Be the first to comment! Enter your comment in the form below.

I love this show no matter who wins! I am sad it's over. I wish there was another season RIGHT NOW! It's such a fun show to watch because I love to see different perspectives from different designers. Also, I imagine what I would do if I was in each of the challenges.

Posted by Wendy – September 20, 2007 12:53 PM

Where was Will and Vern { It's time party} when the picture were being taken? Maybe they had to leave early. Huh? or, maybe I just missed their Picture. Just seems Strange not to see them since they were two of the favorite.

Posted by Bonnie Osteen – September 18, 2007 12:51 PM

Kim, I love her. We shouldn't forget that it isn't just about the skill of design, it is the skill to articulate and pull the viewer into a situation. One thing I saw in Kim AND Will was their ability to support their teams to the best of their ability. It didn't matter if they agreed or disagreed with the design they still put their all into the project.I won't mention any names but one particualr jerk, never bothered to measure anything. He just jumped in and others had to clean up for him.

Will especially, made a dent in my memory. I would have liked to have seen him win. He is what, musician, Billy McCloughlin would call a bow. A bow is a person who will push, nudge and give support to enable a person to go forward, like an arrow. That is what he did for Robb and ,especially Kim. When the judges told her that it would be wise to get rid of the carpet, she was understandably stressed. Will stepped up to the base and said,"Don't worry, I got'cha." These words were magic to me. Will, if you should read this, you are worth your weight in gold x 3. You may not have been the winner, and honestly, I would not have picked you because of your awkward screen presentations. But I believe that you will always find work as a designer and I am sure that we have not seen the last of you on HGTV. I suggest that you work with a screen coach so that you can improve on this kind of thing 'cuz you WILL be back. Where there is a Will, there is a way.

All in all, I wish all of the Design Star contestants the best.

Posted by Mary Titus, Orange California – September 17, 2007 9:16 PM

I think Kim is a an elegant style to her designs. I would be happy to have her design a room in my home.

Howeer, I think Todd should have his own show. It should be called "Home Problem Solving with Todd". Put him in situations that require unique solutions. We all have those problem rooms that have load-bearing wall, a column in the way in the basement, window in the wrong place, doors that preven the use of a closet,... He could come up with new ideas to utilize the space and give the homeowner a new idea of how to use their space. I also feel he would bring in young viewers with his "fun and unusual" design ideas. Can you image him desiging dorm rooms, or college lounges or school playrooms? He would be awesome.

I am confident that both will find their way in the world. But I think that HGTV is missing out on an opportunity to gain viewership from a new demographic of viewers.

Posted by Juliette – September 17, 2007 1:24 PM

I am disappointed in the voting. HGTV is covered with people who can do the same stuff Kim does over and over and over. It is like every show they have. Todd was a chance for another genre where someone could both build and create for those who liked a more extreme style. I think he got ripped off considering people only looked at Kim's last work but didn't realize that Kim didn't finish a challenge and really did nothing but strip flowers in the wedding one. She is very limited.

Posted by TC – September 17, 2007 10:33 AM

so excited, kim is definitely the best designer hands down! I am a gay male and really got tired of seeing todd with his shirt off and half arsed designs. So glad kim won. I love hgtv, but a few things i would change... As for the last design starr. david B. Geesh could his show be any more about him and the way he poses and the outfits he wears? he is such a phony. oh and while im at it. The show with the bald dude...those 2 second camera shots make me dizzy. i have to turn it off. It must be geared to gen x erz. doubt if they are watching.

Posted by jace – September 16, 2007 10:12 PM

THANK YOU AMERICA!! For giving a deserving young lady her chance to show us how to decorate OUR homes. I just hope that HGTV gives the co-host job to Will! I will definitely be watching her new show. God bless you Kim and good luck in the future. Your life will be changed, but I truly believe you can handle it and give us what we have been waiting for - Designs for everyday people. Rene from Latrobe PA

Posted by Rene – September 16, 2007 10:06 PM

The competition is about more than the last room. Will didn't have what it took to carry a show, period. Todd could be trained for the camera, he's just rough. His creativity and actual design skills far outweighed Kim's ability to decorate. It depends (as I said last week) on the type of show that HGTV is planning on putting out there. Kim is extremely boring in front of the camera. Todd is over board (no pun intended to the surfer boy), but you can train that. It's easier to tame a wild horse than make one exciting that just doesn't have the "gait". Kim's pirouette in the Newton's home was hilarious. Let's get real about the overall picture here and not just the last show. Also, remember, it's an all around competition in the end, not just your impression. David B. is not nearl the same person he was last year, due to all the training, coaching, prepping, etc.
Kim's show will not last and it will not be a hit, even though she may win.

Posted by dnels – September 16, 2007 8:49 PM

I didn't see last years Design Star but I love David's show. I was surprised that they call everyone on the show a designer, when clearly they are not all designers, some are decorators. This show proves that just because someone has a degree in Design does not make them more talented than someone who decorates. I did not like either room in the final challenge and for a lot of the same reasons posted on this blog. In the end my vote is for Kim, as I don't think I could handle listening to surfer dude talk for an hour at a time...been there done that, after living in Surf City USA for 5 years. Also, How is Vern "America's Favorite Designer"? If I were to guess, I'd say that Candice Olsen is, not Vern!

Posted by kathy – September 16, 2007 8:49 PM

I have to agree with so many that have wondered how Todd got into the final two. Will would have been my choice as well. He may not have had speeking skills but I didn't have trouble listening to him. Beat the heck out of Rob didn't he? (Rob has talent but could you imagine having to watch him knowing he was ordering someone to 'write that down' behind the scenes?)Kim has had my vote from early on. Even when she and Rob were having words, Kim was controled not controlling. I loved her final room. The colors were great. Is there a spot where I can find that turquo blue she used in the shelf area? It looks like one I have been looking at for a few weeks. Best wishes Kim. Find a way to use Will's talents in your new show.

Posted by Bettysgirl – September 16, 2007 8:47 PM

I think that Todd rocks! He is an awesome carpenter and has such great visions! He would be a great host too if he had a little coaching on what to do. He has much more talent than Kim. I voted for him and I hope he wins! Plus too, he is HOT!!

Posted by Jo – September 16, 2007 8:07 PM

This season certainly turned out to be anti-climactic.I really don't care who wins at this point. I do feel that Kim would be the more practical choice. I'm with all the viewers who suggest a combination of the contestants. I too liked Will, Josh and I also thought Christine was very talented and had a cute personality. Going back to the white room competition says it all. Christine, Will and (I hate to admit but) Robb had the best rooms. Todd's was an art display, not a room! Kim's was just ok. Actually, I thought (Sparkle) Josh's was better!
I suppose I'll turn the show on at the end just to see who won!

Posted by Amy Martin – September 16, 2007 7:21 PM

WELL TONIGHT IS THE NIGHT....for me I just hope Kim wins or I for one will be so disappointed..If everyone who posted here voted for her she has one great chance..I have read alot of the postings an boy let me say some of you really have some strong feelings..Some really mean one's..I don't know if the judges or HGTV will pay attention to any of what we have to say..I sure hope so..I was so upset to read someone actually tore into Will the way they did..He was in no way as bad as they made him out to be..His speaking was no way near what they said an I deeply feel it was wrong.But that is on them..How cruel of them. WORDS DO HURT ALOT..I am just glad I am NOT THEIR JUDGE.. BEST TO YOU KIM..P.S. OH HOW I AGREE WITH THE WAY SOME OF US COULDN'T VOTE IF WE DIDN'T HAVE THE CELL PHONE..JUST ONE VOTE ON THE WEB I FEEL IS WRONG..HOPEFULLY HGTV WILL DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS FOR THE NEXT CONTEST..WE CAN ALL HOPE ANYWAY..

Posted by cat555 – September 16, 2007 3:55 PM

I hope Will gets his own show. He was the best.

Posted by mimosasta – September 16, 2007 2:24 PM

I also hope that Kim wins, because I can't see a season of Todd
jumping around. I also think Will was cheated. I think he was the true winner, and I was not in the least offended by his presentations. I am sooo sick of the "over the top" energy driven hosts. Will was a classy designer and a genuine personality.

Posted by suelle – September 16, 2007 2:08 PM

I just posted a comment, then read a few more notes from other bloggers.

A recurring suggestion from HGTV viewers to the network executives gives me the following idea: feature several of the designers whose shows were cancelled too soon, and make it a "Design Across America" format. Hosts from different geographical areas of the U.S. could showcase "typical" design features in various parts of the country while also creating their own designs to showcase.

This would give a chance for the following types of design to be featured: a Frank Lloyd Wright-type show, featuring the amazing homes in Oak Park, Illinois, and showing how that type of design could be incorporated into a "regular" home; "lake cottage" style from the midwest/Great Lakes area; homes using mountain settings in the Appalachians, Smoky Mts., Rockies, High Sierras, etc.; Florida and Hawaii homes with the "lanai" style; "low country" style in Beaufort, SC, and vicinity; etc., etc., etc.

I personally would love to see regional trends from all across the country, and I'd surely be interested in how HGTV would portray my hometown--Fort Wayne, Indiana--and other midwestern prairie locations.

Are you listening, HGTV? That's a theme you don't have already but that could be very appealing to a wide audience.

Posted by Jean – September 16, 2007 12:24 PM

Along with the rest of you bloggers, I am looking forward to the "reveal" tonight, and I expect that Kim will be named the next Design Star.

I teach high school English, and one thing I haven't seen mentioned is the biggest problem with Todd's presentation skills: He makes his whole presentation sound like one long run-on sentence. His voice never drops at what should be the ends of individual sentences--but only at the end of his very last sentence. This is a problem that I've noticed more and more among English speakers, as though everything they're saying is just one long LIST.

Kim speaks in sentences, as does Will. I totally agree that Will could be given some hosting training to put his verbal skills on a level equal to his wonderful attributes in design, character, and just plain human kindness.

I'd love to see Will as a co-host/co-designer with Kim, just as David Bromstad works so much with that cute painting expert, Danielle. On his show, David makes it clear how many assistants he has working with him--mainly for execution of his designs; however, he and Danielle are really co-designers on that show, and I think Will would really complement Kim's talents. Bring in Sparkle Josh as a third co-designer and you'd have a combination that would have much of America tuning in every week.

I hope the execs at HGTV have been reading what ordinary Americans have been saying about the show and its season two format. If there is a season three, please take the best elements of the first two and make #3 even better. It's obvious that there's a huge talent pool out there, and I--for one--would love to see many different styles showcased.

Kim, best of luck with your new show. I can't wait to see you on the air regularly.

Posted by Jean – September 16, 2007 11:53 AM

Go Kim!! I cannot wait for tonight! Her personality, design talent, and approach to color are fantastic. Todd can build stuff, but Armpit Man is way too over-the-top, his only actual room designs seem to be places that would drive me nuts and have little warmth or comfort.

Yes, I too think Will should have been in the top two, but then it would have been harder to vote! HGTV, PLEASE make sure you get Will, if not his own show, then maybe as a part of an ensemble show? That's talent way too good to waste!

Posted by Sea – September 16, 2007 10:02 AM

I've read all the comments, and I take it most of you guys have just watched the last show. Did you guys not see Todd in the Wayne Newton show? Or for the deserving family show. I didn't see anything about the sufer thing in those shows. Kim is ok but she is very boring. But I do agreed with most of the readers, Will should have been the next host. He was great! But with him out. I have voted for Todd.

Posted by shirley odell – September 16, 2007 9:59 AM

Kin won this challenge it is clear. I wasnt impressed with Todd at all and am not sure how he even made it to the finals. But lets be real, Kims room was better than Todds, but really bad. Last season, I didnt think David had the best of the two, but both of the designs were incredible and this year they fell very short of the expectation last year set. David has turned out to be a joy to watch and I love his show and everything he does, except that 3D myral but that is a matter of taste, the owners loved it. Any way I thought Will's room the week before that he designed for the girl in the wheel chair was better than both Kims and Todds. What was Kim thinking putting beige carpet in for a coal miner? I think they could have done a better job with the money shopping at Levitz for themselves. And Todds room was appealing but not functional, I kept waiting for those kids to get their fingers caught when those toy chests slammed down, I am sure they wouldnt show that on tv. I know it seems as though Kim has the best hosting abilities because Will was a bit awkward and Todd was over the top and how many surf rooms can we watch him do anyway? but I dont see her achieving the same status as David has and therefore I am not voting for anyone and may not watch next season. Who am I kidding, I am addicted to HGTV!

Posted by Stacey – September 16, 2007 5:48 AM

I just read all of the comments. I can't believe there are so many people for Will. He didn't have one good room in the competition. That room for the girl in the wheelchair was hidious. What were those pictures he hung on the walls or those vases with sticks coming out. Those are not decorations for a young teenager. Think! who you are designing for. A girl with more courage than Will has designing sense. That room was for a twenty or thirty something with no job still living at home with Mom and Dad.

Posted by Lynda – September 15, 2007 11:13 PM

I watched all of this season's shows today and I have to say the most boring were the judges. From listening to their comments, I wouldn't let anyone of them design a room for me. The designers that were picked for this competition were terrible. I wouldn't watch any show that any one of them would host. Will was like "Igore does design" (I wouldn't hire someone coming into my house acting like he just came off the mountain. No presentation and no designing thoughts). Rob was annoying just for the sake of being annoying. (Every reality show has one). Josh was your typical designer stereotype (some good thoughts but too much over the top for the people that watch HGTV and we don't need another one on TV), Kim's designs were awful, the same color palette (She should do a craft show. I can see her pasting sea shells on a picture frame) and Todd should stick to his landscaping capability, he is definitely not a designer (although the room for the family show was on the money. I could see him doing an outside landscaping show). All the rest of the contestants do not even credit mentioning.
The final competition show. OMG! not one room deserved to be called upscale hotel design.
Kim's colors were so unpleasant. Nothing I would want is to pay a couple of hundred dollars a day for a room and have to walk on an ugly painted cement floor and have roofing pieces hanging from a chain to seperate two rooms. Every thing in that room was hard on the eye and not soothing at all. It could be the bridal suite for someone in recovery at Motel 6 (if they even have one.)
Todd had a good idea but blew it with the blue and all that funky art detail. When you are out in the sun and on the beach all day, the last thing you want to see is blue, blue, blue, especially harsh shades of blue. His design was definetly not upscale, more like a cheap room off the highway at Disney World. If I was traveling with children and that was their room, it might work. (with a little more forethought) Otherwise that suite was too juvenile to be considered upscale.
As someone had mentioned, why didn't either one of them use colors to complement the rug they had. That is the test of a good designer. To know what you can change and to use what you can not change to your best advantage. Neither took into consideration who would be staying at an upscale hotel or what they would expect when they arrived to their room.
I hope next season is better and new judges are hired. I felt like I just spent a couple of hours watching a train wreck.

Posted by lll – September 15, 2007 10:59 PM

I just watched the reruns of all the shows today. I loved Kims room and voted for her this week. However, after looking at the reruns, I was somewhat angry about the judges choices throughout the series and dont understand their definitions of "Designer" and "decorator". When doing Wayne Newtons home, Todd thought up the revolving lazy susan and spent all his time building that. However, Will did all the shopping (tables, rugs, chairs, curtains), did all the painting, made the drapes and cornices. They judges were wowwed by Todd and not impressed by Will (because he is a decorator?????). Think Will should have been in the final. Todd and his bright blue paint should have been sent home. By the judges definition, Vern is a decorator and the two women are viewers.

Posted by suzy34 – September 15, 2007 10:48 PM

It just goes to show that some people just have an innate sense of style. Kim - We love you. We can't wait to see your new show on HGTV!!!

Posted by Deb & Shel – September 15, 2007 10:06 PM

I was truely disappointed in Todd, I thought this was going to be a great competition but he missed the boat.The way he made it blue to compliment the view achieved the opposite it competed with the view instead of enhancing it.Kim blew him away with sophistacation and class.Also moving the bed to where he did was a mistake,and I wouldn't want a bathroom in my eating area either. Todds finish work on his carpentry I thought was not professionally done whereby Kims headboard was awsome.Todd you use your strong points and hire out what are your weak points.

Posted by Barbara Cogan – September 15, 2007 9:19 PM

I'm soooo disapointed that I couldn't vote. I don't have a chance to watch cable that often, so only saw the show tonight. However, if given the chance I would vote for Kim. I liked both rooms, but as this is a hotel suite her room would have more appeal to a wide variety of people. I hope she wins!

I would also like to add my two cents about voting. Please, forget voting via text messaging! Not everyone who has a cell phone has this feature (or wants it). Also, it is very unfair to allow 5 votes a day for cell phones and only 1 a day via computer. If texting is so important, how about this: a person can vote once a day via computer, cell phone or regular phone. This would allow many more viewers to vote.

Posted by Lori – September 15, 2007 9:00 PM

i realy can't wait for you to find a position for will on hgtv he has great talent.it was great to see him when you brought him back to help kim. he proved just how good he is especially with that concret floor. he also has the ability to work with just about any. if a self taught designer could get this far on your show that says a lot about his talent

Posted by missouri – September 15, 2007 7:32 PM

Posted by Corey – September 10, 2007 1:37 AM "I must say that I am shocked that anyone liked Will, since he has a speach problem and his designs where horrible. I was glad to see him go, then upset when they brought him back. I had to turn the TV on mute when he tried to talk."

*******

Before you criticize someone's speech, perhaps you should learn how to spell...

Posted by Glen Bradley – September 15, 2007 7:04 PM

I started watching the competition a little bit late, I'm not sure if the two deserving designers are in the finals. Although I am certain Kim will win the competition. Todd is almost the same age as me, his designs are a little too youthful and whimsical for me. Most people want practical and modern designs. I would be frighten if he would be designing a room for me, because his designs are just too over the top for my taste. He definitely is amusing and captivating to watch with his boyish good looks, but without real talent in my opinion. I think he has that personality appeal to hold his own tv show. I feel so energize after seeing him jump literally off the walls. I wonder if he ever suffered with ADHD? just a thought. I wish I had watched the shows earlier so I could have voted. bummer!! Must have more of KIM designs and less antics!!

Posted by LaShawn – September 15, 2007 5:45 PM

This is another comment for Corey(9-10-07 @ 1:37am) Will may have had a "speech" impediment but you have a spelling impediment with the word "speAch". I have to agree with Emma on how small your mind must be to call people down for their "real life" problems. Looks and speech does NOT make a designer! Enjoy the designs from the REAL PEOPLE because its evident your seven figure clients don't realize what the real YOU is like. GO KIM! I loved your room! Sorry Todd but another blue room and your shirt off, I may have to vom.

Posted by Agnes – September 15, 2007 5:17 PM

I sure you are all as excited as I am to see tomorrow nights show..I hope Kim wins..I see most of the blogs are for her an I am so glad..Todd just doesn't have it, he is too cought up with himself..I sure wouldn't want to have him do my room..On other design shows I see certain designers who are just SO FAR OUT that no one would want their rooms..I just can't see him as the winner..YES, I did see he has a wife,someone else mentioned that an that he wasn't all that excited to see her as he was to see his brother..I wonder why?? I felt bad for her..Now Kim was so very happy to see her hubby,that is natural..She has so much love for other's..Alot like Will, they are so much alike an work so well together..He is just so precious..I read he is really spiritual an that does make a huge differance,you can see why he cares about others first..I do feel alot of us will be so upset if Todd wins this tomorrow..I know I will cry an then get really mad..I will feel the contest was unfair for sure then..I do think it has been alot so far anyway..Someone said they need to have differant judges once in awhile cause I saw where Vern,as much as I love his work, I think he is partial to Todd an I don't like that..I hope I AM WRONG..His new show is going to be good an will bless alot of people..I really wonder how these people get picked to have their homes done..oh well...see you all tomorrow night I'm sure..

Posted by Cat555 – September 15, 2007 3:17 PM

I didn't read the whole blog, so someone may have already commented that Todd's room was somewhat reminiscent of the old "Trading Spaces".
I could not for the life of me see where he could have spent the 10 grand. It was and certainly looked like a plywood nightmare! Kim's room on the other hand was great.. Hope she wins.

Posted by Betsy – September 15, 2007 3:13 PM

I personally voted for Kim. I felt her room was more suited for relaxing and for the everyday person on vacation. Todd's room was very juvenile and really not a place that I would like to stay. Also, I love David from the first season, and I feel that if Todd wins we will be getting a remixed version of David. Season two needs a change not more of the same. Surf's up dude!

Posted by GA – September 15, 2007 1:12 PM

I'm disappointed in the voting procedure this year. Is HGTV in the business of selling Cell phones? Anyone who didn't have one ( and yes, not everyone does) would not have the same oppurtunity to vote. Voting procedures should be open to the general public and not target a special group. I hope they stop that or make it available to land phones with an 800 number.

Posted by Andrea Lorton – September 15, 2007 9:24 AM

Its very clear to see almost everyone has pointed out, how we loved the combition on Will , Josh and Kim!!! Now please give us a show that they are all working together on and everyone will be happy! And it shows the people are not happy with how the DS show was run this year. Or happy with most the judges. Its also clear what most everyone feels about, Todd = harsh = unpleasant in action or effect,grating; strident,unrefined; crude; raw. Where do they pick the contestants? That Lisa was just way out there!(can we say freaky? lol) Seriously why not invite some student designers? Fresh new with a basic training and new ideas! Still staying open to people that have real talent and come from different back grounds like home makers, hair dressers or whatever. But please make sure they aren't just freaks and weirdos that think they can make art from paper fans!

REMEBER WE WANT WILL , JOSH AND KIM! TOGETHER!

Posted by Gigisdiamonds – September 15, 2007 4:57 AM

OMG..I just really want Todd to put a freaking shirt on. It's obvious that he is trying to grab all the female viewers but...really come on. I'm convinced that if he does win his show is gonna start like this: Hey guys its Todd here..your totally chill design guy and this is shirtless design. I wanna vom.

Posted by Patrick – September 15, 2007 4:30 AM

Kim should be the winner, hands down. She carried it off. I guess some people have not seen stained concrete with rugs on top. It is popular and can be designed in very good taste with carpet ajoining and with designs put on also.

Posted by pseale – September 15, 2007 2:21 AM

THIS IS FOR COREY (9/10/07 0137 AM). HGTV IS DESIGNED FOR "REAL PEOPLE". YOU DON'T QUALIFY. YOU MISS THE MARK. WHY ARE YOU WATCHING HGTV IF YOU DESIGN FOR SEVEN FIGURE CLIENTEL?! NEED IDEAS?! I'M SURE YOU HAVE BORROWED A FEW. TO NEGATE A PERSON FOR HIS SPEECH IMPEDIMENT OR SOMEONE FOR THEIR LOOKS SHOWS HOW SMALL YOUR MIND IS. DOES WATCHING HGTV SHOW YOUR LACK OF CREATIVITY A TRUE DESIGNER POSESSES? THE NEXT TIME YOU ARE TURNED DOWN BY A PROSPECTIVE SEVEN FIGURE CLIENT, CONSIDER HE/SHE MAY HAVE SEEN HOW SMALL YOUR MIND IS. BEST OF LUCK TO YOU WHEN NEED A TIP FROM "REAL PEOPLE". CONTINUE TO WORK OUT OF YOUR BOX.
POSTED BY EMMA

Posted by Emma – September 15, 2007 1:45 AM

Ive got to tell ya, I think Kim will win. I liked her room. How can anyone resist that headboard? I for one, think Todds room looked a little cheap with that blue paint. Soon, DS3!!!

Posted by DenDenise – September 15, 2007 12:14 AM

As far as design goes, the far better designer was Will. Each and every room he was involved with had style and class. I wish someone had taken the time to help him with presentation, because the show would have certainly ended much differently. I also feel that I would much prefer watching a weekly show of an ordinary talking great designer then the lackluster or just plain unadaptable design of the two glib finalists.

Posted by Linda – September 15, 2007 12:12 AM

You have to choose Kim. Todd is an artist but not a design star. Kim has grown through the entire show to become a much better designer. Todd hasn't changed or grown. I do have to agree with other bloggers that this series was much less competitive than the first. I hope the producer raisies the bar if there is another series. I would prefer to see more individual challenges and less "group" challenges. What was that wedding crap about anyway?!

Posted by txgal`1 – September 14, 2007 10:41 PM

Kim's room? BOOOOOOOORING. Does she know any other colour palette than browns? I am so over DS2. If Kim wins - I will never watch her show. BTW, she's not that great a host. Todd's room was very good. One question. Who is "Vern Yip"? The only other place I ever saw him was DS1. So how did he get the gig? Particulalrly since he so lacks imagination. Anyway, this whole season did not pan out at all.

Posted by Sonia – September 14, 2007 10:19 PM

I can't wait to find out who the winner is! I hope it's Kim. I like Todd, but I don't want to look at him jumping around every week. I think that Kim is adorable and classy, and she has great taste. My vote is for Kim!

I also think that Will got cheated. When he came back to help Kim, he proved just how good he is at what he does. He might not have a natural gift for gab, but I really wished they would've worked with him on that. His kind, gentle nature, his ability to work with just about anyone, no matter the style - I think he's a gem, and he deserved to be one of the last two left with Kim.

Design Star, I love your show, but I think you blew it when you chose Todd over Will. I'd like to see Will come back in a future show or shows to work with Kim again. I think they make a great team.

Also, Rob should've been disqualified for his awful behavior. And that wedding with the giant poker chips... it was just awful. Even when he came back, he was still obnoxious to Kim.

I also really liked Josh Sparkle. I'd really love to see him again.

Posted by Davetta – September 14, 2007 9:27 PM

When all is said and done, I think Kim should be the next design star. Todd is fun and energetic, but a good designer fulfills what the clients want not, just the same cookie cutter design pushed into every environment (surfer dude penthouse suite!). Kim listens better to what is being requested and that goes for a long way. As for her color choices, I think they were great, last year I lived in one of the newly designed Marriott for a few months and she actually caught the emerging trend in higher scaled hotel color trends. I would watch her show - I would have her in my home. She does have growing to do, but it's not growing that she can't do as she does a show (like how to use power tools and finishing touches). She has a good foundation; she also has the "eye" that Todd does not have and I think she can appeal to a greater audience range.

Even so, great job Todd, you most definitely were a dark horse and did a great job at what you do. However, I question that he could keep the audience coming back for more. But who knows? - he may be a dark horse there too!!

Like so many of my fellow bloggers I think that Will and Sparkle Josh were overlooked and canceling their shows was a bit premature on the judges' part. One of the things that David shared in his predebut show was the polishing he was given to prepare for his show -given the same opportunity Will would do as well if not better. If as a self taught designer the guy is this good, how about getting around good experienced professionals in the field to help him shine?

This year's show did indeed lack some of the integrity of last season's. I was disappointed from the start by the slim pickings of truly talented people. I was greatly disappointed that non team playing attitudes (Neereja and Robb) were played up like they were great assets. Designing is a team effort no matter how brilliant the designer and no one wants to work for or with rude, inconsiderate people no matter how talented. The judges, I believe, were hasty in eliminating Lisa. I did not care for her design choice, but her thought, approach and the fact that she executed her design should have outweighed Neereja's incomplete work and nonchalant attitude about it. I am an admirer of Vern Yip as a leader in his field however, I thought he was unprofessional, abused his professional influence and was downright rude to her in his comments. Unlike last season's Ramona, who just did not cut it, Lisa has far more potential and room for growth - she was only different not wierd.

Ideas for DS3:

I agree - fresh judges. I know design uses mainly the same concept whether clothes or living space, but I think that being judged by what will become peer, other HGTV hosts, may be a little more realistic, HGTV is not about fashion/clothes. Also because other hosts are coming from their own styles and preferences that should break up that little Vern Yip override that happened far too often this season. Love you man, you are great at what you do, but you aren't always right.

What is the criteria for entry? Shouldn't contestants be able to identify period/styles and their pertinent colors and materials? - Remember how collectively either group couldn't really nail Tuscany? How nobody bothered to measure the countertop, twice nonetheless, to be sure they bought enough tiles? Punch list anyone? - how did the fridge get left out the kitchen?? Also, there was a heavy leaning towards modern, contemporary which contributed to some boredom in the designs. Was that intentional or ignorance? I'm not saying everyone has to be PhD Design educated, but the basics can't be overlooked.

A smaller group is more interesting, manageable and gives contestants a better opportunity to show who they are. By the time you figured a contestant out they were gone.

Limited group projects, unless the goal is next design group. Next design star kind of says one person shining. While group projects are good to see the dynamics and interaction- they also promoted alot of cut throat, throw my fellow contestant in front of the train to save my butt drama in this season's group. Not to mention a few people got to hide and others got stifled - adding to the drama and viewer frustration.

So Sunday night we will see what America says and then like all good 21st century Americans we'll be chomping at the bit waiting for Season 3 - so we can all blog again and have a platform for our own two cents!!!!

All the best to you Kim and Todd!!! It's not always about being the star- it's about getting and making use of the best opportunities of your life.

Posted by ap – September 14, 2007 5:38 PM

I totally agree with Eva who posted on 9/13 about the judges. They should mix it up a bit; bringing in either a whole new crew for DS3 or a guest judge or two. I can see where they'd want the entire panel to remain the same, so they can get to know the designers and see their growth during the season, but Eva's right, we are not all Park Avenue denizens out here, a lot of us live in plain old middle America - it ain't Park Avenue, but we love it, and we want our spaces to be beautiful too.
I too, would like to see less double elimination and while it's important to be able to lead a team, and the judges need to know that, more individual competition would be good.
Will, don't know if you're reading this or not, I hope so, but I want you to know my husband and I agree that you showed the best of the best in overall character, integrity, humility, and joy. We hope you go far, and with those traits so strong in you, we know you will. "Sparkle", you too delivered a great deal of class in your attitudes toward your fellow designers and the judges. You're awesome.
Kim, I can't wait to watch your new show.

Posted by lotr – September 14, 2007 4:27 PM

Kim should win as she produced a splendid looking suite (even with the concrete flooring) while Todd again went off the "deep end" with his blue lagoon of a suite. Only my grandson , 4 years old, would enjoy that room.

We should have kept sparkle josh instead of bully Robb, and then we made have had a better contest. Season One had the real talent.

Posted by carole – September 14, 2007 1:46 PM

I am still bothered that Todd won the .99 cent store challenge. He got all kinds of praise from the judges for "designing outside the box." The reality is that if he had tried to seriously design a room that his room would have probably been the very worst. He knew that he could not compete with the other designers on an even playing field. It was further insulting when he stated that he thought all the other designers were basically doing the same thing (i.e. buying a lot of stuff and arranging it in the room). Guess what, Todd?! THAT'S INTERIOR DESIGN. Most every normal household has a couch, coffee table, and books shelves. It is what a talented designer is able to do with those basics that makes great design. Todd should have never made it to the final challenge.

Posted by Simonesa – September 14, 2007 1:46 PM

Gracefully said JANE.....I too look forward to seeing my champions on Sunday night!

Posted by Pret07 – September 14, 2007 11:28 AM

I have read all the comments about how great Kim's room was.....Am I the only one that saw the floor??? Stained up concrete with a shine. If I payed for a room and walked in to see that mess on the floor, I would have asked for my money back. Todd's room was loud, but it was finished. I find it hard to vote for either one of them. I don't believe I would pay to have either one of them design a room in my house. Maybe HGTV should have used the money that they spent on this season and gave it to David from Season #1, so he could have two shows(Color Splash)a week. I really didn't want to vote for either one. I finally decided to vote for Todd, but only because his room was finished, not becasue he is a great design star. I watched all of last years Design Star and all of this years shows and I felt that this years show lacked talent. Who ever wins will need design lessons before I will watch one of their shows.

Posted by Carolina Girl – September 14, 2007 10:57 AM

Just have to say it again, I think Will was quality and class. You are a winner in our eyes! All the best to you and don't change a thing about yourself.

Posted by Brenda – September 14, 2007 10:31 AM

I think Sparkle Josh & Will would make a great design team for TV. I did not vote because I don't think either room was exceptional. But we really didn't get to know the design personalities of the contestants this year because there was not enough individual challenges. I feel like you sold out HGTV - hype for content. And I agree with another blogger that Lisa LaPorta would make an excellent judge.

Posted by Alisa – September 14, 2007 9:48 AM

A few more thoughts. The more I think of it, neither room ended up being a luxury suite. If you like at really good designs (Candace Olsen's, the designers on Designer's challenge), you notice that paint color takes a back seat to the overall design. The more low budget the kind of work - Design on a Dime, Design Cents..etc, the more paint color rises to the top. Think about what you would expect in a luxury hotel..muted, probably mostly neutral colors, CLEAN everything..all the amenities. You would want a beautifully hidden TV, a nice place to sit, a beautiful bathroom, luxury duvets..nothing flashy. Just comfort.Neither of these rooms, (though I voted for Kim's room over Todd's "Sponge-Bob goes surfing" theme) would be anything I would expext in a luxury hotel. Kim's clean flooring and large comfy neutral sectional, yes..the rest, no.

A second, if random thought - I had to laugh at the point in Todd's presentation when he pointed out the fact that the base of the TV lined up perfectly with the horizon. This would be important..why? I don't imagine that anyone who was looking at the spectacular horizon, would be sitting back saying.. "This is sooo lovely honey, Look how the TV cabinet and the sunset are all on one line. Don't you love it?" Ah well, maybe it's just me...I have never dreamed of a view where the entertainment center and the horizon were all lined up. Call me strange.

Posted by stormskyblue – September 14, 2007 4:37 AM

I really enjoyed watching my first Design Star Reality T.V. Show. I especially enjoyed the designs of Robb, Todd and Christina. I learned alot from all of the episodes and I watched every single one and placed my vote. However, I still believe that Robb should have gone all the way. Maybe HGTV can bring Robb back for a new show that I would like to suggest because I have the next challenge for Design Star! We desperately need HGTV's help! My fiance has been building a house in the hills of Arizona on the weekends for a very long time. I was hoping we could have a normal life in a real home sometime around Thanksgiving and have a normal kitchen to cook Thanksgiving dinner in or a place to set up a Christmas tree. Plus, my fiance hasn't seen his daughter in years and recently found out he's a grandpa and is going to be a grandpa again in October. I want to write his daughter and invite them for Thanksgiving or Christmas so they can be reunited again but there's no room at the inn... not even for the two of us yet. We've been living in an itty bitty camper with 4 dogs and it gets unbearable at times. To make matters worse, my fiance had a bad fall this week and now he needs time to heal so that's going to delay the building process further. I know he's tired of being tired but he doesn't want to ask anyone for help because of the cost and the fact that he believes people don't want to help. I want to prove him wrong. I'm different. I believe that if you ask it will be answered. So I'm secretly asking HGTV for help. The house (on 5 acres of desert) will be approx. 1700 sq. ft. when it's completed...3 bdrms/2bath and one of the bedrooms needs to be my office so I can start working again. I haven't worked in six months and it's almost time for him to retire. The stress is building. Most of the plumbing is complete and 3/4 of the framing and roof are complete. It's definitely becoming a challenge now and quite overwhelming. Plus the weather is going to change real soon where we live and this camper is wearing down. Please, can you help us? Thank you for your time and consideration.

Posted by abbey – September 14, 2007 12:57 AM

This was my first season to watch Design Star and I really enjoyed it. I think Todd and Kim are great designers each with their own style. I personally prefer Kim's style but that is just me. I thought Todd had great out of the box ideas that were awesome. I don't think he did as well at hosting as Kim did however. The Hawaiian suites...Kims was warm and comforting, Todds vibrant...designed for a surfer dude I guess. I really liked Will and his honest and caring personality not to mention his wonderful designs. He did lack at hosting however...too bad! But that does not matter because his show was cancelled! Bummer! Robb....RUDE!! But I do have to say at least he had a good and helpful attitude when he came back. Might as well make his final impression on the show as a good one. I cant wait until Sunday! Go Kim!

Posted by lisamr – September 14, 2007 12:35 AM

Words of advice to Design Star 3 contestants:
1. Get to know the judges and what they like.
2. Lay low for the first 3 or 4 challenges and do not draw attention to yourself unless it is to point out your good looks.
3. Be nice and if you don't know what your doing, think to yourself, "what would the judges want to see?"
4. After some talented designers who did draw attention to themselves make mistakes and get eliminated, start practicing your speaking skills. This is when sounding good and dressing well on tv really pays off.

Posted by Jane – September 13, 2007 11:41 PM

I have watched season 1 and now Season 2-I do agree that season 1 was better. David ran off with that show totally. I would have liked to see more from each of them one-on-one. I'm so glad that Robb was offed. I would not have watched anything with him. Even when they brough them back and he was working with her he tired to be the boss, like it was his room!! I think he has a problen with working w/women. Then when he went over to see her room and went back and told Todd he was still showing his true color's. I loved Kim room the colors where great I could be totally comfortable in that room. Todd's room well that reminded me to much of the first room he did. BLUE_BLUE_BLUE I could not stay in the room, blue is a nice color but blue can also be a drepressing color if not use well.....I hope Kim wins the show. I think with a little coaching and advise she will be great. Now one show that I would love to see them do is put something tomogether with Will & Josh! That will be a blast to watch and I think they would make a great team...GOOD LUCK KIM and I did vote for you!

Posted by mslilangel – September 13, 2007 11:23 PM

I don't watch alot of TV, but I LOVE this show.
Todd's all about Todd. Pretty one-dimensional, and his teenage behavior just gets annoying after awhile. His approach to design is narcissistic. Kim is poised and warm, and her designs are elegant and yet so inviting.
Todd's demographic is 25 and under. Kim's style and personality outshines the loudest woo-hoo, yeah, dude, or whatever Todd throws out to show off.

Posted by ccook1959 – September 13, 2007 11:08 PM

HGTV MESSED UP!! Will was the best choice and I will most likely not watch a show by either Kim or Todd. Why couldn't they have a write in vote. Please bring Will back!!

Posted by Tesa – September 13, 2007 10:52 PM

My fellow bloggers shared some great observations. I'm glad to hear that others agree with me that some of the best designers were eliminated far too soon and for some pretty bogus reasons. Additionally, one or two contestants stayed far longer than they should have and made watching the show extremely unpleasant. I think we can agree that there were many mistakes made this season that we would not like to see repeated. The double elimination was poorly thought out and left us wondering what might have been.

In spite of my disappointment in season two, I hope there will be a season three Design Star Challenge. If HGTV wants to stick with a 6-8 week format, they would be better off starting with fewer contestants and giving them more individual opportunity to show what they can do.

Viewers will always have their personal favorites and will grieve when their shows are cancelled but at least their champions will have had their moment in the sun. I'm looking forward to seeing some of my champions again this Sunday.

Posted by Jane – September 13, 2007 10:43 PM

I know I blogged earlier in the week, but I really need to say something else about HGTV, Design Star, etc. Not all of us can persue our dreams due to our life situations,or can buy the things that we would love to have to make our homes beautiful, or even live in a home like we would have chosen if things had been different but you know what...Design Star and simular shows on HGTV really brightens my day and the lives of others like me...so I try to make my home more joyful and pleasant and just pretend that I could become a designer and that when I work with what I have maybe it's creativity coming out and not a pitiful effort. Any way I'm probably not the only viewer who is helped by the dreams these shows create...thanks to all involved. Keep up the good work.

Posted by Becky White – September 13, 2007 10:28 PM

Well I can say that I thought Kim did a better job than Todd but people keep calling her work an upscale suite. It was NOT an upscale suite. The judges might have thought so, but then I would ask the question, "What hotel have they been staying at?"

Kim's work was certainly better than Todd's - no doubt about that. But, it was certainly not worthy of being called upscale. It could probably be located in a 3 star hotel at best. And that's pushing it.

Upscale hotel suites are in Marriott, Hyatt, Four Seasons, and the likes. If Kim went to any of those chains and proposed that she put her design in their rooms, they would politely decline because her work is not up to that level.
She could probably sell it to the Comfort Inn line though.

She tried hard, I know she did. Does she deserve to be the next DS? Only if it's a show something along the lines of what someone else suggested - Design 101. She would do well with teaching the fundamentals of design (with some help or if she studied design a bit more). Some of her furniture placement was off but hey, she was under pressure. I'll cut her some slack on that.

Posted by sharkeye1 – September 13, 2007 6:51 PM

There is no contest between kim and todd... If you like watching someone jump on tables pretending there surf boards, calling furniture sweet, and showing his chest at every opportunity, then Todd is the guy for you.

As for myself, well I prefer Kim as she is classy, smart, fun to watch, extremely good at hosting, with a good eye for design. She is a natural in more ways than one....

Can't wait to see her on HGTV!!!

Posted by caladora – September 13, 2007 6:05 PM

Just one viewer's opinion, I enjoyed DS#1 much better. The changes in DS#2 were not an improvement. I was really looking forward to #2. I cannot tell you how disappointed I was. I missed getting to know the contestants and the comments from the judges. Two eliminations per show was too much and why you even had Robb on is beyond me. I almost stopped watching because it was so unpleasant with him on the show. TOOOOOOO much drama with that guy. Also too many group projects. The whole series seemed rushed and incomplete. Quite honestly, neither Todd or Kim came anywhere near DS#1 designers. I probably would not watch a show from either one of them. Now David...he is a true Design Star and set the bar very high.
Sincerely, A faithful HGTV viewer

Posted by Maxine – September 13, 2007 5:26 PM

I've read most of the comments regarding the contestants and have some comments of my own. Kim has grown during the process, learning quite a bit but I found her designs were more dependant on premade products. In the final episode the intention of the design might have been upscale but I disagreed with the judges. I found her room to be have an unfinished look to it. Sanding the edges and even staining with a clear poly would have given it a more finished look. Todd's design was definately blue but he took the color scheme from the outdoor elements of the beach and water. I would agree with his possibly overuse of blue but I remember his design for the family. The design was in warm colors and the style was executed for the family and not his personal taste. Something I found appealing as a designer who cares about the client and the clients needs. Will appeals to most everyroom. His designs are clean and functional. There is a serenity to his spaces. He also allows for the client to add in expressions of themselves without comprimising the design.

Posted by Carol – September 13, 2007 2:47 PM

Congrats to both finalists.It's been a long journey to this point.I firmly believe that Will should have been one of these two.The judge's comments about his presentation skills seem like a" cop out" to me. If memory serves me correctly,in 2006, the very same judges spoke about David's presentation skills. He was by no means the best presenter but his design skills were far superior to the others and this was the predominant factor in him winning. There are professionals who coach presenters. Nevertheless, talent like Will's can never be suppressed and I expect to see him on HGTV in the near future....if they are wise. Anyway, Kim's got my vote.

Posted by Islandbeauty – September 13, 2007 1:22 PM

I guess I'm in the minority... I didn't think either room was great. They both missed an important element in their designs -- the view! Why design rooms to compete with the most outstanding element of the space? Although Todd acknowledged the view, even changing his space plan to take advantage of it, his strong color competed with it. And Kim didn't even think about it. Her room was nice, but nothing special. I would have much preferred to see someone do something clean, elegant and subdued so that when you walked into the room, you were totally drawn into the view. I kept thinking, "I wonder what Will, Sparkle Josh and Christina would have done with this space." I'm with all of you who love Will. His designs were fresh and clean without being "out there." So where does that leave me... Well, other faithful viewers, it's up to you. I didn't vote for either. I like Todd's originality and I think he'd do a spectacular job on a kind of "Extreme, Extreme Home" show. And Kim??? Well, she's ok, but to me, her style isn't revolutionary. This was my first time watching the show, and to be honest, I wasn't impressed. Too many good designers were ousted before we really got to see what they were about. Good luck to Todd and Kim... and to Will, Sparkle Josh and Christina. You did the South proud! :)

Posted by GM – September 13, 2007 1:06 PM

I voted for KIm as much as possible. I thought her room of course was so much better, than Todd's.
I tried to use my cell phone several times to vote for Kim and for some reason there was something wrong with the lines, not busy, I don't know what was going on, but feel it was unfair. I do hope she wins. I would love for her to decorate my home.
When she was in W. Va. I thought she did great, due to the fact that so gave this family alot of what they so desperately needed. The weather did not coorporate with her and that was not her fault, as well as being so far out in a rual area. I thought she did great. Maybe the furniture could have been aranged alittle different, but that is a simple fix. After all when you consider the time frame, weather, and rual area, she did a great job.
I also loved what Will did for Brittney.
As for Todd, he is the one I feel does not listen, how many people asked for the surf theme?
if not all, most of his colors were based off that theme. I would be afraid for him to decorate my home.
Anyway GOOD LUCK Kim!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Good Job.

Posted by zina – September 13, 2007 12:21 PM

I loved Sparkle Josh too! What a positive outlook. Josh brought that 'sparkle' to the show.

Will showed a LOT of class in his exit speech. I was so touched that he commented how much the client that he designed for had touched his heart! And I was glad to see Will be a part of the Hawaii trip. I loved the way he said to Kim "I've got you covered" (or similar words).

I voted for Kim. I like her positive attitude and her sophisticated style choices. Kim has a soft but upbeat way about her that will be fun to watch.

From what others have said on this blog, it looks like Kim will win. I liked Todd too, he added fun and light heartedness to the show. His family is lucky to have his positive attitude and I'd love to see his landscape designs! How about a Landscape designers challenge show - and bring Todd back for that :)

Posted by Nancy – September 13, 2007 11:50 AM

I've watched this show since about the middle of the series, and I watch HGTV regularly. Over the years, the network has changed from an emphasis on home improvement to decorating. Looking at the votes, it looks like we'll be seeijng more of the same, except with a less interesting host. If they wanted to go with another decorating show, at least Josh Sparkle would have been unusual and funny. I would prefer a new show where the host can actually DO something, rather than another community-theater style plastic presenter. Todd's show would be inventive, Will's would have been practical and genuine, even obnoxious Robb would have created some sparks. Kim is and will be BORING. Too bad.

Posted by mcstowy – September 13, 2007 11:13 AM

Kim or Todd- who cares? Kim is kind of boring and Todd is one-dimensional. The only personality with a broad range of interesting designs was Robb. Once Robb was gone, I realized I just don't care who wins this contest because I'll never want to watch their show!

Posted by revy – September 13, 2007 10:36 AM

Did HGTV ever consider a PREQUEL special to the Design Star Season? I was just wondering how the season would go if AMERICA chose the Design Star Hopefuls....maybe a two-hour special where we could see your top contenders and vote for ourselves who we would like to see in the upcoming season.
It would really be great to be able to see at least ONE individual challenge and hosting opportunity for each contender before they are sent "packing".
The judges comments? I really don't care WHO the judges are...as long as I can at least see some kind of consistency in their comments - sometimes I am not sure what they consider good design...one week space planning is criticized, the next week it is over-looked. Maybe the best tips were lost in the editing of the program.It gets to be confusing for a person like me who is looking for guidelines in understanding our own living spaces.

Posted by Pret07 – September 13, 2007 9:33 AM

Sparkle Josh didn't win because his design lacked. So, alll the Josh fans out there, you need to move on. He's not the Design Star!

Posted by Theresa – September 13, 2007 8:37 AM

OK, I will move out of the country if Will doesn't continue to appear regularly on HGTV in some suitable format...How about something like "Designing for Smiles" where he would have the opportunity to recreate the wonderful sense of joy that he gave that disabled girl...what a great way for HGTV to give back to the community by dedicating a designer and a show to improving the lives of those with physical and/or mental impairments...As a psychologist who worked with these very special people for many years I know the tremendous good that could be done by improving residential and social facilities for people with impairments, young and old...or, at the least, how about dedicating a season three episode to that, with Will overseeing the candidates and participating in the judging of their work? Smiles all around!!!

Posted by PsychHal – September 13, 2007 5:14 AM

I hope HGTV reads evry one of these comments and takes them to heart.

I agree with everyone who feels that next season calls for new judges and better planning of challenges. The judges have been "predictable" --the charge they levied against Will when they voted him off the show. How about replacing them with designers of various styles, and perhaps having a different panel (or perhaps a "guest judge" or two) each show. It would be great to see Candice Olsen, Christopher Lowell, Kenneth Brown, Lisa LaPorta, Debbie Travis, the gang from "Design on a Dime", and Jane (don't remember her last name) from "Get Color". The designers wouldn't be able to design for a particular judge as they did this season, but would have to actually design for a variety of tastes. Anyway--why are Martha and Cynthia judging? The magazines they work for cater to New York Fifth Avenue and Central Park tastes--that may be great, but most of America does not live there! Duh! Besides--theirs is not the only tasteful style around. Wake up.

As far as the format goes, the season should be longer than it was this year with no double eliminations, more individual work, and no eliminations for the first few shows--give everyone a chance to show what they really have. Personally I see no need for more than 2 group projects. I don't really understand how the judges can pick one member of a group to eliminate anyway--how can they possibly know who deserves to go and who deserves to stay? I find the explanation that someone is a great shopper, but not enough of anything else to be a weak excuse for elimination, especially if that person was chosen by the group or group leader to do the shopping because they trusted their expertise and taste!

My 2 cents worth. Design Star is the only reality tv show that I watch, and I do enjoy it, but it could be so much better. If HGTV does nothing more than change judges it will be agreat improvement. Vern can stay, but the girls have to go. Besides, the 3 of them together seem to have one sense of style and taste among them--time to mix it up!

Posted by Eva – September 13, 2007 2:38 AM

Clearly Kim had the better room in this last challenge. And while both of them were "functionality" challenged, Kim's rooms have always been at least more functional than Todd's throughout the entire season. Kim has my vote as the best of the remaining two; but I still say the best designer *and* host of the original 11, was Will.

I for one would far far rather see Will with his own show than Kim. I might watch Kim, maybe 50% of the time. I might watch Todd, maybe 10% of the time, but I would surely watch Will 100% of the time. HGTV - clearly the fan favorite here is Will. I do so hope you are listening...

Posted by Glen Bradley – September 13, 2007 1:34 AM

Now that it's over and I'm seeing the blog, I have to say (and I have a witness) that I was talking up Will as the should-be winner since the early 99 cent challenge episode. Boo on the judging as it sometimes looked biased (Martha McCully: "no, it's full-throttle-Todd teehee!") and occasionally moronic because the judges had less viewing information to go on than the audience. Need more proof? Go back to Episode 3 where Vern Yip absolutely loved Robb's frat-boy "I'm sitting in a giant flag!" beerfest room...supposedly a living room, by the way.

Lots of credit to Kim for saving her best for last...she trounced Todd, who is better suited to designing spaces for museum exhibits, not for practical living spaces. However, as comfortable as she is on camera, she's not as good a designer as Will, not as good a shopper as Sparkle Josh, and her space planning (look at all the episodes) was rightly criticized. Even the judges at some point said that no one left "had all three design star qualities"

Kim, you're probably lucked out that Will wasn't your final competition and that they put so much more emphasis on hosting (yeah, like their other network hosts are such showpeople!) Either way, you stuck it out so go get your show girl!

Posted by RicRush – September 13, 2007 1:22 AM

KIM, YOU ARE DEFINITELY A CLASS ACT. YOU GO GIRL! I WISH YOU THE BEST OF LUCK. I THINK THAT YOU WILL GO A LONG WAY. TODD, TODD, TODD. IT IS GREAT TO BE AS CREATIVE AS YOU ARE. YOU DEFINITELY THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX. I THINK THIS TIME YOU BLEW IT. IF I WERE ON VACATION I WOULD WANT A ROOM THAT SAID "RELAX" "ENJOY". YOUR ROOM WAS TOO LOUD AND UPROARISH. I AGREE IT WAS TOTALLY TODD AND IT WAS GOOD, JUST NOT GREAT.

Posted by joann – September 12, 2007 11:50 PM

I am so glad to see that Kim will likely get the show instead of Todd. In the finale, she was just about perfect – all she needs is a new hair style!

I never thought I would see anyone else who loves blue more than I do – my last 3 cars were blue and most of my clothes – but I have to say this to Todd – ENOUGH WITH THE BLUE ALREADY! That intense shade of blue that he uses is very hard to live with 24/7, even in a resort suite. Kim knows how to use blue as a contrast, not the only color in the room. Besides I was getting tired of looking at Todd’s hairy underarms all the time. At least Kim keeps her shirt on!!

Will I watch Kim? You bet!

Posted by Deanne – September 12, 2007 11:29 PM

Well Kim - I hope you made it! We'll find out Sunday.

Next year I hope Lisa LaPorta & Joan Steffend are two of the judges! And, hope the voting is limited to one vote per person per day. This year it won't be "America" deciding the vote - it will only be America's text-messengers!

Posted by Ilene – September 12, 2007 11:19 PM

I am almost positive that this is a cumulative show, meaning that it's not only the last challenge that counts, it's every single room and every single design. Really?!? Kim?!?! No way! We don't need another hunk? Are we all women here? I can't believe what I am reading on here! So Todd's room wasn't as colorfully appealing to all of your eyeballs, he took risks, something that Kim would never do on her own. She had to be told to do everything out of the ordinary (ripping up the carpet) and the ONE AND ONLY design she did on her own (in West Virginia) was a disaster! The poor family could have come up with a better design if they were given the money themselves! Kim nags and nags and her personality is so annoying it will make it almost impossible to make it through her whole show without changing the channel in frustration!

Todd, please pull some strings with the big guy because apparently we can't rely on America to make a sane decision around here! You're awesome, don't let anyone make you think otherwise!

Posted by Rachel – September 12, 2007 11:02 PM

~My vote was for Will. What happened? Great Team Player, oh never mind. I love what he did for Bridgette! Great Job an what a good out look on your Show ending. You'll go FAR.
~~My vote is on Kim. GO Kim GO! I feel any Human...that can do what she did...out in the stickers of V. dealing with wind, rain, mud & going to the Main Road, make sure the carpet didn't get lost. Should get the Vote. Even thou the carpet got MUDDY, She finished up, Mud dried, an WOW...like it was a MADGIC Carpet, ha ha. Kim sweep it up like no big deal! Great with the camera too. The Big "Design Star" Camera! Go KIM!
~~~ Had a fun time watchin' "Todd from Cali" adding a "Splash of Home" to his design. Always going head over heals to start at Home. Todd has a good spirit. I Love S.B. too!

Posted by Barbara~Ann – September 12, 2007 9:46 PM

to all of us who voted,
I think Todd's out of the box designs and Kim's elegance in design go hand in glove.
BOTH Kim and Todd are a winner. IT'S A TIE.
They are consistently strong, resilient, and commited to the project. Beryl

Posted by Beryl – September 12, 2007 9:35 PM

Kim's suite was awesome! It was much better than Todd's teenage bedroom. I want Kim to win so bad!! Good luck, Kim!

Posted by RB – September 12, 2007 9:22 PM

Get a life! Kim is a HAIRDRESSER! Todd is a schooled designer. If you disagree with Todd's decisions, which I believe were on the mark, then so be it. But, look at the larger picture, Kim can't design kitchens. Kim isn't a master carpenter. Kim can't confess to having previous designs under her belt. Therefore Todd is the clear winner. I am an intellectual, a true professional student. With this being said, I vote on he side of education, not silly emotional blah!

Posted by dr. who – September 12, 2007 9:17 PM

Totally agree with JP. Will...Sparkle Josh...Christina and Scott were the only ones who showed any real potential in this show. They were never given a true chance to shine. Will had the most opportunity and proved himself over and over again and yet...the judges still voted him off! He got a long with everyone and had the best attitude. I agree with JP and they all should be given a second chance and would hope that maybe Kim would have at least Will on her show and maybe some of the others. I voted for Kim!!!

Posted by Teresa – September 12, 2007 9:12 PM

Well I have decided not to vote at all. I'm sorry thinking back through all these two's designs I just couldn't bring myself to vote for either. I was leaning towards Kim after her Hawaii room but really wasn't that impressed with it either to be honest and felt without Will's help it would have look as good as it did. But once I found out that she had moved from CA to NY to go to acting school 10 years ago I couldn't do it......that answers my question why everyone thought she was a natural and so at ease in front of a camera she went to school to be a actor not a designer.Their were several designers gone way too early Will, Scott, Josh and Christina. I would have liked to see their work on individual rooms instead of group projects. So, I've decided not to vote this time

Posted by anne061 – September 12, 2007 8:10 PM

DESIGN STAR , I HAVE TO SAY THIS -- TODD HAS SO MUCH ENERGY THAT IT COMES ACROSS THE T.V. AND IF YOU ARE WATCHING IT MAKES YOU FEEL THAT YOU CAN GET UP AND DO SOMETHING WITH YOUR OWN SPACE , TO THINK OUT OF THE BOX AND TRY SOMETHING YOU HAVE THOUGHT ABOUT EVEN IF IT IS JUST COLOR OR DESIGNING SOMETHING THAT YOU HAVE WANTED TO DO .
HE MAKES IT SO YOU WANT TO GET UP AND DO IT ---
SO YOU LOOK AT YOUR BANK BOOK AND THINK OKAY I HAVE SOME MONEY SET ASIDE AND I NEED TO DO SOMETHING WITH MY SPACE AND YOU FEEL GOOD ABOUT IT . NEXT THING YOU ARE ON THE PHONE TRYING TO LOCATE SOMEONE WHO CAN DO THE WORK FOR YOU .
THIS GUY HAS SO MUCH ENERGY HE JUST SPREADS IT AROUND AND THAT IS A GOOD THING . I AM SO GLAD TO SEE SOMEONE SO UPBEAT , THAT HAS THAT OUT LOOK ON LIFE . GOOD LUCK TODD !

Posted by GERRI – September 12, 2007 8:08 PM

fIRST OF ALL THE SCREEN ON THIS BLOG IS WAY OFF TO THE LEFT . tHIS SHOW IS JUST GREAT I WATCH HGTV ALL DAY AND 1/2 THE NIGHT -- PROBLEM IS THEY ARE BEGINNING TO HAVE TO MANY RERUNS .DESIGN STAR IS MY FAVORITE AND CAN HARDLY WAIT FROM SUNDAY TO SUNDAY TO SEE WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN . ALL THE STARS THEY HAVE HAD ON HAVE BEEN GOOD AND IT WILL BE HARD TO PICK A WINNER BETWEEN TODD AND KIM AS THEY ARE BOTH SO GOOD BUT IN COMPLETELY DIFFRENT AREAS . I THINK TODD WOULD BE BETTER AS A TV HOST BUT YET YOU NEVER KNOW AS ALL THINGS CAN BE LEARNED . I THINK ALL OF THEM WILL END UP IN MUCH BETTER PLACES WITH WHAT THEY LIKE TO DO . I WOULD LIKE TO SEE SOME OF THEM BACK AS PART OF THE DESIGN STAR AS SPECIAL GUEST OR SOMETHING . I WOULD HATE IT IF WE NEVER GOT TO SEE THEM AGAIN IN SOME WAY OR MANNER . I THINK THEY WOULD BENFIT
THE SHOW IN A BIG WAY .
THANKS DESIGN STAR FOR A WONDERFUL SEASON AND KEEPING US ON THE EDGE OF OUR SEATS , IT HAS BEEN GREAT .

Posted by GERRI – September 12, 2007 7:35 PM

I would like to suggest the people who are choosing contestants PLEASE look for someone who can do french country, cottage or folksy fun design. Working all day in stark sleek surroundings does not mean you want to come home to more of the same. Nurturing design that listens to the environment cradles your body and takes you away from all that means stress is what I would like to see.

I agree with another comment that the focus needs to be on design. Who cares if the guy has muscles. I want to know how to create space where there is none, make my family and friends feel like they never want to leave and do it on a budget.

Maybe adding two more judges would not be a bad idea either. The comments are usually on target but there is such a directional pull toward modern it has almost rusted my stainless steel.

I hope next design star will have more serious competitors in challenges that are less Vegas and more middle America.

Kay

Posted by Fran – September 12, 2007 7:33 PM

I am in agreement with the other post-ers that are suggesting new judges for next year. If, there is a show next year. I think HGTV should have judges on the panel that are HGTV viewers. People who are not in the design field, just regular fans of the network. Then maybe HGTV would really see what their viewers are looking for.

Posted by vanalinda – September 12, 2007 6:35 PM

Hope you are listening HGTV, for "Where there's a Will, there's a way!" There needs to be a way for you to bring Will's sparkling, clean fresh and very approachable contemporary design back. All too often contemporary is cold and out of touch, his style has sensitive elements built in and is very approachable--even for those who wouldn't ordinarily like contemporary. This man has great style, obvious skill, and is seriously client oriented. He is quietly confident and a true southern gentleman who knows exactly where he is going with his designs, how he is going to get there. He has gentle and kind ways that attract viewers but was seriously underrated by the judges. Grace under pressure and a centered, humane character cannot be taught, hosting can be. Will already knows what he wants to tell you about the design, a little coaching would add polish and ease. People want a designer who listens--Will does, and who takes their information and makes their dream come alive. It is an immense joy to express your desires and dreams, even share your poor little sketches with a talented person (like with my architect when I was building) and see these client wishes blossom into something really beautiful in the hands of a talented designer. Will is that person, and you should be reading all these posts that want Will to come back.

Posted by SuzyQ – September 12, 2007 6:11 PM

I want to comment on the inequality of voting. Texters can send up to 25 votes plus those from their computers. Those of us who don't text are limited to the 5 we can send via computer. Texters are more likely to be younger and might favor the more "youthful" taste of Todd. My votes went for Kim. I'd love to see Kim's Design Show with Will "having her back". What a warm and talented pair they would be.

Posted by SunnyBlaz – September 12, 2007 6:10 PM

To the Producers:
Please rework the show for Design Star 3. There are too many group challenges that it is hard to see the talent of each individual. The first 3-5 shows should be individual efforts. Eliminate two people each show if need be. Then introduce the group challenges to see who plays nicely. When you get to the final 4 offer each designer some coaching on hosting. I think that format would make for a better outcome both for viewers and HGTV. Thanks!!

Posted by Cathy – September 12, 2007 5:45 PM

We still miss Sparkle Josh. He was the "DESIGN STAR".

Posted by KK – September 12, 2007 5:19 PM

Will has a heart of gold and an eye for design and listening to his clients wishes. How about this - he has that southern accent as many people do and it can be polished. When it comes to satisfying a client I think he will be judged by how happy he has made them because he has given them a room designed to their wants and not how he speaks. Consider that - Miss Judge with the blonde hair. Thanks Vern for giving Will the respect as a human being! Everyone deserves a chance to make it in this life and Will gave it his all.

Posted by HGTV Fanatic – September 12, 2007 3:35 PM

So many of these comments are really funny, it makes me wonder if everyone saw the same show. I am waiting for someone to say they are going to move out of the country if their person does not win. One very big thing most people are missing is that is called design star. NOT redecorate star. If it was, clearly Sparkle Josh would have won hands down. As well as Kim speaks, she has no design qualities. Robb brought this point up in the kitchen. They could always make her show all about living rooms. Then again, she did a poor job on the living room she did on her own. Will did a very good job talking about what he did and why; he just could not do it in a presentation. As for Todd I did not see one surfing influence on the two living rooms that he did. In case some of you missed the last show. It was in Hawaii, Kim closed her room off. Where Todd made is so you were always aware that you were there. First thing as soon as you got up you had the views of Hawaii.

Posted by Lilbeavis – September 12, 2007 3:28 PM

Kim should be the next Design Star. She has a flair for color, space, and has great ideas. She has grown so much week after week. I'm amazed that Todd got to the final. His energy level is high, he's a good carpenter, but his designs are lacking. He overuses blue in his color palates, and his room did look like a teenager's bedroom. Will was great. It's a shame that he didn't make it to the final two. I don't know why Robb was even on the show. His Las Vegas wedding was "scary"!! That was the ugiest wedding set up I have ever seen. He had a terrible attitude, did not relate well to others, not a team player, and just plain obnoxious. I don't know why you brought him back in the last episode. He did not deserve to be there. Christina would have been a better choice. Kim handled Rob very well. She's a true professional and didn't let him walk all over her. My vote is with Kim! If she appeals to the masses, that is great. The more people who watch HGTV the better. If Todd has his own show, I know I will not watch it. I hope you would insist that he wear a shirt.

Posted by Barbara Par – September 12, 2007 3:19 PM

My wife and I voted for Kim. We liked her color choices and presentation. Todd was a little to intense for us. He needs to chill a little. I would not have switched the rooms, mostly because I would rather look at the ocean before bed not after.

Posted by Paul – September 12, 2007 2:47 PM

To HGTV Design Star producers:

Think about what your viewer are saying...you guys have the designer's mindset, but we are the ones who actually judge the outcome. Almost NO ONE liked Todd's work OR his on-camera presence, but you guys did. Everyone liked Will's work, despite the fact that he wasn't flashy. He was GENUINE and cared about the people who lived in his rooms. And his work was good.That means something to viewers.

Kim was senstive to people's requests, but I think she did a poor job in the WV home. It didn't look much better when she left, but I'm sure it pleased them to get some new furniture. But it wasn't all Kim's fault. Pick homes where the families are open to new ideas, which the WV family was not.

Kim grew during the season and was a better designer than we saw in the beginning because she had to work with Neraja's indecision about tile in the kitchen. But she did WORK very hard.

Here's a suggestion...a follow-up mini-series for cash prizes. Three sessions of two hours long. There was too much time spent leading up to the real design contest, and not enough design time. Editors, cut out some of the armpit footage, and give us more sweeping shots of the entire room. We barely get to see a whole room when you cut up the view into small sections.

Have a vote off for this year's designers who didn't make it to the final. Give the top four designers three chances to do something totally on their own...no teamwork. I'd venture to say viewers will pick Sparkle Josh, Will, Christina and Scott. Give them descending amounts of cash based on first, second, third and fourth places.

I think you nailed it by sending Lisa home first. She's almost as bad as the first loser on Season One who painted the goofy mural. But there were some designers who were impressive but never really got a chance to shine on their own. I'll bet Scott, Josh, and Christina would make some of the finalists look amateur in comparison.

How did Neeraja and Robb even make it on the show? He was at the bottom several times and finally came up with a funky room and got praised. But his attitude was atrocious, and Neeraja's was not much better. She even told the judges in the beginnning that she didn't work well with people.

Christina's room beat Robb's room hands down. Her room was classy and his was garish. She also did a great job on the women's bedroom despite working with Andrea who over decorated. Christina had a good team spirit.

Think about giving some of the "losers" who lost by default another chance. Leave out Lisa, Neeraja and Robb. Give the rest a shot at some cash. I think your viewers would love it.

Use real interior designer judges, not fashion designers. Pick people who are confident in their opinions, who don't just mimick what the previous judge said.

Vern did a fair job in expressing his opinion, but he is too extreme. He either loved you or hated you...and showed it by his facial expressions.

That's okay as long as the judge doesn't pick a favorite personality up front and never actually judge what he or she produces. I think that was the situation with Todd. He couldn't lose no matter what he came up with. And Will, it seems, couldn't win because they never liked his presentation.

People watch or don't watch a show based on several criteria:

1. The design changes - are they practical, affordable and doable?

2. The person in charge - are they knowledgeable, likable, understandable and respectful?

3. The finished product - is it appealing or apalling?

JP

Posted by JP – September 12, 2007 1:45 PM

Week after week there was one thing I got a big kick out of: watching Martha McCully's face when she spoke to or about Todd, when she was watching Todd's videos, and when Todd was talking to her.

My teenage daughter and I agreed that Todd was the kind of surfer dude that would never marry. Imagine our total SHOCK when his "hot wife" appeared in this episode! ITA with another poster, though, that his affection appeared to be for his brother and his boy (whatever that means).

Kim is delightful -- she might not be cutting edge, but then she has grown tremendously throughout the show and when she wins and gets her own, she will *continue* to grow and may surprise all you nay-sayers! I'll definitely watch her.

Todd's show would not be on my list. His hosting skills alone are grating, let alone his style. Sorry, but I'm over 40 and don't live near a beach!

Thanks hgtv for good entertainment with Design Star.

Posted by Gigi – September 12, 2007 1:24 PM

This morning my 5th grade art students were studying Vincent Van Gogh's bedroom painting. The assignment following the discussion was to create a bedroom of their own. I decided to let them see Kim and Todd's rooms and let them "vote".
I thought you would be interested to know that their votes were 14 for Kim and 20 for Todd. The vote was mixed, but more boys voted for Todd and more girls voted for Kim. They all loved the rug in Todd's dining room, and the headboard in Kim's bedroom.

Posted by Patty – September 12, 2007 1:21 PM

Someone on here said that if Todd didn't win we'd be doomed to another show that appeals to the masses. Why should HGTV want a show that only appeals to a handful of people? Advertisers aren't going to want to pay for air time during a show that hardly anyone is watching. HGTV is, after all, a business and in TV ratings make or break a show. If Kim wins, it's because America has spoken and because she is what the majority of America wants. Todd needs to find a show on MTV or something appealing more to teen boys. I don't know any teen boys who watch HGTV.

Posted by Mindy – September 12, 2007 12:52 PM

I really enjoyed watching this season's Design Star and will be thrilled when Kim wins! I think Todd is very unique in his design but almost too predictable -- the theme is always water related. Kim, on the other hand, seemed to have a specific and different plan for each client and a good follow through. I realize time was a major constraint for all involved, so some creativity may have gotten lost along the way. All in all, it's been a pleasure watching Design Star and I look forward to next season.

Posted by Linda – September 12, 2007 12:48 PM

Todd couldn't possibly pull off a show on his own, he doesn't present - he babbles. Kim has been at ease on camera since day 1 and has improved her design talents with every challenge. Todd got by on one challenge by breaking up furniture! It may be art, but it's NOT design. Everybody loves Will ~ so do I ~ but let's all remember that this challenge was for a TV show and he just (unfortunately) didn't have the requiste skill. He absolutely would make a good assistant or collaborator.

I do agree with a previous comment that there's room for another design show with a new focus ~ maybe true structural remodeling would be a great concept.

Posted by Brazy – September 12, 2007 12:33 PM

I thought I was going to vote for Todd based on Kim's atrocious makeover of the W. Virginia couple's home, but she saved her "A" game for the final challenge and I gladly voted her since I couldn't vote for Will. Her room is everything one would want in a hotel (penthouse) suite. It suits a wide variety of tastes. Hotel rooms are supposed to appeal to the masses unless you go to a hotel room that has theme rooms. Todd's room would fit in perfectly at a boutique hotel that offers its guests theme rooms. The Outrigger Hotel is a mass market hotel. Only a surfer or child would find his room appealing. Why did he think people would want to sleep next to their kitchen. The space planning was horrible. I know some folks admire him for sticking to his guns and seeing his design through to fruition; but, that doesn't justify a bad decision. A designer NOT only needs to maintain his/her vision but s/he has to keep in mind the needs of the client and often will need to tweak the design to ensure the client's objectives are met. That's the mark of a good designer.

As others have mentioned, Will more than deserves his own show. HGTV should right the Design Star judges horrible faux pas and give that man his own show.

Posted by Cute-T – September 12, 2007 12:21 PM

HI EVERYONE, I HAVEN'T BEEN ON UNTIL NOW SO IT IS SO INTERESTING TO READ MOST OF THE POSTINGS ABOUT KIM AN TODD..I FOR ONE LOVE ALL OF WHAT KIM DOES AN TODD WELL TO BE HONEST, I DON'T LIKE ALL HIS WATER IDEAS..OH SOME IS GOOD, BUT THAT SEEMS TO BE ALL HE DOES..HE DOES HAVE SOME TALENT ,BUT KIM TOPS HIM TOTALLY..I REALLY HOPE SHE WINS..I WILL BE SO DISAPPOINTED IF SHE DOESN'T..I SURE WAS GLAD TO SEE WILL BACK ON ,BUT WAS SO UPSET TO SEE ROBB..HE IS SO SNICKY GOING BACK AN TELLING TODD WHAT KIM HAD DONE WAS SO WRONG..HE HAS NO CLASS AT ALL..HIS ATTITUDE WAS BETTER ,BUT I FELT HE WAS JUST BEING "FHONY"..I AM SORRY HE JUST COMES OFF SO MEAN AN SNEAKY.HE DID DO ALOT TO HELP KIM AN I WAS SO GLAD TO SEE THAT..OH WELL, IT IS ALMOST OVER AN I JUST PRAY IT IS KIM THAT WINS..IT WILL BE SO GOOD TO SEE THE WHOLE CROWD BACK ON FOR THE LAST SHOW , THAT IS IF THEY DO IT LIKE THE LAST TIME..I FEEL SO DISAPPOINTED WITH THIS SHOW COMPARED TO LAST TIME..I KNOW THE JUDGES HAVE TO LET SOMEONE GO HOME, BUT THE WAY THEY DID WILL WAS WRONG...DAVID HAD TO LEARN HOW TO BE ON T.V. AN THEY COULD HAVE WORKED WITH WILL, BUT DECIDED NOT TOO..HE WAS SO MUCH BETTER THAN TODD.I DO FEEL THAT VERN WANTS TODD AN THAT IS THAT SO I AM GLAD THE LAST VOTE IS UP TO ALL OF US AN NOT THEM.I LOVED WILL'S GOOD BYE WORDS ABOUT THAT PRECIOUS YOUNG GIRL IN THE WHEELCHAIR AN HOW SHE MEANT SO MUCH TO HIM..NOW THAT IS CLASS..I WOULD LOVE TO SEE HIM AN KIM AN CHRISTINA HAVE A SHOW..ALICE SHOULD HAVE ONE AS WELL.. OH WELL I AM NOT A JUDGE, I WISH I COULD BE THOUGH..LIKE MOST OF YOU OUT THERE...

Posted by Cat555 – September 12, 2007 12:19 PM

Todd is way too annoying he would be good for doing childrens rooms because he is a overgrown child himself. He just is way too hyper... Now Kim she has class so I believe she will and should win. I would much rather stay in a nice calming upscale room than that mess of a undersea thing Todd created. To each his own though.. these are just my opinions.

Posted by Keribean – September 12, 2007 12:13 PM

Hey Guys!

My vote is for Kim all the way,I love her style,she's cute and comes across really well on tv, she make you want to try some of the stuff she does, I love her warm colors and she's the bomb when she gives her presentation.

I loved Will too I love especially his clean designs and I hope that he may possibly get his own show as well.

I also love Todd he's cool with his designs and flashy with all of his colors he could possibly have his own show as well.

But my voites are in for Kim Go All the Way Kim!
Yeah You Rock!

Posted by Virginia – September 12, 2007 12:09 PM

Did you say they were to appeal to the masses? I did not think that any of these design challenges were intended to appeal to the masses! Some were more specific than others, but never did I hear appeal to the masses. It was all about individuals showing their personal design powers.
And the hotel suites were a poor choice for the final challenge - they were doomed before they even started. Vote for Todd or we are doomed to another boring show designed to appeal to the masses!

Posted by MAM – September 12, 2007 11:46 AM

I’m a big fan of HGTV. I’m so disappointed that judge let Will go, what are they thinking??. I wanted to see his design more on his show. We don’t have the type of designer like Will in HGTV, his show could have been a big hit in HGTV. On the other hand, Todd or Kim’s show would be ordinary HGTV designer which I would not even mind even though I missed watching their once a week show. I voted for Kim because I would be scare to have Todd designed my room and I can not get any good idea from his design ( not useful). His design might be good for magazines.

Posted by RB – September 12, 2007 11:43 AM

How like any competition: it is possible to make a bad decision at a very critical moment. It happens in sports all the time, and it happens here. Last year Alice, whom we all love, made some poor decisions. Turning the glass room into a children's room was a bad choice because David had just done a children's room (and his was better). Had it not been a competition, Alice's children's room would have been very nice. But the choice was all wrong for the moment.

From this point of view, I thought Todd's poor design choices on this final room were really interesting. Normally, he has a great sense of color and scale. But this time... I won't repeat the errors that have been mentioned already but only my particular peeves: the colors black and blue together, the creepy jelly fish thing, the cheap, cheap frames around the cut-outs, the wave behind the bed that didn't look like a wave at all, the huge TV elevated on top of a big, useless box, the ugly rug, the suede black furniture (who wants to come in from a hot day in Hawaii and sit on suede furniture?), the tacky lamps, and the big, black heavy frame over the bed next to the cheap brown wooden frame. I can see where he wanted to go, and he almost made it. But almost isn't good enough for any competition.

Of course, for me, it's Kim. I really like her room. Is it perfect? No, I am sure she would agree. But for the time she had to do it, she made good, solid decisions.

Two more general peeves: it is not fair to have the big group projects with team captains because the captains have to take the rap for the failures (and they are mostly failures) and then they are eliminated. And it was not fair to have the bride and groom eliminate Christina. Her design was not worse than any other.

I love HGTV and I love this show. I used to be a news hound. But since the war started I cannot watch the news. My nerves just cannot take it. So, I watch HGTV.

Posted by sue – September 12, 2007 11:40 AM

It is a real shame that the way this has been presented to America - that their votes on the final challenge will decide the winner. The decision should be based on all of the challenges.
Like I said before, Kim is good, but she really has just sort of bumbled here way through each challenge and somehow ended up in the final 2.
Her show would just blend in with all the other design shows - there is nothing new or exciting I see that she could possibly bring to a show.
It really was puzzling how Rob kept eluding elimination from the judges. Cutting Sparkle Josh was the first bad, bad move. And, then Will over Kim was just too much.
But, my vote goes to Todd - even though the squid did not float my boat and he used blue twice. He has something new and vibrant to offer - I do not think he is all about Todd and the beach scene.He works for a living and I am sure he knows how to cater to his clients wishes. But, was not that what this show was all about - to make yourself stand out .... and he did that in everyway.
I am sorry for the people who were so distressed or distracted by his chest - they must have some kind of personal problem. I did not find it distracting at all - who cares! This was not a fashion show. America needs to pay attention to real purpose of this show and not all these petty judements. Kim's show will be boring. Todd's show will be upbeat and fun. What would you rather watch?

Posted by MAM – September 12, 2007 11:31 AM

Yay!!! Kim, you are fabulous.
Todd ,is terrific they should do a couple of
shows together??

Posted by Linda – September 12, 2007 11:22 AM

I keep on going back to the photos of episode 6,
along with the photos of the Hawaii episode, and I still believe that Will's work was the very best. I also believe that Will's hosting was just fine; your audience is really captivated by
Will, not only as the best designer, but also as
the most compelling candidate. All of my friends agree with me. We feel that even Ray Charles would have been able to see that! We realize that things are not set up so that we can vote for him, but we are hoping that HGTV will still do the right thing and give him his own show. My
friends and I would watch every episode. Judging by other posted comments, I really think that his show would be a hit. I would let Will work in my home anytime! Look at the fantastic photos on
his website.
We were also impressed with Vern Yip's new show.
I recall that Lisa LaPorta did some work with
Michael Payne on "Designing for the Sexes." Perhaps Will can work along with Vern.

Posted by Sara Anne – September 12, 2007 10:57 AM

I had already decided that I was voting for Kim for all the same reasons that are posted in this blog. My 18 year old daughter was watching tv on Monday night and it happened to be on HGTV showing the rerun of the final challenge. She has never seen the show so had no opinions or biases up to that point. After it was over, I asked her which one she would vote for. Immediately she said "Kim". She went on to say that Todd's room looked like a kid's room. BINGO!!!

Posted by safe – September 12, 2007 10:54 AM

Going against the flow...vote Todd. Not because he was better in the final challenge but that he was stronger in his other room designs. But becuase he is nicer or sweeter tha Kim but because his energy can be infectious. Not because he's a better host than Kim but because HGTV has too many "Kims" already.

Posted by lonnie 1 – September 12, 2007 10:49 AM

From reading all the blogs I can see Kim winning hands down! Wonderful!!!!! Cant't wait to see her on her own show.

One thing I liked was that not all the designers were from other fields other than interior designers. I would like to see the next design star episode of people from all walks to show us that the "common joe" can be design stars. I love watching HGTV but sometimes get tired of seeing shows where people are spending $$$ to redecorate. I would love to have the money to do decorate my house, but am limited to a small amounts. Bring on more shows that show us how to decorate on a budget.

by the way - KIM WELL DONE - you got my vote!

Posted by Pat Southern Belle – September 12, 2007 10:48 AM

The basic issue with these shows--Design Star, Food Network Star, etc. etc. etc.--is that the individual talent of the person may or may not be in synch with their all-important-for-a-TV-host LIKEABILITY quotient. Let's face it, even if Robb was a design genius (which he certainly isn't) he's such a JERK and so unpleasant to spend TV time with that he had NO chance. My question is...why are people like that even in the game? The other way this issue messes things up (and I have to say that Design Star has done a MUCH better job of "casting" in both seasons than the Food Network Star has done in ANY of theirs) is when somebody as talented, down to earth, and genuine as Will is dissed and dumped in the end by the "judges" because he isn't "polished" as a host. Frankly, that kind of "gloss" is off-putting, too. If any of you saw the "making of" show about David's show's creation, you know that even the charming lad was given a LOT of coaching and help to become a TV host, and I'm sure Will would have risen to that occasion, too. Having said that, I'm clear that Kim brings not only style and hosting to the game, but LIKEABILITY too, and that isn't to say Todd's not a nice fellow. In the real world, the stuff that wowed the judges (and primarily the female ones, not Vern) such as wave murals, deconstructed furniture, revolving living room pedestals, etc. etc. is not what real-world CLIENTS will want to LIVE with in their homes. A hotel suite is slightly more foregiving of eccentricity because you only stay there briefly, but even in little ways Todd doesn't think function at all--for example, it is one thing to call a table an "adventure-planning center" but why not stage it with a map of Oahu or the like? He "gets it" only to a point, then gives in to the urge to be flashy. I wish Todd well, but I hope and expect Kim to be the next Design Star, and wish, as many here have said, that Will had a show I could watch every week. He is the most LIKEABLE and down-to-earth of 'em all, and being a "polished" presenter is irrelevant to that...and maybe even counter to it.

Posted by Victory6 – September 12, 2007 10:04 AM

HEY EVERYONE~ I THINK THERE SHOULD BE A CONTEST ON NAMING THE NEXT DESIGN STAR SHOW. I MEAN COME ON... WE ARE SOME REALLY PASSIONATE FANS OUT HERE! THE WINNER OF THE CONTEST SHOULD HAVE THEIR NAME ANNOUNCED AND A SPECIAL PRIZE OF HAVING A ROOM DONE BY THE WINNER OF THIS YEARS DESIGN STAR. HOW COOL WOULD THAT BE!
OK MY SHOW NAMES ARE: AND I GAVE THIS SOME THOUGHT...~~~

*EVERYDAY LIVING/STYLE with Kim Myles
OR
* RADICAL SABBATICAL with Todd Davis

WHAT DO YOU THINK HGTV EXECS?
I'D LOVE TO READ OTHER NAMES OUT THERE DS FANS. ;-)

Posted by Kaff – September 12, 2007 9:42 AM

I was disappointed that Kim ignored the carpet color when she selected her colors...she should have done the design keeping that in mind. The paint in the kitchen looked odd. The two things that stood out in the room were the wood divider and the concrete floor. The rough wood and chains were not anything you would find in a classy hotel suite nor would the concrete floor. But her positioning of furniture was very good.
Todd's room was too dark. Dark paint, dark furniture, dark bedding. He may have pulled it off had he used lighter shades. The one room I liked was the color in the dining room. Once again he used cheap pine for a picture frame. As for the view, I think he forgot that people are asleep when they are in bed. To try and place the sofa against the bed made the whole suite look smaller and to have the kitchen in another room from the dining table is foolish. No high end suite here!
Rooms cost a lot of money per night, and if I was on vacation and given the choice, I'd be more comfortable in the one Kim designed(if I could get it for half-price)

Posted by Vickie – September 12, 2007 9:02 AM

So much Todd bashing out there, I just had to write. Lets focus first on design. Kim nailed her last two challenges no doubt there, and Todd came though big time for the big families living room. However, he just didn’t measure up on the final challenge. Original and creative, yes, practical and “high end suite” no. I believe that eight to twelve more hours and the outcome of this challenge would have been a whole new ballgame. The designers were taxed to the max, time constraints dictated the avenues of design possibilities. Todd’s approach just fell short on time, as the old saying goes “you don’t rush art”.

Now on to my defense, support, and thoughts about Todd. As has been pointed out in numerous postings the boy has to keep his shirt on. Yes, I take off my shirt when I’m working and its hot but then I’m not on TV. Personality wise, I think I could come to like a show hosted by Todd, he seems genuine enough. At first I thought he was immature and egotistical but he really shined last week when working on the family living room. The ability to host a show and throttle back a bit so he wouldn’t be so IN YOUR FACE is easily taught and then his “life is fun” personality would come though in a manner all could enjoy.

Bottom line, really the last thing HGTV needs is another interior design show. Kim will be great at such a program, I too would watch a program hosted by either Kim, Will, or Sparkle Josh. But Todd I think would do himself much better to go after the other elements of design in and around the house. His mantra of go big, his personal energy, and his construction skills lend themselves to a show of major projects. I could see him on a show where he would rip out a wall or build an addition, or otherwise improve a space rather than just decorating. Now that’s a show we could use on HGTV

Posted by Craig Lehrke – September 12, 2007 8:48 AM

Everyone comments about Todd being able to "think outside the box." Has anyone noticed that it is always the same box? I don't think creativity means doing the same thing over and over again. All we have seen from Todd is blue, waves & variations thereof. Kim has been much more creative & seems to be continually evolving as a designer. Good luck Kim! And yes, HGTV, you need to bring on Will as one of your regulars. He should never have been bumped from the show.

Posted by Deb – September 12, 2007 8:07 AM

LOVE the show!!!! Have to agree with the many fans that have voted for KIM. SHe is AWESOME! Goes to show that design is a GIFT. She was just born with it. Loved her suite. Hated Todd's. I truly believe the two female judges are more infatuated by his good looks than his design talent. That room was AWFUL! Kim's was elegant, well thought out and chic. The color combination was outstanding, and the polished concrete came out great. Her presentation was professional and her enthusiasm was tangible. She really did a great job! Good luck to you Kim! You will get far!

Posted by Tina in R.I. – September 12, 2007 7:28 AM

My suggestions to HGTV are to have many more individual challenges, versus group;
not allow participants to be dumped by guests, only judges or at the end all of us;
voting should be done by PHONE, or computer and only once per person. There are people who watch your show and do not have a computer or cell phone. Also it is time for new judges, as we have gotten tired of the biases of each of these three.
I know all the participants were glad to be home, where they could finally get some real sleep.
Lastly, my husband and I consistently enjoyed Will's design, listening skills, warm and genuine style and like David, he could have been coached to improve his overall personal presentation, but you cannot not teach someone to open their hearts and be loving and supportive, in a genuine manner.
We feel blessed to have met him and would love a show where he is host or a member. Currently on HGTV there are several Caucasian males, with lots of energy and enthusiasm; lots of attractive, slender, Caucasian females with the same...time to add more diversity to serve your diverse audience.
Thanks to all the participants for all their hard work under very tense and stressful time straints.
We look forward to Sunday finale and hope that Kim is chosen the winner. She has grown a great deal and did not get any kudos on air for her excellent design contributions in the original penthouse.
Todd is an interesting and stimulating designer and I know he will do nothing but prosper and shine. Good luck to all of the 11 in their futures.

Posted by Victoria – September 12, 2007 4:42 AM

I can't wait until Sunday night to see if all the rest of the world feels the same way about Kim and Todd's designs. Will it really be judge
on who's the best designer? or, will it be a popularity contest? I just hope we all be fair. I will except who ever wins. and support them. But, Some of the others were also very talented
Some of their design were a lot better than we saw Sunday night.

Posted by Bonnie – September 12, 2007 4:27 AM

Interesting reading! However, I've checked all over the HGTV site and can't find where to vote!
Of course, my vote would go to Kim...Todd is very imaginative and creative, but I don't think people in the real world could live in a room with the surf pounding the furniture to pieces LOL. Kim takes her art seriously, focusing on what her clients would like in the way of style, comfort and livability. All that along with her exuberant smile and sparkling eyes. WTG, Kim!!

Posted by Kay – September 12, 2007 4:21 AM

I think this season seemed very rushed. There were too many group challenges. I don't feel I really got a sence of the designers. The whole wedding show sucked. Two people were eliminated prematurally. HGTV, stop and think for a minute. What is the purpose of the show, pick a designer that the public likes, wants. Let us get to see their work and who they are, this would create more loyal viewers that want to see their show. The final was a bit of a disappointment. Todd is bizzar for the sake of being bizzar, I would not want to live in any of his rooms, and he comes off a bit arrogant, he shouldn't he's not as good as David B. I wouldn't watch Todd's show. Kim, is the better of the two, but I just don't have a sence of her work, and her semifinal room left much to be desired from. Hard to believe she is the best you could come up with. Please reconsider how and how fast the eliminations are done in future series. This series was a shame, both people eliminated by the wacky wedding may have produced a better final product/new show.

Posted by j0115 – September 12, 2007 3:57 AM

Kim . . . Go, Girl! Can't wait to see your very own show. Maybe you could invite Will and Sparkle Josh to join you for a few shows. Please do not invite Todd or Rob. Thanks.

Posted by Kathy – September 12, 2007 3:34 AM

Today was my 1st time reading these comments. I am gald to hear that a lot of people feel the same as I do about Will. If you remember when Will and Todd worked together most of the design was Will. Todd's thing was the platform, everything else was Will. Will's last statement when he was voted off made him a winner. Since Will was not in the final two, it got to be Kim. Their rooms were on two different levels. Kim's room was a high end hotel room and Todd's was a budget end motel room.

Posted by Norma – September 12, 2007 3:04 AM

I hope to God Todd does NOT win because who could stand an entire show of his juvenile over the top antics? It's too much. I watch HGTV shows to learn new design techniques and ideas...not surfing. Yes he is creative, but I really think he'd do better designing department store windows or displays. He could really go crazy there! I thought this last challenge proved he really didn't understand it. Moving the bed into the living area? Come on! Almost hitting the kitchen area when you get out of bed is ridiculous. Kim was so on it when she broke up the space into different areas. Her screen divider was beautiful and ingenious. Why not lie on a nice big sectional and enjoy the view from the designated living area like Kim designed? Who wants to see the bed when you walk in the front door? Yes, Todd stuck by his 'vision'...unfortunately it's one I hope don't have to look at on a regular basis. Kim explains what she did, how and why. Surf-boy screams and bounces. I think Kim did an awesome job hosting and designing. And Will was a sweetheart--he just couldn't get his personality to shine through with any authority. Todd would not have been my pick to be a finalist though he does look good on TV. Just spare me his constant posing and hollering! The best thing he did was the squid on the wall. Good job Todd! Now get your boogie board and go home. Go Kim!

Posted by Jan – September 12, 2007 2:56 AM

I enjoyed this year's competion very much. I think that Sparkle Josh would make a great side kick for one of the other shows like Design on a Dime. The judges had it right when they said he was a great shopper but I did think he had a problem with design itself but gosh he was a LOT of fun to watch and listen to. I'm voting for Kim I do believe that she handled Robb with grace under the circumstances and her designs were all something that I would like to live with. I have liked the idea that she isn't a "trained designer" HGTV could use a design Rachel Ray. Kim has always been classy and even generous to her fellow cast mates how people operate in that kind of pressure speaks loads about their character. Kim's character has shined in my opinion.

Posted by everydaylady – September 12, 2007 2:28 AM

Do you all really think Kim is good? I don't even know how she got to the final 2.
A) She couldn't even finish tiling a countertop.
B)Her "wallpaper" with paper plates was lowsy and look exactly like coming out of a dollar store with a very outdated pink paint as the background.
C)When she worked with Rob as "a team" as she claimed so many times, they couldn't even put the fridge in the kitchen, where it belonged, besides the fact that the space looked to bare and unfinished.
D) Her $10,000 makeover didn't improve the space and she used too many angles with rugs and furniture because she didn't know what else to do, claiming also that she made the barn looking bar when it was already there. The only thing she did was stained it. She didn't even change the furniture arrangement!
I don't think anybody else made more mistakes than her and yet, she is still there when she should've been the second one to go since she was only better than the first lady to leave, whose name I don't even remember.
If she wins I won't watch because I think she is a boring, predictable self-proclaimed "designer", and in any case, a mediocre shopper since all her spaces were too much the same, except for the paint in the last challenge.
I prefer Todd, although we was not my first choice.

Posted by Tootsie – September 12, 2007 2:12 AM

I just want to say that although I love hgtv, this year watching the DS series was sad. Why can't we have Candice and Lisa judge. I almost stopped watching because of Martha and Cynthia this year, but instead just muted them. I'm sorry Todd made it to the finals. I thought sponge bob or bright yellow star pillows and glowing stars on the ceiling were all his designs were missing. Total Hotel 6. Maybe next year HGTV will decide to raise the bar. I hope so.

Posted by jaci – September 12, 2007 2:11 AM

HGTV: Does it really have to be only one winner???? Perhaps the ideal would be to have the best 2 selected to share a show... At least we would not be stuck with Todd's predictability and boring movements. And if does win, please, please, please: Have him buid but not design!!!!

Posted by ap – September 12, 2007 12:57 AM

I think Todd displayed the self confidence necessary to be the design star. When the judges came and critiqued his room, he stuck to his guns and created his vision. Kim waffled, got scared, and did what the judges told her.

Posted by Diamond – September 12, 2007 12:56 AM

I agree with Icy. HGTV needs to mix it up a bit and bring Will and Josh "sparkles" back for their own show. This would be a breath of fresh air. Fantastic design with these two great personalities. ( seems like 99% of the viewers in blogsand comments have felt the same way)The judges were worried about Will's T.V.presence, but I think he and Josh would play well off of each other. Are you LISTENING HGTV ?

Posted by Cindy – September 12, 2007 12:55 AM

Even with a lack of training, Kim has by far a sense of understanding the client, Todd on the other hand should stay in Hawaii and surf dude. He does not listen to anyone. Would you hire someone that does not understand the value of listening and paying attention to what the client is saying? A designer is no different than any other consultant, which is stop, listen than execute.Todd comes across as a used car sales person cramming his personality, his ideas and his design down your throat whether you like it or not. Kim, you deserve to win. I like your style. Represent the NYC!

Posted by Elle – September 12, 2007 12:32 AM

I would never have guessed it, but after reading many of the comments here, it seems to me like HGTV viewers are mostly Kim is safe and too predictable. Todd is energy, enthusiasm, fun and talent. I like the jelly-fish. I like the armpits. I like to watch a show where somebody acts like himself and really gets into what he's doing. I watched the show to see what Todd was going to do next. His rooms have movement and form. They show intelligence and life. Dude, I get it - and I know there are many others out there who get it too. Thanks to Todd my kids and I enjoyed watching the show together. HGTV shouldn't miss the opportunity: Forward-thinking people and young people are the future. Capture the newer, hipper viewers and keep the ones like me who like most of your shows.

Posted by Lindsay – September 12, 2007 12:15 AM

GO DESIGN STARS!!

I cannot say this enough. Bring back Will as a co host.
Kim and Will North and South, They are a great equalizer. A winning combo, whose attitudes make you happy when they are done. They balance each others strengths and weaknesses.
And, this would open up opportunities for both of them to grow and learn more as individuals and as designers.
Not to mention it would be great for all of us as well!!

__________________________________________

On the last challenge, in Hawaii. The old saying of know you audience and your surroundings. The client was an upscale hotel, on the beach. The rooms were accessed by sliders off a public accessed balcony.

While the views from those rooms during the day were breathtaking. Imagine the reversed image of those rooms when the light source comes from within and you are now the grand vista?

Putting the bed in the dining room, was more like creating a big blue 180 degree peep show, then a secluded retreat.

Staying in Todds room would have been perfect for a Family travelling with a group of 12 year old boys who had not yet discovered girls, but rather watching TV and playing Video games.

In Kim's room I could get a great nights sleep and still enjoy the view.

Posted by Anabella – September 12, 2007 12:04 AM

I, too, have been following the show and of course David was one of a kind! For this year, I agree that Sparkle and Will should have their own show! It will be such a hit. Now for the last two designers left, I like Kim very much and I think she has such talent! I also like Todd because he is very enthusiastic about his designs and he does have a unique talent so I don't know why people are hating--guess because they don't have any talent! The one thing I prefer about Kim, therefore want her to win, is she is capable of variety of styles, whereas, Todd, it's sort of predictable--don't get me wrong. He is a lot of fun and you can see that in every work he does, but I feel his taste will not appeal to the majority and Kim's will. Todd is actually a landscaper by trade so I think he will do a great job at his own landscaping show!
Good luck to Kim and Todd! Either one will add tremendous viewers to HGTV.

Posted by RoweBeck – September 12, 2007 12:04 AM

Kim has been the sleeper all season, and I was pulling for her from Day 1, but thought we'd never get to see her individual talent. And, so what if she doesn't have the bona fide credentials? David Bromstat was a "starving artist" before he won, and his show is fantastic -- he has never designed anything but beautiful spaces. Kim has that same creativeness and will have her own different show. Todd is a trifle immature, at 35, to be thinking of surfing 24/7 - not sure I could stand many more of his designs. Aloha, baby! Long live Kim Myles!

Posted by Diane – September 11, 2007 11:33 PM

Great going Kim and Todd for being the final two. I learned so much about watching Todd's creative style. I really like how Todd lets go of his imagination. I learned so much.
Kim really was a fast thinker, I loved her motivation to jump in and create artwork. Her style and creativity is an art.
The entire program I was going for Todd. At the end Kim pulled it off. Kim you are truly a design star artist. Great job Kim.
Anyone have any idea how I can have my kitchen done by HGTV? I do live on a real tight budget.

Posted by Joe – September 11, 2007 11:23 PM

Kim you are a wonderful person and i love the creativity you use when you design. I have the exact dream that you have i am only 16 teen but i want to move to New York and go to college to beecome an interior designer. i believen myself and so can you. You make it so I want to keep working hard in school so I can be in your position someday. If anyone can win it is most defintly you because you got the style that everyone wants a taste of. Rock On

Posted by kim Robinson – September 11, 2007 11:14 PM

Although I am voting for Kim, I have to agree with the person who said that people are way too mean about Todd. His personality is overwhelming but that's a matter of personal taste, so let's not be so hard on him. He seems like a nice person. I did love the "armpit show" comment (LOL).

Posted by Louise – September 11, 2007 11:04 PM

In my previous posting I forgot to say thank you to the judges. I think that you all were great. As a whole I found your comments positive and constructive and I think the contestants did too.

Way to Go, Judges!

Posted by Betty – September 11, 2007 10:58 PM

My vote is for Will. He should have been the next Design Star. Judges, this season, you did not get it right.

Posted by DebT – September 11, 2007 10:52 PM

Kim will win. That's good ad she will be fun to watch. Will should be commended for getting her back on the floor dilemma. I agree with the others who are bemoaning the loss of ever seeing Will and Josh again. Will is the calm, efficient one who always put the clients wishes first (his work up for the century's Tacky Wedding honors was much better than I thought possible given red and lavendar colors..and even half elegant which can't have been easy!) So many of the shows on HGTV have no mentioned budget which is why I watch them if it's convenient but try really hard not to miss those with $ specifics mentioned. For a ton of money you can get anything, but what can be done on a budget? Bearing that in mind, why not have Sparkle come and do some REAL budget minded shopping? That would be a show!

Posted by maggie's mama – September 11, 2007 10:48 PM

Oh my God what a disappointment--Todd's suite looked like a 7 year old's bedroom and Kim's reminded of a Starbucks...the best thing of the entire show was the cement floor and that was Will's doing. Personally, I don't think HGTV needs another hunk. Don't get me wrong David Bromsted is the a cutie and has a great show.I really like Will although he did not have the whole host thing going on. I must say Todd's platform living room was a great idea.I'm stuck on who to vote for.Kim just seems to have a flair nothing else. Todd is just plain scary.

Posted by CK – September 11, 2007 10:46 PM

Kim turned into a SHINING STAR in the last episode! YEA KIM! YOU GOT MY VOTE! She's so warm and so confident in what she did. I was absolutely dumbfounded to see that Todd is married!? And not to a surfboard? I sure hope he's not a parent! He's 34 and everything he does is still surf-related? He NEEDS TO GROW UP! [And his copying last Design Star winner David's shirtless antics: that didn't help David win and it ain't gonna help Todd win.]

Posted by Steve W. – September 11, 2007 10:38 PM

I love Design Star. I have so enjoyed watching the show each week and appreciate how both Todd and Kim have grown and progressed in their work and their abilities. I think they are both great in their own way and am having trouble deciding who to vote for. I would like to commend Todd for being such a gentlemen throughout this show. I never saw any strife or bad comments with him. From the beginning he was encouraging and supportive and I love his very obvious love of life. When his family came there was such a warm outporing of love between them all. AWESOME!

I think that Kim is very gifted with the camera and I feel that her designs are very appealing.
I really like her personality also. I think she is a genuine person who comes up with really neat ideas.

I would love to see a show with Kim and Will. I would also love to see some of the landscapes that Todd designs. They have got to be totally cool. We need some new landscape shows.

I think that HGTV had alot of talented people this year and would love to see several of them picked up for shows. WAY TO GO, HGTV!

Posted by Betty – September 11, 2007 10:35 PM

We want WILL & Sparkle! We want WILl & Sparkle! Will outshined everyone from the beginning! The two female judges just didn't like him (from the beginning). It was so obvioius.

We need fair, unbiased judges. We also need contestants with talent! Who was the first lady who was eliminated? What was she thinking? HGTV missed the mark on this show. The competition was not very good and the two finalists definitely were NOT the best! Last year, it was sooooooo hard to choose. This year....sigh. I voted for Kim because she had the best design. Not only did Todd not listen to the judges, his room looked like something my teenager could have done.

Posted by Stephanie W – September 11, 2007 10:32 PM

Good luck Kim! What a beautiful room. So very classy. You will get my vote very day til Wednesday.

Posted by Cristy – September 11, 2007 10:22 PM

I really want to emphasize that allowing cell phones to vote 5 times per day highly favors young, urban types. If I can capture my daughter, I'll ask her to text message a vote for me, but that would be a rare opportunity. I'm casting my one computer vote per day for Kim... I was on the fence until this week, but her Hawaiian design was clearly superior and her personality is far easier to identify with. It is true that TV show hopefuls should consider their audience. I found Todd's nude woman T-shirt to be extremely offensive. Doesn't he know his would-be audience is 99% female? Don't forget folks, Todd let spill on his blog who was eliminated from the final 3 before we even got to see the show! Go, Kim. HGTV: Keep Vern as a judge, but let's vote the other 2 off. And stop the cell phone advantage. Let people call in to an automated robot instead. We all have real phones.

Posted by Lisa S. – September 11, 2007 10:07 PM

Kim definitely has my vote! And the judges are right when they say she has grown the most as a designer. My favorite part is when she took the advice of the judges - unlike Todd!!! - and ripped out that carpet. She demonstrated her tenacity to take on whatever came her way. And so often, isn't that how life really is. She didn't know what was underneath that carpet but she moved forward and with some input from Will, they made a great decision! She remained calm when it got crazy and she blended design with functionality! Todd has some amazing ideas that definitely have their place but Kim takes the cake on this one!!

Posted by Crystal – September 11, 2007 10:04 PM

Todd makes for interesting TV but Kim makes beautiful rooms. Next year lets have a landscapers design star and see if Todd can excel outdoors. He is not quite up the the challenge indoors. Will should have a shot at a Design on a Dime team or an assistant on another show.

Posted by Dale – September 11, 2007 10:03 PM

Sorry MAM...but I have to disagree with your "color is over-rated" statement. Color is a very important part of any design - whether it be interior design, artwork or just everyday objects in general. Many people chose their car because of its color, or an appliance or clothing or my oh my...the color of their hair from a bottle!
And I really don't relish the thought of painting my room all the time with the changing of the seasons. I look for style and design that will stand the test of time. I think Will and Scott were two people that really understood color and how important it is to design, along with space planning and functionality because my opinion is that most people want a nicely decorated home that functions well (yep...I said decorated). And having said all that - in my humble opinion Todd had great ambitions, great visions ( I personally liked his .99 challenge for its creativity)..and he can certainly come up with the most outrageous ideas...but just being the most daring and most outrageous doesn't always equal successful design in a day to day living space.

Posted by Pret 07 – September 11, 2007 9:59 PM

Just a few points: Voting for Kim, but without any real enthusiasm. I agree with the wave of support for the far more personable and entertaining Will and Sparkle Josh. The show desperately needs new judges, ones who won't be so blatantly influenced by a candidate's looks and ones who are all actually interior designers and will provide honest and direct critiques. Too many team tasks. Two, at most, would have sufficed and one would have been optimal. No more double eliminations. Did the producers lack confidence that the viewers would stay with the show for 11 or so weeks? If so, shame on them. BTW, does anyone find it ironic that our "distinguished panel of judges" did NOT put Will in the original top 10? And, would he have been in the final two if only he had taken his shirt off a few times and broken a table or two? Or perhaps if he had tried to reignite the conflict between Kim and Robb the way Todd did. Classy, Todd. Finally, I think that the way losing candidates are dismissed is extremely callous. I fervently hope Season 3 brings needed improvements, including leaving Las Vegas.

Posted by PsychHal – September 11, 2007 9:40 PM

I'm just totally excited that we'll have a new show on HGTV. Between Kim and Todd I, I've been trying to envision the type of show that would go well with their skills and personalities. Kim's gifting seems to center around Feng Shui...and client mood matching (already she's proven to the world that the school of HGTV produces valedictorians too). Todd, with his creativity reminds me of David (2006 winner)...he could have a show that gives a modern touch...something futuristic. He could also do a show on creating the perfect focal points. I'd definately watch either show. Please don't make me wait too long.

Posted by Neenee – September 11, 2007 9:38 PM

GO KIM!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I love her energy! She is so fun! Not only does she deserve to win this competition, I believe she will bring a new viewpoint to the same-old-same-old shows on HGTV. (zzzzzz) Who said a Kim-and-Will show?? GREAT IDEA! we all love them both. 2 great smiles and personalities-- I hope hope hope we get to see more of them. But, I am sure if HGTV is stupid enough to let Kim go, some other network is waiting for her!

Posted by Maura – September 11, 2007 9:38 PM

This show is fantastic! The only aspect I don't like about it is Vern. He's so plastic and underneath what he thinks is a "nice guy" exterior I detect is a mean man. I watched his show the other night. I thought, "How can he give hosting advice to the competitors when his own on-air delivery is dead-pan and boring?"
He seemed a lot nicer on Trading Spaces.

Posted by Liz Brown – September 11, 2007 9:23 PM

Kim has my vote. She designed a hotel room that was tasteful. She also has great host skills. I felt that Will should have been given another chance--and that this year's show was too rushed.

Posted by Noreen Connell – September 11, 2007 9:13 PM

I agree with another poster's comments about the poor choice of judges for the show. I Would have loved to have seen Michael Payne, Candace Olsen and maybe David Bromstadt and/or the Freestyle guy as judges. WHAT WAS UP WITH CYNTHIA RAWLEY'S BLATANT FLIRTING WITH TODD?? They should have just gotten a room....a nice blue room with a half-pipe in it...and ridden off into the sunset. This vote is easy. It would have been a real face-off if we saw Kim up against Will. Will was absolutely the best designer of the group. Pair him with sparkle Josh and Kim, who can join in hosting and you've got a show I'd like to see.

Posted by stormskyblue – September 11, 2007 9:05 PM

Another comment: Why only one vote from the computer and 5 from a cell phone? This is not fair to those of us who only have a computer to vote from. It limits us to only 4 votes! Why can't both of us have 5 or only one on each. It does not seem anyway fair to me. Does anyone else feel this way? Also I agree with some of the comments about a landscaping design star show - how about it HGTV? A fresh idea....
Again, new judges PLEASE

Posted by Rene – September 11, 2007 8:37 PM

Design Star Todd?????? NO WAY! It's Kim all the way Todd was so out of the hotel suite style, it was awful. Kim nailed it right on the head. Her room was fantastic so relaxing and inviting. I hope she enjoys her new career as the next Desgin Star way to go Kim!!!!!!!

Posted by audrey – September 11, 2007 8:35 PM

I think it's time for Todd to "get back in his box"
The only thing he seems to be able to create is beach looks, and his favorite crayon is Blue.
I agree Todd would be great on a kid's show , but only if they like blue. (if he can manage to keep his shirt on and tone down the Whoo Hoo's.)
Kim you Rock !! you have great ideas, talent,and not ashamed to admit there is always room to improve .You have proven yourself through out the shows.
Best of Luck with your new show ( maybe you can get Will to assist you ) you both compliment each other's styles nicely. I'll be watching for you .

Linda

Posted by Linda – September 11, 2007 7:54 PM

I watched the final episode only because I love HGTV and I appreciate their programming. Of the two designers we were left with, Kim is clearly the best. I am sooo glad we don't have to look at Todd's armpits anymore.

A final episode with the best designers, Josh, Will..., would have been such a joy and excitement to watch. Have you signed Josh up for a show yet?

HGTV, please give us better judges next year. Someone really competent, such as the best designer currently on TV - Lisa LaPorta. She is such a clear thinker and her ideas are so on target -- I know she could really do an excellent job culling out the talent.

HGTV, please don't let us down so badly again.

Posted by Lisa – September 11, 2007 7:52 PM

I want Kim to come and design my home. Todd can do my boys rooms. My house would be great then.

Posted by ZsaZsa Rendeczky – September 11, 2007 7:49 PM

I have enjoyed watching both seasons of Design Star, and that is something considering I don't even like "reality" TV. It was obvious about halfway through though, that Kim and Todd would be the 2 finalists. I can't BELIEVE that anyone would think Sparkle deserved to be in the finals. I hope Kim wins because her designs are always interesting and inviting, and she does a wonderful job in front of the camera.

Posted by teacher4 – September 11, 2007 7:40 PM

I JUST WATCHED THE VIDEO "STRATEGEY COUNTS" & IT IS VERY INTERESTING THAT KIM SAID ROBB WAS THE ENERGIZER BUNNY FOR HER BUT THE NEXT DAY HE FELL ILL & WAS NOT ABLE TO PERFORM FOR TODD UP TO HIS EXPECTATIONS. TODD COMPLAINED TO CLIVE THAT HE HAD SO MUCH TO DO. CLIVES ANSWER TO DUDE WAS "GIVING ROBB TO KIM 1ST CAME BACK TO BITE YOU" SOMEDAY THIS DUDE WILL LEARN THAT HIS STRATEGIES DO NOT ALWAYS WORK.

Posted by pf – September 11, 2007 7:29 PM

(I will try to post again- don't know why my 1st try didn't make the grade to get posted yesterday???)
Kim is the winner hands down. Her sense of style, color and design came shining through in the "tropical punch" she put together. Kim has a calm, pleasant hosting style that puts the viewer at ease immediately. If given enough time, I'm sure Kim would be able to do a "Trash to Treasure" or "Here's How You Can Do This At Home" type of segment on the elements she made herself. These could include items such as the neat screen she put together (in very little time) that separated the kitchen from the rest of the suite, and the luscious light tropical leaf on the mocha wall motif design that took the place of a headboard in the bedroom. Kim is proof that you do not have to have a degree in interior decorating or design in order to have a clear idea of how to bring together many elements that reflect different styles. She is always spot on in choosing accessories that pull the "theme" or feeling that was desired in the room together.
Her competition often overlooked or simply did not choose accessories that fit the style of the rooms.
Will is an EXTREMELY likeable person, with such personality that makes us all want to cheer for him. He has a marvelous sense of style, and did a fabulous, caring and thoughtful job on the room for the young lady with a disability on the next to the last show.
Will was also was able to calm Kim's panic in a MAJOR way with the flooring in her suite by suggesting that she pull up the carpet and treating the floors in an appealing manner. He just needs help in polishing his presentation in hosting, and he will be an excellent addition to, or host of an HGTV show. PLEASE HGTV DO NOT OVERLOOK THIS TALENTED MAN!!!!
Kim is the winner in Design Star 2, but definitely keep Will in the running for assistant or use his talents in some way!!!
Todd needs no further comment--Kim has "stolen the show!"

Posted by Sara T. – September 11, 2007 7:15 PM

I was not impressed by Todd's design. I thought ahead that Todd is more capable because of his background. As much as I would like for him to be the finalist, he truly screwed up. There was nothing catchy or unique in the room. Kim has more basic design ability but she is more predictable and has great sense for color and style.
My vote goes to Kim, she will be a great designer and presenter who will work well in any situations.
Good luck to them both.

Posted by Edie P. – September 11, 2007 7:13 PM

I think that Sparkle and Will should join forces on their own and start a design company. They can play up the fact that they were on DS 2007 and get lots of clients. They would be on every talk show in America. It would be great if HGTV saw the benefit of giving them a show. Unfortunately, only one person gets their own show.

In reading the postings, I agree with all of the Todd comments; i.e. needs to keep his shirt on, grow up, etc., however, he would make a great designer for a kid's only show. Maybe he could teach kids about carpentry, art and design. That would be a great show. He would appeal to the kid's as he is still one!

Most of the comments were pro Kim. I do hope that everyone is voting to the max so that she wins. She would have been my third choice after Sparkle and Will. So I am voting for Kim, everyday.

Posted by Islander – September 11, 2007 6:53 PM

my vote is for Kim =o)
HGTV?? ever think of having a landscape design star competion?? You really could use some new landscaper shows

Posted by Sage – September 11, 2007 6:41 PM

Just a comment - someone mentioned Cynthia's Hot Pants WELL what about the Pink DRESS???? Did she get it from the kids section? She is someone who is deciding on how well someone designed? Aren't the two ladies fashion designers, or work for fashion magazines? Or am I mistaken? Anyhow, I thought the pink dress was WAY too short and when she got down to check the rug, I thought we were all going to get a free show! Sorry, Cynthia, but I thought it was in bad taste. Even worst taste then Todd's constant armpit show. Again, I vote for Kim (and if I could do it for Will), AND new judges for next year. I feel I know what each of them are going to say, after watching them for two years. Go Kim - still want to see a KIM & WILL show. Rene

Posted by Rene – September 11, 2007 6:38 PM

Love the show & look forward to the challenges each week. I am still in bewilderment as to how Todd made it to the finals? Who really wants a skate board ramp in the main living area?? He appears to be a surf-boy who grew into a surf-man & his designs reflect such non-maturity. On the other hand, Kim's not a puzzlement. She desires to be there. Her designs reflect pasion, elegant, & mature details. Good luck to Kim - would love to watch her on HG TV! :)

Posted by gmark – September 11, 2007 6:35 PM

Todd seems to do the same thing over and over. His last room reminded me of the awful shipwreck room that the judges seemed to like. Not real, not livable.Kim, on the other hand, without the background, takes the ball and runs in the right direction every time. Her color choices are great and appealing to many. Her hosting ability was the best of all the finalists. However, I, too would like to see Will get a show from this. He was great with both color and design and such a likable person. Even his exit was first class!!
Go Kim-----and Will.

Posted by Mary – September 11, 2007 6:24 PM

Kim has my vote by far. Her design was relaxing and sophisticated, what you would expect from a high class hotel. She is also a wonderful host in front of the camera, filling in the viewer on design tips as she describes what she has done. Todd is very creative but not practical in the least and way to full of himself. Good luck Kim!

Posted by nancy – September 11, 2007 6:20 PM

MAM, I can't DISAGREE with you more. You actually thought Todd should win with his juvenile hotel room? Those circles look like a 3-year-old drew them! And the reason he won't win is precisely because he is always "showing his self in each challenge." A good designer listens to what the CLIENT wants, not what he/she wants. And apparently Todd has a problem listening to anyone but himself. Did he hear Vern's advice? In this design competition, each designer should be designing to appeal to the masses! Like Kim did.

Posted by daisyduck – September 11, 2007 6:20 PM

Has anyone ever worked on rooms and not wanted to take their shirt off? I have, and have (taken my shirt off, that is). Puleeeeese folks they were in Hawaii, hot as hell. Kim did a good job, but Todd was consistant all the way. He never had a bad word to say to anyone, and was always a gentleman. Let's not be critical about someone who is a "A" type personality. Remember he also does a lot of skiing and snowboarding, etc. Has a lot of energy, and appears to be truly a likable young man. When his wife, brother and friend came in the room, they jumped on him, what was he to do. He seemed truly happy to see his wife. Stop bashing Todd. Todd also has expertise in working with any type of power tools, etc. I'm voting for him over and over and over, just because of so many unkind things that were said about him. Kim was great, but I loved to see Todd when he was relaxed......he had a lot of gestures I see in a lot of young folks, and he always cracks me up, he's so for real.

Posted by Lee – September 11, 2007 6:12 PM

Wow!!!Kim nailed it again,I absolutely loved her design on this,and she does very well at presenting herself as well I hope she does win...

Posted by Mary – September 11, 2007 5:51 PM

Clearly Kim had the better room in this last challenge. And while both of them were "functionality" challenged, Kim's rooms have always been at least more functional than Todd's throughout the entire season. Kim has my vote as the best of the remaining two; but I still say the best designer *and* host of the original 11, was Will.

I for one would far far rather see Will with his own show than Kim. I might watch Kim, maybe 50% of the time. I might watch Todd, maybe 10% of the time, but I would surely watch Will 100% of the time. HGTV - clearly the fan favorite here is Will. I do so hope you are listening...

Posted by Glen Bradley – September 11, 2007 5:44 PM

I thought I'd be voting for Todd at the end but his hotel room was a big dissapointment. Liked the Diamond Head view idea but I didn't like the dark blue. And having that awful beige kitchen on top of the bedroom... YUCK. Why not paint it & shield it from the bedroom like Kim did? Not only was it ugly but it gives the impression he wasn't paying attention. And I know I wouldn't be able to watch that ultra hyper presentation every week.

I loved Kim's colors, her presentation and even the concrete floor. I had my doubts that would go over in a high end hotel.
Hope she's our new design star this Sunday.

Will is truly a winner, too. It was great that he took so much from his experience in his last challenge.

Posted by Cheryl Herries – September 11, 2007 5:14 PM

WOW, Todd, I love it, I also come from a tropical paradise, and your design would defintely fit here too. Again WOW!!!! You have my vote.

Posted by monalisab – September 11, 2007 5:11 PM

Todd has never impressed me, I am not sure how he got this far in the competition. He really does seem full of himself. My favorites from the beginning have been Kim, Will and the lady from Mexico who I thought was really good. I sincerely hope that Kim wins, she has the on camera presence, she seems like a really nice person and I want her to win because she has such classy, versatile style. Todd, grow up, put your shirt on and go back to San Francisco. I watch Color Splash cos I love David's style and his personality, I would watch Kim's show for the same reason. Todd does not cut it for me. I thought his hotel room was a joke.

Posted by Africangirl – September 11, 2007 4:32 PM

I really think Todd shot himself in the foot Sunday. It was ugly...cartoonish! As upbeat as he was, Kim outclassed him all the way!

I voted for Kim at the end of the show. She really did a much better job.

I think Todd has a limited ability to do different things in the long run. He was getting stale and predictable at the end of the day. He's too much of a "Johnny One Note". His ideas may be off the chain, but it's at the expense of people who would have to live with his projects.

Posted by Juni G – September 11, 2007 4:25 PM

Kim's approach to the suite design was more in line with hotel decor. Todd went over the edge with a design that did not please my eye at all.

Talent can always be enhanced. Kim seems to the the type to listen to advice. Todd totally ignored the judge's comments. A good designer must listen to the client and to those with more expertise.

Posted by Leonette – September 11, 2007 4:20 PM

My Vote goes to Kim!!!! Although I think they BOTH missed the mark on the last challenge. They are in the beautiful state of Hawaii, but neither one of them really brought Hawaii to the Room. When I vacationed in hawaii 7 years ago, we stayed in a beautifully decorated condo that was a direct reflection of Hawaii...ie. Bamboo Furniture, floral cushions, very light and airy feel to the room.. I didn't get that from Kim and Todd's room design.
They are both good in front of the camera, but Todd has sooo much energy, it makes me nervous. Kim is much more smooth and calming to watch.
Way to go !!!! both of you

Posted by Joyce – September 11, 2007 4:17 PM

Todds room express Todds personality and style. That's not what design is all about. Design is about nailing your clients style.

I will enjoy watching Kim's show!

Posted by sunschild57 – September 11, 2007 4:14 PM

This was the first Design Star series that I watched, and I enjoyed it! I will have to say that I went for Kim. I like her style for the most part. Todd was a little overboard, unless you are young and hip. But the one thing that got me that just totally drove me nuts was when Todd was doing his presentation of his room. Is it just me or was he talking so fast that you hardly caught some of the things he was saying? I got to thinking back a little and when he was on camera before he was the same way. You can't do that. You have to speak slow so that people can understand you and take in what you are saying. I can still remember what Kim said about her room, as for Todd's I honestly can't. Todd slow down a little!! It isn't a race as to how fast you talk. No matter what good luck to all of the contestants!!

Posted by Tammara – September 11, 2007 4:13 PM

This is Design Star -the designers had to each make themselves standout. Who had the most creative ideas and who could create and construct their ideas. There should have been no copying of traditional designs. This is about creativity. They were challenged to show their designs. Wall color should not have been such an issue-it is highly over-rated when it come to the demanding challenges the designers were faced with - people are constantly changing the color of their walls just for the fun of it.Design basics should stand on their own - so you can change your wall with each season if you wish. Why do you think there are so many paint stores? And we all have experienced the mysterious ways of paint - it sure looked different in the can at the store!
Each challenge was a combination of givivng people what they think they want as well as giving them a part of each designers personal vision. Confidence is a key factor.
So as far as this entire season went (so rushed on time, and often with little or no direction)the challenges were planned well to let each person show their true self in their designs. I think Todd is the only one that came close to showing his self in each challenge - whether it was his "out of the box" mentality or his creative expert construction work - he showed himself to be true to his self through out each challenge and he left his touch in each and every challenge.
The final challenge was a poor choice by HGTV and they were not given enough time. I have never been in a suite where the bedroom was a seperate room, unless it was an adjoining room. The room has major design flaws. The bath should have been to right as you came in, closet space to the left and then you walk into one big room with the bed to the right (as Todd did). The kitchen area should have been backed up to the closet wall on the left side of the room - point is, the room need major reconstruction. Really, how often would you cook and dine in your hotel suite if you were there on vacation? Not me, I order room service or be out and about. I would not even want to see a kitchen really. But, I think Todd was on the right track. Just becasue he used BLUE twice, you all think he is hung up on the surf. And, honestly a lot of boys from California just talk and act that way no matter how old they are. He could have been from Jersey and sporting a whole different personality. So you folks need to lighten up on talking down about the way he is - he grew up there. Give him a break.
But, the point is Todd is stronger and far more confident than Kim - Kim just knows how to shop and put it all together, I do not think she could be as bold as Todd in her thinking of design. Todd could probably build the coolest eco-home on the planet and he could very easily decorate it as well. His accents were always great. He has a great sense of style and proportionment. He could build anything from a T.V. set to a Hollywood mansion. I like Kim, but she has just bumbled her way through. I think it is time HGTV steps it up and moves out of the box. We need to be the future, not just folks sitting here waiting on it. Really, you can only take so many design shows whether it is on a dime or remixing or whatever....it gets old. Sometimes even depressing because you know you do not have the money and these people will never come to your house.

Anyway - Vote for TODD- he stood up to every challenge, kept to his beliefs, and never once spoke badly of any of his competitors. He stayed out of all the bickering and actually got the others moving forward. For Todd, it was all good.

Posted by MAM – September 11, 2007 4:10 PM

I'm glad somebody finally noticed the splinters on the ends of Kim's room divider! That being said, I liked the concept of it; if I ever need an open room divider in the future, that design will stick in my my mind. Overall, I thought Kim came out on top in this challenge. She showed a much more sophisticated design appropriate for an upscale hotel suite. I loved the delicately elegant headboard. Todd's artwork would have been great in a kid's room. Notice I said "artwork." His space planning stunk. I really liked Kim's hosting skills. She has a warm presentation while actually imparting design information. I agree with other postings which have expressed a need for new judges! Vern is OK, but let's get some other real INTERIOR designers like Michael Payne or Lisa LaPorta. I have met both of them and they are wonderful people as well as excellent designers. Get rid of the magazine editors and dress designers.

Posted by Donna Ellis – September 11, 2007 4:05 PM

This year was soooo disappointing. People got taken out so fast and I didn't see enough personal design. I almost get the impression that HGTV already has an idea on what this next design star is going to do, and it is not individual work. I really like last year and the show color splash. I will be hard pressed to watch it next year if they choose to do another run of it.

Posted by sheriAnn – September 11, 2007 4:05 PM

This is like going to McDonalds and they are out of french fries. (The french fries being Sparkle Josh) I was horrified by the half pipe, the 99cent broken furniture design, surely he could had done something else with that sore thumb red beam in the living room and now I wonder if there are crumbs in that hotel bed. Sorry Todd. I like you but your designs are more like art work creations instead of living spaces. The hotel room reminds me of a restroom at a water park. Kim ! you said you hate kitchens! I didn't think you would make it this far- and I hope you are ready for all this- you get my vote.

Posted by The Dixie Girl – September 11, 2007 4:01 PM

OK....so having to look at Todd's bare chest is sooo last year. At least it's better than what he wore in the last episode. A T-shirt with a silhouette of a naked woman with the word SKIN underneath it. I mean really....who is he trying to appeal to? And this episode he's all over his buddies and hardly even acknowledges his wife's presence. OK...so enough about personalities this is a design competition...or is it? To be honest I don't really care who wins. I won't be voting. I will probably never watch the "winner's" show. This years competition has had very little, if anything, to do with the competitors design capabilities. Unless they do some major reformatting of "Design Star" next year, I won't be watching that show either.

Posted by vanalinda – September 11, 2007 3:52 PM

Design Star REALLY needs to rethink their "teamwork" design plans of the designers for the shows and give each applicant a chance to do MUCH, MUCH more independent original designing. I loved last years shows, and the chosen group of talent this year was awesome, but I came away from this year not-at-all-sure what kind of consistent genuine originality and style ANY of the potential Design Star designers actually consistently have. The double teaming bit was a BIG BUST guys! It clouded the viewers . . . and dare I say the judges! . . . ability to discern who really is richly CONSISTENTLY talented . . . because they didn't really have that much of an opportunity . . .when the field was narrowed down . . . to shine! I appreciated both Todd and Kim as delightful original people, but both seemed to miss the mark on the last challenge. Sorry Todd, I like your enthusiasm and ability to think outside the box, but your room was a disaster . . . just awful. . . again, sorry hon . . . And though I voted for Kim . . . and she deserves to win in my opinion . . . for whatever it is worth . . . it was on the basis that I'm hoping she'll grow as an overall novice designer . . . week by week . . . in her new show . . . her space design was really quite nice . . . I loved her window treatments - what little we saw of them! . . . but her color scheme just didn't blend and work together well . . . the suite as a whole turned out looking hodgepodge . . . rather chaotic . . . instead of gorgeous harmony plus which is what I look forward to when staying away from home on a vacation . . . you're a GREAT personality Kim . . . and here's wishing you the absolute best as you learn and grow into your wonderful new Design Star job! And Will . . . hope you are out there dear Will . . . your designs are my absolute favorites of all the designs that showed up this year! Judges: Strange as it may sound, I really think Will could have grown more quickly into the TV personality presenter you were looking for than Kim will be able to grow in developing her considerable but very novice design skills, as talented as she is . . . Here's wishing all of you the very best . . . God Bless!

Posted by lvdecorating – September 11, 2007 3:24 PM

Kim has done a super job. Would love to have her come help with my house!! I voted for Kim because she seems to have done the better job. If Todd would have used the big waves he had in an earlier version it would have been fantastic. But who could sleep in a room like Todd's? I would love to stay in the room Kim designed.

Posted by Turtle – September 11, 2007 3:20 PM

Kim has my vote! Robb was too over the wall on this one. Too Blue and too childish. This is a classy hotel with guests of all kinds and his designs only fit with the teenage generation.

When I am on vacation, I am out exploring all day long and when I come back to my room I want comfort....Kim's room offered beautiful colors, classis style, and best of all comfort. Kim has my vote...I am hoping that they will let Will come back and co-host with Kim... Todd maybe they could let you do some landscape challanges.

Posted by Lucy Stern – September 11, 2007 3:09 PM

If I were going on vacation anywhere, I wouldn't expect to stay in a room like Todd designed. Im telling you, I have stayed in nicer rooms for $19 dollars a night. Kim's room was the type of suite I would love to stay in. I hope she wins.

Posted by Nancy – September 11, 2007 3:08 PM

I don't think this season was as good as last - THe designs were better and the personality of those in the running more fun to watch

Kim will win - but there are too many like her already on HGTV - Todd is another David so HGTV should really listen to the viewers and mix it up a bit - bring in Josh and Will and even a few who got knocked out early - there was talent there - Todd just made more waves !! Kim will be "Fine" but no stand out - nothing I would make a point to watch

Posted by lcy – September 11, 2007 3:04 PM

Kim, great job throughout the competition. Your selections involving local artist added to your understanding of both the environment and the client for whom your were designing. All of us have talents we would like to see showcased in one form or another. With you on the air, I am sure we closet designers will learn a great deal.
Our showcase will be our home. See you soon as HGTV's newest Design Star.

Posted by tazlady357 – September 11, 2007 3:03 PM

I really enjoyed last year's competition a lot more than this year as the talent was not as good. No one really "wowed" me as they did last year. I voted for Kim because she truly had the better design. I liked one of Todd's designs in the beginning, but he is a bit too immature in his personality and in my opinion this looses some credibility with the viewers.

Posted by Rozell – September 11, 2007 2:47 PM

Todd has the talent and the skill, but Kim has the win.

Todd has been able to dazzle the designer judges (and me). I think he is likely the best candidate for a new show. But I don't think he'll win.

Why?

Because if America is deciding, then America is going to go with practicality and comfort PLUS style. That's not necessarily what design judges will vote for, but it is what America will vote for.

Todd didn't do that by moving the bedroom to the dining room...Kim did it by visually dividing the room.

Todd's is more stylistic and interesting, but Kim's is what America will want.

Todd's show would be a unique and interesting addition to HGTV's line up. Kim's will be like most of the others....

Posted by JT – September 11, 2007 2:41 PM

Todd blew this final challenge. He has "hands down" been the best designer in each competition, but this last one isn't up to the judges, it's up to the audience and I think he's going to lose. I hope not, but I gotta believe that there are more women out there watching than men and many women are going to vote for the design and not the man. Todd has the personality to be the winner and he has the talent. So does Kim. However, Todd's show would be far more fun and interesting to watch than Kim's.

I hope that even if Todd loses, HGTV uses good judgment and decides to give him a show anyway. It would be a gonzo show that many men might tune in to watch.

Posted by moneypitowner – September 11, 2007 2:32 PM

Kim won me over when she said she loved the resurgence of wall paper. I, too, think wall paper used correctly in a room can be a beautiful thing. I think she looks beautiful in front of a camera, & whether she wins or not, in my book she is already a star. Thank you Will for being such a great help to her. I am a 66-year old grandmother & wouldn't want to watch a show with Todd tumbling & jumping all over the place. I wish him the best in life, but, I am voting all the way for Kim to be the BIG WINNER!!

Posted by Nancy Webster – September 11, 2007 2:31 PM

Just had to say... if I was staying in a suite overlooking the ocean in Hawaii, I'd most certinly prefer Kim's suite to Todd's. Good job, Kim! Good luck!

Posted by Becky L – September 11, 2007 2:02 PM

I picked Kim from the get-go ... their initial interviews ... because of her self-assured on-camera presence. She hasn't disappointed me ~ she continued to improve with every show and completely outdid herself with her hotel suite. I'm totally tired of Totally Todd ~ he has some design capability but I'm weary of his woohoos and shirtless style. I wouldn't watch Todd's show but can't wait to see Kim's new show ... which I'm sure will entertain as much as David has with Color Splash! YOU GO KIM!!!

Posted by Beachy Girl – September 11, 2007 2:01 PM

So tired of Todd's and his screaming woo hoos. save it for the beach! His is out of the box but most of his designs are not liveable. Kim is very tasteful and calming in her designs and a very good host. Go Kim!!

P.S. Judges - don't bring Robb back ever - his exit was the worst all season - what a baby!

Posted by judi hecht – September 11, 2007 1:55 PM

Agree w many that Sparkle Josh and Will were better choices. So Josh was a good shopper-that's what designers do. And the results were beautiful. Will had much more poise than Todd. What do you want in a designer? Poise or skateboarding? I blame Vern (and I do think you are a grt designer, Vern) for encouraging him w the skateboard ramp from the very beginning. That was something he built for himself and no one else, and it was childish. Don't get me wrong about Kim I think she did a good job, except for the carpet and accessories, but I think Will or Sparkle Josh would have done better. There is something to be said for design experience, which both Josh and Will had.

Posted by Judith Woody – September 11, 2007 1:54 PM

Ok...get over the fact Josh isn't the final two. I agree with some of the blogs. What was Todd thinking? He moves the bed next the kitchen, and he paints the entire room blue. Kim did the best job. Also, how come in Todd's Design Star Bio he doesn't mention he's married or has a son? It's like he was hiding it from the viewers.

Posted by Theresa – September 11, 2007 1:53 PM

Once again, Todd has WOWed me with his surfer dude attitude and armpits but NOT with his design. He's very talented but much of his design throughout the season was better suited for children and teen themed rooms. Kim totally ROCKS. Her on-camera presence is natural and engaging and her design is very sophisticated. She needs some more self-confidence and a new hairstyle but she should be the next HGTV design star. Todd should go back to the beach with his other armpit showing frat-boy surfer friends where he can do his stupid backflips and scream "wooooo" all he wants. I'd never watch a show with him as the host.

Posted by southpaw – September 11, 2007 1:31 PM

I agree with the comments I have read regarding the "shirtless" designers. This is not the place for that and it comes across "cheesy". Put your shirts on boys - this is an adult show.
Bonnie

Posted by Bonnie – September 11, 2007 1:22 PM

I have heard that sex sells, however, I am really tired of looking at Todd's bare chest. It should be won on talent alone and Kim has won hands down over Todd. So - Todd - go get dressed and go back to your blue home!!!!

Posted by Donna – September 11, 2007 1:10 PM

First let me start by agreeing with what so many others have said: What a pleasure to see Will again. Not only is he a good designer, he truly appears to be a good person and that is pleasant to watch. I don't believe for a minute that he isn't good on camera; his quality came through. Will, I have an early 1960's house in S. Florida that needs to have a more efficient floor plan and update. Whaddya think????

Then let me comment on the final challenge of DS. My observations throughout this series have been that Todd is highly creative/capable and that Kim has potential but not as much experience. I was undecided coming into the final challenge. Based on their work in Hawaii, I have chosen Kim. She truly pulled it off. She created a space that I would want to stay in. One of the pieces that Kim brings to the table (b/c she isn't a design 'professional') is that if she can do it, then I can do it at home. I will enjoy watching her show and I think she will blossom (as David B. has).

Posted by Brenda – September 11, 2007 1:02 PM

Except for the initial trials with the judges where they were weeding out the final 11 people, I've watched the show every week and Kim has been our girl!! Kim's work has been amazing even though she has had the least amount of formal training. In the final challenge, she has come out as a true design artist/decorator. We would hire her in a second!!
Loved seeing Will and Robb back which makes me think that HGTV should reconsider a 2nd show where you get the designers placing 2nd, 3rd, and 4th respectively working as a group on another show maybe called Design Dilemma. Will and Robb have good potential~Robb and Todd could also do a "wicked" type of show for MTV possibly. Robb could show his abrasive best and Todd could just be the Cool Dude with great carpentry/design? skills.
Finally, when all is said and done, Kim is going to be an amazing investment for HGTV. Can't wait to see her show!!

Posted by jkatz – September 11, 2007 12:55 PM

Todd could have designed the most fabulous room ever, but (aside from the fact that he chose to do the "pre-tsunami" 99 cent room), in my eyes he lost the challenge as soon as Will and Robb showed up. To select Will because he wanted to screw-over Kim by making her work with Robb was disgusting. He could have kept that thought to himself. I'm sure we would have guessed his reason. But to admit on-air that he was such a poor sport made me ill. I wouldn't watch a show with him as a host - even if I thought he were talented.

As far as the comments on Kim not being formally trained as an interior designer go - check the bios of some of the other HGTV (or other network) design hosts. You might be surprised to find out that your favorite ones have gotten where they are through years of hands-on design experience without the benefit of a degree in interior design. But, a degree doesn't mean that you have good taste. I bet Wayne Newton's home was designed by someone with a degree in interior design. 'Nuff said.

I'm not sure who actually was the VERY best of the entire bunch since there were not enough challenges to see what kind of work they were capable of. But Kim's professional attitude, engaging camera presence, innate good taste, and ability to "play well with others" makes her my obvious choice. I look forward to watching her show.

Posted by Maureen – September 11, 2007 12:45 PM

Todd... What is going on in your head? Whatever it is, it's painted a nauseating blue and isn't wearing a shirt. Will should have been in the final two. If I had been asked (which I wasn't) to decorate one of those hotel suites, first on the list would have been to remove that gawd-awful carpet and those dated shutters that blocked off the kitchenette. I was grateful that Kim polyurethaned the floor - anything, even saw dust, would have been better than leaving that blue-grey junk on the floor. What was up with Todd putting the bed next to the kitchen? When I am on a vacation, I don't want to wake up in the middle of the night and grope around in the dark looking for the bathroom - the space HAS to make sense. Comfort is a major factor. Totally Todd is Totally Terrifying.

Kim, your new show on H&G TV will be fun to watch.

Posted by Pull Up A Chair – September 11, 2007 12:00 PM

I voted for Kim. It is always hard at this final showdown to choose your own star. Between Kim and Todd, Kim's sense of color and space are a lot more sophisticated; but Todd has much stronger hard skills, like carpentry and drawing. He is a landscape architect anyway.

However from the final result of this hotel suite renovation in Hawaii, Kim's is a much better one. Go, Kim.

Sue, from New York

Posted by sue – September 11, 2007 11:51 AM

I voted for Kim. It is always hard at this final showdown to choose your own star. Between Kim and Todd, Kim's sense of color and space are a lot more sophisticated; but Todd has much stronger hard skills, like carpentry and drawing. He is a landscape architect anyway.

However from the final result of this hotel suite renovation in Hawaii, Kim's is a much better one. Go, Kim.

Sue, from New York

Posted by sue – September 11, 2007 11:51 AM

I think the best designers made it to the finals! Will is such a great, positive person that I'm sorry there couldn't be a third in the finals. (I couldn't stand Rob's attitude so, for me, his departure was deserved but late in coming!!) Thanks for another entertaining series!

Posted by JackGrrrl – September 11, 2007 11:47 AM

Okay, not too late! Make a new show with Sparkle Josh and Will. The nation will watch. Kim can be on it too but not Todd.

Posted by S Bliss – September 11, 2007 11:44 AM

kim is going to win

Posted by randy shader – September 11, 2007 11:41 AM

I'll try posting again. For some reason my last 2 posts over the last few weeks never were allowed, or didn't come through due to a tech glitch or something.
Anyway.....my vote is for Kim. Honestly, I didn't expect she could pull it off. I think Will's balance gave her the eleventh hour support she needed. Without it, I'm not sure she would have been able to finish properly. I do love that she is not officially trained as an interior designer. I think that if she gets her own show, it gives a unique slant to it and would be very inspiring to all of us out here who are good at design but do not have the official stamp of approval from higher powers. Her media presence would validate and give credibilty to the "untrained yet talented" sect.
Todd once again treated this challenge like a college art project. I don;t think he has the ability to think outside of himself to be able to get inside a client's head. At best, his room would be more appropriate for a kid's room at a Disney Theme Hotel or something. Even so -his space planning missed the mark yet again.

Please HGTV - we need Kim, we need sparkle Josh and we need Will somewhere and somehow in your future plans. Karen H.

Posted by karen@easydoesitredesign.com – September 11, 2007 11:39 AM

I'm an addict of all the home design and reality shows. Each one of the challengers are unique in their own way & I love it. Now that I'm divorced have 2 happy & successful sons, have a college degree, survived Hurrican Ivan & Jean (lost everything)and lived after a drunk driver changed my life. I'm ready for a makeover and attempting to discover my "so-called" new life style. Since I'm on a very fixed disability budget I'm learning how I can really pull my life together with design & color. Thanks for being so personalble with your comments, people and life. Your writers & producers give me a great deal of hope for a brighter life whereas I have one of those bad yucky days of pain. Keep being my sunshine. Love all of you.

Posted by Theresa – September 11, 2007 11:31 AM

Well as a big fan of the show since the 1st series. I think as always the show gets better.WOW!! what a second series. I would have liked to see Christina go all the way I thought had a great wedding design and she should have went all the way.My personal thought is that at this point Kim is far more talented and host worthey than Todd.

Posted by Jerry McB – September 11, 2007 11:28 AM

Hey Vern - get Will to assist on your new show Deserving Design - he is a natural fit for that and we would all watch it to see the two of you work together.

Kim - you go girl. Hate to say it but everybody, I told you so. Kim was the sleeper all along and finally got her chance to really shine. Her show could be called "Only Your Hairdresser Knows For Sure" or "Permanent Design". She is the true star for this one. Again having to put up with Robb and his snooping on the second day - "Todd, they are pulling up the carpet over there...." I just knew he was going to do that. Will saved the day when the judges came around and I am so very glad that Kim had him to help her on that day and not the Robbinator - kudos for Todd picking Will the first day and getting stuck with his counter ego the next. Those two deserve each other.

Posted by jaykay – September 11, 2007 11:13 AM

Kim has so many qualities of a good designer, the most important being listening. She took to heart the advice from the judges to get rid of the carpet and her friend Will assured her it could be done. I would have liked to see Will in the final two instead of Todd. Anyway, Kim is the best choice now. And she deserves to win.

Posted by Maria – September 11, 2007 11:09 AM

The best two designers are gone....Will and Sparkle Josh.

Posted by Karen – September 11, 2007 10:53 AM

Hakuna Matata~~~~~~~~Kim~~~~~~~~You have NO worries...lol...you have great taste rich, comfortable and soothing...I'd love one of my rooms to be finished by you!...Todd cannot conform to most peoples styles - he stays on the same theme wild/beachy some would consider this style tacky especially if they put out alot of money...if he thought better he could have used a spa/retreat would have been different still than kims, but something you'ld want to say " ahhhhh...this is nice " and enjoy

Posted by Leigh from Massachusetts – September 11, 2007 10:53 AM

If Todd doesn't listen to the judges (who KNOW about design), how will he listen to his clients who are naive and just know what they like. Kim is down-to earth and awesome.

Posted by vschick – September 11, 2007 10:52 AM

Both designers have done a great job.
However, Todd needs to get his ego under control. I was so sick of seeing him without a shirt- get some class man!
Kim is very talented as well as relaxed and easy to watch.
Todd wears me out with his constant yelling and manic hosting attempts.

Posted by Kevin – September 11, 2007 10:21 AM

GO TODD GO!!!! I LOVE YOU AND YOUR DESIGNS!!
I WILL WATCH YOUR SHOW EVERY DAY..YOUR ENERGY, YOUR EYE CONTACT REALLY ROCKS!!....
KIM IS ALSO A WONDERFUL DESIGNER BUT....I DON'T THINK I'LL WATCH HER SHOW EVERY DAY.. KIND OF BORED......
WILL, YOU ARE A GENIUS MAN, VERY PEACEFUL AND INTELLIGENT.. KEEP DOING A GREAT JOB!
ROB..YOU FROM ORLANDO, ,ME TOO.. GREAT JOB!!
....HGTV..WHY DON'T DO "lANDSCAPING DESING SHOW"?..
TODD..YOU ARE MY BEST STAR!!

Posted by Karen – September 11, 2007 10:20 AM

Kim has my vote because she courageously survived more disadvantages than the others. The talent this year was just not up to last year's. Compare the rooms from the final challenge - no comparison. I was shocked that the judges had to point out to both Kim and Todd the importance of the flooring. Todd is not teachable while Kim is and the results will be her own show!

I suspect Scott is the most talented and well rounded of all the contestants, but he miscalculated his strategy. Will's overall practicality, charm and basic design understanding was one of the highlights of the show and his partnership with Josh would be a show I'd watch. Poor Christina just couldn't tacky-down her innate good taste!

Love the show especially criticisms on basic design elements from the judges.

Posted by J.J. – September 11, 2007 10:13 AM

My vote is for Kim. She clearly listened to her client and tried to give them what they wanted. She has sophisticated taste. I got tired of Todd trying to act like the young surfer boy.

In future shows I would like to see more individual work. To me the final challenge last year, starting out with the glass room, was better than a redesign of an old penthouse suite.

I also think that Will should have been in the final instaed of Todd. Will is such a gentlmen and clearly has a much better design sense than Todd. I know that hosting ability was a big factor in the decision. But, you can teach someone how to have a better camera presecnce or write a script for the final showing, you cant teach someone good taste. I would really like to see more of Will in the future.

Good Luck Kim !!

Posted by Lorraine – September 11, 2007 10:13 AM

Down to the final voting - man! where did the season go?
I was really backing Will the whole time - from the very first makeover - what a bedroom!
Sparkle Josh - his face lit up the screen everytime he was on...what a great, great personality!
And Scott - okay he really did overdo the .99 challenge but the best design element I saw in this entire season was what he did with the wall in that challenge..and the "rug" textures and colors... Would have liked to have seen more of him.

I think the thing that threw me this season was I really didn't gravitate towards the final two designers like I did last year...Season One - it was Alice and David all the way.

Posted by Pret07 – September 11, 2007 10:07 AM

SOME INOVATIVE IDEAS, TODD. NOT EVERYONE IS A SURFER DUDE. SURPRISE (SHOCK) VALUE, BUT IS IT FUNCTIONAL?? GO, KIM. I THINK YOU'RE A TRUE WINNER.

Posted by GRANDMA MELLON – September 11, 2007 9:55 AM

Kim is the best designer. She has talent and knows what she is doing. Todd is all surf city. I would like to know what he would do if he had to do a design where he couldn't use the beach scene. Go Kim!!!!

Posted by Nancy – September 11, 2007 9:18 AM

For those of you who keep comparing David Bromstad (Design Star 1) and Todd: Last night I watched Color Splash where David B. did an ocean-themed room. Then I watched the re-run of Design Star. I am not a Color Splash fan and didn’t really care for the Bromstad-designed ocean themed living room; but the difference between the two “ocean themes” was oceans apart (pun intended). Todd does not even come close to David in design skills.

Todd is definitely a creative artist as shown by his tidal wave crashing into the furniture in the first individual challenge (remember that function was not an issue in that challenge). But Todd is just not an interior designer.

On a second viewing, Kim’s hotel suite is still far and away better than Todd’s blue ocean suite. (And I thought it even was better than Bromstad’s room.) However, I would have ripped out that carpet first thing and replaced it with bamboo wood flooring; but, perhaps there wasn’t time or budget. (“Where there’s a Will there’s a way” and Will saved the day.)

I still say that Will and Sparkle Josh would make the best show. But my votes go to Kim.

Now, after the finale next week; does anyone have any cures for Design Star withdrawal?

Posted by Jane Also in SS, TX – September 11, 2007 9:12 AM

Kim - my vote goes to you! The beginning of this season seemed flat, and no one stood out; then, slowly but surely you began to shine. Your design taste, talent, and on-camera warmth were a delight to watch. Can't wait to see your new HGTV show!
P.S. You can redo my house anytime!

Posted by Sue – September 11, 2007 9:07 AM

Love this show! I think it is pretty clear why the producers kept Todd. He is interesting, attractive, unpredictable and a decent designer. He makes for good TV. But Kim so clearly has outdone him and especially in this last challenge. Todd's idea of moving the bedroom into the living room "to take advantage of the view" was ridiculous. Where does one spend the most time??? In the living room -- not the bedroom!

Posted by Gale – September 11, 2007 9:07 AM

As always Todd created a non-functional room. Can anyone explain to me why he lasted this long? Oh, and then they treated cry baby Robb to a free trip to Hawaii, what a looser. How about letting the designers pick a helper. I would have picked Will or Sparkle myself, Chistine would have been a great help in this challenge too. Next year how about putting a couple fo real live HGTV viewers on the pannel of judges because personality and watchabiliyg is as important as design talent. Finally, whats with this cell phone users being allowed FIVE votes per day! Come on, one viewer one vote.

Posted by Craig – September 11, 2007 9:00 AM

Todd thinks "outside the box?" Is there a more cliche decorating scheme for a beachfront room than ocean blue? The only things he left out were seashell pink accents and a sand colored floor. Todd would be great with his own show - designing rooms for 13-year-olds or dorm rooms for freshmen college guys. Kim designed a hotel room that adults would enjoy and she gets my vote.

Posted by Diane – September 11, 2007 9:00 AM

While I agree with many bloggers that Kim's room was way better in the final challenge, I also agree that she would be boring as a show host. I can't believe the judges think she's so great in front of the camera! She has no pizzazz. In all of the other challenges, especially the trailer, I found her designs to be mediocre. Her choices for the trailer were downright ugly. Overall, I think Todd should win hands down. His show would be fun to watch and innovative. Go Todd!

Posted by AnnMarie – September 11, 2007 8:28 AM

I can't believe that neither one of them considered that nasty carpeting from the get go. If I'm going to stay in a suite - I don't want 25 year old carpeting under my feet! Kim's room was tremendously impacted by the judges input on that. Then, when they said that Todd didn't change the drapes either -- I thought, nasty, nasty, nasty!
For me, Kim has more talent and what seems to be a willingness to learn and grow.
Todd could host a show for kids rooms as I think his style sense warrants it.
Either way - loved the series - and love that I get to enjoy the talents of David Bromstead each week because of season one. His designs are exceptional and he is incredibly real and genuine.

Posted by B. R. – September 11, 2007 8:21 AM

My vote goes to Kim. Not only was she consistent throught the shows, she demonstrated that she was flexible when the judges made suggestions about her final design. It shows that she would be inclined to listen to her clients rather than follow her own personal inspirations. Her ideas are creative, yet functional. I could happily live in a room designed by her.
Lorraine M.

Posted by Lorraine Mazza – September 11, 2007 8:14 AM

Todd has been out of the box the entire show- He would be great to design a play /game room or a childs room- he is fun not sophisticated. Don't get me wrong, there is a place for his style but it is not for everyone. I also didn't like that he didn't listen to the judges. It seemed as if he would go with his look no matter what anyone had said. How will he adjust to a clients concern, would he be willing to bend to please the customer?
Kim is classic and I enjoy her presentations. Her room was a penthouse suite. I would love for her to design a room for me.
I believe she has a whimsical flair without being over the top. She has my vote.
Unfortunately, we - all of us watching the show keep comparing the contestants to David. I love his show, his talent is different.
He is one of a kind and I think will be on HGTV for a long time.
Let's give the new guy (girl) a chance to shine too.

Posted by Vivian – September 11, 2007 8:09 AM

I have to disagree with Don's blog yesterday, I don't think Todd's design was a disaster, however I didn't find it a tranquil place to spend a vacation. I would after a day or two run screaming back to the j-o-b requesting asylum. Todd is an artist and I've never denied, or with-held props for that. I don't think that it is functional or a long term choice I could make in my home. Sorry Todd. Good Luck.

Kim,WOW. I loved the color palette and loved the spa setting. Now that is a hotel room I could spend time in. Usually hotels are for sleeping and not for spending time in on vacation. You should be out and about spending time and money enjoying yourself with the local fare; however, that suite was beautiful and I could see myself having some friends over for a drink before going out. Great job Kim and I've only voted 6 times so far...3 computers 2 days. One more day to go

Posted by Beth – September 11, 2007 7:00 AM

I want to say, I don't think Kim should have made it this far. The West Virginia house should have been her downfall. She didn't listen to what they said at all. He was a coal miner and look at the pale rug she gave them. She kept talking about dirt, not coal and got them a brown sofa............she wasn't listening. Then she took creidt for the breakfat bar and said it wasn't there before.......... what did she really do in the room other than the floor which was a bad choice? She painted the walls, put more wood over the already wood walls and did some staining. The room lacked flair and any concession to the fact that they were PARENTS and a child lived there as well. With $10,000, it looked like she spent maybe $2,000. Will could have given them what they wanted so could Todd, it looked like Kim was trying to make what she wanted. Will's design was on the mark for the little girl becoming a teen. Todd was great with his challenge to seat so many ans still make a space for the Little kids. Kim didn't even consider the fact they had a child, she still has a lot ot learn about design and listening. I don't think she should have lasted as long as she has. Kind of makes me loose faith in some of these shows when peolpe stay longer than they should and far talented people leave. Do the judges have access to the client videos before they go to judging? It just really bugs me that Kim got so praised for the job she did and she just didn't even budge me much less wow me with her redo of the "deserving family" living room. It was very bland and lacked finish. I honestly don't think she has any creativity to make a series last. It just seems like such hard work for her and I don't get the feeling that she actually enjoys doing it.

Posted by Jenniffer – September 11, 2007 6:51 AM

I live in Hawaii, and Kim really nailed the island lifestyle. So many hotel suites and condos were built in the ugly 70's & 80's in Honolulu...and most of them still look like the "befores". Yuck! Using art by a local artist (the laser cuts) and utilizing Hawaiian quilt patterns scores big points here. I was hesitant about the color choices (hot colors in a hot climate), but they all worked beautifully in the finished product. As for which person I'd rather watch on TV, no contest! Kim's it. Todd is too MTV/beerbong/frat party for me and just needs to grow up a little. He's better suited for "Sufer Dudes Gone Wild" than HGTV. Kim has spunk without the "punk", and is a pleasure to watch.

Posted by Holly Mardis – September 11, 2007 5:41 AM

It's very interesting seeing how the majority of people think the same things I've thought.

Kim rocks.. Todd is an over the top one trick show and Will is the man with an awesome talent.

Kim has my vote and I sincerely hope we see Will again as well.

Posted by Paula – September 11, 2007 4:26 AM

Kim is a first class act. She is by far the best designer and deserves her own show. Her hotel suite was elegant, romantic and serene. While Todd has talent, his suite looked like a Smurf's nightmare. There was nothing elegant or serene about it. After one night in his suite, I'd leave feeling blue. His demeanor is not suited for TV either. While Kim is very gracious, Todd is too full of himself and very immature. Go Kim! You've got my vote.

Posted by HGTV Fan – September 11, 2007 4:25 AM

I soooo want Kim to win because I'd watch her show. She really did well this week with the hotel challenge. I think she quit trying to keep up with the spazzy men on presenting the room, she didn't jump around like spazzy Todd and Robb, she just looked classy and professional. What I'd love to see is Kim and Will on a show together. I still love Will, and Kim's outgoingness would offset Will's reserved personality. Go Kim Go!!!

Posted by gayle – September 11, 2007 3:38 AM

THE MOST IMPORTANT THING TO CONSIDER WHEN VOTING FOR THE NEXT DESIGN STAR IS, WHICH ONE WOULD YOU TRUST TO DESIGN YOUR HOME? I WOULD BE AFRAID OF TODD'S "OUT OF THE BOX" APPROACH. KIM HAS BEEN THE MOST CONSISTANT OF THE TWO. SHE WILL GROW WITH HER NEW SHOW AND WILL ALWAYS PLEASE THE HOMEOWNER. WILL THINKS SHE IS THE BEST AND SO DID THE JUDGES. I THINK TODD WOULD BE GOOD IN A DIFFERENT TYPE OF SHOW. PEACE AND LOVE

Posted by Ellyn – September 11, 2007 3:26 AM

I realy loved your design,me and my sister watch youall th.Good Luck

Posted by Kathy Colddiron – September 11, 2007 3:14 AM

I realy loved your design,me and my sister watch youall th.Good Luck

Posted by Kathy Colddiron – September 11, 2007 3:14 AM

LOVE KIM, and so does my 4 year old daughter! We had so much fun watching the show together. She has grace and poise in front of the camera! She has fun design ideas the can be incorporated by mortals while appearing elegant at the same time. The only thing I would love to see more of, is, of course, WILL. He needs his own show too!

Posted by Kelli – September 11, 2007 3:08 AM

This is the only episode I've seen, so I can only judge by what I saw this week. I liked both designs but I preferred Kim's. I think blue is overdone as a color in an ocean-view place. Don't compete with Mother Nature! Also, regarding switching the rooms: I would rather have my bedroom where I only sleep and do other things I keep the curtains closed for. (Who wants to change their clothes with windows all around?) I'd want to sit eating watching the ocean. I did like his artwork and the dining room was nice.

Everything about Kim's room was fabulous. I loved the woodcuts and room divider. Beautiful. I liked the concrete floor--it gave the room texture and is much easier to clean up when you coming in from the beach dripping sand and water.

And then there's personality. I barely was able to stomach Todd's 3 minute introduction to his room. He's how old? 35?? He was acting like a teenager. He looked and sounded ridiculous, with the split-finger thing which looks dumb period. He also rushed, trying to fit too much in, and was difficult to follow.

Kim was easy to understand, clear and concise, highlighting that which she had time to discuss. I would definitely be willing to watch a show starring her.

Posted by Kelly Hawkins – September 11, 2007 3:05 AM

Reading people's comments is like seeing the film Roshomon. We were all watching different shows! I wish the comments were more respectful toward both the contestants and the judges. I think this season's contestants were more evenly matched in talent. The first Josh was dismissed before we could see his talents fully; Sparkle Josh should have stayed on the show a bit longer. Christina was, I think, eliminated unfairly. A client shouldn't be given the power to determine who goes or stays on the show. Robb was allowed to be incorrigible and should have been advised behind the scenes to be civil. He had energy and raw talent but would never had made it as an acid-tongued host. I liked Will for his sincerity and ability to listen to what the clients wanted as well as his classic design ability. Todd was at times exciting and showed great artistry, though he made me exhausted just watching him. Kim grew throughout the shows and nailed the last competition. I voted for her but wish Will was in the running. I, for one, would like to see more diversity in the designers on HGTV.

Posted by Beth Anderson – September 11, 2007 3:03 AM

I must have missed the part where they told Todd that he was designing the play room at the hotel's daycare center, while Kim was designing a luxury suite.
That blue room was so utterly depressing! A black suede couch and a cut-out headboard, wooden jellyfish, bubbles coming out of the lamp onto the wall behind the bed. Was it an aquarium? Was it an old Vegas dive? Or was it an aquarium IN Las Vegas sitting in Hawaii? A bad dream...that's all it was honey...a bad dream...we'll go back to the desk and they'll give us the keys to the luxury suite we paid for...It'll be OK, you'll see.

Posted by stormskyblue – September 11, 2007 2:36 AM

I'm not sure if this information has been posted already and is old news but I just wanted to let everyone know that Scott is Tyra Bank's designer! I saw her 1st show of the new season in New York and he either designed or helped design a pre-school classroom. It was really good!

PS
Go Kim!

Posted by Nicky – September 11, 2007 2:17 AM

I wish them both good fortune. And, I believe that overall Kim
has exhibited the best combination of design, humility, humor
and honesty. I like that she understands that Design is a work in progress. And, that its not always fun, or easy.

I felt that she conveyed the warmth and sincereity necessary to put all future home owners at ease, whether they be a superstar
or a coal miner. This last challenge proved , that she was open to last minute changes, such as taking out the carpet and
glazing over the concrete floor. I would suggest that in future episodes that you bring back Will as a co host.

Posted by anabella – September 11, 2007 2:09 AM

Love to watch the show. I found it interesting that Kim and Todd did not even address the flooring until the judges mentioned it. Even though Todd seems like a nice guy, he's not a designer/space planner. There is NO WAY a hospitality client or a guest would accept placing the bed away from the rest of the bedroom/bath amenities! He had the same problem with the previous challenge, not space planning the sectional so that the homeowners could view the TV comfortably. Kim did a great job on the suite and will be a terrific host. And to top it off, she seems to be a really sweet person. Good Luck to Kim!

Posted by W – September 11, 2007 1:46 AM

Kim wins, hands down. She is warm, caring, listens to what people say, and can take advice. I would let her design for me. The final mistake Todd made was when he tried to trip Kim up by selecting Will as his helper and was hoping that Rob would cause Kim to fail in the final analysis. He hurt himself. First by underestimating true class when he sees it, and then when Rob responds to Kim so positively that he is absolutely physically worn out when he has to assist Todd. Good manners, good design, good presentation, and a friendly manner will bring in television audiencies to watch Kim's show. I agree with some others, Will should be given guest status on a recurring basis. They work well together with mutual respect which comes through.

Posted by Rascal Annie – September 11, 2007 1:43 AM

Todd has shown talent throughout the season. He can do more than put pretty items bought from a store into a room. He creates the room. Aren't there enough shows on HGTV already with host that can paint and purchase items? It's time for a show with a host who can think outside the box and bring the WOW affect to a room. It seems many are only voting based on the last show. And yes, Kim did beautiful work with helpful suggestions from Will and the judges.

Has everyone forgotten the unfinished rooms Kim worked on? Did you notice how all season Todd got along with everyone and never had problems finishing his designs/rooms, many with custom made items? Also, as far as only being able to work in California for teenagers...maybe you missed the beautiful family room he built a few shows back? That family was overjoyed at his work. I personally would love custom made shelving, artwork and other pieces around my house. I wouldn't hire a designer to make my house look like everyone's house in the neighborhood. I already have Pottery Barn.

My vote is for Todd!!!!!!

Posted by KD in SF – September 11, 2007 1:36 AM

Because the individual challenges were so few this season, I was really anticipating this final challenge. I like both Kim and Todd... but I have to say Kim blew Todd out of the water! Todd's room reminded me of those themed hotels at Disney World. Great for the kids but for me... not so much. He has a great personality and is a decent guy but I can't see him having a show unless it was specifically geared toward over the top and out there design. I do wish him well though. Kim's design on the other hand is exactly what a hotel room on a tropical island should be. Peaceful, soothing, and tranquil. The space was planned and executed very well and the colors were great. Thank goodness Will came through with the brilliant plan for the floor! He has a bright future ahead of him. Also, Kim's natural flow and relaxed ease on camera really holds your attention. Well Kim has my vote now that I've seen what they can really do. Kudos to both for having the guts to pursue their dreams!

PS
Design is art and art comes from within. Yes there are technical aspects that are a part of it but without the natural talent you are not a designer. Taste cannot be taught just like you can't actually 'teach' art (art school in my opinion is an oxymoron). So the idea that because you don't have 'formal training' then you are not or can't be a great designer is ridiculous. Go Kim!

Posted by Nicky – September 11, 2007 1:30 AM

Don't forget Scott, when they said his work was the best, he just overstocked' his room. Should have had another chance....Just think of what he could have given us.

Posted by EGGZ – September 11, 2007 1:26 AM

Although I liked both of Todd and Kim's designers, ultimately, I thought that Kim was a better designer - especially in the final challenge. Also, I am looking forward to getting some DIVERSITY in designers on HGTV.

Posted by Lianda L. – September 11, 2007 1:19 AM

I truly enjoyed last year's series but thought this season was lacking -- and I sensed a pattern not only of the types of designs the contestants were to do but also the reasons behind (and timing) of their cancellations. Makes me wonder -- for the first time--if the outcome has been rigged.
That being said, I think Kim is definititely the winner. Will has beautiful taste and I think he should have been in the final with Kim. Also, I was sorry to see Sparkle Josh go. I thought his "Celebuteen" room was exactly what he wanted it to be, and my pre-teen granddaughter would love it and not think it was cheap looking. (But come on, judges, it was a 99 cent store, after all.) Scott's room was really pretty, if a little overdone, but infinitely better than that smashed up mess Todd did. He should have been booted from the competition for that one.
I don't understand the judges on that score, but I guess "designers" are pretty much into that avant garde stuff, even though us mortals don't get it.
As for Todd--time to grow up! You're 35!! You're designing for PEOPLE -- not surfer dudes!

Posted by Eva – September 11, 2007 1:16 AM

This show has been a lot of fun this season. I loved Will's, Sparkle Josh's and Kim's designs. I am from Queens also, and I am quite pleased to have a hometown girl in the top two. The Tropical Punch suite was beautiful! Kim definitely has my vote!

Posted by Chey – September 11, 2007 1:12 AM

Both rooms were terrible. From a design stand point you are in Hawaii the view is what you are there for... both rooms had color on the wall that interfere with the beautiful views. While the rooms started out looking very dated both "designers" went completely too far in their color choices. Todd's idea of moving the bed to the living area was completely idiotic. It makes the apartment into a studio. Kim's complete lack of dealing with the floor is a disaster... concrete floor in a penthouse, sorry but no. While her color choices are more diverse than Todd's they are still overwhelming. Overall Todd's was the worst. Kim at least had good alignment of the elements and repetition... something that Todd does poorly.

The show I want to see... is the Kim and Robb show. It would be awesome to see them fight each other every week. That is the drama... like all other great shows where there is some tension between two characters. Kim and Robb made this season worth watching.

Posted by jump07 – September 11, 2007 1:01 AM

Kim's room was clearly the winner. She got my vote and I hope she wins.

Posted by Cheryl – September 11, 2007 12:52 AM

Kim, Kim, Kim! I, too, miss Will and his warmth and skill, although I had to agree that his room for that teenage girl WAS beautiful and exactly what she wanted, but a bit impersonal, as one of the judges noted. Like so many others here, I just miss having Will as a part of the show.

There is no way that anyone but Kim should win at this point, though. I think viewers would get tired of his hyperactive, frenetic enthusiasm, and would prefer a host who is articulate and can convey some information about design in the presentation. Kim's work is superior not only in her composure and presence in front of the camera, but in the content of her talk and in the DESIGN!

I found Todd's "art" to be juvenile and uninteresting. He did do a great job of using the outdoor environment in his presentation, a big plus, but that was the only way that his work was any better than Kim's. She has the skill, design talent, warmth, and composure to appeal to viewers week after week. How many blue rooms with waves and sea life would we want to see next year? I've had enough, thanks. And he can put his shirt back on, too. Better a mature presence, CLOTHED, than more foolishness from the shirtless wonder. My vote has been with Kim for weeks, and tonight just was the icing on the cake. Go, Kim!!! You rock!

Anne

Posted by Anne – September 11, 2007 12:48 AM

Kim sopishitcated,,,,that's wehre I want to be..Todd...a Santa Cruz surfer...each has it's own appeal...I just didn't like all that BLUE, adolesent unmathchning, or otherwise.....and room replacment...if I was going to spend a holiday in Hawaii...I would prefer..Kim's romm!!!much more luxcious.. that's where I would be....luxciating.....sp??? What am I in Hawaii for??? depends on one's perspective, of course..
Great show...enjoyed every Sunday...

Posted by ainman – September 11, 2007 12:48 AM

Kim, you rock girl. Love your suite, great color pallet. When you win, because you will win, if HGTV allowes you to have a side kick, I will choose Will, he was great also.

GOOOOOOOOOOOD LUCK KIM : )

El Centro,

Posted by Martha Lopez – September 11, 2007 12:47 AM

Oh my goodness! Anyone who thinks this is even a contest has to be out of their minds. Todd's design was a terrible room. If I went and payed top dollar for a suite in Hawaii and got that eyesore I would be asking for a refund. The kitchen next to the bed looked like something I would get at a Quality Inn. Kim's room was beautiful, relaxing and extremely well done. She is a joy on camera and someone who would really hold my intrest. I feel like I would get ideas from her on how to make my own house work. I feel like Todd would show me how to make a carnival ride. He didn't even tell me how to make the things or why they worked. Why would I watch a show that just showcases what HE can do? Please, vote for Kim. We should vote for the person with the most talent, not the person with the six pack.

Posted by Courtney – September 11, 2007 12:45 AM

I vote for Will! Todd just isn't a designer and Kim has done weird floorplans and does detail, not a whole space. The gold room with the blue just didn't work for me at all. It's Hawaii - you don't need warm colors! I think the best designers were eliminated early.

Posted by Jane – September 11, 2007 12:42 AM

Kim is amazing!! It's her show for sure. I agree with everyone about Will...we all love Will!!! Give him a show too. Will...as a Southerner, you make me proud.
Good luck Kim, your designs are totally thrilling to watch. And I know a thing or two. Can't wait till Sunday.

Posted by Judy – September 11, 2007 12:40 AM

I voted for the designer with the broadest imagination, Todd. Kim's a doll and would love to see her televised in some capacity. Alas, I didn't care for either of their final rooms.

Posted by Vicki – September 11, 2007 12:37 AM

I watch HGTV for entertainment and to get design tips. Kim is really enjoyable to watch and creates designs I like. I hope to see a KIM show.

Posted by Rich – September 11, 2007 12:35 AM

I am delighted that the final design was different this year than last. Giving the two designers an even playing field makes it much better to judge their talents. Did Kim do an amazing job, or what. Todd is great with the thinking out of the box but when all is said and done it may not be appropriate in most of americas homes. Kim has just gotten better with each challenge and she just blew Todd out of the water on this final challenge. Way to go Kim. I will watch her new design show, she is a natural in front of the camera I can't wait to see what the producers have to say, she's already great.

Posted by Susan Pariseau – September 11, 2007 12:27 AM

Todd's room was NOT a room I'd want to spend any time in at a high class Hawaiian Hotel.I did not like the reassignment of the bedroom to the front with a kitchen right next to it...closets where you dine?? I think not. A rather hectic looking blue was used, for a bedroom it wasn't restful. Again Todd goes for the big gesture and a very guy point of view...too large a TV in a place that's all about relaxing and enjoying the outdoors and NOT about watching television. All in all it wasn't a relaxing, comfortable or practical design for a hotel room. Certainly not usable as he left it. Although he seems to be a very nice and a very genuine guy his commentating is hard to watch -- too fast, too much bouncing around and too hard for the camera to follow.

Kim was my pick from the beginning and she did not disappoint me! A wonderful hotel room and one I'd pay money to stay in. And congrat's to her for having the courage to ditch that awful carpet with very little time to do anything creative with the floor. She and Will made it work. Her commentating style was wonderful and is always a joy to listen to. I loved her choice of colors and disagree with Vern's comments under the pictures on the website, they look restful to me and not at all disturbing like the electric blue of Todd's room. Great artistic island touches ground the room in it's Hawaiian location.

Thank goodness Robb behaved himself. Will is always a delight and a wonderful support to those he works with.

Posted by W.E. – September 11, 2007 12:25 AM

I agree with the majority (at least the majority of the 150 plus comments that I have read) that Kim is by far the best choice. If there was anyone who would give her a run for her money it would be Will. He was a wonderful designer, has exquisite taste, and a calm, kind personality to boot. I never heard him say anything bad about anybody, even when Robb was pushing all his buttons. I think the worst Will said was that Robb was "aggravating". That is the understatement of the year. He was much nicer than I would have been under the circumstances. As an aside, I wonder if Robb will ever see that he got "fired" for being a jerk, or does he still think everyone else is a "fool"? Anyway. Will and Kim would make SUCH a wonderful team... I wish HGTV would LISTEN to the people who has said the same thing I am saying, and realize that Will's only fault was not being as glib of a host as others. If I had to make a choice between Kim and Will, as designers, it would be a dead tie. I realize this is about HOSTING your own show, therefore the ability to actually be a smooth host is a huge part of the job, but I think that being polished on camera can be learned. Will could have learned that. He CAN learn that.

Now don't get me wrong, I LOVE Kim. She is awesome! She is the type of person that you feel like you have known all your life. Her personality is infectious and genuine, and she is such a smart person who listens to her clients. (She'll learn kitchens I bet! lol) I look forward to watching her grow before our very eyes on National TV! There is no doubt in my mind she will win.

Maybe Will can come be a guest host when she needs a break, or perhaps they can work him in somehow, because that man deserves his place in the sun too. He's equally talented. I have never been as diappointed as I was when his "show got cancelled".

Go Kim!

Posted by Tracy – September 11, 2007 12:24 AM

Kim's final design was classy and the perfect get away retreat. If I had paid big bucks for a horrible blue surf board ONCE AGAIN design I would have demanded a new room. That design was just horrible. And I'm so tired of seeing him without a shirt on. Maybe he needs to audition for a show in Las Vegas instead of the next Design Star. Kim's design was so detailed and yet showed her usual restraint. I wanted to see more of her design. I think most people could have beat Todd's design. Can he do anything besides cobalt blue and surf boarding? I would have loved to see what Will and Kim could have done in the finals. Now that would have been a great show.

Posted by Mj – September 11, 2007 12:23 AM

I thought Kim had it nailed. Her designs are Great!!! She should be our next Design Star, without a doubt. Diana

Posted by Diana Westerman – September 11, 2007 12:23 AM

I was really surprised at how great Kim's design was - so I watched the show on re-run. This only shows that the lack of individual challenges earlier made it difficult to see what each designer had in them. Will made a crucial contribution to her design by suggesting that the carpet could be replaced by polyurethane on concrete. Will said it could be done. Robb told Todd they bit off more than they could chew but Will was right and they did it. Will also said Kim has great taste - which is more than enough of a recommendation for me.

Posted by Babette1952 – September 11, 2007 12:18 AM

Kim won hands down. I don't think I could stomach watching "YEAH" screamed continuously and Todd jumping on tables (Although he is adorable). It was just TOO MUCH enthusiasm, I think he was trying to hard to have that exciting personality that everyone would want to watch. (so they would all want to vote for him) By then time it was just the two of them, I couldn't take it anymore. Poor Kim having to hoot and hollar to try to keep up with him. Kim's design was calm, classy and with no formal training? Great job. Todd's room was just a little bit juvenile, if the suites were ajoining I think my kids would love to stay in Todd's room. Todd is very talented, but this was Kim's win.

Posted by Tracy – September 11, 2007 12:18 AM

I voted for Todd! I enjoy HGTV but really love it when the host has alot of energy like Clive or Tanya Memme. Kim would be so boring, I would probably flick the channel changer until the end of the show to see the final product. Todd is fresh, original and full of energy! You never know what he is going to do - Kim very predictable, even her color choices!

Posted by Vickie – September 11, 2007 12:13 AM

I'd hire Kim in a heartbeat. My vote is for Kim! What a wonderful experience it must have been for a hairdresser, even if she doesn't win, she should start her own design business.

Posted by brodysgrandma – September 11, 2007 12:13 AM

Kim has the talent and the personality to have her own show. I loved her design, so classy and her hosting skills seem very natural. Todd is like a surfer on Red Bull, or after drinking 20 coffees. He is over the top, acts like a teenage boy and really needs to find some shirts! Todd is talented, he just needs to tone it down. I would love for Kim to have her own show, with Will, Sparkle Josh and Christine helping her out.

Posted by Vic – September 11, 2007 12:13 AM

No question - the winner should be KIM! Watching Todd is like watching a teenage boy - Dude! I think Kim has great instincts. HGTV should capitalize on the fact that she is not a trained designer but that she still makes it work - making the viewer think that they, too, can make it work. I LOVE THE IDEA OF CREATING A SHOW AROUND KIM AND WILL. WHAT A WINNER!!!! HGTV - are you listening?

Posted by Marilyn Elliott – September 11, 2007 12:12 AM

You couldn't pay me enough money to watch a show with Todd as host and designer....come on here...lol....maybe his landscaping is better than his designing....but he's a freaky guy....not one I would want to PAY for his designs in my home.

GO KIM!!!

Posted by Joni – September 11, 2007 12:12 AM

Many seem to believe that Will's help made the difference with Kim's room?

Please remember - Todd had the head start with Will the first day. Kim had Will's help the 2nd day. And both had the same PROFESSIONAL RECOMMENDATIONS from all three judges! Obviously, Kim listened & learned something! And, just as obviously, Todd didn't! (Even David B. enlists & respects input from his team!)

The results speak for themselves - & say:
Congratulations Kim!

Posted by Ilene – September 11, 2007 12:12 AM

I think they both rocked it out! They are just two very different styles, apples and oranges, neither necessarily better than the other. I think Kim is more watchable and addresses real life situations better but Todd gives a fresh approach. He is definitely "outside the box".

Wouldn't it be great if Kim got a show with Will as a co-host and Todd with Rob? I can think of a few shows that seem old, tired and done to death that they could replace...

Posted by Kim – September 11, 2007 12:10 AM

I think both designers have the potential for their own show. The final Hawaii competition was mindblowing. Kim is a fantastic designer, although she gets stressed she usually creates a great space.

Todd, on the other hand, was wonderful. He's so refreshing! The enthusiastic way he designs takes design to a all new level. Although his room choices could have been better I still think he outshines everyone and will make an amazing new design star.

And by the way, I adored his color choice. He really succeeded in bringing the outside in.

Whoever wins I wish them luck but Todd has my votes and complete support.

Posted by Ruth Wells – September 11, 2007 12:06 AM

Kim, totally! The colors were beautiful, sectional couch amazing, bedding (albeit last minute) was simplistic and wonderful - loved, loved, loved it!

Still miss Will, as always. Him and Kim need a show together. I wouldn't miss an episode!

Posted by Melissa – September 11, 2007 12:05 AM

All I can say Kim is a great designer. I would like for her to redesign my house, I hope that she is the next Design Star.

Posted by Georgia – September 11, 2007 12:01 AM

All I can say Kim is a great designer. I would like for her to redesign my house, I hope that she is the next Design Star.

Posted by Georgia – September 11, 2007 12:01 AM

My vote ABSOLUTELY goes to Todd.. I can't imagine having to watch a half hour of Kim nevermind and hour. She is only capable of one kind of design, whereas Todd mixes things up everytime. He always caters to the needs of his clients and always makes it fun. How many more designers do we need doing the same old modern design? Todd would add a spark to HGTV and could focus his show on the unique ways he uses a room. Plus he is absolutely adorable and so so energetic. You guys are crazy!

Posted by Kristen – September 11, 2007 12:00 AM

Well, Kim has my vote. I don't think I would watch Todd's show because he's not my style. I think he's very artistic and creative at what he does but it isn't for the majority. He would be fine in designing a kids room or maybe a non- sophisticated twenty something. He just isn't very mature or refined and he doesn't really have space planning figured out. (He seems like a great person though and when his actions mature to meet his age then I would be able to enjoy his show) HG doesn't have anyone on that's like him so I think they could probably use a show like that to round out their schedule but I think Kim would certainly get a higher viewership and I for one would watch. David's a little more contemporary and Kim would be more transitional. Go Kim!!!

Posted by Jack – September 10, 2007 11:56 PM

I would like to watch Todd's show while staying in Kim's hotel room.

Posted by Annie – September 10, 2007 11:54 PM

I cannot figure out what on earth the judges were thinking this season. Is HGTV really looking for a show where the designer designs for himself and forget the clients? Todd may have a unique personality and "design style" but he isn't what most of us expect from HGTV. I love David Bromstad from 1st season and watch his show every week. Surely, the judges don't consider Todd in the same league as David. Kim's design in the final challenge was brilliant--I'd pay top dollar to stay in the room she designed. You'd have to pay me to stay in Todd's room. I am soooo sick of his surfer poses and jargon AND if I had to see his armpits one more time I would have heaved!! Guess it's obvious who gets all my votes!! I won't be watching "The Todd Show" if that's what it comes down to and I watch HGTV alot!

Posted by Cathy – September 10, 2007 11:53 PM

Kim all the way. She did an upscale suite. Todd didn't. Kim listened to the judges suggestions, Todd didn't. Even last week, Todd really didn't listen to what the family wanted. Even though he included something for everyone in the room they also wanted a nice place to watch movies together but most of the seating wasn't facing the tv and fireplace.
Kim is very confident. She is a great host. Kim got my vote. Even Vern said she has a sophisticated eye, and when the judges walked in he said "awesome". All of the judges were very impressed with her room. Todd's room was a typical Todd room.

Posted by Karen – September 10, 2007 11:53 PM

I HAVE TO ADMIT FIRST OFF THAT I HAD EVERY INTENTION GOING INTO THIS FINALE TO VOTE FOR KIM SIMPLY BECAUSE I DIDN'T WANT TODD TO WIN AND NOT BECAUSE I THOUGHT SHE HAD GENUINELY EARNED IT...WILL WAS ABSOLUTELY THE BEST AND WOULD HAVE DONE A WONDERFUL JOB ON THIS CHALLENGE (HE WAS SPECTACULAR AS A HELPER AS WELL...GAVE ME CHILLS WHEN HE TOLD KIM HE HAD THE FLOOR!!!) BUT SHE REALLY DID BLOW ME AWAY WITH SUCH AN AWESOME SUITE AND I COULDN'T BE HAPPIER FOR HER!!! BY THE SOUNDS OF THESE BLOGS SHE OUGHT TO BE THE WINNER AND I WILL SINCERELY BELIEVE IT'S A FIX IF TODD WINS...I'VE TRIED AND TRIED TO LIKE HIM AND HIS WORK (CREATIVE IS THE BEST I CAN SAY)...BUT I CANNOT TAKE HIS ARMPIT HAIR ANY LONGER. WEREN'T ANY OF THE PRODUCERS, DIRECTORS OR CAMERAMEN EVEN SLIGHTLY GROSSED OUT?? SOME OF YOU COMMENTED ON ROBB'S CUTE WINK...I FOCUSED MORE ON HIS TYPICAL EYE ROLL.

I KNOW ROBB IS SOMEONE'S SON, BROTHER, FRIEND OR WHATEVER AND ALL I CAN SAY IS GOD BLESS YOU! HE'S PART OF THE REASON I FOUND TODD SO HARD TO LIKE. I TRULY HOPE HGTV FINDS A PLACE FOR WILL AND ALTHOUGH I FOUND THIS SEASON TO BE DISAPPOINTING I WILL CONTINUE TO VOTE FOR KIM, WATCH THE FINALE AND HOPE NEXT SEASON IS BETTER!! I WILL NOT WATCH A SHOW HOSTED BY TODD UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES. CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Roseanne – September 10, 2007 11:52 PM

I think Kim won this last contest hands down. I especially liked her room divider. I am tired of the "Surfer Dude" reaction to every design challenge-let's have a "wave" or the color of the ocean, blah, blah, blah. Really, I wouldn't want that in my home.

The designers this season weren't nearly as good as the top ones last year. Maybe for next year, HGTV could do some things different. For example, skip any contestant without a shirt. It's disrespectful. Next, skip some of the group challenges and do a few more of the individual room challenges. Up until the last show, I really wasn't certain what Kim's design style was.

Posted by sue – September 10, 2007 11:47 PM

Kim knocked this one out of the park! I commend Kim for her handling of Rob. What a curve ball for her. You can never tell how he will act. However, I do have to commend him as well for his most improved behavior. I was presently surprised.
I like Todd but would not want to pay big $$ for his room on my once in a life time vacation. Face it not everyone has tons of $$. Life is not always over the top and extreme!

Posted by Alisa – September 10, 2007 11:45 PM

I still believe out of the two...Kim is the best choice. However...I still stick to my guns and say Will should have been in the final two. It was so good to see Will there helping. I also still believe that this season was somewhat of a disappointment and hope the judges learn from their mistakes. It was good to see that Robb had a nice attitude change. He was still himself...but definitely became a team player...which was something that he wasn't during the whole season. Well...my vote is for Kim and I hope her dream comes true and she is the next Design Star!

Posted by Teresa – September 10, 2007 11:40 PM

Kim deserves the win based on the last show. Todd has a lot of interesting ideas, but practically not as appealing. On somewhat of a separate note, I wish this season was longer, like last season. I was not thrilled with the double eliminations. I didn't feel like I got a real sense of everyone's design style - seems like last year, there were more individual assignments.

Posted by Yolanda – September 10, 2007 11:40 PM

Go Kim!! You are amazing!!!

Todd? you gotta be kidding me....way too far out there for "normal"

Posted by Joni – September 10, 2007 11:36 PM

When i started watching the last challenge i was prepared to vote for Todd for much of the same reasons that others cited. He is unique and over the top with his own interpretation for everything. In the end, I voted for Kim because the reason I watch HGTV is for ideas for my own home. I have yet to see anything that Todd did that I would actually apply or even adapt to a real living space. Kim's designs are lovely with enough originality to be interesting. I am interested to find out what the context of her new show will be.

Posted by Subie – September 10, 2007 11:31 PM

First of all I love HGTV, and I loved last season.Color Splash is one of my favorite shows, I tape it every week. Maybe that's part of the reason I'm so disappointed this season. I would have been happy watching David or Alice last year, but this year I can't imagine watching either one. Kim is o.k., but not inspiring. Todd's the most annoying "Dude" I've had the displeasure of watching. I was sure he would be eliminated after the first solo, but the judges thought he was innovative. How many rooms can you paint blue and expect people to watch? The thought of watching him strip down and jump around the room, waving his arms has me reaching for the remote. He's not in high school anymore, time to grow up. Bring back Will, great designer, nice guy, pair him with Kim and you might have a show.

Posted by Margie – September 10, 2007 11:27 PM

Kim's hotel room was awesome last night! She knows how to incorporate the perfect colors to make everything work together. Her personality is sunny and her smile is infectious. She looks good in front of the camera and I can understand every word that she is saying...unlike Todd. He needs something to calm him down a bit, way too hyper for me. I would love to open my hotel room door and find that my room looked just like the one Kim did last night. It was calming, beautiful, warm, inviting, and very upscale. Way to go Kim, my vote is for YOU!!!! You go girl!!

Posted by Cindy P. – September 10, 2007 11:23 PM

Yes, Kim finished the better room in Hawaii-the final challenge. However overall Todd would have the best show for HGTV. The show could be called HGTV "Full Throttle" with Todd last name. The show would be fresh fun and exciting.Todd would do his thing featuring his design-that would probably have some original or exciting feature-typical Todd. HGTV has enough shows with Kim type people in them. Good designs but nothing special. HGTV get live. Let Todd and Kim have a show-Kim for mastering the hotel suite and Todd for mastering the other competitions. Let them host tgether-they would compliment each other...

Posted by Yvonne – September 10, 2007 11:20 PM

The manic surfer dude has got to GO!! His design was childish and not at all what I would want in an pricey hotel. Kim should win! Her design flowed nicely and was pleasing to the eye.

Posted by beth – September 10, 2007 11:19 PM

I HOPE KIM IS WINNING. SHE IS THE BEST. I DON'T WANT TO SEE A SURFER SHOW.

Posted by DEBORAH LARKINS – September 10, 2007 11:15 PM

All season, Kim seemed to get better and better. Todd was also amazing, but I didn't see the growth in his abilities over the course of the season (as much as Kim). Don't get me wrong, Todd is am amazing designer. But in the end, Kim takes the cake. She had an insipiring and comfortable design, with a Hawaiian theme, that could cater to everyone. My vote comes down to the room that I would rather rent for my week in paradise....that that goes to Kim!

Posted by Nolan – September 10, 2007 11:11 PM

This is "Design Star." Kim is a decorator. Todd is a designer and an artist. I had to vote for Todd. The winner is supposed to be a triple threat -- design, build and host. The only things Kim "constructed" were some wood strips held together with chain and paper plate leaves! Todd is totally out of the box and can conceive and build ideas that none of us ever would. He has my vote, since Will is not in the running.

Posted by Deanne – September 10, 2007 11:03 PM

Maybe it's just me but I have trouble getting excited about either one of the finalist having a show. I haven't seen anything from either of them that makes me yearn for more. Todd's final room was just that...his final room. He may be an artist but he's not a design star. Kim's room was the better of the two but I had the distinct impression that had Will not been there or had the judges not given her a clue how to improve the room, she would have had a much less attractive result.

So who does that make the design star? Sadly, though they are both nice people, neither one is a design star. Kim will end up with a show and fortunately for her they will pair her up with someone with the technical abilities and experience that she lacks. The real question is, who will be the new design star side kick?

Posted by Jane – September 10, 2007 11:00 PM

I love kin ...she should be next desing star. Hope you win.....love

carlos Juanchuto
miami florida

Posted by carlosalberto – September 10, 2007 10:58 PM

And the winner is...KIM. I watched the whole series waiting for Todd to run out 'tricks' and he finally did at the worst time! Didya notice Kim had act like an overzealous nut to keep up the energy with Todd? But in the end she shined. I'd watch her show.

HGTV should also do a show called DESIGNERS YOU LOVE TO HATE starring Rob. He could act like an jerk, order the helpers around, belittle them, and then say, "what did I do?" End the show with his crying monolog, calling everyone else a loser. Then, in the next episode, it could start all over again with a new crew! Whaddaya think?

Posted by Sincopare – September 10, 2007 10:45 PM

Todd's room, as ever, was a disaster. It looked like some teenage boy with no taste ran amok with buckets of blue paint. All of that blue does not denote a peaceful and serene environment. It creates the opposite effect. His "wall art" looked like it arrived from a third art class. His space planning, as usual, was deplorable. And the Judges STILL PRAISED HIM????? If Todd did not have the "Cover Boy" blond Nordic looks, the Judges would have examined and critiqued that hotel suite for it for what it is "mortifying". I've seen more talented, inviting, innovative design in a Super 8 hotel room on the New Jersey Shore.

And once again, HGTV and their beguiled producers, have upped the ante with MORE shirtless scenes of Todd, posing and preening before the camera. The viewers were subjected to an hour long imitation of "Bay Watch". What is this? The swimsuit competition at a male beauty pagent?

The viewers were then treated to a luau, amidst the posh settings of Hawii - photographed in a lush travelogue. It reminded me of a subrate episode of "Dynasty" mixed with "Fantasy Island." Reminder to HGTV - This is a DESIGN SHOW.

As for the Judges - I kept hoping that at least Vern and Cynthia would step up to the plate and REALLY CRITIQUE. Not a chance. More gushing. Judge Martha is hopeless - but at least she exercised a modicum of self control around Todd, THIS TIME, and drooled less over his surfer boy looks.

Todd did not display good hosting skills. His presentation was too rapid, appealing more to attention deficit. Once again, no substance. Kim was marvelous in every way. Her presentation was wonderful and she did a marvelous job on the suite.

Why won't HGTV LISTEN their disgruntled, disgusted viewers about this pathetic excuse for a design show?

Posted by Don – September 10, 2007 10:39 PM

Kim wins for best design.

Todd wins for best 99-cent store design - on a 10K budget.

Will (once again) wins best person award.

Posted by steve – September 10, 2007 10:37 PM

GOOOOOOO KIM !

Posted by SK – September 10, 2007 10:35 PM

Unlike most of us who view this program, I get after midnight, because mt social life dictates it.
It was a stunning show case of talent and creative ideas.
The decision is a most difficult one. I truly wish they could share in a program designed for dual personal reasons.
Kim is bright and refreshing.
Todd is over the top in a great way!
Both are gifted persons and would blend new and tried designs if put together.
So my votes will cancel each other out.
Hey network listen to what would be great for all.

Posted by tery Pompa – September 10, 2007 10:20 PM

Kin should win just for having to put up with people filled with too much ego and too little substance. She gets my vote just based on that.

Her designs are so sophisticated and her camera presence so smooth that she has too much designer start aura NOT to win.

The girl is kickin' chicken!

Posted by SageRave – September 10, 2007 10:14 PM

It's been interesting to read everyone's thoughts. I stand by Todd as I said before. As a show HGTV has to decide what their goal is. Todd will be more able to adapt to whatever the show is than Kim can. Kim is relaxed, but a little boring in front of the camera. Her show would be no different than any of the line up on HGTV. An "out of the box" show would be good and entertaining for HGTV. It's time for a new flavor of design. As far as the no shirt. Oh well. IF the producer's had a strong opinion on it, then I think it would have been addressed. IT wasn't, so, I guess it will stand. Personally, I have noticed a trend on HGTV to put their younger hosts in trendier clothes. Check out the ads and watch the girls in dresses, heals, David Bromstad w/ no shirt himself. I guess it sells. All that said, Todd's leadership skills far outweighed Kim's. He seemed to develop a team even when he wasn't the leader. He made a plan, worked the plan and delivered. Even though I had mixed emotions about the whole bedroom thing, he stood by his own decisions, which is a sign of confidence, another key component.
I also believe that in the "Real world", a hotel may have allowed more "gutting" of the room and the kitchen may NOT have been right by the bed, but in the short amount of time, it wasn't realistic to move the hard structures around. Anyway, I stick by Todd. VOTE FOR TODD

Posted by Dnels – September 10, 2007 10:10 PM

I think I have to comment first on Robb's gracious return. I was concerned that he was very upset about being ousted, but as a designer, you have to work with all involved, and his personality did not seem to be made for this. Of course, we are not able to see all that goes on, behind the scenes, either, and I was pleased to see that he was, at last a gracious second to two extremely talented people, along with sweet Will. Good luck to all the wonderful talent. This year is much harder to choose than last year was.

Posted by Sunriz – September 10, 2007 10:09 PM

I thought that my decision would be to vote for Todd. But, wow! It was no contest. Kim really won hands down. Think about it folks..if you checked into a hotel and had a choice of suites, almost anyone under the age of 17 would pick the beautiful tropical suite. Todd's design looked like an amatuer compared to Kim's. Perhaps he is a better landscaper and should try again if there is a landscape challenge. I really look forward to watching a show hosted by Kim. Come to Indianapolis Kim and decorate my condo!

Posted by Deborah – September 10, 2007 10:05 PM

My vote goes to Kim. I thought Todd is talented but he was too over the top for me. It seems every time he felt the need to have that WOW over the top factor. Great on a TV show I suppose but I don't think that is what the average person wants. What happens when someone tells him they want French Provincal?

I do think Todd is talented but it is just too one dimensional and too off the wall.

I think last season the talent was better. It seemed this season it was a bunch of design wannabee vs. people who were actual designers as a career. Todd and Kim are a hairdresser and landscaper.

Posted by Bella – September 10, 2007 10:05 PM

I would really like to vote but for some
reason the page will not load up correctly!!
please help me vote for kim

Posted by jtalley – September 10, 2007 10:02 PM

GO TODD!!! What a great Show Todd would have. So fun to watch. Kim's show would be boring and dry...the same old same old. HGTV needs to step into 2007. HGTV needs Todd!!
Todd's got my VOTE!! Good luck.

Posted by angela – September 10, 2007 9:55 PM

I voted for Kim. Her room was so lovely and relaxing, just like I would want in an upscale hotel suite or my home. I agree with a lot of other bloggers about Will and Sparkle Josh--they were great! Anyone know how the homes are picked for the HGTV shows? Would LOVE to have my home considered!!

Posted by Carolyn – September 10, 2007 9:49 PM

If I checked into a luxury hotel, expecting a luxury suite and paying for a luxury suite - if I was given the key to Todd's room design - I'd ask for another room. BLUE, BLUE, BLUE, BLUE. The only thing missing was Elvis in the background singing, "Blue Hawaii."

Kim's room was liveable, well within the Hawaiian motif and yet not quite. I could relax in her room.

Kim got my vote Sunday, today, tomorrow and Wednesday.

Posted by David – September 10, 2007 9:45 PM

Even though none of the rooms this season were even close to the styles that I love...I vote for Kim because between her and Todd...she has the best style and personality that is more appealing and calming. I feel a show of hers could inspire me more than Todd's.

But I really would rather watch Sparkle Josh, Scott, Christina or Will's shows!! They would seem to be able to deliver more variety styles of decorating instead of modern. Pretty tired of that style!!!

Thanks for letting us voice our opinions!

Cindy from Texas

Posted by Cindy – September 10, 2007 9:42 PM

i've worked as a designer for 25 years and was so impressed by kim's room. she has a great eye for color and a fantastic spacial sense. i also thinks that she's makes a wonderful hostess. she's very warm and casual but at the same time informative. personally i loved todd but i think his personality would be too over-the-top and hard to take on an weekly basis. i'd love to see him use anything but the color blue and make it work well. i wasn't impressed with his room at all. but i'd love to hang out with the guy. he's seems like a very genuine person and a lot of fun.

Posted by dee – September 10, 2007 9:42 PM

Kim wins hands down. Even though her colors, IMHO, could have been a little softer. Her design was more evolved than Todd's. If you want to sleep in the middle of a skate park, Todd is the "Dude. If you would rather stay in an adult environment, hire Kim.

If I arrived in Hawaii and was dropped off in Todd's room, I would pay to be let out. Who wants to have jelly fish and dark blue walls? Tony Hawk, maybe. The rest of us, who walk in, instead of skateboarding in, would want to run for our lives.

Todd decided that cheap looking dark blue walls and crappy, used up carpet was the way to win this challenge...

Kim did what I would have done, tear out that loathsome carpet and put a coat of polyurethane on the bare concrete.

All I can say is, Todd is the decorator to the surf bums. Kim is for the rest of us.

Posted by Pull Up A Chair – September 10, 2007 9:37 PM

As I said before, Todd is suited more for designing rooms like the show 'Design on a Dime' and not necessarily having his own show to showcase. Most of the designs on this show are awful.

Posted by Gail – September 10, 2007 9:32 PM

Can any of you imagine week after week watching Todd try to transform a room in Idaho, Montana, Kansas Utah, etc into a beach, water theme room. We don't all live for the Big Wave. Kim on the other hand seems to do what the area and clients want and she has the insight as to what they will really love and integrates this into her design (remember W. Va.) I read the blog where this design was thought to be unreal for the area - did you notice how the carpet she chose sweep up like new and fabric can be treated to withstand dirt and hard wear. She was on the button with this design. I think the last three have done amazing designs with $10,000. Will would be our second choice if we can't have Kim. Todd is definitely a one trick pony; if he painte one more room BLUE.........................

Posted by mrsluckyaz – September 10, 2007 9:31 PM

I voted for Kim. Her design for the suite in Hawaii is somewhere I would enjoy staying. Will is such a gentleman and has good design ideas. I, too, would like to see a show with Will and Josh together. I hope HGTV is reading these comments. Good luck Kim.

Posted by cindy – September 10, 2007 9:31 PM

Why is a middle aged woman as Cynthia obviously is, wearing hot pants? You bet she loved Todd's space. The two of them define ARRESTED DEVELOPMENT!

Posted by roomz – September 10, 2007 9:28 PM

Although I think Todd has a talent that would appeal to a narrow market, I think Kim nailed the Hawaiin suite. Come on folks. Would you really want to pay big $$$$ to stay in that ugly blue room with a cut out of a jelly fish hanging in the room? For those that are critical of Kim's lack of formal training, you'll have to explain to me what that has to do with taste. Kim will continually learn to trust her taste. But really, could you see Todd decorating an upscale home? ("Dude, how about a sea mural in the front foyer???) A true designer must be able to adapt. Todd was annoying and immature. Good luck Kim. You went for your dream and you are almost there!

Posted by Jan – September 10, 2007 9:27 PM

Good Gosh, what a season on Design Star. It has been an emotional ride, to say the least. This is the type of show that you love, or love to hate...and chances are, either way you feel about it, you are going to watch! If not for any other reason, just to relish the episode when your least favorite contestant gets the "BOOT"!!
I know I got to call a couple from the get-go, but one in particular, I had to wait....AWHILE!
But I was so EXCITED when this person FINALLY had to exit the studio...it is just too bad that a couple of my personal favorites bit the dust, way too early in the show. But I continue to watch, because I tend to believe that my vote may really count for something! YES, this has been a very emotional rollercoaster ride...one that I will gladly climb on again next season, just for the thrill of it!!!

Posted by Lavonna – September 10, 2007 9:21 PM

While it was nice that Kim 'surprised' us, and I commend her for that, did it occur that had it not been for Will, the end product might not have been as polished, which we know are the hallmarks of Will.

Will and Kim need to do the show together. HGTV, are you listening? What a waste of talent and readymade viewship by not giving Will his show.

Posted by Phoenix – September 10, 2007 9:15 PM

Todd's show would be the best. HG already has enough Kims. He would bring a fresh face to the network.

Posted by Brian from DC – September 10, 2007 9:14 PM

Todd is energetic, thinks outside the box, and a talented artist. (He's a babe but seriously, even as a gay man, I tire of the bare chested look).

However, overall, Kim should win. She's has a great spirit, is a wonderful host, and has classy taste and design style.

Posted by gary – September 10, 2007 9:11 PM

I love HGTV and will enjoy Kim's new show. Yes, Kim has my votes. I loved the sophisticated, tropical suite she designed, especially the headboard. Kim is warm and real. When designing for real people (even the Wayne Newtons), she makes eye contact, listens carefully, and speaks to the baby. I love in last week's challenge that she incorporated the dining room in her design. She recognized a need and filled it. Way to go Kim. And then there's Todd. Didn't anyone ever tell him that its disrespectful to jump on furniture? His design for the suite belongs in a kids surf shop, not in an upscale hotel suite.

Posted by BeckyZ – September 10, 2007 9:01 PM

I have loved Kim's design style and personality from the beginning and she designed a GORGEOUS room. It is great that someone without any design training can transform a room like that...especially under such extreme conditions! And her hosting skills are AMAZING!!!!! She is so easy to watch!!! With her total confidence and ease on the camera it is easy to believe that she was a performing arts major. She definately has my vote.

Posted by middleearthsdlf – September 10, 2007 9:01 PM

Kim has the better designs and TV personality. She gets my vote. I would like to see Will and Josh "sparkles" have a show or guest spots. I don't understand how Todd was picked over Will anyway. From what I've read, everyone loved Will. So, the judges were wrong to assume his TV presence could not hold an audience.

Posted by Cindy – September 10, 2007 8:54 PM

I on the other hand have to laugh at Corey's ranting. It is harder to create a design with monetary contraints. I have been in both situations and talk from experience rather than off the tip of my nose. Corey, if you are a designer you should know that. It sounds as if you want fairy tales and cotton candy. Life is not like that and the reason the designers (yes even Candice) do these shows is to show that design takes on different ideas and textures for each person. Wake up Cory and Katrina.... Life is passing you by.

Posted by Southern Belle – September 10, 2007 8:54 PM

Well, I felt Kim had done the best all the way thru the shows, and felt she deserved to win each time. She does handle herself well on screen too.
I got a lil tired of seeing Todd's armpits every five seconds...LOL, keep the shirt on pleese. To me Kim seems composed and confident...Todd seems like a big kid that needs to grow up and lose the teenager demeanor..he is about a decade too old for that...
Vote for Kim!

Posted by Brian – September 10, 2007 8:54 PM

Todd's room was definately interesting, but please - we aren't all "surfer dudes"! Actually, he might be a good guest designer if HGTV decided to do a show either on children's/pre-teen's/teen's rooms, or on out-of-the-box extreme design. However, I don't think he's mature enough to host his own show. Kim's design was much classier, and fit the venue. Sure, she made a few mistakes - she had a lot less time to work than most real life designers have, and she didn't have the staff that most designers (and HGTV hosts) all have. At first, I didn't like the concrete floor, but then I got to thinking - Hawaii - hot air, cool floors - sand and wet bathing suits, easily cleaned floors - it makes a lot of sense!

Of the two, I believe Kim is the more deserving to win, and I'll definately catch her show occasionally. But take note, HGTV - you REALLY missed the boat when you canceled Will Smith and Josh Johnson! Of the 8 designs rated 4 stars and up, Will was directly involved in 5, and was Kim's helper on the final challenge. He is warm, caring and personable, and his designs are superior. Josh Johnson has the flare for hosting that Will might lack and, as someone who is trying to turn a 60's plain-box ranch into something beautiful on an extremely limited budget, I could really use his help on shopping! This is why I love Design Remix and Decorating Cents with it's Trash to Treasure segment. Owners of McMansions can afford to hire out the interior designing - most of us who watch HGTV are of much more modest means, struggling to infuse beauty into our homes "on a dime", as it were.

Posted by JudyS – September 10, 2007 8:49 PM

Sunday night's SHOWDOWN between Todd and Kim was the best Design Star show so far and believe me, these shows have been super fun and illuminating. Tough choice between these two charming and talented finalists so here's my brainstorm of the day.

Why not call it a tie for Design Star? Why? Because a new show with BOTH Kim and Todd titled East|West or something along that line could feature alternating designs from them. Kim is from the NYC area and her design aesthetic is warmly eclectic and liveable and Todd is from SanFran and has a zany, "life is too short" to be bored and humorous approach. Todd is a breath of fresh air and originality and please folks, don't forget that the folks he designed spaces for LOVED them so please, drop all the frivolous surfer dude slams. He added his own personal spark to every space but he also designed for REAL PEOPLE too -- a quality which is sometimes lacking on tv design shows. Kim is a wonderful, calming, genuinely caring earthy presence but I'm not sure I would want to watch just Kim every week.

So to get back to my IDEA, a new HGTV show that features both Kim and Todd would really grab my interest and they are the perfect yin yang couple. And hey, why not hire Will and Rob to be the helpers on the new show. That frisson of friction between Rob and Kim could add some dynamism to all the pretty stuff and colors and since we all like this winsome foursome, why go casting about for other fresh faces when you have TOTALLY WINNING team in these four people who are all hard working, energetic, ambitious in a good way and creative in a way that's fun to watch.

Please don't anoint a single Design Star winner here . . . the real success formula for a REALLY WATCHABLE new HGTV show would be to see the perfect bicoastal pair - Kim and Todd - yeahhhhh!!!!

Posted by Jan Liverance – September 10, 2007 8:42 PM

I have to complain about the last show. Compared to the first season this one was a poor second.
First of all you should have given them a clean slate to work with. (the glass room) You gave them rooms with gross flooring that wasted time and engery trying to change without success. I can't vote for either one this year because I think I could have done a better job given the same cash and rooms. I love the show. I learn a lot of what not to do.702294

Posted by Carol – September 10, 2007 8:35 PM

Todd, for public space design, out of the box is fine. But Kim is for me, she is Stand and Deliver every time. A lady, warm, poised, realistic and who keeps the client in mind, is just what we need to tell us how to--in our own homes, with our own hands. As she explains her work, she conveys loads of information in an easy to understand fashion. For each challenge, she exibited grace under pressure, patience, genuiness, dignity, growth as a designer, and most of all, realism and an ability to relate to anyone.
Don't understand how Todd got as far as he did, not that his creativity is not refreshing and eye opening, but while he was building a skateboard thing, Kim was building a beautiful calm space for dining. That says it all.
I will add my vote for Kim, but I hope that HGTV is paying attention, for Will also carried himself with dignity, poise, sincerity and warmth. He also made me feel like he would genuinely care, listen to me and produce good design. He could train a bit on hosting--and who couldn't, it is not typical to be camera rolling ready---but he understood design and could make it understandable to me or anyone. Will exuded calm, confidence and patience, and he exhibited great grace and compassion even in defeat. I think the judges overvalued the hosting element with him, and overvalued the hosting element with Todd. I think they used the wrong equation on both men. I would rather see Will than Todd anytime. And by the way, on Kim's show, she should have guest designers Will and Sparkle Josh show up, now that would be the ideal team!

Posted by suzy – September 10, 2007 8:32 PM

Todd and Kim show??Neither one alone is worth a show-together it might work. I voted for Todd-even though I did not care for all aspects of the design-I did agree with him to maximize the view-despite all the negatives-I don't understand how anyone could even considier Robb or Will even as a guest -Robb's ego is a turn off-and Will comes off with at best average talent and very poor TV presence-Unlike last year-with David B-his talent was so obvious and superior not only to the other contestants but to the judges-the only way out of this for HGTV is declare a tie and see if having both will result in an enjoyable show-I could not take either one alone-Todd needs to keep his shirt on and Kim needs to be more creative-so togther it might work. Is Vern Yip really that taleneted? I guess if they consider Clive talented-it must be so? Kim will not be the Rachel Ray of HGTV-and Todd will not be another David B-they are rare-maybe next year?

Posted by Tony Michigan – September 10, 2007 8:15 PM

LET'S TO KIM, LET'S GO....YOU GO GIRL. I AM SO HAPPY FOR YOU. YOU NOT ONLY DID A GOOD DESIGN, BUT YOU ARE ALSO A PERSON WHO IS NOT FORMALLY TRAINED IN THIS FIELD AND LOOK WHERE YOU ARE!!! SO MANY PEOPLE THINK THAT THEY HAVE TO HAVE A PIECE OF PAPER THAT SAYS THEY THEY HAVE COMPLETED A COURSE THAT GIVES THEM THE RIGHT TO CALL THEMSELVES "INTERIOR DECORATORS". YOU ARE PROVING EVERYONE WRONG BY DOING SOMETHING THAT YOU HAVE NOT BEEN TRAINED IN, BUT HAVE A PASSION FOR. MY VOTE IS FOR YOU!!!!!!

Posted by Tiffany – September 10, 2007 8:07 PM

I think Todd is stuck on the color blue. He also displays a lack of maturity. Kim, however really pulled together a very classic suite.

I love Design Star and watch Colorsplash with David B. all the time.

I hope Kim is the next Design Star as she is very comfortable in front of the camera, mature, and filled with confidence about the design she creates. She points out the various aspects of her design in a excellent flow.

However, I don't think any of the people measure up to David B's beautiful designs.

Posted by Del – September 10, 2007 8:04 PM

Most HGTV watchers are looking for ideas they can use. Most of the challenges this year did not lend themselves to emulation. Most of us do not own Penthouses or Hawaian condos.

This season was a big disapointment. Fortunately, despite bad assignments, talent still came through.

Posted by Linda – September 10, 2007 7:58 PM

Oh come on y'all --does anyone really believe that HGTV is going to allow another "cool dude" white guy to win this thing? If Todd is announced as the winner - which he totally should be vs. Kim - well, that will be the surprise of the year!!! I must admit - when it didn't end up being between Kim and Will, I was really surprised. Personally, I'd love to see Will in a show with Todd and "Sparkle" -- would that be great, or what!!! Innovation - classy style - and the shopper extraordinaire!!! WOW !!!

Posted by Nanci – September 10, 2007 7:57 PM

I think Kim is fabulous. She has consistently delivered classy and classic designs that have appeal to the masses. It does not matter that she does not have design training. As Vern stated, she has a sophisticated eye. Kim is also much more accessible and articulated in front of the camera. She is relaxed, easy to follow and does a great job explaining her design choices.

While I think Todd is talented, his design style is almost cartoonish and does not have broad appeal. Oddly, while he is a year older than Kim, his design styles are too young for the general population. I think he would do far better designing for children or for those with quirky contemporary taste (e.g. Wayne Newton). Todd is a bit too frenetic for my tastes and not easy to follow.

My vote is clearly for Kim!

Posted by Lisa – September 10, 2007 7:56 PM

Was this a design show or a topless review?? It's clear the judges love Todd since he was shirtless most of the time! All that aside, Kim's room was beautiful! For a high dollar hotel in Waikiki, Kim's room reflected the class of the hotel, Todd's room looked "typical" of a cheesy hotel room. I'd watch an HGTV show with Kim but would pass on the predictible egotistacal Todd.

Posted by Janette – September 10, 2007 7:56 PM

My husband and I were disappointed to see Josh let go of so soon. Have noted Kim and Todd's talent from the beginning and Will's design capabilities, also. When it comes to hosting a show you have to look at the whole picture, not just the final product (Hawaii).

My husband chose Todd; I would have gone with Josh and what I had seen with him. I liked the work of Kim, but saw that she needed to depend a lot on Will to get her work done correctly. Could she have done it alone? I don't think so. And yet, I saw from the beginning, she had something there.

We voted for Todd because of his uniqueness. But it looks like Kim will win (It looks like she will from what everyone is writing)

We do both HGTV will bring back Todd, Josh, and Will and make full use of them. All these guys are so gifted. Don't let them go.

It is so much more rewarding watching this channel than it is watching anything else on TV.

TC

Posted by TC – September 10, 2007 7:54 PM

I ENJOYED THIS YEARS DESIGN-STAR ALMOST AS MUCH AS LAST YEARS SHOW. DAVID STILL ROCKS THOUGH. I LOOK FORWARD TO EVERY MONDAY NIGHT TO WATCH COLORSPLASH. THIS YEARS SHOW HAD ALOT OF INTERESTING PERSONALITIES, I THINK KIM'S DESIGN IS MUCH MORE UPSCALE THAN TODD'S AND I THINK HER COLOR PALATE IS MUCH MORE RELAXING AND CONDUSIVE TO VACATION THAN TODD'S ROOM. PERSONALLY I THINK TODD WOULD DO GREAT ON A LANDSCAPING SHOW WHERE HE COULD BE "OUT OF THE BOX" AND HAVE A REASON TO KEEP TAKING OFF HIS SHIRT. I THINK A SHOW WITH WILL AND KIM IS A GREAT IDEA, THEY COULD BE ANOTHER MATT AND SHARI FROM ROOM BY ROOM.

Posted by MAGGIE – September 10, 2007 7:50 PM

Loved what Kim did with her room. Very sophisticated Todd is just juvenile Todd in a blue room and surfing ramps. It was fun for a while, but not all the time. Was unsure who to vote for before this challenge. But now it is clear. Kim all the way. Go KIM!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Lana – September 10, 2007 7:35 PM

I feel Kim has some real talent. I also see her in a show that will compliment the existing shows rather then being perceived as competition. Need further variety. There are too many real estate shows and make overs that are not practical once you factor in the labor costs, which the shows seem to down play. How about some shows on how to bargain shop. I also would love to see Will get some air time. He was refreshing and down to earth. I was thrilled to see Alice from last season get some exposure. I would have loved it more to see her on camera with David, from time to time. Maybe we can see something developed for the loosers we have all loved.

Posted by Aneesia – September 10, 2007 7:34 PM

Kim did a better job. Once again Will proved to be a super gentleman. Todd's design appeared to be a remake of the 99 cent store challegne.

Posted by nonideb – September 10, 2007 7:33 PM

Kim did a better job. Once again Will proved to be a super gentleman. Todd's design appeared to be a remake of the 99 cent store challegne.

Posted by nonideb – September 10, 2007 7:33 PM

Well...from the start i guessed that Kim had the most potential. But towards the end I wanted Todd (the surfer) to win... jus cuz I thought HGTV could use a fun designer - everybody else is designing the modern way - so why not squeeze in a different way. And he could definitely work power tools. I didnt like how Kim would put a dining table next to a wall- I wish she'd dress it up more vs leaving it a 3 sided table. And i dont like how Todd use one color and its multi shades.
But in the end - I was disappointed about Todd's room. The squid was just not classy, and the blue was kinda kiddy. I wish he did better. Kim's room was definitely top design - although im not a fan of her little gadgets-or designs on the wall (like in episode 3 - her white irish flowers or something made of paper plates) in this suite she hung up white carved flowers or something.
But I don't know if i should vote cuz I didnt raelly get to see their styles - unlike season 1 - one elimination a time and they had more chance to shine. Kim won this episode, and she picks better colors, but Tom has a unique style. I dont know. I guess everyone is going for KIM...

Posted by Lokamoka7 – September 10, 2007 7:16 PM

Kim was the clear winner over Todd - but both Todd & Kim would have been in a crunch without Will's help (didn't see the other one doing as much). It might have been a more difficult choice if the final two had been Kim & Will. That said, I also thought, since David has a partner on the show, why not give Kim the option of having Will on her show - it would boost her ratings and give Will a chance to practice his "hosting skills".

Posted by Carolyn – September 10, 2007 7:16 PM

I think there are sooooooooooo many negative comments being posted here. I'm surprised anyone wants to be on DS.I liked the show this season and think everyone did a good job! I had my favorites, but they didn't make the final 2. But I will vote for 1 of the finalists and probably watch the new DS show.

Posted by sweetamenity – September 10, 2007 7:16 PM

No contest last night-todd blew it. He doesnt listen. He was supposed to redo a penthouse suite and created a teenagers room in a penthouse. I am glad though because as nice of a person as he is, I cannot see him being able to design for many on hgtv. I do think he is more of an artist than a designer. Kim did so well, she fits the part, has the talent and despite working with a tough tough egotistical bunch she rose to the occasion. I am proud of her and cannot wait to see her show.

Posted by kim c – September 10, 2007 7:13 PM

One last post. HGTV really lowered the bar in this season's Design Star. I personally felt like they tried to "dumb down" the show for us the "dumb viewers". I was insulted. Then, I read all the viewers comments and how much they all simply adore Kim. So, maybe the HGTV powers that be know more about their average viewers than I do. They really are mostly dumb. They liked Kim. That's all the proof I need.

Posted by katrina – September 10, 2007 7:13 PM

My vote goes to Kim! No doubt she is the best of the two finalists. Todd became a bit of a bore after a while. Good luck Kim!

Posted by Kathy – September 10, 2007 7:12 PM

I don't think any of the designers from this season hold a candle to the cast of the first season. No one stands out as a clear winner. David made HGTV fun to watch again with his down to earth demeanor and amazing, out of the box ideas. He had to earn it last year from a cast of GOOD designers. This year, everyone is mediocre at best. I don't think we saw the best two last night, i think we saw the two who were left. There is no excuse that Will isn't in the final two. Todd's stuff is too concerned with how 'cool' can it be, but there isn't much practicality or beauty in his designs. And Kim's lack of experience shows often, I think she REALLY benefitted from having Will on her team on day two, his ideas were strong throughout the entire show and I think it saved her from a disaster in the final challenge.

I can't imagine what show either Todd or Kim could possibly host that I'd bother to watch. I couldn't take advice from Kim who clearly doesn't have a clear idea what she's talking about or doing. She got by this season mostly by staying under the radar of more dramatic people who got themselves 'canceled' and teaming up often with better-minded designers whichh made her look better. And Todd, while apparently good with building and fabrication, doesn't seem to have enough knowledge of design to be able to advise. Todd only does what Todd likes, but that doesn't work for everyone, and how many shows could he do before it's old (it already is).

With all the group tasks, there was no way for the contestants to really show what they can do. I think last year was great, this year seemed rushed, the challenges poorly thought out and no variety and I agree with the person who said that the female judges seemed to be drooling all over Todd. One said, "Yeah! I'd watch Todd's show!!". I say, why? to see him with his shirt off? What would the draw be on the second episode, or how bout for those of us who aren't interested in seeing his nakedness? It seemed to me that Vern was the only one really seemed to critique design. The women seemed to just nod, smile and drool over Todd. How bout let David B. judge next year next to Vern.

I hope the other designers who didn't make it to the end don't take it too hard. They weren't defeated by 'better' talent, they were just victims of TV drama. Many of them are way better talents than the last two.

But of the two, I'd have to say Kim seems at the very least more mature. I don't know what shows either of them would do that would be of any interest, but I don't think i'd watch em. I'll be watching Color Splash.

Posted by Steven Wolpert – September 10, 2007 7:07 PM

Was it luck or what that Kim had Will second? He calmed her fears and helped her those that awful carpet. Is Will good or not? Robb surprised me. He seemed geniunely helpful to both Kim and Todd. Why couldn't he be this way during the competition? He shot himself in the foot with his ego. This is a real tough decision. Todd is totally "out-of-the-box". Kim is totally classy. Too hard to decide. Guess for now, I'll have to leave it up to the others.

Posted by Julie – September 10, 2007 7:04 PM

Poster Corey: You make more sense than any other post I have seen on here. This entire show talked down to the HGTV audience. We are not all dumb clucks. Some of us have sophisticated tastes and would like to see some real design by some real designers. I am sorry HGTV but this entire season was a BIG DISAPPOINTMENT.

Posted by katrina – September 10, 2007 7:02 PM

Producers - I COMPLETELY AGREE with everything "debles - September 10 at 6:19" had to say. Last season just seemed a bit more down to earth & realistic. Definately do not like the multiple eliminations.

Posted by Stefani – September 10, 2007 6:59 PM

Yes, Kim's suite was better in this challenge, and she has a great personality. But I'm afraid Kim is guessing about design--lacking the formal training--and her color choices for this room did not work well. In the previous challenge Todd was a clear winner. And his television presence is very good--enthusiastic. He works, however, within a box--limits himself--to a "sporty young guy" aesthetic. Too bad. If he can break with that--really work in a CREATIVE WAY--he has more potential. He knows design principles, so I'll put in a vote for Todd. Neither measures up to David Bromsted.

Posted by lonnie l – September 10, 2007 6:58 PM

Ya know I've liked Todd throughout was a little worried about the presentation but he did a great job his last couple of challenges. I really like Kim too and think she does a great job but when I sit back and think about it, honestly she designs like many of the other hosts on the show, sometimes you feel like you are watching the same thing over and over again, which ya know I'm ok with LOVE it but I think it would be great to see Todd's show of course as long as he still gets to think outside of the box. I think he comes up with some really cool things and would love to see what other unique designs he can come up with

Posted by Brandi – September 10, 2007 6:55 PM

I have watched all season and have alternated between elation and disappointment. These shows really bring out the personalities! I agree with so many others that Sparkle Josh and Will are fantastic, but Kim has been consistent. Something I think a design star need to be! She may not have any serious "design education', but she has proved you don't need it to make people happy. Todd has remained consistent also...true to his own way. He doesn't design for anyone but himself. We had a bet going last night that Todd would design as he always does...too bad there was no money involved!! Anyway, my vote goes to Kim, no contest. I do hope that when she wins, they will incorporate Josh and Will into her show. Awesome!!

Posted by kathy – September 10, 2007 6:48 PM

I loved kim's room and she had smooth presentation. I swear if I heard Robb or talk in a surfer mode one more time I'd scream. Yes David B. last year was exuberant but not juvenile. AND could Robb do anything other than Blue. He needs to remember it's not him in staying in the suite - it's people of various walks of life. Kim's room was more suitable for anyone. I agreed with Vern - she designs with class. I hope she wins - I watch David show and I'd look forward to seeing Kim.

Posted by Becky – September 10, 2007 6:46 PM

My vote goes to Kim, when I turn on HGTV its to get good decorating ideas. If you want to see mens with bare chest watch MTV or VH1. What is HGTV about..... Home & Garden TV.... or Hot Guy TV.

Posted by RENEE – September 10, 2007 6:45 PM

I am ready for the "Kim & Will" show! What a pair they would make. Sorry, Todd, I just couldn't take one more minute of your arms raised (when you have seen underarm hair once it is ENOUGH!) Your room would be fine for my grand children - not me. AND my bed next to the kitchen???? I agree that it was a wonderful view, but I would rather sit with my morning coffee at a dining room table or a couch, than get out of my bed and run into the kitchen sink! Kim, you are so fresh and refreshing! No training and you come up with wonderful ideas that I can use in my home. I would call on you and Will to do a room or rooms in my house (in fact I wish you would!) I will be looking forward to the "KIM AND WILL" show next year.
Go Kim! You have been my choice from the first show. Seeing you with your husband and family let me see you are a REAL person, and one I could watch each week and learn things from.
Rene

Posted by Rene – September 10, 2007 6:44 PM

The show I would most like to watch, learn from and be inspired by? The Will and Sparkle Josh show.

Every designer was at his/her best when with Will, because will has the best design talent. Sparkle Josh is best at shopping? Well, let him shop!

I'd love to learn about design from Will and how to shop retail (for those of us that can't afford designers and "to the trade" only furnishings) from Josh.

Please, producers, please????? I'll trade you one Devine Design and two Design on a Dimes for one Will and Josh show!!!

Posted by joan – September 10, 2007 6:43 PM

I didn't vote for David last year because he couldn't keep his shirt on and I won't vote for Todd for the same reason (not that Todd deserves to win). At least Kim will keep her shirt on.

Posted by LarryE – September 10, 2007 6:43 PM

I loved both designs but for diffrent reasons .
1. Todd's room to me was for a party group of a younger bunch but very good .
Kim's room I would love to stay in and relax on vacation .
Both were super in thier own right just diffrent crowds of flavor . I would vote for both for very diffrent reasons . This is very hard as both are so deserving and talented . I have totally enjoyed this years Design Star and look so forward to next seasons , hopefully it will be just as good . Good luck to both but I also hope to see some of the others back as assit's
or guest host or stars . That would be great !
Thank you Design Stars for a wonderful show , I
wouldn't miss it . Gerri

Posted by Gerri – September 10, 2007 6:39 PM

Ok, my previous post will probably not make it on here because someone could consider it "malicious" so here is my "nice" version. I personally believe that Kim lacks what it takes to make it as HGTV's next design star. Now, take that information and put it into terms some might consider malicious, and that is how I feel about it. If she wins, I won't be watching her show, and perhaps no more HGTV at all. Just one more thing: "mama's goin' to Hawaii" ???????

Posted by katrina – September 10, 2007 6:37 PM

Kim got blind-sided on almost every challenge. Two, count 'em two, kitchens and both times having to work with ego oriented leaders, sent to the rural country with no easy access to supplies or material, direct confrontation on more than one occasion challenging her professionalism, and then...on the final challenge, clock winding down and she hears that she should get rid of the blue rug (bet she was out of money too). She never collapsed, just took the bit in her teeth and moved forward.

Although I doubt that the Outrigger will keep the poly covered concrete floor, the rest of the suite was warm and inviting and certainly upscale.

I clearly remember some of David Bromstad's earlier shows, and he grew throughout last season and into this one. Kim, too, will become a "Design Star" to be reckoned with!

I hope we get to see more of Will now and then. what a classy guy!

Posted by stubbster – September 10, 2007 6:32 PM

Great sense of style Kim (especially given the time constraints). You get my votes. After winning she will have time to work on her kitchen design skills. Todd is good too. However, his style is MUCH better suited for a theme/kids room design show. I would like to add a big ups (props, kudos, etc.) to Will. I thought he should have been in the finals with Kim. I would have also liked to see Adriana get further in the competition as well. I thought her passion and sense of style might have played out well later in the competition.
...but in the end I see Kim as the next Design Star. I look forward to watching her series.
Note: Will and Josh worked together well...that's another show that I'd watch.

Posted by Brian L – September 10, 2007 6:25 PM

I loved watching Design Star. Todd has a lot of energy and I think his designs appeal to other people like him. Kim's designs are more realistic to me. Her designs come closer to what I would want in my own home. Good job, Kim. You go, girl!

Posted by Rebecca Hill – September 10, 2007 6:23 PM

Some advice to The Design Star producers: Next season you need different judges. Vern is great the two women: not so good. They acted in love with Todd all season and don't really have home design backgrounds.
Don't do multiple exits again and have more individul tasks with more time and money. I realize it shows what you can do in a short time period but I'd love to see what they could do with a week! Kim would have done so much more with another couple days. And every designer has contractors, builders, carpenters who do the labor. The designer is the artist!
Please don't go for way out kooky characters. I realize this is TV but WE , the viewers want REAL design we might do in our own house. Not telephone books, skate board set ups or jerks like Rob. Maybe screen better next time!
I think Kim will be a great Design Star with time to work. And give Todd a landscape show in CA where he can stay shirtless which is what he loves.

Posted by debles – September 10, 2007 6:19 PM

I have to make a comment regarding one post saying Kim didn't build anything. My question is define build. Kim's designs were good enough where she didn't have to build something in each episode. I believe the custom headboard and room screen divider were just the right touch. Now maybe it wasn't a half pike boarding ramp or a spinning furniture platform devise but, then I ask you how many regular homeowners want that in their home. This is a design show not Chuck E Cheese . Not to mention one very crucial element... each designer has their own carpenter for the show. Great design should NEVER be compromised by building apparatuses. NEVER! Todd was good but, Kim was far better at meeting each challenge with the client in mind. Very important when you have your own show. Now as far as the few laughs you were referring to well, you know there's always Comedy Central for that!

Posted by Kaff – September 10, 2007 6:11 PM

HI-Ive seen David Bromstad and these two are no David Bromstad. Im not going to watch either of these people's shows so Im not even interested enough to vote this time. Oh well-next year!

Posted by chris chesterfield – September 10, 2007 6:03 PM

For me, there was no question going into the final challenge who I was leaning towards. That was Kim - but I was willing to give Todd the benefit of waiting to see both final results - hoping that he was going to surprise us all and design something that would appeal to the general public.

Results are in and Kim is the clear winner and has my votes!

I've thought all along that Todd was a one-trick-pony and he didn't disprove that thought last night.

I am not going to get into a list of personal notes, but how many 35 year old men act like Todd and expect to be accepted as a professional? (Unless you include professional surfer dude.)

Kim - especially since she comes from a non-traditional design back ground was more impressive of the two and I would much rather listen to her commentary because she makes me believe that I can do some of the things around my own home.

TAKE NOTE JUDGES: Will's very presence as well as his support for both of the final two should have shown you that he DESERVED to be in the final two.

HGTV - along with Kim as this year's winner, PLEASE schedule show spots for Will and Josh Johnson. From the feedback on this blog you will have a ready made audience.

Posted by kelsmom – September 10, 2007 5:53 PM

Kim seems to have all the votes, except mine. She could not have done that room wihtout Will's help. Even my young grandson knows that you have to sand splinters off wood. The divider was an eye sore, especially with the chains holding it. Why not rafia, or rope to go with the theme? Seems everybody has forgotten previous designs from Kim. Duh! What designs? I will not watch her show if she wins. I hope HGTV has something else to offer! What is the reason that my posts are not published? Am I too abrasive? Just voicing my opinion, like everyone else.

Posted by Nicole Duke – September 10, 2007 5:53 PM

Kim's room was by far the best. I would gladly watch her show. There is NO WAY I would watch a show hosted by Todd. He needs to learn that there is more to life than surfing and that not everyone wants to stay in a boys party room.

Posted by TJ – September 10, 2007 5:39 PM

I am a landscape designer and for yrs worked as a interior designer. I chose Kim because Todd's design was so juvenile. His designs are insulting to my profession. I think the jumping around and no shirt are because of David from last yr.
I honestly couldn't understand Kim not changing the carpet from the start. She had $10,000!
A high end suite would not necessarily be modern. In Hawaii it would just as well have been full of beautiful antiques. THAT would be high end.

Posted by Judith Woody – September 10, 2007 5:31 PM

wow what a rush i'd stay in kims suite any time very cool use of the paint colors and all the stuff she did the divider and the floor awesome . hotels here in orlando with rooms like that would go for over 300 a nite and condos they are building here have floors walls and stuff just like that and go for over 400,000 for a 2 bedroom!!!!!!! way to go kim i'll watch your show!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by james – September 10, 2007 5:29 PM

I voted for Kim simply because Todd's designs are always a work of art but, for my family, they aren't practical. I also like to watch the shows to see things I can do myself and learn tips & tricks. I could apply things that Kim & Will did to my own home and do most of them myself but not with Todds. I couldn't build a rotating platform for our house and the style is always something very original and artistic but not applicable to my life. I would watch any show with Will or Kim because I can watch, learn, and apply myself.

Posted by laughmore – September 10, 2007 5:25 PM

Again nobody like David Bromstad he is the best designer in many years to come but since he is not competing Will, will be my choice but since Will got out my vote will go to Kim.
I like to say something to the judges, Will do not have bad hosting his presence on camara give me a sense of peace,and he is very secure with his decoration ideas and clients like that. I still dont understand how Todd got so far there were so many designers much better than him and you guys let them go.

Posted by loida – September 10, 2007 5:22 PM

Thanks HGTV for a design competition show where "great TV" is not the only objective. Great design is. Design Star is one of the few shows where the competitors understand that working together and pleasing the client is the priority (except for Robb!). Love Kim's style and ambition. I am a swimwear designer and am oh so too familiar with the likes of a Todd. Todd you have a great future in theme design, but you need to expand your vision for the rest of the world. I am sure you are a great landscape designer. Kudos to Kim for her classic taste and ability to follow the direction of the challenge and that of others. And good luck to Will. You are so very talented, I would let you two design my home anytime! My vote goes to Kim.

Posted by Msredhd – September 10, 2007 5:14 PM

I'm voting for Kim with Will as co-host!

If Todd wins, the show should be called "Totally Todd", but I wouldn't watch it.

Posted by Susan – September 10, 2007 5:07 PM

Although Kim did a great job this time, I think Todd has been the stronger contestant throughout the show. Kim seemed to be a wall flower that got through by playing it safe. Todd on the other hand has really made bold moves and been at the forefront of the competition the entire time. Kim was part of the kitchen tile debacle, but besides that, I can't really recall anything memorable about her past designs or group efforts. Todd on the other hand made that cool turning living room, the half pipe, and that amazing wave art piece at the MOMA. I can't see Kim making a show that I want to watch. Todd has the depth of talent and skills that make TV worth watching.

Posted by Paul – September 10, 2007 5:05 PM

Kim has a wonderful honesty in her designs...simple,
understated elegance and oh so classy. I would love to be a client for her Design Star show. She is very talented, perceptive about the spaces to be renovated and the people who will use them and she demonstrates a perfect marriage of listening to clients and implementing designs that work! You go girl...you definitely have MY votes!!!!!

Posted by Carol – September 10, 2007 5:04 PM

Well, skimming all the comments, I'm not sure if it's worth jumping in, but I think there are a lot of points that carry weight in picking a design star & show host. I like both contestants, but do feel that if the new show is going to have anything to do w/ actual design and not just decorating, then it would have to be Todd. I agree w/ all the comments about his immature nature, but who knows..maybe nerves? All that said, Kim is sweet, but very blase. She would lose my interest in a short time if I had to listen to her. Either of them can be trained to "perform" because both have talents and weaknesses. IF the show is going to have anything to do w/ building or creating something which would be a nice change on HGTV once, then Todd is the one. IF it's just another decorating show or "how to choose color" and "faux painting" or "decorate for everyday", then Kim is the choice. I personally think it's time for a show that takes some construction, saws, etc. to pull off. The shirt? Oh well....though not impressed, not hard on the eyes either!
LOL Either way....it's been a fun season to watch. I had to vote for Todd.

Posted by Dnels – September 10, 2007 5:01 PM

I loved the show last night. Kim will be the next design star. Hope to see more of Will. He deserves another chance.

Posted by ATL Peach – September 10, 2007 4:58 PM

I thought it was interesting that other bloggers picked up on what I did -- Todd seeming to be frozen in an early stage of adolescence. Note the interesting dynamic when his friends & family showed up: the "hot wife" stood by, smiling self-consciously and mainly unacknowledged, while Todd was whooping & wrestling around on the floor with "his boy" and his brother. This fits in with Todd's consistently What-would-a-13-year-old-boy-love design, and failure to form friendships or bonds (at least in the edited footage that we see) with any of the woman designers. He's toned down the "extreme" hand-stands, thank goodness, and even before Rob left, Todd was beginning to dial down his middle-school antics with him as well. But I think we've pretty much seen everything he has to offer.

Kim, on the other hand, has shown enormous improvement since she began the show -- not a very long time ago, to be sure, because of the producers' decisions to axe contestants right & left. But the Kim who resdesigned the hotel suite last night was infinitely more polished & confident than the Kim from the kitchen tile debacle (although she was mainly a bystander to that train wreck). She was quick to utilize the judges' suggestions like getting rid of the carpet -- Invaluable Will certainly stepped up to help out with that problem -- and her image on camera is certainly easy and easy to take ... as opposed to Todd's jump-up-on-the-furniture and "look at me, dude, I'm a surfer!" schtick.

Isn't it funny that when David takes off his shirt, it's endearing, but when Todd takes off his shirt, it's annoying?

Posted by Liz – September 10, 2007 4:55 PM

I truly thought Kim did an outstanding job. Todd is a gentleman, fun, and innovative. However, if I went to his hotel or resort area, I would not want to return. The room was too busy, too dark in color, and sophmoric. I think he has a place on HGTV, but he should not get the title of "Design Star." "Design Innovator" but not "Star." There is a huge difference. Kim exhibited grace under pressure. Also, I am so glad the judges saw through Robb. He is a spoiled child who did not get his way. When he doesn't win, he sabbotages everyone else's efforts. I respect the judges for having discernment and seeing through his personna.

Posted by Paulette – September 10, 2007 4:52 PM

I disagree with whoever said that Kim had not picked up or used one power tool!! Watch all of the series and you will see her with power tool in hand and using it. I'm not sure which one/s but I do remember it for sure.

Posted by blestwoman – September 10, 2007 4:35 PM

Kim's Hawaii suite is a well-coordinated, upscale and sophisticated design with pragmatic details such as her self-made semi-private hanging screen to shield the utility of the kitchen area from the conversation space. Add her charming, self-assured personality and you have, in my opinion, the next Design Star. Good luck Kim!!!

Posted by Bradtex – September 10, 2007 4:29 PM

Love the show l voted for Kim. she is so smooth and calm. her designs are something l would have in my home. she makes everything pop. I liked Todd but I think he is a little hyper to watch and to grown up for the teenager he still wants to be. His designs are very nerve racking, not soothing or calm. Unfortunately, I think if he acted a little more grown up, his designs would reflect maturity. Love Wil...Buttons

Posted by buttons – September 10, 2007 4:29 PM

I think Kim is the best remaining designer. Todd is fun and has a really cool edgy style but I agree with others who've pointed out he hasn't progressed or changed designs from the start like the other contestants. Kim has a more inviting on screen personality. I'd like to them both of them get their own show but with different directions. Kim can do the "Vanity Fair" while Todd does "Disney meets Jurassic Park" ....PERFECT!

Posted by Aloel – September 10, 2007 4:28 PM

Great idea to bring back finalists #3 and #4 to help on the last challenge. I had found Robb so toxic, seeing him last night on the show gave me a chance to see him in a better light.
I wish them all well.

Posted by Virginia – September 10, 2007 4:25 PM

Kim is a true design star. But let's not take that for granted. We all have to vote 6 times a day for her to make sure she really does win.

Posted by kathy – September 10, 2007 4:21 PM

Kim and Todd both are great, but I had to vote for Todd because of his out of the box style!! I love it. good luck!

Posted by Donna – September 10, 2007 4:20 PM

Hurraaaaaaaaaaaay for Kim! She rose to the top for sure last night! And might I add, in every way! She will most definitely be the next Design Star. Todd did well, but Kim it definitely the winner here.

Posted by blestwoman – September 10, 2007 4:18 PM

I liked Will's demeanor and designs the best, but I have to give Kim points for going over the top and also doing the kitchen in the trailer.
Todd- get a shirt on dude.

Posted by Robo – September 10, 2007 4:18 PM

Kim is the definite winner! I have felt from day one that Todd needs to grow up. Jumping on the table at the conference center in Las Vegas, etc. - he seems to be more destructive than creative. When his family arrived last night I felt he was more excited to see his brother and friend than his "hot" wife. Is he only 12?

Kim has a calm sense of style that is original and very livable. I would watch her show on HGTV but change the channel in a heartbeat if Todd had a show.

I too, live in Paradise (Phoenix AZ) and I love bright colors but when choosing bright colors you need to be very careful or you'll wind up with a room like Todd's - much too much!

Posted by Linda – September 10, 2007 4:16 PM

Can we vote for Will? I was so disappointed when he was sent home. I think the judges kept Kim because they think it is easier to train her eye for decorating than turn Will into a good TV commentator/host. But she has not been strong throughout the competition with her design. I didn't even watch this episode. Viewing the photos you can have surfs up or nerve jangling color and hanging slats divider (again!). Put either room up against the dorm Will and Sparkle Josh designed and they pale (thank heavens) by comparison!

Posted by Kathleen – September 10, 2007 4:15 PM

Great show for both but the vote goes to Kim! I would not want to pay for a luxury suite in Hawaii and walk into a bedroom in the kitchen!
What was Todd thinking? Surf's up Dude? Maybe the room is everything he wants, but it was not a luxury suite. Blue is my favorite color, but there is a limit. Both are very talented but when it comes to designing a room to suit the customer, Kim stands way out in front. She even has the personality to handle that jerk Robb.

Posted by Jane – September 10, 2007 4:15 PM

Personally, I'd vote for Clive coming on and saying that this whole season was a dream and that they're going to start again with 12 new designers. I've not been even moderately impressed with either from episode one. Kim, although very personable, has only 2 successful tasks under her belt (mobile home and the Hawaiian suite). She showed very little the rest of the time and should have been booted for the kitchen fiasco. Todd, on the other hand, has shown a interesting (repeated to the point of being irritating) knack for doing the "out there" stuff. He's talented as a carpenter/artist, but hasn't shown once, the ability to listen to others and work from their input (either "clients"-disgusting red-room or "judges"-Hawaii). Oh, by the way, can anyone tell me if his arms were up or down more this year (how old is he again? 12-15?

Of the others, Will had the best design sense and style but he failed on hosting abilities.

Please make this season go away and try again...

Posted by aulicny – September 10, 2007 4:12 PM

I didn't think anyone was really super talented this season but kim has come a long way- she has matured throughout the show, has shown to be neutral, and has been a good team player.Let's remeber she is not a designer by trade, but a hair stylist.

I know it may not be fair to say this, but Will and Sparkle Josh deserve their own show-- where do you find or see characters like these too-- that's a show I would watch!

On another note, I agree with many of the comments about Todd. The shirtless act has to go and his design style has not evolved much since the start of the show-- Its always a beach, surfer theme, which only kids and teens may like.

My vote is for Kim and I will be watching to see her win! YOU GO GIRL-

If Will and Sparkle Josh read this please note that I'm currently an umemployed TV executive who would produce your show in a heartbeat--
HGTV please call me I need a job!

Posted by Maggie – September 10, 2007 4:11 PM

I love the show. It seems like it was over WAY toooo soon! I voted for Kim, but I think the perfect show would be similar to the "Designed to Sell" show, with Kim as the main host/designer and Todd as her co-host and designer/carpenter. I really think together they would make a Dynamic Duo of Design. That would make one of the best shows on HGTV yet. Keep up the great work folks. I love HGTV. Wouldn't want to live without it.

Posted by Peggy Covey – September 10, 2007 4:10 PM

Kim! Where have you been hiding?!? You are in your zone, your own personal element. Get ready to rock the design world! Every step of the way, Kim has been able to showcase her own personal style and originality, and yet, has been able to showcase the space to it's fullest potential. That's a gift! A person just wants to breathe in her space, enjoy it, and relax in it. She has a unique hosting style. She makes me want to sit and let her draw me into her ideas as she invites me to see what she's just done and let me in on her savvy of the how's and why's. That suite? *****-5 star!

David, Color Splash is going to have some new competition and we call her KIM!

Good luck, Kim!

Posted by gayle – September 10, 2007 4:09 PM

Todd's was neat for a kid or teen. Kim's was awesome!! I will admit that it wouldn't have looked as good, if the carpet had been left. I wish Will had that "tv personality", because he probably would have had my vote. But Kim is awesome also! I would totally watch Kim's show. I love David Bromstad! Wouldn't watch Todd.

Posted by Heather – September 10, 2007 4:08 PM

I was one of the first to bash Todd over the half-pipe, no shirt, way out of the box testosterone-laden juvenile style. Then I started seeing his team style, exhuberant personality and ease in front of the camera. When he designed the room for the family, I really thought I was going to have to change my mind about his style and ability to design. Then the final challenge came and it was back to the same blue surf and campy design.

I think I was the first to suggest an Ebony and Ivory show with Will and Josh. Still would like someone to jump on that. But I also said, long ago, that folks were giving Kim short shrift. Last night she rose to the challenge and knocked it out of the park. I thought I was going to have a tough time deciding, but last night's challenge made it a surprisingly easy choice. I know the posts overwhelmingly indicate Kim's the choice, but the proof is in the voting.

By the by, I mentioned in an earlier post that we really needed a Vern Yip show and low and behold we have one. I like it so far, but still not quite up to what I am used to seeing from him. Hope future episodes bring back that simple but elegant, innovative but not crazy, classy design I love him for.

Posted by blkcfy – September 10, 2007 4:07 PM

I would really like to see the show released on DVD as well. It is nice to have the show online, but just not the same. I have been writing to HGTV since last season to release the show on DVD. Maybe if they hear from more of us, it will finally happen.

Posted by Teresa – September 10, 2007 4:06 PM

I had to vote for Kim, I would have loved to be in that hotel room. The nice thing about both Kim and Todd being the last two standing,is that they have managed to be "nice" the whole show, and yet when challenged don't cringe but stand up and behave in a classy manner. I just hope Kim choses Will to be her co host when she gets the job

Posted by CalicoBelle – September 10, 2007 4:03 PM

This is a very difficult decision - Kim's design is more "livable", Todd's is more artistic. Kim is a real natural on TV. Todd is less fluid, but has lots of personality. Hated the room divider and the jellyfish. But, wish they could both win.

Posted by Mariele – September 10, 2007 4:00 PM

I must be missing something. When I'm traveling, I don't spend time in the bedroom until after dark and it's difficult to see the view then. It's during the day that I would like to relax and enjoy the view FROM THE LIVING ROOM! Can't imagine why Todd made the bedroom part of the kitchen. Oh, well, he seems to think like a kid and acts like one, too. I couldn't imagine watching his hyper antics week after week. A little bit of funk goes a long, long way, and it becomes tiresome after a fashion. I hope the rest of America thinks the same way. Go Kim!!!

Posted by Clophy – September 10, 2007 3:57 PM

I think Kim should be the next Design Star. Her designs are always spot on and she has the perfect personality to host her own show.
I'm voting like mad for you, Kim!!
GOOD LUCK!

Posted by Heather – September 10, 2007 3:53 PM

I think Kim should be the next Design Star. Her designs are always spot on and she has the perfect personality to host her own show.
I'm voting like mad for you, Kim!!
GOOD LUCK!

Posted by Heather – September 10, 2007 3:53 PM

I have only recently started watching HGTV and I am certainly happy that I did. I loved watching DesignStar. There have been some wonderful designers on the show. I was so glad to see Kim and Todd make it to the final two. I wish HGTV would make them co-hosts. Todd has such a fun side while Kim seems to be traditional. From other blogs I have read, the majority of the people seem to remember Todd's surfer designs, (which really stand out) but none of his other designs. I think he did a fantastic job in Wayne Newton's guest house. He also did a great job in the penthouse (adding fun to the room). Todd seems to be one of those people who has leadership qualities while Kim appears to more the type to work well as part of a team. In saying all that, I think "high energy" Todd would be great at hosting his own show.

Posted by Jerri – September 10, 2007 3:47 PM

Entertaining show!Happy to see Will and Robb on board to assist Todd and Kim;both rooms were good,Todd's design was fun and Kim's layout was predictable and safe, but her color choices were beautiful.

Posted by Evie – September 10, 2007 3:33 PM

549734
I wasn't very impressed with this years show, I really didn't like any of the designers. None of them were very good. Now last year, David was awesome. I still watch his show every week. He was and is great. One of the best designers I have seen on HGTV. My husband and I have watched everyshow. David was really good and we didn't have any problem knowing who to vote for. You must have design talent to go with your hosting skills and I just didn't see that this year. I really didn't like Todd or Kim (or any of the rest of them for that matter. We really are having a hard time voting. The talent just isn't there.

Posted by Carolina Girl – September 10, 2007 3:24 PM

Todd's room was fine if you wanted to go to Disney World. But this wasn't Disney this was Hawaii. kim's room was great..mixture of Island. I could sleep in her room and be in an Hawaii vacation. My vote is for Kim..Also, wanted to say..Will was so positive with Kim when the comment about the carpet..He really worked hard with her..

Posted by Peggy – September 10, 2007 3:24 PM

love the show couldn't for this season to start. i theink i like kim better than todd. love todd also, but todd is to far out there for my taste. i preferr to elegance to shocker. todd needs to team with hildi from trading spaces.

Posted by diane – September 10, 2007 3:19 PM

I prefer to pay for a luxury suite and Kim nailed it. Todd is good but all of his designs go right back to the beach or surfing or skate boarding. Will he design every other room with beach, surfing or skateboarding designs? I wouldn't want that as a home owner. I haven't seen design class in Todd's rooms. Kim you have my vote! You are awesome. Not all designers are carpenters!!!!

Posted by HGTV Fanatic – September 10, 2007 3:18 PM

If HGTV wants to utilize Todd's talent, I feel his daring, adventurous style is well suited to what he actually does as a designer: landscape design. None of the season's challenges involved landscape design. I'm sure he comes up consistently with innovative designs in that arena, and that this was what he probably showcased to the selection committee in the first place. His talents are not as well suited to Interior Design.

I had hoped that "Sparkle Josh" might win this competition. He's a wonderful designer. I also loved his personality. That given, however, I agree with the judges that Kim avoided turning her hotel suite into something garish by her intelligent, tasteful use of browns and oranges to keep the palette warm, inviting, high-end in feeling, tropical but soothing. This made the aqua blue-greens she employed all the more lovely. It was nice to see darling Will comment on Kim's good taste.

The thing about Kim's on-screen presence is that she has always come off as unflappable, even when she was working with Robb. It was Robb's insecurities, not his obvious and admirable passion that was challenging. That unflappablity will, no doubt, serve Kim well if she is going to have her own show and still try to keep her married life intact. We know David Bromstad has had to deal with some terrible worries about his dad, but it does not seem that he has had the added challenge of trying to keep a relationship going while he has been making this huge adjustment to his new life. (David is absolutely wonderful, by the way. We watch, and RE-watch every episode of Color Splash, and are so happy the show has been picked up for another 26 episodes.)

Posted by Theo – September 10, 2007 3:18 PM

Things often look different in the light of day; so I decided to look over Kim and Todd's work one more time. Especially now that I'm 16+ hours away from the offensive armpit assaults,thanks Todd,Not! Aside from the hideous BLUE placing the bed in the living area was not smart. When we attended an away wedding in August we selected a suite for our stay. Why? Because we wanted the privacy a bedroom separate from the living area offers.Entering into a living area evokes a homey comfortable feeling not to mention more conducive to entertaining guests.Bottomline this is an upscale resort suite Todd should have listened to Vern but he chose to do his own thing and design,and I use the term design loosely,for himself.Sorry my opinion has not changed. Todd's room is fine for a teenager, theme type resort, or aging surfer"dude"type and that's about it.I much prefer Kim's room.Lastly hosting, Todd is far too immature what's w/ the leaping on the coffee table? I could never sit through a Todd show had a hard time w/ this one. Kim nailed the design aspect as well as the hosting.

Posted by ccrc – September 10, 2007 3:02 PM

KIM DID IT!! I like Todd but Kim's room was SO much better in design. Todd centers too many ideas around water and waves and the color blue! He would be great at theme rooms. The judges suggested he not put the bedroom in the living room and he did not take their advice. The outcome (whether in fifth gear or not) was tacky. I agree with the other blogger that if you are sleeping, you do not care what the view is. GO KIM!!!

Posted by Ricardo – September 10, 2007 3:00 PM

WOW WHAT A ROLLER COASTER RIDE THIS SEASON! I can't believe it's time to vote already but, I am totally ready for it. My vote will go to KIM! She has every marking of a great Design Star. Great design eye, confident, detailed orientated, in tuned to the clients wants, and last but not least a really professional and fun television demeanor. What else can you ask for! I have been enthusiastically cheering her on from the very start. Tonight's last challenge pretty much summed up her seasons BEST work! Todd's room while I thought it was fun & playful it did not invoke the luxurious Island penthouse theme. This room maybe for the kids but, not for a couple looking to get away to a luxury island suite. Kim not only delivered a refreshing tropical (Punch) getaway her clever usage of material and detail to every room was a breath of fresh air. What I love the most about Kim is her quiet confidence, patience and, loveable personality. It's funny looking back on the shows personalities. Some were bold and cold to sparkle and shine. Kim's consistent and steady wins the race attitude has made her shine above the rest. Kim if you get a chance to read any of these comments I am putting my bid in for YOU to be my Designer!! Kim is small in stature and huge in TALENT! Like they say... GREAT THINGS COME IN SMALL PACKAGES!!
YOU ARE AMERICA'S NEXT DESIGN STAR!!
Good Luck Kim~~~

Posted by Kaff – September 10, 2007 2:56 PM

I realized last night that I was smiling throughout the show. Design Star is so enjoyable and so uplifting after all the garbage on TV all the time.
Thank you HGTV for a wonderful show! Please remember that there are millions of viewers over 50 who love to get new ideas for decorating that are practical and beautiful and not all viewers are excited over bare chested males jumping up and down.
Kim has a wonderful approach to hosting and designing and gives one ideas that are great for our own homes. I vote for Kim!!

Posted by Nancy – September 10, 2007 2:56 PM

I really enjoyed the show - was thinking wow Hawaii! As far as the desigers I was hoping for some really swashing results, but was very disappointed in Todd's room. He's 37 going on 16 it seems - All of his designs all center around surfing. Sorry dude but not all of us are into surfing - we love the relaxed life.
It was Kim's room that was the most desirable of the two rooms. When I go to Hawaii I want to come to my room afterwards and relax after a full day of taking in the Hawaiian culture. In Todd's room I would go absolutely wild. I understand he wanted to create a place to enjoy the scenery but my gosh it was a room suited to a teenager not an adult.

Kim's room on the other hand was comfortable, and not the hoakey "beach theme." When Ispend big dollars for my room I want elegance and a relating atmosphere. Kim did it! She listened to the tips the judges gave her, and produced the winner!

So it's Kim hands down,.

Posted by Patricia – September 10, 2007 2:51 PM

Kim, all the way.
I had to think back to the room that Todd did for the large family. Has he ever been in a room with all the children there at one time? I think not. If he had been, he would not have choosen the bright red. What an unsettling space that would be. Sure, it looked great on the camera, and the people loved it, but wait until they live with it for a few months.

He, also, mentioned being able to see the view from the bed! All I could see when the clients were to be laying down, was the roof line of the place next door.

And of course, we had his juvenile attemts at design. I wish he would do a child's show. I can remember Vern's comment about liking some activity in a room, but not a skate broad? May, how soothing that would be after a hard days work?

Loved Kim's work from the very beginning and feel she has improved each week. I do wish, however, she had spent some of the money on her project in Virginia to insulte the floors. One of the things the clients mentioned in the beginning was how cold the floors were. Next, I wish she could have picked out a more suitable color for the carpet. After all, the client is going to have to live with that choice for a long time. It all looked great in pictures but I would think that functionality would come into play.

After all of this, whoever, my vote goes for KIM, all the way. She is great now and just think how she will be after some more experience under her belt

Todd will always be Todd, dude. Not everyone is into surfing!!

Posted by Veronica Walburn – September 10, 2007 2:50 PM

Last night was great! I absolutely adored Kim's design and would gladly let her into my home. My only wish is that, we would have been able to see more of her design talents earlier in the competition. That is why we loved Will and Josh so much earlier on, because we were able to see their work individually. Now I can understand what the judges saw in her, however I still don't know what they saw in Todd. Todd is very talented but, he should have been on the show MONSTER HOUSE when it was airing, not design star. I hope for the next design star competition, HGTV change some things. Even though we now love Kim, I hope they realize why we loved Will and Josh so much. There are plenty lessons to be learned by this season of design star and I hope HGTV figure them out.

Posted by Donna – September 10, 2007 2:50 PM

I will not vote this year. I didn't think any of the contestants had any real design flair. If they did it certainly wasn't given a very good venue by HGTV to show it.
I thought every show was too "put on" and that they were trying to "one up" the reality shows on other stations. I watch HGTV to avoid the shows like that. Design Star was very disappointing this year. Last year's show was a class act all the way but you lost it this year.
Neither Kim or Todd's room was nice at all. I would be asking for my money back if given one of those rooms and would not revisit that hotel.
Surely people with "real" talent can't be that hard to find.

Posted by mouse92yes – September 10, 2007 2:45 PM

I think the producers were genious to bring Robb back on the scene. I cannot stand him but it did add some tension to the show. Plus it was good to see him come back on knowing that he is the loser that he is. Kim was ever the great lady and was very gracious to him. He was the one who had to change his attitude. Kim is the winner of this show. Todd just cannot come down to a level that regular people could live with. He really wore out that surfer, skateboard theme out. And what is it with him and blue, the color hardest to make look good and all those waves! i think that he is an artist but not a home designer. And I agree with the comments about the shirtlessness, it got old.

I think that the suggestion that next year the contestants dont get voted off is good. Just use a rating/point system and choose the winner on the last show. And by the way, how about some new judges. I really like Vern but the ladies need to go. What was that awful outfit with the little ponytails and the short shorts. Too old for that, she was.

Posted by bev – September 10, 2007 2:41 PM

I agree with most comments. Todd's space planning was poor, his design boring, his colors too bright--why is he competing with the view? Only the dining room area impressed me. Kim's design was elegant and classy. Don't think either of them are star-quality though. If I'm going to watch a TV design show I want the designer to be more qualified than me, to teach me, to impress me. Don't think that would happen with either Todd or Kim. That said I will vote for Kim: she's got class, creativity, and elegance and Todd doesn't even come close. The only design show he could host would be for children's rooms or dorm rooms. Not interested in watching that. Will was the one I would have watched!!

Posted by Laurie – September 10, 2007 2:28 PM

Enjoyed the show, but I did not think that allowing shirtless designers on the show is very professional. I wouldn't expect to see a shirtless male designer working around my house. It was a distraction and HGTV needs to lead the way in class. Also David Bromstadt needs to keep his shirt on. What's the deal with these shirtless guys?

Posted by catherine – September 10, 2007 2:26 PM

I voted for Kim!! She is adorable and did an exceptional job with the last challenge. I also want to say that Will is such a great designer and I loved his comments and his compassion for the young woman he designed the room for in his last challenge. Let both Kim and Will work together on your new show.

Posted by Patricia – September 10, 2007 2:24 PM

Todd has proven to have a GREAT amount of talent but Kim pulled way out in front with her hotel suite design. If I was going on vacation I want a room just like Kim's design. Soothing, relaxing but also has an energy to it. Sorry but Todd's room reminded me of a young boy's room. I totally agree with Carol J's idea about Will and Sparkle Josh having a show together, that would be a must watch show! I also loved Scott, his talent was much better and more sophisticated than most of the designers that stayed on the show longer. Please bring Scott back.

Posted by Jen – September 10, 2007 2:18 PM

Ok so, although Kim's color pallette is not in my "preferred ranged" [i personally like cool tones] i thought her space ROCKED!!! amazing, beautiful and soothing. Just what i would expect from a designer. I love the fact that she is able to mold herself to the space-something which Todd does not. She redeemed herself,i thought she should have lost to Will last week[Will's design imho was hands down the best] but am happy to vote for her today and everyday--you go gurl! A gurl from Astoria Queens-who'da thought??
much love from another Astoria Gal

and oh,
PS in case HGTV marketing/development staff reads this--Josh, or Josh and Will need their very own show!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Liz – September 10, 2007 2:18 PM

I did not like either design last night. It just did not click with me for a Hawaii vacation suite. In fact this season wasn't as good as the 1st season. Todd tired me out .. he needs to grow up or design for beach bums. To bad Christina shot herself in the foot, by not listening to the clients for her wedding design. She was way to good to leave so soon. So I voted for Kim by default.

Posted by cj – September 10, 2007 2:15 PM

Kim has done a terrific job. Good solid design and strong hosting skills. I like Todd's ability to think outside the box. However, watching him host reminds me of Bill and Ted's Most Excellent Design Adventure. Too boy -- all that shirt off hopping around punching the air stuff. Sorry, Todd. Kim's the host for me!

Posted by bh – September 10, 2007 2:10 PM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM

You won it ABSOLUTELY!

Posted by Qbear – September 10, 2007 2:04 PM

Part of being a good designer is to pay attention to the space you are designing and thinking about what it is used for. A pent house room deserves sophisticated design and function. Kim thought of these and directed her design in that direction.
Todd directed his design around the ocean. His room would have been great at Disney World in a regular room, where sophistication takes a back seat to all out fun.
Kim gets my vote.

Posted by Linda – September 10, 2007 2:03 PM

I was worried that Todd would "outshine" Kim but that did not happen. She is so talented. She gives the people what "they" want. Big difference in her work and Todd's.
I like Todd but home design is not always about the surfer dude. He has talent - he needs to learn to channel it. I agree with the others, his designs are repeticious and not everyone wants the surf in their living room.

Go KIM!!!

Posted by Bonnie – September 10, 2007 2:02 PM

i thought both rooms had a lot of character i did like tod's idea of moving the bed really if your staying in hawaii are you going to eat in? really!!! but waking up to that fab view!!! i would have done curtain on wire in front of the kitchen to close off . kim's is the best tho the colors the details loved the floor rug and the small table left of the sectional and that looked comfortable to me. also hosting she can come to my house to dinner anytime !!! and bring her family. i think bringing in will even rob was cool. and having the non winning contestants as guests would be awsome esp the ones without the annoying personalities. i think kim's so got it!!!!! she just needs to invite sparkle ,will and tod on her show .

Posted by colleen – September 10, 2007 1:54 PM

Personally I'm not sure I would want Todd to jump aropund on my furniture the way he seems to all the time (remember the wedding table) He would drive me nuts wondering if I was gonna come home to a disaster or a different designer due to his hospital stay from breaking his legs falling off something..I think he has great talent, if you are into over extravagance and not realistic on how you live your life every day. I think he should have toned down his immage a bit. to loud and over the top..seems like a nice guy..anyway...KIM WINS HANDS DOWN! She has class in her design and she cares about what is asked of her to do.You go Girl! You have my vote! and by the look of it, alot of other peoples too...This is where all the noise counts..not on the tv screen!

Posted by Julie – September 10, 2007 1:54 PM

I think Kim, for having no formal design training did an excellent job during the entire competition. She was certainly "Grace under Pressure" when working with Josh who was a total ego trip. Don't judge her on the kitchen project. Now one but Josh has much to say about that challenge. Todd was an artist, just as David (last year) was but Todd's designs are so predictable. Kim has style and elegance and I think she's proven that can design both sophisticated (hotel) and normal, every-. man, down to earth (West Virgina house). And yes, I too wish Will had been in the final two. Hosting skills can be learned, but design takes both talent and the ability to put that talent to work which I think Will did.

Posted by Barbara – September 10, 2007 1:53 PM

Kim rocks! I was pleased as "tropical punch" to see Kim really step up to the plate and design a beautiful, functional suite. Loved the headboard idea...very creative! Kim has shown real growth throughout the competition and her hosting skills surpass Todd's hands-down! And to think that she has no formal training. It just goes to show that you either have an eye for design or you don't. Kim definitely does!

As for Todd, grow up, Dude! Although Todd did an admirable job designing the room for the family in last week's episode, he went right back to the "surfer dude" look for the final challenge. And his hosting is just too over the top for my tastes. I don't want a host who yells at me. The judges' comment that the room was "totally Todd" was more revealing than perhaps they realized. A good designer realizes that the design has to be about the homeowners or the people who will be using the space, NOT THE DESIGNER. It's not all about you, Dude!

Kim gets my vote. She's the only one whose show I would watch regularly. Hope you come out on top, Kim!

Posted by Brenda – September 10, 2007 1:50 PM

Kims's room was GORGEOUS!! I would stay there in a heartbeat. Hawaii is beautiful enough on the outside, but after a day in the sun and surf, who wouldn't want to relax in such a calming, upscale space. Honestly, Todd's room looked like something my teenage son would enjoy, especially with the bed right next to the fridge. That said, I don't think I would ever watch any show hosted by someone who acts so juvenile. KIm, you are awesome to watch...and I loved your room!

Posted by ladyliberty42 – September 10, 2007 1:50 PM

I have to agree with most of what I have already read--Kim gets my vote too and I sincerely hope she is the next design star. Todd seems to automatically presume that he will win, but Kim outdid him in every design aspect as well as in hosting. She keeps her clothes on; she is always presentable, professional and polished. She has real class. Kudos to both spouses for being so supportive as this has to be difficult for them. All in all, Kim has learned from her mistakes, grown more each week and topped the charts with her final design. Todd is too self-centered--Kim has earned this win!

Posted by denverslady – September 10, 2007 1:48 PM

Too much blue in Todd's room for my taste. And, who wants to sleep with jelly fish and bubbles... in the a kitchen?
Loved Kim's personality and attitude. And her color scheme was great. She certainly used the judges' comments to her advantage and rocked out a beautiful, classy upscale hotel suite. Now, who wouldn't want to vacation in that? Best of luck to you Kim. Sunday can't get here soon enough.

Posted by Jennifer – September 10, 2007 1:47 PM

I have loved this series and liked Kim from the beginning. Will and Josh are my second favorites and I'd love to see a show with them teamed up. Kim has my vote hands down. She not only has talent, but the fact that she doesn't have professional experience also impresses me. She's mainly been an arm chair designer like the rest of us, but she has sure out-shined everyone and definitely deserves to win. Classy lady!!

Posted by Marcia – September 10, 2007 1:47 PM

Really hoping Kim wins--she has such a wonderful sense of style and she's so graceful. Todd is a little much for me, but he'd make a great guy-oriented show. My husband really liked him.

Whoever wins, I hope the producers don't take the show in a David-Bromstead direction and have the host spend 20 minutes talking about themselves and have the clients spend another 20 gushing about how much they love the host and how they watched Design Star and how they cannot believe THE Design STAR is coming their house!

The show should be about design, not the personality.

Posted by Melody – September 10, 2007 1:43 PM

I watch a lot on HGTV, too many favorites to post.
Design Star is wonderful & we never miss an episode. I really like Todds designs, but Kim is really wonderful, soothing & exciting designs at the same time. her personality is bubbly & happy.

Posted by Carol Johnson – September 10, 2007 1:39 PM

Kim is great and she will only get better once she gets her own show. Todd's final design was very weak compared to some of his other designs. I hope HGTV continues to have a nice, clean show without the 'drama' that occurs in all the other reality tv show.
Good Luck Kim!!!!!

Posted by Amy – September 10, 2007 1:39 PM

Too much blue in Todd's room for my taste. And, who wants to sleep with jelly fish and bubbles... in the a kitchen?
Loved Kim's color scheme. She used the judges' comments to her advantage and rocked out a beautiful, classy upscale suite. Best of luck to you Kim... YOUR ROOM ROCKS.

Posted by Jennifer – September 10, 2007 1:36 PM

You go girl!!!! Kim is clearly the best choice. Her warmth and serenity shine through her like a light. This young lady has a great career ahead of her. I can't wait to see her new show!
I agree with the one viewer about Disney...Todd would fit in very well as a theme-designer for their public spaces and hotels-for kids, in Atlantis. Great imagination, but no praticality,

Posted by Connie – September 10, 2007 1:20 PM

I loved both rooms; both artist kept true to themselves. I think HGTV would be at a loss to let either personality go. I would love to watch a show with Kim as the designer. Her style relates to most people ,I think. She brings to the concepts a style that perhaps I could take into my own home. She relates well with everyone. As for Kim's room, loved it, think that it would be easy for the hotel to recreate in other rooms as well. Yet, Todd brings this wild, unexpected flair to everything he does. A show that would keep me watching to see what is going to happen next. ;] Would I dare bring those concepts into my home? Perhaps I might just. As for the room, though, the bed in the front area? I understand where he was going with that, but I'd rather close off the bedroom ,so my ole man could sleep in, while I had my coffee and enjoyed the sunrise. but thats how we get freash ideas. Great job by both!
connie

Posted by Connie – September 10, 2007 1:19 PM

Sorry, Todd, but your enthusiasm gets in the way of your originality. Kim, is poised, original, charming and has the maturity to listen to the judges while growing her designs. I voted for Kim. I could watch her show every week.

Posted by Pat Fuller – September 10, 2007 1:19 PM

Good luck Kim.

HGTV if you are reading this - I would LOVE to see Will and Todd teamed up on another show with Will as the designer and Todd as the carpenter. I thought they worked well together as a team.

Posted by Sue – September 10, 2007 1:14 PM

I'd LOVE to give Kim my votes but lost the cell ph #. Can someone please post the full number here ? Or email it to me... On the voting page it doesn't give the full number.

Thanks !!!

Posted by Sherry – September 10, 2007 1:13 PM

I think an artist seems to do better in these competition and there didn't seem to be the talent to match David's from the first season. I thought Todd would be better, but switching the rooms lost it for him. I worried about Kim's design ability, since it really wasn't coming out in the team competitions, but she knocked it out of the park for the final competition.

I think Todd would do well to have an outdoor design show. I would be very interested to see what he would do with that. It's a shame that HGTV doesn't put outdoor design into the competition. It surely is part of what they do.

All said and done, I'm voting for Kim. Her stable and mature personality is something we depend on in a TV host. I do think she needs to increase her design knowledge. Her eye is good - you can't educate someone into that, but she does lack in background, experience and technical prowness. That's something that can be fixed, as David's presenting skills were.

Posted by Kate – September 10, 2007 1:02 PM

Design Star is another show on HGTV that I am addicted too. Kim's design was AWESOME! Not only did she present a sophisticated design she has a great personality and is fantastic in front of the camera. I would definitely watch her show! You go girl!!!

Posted by Perfectdesign – September 10, 2007 1:01 PM

Would you really want to see any more of Todd's armpits? That's enough reason right there to vote for Kim. Not to mention she's got style with a capital S.

Posted by Sienna – September 10, 2007 12:59 PM

Kim definitely should win.

Her presentation style is more polished. While they are both talented, Todd seems to be more one-dimensional in his designs. There is no subtly or quiet nuances. It's always loud. Plus, two or three of his designs were all blue and water/surfer based.

Finally, what is it with his never wearing a shirt?!!?!?

Posted by Ray – September 10, 2007 12:58 PM

I love both designers.
Todd's room was a little dark for me. At the beach I want light and airy not deep dark ocean blue. And I dont think I could eat with a huge squid over my dining table.

Kim's colors were bright and fun. Loved the art work and headboard.

Todd seems like a fun guy. He has some great, unique ideas but for a more traditional approach, I would have to go with Kim. I love her style and creativity. Kim has my vote!

Posted by taryn – September 10, 2007 12:52 PM

Will did it again!
The judges are going "lose the carpet"
(so is the audience!)
Kim's saying "how?"
Will just goes "it's okay, I've got it covered"
and he did.
Will handled every challege with grace and dignity, ALSO when he wasn't "Hosting" he was quite comfortable and personable in front of the cameras!
Could there be a place on HGTV for
"Kinder, Gentler Design with Kim and Will"?

If Todd had a show the audience would have to take Ritalin just to survive! Even though Todd did become more likeable as the programs have progressed he is still more 'artist' than 'designer' and Kim's headboard beat Todd's wall art hands down!

Posted by Sunny – September 10, 2007 12:49 PM

Will did it again!
The judges are going "lose the carpet"
(so is the audience!)
Kim's saying "how?"
Will just goes "it's okay, I've got it covered"
and he did.
Will handled every challege with grace and dignity, ALSO when he wasn't "Hosting" he was quite comfortable and personable in front of the cameras!
Could there be a place on HGTV for
"Kinder, Gentler Design with Kim and Will"?

Even though Todd did become more likeable as the programs have progressed he is still more 'artist' than 'designer' and Kim's headboard beat Todd's wall art hands down!

Posted by Sunny – September 10, 2007 12:49 PM

I enjoyed this final challenge. Kim's room definitely appealed to me and would be the one in which I would choose to stay if given the choice. I would like to see Kim win this. The fact that she is a 'design enthusiast' with no formal training is actually a lot of people's dream. We sit and watch HGTV all week; get ideas; boo the the ones we don't like; try the ideas that we do like and soon we're helping friends and relatives and being talked into trying out for the show!

If Todd happens to win, I can see HGTV setting him up with a show similar to the Food Network's "Glutton for Punishment". The host reminds me of Todd. Over the top; energy to spare; oddball assignments designed to appeal to the younger crowd.

We'll see on Sunday!

Posted by Kathy O – September 10, 2007 12:48 PM

While I loved Kim and Todd's room, I would love to stay in Kim's room as she really made it look very upscale. Now on the flip side, I feel cheated that the show did not showcase the others talents more like they did the first season. The other contestants really did not get to shine or fail this season. It was short, true but to many were eliminated to soon. I an sure that sparkle Josh would have had a chance to redeem himself he had more time. Will, I loved his designs and would have shone if given more time to hone his hosting skills like they did in the first season. I hope they give more individual challenges in the third season.

Posted by Christine – September 10, 2007 12:41 PM

Hey HGTV, you should let Sparkle Josh sing on the finale, he has a wonderful voice!!!!

Kim did an outstanding job of making her room look like a luxury suite - it was totally what I would expect to get paying what you pay for those suites!!

Posted by lstav – September 10, 2007 12:36 PM

Todd is an artist. He is very good but i think Kim is a better designer of practical living space.
Further, Will was better than Kim and Todd the week he was eliminated. His on screen personality did him in, but his design for the young girls room blew away Kim and Todd.
Anyway the show is great

Posted by Rod – September 10, 2007 12:35 PM

Kim's room last night was by far the best--very creative and appealing to the eye. She has impressed me from the very beginning, and the way she handles herself under stress is amazing. She is a natural in front of the camera, too. She gives information while showcasing her work and therefore, the viewer learns things about decorating. It's amazing to me that she has no formal training and yet she is in the finals. GO KIM!!! You have my vote(s)!!

Posted by Barbara – September 10, 2007 12:35 PM

Kim was so far ahead of Todd there was no competition. She creates beautiful space with her designs and decorating. Her presentations are fantastic. She explains her designs and the reasons she created them.

There is no doubt that Kim is the new Design Star.

Todd is "cute" - the boy next door with bare chest and hairy underarms, (which he loves to show by raising his arms every chance he gets..) with totally outragous ideas in decorating... I certainly would not want him near my house with a paint brush!

Posted by Ellie – September 10, 2007 12:32 PM

First, congratulations to both remaining designers for making it this far. Todd from the beginning has always been a standout possibly for his 'out-of-the-box' thinking and carpentry design skills. He has never been up for elimination. Kim on the other hand was never a standout especially with Will being in the competition but she has great listening and problem-solving skills. I always viewed her as the underdog because of the team challenges and her design last week - the placement of the furniture and carpeting - was a design mishap but got her to the final round. I think Todd's over the top design is more suited for a show like 'Design on a Dime'. When you add problem-solving, color schemes and able to inform the audience of ideas to change a color or design of a room is great. Therefore, I will vote for Kim.

Posted by Gail – September 10, 2007 12:31 PM

Of course I'm voting for Kim--that is an understatement! Her beautiful designs and her centered and gracious personality make her the obvious choice. One BTW to HGTV...give a show to David AND Todd and call it "Designs for the Desperate Housewife." Why can't these two keep their clothes on?!

Posted by Marilyn – September 10, 2007 12:31 PM

Kim all the way! her design was by far better. I agree who wants to see bubbles and jellyfish on there walls and that blue all over would give me a headache! I am a big fan of the show. Cant wait to see Kim's new show I think it will be a hit. If Todd wins I dont think I will watch his show. I dont need to watch another shirtless design show.

Posted by Kellie – September 10, 2007 12:30 PM

Both Todd and Kim are outstanding designers. However, Kim has classy style where Todd tends to go for the unusual. Not something everyone can live with. I didn't get the ugly brown sofa in the over-blue room. I would have preferred something lighter. After all, this was supposed to be a kind of beach theme, I think. Love Todd, but have to go with Kim. I love her warmth, sincerety and caring.

Posted by Kay – September 10, 2007 12:30 PM

I loved both of their designs, however, I used to live in Hawaii and thought that Kim's design best fit in with Hawaii. Waikiki now looks like Rodeo Dr. and I think that many tourists that come to Hawaii are looking for the original authenticity of Hawaii. I loved her headboard, the couch pillows and the colors...it is very "authenic" Hawaii and looked very classy. It was ingenious how she turned the suite into 3 distinct spaces. Kim's personality is warm and approachable.

I loved Todd's design as well, but I pictured his room design to be in an upscale hotel in Monterey, CA. I like Todd's out of the box thinking and his personality.

It was very hard to choose. I like them both and think that both of them would make fantastic Design Star winners.

Posted by Mary – September 10, 2007 12:17 PM

I think we have a new design star on our hands. Move over David; just kidding. Kim rocks.

Posted by yulia – September 10, 2007 12:16 PM

I would not like a suite with old ugly carpet OR with a visible concrete floor. Josh would have put a great floor covering down!!!
Vicious Vern and Mooning McCully- why did you send the best designer home?

Posted by cynthia – September 10, 2007 12:14 PM

Kim is an upcoming designer. She learns and improved every week. Her talent is hosting; something you need to do to host your own show. I loved her room even though I am not much on browns it was beautiful and elegant. Her unique perspective was top notch. I would love to stay in this hotel room. As for Todd, I would send the kids to this room. His colors are almost always the same along with the surfer thing. His hosting abilities are something of a joke with too much jumping up and down. I agree with another post, go to the Disney Channel and design for kids. I love blue but it was over the top. The room was not elegant and I would not pay top dollar to stay in his suite. Go Kim, you got style!

Posted by Deborah – September 10, 2007 12:08 PM

I'll vote for Kim because she's the better of the two that are left. That being said, there's no way Todd should have been in the final two. I think Will had the most talent of all the contestants, and he should not have been eliminated because he was soft spoken. As a matter of fact, my favorite designers/hosts on HGTV have personalities similar to Will's (Kenneth Brown, Suzanne Wang, Michael Payne, Lisa LaPorta). I would like to see exactly how each judge voted each time. At least that way I could either confirm or deny my suspicions about Martha's predisposition to vote for the contestants to whom she's physically attracted, regardless of their design talent.

Posted by house hunters fan – September 10, 2007 12:04 PM

If I ever get to Hawaii I probably won't care WHAT the room looks like....smile...but if I had a choice between those two, I'd have to pick Kim's.....it was beautiful....she did an excellent job! And it was great to see Will back, too!

Posted by Deb in GA – September 10, 2007 12:00 PM

Todd's Hawaii design was a real dissapointment. Kim actually surprised me as it was the first thing that she did that I liked. I felt that she should have been cancelled on her West Virgina design and Will be made the hero on that episode. I'm dissapointed in the judges this year. I do think Kim has a super personality and great hosting abilities. But, I feel that Will was superior to Kim and Todd. I would have loved to have seen what Will would have done to one of those rooms in Hawaii. What's the matter with you judges??!! It made me not want to even watch the first episode of Vern Yip's show that aired after DesignStar last night. The best parts of this years competition was when David was on! Now there's a great designer, artist, and all around person.

Posted by Linda Laverne – September 10, 2007 12:00 PM

I was surprised, by both designs last night. If you love bold. I guess I am just to meek for such boldness. It is so strange, that they used all the colors I have avoided. I am not scared of color, love color !!! but , to me these colors are great, by them self. But it worked for both of them .It's shows they know what they are doing. Had I tried those colors in my home I would have had a cotton picking mess. I would have had, to call Will to get me out. Yes I love Will, and was so glad to see him last night. Surprised again to see Robb, It's a wonder Kim had not done her room in RED, after seeing him pop up. But Kim handle it like The pro she is. I think both designer will go on to be big time. From all the fan mail Kim's getting, she will be working until she can't work any more. Todd, What can I say , It's being held against you because your handsome , Hardheaded, and playful. Fans just wanted to see you get serious Because you have great talent and I can see that, and after fighting breast cancer , and a host of other illness your playfulness was like a breath of fresh air to me. Your Playfulness, and Will"s tender heart made the show worth watching. for me. But after all It is a design show. Get serious because I am voting for you. Wish I good vote for you and Kim both!!! Love you both.

Posted by Bonnie Osteen – September 10, 2007 11:44 AM

Well, this is certainly a very difficult decision. I really like Kim's style and Todd as well. Todd is more of a "balls to the wall" kinda of guy. I can see him coming up with some really innovative and artistic ideas. He doesn't like to play it safe.

Kim is a sweet and caring girl who has a talent that is few and far between. I love her taste in color and I do have to say she nailed it on this last challenge. While Todd's was great, he used the same blue color that had used previously.

While it is unfair and unjust as I truly believe that they are both SO talented, HGTV could come up with 2 very different shows for both of them. I could see Todd Designing these crazy houses with unique style and bitchn' arrangements. I can see Kim with your typical- divine design taste- which is good, believe me. I can't even decorate my office.

Still, one thing that clenched it for Todd, well HE'S HOT! I mean what girl wouldn't want to watch him shirtless decorating YOUR house??? Hell, He won it based on that, but his personality is exciting and you never know what crazy thing he is going to come up with next.

That's what HGTV needs now- a show like that- on the edge, new, exciting, unpredictable and hosted by a hottie!

What more could you ask for?

-Lisa in the ATL

Posted by Lisa in the ATL – September 10, 2007 11:41 AM

Todd's room looked like something out of Nickelodeon--I expected SpongeBob to peek out at me from behind the "artwork". I don't like the bedroom in with the kitchen, nor a clothes closet in the dining room. I love blue but way too much blue in that suite for me. If the hotel had given me that suite to stay in, I would have asked for another suite.

I didn't know what to expect from Kim but I was blown away! Wow!! That suite is worth the money to stay in. I love the colors. I love the screen she made--just right for that size space. I love the separation by function. I love the way Kim took the chance and removed the carpeting. (Thank-you, Will, for helping her!)

I wasn't sure who I was going to vote for until this final show but now I know--KIM!!

Posted by terry – September 10, 2007 11:39 AM

I vote for Kim all the way! Kim, your design was sophisticated, elegant, classy, calming after a hot day, functional and aesthetically pleasing. Its just what you'd need after a day at the beach. Todd, sorry but the layout of your room just didn't work. I know you're trying to be different, but remember, less is more.

Posted by Caribbean Lady – September 10, 2007 11:34 AM

What a show! I was totally convinced that Kim is the better designer. Her shopping at the Crate and Barrel, and overall elagance of her room. Todd is a Holiday Inn disaster. And I'm sorry, I've been to Disney and the allstar cheap resorts even have a tact about their theme rooms. You're right, Todd is a good match for the all-star bargain basement. I'd expect more from a Grand Floridian type/priced room and I think Kim gave it all! I'd love to be in her room. GO KIM!!

Posted by Lin – September 10, 2007 11:31 AM

I have liked Kim from the begining. I like her style and how calm she is. I like to look at Todd but do not like his style.

Posted by Sue – September 10, 2007 11:29 AM

I think that the judges missed the mark big time this season. None of these contestants were up to the caliber of last year's final two, in terms of natural talent or presence in front of the camera. That said, Will is clearly a better designer than the two that are left. It's hard to vote for either. I like Todd's presence better, although he could tone it down a bit. He's more pleasing on the eyes and seems to enjoy what he's doing. Kim doesn't come across well on camera, to me, and her designs aren't unique or inventive. Plus, they had many more challenges last year so you had more to compare than this year. I don't know who to vote for and I'm not sure I'd watch either of their shows...

Hopefully, next season will be better thought out.

Posted by Allison – September 10, 2007 11:28 AM

Kim has my vote! Todd would be very tiring to watch--I would be leaving my chair often. Todd needs to remain as a landscape designer--always the same theme so wasn't surprised of last night's design. Since when would we go to bed so early just to see the view? It is dark when I go to bed. If a person is on vacation, why spend time in the room? Kim is so great on camera, whereas, Todd is always high energy, waving his hands and in your face person. Would never watch his show. Also, please make it a rule that shirts have to stay on--don't care to see the hairy armpits!

Posted by Millie – September 10, 2007 11:26 AM

Kim has my votes for yesterday and today. She is a natural on the screen and her designs were even better each week. Her last room was awesome, and she is such a sincere people person. Todd was entertaining, but... I look forward to Kim's show next year!! Go Kim- you are the next star- very polished, composed, (don't know how you kept your cool on one episode- but this is so sweet, "Mr Kitchen") and lots of personality.

It would be great to have the competition come to Bay St. Louis, Waveland, Pass Christian, and areas like this on the MS coast that took the direct hit of hurricane Katrina. We are ground zero and extra talent is always welcome. I am sure everyone here would be thrilled with the designer picked. Duo Will and Josh would be super. Todd would be a great help - if he left the crashing waves out of the their homes, unless requested!!

I just read in the paper that FEMA is trying to work out a plan to drill a well or something to provide more water for the school in Pass Christian, requested almost 2 yesrs ago. They had the least damage so all the school combined with the use of portable bldgs. I think Robin Roberts from Good Morning America called FEMA (Pass Christian is her home town). I apologize for the digression, sometimes after I read or see something, I may share it to get the word out that we are not even close to whole again and hopefully will be better than before in the future. Thanks to anyone who just took the time to read this. I am the only one in my family that had a home to come home to - that's pretty much the story across the MS coastline. Everything is pre and post Katrina in conversations with the people that are still here. I can't believe I am blogging to a site! Use computer a lot - guess now I will be looking at blog sites. kidding, never get anything else finished!!

By the way HGTV is my favorite TV and about the only TV I watch. Now I'm off to start a project in the kitchen - tiling for the first time. Many more plans after that. I have watched so much I think I can do "almost" anything. HA

Posted by Debbie – September 10, 2007 11:24 AM

Kim has my vote! Todd would be very tiring to watch--I would be leaving my chair often. Todd needs to remain as a landscape designer--always the same theme so wasn't surprised of last night's design. Kim is so great on camera, whereas, Todd is always high energy, waving his hands and in your face person. Would never watch his show. Also, please make it a rule that shirts have to stay on--don't care to see the hairy armpits!

Posted by Millie – September 10, 2007 11:23 AM

I was pleasantly surprised at Kim's talent last night. I don't believe it really came through until this episode. Todd is such a talented young man, but he doesn't seem to know how to be serious when needed or when the design calls for it. I think rooms should have a little whimsy in them, but not permanently all over the walls, especially in a high-rise expensive suite. Kim has far better poise on screen, giving advise on hints as to what she did to arrive at her design, which is one of the reasons we all watch HGTV - to learn how to make changes to our own homes. As cute as Todd is, I would much prefer to watch a show with a calm, sophisticated, and talented person like Kim. Good luck, Kim! I'll be watching Sunday night!

Posted by avaholley – September 10, 2007 11:21 AM

I don't watch many design shows, but if Kim wins and I think she will, I will watch every show! She does things that I can do myself and would use in my home. She is a natural at this and keeps getting better.

Posted by Cheryl – September 10, 2007 11:18 AM

I enjoy Design Star very much. I like Kim's design over all. She has shown that she can adapt her designs to the needs of the challenge. I would want to stay in her room in Hawaii. Todd on the other hand would make a great kids room designer. His designs have not changed much since the show started. I think his design level is definately teenage level and younger. His designs are more for fun like a play scape then daily living. Even his living room design in Vegas was set up for just one person. If one person wanted to watch T.V. and another wanted to enjoy the fireplace both could not be done at the same time because of the revolving seating area. Todd's designs are not permanent just temperary and fadish.
Kim's designed are easier on the eye and very stylish. Kim has my vote! I also believe Will and Kim would have been a very good choice to pit against each other.

Posted by Anita – September 10, 2007 11:15 AM

I thought both rooms were nice, very different from each other, yet somewhat mediocre. None of them "wowed" me or blew me away. I liked Todd's idea of moving the bedroom into the living room; the view was definitely amazing. I didn't like the color choice or the jellyfish artwork too much. Kim's looked more like a high end suite; it had nice furniture placement and the space planning was much better than last week. I didn't like the custom screen divider (unless it had a way of being folded up) and I thought she could've pushed back the window treatments to showcase the view from her room. I also wasn't a fan of the custom artwork. It would've been nicer if it was stained or painted and not left with the natural wood color that made it seem somewhat unfinished. All in all, I'm not thrilled about eather design star choice and am curious to know how Will would've designed the hotel suite. I admired Will's demeanor as he calmed Kim's fears and assured her that ripping out the carpet and replacing it with vinyl flooring could be accomplished within the allotted time... and he delivered on that promise.

I wish there was a way for me to vote for Will Smith instead!!! He still has my vote!

***And I would rather not have Will be just an assistant on the Kim or Todd show... I want to see him lead his own show!!! (or at least have equal weight as a co-designer)***

Posted by Bisi – September 10, 2007 11:15 AM

Is it me or does Todd think he is the hottest thing around? Put a shirt on bud.. hello!!! This is D-E-S-I-G-N show/contest, not a body building contest. Please! Every shot of him witout a shirt I couldn't help but think that he is totally stuck on himself and that he's flaunting it to impress the audience and judges. Sorry! And what's with him raising his arms all the time? Could it be more annoying? Don't get me wrong, he is definitely hot :), but I get past feeling like he was trying to "use" his physique. And, the running and jumping was just TOO distracting. Grow up and calm down. Whew... now that I got that off my chest: since it IS a DESIGN show afterall, when he said jellyfish I thought was eeewwwwwwwwww, who wants to see a jellyfish on the wall? Maybe at an aquarium but not a high end suite. I did not care for the design. Blue is way too predictable... It was like MarineLand gone bad!

Kim's suite was gorgeous. When she held up the color pallet my initial reaction was ut-oh.... But she pulled it off BEAUTIFULLY. My favorite was the bedroom area. The headboard treatment was absolutely brillant! Modern, clean and totally captured the essence of Hawaii. I'd love to stay in that suite. And she scored points with me with her grace and for her patience with Todd. She seems like such a warm, thoughful and caring person. These are great attributes not only for a TV host, but also for a Designer. She truly CARES about her pleasing clients, not just executing her vision.

And Will just plain rocks! He was such a team player and good sport. As another poster astutely pointed out, he not only kept Kim calm about the floor, but he knew it was the correct thing from a design perspective AND he made it happen! It looked positively AWESOME!

Can't wait till next week!

Posted by Love design – September 10, 2007 11:11 AM

Well, it's pretty obvious from reading these comments and the room ratings who our next Design Star is going to be, and boy am I glad! I could not not sit through a half hour show with Todd hosting unless I drank about a gallon of coffee beforehand! He is just too over the top high energy. I really wasn't impressed with his room, either. It was just way too blue and had too much going on. It was too visually stimulating. I want a hotel suite to be calm and relaxing, which Kim's definitely was. Kim is also so calm and cool in front of the camera, really a natural. A lot of people have made comments about her design ability, especially after the last challenge, but if you read her blog, it was the clients who wouldn't let her use flooring or furniture that was easy to clean. She gave the clients what they wanted, and this week the judges were gushing over her room.

I can see Robb hasn't changed. Oh, sure he put on a friendly face, but his smugness came out with the comment about the carpet. I'm sure he wants Todd to win. I'm actually kind of surprised that he didn't do anything to sabotage Kim. Did you see the look on his face when Todd chose Will for the first day?

Posted by Mindy – September 10, 2007 11:11 AM

Kim all the way. If not, then the show will definetly suffer because it would appear ridged. I've reviewed the comments and most are for Kim. Statistically speaking and rightfully so IMO,she should win but hey, John Kerry thought the same thing. lol

Posted by Buddha-man – September 10, 2007 11:10 AM

I am very pleasantly surprised to see the whimsical surprise element shown by Todd(which I love). Every single design is not whimsical and I think that limits his range of people. My opinion of Kim is elegant and practical for every day people and the rich and famous. Kim's personality obviously could design that whimsical and surprise aspect if necessary. I am torn between the two diffrent talents, but Kim has the edge for my vote. It is amazing how comfortable she is in front of the camera. The first season Designers could not compare to Kim's hosting ability. Not even David (I love David, he can do no wrong) Suggestion: Kim's show: Every Day Design(practical and rich) starring Kim. Todd's show: Design Magic starring Todd. 1 hour show Everyday and Magical Designs by Kim and Todd.

Posted by Jackie Hawkins – September 10, 2007 11:05 AM

Todd really got it wrong on this one ... who wants the best view from the room you will be sleeping in, or the kitchen next to the bed, or the bathroom off the dining room? ... no thank you. As for his design, it didn't have the sophistication one would expect, and there was way too much blue. As for his hosting ... it was definitely better, but still too much "in your face" to suit me.

Kim's room, on the other hand, was great. I gasped to see that she was going to have to work with Robb again, but she handled it quite graciously. I was really glad she had Will on the second day, because when it came to the judges suggestion to remove the carpet, his calm confidence that they could do it was just what she needed. GO KIM!

Some of the others I would watch if they had their own show would be Sparkle Josh (he is very warm and personable) and Will (he's very sincere and I loved his designs).

I love watching David Bromstad on Color Splash, and I'm sure I will love watching Kim Myles on her new show!

Posted by Shar – September 10, 2007 11:03 AM

alrightie... todd needs his own show, maybe called off the wall. [serious about that]
kim should win this one, add will as her ast.
and thats it for my opinions.

Posted by ju – September 10, 2007 11:02 AM

I will admitt I liked Kim's room better, but truley felt like Will's presence was all over the room!! First lets admit this, the carpet would not have come up had it not been for Will!!! To vote for Kim would to be to vote for Will!! So at this time I will not vote for either until people admit that Kim's room would not have been had it not been for Will!!

Posted by cindy – September 10, 2007 11:00 AM

I voted for Kim also. I think her designs are great. In the hotel suite, I didn't like Todd moving the bedroom next to the kitchen. The view was breathtaking but when you are asleep, who is going to see it. Also, when you are getting dressed, you want the shades closed. If you really wanted to see the view, you could see it from the couch. Kim's hotel design was so elegant. I don't know how she finished everything but I absolutely loved it. Plus, on these shows that I have been watching about selling your house, they always say don't put things up that are your personal taste. Waves on the wall seem like Todd's personal taste to me. Why look at that on the walls when you can go out and enjoy it in Hawaii? If I walked into a hotel room that looked like Kim's, I would just be so thrilled. It was beautiful. Loved the headboard she did and also the room divider. Ingenious. I think Todd and Kim both do well hosting.

Posted by GMorrow – September 10, 2007 10:58 AM

I watched the last three episodes and thought Kim was the one from the start. Did anyone notice she actually painted the kitchen cabinets and the bedroom built ins? Not one of the judges said anything about it. I thought WOW Kim completely did what was asked. Todd just made a mess. The kitchen cabinets were untouched! Ugly!! I voted for Kim and plan to each day!

Posted by Bonnie – September 10, 2007 10:58 AM

I wondered if anyone would catch the fact that Will saved the day carpet-wize for Kim...good comment from "she luv hgtv". It was Will's idea, and a very sensible one given a tropical climate.
Still...would like to see Will & Sparkle Josh! Alas Kim, you got my vote You Go Girl!

Posted by wwwebduster – September 10, 2007 10:47 AM

I love watching this show. My question is: Will they ever be put on dvd for sale? I would love to have both seasons for my future enjoyment. By the way, my vote is for Kim all the way! 726055

Posted by nancy webster – September 10, 2007 10:47 AM

I am voting for Kim! Really, no competition.

Maybe if Will was still in it, the final challenge might have actually been competitive. As it is, I think he probably worked really hard to help put Kim over the top. Her room was just amazing. And completely unexpected. I have never been a big fan of her, but I do love this final challenge room and I do think she could have a good show. She should probably do something along the lines of cost efficient design elements to smarten a room.

I really have nothing against Todd. He would probably be great in a graphic design competition, but he has never shown much talent for interior design. I imagine he is a great general contractor. He is certainly a very competent carpenter and seems more in his element building things. If he wins this competition, it will have nothing to do with design skills.

Posted by Teresa – September 10, 2007 10:46 AM

I did not watch last season and now wish that I had. I was glued to the set for this season and if I was away, it got recorded. I was not really sure going into this finale just who I would vote for but after seeing how each design came together, Kim has my vote. I feel that both Todd and Kim have it altogether for their particular focus but when you are designing for someone else, you really need to take into consideration how your client would take to the space. Kim created a hotel suite that could work for many a weary vacationer. Todd's was more juvenille and "Todd centered." Even when Vern suggested that Todd rethink the switching of the bedroom and living room, he ignored that. It is commendable to stick to your true form and style but it becomes egocentric when you cannot see what the best decision is for others. Kim's space would work for many different personalities and preferences. Plus Kim took the judges advice and pulled up the clashing carpet.

Thinking back through all 7 episodes, Kim has been true to design implementation and follow through. She was really upset when their team's kitchen did not get completed. She created a calming room from the "white box" and came through as a team player in other challenges. She was clear in what she was uncomfortable with when working with others but pulled her portion together. Todd is 'full throttle" and all about making it exciting and over the top. When he had to be more subdued with the family in Indiana, you could see his frustration when he could not move the support beam and he stated that it messed up his plans. I think too many Todd episodes may start to blend together and be repetitive. I must say he is an outstanding artist though and I envy his ability in that arena.

When looking at their hosting abilities, I have not looked so much as who is the most comfortable but rather how they define the space. Kim uses design terms in showcasing the space and you can understand why she made the choices she did, while at the same time not going over the top with self-reflection. Todd uses such terms as "fun", "moving", "awesome" and is fairly basic in his descriptions, which does not tell me why he did it the way he did but rather that he really likes what he did.

Kim definitely has my vote. She has stood strong throughout and can deliver.

Posted by Colleen – September 10, 2007 10:46 AM

Love the show! Kim has my vote. Todd is too much 'out of the box' for me. He has some great designs but overdoses on the 'fun factor'. Too much spice spoils the pot. It would be interesting to see his rooms once and then I would be bored with them. Nothing I would want to live in everyday. My fiance disagrees..he liked Todd's creations. Go figure.

Posted by Sandi – September 10, 2007 10:46 AM

I am sooo glad to see that mostly everyone felt as I did about Todd's style. I think he is very creative, but not something the majority of people would like...My vote is for Kim. Love her style, love her personality. Her room rocked!

Posted by Kathy – September 10, 2007 10:42 AM

In the beginning of the season I liked Todd's energy but his "California Dude" act (please say it was an act and not his real personality) got old fast. Kim was great from the beginning and I LOVED her room. Todd's was a mess. WHY would anyone want a bed in the kitchen and why did the dining room table need a room essentially to itself (plus the ugly original vanity?). Even the "artwork" was bad - Todd does have a niche - adolescent surfer dudes but I suspect they don't watch HGTV. Kim's room was a class act all the way and I'd love to get design ideas from her show.

Posted by Alice – September 10, 2007 10:36 AM

I was so excited to see the finale. I thought the venue would favor surfer Todd. His design choice confirmed he only knows one vision for design. Kim has flare and elegance. She is a class act. I have voted for her and hope all the others who rave about her do the same. The sea creatures on Todd's walls seemed something a teenager would do. Everyone thought the carpet was gross. Who wants to walk on gross carpet in bare feet? By listening to the judges and taking the carpet out, Kim took a risk. It paid off. Thank goodness she had Will there that day to help her. I thought it was characteristic of the weasel Robb to "tell" Todd what Kim was doing. He never did display any integrity. I hope the winner is Kim and the voting is counted correctly. I also hope that an appropriate program is created for Kim, the viewers choice.

Posted by Jeanne – September 10, 2007 10:33 AM

I vote for Kim. She has an eye for high design that I think would appeal to a larger audience. Todd although he is innovative, his designs don't appear finished and seem too juvenile. He would be good for designing a fun house at a theme park. Kim is who I'd watch on HGTV.

Posted by Captains Wife – September 10, 2007 10:29 AM

My family watched the whole season on our DVR.But watched the last episode live. Kim was a fav in the begining. During the show and as eliminations happened she stood out more and more...Kim you have our vote hands down...you have a great eye and we love your personality...you truly represent what most people are... a woman with a talent that works hard and has a chance to show her eye for beauty...you are already a winner....GOOD LUCK...we will always watch your show...stay true....we love you

Posted by Johni Maria – September 10, 2007 10:29 AM

Design Star has been a great show to watch! Both Kim and Todd are very talented in their own personal ways. I voted for Todd for two reasons. Remember on the very first episode when Clive made it clear that the next Design Star should and would be on who cannot only decorate, but also DESIGN and have the necessary skills to EXECUTE DESIGN. This isn't Decorating Star. We've not seen Kim build a single thing or pick up a power tool once. She's a creative and talented decorate who has an eye for color, nice furniture and attravtive accessories. Secondly, HGTV needs someone like Todd so they can put some variety into their programming. I live HGTV, but every show is so "mellow." I think they're looking for and NEED someone with a bursting personality to ass some spice and variety to their programming. Kim is a doll with a very sweet personality. Todd also has a great personality and is just simply FUN to watch. His show would bring a whole new segment of viewers to HGTV. I'd watch him, just for the mental break, a few laughs and appreciation for his creative design and overwhelming talent.

Posted by themilanos – September 10, 2007 10:23 AM

hey lwatkins -
Did last year's Design Star, have a blog, and a chance to rate the shows during the competion?

Hi! Yes. There was a blog last year. But, it couldn't have been as fun as this one! Just kidding! I can't remember if there was any place where one could rate the shows. I'll have to check! Thanks so much for writing in! lwatkins :o)

Posted by delightindesign – September 10, 2007 10:23 AM

Okay, I have sailed on the QEII and stayed in upscale hotels, with that said, who in there right mind wants to sleep next to the fridge?!?! Not only can it be loud when it cycles on, but not very romantic. Yes, you have a nice view, but when I'm sleeping I don't care about the view. Big mistake Todd. I wasn't going to vote for you anyway, but after seeing that suite I really wasn't going to vote for you. The colors are too loud to be relaxing and you didn't listen to what the judges had to say.

Posted by Mickie – September 10, 2007 10:16 AM

Kim gets my vote from a pure design standpoint. Todd's bedspread was wrinkled...like in a dorm room. ARGH! Something I don't see being commented on is Todd's following in David's footsteps...going shirtless a lot of the time! Will we find out that is what makes a winner? Also, thanks to HGTV for emphasizing the POSITIVE...the final two contestants' rapport was refreshing! I kept waiting for it to get personal and they never went there. As far as I'm concerned, Kim, Todd and HGTV are all winners in that department! Kudos to a "too short" season!

Posted by patter – September 10, 2007 10:14 AM

HGTV....After Todd comes in runner-up, his show should be about Kids rooms, or even themed rec- rooms!

Kim has my vote for DESIGN STARR!!!

Posted by Reje – September 10, 2007 10:12 AM

What will I do on Sunday nights after next week's finale??? Hopefully, in a few weeks, I'll be watching Kim's new show!!!! I honestly feel she has what it takes to host and successfully be HGTV's next Design Star!!!! Both are very creative, but when we come down to real time, the way 99% of us live, Kim can design, redesign, and fulfill the wants and needs of daily living, living well!!! She can carry off a high end design as she has shown in this week's challenge, or she can completely change the living quality of life like she did in last week's challenge for the family of a miner. Along with everyone else, I feel someone needs to find a place for Will...I know Will feels like I do, he will be led to the right place for him...but if the people who have the power to bring good design, calm thinking and understanding the needs and wants of the clients...we will see both Kim and Will with their own shows. Please HGTV, make us all better for watching...give us Kim and Will...their own shows....I've enjoyed every minute of this ride, don't let me down now!!!

Posted by Kathy West – September 10, 2007 10:11 AM

Kim rocked the final challenge. Todd, while creative and talented, came across the line a distant second. The difference: usefulness and suitability of the space. Kim exceeded the high hopes I had for her. Todd proved he's got one predominant theme. He does what only excites him...rather than what the client needs and wants.
Kudos to Will & Robb for the 100% unbiased support they gave to Kim & Todd. Finally, non-winners (it'd be wrong to call them losers) who presented the best of themselves while helping a finalist. THAT will not go unnoticed by your future clients. Congrats to all 4 finalists. Can't wait to see Kim crowned next week.

Posted by Kat – September 10, 2007 10:10 AM

I wasn't really impressed with any of this year's contestants -- it all seems very amateur to me. But I've been intrigued with Kim all along -- she's a great team member, and has in a subtle way saved the projects of everyone she's worked with. I especially liked Kim's work with the people in West Virginia - she made their trailer home into a very pleasant space, with good taste in using inexpensive materials very stylishly. I think Todd would have given them a surfboard theme! Puzzled why the female judges drool over him -- last time I was impressed by a guy who jumped on tables, I was 11. His final project looked like a Holiday Inn in Myrtle Beach! Having the bathroom off the 'adventure planning room' rather than the bedroom is just really wrong, having the bed in the kitchen is just as bad. If you were staying in a luxury suite in Honolulu, you could afford to go out and see the water, not just watch it from your bed. (There are more people in the world -- especially the ones who can afford luxury suites or hire interior designers -- than teenage boys.)
Kim should be the winner -- but for a show, pair her with someone who's a little more adventurous in design, and let the argue it out about where the compromise point should be between aesthetic 'punch' and practical comfort. That would make an interesting show.

Posted by Pat – September 10, 2007 10:08 AM

I loved both rooms... they did a great job... but I have to vote on the result.. These were the luxury suites... and although Todd's was great... it wasn't a luxury suite I'd be willing to pay top dollar for. So even though Todd had been my pick to win in the challenge it wouldn't be fair for me to vote for him since in my opinion he didn't win this challenge. Kim created a luxury suite with style and class so she gets my votes.

Posted by Deedee – September 10, 2007 10:08 AM

This is what I think would make the most viewers watch your show: Last season David and Alice were great together. I loved watching them. I think if the Design Star gets the option to choose their partner from the top 4 or let the show choose anyone that would be great. David and Alice would be so fun to watch. Alice has the personality and talent and David has the talent and great design, not as much personality as Alice. Kim and Will would be great together!!! Will isn't as natural on camera as Kim, but you can tell that he is just a nice genuine person who can teach a lot about design. He has a way of explaining things in very simple terms that regular non-designers can understand.

Posted by Ravenstone – September 10, 2007 10:07 AM

Kim hands down. I thought I would be torn until the end, but I wasn't. Three things really put Kim over the top for me. Her style of course and then seeing her family. Kim's ability to smoothly explain what and why she does something is very easy to follow.

I watch HGTV to learn and adapt what I learn. Sorry Dude! I'd never learn to deal with a half-pipe, rotating platforms and partial pieces of furniture sticking out of walls. Fun stuff, but not 'design star' quaility. Vern had it right 'rock star design' stuff. Go Kim!

Posted by lauren – September 10, 2007 10:02 AM

My mother watched the entire series and now cant vote. We cant download Adobe player and we dont have a cell phone. We would have voted for Kim. We thought she was great!

Posted by Denise – September 10, 2007 10:02 AM

Kim is the one! Style, good sense, etc. Todd is sooo juvenile. I have never watched a show like this, but stuck with every episode and loved it. I just wish someone would get Will (what a sweet-heart!) and "Sparkle" Josh(equally sweet) and put them together: they are sooo simpatico, their talents mesh so well and I think everyone in the USA loves them together!! Loved both their ideas and their style. If nothing else, these two have GOT to go into business together! Love 'em. Now, about Rob.....I am surprised he left the show in one piece. The remarks he made after being cancelled? So rude and uncalled for. I kept yelling at the tv every time this jerk was on. Kudos to Kim for not bashing him with a heavy object. "Artistic temperament" is one thing: being a jerk is another. And...he has NO TALENT!!!!!! Good luck to Kim!! Hugs to Will (so thrilled to see him on the show last night!)and Josh. _

Posted by Chris Nodurft – September 10, 2007 10:01 AM

Todd made the mistake of thinking people sleep with their eyes open so they can take in the view during those dark watches of the night. His rooms were a TOTAL disaster! Kim's brown paint had me worried, but in the end, all was well and her rooms were everything one might expect in a deluxe suite in Hawaii. I admit I was on her side throughout but she really deserves to win and I think she will. She got my vote.

Posted by Elizabeth – September 10, 2007 10:01 AM

I have to admit that three weeks ago, I thought Todd would be the winner. His personality really rubs me the wrong way but his designs have been very innovative and completely unique. The last couple of weeks though, Kim has really stepped it up. Her designs have been pretty good and it is apparent that even though she is not a designer,she has good taste. Her personality is her hugest asset. She seems so genuine and grounded and is a pleasure to watch. I'm voting for Kim! Question for seasoned viewers: I'm a designer and would like to try out for season 3 (I know a million other people will too)but I have two young children and I don't think I could stand to be away from them for 6 weeks! Do you think they allow any visitation at all during that time?

Posted by corbin – September 10, 2007 9:59 AM

Very enjoyable! Kim is talented, able to provide viewers with great take-home points--a natural teacher with enthusiam to spare. Great Job! Todd interesting, but I saw hit pits way too many times! I felt like I saw enough of his designs a couple of weeks ago--agree with other bloggers about repetition. These reviews are very pro Kim, but DON'T TAKE THAT FOR GRANTED> BE SURE TO VOTE!!!

Posted by Avid Viewer – September 10, 2007 9:55 AM

Kim - you *get* aloha! Your room was soothing, comfortable and inviting, and you really captured the spirit of Hawaii. Many rooms in Hawaii don't have carpet because of all the sand that is dragged in; hard floors are so much easier to keep clean, so ripping up the carpet was a great idea! I loved your color scheme - the only thing missing was a vase or two filled with fresh Hawaiian tropicals. The headboard kicked butt!! Your furnishings and accessories were all beautifully placed, added a splash of color where needed and fit in well with everything else. I loved the Hawaiian throw on the bed! (Where did you get it?!) Where you REALLY knock it out of the ballpark is with your hosting skills. You're a natural! I hope to see you on tv in the future.

Todd - In the beginning you were a favorite (in spite of poor hosting skills), but as the show progressed I felt like you weren't improving. I'm literally in shock at the Vegas-style themed room you did for the final challenge. (Didn't you already do this room earlier in the competition?) The wall colors were awful, the carpet was atrocious, the paintings on the wall, tv stand, etc were dreadful. The rug in front of the tv was downright ugly. The kitchen table and chairs were too high and definitely did not look comfy. The artwork on the wall was interesting, but not appropriate for a nice suite, not to mention that frame was ugly. While I loved having a view of Diamond Head from the bed, I did not like having it at the expense of the kitchenette being next to the bed and the new kitchen area being so close to the bathroom. Unfortunately, I feel your biggest weakness is your hosting skills. You seem rushed and it all seems so forced - it's not comforting watching you. I would not tune in to your show - sorry.

And there you have it. :)

Posted by Leilani – September 10, 2007 9:53 AM

I wasn't expecting the final two to be either Todd or Kim, I admit it...
I truly thought it would be a Will and Scott duo (amazing designs) or a Will and Sparkle Josh match-off (amazing personalities).
So...having to rethink I tried to go through the strengths presented by our final two:
Todd - definitely over-the top style. His first individual challenge with the blue waves crashing! - didn't have to be functional (it was stated as such)..and I found it fun, imaginative and it made my senses come to life ( I could almost feel the wind and smell the salt sea air)
But then the gimmicks got to be too much in a true space setting - and function (when it was needed) was lacking....
Kim - her previous designs didn't impress me...but I could acknowledge that she DID have a grace in front of the camera...and she did bring together her best work in the final challenge. It was liveable, likeable...and she had some surprise elements I think I could run with....
Sooo....
guess who got my vote?

Posted by Pret07 – September 10, 2007 9:50 AM

I thought Kim stood out, not only in designing something that was classic, but in her continued presentation skills. Her room divider was clever, somthing that people at home could do. Part of a successful show is something I would want at home. I'm not big on jellyfish and bubbles, or living in an aquarium, but when a person wants whimsy, then Todd was great at that. I agree with the one person above, start a show with Will (more class than I can imagine) and Sparkle Josh, I think it would be a winner.

Posted by ken – September 10, 2007 9:49 AM

I am so glad to see so many people voting for Kim. Add me to the list I have voted for her all five times on cell and once online and will do so everyday I can. Kim definately has a style that if made into a show I to would watch all the time.

I do appreciate Todd's style he is an amazingly "creative" designer but most of his style stays pretty static and beach themed which is ok but you can only do beach so many ways.

Kim is more earthy and grounded which appeals to this Taurus ~smiles~ so ROCK ON KIM, you have all six of my votes everyday.

Posted by Julia – September 10, 2007 9:47 AM

Kim has my votes hands down. Todd's room was great for a dorm room but it was completely inappropriate for a hotel penthouse. I really don't believe Todd could design for a homeowner. He obviously showed the judges that he felt his ideas were superior to their years of experience. I doubt he could actually listen to a homeowner and give them something they wanted versus what he would want to do. Too arrogant and over the top. Kim = elegance

Posted by Donna – September 10, 2007 9:47 AM

Having lived in Hawaii for many years I feel Kim hit it right on with her color choices in her suite. When you're in Hawaii you're either on the beach or running around the island taking in all the sites. When you come back to your room you want something soothing, warm, and restful. Todd's use of blue was too much blue. I can sit on the beach and see all the blue I want. And at night when the lights are on I think Kim's room is more restful. Godd job girl!

I think Kim and Todd could work well together. Todd's amazing artistic insights and Kim's naturally talented eye could make for an amazing design statement. I wish them both the best of luck in their future's.

It was good to see Will again. And even Robb. Robb showed, on this episode, that he can work with others. Probably because he wasn't "in charge".

My vote went to Kim because I think she can appeal to a wider range of people that Todd can. I'm not a designer but like Kim, an "enthusiast". I wonder if she needs an assistant?

Posted by Mary McPhillips – September 10, 2007 9:38 AM

Things often look different in the light of day; so I decided to look over Kim and Todd's work one more time. Especially now that I'm 12+ hours away from the offensive armpit assaults,thanks Todd. NOT!
As for moving the bedroom to the living area,bad move; we attended an out of town wedding last month and as we've often done in the past, we selected a suite for our stay. Not unlike othe