Be the first to comment! Enter your comment in the form below.

I did not get to vote, but when they were opening the envelope I was yelling and calling out Kim, Kim, Kim, I knew you would win. Congratulations Kim, Great Work, You deserved it!!! Just keep being cute and yourself through your shows and you will stay a hit like David Bromstead (he is talented and a cutie). I think Sparkle Josh, Will and Mr Santa Barbara are cuties too..
Kim again, Good Luck on your new career and May God Bless and continue lighting your way.

Posted by M Martinez – September 21, 2007 4:01 AM

Congratulations to Kim on the huge article in Thursday's Newsday. New York is the heart of interior design and recognizes talent. Great pictures of your Hawaiian hotel suite -- and very large full page picture of a smiling Kim. Great!

Posted by olivia – September 21, 2007 2:04 AM

Congratulations, Kim and HGTV. It was a great finale. Enjoyed all the flashbacks. I believe Todd sealed his fate when he chose Will first to rattle Kim with Robb. That meant Kim had Will on the last day. And when the judges suggested Kim take up the carpet and put a coat on the cement floor, this would have been difficult if Robb had been with Kim that day. But Will told Kim "Do not worry, I will take care of it". Can you imagine Robb doing that??? Kim was a wonderful designer and deserved the honor. And Will was a great designer and a great friend!!

Posted by Dee – September 20, 2007 11:44 PM

Question: What is the difference between an Interior Decorator and a Designer? What type of work would I hire each of them for?

Congratulations Kim! I enjoyed every episode.
As Debra said, "To Cheryl (9/20) re hatemongers ~ You said a mouthful girl and I agree with every word! Thanks for all of that." -- me too! It was nice of Cheryl to take the time to write all that.

Posted by Ruth – September 20, 2007 10:22 PM

Kim was the clear star from the beginning. Not only is she talented at design and the best on-camera host but her humanity and genuineness was refreshing. I voted for her and I've never voted for anyone on any reality show in my life. She was worth it.

Posted by Marie – September 20, 2007 9:49 PM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!

We were rooting for Kim the whole time because if you follow the whole series from day one, Kim was the underdog. In any other dimension, Kim would have never made it. The odds were stacked aginst her.

However, Todd Davis -- loved you man! You brought it "fifth gear and full throttle" the whole time. Somehow, I think that HGTV has plans for him and Tood wil bring HGTV the kick in the butt that it'll need from time to time. I'm sure that something is in the works even now as we speak.

Also, don't think you've seen the last of most of the cast of the second season. Lisa Myles, "Sparkle" Josh Jonson, and Neeraja Lockart, we'll see you soon as well!

-- Vince

Posted by Vince "The Wolfman" Dawson – September 20, 2007 8:20 PM

My pick from the beginning of the show was Todd - his ideas were presented very well & professional. His downfall was the last episode in Hawaii - I personally thought he could have been much more creative - Kim really outdid not only herself but also Todd! Congratulations Kim.......

Posted by Pat – September 20, 2007 7:52 PM

DOES ANYONE KNOWS IF WILL HAS A WEBSITE OR SOMETHIN???.........AND CONGRATULATIONS KIM YOU'VE DONE AN EXCELLENT JOB!!!!

Posted by rosie flores – September 20, 2007 6:09 PM

Good posts: blestwoman "Ok, I wasn't going to even say this (refer to race)...", Cheryl "To all the hate monger's..." and Linda "Not only did America vote, but other countries as well...".

Congratulations Kim for making your dream coming true. Best wishes to Todd and the rest of the contestants for competing admirably. Looking forward to seeing what HGTV and Kim will do.

Note: HGTV...And yes I agree with most, see what can be done about getting Will and Sparkle on the schedule.

Posted by Brian LJ – September 20, 2007 5:50 PM

I was very disappointed that Todd did not win. I don't think Kim will make for a very good series. I didn't care for her designs or attitude throughout the season. Todd had such a refreshing design style. I would have watched his show with excitment to see what he would come up with next. He was unpredictable and I loved that about him. He was never boring and he has tons of energy. Too bad he was not the winner..... I would like to see what the voting tally was, somehow I don't think he lost by much (if at all). It is hard for me to believe that Kim won.... I just don't see how???? She was sooooo boring. I watch Davids shows all the time. He was the best candidate from last season. This seasons winner is a big mistake, she will not be able to hold an audience for very long if at all. TODD YOU WERE TAKEN...YOU SHOULD HAVE WON THIS THING. HGTV, please list the votes so we can see the results......

Posted by Janice – September 20, 2007 5:49 PM

HOORAY! Congratulations, Kim! Your genuine smile and winning personality shown through! Your ability to work positively with others was a huge benefit! My vbf of 30 years and I were both rootin' for ya! While we both admired Todd also, your gentle smilin' spirit made you the clear winner! Can't wait to see your future designs!

Posted by Steph – September 20, 2007 5:16 PM

Kim, Congratulations on the win, I knew you could do it! Altho I don't know you but you have such a presence. Can't hardly way to see your new show on GHTV!

Posted by Helen Strandlund – September 20, 2007 4:42 PM

I watched every episode & enjoyed it immensely.
I am happy for Kim, but I also liked Todd's creativity. Todd did not do well however in Hawaii. I still like Will; his kindness, humility, and creativity are awesome. I did not like Robb; he was rude and unkind.

Posted by Jannette – September 20, 2007 4:41 PM

Ok, I wasn't going to even say this (refer to race), but I am as white as they come, and I have been rooting for Kim/Will since about halfway through the Design Star Series. I had a hard time deciding which one, but it was so evident that Kim was a natural on camera (though I do feel Will could have been coached successfully on that). I wasn't at all concerned with their color or race. As a matter of fact, I wasn't sure what Kim's race was nor did I care. Why did Adriana have to refer to her race when she said she wanted to be the next "Hispanic design star"? I dearly love Hispanic people and speak Spanish, but that turned me off. I am an artist and would love to be famous someday but I don't say (or even think) that I want to be a famous Polish (or white) artist someday. I'm glad Kim won and wish she and Will could have won. It has nothing to do with race. It's called talent and who is right for the job.

Posted by blestwoman – September 20, 2007 4:38 PM

Congratulations to Kim ~ I liked her from the start and never wavered.

To Cheryl (9/20) re hatemongers ~ You said a mouthful girl and I agree with every word! Thanks for all of that.

Posted by Debra – September 20, 2007 3:32 PM

A BIG Congrats to Kim. I thought she was awesome and very real,she listened to her clients and gave them what they wanted. Wake up America! This is the land of opportunity!!! I voted the max votes each day for Kim and I am excited that she won. I never considered ethnic background an issue, people that do should wake up and realize that times have changed. I look forward to her show!! Great Job KIM!!!

Posted by Penny – September 20, 2007 3:23 PM

I am so glad Kim won! She just has the natural presence required to be on television! Ok, so I was thinking maybe HGTV should consider calling her show "Situational Design"! Anyone, anyone?!?

Posted by Shar – September 20, 2007 3:08 PM

Congratulations Kim. I did vote for you and more than once. I do await your new show and wish you every blessing God has in store for you and your family. You didn't start out fast, but you brought it home. I really liked your winning bounce at the end and the congrats from David B. because only he understood what you were really feeling at that moment. You were truly surprised, but extremely happy that you won. God speed!

On another note, all the recommendations for Will and Sparkle Josh to have a show together i greatly agree. What a hoot and a holla that show would be, and we would still learn a lot. Will has a lot a knowledge about design and Josh has and displays a lot of flair. So, HGTV, you have ready made STARS in these two; find a way to tap into such great resources and create something new in programming that would garner a lot of support from your audience. Peace.

Posted by marie – September 20, 2007 2:21 PM

Congrats Kim i was pulling for you the whole time.

Todd was a very good decorator also but a bit to whimsical for my taste.

i'm sure glad i didn't have to be a judge this year, there was alot of great talent in this show.

I think Will and Josh should have a show of there own also they make one hilarious team

Posted by Pat – September 20, 2007 1:37 PM

Love your work, hope to see alot more of your design. Am looking forward to watching

Posted by susan smith – September 20, 2007 12:58 PM

Kim, I am so glad that you won. I voted for you with good warm wishes. I really thought that Todd was very good also but in the end my vote was for you.I am sorry that you have had bad comments but no telling how people react.Some people even liked Rob,LOL. I am pleased that you,without formal training could win your own show. I wish you must success and wait to watch you next year. Make your fans proud.

Posted by Diana – September 20, 2007 12:56 PM

Not only did America vote, but other countries as well. Kim won - period. And the planning is underway for her show as well as Design Star 3. I look forward to the debut of her show next spring. I, like so many others that have responded, watch a ton of HGTV shows because I enjoy them and the diversity in the types of shows (e.g., angles, hosts' personalities and styles, interior, exterior, etc.).

I scanned quite a few of the comments as I was curious to read what was said about Kim and her ethnic background/race after I ran across the first one that mentioned race. And I instantly thought "here we go - it never fails". But I got tired of looking through them. And not that those comments matter to me; it just nevers ceases to amaze or surprise me that such ignorance exists. But unfortunately, so many of our society's issues have been and always will be underscored by race or ethnicity (e.g., education and the achievement gap, housing, employment, crime, etc.). And that's really sad.

As an African American, I'm glad that Kim won and not because she is African American but rather, she is someone who pursued her dream and achieved it. Her ethnicity or race is the "icing on the cake". She provides another role model and success story for our youth on achieving your dreams, hard work, leveraging your skills, critical thinking, communications, recognizing that life isn't easy, never be ashamed of expressing your true feelings, having a strong support system, surrounding yourself with people who encourage and want the best for you, and having determination. She can also open their minds to another career path in addition those such as sports, accounting, legal or nursing - all of which are worthy career paths to follow. It was also great to have Will on the show as an African American male.

My daughter and son watch a number of the design shows with me on occassion and they have asked me why there aren't many African American designers who have shows on televsion or support personnel like Robert on Design to Sell (there is another African American male that serves as a host on this show but his name escapes me at the moment). While I don't have "the definitive answer" for them, I have shared that it is not one of the "mainstream" careers that we are raised to think about or are exposed to. I can think of only two designers - Sheila Bridges and Lauren Lake - who are African American and have their own shows. There is a third women who has an "organization" type show but I hardly ever watch it as it's not on HGTV or Fine Living. I suspect that there may be - or not - others on Discovery Home or some other channel with a design show.

So while I am disappointed (but not surprised) that some folks believe Kim won because of her race, I suggest that they take into consideration that other countries were involved in the voting. So I sincerely doubt if most of those folks voted for Kim just because she is African American. And I appreciate the comment that one other "blogger" stated in that a majority of the viewers (given the demographics of this country) that watched the show and voted were probably not African American.

Hopefully, some day more people will be given credit their accomplishments because it was earned and not as a token. And I pray more and more people would celebrate and embrace diversity and all the wonderful advantages that it presents and not use it as an excuse that someone was given something that he or she didn't deserve. Then we can have more conversations (at least on the HGTV website) about the merits of the shows and appreciate the essence of what many of the various shows are about - information, inspiration and entertainment.

Posted by Linda – September 20, 2007 12:46 PM

What Happened!!Kim was what I call a piggybacker. She was shrude.She did one thing right.She spoke well in front of a camera. nothing more.It made me ill that she was in the last 5.If they wanted a woman Adrianna was the one. Now all my friends and family want me as a contestant. Another sad show.LETITIA

Posted by Letitia – September 20, 2007 12:08 PM

To all the hate monger's,( Poor sports) here's a few comments to:
#1. Sylvia from 9/18, It's sad to see that you have a conspiratorial complex,"Kim could only win because of contacts with the judges". I read the contract for Design Star, and they are very careful that there are no relationships that exsist between contestants and staff.
#2. Renee Taylor 9/18, Hairstylists have to put in a minumum of 1500 hours of training in order to get licensed in most states. It involves learning the color charts, listening to clients wants and learning constantly to keep up with new trends. It is not a reach to switch those skills into other area's of design.
#3. Lisa 9/18. To quote, " The headboards weren't even her idea", When Kim went shopping, they weren't head boards, they were wall hangings. She reinvented their use.
How did Kim get her way in the kitchen design with Robb? She told him he couldn't put the dishwasher under the sink. Can you put your's there? I can't.
She didn't agree with putting the stove/oven between the sink and dishwasher. I don't either, that just is not practical design.
#4.Denise 9/18. What is wrong with wall paper? Even Candace Olson uses it.
#5. Paul 9/18. Shame on you, calling the home in West Virginia "Hillbilly Hollow". That is the home of very hard working people who risk their lives to make yours more comfortable. Commenting that Kim " Forest Gumped her way through that was design was a cheap shot too. She had to travel quite far just to purchase supplies and the carpet was certainly the only choice with the lack of time, I would have chosen differently if I had the time for ceramic and wood, but she didn't.
#6. Lynda 9/17. Don't watch the show anymore, we can live without people like you who just want to see others fail. Does it make you feel like a bigger, better person? Didn't think so....
#7. R.Kincaid, You stated "Kim used people, and was arrogant". I think she showed confidence in her ideas, and worked hard to keep up a good countenance with Robb.
#8.Rebecca Ray, Clive announced the voting deadline several times during the broadcast of the final challenge and it was posted online also. Your comments make you look like a poor sport, come on you had a chance, as did your family to vote just like everyone else. The paperplate cut-outs took thought and time to execute, along with the table, they were original and smart.
#9.Cabanche82, Shame on you! Racist remarks just make you sound little. America showed it was passed the race issue by voting for Kim.
#10. Sue 9/17, Yes she started as a hairdresser, can't she do anything else? Are we limited to just one choice in life to do only one thing? Or can we shoot for the stars, strive for a dream to come true? I hope so....
#11. Cristine Kinan, Again with Robb's kitchen, it wasn't well planned at all. How many of you want to have to cross over an oven/stove to load your dishes. The green tile work was also sloppy and unfinished looking. Robb's proclaimed experience didn't shine here.

Well I could go on and on there are so many bitter and hateful statements that could be addressed I would be here all day, but I have to go redesign my kitchen, cut my hair, landscape my front yard and wear a more flattering dress, that doesn't show my belly button .But none of this should be a problem, because in the real world, I am going to go watch some HGTV!

Posted by Cheryl – September 20, 2007 11:22 AM

Congratulations to Kim. It was obvious the first night that she'd be the winner. She's a great host, and an alright decorator. I LOVE the posting by the Design Star team on Sept. 17! To funny....especially the part about Robb being captured by a band of preschoolers and put in time out!! He's a bully.....can you say Prozac dear??? LOVE, love, love Sparkle Josh. He and Will definately need their own show....now there's entertainment!!!!!

Posted by Linda – September 20, 2007 11:14 AM

I was intrigued by the so many discussions of "this one is only a decorator" and this one is a "designer". What's the issue?
There are many formally trained (and even not so formally trained) professionals and amateurs who truly are masters of what I call the "design" phase - they understand layout, scale, color, functionality...some even have the special knack of custom created pieces that enhance their design plan. I appreciate their expertise...and their decorating skills (it's all in the details!). Is it because one thinks everything HAS to be custom made to be a "design"? There is nothing wrong with shopping at Wal-Mart, Pier One, Target, vs. the most upscale furniture stores for ready made stock materials...it all has to do with WHAT CAN I AFFORD and what is my SKILL LEVEL. Professional designers have told me (saw it in an HGTV special)that having artifical plants in my home was a design NO-NO - guess what? In my home artifical works well, my allergies thank me....so take what ideas you can get from the professional and ignore what doesn't work for you. The best designers and decorators are the ones with the best listening skills.

Posted by Pret07 – September 20, 2007 10:34 AM

I watch the Design Star sence the first time it ever came on HGTV. This show has help alot when my house got finish and helping design the inside of my house. I love David and Kim I'm glad she won. I love HGTV and Design Star.

Posted by Josie – September 20, 2007 10:21 AM

An Interior designer does everything a decorator does, plus has a degree in interior design, by studying for four or five years to become well versed in many pertinent fields: space planning and functionality, drafting, lighting, airconditing and heating , fine arts, perspective, art history, history of furniture, architecture, project managing, commercial design, budget managing, time managing, color coordination, fabric choices for safety and durability, design for the handicapped, state, local and federal laws pertaning to safety and building codes, and many other issues. Probably only ten percent of the designer's time is spent
being a decorator and making the place look pretty.

Posted by Joline Diehl – September 20, 2007 10:12 AM

First of all I want to say to all of the designers this year - Congratulations! I can see it was very diffcult from the beginning to make choices of elimination. However, I have to say that from the very beginning I found Kim's style and personality to be wonderful for an actual TV program. She always made me feel as though I was sitting with my best friend over coffee, comforting, easy and very diplomatic. That was a big plus for me.

I look forward to the new Kim Myles show, and what fresh ideas she brings to HGTV.

Posted by Kitty – September 20, 2007 10:11 AM

I was unable to watch the series from the beginning but did tune into the final two, (sorry I missed all the designs). I can't help but believe that Todd and Kim are both deserving in their own way for their own shows but I feel that Todd chose the wrong time to bring out his "personal" flare when there is such a harmonic balance of traditional vs. "freestyle". I thought he might have been a little dangerous saving this design, although it was fun and exciting, for his final attempt. When I think of a vacation area, I really want to come back to a hotel room or condo and relax and unwind. Save the hoopla for sightseeing and activities. Todd is a great guy but we have enough colorful figures out there. I personally like the fact that Kim was able to speak her mind about things that went wrong without going over board or pitching a fit. She is calm and cool under pressure and definitely "gracious". Congratulations, Kim. I had a feeling from the first time I saw the Hawaii room that you were a shew in. Todd will in no doubt have many opportunities for a fascinating career and probably even his own show. It's America! The land of opportunity. Let's not hurl insults. Plenty of people have no formal training and yet have plenty of talent and taste. I think your show will be great as is David's. P.S. How can America get it wrong it they voted their feelings! Did you vote yours? I hesitated to vote and lost out on the chance to do so but thank you America, you voted for me! Yea, the system works!!!

I love watching HGTV and can't hold them responsible for my taste nor the taste of others. It's a democracy, get over it!

Posted by Sherry Muzyka – September 20, 2007 9:41 AM

Kim you and Todd were my choice from the first show to win the competition. It was great to watch you come from the back of the pack to win. Wish it could have been a duo this time and you and Todd host a show together. But seeing how only one could win, you were the right choice. The designs are awesome and I would be honored to have you do a complete make over of my home. I love your style. I love your personality. You are going to do a GREAT job and make the producers of HGTV very proud. I will NOT miss one of your shows. Always be you and you are going far in this world.

Jim Colbert, Denton TX

Posted by Jim Colbert – September 20, 2007 9:28 AM

Congratulations Kim I can't wait to see your new show. It's great to know that even if you don't have professional design experience or a degree in design that you can still be number one and people respect you. What an inspiration to all of us who like to dabble in designing spaces at home and in our communities. Keep up the good work and thank you.

Todd, I just want to say you handled yourself so professionally and polished on the final and sincerely were a great sport and supportive to Kim. That speaks volumes and so great you can be that way. I watch HGTV with my children and being that way sets a great example to them that you give it your all and hope you end up number one but that doesn't always happen. To see you handle yourself that way is a great example to all and shows that you can still be happy positive and make a difference in people's lives even if you aren't the last one standing. My kids notice these things and so do I.

I have to say that most of the contestants seemed to be very supportive and it really makes it nice to watch...there were a couple of shows where my kids thought someone wasn't very nice but I used that as an example. There aren't many shows you can watch with young children anymore and it is great to see HGTV bringing educational content that impacts your daily life and still wholesome enough to watch as a family.

Keep up the good work! Thanks!

Posted by AM1985 – September 20, 2007 7:51 AM

DESIGN STAR III and future design stars should have to have an interior design degree and at least 10 years design experience before even being placed in the top 25. Then the judges and America can decide on the rest; creativity, design concept, personality, looks, hosting abilities, etc.

Posted by LasVegasGirl – September 20, 2007 6:27 AM

Todd should have won! He had the personality, talent,energy, and experience to entice viewers to tune in to his show. I'm not sure why anyone would want to watch Kim's show??? I won't be.

Posted by Janet – September 20, 2007 12:36 AM

I am very glad that Kim won! Her sweetness and quiet spirit will carry her far.

hope to see Will and Jash go on to do something I also liked their work

Posted by Marie Allen – September 20, 2007 12:28 AM

CONGRATS KIM !!! I wanted you to win from day one,and you DID !!! I have read some of the other blogs, and Kim, I dont care what color you are, I would have voted for you, based on your talent not your skin color.(Some people are so off their rocker).You had the class and the imagination to pursue your dreams.YOU GO GIRL !!

Posted by Karen – September 20, 2007 12:14 AM

I was SO hoping Kim would win! As an artist and art professor, I approached this series as I would have a semester of class with talented students. Early on, I intuited that Will, Kim, Sparkle Josh and Todd (as well as Neeraja!!) would be "the Best in the Class". I HATED the double eliminations---that is like failing a student after the first project! HGTV, Puh-leaze do not do that again---make the series longer if necessary!! That was just wrong! Continuing the "classroom" context, Robb would have been expelled after 2 or 3 sessions; his sexism and rude, disruptive "high energy" have no place. Todd clearly has skeels and a what could be a "style"; I appreciated that, but he repeated himself instead of EXTENDING his obvious innovative talent,he was WAY too concerned with the "STAR" part of it, rather than pushing it to the REAL full throttle! Of course, like many other bloggers, I regret that we were able to see so little of what REALLY went on. I kept having the sense that we saw MUCH more in the first season. Surely this does not have to be so slick-and-sleazy (WHO came up with Las Vegas as a venue?!) like so many of the current/recent HGTV productions---maybe you should change your associations with "that company" (you know who I mean!!). I long for the old days when we saw so much more from Canada--MISS DEBBIE TRAVIS!! What ever happened to "Small Spaces..." C'MON!!! Give us back the quality we deserve!!
I have not gone off the subject. I'm just saying LISTEN TO US!! I concur with so many of the above blogs, and with Cynthia's comment---"Can't we just have a Group Show?" Will and Sparkle Josh should have a shot at co-hosting; they are both terrific, in their individual ways and together! Will really got short-changed; he has more "presence" despite his accent (perhaps BECAUSE of it!) than Todd could muster with all his antics! NOT EVERONE HAS TO FIT THE MOLD OF "Camera-Ready". Give us, give America, some AUTHENTICITY!!! Josh got short-changed, too! Neerajta had incredible "stage presence" and a unique approach (like Candice Olsen, but less "staged".) I am truly happy Kim won. She has the potential to give us something fresh and wonderful, and if some of the others are not included in some of her episodes or on their own shows, I will be severely disappointed in HGTV's sense of what we the Viewers want!!

Lin Fife, Professor of Art/Design

Posted by Lin Fife – September 19, 2007 11:40 PM

I was disappointed with this years show overall. There was absolutely not the talent there that they had last year. I thought they got rid of Lisa too early. Even though she was so different, and usually not someone who would appeal to me, her designs they showed of what she had done previously proved that she did have talent. And I really didn't think that the work she did on that first show was nearly as bad as the little "lounge" area that Robb and I think it was Josh did. (Even though I think Robb is VERY talented)

I like Kim as a person. She was very nice. But she had no original ideas of her own. Will gave her her ideas for the room, and then the judges suggested doing the floors. It was not something she came up with on her own. Even at that, Will was the one to come through and do them for her.

I believe that Will didn't win because of his grammer. He was fun, personable, likeable and VERY TALENTED. It is too bad that he didn't work on his grammer before the show, because he was far and away the better host with the exception of his grammer.

And I LOVED Sparkle Josh. Hey, a show with SJ and Will together would be great-they worked very well together!

Posted by Lorrie – September 19, 2007 10:49 PM

Hooray KIM!!!!! I thought it should have been between Will and Kim. They were both so personable and polite and worked the clients wishes into their great designs! Todd on the other hand should be designing sets at Disneyland. (I'd like a big wave on my bedroom wall, or a skateboard ramp in the living room--NOT! GET REAL TODD) I'm so glad everyone else voting thought he was not as great as he obviously thought he was.

Posted by Janet – September 19, 2007 10:21 PM

Truely a mistake was made...Todd was the best designer all the way..too bad he didn't win..I will not be watching Kim's show that is for sure.

Posted by Jodi – September 19, 2007 10:00 PM

Kime Kim Kim, I am delighted you won, I found your ideas young and refreshing. You also have a great personality that I think will shine though on HGTV. Not only did I vote for you, I made sure I watch all your designs. Glad you won girl.

Posted by Maggie Borham – September 19, 2007 8:46 PM

I too am jazzed that Kim won! Way to go girl! To me this was a hard decision, as I only got to the contest about mid-way. I love how Kim explains her process, has good hosting skills, and is just plain enthusiastic when she is dead on her feet! Robb, you did a great job, you will find your niche in design. A little too daring for me at this stage of my life, but I could relate to your ideas.

You both are truly blessed with talent. May you use it to make people's lives better, not just for the big money.

Posted by Callie Calligan – September 19, 2007 8:40 PM

Not to take anything, away from Todd, He is who I voted for, not because he was white, handsome, or silly. Just thought he had Talent. and I thought that was the idea. Every body looks at talent in different ways. and that the way it should be, for everybody. It heartbreaking to bring race into this. It hurts a lot of people and I am sure, that was not HGTV intentions. That why I wish now , That it had been between, Will and Kim
as the top two, I am sure a lot of these ugly blog would not have been written..
I would have ,no doubt voted for Will, Will just has it, in all departments. Or had it been down to Will and Josh, I would have had a problem
Because, they both were, and are good. But if I had voted for Josh it would not have been because he was white It would have been based on talent a lone. I am just glad I did not have to make that choice. Kim won, fair and square , and what did race have to do with anyway.? Give her A break. let her do her shows and if you are not pleased, turn the channel, That so easy to do. I do it all the time ! when, people use fowl language. Just ask yourself. If, it was Will and Kim, in the top two. {Because we love them both] WHO WOULD YOU HAVE VOTED FOR ? That will
let you know it all about Design,

Posted by Bonnie Osteen – September 19, 2007 8:29 PM

I will not watch.

Posted by will not watch – September 19, 2007 8:17 PM

I voted for you. I think you have a good sense of what Middle America wants. Not something over the top or out of our price range but some good designs that inspire us. I want something with a little flair but I don't want to spook the neighbors. I'm so happy for you and I wiah you all the success you deserve. Keep learning and growing. that's what life's about!

Posted by cheryl – September 19, 2007 7:50 PM

At first, I wasn't attracted by either room in the last episode so I gave some thought to which one I would choose to spend the most time in - Todd's won!

Posted by Elizabeth S – September 19, 2007 7:50 PM

Just one last comment and then I am going to get on with my life. I suggest that the rest of you do the same! Enough of the negative comments - it's over, it can not be changed so live with it. Don't watch Kim's show if you feel that way. For me, I will be looking forward to her "design" AND "decorating", and her show. I truly believe her show will give US, regular people, ideas of what we could do in our homes. As much as I LOVE Candice Olson, I could not afford her designs. The Design on a Dime shows are good, BUT - sometimes they seem amatureish, other times I do get good ideas that I can use. What I think Kim will bring is a middle ground with things we can do and use in our homes. I did like the way she explained things that "you can do in your own home". That's what I want - not the programs with an unlimited budget. Most people that watch HGTV are those who are looking for ideas that WE can do - not things that we need to hire a "Designer" for. I have been and will continue to be an avid HGTV viewer. I will also look forward to next years program. A PS: PLEASE have Will AND Kim do the new show. I really think they would make a great team.
Rene from Latrobe PA (another PS Kim and Will come and re-do my home - I would even settle for one room!

Posted by Rene – September 19, 2007 7:33 PM

Way to go KIM!!! I voted for her because of the great designs. She was sooooo comfortable in front of the camera. She so wanted it and so got it. I can't wait for her show. CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!!

Posted by daykotah – September 19, 2007 7:30 PM

I'm pleased to say I voted for you Kim, and I'm delighted you won! CONGRATS! Whatever road your new show takes, I'm sure it will be fun to watch...and I WILL watch it.

Congratulations to the rest of the designers, too. You all deserve recognition, because you wouldn't have been on the show, if you hadn't had more talent than the majority of other contenders. It was fun watching all of you, and good luck in the future!

Posted by dollfriend – September 19, 2007 6:52 PM

I was hoping Kim would win right from the beginning. Her smile and personality won me over right at the start and her talent kept me voting for her.
Congratulations Kim. Now come on down to Sanibel Island and redecorate my house.

Posted by Heather – September 19, 2007 6:45 PM

Kim -- you proved that innate talent, intelligence, and hard work may oftimes overshadow formal training. May your life change just as you wish it to!

Posted by Dunes_Studio – September 19, 2007 6:39 PM

Kim, congratulations. You are a very polished young lady with a strong sense of style. I enjoyed your presentation skills and your ability to connect with your audience and explain the design concepts you used. I also loved the way you checked Rob! I look forward to seeing your new show. You go girl!!!

Posted by Mary in Chicago – September 19, 2007 6:36 PM

Congratulations to Kim! Of the two finalists, Kim's designs were the best. My choice would hae been Will for overall design expertise; and I, too, thought he could have excelled at hosting with some coaching. All of the designers were great! For those who don't realize that we are living in the 21st century and a global society, please don't make Design Star 2 an issue about race. There are talented designers from all ethnic groups and I applaud HGTV for it's effort to be inclusive and diverse in it's choice of the 11 designers. We must remember that AMERICA VOTED, AND AMERICA VOTED FOR KIM; 'nuff said. Let's support her by watching her show and observing how she will develop into an awesome design star. As to her ethnic background, I was truly blessed to see her husband and family love her and support her wholeheartedly. The genuine love and support her family displayed was even more meaningful than her awesome victory! I voted for Kim, not Todd. He's a builder and a surfer with no design sense. He "lucked" into the finals due to the female judge's affinity for his good looks. And will someone please tell the judges to put on some clothes. I thought that last outfit Cynthia(?) wore to the finals was a disgrace, along with her hot pants and barely there pink mini dress. I love HGTV and watch almost every show; but I am not impressed with David Bromstad -- he uses too much red and his artwork can be a little amateurish; but Candace is a true design diva!! Thanks!

Posted by Betty Sims – September 19, 2007 4:38 PM

TODD YOU ARE A WHINER. I was very UNimpressed with you and how you moaned and whined over every project about something.I would NOT want you in MY house. Kim however is fun adaptable and eager to please. I LOVE that she won

Posted by Danni – September 19, 2007 4:03 PM

This wasn't JUST about design. It's also about personality, whether or not a show can be built around the winner. Todd is exuberant and talented, yes, but after three shows of his tumbling into a room, shouting "YEAH, Bring it ON!" and doing something over the top and so very California, I think many people would tune him out. Kim has talent as a designer and a different eye for color. She is good at finding ways to explain to an audience how to replicate her work and how to breathe life into a space. There aren't enough women doing these shows and I think she could add something to the HGTV line up. I wish she'd do a show with Will... or maybe Sparkle and Will could have something great together, I don't know. I agree that there were too many double eliminations very early on, so who knows what talent disappeared because of poor leadership over a team? Congratulations Kim. And KUDOS for not showing EVERY disagreement up close and personal like Bravo's reality shows. At least you minimize the disagreements to personality conflicts ON THE JOB

Posted by jet – September 19, 2007 4:00 PM

HGTV should bring back Sparkle Josh and Will in their own show. Congrats Kim!!!!

Posted by Nancy – September 19, 2007 3:00 PM

Congratulations Kim!
I can't wait till Spring when your show comes out! I am sure it will as be exciting and interesting as you made the entire season of Design Stars. You are a natural and I look forward to watching you create for years to come!
Hugs, Jan

Posted by Jan – September 19, 2007 1:28 PM

Kudos to Kim. African-American? I didn't know that nor do I care but I must wonder why people are bringing that up...what nonsense, eh? Kim did a fine job and her hosting skills are magnificent. She will get trained and honed and coached and helped and she will only get better. I, too, thought Todd did a fine job at the beginning, but you know...a little of the cartwheels and handstands and macho bravado goes a long long way and he seemed to miss the obvious! Like that last design in Hawaii...bad!!!! And those kids' little hammock where they could fall out right over some wooden storage pieces!! I betcha Will will visit Kim when she begins her show cause Will is and was such a plus. Kudos Kim dear!!

Posted by shi2shi – September 19, 2007 11:51 AM

If you look at all the "Rate My Design"'s on the home page of HGTV, you will note that Will's designs got more high ratings than all others... So, what does that tell me? Boy last season, girl this season....

Posted by ssam – September 19, 2007 11:40 AM

I just finally got to watch the finale as I DVR'd it, which a mom with 2 young children typically ends up doing, although I did cheat and see who won prior as I visited this site and read the blog -- I couldn't help myself.

Congrats to Kim! I voted for her and will be anxious to see what kind of show she does. Maybe they should call it "The Situation Room" since she was always describing everything as a situation!! That was funny.

I enjoyed seeing all the castmates back together. I loved all the clips. They looked like they had a lot of fun together and I definitely saw more of their personalities than we were allowed to see with the editing and the pace of the show, and I have to say, I liked them a lot more after this finale. Sparkle Josh is a riot!!! Will is the coolest ever. I would like Josh and Will to come hang out with me and help me do some things in my home and then hang out and cook after -- what fun that would be!!

Anyway, I disagree with the judges that there was more talent this year than last, and I have to say I definitely enjoyed season 1 much more than this one. I love Kim and I'm glad she won (though I liked Todd as well) but I don't know if she was THE most talented out of this bunch because, as many have said before, we never really got to know them because of the double eliminations and the type of work they had them do. So, I definitely never want to see Design Star in Vegas again because it just bred tackiness, and I hope next season is truer to season 1's format and has more individual competition. Also, they'll have to change up those little rooms they do in the beginning (Wildcard Challenge/99 cents)because it needs an infusion of something new.

I wish everyone from this season all the best. I know we will see some of them again for sure. I am looking forward to seeing what Kim's show will be like - congrats again! I would love to be on Design Star 3 but I really don't have a pinky's worth of these people's talent and I would never want to open myself up to the criticism from everyone like they do, especially bloggers, because blogging tends to attract the haters and the armchair critics who are too busy living their lives in front of the computer criticizing others to live their own lives and take any chances of their own. I can say that because I blog and I try to keep it positive, but if you read blogs regularly, it's definitely a "safe" place for people to vent (and vent they do) and it can really drag everything down. I would never read them if I was on TV.

Anyway, HGTV, let's get a good balance of season 1 and 2 for season 3 and give us what we ask for. I can't wait!!

Posted by Mandy – September 19, 2007 10:32 AM

I think that it is great that Kim won. It shows us that an ordinary person can be a Design Star. I would have liked to see Will win though. I thought that he had the best designs, and you can clearly see that his heart was in every design. He was also a great team player. Todd was also a great designer and a good team player, however, I think that his designs were too over the top, and he did remind me of the 1st design star.

Posted by Jay – September 19, 2007 10:01 AM

I love HGTV & would have watched either Kim or Todd on a new show. Best wishes to Kim & encouragment to Todd.

Posted by Nagatha – September 19, 2007 9:35 AM

STOP REPEATING YOURSELVES AND COPYING AND PASTING MESSAGES PLEASE.
I THINK THE HATE SHOULD STOP AND PEOPLE SHOULD GIVE POSITIVE COMMENTS AND CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM ONLY. What Would You Add or Make Different for the Show Next Season to make it better, more effective and fair?
STOP DWELLING IN THE PAST. AND AS FOR THE TRADING SPACES COMMENT, ALL I HAVE TO SAY IS THAT I DISLIKE SHOWS WHERE DESIGNERS WANT TO SHOW OFF AND COMPLETELY IGNORE THE TASTE AND NEEDS OF THE HOME OWNERS. WHY DO YOU THINK Ty Pennington LEFT FOR HIS OWN GOOD? I NEVER LIKED THAT SHOW AND NEVER WILL.
ANOTHER EXAMPLE IS DEBBIE TRAVIS, WHO HAS A COPY OF DESIGN STAR IN CANADA, SINCE I RESEARCHED HER THE OTHER NIGHT. I LOVE HER AND THINK SHE IS A DIVA,(ALTHOUGH MY FAVORITE IS CANDACE OLSEN),BUT HER SHOW FACELIFT SHOWS HER DOING WHAT SHE WANTS AND SHOWCASING WHAT SHE THINKS LOOKS BEST, AND ONCE AGAIN, BY IGNORING THE HOMEOWNERS WISHES COMPLETELY.
HOME OWNERS ARE "THE CLIENTS", HELLO!!!
THAT IS WHY I THINK HUMOR IS A RECIPE FOR SUCCESS. JOSH SHOULD HAVE HIS SHOW AFTER MORE TRAINNING IN DESIGN, AND WILL, NEEDS SPEECH COACH AND HOSTING CLASSES. I THINK JOSH SHOULD BE WITH ADRIANA (strong hispanic woman)AS A CARPENTER AND DESIGNER (who could also have a show about women doing handy work for themselves), AND SOME OPPOSITE PERSONALITY LIKE ROB TO MAKE BALANCE (after he learns how to measure rooms), OR SOMEONE GAY BUT STRONG, LIKE MICHAEL MOLONEY FROM EXTREME MAKEOVER HOME EDITION. THE OTHER DESIGNERS DON'T REALLY SHINE IN MY OPINION.
I ALSO THINK VERY STRONGLY THAT HGTV SHOULD HIRE Niecy Nash FROM "clean house" AND Andrew Yumbo FROM "diy" FOR AN ORGANIZATIONAL SHOW WITH HUMOR AND SPUNK!
AS A MOTHER, DOMESTIC DIVA AND FAN, AND ARTIST, I THINK THERE ARE GOOD PEOPLE, AND PEOPLE THAT ARE GOOD AT SOMETHING, BUT THERE ARE OTHERS THAT ARE GIFTED AND SIMPLY AMAZING. People THAT HAVE THE PASSION, BUT WERE BORN WITH THE SUPER NATURAL TALENT AND CALLING. THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE! DAVID BROMSTED IS AN EXAMPLE OF "EXCELLENCE", CANDICE OLSEN IS ANOTHER. I THINK THE SHOW Design Star SHOULD DO MORE INDIVIDUAL CHALLENGES IN MORE REALISTIC SCENARIOS AND TIME FRAMES, AND WITH TRAINNING classes given by Pro's, LIKE I SAID IN MY MESSAGE OF SEPT. 18TH.
Remember, if you don't have anything new to share or suggest, don't write at all. GOOD ENERGY ONLY PEOPLE!

Posted by Yanny – September 19, 2007 2:46 AM

I wish that next year HGTV would change their elimination method. This year some good designers were cut too quickly without us being able to see their talent. Perhaps next year "points" could be awarded to designers based on their designs for the first three episodes, then the lowest scorers could be eliminated starting with episode 3.

Posted by Diane – September 19, 2007 1:39 AM

So sad to see so many negative comments about Kim. I believe she is a real person with a real family. She gets my vote because she actually loves her family and they obviously come first. Her husband gets an A+ for allowing her this opportunity to grow into a exciting new person. It must be exciting for them to watch the transformation. You go girl!

Posted by karen – September 19, 2007 1:00 AM

Congratulations, Kim. Clearly the better finalist won. I loved your Hawaiian suite, and the concrete floors were very modern.

To the other posters on this (or any other)site: please use punctuation, check your spelling and grammar, and DON'T SHOUT.

Posted by Kim – September 19, 2007 12:36 AM

Dear Kim, America and HGTV:

Congratulations Kim....so glad you won and I hope you will ensure that you have Will on your show so that it can be a first.....TWO official African-American designers on HGTV at the same time!!!!

I am not at all shocked or rocked by the racist comments being made about an African-american female, who happens to have a white husband, winning "Design Star".

.....Indivisible with liberty and justice for all my paint brush!!!! ONLY IN AMERICA!!!

So while I am sorry that Kim is receiving all of those negative comments and opinions....once again, the order of the day does not ALWAYS have to represent YOU and what YOU think....thanks to the American's who voted for the best design and the best effort and thanks to all of you so-called Americans with your negative views that keep African Americans and others "in tune", "on-guard" and "very much aware" that racism and racist remarks in America is a prevalent as good 'ol american apple pie....or rather as good as "color, space, theme and design" as indicated and viewed by some sorry viewers of HGTV.

Right on! Kim, Will and Right on! to all African-American designers.....you all are definately on a roll!!!!

Hey HGTV....how about getting some African-American judges....this would be REALLY representative of an America that needs to grow up and continue to acknowledge the contributions of others....fair and squaree!!!!!

Posted by Belenda – September 19, 2007 12:09 AM

There has been so much discussion of whether or not someone is a “decorator” or a “designer.” (i.e., Kim is “accused” of being just “decorator”; while Todd is a “designer”?) Would someone (knowledgeable) please explain the difference. It would seem to me that these two terms, if not interchangeable are, at least, closely related. Don’t most “interior designers” do both?

As far as the winner (Kim) goes, it is interesting to note that almost all of the comments running up to the final supported Kim as the winner; now that she won, there are lots of comments complaining about the outcome. So go figure.

Congratulations to Kim! It will be very interesting to see what kind of format for Kim’s show, HGTV will develop.

And for the third, fourth, fifth, or sixth time, I still think that Will and Sparkle Josh would make the best team for a new show!

The comment from “design star reunion” was a classic and very, very clever. Where Are They Now (from Design Star 1 and 2) would make a great show.

Design Star addicts need a longer season. My top ten suggestions for DS3:
1. One or two fewer team competitions; one or two more individual competitions.
2. Do not eliminate anyone the first show; give everyone at least a second chance. And please, please, please, no more (or at least far fewer) double eliminations!
3. Someone mentioned a Christmas design competition . . . that would be interesting and fun . . . or have each pick a holiday out of their paint can (Christmas, Easter, New Years, Halloween, July 4th, Thanksgiving, etc.)
4. Would like to see a competition based upon different randomly drawn styles (French Country, English Garden, contemporary, Arts and Crafts, etc. etc.). Allow the designer to do some research into the style . . . no more fake Tuscan kitchens.
5. One kitchen is enough, but kitchens would have to be a team competition.
6. How about designing a bathroom?
7. Because kitchens and bathrooms are really labor intensive and involved, perhaps do these designs on paper only for the judges to evaluate. Can’t realistically accomplish in 24-26 hours.
8. Designing the same apartment based on a different color choice (from season 1) was an interesting competition that ought to be repeated.
9. Deserving Design was a worthwhile interesting challenge. How about teaming up with Habitat for Humanity? Or help with reconstruction after Katrina? Each team or individual could do an entire house.
10. Clive is a wonderful host; Vern Yip is a great judge; think about adding some new judges and/or some guest critiques from people like Candace Olson, Kenneth Brown, Michael Payne, or Joe Ruggiero.

HGTV is my favorite network. And Design Star is so much fun and entertaining; the blog (which I participated in for the first time) was great fun. I am really looking forward to Design Star 3 and all my favorites (Divine Design with Candace Olsen, ReDesign with Kenneth Brown, Homes Across America) and perhaps some new shows. But “Get It Together” is not as good as Michael Payne’s “Designing for the Sexes.” I think that HGTV is getting too heavy into contemporary design to the exclusion of other styles. And too many real estate sales shows. Also it seems that HGTV is chasing a much younger audience? Remember that the biggest demographic is still “Baby Boomers” . . . . interested in many design styles and who will be retiring soon. A show on “downsizing” and “upsizing” for retirement would be great.

Thanks for reading; I enjoyed all the other comments (even the tacky ones I did not agree with). Kudos to HGTV for a fun and entertaining season.
Regards

Posted by Jane Also in SS, TX – September 18, 2007 11:37 PM

Comment to Renee Taylor
There must be a reason to live in America!! Where have you been? Did you just watched the last episode. Kim deserved to win. Just to be able to handle Rodd was enough to give her the title. And for your information were you born being a designer?! Many people have different "jobs" before they reach their dreams? Do you think that the actors and actresses went straight to the screen without any audition? Who knows what it is that you design? By the way if you had seen last year competition, you could possibly agreed that this year group was superior in many aspects. If you feel offended, do not bother watching the show because Kim does not have to prove anything to you and those people that feel like you. Kim congratulations. I can't wait to see your show and what the name will be. Success to you and the best to all the other contestants.

Posted by Olga Baez – September 18, 2007 10:21 PM

Good Evening everyone...

It's Trudy, who commented in the wee hours of the morning, congratulating KIM & giving my candid & constructive Feedback to all.

I enjoyed that ALL of us have our own true passion for this show, what it added to our own lives, hopefully some of our own design creations in our own homes...I even chuckled about another fan in 'Withdrawal' as I realized it resonated with me, like: 'Shucks! What am I going to be excited to see 9 PM Sunday, OR I'll REALLY MISS THAT SHOW...!"

What surprises & disappoints me is the unnecessary negativity occasionally vented by some here. Yes, I DID vote for both winners each year; Does that make me a better person? Heck, NO! A friend of mine did not vote for David, & was for Kim, yet did not vote. IMPORTANTLY, 'we can agree to disagree.' I find that the highest form of relating. Why can't we do that here? (I feel like 'Will' all of a sudden.)

I also thought some of the CONSTRUCTIVE COMMENTS, like changing the format to: No eliminations till week 2-3; Using Teams for Spot Shows, etc. were MOST creative & inspired. Why can we not use our perspectives in a positive way to make HGTV & this experience a plus rather than the uncomfortable name-slinging which got the 'old Rob' PRIOR to "Damage Control ROB" booted out, as we MUST get along, to be able to work effectively?

I applaud "the larger HGTV Fan Family" who made positive comments on how to better the process of the show, rather than to express volatile or inappropriately hostile comments. Please do not get me wrong; I am not a "namby-pamby" type person,& I call things as I see them, which does NOT always make me popular; still,when I must give Feedback that is NOT positive, I have tried to develop a Formula (for lack of a better word):to direct the constructive criticism to THE BEHAVIOR and NOT TO THE PERSON!

In fact, I usually start with what I like about the person as a human being, and LEAD INTO what I did not like about their behavior.

Let's face it folks...there go WE. My own personal feeling, for whatever it is worth, is to reflect how each of us, IF NEGATIVE had to be shared with us, COULD HEAR it most powerfully as a learning experience, and come away with LEARNING something, PLUS, (and MOST IMPORTANT) leaving our Self-Esteem intact...THAT ought to also guide Judges...even Vern said HE felt nauseated, NOT that the Person was a Nauseating Human being. The Design made his stomach queasy (my words not his)...NOT the individual...(and he could also use some of what was shared to modify a bit, as I am certain he does care about the Designers as much as he does about Design.

About THIS show, it for ME has been the ONLY show where AMERICA rather than behind the scene politic HAS SPOKEN...my votes NEVER seemed to count before. I am impressed by this...Thank YOU!

So, "HGTV FAN Family"... let's make Peace! Just as when we as Americans elect a President, whether or not we voted for him, he remains 'our' President, & we are supposed to unify behind him. No, it is not always fun...still, it IS the democratic way. Let us ALSO continue to admire Todd's inventiveness; Sparkle's sparkle; Rob's abilities; and everyone's assets; Let us continue to make creative comments HERE to the HGTV Sponsors HOW TO IMPROVE the Process for the Designers and for US as Viewers...that is what we can be BEST for all.

Last comment, regarding Alice from last year, I JUST discovered today that she is HERE with so many wonderful ideas on how to do window treatments and design headboards...Did you know that. Yes, I agree HGTV would attract many a viewer to put her BACK on TV with a special designing with David Bromstead, letting HER take the Lead & having him help her...There are many possibilities! Let's come up with more than the sour comments. Sour stuff is best left for sour dough bread. Peace to all and to Clive, Vern and the whole Team of Teams...
Peace to all,
Trudy in Boston

Posted by Trudy – September 18, 2007 10:12 PM

GREAT JOB KIM:} CAN'T WAIT TO SEE YOU ON YOUR OWN SHOW, I ALSO IENJOYED WILL, HOPE TO SEE HIM IN SOMTHING SOON.I JUST KNOW THIS IS NOT THE LAST WE SEE OF HIM, GREAT PERSONALITY.

Posted by GWEN – September 18, 2007 10:09 PM

GREAT JOB KIM:} CAN'T WAIT TO SEE YOU ON YOUR OWN SHOW, I ALSO IENJOYED WILL, HOPE TO SEE HIM IN SOMTHING SOON.I JUST KNOW THIS IS NOT THE LAST WE SEE OF HIM, GREAT PERSONALITY.

Posted by GWEN – September 18, 2007 10:09 PM

I voted for Kim and I am so glad that she won. But I must say that Todd was an extremely gracious runner up. He immediately stepped to the back to let Kim enjoy the limelight. And at the party (online video), he was a true gentleman. He was also very polite and personable in his exit video online. Todd, I wish you the best.

Posted by Kathy – September 18, 2007 10:09 PM

Paul - You said it all...

Posted by bj – September 18, 2007 10:00 PM

Congratulations, Kim. I leaped for joy when your name was annouonced as the winner. Nice work. Love your designs.Keep it up. Praying that your show will be a tremendous hit. Keep up the good work.

Brenda of Plainfield, NJ

Posted by Brenda – September 18, 2007 10:00 PM

Where was Will and vern When the pictures were taken at the party after the show?

Posted by Bonnie – September 18, 2007 9:37 PM

Kim deserved to win. Period!
Her final design was more sophisticated than Todd's. PLUS her hosting skills were light-years ahead of the other contestants. She looked and sounded like a TV professional already. In the other hand, Todd was phenomenal! Very Creative and great personality. Unfortunately as a host he ddn't score. He should have toned down a little. I think it would be real cool to have someone like him (surfer dude) as host but he needs training.
On another note, too bad Sparkling Josh didn';t make to the hosting challenges. I have a feeling he would have rocked. He has a lot of character and carisma.

Posted by Gustavo – September 18, 2007 9:20 PM

What is the problem?????
Men take off their shirts when they worked.
So what.
It does not matter if you like Kim or Todd but I do not understand the big deal about Todd not wearing a shirt.I see men working all the time without a shirt.
Is that the only thing you can find wrong with Todd or his work????

Posted by Kathy – September 18, 2007 8:04 PM

I greatly ENJOYED watching the show---Thanks HGTV !! I love Kim's warmth and personality--I thought her hotel room was beautiful. I would like to also see a show featuring Todd. Todd's design style is very different from mine, but his personality and creativity would make me watch the show. (Listening to Kim's voice -- she sounds just like Mia (one of the judges) on So You Think You Can Dance? Are they releated?)
Keep up the great shows. Congrats to Kim !

Posted by Karen – September 18, 2007 7:30 PM

I won't watch Kim's show. She won't be able to pull off a "design" show series. It was obvious that she had more face time than anyone else on each show. She was always front and center and the way the show was designed this year gave her the edge. She had a free ride and only lasted to the end because of faulty judging. I am really disappointed with HGTV and find myself turning them off. She should be disqualified because of her contacts with the judging personnel.

Posted by Sylvia – September 18, 2007 7:30 PM

CONGRATULATIONS, KIM!!!!
I am sooooo glad you won the competition, you deserve it. You are a very classy and talented lady and it will be great to see all the wonderful designs you come up with on your show! Todd was talented and had some good ideas/designs as well, but he was just too "over the top," too far out with his designs that just aren't anywhere at all in the realm of the average HGTV viewer. Plus, I'm a gay man but I got really tired of seeing him barechested all the time. I think he must have known he didn't have the necessary talent to win the competition so he resorted to showing skin to garner votes from all the women and gay men who were watching the show. Well Todd, you didn't get my vote at all.

P.S., Someone please send Vern Yipp back to school to take a class in learning the English language. Dude, the correct way to say it is, "I am NAUSEATED"--- NOT "I am NAUSEAUS." HGTV ran that clip over and over and over and I just wanted to throw something at the tv every time. Vern, I'm definitely NOT watching your new show.

But Kim, I'll definitely be watching your new show, I can't wait! Good luck, Kim!!

Posted by Ryan – September 18, 2007 7:25 PM

Top Ten Reasons I am Glad Kim Won!
1. She has talent with class and style.
2. I would sleep in her room without feeling I was in cyberspace.
3. She is not Robb.
4. She is not Robb.
5.-10. She is not Robb.

Posted by Paulette – September 18, 2007 7:02 PM

Thank you, Paul, (posted Sept. 18 at 12:07 AM) for expressing yourself so well about the quality of Kim's work. I agree that, at best, it was mediocre. She may be 'very sweet, very nice' as many are saying, but this was not a personality contest. We needed a fresh, PROFESSIONAL approach to interior design, not 'decorating'. Even in that category, Kim seemed so hesitant, so bland and so predictable. She lacked zest and the ability to really get in there with ENERGY, enthusiasm and creativity. (She was no match for Todd who was fabulous.) HGTV, please rethink your criteria and quit trying to go middle-of-the road and please everyone---no matter how "sweet and nice" they may be. As for the audience choosing the final winner: The average HGTV fan is NOT qualified to select on the basis of fine design. AND, giving six chances to vote per day can stack the deck AGAINST the deserving winner. It happened this year. It may happen again.

Posted by June – September 18, 2007 6:58 PM

I was sooo looking forward to seeing more of Todd. I can't believe she won... really....RECOUNT!

Posted by WANDA in Hollywood – September 18, 2007 6:54 PM

I voted for Kim and am happy and excited she won. But for those with the negative responses, did your life change, I hope not America voted and she won. It is not the end of the world. It was great TV. If HGTV gets enough of a response, you can still see Todd in his California Dreaming Surfer show, (I even created a great name). Lighten up. This year was great, I think HGTV may want to think about some mid season mini replacements with Will, Sparkle, and yes even Robb, (for the designers with just a little anger)

Posted by jbs – September 18, 2007 6:45 PM

Hey, Congratulations to Kim!

Vern is right - you have a sophisticated eye. You know how to talk to an audience, an audience in California and New York at the same time. You know how to demonstrate grace under fire. You will be an asset to HGTV.

I'm sure HGTV will find something for Todd to do, much like Alice from last year. Todd has talent but needs coaching in making him realize that in a contest involving 50 states, it doesn't do well to jam California, a lifestyle and a language down a yankee's throat. Not that Todd needs to be P.C. - he just needs to use common sense - something he seems to be have a slight deficit in.

They've got me as an audience for Kim's new program and for the next season of Design Star.

Posted by David – September 18, 2007 6:32 PM

Congrats Kim. I've been voting for you all along and you certainly are the best this year. Todd you might want to keep you shirt on and quite jumping on tables and painting everything blue - then you too can get a show. I really didn't think about any racial background . . . just thought Kim was an American doing a good job of designing within the alotted time for each show. Kim, if you can keep smiling while putting up with Rob's insults, you can do anything. I just wish Rob would "go away" and never be seen on HGTV again. Will, so happy they gave you the $5,000 credit card. Kim, when you get your 'elegant small spaces' design show, perhaps you can pick Will and Sparkle Josh to help you with your design jobs. You would make a great team. Again, congrats Kim. Keep up the good work.

Posted by B Best – September 18, 2007 5:59 PM

Congrats Kim! You are a winner. I really enjoyed watching you deliver your goods.

Dianne

Posted by Dianne Campfield – September 18, 2007 5:11 PM

Without a doubt Will & Robb were the most talented designers on the show. The format needs to be changed next year to reflect more of the individual's design ability, not teamwork.

Posted by STEVE – September 18, 2007 4:45 PM

Loved the finale especially seeing the original 11 back together! Also, great to see hgtv personalities in the audience like Constance, Angelo, Danielle, and the Freeman ladies. Nice to see Will rewarded although reward was paltry ($5K? Should have been $10k)Lisa--who was voted off a little early--looked angry especially when she was viewing what the judges said about her work. Lisa did not really deserve the discovery award money...3 days crowded together is not enough time to make long term friendships.
Vern Yipp stands out as the judge with integrity and substance. Love his new show and his designs!!All in all, I just wished that the Design Star contestants had a lot more opportunity to show their potential given the time constraints for each challenge~no double eliminations please!! Looking forward to seeing Kim's show and the 3rd season of Design Star!!

Posted by jkatz – September 18, 2007 3:28 PM

Congrats Kim. I am ashamed by all the people who said Kim won because she is African American. It's my guess, but I think largely HGTV viewers are white. I personally voted for her six times a day. Of course, I may be wrong about the demographics of the viewers, but I mostly see them renovating the homes of Caucasians. Therefore, it's these viewers who chose the winner and not HGTV. Viewers who are mostly white. She was chosen on her merit, not on her race. There were over 13 thousand people who clicked on Kim's design and only around 9 thousand who clicked on Todd's design. What does that tell you? Viewers did not like his design. All the racist people out there should understand that no one wants to see Todd's in the box design every week. How often was he going to create a surfer theme? His taste is more suited for children. He design was only tasteful when it was decorated by Will or other designers. He is more of a builder of things than a designer. A carpenter does not usually make a designer, and this wasn't any different. That said, he has some talent and maybe would be excellent for theater designs or for children designs. Let us all pull together and support Kim and stop acting like a sour puss.

Posted by HayRiv – September 18, 2007 2:43 PM

I'm an older lady living in the mid-west. I watch HGTV at some time every day. I want ideas that I can use in my own home on a limited budget, and that does not include ramps (at least not for a few years - then maybe for wheel chairs!), turn-tables and obnoxious blue. I love blue but not cartoon, crayon-box blues - and a jellyfist! Please!! NO bare chests, hairy arm pits, jumping on the furniture. This is a design contest not muscle beach. I like David Bronstadt, but when he's fully clothed. Congrats Kim. You survived Rob, you can survive anything.
Pat

Posted by Pat – September 18, 2007 12:58 PM

Congratulations Kim! You won because you deserved to win!

For the record, I'd like to say I'm also appalled by those who've attempted to project their shortcomings/prejudices here as the basis for your win. It's unfortunate that there are some folks who feel as if they must make this about race or gender when it obviously isn't... It's about being the best and, indeed, you are the one who "nailed it"!

Keep up the good work! I'm looking forward to watching as you grow into your new career as HGTV's new Design Star!

Posted by dventi – September 18, 2007 12:58 PM

Cindy, who posted on Sept. 18, I totally agree with you. It is a shame that people are treating this like the end of the world and have so many negative things to say about Kim. She thought she had the talent to design/decorate and America, obviously, did also. I think that everyone on the show this year had a bundle of talent and would have watched any of their shows... FAITHFULLY.
To those with negative things to say about the competition, do as you say and don't watch but I am sure there are enough Kim Myles fans to keep the show afloat. Kudos Kim, Todd, Sparkles, Will and yes, even Robb because they are all great. Wouldn't it be something if Kim and Will have a show together? I would definately watch that!
Tams

Posted by Tammy Thompson – September 18, 2007 12:17 PM

Yes....there was a time limit that was announced. (responding to Rebecca Ray's comment) Sorry you didn't hear about it. And sorry to hear you feel so bad about the winner.

You know...last year my favorite Alice didn't win but I supported the winner David and watched his show WITHOUT bad feelings even though his designs didn't appeal to me and I felt Alice was the best. I knew that most of the viewers voted for him so I decided I would support what the majority of viewers voted for.

It's really sad to hear so many negative comments from viewers that are really just very poor sports. It really tells you a lot about people. You can really tell a lot about a person's character when things don't go their way. True colors of character are revealed through adversity!

Wishing all the best to all the designers in their careers!

Posted by Cindy – September 18, 2007 11:22 AM

I love this show!!! Congratulations to Kim. I did vote for you. Your last room was so professional. I must say I do love Todd's design style as well. Maybe he can have a show, too; Design - Full Throttle Style.

Posted by Angell – September 18, 2007 11:18 AM

Kudos to KIM!!

Thanks to you, I have now learned how to text a message. I never knew how to do it before. I am surprised that I watched this entire series and participated in the outcome. I was glad to see that Will received a consolation prize for the judges snafu. He, in my opinion, and in the opinion of hundreds of others, should have been in the final two. I really enjoyed the series and look forward to watching Kim. All of the participants made the show work. Congratulations to all of you!

Posted by E – September 18, 2007 10:53 AM

Todd was the best Kim never showed any talent that was unique or different from any one else her room at final challenge was nice but Todd showed talent from the beginning along with Will and Rob I am a Designer and I feel a bit insulted to think that they will give a design show to a hairstylist I think that the judges should have emliminated her sooner she seems very nice but thats not what it's all about you need DESIGN EXPERIENCE NOT HAIR.

Posted by Renee Taylor – September 18, 2007 10:37 AM

congrades kim you were good but todd was better but my top favs. were josh sparkles,todd,will and you I think hgtv needs to give todd his own show like they gave last seasons runner up and I would love to see josh sparkles and will with there own I would hire all 4 of you I just might if possible for a couple jobs in jamica My fav. 2 were todd and josh sparkles you all rock good luck send me your emails I am serious about hireing the 4 of you together.Mine is ednasangel@yahoo.com great job top 4 molly.

Posted by molly – September 18, 2007 8:42 AM

I am sooooooo glad Kim won...She, to me, was so like "the designer next door"...I did enjoying Todds designs as well but my only issues I had with Todd are...most of his designs weren't anything I would want to try myself at home...a little over the top....AND yeah he's hot to look at but I felt as if at times he was trying to mimic David from season 1 by constantly having to take his shirt off...CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!!

Posted by Rick – September 18, 2007 8:33 AM

I can't believe Kim won. Kim you are nice but have no personality. What is so innovative about her that we are going to watch in the show. It seemed as if she was always doubtful and struggling to make decisions.

Posted by mary silva – September 18, 2007 8:04 AM

I liked various parts of the Design Star finale.
WILL certainly didn't have any problems in expressing himself, smiling, and being very comfortable. He looked great and has the most winning smile that I've ever seen. It was good to see that he was the most appreciated member of them all. That is what America saw long before! He has the special ability to make everyone feel good about themselves. If he could make the contestants "feel like a family," you can just imagine how he touched our hearts. His DESIGNS had the PUBLIC'S HIGHEST RATING. Now we know that the judges COULDN'T AGREE AND FOUGHT about eliminations. SPARKLE JOSH is another favorite in America. HGTV, you just couldn't go wrong if you gave them a show of their own or together. Truthfully, they were really the highlights of the finale. People on both sides of the aisle really liked them both. What more could you want?

Posted by Sara – September 18, 2007 7:48 AM

#1 Congrats Kim! You proved that God can dream a bigger dream for us, and if we are confident, anything is possible and there are no limits. People are tired of lifeless boring personalities and want REAL souls like yours. (That is the reason behind REALITY TV). I hope that HGTV pays for your degree, so people have nothing to say, you give an example to other women and girls, and also because unlike others, you don't have a license, but you have "the gift". Education is important and it keeps you current and enriched, I'm sure you will do it! Stay positive and confident, if you keep the faith, God will take care of the rest. I feel like you are a family member; you are my sister in Christ!

#2 That said, I think HGTV got it right with David Bromsted. But, I agree with the fact that the double eliminations made this show unfair. We couldn't see enough of the designers and there was no room for improvement. You get it wrong one time, you are gone? Its not fair, there should be room to grow and learn. After seeing this people's presentation boards in the beginning of the search show, it was so sad not to see more of their work, so unfair not to let them shine. They were chosen for something, but they were not given the time and conditions to perform. People come with different backrounds and trainning, some are still diamonds in the rough. I believe the first challenge should be kind of free style, with no elimination, just to get them loose and to give them tips to improve and correct their misconceptions of design. I believe that things like accesorizing too much shouldn't be a reason to kick you out of a show, like it happened to Scott. If they give you another chance, you can polish that. (I wish they will show the opening where he gives that sexy look to the camera. Yes I know he's gay, but it was sexy,lol. I think he deserves his own show too! with Will and Josh maybe.)
And anxiety and lack of sleep can cause people to make poor desitions. I think they should have a day off in between challenges also.

#3 I also believe there should be classes to complement their knowledge and to serve as an example for a challenge and will educate the audience as well. For ex. A class of "The impact of architecture as an art form in contemporary design", perhaps. And have the designers create rooms taking the lesson learned in consideration. The classes should be thought by PRO's of design & architecture, starting with HGYV's own, like Candace Olson and Debbie Travis, (which I think should do a show together with maybe a third person and call it "Desing PRO's or DIVA's").

#4 Behavior issues are bad, but they don't say that you are a bad designer. I think Rob deserved another chance. Is refreshing to see a masculine guy with sensibility in art,(even though he has to work in not being so conceded and not imposing his ideas and respect other's contributions).
However, I think that Kim was right on the money, not letting Rob humiliate her and standing her ground, (just because she has less experience does not mean He had the right to disrespect her. If you have the need to make someone feel little for you to feel big, then you have no value at all; TRUTH DOES NOT YELL), not only she is a woman, but also a fellow contestant who was chosen because she had what it takes.

#5 I think that all of the designers needed training on divorsing themselves from what they like and learn to represent "the client". I love Josh and the spark, but not everyone wants spark in their home, and HGTV was not looking for "the next comic standing". Diversity is key, especially in today's world. I think he will be a hit though, don't get me wrong. I want to see more of him, he is an awesome soul.

#6 When it comes to the comments about Kim not being able to perform without the other's help, let me ask this. What designer in HGTV works without a team and no help at all? None, thank you very much. Everyone has a carpenter, a color expert,etc. Even Candace Olsen, that is a PRO, has an army of people, please watch the "backstage or how did we make it" kinda shows she does and you'll see the HGTV army backing her up. And I don't know of anyone that can top her. She's my IDOL and my family in Puerto Rico loves her too. (Let me know if you want to go Caribbean Candace, I will be your guide. But please do my mom's house,lol. Love ya!)

#7 When it comes to speculation about HGTV prefering Todd, but having to choose Kim because of all the votes she got, I think it is just that, speculations. Todd is great! and again, a few coaching classes would've made him a star, but he needs to step away from his "California Surfer Boy" confort zone and learn to put on different hats according to the needs, taste and desires of the clients. The water theme was repetitive. But like I said before, all of them needed a class in TV hosting and another one in diversity of desing. If the judges would have given them a quiz on design styles, most would've probably failed. I think they (HGTV PRO's)need to refresh and retrain their minds before throwing them at the lions. Is like leveling the plainfield so they are all in equal and fair conditions.

#8 I think HGTV should get rid of Design on a Dime, Decorating Cents, Get it together(too dominating and imposing, just like Rob, weird color choices too), Mission Organization, 24HR Design, Hidden Potential and other shows that are more of the same (even though I used to like them, but I am tired by now), with the same predictable script, and take the best of each one and combine it with new elements and new hosts, (after taking hosting classes)like: Josh, Will,Scott, Rob, Adriana(better than "tool belt Diva", kick ass homemaker design!)and Todd. And Niece Nash from Style, Michael Moloney from Extreme Makeover Home Edition and Andrew Yumbo, from DIY. I think the hunks Carter Oosterhouse and Eric Stromer should do a show together, that would be some "Designer Guys" to watch, not three blend gay guys. Since when gay is blend?, that is a crime, my friends will say.

#9 George Gray should host more shows on HGVT!!!!!!!!!!, why don't you replace the other guy that hosts with Clive Pearse on Design to Sell for him, that will result in "Top Dollar" for HGTV. I like him, he can do Curve Appeal, but George is my favorite!!! and Clive too!

#10 Another better version of Extreme Makeover Home Edition, with the best of all Design Stars and new faces like the ones from other channels I suggested.
That's it for now.

Live well, Laugh often, Love much!

Posted by Yanny – September 18, 2007 3:08 AM

This is a popularity contest, not based on real design talent. Kim did not win because of her knowledge of interior design, definitely not. She can host, that's it. I did not like her coffee table with paper plates idea, the place looked like a hair salon to me, bec. of the feel and color choice (and at the time, I didn't know that she was a hairdresser). I didn't like her W. Virginia home, it lacked design and color, it looked like a huge space with new furnitures, that's it. Her last challenge had awful floors that were covered up. Cut out headboards that were not her original idea. I'm sure they will need someone to back her up and teach her how to do real designs for her show to be able to last. Last years winner David is impressive and had real design talent. This year is a disappointment. The only reason why she got lucky in the end is because she chose a good color scheme that seemed better than Todd's color scheme, because people may have gotten tired of all the color blue in Todd's designs. But at least, his idea of giving the best view to the guest is excellent, his jelly fish is his own artwork, he had innovative ideas that are outstanding and out of the box. Kim needed to put the pressure on Rob in the kitchen project, because she got insecure and wanted to get her way and she did. I am not very impressed with her character. She is sweet on the outside, but I do not think she's truly genuine. Although Rob's attitude was not really very attractive, Kim does not shine either. Will is genuine and real and HGTV is right on with giving Will the $5,000 gift. He deserves that and more.

The judges decisions were often subjective and just discussed among themselves which is not fair. I think it would be more fair if they do it like in "Iron Chef America" where they have points system and tally their points in the end. It would have been more fair than based on favoritism. It would even be more fair at the last round, to have the points added from beginning project till end. Then, the votes will not only depend on the result of final challenge but all the work that was done from the beginning.

Will should have made it in the end opposite to Todd. I also think that HGTV shouldn't have let the couple in Las Vegas to make a decision who will be removed from the competition. Christina should have lasted longer because I believe she has better talent than Kim. She's truly sweet and I understand why she chose to have a real romantic design for the couple which was misunderstood. Although Christina made a mistake on that, I don't believe it was enough reason for her to be dismissed. Sparkle Josh is great, too, he just needed more punch with his color choices to stand out among his sparkles, but he is even a better shopper than Kim and has better personality, I believe.

All in all, I believe the judges did a great job in combining all these talents and personalities, they were fun to watch, but they failed in making important decisions in letting go of Will and Josh and Cristina. I think they wanted more to entertain than find real talented designers.

Posted by Liza – September 18, 2007 2:22 AM

Mucho Congratulations KIM!
Yes! You kept saying "I'm not going home," & You made yourself a self-fulfilling prophecy. For all who felt she didn't deserve it, do take note that: SHE came through with Pizazz in Hawaii when it REALLY counted. Yes, Todd is ingenius, inventive & creative; still, spinning living rooms are not what typical Americans want. Yes, his talents ought to be used somehow; yet Kim deserved this! ALL contestants reuniting was wnderful to see. This ending show, with the clips etc. was incredible & needs to be cherished by us all. Clive et al did a great job, as did the judges & all of AMERICA's voting, yet again!
Yes, David Bromstead has been terrific & fun. I DO JUST wish they'd do some mauves, purples, lilacs & aquas. I am SO tired of the 're-discovery' of yellows & earth tones, as IF it were a surprise, week after week. Obviously, I am not an earth tones person...There must be other viewers who are not as well. Maybe Kim will liven it up in winter tones. Hearty high fives to ALL the Designers who shared of themselves with us. And Rob came through with his 'Damage Control Consulting Business,' a true treat to see him view that part of himself with humorous perspective. I disagree strongly with those who say the Design Star ought not ALSO be a good host. We need this to be a Combo, or it could be a real Dud! Both David & Kim have it. Blessings to all from a devoted fan,
Trudy

Posted by Trudy – September 18, 2007 2:11 AM

WILL TOTALLY DESERVED TO BE HGTV DESIGNSTAR,I think the only reason he didn't win was his dialect and appearance he is very talented,creative,artistic and he can design....Kim is a ALRIGHT decorater period!!!! Todd is and artist and I don't feel that all of his ideas will work for everyday living....When the judges told Kim to remove the carpet she was scared out of her mind it was so obvious BUT WHO WAS THERE TO SAVE HER WILL!!!!!

Posted by KAREN DESSESAURE-JONES – September 18, 2007 1:03 AM

I am very happy for Kim. I also voted for her. Todd's final design was not put together very well. Kim's design was very elegant. I too also think that Will and Josh should have their own show. I think HGTV would miss out on something great for the audiences to see. They should really listen to the viewers, since it is the viewers that keeps the shows running. If not then just ask the ones that loss their shows and why? Because we werent watching them. Anyway, best of luck Kim.

Posted by Deb – September 18, 2007 12:48 AM

Okay.... I first of all want to say that we were looking for a HOST and A DESIGN STAR. And that is exactly what we have in Kim. Candice Olsen, my personal favorite designer in the world other than myself, said it best, "Todd and Kim BOTH deserved to be there." Both have an eye for design and creative flair. Todd was very new and spontanious while Kim was more classic and poised. Their design styles are definately different but please don't knock Kim for doing it big! I am a licensed interior designer and I have to say that they both have inspired me in the form of design. All those we state that the competition was not about hosting are absolutely wrong. Who wants to watch a show with a boring designer? That's why we love David Bromstad, Candice Olsen, Lisa Laporta and Carter Oosterhouse, (I think that's his last name :). We are in need of a designer that can keep our interest... and we just got a new design star. Be happy for her and Todd because I know we have not seen the last of him. They are both winners!

Posted by Tammy – September 18, 2007 12:32 AM

Well this was just a terrible finish.....Kim is very sweet but has no designing talent at all. She likes wallpaper for goodness sake.

This was a very poor job on the part of the judges to leave us with Kim as a choice...Kim should have been gone many weeks ago when she wasn't cutting it as a designer.

Todd you were robbed. I would have watched a show of extreme design, surfer style...but I will not watch another boring show on color choice and wallpaper selection..

Just so predictable, white male last year, black female this year. America did not vote on this..no way.

Posted by Denise – September 18, 2007 12:22 AM

Congratulations to
Kim,she seems likea very nice person, but I voted on design and Todd got my vote. His ability to think in and out of the box caused him to break the sound barrier in design . I hope HGTV will find a spot for him because he has made a difference in how we now view design and would like to see more of his ideas.I'm going to use the turn table idea in my own home

Posted by HGTV VIEWER – September 18, 2007 12:10 AM

Another paint and shop show? Gag me. I watched every Design Star show and I can't say I have ANY desire to watch Kim paint and shop. How are they going to resell this? Kim seems like a very nice person, yes, but I have better design and build skills than her. Give me someone with skills. Give me something new. Give me extraordinary. Give me something. But Kim? Is that all HGTV could come up with? And Kim in place of Todd? Todd who was solid the entire series? Please. Nothing Kim did this season comes to mind except for the hotel room. Todd built the front room for her in episode one. Episode two Kim imploded on the tile kitchen counter. Episode 3: paper plate cut outs? Rob, Todd, Will, and Kristina showed huge talent here. Episode four she helped out while Rob ran the show. Episode 5, Kim went shopping while Rob built the kitchen. Episode 6, she did a mediocre remodel of Hillbilly Hollow. Who could not have made that space 100% better with 10K? Will hit this one out of the park. Episode 7, hey look who shows up: Kim. She Forest Gumps her way through the show, a total wall flower, and then pulls out a decent deign with Will's help to win her own show? Are you kidding me here? HGTV, that's what you have for me? Sparkle Josh was funny. Will was talented. Todd had major skills, the look, and the passion. Todd’s show would sell, be controversial, and create a huge buzzzz. Kristina was cute as a button and had ability. I’d watch her all day long. Rob was talented and called it how he saw it. I can appreciate that Rob said what was on his mind. In the PC world, it is refreshing to hear someone call it as he sees it. I’d watch that. That would be fun. But of all the designers, Kim wins? I'm going to need some better editing next year in order to drink the cool-aid.

Posted by Paul – September 18, 2007 12:07 AM

Loved the show this year! You have a number of standouts that deserve a second look...Sparkle Josh should have a part in a show just for his personality!!! Everyone I know that watched, LOVED him (regardless of his designs). Will is very very talented, and hosting skills can be taught. I thought Todd was very gracious about losing and whether you liked his designs or not, he is very creative and talented and deserves kuddos for what he brought to the show. Can't wait for the next show.

Posted by Rhonda – September 18, 2007 12:01 AM

I agree with Pret07 (September 17, 2007 8:27 AM). Will looked so nice last night. Oh how I wish he had dressed up a bit more when he presented his designs to the judges. I'm sure it would have given him more stage presence (which was obviously what they were looking for). There is something very special about that gentleman; he reaches right into people's hearts.

Posted by Jane – September 17, 2007 11:51 PM

Congratulations Kim!!!

I hope that this will be new turn for HGTV - the newer shows are kinda getting stuck in a rut. Please give Kim a new angle that will not only bring some freshness, but give her a chance to grow and continue to shine.

Like so many, I like to see a where are they now in a year or two. In fact where are they now for last year's contestants would be great too.

All the best to you Kim!!! Looking out for your show next spring!!!!

Posted by ap – September 17, 2007 11:33 PM

Congratulations Kim! I missed the show and got on line to see who won... I had hoped it was you!

Todd... you came in second with grace. You gave it a good shot and you will still go far.

Congratulations to you both.

Posted by jw – September 17, 2007 11:31 PM

Great that Kim won! I really look forward to her new show.

I agree with Lwatkins that Neeraja was misunderstood. She was eliminated for the right reasons, but why did everyone seem to dislike her so? She said it like it was, and in a nicer way than Robb.

Also agree with whoever said WHY is everyone suddenly thinking Robb was so misunderstood. The scene in the car with poor Josh gave me a terrible impression of him, which was not improved by subsequent tantrums whenever anyone had the nerve to stand up to him and disagree. It's easy to be nice when you get your way. Please, don't bring him back!

Todd did irritate but definitely deserves an out-of-the-box show. I wouldn't watch it, but maybe others would!

Wah, I wish Will could have his own show. What a gentleman, and frankly, I liked his rooms the best.

Please, HGTV, make the season longer next time. I totally agree with all those who said that eliminations shouldn't start quite so soon, no double eliminations, more individual challenges, NEVER let the clients choose who is to be eliminated, and PLEASE let the judges see earlier how the contestants work with others.

Posted by Louise – September 17, 2007 11:27 PM

I loved design star reunion comments. I would hope that would hold true for the future. I would like all to be successful in some design capacity and I would think it would be great to do a reunion type show as one blogger said.. maybe a Christmas redesign for someone needy as Vern Yipp show does only using Vern as the host and former team members as the designers to remake a home of a deserving family. Let them work together in a non competitive way to bring the best of the Christmas spirit to a family or a group home or something then interview them as part of the segment to see how they have grown or changed since their involvent with Design Star. They could do something good and we could still "keep in touch" Thanks, a positive fan.

Posted by francene – September 17, 2007 10:50 PM

I don't think this season was as good as the first, the talent wasn't as good and it was too rushed. As for the last design of the luxury hotel suites, I was fortunate to stay in a few different hotels in Hawaii, and those two were not luxury suites! I don't get the enthusiam for Kim either as a designer or host; I guess I missed something. She seems pleasant, however. Last season it was difficult to choose between David and Alice, but I didn't vote this year. because I didn't feel strongly about either Kim or Todd. Hope DS3 will be better.

Posted by Marta – September 17, 2007 10:37 PM

It's been interesting to skim through some of the comments and see the diverse opinions about who is the better designer. I saw a number comments that were adamant that Todd deserved to be the design star because, among other things, he was better at building and painting. I thought this was a competition for design capabilities, not carpentry. I have a designer that has helped me off and on for a number of years in putting together my home. He's never picked up a hammer or a paint brush. I use him for his ideas not his manual dexterity.
As for Kim not being a good designer because of supposed flaws in the West Virginia project...the reason she chose the carpet (beige) that she did was because it was the only one available for immediate installation. Yes, it was probably too light but it was her only reasonable choice given the time constraints. Vinyl and wood would have been way over the budget and wood, which some have suggested as the best flooring, would have taken too long to install. She made a reasonable descision given her time constraints and limited options.

Which leads me to my single biggest complaint about the whole season (which I watched and really did enjoy). I think the time pressures on several of the projects were unrealistically short, forcing designers into compromises that would unlikely occur in a real life situation. While we certainly learned who operated well under pressure and who was quick with developing ideas, I would never allow a designer to do a project for me that wasn't well considered, well thought out, and carefully implemented. If they had at least one challenge that allowed the designers adequate time to complete and polish a design I thing we'd get a much better sense of their real design skills.

Posted by mary d – September 17, 2007 10:11 PM

Todd is awesome! He should get his own show because he has all the right stuff. He has talent, excitement, personality and pizzazz. America would love to watch Todd! Two shows with low ratings - boring Vern and ho hum Kim should be canceled.
Please do America a favor and find someone to replace Vern on your next Design Star show. He has a big chip on his shoulder.
Thanks for listening.

Posted by Lisa – September 17, 2007 10:01 PM

I am soooo glad Kim won. I was so tired of looking at Todd's bare chest. I thought he was more hype than style.

Posted by Susan – September 17, 2007 9:58 PM

When did Martha, one of the judges, make the comment about Kim's dress? I must have missed it.

Posted by Kathy – September 17, 2007 9:56 PM

AGGGGHHHH!!! I have been depressed all day!!! I suffer from Design Star withdrawl! Last night's episode was so great because everyone was back. I didn't realize how attached I had become to all the contestants! I loved seeing Scott & Sparkle Josh & Wonderful Will & Robb too, as well as Kim & Todd. I feel like they were a part of my life for 6 weeks & I will miss them. I think they all kicked butt putting in the hours they did under the pressure. What an accomplishment. Let me tell you how Design Star has changed & is changing my life... I'm a dance instructor & this summer I broke my foot so I had to watch alot of HGTV (my fav). I got so into DS that I decided to go back to school at the age of 54 in Interior Design!!! I start classes next week! & it's all because of HGTV & Design Star. So let me just tell you guys who produced & participated in the show...YOU CHANGE LIVES! Keeping it "real" kept me coming back & I can't wait to see what the future holds for the 11 and look forward to next season already!

Posted by Kathy (recreatingkat) – September 17, 2007 9:47 PM

Congratulations, Kim! Your designs are so rich and creative. You are genuine and so good on camera. David's show has been such a disappointment- his garish designs and trying too hard personality are a real turnoff to me. I'm looking forward to your new show,Kim.

Posted by Luke – September 17, 2007 9:38 PM

Kim received the most votes. Most voters considered her to be the Best. She won fair and square. Congratulations, Kim. Most people liked her style, design flair, and personality; those people for her. Again, Congratulations, Kim!
For those of you who say you will not watch her show - who cares? TV has many channels - watch a sit-com instead.

Posted by Carol – September 17, 2007 8:53 PM

Kim??? Are you kidding me??? This completely ruins this show for me. She is totally not a design star! She is merely a sidekick with very little original thoughts! Booo HGTV!!!!

Posted by stacey – September 17, 2007 8:45 PM

Congratulations, Kim!!! You are going to be great, can't wait to see your show. After watching that clip of you last night, here's a suggestion for a name - Situation Solutions!!! LOL
Best of luck.

Posted by Kathie – September 17, 2007 8:38 PM

I was glad to see Kim win last night. I liked most of the contestants except for Robb. i loved seeing him have to make nice when they brought him back and knowing he was still a looooser! he was just rude and arrogant and not that talented. the only thing he really won was the Vegas wedding and that was garish. I have to think HGTV producers see the potential in Sparkler Josh, he is such a tv personality. They need to grab him for something. He is funny and very entertaining.

Posted by bev Smith – September 17, 2007 8:19 PM

Kim,
Congratulations!!!! You just made my confidence level go sky high. I have been doing interior decorating for years, just started because I wanted to do my own place so I took a few classes. It soon became a second passion, real estate was my first. I did display homes for free just because I love making spaces beautiful. Last year I got a big break with two local physican who expanding their practices and was referred by a a friend, I surprised myself. I have been busy since. I am no way formally trained and you just proved either you got it or you don't. Lady, you have got it all grace, finesse, class, personality and talent to boot.

Thank you for being such an inspiration.

Congrats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Regina – September 17, 2007 7:59 PM

Congrats to KIM. Don't listen to the bitter people that are trying to trash you Kim. I and the majority of people who voted, voted for you!
To the critics here: I'm not a designer, but I like to do things to make my house look nice on a limited budget. Kim can do that, and I'm sure there are things that I can learn from her. I wouldn't have been able to relate to Todd's designs or to him, or be inspired to do or try anyhing he does. So Kim doesn't have lots of experience with some things, big deal. She's like me but more advanced in design than I am because I work alot and don't have time to design much, so I can learn from and relate to her. I look forward to watching her learn and grow as her show does. That is worthwhile to me.
I look forward to watching the show. You go for it Kim!

Posted by Laurie in Calif. – September 17, 2007 7:48 PM

I cannot believe Kim won! I wanted Todd from the first show. Will would have been my second choice. I don't know why the judges didn't send Kim packing a long time ago. Last year's winner, David, was not that great at hosting during the competition but he was the best designer. Same with Todd & Will! They said that Sparkle Josh was a great shopper and fired him. Well, Kim only proved that she could shop, not design. Todd did his own artwork, carpentry, etc. He had it all!

Posted by Gina – September 17, 2007 7:40 PM

Okay I am writing in this blog again and can't believe I am doing this. I still can't believe there are so many people excited about Kim having her own show. One, she is a terrible designer with not much originality or color sense, two, she is not a good host. Her body language and her hands are very distracting. I want to be taken into a new world of design with someone that has fresh ideas and suggestions for MR and MRS America. She can not possibly take us there.
Todd at least made you laugh and although I did not like his work (although I did like the room he did for the family of 10). I would at least give his show a chance.I still think Todd should have a landscaping show. We should see what he could do first. I would just watch Kim at first to see if she falls on her face because that is what I feel is going to happen to her. BUT, what a terrific chance for an amature to get a start. Please, stop saying how wonderful Will's designs were, They were NOT. He may be a nice guy but not every nice guy deserves to be on TV or host a designing show.Again I feel like I just watched another train wreck. I need to find something better to do on a Sunday night.

Posted by lynda – September 17, 2007 7:40 PM

I am pleased to see Kim win Design Star. Will was a surprise and with better on air presence, would have faired the best. Kim had it all, though. It will be great to see her grow from this on the tube. All the best to her.

Posted by clark – September 17, 2007 7:32 PM

Congrats to HGTVs new Design Star--> Kim Myles!!!
Your intuitiveness and class won out over all.
Amazing gracefulness in each presentation. You had my vote dear lady.

Posted by Joyce – September 17, 2007 7:28 PM

Congratulations KIM!!!!!. What a great designer with the whole package. I am so happy for her. I played the online "pick" game and honestly picked Kim from day one. I did change it a couple of times but came back to her after the final four challenge. She is very talented for someone with no "formal training" which means that she has been blessed with a "natural gift". I have no doubt she will only get better as time goes on. I feel sorry for all the haters. Jealousy is so ugly!!!!! Personally, I can't wait to watch Kim's show. I plan to watch every episode. And for the negative comments regarding HGTV, they didn't pick Kim, America did!!!!! That should speak for itself! Kim, stay grounded and real. Don't let all this change your very warm and caring nature. I am glad to see that you have a very loving and supportive husband and family. Be Blessed! And next Spring.....Blow the doubters away!!!!!

Posted by SugaLump – September 17, 2007 7:23 PM

Hurray, Kim! Your on-camera presence, warm smile, grace and style won me over several episodes ago, so of course my vote went to you.
Am looking forward to watching your new show.

To the other designers...thanks for an interesting season!

HGTV - can we please have a "Designed to Stay" show...I really need the help!

Posted by Sue F – September 17, 2007 7:16 PM

It was Kim's law of attraction to win . She won because the viewers in thier own way enjoyed what she had to offer, regardless of all the negative things the haters mention. Everyone has time and room to grow and I have no doubt in my mind that Kim will develop into her own as america watches. HGtv is looking to give us what we want, which is why the final vote was given to us, the people. I doubt that any voter picked kim because she was black. So for all of those that feel that she was,you need to do some self evaluation and see how you keep the world from moving forward. I don't appreciate you taking such a great program and turning it into a racial issue. It isn't the racial issue of hgtv, it's YOUR racial issue . Congratulations KIM!!!!!!! Best of all luck to TODD and his gift of design.

Posted by stephanie – September 17, 2007 7:09 PM

Way to go Kim!!!! You rocked Design Star from Day One, and it's a well deserved recognition (nationwide, no less!) of the major skills you possess. I'll be cheering you on at the unveiling of your new show. Can't wait!

Rock on Kim, Rock on! Oh yea, and CONGRATULATIONS!!!

Posted by Jan – September 17, 2007 7:08 PM

The positive: no more hairy armpits, no more "wahoos!" that disrupted the real purpose of the show. Todd's performance was very "planned" (obviously, from David's comment about the shirt).
He set out to be different, and that he was. The immaturity got VERY old, and possibly disguised a talent he must have had to get on the show.

In a world that's full of that overbearing, loud style everyday, HGTV will coach Kim into hosting a winning show...in a calm, sophisticated manner that we need today.

Posted by Designer-in-training – September 17, 2007 6:57 PM

A show with Sparkle and Will would be great! Couldn't HGTV use a little comedy in their lineup?

Posted by MHSMITH – September 17, 2007 6:52 PM

WOW!!! CONGRATS KIM you deserved it. I voted for you every day and as often as allowed. You did a great job. I disagree with the negative comment made above about Kim's $$ store design. After all, the design materials did come from the $$ store and Kim did a marvelous job creating something classy. She also had to design the living room in WV according to the owners requirements, which she did because they were thrilled. The challenge was not about pleasing us but pleasing them. Being a design star means you have to not only have great ideas and implement them, but you also have to appeal to your audience and Kim won hands down. Todd's enthusiasm was great but his design focus was all about surfing, sports or unrealistic wood concoctions. And let's face it folks, would you want a revolving living room in your home? Todd's ideas were a little too off-the-wall, too out-of-the-box. I am a 65 year-old female who watched every show and all the re-runs and loved it. Thanks HGTV for a great series.

Posted by Sharon – September 17, 2007 6:47 PM

YEY KIM!! We were with you all the way. And whats with the Todd comments saying he has more design talent...yes he can build turn tables, ramps, simple shelves, paint rooms all blue with bubbles. His family room 'kid area' was an emergency room visit waiting to happen and he has no sense of furniture placement....that's design 101. Got tired of the hairy arm pits... Looking forward to seeing Kim's show.

Posted by k – September 17, 2007 6:38 PM

I have to say, I think Todd was misunderstood by a lot of people and it did show with the "rate my space" comments. When you look at his 2nd place video, you see a caring and articulate man. He showed this side at times but went too much and overboard with the "eccentric surferdude" that the judges were looking for and not the appeal to the audience watching (voting at the end). I was disappointed to see Kim's dress when she came out. You could see the outline of her belly button. She did not appear as a host of a tv show but more of a thrown together person. Then to learn that she knew someone from InStyle was disheartening. I don't think that is why/how she won, she got the votes but it makes you second guess her win. Fair or not, it puts her win in question for a lot of people. Watching the show last night, she did seem to stay under the radar which helped her to get to the spot that she did but it was a result of the elimination process. However, I do think she has spunk and has a TV personality but doesn't appear to have the design skills to bring a new show to HGTV that doesn't mirror another show. I know people have mentioned it would be great if Will and Sparkle had a show as awesome and fun to watch as that would be HGTV can not justify it based on the one winner, sadly. Now that would be an original stand alone show! Christina handled herself well when the judges said they were surprised when she did not return. Shows that that may not have been a fair elimination. I like watching HGTV shows to get new ideas, spark my imagination and/or confirm "hey, I'm on track with my thoughts". I knew Kim would win but at this time, don't know if I will get the new ideas or the "wow" from her. What is sad, I just don't feel the excitement that the "best person won". Not because of Todd but more because I don't think the show enabled the audience to see indivdual talent and focused too much on teams.

Posted by Diane – September 17, 2007 6:30 PM

I am very very disappointed with HGTV. The only talent Kim has is shopping and using other people. If you want someone who is able to look down at other people, you have your person.
I would never watch a show with Kim. I found her very arrogant. I'm sure her show will use many other people, since she surely can't carry a show on her own. She needs to use the people around her. I believe the whole show was a set up. They were many qualified people who were eliminated. I think the last two were close to the least talented. Shame on HGTV!

Posted by R Kinkaid – September 17, 2007 6:20 PM

Will, and David bromstad Best designers. Congrats Kim you show normal people with good taste can win such a big contest like HGTV design star.

Posted by loida – September 17, 2007 6:07 PM

Congratulations, Kim! I voted for you :) A word to Rebecca Ray who has recently posted her comment: did you forget what was all the competition using 99ct items about? It didn`t look like plates at all! It was so inventive!

Posted by Karolina – September 17, 2007 6:07 PM

I was so upset that Todd didn't win. He is such an amazing designer. Always so excited and taking a fresh approach to every room he tackled. What an amazing problem solver with the rotating floors and room changes in the islands. It's so refreshing to see a designer break out of the comfortable layouts and do something different and beautiful. I hope HGTV is smart and finds a way to give him his own show too. If he instead gets a show on TLC I am DEFINITELY going to watch EVERY ESPISODE!!!!!!!! Watch out Trading Spaces!!!

I hope Todd is reading this and knows how amazing he did. I definitely voted for you and was so excited to see you get the show you earned. No matter what you do from here on out you will still be a Design Star!

Posted by Charity – September 17, 2007 6:03 PM

Does anyone know what the percentages were on the final voting? Interesting that wasn't mentioned.

Posted by amanda – September 17, 2007 6:01 PM

I enjoyed the season. I loved Will from the beginning selection episode for contestants when I told my husband that it had to be Will. I would watch Will.

Kim's room looked nice, and I was really happy for her last night. Her show will be entertaining and I agree with other viewers that she should choose a niche for Designing for Real people with rooms that need to work on a legitamate but reasonable budget (don't go off the deep end with $1000 rooms-- that's too cheap, if you hire a designer maybe $5-10k would be appropriate).

Todd, your inspirations were great and I enjoyed the energy. I have to admit though, when the final 3 went to the final 2, I hoped it was your show that was cancelled. The creativity and talent are there, it's just too much for my 27" real workld TV. I can't imagine a whole house designed by you-- but it would be one heck of a play room. The loss of the kitchen on the Hawaii project showed that lack of understanding. Why have such a nice dining area with the kitchen in the bedroom?

Thanks to all the contestants, It's tough to do your job with an audience. If you put any of us in that situation, even in things we think we're good at, it would be really humbling.

amanda

Posted by amanda – September 17, 2007 5:54 PM

Todd's designs were shock and awe...for real life they wouldn't be reasonable for real people to live in the spaces.
Kim's designs were clean, functional places with an ultimate touch of style.
Kim, if you scan these comments, do some segments on renter rennovations; temporary touches that would update and enhance a space.
Congratulations, Kim. I voted for you.

Posted by Mary Lou – September 17, 2007 5:53 PM

Congratulations to Kim!! I'm sure the producers will develop a show to take advantage of her sweet personality and grace. She is a nice contrast to David from last season who is more of an artsy kind of designer. I enjoy him, but she can be the "real" person for "real" America. She may not be "out of the box" as some wish she was, but most of us who furnish our own homes need her kind of help with taking things from a store that we like and making them look good together. I enjoy the artsy, so I can dream a little, but in the end I must live with what I create and it must be practical.

Posted by Nancy – September 17, 2007 5:47 PM

To all you people out there who were SHOCKED and HORRIFIED about the results of this years "Design Star", I say, AMEN! I couldn't agree with you more! This was supposed to be a search for a "DESIGN" star, not a hosting competition! Kim would make a GREAT host for someone else's "DESIGN" show, but she CERTAINLY DID NOT "EARN" her own show! Have you forgotten those ugly paper plate cut outs on those ugly mauve walls? Or that poor family in W. VA? The only good thing they got was the T.V. Need I continue? Oh, don't even get me started on the Hawaii deal, Todd so rocked that one, of corse you'd want to spend all your time with those views. Everything he "DESIGNED", and BUILT, and PAINTED, his own ARTWORK, was a GREAT display of what people SHOULD have been looking for! Todd you ARE the TRUE "DESIGN STAR". I will watch 1 episode of Kim's show, so I can say, told you so. Kim you seem very nice, but I truly believe Todd should have WON. ...Perhaps Todd lost because voting was over before my family and I, and untold amounts of people even got there. Never heard about a time limit? When was it? Very angry about that. Anyone else?

Posted by Rebecca Ray – September 17, 2007 5:35 PM

I am glad Kim won, I like her and thinks she has talent, and I voted for her. I look forward to seeing her new show.
I think it is obvious that we all fell in love with several of this years challengers. We all came to appreciate Will's kind nature and all around goodness (its so rare that you find that on television!) and we all love Josh's sparkle and wit. I even like Robb once he was eliminated and he became nicer. And the only bad part about Kim winning was that Todd lost. I loved Todd to and really enjoyed his enthusiasm.
So, HGTV Executives, how about you bring us (your viewing audience) all of our favorites into one show. I see other shows that have a format of team hosts. Why not a show that would bring Will, Todd and Josh together, even Robb, and have them work on various projects??? I think it would be more interesting than some of your on-going programming. And I agree with the other writer that suggested that you get rid of Donna, the lady who makes fun of everyone's elses home. I can't say anything nice about her style.

Posted by Libertytide – September 17, 2007 5:33 PM

To "Design Star Reunion", I had to tell you how brillant your piece of the future for each one is so great..That took alot of deep thinking an planning..THANKS FOR DOING THAT FOR ALL OF US TO SEE..I HOPE ALL THE ELEVEN AN HGTV AS WELL GET TO READ THAT..TRULY BRILLANT!!!

Posted by cat555 – September 17, 2007 5:25 PM

Wow Kim! You had my vote. Can't wait to see what you end up doing next. Loved watching you on the show, and know you will be a big part of the HGTV family. Way to go.

Thom.....New Orleans

Posted by thom – September 17, 2007 5:18 PM

WOW, I am so happy Kim won..She is so very deserving of this..It was great seeing all of them together again..They all had such a great time laughing over the stuff they did an saw that most of it was on tape..Clive was really good with it all..I have read most of the postings an am so upset over some of the remarks.I find them to be so offensive..Why do some of you have to be so mean with your words..Just because Todd didn't win you felt you had the right to just rip Kim to shreds. Just because some of you don't like a certain style you condem other's.I don't understand,you couldn't have been taught to not be so rude to others.Has it ever crossed your minds that maybe Kim or whoever or worse one of their family members would read what you said? WORDS DO HURT!! CONGRATS KIM, AN HOPE TO SEE THE OTHERS SOON.WE ALL NEED TO BE MORE AWARE OF OTHER'S FEELINGS..

Posted by cat555 – September 17, 2007 5:15 PM

Congrad Kim
I am offended by this person "Lee passing herself off as a black woman,it is this type of behavior that spoil a good show. Lee you are not a Black woman. stick with the contents of the show not this race issue. shame on you.

Carolyn

Posted by Carolyn – September 17, 2007 5:15 PM

I wouldn't watch either one of these people so it didn't matter who won. It was a good soap opera, that's about all I could say about the entire show. Maybe next season we'll go back to people who can actually design a room people would want to live in. Turntables, concrete floors and white carpet in mud country may be good television but it's lousy design.

Posted by Tom – September 17, 2007 4:57 PM

Congrad Kim
you are the best designer.I voted for you and happy you won. The person that say you was not the best designer well it has nothing to do with your elegant,sophiscated,classic state of the art vision it's their own personal decay. Todd is Todd and he bring something different to the table,would I turn my home over to him? only my 12 year son room, their he would be great. Oh yes did mention I am a designer,and a good one.
So do that which you do best DESIGN,DESIGN,DESIGN.

Shakar

Posted by shakar – September 17, 2007 4:46 PM

Yea! I'm glad that Kim won, I really liked her and Will. Todd was a good designer, but not something that most would want in their house. I think Todd would have won if his personality would have been better, I found him to be a little childish and that would keep me from watching his show.

Posted by Jimmysgirl – September 17, 2007 4:45 PM

Congratulations Kim. Yes, you got my vote. Plus your personality gets kudos too. I don't normally watch these type shows but each contestant brought something worthwhile to the show.Todd,Will,Sparkle Josh,Robb,Christina we have not seen the last of you. Best wishes

Posted by Sandra – September 17, 2007 4:39 PM

Congrats to Kim. I have an idea and hope some of you agree and hop on the band wagon. Since HGTV has a host of TLC alumni doing there own shows, why don't they buy the rights to Trading Spaces, get a hostess like Tava Smiley, and have all the contestants from Design Star be the guest designers. THERE YOU HAVE IT FOLKS! We will get to see all our fabulous favorites from time to time.
Now, to all the Todd and Kim bashers out there. CHILL OUT! It's over be a good sport about it just like Todd.
MEJ

Posted by MEJ – September 17, 2007 4:37 PM

Not to sound to mean but are you people nuts? Kim as the next Design Star!!!! What a waste. I have no problem giving credit where it's due. Can she match colors? Yes. Is that worth giving her the new show?? Hell no! HGTV totally blew this. Granted I agree with alot of people out there about Todd. Yes put your shirt back on. Yes tone down the surfer language. But the guy had the flair. He was fun to watch. He would have brought a new wave of shows to the network that they really need to catch the viewers who, like me, are tired of the same old thing.

And I don't know about the rest of you but I think the whole vote for...add name here.... is a total fake way to get viewers to watch. I believe they had the next DS chosen way in advance. I remeber after the wedding challange my wife and I were talking aboout who would win. Right there I knew it would be Kim. Not because she earned it. But it was the pc thing to do. First Robb would go cause of his temper. Which is a shame. He knew how to build and design. Next Will would go. HGTV didn't need another male host. Again terrible choice. Will should have won this. Plus why keep a male colored designer when they had a female colored designer. Killing two birds with one stone. Again a horrible mistake from HGTV. And if I'm wrong then I'm sorry.

Unlike most people I won't say that I'm done with DS. Come next year I'll be here again complaining who should have won and why. That is if HGTV get's it right and let's the right person win.

Here hoping that Will, Todd and Rob make it on a show someday.

Posted by Cabanche83 – September 17, 2007 4:29 PM

Thank you, producers! This was a fun series to watch and last night was great. Congrats to Kim, she is definately the best.

Posted by ph – September 17, 2007 4:20 PM

Well, Kim's winning didn't surprise me. Not because I thought she was the best and should win but because between her and Todd, it was logical that she would win. Todd was just too off-the-wall for mainstream America and his hyperactivity probably grated on people's nerves. Do I think he was talented? Yes. He thought "outside of the box" and given the right show could have been very successful with it.

Do I think Kim was talented? She has some capabilities but is more decorator than designer. And she is really at a notch above novice level. She has some hosting capabilities and with the right show she, too can be successful.

I have really disliked seeing all the cruelness on this blog and the message boards. Some poking fun at people is fine (I've done my share of it) but there has been some downright cruelty slung at Todd and Kim. Really unnecessary.

I didn't vote for Kim because I would have liked to see someone who does think "outside the box" have a show that gave us a little more than the standard decorating show. But, I do wish her the best of luck and I will watch her show, at least initially, because I want to see how she does.

I think it's fantastic that she had the guts to put herself out there and pursue something she is passionate about. How many people are really willing to do that in life? She took a chance and went after a dream she had. Good for you, Kim! I hope your willingness to do that will inspire other people to do the same thing - including myself. In the end, that will be the legacy that you leave to people. It won't be about the show. It will be about the inspiration you provided to others to go after something they want just as badly as you wanted this win.

Posted by sharkeye1 – September 17, 2007 4:19 PM

Me again, the armchair designer. Well done, HGTV! DS2 was fun to watch. Looking forward to Kim's show!

I was disappointed in Todd's childish comment. When Clive asked Todd how was he feeling, Todd's answer was something like, "I'm feeling like taking off my shirt and raising my arms." That was a direct 'up yours' to us posters who commented on Todd's shirtlessness and showing his arm pits. Hmmm...and he wonders why he wasn't #1?

David surprised me with the insider remark to Todd, saying something like, "We're both wearing shirts." Tsk, tsk, David, I'm disappointed in you! I notice you're fully clad in "Color Splash!" It seems a little male chauvenistic the way those two let us know they didn't like the shirtless remarks. Am I wrong? It seems women wouldn't behave that way!

PS. Don't think I'll watch "Color Splash" anymore.

Posted by Marilyn – September 17, 2007 3:41 PM

I said from the beginning that Kim would win. I am so glad that she did. My next choice was Sparkle Josh. I love his personality and he is so cute! His designs are not up to my taste but he needs his own show doing something.

Posted by tvwatcher9 – September 17, 2007 3:41 PM

Congratulations Kim!
Just an idea...Todd could be Kim's carpenter!? Kim would still be the "design star" but the fans could get the best of both worlds as Todd's strengths are in constructing big ideas.

Posted by Gretchin – September 17, 2007 3:39 PM

YEA KIM--So glad to see you get what you so richly deserve. I have been an HGTV viewer for years and watch several hours a day when I can. I will say, however, that I wouldn't watch if Todd had won. He is too immature and wears on your nerves fast. I think his designs lack function and are one-dimentional. You couldn't and wouldn't want to live in a house with furniture tipped over against the wall. I couldn't take the words 'DUDE', 'FULL THROTLE, FIFTH GEAR", one more time. Also, a professional would certainly keep his shirt on. I honestly believe if he would have won, he would have ripped his shirt off. But back to the reason I am writting in. It's Kim's class, clever designs, tack, and "eye" for changing a room that gave her AMERICA'S VOTE. When I watch TV, it's to unwind and relax. I can do that watching Kim. I also like Kim the person. She knows what's important, putting her spouse first and speaking of him in a respectful way. I truly think that Kim will really listen to her clients' wishes and not force a "one dimentional view" on them like Todd would. Being a designer is the "total package" KIM--YOU ARE THE TOTAL PACKAGE. I wish you much success.

Posted by Sandy – September 17, 2007 3:39 PM

yikes, last night was a tough one. yes, todd was totally fun and super, super creative, but he just couldn't touch kim's elegance and class both in design and personality.

sparkle josh. I LOVE HIM. i was bitter at first with that nickname because i thought it was demeaning just cause he's gay, but after what will said (OMG -- will, you are SUCH a good man), i couldn't think of any other name that would be more fitting. gorgeous-sparkle josh made me laugh, made me happy -- i just want to perch him on my fireplace and stare at him! he's beautiful, hilarious, talented, a good person, and ridiculously sexy. he MUST have his own show!!

i don't care how misunderstood rob is -- get on meds, dude!

that christina is so pretty and sweet. i just want her to be happy.

i think will is an EXEMPLARY human being and should definitely join kim on her show. he is easy-going, non-judgemental, a hard worker, and just a personified heart. i would love to see him speak at children's schools and teach love, kindness, and compassion to our future leaders.

i'm so sad this season is over. i wish i could get kim, gorgeous-sparkle josh, christina and will to work on my place. i know i would cry every time i walked in the room. they are SHEER talent.

Posted by Michelle Marino – September 17, 2007 3:34 PM

I am happy for Kim. She does have some polishing up to do in terms of some design concepts and how to handle the "challenges" - see them as such - not problems to whine about. On camera, anyway. But I believe that her show has great potential for the HGTV execs to implement a unique twist/approach. Personally I am tired of watching rich people getting most of the room makeovers and watching young rich twenty-somethings house hunting for $500k homes.......Shows like Freestyle and Decorating Cents are the best, IMHO. Middle America comprises most of our country's demographics. It only makes sense to appeal to the masses. Perhaps with Kim's shows, the focus can be on 'real' people - even profile designers who didn't go to a 4 yr college or pay $3K for a week seminar and then get to have fancy initials after their names. A true designer designs for the client with their talents and heart and it doesn't have to be pricey, either. Since Kim's description is "Desigh Enthusiast" - well, there ya go - show theme already taken care of. I think she will have great TV presence especially if HGTV leverages her people and communication skills. Best of Luck to you, Kim. Way to go, girl :) P.S. -Still any chance of a Sparkle Josh/Will team show or SOMETHING? - Karen

Posted by Karen H. – September 17, 2007 3:29 PM

Congratulations Kim.

I think the next Design Star needed to be a grounded person and you are that. Todd was great but he would not settle down, too much jumping and leaping and tearing off of his clothes.

I would like to see a show where these contestants work together on projects as a series. At least I would like to see Will and Sparkle on some shows!

The producers did a great job of choosing contestants this season so why not stick with them? We, as the audience, loved them and will love to keep watching for them.

Posted by nipster – September 17, 2007 3:29 PM

To those who’ve chosen the low road, deciding to sling insults and accusations at Kim and insulting the voters. All this anger simply because she was chosen over Todd? I feel sorry for you. Congratulations Kim and best wishes to Todd also.

Posted by ccrc – September 17, 2007 3:29 PM

Thanks HGTV for giving us Design Star, I've enjoyed it so much.

I'd love to see a reunion Christmas show with the 11 (or 10, since Kim has her own show). Give each designers a room to decorate for Christmas. We would get great decorating ideas and could see what has happened to them since being on Design Star.

Congratulations Kim!

Posted by Jana – September 17, 2007 3:10 PM

Great job Kim! I'm so glad you won. I voted as often as possible for you! Your warmth, calmness, and talent are going to make for a great show. Can't wait to see it.

Posted by lj6983 – September 17, 2007 3:08 PM

Felicidades, Kim. Vote por ti y estoy muy contenta por tu eleccion. Definitivamente eres la estrella que todos podran ver brillar en tu show. A proposito, me muero por saber el nombre del show. Dios te bendiga y disfrutalo.

Posted by gloria – September 17, 2007 3:06 PM

Martha, someone needed to instruct Todd how to select a shirt! You may have disliked Kim's choice in a dress, but at least she wore clothing at each challenge! To quote you, "A designer knows how to dress herself (himself)". Perhaps since Todd is still in his childhood that will come with age....

Posted by Val – September 17, 2007 3:02 PM

It is now two years later and we check in on our contestants.
Scott C. is mayor of Santa Barbara, and is working on unifying the color palate of his lovely city.
Lisa M. is busy in her boutique featuring design in paper, papyrus and recycled textiles. She also specializes in anagram giftwrap for every occasion.
Josh is designing animal sanctuaries worldwide to bring style to flora and fauna. He is currently in Alaska helping a polar bear colony choose a color scheme.
Adrianna has found a new joy in teaching women carpentry skills at the local college.
Christina is busy working out the final design of her Rose Parade float.
Neeraja bought a charming art deco Bed and Breakfast in Paris.
Sparkle Josh is a designer for national and international pagent sets. Shine on y'all, shine on.
Robb was captured by a group of renegade preschoolers. He is in timeout until he learns how to play nice.
Will is Goodwill Ambassador for North Carolina. He is a frequent guest on several popular design shows.
Todd is currently in training, but he still is having problems grasping down, sit, and stay.
Kim's award winning design show has led her to write a bestselling book on design for real people.

Posted by design star reunion – September 17, 2007 3:00 PM

WAY TO GO KIM---

I love SPARKLE JOSH and WILL-- Can someone PLEASE bring them back to a show????

Again HGTV execs I'm a 15 year TV veteran that needs a job-- CALL ME

Posted by maggie – September 17, 2007 2:57 PM

Congratulations Kim!!!! My family has been cheering for you from the beginning and are so happy you won - we screamed and stomped. I am glad the voters recognized you are the Design Star.

Kim represents America - she is the one I can see having over for coffee and she is the one I would let design in my home! Not Todd. OMG, the idea he might win made me want to vomit. His blue surfer dude routine got so old, so fast. Thanks to the other views for not voting for Todd.

I do like Sparkle Josh and Will and together or alone I wish they would each have a show. I hope HGTV snaps them up before someone else does.

But, again, Kim - I am so happy you won. You seem like such a real genuine person and I can't wait to watch your show! Stay true to yourself and you will go very far!!!

Posted by Agrimony – September 17, 2007 2:53 PM

I am happy Kim won, do u know y? She is a hair dresser, and won, what a awsome chalenge, that's what i call design star, if she wasn't good enough she wouldn't had won. Congrats Kim, I am so excited to watch your show.

Posted by Ana – September 17, 2007 2:42 PM

Congrats Kim!!! I enjoyed Todd's unique decorating style too, but felt that you have so much untapped creativity, that you really deserved to be the newest Design Star. I'll be watching for your show as much as I watch all of HGTV's line up. Best wishes!

Posted by Shari – September 17, 2007 2:35 PM

I knew Kim will win based on the last competition in Hawaii. Congratulations to Kim. However, I voted for Todd because I'd like and hope to see a different kind of design show on tv, something fun and bold and innovative. Why not?

Posted by Tully – September 17, 2007 2:35 PM

I loved all of it and I can't wait until next year's Design Star. That was so much fun. Kim did nail that last room just like David did last year against Alice. All extremely talented men and women. It just came down to who did the better job and this year it was Kim. Thanks for the good time.

Posted by laura – September 17, 2007 2:35 PM

I was SOOOOO excited when Kim won! She has AMAZING talent and I CAN'T WAIT to see her show!

Posted by middleearthsdlf – September 17, 2007 2:34 PM

The show was so much fun to watch. I laughed and laughed. Sparkle Josh....you should get your own sitcom. Neeraja...go home, and stop criticizing Robb...CONGRATULATIONS KIM!

Posted by Theresa – September 17, 2007 2:25 PM

After reading all the other postings, I still believe Todd should have won. Really, Kim knows how do what has already been done. And she does it well. Todd, however has thought out of the box the entire time. He showed the most inginuity, creativeness, thoughtfulness to the client, an all around fun-loving, unique excitement. He would have had us all waiting on the edge of our seats for his next great design. Kim, on the other hand, well, it's going to be a very long year. Yet another boring show taking up valuable air time. Hey HGTV, when are you going to get with the times? Maybe a show called, "Full Throttle"??? Something that perhaps both the husband and wife can have fun watching??

Posted by Kelph – September 17, 2007 2:15 PM

I enjoyed the show, but thought that last year's contestants displayed more talent. I think that's why the judges had such a hard time each week -- because no one every stood out consistently.

I was glad Kim won, not that she was my favorite "designer". I liked Will's designs the most, but thought he mumbled and lacked hosting skills. Kim did display, consistently, the best hosting skills. She just felt natural in front of the camera, and I thought she was fun to watch. I'll watch her show.

Design Star does not test who is the best "designer". That changes according to tastes, as you can see from the comments on this board. They all compete under very strange circumstances, similar to what it would be to put on a tv show on decorating, I think, rather than who is the "best" designer. Who knows what any of the contestants are capable of doing if given the time constraints of the real world?

I like to see a reality show where "winning" is not based on tearing down all the other contestants, making alliances, etc. Thanks for that, HGTV.

Posted by Jennifer – September 17, 2007 2:04 PM

Kim is a great person, however I feel the judges missed their marks on this one. Although she is good at what she does, she does not provide anything new to the world of design. She merely copies what has already been done. I fail to understand how this country of HGTV fans thought she had anything over Todd. Todd would have brought so much uniqueness and inginuity to HGTV. It's a sad day, but one I will have to put nehind me. This has taught me a great deal about how the world works in the television world. I have been shown the light. Don't watch TV. Live in reality. Make the world what you want it to be and don't rely on the rest of the world to make your decisions for you. Good bye HGTV.

Posted by Kelph – September 17, 2007 2:02 PM

The funniest moments of the show: the "catch phrase" montages, especially Christina "Yeah" and Kim "Situation"; and Martha's blooper, saying "His package is just so intersting to watch," which had me in pain from laughing so hard, and I'm laughing again as I type this. I wasn't thrilled with the outcome, but it was a fun season overall.

Posted by Tom – September 17, 2007 2:01 PM

Hi kim, congratuation on make your life goal come true!!! i loved your final design plan. Watching you make your vision come to life was fantaic (oops).I can't wait to tune in to watch you creat!! Keep up the good work!!!

Posted by turkessa – September 17, 2007 1:56 PM

Congratulations, Kim! Can't wait for your show! It would be wonderful if you could be assisted by Will...and maybe by "Sparkle" Josh too as I will miss seeing those 2 guys. Shame on any posters who diss you--they just don't know what they're talking about!!!

Posted by JKay – September 17, 2007 1:54 PM

TODD is an ARTIST, DESIGNER, AND BUILDER. VERY CREATIVE VERY HIGH ENERGY.SOMETHING DIFFERENT AND WORTH WATCHING !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
KIM IS AN ACTRESS & HAIRDRESSER SHE DID NOTHING GREAT, NOTHING DIFFERENT. SHE SIMPLY DID A GOOD JOB OF ACTING THE PART. I loved everything that TODD and WILL did and nothing that Kim did. JUDGING should be a combination of the public, professionals, and the fellow CONTESTANTS!

Posted by SUE – September 17, 2007 1:54 PM

We are so glad Kim won: good design & style and a warm, accessible personality.

It would have been such a bummer to have Todd on HGTV, doing his tiresome 'Look at me! Look at me! Look at me!' thing. I agree with Tony, the guy's pushing 40 and his behavior is really annoying.

You totally CRUSHED THE COMPETITION, KIM! SWEEEEEET!! CONGRATULATIONS TO THE LITTLE HAIRDRESSER THAT COULD!

Posted by Beasley – September 17, 2007 1:52 PM

Congratulations Kim,

I am delighted for you! Proof, good people can and do win. Your win is a WIN for us all ordinary people. We don't need sparkles, bullies or shirtless designers ----you are REAL, keep it that way!
Laura

Posted by Laura – September 17, 2007 1:52 PM

Congrats, Kim.
I hope HGTV follows their past ideas and works with both finalists. I think both Kim and Todd are very deserving of their sucesses and were as they have said "Triple Threats".

Posted by Bill – September 17, 2007 1:45 PM

Congrats to you KIM! What a great ending! The whole show made you laugh just watching all the fun and yes, mistakes they made. Was great to see them all together once again. And to see the judges have some fun too.

Sparkle Josh is a hoot to watch, and hopefully one day we will see him again. Will just has that special class that makes him who he is, and hopefully we will also see more of him.

I enjoyed the show last evening more then any other of the episodes so far. It's nice to let your hair down and just be who you are.

Best Wishes Kim, I'll be watching for you in the spring!

And Best Wishes to all the other contestants, I wish you all well.

Posted by justadream – September 17, 2007 1:42 PM

I thought last night's show was the BEST recap/winner announcement show in the history of reality shows. I couldn't stop laughing and crying! Kudos to the producer or editor or whoever was in charge!!! The group this year was great and Kim will be a shining design star!!! Love those judges - Vern is wonderful!
Carol

Posted by carol buffington – September 17, 2007 1:41 PM

Congratulations Kim, To Martha who made the comment about Kim dress that she "does not even know how to pick a dress that will disguise her stomach" So uncool and what a witch.

Posted by Nette – September 17, 2007 1:40 PM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM, I HOPE YOU CAN GET EVERY THAT YOU WISH WITH THIS OPPORTUNITY THAT HGTV IS GIVING YOU .......

I WISH TODD WITH YOU ALSO ,HE IS GREAT

Posted by Anne – September 17, 2007 1:36 PM

Anyone can mimic a Potterybarn catalog. I saw absolutely no originality in Kim's decorating. I won't use the word "design" because she made no such attempt the entire season. Her show will likely be as cookie cutter as her rooms. Todd, on the other hand, is a true original and kept me waiting with anticipation to see what he would do next, i.e., NOT boring. HGTV, I double-dog-dare you to give Todd a show regardless of this competition. Come on, does every series have to showcase "warm colors," dark wood and Indonesian accent pieces!?!

Posted by Little Mom – September 17, 2007 1:35 PM

Hooray for Kim! Her final presentation to the judges was so solid - she has such a natural ease as a hostess. I had been torn until that point, but then it really was obvious. Todd is more talented in terms of out-of-the-box thinking, but how would his designs really transcend to the average project? I am not sure I'd hire him for something "normal" but if I wanted something crazy and cool, he'd be my guy!

Posted by SFH – September 17, 2007 1:31 PM

Personality plus!!! Yay Kim! This season has had its ups and downs but in the end the process worked. Kim IS a star and I can't wait for her show.

I'm commenting to say again to HGTV: Will and Sparkle Josh are ALSO stars! Please, please please use their incredible talent and chemistry on your network. Every time they worked together they shone even brighter. A show teaming design's "Faith Hill and Queen Latifah", as Sparkle called them, would be HUGE! Love them both separately, together they are magic.

Posted by harrietthespy – September 17, 2007 1:31 PM

Congratulations Kim! I am so happy for you. I liked you from the beginnging, but you really won my heart when you came to Wayne WV, not too far from where I live. You gave that family something they will always remember. you made a difference and touched the lives of those people.That's what it's all about.
Can't wait for your show. Good luck!

D. Payne

Posted by danny payne – September 17, 2007 1:29 PM

I guess, i have watched Candice so much ,she has me so hooked I can't see anything to compare with her talent. She could take this old mobile home of mine, and make it look a mansion. no doubt in my mind. To me she is what design is all about. I know it not fair to to compare new designers to her. But she is just the best I have seen. And I love Vern's work also, plus he a super person. Love his new show. And I will watch the show HGTV gives Kim. I have a feeling, Kim just might surprise us all We should give her, her chance to bloom. She may be another
Lisa L. She is just great. She takes the cake on that show. Hopefully, she will be there for Kim. HGTV really has some good shows. Don't care for Donna freeman , I'd like to see her house Must be Awesome from the smart remarks she makes. I do not watch her anymore. There has to be a nicer way to help people sell their homes. When she on design to sell I cut down the volume until she off.
But, I wish all 11 stars the best. WILL I LOVE
YOU. Hope HGTV finds you and Josh a Spot. You
both are good. HGTV please don't let these people slid by The fans loves them. Show Us what you can do Kim. Make America Proud They chose YOU!!!

Posted by Bonnie – September 17, 2007 1:27 PM

Kim,
I am so glad you won. I was rooting for you from the very FIRST episode. I like your style!!!!

Posted by Peggy – September 17, 2007 1:24 PM

Congratulations Kim!!
Every single show I made the comment that I would trust Kim to decorate my home anytime!! There were talented competitors but it was in Kim that I kept seeing the same qualities I most admire in Vern Yee. I look forward to seeing your very own show and envy those who will benefit from your understanding ear and discerning eye.
Sincerely ~ Marilyn Jo Smith ~ Midland,TX

Posted by Marilyn Jo Smith – September 17, 2007 1:24 PM

Big congratulations, Kim!!!! Good to know my vote helped choose the winner!!!!!! With your personality and your ease with the camera, you will be a delight on your OWN show. I will be watching - so glad your dream came true!

HGTV please give us an added treat and give Sparkle Josh and Will a show together - then this season will feel complete.

Thanks for the great blog lwatkins.

Posted by Joanie – September 17, 2007 1:21 PM

Kim, you took it all the way!!!! I never had any daught that you wouldn't. You have class and style and you know how to take the two and make it one. Tears fell as they said your name as the winner, and my tummy wasn't even upset.....You go girlfriend and now that you're at the top never forget there is always and will always be one more step. Just the short time I felt like I got to know you through your talent ( an you really did put Rob in his place and did it so smooth and showed us that it was from the heart, and you ment business). I am really looken forward to your "KIM" SHOW ON HGTV in the spring and I know you will teach me lots. I love design and I feel HGTV is the best show on that square box they call TV, its on at my house almost 24/7. I wish you the best and I hope and pray all the changes you have ahead of you will be good to YOU! Congrats, You go girl, shine!!!!
And i have to say this, If you ever need to design and don't know where to go, well here it comes..My rooms are yours....Jeannie

Posted by Jeannie Johns – September 17, 2007 1:21 PM

Well deserved, Kim. Thank you for your class. Thank you for your assertiveness(handling Rob) and your belief in yourself. I especially thank you for your tactfullness and your presence on the air. You have captured what appeals to the majority of the American public with your in-born design talent. You have wisely taken into consideration the dreams of those who would tune in to HGTV. Congratulations for having your finger on the pulse of America.
Todd was a real challenge, but not for the homes of America. I am certain he has earned his place designing TV sets or working for Disney. It was enjoyable to watch him express his free spirit and perform his childish antics. I am looking forward to your program this spring. Again, a heartfelt congratulations from the deep SOUTH! The best to you!

Posted by marco770 – September 17, 2007 1:17 PM

Congratulations KIM from TEXAS!! Keep you sweet personality and you will continue to be a success. Don't get all uppity like some of those snobby designers, with unlimited budgets - Keep it REAL!!

Posted by TexasGal – September 17, 2007 1:16 PM

When I first saw Kim wasn't professionally trained, I figured she'd be the first or second to go. She managed to play the game well: wasn't argumentative, worked hard, and stayed below the fray. I never felt like she looked at a space to wonder "what could I change? what could I alter" but merely decorated the room. I think HGTV should make it clear that they are looking for a decorator or a designer. It's one thing to pick paint colors and flooring, but to change a space is something else.

Part of the problem for me were these double-elimination episodes. It's like they were pressed for air time and condensed the season. I needed more of the individual room challenges.

Posted by Liz – September 17, 2007 1:14 PM

I must say that I am disappointed that Todd did not win. I LOVE HGTV and I watch their shows daily. However, I am getting a little bored with the same "type" of designs over and over again. The neutrals, soft colors and clean lines. I hear these sentiments stated over and over again!!!!

Todd seemed fresh to me. He had the X factor that I believe is missing from the lineup right now. He was a little outrageous at times, but that was only a testament to his creativity.

So instead of creativity, we will have another 30 min show on "clean lines".

Posted by Mo – September 17, 2007 1:14 PM

Way to go Kim!!!
I will watch her show in the spring time. Sorry to hear about Todd's fan being a poor sport but lets face it..Kim won!! More people voted for her. Why would HGTV fix the votes?? I thought with Todd's fans being younger because his ideas they would have the advantage due to the fact they like to TEXT more than older ones..but guess that was not true..Way to go KIM!!!

Posted by Peggy – September 17, 2007 1:12 PM

Kim is nice, but SPARKLE JOSH IS THE STAR!!!
I wish HGTV would give him his own show...
SPARKLE, YOU ARE JUST GREAT!!

Posted by La befana – September 17, 2007 1:11 PM

Congratulations Kim!!!

I was praying you would win and when I heard your name I was so happy for you. I voted for you and can't wait to watch your new show. If you do any makeovers in the South Bronx I am here for you.

Posted by Cynthia Wilkins – September 17, 2007 1:10 PM

Given who was at the end, I'm glad Kim won. I am, however, disappointed in Season 2. Let me tell you why...

1. In the attempt to get the field down to a small size, almost all of the early shows lost people as a result of - not design flaws - but teamwork or planning issues. I honestly believe HGTV lost some good designers in the early weeks because it wasn't "design" that was the primary measure.

2. I don't know how the judge's missed getting rid of Rob earlier. From the beginning, it was clear he wasn't a team player.

3. Again, in reference to the early shows, the judges let strong personalities win the day over contestants that were simply trying to not make waves. It almost felt like the one who talked the loudest won.

4. Give Clive a bigger part. His script this year was predictable. Same thing every week. We know he's better because we have all the other shows he's on to prove it.

Overall, I felt Season 2 was abbreviated and rushed. If next season follows the same script, I doubt you see a 4th. It could have been so much better.

Posted by BigCity – September 17, 2007 1:09 PM

I am so glad Kim won, but I still would rather see a show with Sparkle Josh...now he is entertaining!!! HGTV or someone ought to give him a platform..maybe Comdey Channel

Posted by Jeanette – September 17, 2007 1:08 PM

Hey, I´m from El Salvador, and let me tell ya, here we´re fans of HGTV too... and we´re very excited Kim won her own show, she really deserved it!!! CONGRATS KIM!!!

Posted by Mario Cordero – September 17, 2007 1:08 PM

My sentiments exactly DEANNE. Only difference is, I will watch one or two episodes of Kim's show as I believe in giving everyone a chance. Sometimes they may surprise us!

Posted by susan – September 17, 2007 1:07 PM

Congrats Kim!!
way to go gurl. wishing you onlyut he best. I am so proud fo the entire team for giving their props [respect] to Will- what an absolutely genuine human being-his gentle soul will make him go far in life on so many levels. Mwaaahhh. And Mr Santa Barbara man--lol- in stiches i was - enjoy! and sigh, Sparkle Josh-another sweetie and talented man i know you will continue to grow and develop into a deorator who we will see in the near future everywhere!!!!
best to one and all!
Liz

Posted by liz – September 17, 2007 1:07 PM

I think Kim will be the better host of an ongoing show, but I would love to see Todd do a special or two. He has such an interesting outlook, and took every one of his designs to the absolute limit.

I felt Kim's spaces were more livable (even the one in West VA -- come ON it was a double-wide mobile home!) but Todd's were fresh and interesting.

Will comes off as a wonderful guy on TV. I agree with his mom that he should have dressed up more. I think that Will, with a little coaching on on-camera behavior, could turn into a great TV talent. I hope he gets some specials too.

I never got on the Sparkle Josh train, but he seems to be a sweetheart. I wanted to see more of Adriana's designs but was not sure of her hosting skills.

Posted by Theresa – September 17, 2007 1:06 PM

I am suffering from bitter disappointment after last night's Design Star Finale! I will never watch any show hosted by Kim Myles! I feel it was a classic case of Kim having Will and Robb doing all of her dirty work painting her room and ripping up carpeting during the last challenge. Her design consisted of totally store bought items and she had no original ideas of her own. Would she have taken up the carpeting without the suggestion of the judges? No. Did I hear her say a local artist designed the headboard to the bed? Those leaf cutouts were store bought. Much has to be said for Todd who stood behind his design 100%, created his own artwork, mixed and muted his own paint colors for a unique wall color, and blended what became a travel friendly Hawaiian suite. When Kim's design was shown for the first time, all of the ocean views were covered by curtains and her so-called eat in kitchen consisted of a high table with bar stools. To get to the kitchen, I would have skinned my elbow on the swinging, sharp pieces of wood she hung from the ceiling with unfinished ends. In a suite with ocean views, why separate the room into sections? Why eliminate the ocean views? I would also hate to slip and slide on her cement floor after tracking in sand and water from the beach after all day. I bet none of the viewers gave any thought to how non-travel friendly her suite really was. Imagine how the hotel staff would feel about cleaning up that floor when they could just run a vacuum to clean up sand on carpeting? HGTV had many talented designers this year and if they were truly intelligent, they would also give Todd a chance to host his own show. He stood out from all of the other candidates on Design Star very early this season. HGTV give Todd a chance!!! FULL THROTTLE!!!!!! America this should not be about popularity, but about good design!

P.S. Also, I think Robb got a bad reputation for no basically no reason. He was a fantastic designer under much pressure. I think on the kitchen episode Kim should have deferred to him since he was more experienced on kitchen projects instead of sulking, tattling to the judges, and making sure Robb was sent off the show. Wayne was satisfied and pleasing the client is all that matters. Kim gleefully laughed when Robb's countertop measurements were incorrect (in a situation where a mistake would cost her, too, and I believe that shows a person's true character), but in the finale, Kim proved that she couldn't even tell the difference between a king or queen size bed.

Posted by Christina Kinan – September 17, 2007 1:05 PM

Very disappointed Kim is a lovely person, lots of charisma but not a designer. Her designs were amateurish at best, lacking all sorts of creativity. One watches the network and shows to learn, from Kim there is nothing to learn from.

Posted by ib – September 17, 2007 1:04 PM

What a waste. Sure, I voted for Todd, guessed him from the start. All his designs were "Off the hook" I wonder what kind of show will come out of Kim, maybe some kind of craft show. Just about anyone else would have been a better pick, maybe not Neerja. Maybe Steve Hanneman can help her out, cause she can't do any of the work to a successful completion.

Let's try some new judges next year, Vern will be too busy with his new show. How about Lisa Laporta?

Posted by Michael – September 17, 2007 12:51 PM

Kim! Congratulations!!! I can't tell you how happy and excited I was for you to be the new HGTV Design Star! It is really rare to find genuinely kind people that deserve this lifetime opportunity. As a new homeowner I'm stucked watching HGTV. Now, I can't wait to see YOUR show. Best of luck in your new journey!
Henrique

Posted by Henrique – September 17, 2007 12:49 PM

Kim - great job. You are bubbly and fresh and exactly what I want to see on HGTV. Todd, you're good looking, active, free spirited with a good energy and a few unique ideas - But I can only watch you for about five minutes before I need a break... The editors really helped you on this show because after you knocked over a table or threw your body out of frame they cut away to another designer...to give us a break! A full half hour of that is like watching my kids jump around and play - Most viewers of HGTV are busy mothers with kids...HGTV is time out, an escape....one can't escape a frantic, stressful day with Todd......Maybe a 5 minute Todd segment in between other shows or on another show - "Five Minutes with Todd" where you can jump around and show a cool design for a magazine shoot - but for a half hour??? Not for me. Again, Kim, you are sweet, bubbly, practical with some great ideas and explanations...exactly who I want in my home once a week. Good Job America!!!! We got something right. And Scott from Santa Barbara? I hope we see a lot more of you too. Great personality and great design ideas. Would love to see Will doing something too.

Posted by Patricia – September 17, 2007 12:45 PM

I would post my remarks to the idiots who came up with the lamest excuses why Kim should not have won, but blogs aren't designed for arguing (eventho millions do it everyday). It leaves no room for listening effectively. So to save you "haters" from skimming and scrolling down just to post another stupid comment...I'll just say "Congratulations Kim," and hope that somehow the other contestants (i.e. Will, Sparkle, Robb, and Todd) can get a show too.

Posted by Jay – September 17, 2007 12:41 PM

I was not impressed with Kim. Do not plan to watch her show. I noticed the carpet first thing on the final design show and also anyone who can not protect new carpet (West Virginia) should not be the new design star. I liked sparkle Josh and Will, they would make a great team show. Did not care for Todd either. I was disappointed in the desginers this year, too much drama and not enough invidual designs. I did not think the show was as good this year.

Posted by janet tinsley – September 17, 2007 12:40 PM

I missed Season 1, but love David's show, "Color Splash" so much that I tuned to Season 2. I LOVED IT!!!! I not only watched each Sunday night, but watched the reruns and marathons. My husband even sat down and watched a couple of episodes with me -- and he HATES "build to sell" shows! But this show was fantastic. Each week I fell more and more in love with the designers and hurt with them when they were voted off the show. I loved Will (but admitted he lacked on-air appeal, but not when he did his own video -- it was great!). Sparkle Josh was wonderful and so outlandish you had to love him. Christina was warm and genuine, but it is a severe lesson that you must LISTEN to the clients and take their wishes into consideration when doing a design for them. I understood her take on the "bridey" wedding she planned for the couple, but this woman was in love with this man, and she would want his wishes respected and considered. A bad mistake in judgment for Christina; even though her wedding board was fantastic! Robb was hard exterior with a warm heart. I think the ribbing that Kim gave him during the finale was just that -- poking fun -- Robb understood that. Scott is a truly talented designer. I would like to have seen him "on-air" just to see what he would have been like. Maybe next year you will consider doing "on-air" for each one of them, at least a snippet so that we can see what they would be like on camera. This was truly a fun season, with so much talent. I will be viewing Season 3 (should the Lord tarry) and, if it is anything like Season 2, I will enjoy every minute of it.

Posted by Janice – September 17, 2007 12:38 PM

WILL AND SPARKLE JOSH WITH THEIR OWN SHOW WOULD BE ONE OF THE MOST POPULAR ON HGTV!!!

Posted by a Fan – September 17, 2007 12:34 PM

Congrats Kim!

Posted by Renee – September 17, 2007 12:22 PM

Loved this season! I was torn at first between Kim and Will, but rejoiced with tears at Kim's win! What elegance and grace in style Kim has and what a charming personality. I am proud of you, Kim. I can't wait to see your new show, and I would trust you to decorate an entire home for me. I am looking forward to your show that I know will have innovative design ideas for family homes. America chose you for your natural ability to bring beauty and style to a home while keeping the design liveable!

Posted by laurie – September 17, 2007 12:20 PM

Kim, I watched the show's entire season and was routing for you all along!! I am so glad you finally won, as I voted for you. Your personality and perserverence finally won out!! I enjoyed all of the contestants and thought most had talent. Best of luck to you in your new show, I'll be looking forward to watching...

Posted by Candy Morgan – September 17, 2007 12:13 PM

America voted and I was thrilled and relieved that Kim won. She is truly better suited for the job and a better designer. The last challenge proved that to me. Todd's design may have worked if he had LISTENED to the judges like KIM did and got rid of the carpet and put the bed back in the bedroom, not leave it next to the kitchen with the fridge making noise all night. When asked about it, Todd said he didn't care what the judges said and he was going with his design. "Fifth gear/full throttle" should not be confused with "my way or the highway". Todd, you should have LISTENED, they were trying to HELP you - remember the judges were the ones that enabled you to get to the final round! Kim was told to get rid of the rug and did, with reluctance, but she did it and made the best of it. Todd should design kids' rooms and apartments for single guys, not homes for families. His best design was with for the family with the eight kids. Kim was clearly the one who listened to her clients and won their praise. I would much rather hire Kim than Todd, I just think Kim would works better with clients. Congratulations Kim! I look forward to seeing your show. Good Luck!

Posted by peppypeep – September 17, 2007 12:10 PM

Congrats, Kim! What a talented lady and kind soul. Kudos also to Todd (a fellow San Franciscan) and Will. You three were fabulous to watch and made for incredible teammates. Kim, I will be tuning in faithfully to watch your success and hope to see Todd, Will ( go, Charlotte!) and Sparkle Josh as guest designers on a few episodes in the Spring season.

Great job, HGTV, on a successful summer filler!

Posted by Patti A – September 17, 2007 12:09 PM

Kim!!! Congrats, I knew you would win. I liked your style, your confidence, and how you handled yourself with some of the others when the others were kind of mean to you!! YOU ARE A STAR!!!
Todd was good too, and I'm sure he'll benefit also from this experience in some great ways! Again, Kim congrats, Can u come to my house, I need your style. Good Luck, I'll see u in the spring!!!

Posted by Liz – September 17, 2007 12:02 PM

After reading all the blogs so far this morning it is hilarious to see how many people take this show too seriously!
It's entertainment, it's not your real life!
These designers were ALL talented, the show is fun to watch because of the different personalities and drama. But for bloggers to state they will never watch the show again, that is was racist, that it was fixed. etc.... is just maddening!
I agree with several other bloggers who have defended the voting process. America voted, not HGTV. If you read the blogs after last weeks show it was clear Kim had the majority of support. NOT TODD. He was fun to watch, his imitation of taking his shirt off last night was funny, lighten up people!
Kim wasn't rude about Robb! She could have really let him have it, but she made a truthful, tactful comment. Even the editors thought it was fun to highlight his character in the video montage.
I thought all of the clips edited together with the repetition of phrases, and bloopers, were the highlight of the show, very funny!
I do wish this show wasn't so short, it is very entertaining and I loved the whole season.
I think Kim's new show will be a surprise for all of us. Remember David B. wasn't a designer when he won either!
Congratulations KIM, you go girl!
Thanks to lwatkins for the blogs!

Posted by Cheryl – September 17, 2007 11:52 AM

Congrats to Kim, the best New Design Star won based on America's voting not by HGVT's politically correct moves. I enjoyed the finalie and look forward to Kim's show and DS3.

Posted by ladytaz357 – September 17, 2007 11:50 AM

I am so bummed that Todd didn't win!!! He rocked! The judges clearly favored him & were shocked that Kim won! I may give Kim's show a try but I don't know if I will watch Design Star next season. I thought Kim should have gone home 3 or 4 episodes back. What was with those cheap paper plates cut out like flowers?!?!? I would never hire her to do my house but I would definitely hire Todd!!!

Posted by Gina – September 17, 2007 11:50 AM

The results have little to do with talant
Kim maybe a sweet lady, but she is NOT a good DESIGNER
She should be working for JC Penny in the local mall, giving other housewives design tips

Todd was truly original, and really does have a great future ahead, too bad Design Star sold him short

Posted by Fitz – September 17, 2007 11:40 AM

Will in my opinion should have been next design star.

Congratualtions Kim on the Victory.

Todd all your designs seem to be about along the same aquatic theme.

Posted by Stephen – September 17, 2007 11:40 AM

First, congratulations to Kim. I hope your show does well.

Second, admittedly, I stopped watching the show after Sparkle Josh was eliminated, except to tune in for the last few minutes of each episode to see the rooms and who was eliminated. I only really watched the finale because I wanted to see Sparkle again. I haven't changed my opinion to accommodate the rest of the season (as it appears many others have) -- I'm not that malleable. I still say this year pretty much blew, especially compared to last year.

To recap, Robb never should have been in the final three after having been on the chopping block TWO COUNT 'EM TWO shows in a row (seems the judges just forgot from one show to the next -- and Martha tried to explain that away last night, but her explanation just didn't cut it).

Todd should have been on the chopping block for being the driving force behind that horrible "Tuscan" (cough) kitchen. His individual room was great as art, but not as a designed room. And what was with that supposed upscale Hawaiian suite? It reminded me of the motel Goofy's son chose in the Goofy Movie! Does anyone besides me remember that? Great for kids, but not for a grownup upscale suite! (It was like a Hawaiian version of the tacky Tuscan kitchen.)

Lisa never should have been eliminated so early -- her space was NOT "a failure," especially compared to Robb's harem pillows and car door on the wall! Eeek!

By the way, what's with so many people now coming back and saying Robb was "misunderstood" or some such poopie?! Are you kidding? Do you remember all the mean stuff he said and did in this competition? Yipes.

Yes, I'm afraid this year, still, overall, sucked - because (1) I find it hard to believe the most talented designers were chosen to begin with, (2) the judges DID NOT remember past competitions when deciding whom to eliminate, (3) I STILL believe that Todd was chosen as the design star early on, but Kim won only because the producers couldn't deny that so many more votes came in for her than for Todd, (4) too much Big Brother reality show garbage was chosen over good design tv, and (5) HGTV betrayed its core audience this year in favor of trying to broaden its audience. As the saying goes, if it aint broke, don't fix it.

That being said, again, congratulations to Kim, and hopefully next year's season will be better.

Posted by Kathy Gardner – September 17, 2007 11:38 AM

KIM .. You have a lot of class, and poise. Well done.. and looking forward to your new show. Have Sparkle, and Will, and a few others on with you once in a while. What a great bunch ! Fun to watch you all work together.
Sure do hope HGTV picks up Sparkle, at least. I would watch ANYTHING he did. He is such a sweetie, and makes the smiles come. His charisma is like a magnet.
Congratulations, Kim!!

Posted by Jackie – September 17, 2007 11:35 AM

I am extremely disappointed in who one last night. I think Kim rude, fake and non talented. It will be interesting to see if she can actually accomplish something on her own. With out the help of Rob and Will and I don't believe she would have one. She does not no how to execute her ideas. She should have been gone a long time ago. It should have been Will and Todd up there. Not her. Needless to say, I will no longer be watching HGTV!!!!!!

Posted by moonface – September 17, 2007 11:33 AM

I'm happy that Kim won -- Now, here is an idea for her show's name: The "Situation" Room! Oh, wait... I think that title is already taken, for a show on CNN or something. :-) :-)

Posted by JAM – September 17, 2007 11:32 AM

I’m shocked! I think Todd has much more to offer – his ideas and creativity are AMAZING! Too bad, America doesn’t know what a real designer is!
Todd you’ll do just fine without this show!

Posted by Djana – September 17, 2007 11:32 AM

Congrats Kim! Each episode, I would anxiously await your finished tasks and love the results!You have a great personality and really good energy for television. Let the blessings flow and keep up the great work!

Posted by Sharita – September 17, 2007 11:29 AM

Getting another chance to see my favorite designer, Sparkle Josh, made my day !!!

Posted by MarshaWC – September 17, 2007 11:29 AM

Sparkle Josh - Dahling can't get enough of you, look forward to seeing plenty more of you!!

Will, we are so happy for the recognition that you received atlast and expect to see more of you.

Next time HGTV why don't you add "the viewer's votes" for each show and make them count!!!. We know who we want to see in our homes. Our #1 vote goes to Josh and Will as a design team from day 1.

We congratulate you Kim, you have class and style so chosing between the both of you was a no-brainer.

Last what a relief that we will not be seeing any more "arm pit camera shots!" ESPN needs you Todd!! Your show will be called "Dude design".

To all participants - you gave us a great ride, you sacrificed so much to do this show - "YOU ARE ALL STARS!"

Posted by Jewelbaby – September 17, 2007 11:26 AM

Congrat... Kim.. I was so nervous as you were... I am exiting to watch you on your tv show now. If you want to make my familyroom, I would appreciate it...

Posted by adriana millan – September 17, 2007 11:25 AM

Rob was Robbed! I tried to vote for Todd but could never get the vote page to come up on my computer. I am a trained interior designer with my degree from the University of North Texas in 1955. Today I am retired with the ravages of Rheumatoid arthritis and loved the way Will listened to his physically limited client! I am glad to see some of the design advancements that are now coming about that we could only envision back in the 50's. I am sorry that Kim won for several reasons. I thought her treatment of Rob was deplorable, there was nothing gracious about it. She reminded me of some of the difficult people that I supervised in the past. I would have been glad to be the "notetaker" rather than the measurer. By the way, where were they going to put the refrigerator? I have reviewed that episode several times and did not see any plan for its placement. Had Kim been less confrontational I think that solution could have come about. Kim blew it in W. VA. They aked for a log cabin look and got an overhaul of their mobile home look, they were so poor anything new and clean would look good to them. Personally, I didn't like Kim's hosting style as to me she comes off sounding phony rather than natural. (Among other things I have done is be a speech teacher whose students have won many awards.) Sorry, America, you don't know the difference between design and decorating! Todd is so handsome and natural. It would be easy to get his hosting skills a-one with just a little coaching. He is inovative, inventive and exciting. I would make an effort to watch his show. I will only watch Kim if I'm waiting for Connie Olson or David Bromsted. Devine Design is HGTV's best in my book. I am so glad to get my feelings out. Good Luck on next season, makes me want to be young again so I could compete.MC

Posted by Mariella Cornell – September 17, 2007 11:24 AM

Kim, you rock! Todd, you rock! Both super-talented, both deserving, but only one could win! Kim's composure, eloquence, and lack of the dramatic made her my pick.

Rob, however, was such a jerk, and the unfortunate thing for him is that he is not an actor, otherwise he could blame it on character acting.

I loved watching these guys interact, it was by far the best way to spend my Sunday evening!

Once again congrats Kim!

Posted by melanie – September 17, 2007 11:23 AM

I think it's really interesting that some people think that this was fixed that Todd didn't win or that they couldn't believe Todd didn't win! If you go back and read the blogs before voting took place...you can see an overwhelming response that Kim was the favorite. Most people didn't want to see Todd on a show with the no-shirt thing going on, plus all his bizarre and unpractical designs plus the fact that Todd had already asked Robb to be on his show that he thought he was going to win. I'm so glad Kim won! I voted for her and everyone I know voted for her!

I voted for Alice last season and I was disappointed that she didn't win. But David has surprised me of his success just like I think Kim will surprise viewers that didn't vote for her. I don't believe HGTV fixed anything on the voting.

However....I do wish HGTV would fix some of their programming. Too much modern designs! Please....more home tours. Home tours inspire me more than fix-it or how to shows!

Anyway....Kim, I'll be watching your show! Looking forward to next spring!

Cindy

Posted by Cindy – September 17, 2007 11:04 AM

Congratulations, Kim! Your design in the last challenge was fabulous! Tod is handsome & his personality on camera improved after Rob, the super-jerk FINALLY left, but he was no competition for Kim in my opinion. He had one style only -- blue, surfer dude. How many shows can you build around that? I am looking forward to Kim's show & hoping it is as good as David's Color Splash.

Posted by LInda – September 17, 2007 11:03 AM

very disappointing.

Posted by ct – September 17, 2007 10:53 AM

Thanks lwatkins for being in charge of the blogs. You did a great job and I enjoyed reading your comments. You are funny!! I'm happy that finally someone I voted for won! I voted for Alice last year. I'm just glad another modern designer didn't get a show. David is good but has modern taste and so does almost every other host on HGTV. I just don't care for modern designs at all. Todd does however need a show on MTV because of his artistic rock n roll designs.

I still really want to see a show with Sparkle Josh, Will, Scott and Christina. I think they showed to be the most talented and they have the most charming of personalites. I would record every show that they would do!! I would still like to see a show with Alice also. Please HGTV...give us shows that show tradtional, french country, cottage and garden and eclectic styles!!! Enough already of the contemporary, modern and minimalist designs!!! Thank goodness for Candace Olsen (Divine Design) and Joe Ruggerio (Homes Across America). Those are the only two shows that appeal to me anymore!

Anyway....of the two we had to choose...I'm thankful Kim won. I hope she brings a breath of welcomed fresh air to HGTV!!! She seems to be really charming and she has good vision. Kim...can you please do the decor styles I mentioned above for the viewers who love them also?!

Thanks HGTV for letting us voice our opinions. I truly hope you read these blogs and seriously listen to your viewers!

I miss seeing my favorites....Alice (from Design Star 1), Sparkle Josh, Scott, Christina and Will!! Hope to see you on TV somewhere in the future! I loved getting to know you as far as the producers would let me. Loved your personalities, your design sense and your values as human beings! Best to each of you always!

God Bless All!
Cindy from Texas

Posted by Cindy – September 17, 2007 10:50 AM

Put Candace Olson & Kim Myles together, that's knock out creativity. These two women have personalities that are down-to-earth and Classy Upscale Styling I would hire either one in a minute to do Interior Design. Last years star David Bromstad is the best at artwork he could team up with Will from this years challenge please keep his show on too. I am so inspired by these gifted people. Thank you HGTV for giving me a new enlightening hobby.

Posted by Denise – September 17, 2007 10:50 AM

I am so happy for Kim. She is very tasteful in her choices. The judges said it as they walked in to her Hawaii suite that she had decorated "Now THIS is upscale!"

Todd shocked me with his headstrong foolishness and you can't have that when trying to please clients. He left the carpeting in and located the bed in the kitchen. IMHO that just blew him right out of contention. Ya, the view was nice but to what sacrifice? He would have put all the furniture in that room if he could have. His judgement was very poor, not surprising for a landscape architect.

Many women, regardless of vocation, have strong decorating skills and Kim knows her stuff. I'm sure she will continue to learn and be wonderful at her show. I'm looking forward to it.

Posted by Sue – September 17, 2007 10:48 AM

Congratulations Kim! I really felt that between Kim and Todd, Kim was the better choice. Although I didn't like her West Virginia design at all, she really came back to her senses in Hawaii. Although I absolutely love David Bromstad, I didn't really like seeing him with his shirt off during the competition and I liked it even less with Todd (because he was shirtless so often!) Still, my choice would have been Will. I nearly cried when Will's show was cancelled, as well as Sparkle Josh's. It was really great to see them again last night. I disagree with those who say Kim was rude to Robb on the final episode. I think she was graceous as could be. Although the judges kept saying that the talent this time was so much greater than last, I disagree. I don't think that there was one contestant this time or the first, that has the talent and personality that David has. He is still a winner in my book. But, again, I congratulate Kim and will look forward to her show. Knock 'em dead, Kim!

Posted by Linda – September 17, 2007 10:44 AM

Be real Todd was very creative, but not many people want to live in a house with rooms that look like freaked out artwork,skateboard ramps or rotating furniture pedestals. Now Todd has talent but probably would only interest the eccentric types.

Posted by Shirley – September 17, 2007 10:40 AM

I'm vert disappointed in the results. HGTV has people who can do the same stuff Kim does over and over and over. It is like every show they have. Todd was a chance for another genre where someone could both build and create for those who liked a more extreme style. I think he got ripped off considering people only looked at Kim's last work but didn't realize that Kim didn't finish a challenge and really did nothing but strip flowers in the wedding one. She is very limited and Todd should have won hands down. Congrats to HGTV for getting another cookie cutter designer.

Posted by TC – September 17, 2007 10:36 AM

Congrats from Kentucky, Kim!!! I was holding my breath with you, waiting for them to announce
YOUR name. And they did! I'm so excited for you. You are going to be so busy, creating a new show tailor made for you. I voted for you.
;) smiles all around my house for KIM.

I thought the show was great, bringing back all this year's designers. Now that the pressure was off even Robb calmed down, he was all smiles
at the show. I'm sure he wishes he could "edit" his behavior during the show, but he can't. Perhaps this can be a useful tool for him to make
improvements......he got down to the final 4, he should be proud of that, he might have gone further were it NOT for his behavior towards the others. He was funny talking about getting a new career in damage control.

Posted by BEVERLY RIDDLE – September 17, 2007 10:36 AM

WAY TO GO KIM! Of the final two, you are definitely the better desginer. Ignore the negative and snide comments (especially the one posted about the outfit you wore last night) posted by the Todd followers. You looked great. You are a lady with definite talent (which is why America chose you) and class. As a reminder to those who continue to write YOU didn't complete a project; remember Neeraja was the team leader (i.e., the tile kitchen, you assisted her) and she was voted off. The judges didn't like the FAUX on FAUX kitchen either, and Team Leader Josh was voted off (didn't hear any of you complaining that Robb should have been eliminated especially after he told the judges that even though Josh was the leader, HE...Mr Wonderful had the most say in the design). Keep on doing what you're doing girl. Sore losers, get a life.

PS - I would like to see a show with Will and Sparkle Josh. I believe Will is truly a Star Designer and with Sparkle Josh as a co-host, it would be an amazing show.

Posted by Debbra – September 17, 2007 10:28 AM

Hi HGTV winner I loved evey one of your designs& also voted for you,have a great time on your OWN show I will be watching,however I didt like Todds designs too,I do agree with Cheri who stated that he would be a good stage & set designer,but the one I most liked was SPARKLE JOSH & WILL (what a big heart). I hope I will see some more of both of them. If you orWillever need a canvas for your design I have a House in Veagas I would be honored to provide as your "palette".Go "Baby" go You 2 are terrific.

Posted by heidi – September 17, 2007 10:17 AM

Frankly I was stunned by the results of the vote! Todd showed so much confidence, creativity and leadership throughout the entire show. Not to mention his sense of fun and flair. He consistently showed his sense of teamwork and support of the other cast members and is truly a class act. I can see a very cutting edge design show featuring Todd, one I would take the time to sit down and watch.
Kim...well she seems sweet, her design is safe and familiar. She was a follower and lacks the energy and talent to keep my attention. There are plenty of designers on TV already doing this type of stuff.
HGTV...don't miss the opportunity to "sharpen" your image, sign Todd.

Posted by Amy – September 17, 2007 10:01 AM

Congratulations to me! I've picked the winner for the second time. While I thought Todd was very industrious and creative, he seemed to dwell on over-the-top nautical themes too much.

I think Kim will handle her own show quite well. It's unfortunate she was paired with the tyranical fellow who was unable to share in the experience.

Good luck, Kim, and congratulations!

Posted by Vivian – September 17, 2007 10:00 AM

I wanted to say that I enjoyed this season. I enjoyed the judges outakes it made them seem more real. I voted for Kim because she seemed like a real person,there is far too much fake on TV now. My hope is that she grows as a designer and proves how fantastic she is.My only negative I can say is "don't wear that dress again". I will take the time to watch your show. Please HGTV don't pick a side kick for her this time. Put Will and Kim together they come across as genuine empathic people. We can all take the time to watch people like that make it.

Posted by flasusan – September 17, 2007 10:00 AM

OMG Miracles happen and I am sooooo happy that KIM WON! I can't wait to see her show. She totally brought it week after week and her last design was icing on the cake! I'll miss all the people this Season yes even Robb. ;-) I would love to have everyday elegance added to my home by Kim... she ROCKS! CONGRATS KIM you totally deserve it!!

Posted by Kaff – September 17, 2007 9:58 AM

congrats to Kim, You were my first pick! David was my fist pick last year! You went thru many challenges (some not too fun) but your talent beamed!

Posted by n koch – September 17, 2007 9:55 AM

Congratulations Kim! I am sooo excited for you. When Clive announced you as the winner I screamed so loudly I set off the glass breakage alarm in my house. The police were dispatched and everything. You Go Girl! I am really looking forward to your new show.

Posted by dstdiva – September 17, 2007 9:54 AM

This season was very enjoyable to watch(and try to guess the winner). All of the designers were great, we really didn't get to see enough of their individual work, maybe next season HGTV. While I liked Todd, most of his design were too "out there" for me. I'm just a dreamer and closet designer, who uses designs from HGTV and many other sources,and didn't think I'd get usable ideas from Todd. Hope to see more from Sparkle and Will. Way to go KIm!!!!!

Posted by midamerica mom – September 17, 2007 9:47 AM

I'm happy for Kim, but felt like she is the typical designer who gets it right, but doesn't really test her skills. I voted for Todd, because I felt he really had the entire "package" (tee hee) and that I would tune in to see his show because you NEVER know what he'll do next. I probably won't watch Kim's show, because everything she did was predictable! What fun is there in that? I hope someone picks up Sparke Josh, Will and Todd for a show...is anyone listening??? TLC????? You just might bring me back to TLC with those guys as hosts! I quit watching that network when Hildi (Trading Spaces) kept ruining people's homes with her disgusting designs and lack of sensitivity to the homeowners! You could just win me back with a good show from one of the guys!!!

Posted by Dana – September 17, 2007 9:46 AM

THE PRODUCERS SHOULD REWORK THE ELIMINATION PROCEDURE. There should be no eliminations until the third show. By the third show the contestants will have expressed their design talent and personality individually and in team competition. The elimination of a contestant by a receipitant based solely on presentation was very questionable. The judges should be more deverse i.e. a notable highend designer, a TV producer and a designer for the masses.
This foremat would be much more fair to the contestants and more fun for the viewer.

Posted by Charlotte – September 17, 2007 9:46 AM

Conratulations to our new Design Star, Kim! I look forward to watching your new show. And thank you to IWatkins for hosting the blogs for Design Star this season. Your commitment and objective approach to blogging was most appreciated.

Posted by Meadows – September 17, 2007 9:43 AM

I have to say each week it was hard to see people eliminated - I think they all had talent and in sooo many different ways. Very cool show and contestants - way to step out of your comfort zone to be on Design Star! Congrats Kim!!!! I am so bummed that I had a family thing come up and didn't get to see the finale last night! Will it be on TV again any time soon...... can anyone tell me? I can tell from your comments that I missed a good show.

Posted by tami2js – September 17, 2007 9:40 AM

Congratulations to KIM !!!!! She clearly possessed all the talent, personality and dignity of someone who deserves to have her own show on HGTV .. Her designs were relatable, aesthetically pleasing and highly functionable ... Rock on Kim ... Rock on !!!

Posted by TMaynes – September 17, 2007 9:37 AM

Congrats Kim!

I screamed so loud, my husband admonished me for waking up the 10 year old, who had begged to stay up and watch the finale. As I expected, America chose the classic girl vs. the "surfer" dude. Let's face it, the majority of America does not live on the coast, nor spends our time participating in or watching "extreme" sports. They're struggling just to make ends meet. I certainly felt Todd was the strongest contestant going into the final challenge, and was given somewhat of a leg up with the location site being Hawaii. However, clearly Kim's overall final design was superior. America, nothing wrong with desiring the whimsical, playful, youthfulness of Todd, but reality is that that period of life only lasts a brief time. Let's face it, I doubt that Todd will be surfing tables when he gets 50 or 60, because by then, arthritis will have set in. Congratulations Kim, and thanks for representing the short, petite black females of the world!!

Posted by Dr CH2 – September 17, 2007 9:16 AM

Kim's victory last night was a huge disappointment to those of us who appreciate someone with REAL talent in design, namely Todd. Todd's approach to interior design is fresh and original. He designs with originality, balance and a flair for creativity. I have absolutely no plans to watch Kim's show.

Posted by June – September 17, 2007 9:15 AM

Congratulations Kim.
The Best won for a change. No naked chest or Right On's for the new series. I am gettig tired of all the shows having boobs hanging out and hairy underarms exposed.
I like your tact and ability to use constructive criticism to your advantage. You are also adaptable and able to create everyday useable designs that people can really live with.

Posted by Carolyn – September 17, 2007 9:14 AM

I told you they would pick a woman.
Next, they will pick a minority man...It is so predictable. They do it on all these type shows.

Kim did NOT deserve to win on talent.

Posted by karen – September 17, 2007 9:12 AM

HGTV are you listening???? America wants Josh Sparkle & Will!!!! We're sick to death of the boring shows. Too many real estate shows too! Deserving Design? The name drives me crazy! I won't watch that show just because I think the name is condecending. Color Correction...ick

Posted by kathy – September 17, 2007 9:09 AM

I am SO glad America selected KIM as the next Design Star!! Kim was the obvious choice. Todd's designs would do great in theme rooms for children, but not for everyday people. Congratulations KIM!! I have some words for the people who say they will not watch the show because Todd didn't win; You sound like spoiled children who did not get their way! Will you hold your breath until you pass out, too?!

Posted by Ricardo – September 17, 2007 9:05 AM

Nice going, viewers - you've just chosen to watch another bland, run-of-the-mill decorating show. You missed your chance to get someone fresh, new and exciting - Todd.

Have fun watching another endlessly repetitive show about wallpaper and pastels.

I'll be searching the web - or watching DIY.

Posted by Finn – September 17, 2007 9:00 AM

Thank goodness! Kim was definitely the star from the beginning and deserved to win. I was touched by her humanity toward that family in West Virginia, how she took a risk by giving them the additional dining room when she was only supposed to do the living room. That showed great courage and creativity that hopefully she can carry over into her new show. Perhaps a good format would be helping other disadvantaged families with their homes. God bless you Kim!

Posted by Dennis – September 17, 2007 8:59 AM

Congratulations to Kim! I think she will be great on her own show. Todd has a lot of talent but I think the best person won.
Love the show!!

Posted by vikums – September 17, 2007 8:56 AM

After seeing tonights last show, with all the parts we didnt see, it was very difficult for the judges to even get it right, and they came right out and said it was so hard , did we send the wrong one home.. It was nice seeing the whole team again ,, Congrads Kim,,, I thought they both did a great job,, We have one down to earth designer and one who thinks outside of the box and not afraid of taking chances to better his work,,, I wish you all the best Todd,,

Posted by Sandy – September 17, 2007 8:54 AM

You just got to LOVE these people who say..."I'M NEVER GOING TO WATCH HGTV DESIGN STAR AGAIN" because you didn't pick who I wanted to win...
GET A LIFE...PLEASE!!! Like HGTV will CANCEL Design Star because your person didn't winand you WON'T watch. Would you want a DESIGNER to come to your home and say...HEY DUDE...WE CAN MAKE THIS PLACE SWEET...How professional is that. Or do you want a person who can "visualize" your plans and talk to you without jumping around, wanting to take off the shirt and literally bouncing off the wall. It is a TV show...nothing more...nothing less... Don't like who won? Then get yourself cable TV and a remote. There are hundreds of channels you can watch and NEVER EVER have to watch HGTV again. Only in the USA can this happen. Be grateful you even have a TV to watch...

Posted by Maxx – September 17, 2007 8:36 AM

HGTV voters got it wrong. Kim is nice and all - but what does she bring to HGTV that it doesn't already have? Todd would have given HGTV a show with a much-needed edge. Something that's currently not in its lineup. A niche show, yes. But at least it'd be entertaining.

Posted by ho hum – September 17, 2007 8:36 AM

Im dissapointed for Todd :-( I thought he was much better, more polished and a thousand more times more creative. America was obviously pulling for the underdog, trying to prove a point that someone without classical training can still do a good job. Im Happy for Kim but I wont be watching her, im sorry, Todd is more fun to watch for ten thousand reasons. I can only hope that someone will pick him up, I know coming in second sometimes pays off better, more opportunities arise so we can only hope for Todd! DONT GIVE UP TODDDDD!!!!

Posted by vewggie mom – September 17, 2007 8:30 AM

Enjoyed the finale last night...Great to see MY Design Star again - WILL! You definitely clean up nice (thanks Momma). And you still blow me away with your geniune smile, keen eye for design (even if sleek and modern isn't my style), and down to earth personality.

Hoping to see some changes in the Season 3 format:
less edited "drama", bickering, etc.
More individual competition - maybe fewer design hopefuls.
NO MORE kitchens in 2 days!

Wouldn't it be a hoot if each design star hopeful had to present the same room done by an established designer and showcase it's design qualitites?

Posted by Pret07 – September 17, 2007 8:27 AM

I agree with Kayla, Todd should have his own show. I also doubt that I will watch Kim's show.

Posted by franteaks – September 17, 2007 7:54 AM

Loved the finale until the end! For the life of me I can not understand how Kim was chosen as the winner. Todd was far more talented. What was America thniking?

Posted by franteaks – September 17, 2007 7:51 AM

Congrats Kim! You deserved it! Wow! What a show! I was entranced from week to week, wondering how in the world the judges were going to be able to choose the one going home.....I don't think I could have chosen. Although, seriously, I would have sent Robb home instead of Lisa on the first show. However, Robb's individual challange on the room challenge blew me away...and in a good way! Robb is very talented but he needs to work on his ability to get along with others and still maintain his design. The little hairdresser who could, how awesome! Todd, you are a fantastic designer with amazing vision.....I wish we could keep seeing all these designers in some way....what about it HGTV????

Posted by Angela Grizzle – September 17, 2007 7:41 AM

We're SO happy for Kim. She has great taste and brings reality to design. We never would have watched Todd's show - too much "full throttle" would have made us more nauseous than we already are with him. GO, KIM!!!!

Posted by Fiona – September 17, 2007 7:37 AM

What a fiasco! Totallly disappointment. The most creative and innovative designer was Todd. The guy was the best on air personality By FAR!!. HGTV need something different show and Todd deserved. The guy was able to execute and designs as well as create them. It would have been great to see what he would come up with next; indoors and outdoors around the country. I hop we will see you on other tv channel.

Posted by JL - September 17, 2007 7:18 AM

Posted by jl – September 17, 2007 7:20 AM

Last night's show was anti-climatic with Kim winning the competition. Truthfully, neither contender impressed me enough to watch his/her show in the future. Enough of rewarding mediocrity. The judges did a poor job of selection. I was irritated with their inane comments just to say something. I felt the true designers were eliminated too early. For those accusing some of the contestants as not being handy, you don't have to know how to use tools to execute good design. Unfortunately, I did not see any creative design, just a typical reality show about personalities. HGTV has dropped the ball this season. If this method of selecting new hosts continues, HGTV will have a program schedule loaded with uninspiring "design stars".

Posted by Margaret – September 17, 2007 6:22 AM

TODD WAS ROBBED!!! He was clearly the BEST BY FAR!! I think the vote was ridiculous--Kim is a "hairdresser"--NOT A DESIGNER!!!! She has absolutely NO CREDIBILITY!!! I WILL NEVER WATCH HER SHOW!!!! I thought she "coasted" on the coattails of the other talented designers who actually knew what they were doing; she couldn't begin to do the kitchen projects, and I thought she was TOTALLY RUDE TO ROBB--HE GOT CALLED ON HIS COMMENTS, BUT SHE NEVER DID!!! I think HGTV rigged the vote because the last winner was a "hunky male" and they had to have a female--given the fact she is a minority is a plus for them as well--if that were the case, Will was much more knowledgeable and truly a designer with "credentials!!" Todd was the true "star" of the entire group--he has the most talent, he is the most creative, he had the building "know-how" over and over and over again, and he had the most "charisma" on camera and the very best personality by far--got along with everyone well and he was a TRUE LEADER!!! Kim didn't LEAD ANYONE--she was always a follower--KIM WAS NOT DESERVING OF THE WIN AT ALL, AND HER SHOW WILL BE A TOTAL FLOP!!!! This was a TERRIBLE MISTAKE HGTV!!!!! Your show has lost ALL CREDIBILITY with me!!! WHAT A COMPLETE AND TOTAL DISAPPOINTMENT!!!!

Posted by BKB – September 17, 2007 5:53 AM

Congratulations,Kim----I enjoyed watching and liked your designs a lot better than some of the more formally trained designers. I have been reading some of the other comments---we have to remember---taste is subjective---I , for one, am so tired of brown, brown and more brown I could scream. I do not care for very minimalist design and would love to see someone work soft, pretty colors and 18th century style furniture----knock--offs----not antiques----that the average person can afford and is able to replicate ( i miss "sensible chic")----every one raves about David's show ---and while i voted for him last year---I think the show is so-so---to me it is more of the same---all of the shows are starting to look alike-----As for the other contestants I too (like most of the country)--loved Sparkle Josh and WIll-----hgtv better grab them before someone else does---I also liked Robb----he was tempermental---but many designers are---if you ever watch Trading Spaces--you know those designers (many--not all) are tempermental and many of them design down right ugly rooms with no desire to please the client----I loved trading spaces when it first came on---they really tried to make nice rooms---now I wouldn't let most of them do my linen closet-----at least Rob did try to please the client-----all in all i enjoyed the show this season-----wish there had been more individual jobs---(thought Christina was robbed when the client and not the judges decided that one)--------would like to see them all given the same type of room to do --and no more dollar store designs----if you are hiring a designer --you are not buying at the dollar store------Again--congratulations Kim and i am looking forward to seeing your new show.

Posted by kathleen62 – September 17, 2007 5:51 AM

Way to go Kim!!! What a huge honor to be chosen the best of a cast of awesome designers. Your creative abilities and your inner beauty just shine through in all that you do. Todd's designs were awesome, but in my opinion they were kinda "out there" and not really something the average Joe can try to do in their own home. I'll be watching for Kim's show... she knows how to design for her audience. God bless!

Posted by Donna – September 17, 2007 5:38 AM

America has spoken! Congratulations, Kim! I can't wait to see the direction your new show takes! I hope they have the same type of show they did for David where they showed the process of developing his show.

Posted by Kathy O – September 17, 2007 5:26 AM

This years Design star was disappointing from a lot of stand points. But Kim winning was a joke. My friends and I agree this is one show we won,t be watching. We're sorry we wasted our time watching the show only to have a no talent lazy whiner win.

Posted by Brigid – September 17, 2007 5:08 AM

Yeah Kim Won!! Kim's designs are what I can do and live with everyday. If I wanted to have a really tacky room I would have used Todd. He was too wrapped up in himself and his surfer boy attitude. Most of us don't live at the beach. I can't wait for Kim's show!!! Truly the most talented and realistic won!!! I miss Sparkle Josh too.

Posted by Louise – September 17, 2007 5:01 AM

Congrats to Kim!!! I believe in miracles, too! To me it is so refreshing to see someone without all the "schooling" step up to the plate and hit it out of the park. That's exactly what my "home girl" did. She was/is a STAR in all three aspects HGTV was looking for. I believe that put her over the top. That's why I voted for Kim!!! America made the choice. Let's honor it. Blessings to Kim.

Posted by Kelly (aka SignNWonder) – September 17, 2007 4:58 AM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM! YOU ARE A DESIGN STAR AND WELL DESERVING OF YOUR OWN SHOW. I WILL DEFINITELY WATCH YOUR SHOW. YOU ARE THE BEST! MUCH ALOHA TO YOU AND WE HOPE TO SEE YOU BACK IN HAWAII SOON! BEST WISHES!

Posted by KAWENA – September 17, 2007 4:35 AM

I'm pleased that Kim won, but I do have to say that I hope that Todd can learn to use his colors and ideas while incorporating them into a functional space. New ideas are always wonderful, but shock treatment should be kept in the lab. I think that's why so many people voted for Kim, rather than Todd. It isn't that the majority of Americans are afraid of any color other than white, beige or taupe; usable spaces are what most folks really want to see and then adapt into their own homes.

If anything might have turned off the viewers, it was the combination of "Full Throttle," "DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUDE," and "SWEEEEET!" all the time, mixed with the constant childish behavior (Todd is pushing 40, remember), jumping on the furniture and behaving as if the entire world wanted to see his near-naked body. This is HGTV, and there are so many handsome, hunky, super talented, unbelievably skilled, manly and heterosexual men featured in so many shows on HGTV who do not feel it necessary to go shirtless 24/7. In the Hawaii episode, the reference to his wife as a "hot chick" was pretty tacky and demeaning; that was the point in the series that I decided that Todd would not make a host whom I would enjoy watching.

I can't speak for everyone, of course, but when Todd introduced his "best buddy" before his wife, I knew instantly that the choice of Kim as the next Design Star was correct. If Todd relegates his wife to second-tier status, then I have to agree with so many others that Todd is of the same ilk as Robb, and I would definitely not want either of them in my home. Enthusiasm and self-confidence are important, but placing your spouse below a "bud" is the worst of bad taste.

I'm hoping that Kim's show will be a great reflection of her personality, drawing the viewers into her circle of warmth and being a great addition to the HGTV lineup.

Posted by Tony – September 17, 2007 4:31 AM

So glad that Kim won!! I've just read comments posted after the last challenge and was so gratfied that the majority voiced my thoughts exactly - - that Kim's design and demeanor are far more apealing than Todd's; that Will has great talent and personalty and will hopefully join Kim or other HGTV shows at some time; and that Christina and Josh Sparkle should have gone farther. Also that giving phone texting so many more votes than on-line is unfair and that the show should have new judges next year. Again, congratultions to Kim, I'm looking forward to her show.

Posted by Jolene – September 17, 2007 4:16 AM

Congratulations Kim! I am so happy for you. I was really wanting you to win, and you did. I hope they give you a show that contains average to lower class of people. You did such a great job in West Virginia, I would like to see more of that type of show. A lot of us in our area love to fix up our houses and landscapes, but we are on such a limitied budget, that we can only do what we can with what we have. Your personality is wonderful and we really enjoy watching you. Enjoy your well deserved future, and best of luck to you and your family.

Posted by Maw Bishop – September 17, 2007 4:13 AM

Kim got to the finals in classic American fashion: doing little herself and riding others' coat tails. And she won in classic American fashion: uninformed and uninspired voters. First episode -- totally carried by Scott in the dining space. Second episode -- left everything up to the others in that kitchen; couldn't even buy enough tile. Third episode -- have to give her credit for the coffee table, but that's a craft project, not interior design. Fourth episode -- again, just along for the ride, stripping roses. Fifth episode -- did the shopping for Wayne's kitchen (decorating), but apparently forgot accessories, as the judges noted there were none in the space. Sixth episode -- completely bombed in W.Va but not eliminated. Huh?? Yes, her hotel suite had nice colors, but everything was store bought. Zippo creativity or execution of original ideas. (Oh, wait, she screwed chain to rough pieces of wood. Sorry. My bad.) I will NOT watch her show as I'm not sure she has anything to offer. Smooth host, I'll give her that, but they will have to pair her up with a designer to actually have a design show. I would love to see what Todd could do, especially with outdoor spaces. I guarantee that her show will not be renewed like David's has been.

Posted by Deanne – September 17, 2007 4:02 AM

CONGRATS Kim! I really thought you had improved with the last challenge: You worked the space and the colors...excellent! I am happy for you, and I will be watching your show next spring. I really believe you won because every time the judges said "improve on this" or "improve on that", you did on the next challenge, and on the final challenge, you seem to incorporate all that you had learned since the beginning of the season. Once again, CONGRATS GIRLFRIEND!!!

Posted by Tracee – September 17, 2007 3:18 AM

YEH KIM,,,best final design...Todd would be better suited designing sets for The Price Is Right, not real rooms to live in...wish every one of the contestants had more chances to do individual designs....we saw more of the drama between them than what they could really do.

Posted by Carol Gladney – September 17, 2007 3:12 AM

Congrats Kim! I ran around my office using everone's computer each day so I could vote for you as often as possible! I'm so glad you won. I personally think you showed extreme class and sensitivity in dealing with Rob's boorishness and bullying, and although most people would have been in a snit you remained professional and stayed calm and did your part of the Wayne Newton kitchen in an extremely professional way. And when Todd tried to psych you out by giving you Rob as your partner first, he actually helped you by allowing you to use Rob on the day you went shopping and could just assign Rob to paint (at least he was professional enough not to deliberately sabotage you on that) and you didn't really have to interact with him at all) whereas on the next day when you really needed the moral support you had sweet Will'd design energy and support. I loved how Todd's attempt to be an ass about this ended up helping you -- karma always pays back. And hosting skills -- please, people -- Todd's frenetic jumping around made me feel nervous, NOT what I want to watch. He is a one note (and one color -- blue) wonder. Every design of his is themed like skateboarding or ocean/surfing. Time to grow up, dude. Not everyone wants to live in a skate park. The turntable was completely stupid and if you looked closely was poorly executed with ragged plywood edges in this supposedly elegant design, plus it limited the seating area of this large room to 1/3 of the room or else you would fall off the platform, which was illegally high from a building code point of view. Now Wayne Newton has a big hole in his brand new hardwood floors! Every one of Todd's designs was too hyper, too juvenile, too over the top to be anything but circus like showmanship screaming "look at me".
And his constant jumping around like he was just jumping in on his board, and his constant taking off of his shirt, is reminiscent of Matthew McConaughey -- for pity's sake, get dressed once in a while.

I am very very glad Kim won. I think her designs were always elegant, spiritual, serene, restrained, and classy, as well as very creative and innovative in their use of cheap materials in a unique way. I look forward to her show! Congrats again, Kim!

Posted by Lauren – September 17, 2007 3:09 AM

Thanks to all 11 design stars for a very entertaining season. All are unique with 11 different takes on design. While Todd would be great for designing rock star stages, TV sets, etc. it's good to know that we'll be watching Kim next spring. I love Todd's designs but come on! Who wants a skate board ramp or half a room of broken furniture in their home? Middle-class Americas wants a room that's usable. Congratulations Kim! You're one gracious lady!
Knock our socks, er shirts off next spring.

Posted by charli – September 17, 2007 3:02 AM

Congrats to Kim, and yes, I will watch her show. Best thing about the show tonight was seeing all the designers back together again and hearing them talk about what a great experience it was. The real reason I watched was just to see Sparkle Josh ... dang, I have missed him! He sure did look great. Will and Scott did, too. I wish the best for all the designers, although I wasn't thrilled with this season of Design Star. I hope all this year's contestants are able to turn their national TV exposure into great opportunity for their careers. And for Josh Johnson ... Do you bedazzle? Ohhhhhh yes you DO! (He's the real STAR!)

Posted by Rainey – September 17, 2007 2:57 AM

Congrats, Kim.

You deserved to win. The others were good...but you had the complete package. You did not enter the show "telling everyone" you were the next winner...you had class, love, compassion and grace. You have a kind family too. I think viewers don't like to see the boasting of egos..Todd was so different and did have his own style..he and his wife just told us a little too much. I guess "bragging" would be a good word for it. Viewers aren't real fond of that. He was easy on the eyes and brought some great stunts to the show...but I think we all saw the determination, with confidence and poise...Congrats !!

I agree with SO MANY others....I hope HGTV snatches up Sparkle Josh, Will ( oh what a GREAT man, wonderful designer he is ) and Todd...yes Todd. These three are DEFINITE KEEPERS.

These three people would make super "guest designers" on Kim's new show. Look how Joan Steffand on Decorating Cents has a guest designer do a room on each show.

I just hope we see more of Sparkle Josh and Will....those two would most DEFINITELY add pizzazz to a new HGTV show and you would have a HUGE viewer following, which adds up to RATINGS and a super show for us !!!!!

Oh please don't let Sparkle Josh and Will go....

Posted by Lisa Taylor – September 17, 2007 2:52 AM

Congratulations to Kim! Looking forward to your show. :)
There were so many talented decorators this season. I am one of the many that wish to see more of Sparkling Josh and Will's decorating skills. HGTV, how about giving these two a show of their own!
Lou

Posted by Lou Russell – September 17, 2007 2:50 AM

I just want to say Todd's designs are not just for the young. I'm 55 years old and wanted to him to win because of his innovation and creativity.
Maybe it's because I'm from San Francisco, who knows?

Posted by Aileen – September 17, 2007 2:45 AM

Congratulations Kim!!!!!!!!!! you showed real class when asked how you really felt about Robb. I look forward to your show.

Posted by Alice – September 17, 2007 2:36 AM

Congrats. Kim
All the best to you. I would love to have you come and update our bedroom. I am in love with your sophisticated eye for design. You ROCK. GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY. I will be looking forward to watching your show in the spring.
ginger

Posted by Virginia – September 17, 2007 2:35 AM

There's something about Kim -- She is contagious. Congrats Kim -- I knew you were going to win over Todd.

Todd has a great smile and great 'set' designs, but not what I would want to see on a weekly basis for real people design. Todd to me has the feel of 'What's with that House?' -- which obviously some folks like too since it's still on tv.

I'm looking forward to seeing some New York urban design from Kim and hopefully a show from Will and Sparkle Josh.

Thanks HGTV for bringing something a little more exciting to the plate...I had stopped watching but I'm getting excited again.

Posted by caron – September 17, 2007 2:34 AM

Great Job Kim.... I am so happy for you. You have worked so hard as did all the designers, but you always had that "push on" spirit, even in all that rain and mud!! You exhibited a desire to get along with others and you were always willing to do anything that was required of you. I believe that this is part of what it will take to have your own show. I think people will want to work hard for you like you have been there for others. All the folks on a show (or in a business ) take the enthusiasm and the attitudes from the lead person. You will set the pace and the flavor of your new show and it will be great because of your personality and enthusiasm. Your final chalenge turned out fantastic. I would love to spend my vacation in your room!!!! Your willingness to listen to the judges showed that you are open to help, and have a humble spirit, able to learn from others, another great trait. I wish you all the best. Most of all I want to point you to your creator God who gave you your talents and skills. He deserves all the praise and glory as HE made you who you are. It wasen't till age 35 in my own life, that I discovered this fact and I have been blessed ever since in my own design carreer. Looking forward with anticipation to see you on your new show. God Bless You. Karen

Posted by Karen – September 17, 2007 2:30 AM

Congrats to Kim!!! I'm sure HGTV will construct an appropriate show that will make the most of your talents and your warm personality.

Todd's a nice guy, but gosh if he bounced like a puppy or talked about taking off his shirt one more time - !

And yes I too would like to see a show with Sparkle Josh and Will together......

By the looks of it Todd will never 'get' how annoying and abusive he was. Scorpios have stingers and he certainly used his. Too bad. I plan to forget him.

Posted by WendyE – September 17, 2007 2:30 AM

I caught the rerun of the final show after work this evening. I enjoyed seeing the other contestants and hearing from each of them. I just know that Sparkle Josh has a future in television waiting for him - such charisma!! He is great looking and seems to touch everyone with his wonderful sense of humor. He and Will both seem to be the kind of men you could imagine having as a great friend. ( Quite an asset if you are coming into someone's home every week on TV). Will is a real sweetheart. I am sure Kim's show will do fine and develop a following. Without the hindrence of competition it will be interesting to see how she does and in what format they present her.

Posted by Kathy – September 17, 2007 2:29 AM

I enjoyed tonight's show with all of the contestants back together again. The joking and kidding around among everyone was fun. Clyde is a great host. He is so funny and I love his personality and I watch everything that he hosts. I liked Becca's suggestion for Kim's new show "Myles of Style". I think Kim will do a great job and to the people who say they won't watch the show -- GIVE THE GIRL A BREAK!!! She may surprise you.

Posted by Lynda – September 17, 2007 2:29 AM

KIM Congradulations!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You have such a sophistacated eye. You are the best. I wish you could come and update/fix my bedroom. I love your design style. I would be honored to have you in my home. I am so glad that your were able to "take it all the way". Keep up the good work. I can't wait to see your show. I will be watching. GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY.
Ginger

Posted by Virginia – September 17, 2007 2:28 AM

I'm so disappointed that Todd isn't the next design star. He obviously has great talent. Even though I may not have agreed with his interpretations at all times, I would be waiting with anticipation what his next design would be. He is just a great, creative, out-of-the-box designer.
And Kim? I'm at a loss, actually. She's okay, but not in the same league as Todd. I guess most of America doesn't know what real talent is. So, we get a ho hum, run of the mill, show. Yawn.....

Posted by Aileen – September 17, 2007 2:28 AM

Congratulations Kim. I voted for you and am delighted that you won. If you want to do my double parlor rooms in SF I would love it.

Elizabeth

Posted by meholmes – September 17, 2007 2:25 AM

I enjoyed Kim's performance as a host throughout the season. Kim always explained her placement of mirrors, art, color, furniture, rugs, etc. She told the viewers why she designed each project the way she did. I appreciated her approach and I believe she has alot to offer.

What I really enjoyed about the show is seeing how different individuals approached the same task. Each had their own personality and was unafraid to let it shine through. All contestants should be applauded for their efforts.

I am saddened that people have chosen to use this forum to make political statements (education system + design tv is connected how?), insinuate racism (I did not know anyone consider race as a credential for a designer), or claim misdeeds and favoritism by media outlets (viewers chose the winner not HGTV).

It's a TV show - get over it.

Posted by Liz – September 17, 2007 2:23 AM

Was there every really any doubt who would w!!! I was so happy to see Will get a $500in between the two??? Of course not!!! Congratulations Kim0 gift card!!! He so deserved it!!! I think HGTV heard our cries about how unhappy we were and rewarded him for being such a great team player!!! To me...he had the best heart of all the bunch! What a humble person he was...and still is... I am also happy that the judges acknowledge Christina's talent and still feel they should have never let a novice eliminate her. But it was still nice to know they liked her work. I am also glad to see that Lisa received something for being the first one eliminated by her peers. The finale righted some of the wrongs and I'm glad it ended on a positive note! Again...congratulations Kim!!!

Posted by Teresa – September 17, 2007 2:18 AM

Okay, where are the numbers on this vote? Kim, you seem like a sweetheart and a gal who can clearly execute good design, but where's the wow factor? Todd, WOW! Crazy blue waves to spinning living rooms and jelly fish, who wouldn't want to escape to one of these spaces? Either way, both of you will move on to do great things, I'm just disappointed to see another predictable ending chosen by the benign masses of conservative America. Good luck you two, Todd you ROCK superstar! You still have my vote!!!

Posted by Cherie – September 17, 2007 2:11 AM

Still not my favorite. The best designer was Will and the best TV personality seemed to have been one of the ones in the front of the contest. Next time use a combination of two voting systems so the judges don't get it so wrong. Public vote and judges vote on each challenge. I am sure Sears and other sponsers would rather have return viewers and feel a part of the decision than this situation. Will would have had a better chance if the public had had a say.
Kim's talent was always her on air skills. Look back at the design efforts. Awful..
ann

Posted by ann ferguson – September 17, 2007 2:05 AM

todd, you are a rock star, you got robbed. Also, Robb-you had some great designs. Sparkle Josh will get his own show on the red carpet or something.

Posted by mg – September 17, 2007 2:01 AM

Big, Huge disappointment! Todd is the man, not her!
Kim is NOT a designer, she's a decorator, and as such, quite boring and predictable. Same colors (browns), same safe looks, just bo-ring. If that's her style, her show will definitively be cancelled, but for real. Zero ratings, for sure.
And, as she said: "The hairdresser that could!" That could what? I ask.
Total disappointment.

Posted by cristina – September 17, 2007 2:00 AM

Congratulations Kim - Great Going, Great Designer and hooray for you. I not only voted on line for you, I text messaged too because I thought you were the BEST. Only thing I can say is I think everyone thought Todd was going to
win and I think he did too but guess what AMERICA VOTED AND KIM WON - YEAH.

Posted by Karen – September 17, 2007 2:00 AM

I love the show, but very disappionted. I personnely think it was fixed. To have two male designers in a row win the show most likely would not be allowed. The episode of Kim giving the log cabin feeling for much needed family was horible. Todd was a much better designer with much more creativety. If a female would of won last year, we would of seen a differrent outcome. Shame on you HGTV!!! Two buff guys winning in a row! ha

Posted by MEM – September 17, 2007 2:00 AM

First, CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!! My family and I didn't expect any less, and my daughter is already drawing pictures of you doing your show, hehe! We're all currently celebrating your victory with ice cream! ^_^ Can't wait until the spring to see your show!

Second, I'm pretty ticked off about how unreasonable some people are being about Kim's victory. To say that they only gave her the title because she is a black woman is both an ignorant and unfair statement. In case people have forgotten, AMERICA voted for her. Kim got the most votes and she is obviously what most of America wants. All of those who are bitter about Todd losing don't want to comprehend this for some reason. I also don't agree that Todd is a better designer. At least Kim can come up with ideas other than a surfer dude/skater theme! Kim is also better when it comes to giving rooms functionality, something I think Todd seriously lacks. And to the guy who said Kim treated Robb badly...did we watch the same show? ROBB was the one who constantly treated everyone else like they were below him.

For everyone crying that they won't watch Kim's show, I'm sure you won't be missed. As far as I can see, Kim will have plenty of viewers and I personally cannot wait for her show. I'm sure she'll prove all the naysayers wrong.

Posted by Joanna S. – September 17, 2007 1:50 AM

Kim received the votes from America. She won because she was classy and has a natural talent to design. Yes Todd has talent and may have had some great and interesting designs but were any of them practical for the average American Home? I would much prefer to watch Kim host a show and teach me more about design than to watch a acrobat bounce around the room. Kim I rooted for you the whole season long.

Posted by Larry – September 17, 2007 1:46 AM

Congrats, Kim!!! I will anxiously await your show. I know you will be successful. To Lee--who is the "they" that gave the show to Kim??? We "the People" voted -- the same people who cast ballots for American Idol, Dancing with the Stars, and the President of the United States.

Posted by cheryl – September 17, 2007 1:46 AM

Congradulations Kim, I voted the maximum amount of times for you. I love your classy style.
Linda, Phoenix, AZ

Posted by Linda – September 17, 2007 1:44 AM

This was my first time watching a show on HGTV ever. I stumbled upon the first show of the second season of Design Star and was immediately drawn in by the cast, especially Todd. He brought a sense of fresh energy that was innovative and new. He was truly fun to watch. The fact that my husband actually even sat and watched the show with me says more than you would even know. We both looked forward to what he would do in each challenge.

Watching the season finale tonight, it was apparent that this was not a "competition" of skill in design, but something more of popularity contest. What a shame.

Without Todd, I'm afraid there's no real draw for us to watch going forward. It seems most of the shows look like cookie-cutter replicas. We want something new. Todd offered that and I could only imagine if he had his own format what more we could learn from his creativity, craftsmanship and boundary-less design approach.

I congratulate Kim for the win, but unfortunatly it won't convert me as a HGTV viewer going forward.

Tell me Todd will have his own show and you'll have two engaged "superfans" enjoying an evening in front of the TV.

Posted by Carli – September 17, 2007 1:42 AM

I am so delighted and happy that Kim is the next Design Star. She demonstrated each week the ability to not only work well with the other designers. but to share responsibility, work hard, share ideas, be creative and stay grounded.
She wasn't afraid to ask others for help if needed and her warmth continued to show through. I can't wait to see her show in the Spring.
Congratulations Kim! I think HGTV is very lucky to have you as their new "Design Star".

Posted by Maxine – September 17, 2007 1:36 AM

I thought it was offensive how Todd made fun of us--the viewers and fans--when he "pretended" to take his shirt off twice, sarcastically, in this final episode. He was obviously doing this because of all the negative comments about his lack of clothing. Very uncool!

Posted by egrajeda – September 17, 2007 1:30 AM

How very disappointing. But I imagine that the HGTV execs are happy. Bet they "fixed" the vote... I seriously can't believe that America voted for Kim... She's so boring...

Posted by Samantha – September 17, 2007 1:30 AM

Congratulation on your win Kim. I am very happy for you. You and Will were the better designers. I was surprise that Todd was in the final 2. He doesn't design. He is a carpenter. I hated the first blue room and hated his final one. His designs only looked good when other designers dressed the room. He should design for children. Ignore the haters Kim, they have a one track mind like Todd. Todd didn't think out of the box. He is locked in a box of blue and this time he drowned in it. The one time he did not do blue, he killed the space with red and did not tone it down with any other color. It was tacky. Now haters get off Kim's back. She was great. I will be watching her show. Todd you do have a beautiful face.

Posted by Hayriv – September 17, 2007 1:30 AM

I am so glad Kim won!!!!!

Congratulations girl!!!!

Posted by SageRave – September 17, 2007 1:26 AM

Somehow I can't believe that America voted for Kim! However, I'm sure that the HGTV execs are pleased by the selection. I wonder if they "fixed" the vote...

Posted by Michele Buttelman – September 17, 2007 1:26 AM

Kim congratulations!!! HGTV, thanks for a wonderful show!!! I even got my husband to watch with me tonight.

HGTV, it would be great to see more of the contestants' designs before the elimination process starts. Also it would make for more interest if you could alternate the individual and group designs each week. The contestants abilities and personalities were so diverse that I hate we didn't see more of some of them before they were eliminated.
For those bloggers who are still complaining--Formal training does not mean a person is a good/great designer. David was not formally trained (he was an artist) and look at the terrific job he does now! He has a natural gift as does Kim. I'm certain that HGTV will place Kim in a show that will highlight her talents, just as they have done with David. Not to watch Kim's show is your loss.
It's time to move on folks and remember that HGTV didn't make Kim the winner, America did with our votes.

Posted by msmultit – September 17, 2007 1:25 AM

congratulations Kim, you deserve your own show can't wait to watch!

Please HGTV give Sparkle Josh and Will a show together.

Loyal HGTV watcher

Posted by sammy – September 17, 2007 1:24 AM

I liked Kim as a person--she has a great personality and did the best job of hosting. But I watch hgtv for design ideas. Kim's ideas were nothing to rave about. I definitely will not watch any of her show.

while Todd missed on his last challenge,his ability to think entirely out of the box, namely the 99 cent challenge and the revolving living room, make him an exciting designer. He is the kind of designer who makes new trends, not follows them. I believe America will miss his creative intensity.

Posted by wes – September 17, 2007 1:24 AM

Congratulations Kim. I voted for you and so glad that you won. I will be watching your show and hope to see it soon .

Posted by Shawnna – September 17, 2007 1:22 AM

Congrats Kim I knew you would win. You definately have what it takes. I can't wait until spring gets here. Good luck and I'll be watching you.

Posted by Charlitta Luke – September 17, 2007 1:19 AM

I am so happy Kim won, her future designs will be timeless. I am sorry to say but Todd's designs would drive you nuts and you would want to change them in a year.

Congratulations Kim, glad that I got the opportunity to make my vote count.

Posted by sasha – September 17, 2007 1:18 AM

OMG!!! Kim congrats! I can't wait to see your show. You had my vote!
And I would like to say thanks to the designers! They all made the show so wonderful and fun to watch!

Posted by SG Girl – September 17, 2007 1:17 AM

Happy for knowing them all and enjoying every personality; that was the best of the show! It had a human part that made it unique and unforgettable!

HEY, THANKS FOR THIS GREAT BLOG, IT'S BEEN AWESOME!

My comment about the winner? Happy for Kim of course, but my vote still goes for Todd! 'cause I might not be too young but I still believe in creativity and innovative designs!

Disagree with who ever said that dearest Will "has great presence on screen"; no, sorry, that's what he lacks the most, but he has abundant sweet lovely personality to fill that "fault"!!
Hope to see them all again, even the "hated" Rob end up stealing our hearts! God bless them!
Oh, and almost forgot to comment: so nice those gifts for Will and Lisa, wow, wonderful, meaningful detail!
See you when the next competition starts, I'm going to fry my fish!
MariaJ.

Posted by MariaJ. – September 17, 2007 1:09 AM

i agree Kim was unnecessarily rude and mean towards Robb tonight, afterall he did help her out in the final challenge. i am disappointed that this is who america's next design star is.

Posted by chocho – September 17, 2007 1:09 AM

Some idiot said Kim won because she's black. Well, she's "half" black. Get it straight. She won because she sprinted to the front and left Todd to eat her dust. Only design color was involved.

Posted by Ms. DeeDee – September 17, 2007 1:09 AM

KIM,
Congrats Kim!!

I voted for Kim because I felt I could watch a show hosted by her, more than a show hosted by Todd.

Kim will do a good job. Kim is living proof that if you want something bad enough, and you focus and put your mind, heart, and soul into it, that you CAN GET IT!!!!

I still feel THE REAL design star is Will.

I am glad Will won a prize! He earned it!

I think HGTV gave Will a prize because they know in their hearts that they messed up, and that he should have been in the final two.

Now that Kim won, I know for sure that if Will would have been in the final two, that he would have won tonight!

America would have voted for Will over both Kim and Todd! HGTV knows this too; that is why they gave him the $5,000.00.

They didn't give it to him for being a nice guy; they gave it to him because they know they robbed him of a contract that he deffinately would have won through America's votes.

WILL,
I hope they give you your own show, or one with you and Sparkle Josh together! Everyone would tune in to see that!

Iwatkins,
Thanks so much for having this blog! It was great to be able to vent about my disagreements, laugh about funny happenings, praise fantastic work and designers, and hear what other people felt about the shows too.

I hope that you have this blog again for desin star three!

Posted by alicia – September 17, 2007 1:03 AM

I'm sure that Kim is very happy to have won and I wish her good luck. I could not bring myself to vote for either finalist. I feel that Will should have definitely been in the final two. If there was any question in the judges' minds, this finale should settle all doubts. Will was quite
handsome, well-spoken, and was the favorite of the "design stars", themselves. The viewers could see Will's popularity, along with his great
design style. I'm happy that he was given a check, but I think that Will will be given his own show. America just loves will; a great designer and an incredible human being.

Posted by Eddie – September 17, 2007 1:01 AM

Congratulations to Kim. My 94 year old great aunt and I was so excited when Clive called out her name. Kim is "every woman." I think that is why most everyone voted for her. She represents all of us. Small town, uptown, hair dresser, store clerk, secretary, CEO. She represents us all with style, grace, and a very sweet smile. I can't wait for next springs show. Why don't you get Kim and David together to do a special, like at Christmas. WOW! Thanks HGTV for another fun Design Star.

Posted by Lynn – September 17, 2007 1:01 AM

thought the whole series was wonderful- I looked forward to it every Sunday- all were good in there own way and own style, but i thought Kim was the whole package, designing, personalty, and
being able to be a hostess that was easy to understand and had a wonderful happy delivery, that made you want to watch. Todd was a little california for me, since I am in Ohio- everyone isn't a surfer, but he had interesting ideas.
way to go Kim I cheered when you won.we will be waiting------

Posted by judy gibson – September 17, 2007 12:59 AM

For all you anti-Kim people out there......Todd was lucky he lasted as long as he did. He should never have made it past the first episode - a skateboard ramp in the living room??? I could maybe understand if all 11 of the contestants were skateboarders, but that wasn't the case. How does building a skateboard ramp for overgrown teenagers qualify as design?

Posted by dmz – September 17, 2007 12:57 AM

i have been rooting for kim since the beginning of the program. she is so fresh and original. todd is also awesome -- it really WAS a difficult choice as to whom should be the next design star, but for me, kim has always been the one i have rooted for since the first episode. she is such a gracious lady.

Posted by Annie – September 17, 2007 12:56 AM

Congratulations, Kim. I thought this year was better than last. There were so many people with both personality and talent. Will, Sparkle, Kim, Scott... anyone of them would have made a good design star.

Posted by Chris – September 17, 2007 12:55 AM

Happy for knowing them all and enjoying every personality; that was the best of the show! It had a human part that made it unique and unforgettable!

HEY, THANKS FOR THIS GREAT BLOG, IT'S BEEN AWESOME!

My comment about the winner? Happy for Kim of course, but my vote still goes for Todd! 'cause I might not be too young but I still believe in creativity and innovative designs!

Disagree with who ever said that dearest Will "has great presence on screen"; no, sorry, that's what he lacks the most, but he has abundant sweet lovely personality to fill that "fault"!!
Hope to see them all again, even the "hated" Rob end up stealing our hearts! God bless them!
Oh, and almost forgot to comment: so nice those gifts for Will and Lisa, wow, wonderful, meaningful detail!
See you when the next competition starts, I'm going to fry my fish!
MariaJ.

Posted by MariaJ. – September 17, 2007 12:51 AM

As a white Southern grandmother, I am offended by the remark that Kim won because she is female and black!
It's true that Todd is a hunk, but almost every design he did (though "outside the box") was very impractical for the average home. He would be great as a set designer for movies or the theatre, or as a landscape architect, but homes for real people? I think not.
Kim may not have a lot of formal training, but she has an innate sense of beauty, and knows how to listen to clients and please them. She will do well.

Posted by Sara – September 17, 2007 12:48 AM

What a disgrace Kim had zero design talent I would never watch her show .I really think HGTV WERE LOOKING FOR A NEW HOST and they got one.BYE BYE Clive your out.

Posted by kaos3599 – September 17, 2007 12:33 AM

Congratulation KIM ,, VOTED FOR YOU , IAM so sorry I miss the show, the only ONE I MISS. I WILL BE WATCHING FOR A RERUN OF THE SHOW . WILL BE WATCHING FOR YOUR SHOW ON HGTV. POSTED BY GLORIA CONNELL SEPTEMBER 16,2007 11;00 PM

Posted by Gloria Connell – September 17, 2007 12:32 AM

Great finale! I loved all the clips, catch phrases, bloopers! What I enjoyed the most was the chance to see more of Sparkle Josh. I hope HGTV snaps him up and gives him his own show, or some other network will...and I'll watch it, too!

Congrats to Kim!

Posted by Cheri – September 17, 2007 12:31 AM

What a disappointment. Todd was obviously the most talented and creative designer. Even worse, is the fact of how rude and lack of class Kim behaved toward Robb on national television. Someone like that does not deserve to win. America's loss.

Posted by Brian – September 17, 2007 12:29 AM

Come on America - what were you thinking. Todd was the better of the two finalists. I really thought that Todd would win - his vitality really came through on TV. Kim seemed a little too forced. I can't imagine what kind of show they will give Kim - I didn't think she was a very good designer. She was creative but not a designer.

Posted by Maddy – September 17, 2007 12:28 AM

Congratulations to Kim! I really think her show will be great! Was she always my first choice? No, I have to admit. But, she learned and she grew as the season went on. When it came down to the final two, there was no other choice. I flat-out did not like Todd's designs. They may be creative, but they aren't practical. And they're all too blue. (This coming from someone who loves blue!)

As for those wondering if HGTV personnel read this blog? I'd have to say "yes, they do". Look at how many references were made on the final show tonight about Todd's shirtlessness. David even quipped something about "look, we both have shirts on" or something to that effect.

If no one from HGTV was reading the blog or maybe emails to the web site, no one would have mentioned the lack of clothing between the neck and the waist. :-)

I'll miss Will and Sparkle Josh. Wish them- and the other contestants- all the best in the future.

Next season it would be fun to see the first challenge be one with no one eliminated so we could get at least a little better feel for their design skills (or lack of) before one gets sent home. Just a thought.

Anyway, congrats again to Kim, the new Design Star!

Posted by Jade – September 17, 2007 12:28 AM

What a major disappointment. Todd was without question the most talented designer. However, the biggest disappointment was seeing how rudely Kim acted toward Robb. Someone who continues do display such bitterness and lack of class to other contestants simply did not deserve to win. America's loss.

Posted by Brian – September 17, 2007 12:24 AM

I thought Todd had the best on air personality. I love HGTV, but I doubt I will watch Kim's show. Give Todd, Sparkle Josh, or Will a show too! I think Kim did a good job on the last show, but skated by all the other weeks. I think America got this one wrong, but I guess we will see how her show does.

Posted by Debbie Ellis – September 17, 2007 12:15 AM

I love Design Star. It is one of my favorite shows on HGTV. I think Kim will do wonderful things. I picked her. I cannot wait to see her show.
I also never miss Color Splash with David. He was my pick from the first season and he has certainly proven he is a top designer! Thank you for a wonderful show!!!

Posted by Lynn Moss – September 17, 2007 12:11 AM

First,Dmhannah, You were quite accurate in your description.
I am tired of seeing the same old modern designs favored by so many. In the beginning of the series they distinctly verbalized their desire to have an all-around host that had carpentry skills in addition to hosting skills.
Todd was able to execute the designs as well as create them. It would have been great to see what he would come up with next; indoors and OUTDOORS with his landscaping design experience. I would rather have seen Sparkle,Christina or todd as designers. While I congratulate Kim on her victory, I won't be watching her.

Posted by fleursauvage – September 17, 2007 12:11 AM

I'm very disappointed the surprise was spoiled. The show is just now starting in my home town. At least do a "spoiler alert".

I'm glad, however, Kim won - I think Todd was too wrapped up in himself and I would never have watched a show with him as host.

Posted by juliet – September 17, 2007 12:09 AM

Kim you are truley blessed. I saw your potential and kind heart,the moment I tuned in. You never had a negative remarks about anyone you worked with. Your energy showed through. I read how some feel Martha and Diana. Sign up and see what you got. Don't hate on the girl. She was good. Love you Kim,show them what you got. I got ch back.

Posted by Patricia – September 17, 2007 12:06 AM

Congrats, Kim. I would love to see HGTV develop a show for you where you would be paired each week with one of the other 10 Design Stars. Each DS could bring their own special "flare" and combine it with your lovely ideas. I would especially enjoy a show with you and Will. Again - congrats!!

Posted by Marilyn – September 17, 2007 12:00 AM

Kim, congratulations on your win! You really deserve it! I especially enjoyed the working chemistry between you and Will together! HGTV needs to give Will a show this coming season also, or needs to include him on Kim's show as a co-designer FOR SURE. HGTV has GOT to find a place for Will!!!!

As for Todd, he is creative, but is not an interior designer for homes. At this point, he is an artist, but needs more training to shape his work to be suitable for living spaces. As for his presence on the show, if he took his shirt off one more time, said "Dude" or "Sweet" or anymore surfer talk one more time, I was going to shoot the TV (and actually, what's up with the surfer talk? He's from Northern California, not Southern, so what's he doing with the surfer lingo? I've lived both places: Born in S. California, live in San Fran now -- and people don't do the surfer talk in N. California. So fake of him).

What's important is that Kim won! But HGTV, LISTEN: Give Will a show or include him in Kim's show! People love him and he's a great designer, and really has a great presence on screen!

Julie
Loyal HGTV Watcher For Years and YEARS

Posted by Julie – September 16, 2007 11:56 PM

While I'm really happy to learn Kim is the winner, I'm really disappointed to have the surprise spoiled. The show won't air out here for another hour.....

Posted by Michele Inman – September 16, 2007 11:51 PM

I'm so disappointed that Kim won. I don't have anything against her per se, I just preferred Todd. I'm sorry you didn't win Todd, I think you are the better designer. I hope your future will be bright and happy. I won't be watching Kim's show. Life is too short.

Posted by lexie – September 16, 2007 11:51 PM

If HGTV is really reading these posts, Will and Josh J will have, at least, a special of their own. I'd love to see them design for the physically-challenged. It would be a great show.

WTG Kim!

Posted by poohloveshoney – September 16, 2007 11:49 PM

I voted for kim, because, shes real good designer, I enjoy her work, Ill have her design my house.

Posted by Rhonda – September 16, 2007 11:49 PM

Congratulations Kim. It has been so nice to see someone that is polite and so charming. I look forward to watching your show. HGTV is my favorite channel. I've enjoyed watching Color Splash with David and I know yours will be great too. God bless you and stay just like you are

Posted by Melissa – September 16, 2007 11:47 PM

Lena don't get angry at Lee for telling the truth. It is so obvious she was picked for being black and not for being talented. She does not even know how to pick a dress that will disguise her stomach. A designer knows how to dress herself first and a room second. She obviously does not know how to do either. I wonder if the score was calculated correctly because there are so many people who agree with Lee and think Todd should have been the winner.

Posted by martha – September 16, 2007 11:45 PM

Didn't even vote this time because I was so confused-- Kim was great at hosting but not very innovative with her designs.
Todd was clearly fun to watch and is truly an innovative designer but the last challenge he fell short and Kim came through with a great design. He just needs a little training in front of the camera which would be easier to teach than trying to teach Kim to come up with creative and fresh design ideas.
Also, If HGTV lets him get away with out plugging him into his own show somewhere they will clearly be the fools of the century--Todd has a unique design perspective that would be a lot of fun to watch! Not to mention that he already looks like a movie star!

Posted by tina – September 16, 2007 11:45 PM

So disappointed in this year's series. Kim seems ok, but her work was always seriously uninspired and I completely agree that she just stayed under the radar. When Robb was eliminated, it appeared that all of the design came from him (although she did the shopping), but she got him eliminated by complaining about him. When Will was eliminated, his work was very good and hers was extremely poor, so I guess her smoothness on camera got her through? Her last effort was barely ok, but the judges gave her rave reviews (and credited her with removing the carpet even though they had to tell her it need doing and even then Will had to come up with the solution for her). Her smooth ability on camera is fine, but she could use that to be a weather person or something - has nothing to do with design. I learned nothing from watching her, see nothing to cause me to believe that she has anything to teach that I couldn't get out of a magazine, and won't bother to watch when her show comes out. Todd is attractive and interesting, and his work was sometimes very inspired, although his last effort was quite weak. They could have worked with him and made something interesting to watch. I would have checked out his show to see if they used him properly or just tried to make another cookie cutter out of him. Sparkle Josh has an interesting and likable personality and would have been fun to watch. Will seems like a genuinely good person and it would have been good to watch him help people. I would have checked out their shows and watched if the shows were good. But overall, the season was a great disappointment. I watch HGTV a lot, and have done so for years, but am becoming more and more bored as time goes by, due to the lack of creativity. I looked at Vern Yip's new show and find his work pretty good, but extremely predictable, so I shouldn't be surprised that he raves about work that is no more than a poor imitation of his own style. I was very pleased with David's victory last year, but would have found a victory by Alice to be like Kim's victory this year - some decorating ability, good camera ability, nothing to teach design-wise, totally unacceptable. This year, I would have accepted a win by Todd, Will, Robb, or Josh Sparkle as legitimate, although none of them has the talent that David has, but the judges did not permit voters to have a choice actually based on design ability. If the judges continue to make such bad decisions in the future, HGTV will lose all credibility.

Posted by sodisappointed – September 16, 2007 11:41 PM

Congrats Kim !! BUT, we need to give TODD a show!!!!

Posted by Maria – September 16, 2007 11:40 PM

Congratulations Kim, you are the answer to the america's designing dreams. Kim, has the compassion and understanding to know what the average person wants in decorating. I am looking forward to the show. God Bless you,Kim Judy

Posted by judy jackson – September 16, 2007 11:38 PM

Hey Kim,

I am so happy you won. I scared the dog with my big Whoop when your name was announced. Good Luck in all that you do and never lose that smile.

An ex-Queen's girl from Astoria.

Posted by Rosie – September 16, 2007 11:38 PM

Hey, I am personally so disappointed. I knew that Kim would win, and was even trying to prepare myself for it. But when they said her name, the true unfairness of it all came through to me. Todd is original, fun, and more creative than anyone I've ever seen on HGTV. SO I knew he wouldnt win. I dont think most people want someone who pushes the envelope and challenges their ideas and preconceptions of what design should be. Todd would have done both of those things with a flair that by far makes up for his lack of hosting skills. To use his terminology, I'm bummed. We have enough safe shows with boring, modern design. I'm someone who likes pretty design, and since no one does that any more, I'll take interesting and imaginative any day. Todd, I doubt you're reading this, because you strike me as someone who has better things to do and bigger fish to fry, but I think you are awesome, and I think you were robbed. Good luck in all you do.
Diana

Posted by Diana – September 16, 2007 11:35 PM

WWWWWWWWOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHOOOOOOOOOOOO! KIM say hi to sparkle Josh 4 me ok!! Love all you guys so much!! Way to handle Robb You go girl!! Sana Barbra!Ya Know what I'm saying!!

Posted by The Next Sparkle Laura – September 16, 2007 11:33 PM

OOPS! Sorry, Candice! My bad---it's "Olson", not "Olsen".

Peace and Love.

Posted by TeacherLisa – September 16, 2007 11:31 PM

HGTV staff, if you don't use Todd on a show, you are really missing out, his creativity is awesome to young people.

Posted by Jeanne – September 16, 2007 11:30 PM

This episode was so fun to watch. Not only did Kim win - HURRAH - but the clips we watched were great.

I noticed Martha did no drooling - well not that I could see from one run through on my DVR.

Vern has really loosened up. I absolutely loved the clip of him jumping on the bed. I also like his new show "Deserving Design". I wish I deserved design since my disabilities make it truly difficult to afford any designing and prevent me from doing my own. Oh well.

Cynthia is funnier than I had thought. Seeing her crack up like that, as to what Martha said, had me laughing so hard tears came to my eyes.

I just have to say something about Clive. I adore his wit AND his accent. He’s a stunning dresser, too. Are you taken Clive?

It was great seeing every one of the 11 together again. I don’t think I really remember Organic Josh saying anything. Guess I’ll have to watch it again to see what I may have missed first time around.

I still would really love to see Will and Sparkle Josh get a show together. Don’t know if HGTV can right away, as that wouldn’t be fair. I expect that HGTV will have stuff from Todd on the website as they did for Alice. To see each of them guest-star on Color Splash with David Bromstad would also be terrific. At least Will, Sparkle Josh, Todd and even Robb. I fell a bit guilty for bashing Robb. He did kinda asked for it, though. He’d make a temperamental host of his own show, but in the final challenge in Hawaii, he did show he could follow orders better and is able to work hard. He also acted like a real human being on the last episode. He took all cuts with a smile and some class. Keep that up, Robb, and maybe one day things will go better for you.

To be honest, a show with Todd would be great fun to watch. It just probably wouldn’t have “usable” design for the average person. I am happy, though, that Kim won. It’s the “all American dream”. She ended up winning even though she had no formal training. I do hope, now, that they create the right show for her and she ends up going strong on HGTV for many years to come.

This is a long post but, sadly, it’ll be the last here as the season is now over. Now we have to wait through a miserable cold winter before Season 3 and Kim’s new show. I sure wish they’d do this show throughout the winter to help us get through it.

I would love to see a forum or blog start up that starred one or more of the other 10 contestants. Participating in that would be fun.

Posted by Toni – September 16, 2007 11:30 PM

Thanks for a great season of Design Star! Love 'em or hate 'em -- the controversy, talent, variety and personalities made it an interesting and fun show to watch. Loved the finale tonight -- it was heartwarming and funny, and made me sorry to see it all ending. Congratulations to Kim, and best wishes to Todd and all the others, too. You all will do just fine! Looking forward to Kim's show, and wishing we could see more of Will, Christina, Todd and Sparkle somwehow, someday, too.

Posted by grandmapumpkin – September 16, 2007 11:29 PM

Congratulation, Kim! You deserved to win--you have had incredible talent and drive throughout the challenges as well as grace under pressure--certainly the mark of a true lady. You must have a fantastic family to have loved and supported you through all this--you are truly a "Design Star" and I can't wait to see you on your own show. You're right-miracles do happen. Best wishes for your new future. You are one class act all the way!

Posted by denverslady – September 16, 2007 11:28 PM

Congratulations Kim! I enjoy your genuine warmth and personality, you deserved to win very much and you inspire everyone to follow dreams and give people confidence in designing. To HGTV I would love to see Will on Kim's show, he to had a genuine personality and great design skills but was just a little too nervous hosting but was great at being himself on camera. PlEASE consider him for Kim's show or another show.

Posted by maudesmama – September 16, 2007 11:24 PM

Best Wishes for a wonderful show in the spring KIM. I remember how long it felt, waiting for David's first Color Splash. It is going to be a long Fall and Winter wait but will be worth it I am sure. Celebrate and enjoy. Your family looked so happy for you. America is happy for you too. I enjoyed all the Design Star Shows. It was fun. Thank you.

Posted by Elaine – September 16, 2007 11:23 PM

I'm glad Kim won. But what will the HGTV execs offer her as her show? So HGTV if you are reading this, my vote would be on TEXTURE. And the cool thing would be her hiding out in a homedepot store, etc and surprise an unsuspecting person who is buying paint or tile and offer to do a textured feature to bring together or add to their do-it-yourself design. Or the selection of who & whose space could come from viewers writing in. Hope you guys read this, HGTV!!!!!

Posted by Cindy – September 16, 2007 11:23 PM

Kim - Congratulations! And, it was so great to see everyone again tonight! Love & Blessings to all of you!

Posted by Ilene – September 16, 2007 11:22 PM

Congrats to Kim. You deserve it and I wish you the very best. So happy that Will got a gift card from Discover. Did you all notice the huge, sparkle letters to spell out Sparkle Josh's name? It is interesting that Will and Sparkle both were recoginized tonight. . . a lot more than the others. I would like to think that HGTV heard our cries over Will and Sparkle Josh. Next year, no more double eliminations, more individual challenges, and do NOT let outsiders like the bride and groom determine who will leave the show. Obviously the judges really liked Christina and were shocked when she was kicked off by the wedding couple. Only the real judges should have the authority to eliminate someone. Well. . . all in all it was a GREAT season. I must say that I never missed a show and I would not even answer the phone when it was on. Thank you HGTV for a great season of Design Star. I enjoyed every minute. Sparkle Josh and Will, you were my favorites. I hope that I see you both again. The best to both of you. Kathy

Posted by kathy – September 16, 2007 11:18 PM

I screamed when it was announced-I was SO happy for Kim! I was SO bummed last year when David won over alice but this year I picked it right! I dont take my vitamns everyday, but did I vote everday and text everday for Kim to win...YES!!!
So great job, you are going to be great on TV and I will watch your show. My heart was pounding out of my chest waiting for clive to announce it that last 2 minutes...like I was being called for an exam or something! I really got into this! HGTV also did a great job for this whole final hour-it was so funny and I love that you exposed rob...poor guy-he is still in denial that he doesnt play well with others. Well that was a great hour- Congrats to Kim-you deserved it---Best wishes to both. Todd is a great artist but way too out there for my taste. A seemingly Great person though.

Posted by Kim C – September 16, 2007 11:18 PM

I was hoping Kim would win. She has so much talent, but no background in design. She will be able to reach the viewers who also have no background in design. I can't wait for her show this spring! Congrads!

Posted by James Greenwell – September 16, 2007 11:13 PM

For all those people who are still bashing Kim, the west virgina people WANTED carpet; that was the darkest beige she could find in the area, any dark color would have darkened an already dark room (trailers are not known for light) and I'm tickled pink the majority agreed with me and voted for her. The california surfer dude didn't cut it, now get over it and stop slamming the winner. Talk about sore losers!

Posted by Andrea Lorton – September 16, 2007 11:10 PM

Congratulations, Kim! I will looking forward to your new design show. Come to Delaware!!!

Posted by sparkling wine – September 16, 2007 11:06 PM

CONGRATULATIONS, KIM!!!! I voted for you several times. In playing the Fantasy Game, I had actually picked Todd...right after Scott got eliminated but, after watching the last few shows, I decided I wanted you to win...whether or not I was voting against myself. The facts are that you are a much more sincere and down-to-earth person. Todd is not a bad guy but he was just so sure he was going to win it just I can see why he and Robb get along.
Anyway...CONGRATULATIONS again. I am sure you will do great and have a blast. I would try to get in on Season 3 except I am disaled and couldn't do alot of the physical work!
I look forward to seeing your new show...it'll be GREAT, I am sure!!!
'

Posted by Terri' – September 16, 2007 11:04 PM

Kim is a nice lady, with a great personality, who doesn't know how to even tile and didn't finish projects this season. She did one good design and is now a "Star". I wish her the best, but I won't be tuning into this show next season. I watch HGTV to learn from experts, not "designers" who don't know what they are doing. Design Star, this season = amateur hour.

Posted by barney – September 16, 2007 11:02 PM

This was my first season watching Design Star. I am a huge fan of Candice Olsen's work and thought this would be fun to watch, as well (thank goodness for Tivo). Although my choice was Todd, I'm glad Kim won, too. Therein lies the conundrum of Design Star: after all the creating, eliminations, and incredibly hard work, when it comes down to it, they BOTH deserve to win. How can you choose between Todd and Kim? It's SO DIFFICULT. Having said that, in the end I chose Todd because of his bold, exciting designs---from the moment he created the "blue wave room", I was hooked. He is a true original. I have a sneaking suspicion that with his eccentric take on design, those teeth, and that personality, HGTV will NOT let Todd slip through their fingers. He probably already has offers up the wazoo from all over the place. Aaaah, the power of television...Again, congrats to Kim.

Posted by TeacherLisa – September 16, 2007 11:01 PM

Congratulations Kim! I was pulling for you all the way. I knew you could do it! I will be watching your show!

Posted by Nancy Webster – September 16, 2007 11:01 PM

Anyone who says Kim flew "under the radar" didn't watch all of the show. Those of us who saw it will never forget her use of one inch pieces of tape to make that fabulous coffee table. And remember, there were times when she could have been voted off. When I saw that kitchen DISASTER with Neeraja I nearly lost it! But in the end kim proved to be a versitile and well rounded designer. Todd just didn't know how to design a room for regular people, which is exactly what HGTV at least "tries" to do. Color Splash was one of those shows that blew us away with fabulous design in homes of people who really deserved it. And speaking of deserving design, that's now my new favorite show! Peace!

Andrea

Posted by Andrea – September 16, 2007 11:00 PM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!!!!!!!!!!!
Great show tonight, and great choice for the new "Design Star".
The Big Dream came true. Take it beyond limits. Enjoy the ride for all of us. Your hard work paid off.
The very best to you and your family.
Mary J. Anderson

Posted by Mary – September 16, 2007 10:59 PM

Geez, not only did my pick not win, but HGTV folks spoiled the surprise for all of us on the west coast before we could watch the show!Bummer.

Posted by Bummed Out Fan – September 16, 2007 10:59 PM

Kim, Congrats on your win! You so deserved to win if Will or Sparkle Josh didn't. Love your designs and look forward to seeing your show. You showed such grace under pressure and I enjoyed it.

Posted by theorganizer4195 – September 16, 2007 10:59 PM

KIM! You were an outstanding contestant and I'm so glad my vote counted!! You looked absolutely elegant tonight and demonstrated what a class act you are!

C O N G R A T U L A T I O N S ! !

Posted by Nina – September 16, 2007 10:54 PM

Im so Glad, Kim won,I voted for her.

Posted by Rhonda – September 16, 2007 10:52 PM

Congratulations Kim!! I think you'll bring some down to earth perspective.I look forward to seeing your show.

Todd: Dude, I'm sorry you didn't win. You performed every task with passion and originality, and I think you would have made a terrific host.

Dear Todd & Kim haters: It's over. Kim won, Todd came in 2nd, and Sparkle Josh came in 5th and does not have a show. Maybe he'll get one some day, but meanwhile, stop making comments like "There is no Design Star this year." Move on, already!

Posted by EddieAlbania – September 16, 2007 10:51 PM

Congratulations Kim! It is nice to see a gracious woman as your self win this contest. I wish you all the sucess in the future. You have a wonderful family supporting you and you can see how much you are loved by them and your fans.
Good Luck and will be looking forward to watching your show.

Posted by velvet350 – September 16, 2007 10:50 PM

I yelled and screamed when Kim won. I am so happy for her. I voted for her and I think she truly deserves it. She may not had the formal training but she had the eye and the graciousness to pull it all off. I am so very proud of her. Congrats to HGTV and to KIM MYLES

Posted by Mo – September 16, 2007 10:49 PM

Now that all of this is over and we have a new design star please bring back JOSH!

Posted by mary – September 16, 2007 10:46 PM

America, you stripped Todd's gears -- Kim is an outstanding decorator, but is NOT a designer. That "designer" was Todd.

Did the judges suddenly go blind when they entered her space with the glue clearly showing on the bare concrete floor of the hotel suite, the splintered edges on the homemade divider, the lack of trim on the floor from where poor Will was forced to remove the carpet and it left a gap? Hmmm, have to wonder why the oversights? I suppose knowing someone from InStyle mag made all the difference in the world.

When Todd designed the space for the deserving family, did anyone notice that he actually listened to the family and did not go "tubular" or too "out there?" He did what they wanted, using his sense of design and talents. Kim, for all her kindness, did not think it through. Who on earth would place a white carpet in a W.VA coal mining, muddy town? I must wonder how long it was white. Not to mention that it looked pretty much the same as before she started. Not very practical or creative I would have to say, but a lovely decorator.

The intellectual level of these blogs has been massively disappointing but not unexpected. America, you are a testament to your educational system. Congratulations, you get what you deserve! I shudder to think of who will get voted into office in 2008 with such a high level of sagacity and acumen. Fifth gear and full throttle, America. You rock.

Posted by dmhannah – September 16, 2007 10:45 PM

Yeah Kim... I am thrilled you won. I know that you are going to have a great show! I love your genuine charm and design style... You show 'em girl. Kick the lid off the box!!!!

Posted by Tawn – September 16, 2007 10:44 PM

I was so happy to see Kim win. I am just amazed that she has no design training, because her work looks so professional. Look forward to her show next year.

Posted by Terry – September 16, 2007 10:44 PM

I'm really shocked that Kim won. I definitely was not the dedicated fan this year as last. It just didn't have the same ooompf as last year's show. Maybe the newness just wore off....but I think Todd was the better pick out of the two. I just never got the judges' facination with Kim's "hosting ability." Both the guys in my house really want to see Todd do a show too, maybe TLC will pick him up!!

Posted by Lori – September 16, 2007 10:44 PM

Congratulations Kim!! You earned it. I'm angered by the comments posted by Lee, "I think she won because she is a woman and is Black. As a black woman myself, I'm insulted that they would give the show to her for these reasons not her performance on the show."

I believe that Kim won via her talents, not due to her race. I too am a designer as well as an African American. Are you maybe offended that a 'non designer'won? Todd was more of a set designer and Kim designed a room.

Posted by Lena – September 16, 2007 10:43 PM

SOOO disappointed Kim won. Another mediorce designer for middle America. Todd clearly has the skills, energy and personality for an original "out of the box" show. Thanks, HGTV, for being so predictable.

Posted by LadiDi – September 16, 2007 10:43 PM

Congrats Kim, but you are no design star....please improve the show for next season!

Posted by HGTV Fan – September 16, 2007 10:42 PM

AMERICA GOT IT WRONG!!

Posted by Patsy – September 16, 2007 10:41 PM

Congratulations to Kim. She will be a wonderful designer-host and I will watch her show!

Todd fans who are disappointed--please try to be good sports. There is nothing scientific about this contest and the fact that Todd didn't emerge as the new design star in no way detracts from his talent, enthusiasm, and upper body appeal.

Posted by powerboat – September 16, 2007 10:41 PM

CONGRATS KIMMIE! I rooted for you the whole season. Maybe when I get my new home you can put me on your show!! I am sooooo looking forward to you being on the HGTV family! Again, CONRATULATIONS!!!!!

Posted by Scott – September 16, 2007 10:41 PM

CONGRATS KIM!! Can't wait to see your new show. You have such a bubbly personality it will be fun watching your show. This season was so much fun to watch.

Posted by Karen – September 16, 2007 10:40 PM

Hello...WAHOOO! I have to admit that Kim was not my first choice originally, but, I am SO glad that I do NOT have to watch Todd! One more scream and I felt like I would pull him from the TV....and, bummer that he introduced his brother first, and not his wife! I would be bummed....but, then, my husband would have done the same thing....sigh.

Posted by kelli – September 16, 2007 10:40 PM

People- You can't blame HGTV for Kim winning. We (America)voted. So it's us you need to blame if you didn't want Kim to win. You go girl! I'm glad you won. I still wanted Will to be in the final 2.

Posted by Denise – September 16, 2007 10:37 PM

I am very disappointed to see how political correct your show turned out to be. It had nothing to do with talent. If the judges who know about talent were allowed to choose, I know they would have chosen Todd. Kim has a few talents but she absolutely is no comparison to all of Todd's talents. I have seen many of your shows from A to Z and many of your designers have talent. Since I was born, I have been surrounded by by talent. My mother was a very talented woman to knew how to design and create whatever the client wanted. I would have never chosen Kim because her knowledge and abilities are not as strong as Todd's. She never created anything worthwhile in my observation. It is a shame you would allow the general public to choose instead of professional designers. Shame on you. I will not watch this show again.

Sincerely,

Martha Eceiza

Posted by Martha Eceiza – September 16, 2007 10:37 PM

Kim - congratulations! I voted for you and now that you've won, I wonder if you would come do a room in my house! I thought your Hawaii room was outstanding! Good luck with your new show! You truly deserve it and I'll be watching - you'll do a fantastic job!

Posted by Shelly – September 16, 2007 10:35 PM

Who, Kim? Kim Myers?! "Oh this is no surprise to me." You just go you little hairdresser you. You master of diplomacy.

"CONGRATULATIONS from your designing neighbor in Baldwin Long Island!!!" You well deserve it. Only one thing I ask you to consider....make Will your assistant or side kick. There is a good working chemistry there.

"Good Luck Girlie! You're a Winner!"

P. S. I loved Todd's attempt at toppling you by selecting Will to assist him on the first day on of the final challenge. I saw the expectation of the second day outcome between you and Will in your eyes immediately....when Todd made his selection. That is what makes a winner.

Posted by Edina – September 16, 2007 10:34 PM

Fist of all thank you IWatkins for your amazing blog throughout this season. Looking for to Design Star 3. I enjoyed going back and looking at the recaps of the season and seeing everyone, ESPECIALLY OUR VERY OWN SPARKLE JOSH ( i have him as my screensaver on my computer) and of course Will always being the gentleman. And most of all Congradulations KIm.

Posted by zee48 – September 16, 2007 10:32 PM

congradulations kim,great job

Posted by geno – September 16, 2007 10:31 PM

I am so truly thrilled for Kim ,lots of us have design style with no formal training ,I read her bio and I love her desire of all things beautiful .Great Blessing to Kim and her Beloved family

Posted by Beeveer – September 16, 2007 10:30 PM

Oh my...this season was sooo...much better than last. Last year the wrong person won as evidenced by his show but this year it was right on the mark!!! The people on the show this year were really a cut above the extraordinary. Great show we'll all be watching for your show Kim. Enjoy the win, savor the win. Todd what a great competitor. Your enthusiasm was great and contagious. With a little maturity you will wow the world. Good luck to all.

Posted by F Muir – September 16, 2007 10:30 PM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM. I am in tears. I had a houseful of people watching the marathon at my house yesterday and EVERYONE of them thought Kim should win. Of course it was too late for them to vote, but I know they are excited right now.

It was great to see everyone back together again. It was fun seeing the stuff that we didn't see on camera. One of the people that was at my house caught that Christina said "Wellllll" alot and she called me when that part happened and laughed so loud.

Great show and I will watch Kim's show every week.

Posted by she luv hgtv – September 16, 2007 10:29 PM

Congrats to Kim! How great it was to see all the design star "winners" on tonight's show, but oh so sad to have it end...what great entertainment these past few weeks! Hope they do a "where are they now show" someday...I feel like they are all family!!!

Posted by Sandy – September 16, 2007 10:29 PM

Wow America! I'm really shocked and surprised that Kim won. Don't get me wrong, I'm really happy for her, she deserves it, but I was certain that America would choose the "Golden Boy" Todd. Congratulations Kim! My personal tastes lean more towards Todd's work and I thought he was more creative, versatile, and much better trained. He is definitely a winner and I'm sure this is one of the few times he has lost at anything, but the underdog took the day! Its really too bad that there isn't room for several new shows on HGTV. I'm looking forward to watching Kim's new show, but I'd really like to see more from Todd, Christina, and Sparkle Josh to name a few. I think both Todd and Christina appeal to a niche market and would have an instant audience. Todd's style appeals to the twenty something, first time homeowner, male market (as well as the females, like me, who thinks he's hot!) and Christina's style appeals to the suburban housewife, working mother market. Todd could showcase masculine style with an extreme sporty edge and Christina could showcase gracious traditional, eclectic, and modern southern style. HGTV would be remiss if they let these two talented individuals disappear into obscurity.

Posted by SeaNymphette – September 16, 2007 10:27 PM

I've seen the last episode and I know that Kim is our next Design Star and I know that if Todd had won I would NEVER watch this show or HGTV EVER again! Now ... who are you? Your posts don't read as "corporate schtick".

Posted by Steve W. – September 16, 2007 10:27 PM

Kim, Congratulations! You are a role model for all women. I loved it when you said I think I can and you did! What a wonderful opportunity. You made me proud! I am so happy for you and can't wait to see your show! Shirley from Amarillo, TX

Posted by Shirley from Texas – September 16, 2007 10:25 PM

what a wonderful surprise ! The right person won !
No more shirts off, surfing poses, strange projects, just an warm, person interested in giving a client what they wanted not a room with an accident waiting to happen (and the insurance rates going up).
I'm so glad Kim won.

Posted by jed – September 16, 2007 10:25 PM

You did a great job of coverage of each talented person. What an assortment of interesting talent and unique personalities.Kim's show will be watched by America for sure!!!!
Kim had such Grace and balance that is life's great success tip for a great future.
HGTV is terrific and getting better all the time.Thanks to all!Clive and the judges were more fun than last time.

Posted by dee – September 16, 2007 10:23 PM

Its so nice to see a such a deserving winner. I think we are about to see some great elegant designs.

We are so happy for you KIM !

Posted by Mark – September 16, 2007 10:23 PM

Congratulations Kim and HGTV!!!! I am already a fan!!!

Posted by Peggy – September 16, 2007 10:22 PM

Kim has been gracious, natural and charming throughout. Moreover, her creative designs really WOWED us. This is good news, indeed!

Posted by Stacy – September 16, 2007 10:22 PM

I was so indifferent about these
two finalists that I didn't even vote. blah................Originally, I thought that Todd was so superior that he would be picked, but his last design was pretty lame..........either way, we do not have a true Design Star..........sorry.

Posted by Beth – September 16, 2007 10:22 PM

This year's show was the best so far! Great job Kim! Todd you were awsome. HGTV "You Rock"! Can't wait for season #3.

Posted by Alec Charlie – September 16, 2007 10:21 PM

Well, other season, I was right on again. I love David and I love Kim. Don't get me wrong; I love Todd's works; however, I could not see myself looking at a show that brings on nothing but cartoon-like design all the time. I was a bit much. For his last challenge, I think he should have provide some classics, which would have been the best. He has proven his creativity.

Now, my girl, Kim, very seasoned television presents and extraordinary designer. She makes me want to just sit and watch her shows over and over again. This is one time in my life that I feel my votes really count and they have been honored every time. THANK HGTV. CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by CC McPherson – September 16, 2007 10:20 PM

I want to know the voting score!!! I couldn't pick Todd or Kim, because I thought they both deserve their own show. How close was it?

Posted by keith – September 16, 2007 10:20 PM

Josh was even more funny tonight. I wish they would give him and Will a show together! They were the true stars of this season and the whole audience gets it even if HGTV doesn't. Kim is OK - I don't buy into the whole conspiracy hate thing. I am glad she won over Todd - but probably will not watch her show - I just don't think she has the talent. I think America picked their winner (O.K. - 2 winners) - HGTV just didn't listen.

Posted by Cheryl – September 16, 2007 10:20 PM

Yeah!! Way to go Kim! I am so looking forward to watching your show this coming Spring! What a fabulous end to the wonderful Design Star2 show! Keep smiling and enjoy every minute of all that is ahead for you. You are such a graceful lady and I know your hometown is proud of you as we all are! Blessings to you!

Posted by Patsy Laufer – September 16, 2007 10:19 PM

I'm so glad Kim won. Thought Todd was too fake with his arms always up and shirt off. Kim's final design really was the best. Congrats and I can't wait for next season. Hope there will be more individual compitions as in season 1.

Posted by Karen – September 16, 2007 10:19 PM

The show's finale was so fun to watch! I'm glad that Will got to have a prize. I also enjoyed the laughs and "bloopers". Sparkle Josh is so funny.

Posted by Teresa – September 16, 2007 10:18 PM

Just wanted to say, "Congratulations, Kim." I've watched every episode and have been so impressed by your grace under pressure, not to mention your design talents.
I'm a nurse turned graphic designer so I know how stressful it is to try to change careers; not that my change was anyway near the magnitude of yours!
I love HGTV and watch it a lot. Anyway, congrats and I can't wait to see your show.
Martha Rogers

Posted by Martha Rogers – September 16, 2007 10:16 PM

Congratulations Kim! Not too surprised that you won! Can't wait to see the format of your new show! It was nice to see the little "extras" that weren't originally aired on the show. What was especially nice to see was the our opinions of Josh J. and Will were right on. The extra clips that we saw just proved to us all that you both are the sweetest, kindest, caring people that we have had the pleasure of knowing! I'm keeping my fingers crossed that HGTV reads some of the viewers opinions and have you both on their payroll! Where will I get my Sparkle and Will fix now??!! Keep up the good work, and I'm sure we'll all be seeing you again!

Posted by pooky500 – September 16, 2007 10:16 PM

I'm so glad for Kim, she was the one who was steady all the way. I felt from the beginning that she was going to make it, and I'm so proud of her. For someone to show such great ability when it wasn't her actual career is amazing. My congratulations and I'm looking forward to watching her show. Since I voted for her I feel that her show will be my own as well. I'm sure others feel the same way. Todd was fantastic as well, and I'm sure if he got his own show, it would be a blast to watch. Maybe HGTV will consider giving him a chance as well.

Posted by Betty Mell – September 16, 2007 10:14 PM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!!!!!! I knew you could do it. You're warmth and sincerity are so welcoming and I can't wait to see your first show.

Posted by D.BUTLER – September 16, 2007 10:14 PM

I'm so glad Kim won. I already have ideas for the title of her show. Styles by Myles, Myles of Style kind of a play on words and her name.

Posted by Becca – September 16, 2007 10:13 PM

WAY TO GO KIM!!! I voted for you every day, you will be great at your "New" job. Keep your smile and winning attitude and you will SHINE!!!
tehoe

Posted by tehoe – September 16, 2007 10:13 PM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!!!! Each Design Star Had A SPECIAL LIGHT
but Kim, tonight you are the brightest STAR in the galaxy. I can tell this is absolutley a dream come true for you and your husband and I know that you will treat us all to your talent, creativity and down-to-earth style each week on HGTV! I also want to commend TODD on his incredible work and obvious talent as a super-star artist. There is no limit to what you will do with all of your gifts. Will, I need to SHOUT OUT to you, your talent and compassion make you my number 1 FAVORITE DESIGNER! To each of the talented 11, thank you for a great season of fantastic design and full throttle fun!!!

Posted by Linda Joy – September 16, 2007 10:12 PM

i like todd much more than kim. every design Kim does was just to usual; no surprises. Most of the designer shows design was very a much like the one another; not much of a different. I like the 1st designer start-David because he will do something different than other shows. He draws a picture for every room he design and the picture brings out his design; which is very impressive. Kim is just too flat. If HGTV is looking for someone same as other designer that have, why bother to have this show? I would of thought HGTV will be looking for someone who can "wow" and design outside of the box and still down to earth.

Posted by love hgtv – September 16, 2007 10:12 PM

CONGRATULATIONS KIM MYLES!!!! The show tonight was great! I loved seeing everyone back together again! Josh and Will were great! Such great personalities. Everyone seemed sincere in their wishing Kim and Todd the best. Once again CONGRATULATIONS KIM!!! YOU ROCK GIRL!

Posted by Agnes – September 16, 2007 10:12 PM

we sat and watched tonights final show with fingers crossed. how exciting to see that kim came out on top. we cheered along with the audience.
my mother and i religiously watched each show and quickly picked our favorites. kim was always up there in the top three or four along with will and sparkle josh.
i'm hoping the producers have been reading these blogs to find out what how viewing audience feels about this years format. i truly believe that more individual design challenges would have given us a slightly different final 4.
but, while waiting for season three, we will be waiting anxiously to see what kim does with her own show, without the very limited time frame and with a full staff. way to go kim.....congratulations.

Posted by ruth – September 16, 2007 10:10 PM

truly enjoyed this year's competition. looked forward to each new episode. kim's 'heart' really stood out. todd's muscles were no 'wimp' factor. will's respect of each person was pure joy! and 'sparkle' did. thanks hgtv...this was truly a winning show!!!!!

Posted by linda Ervin – September 16, 2007 10:10 PM

i am so glad that kim won.... i can not wait till her show comes out..... i think it is going to be so much fun

Posted by Cody – September 16, 2007 10:09 PM

YEAH KIM!!!!! Congratulations! She has earned it. I hope that all HGTV fans will allow her to enjoy this moment and leave the past and the negative remarks behind.

Posted by Belinda – September 16, 2007 10:08 PM

I watched this series and am disappointed to see that Kim won. Todd was and is a better designer. Kim did not do one thing but stay under the radar from elimination. I think she won because she is a woman and is Black. As a black woman myself, I'm insulted that they would give the show to her for these reasons not her performance on the show. Todd deserved to win.

Posted by LEE – September 16, 2007 10:08 PM

good for kim,,,but=== boring,,,,kim's work was ok but so same o same o,,,i hope hgtv will find a place for todd to use his great out of the box ideas

Posted by j net – September 16, 2007 10:06 PM

I can't beleive it... HGTV clearly made a mistake! Todd RULED the entire show. Kim seems like a wonderful, sweet person... but I would MUCH rather watch Todd. No offense to Kim, but I doubt I will watch her. HGTV should give Todd a show ANYWAY to make up for their mistake.

Posted by Kayla – September 16, 2007 10:06 PM

I am so happy Kim won!!! She was the best overall and I am so glad American voted her the best! Congratulations Kim!!!

Posted by Jeannie – September 16, 2007 10:04 PM

I am sooo jazzed that Kim won! I can't wait to see her show. My family's quality of life will be greatly improved :)

Posted by Dr. Julie – September 16, 2007 10:04 PM

KOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!
CONGRATS KIMMIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SO GLAD I TOOK THE TIME TO VOTE, U SOOO
DESERVE THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by njdeb69 – September 16, 2007 10:03 PM

Congratulations Kim. Yes, you got my vote. Good luck on your new show.

Posted by coolinchic – September 16, 2007 10:03 PM

WooHooo!!!! Grats Kim!!

Posted by Marybeth – September 16, 2007 10:02 PM