to go. He surfs the waves too much. I'm afraid everyones home will be flooded out. I like Will, he just needs to step up the hosting ablity. I'm not sure about Kim. Her background of being a hair dresser only makes me feel uneasy. I think I would prefer someone who had a little design experience, but I do like her work.

Posted by Denise – August 27, 2007 5:53 PM

I was soooooo glad to see that lil twerp Robb leave. He called the judges "fools". So, Rob if you applied to be judged by a bunch of fools, answer this, who is the real fool? Singing nah- nah-nah-nah, nah-nah-nah-nah, hey-hey-hey goooodbye! HGTV wasn't going to give a Bubba Backwoods a TV show. So long sucker! Ha, ha!

Posted by Renee – August 27, 2007 5:26 PM

How can they NOT bring back Sparkle Josh when we all love him so much????? I am so glad to see Robb gone. He was totally irritating, rude and obnoxious. But I really don't see the quality design talent that we had in the last season in the remaining contestants. I think the judges got rid of the good talent ... Josh J and Christina and Todd. To pick from what is left, I guess I would pick Kim. I would probably watch her show if she got one. Certainly, she is as good as some of the others currently on HGTV.

Posted by nanajulie7 – August 27, 2007 5:14 PM

WILL is definately the Best Designer of the 3!!!
He and Kim could have a good show together, but he and Sparkle Josh could have a Great Show.

Posted by fan – August 27, 2007 5:12 PM

Like many others, I'm glad not to have to watch Robb any more. Unlike many others, I've just started wondering what sort of show will be created for whichever person is voted the Design Star. If Todd wins, things may go in a very untypical direction for HGTV. I didn't like him at first, but his extreme difference from the others is starting to grow on me. Plus, he is the only one who has gotten along with all of the other players... even Robb. That takes a very special person.

That being said, I still like Kim and Will a lot. Will didn't do very well on the hosting, but that's just because he is low-key. He is the best pure designer left on the show. He could learn some techniques of presentation on-camera. Kim was great on camera as a host -- a little manic (possibly nervous), but it went over well with the judges. Some people on this blog doubt her design skills, but with the right type of show she could do well.

I can't believe that HGTV would want to do a "cookie cutter" by copying the format of David Bromstad's show exactly. David is so good that none of these others could compete on that level. I think they need a brand new format for the new show. I don't know what, but I'd like to see something different, with an interesting host.

Posted by JAM – August 27, 2007 5:04 PM

Well, this is my first time entering comments on a blog, but not my first time watching Design Star. I was totally hooked last season.

I have to agree with the viewers who have said that Robb should have been gone. There is nothing worse that having to work with a arrogant, hardly talented, wannabe David Bromstad, my-chest-is-bigger-than-your-chest man.

I believe, at the end of the day, it will be Will and Kim...and, it is about time a person of color (yes, an African-American) get his/her own show on the network...and if I had to choose, I think Kim could bring in a great audience.

So, I will be glued to the TV this Sunday...and I might even watch during the week just to see Robb get the boot, again...it is like the gift that keeps on giving...Oh, sorry Robb, just could not help myself. But, much success to you...keep designing those hundreds of kitchens!

Posted by Red Rose – August 27, 2007 4:44 PM

Well there is always one in every bunch, one who thinks he has talant and well.....Now he is gone. My husband, who watches with me, Wanted to know what women p.....d him off. Well Exactly what he said was "Wow He really doesn;t like women does he. Nor does he really respect them either." I really don't know what the agenda is that the producers have but i have not been very impressed with the show this year. I think they are looking for a good overall personality that will appeal to all people who then has a bit of design talent. And the next to go should be Todd, He is just as arragont. Please PUT YOUR SHIRT ON!!!!!!!! Design is what we want not skin.

Posted by Tribby – August 27, 2007 4:44 PM

I had made a decision that if Robb remained on the show, I would stop watching HGTV. What an egotistical jerk!

I would like to see a show that features Sparkle Josh and Will Smith. They had synergy when working together.

Posted by berniem – August 27, 2007 4:39 PM

Finally, Rob is gone! He would never have attracted viewers to a new show on HGTV and few home owners would want to deal with a know-it-all arrogant designer in their homes. I believe Sparkle Josh had the best overall package with talent, skills, personality and flair on camera. I don't think Kim has anywhere near enough design talent to have her own show. She would probably be high maintenance for the support staff to help her on her own show. I would not want Todd to design anything in my house. He's too impractical for everyday living. If Martha McCully could stop drooling over him for a minute, she might realize this. Will has the best design talent of anyone left. David Bromsted didn't have a lot of flair for the camera but he learned how to do it. The same could happen for Will. Will definitely has the talent and yet the judges are constantly questioning him as to what he did. He just doesn't stand up for himself enough.

Posted by Bertram – August 27, 2007 4:37 PM

Don't forget - the area Todd and Will designed was a "guest" house. No one is going to be living there all the time. They will be visiting and visiting a star at that - expecting something different. Looked at in that way - I like the rotating room. Oh yeah - glad to be able to say bye bye Robb.

Posted by yloo – August 27, 2007 4:33 PM

I was sooooo sad to see Robb go. I think he would have made a great show host, had design talent, was sexy and should have taken his shirt off like Todd and shown his stuff. Robb is a good looking hunk and his abrasiveness would have been toned down on a set. He was in a competition and played it like a competitor. Robb, I shall miss you. Good luck in the future. You, Scott and Sparkle Josh were the best ones. I am bored with Design Star now. Can't see any of the remaining ones doing a show and I shall not watch any of them nor Vern's new show - yuk!

Posted by Dee Dee Cee – August 27, 2007 4:30 PM

It was about time! Robb, if you are reading this, which I doubt, you are a mule's rear end. And, I apologize to all mules out there. And, as others have pointed out, your designs have not been all that great. Your tile job was absolutely hideous. It was worse than the unfinished tile job that Najerah or whatever, her name was, didn't finish. You two would make a great couple. Oh, wait a minute... both of you think too much of yourselves to even think about someone else. You should have been kicked off on the very first show. Apparently the judges do NOT look at the film of the potential Designer Stars doing their work or both of you would have been booted off the first show, instead of the girl with the black and white hair. Neither one of you knew how to play nice with others. Most of us out here know that is one of the most important traits they are looking for in a New Design Star, is how well they get along with others. Not arrogant people like yourself who bully others to get what you want. If you can't play nice with others, then get the heck off the set. Robb, you are a bully! Own it, and get over it! If not, I doubt anyone will want to hire you after this.
Todd, on the other hand has settled down some, which is good.
I don't have a preference for any of the last three contestants. We will wait to see what happens.

Posted by Joyce – August 27, 2007 4:25 PM

Producers and Editors chose what viewers will see in each episode, which means they can influence how we feel about the contestants and how we vote. I'm not sure if the judges see more or less than viewers do. I find the qualifications of most of the original slate of contestants surprisingly questionable (most had little or no design working experience and/or training). I also don't think the weekly challenges have been designed to test either the true design talent and skills or the hosting skills of the contestants (though they be able to acquire them with training). That being said, here are my views of this weeks episode.

Loser Robb deserved to go. He should have gone in the first episode (his design effort was judged a failure and even then his EGO was obnoxious), but evidently the judges weren't able to see it the way tv viewers could.

His "contribution" to the design part of this episode was less than sub-standard. Once again, his measurements were off; his tile job was actually worse than Kim's in the previous kitchen challenge (glass tile with unevenly-applied grey adhesive & sloppy grout job?); his "vision" for the wine/rock wall lacked a professional quality finish and was incorporated awkwardly (more eyesore than innovation); he may have experience doing "thousands of kitchens", but he hasn't USED many kitchens, because his appliance placement lacked a user-friendly (usually triangular) placement and where WAS the refridgerator going to go -- in the mud room by the back door, would he actually consider that placement convenient?
From the first episode, his lack of respect for others (an understatement after his performance toward Kim in this episode, but consider his treatment of former "team-mates" Will, Josh, etc and his on-camera poison-tongued and his facial "back-stabbing" of all the others) and his over-inflated self-admiration (aka bully braggart swaggart) negated any design talent he may or may not possess (and blinded him to his design flaws). We were shown that he "gets along" with others when he is pandering to clients for a job or basking in the glow of a compliment. His behavior is typical of a man over-compensating for poor self-esteem -- not sure if his problem stems from a Napoleonic complex or his obvious discomfort about his balding problem which caps, hats, and kerchiefs didn't really disguise (well at least we were spared an ugly comb-over -- okay, a pot-shot, but his hateful rants bring out barbs).
Robb needs to get a new life view: design (like fashion, a "here today, gone tomorrow" industry) and physical appearance aren't what's important in this life! How we treat others is the measure of a great man (or woman)! In this life, truly successful people ARE kind, because if you're talented, you'll get some jobs; but eventually you'll be ALONE, because no one will work with you or want to share a life with you (and that's what success is: building and sharing a life).

Winners Todd, Kim, and Will deserved to stay this week. They made better design and behavior choices than Robb.

Posted by Reen – August 27, 2007 4:23 PM

I agree with Tim Hermetz, Robb was a great Design Star. He may not be able to work with people well now, but that can be learned just like David Bromstad learned how to host after he won. Todd is a joke and if Martha hadn't been drooling over his body since the first show he would have been gone the first week for that stupid and selfish skateboard thing. Kim just smiles and goes on pretty well for someone with no professional training but she is no design star. Will has common sense and is a Vern Yip wannabee. Crikey! We don't need another Vern who decorates with lemons and candles! The only decent judge is Cynthia Rowley.

Posted by Dee Dee Cee – August 27, 2007 4:17 PM

It's very obvious that the show is design star ,not decorator star,rRobb is the only one who has built things in all kinds of rooms , your decorators will be over run by contractors,because they carry no experience in the designing of the space, actual construction,he got along just fine with the carpenter. The design team of judges made their decision , based on I don't know what? Who ever wins ,their show won't last, the same as last years loser,his rooms are so pedestrian,not high end in any streatch of the imagination,well I guess you have to pick the pc person,affirmative action in it's most obvious !!!!!

Posted by Thomas Hess – August 27, 2007 4:14 PM

Well, Rob is gone. I thought he was just mean but at the exit interview he proved he really needs a good dose of TLC. None of us can give it to him but someone in his real life hopefully will care enough about him to help. HGTV is not the place for him that is for sure. I kind of miss Sparkle too. It would have been fun to watch him. Todd is different. His designs are unique. Kim is a sweet person and has some ideas. Will is a nice guy and a good planning,hard working designer but seems lost in front of the camera. SO...bring Josh Sparkle back and see what happens.. they made a great team.

Posted by Barb C – August 27, 2007 4:06 PM

The work at Newton's guest house was terrible. I hope he gets someone to fix that mess. However - considering the 4 designers has only 24 hours, did not coordinate their ideas before they started, and had to work with Robb - the results were doomed from the beginning. Doesn't someone in the production of this show have a way to monitor what's happening. This show should have been halted long enough to remove Robb. He was so abusive. Todd is immature but he certainly is creative. Everyone needs some design help that is "outside the box". Todd would be a great person for a spot in HGTV. He just needs a little training. Will is very very creative, he shows design experience, he knows how to make people feel good about themselves while he is introducing his ideas. Will is another person that would be great for HGTV with a little more training, Kim is talented too. The tile mess was not HER fault - remember the one who didn't measure the space !!! What was that witche's name??? Anyway, like the rest of the HGTV design star contestants, she needs some training. A hair dresser is trained to design and consult about hair styling. What training does she have in home design? Kim is wonderful with the other contestants. I have to say she demonstrated the utmost of self control in that she didn't physically injure Rob. I'm so glad he's finally gone. I hope he reads these many comments about what a bad creature he is.

Posted by BJ Johnson – August 27, 2007 3:57 PM

Design Star is about a talented designer. It is about someone that expands our minds as to what design is and can be. Todd gets us thinking. So we might not want the half pipe, the wave, or the turning platform, but boy did that expand my mind as to what a person can do with a living space. Most look at a room with a color wheel and some molding and try to figure out how to make an Ikea, Pottery barn, or Restoration Hardware type of space. A half pipe is not my thing, but I had a loft I would probably have a basketball court. And yes, I have children. Silver Spoons had a really cool train. I prefer Todd’s more intellectual and future thinking approach to design. Todd challenges us to think beyond our self imposed limits about what a room can do for us. That is truly a design star! Kim and Rob don’t even appear to be as talented as myself when it comes to designing and redesigning, and I’m a weekend warrior. Please give me something greater than myself and challenge me to think beyond the mundane.

Posted by Paul – August 27, 2007 3:48 PM

The calibur of designer this season has been far lower than last season. None of these designers (sorry Will) has really separated themselves from a pack of middle-of-the-road talent at best. And I can't for the life of me figure out why the panel loves Josh so much. It may have to do with the fact that he has a good on-air presence, but to me he seems more like the zany surfer dude carpenter that appear on most HGTV shows. Last year's winner, David (and yes Alice) showed the range and know-how to really distinguish themselves. I have yet to see any evidence that this will occur this season. It's going to be very predictable, Will won't win because he's not charismatic enough. Kim won't win because she has virtually no practical experience. Which ultimately leaves us with Josh and his "radical" schtick. Whatever.

Posted by Dave – August 27, 2007 3:46 PM

I’m a huge fan of HGTV’s Design Star. My comments here echo many of the others I have been reading concerning last night’s episode. I did not like the lazy-susan in that living room…not practical for a living room, and it has the potential to be quite dangerous. I wouldn't want it in my guest house, only to have my guests injure themselves and end up suing me. A great idea is only great if it FUNCTIONS and this clearly did not. I agree Will is likable and has a good design sense, but does not come across well on camera as a host and that part is as important as the design aspect. (In fact I am surprised they do not emphasize the hosting portion more from the beginning-if they did we may have had a completely different group of finalists - which would have been a good thing.) I also agree that this season is lacking something. This season’s group of contestants isn’t as engaging as last season's, and the wrong people are being eliminated, leaving us with a motley crew of rude, crude, and shirtless amateurs, who wouldn't know class and style if it bit them. And thank heaven Rob is gone - what a jerk. And his "fool" comment in his exit interview…he's so full of himself it's disgusting. At this point I am rooting for Kim, not necessarily because she's the best, but because she's the most likeable of the ones that are left. But I'm afraid Todd will win. In fact he's my choice in the "Fantasy Design" challenge. Not because I think he deserves it, but because I am sensing something in the judges comments that tells me they like him a lot. Although, I have to say, maybe he would have the most unique show on HGTV…doing wild, crazy, impractical things with people's spaces (ala "Monster House"). He may just cater to that younger and hipper niche audience that they haven't quite captured yet. He may be a good choice in a business sense, but not when it comes to pure design. But regardless of my opinions above, I love the show and can't wait until next season. P.S. I LOVE watching Color Splash with David Bromstad. He has really blossomed into a great designer and performer. Good choice. And one more thing…I agree with everyone who is missing Sparkle Josh. He was clearly a stand-out and I am still dazed and confused as to why he was eliminated.

Posted by patger – August 27, 2007 3:44 PM

It has come to the end of the show. Well, at least the end of my watching the show. I am just amazed at how the judging has gone and who has survived.

Perhaps HGTV will give Josh a show of his own anyway, to fill the gap of whatever show they bring out in the future with the (supposed) winner of this current season.

After watching all fo the Project Runway episodes, Top Chef episodes (all from that competitor Bravo) and then seeing Design Star, I was thrilled that HGTV would take one such a great concept. David winning last season was great...his show tells that. But this season shows a lack of concept.

There are no contestants left who I will tune in to see their own show, let alone the finale and final episodes. I will just set my DVR up to record the older episodes of "Design to Sell" in order to get the "Clive Fixx".

Good bye Design Star...who ever you are.

Now, back to Bravo!

Posted by Brad – August 27, 2007 3:44 PM

What a NICE CHANGE last nights show was from the past several weeks. The judges actually judged the work. I will look forward to next weeks show. As yet - we have yet to see the 3 contestants design all on their own - so this should really be an exciting next few episodes.
These 3 people have shown glimmers of different abilties - which one will have design capabilites, satify peoples real makeovers and be able to learn to how tos of hosting a show on HGTV? I can't wait!

Posted by christine – August 27, 2007 3:42 PM

Of the remaining three, the only one I would allow to design a room in my home is Will :)

Posted by Linda – August 27, 2007 3:42 PM

I was disapointed that Will and Kim were chozen its too bad, their talent does and did not strike me as the best of the lot, and if they should happen to get chosen as the "design star" well you lost me as a viewer... THEY ARE DULL DULL DULL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! the judges said Kim did a wonderful job on her tv interview - it was HORRIBLE AND SO WAS WILL'S - very dissapointed that they were chosen

i was so excited when your last Design star won and i thought HGTV WOULD HAVE HAD A GREAT SHOW lined up for him and its BLAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i DON'T WATCH DAVE (your past DESING STAR) his show "color splash" is shoddy for such a talented designer. He was the best and HGTV is not usuing him to his potential. I am disapointed with his show, whishing that you could give him something better ON HIS OWN.

wishing out of the three that ""JOSH"" WINS HE IS THE MOST TALENTED AND HGTV WILL HAVE A BIG LOSS IN MY EYES BECAUSE THE OTHER TWO ARE USLESS DESIGNERS

Posted by GISELLE – August 27, 2007 3:37 PM

I agree with many of the others who commented that it was difficult to choose the most talented because we have only seen one challenge that the designers worked on by themselves other than the wedding. Perhaps the purpose of the wedding was to see who would leave out the groom's desires while concentrating on the bride? Personally I would not have liked such a reception but then I am older.
I, too, have been wondering what happened to Sparkle Josh? It seemed like he was bowing out gracefully rather than fighting for his chance in the spotlight, especially when no one else considered him to be a competitor but their own personal friend. That had to be demoralizing.
So, HGTV folks, do you have a way for the public to contact their favorite designers once they have been tossed? If nothing else, all these designers deserve to have acclaim in their own cities of domicile.
Good Luck to all the finalists.

Posted by Gloria B. – August 27, 2007 3:37 PM

I too am happy that Robb is gone. I can't believe it took 3-4 other contestants complaining about his abrasive communication skills to get him tossed. Could you imagine anyone having to work with him on a show? I bet the carpenters and assistants would quit after one episode of him calling them "fools" and "morons".
As for his talent? The 4 contestants all agreed on a cohesive color scheme (picked out by Will), the kitchen wall colors are paprika/squash like with warm wood tones in the flooring and rocks...Robb picks seafoam green tiles with black grout for a backsplash, yuck!!!!! Remember he did all the shopping at the home improvement store because he feels Kim is stupid. Then how dare Kim and the carpenter question Robb's placement of the appliances...hello I don't want the oven frying my kneecaps while I'm doing the dishes!(the dishwasher and stove are right next to each other under the sink and cooktop...is there no other space in the kitchen) Why did he remove the wall oven, and put display shelves in it's place. Granted I am not a wine drinker, but is it really necessary to put in a wine chiller and not have a microwave...I think the old fireplace area could have been used much more efficiently.
I think Will has a good eye and really works well with others, he's just not assertive enough. On the individual tasks I think he shined. I disagreed with the judges that his was the weakest presentation, I felt that Todd was equally as stiff. On Camera presentation is what acting classes are for..look how long it took for David's show to get on the air. I too have sensed that 2 of the judges really do not like Will, and for that reason I am not holding out much hope for him next week...but I have my fingers crossed.

Posted by lois – August 27, 2007 3:23 PM

I must repeat this blog- I think that this is the most concise and appropriately worded blog of the day! Thank you Grazzi, I couldn't agree more! Beth

Robb's post-elimination tantrum proved that he fully deserved his ouster. Sparkle Josh was gracious to a fault when he was asked to go, but Robb used the opportunity to call the judges names. Nice going! One of the reasons everyone loves David Bromstad is that he is fantastic at relating to a wide swath of personality types: prickly yuppies, traditional couples, 'working class' groups, new parents, etc. Even people who may not be wild about (ahem) flamboyant individuals warm to David naturally. Robb was the antithesis of David, capable of turning anyone off more or less instantly. He would have been horrific to work with.

Kim has the sort of personality that would shine on her own show, but so far has failed to display the actual design skills necessary. Will isn't terribly eloquent, being a quiet sort, and Todd is like "Dude!" I'm not sure any of them is The Whole Package. Sparkle Josh, despite a horrifically bad "99 Cent Store" room, was BY FAR the best choice for his own show. He was funny, classy, caring, visually attuned and people of all sorts gravitated towards him. A real loss.

Posted by Grazzi – August 27, 2007 4:30 AM

Posted by Beth – August 27, 2007 3:20 PM

Enough about Robb, gotta add to the "screaming through" who's got talent? How would we know? version of this show. Don't really care about any of them except Todd. NEED that guy to go. I thought I had seen the last of the contrived shirtless designer look. For the love of fabric, leave your shirt on Todd, nobody (or is that NO BODY) wants to look.

Posted by Joanna – August 27, 2007 3:18 PM

OH AND LWATKINS, I love reading your posts. Your posts are what motivated me to come to the blog section.

It is like you are in my head, because you say some of the same things that I am thinking. I found a kindered spirt.

Read at cha later -- Sheila

Posted by she luv hgtv – August 27, 2007 3:17 PM

IT IS ABOUT TIME THAT ROBB GOT KICKED OFF THE SHOW. WHEN ARE THE JUDGES GOING TO GET KICKED OFF? SURELY THEIR ARE JUDGES OUT THERE THAT COULD BE FAIR AT JUDGING THE CONTESTANTS.

Posted by Janet – August 27, 2007 3:12 PM

HAS ANYONE ELSE NOTICED OR IS IT JUST ME THAT THE MORE CLOTHES TODD TAKES OFF THE LOWER THE NECK LINES ON THE FEMALE JUDGES GET EACH WEEK??? IT IS SO WEIRD TO WATCH THEIR INTERACTION WITH HIM. THEY MIGHT AS WELL GET A HOTEL ROOM WITH HIM IN VEGAS AND GET IT OVER WITH. OR MAYBE THEY ALREADY HAVE. THEY SAY WHAT HAPPENS IN VEGAS STAYS IN VEGAS HMMMMM

Posted by pf – August 27, 2007 3:09 PM

Another viewer here extremely happy about Robb's demise. What an a-hole. He should have been gone ages ago. I think they left him on the show for tension's sake. This is all about ratings you know.

IMO, Will is the best designer, but he'll have to quickly develop a "tv persona" in order to win. Kim has a great tv personality... but, is design skill really that important on HGTV? I mean really, folks, I've seen some damn ugly stuff on some of the other shows...

Posted by malarkey – August 27, 2007 3:05 PM

Well .... Robs gone but even though he wasnt my favorite by a long shot it was sad for him ... He is very talented but just has some problems that he needs help on . All in all i think the show went well . I felt sorry for Kim getting talked to like that ... . Who will the winner be? Its really hard for me to vote this week cause they each are so talented in there own way .. Who has the best repore with people I think Todd and Kim but i Love Wills Designs ..Hes very very good but kinda shy in alot of ways ... Its any bodys Ball game from here on out ... It just doesnt seem the same with them all gone ... Wheres the Sparkle??? Hugs Paula

Posted by Paula – August 27, 2007 3:05 PM

I could tell Robb was a smart mouth, know it all pain in the arse from the beginning of the show. His final remarks showed his true colors. The crocodile tears didn't impress me at all.

If Robb had not been eliminated from the show, I would not watch the rest of the season. Robb being the 'Next Design Star' would be the downfall of HGTV.

I am glad the judges finally woke up before it was too late.

Last season I was not convinced David should be the New Design star until the final challenge. I pulled for Alice until the last show.

Last year we got to see the individual personalities emerge, which I miss seeing this year and hope next season we will get to know the contestants as individuals.

I am anxious to see who the winner will be this year.

Posted by Brenda – August 27, 2007 2:58 PM

I think almost everybody shares the same feeling against Robb. He should be the first one to get eliminated, but i guess they'd keep him this far so the show will be more interesting; however, it was unfair for other competitors who are more talented than Robb if that was the case. I jumped for joy when Robb's show has been cancelled. Robb needs to learn more in life specially in the profession that he chose.

Posted by tess m.d. – August 27, 2007 2:54 PM

Reading the post by Tim Hermetz, I began to think he was the second coming of Rob! Either that or Rob paid Tim to shill for him. In either case, once I stopped laughing I felt compelled to respond with seven simple words: You have got to be kidding me!
Rob was the epitome of emotional retardation, misogyny, condescension, a WAY over inflated sense of his talent and most important of all, he was patently dishonest.

See ya, Rob. Don't let the Design Star door hit you on your way out. Go home, throw a temper tantrum, go to bed and suck your thumb.

Posted by jmhh – August 27, 2007 2:54 PM

I wonder if Rob was acting like he did because he was trying to copy Doug Wilson of Trading Spaces on TLC. I believe his bio says that Doug Wilson is his favorite designer. Doug Wilson and Hildi became popular for being negative and pushy, espeically Doug. It worked for him. Or, I remember in the casting show that Rob said that he felt he represented the men of America. Maybe he was trying to act macho in a way that backfired. In a real life situation on job though, Rob's manner is the way things are in construction projects if he is a foreman. He may be used to acting that way at work, which would be expected of him. Can you imagine how Eric Frommer, Steve Watson, Bob Villa, Ty Pennington would react if they had to totally redo a kitchen in 24 hours with the help of someone who is a hairdresser with no design or construction experience. They would probably all act like Robb did and expect their hairdresser team mate to take notes, shop and do the decorating. When you are on a 24 deadline, this is not the time to teach home improvement and design skills to your team mate. I think Robb was talented. I was disappointed that he did not draw his designs to scale though since he took graphic design for 3 years. Maybe he is used to doing his designs on a computer with a program that scales it for him. What kind of show would Kim host if she won since she has no experience? I also wonder if the show is being edited to make certain contestants look a certain way (Robb being the hard to get along with person, etc.). I would guess that some o fhis commments were to himself, not to Kim and that they were picked up by a microphone he had on him. He and others probably forgot they were being taped at all times and had to watch what they said and did. I wish Robb the best, as I wish all the contestants. (Josh, come back!)

Posted by Lara – August 27, 2007 2:49 PM

I'm just another who agrees it was long past due to have Robb's show cancelled.

However, I've yet to see anyone suggest a future season of bring back the previously canncelled folks for another try - then we might get to see what else Sparkle, Scott, etc. could show the judges. I think that might be a new challenging season!

I wish each of the remaining contestants the best of luck - but have to say that I am pulling for Will - I think he's very talented - just needs a bit of presentation assistance - and when haven't we all needed that?

Best of luck to all!

Posted by Sue – August 27, 2007 2:48 PM

Curosity got the best of me after I said I wasn't going to watch. I had to see if Rob would endure. It's really sad that the judges eliminated Josh before Robb. Why couldn't they do the right thing and eliminate him earlier. I am still wondering about this Kim girl. I don't believe she can carry her own show. I ask you once more, please bring Josh back. You will make millions of viewers happy.

Posted by edna wilson – August 27, 2007 2:41 PM

I don't think any of the designers were of the stature of last season. I really can't see watching a show featuring any of them, except perhaps Sparkle Josh. I don't think we really got to know any of them. Went way too fast!

Posted by Marta – August 27, 2007 2:40 PM

I think next year HGTV should try to find design contestants that mirror the most interesting personalities already on HGTV. there are a lot of them, so they should be able to get a good diversity. Here is a list of 55 I would compile. They all have a good sense of humor, which, to me, is very important in a TV host, and are entertaining, fun and talented in many ways. The top dozen are in order of my favorites. The rest are not in any particular order.

1. Georrge Gray (host of What's up with that House)
2. Blond Junk brother
3. Dark haired junk brother
4. Paul James, the gardener guy
5. Matt Fox
6. Carter Van Oosterhouse
7. Kevin Farmer, who used to be the host of While You were Out on TLC and had a show on MTV and who now is sometimes host on Freestyle.
8. Male Host of "Cash in Attic" (forget name)
9. Female designer of My Parents House
10. Male designer of My Parents House
11. Chico from Candice's show (electrician)
12. Debbie Travis
13. Joan Steffins
14. Karen MacAlvey
15. Eric Frommer

16. Carpenter from Candice's show (Paul?)
17. Female afro-American designer from Designed to sell based on Washington DC
18. Lee Snyders
19. Charles from Design on a dime
20. Summer from design on a dime
21. Kristin from Design on a dime
22. Sparkle Josh from Design Star
23. Ali from Design on a dime
24. AFro-American male host of Chicago based Designed to sell (forget name)
25. Candice
26. Andrew, painter from Candice's show
27. Lisa LaPorta
28. Male host from Freestyle (not Kevin Farmer, the original one)
29. Donna and Shannon Freeman
30. Suzanne Wong
31. Vern Yip
32. Steve Watson
33. Danielle, who is David Bromstead's assistant
34. David Bromstead
35. Ed Bagley
36. Host of If Walls Could Talk (forget name)
37. Host of Rezoned (forget name)
38. Host of Curb Appeal (forget name)
39. Older afro-American host of Groundbreakers
40. Female Host of Gardens across America
41. Female host of morning craft show
42. Male host of morning craft show
43. Carol Duvall
44. Female host of quilting morning show
45 Angela Martinez, the female AFro American host of Crafters Across America
46. Angelo from the 24 hour design show.
47. Kenneth Brown
48. Clive Pearce
49. Sherri Hiller from Room by Room
50. The older overweight lady who used to do various tips in the early morning (have not seen her show for a while).
51. Younger lady who replaced her with a tips show early in the morning that I have not seen for a while either.
52 and 53. Two brothers who make unusual things, one used to be a policeman in NYC.
54. Bryce from Design on a Dime
55. The male team leader from Design on a dime who sometimes alternates with Bryce.

They should also add as contestant role models these people from TLC and DYI:

1. Frank from Trading Spaces
2. Christie from Trading Spaces
3. Barry when he was on Trading Spaces (the new Barry on HGTV is too serious and not fun enough. The woman designer who alternates with him is far worse. I never watch this show when she is on it, only when Barry is on it.)
4. Andrew Van Jumbo or whatever his name is, the afro-american carpenter from While You were Out.
5. Bob Villa
6. Doub Wilson from Trading Spaces
7. Edward from Trading Spaces
8. the hippie like male designer from While You Were Out
9. Ty Pennington

Posted by Lara – August 27, 2007 2:40 PM

Good riddance to the obnoxious, abhorent, redneck Robb. Go back to being a truck driver and talk like a truck driver!

Posted by Phoenix – August 27, 2007 2:34 PM

It is not worth commenting on Robb good design/bad design because his lack of politness and decency is way too much...
Todd comes up with these surreal constructions but we are still to see some good design that can be applied in real life. The best thing about him is that he never makes negative comments about the others...he restrains himself from behind talking and that is neat!
Will is the most adorable person! He is completely sweet and modest...and he has been doing the best consistent design...
Martha does not seem to agree...and quite frankly is very revolting to hear her comments on Will...she is constantly trying to send him home and keep whom?!
It is so obvious her prejudice that I think they should pick a better and more emphatic person for the jury.
Kim is nice and cool. I am curiuos to see how she handles the next challenge.
Go Will and Kim! Hope to see you both at the final

Posted by Ana – August 27, 2007 2:28 PM

Robb is Gone! Yippee! This guy was a jerk from day 1 and I am so happy he was booted off and did such a crappy job. Kim was a saint and deserves a lot of credit for tolerating him. I thought she was weak in the beginning, but maybe I was wrong. Unlike others on this blog, I do like Todd. Yes, he is a big kid, but he does come up with interesting ways to use a space and I find that very inventive and refreshing. Who will be next? I suspect Will is next to leave. He has not screen presence and this being a TV show, he needs that. Kim and Todd certainly do.

Very exciting, but I do agree that the show seems contrived. They is very little view into the designer's style, background, etc. Unlike the Next Food TV Star, this show devotes very little to knowing the person.

Posted by Gary – August 27, 2007 2:28 PM

this design star season is not as good as the first one...but IM SO HAPPY that Rob is SO GONE his attitude was not going to take him anywhere, I would love to see josh"sparkle" back but my favorite now is either Will or Kim I just love their decoration styles and personalities.....good luck to both of them

Posted by rosie flores – August 27, 2007 2:17 PM

Okay so I think the final two will be Kim and Todd....and Todd will probably win...

I can see Todd doing some outlandish kind of show which I probably would never watch. Kim is so cute but I think she lacks some of the design skill of the others on her own....she would be great on a show where she brings in skilled designers and translates what they are doing for us know-nothings (kind of like decorating cents)...she is just a fabulous hostess!

Posted by robyn – August 27, 2007 2:17 PM

I don't think anyone wept last nite when hey gave robb "das boot" what a one sided self absorbed little man. He should feel blessed that he got a s far as he had. he should have been booted when he did the kitchen with will. kim deserves honorable mention for standing her ground and proving herself right with some of the design choices(like raising countertops to accomodate appliances) almost everyone on this sight finds the judges call "fair" Robb... now pull your head out for your chocolate star, and get back to sacking them groceries!!

Posted by robert – August 27, 2007 2:14 PM

I can't believe the judges finally told Robb that he is not a team player! What? Haven't they been watching or listening to the others? When his show was finally cancelled I actually clapped and cheered. The way he treated Kim was horrible. I loved that she stood up to him and told him that she is his partner and to talk to her.
I miss Sparkle. He should never have been let go. I hope Will wins. He just needs to work on his hosting abilities. Kim did a good job hosting but except for the wedding episode (which was awesome) we haven't seen any designs from her.

Posted by Karen – August 27, 2007 2:11 PM

I was glad to see Robb go. Kim really stood up for herself. She handled Robb and still got the design done except for the fridge. 24 hrs is Not long enough to do an entire kitchen! Kim was the best host also. Give her a show. Will and Todd make a good team. Give them a show together and bring Josh back.

Posted by Cheryl Stanley – August 27, 2007 2:10 PM

Robb's personality is pathological. I couldn't stand another episode with him in it! I think the real talent is Will. He designs spaces that real people can live in and enjoy. I don't need a host who acts as though he is teaching preschool. I just want someone who can present some great ideas and good design in a pleasant manner. Will is genuine. I hope he wins!

Posted by Mary C. – August 27, 2007 2:08 PM

I watch HGTV to learn how to make my home more beautiful for my family. Kim and Will know no more about design than I do, Todd should go to NY and be a Broadway set designer. Robb should have learned to keep his thoughts about others to himself because he probably is talented. So I am no longer interested in any new design show hosted by these people.

Posted by Pat – August 27, 2007 2:08 PM

Regarding Rob - I am glad he is gone. While Rob had talent, he was always contemptuous and haughty. In the portion where he gave his demo tv presentation, he spoke too quickly was his words were blurred. There is NO way he could have made his tv show work.

The lesser skilled Kim has the better tv personality, and can carry her weight in a tv show. Also, in a tv show, she can have other's prop up her work and no one will know.

Posted by Edith Meyers – August 27, 2007 2:06 PM

Thank Goodness that @ss is gone - I don't believe I have ever seen anyone that obnoxious on any HGTV show! I agree that there should have been more individual shows so that we could see what the quieter designers can do. From the very beginning I could not understand why he was ever chosen for the show.

Posted by Bonnie – August 27, 2007 1:58 PM

WOW! What a show! I was so happy to see Robb go I almost felt a tad guilty for taking such pleasure in another person's demise! Poor sad unaware little Robb! I have the name of a very good therapist who can help you get to the crux of your low self-esteem issues. And folks - THAT'S Robb's problem - LOW self-esteem!! No one worth their own salt who has even a modicum of self-esteem has the need to steamroll others and revel in their pain unless they are in emotional pain themselves. His behavior borders on anti-social. And speaking of 'border'...can we say 'borderline personality disorder'?? Robb, I may have been glad to see you go from the show, but I sincerely hope you get some big-time help so you can learn to play well with others. You are waaay too young to isolate the rest of the world and risk being lonely for the rest of your life! If you continue to push people away like that, pretty soon, there won't be anyone left to push but yourself. Sux, pal, but it's true.
Kim - way to come through! You held your ground and your head high! You were justified in your frustration and being relegated to being the 'note-taker' for someone who was supposed to be your 'partner'. The word itself is indication of the position: it's 'PART'ner...meaning you have a PART in the relationship, not 'WHOLE'ner. Robb is a bully. It doesn't matter if he had designed a hundred kitchens or NONE, he had NO RIGHT to assume or insist that he was in any way in charge or control of the WHOLE project. He completely discounted your talent and rejected your input. You attempted to calmly reason with him, but unfortunately it's impossible to reason with the unreasonable. You may have not been given the change to fully express your design talents as fully as your decorating talents, but your input DID count...you were spot on about switching the sink and the stovetop. Robb's tile job looked so unprofessional and slipshod, I would have been embarrassed to call it anything other than a despirate attempt to finish. And Kim, your hosting clip was such a pleasant surprise! You really came out at the moment the spotlight was on! Great job! And witty! VERY critical for a host to be able to ad lib and be clever and keep the audience interested and wanting more.
Will and Todd's space turned out lovely! And they worked well together - even when they didn't agree on the design concepts. Will's designs are indeed very clean and modern, but so far, he has played it very safe and very close to the vest. Great for a huge part of the population - most everyday folks do tend to play decorating safe. But, his hosting skills may be what does him in. Not only is his grammer unpolished, he lacks the dynamic to be the kind of host who could keep the audience's attention. So what if there's texture in the room - make me WANT the texture...make me practically FEEL the texture...don't just blankly say that there are many textures in the room. He has a great personality and I'm certain is fabulous when working one-on-one with clients. But as a TV host, you have to be engaging and captivating to keep the audience from falling asleep or worse, changing the channel! Come out of your shell, sweet Will, be a showman!!
Todd - VERY creative design with the rotating platform. And it seemed to work well in this isolated situation in the guest house of a performer who has an appreciation of being 'on stage'. However, yet again, you seem to be demonstrating your marvelous artistic abilities to think outside the norm and you do everything BUT play it safe...which may have added to the mix of why you and Will worked well on this challenge - you balanced each other out quite well. My concern with you is, how well can you function in a world where a revolving platform would be a safety hazard? So far, your designs don't play well in real-world scenarios. What are you like at designing space for middle-class suburbia?? Who's your client-base?? They can't all be wealthy celebrities. If they are, then you will likely be a very successful designer! Your work is amazing, but it's ART. Not liveable DESIGN. There isn't anything folks can take away with them and think "I'd like to try that in MY home.". You really do push the envelope and that's great for an ARTIST - which you have proven again and again that you ARE. But envelope-pushing isn't necessarily good DESIGN practice.
Overall, the show was great and the Newtons seemed really pleased with the results. Now, Design Star, let these three REALLY show us what they're all about with INDIVIDUAL design challenges! We're getting down to the wire and frankly, right now, I'm not convinced any of the three remaining could carry off their own show.

Posted by Ena – August 27, 2007 1:49 PM

I think Cynthia Rowling needs to get some of Kim's "balls" and tell Vern to back off. It was clear that she really liked "Sparkle" Josh, but she just sat there and let him get voted off. I don't think she likes Will much, but Que Sera Sera. I miss Sparkle, and he would have been great as a host. He caught my attention from the beginning, just getting out of the car with his designer luggage. I am glad they didn't keep Rob in. He was in 5 shows too long.

Posted by she luv hgtv – August 27, 2007 1:48 PM

Yea!!!! no more Robb he will not be missed. I think next year judges should be Vern, Lisa LaPorter and David Bromstead, they would be much better a judging design. I do enjoy the show and hoe that next year it is on again.

Posted by audrey – August 27, 2007 1:43 PM

Dear Vern, and the other two judges. I am glad you opened your eyes and cancelled Robb's show he was a bully and would not make a good design star. Now the real design star shall prevail YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Benchwarmer – August 27, 2007 1:43 PM

Ding, Dong, Robb is gone.... Robb is gone.....Robb is gone!!!!Need I say more??? My ONLY complaint this year is that they are eliminating way too quickly... the show needs to last longer and they need more individual rooms, to really see each designers creativity!!!

Posted by Missmarty – August 27, 2007 1:38 PM

It was about time they got rid of Josh. I was so afarid I would have to sit through another week of him. He is so full of himself. I really miss sparkle Josh. He was so cute and sweet. It is hard to decided who I want to win out of the three left. They are all so good and I love their past designs.

Posted by Tonya – August 27, 2007 1:34 PM

Congrats to Kim, Will and Todd. I think each one performed admirably to make Wayne Newton's guest house an attractive, livable space. Kim should have won a special award for the extra stress she had to deal with which had nothing to do with designs or deadlines. I don't think she has the design experience that Will or Todd has but she strikes me as the kind of person who can learn what she needs to know. I think Todd is extremely creative. He sees a blank space and very quickly envisions what can be done with it. He also has the experience to know what can be done. His living room lazy susan was not just an off the wall idea that he shoved off on the carpenter but one that he implemented himself. But that living/dining room would have looked quite stark with just a platform in it. Our Will made it a home. He did the painting and shopping and dressing of the rooms. I think he is quite talented. The three remaining designers are very capable and it will be interesting to see who wins the competition. Good luck to Will, Kim and Todd.

Posted by bkacker – August 27, 2007 1:34 PM

At first I thought Todd was only copying David, as if...,but after observing him more closely, I donot believe that to be true. My favorites throughout the entire series this year have been Will and Kim. I think they have both shown more class than all of the other candidates put together since the beginning. But Design Star is not just about class; Design Star is about designing spaces for people to use (or look at), executing that design , and then to get in front of TV cameras and let their audience know what they are doing or are going to do - hopefully without patting themselves on the back while doing so - and then concluding tastefully and in an entertaining manner. I am soooo glad Robb is GONE and think that Todd's inventiveness may just get the show in trouble - who wants a Lazy Susan in their living room.

Posted by Patricia Cox – August 27, 2007 1:31 PM

I was shocked when the judges cancelled Robb and let Kim and Will stay in the competition. They are both really weak. The only thing Will did on his own this week was buy the sofa -- and it wasn't even anything special! Todd came up with the idea for the rotating platform and built it with the help of the carpenter, and it was the only thing special in the room. Kim has shown time and time again that she isn't really a designer -- she's just someone who dabbles in it. She has no training and few ideas of her own. Cut up paper plates on the wall? A horrible, incomplete tiling project? A black and white cheap-looking dinette set in the Newton kitchen? Yuck! Kim and Will haven't done anything to warrant still being in the competition. Yes, sometimes Todd's ideas are wacky, but at least he's inventive and creative and can actually do things himself. And while Robb might be a pain in the butt, he has far more talent than either Will or Kim. Kim also couldn't wait to throw him under the bus in front of the judges, which shouldn't reflect well on her, either. The judges made a big mistake.

Posted by Shannon – August 27, 2007 1:25 PM

Have you notive tha in each challenge that Tod is involve he designs something creative I have to say, but that is as far as he has gone, he depends on the team menbers to do the rest; at least that's the way I see it. I may be wrong. I am glad that they will work on their own design and that now we can really see their talent. Will is one of my favorites and yes he is not great in front of the camaras but remember David? he was shy, a little bet insecure and look at him now he is GREAT!!! I love his show and the way he host it. So, why not give Will this opportunity? right?

Posted by Marisela – August 27, 2007 1:22 PM

Everyone needs to review all the past episodes. Robb only made it to Episode 5 because of the other designers helping him. The wedding reception would not have been completed on time if the other designers took the attitude that Robb had. The other designers made Robb's design shine. HGTV needs a "design star" that will compare to Lisa, David, Candice, Karen, etc. Todd is cute but can he really design a room someone would want to live in? I haven't seen him pick out paint, accessories or furniture. Will and Kim are part of the final 3 because they have shown themselves to be team players. I will vote for Will or Kim in the final showdown! I know they have what it takes to hold their own. Also, everyone - if you write a blog please spell/grammar check.

Posted by Sandy – August 27, 2007 1:22 PM

YEAH!!! Robb is gone - finally! He is rude, arrogant, egotistical and obnoxious. He may have some talent in designing but absolutely none in executing his design. If his buddy Todd was his partner there is no way he would have talked to or treated him the way he treated Kim, on a human level alone, that was disgraceful . Todd has some "out of the box" design ideas but it was Will who pulled the room together with the beautiful furnishings and colors. It was nice to see Todd acting more mature and not so "skater boy" like a 12 year old. Next week we will definately see who has the whole package. At this point Will is definately the best designer by far, but will need training on his presentation skills. But if I remember correctly that was a problem last year with David and the judges made the comment a few times that hosting is something that can be taught. And look at David now, he is fabulous! Todd is much more easier to take when he calms down it will be interesting to see the room that he does by himself next week. I'm not sure about Kim's abilities. She is cute and adorable but I don't have a feel for what her design style is at all so next week will be interesting to see for her also. Sparkle Josh I still miss you, what a kind, sweet, charming gentleman. He would be great on his own show!

Posted by Mary – August 27, 2007 1:19 PM

Yeah, finally the judges picked up on the fact that Robb's attitude problem is not going to change.

Kim, I was so impressed with the absolutely outstanding hosting job you did. You held your own throughout this show! You go girl - like someone else said I think I have found my favorite!

Todd and Will did a fine job. It's fitting for a TV star to have a revolving platform in his guesthouse - but again, I have to say I would have liked to have seen a design suitable for real people - the platform was not it!

Will does need to step it up to shine next time - good luck to you!

My new favorite is clearly Kim - she showed she can handle any situation and turn around and do a brilliant hosting job. Didn't know you had it in you girl. Go for the gold!

This episode was great, the star couple was gracious, we saw great design in the making, the sparks flew between Kim and Robb - good for you Kim, Robb finally got the overdue boot he deserved and my girl Kim came out smiling and ontop. Can't wait to see the next episode. HGTV you are back in my good graces again - just kiddin'.

Posted by Roswitha – August 27, 2007 1:18 PM

i'm laughing so hard almost wet myself. leslie 8-26.1021pm too funny. and so many others as well. good god rob is gone !!!! kim kudos for being a professional, can those judges even imagine working with such a jerk as rob without causing him bodily harm???? the spinning living room cool idea but not functional for most of us but mr newton is kind of an out there type of guy, so prob ok for him . id prob kill myself but if you put locks on it.[maybe] but better sober. the kitchen for the money and time pretty cool. bring sparkle back, good luck tod will and kim, at lease i could invite anyone of you into my home

Posted by colleen – August 27, 2007 1:15 PM

Glad Robb is gone. Pity it took an actual "scene" in front of the judges to show them how disrespectful and unpleasant he is. And, Martha, please wipe the drool off your chin!

Posted by Rainey – August 27, 2007 1:14 PM

I think kicking off Rob was a BIG mistake. I think he had a bit of a strong competitive edge that came off as confrontational but he was copeting for a chance of a lifetime and there behavior with one another is really not what they are about design wise. He has great talent and I am sooooooo shocked that the judges took him out. Todd is adorable but I would say 90% of HGTV's audience probably would not ever like anything Todd has to design. Robb really should have stayed.

Posted by Gail-La Habra, Ca – August 27, 2007 1:02 PM

Robb's gone! Nuff said... Of the remaining three, Will has the most true design talent. Todd's ideas are unique, however, I have issues with his overall design ability for everyday households. Kim has design talent, but nothing that truly impresses me yet (I look forward to next week's individual challenge). Will, a tip from me for next week, introduce your design with, "Where there's a Will, there's always a Way!".....let that be your motto and step up your presentation....I am pulling for you.

Posted by Craig – August 27, 2007 1:00 PM

Design Star and Color Splash are programmed into my Tivo but this years winner of Design Star will not be so lucky. HGTV hit "pay dirt" with David Bromstad. Sadly, the remaining contestants do not have the "wow factor" needed for a design program.

Posted by Vickie – August 27, 2007 1:00 PM

I couldn't watch last night, mainly because I saw the trailers of Robb smarting off and he just made me sick. If he remained, that would have been it for me. Now that he's off, I can return to my regularly scheduled viewing.

Wasn't Robb the one that did all the pillows in the first week (that was weak)? Then he hid stuff in the 99cent store? My gosh what a loser.

I agree that Todd's over the top designs are novelties, so unless the new show is called "Rad Design" or "Gnarley, Dude," I can't see him winning.

Always thought Will and Kim had the best design sense.

Posted by Stephen – August 27, 2007 12:53 PM

Ding Dong, finally Robb is gone. Took long enough. It just kills me it took so long and sacrificed so many superior designers to reach this point. I don't love Kim, but I totally loved the way she stood up to Robb. "What a moron?!" as Robb would say is exactly right! I loved how he had the nerve to bring up the tile fiasco from Kim's first kitchen challenge Dueling Kitchens. Looks like he did not finish and the job was even more crappy than the half finished mess left by Kim and Neeraja.

I was a bit like Will when Todd mentioned rotating platform. WTF?! Will is the only one left with any sense. Martha seems to have already decided that Todd is going to be the next Design Star. She has been flirting with him since the audition. I am not immune to his shirtlessness, but the boy cannot design. I am really hopeful that he will finally fall on his face when he has to do something "functional" next week.

There was nothing wrong with Will's presentation skills! If he was a bit nervous, so was David. At least that is a skill one can acquire. I am really hoping to see Will make it to the finale. I think if the people are able to choose the next Design Star, Will will prevail.

Posted by Simonesa – August 27, 2007 12:53 PM

I am SOOOO happy that Rob is gone, gone, gone; I've been voting for his demise since the first episode. But how sweet is Josh Sparkles to support everyone! Josh you were and are my favorite. You brought sincere kindness to us and I promise to pay it forward.

Posted by kcm – August 27, 2007 12:52 PM

Robb was a cut-throat competitor from the very beginning. In the 99 cents store challenge, he bought all of the puck lights because he knew that other designers would want to use them in their rooms. He constantly put Will down and actually lied on him in the wedding challenge. If Will had not shown him the error of his ways in color selections, the wedding would have looked like more of a circus than it did. He should have gone long before he did. That first room he did with the car door on the wall should have been enough to lead him to the door.
As quiet as it's kept, Will has the most design talent of any of the contestants, but his low-key personality doesn't show up well on the screen. Kim's bubbly personality is cute, but she hasn't shown any really great design skills. Todd is too out-of-the-box for the average homeowner. I will be watchi g with great anticipation for the next episodes. I think it's anybody's ballgame at this point. Good luck to everyone.

Posted by Barbara S – August 27, 2007 12:47 PM

Robb should seek therapy for his passive-agressiveness. It always YOUR fault, so he (Robb) thinks. I hope Kim had a shoulder to cry on after that nightmare big bully was hurting her feelings. She handled his nastiness with such maturity. I loved the platform. I want one in my living room, because I have the same dilemma of what to do with the furniture arrangement - Firplace, TV, or pretty view? We use the TV more, but I refuse to hang one over the fireplace! What a clever idea!

How about a show with the three working as a team? Kim, Will, and Todd. I want them to come and do a few rooms in my house!! Hopefully, Todd will take his shirt off too!

Posted by HEATHER – August 27, 2007 12:42 PM

Love The Show HGTV.... I AM SO GLAD Rob is OUT OF THERE!
What nerve, he even called the judges fools...We really know who the fool is!

I would have never watched His show!

Posted by Julie S. – August 27, 2007 12:40 PM

I am so thankful that Rob is gone. If I would have had my way he would have been gone the 2nd show. To call people fools and yet be such a spiteful person is just wrong.
My hope is that Kim will continue to do beautifully and make it as the NEXT HGTV STAR.
Kelly

Posted by Kelly – August 27, 2007 12:37 PM

I am So-o-o-o happy to FINALLY see "Rob the Slob" booted out of this competition!!! I'm just surprised that some of the other contenders hadn't already booted him literally! I wouldn't even have let that jerk on my property, much less into my home to design ANYTHING (his footprints would probably kill the grass!)
I think Kim has what it takes to be a great designer if she would just put a little hi-octane in her tank and get ON with it! She has the potential, but is perhaps just a little shy on the self confidence. Will is pretty good too, with what little we've been able to see of him. Pretty much all he's been allowed to do is paint and I think he has a lot more to offer than that. Good luck to both of you. Now that the trash has been taken out... the place probably smells a lot better!

Posted by Becky Taylor – August 27, 2007 12:35 PM

My humble opinion of this and the other challenges--by designer:

Scott: Yes, I know. His individual challenge was too, too much stuff, but he is probably the best designer there. The eating pit in the first design, coupled with the zen area was the best work done so far.

Todd: Over the top imagination, which would probably be great in a landscape designer, but not so much for a house. I notice that he comes up with the wowzer ideas, but I don't see any sense of style. I thought the skate board thing in front of the sky-high windows was beyond stupid (hey, Dude! Betcha I get to the ground floor first!). The other two designers used the thing as a sculpture piece and saved it. The turning living room was (1) ugly and (2) stupid and impractical and (3) ugly. Why didn't they play off the lava rock with say a tall, zen copper water feature and use glass rocks and a gas flame in the fire place? Could he host a show? He'd be great doing those kinds of wow things in an outdoor space--a revolving living room in say a gazebo with views of the city and of the pool would be wonderful. He's in the wrong element.

Josh Foss. How did he get picked in the first place? Those harem throw pillows in the first challenge, coupled with the lost little boy personality should have made him the first "cancelation". He was totally out of his depth.

Josh Johnson. Adorable, but I agree with the judges here--his instincts are great but he really needs a modifying force. He would be PERFECT coupled with someone who could put the breaks on his bling. I'm a shopper myself and I'm really impressed with his ability here...how about a show where he's given a budget and a few instructions and he gets the stuff and another designer has to make it all work? Couple him with a sardonic, quick wit and the show would be wonderful.

Neeraja. How did she get picked? Surely that ridiculous head band didn't fool ya'll into thinking she was artsy. She ended up being very charming though, and I've got to admit that her comments about Robb made me smile. And Robb's response (whiny--how dare she! SUCH a man, our Robb.) was interesting considering Robb's ability to dish it out without any conscience whatsoever.

Lisa? Oh my. I'd love to see her design a kindergarten or children's room. Otherwise, it was simply awful (but unlike the harem pillows, it was at least an effort). I would have liked to have seen at least one more effort on her part. And the hair? She needs Stacy and Clinton. Someone asked what she could have done with a garage door. Several things. How about contrasting the industrial with some impressive rococco antique piece and a modern bench and a mirror to check yourself on the way out and some shallow, modern boxes arranged as an art piece so individuals can drop their keys or whatever. That would have been another great place for a water feature.

Kim: Cute but I have yet to see anything she's done that impresses me (except for standing up to your local graduate of Attila the Hun Charm School). I did think her wedding design was the best of the bunch--a nod to Las Vegas while keeping in mind that it was a wedding not a keg party. I thought her idea of wall-paper was good, but the execution was yuk (I'm not a fan of pink and the even spacing of the plates didn't appeal). She didn't get much opportunity to contribute to the kitchen what with "It's All About Me" Robb--so the fact that she maintained any kind of cool gives her BIG points. Good thing Robb wasn't paired with Will--ya'll would finish the season on Court TV.

Andriane? She'd make a great designer for Levetz Furniture Store. No taste. I didn't care for anything she did. It all looked, well, cheap. And the personality? I'm sorry, but I think I'd rather deal with Robb than the whiny little girl act. Honestly, did you all notice how very "me, me, me" it was in the first challenge? Did you all notice how very quick she was in pointing out what SHE did in the disasterous kitchen? No charm. No talent. How did she make the first cut? This girl has passive-aggressive down to a fine art.

Christina. Nice, cute, design was OK but she was a less forceful and less talented Alice. I'll bet her home is gorgeous though. Sweet, with a lot of grace--If I'd had to deal with the saccarine bull dog (Adriana), I'd have been tempted to b-t-h slap her.

Will. He has a good eye. I didn't love all his choices, but he has a good sense of color for drama and arrangement. In defense of his last challenge, he let Todd limit the design disasterously. There wasn't much one could do with a revolving square platform. I thought his bedroom with Scott was the second most impressive design and his individual challenge wasn't to my taste but it was striking.

OK, let's talk about Robb as a possible candidate for Dr. Phil. And his designs were gawd-awful. Every single one of them. Sorry, judges, but I agree with your host: his single challenge looked like a Swiss rescue unit sign. It wasn't attractive on any level (and his stealing all the lights was less than impressive). The wedding looked like the Beverly Hillbillies meets the Dollar Store. Repulsive on every level (and, yes, I know the poor deluded couple picked his design--but isn't part of a designer's job to direct the client away from their worst instincts?) And both his kitchens! The crackled cupboards and the fake brick were cheesy in the worst possible way. And the lava rock kitchen looked better in the before picture. What was with the light countertop? What was with the Danish modern built-in's against the rock? The window shade was ugly, as was the furniture, which looked like they picked it up at WalMart. The wall "art" was awful, and was all that bare floor meant for dancing? Colors? All wrong. Design? There wasn't any. The only thing big enough to hold Robb's ego is that great void where his talent should be.

The "kitchen" in the last challenge wasn't really a kitchen, was it? It was more a quick-snack, hang out drinking kind of room and the furniture should have reflected that. Comfortable chairs to play poker at--anything but the cheap fifty's diner look they ended up with. That rock wall should have been embraced or balanced and it was neither.

One final word about that wedding challenge. Apparently no one there knows what Rockabilly is. If someone would have taken the time to come up with something like "Graceland" and explained it to the couple, MAYBE they could have been rescued from themselves.

Oh, and you know what I would have done in the individual challenge? A gentleman's room with a leather sofa (tissue paper, crinkled with watered-down children's white glue, stuck to the couch, painted and then the faux leather shading put in with shoe polish from 99 cent store---walls with molding made from ....)

Posted by Amy – August 27, 2007 12:34 PM

Rob shot himself in the foot. His personality, although his excitement can be contagious, his non abitlity to be a team member and look down his nose at others, DID HIM IN! His exit interview only confirms that the judges made the right choice. No remorse!
All I can say is to bad, so sad. Hopefully he learns from it. Although, I doubt it.

Posted by Kim Staple – August 27, 2007 12:32 PM

Finally Robb is gone!!!! I wonder if the people that are writing the bolg saying that they like Robb are his family or friends, because the first thing you need to have in design or in any other career is PEOPLE SKILLS!!! The guy definitely lacks of it and it makes it really hard to work with him. Not only that, but he talks down on people making it even harder to deal with him. I wonder why he was not eliminated before, especially when his drawings were out of scale last week. I worked designing spaces for a large company and this was a key factor in the success of our installations. Robb should have been gone long time ago. Last night the skies opened and stars were dancing, rejoicing that Robb was gone, did you see it???

Posted by loving it – August 27, 2007 12:23 PM

I am so glad that Robb is GONE!!!! What an egotistical jerk. He should have been eliminated long before now just because of his attitude and inability to get along with others. Kim is a lady and a level-headed designer. I would not be unhappy if she is the next design star. Nor would I be unhappy with Will. He is definitely someone who could work with anyone well in designing and decorating their space. Although, Kim has a better stage presence. I think Sparkle and Will would make a great team! Todd is a nice, fun-loving guy but is a little too far-out in his designs. He should work with a sporting goods company to design their displays. Thank you, judges, for doing the right thing at the end of episode 5! Can't wait for next week!!!

Posted by Patsy – August 27, 2007 12:22 PM

Ok, so how about if Will won Design Star (he's obviously the best designer) and Sparkle came back as his design assistant? I wish Sparkle could win, but since that's not going to happen, wouldn't that make a pretty awesome show? Sparkle has the personality, Will can work on his presentation and they BOTH have the necessary talent. I would definitely watch that show!

Posted by Keona – August 27, 2007 12:15 PM

I hated Robb from day one. There is absolutely nothing good about him. He's all evil. Even if he were to watch the show or read these blogs, he is so pathetic, he wouldn't be able to recognize how awful he truly his. I feel so sorry for him. He is a sad example of a human being.

Posted by Lora – August 27, 2007 12:14 PM

I believe that the most talented DESIGNER was eliminated last night. The producers obviously want Todd to win so they got rid of his only true rival. Robb was completely right when he said that Kim is a decorator-not a designer.And Will? Are you kidding me? Not a bit of talent.Won't watch anymore--don't care.Voting time comes--I'm voting for the most talented DESIGNER--ROBB!!!!

Posted by anne – August 27, 2007 12:14 PM

Finally the shrew is gone (Rob) For those who believed Rob had talent - he proved all of you wrong once again with his poor tile work, lack of accurate measurements and his so called design presentation. Kim nailed the presentation the best out of all the contestants. Last time I checked being handy with a hammer and a saw- a designer did not make. That is why you hire trades people. Will, keep true to your design style and integrity you are the next design star in my book. Call me crazy but I get enough craziness and drama from the outside world – I want my home and work space to be a place of peace and tranquilly- Will’s designs have been all that and more.

Posted by Gina B – August 27, 2007 12:06 PM

Rob The Bomb?
Please,he needs to learn that how to play with the other kids in the playground.He wanted to be the bully. Bully's don't get far. The man has talent,and looks but his attitude needed major ajustment. Glad he's gone. I give Kim her props for putting up with his crap. I can honestly say that I have yet to see the likes of David in this bunch. No one really compares to his talents. We'll see what happens in the next episodes.

Hector A

Posted by Hector Arguinzoni – August 27, 2007 12:06 PM

HGTV needs to do design shows in other styles than the ultra modern, clean lines, industrial designs that they are going toward. That is one of the many reasons why Josh Sparkle would have been a good host. One of his styles was the southern style, which would have been interesting to watch him do. I personally like country, french provincial, rustic, eclectic, shabby chic and maybe a little formal/traditional/old world. Occasionally a disign show will touch or do one of these, but not often. I love the curvy lines, inset scrolling, white and off site furniture. I do like distressed, crracked and faux finishes, which Debbie Travis does a lot of.

In my prior post, I forgot to say I do like Debbie Travis's shows and just love Matt and sheri's shows. matt and Sheri and Debbie Travis probably do the best actual design on HGTV (other than Kenneth Brown, who wins design hands down). It kills me to see the Design on a Dime crews destroying beautiful pieces of country or french provincial furniture to turn them into ugly pieces with their clean lines. I like the two people who do the creative craft shows early in the morning too. They have great personality and are quirty and fun. I like crafters coast to coast too. They are all fun people (or made out to be fun people) and quirky. I like Carol Duvall too.

I would also like to see more older designers/hosts in their fifties to seventies. Maybe they would be more included to do things in the country, southern, rustic, etc. style.

However, evne though most of the shows showcase the modern/industrial design style I can't stand, I watch IF the personalities are fun and entertaining.

Go Todd! (Josh, come back and host a show showing gracious period design.)

Lara

Posted by Lara – August 27, 2007 11:58 AM

I cannot believe it took the judges so long to see thru ROBB. What an ego-maniac - enough said.

Love the show, not the judges so much. Love David

Posted by jpullin – August 27, 2007 11:57 AM

First, let me send my best wishes to Sparkle Josh! He has a great attitude and I had a blast watching him! I'd love to take him shopping! Bring him back somewhere, HGTV!
Next, YEAH to the cancellation of Robb! I have been waiting for it all season! I have to admit, I've wanted to see the "Frat Boys" who are Robb and Todd gone, but I think Todd has redeemed himself. I am a bit put off by the whole no-shirt thing...it was nice to look at once, maybe twice, but enough already!
Not sure who I'd like to see win the show but the real winner has already left the building!

Posted by mh31 – August 27, 2007 11:50 AM

Evan Farmer (used to host While you were out on TLC and was on an MTV show) did a great segment on Freestyle in which he waterskiied with the homeowners to decide if the pool table stayed or went (the homeowners were split). This made the show much more entertaining than if it was straight design. If people wanted straight design, they could take a course or read a book. I really was never into design shows, but like safe programming on TV. I watched HGTV a few times for this perk and stayed watching due to the PERSONALITIES and HUMOR of some of the people on the shows.

The guy on the original Desiging for the Sexes had great design, but was borning to watch. So was Sara Richardson of Room Service and the guy who designed the small spaces. They needed flair. I like the concept of the Steve Watson show and like Steve Watson to a degree, but he needs to loosen up and have some humor. his crew also needs to joke around and have some humor. The "This old House" shows always turned me off because they were boring, although they were informative.

My favorite shows on HGTV are due to the people, not the shows themselves or the design info. My favorite is "What's up with this house" with George Gray, who has a great sense of humor, great camera presence and charisma. Design STar needs to get a personality like George Gray in the contestants. My next favorite show is "Junk Brothers," again due to the personality of the brothers. I like how they joke around, bring their dog with them, besides their talent and creativity. My third fave are the shows with the Garden Guy, Paul James. He has a great sense of humor and makes learning about gardening fun. I also like Eric Strommer's show. I like Candice's show because of the joking around of her crew, which I wish there was more of. Personally, I don't like Candice's design style (way too modern), but love her crew's personalities and watch because of them. I like Joan Steffins shows and Karen MacAlvey's shows. I liked the two designers who were in "My Parents' House." too. They had a sense of humor, were spontanious, did not take themselves seriously, had good design style. I like Clive Pearce's personality. I like the hosts on "If Walls Could Talk" and "Rezoned" too. Kenneth Brown is probably one of the best designers in the world, but he is boring personally, although he seems like a sincere, nice guy. I did love his midieval kitchen though and all the rooms he did. He did things beyond the ultra modern, industrial style that so many of the designers do on the network. So, I watched his shows, even though he needs to work on his camera prsenece and add a sense of humor. I like David Bronstad's work in a way, but he does things way too modern too. I like groundbreakers too. the host is not humorous, but has a nice presence.

I did not like the lady who did the color wheel of food, etc. She was boring and did things too modern. I don't like most of the design on a dime shows too. They almost always do only ultra modern, industrial things. Lee snyders has a nice personality, as do Kristen and Summer. Charles has an intersting personality, as does Ali. I watch these for the peeoples personality. I liked the girly pink/red room that one team did and the retro HOllywood bedroom that Lee Snyder's team did. Bryce has an intersting personality that is fun, although I can't stand his industrial designs. I watch their show to see Bryce and Ali's personalities, not their design.

I would watch Todd's show, even though his design style is way too modern. His show would be fun. He needs work with his presence, but I am sure when he is not tired and stressed, he would step up. I would like to see him doing his athletic stunts as lead ins to the segments to break up the monotony of straight informative textbook design.

HGTV needs to appeal to the majority of people and to do so they need magnetic personalities. Een those who don't garden would find Paul James the garden guy a fun show to watch. Todd is fun and entertaining too.

Lara

Posted by Lara – August 27, 2007 11:48 AM

I WAS SO GLAD TO SEE ROB OFF THE SHOW. HE JUST NEVER SEEMED TO GET ALONG WITH ANYONE. HE WAS A SMART BUTT EVERY SHOW. NO TEAM PLAYER AT ALL.....HE WOULD NEVER MAKE A DESIGN STAR.....AND WHY THE HATS, SCARFS??? WAS HE BALD????? DIDN'T WANT ANYONE TO SEE IT??? GIVE ME A BREAK.......I WAS SO THRILLED WHEN THEY CANCELLED HIS SHOW THAT I LET OUT A SCREAM......AND I LIVE ALONE! I WATCH THE SHOW EVERY WEEK...LOVE HGTV

Posted by Terralene Ayer – August 27, 2007 11:46 AM

I'm back one more time. I am laughing at supportive comments for Robb. Everyone's entitled to their own opinion of course, but seriously, I don't see any of his talent that people are talking about. His individual room gave me a headache. He "crackled and fauxed the kitchen to death." He measured wrong -- how does that happen when you have done tens of thousands of kitchens?!

Give me a break. I was thinking how much I love David Bromstad and how cute it was when that family played a practical joke on him with the lamp on Color Splash, and he was really trying to work that lamp in to the design because it was important to them, and I was thinking how Robb would have been saying - "These idiots want me to put this hideous lamp in their house. They are so dumb. I am not going to do that." But, David really worked with it and actually made a hideous lamp turn out pretty good in the end, and was a good sport about it. Love you, David.

Also, like David said on his vlog - he is an artist and had only done kids' rooms, but he was so talented and just shone and did his thing. No one put him down for that last year. He has lots of vision, that David.

Also, I don't think David is the only one who can take his shirt off while he works. My husband takes his shirt off when he gets hot doing work around the house and so do lots of other guys I know. David does not own the market on working without a shirt on, people.

How anyone can say Kim is manipulative and gave Robb a hard time is beyond me. I only think those people must have anger management issues and extreme self-centeredness like Robb. I hope Robb can take this whole thing as a learning experience and get some counseling and do some yoga, etc. -- get really introspective. I can't see any woman ever dating him; he would berate them up and down. I seriously hope Robb gets some help; he would never be welcome into my home -- I wouldn't even let him build me a dog house at this point.

I agree that Josh is super sweet and fun but he really did not blow me away with his talent, although I don't know that this show was set up to showcase anyone's talent and they got rid of people too quickly this year.

Ultimately, I hope if there is another Design Star next year that they stick closer to the formula from season one. This one was very uneven in so many ways, but will be much more pleasant to watch now that Robb is gone. Wahoo!!

Posted by Mandy – August 27, 2007 11:44 AM

HEY ROBB............B-BYE !!! I TOLD YOU BEFORE, YOUR ATTITUDE WOULD COME BACK TO BITE YOU IN THE A**! As I was watching- I did a little cheer and pumped my fist in the air when his show was cancelled, sorry - I couldnt help myself!

Will, I just love you, man! You ARE the voice of reason: very calming, serence, not showing stress, but you need to work on your presentation skills - step outside the box for a moment and get your groove on!!

Todd, You are growing on me, dude! I have to give you props for your building skills - Awesome work! You are creative and have a different vision. This is what makes you likeable - that and the fact that you're easy on the eyes!

Kim, You need to step it up a notch baby-girl. You have been partnered with some real duds that havent given you a change to showcase what you can do! You have personality and spunk for hosting, but you need to find the balance. If we dont see it next week, I am afraid you'll be going home!

Good Luck next week to all of you!!!
Step up your game...

Posted by Kim – August 27, 2007 11:41 AM

I just saw Robb's comments after his elimination, among other things making the excuse that he's a Scorpio. To the extent that astrological signs affect one's way of being a person, I can see his point. I'm a Scorpio, and we do tend to suffer from inclinations to arrogance and rudeness. But we also learn over time to control those impulses.

He's very young, clearly very talented, clearly still very self-indulgant and moody, clearly not inclined to identify and rope in his immature behaviors, and clearly extremely confused right now. He also clearly does have a good heart, he just doesn't know how to use it well.

I just hope he will take some time to think all this through and to understand why his show was cancelled, and to start working on improving his people skills. I feel bad for him, I really do, as he has considerable potential. Once he starts to keep his good side consistently working in public and team settings, he's going to be a knockout person AND designer.

I wish him good luck.

:(

Posted by Karen Bendorf – August 27, 2007 11:38 AM

Rob~
The most talented dynamic designer of BOTH seasons. Too bad it became a popularity contest! Last show Kim loved your "management style", this episode she submarined you!
You were 100% right, the judges were FOOLS.

Posted by Mary – August 27, 2007 11:32 AM

Strong points that I remember well:
When Will was interviewed by Clive in the .99 Store episode he said, " if I stay true to myself as a designer..." That sounds like a true professional to me as well as a statement from a " nice person. "(as opposed to Robb) Sparkle Josh was always a polite person as well as a designer. Without his choices several designs would have fallen flat. Contestants trusted him & he was complimented by the contestants as well as the judges for his keen eye. Also, you saw him doing other work building and being a team member. Offstage, you saw him laughing and being nice and friendly to all. I miss the sparkle.
The relationship between Todd and Robb gave viewers a sour taste in their mouths. Now, we will be better able to see Todd as as a person. We should all praise Kim for maintaining some sense of dignity when being so verbally abused irreguardless of anything else.If HGTV was really looking for star quality as well as a good person than they missed the boat when Sparkle Josh's show was cancelled. He had exactly that. Many more people would have watched his show than the others. Another point is that it is very obvious that HGTV would only benefit from an employee who worked well with others instead of someone who always had to fight, take up production time, and cost HGTV viewers. Why would a viewer want to relax and learn from a show that was hosted by an egomaniac? Thank-you for the opportunity of sharing my views.

Posted by TuJu – August 27, 2007 11:31 AM

Well, I am glad that Robb is gone but why do the
(they call themselves judges) judges still praise
Todd. He is an egotistical idiot!! He also has
no respect or consideration for his fellow contestants. I will definitely "not" vote for him at all and if by some chance he wins, I will
not watch is show. He can skateboard back to
California!!!

Posted by mary – August 27, 2007 11:31 AM

WHAT A JERK!!!

If Rob would have gotten his own show it would have never aired as he would have had the HG professionals with whom he needed to work so angry at him that everything would have been in paralysis!

Don't understand why it took the judges so long to get rid of him!

Posted by steve – August 27, 2007 11:29 AM

I don't see how or why people don't see that Robb and Todd were the only ones left in the final four with design talent, fabrication skills, carpentry skills and vision. Will has potential that maybe we have not seen yet and hoepfully he will step up. Kim, she is a nasty, overbearing person who rode on the coatails of good designers, played it safe, manipulated the judges and talked down to the leaders and good designers. I will enjoy seeing Kim fail and be eliminated when she has to do something on her own next week. Josh Sparkle had charisma and talent, originality and class. Adriana also had charisma and was multi talented; she could even upholster and do carpentry. Christina had talent too, as did Scott. Josh Organic never had a chance to show his talents off, but his carpentry skills were awesome. Why are all these talented, creative people gone with Kim still here? She really must be able to snow the judges. I agree that Lisa should have been the first to go, followed by Najeera (who was another obnoxious, overbearing woman; she and Kim are from the same mold) and then followed by Kim. AFter that, there should have been individual challenges in rooms that are functional (not just the 99 cent challange, which is fun and should stay) to help with the eliminations.

I liked Todd from the very beginning though. he is very talented; in the casting show, he said all he could do. He should be in the final two (and should be the design star). the other person in the final two should have been someone chosen by their individual design work, which was not tapped into by the judges. Todd did find a way to let his design work and originality come through though, in spite of the group settings.

Lara

Posted by Lara – August 27, 2007 11:27 AM

Apparently talent doesn't matter. Robb totally carried Kim through this challenge. She complained and pushed him to snap back just like whiny Will and the judges rewarded her for her behavior. Robb is a focused guy who just gets the job done while the rest are wringing their hands. Will can be as obnoxious and rude as he wants and that's okay by the judges. So now we're stuff stuck with the surfer, the pushy obnoxious hairdresser and the super whiner. Okay, if I have to choose, I choose Todd. I wouldn't let him design a closet in my house, but since we're not going on talent, might as well go on looks. No need to watch anymore. Who cares?

Posted by EmilyJFB – August 27, 2007 11:27 AM

I was really hoping this week would be individual challenges. I'm sure Wayne Newton had a couple of bedrooms in his guest house so that everyone could have done his or her own room! There are too many team competitions and too many double eliminations this year. Like everyone else, I was glad to see Robb go. I thought he should have been eliminated on the first challenge with his car door hanging on the wall and the tacky pillows. Lisa's room, while not my style, was at least A STYLE and FINISHED! Plus she was a nice person.
Last week's wedding design was so painful to watch. Robb's design was so tacky, but he lucked out because the couple had such tacky taste. Everyone else made their design sophisticated or classy. Am I the only one who thinks that a "gambling" theme is bad luck for a wedding!? When Christina and Josh got eliminated, I was almost in tears. Christina's design was beautiful. And Josh worked just as hard as the others on that room! As for this week, I was hoping that Kim would grab Robb's ridiculous hat off his head and smacked him with it! I am so glad that she stood up for herself. Robb thought she would be a pushover. For someone who says he has so much experience doing kitchens, he made some serious blunders. The layout of the appliances made no sense. The oven was under the sink!? Yikes! Plus the green tile with the black grout was ugly. I loved the color choices and Kim's decorating. I loved her hostessing also. Robb was obnoxious until the bitter end. How does he manage to get any customers? I liked Todd and Will's room. I wasn't crazy about the rotating sofa, but it was interesting. The room was beautiful, except for the planter box, which seemed so 1950's to me. I can't wait for an individual challenge, finally!!

Posted by Jane – August 27, 2007 11:24 AM

MISS YOU SO MUCH JOSH (with that sparkle smile)!! We Want You BACK!

I'm very glad Robb is gone also. Should have been gone the first show. You HAVE to work with great with people to be a good designer! He doesn't seem to! The show will be much more enjoyable and tolerable with him gone!

Wow...the abuse that he gives out but can't handle it when thrown his way! INSECURE...which could mean...you dish it out to make yourself feel superior but when thrown your way...excuses, excuses, excuses!!

(I am suspicious of Robb blogging to us in a unsuspecting name after reading a few of them.)

The remaining left:

Kim is pleasant and seems to put things together well and I like watching and listening to her but not sure about her hosting a show. Kinda weak.

Will is also pleasant and is organized and has wonderful insight into design but not sure about hosting his own show. Kinda weak.

Todd is confusing! He has vision and artistic skills and talent BUT I don't enjoy watching him because he's so hyper and unpractical for the average person. Not very calming to sit down and watch him. He would be much better suited to some MTV artistic design show where he could skateboard through all the decorating and paint and lumber places. Weak also!

I'm not real confident of any of the remaining three. I can't see any of their shows lasting very long on HGTV. I can't see any of them getting very good ratings and people watching them without tiring quickly. Just no SPARKLE to any of them left. So disappointing!

I'm with everyone else...not enough individual design time...too short of time to get the projects done well right and finished...too many getting voted off too quickly and for crying out loud...LET US VOTE from the beginning like alot of the other shows so we get who we want! And yes...Robb...part of it is a popularity contest because we have to enjoy watching you and be likeable and somewhat charming or we WON'T WATCH!! Come on producers...do a better job next year for your viewers before you lose us all and THIS show is CANCELLED!!!

I WANT SPARKLE AND SO DOES THE MAJORITY OF THE VIEWERS! JUST READ THESE BLOGS!!! GIVE YOUR VIEWERS WHAT WE WANT OR YOU WON'T HAVE AS MANY IN THE FUTURE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Cindy from Tx – August 27, 2007 11:15 AM

I thought last nights show truly gave us all new perspective on the real talented people on the show. Rob, Sorry, You really had to go. Long time ago, I told my daughter, who wasn't always tactful. " You have to have people skills to survive in the world." Maybe, you need to take this advise!!!! Todd and Kim, You are the final two! Will, step up your game. There might still be a chance for you.

Posted by Judy – August 27, 2007 11:13 AM

Ding Dong ... Robb is gone Robb is gone Ding Dong the Ding Dong is gone .. ok ok so just a little too happy there.. anyway I am so glad the Judges cancelled Robb's show I kept replaying it last night and could not get enough .. lol lol -- anyway Kim you did a wonderful job and I am so proud of you for not smothering that pompous ass in his sleep (oops sorry) also wasn't it priceless when the appliances did not fit ...

Posted by Salena – August 27, 2007 11:11 AM

I'd pick Alice or Tim from last year's show over any of the three remaining finalists.

Posted by Jack – August 27, 2007 10:57 AM

24 hours after the cameras left you can bet that "lazy susan" was out of there and on the garbage pile! I only hope HGTV paid for the damage Todd did to the new hardwood flooring when he drilled the hole in the middle of the room. Kudos to Will and Kim for bringing the decorating and design this week. And KUDOS to KIM for an awesome hosting job. Next week will be an interesting turn of events. At long last, Todd will have to step-up and show if he can do anything but tumble and saw and nail. And let's hope he does it without being half naked. Enough already man...cover up. You are a middle aged man!

Posted by Bud – August 27, 2007 10:57 AM

Robb Poor Baby..............NOT!!!!!!! I have personally worked with this guy and as a client of his...well lets say...I WILL never work with him again. He treats his clients in the real world the same way he diplayed his lack of talent and poor communication skills on TV. Good Bye loud mouth..America is glad you are gone. Your so called design career is history!

Posted by Orlandofriend – August 27, 2007 10:41 AM

Well they have pretty much ended the series. Will is bland and Kim may have an eye for design but is totally clueless when it comes to the mechanics of execution. Todd is the only one who could be considered a "complete package" and Robb was his only strong competition. The series would have been more interesting had it come down to Robb and Todd, now it is just a matter of waiting for the end. Todd is a showboater, raising his arms in the air like he's Hulk Hogan at a Summerslam event. I wouldn't watch his show so as a vehicle for a new show I would have to call this season's Design Star a failure.

Posted by Tom – August 27, 2007 10:39 AM

Hi Josh, just read your post - had watched for it for several hours last evening. Of course, you always have been and so remain the real class act of Design Star. There is no interest left for me as to the final outcome - will continue to watch the show, but I definitely will not vote this year. It's my opinion that the only way to MAYBE be heard by the judges and more importantly the producers of HGTV Design Star is to make sure the ratings are lower than last year. David and Alice were just the best contestants to survive last year, and they deserved all the accolades they received - just lovely, talented people. I'm sure that these remaining contestants are nice people with pleasing personalities, but IMHO, there's nobody left with that X factor, the charisma combined with talent to carry a show, much less a design show - Josh Johnson has it all.

While the revolving platform was inventive, it's an accident just waiting to happen. Would have worked maybe in the loft - not in that space. The colors and accessories were interesing, Will, since I'm sure he was responsible for everything except the platform. The kitchen left me completely cold - not even a hanging plant or two. ROBB WHO SHOULD HAVE BEEN BOOTED AFTER THE CAR DOOR/PILLOW DISASTER IS NOW GONE, GONE, GONE.

Again, I am so disheartened, Sparkle Josh, that you won't be the next Design Star, but you are by far still outshining them all!

Remember, y'all, as Sparkle says, PLATINUM IS THE NEW BLACK!

Posted by Joy in TN – August 27, 2007 10:37 AM

I AM SOOOO GLAD THAT ROB IS GONE!!! I have not liked him from the start and this week he proved why. There is no way this man would have been able to carry a show, unless HGTV is adding a shockdesigner show to their line up. Kim handled herself very well. I don't think that I could have been that nice.

Posted by she luv hgtv – August 27, 2007 10:36 AM

I actually did a happy dance when Robb's show was cancelled! If he made it through last night I was going to quit watching. If he got his own show it would be cancelled after the first season because no one would want to work with him and no one would watch! I was surprised that the judges even complimented him on his presentation. To me it was over the top and cocky. A design star needs to be likeable and I haven't liked Robb from day one.

Posted by Mindy – August 27, 2007 10:33 AM

I'm surprized that many think the turntable in the living room was not practical. For just a small amount of money (the whole room was $10,000), the problem of furniture placement was solved. This was done on a low budget in 24 hours. Ideally you could set the turntable into the floor, so no step. Also add the ability to lock it into place. I think the turntable makes sense in any room with more than one focal point. Isn't furniture placement a problem we all have?

Posted by Debra – August 27, 2007 10:33 AM

This year's show is so lame. First they have all these weird group challenges, next the colossally stupid judges eliminate the only "real" talent Sparkle Josh, then during an important elimination more group work with a tiny tiny budget (in Wayne Newton's house). The one smart elimination was Robb, unfortunately it was about 3 shows too late. My unemotional husband cheered out of control over Robb's ejection as I'm sure did 99% of all viewers.

Kim, very nice work!!! Oh and awesome patience & class with Robb you are a gem!!!

Will, good job! Nice team work, you are fun to watch, the presentation will come together.

Todd, WOW!!! Nice design, I wish the floor was motorized - I'm sure the small budget was an issue.

Posted by Maria – August 27, 2007 10:30 AM

Rob--Good enthusiasm but good riddance. You had a strong personality but being a good designer is all about getting along with others in a team environment, especially when that team includes other creative people. The glass tile job--uneven and poor grout choice. Good thing the carpenter saved on the miss-measurements.
Kim--Classy behavior, good team player, and enthusiastic attitude. I believe you have talent but need to get more confident and BOLD with your design--you're still playing it too safe. Throw more color, texture, and layer into the design.
Will--I like that you spoke up on day one to Robb and told him straight up how frustrating he is to work with--you didn't slam him, you just said it like it was. Wished he would have heeded your advice rather than trying to "get back" by suggesting you didn't work hard enough on the Wedding project. You definitely have great personal integrity and stay true to yourself but you need to up the ante in the presentation department--first, either wear your shirt IN or OUT of your pants. I see from you and the other contestants that the "style" is to only tuck in the front. It might be stylish on the coasts but looks silly to those of us in the middle. You're a handsome fellow also...no more tee shirts. Dress for a social at church--let the threads on your outside be a teaser for the talent on the inside. You need to work on presentation and speak more clearly but TV coaches can help that.
Todd--you're clearly very energetic, creative and talented. Glad you made it this far and glad you toned down on the athletic showboating. In the beginning you where like watching a teenage boy trying to get attention by doing tricks on the skateboard...uh, wait a minute... I know you are talented but want to see you actually do some solid INTERIOR DESIGN rather than focused energy on the gimmick stuff. The individual room challenge with the wave was WAY cool; Wayne's living room could have been awesome without the platform. Get some balance between the gimmick and the goods. You're talented enough that you didn't need to go shirtless the whole time.
Must admit, I miss Sparkle also.
Love David's v-blogs. Good luck to all!!

Posted by Special K – August 27, 2007 10:25 AM

I'll I have to say is Thank God Robb is gone. The show has not been as enjoyable this season for me. I much preferred the David/Alice friendly competition of Season 1. I've never been a fan of attitude, and I wish Robb had been gone from Challenge #1. I almost stopped watching this season, and I certainly would not have watched his show. I was sorry to lose Scott, but I like the three remaining designers and will enjoy the last few episodes. So glad there is no more attitude!

Posted by Gina – August 27, 2007 10:17 AM

Okay folks, we're finally rid of Robb, he has ruined his last hour of TV and will blame everyone but himself...so lets rewind and leave him in Orlando, go back to the show when we lost Scott, and the wedding when we lost Christina and of course, bring "Sparkle" back...and start over with those 3 still in the competition along with the remaining 3...then we'll have a Design Star in the making. We lost too many good designers in the early shows, and had Robb using up precious air just being in the room...I bet he's a carpenter's assistant in real life!!! Oh, and fans of Scott, did you see him on the Designer's Challange on Saturday!!! I spotted him immediately in a Los Angeles floral market when one of the designer's was shopping for flowers for the wedding reception she was working on...I miss Scott and Josh...."Sparkle" could light up any room with his sweet dispostion and southern accent...again, I'm a 60 yr. old southern woman that loved them both. And Christina. What's next?? Todd will take the last show...Will is very good at what he does, but he has to build his presence better to host a TV show. I love him to death, hope he will step up next week and do well on his presentation. And I told you all that Kim wouldn't be a lackey to Robb....I knew the girl had some steam building and she'd put Robb in his place...before the judges did!!!!

Posted by Kathy West – August 27, 2007 10:16 AM

O.K. Robb's gone. The kitchen was not a stand-out, but then it was Robb's design. Again, he showed he can't measure. Remember the reception where he didn't draw to scale? With his experience you'd think he would know better. Kim did her best to make it work and she did a great job putting Robb in his place. She did a great job on the "hosting" skills too.

Many of the commenters think Todd is way over the top. Just go to his web site. He is an AMAZING designer. No broken furniture or platforms. I do believe he can design a room for us average joe's. Remember, Mr. Las Vegas said "do what you want" and he did. Just as Josh and Will make a good team, Todd and Will showed they are a good team too. The platform isn't for everyone but the clients liked it and that's the bottom line. The room was beautiful.

As for Will's hosting skills...how many of you have bben inf front of a camera? I've had to give training presentation in front of one and the first time you do it, it's nerve-racking! Will can do it because he speaks his passion from his heart and he will loosen up. As the judges said he's informative without being condescending.

I'm looking forward to next week's individual challenges. We should have had more of them as many of you have said. Even David says so. Whoever is left is going to make it tough on all of us to vote in the final episode.

Love hearing from you Josh!!!!!!

Posted by mary mcphillips – August 27, 2007 10:03 AM

First and foremost I'm glad Rob is GONE! He was definitely not a Team Player. Will & Josh (sparkle) has been my favorite two since the show started. Kim showed great restraint when interacting with Rob...I don't think I could have done it.

Posted by DJ – August 27, 2007 9:49 AM

A revolving platform!!! give me a break! The judge thought it was innovative?!?!

That room was huge and the real design challenge star would have created a seating design that could have accomodated several seating areas - instead of a circus stage. I know it is Las Vegas and all - but -- again give me a break!!

I definitely hope in the case of Todd's design element - what happens in Vegas -- STAYS in Vegas. YUCK. He is just too off-the-wall in his design ideas for a design show host.

AND - David B. has already done the take-off-the shirt bit. What is up with that?

HGTV - you have a final three that are nice - but NOT host material. Closest one IMO is Kim.

Posted by Jeff – August 27, 2007 9:46 AM

Robb is gone? After, as he said," staring the Grim Reaper in the face" in the first two eliminatons? After pointing the finger, in front of those pitiful judges, at Organic Josh and then Will? After a failure of a space where he crackled and fauxed the space to death? He was deserving of elimination from the first challenge. I won't thank Vern, Cynthia, or Martha for FINALLY seeing his obese ego and twisted personality. They were foolish enough to let Josh Johnson go and keep rowdy Robb last week. I must be unAmerican because Vern is my least favorite designer, Instyle magazine is off my reading list, and I think Cynthia Rowley has just let Vern run the show. Finally she was unable to deal with the unpleasantness.
I think new judges should be the first ctiteria for the next show. Clive, you are the only good thing left in what was once a fabulous TV series!

Posted by CMS – August 27, 2007 9:40 AM

This episode brings to mind a proverb from an old Charlie Chan movie:

"Tongue Hang Man Quicker Than Rope".

Posted by Veneer Voodoo – August 27, 2007 9:40 AM

Todd's design was creative and cleaver, (I love the way you see and DO so quickly, that's amazing!). Kim's shopping talent was great but I would have bought a rectangular table for the space and three smaller mirrors for each wall. Will is such a great person to be willing to work well for the greater good or design, very commendable! Sooooo glad Robb is finally gone!!! He was so difficult to watch and hear. He is RUDE and that is so unnecessary! I don't think Todd and Cynthia were flirting. She did the same thing with David last year -- she knows a good thing when she sees it and it makes her happy! I have faith in the Design Star show again and anxiously want to see the next episode and see how the last three do on their individual designs. It will be sooo nice to not have to deal with Robb any further - (hit the road dude in your truck and keep on truckin'and take your junk yard door with you--) Robb was very bossy and ruthless in his ability to carry out the design. I must say Kim was strong in standing up to him and getting her point across - she deserves to WIN just because she did THAT!!!! But,I thought Todd's presentation should have won, Kim was too rushed and too many arms waving back and forth! I don't know who will WIN out of these three. They are all great people, designers and talents -- best to you all and I'll be cheering for each of you. Great contest HGTV - I love the show again!

Posted by reena – August 27, 2007 9:28 AM

I miss Sparkle Josh. He is cool and cute and gentlemanly, and talented. The other contenders really don't have his "sparkle." Kim is my next choice because she is knowledgeable and cute on tv. Todd could have some kind of weird show where you do off the wall decorating, I guess, and he might do well there. Will will have to definately step it up in the "showman" area in order to hold peoples' attention, although he is a great guy, and very talented. He and Todd might be good contrasts for each other in a show. But, alas, Josh Johnson had it all!

Posted by Linda – August 27, 2007 9:26 AM

Wow. Loved it (especially the ending!!!!)!! Robb did not disappoint with his level on the A-hole meter tonight! He is so abrasive, childish, overly defensive, and full of himself, I would never, never, never have watched a show that he hosted. And it was soooo funny that he measured wrong!! Hee hee hee hee.

Big props to Kim!! Kim rules. Kim rocks for putting up with Robb on that project and calling him out when he was being condescending and talking to her like she was not his teammate. And I loved that she had to explain to him about the sink coming down too low to put a dishwasher there or whatever it was that he wanted to do. She had great ideas, too. I am just sorry that she didn't get to finish accessorizing because I would have liked to have seen that. I hated the tile they picked out for the kitchen - that seemed like the wrong green to me - yish. No one seemed upset that the fridge didn't get put in. I suppose it didn't make Vern as nauseous as the last time because Wayne has workers to help him finish a project, unlike your regular Joe-Schmoe family. Overall, I thought the kitchen turned out well and I loved that Kim stood her ground with Robb.

Robb cannot hide his ugly personality and it showed all night long. Loved the exit interview. Hey, Robb, it's your world; we're just living in it. He is delusional if he ever thought anyone would vote for him and watch his show. I shudder to think.

I loved the living room. I loved how it turned out. It was fun to watch Will and Todd work together. I thought the platform was a great idea and I liked his reasoning behind that because it was a guest house and meant for fun, and I thought it turned out really well. I loved the colors they chose. I just really liked the room. I think Todd is very inventive and creative and I would definitely watch his show. I think Will has great ideas. He is not very high energy so I think a show he would do would be a more practical type of show, and that's okay, too. Not everything has to be high energy and in your face. His show would be more like a Decorating Cents, Design on a Dime practical type of show, I think. I do like Will and would be happy with him as the next Design Star, too.

Anyway, the guest house is way better than Wayne's actual home. I think those pieces should go back to the castles they came from. Yuck. That was so gaudy, or as Kim said, so over the top.

I could not be more pleased with the final 3 and I am really looking forward to next week. I still liked Season 1 better and thought the challenges were more even and I liked the contestants better, but I am loving it that Robb is gone, so I can stomach it all a little better now.

Posted by Mandy – August 27, 2007 9:20 AM

Thank you for axing Robb. I had trouble even watching the show because of him. I really miss Sparkle -- he has wonderful talent & I love his personality & he would have made a wonderful TV host. I like both Kim & Will...not too keen on Todd. Note to Todd -- put your shirt on...you're not that hot.

Posted by JP – August 27, 2007 9:14 AM

This is in response to BEM...my brother, my brother.....for you to even suggest that Robb had any talent or his mannerisms were anything likeable, dude, you must be just like him....arrogant, condescending, unable to work with others as a team player, talentless....etc. Robb did not have one redeeming quality which is why he got the boot, and well deserved at that. It's obvious by the blogs you fool, that most of America did not like him. Of course noone can change your mind, but anyone who had an ounce of normalcy would realize that Robb would eventually be booted off and wouldn't be in the final two. Obviously, you're not normal.

Anyway, I agree with most of America here, and I do agree with one blogger who wrote, "did anyone notice that the designers who were picked this season aren't as good as last year's?" I totally agree with you!....My only hope is Will or Kim. If Todd put that revolving platform in my house, I would demand my money back and I would fire him. Come on people, even the weirdest of weirds out there would not have that in their home! I guess this is what makes the world go round.....ha-ha!

David Bromstad, loved your blog on Robb and one thing about you, you proved your talent on the second show last season, I knew you would win because you're an artist, and from one artist to another, you are so talented and I have enjoyed your designs every week and am always surprised as to you coming up with beautiful designs every week. Keep up the good work, and you truly deserve everything. Marissa

Posted by Marissa – August 27, 2007 9:13 AM

will is sooo creative he just needs a good stylist and a voice coach.

Posted by cher – August 27, 2007 9:09 AM

I wonder how many aliases Robb has after reading some of these comments that only he could have written about himself.... LOL While the guy has some talent, he has zero people skills and is such an obnoxious jerk that it was obvious he wouldn't have a show from the minute he first opened his mouth. Even after watching the show where he behaved in such an embarrassingly childish manner, I'm sure the idiot STILL doesn't "get it" as to why such behavior is unacceptable in any profession -- especially one where you must be able to interact with others -- and on TV! Maybe he's under the illusion that he was just "good television"... LOL It's really a shame. If he'd learn to harness that mouth, ego, and arrogance, and instead focus on his talent, he could actually go somewhere in the world of design. But he's going to have a hard time having success in ANYTHING until he has a major change in his disposition and, as Kim said, takes a good long look at himself in the mirror and sees himself for the obnoxious jerk that he is. I say good riddance, Robb! He should have been kicked off two weeks ago!

Posted by lwoods – August 27, 2007 9:00 AM

There were lots of losers last night. Rob finally was shown the door. This was the second time in two weeks that he was off scale in measurements. If they didn't have the contractor helper, how would he have corrected the problem? As it was the fridge was outside on the lawn!!
But, what was really sad was the behavior of the InStyle Mgz judge's attitude towards Will. She wants him gone. Period. Her whole facial/ body expressions change when its Todd or Robb. I can't remember the last time an African/Amer. male headed a show on HGTV? To get to this point and now start to worry about the"show" was alittle late. Last night there were a lot of losers: HGTV, Instyle Magazine, Swell....the judges are also representing there own product/images. Get a clue...this isn't looking so good. I can't wait for Todd to win, so American families can all build that skateboarding ramp in the living room.

Posted by lynn schmollinger – August 27, 2007 8:42 AM

All these Rob lovers missed the fact that he would host a TV program and the last two makeovers were not up to scale. Like the sink didn't fit because he measured wrong! Hello, isn't this guy supposed to be the "expert" here?
What alarmed me more was the obvious dislike by the InStyle judge towards Will. She wants him gone. I've watched HGTV for years and can't remember the last time a show was headed by an African/American male. He has the talent but now the judges are concerned with the TV wow factor?
If that is the case, what will Todd bring to the average american family that doesn't see a skateboard ramp as the accessory? Rob was so mean spirited at the wedding towards Will and to watch his behavior towards Kim..so sorry that C. Rowley didn't like the "display" between Kim and Rob but All the HGTV views watched this. This looked horrible for the show, HGTV, Instyle magazine and Rowley. A lot of credibilty was lost
last night.

Posted by lynn schmollinger – August 27, 2007 8:30 AM

So glad the Arrogant One is gone. He should have been eliminated last week instead of Posh Josh. The Las Vegas wedding party may have liked him, but the whole concept was just plain awful. And for him to bad mouth Kim the way he did was unconscionable! Good Riddance!

Posted by Dolores – August 27, 2007 8:28 AM

My husband thought I had lost it tonight. I cheered the TV when Clive said, "Robb, your show has been canceled." It is amazing that he lasted this long. Robb's history came to its just end tonight. The judges had little justification for getting rid of him last week. The couple chose Robb's design which was based on some strange input and the rest of the designers did manage to pull off the design. With Robb managing to get his design pulled off successfully, the judges did not have any justification for letting him go last week. However, Robb's history on Design Star speaks for itself.
(1) He argued with Organic Josh on the first challenge and did not contribute enough to the design to pull off anything other than a rejected harem scene. Was it Organic Josh or Robb that said that there was no time for details?
(2) When they picked teams playground style, Robb was the last one standing. I know how that feels, but coupled with Narisha (sp) that he was difficult to work with set the wheels of fate in motion.
(3) Robb had the nerve to actually say on camera that he was hiding stuff at the 99 cents store so the other contestants could not use it. That is not playing fair.
(4) Watching Will give Robb constructive criticism and accomplishing every task he was assigned -- did Robb do any actual work that episode? -- and then hear Robb tell the judges that Will was the weakest link. To me that nailed another nail into Robb's failed fate.
(5) Tonight we had poetic justice. Robb tells Kim that she is clipping her own wings by disagreeing with him and his wings got cut clear out of the show.
Game called after extra innings and Robb struck out!
I cried when they turned the lights off Josh's SPARKLE, but I cheered tonight. Game shows bring back contestants who were let go after it is discovered that there was an error in the judging. Bring back SPARKLE Josh as the #1 challenger for Season Three. Give him another chance to show us what we were deprived from seeing!

Posted by Louise – August 27, 2007 8:25 AM

This show has been a sham from the get go. You never had the opportunity to see people's talents, as if talent was irrelevant.
They sped this up so fast to get Vern Yip's show going, and Vern Yip in my book is just another same old same old. I think the producers got it wrong, very wrong

Posted by Mary – August 27, 2007 7:59 AM

ROBB is GONE!!! Great job! Now get rid of the overgrown kid Todd and you have two winners. I would have preferred Sparkle Josh, but Will and Kim are my next picks. Come on judges, Tod designs fantasy rooms which the normal family could not/would not use in their homes. He is not for the average person and I really don't care for his style at all. I think Will has great design potential and Kim is fun to watch. Those of you who think Robb was talented, did you forget the tacky wedding, the horrendous "Tuscan Kitchen" and the other half finished things he did? No talent and totally obnoxious, glad he's gone.

Posted by Lynda Carter – August 27, 2007 7:41 AM

My God, it was painful to see Wayne and his wife - they looked multiple Botox experiments that went awry.
Although, if Wayne was going for that LtCmdr Data (Star Trek Next Gen) android look, he nailed it. Yes, Madame Toussaint's wax figures can come alive.
William of Long Island

Posted by William of Long Island – August 27, 2007 7:30 AM

the judges made a mistake and it appears that Wayne Newton, from his comments about the kitchen, would agree. Robb finished the kitchen almost single-handedly while being impeded by the carping of Kim with a smile on her face. I'm sure she is a good beautician but she is not a designer. She painted and shopped but the furniture she purchased did not "pop".

Posted by kathleen pagan – August 27, 2007 6:58 AM

Well, looks like Robb's arrogance finally got the best of him. Thank goodness! I was very nervous at the onset of the show to see if Kim would be able to hold her own and make it thru elimination next to "the bully", Robb. I think Kim handled herself wonderfully. She did not stoop to his level and was willing to take her share of the responsibility for whatever the judges criticized; very classy. Luckily, Robb pretty much put himself up on the chopping block with his owns comments at elimination. Plus, he's not even that talented. If he's done thousands of kitchens, how could he be so off with the measurements. Luckily they had a great carpenter to do the fix-up. And for all his insults about Kim's tile job (which I'll remind everyone she told her teammates up front she had never done tile), Robb's tile job was sloppy and ameteurish. It was hard to tell which were the before and after shots of the backsplash. I agree with the judges that the kitchen needed more accents and finishing touches but I think the color and basic furnishings were excellent.

Todd and Will did a nice job but I didn't see any real "punch". The platform was okay but I agree with Vern that I didn't like seeing all the furniture pieces crammed up on the platform. Also maybe if they had more time, a motorized platform would make it easier to move and alleviate the safety concerns. It was nice to see Todd not go totally over-the-top for a change but I'm still wondering if he's got true design talent.

I'm looking forward to this coming week's individual challenges. And even though this week's show was a bit better, I have to echo with many of my other fellow viewers that this year seems to be lacking the overall quality and talent of last year's show.

Posted by Andrea – August 27, 2007 6:03 AM

The problem this season is the rushed format. We haven't seen enough of the designers individual work to evaluate ANY of the contestants on their design talent. Some may have more potential than others, but honestly, I don't know.

So instead, we are all doing the only other thing we can - pick our favorite personality. Thats why the clear front runner was Sparkle Josh, and why Scott had a sizeable following.

I'll vote for Kim now that Sparkle and Scott are gone. But design ability? Who knows... and at this point, who cares?

Posted by Rachel – August 27, 2007 4:57 AM

Robb a designer? You've got to be kidding. His failure to draw his wedding reception plans to scale made the place look like a brothal, and his failure at correctly measuring the height of the center bar in last night's episode showed his complete incompetence.

What took the judges so long?

Posted by Ruth – August 27, 2007 4:40 AM

Robb's post-elimination tantrum proved that he fully deserved his ouster. Sparkle Josh was gracious to a fault when he was asked to go, but Robb used the opportunity to call the judges names. Nice going! One of the reasons everyone loves David Bromstad is that he is fantastic at relating to a wide swath of personality types: prickly yuppies, traditional couples, 'working class' groups, new parents, etc. Even people who may not be wild about (ahem) flamboyant individuals warm to David naturally. Robb was the antithesis of David, capable of turning anyone off more or less instantly. He would have been horrific to work with.

Kim has the sort of personality that would shine on her own show, but so far has failed to display the actual design skills necessary. Will isn't terribly eloquent, being a quiet sort, and Todd is like "Dude!" I'm not sure any of them is The Whole Package. Sparkle Josh, despite a horrifically bad "99 Cent Store" room, was BY FAR the best choice for his own show. He was funny, classy, caring, visually attuned and people of all sorts gravitated towards him. A real loss.

Posted by Grazzi – August 27, 2007 4:30 AM

Ding dong - the ass is gone! Rob was on every last nerve and I was beyond relieved to see him go. Sure, he presented a good portfolio, but it's the whole package that counts. Especially if you want to be on tv! He thinks WAY too highly of himself and has no sense of respect for others which negates any remote skill set or experience he thinks he has.

Posted by saigon – August 27, 2007 4:27 AM

So glad Rob is gone. Why don't the judges just say they don't like Will. They didn't ask any of the other designers "what did you do?". Very immature on their part. Regardless of what they say Will, they can't take your talent. By the way, the judges don't impress me either as hosts. I will definitely not watch Vern Yips show!

Posted by P Alexander – August 27, 2007 3:51 AM

I was elated when Robb was told that his show had been canceled!!!!! I had put almost all my voting points in the elimination category on him for good reason! I was sick of his arrogant, know-it-all, demeaning, rude, bossy, look-at-me attitude. Did anyone notice how he was swaying and smiling and practically patting himself on the back all the while his review video was showing?!?! We do NOT need t.v. hosts such as him!!! I, like a lot of other folks, saw the good attitude in Will who seems to be willing to bend over backwards to please and do his part. Kim also has a sweet attitude and seems to be easy to work with. Last years winner, David Bromstad, has a great attitude and shows a lot of love for people as well as Candice Olsen, Joan Steffan, Debbie Travis and more that I can't recall right off. They are the kind of people I would want helping me with my decorating needs, not Robb's kind!!!!!

Posted by Mimi – August 27, 2007 3:46 AM

OH MY GAAWWD! In my opinion, Kim should have stuffed Robb into the refrigerator that was left OUTSIDE! Kudos to Kim for not using the carpenter's nail gun to SHUT ROBB'S MOUTH!

Posted by Tammi in Citrus Heights – August 27, 2007 3:38 AM

At least when Robb was on the show, we knew where he was. Now he's probably out there committing felonies. He's just plain scary!

Posted by Deb – August 27, 2007 3:37 AM

"Robb, Your Show Has Been Cancelled." Sweet Music to the ears!! Is it my imagination or has Martha have it out for Will? She made some comment about Him not impressing her or something and has made unfavorable remarks about Him ever since. I guess she is too Gaw Gaw over Todd. I think Todd takes his shirt off because he thinks it worked for David. Well David Bromstad he is NOT! Building is not designing, next week maybe we'll see if he has any design talent. I hope Will or Kim win. Would definately like to see them as the final two. It would be awesome to bring back Sparkle Josh as either Will or Kim's sidekick. Look how well David and Danielle work together. Each of them have their own unique contributions and it works for "Color Splash" Can't wait for next week. Maybe next week, "Your Show Has Been Cancelled" will send Todd home. He is way too flip floppy. Notice how he could not even critique Robb without saying "Just kidding!" Next week ought to be interesting.

Posted by noeokee – August 27, 2007 3:33 AM

WOW! What a blog tonight!! OK, here I go - To Terry G. (Aug 26, 10:23pm) - I totally agree with your comment! Now, I'm not a Robb fan, he had some good moments, but for his own well-being I hope he seeks help. To Mary - Vern was my favorite designer (and the best) on Trading Spaces! Sept. 9th? I can't wait!! To Doug - I think Josh will be back to help one of the finalists. I'm hoping I'll see Will & Sparkle team up again!! To Dale - First time I laughed so hard on this blog! :) Kim cut out ginkgo leaves, not shamrocks! That was cute. I'm not laughing at you, I'm laughing because it kind of reminded me of shamrocks too. To True - I don't know if Todd is tricking anyone. I would like to think he was just writing in, BUT I agree that a contestant shouldn't be writing in until after he/she has been eliminated. I'm very surprised that the producers allowed it. Did contestants write in before they were eliminated last year?

Posted by Eileen – August 27, 2007 3:22 AM

Wow, finally, Rob's show is cancelled. If I had someone in my home and he couldn't have a good relationship with the people he is working with, how could he listen to me............Good going judges.......touch from here on out, but I know who I am betting on.

Posted by gj – August 27, 2007 3:21 AM

This was by far the best show yet. Will and Todd's room was great, but obviously much easier to tackle than that kitchen. I tend to agree with Vern about the "lazy susan" effect of the spinning platform. I really liked their live plant display.
Kim and Robb had their work cut out for them with that time allowance. The kitchen colors were so warm and fresh...loved it! Kim and that carpenter did a great job. Robb...what can I say about him that hasn't already been said? Hmmmmm...maybe he can get a gig driving that truck of his. Kudos to Kim for standing her ground and slaying that dragon! You've made many millions of viewers so happy tonight, Kim!
I can't wait for the individual challenges next week!

Posted by shefalidolly – August 27, 2007 3:19 AM

Dear Fans,
Have to say Kim may be savy--got rid of Robb--but she is no design star. Question for the show producers---why did you focus on all her comments so heavily? Too much of her wining. Her face was on the sreen more than the other three. As though it was a set up. Thought she revealed her true self as having an ugly personality-- in this case. She was so concerned about herself and wasn't focusing on their project. And all she did was shop for furniture--Sparkle Josh was told he was a good shopper, but did not have strong design skills. Welllll think about it judges--neither does she. Rob scored a home run with the wedding reception and worked well with everyone. All Kim did on that project was make the centerpieces and kept saying how much she disliked the flashing lights in the base. Also kept up a banter about not liking anything even though her design was not chosen.If this strategy of hers (criticizing everyone elses work) lands her in the finals, I will have to question the whole Design Star process. Why are the judges overlooking this?
HYACINTH

Posted by Hyacinth – August 27, 2007 3:03 AM

Do you think Robb keeps his head covered even in the shower? Can you imagine if he won and you had to put up with him week after week? I think he has real issues and not just all-consuming anger and arrogance. He's one of those short, bald guys who just can't come to terms with it. Too bad, Robb, those "fools" finally got it right and booted your ass back home. Hope we never see you again.

Posted by Bryn – August 27, 2007 3:02 AM

Thank God that Robb is gone. I did not like his personality or attitude from day one. He was an obnoxious psycho and would have hurt your show. He should have been let go the first day

Todd kind of scares me with some of the things he comes up with, don't know if I want him to work on my place or not, But he seems to have more talet then the rest of them

At first I did not like Will but the more I watched the show Will seems to have better ideals than Todd and think he can make it with a little pratice on selling his self

Posted by Shirley – August 27, 2007 2:57 AM

First of all..."True"...your comments about us being fake is not true!!! I didn't even know that Todd wrote in and have yet to read his blog. He did happen to improve this week and so therefor many of our comments are genuine. There will always be a few "fakes" in this world...it goes with the territory...but it is totally not fair for you to label all of us one!!!

Posted by Teresa – August 27, 2007 2:56 AM

If I had a bottle of champagne, I would be popping the cork right now. Ithought they were never going to get rid of that guy.

Next week should be interesting.

Posted by Alexis – August 27, 2007 2:44 AM

I had totally planned to come on this blog (for the first time mind you) and rip the judges a new one for their comments tonight. Personally, I feel they are a bit racist (in my opinion) and inconsistent. Will is the best actual designer on the show and has been from the very start. Remember, he was the 11th pic in a show that was designed for 10! From the Bedroom in the house with Josh, to his own space design and then his presentation to the married couple, Will has shown well. Is he the perfect picture of what designed look and talk like? Probably not! However, this is still American dammit and this is th eplace where dreams become reality! Nothing Todd has shown us is practical for livng and Kim has done nothing that tells us she knows anything. Robb needed to go, his attitude was/is just bad. He is not a team player and if he had worked with a man this challenge would probably have gotten his behind kicked. Now many of us who watch HGTV could have done several cost effecient and quick designes to the kitchen that would have been better. I disaggree that the kitchen was harder. They could have done stainless steel or aluminum backsplashes. Instead of painting the wood around the wine chillers they could have used stainless steel or aluminum to match the appliances (even the one that got left in the yard.) A rug on the floor woulf have been nice in that kitchen area too. The simple stuff was not taken care of. Now, back to Will is he "country"? Yes! Does he do good work? Yes! The fact that the Judge from In Style magazine has a problem with Will (and has had one consistently throughout the show) says too me that she is racist! I watch HGTV alot. I am African-American and they have no BLACK people as Designers which says to me, they have a problem with African-Americans. Race aside, be honest, Will gives us good product, good character (integrity, etc.) and good design. Hell, they can help him with the presentation. What designer sets out to be on TV any damn way! I just sit here and think, this is America, the show is a dream, I'm praying for Will, but I see he keeps making it by the hair on his chinny, chin, chin. When he is the ost consistent relatable designer this season. As, I stated before... they chose him as the 11th desgner and He has proven he was worthy, can you say that Kim has? We will see!
Bye Robb it really was your time to go!

Posted by K.C. – August 27, 2007 2:36 AM

I completely agree with the comments that 'Lorena' posted - that Todd's designs are not suitable for regular folks. I still cannot understand why he wasn't voted off in week 1. He put a skateboarding ramp in the living room! That's talent?!?! And his 99 cent store room was just ridiculous - come on, this is HGTV, a place where people turn to get decorating ideas for their own homes - not to get ideas for absurd rooms that no one in their right mind would ever want to duplicate.

I agree with most of the other people out there that this season is a big disappointment. The designers with talent, like Scott and Sparkle Josh got eliminated WAY too soon and we were left with talentless individuals like Todd and Robb. Thankfully the judges wised up tonight and relieved us of Robb.

GO KIM AND WILL!!!

Posted by dmz – August 27, 2007 2:36 AM

I loved the show! It was def. time for Rob to go! He just doesn't have the "sparkle" needed! I agree with so many of you, I miss "sparkle Josh", he would have been fabulous tonight.

I am torn between which of the remaining three I am cheering for. I like them all. In fact I think they should bring Sparkle Josh back, and have a show with four hosts!

Posted by spanish_teach – August 27, 2007 2:36 AM

I would have put Robb out in the first episode along with his rusty car door. From the start he was "robbing" people the wrong way. Kim and Will, two of my favorites are still in the competition. Let me ask you fans out there, am I the only one who got the impression Robb and Todd had an idea of what they were going to "create" in their individual chanllenges?

Posted by Marie from Tacoma, WA – August 27, 2007 2:32 AM

Well, at least there's some justice in the fact that Robb is finally GONE!!! Unfortunately, it was at the expense of a contestant I feel we all kind of connected with from day one. Love you Sparkle Josh!. As for the three who are left...that's a hard one. Todd and Will have more talent, but Kim has more "sellability". I'm not sure what the judges were looking for this year, but it seems it was more about drama then it was about design.

Posted by TLC – August 27, 2007 2:30 AM

I am SO relieved that the judges finally realized that Robb is not a "team player" (to put it mildly) and therefore is not at all Design Star material. What absolutely amazes me is that it has taken the judges this long to see that! Robb has an ego that is way beyond description and has a lot of major issues that he really needs to deal with. Even if he did have the talent to become the next Design Star (he doesn't)the show would have imploded quickly for three reasons: #1 - he would have treated everyone on the new show as if they were complete idiots, would have blamed everyone else for his own mistakes, would have acted as if he were the only one who knows anything, and his colossal ego would have made it totally impossible for anyone to work with him for any length of time. #2 - he would be one of those designers who never listens to the client's wishes and would have just steam-rolled over them to go after his own agenda. #3 - no one would have watched the show (unless they just wanted to see how many times he made a fool of himself and to see just how long the show would last).

Throughout this entire series I have wondered just what the judges have been thinking - not only concerning Robb's overpowering ego trips, but also concerning the other contestants that have been let go. Perhaps the judges are only allowed to see the clips of the finished work and not the clips of the work in progress. Perhaps they have their own favorites that they are rooting for. Beats me. But I personally think that several of the contestants were let go prematurely, so not only were they short-changed, but the audience was as well. We were not given the opportunity to see what they were really capable of doing.

The judges need to know that David Bromstad and many of the contestants from the last Design Star series were loved not only because of their design capabilities and talents, but also because of their pleasant personalities. That is NOT to be misconstrued to mean that the personality of a Design Star winner has to be hyper, over-the-top, flamboyant, etc. On the contrary, an open, sincere, laid-back, lovable personality like Will, "Sparkle" Josh, and Kim all have are very refreshing (Candice Olsen is another good example).

Personally I think that the viewers are tired of arrogant, egotistical personalities. For example, I really loved Debbie Travis' design skills and thought that she was a real cutie, but it absolutely made me livid whenever she refused to work with her clients. She would very often dismiss their objections and suggestions with that fabulous smile of hers and say, "Oh, she/he will absolutely LOVE it - you'll see." Once she even turned to the camera and said something to the effect that the show was hers, so she could do whatever she wanted to do (never mind what the clients wanted - and never mind what they had to live with after she blew out of town). Really loved her and her skills, but hated her egotism and the fact that the show was all about her talents and rarely about her clients' needs and desires.

Ok, that all said - since HGTV is wanting feed-back on the series, I would like to be a part of the solution to the Design Star problem and not just end up as another griper. So, I would like to ask the JUDGES AND DESIGN STAR PRODUCERS to at least read and consider the following suggestions for the next Design Star series:

1. The producers and judges should weed-out all of the nuts and fruit-cakes before the series competition even begins (we really don't want to see people who are on major ego trips, vacuum cleaner decorators, and people who are continually doing hand-springs).

2. All of the contestants should stay and participate throughout the entire competition series, so that they can fully demonstrate their true capabilities in every competition. (The exception would be the removal of anyone who quite obviously slipped through the initial screening process undetected - such as Robb.)

3. The contestants should be given a fair and realistic amount of time to design and execute the tasks that they have been given (which quite often has just not been the case).

4. The contestants should be given more opportunities to showcase their individual talents.

5. At the end of each show each contestant should be verbally critiqued by the judges for each and every catagory that is being evaluated for that specific show (concept, design, originality, attitude, execution, etc.).

6. At the end of the series the judges should then review all of the Design Star shows (not just the clips of the finished work) and all of the contestants should be re-assessed in the light of their growth and progress throughout the series. The over-all scores should then be tallied-up and the process of elimination should begin at that time.

7. The remaining two contestants should be evaluated verbally by the judges, and then the viewers may choose the winner.

Hope this feed-back helps.

Posted by Pam – August 27, 2007 2:30 AM

I have one thing to say... It's about time!!! I was getting so tired of seeing all the tension Robb was causing in each design project. It was like an intense nightmare watching Robb critize Kim. Kim did not deserve the treatment Robb gave her. On the other hand...I found it to be so pleasant to see Will and Todd work well together. They had some great concepts. I do agree with the judges...that Will needs to step up his hosting skills if he wants to be the next HGTV's design star. He has been my favorite from the start. It's not impossible...because David was weak with his first hosting episode and he "kicked it up" several notches the next go around and won the competition!!! So Will is not out of the running. I was surprised to see how well Todd did??? He really stepped it up this challenge. As for Robb...it was ashame that he showed a very ungrateful attitude during his elimination round. He was given an opportunity of a lifetime!!! Yet...he has been the only designer who never showed one ounce of gratitude. All he had was criticism...this truly shows yet once more...he was never a design star. Why he lasted this long...is beyond me??? I can't believe the last thing he said about the judges!!! How crude!!! Now maybe...the last couple of episodes will be worth watching... Robb...if you are allowed to view these posts...now that you have been eliminated...please learn from them. If you don't...you will make everyone around you miserable for the rest of your life!

Posted by Teresa – August 27, 2007 2:29 AM

Well, it is about time the judges figured out that Rob is not Design Star material. He may be a contractor who can't measure (I've had them in my house!) but who'd want to work for or with him? He'll go through life always blaming everyone else for his failures and never recognize his curlish aggressive arrogant rude personality. And who would want to listen to that stacatto, machine gun style of self aggrandizment when he hosted a show?

Hooray for Kim for standing up to him and reminding him she was his partner in this assignment.

If you all remember, David didn't have a commanding presence when hosting until he won and was given "hosting" lessons. Give Will a chance, too.

I watched tonight's show with clenched fists but can breathe easier now that Rob's show has been cancelled

Posted by louise jurek – August 27, 2007 2:24 AM

ROBB WAS BEYOND UNPLEASANT, IT'S A WONDER HIS ARM DIDN'T BREAK FROM PATTING HIMSELF ON THE BACK, BUT HIS MOUTH DID HIM IN. Kim, was so like cream coming to the top, Robb's mouth did not do her in. Frankly, I'd like to see a team of Mr. San Francisco and Ms. New York. East - West, he is so off the wall creative, that he encourages us to stretch out of the "typical" and KIM, here is a gal that strongly shows us that one does not need a design degree to have the courage to step up to the plate and paint, hang art and make our own homes a reflection of our selves...tastefully.

Posted by karen – August 27, 2007 2:21 AM

Glad Robb is gone! Several weeks too late! Football season is here and my time was better spent at our pre-draft meeting! Kim is the best of the worst for the off (football) season! I wish David B could consult on the remodel of my kitchen! In any event, I am glad Robb is gone! Hope Robb's side kick Todd is next! Vern is the only qualified Judge, and hopefully next year HGTV hires better judges. I thought the kitchen sucked! But given the amount of time no designer could have done better! Give it to Kim or Will! They are average practical and talented designers who have an appeal to average people!

Posted by A – August 27, 2007 2:18 AM

Glad the judges finally sent Robb back to the
sandbox (that's where children learn to share and
play nice).

Posted by Cindy – August 27, 2007 2:18 AM

Well,
I for one am pleased with the outcome. I know I will watch the new design star's show no matter who it is! Goodbye Robb Goodbye drama!!! I loved the living room. I can't say as much for the kitchen. In the kitchen the colors where squash and warm colors. Then these sea foam green tiles with black grout!!!! That was hideous and did not fit. However on the flipside ROBB IS GONE!! WWWOOOHHOOO!!

Posted by Brooke – August 27, 2007 2:11 AM

Talented and passionate Rob gave one of the most appealing presentations of his finished project for Episode 5, the Wayne Newton guesthouse kitchen renovation, a very difficult task. Rob is a strong designer with a strong personality. He also is a strong leader who knows what he wants in design and execution. Rob gets impatient with others who are indecisive, insecure, lazy or passive. He cannot tolerate disloyalty and having his teammates question his judgement. Rob is a very dynamic, driven person with a hands-on work ethic. He IS an HGTV Design Star. Rob has proven he can hold the interest of a large TV audience while exceeding clients' expectations. Rob should not have been eliminated from "DesignStar." His DesignStar work speaks for itself. DesignStar is about discovering a design star. It's not about grooming a star to be a designer, or grooming a designer to be a star. Rob said it best, "This isn't a popularity contest." Rob should be in the final three of "DesignStar" based on the results of his design projects in the competition. Most all TV stars are temperamental from time to time. Not all TV stars can work well with their competitors, especially in a reality TV competition broadcast before the nation. Prima donnas are preceived as difficult people who are hard to get along with. Yet, in reality, many prima donnas are uniquely talented geniuses in disguise. Rob is a design star genius. He is temperamental, but who wouldn't be under the circumstances of the HGTV competition? Rob is brilliant for his vision and conceptualization -- two elements that make a great designer. HGTV's audience is the loser for seeing Rob leave DesignStar too soon. Rob's Las Vegas wedding reception, a difficult task to successfully design and execute on short notice with such varying tastes and requests of the bride and groom, was outstanding. Rob is a star, whether on HGTV or in real life.

Posted by Tim Hermetz – August 27, 2007 2:11 AM

Thank goodness the judges came to the decision they did and got rid of Robb. He was making it difficult to watch the show. Can you imagine him having his own show? I sure wouldn't have watched it even in anticipation of the train wreck that surely would follow.

Posted by Rhonda – August 27, 2007 2:07 AM

My only regret is that Robb was not eliminated long ago. Had the judges been more astute, Sparkle Josh would have been in the competition this week instead of that obnoxious twit.

Tonight, Todd & Kim pulled off their design challenges and were comfortable on camera as well. Hopefully, Will can quickly improve his on camera skills because he truely is a talented designer.

At this point, the judges seem enamored with Todd and he's obviously the one to beat. However, I think he's more suited to designing skate park than a home or business. I wouldn't want him to design a room in my house but I'd sure let Will or Kim do the honor.

Posted by Jane – August 27, 2007 2:02 AM

You couldn't be more wrong about Robb!! No doubt that Robb was the show's most competitive contender, which in fact, was a good thing and not a negative. He was definitely the leading workhorse of the bunch and was clearly the guy who had the most distinst vision for style, as well as the brains that made it work. NO KIDDIN' FOLKS, ROBB WAS ROBBED!!

In no way does Kim deseve her own show. I don't even believe she could pull off a CRAFT show, at best. However, she has managed to skillfully, fool the judges into believing that she is the ONE, willing participant of 'compromise'. WHAT A JOKE! From the beginning, she tried to screw up Robb's wedding plan with those gawd' awful generic table arrangements while constantly complaining about Robb, and in today's episode, she again, offered absolutely nothing decorative in the Newton kitchen makeover. YEAH, VERY CLEVER, ISN'T SHE!

Todd has not yet designed one single, LIVEABLE space in the entire show.. and the 'Newton LAZY-SUSAN' guest house was no exception!! Of course, the viewers truly do understand why Todd is still in the running.. because, no doubt the redheaded female judge has got a 'thang' for him. Yep, what a pity.. and he'll win because of it, too!

Poor Will.. He's got some talent, but seems to be too darn LAZY to express-it or build-it. And did we hear it right? Did that lazy-susan spin 350 degrees, or was it 360 degrees? Oh well, guess it really doesn't matter now. I suppose that that sucker's been ripped off of Wayne's gorgeous floors and taken to the horse barn by now. YEEEHAW!

Well, for this viewer, guess it's just about quit'n time from all this nonsense. Not only did the show lose it's sparkle' .. but for sure now, lost the best darn designer star contestant on the show .. Robb. See ya next year.

Posted by Sandy – August 27, 2007 1:58 AM

You have a room in your house that you want to completely redo. You have a general idea of what design sytle you want but everything you've tried hasen't worked. You need a designer you can work with. You want control but need "creative" ideas and skills to really make your room special. Who would you choose??
Todd's my man!

Posted by Jabya – August 27, 2007 1:54 AM

This has to be the worst panel of judges. Robb was totally ripped off. Its not unusual for talented successful people to be high strung, sake the guy had real passion and a lot of ability. Kim is a wannabe and not all that creative , kinda average. Will on the other had although very nice, cant conjugate his verb tense or pronounce words, he lacks the necessary polish it takes for quality programming. Todd is a real competitor , the best showdown would be to see Todd and Robb go for it , head to head for the big prize. But, I am not all that surprised , after all Vern is on the judges panel , this is one of the people responsible for ruining peoples homes on the tacky "trading spaces " program where bad design and tacky decorating is celebrated, but then again HGTV is once again proving the point that it has lost its grip again , if Will or Kim win , we will have yet another mindless 30 minutes of tacky low end decorating.

Posted by jc – August 27, 2007 1:52 AM

Hello Everyone--

Oh my word....what a rivoting hour of design television!!....I have to say that I can only empathize with the emotional duress, physical exhaustion, and mental distress that Kim, Will, Rob, and Todd were encountering at this stage of the competition. I believe that with the time constraints, the spaces were transformed into an amazingly monumental and fantastically beautiful result. I also know that a major source of personal tension originated from the fact that each one of them was required to in essence "turn on" in the midst of competiton anguish, and become an instant show host- all smiles, delight, and fun- how difficult and heart-wrenching! Ultimately, I extend my highest commendation and exaltation to the remaining four for their effort, endurance, and star quality in the face of dramatic adversity and intense competition. I love these people and what they brought to the entire show, and truly value their strong efforts, fine results, and notable endurance. Thank you again to everyone who continues to tune in and that cares enough to continue reading my thoughts and sentiments about Design Star- your devotion and kindness are priceless.

Remember to forever BELIEVE, BE TRUE, and BEDAZZLE.

God Bless--

Josh Johnson

Posted by Josh Johnson – August 27, 2007 1:49 AM

Robb was like a split personality. He was likeable when he was on tape or worked on his own. But who could overlook his subsequent tantrum-throwing and put-downs while working with others? Every time Kim (or anyone else) disagreed with him, THEY were the morons and HE was the only one who knew what he was doing. And he said so. Yeah, right. And by the way, was the tile in the kitchen tonight SUPPOSED to look that way?

I think Todd is very creative, but frankly, the novelty of that platform would soon wear off if you had to leap down and turn it every time you wanted to look in another direction. Think about it! I agree that Will was the weakest host, but it was only by comparison with the other three. I also remember that David had the same problem last year. The hosting this time is much better at the outset. Let's give Will a break here. He has such great taste. Have you noticed that everyone he works with gets along with him (except Robb, of course). And Kim--she is really so calm and collected. Even when she was maddest at Robb, she kept her cool. She had the choice of letting Robb steamroller over her or fighting him. Unfortunately, there were no other choices, since Robb can only abuse instead of compromise. I'd be interested to hear what their carpenter thought of the whole thing. She is a great hostess, too! To those who said that SHE was bossy and abusive, I just say that she had no choice but to stand up for herself. I am so glad that all three of the remaining contestants will have a chance to show what they can do on their own. I only wish that others with better people skills (Scott, Sparkle Josh) could have had a chance to stay in. I think the judges really fell down on that one.

Posted by Louise – August 27, 2007 1:46 AM

Don't normally think of myself as a vengeful person, but Robb crying in the elevator was just too darned good! This guy is so obnoxious, he can't even take the elimination in style. First he blusters, name-calls regarding the show, his teammates, and the judges, and then, in typical macho fashion, (not) bursts into tears. What a closet case! Rob might be a much happier person if he faced his macho demons and forgave his mother, his sister, his ex-wife - whoever the women were who have been the cause of his severe misogyny and then just got on with being the "not extroidinary or particularly talented" soul that he is.

Soooo glad that he won't be there next week. If I wanted to watched contestants be abused on national television, I'd watch "American Ido." I DON"T watch American Idol. I'd like to watch some decent design now that tacky boy is gone.

Now is we could just keep Todd's shirt on . . .

Posted by Karly1 – August 27, 2007 1:45 AM

Robb served his purpose, he kept everyone watching the show and talking about his abrasive personality. The judges would never have let him win. It will be tough to decide between the three remaining - they are all creative, talented and personable. I used to think Todd wouldn't win because his designs were pretty one diminsional (surfer dude chic), but I agree with earlier comments that a show by him would be fun to watch. Watching him use his creative talent to expand his vision into other design schemes would be great to watch. I love Kim though, and Will is soooo talented. Tough call!

Posted by Rozann – August 27, 2007 1:42 AM

NEED TO CORRECT MY EARLIER BLOG!!! TODD DID INDEED HAVE HIS SHIRT OFF THIS EPISODE!!! I'M NOT OFFENDED AT ALL AS I WASN'T BY DAVID DOING THE SAME THING LAST YEAR!!! MAYBE THIS IS WHAT KIM AND WILL ARE MISSING!!! JUST KIDDING FOLKS!!! WATCHING THE SECOND RUN JUST REMINDS ME HOW GLAD I AM ROBB IS GONE!!! AND WHY IS VERN DOING A KNOCK OFF OF TY PENNINGTON'S SHOW?? I'LL CHECK IT OUT CAUSE I LIKE VERN BUT IT SEEMS LIKE THE SAME CONCEPT. HGTV SHOULD BE MORE ORIGINAL...AND WHILE I'M ON THAT TOPIC...PLEASE NOT ANOTHER SHOW ABOUT COLOR!!!!!!!!!

Posted by ROSEANNE S – August 27, 2007 1:41 AM

ROBB IS GONE!!!!!! ABOUT TIME!!!! I'd rather see Will receive training with his presentation style; Todd receive 'tone down' training with his over-the-top wacky design style and Kim just get training with practical design, than see Robb again at all.

Want to see the definition of fool or moron Robb, look in Webster's, your picture is there.

Posted by Gwen Taylor – August 27, 2007 1:41 AM

I am so glad that Robb is finally eliminated. What an obnoxious, rude person. Good for Kim, she was the ultimate professional in dealing with him, sorry she had to be subjected to such a person. What has happened to HGTV/Design Star this season, PRODUCERS, JUDGES, CLIVE - wake up - you had a great season last year, but this year what a disappointment. Last year you had talent but this year "not much". How did you and who choose the "potential design stars"? All I have seen so far are two people who might have potential; Christina and Sparkle Josh; and they are gone. Now we have Will, Kim and Todd. Todd might be able to design a skateboard park, but putting a "rotating platform" in a living room - come on, that is not design. Kim and Will are plain vanilla as far as I can see and no design background in either of their bios. I think giving any one of them a "show" will be a big mistake. I bet HGTV's ratings are going to plummet after the final episode. What a disappointment - I loved last year's show and follow David's Color Splash every week. If you plan to do this again next year, please don't, if you continue in the same vein as this year.

Dee Lee

Posted by Dee Lee – August 27, 2007 1:39 AM

Ok, Ok, 'nuff said about Robbeerrtt...I haven't like any of his designs, and tonight's kitchen just left me cold. I suppose those boxes stuck into the brick work was the most practical solution for those "holes" but they surely didn't add any ambiance to the room. As a total kitchen make-over, this one was a dud. Where was the WOW factor here? Neither Robb nor Kim came out of this competition smelling like roses. The kitchen wasn't designed, it was just put together! And as much as I like Kim's personality, we really haven't seen her design style. Frankly, the individual room she created looked like something a semi-talented teenager could do. Maybe next week when she's out on her own we'll finally see if she can actually design a great design.
The living room: Totally awesome! Great colors, great choices of furniture, but as so many others noted, who really wants a gigantic lazy susan in the middle of their living room? Todd's style of incorporating a sports theme into every thing he has done is just horrible. Isn't this show supposed to be about design, not a showcase for Todd's brand of juvenile athletics? (Just because last year David often took off his shirt, does Todd think he's impressing the public by copying him?) He's obviously the pet of one of the judges, but I think his style of design does not appeal to many of the viewers - it just shows what a complete jerk he is. Oops! If teenagers watch this show, I think they could relate very well to Todd - but I don't think Design Star is tops with the younger crowd.
Then there was Will. His individual room in the second(?) episode was fabulous. His contribution to the bedroom was spectacular. And since he obviously did the lion's share of the work in this episode, I'm so glad he is still in the running. I think he would be a great desing star, and hope he manages to stay to the final two. If so, he'll definitely get my vote. If the judges end up with Todd and Kim as the final duo, I guess I'll pass on the voting, for I don't think either one of them has shown their ability to do an actual design solo. Maybe I'll be surprised next week. Regardless, I'll be sure to watch.

Posted by freakyfrog – August 27, 2007 1:27 AM

Robb is gone! It does not get better that that folks!

I think Will was awesome! He picked the paint colors that they used not only in the living room, but in the kitchen as well.

So, Will was not the best presenter tonight, he also was not the worst I have ever seen, either.

1. Let's remember last year, the judges considered eliminating David Bromstad because he had trouble presenting too.

Good thing they didn't, because after winning and taking some classes, David rocks. We love him and his show. They same will be true for Will once he gets some classes.

2. Todd's presentation was not any better than Will's.

I say this because he had the opposite things wrong with his presentation.

Vern liked that Will explained design elements, but thought he should be more enthusiastic. At the the same time, Vern liked Todd's enthusiasm, but critised that he did not explain any design elements.

It looks like Todd needs to work on his hosting skills just as much as Will does. OK, people?

3. I think the final two should be Kim and Will because they both work well with others, do nice clean designs people want to live in, work hard, and are likeable.

Todd is too Ty Pennington like. Been there, done that, already have someone like that. Personally I hate how Ty pennington acts like a two year old wierdo, just like I hate when Todd does it.

TODD IS TOO HGTV TYPICAL!

PLUS, HGTV NEEDS A BLACK PERSON WHO HAS THEIR OWN SHOW!

Diversity please!!!!!!!!!!

4. I also don't think Todd deserves to win because I feel he cheated when he wrote